revista pensamiento penal - castigos irracionales: leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · colectivo de...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y DerechoInforme Regional 2017
Sergio ChaparroCatalina Pérez Correa
Coletta Youngers
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES:Leyes de Drogas y Encarcelamiento
en América Latina
![Page 2: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
![Page 3: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
!
!
!
!
!
!
)
)
)
)
)
)
!"#$%&'(")*$)+,&-*'",)./"01,)2).$/$%3"J).J8J)K)9:;<)
3&&FDLLMMMJ*/"01,2*$/$%3"J"/0)
)
!=>?4@A>)488=!4AB=C+>D)C$2$,)*$)./"01,)2)+5%1/%$#17'$5&")$5)=7E/'%1)C1&'51)
>$/0'")!31F1//")
!1&1#'51)GE/$H)!"//$1)
!"#$&&1)I"-50$/,)
"#$%$&'()=/'151)N50$#$,)@1/%O1)2)=#"5,")8"*/O0-$H)+&$/5"*))
)$*+,-()=/'151)N50$#$,)@1/%O1))
.-/-012342!#+!5-1/2#2()P1&O1,)?"//$,J)Q"&R0/16")*$)#1)S5'*1*)*$)!"7-5'%1%'"5$,T)@$5*1/7$/O1)*$)!3'#$J)
6751+*$&'(!>7'#$)>"#-&'"5,)>J=J)*$)!JUJ))
89021!:!2,-!#+!$751+*$&'()!'-*1*)*$)PEV'%"T)9:;<)
!
![Page 4: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
!
!
!
!
!
)
P'$7V/",)*$#)!+..)
)
!"#$%&$'(")*+,%-,+*"%!"#$%&'()'*".,+/'%012')3'%4"$"*1)'5%!"+,-*./$"
0'(&$,*12)/3"#454"""""""""""""""6&7&'3/$"892:),/";&%)/'*:""
6$,+1"%!,5'%7"+1'%*'%&289%!"</:)=)*" -"3"$1)"%4:+';%-,++'"%!">?@),/""#3/,)*,)A'"#,,)A'"#'.)'*"
506+"
<=21")"%>,13'=?%!"<$*3):" .:+@A'%7")/'$1)2B?%!"8&$9"B')=&$3).*."C&.&$*:".&";)/".&"D*'&)$/"E"
F#60GEBC;D" 5066G"
.,C,%4'*+,%4"*="%!"<$*3):" !12"+*,%D,E'+F)%6"++1*,%!"8&$9"B')=&$3).*."C&.&$*:"C:-1)'&'3&"
5066G"
!,*+1/,%GH+1A)I%J'H'5%!"5/:/12)*" 61")'$$"%>"+*";"),%!"B$-%-*H"
6&I-3(),)*""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""0+FJB;"
D'+/1,%-8"H"++,!"5/:/12)*" -,$'33"%J,=)/'+5%!"+3(*./3"B')./3"""""""6&I-3(),)*"
KLF#"
<=15%K'$1H'%-+=;%!"5/:/12)*" 41')%7'3""$%!"8*M3&3"<*I/3""""""""6&I-3(),)*" NO0"
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%L+)'53,%-,+3:5%!"5/3(*";),*""
""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""#5+06""
!
!
!
!
!
Raúl Alejandro Corda | ArgentinaIntercambios A.C.
Jorge Vicente Paladines | EcuadorDefensor Público Regional
Catalina Pérez Correa | MéxicoCIDE
Jérôme Mangelinckx | PerúCIDDH
Ricardo Soberón Garrido | PerúCIDDH
Gianella Bardazano | UruguayIELSUR
Coletta Youngers | Estados UnidosWOLA
Pien Metaal | Países BajosTNI
Gloria Rose Marie de Achá | BoliviaAsociación Acción Andina
Luciana Boiteux | BrasilUniversidad Federal de Rio de Janeiro/
LADIH/UFRJ
João Pedro Padua | BrasilUniversidad Federal Fluminense
Rodrigo Uprimny Yepes | ColombiaDejusticia
Sergio Chaparro | ColombiaDejusticia
Luis Felipe Cruz | ColombiaDejusticia
Ernesto Cortés | Costa RicaACEID
![Page 5: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&'(!&()"%#*+!,(--!./01! (!
E9! 16748>974U9B4R3! ?! ,9! BT0B1,! 9I1B793! :1!I;0>9! :4674379! 9! ,96! D106;396! 01B,=4:96! D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!?!9!6=6!I9>4,496F!:1!9B=10:;!9! B047104;6! B;>;! 1,! 8S310;F! ,9! 4:1374:9:!61V=9,F! ,9! B;3:4B4R3! S734B9! ?! ,9! 647=9B4R3!6;B4;1B;3R>4B9"! E9! BT0B1,F! D;0! 1A1>D,;F!74131! 4>D9B7;6! :4I1013B49,16! ?!:16D0;D;0B4;39:;6! 6;K01! ,96! >=A1016"!L=3Y=1! 1,! 32>10;! 7;79,! :1! >=A1016! 13! ,96!BT0B1,16! 16! >=?! 43I104;0! 9! ,9! D;K,9B4R3!>96B=,439F!,;6!3451,16!:1!13B90B1,9>4137;!:1!,96! >=A1016! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! 167T3!9=>13793:;! 9! =3! 047>;! 9,90>9371! ?F!813109,>1371F! 6;3! D106;396! Y=1! C93!;B=D9:;! ,;6! 0938;6!>T6! K9A;6! :1! ,9! B9:139!:1,!318;B4;!:1!,96!:0;896"!E9!8093!>9?;0@9!:1!16796!>=A1016!741313!D;B9!1:=B9B4R3!?!54513!13! B;3:4B4;316! :1! D;K01U9[! >=BC96! 6;3!>9:016! 6;,71096"! .,! 13B90B1,9>4137;! :1!>=A1016! >9:016! ?! B=4:9:;096! 13! D9074B=,90F!D=1:1! 71310! B;361B=13B496! :159679:;096!D909! 6=6! I9>4,496"! \;0! ;709! D9071F! ,96!:46B04>439B4;316! Y=1! 6=I013! D106;396!D107131B413716! 9! 80=D;6! D;K,9B4;39,16!709:4B4;39,>1371!>908439:;6!D;0!I=109!:1!,9!D0464R3F! 6=1,13! 7096,9:9061! ?! 1V9B10K9061!:1370;!:1!1,,9"!!
-;3! 016D1B7;! 9! ,;6],96! AR51316! ?! ,;6],96!9:;,16B13716! 435;,=B09:;6! 13! :1,47;6! :1!:0;896F! D161! 9! Y=1! 6;3! D0;B169:;6! 13!64671>96! D139,16! :4I1013716F! 6=1,13! 71310!B909B710@674B96! ?! D0;K,1>96! B;>=316! 9,!64671>9! :1! 9:=,7;6"! ^39! :1! 1,,96! 16! Y=1! 34!9:;,16B13716!34! AR51316!6=1,13!D107131B10!9!,;6! 3451,16! :1! ,4:109U8;! :1! ,96! >9I496!390B;709I4B93716F! 643;! 610! D9071! :1! ,;6!16,9K;316! 011>D,9U9K,16! :1,! 318;B4;"! W43!1>K908;F!9!D1690!:1!169!D9074B4D9B4R3!>13;0!61! 13B=137093! 13701! ,;6! 80=D;6! Y=1! >T6!D9:1B13!,;6!4>D9B7;6!:1!,9!B9089!D=347459!:1!
,96!D;,@74B96!:1!:0;896"!O9>K4S3!61!;K61059!,9!9=613B49!:1,!.679:;!13!>971049!D015137459!?!,9! I9,79! :1! D;64K4,4:9:16! :1! 9BB16;! 9!70979>4137;! ?! 01C9K4,479B4R3! :1,! =6;! :1!:0;896!D909!9Y=1,,;6! AR51316!?!9:;,16B13716!Y=1F! :1K4:;! 9,! B;36=>;! 018=,90F! 61!>93741313!13!1,!B@0B=,;!:1,4B745;"!!.671!:;B=>137;!61X9,9F!9!D90740!:1!154:13B49!1>D@04B9F! ,9! B04646! D134713B49049! 1V4671371! 13!L>S04B9! E97439F! :10459:9! :1! ,;6! 1I1B7;6!9:5106;6! Y=1! ,96! 9B7=9,16! ,1?16! :1! :0;896!C93! 7134:;! 6;K01! ,9! 647=9B4R3! D134713B49049!39B4;39,"! .,! :;B=>137;! >=16709F! 9:1>T6F!Y=1! ,9! 9D,4B9B4R3! :1! ,9! D;,@74B9! :1! :0;896! Z?!6=6! 1I1B7;6! 3189745;6Z! 3;! 6;3! 01D9074:;6! :1!48=9,! I;0>9! 13! ,9! 6;B41:9:! 643;! Y=1!D10A=:4B93! 9! B4107;6! 61B7;016! Y=1! ?9! 61!13B;3709K93! 13! =39! 647=9B4R3! :1!5=,3109K4,4:9:! 6;B49,"! ! L371! 1679! 019,4:9:F! ?!7;>93:;! 13! B=1379! 1,! 709K9A;! :1! ,;6!43I;0>16!43:454:=9,16!:1,!-.//F!61!D0;D;313!,96! 648=413716! 01B;>13:9B4;316! :1! D;,@74B9!D2K,4B9F! ,96! B=9,16! 741313! D;0! ;KA17;! ,;8090!=39!D;,@74B9!:1!:0;896!>T6!A=679F!016D17=;69!:1!,;6!:101BC;6!I=3:9>1379,16!?!13I;B9:9!9!D0;71810! ,9! 69,=:! D2K,4B9! :1! ,96! 6;B41:9:16!,9743;9>104B9396"!
Recomendaciones
Reformas Legales:
LA=6790! ,9! 01D=1679! D139,! D909! Y=1! 619!D0;D;0B4;39,! 9,! :9X;!;B964;39:;! ?! 01I;0>90!,96! ,1?16! :1! :0;896! D909! :467438=40! 13701!:1,47;6!:1!>13;0F!>1:49!?!9,79!16B9,9[!13701!3451,16!:1!,4:109U8;!13!,96!01:16!B04>439,16F!?!13701!:1,47;6!54;,137;6!?!3;!54;,137;6"!
1
SOBRE EL CEDD
Resumen Ejecutivo
Introducción
La cárcel como primera respuesta
Condiciones carcelarias en las Américas y derechos fundamentales
Encarcelamiento por delitos de drogas
Los vicios de la política de drogas en el proceso penal
Criminalización primaria
Criminalización secundaria (punición en la etapa judicial)
Criminalización terciaria: delitos de drogas y obligatoriedad de la cárcel
El encarcelamiento por drogas: una de las principales causas de la crisis
penitenciaria
La política de encarcelamiento en cifras
¿Quiénes son las personas encarceladas por delitos de drogas?
Pobreza y oportunidades en la ilegalidad: persecución y encarcelamiento de los
más débiles
Delitos y sustancias de las personas privadas de la libertad
Usuarios de drogas: criminalización y encarcelamiento
Poblaciones específicas
Mujeres
Mujeres con hijos en prisión
Jóvenes y adolescentes
Extranjeros
Otras poblaciones
Conclusiones y Recomendaciones
Bibliografía
2
3
9
11
1518
18
18
20
23
25
30
30
31
34
37
47
47
55
57
59
63
62
68
ÍNDICE
![Page 6: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
!
!
!
!
!!,! -.//! 01231! 435167489:;016! <13! 6=!>9?;0@9! A=046796<! :1!;BC;!D9@616! E9743;9>104B93;6F! 96@! B;>;!01D01613793716!:1! ,96! 436747=B4;316! 4>D=,6;096!:1,!B;,1B745;G! ,9!HI4B439!13!J96C4387;3!6;K01!L6=37;6!E9743;9>104B93;6!MJHELN!?!1,!O09363974;39,!P36747=71!MOQPN#!.,!-.//!K=6B9!8131090!43I;0>9B4R3!6;K01!,96!B909B710@674B96!?! ,;6!B;67;6F! 6193!6;B49,16!;!1B;3R>4B;6F!:1! ,96!D;,@74B96!13!>971049!:1!:0;896!13!L>S04B9!E97439#!-;3!1,,;F!K=6B9!I;>13790!=3!:1K971!43I;0>9:;!6;K01!,9!1I1B7454:9:!:1!,96!D;,@74B96!:1!:0;896! 9B7=9,16! ?! 01B;>13:90! 9K;0:9A16! 9,71039745;6! D909! D;,@74B96! >T6! A=6796! ?! 1I1B74596#! E;6!435167489:;016! 61! 012313! D104R:4B9>1371! D909! 9K;0:90! =3! 71>9! 13! >971049! :1! :0;896! ?! 8131090!167=:4;6!9!3451,!39B4;39,!?!0184;39,!6;K01!:4BC;!71>9#!!
.3!=3!D04>10!16I=10U;F!1,!80=D;!1,9K;0R!=3!1V7136;!167=:4;!6;K01!1,! 4>D9B7;!:1! ,96! ,1?16!:1!:0;896!6;K01! ,;6! 64671>96! B90B1,904;6! :1! ;BC;! D9@616! ,9743;9>104B93;6#! /4BC;! 167=:4;F! 747=,9:;! W4671>96!6;K01B9089:;6G! ,1?16! :1!:0;896! ?! BT0B1,16! 13! L>S04B9! E97439F! D=1:1! 610! B;36=,79:;! 13! 1,! 648=41371!5@3B=,;G!())*+,,---./012345/6067(1.102,*89:;737;1<64,*01*=/6:,44>71?*:6)1.*/@!!
.3!=3!618=3:;!7;>;F!1,!B;,1B745;!=74,4UR! ,9!D0;D;0B4;39,4:9:!B;>;!1A1!D909!9K;0:90!1,!167=:4;!:1!,96!D;,@74B96!:1!:0;896!13!B9:9!D9@6#!E;6!167=:4;6!:1!169!I961F!>=167093!BR>;!,;6!B96748;6!4>D=167;6!D909!:1,47;6! :1! :0;896! 9! 3451,! 0184;39,! ?! 1,! 7097;! :1! ,;6! ;I136;016! 9! ,96! ,1?16! :1! :0;896! 6;3!:16D0;D;0B4;39:;6!9!,;6!:9X;6!Y=1!,;6!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!D0;:=B13!?!13!;B964;316!016=,793!>T6!,1645;6!Y=1! ,96! B;3:=B796! Y=1! K=6B93! 01D04>40#! L64>46>;F! ,;6! 167=:4;6! 6;K01! D0;D;0B4;39,4:9:! 1VC4K13! ,;6!>2,74D,16!B;67;6!Y=1!,9!D;,@74B9!9B7=9,!74131!7937;!D909!,;6!8;K4103;6!B;>;!D909!4>D;0793716!61B7;016!:1!,9!6;B41:9:#!!
.,! 710B10! 167=:4;! :1,! -.//! 939,4UR! ,96! 016D=16796! 167979,16! 9371! B;36=>;! :1! 6=6793B496! 4,@B4796#! .3!:4BC;6! 167=:4;6! 61! >;670R! B;>;F! 9=3! B=93:;! ,;6! .679:;6! D0;D;313! 9K;0:90! 1,! 71>9! :1,! B;36=>;!:16:1! ,96! 436747=B4;316! :1! 69,=:F! 13! ,9! D0TB74B9! ,96! 016D=16796! 648=13! 6413:;! D139,16F! ,,1593:;! 9! ,9!B04>439,4U9B4R3!:1!,;6!B;36=>4:;016!9!3451,!0184;39,#!!
.,!D0161371!167=:4;!9K;0:9!1,!=6;!:1!,96!D0464;316!D909!9713:10!1,!I13R>13;!:1!,96!:0;896!13!,9!0184R3#!E;6!:97;6!01B9K9:;6!3;!6R,;!>=167093!,96!809516!B;3:4B4;316!13!Y=1!61!13B=137093!,96!BT0B1,16!:1!,9!0184R3!643;F! 79>K4S3! ,9! I;0>9!13!Y=1!1,! =6;!:1!BT0B1,16!D909!9713:10!:4BC;! I13R>13;!B;3704K=?1! 9!9809590!,9!6;K01D;K,9B4R3!?!B04646!D134713B49049!0184;39,#!!
E;6! 167=:4;6! 43:454:=9,16! D;0! D9@6! :1! B9:9! D0;?1B7;F! 96@! B;>;! ,;6! 01D;0716! 0184;39,16! D=1:13! 610!B;36=,79:;6!13!,9!DT8439!:1,!-.//!13!,9!DT8439G!())*+,,/012345/6067(1.102.!
!
SOBRE EL CEDD
2
E
![Page 7: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
!!!D1690!:1!Y=1!,9!0184R3!,9743;9>104B939!C9!,4:109:;!1,!:1K971!:1!01I;0>96!9!,96!D;,@74B96!:1! :0;896! 9! 3451,! 8,;K9,! ?! D0;>;54:;! ,9!31B164:9:! :1! B;364:1090! 9,7103974596! 9,!13B90B1,9>4137;! 13! >971049! :1! :0;896F! 1,!=6;! :1,! :101BC;! D139,! ?! :1! 693B4;316!D045974596!:1!,9!,4K1079:!D909!167;6!:1,47;6!61!C93! 1V9B10K9:;! 13! ,;6! 2,74>;6! 9X;6#! .V4671!96@! =39! 4>D;079371! K01BC9! 13701! 1,! :46B=06;!:1! 01I;0>9! D;0! D9071! :1! ,;6! .679:;6! ?! ,;6!437137;6! :1! 9593U90! 13! 016D=16796! >13;6!01D0164596F!B;3!=3!13I;Y=1!:1!69,=:!D2K,4B9F!:101BC;6! C=>93;6! ?! :1! :16900;,,;! C=>93;!Y=1F! 69,5;! B;379:96! 1VB1DB4;316F! C93! 64:;!100T74B;6#! .3! 9,8=3;6! D9@616F! B;>;! .B=9:;0F!167;6!16I=10U;6F!43B,=6;F!61!C93!0151074:;#!
.3! ,9!>9?;0@9! :1! ,;6! D9@616! :1! ,9! 0184R3F! 1,!9=>137;! D;0B137=9,! :1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3!13B90B1,9:9! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! C9! 64:;!>=BC;! >9?;0! Y=1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! 813109,!13B90B1,9:9! D;0! ;70;6! :1,47;6#! E;6! :97;6! :1!,;6! 167=:4;6! :1,! -.//! >=167093! Y=1! 16796!713:13B496! B;3743293! 9,! 9,U9#! L:1>T6F! 13!5904;6! :1! ,;6! D9@616! 167=:49:;6! 1,!13B90B1,9>4137;!D;0!167;6!:1,47;6!16!=3;!:1!,;6! I9B7;016! D043B4D9,16! Y=1! 1VD,4B9! 1,!B01B4>4137;! :1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! B90B1,9049#! .3!7;:;6! ,;6! D9@616! 167=:49:;6F! ,96!435167489B4;316! :1,! -.//! >=167093! =3! 8093!32>10;! :1! D106;396! 13B90B1,9:96! D;0!:1,47;6! :1! :0;896! >13;016! ?! 3;! 54;,137;6F!Y=41316! D;:0@93! 610! K131I4B490496! :1!9,7103974596!9,!13B90B1,9>4137;F!13713:413:;!Y=1!!,9!D0459B4R3!:1!,9!,4K1079:!13!167;6!B96;6!016=,79!:16D0;D;0B4;39:9#!!
E9! 43I;0>9B4R3! D0161379:9! 13! 1671! 43I;0>1!>=16709! BR>;! ,96! D1396! :16D0;D;0B4;39:9Z>1371! 9,796F! 1,! =6;! :1! 613713B496! >@34>96!;K,4897;0496F! 1,! =6;! ;K,4897;04;! :1! ,9! D0464R3!
D015137459!D909!167;6!:1,47;6!;! 6=! 6;K01=6;F!,9! I9,79! :1! 9D,4B9B4R3! :1! 9,7103974596! 9,!13B90B1,9>4137;F! 13701! ;70;6F! B;3704K=?1! 9,!9=>137;! :1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! B90B1,9049! D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896#!W4!K413F!L>S04B9!E97439!16!=39!:1!,96!0184;316!>T6!54;,13796!:1,!>=3:;F!1,! 9=>137;! 13! 1,! =6;! :1! BT0B1,16! 3;!016D;3:1! 1679! 647=9B4R3F! ?9! Y=1! 6;3! ,;6!:1,43B=13716!>13;016F! 3;! 54;,137;6F! ,;6! Y=1!6;3! B9D7=09:;6! 13! I,98093B49! ?! Y=41316!01B4K13!1,!D16;!:1,!64671>9!D139,#!.3!1,!B96;!:1! ,;6! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896F! ,;6! 167=:4;6! :1,!-.//! >=167093! Y=1! ,;6! =6=904;6! :1!6=6793B496! 4,@B4796! 6;3! I01B=1371>1371!:17134:;6F! 1V7;064;39:;6! 1! 43B,=6;! 13B90ZB1,9:;6!B;>;!>4B0;!709I4B93716!;!>13=:46796!D;0!D;0790! B9374:9:16!:1!:0;896!D;0!13B4>9!:1!,96!7;,109:96#!.,,;!>=16709!Y=1!1,!:46B=06;!:1! D0;71BB4R3! 9! ,9! 69,=:! :1! ,;6! =6=904;6! 61!Y=1:9!13!1,!D9D1,F!>4137096!Y=1!,96!D;,@74B96!:1! :0;896! D=16796! 13! D0TB74B9! B;3743293!13I013793:;! 1,! D0;K,1>9! :1! =6;! :1! :0;896!4,@B4796!:16:1!1,!:101BC;!D139,#!!
.3! L>S04B9! E97439! ,96! BT0B1,16! 6;3! ,=89016!:;3:1! 1V4671! 6;K01D;K,9B4R3F! 16B961U! :1!01B=06;6! ?! B;3:4B4;316! 1V701>96! :1!54;,13B49#! E9! I9,79! :1! C484131F! :1! 98=9!D;79K,1F! 1361016! KT64B;6! ?! 16D9B4;6!6=I4B413716!B;3704K=?13!9!Y=1!1V4679!=39!9,79!D0159,13B49! :1! 13I10>1:9:16! B;37984;696!Y=1!D;313!13!04168;!,9!69,=:!:1!,;6!437103;6F!:1! 6=6! I9>4,49016! ?! :1! ,;6! 1>D,19:;6! :1! ,;6!B1370;6! :1! 01B,=64R3#! .,! =6;! :1! ,96! BT0B1,16!D909!9713:10!1,!D0;K,1>9!:1!,96!:0;896F!,1A;6!:1!D0;71810! ,9!69,=:F! ,9!5=,3109#!/46>43=40!1,!=6;! M;! 9K=6;N! :1! 1679! C1009>41379! D139,!9?=:90@9! 9! >1A;090! ,96! B;3:4B4;316! B90B1Z,90496F!9,!,4K1090!,;6!01B=06;6!Y=1!1V46713#!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!R E S U
M E N
E J E C U
T I V O
RE
SU
ME
N E
JE
CU
TIV
O
3
A
RESUMEN EJECUTIVO
![Page 8: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
E9! 16748>974U9B4R3! ?! ,9! BT0B1,! 9I1B793! :1!I;0>9! :4674379! 9! ,96! D106;396! 01B,=4:96! D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!?!9!6=6!I9>4,496F!:1!9B=10:;!9!B047104;6!B;>;!1,!61V;F! ,9! 4:1374:9:!61V=9,F!,9! B;3:4B4R3! S734B9! ?! ,9! 647=9B4R3!6;B4;1B;3R>4B9#! E9! BT0B1,F! D;0! 1A1>D,;F!74131! 4>D9B7;6! :4I1013B49,16! ?! :16D0;D;0ZB4;39:;6! 6;K01! ,96! >=A1016#! L=3Y=1! 1,!32>10;! 7;79,! :1! >=A1016! 13! ,96! BT0B1,16! 16!>=?! 43I104;0! 9! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! >96B=,439F! ,;6!3451,16! :1! 13B90B1,9>4137;! :1! ,96! >=A1016!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!167T3!9=>13793:;!9!=3!047>;! 9,90>9371! ?F! 813109,>1371F! 6;3!D106;396! Y=1! C93! ;B=D9:;! ,;6! 0938;6! >T6!K9A;6!:1!,9!B9:139!:1,!318;B4;!:1!,96!:0;896#!E9! 8093! >9?;0@9! :1! 16796! >=A1016! 741313!D;B9! 1:=B9B4R3! ?! 54513! 13! B;3:4B4;316! :1!D;K01U9[! >=BC96! 6;3! >9:016! 6;,71096#! .,!13B90B1,9>4137;! :1! >=A1016! >9:016! ?!B=4:9:;096! 13! D9074B=,90F! D=1:1! 71310!B;361B=13B496! :159679:;096! D909! 6=6!I9>4,496#!\;0!;709!D9071F! ,96!:46B04>439B4;316!Y=1!6=I013!D106;396!D107131B413716!9!80=D;6!D;K,9B4;39,16! 709:4B4;39,>1371! >908439:;6!D;0! I=109! :1! ,9! D0464R3F! 6=1,13! 7096,9:9061! ?!1V9B10K9061!:1370;!:1!1,,9#!!
-;3! 016D1B7;! 9! ,;6],96! AR51316! ?! ,;6],96!9:;,16B13716! 435;,=B09:;6! 13! :1,47;6! :1!:0;896F! D161! 9! Y=1! 6;3! D0;B169:;6! 13!64671>96! D139,16! :4I1013716F! 6=1,13! 71310!B909B710@674B96! ?! D0;K,1>96! B;>=316! 9,!64671>9! :1! 9:=,7;6#! ^39! :1! 1,,96! 16! Y=1! 34!9:;,16B13716!34! AR51316!6=1,13!D107131B10!9!,;6! 3451,16! :1! ,4:109U8;! :1! ,96! >9I496!390B;709I4B93716F! 643;! 610! D9071! :1! ,;6!16,9K;316! 011>D,9U9K,16! :1,! 318;B4;#! W43!1>K908;F!9!D1690!:1!169!D9074B4D9B4R3!>13;0!61! 13B=137093! 13701! ,;6! 80=D;6! Y=1! >T6!D9:1B13!,;6!4>D9B7;6!:1!,9!B9089!D=347459!:1!,96!D;,@74B96!:1!:0;896#!O9>K4S3!61!;K61059!,9!
9=613B49!:1,!.679:;!13!>971049!D015137459!?!,9! I9,79! :1! D;64K4,4:9:16! :1! 9BB16;! 9!70979>4137;! ?! 01C9K4,479B4R3! :1,! =6;! :1!:0;896!D909!9Y=1,,;6! AR51316!?!9:;,16B13716!Y=1F! :1K4:;! 9,! B;36=>;! 018=,90F! 61!>93741313!13!1,!B@0B=,;!:1,4B745;#!!.671!:;B=>137;!61X9,9F!9!D90740!:1!154:13B49!1>D@04B9F! ,9! B04646! D134713B49049! 1V4671371! 13!L>S04B9! E97439F! :10459:9! :1! ,;6! 1I1B7;6!9:5106;6! Y=1! ,96! 9B7=9,16! ,1?16! :1! :0;896!C93! 7134:;! 6;K01! ,9! 647=9B4R3! D134713B49049!:1! B9:9! D9@6#! .,! :;B=>137;! >=16709F!9:1>T6F! Y=1! ,9! 9D,4B9B4R3! :1! ,9! D;,@74B9! :1!:0;896! <?! 6=6! 1I1B7;6! 3189745;6<! 3;! 6;3!01D9074:;6!:1!48=9,!I;0>9!13!,9!6;B41:9:!643;!Y=1! D10A=:4B93! 9! B4107;6! 61B7;016! Y=1! ?9! 61!13B;3709K93! 13! =39! 647=9B4R3! :1!5=,3109K4,4:9:! 6;B49,#! ! L371! 1679! 019,4:9:F! ?!7;>93:;! 13! B=1379! 1,! 709K9A;! :1! ,;6!43I;0>16!43:454:=9,16!:1,!-.//F!61!D0;D;313!,96! 648=413716! 01B;>13:9B4;316! :1! D;,@74B9!D2K,4B9F! ,96! B=9,16! 741313! D;0! ;KA17;! ,;8090!=39!D;,@74B9!:1!:0;896!>T6!A=679F!016D17=;69!:1!,;6!:101BC;6!I=3:9>1379,16!?!13I;B9:9!9!D0;71810! ,9! 69,=:! D2K,4B9! :1! ,96! 6;B41:9:16!,9743;9>104B9396#!
Recomendaciones
Reformas Legales:
LA=6790! ,9! 01D=1679! D139,! D909! Y=1! 619!D0;D;0B4;39,! 9,! :9X;!;B964;39:;! ?! 01I;0>90!,96! ,1?16! :1! :0;896! D909! :467438=40! 13701!:1,47;6!:1!>13;0F!>1:49!?!9,79!16B9,9[!13701!3451,16!:1!,4:109U8;!13!,96!01:16!B04>439,16F!?!13701!:1,47;6!54;,137;6!?!3;!54;,137;6#!
W=D04>40! ,96! D1396! >@34>96! ;K,4897;0496F!154790! ,9! :1713B4R3!D015137459!13!1,! B96;!:1!
4 RESUMEN EJECUTIVO
![Page 9: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
:1,47;6! :1! :0;896! >13;016! ?! D10>4740! 1,!9BB16;!9! ,;6!K131I4B4;6!D0;B169,16F! 96@! B;>;!9!,96!;D;07=34:9:16!:1!D1396!9,7103974596#!!
-;364:1090! ,9! 9D,4B9B4R3! :1! 9>3467@96!16D1B49,16! M43:=,7;6NF! D909! ,96! D106;396!613713B49:96!D;0!:1,47;6!>13;016!:1!:0;896F!D;0! :1,47;6! 3;! 54;,137;6F! 96@! B;>;! D909!D106;396! 643! 9371B1:13716! D139,16! ;!613713B49:96!6;,9>1371!D;0!:1,47;6!>13;016!:1!:0;896#!
\0;>;510! 1,! 1679K,1B4>4137;! :1! >10B9:;6!,189,16! ?! 018=,9:;6! :1! B9339K46F! 43B,=?13:;!B,=K16! :1! B9339K46F! ?! 1VD,;090! ;DB4;316! :1!9BB16;! 018=,9:;! D909! ;7096! 6=6793B496!:1B,909:96!4,@B4796#!!
Uso de drogas y la ley:
/16B04>439,4U90! 1,! B;36=>;! :1! :0;896! ?!:171310!7;:9!B,961!:1!D1061B=B4R3!B;3709!,;6!B;36=>4:;016F! 43B,=?13:;! ,9! D;6164R3F!641>K09F! B=,745;! ?! B;>D09#! .6! :1B40F! 61!01B;>413:9! 69B90! :1,! :101BC;! D139,! 7;:96!,96!B;3:=B796!31B1690496!D909!,,1590!9!B9K;!1,!B;36=>;F! 96@! B;>;! :1A90! :1! =690! 9! ,;6!B=10D;6! :1! D;,4B@96! M=! ;7096! 436793B496!618=04:9:N! B;>;! D04>1096! 436747=B4;316! :1!9B10B9>4137;!9!,;6!B;36=>4:;016#!!
^690!=>K09,16!D909!I4A90!B9374:9:16!>@34>96F!K969:96! 13! 9713B4R3! 9! ,96! D0TB74B96! :1! ,;6!B;36=>4:;016F!D;0!:1K9A;!:1!,96!B=9,16!3;!61!D=1:9! 1679K,1B10! 9B7454:9:! :1! B;>10B4;F!D10;! 643! D10>4740! Y=1! D;0! 13B4>9! :1! :4BC96!B9374:9:16! ,96! D106;396! D=1:93! 610!693B4;39:96! D;0! :46704K=B4R3! ?! 70TI4B;#! .3!7;:;6!,;6!B96;6F!1,!.679:;!:1K1!D0;K90!Y=1!,9!43713B4R3! :1! ,9! D;6164R3! 16! ,9! 51379! ;!:46704K=B4R3! B;>;! B;3:4B4R3! D909! 693B4;390!:4BC9!B;3:=B79#!!
HI01B10!61054B4;6!:1!70979>4137;!5;,=37904;!?!8097=47;! 9! ,96! D106;396! Y=1! D01613793! =6;!D0;K,1>T74B;! :1! :0;896F! 7937;! B=93:;!B;>1713!;70;6!:1,47;6!B;>;!B=93:;!3;#!.671!70979>4137;! 3;! :1K1! 16790! 6=A17;! 9! ,9!9>139U9!:1!=39!693B4R3!D139,!;!4371039B4R3!B;>D=,6459#! /4BC;6! 70979>4137;6! :1K13!!6=671379061! 13! 154:13B49! B4137@I4B9F! ! B;3! =3!13I;Y=1!:1!01:=BB4R3!:1!:9X;6F!?!:1K13!610!,,159:;6!D;0!D0;I164;39,16!:1!,9!69,=:F!3;!D;0!A=1B16!D139,16#!!
Mujeres y encarcelamiento:
_1:=B40! 64834I4B97459>1371! ,;6! 3451,16! :1!13B90B1,9>4137;! :1! >=A1016F! ?9! 619! D;0!>1:4;! :1! ,9! 9D,4B9B4R3! :1,! D043B4D4;! :1!D0;D;0B4;39,4:9:! ;! D;0! ,9! 9:;DB4R3! :1!9,7103974596! :4I1013716! 9,! 13B90B1,9>4137;F!7937;! 13! 6=6747=B4R3! :1,! =6;! :1! ,9! D0464R3!D015137459F! B;>;!13! 1,! B=>D,4>4137;!:1! ,96!613713B496#!
Q;! 13B90B1,90! 9! ,96! >=A1016! 1>K909U9:96! ?!>9:016!:1!>13;016!:1!1:9:!B;3:139:96!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!3;!54;,137;6#!.3!1,!B96;!:1!16796! >=A1016F! :1K1! B;364:109061! ,9! 9D,4B9ZB4R3!:1!9,7103974596!9,!13B90B1,9>4137;#!
L618=090! Y=1! ,;6! ;D109:;016! :1! A=674B49!713893! ,9! I,1V4K4,4:9:! :1! 7;>90! 13! B=1379F!:=09371! 1,! D0;B16;! ?! :1710>439B4R3! :1! ,9!613713B49F! ,;6! I9B7;016!:1!5=,3109K4,4:9:!?! 64!,9!9B=69:9!74131!:1D13:413716#!!
Jóvenes y adolescentes:
P>D,1>13790! D;,@74B96! D2K,4B96! 4371809,16!:40484:96!9!,;6!?!,96!AR51316!?!9:;,16B13716F!?!9593U90!C9B49!=3! B9>K4;!:1,! 9B7=9,! 13I;Y=1!16748>974U9:;0! ?! :1! B04>439,4U9B4R3! Y=1!1V4671!6;K01!1,,;6#!
5RESUMEN EJECUTIVO
![Page 10: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
LD,4B90F! 13! ,;6! B96;6! :1! AR51316F! ,;6!K131I4B4;6!?! ,96!9,7103974596!Y=1! ,96! ,1?16!:1!1A1B=B4R3!:1!D1396F!:1!,;6!:4I1013716!D9@616F!1679K,1B13!D909!169!I093A9!179049#!!-=>D,40! B;3! ,96! ,1?16! Y=1! 1679K,1B13! ,;6!64671>96!:1!`=674B49!\139,!D909!L:;,16B13716F!,;6! B=9,16! 018=,93! ,9! 016D=1679! 167979,! D909!:1,47;6! B;>174:;6! D;0! D106;396!>13;016! :1!('!9X;6F!?!Y=1!1679K,1B13!Y=1!,9!D0459B4R3!:1!,9! ,4K1079:!:1! ,;6!9:;,16B13716!:1K1!610!6;,;!=39! 1VB1DB4R3[! 9:1>T6F! 61! :1K1! B;364:1090!Y=1!,96!>1A;016!693B4;316!13!167;6!B96;6!6;3!9Y=1,,96! Y=1! 3;! 4>D,4B93! 13B4100;F! 79,16!B;>;! ,9! ,4K1079:! 964674:9! ;! ,9! D01679B4R3! :1!61054B4;6! 9! ,9! B;>=34:9:F! 96@! B;>;! ,;6!:45106;6! 01B=06;6! Y=1! ,96! ,1?16! 1679K,1B13!D909!016;,510!,;6!B96;6!I=109!:1!,9!5@9!A=:4B49,F!?! 9! 7095S6! :1! ,9! A=674B49! 01679=097459#! L64Z>46>;F! :1K13! 9B;079061! ,96! D1396! >TV4>96!D909!:1,47;6!B;>174:;6!D;0!>13;016!:1!1:9:F!?!:1!1679!>93109!3;!1VB1:10!,;6!1679K,1B4:;6!13!43670=>137;6!4371039B4;39,16#!!
!!!!!!!
/;790! :1! 01B=06;6! 6=I4B413716! 9! ,;6! 64671>96!:1!`=674B49!\139,!D909!L:;,16B13716F!9! I43!:1!Y=1! I=3B4;313!:1! I;0>9! 16D1B49,4U9:9F! A=679!?! 1I4B41371F! 648=413:;! ,;! 1679K,1B4:;! D;0! ,9!-;3513B4R3! 6;K01! ,;6! /101BC;6! :1,! Q4X;! ?!;70;6! 167T3:9016! 4371039B4;39,16! 6;K01! ,9!>971049#!!Alternativas al encarcelamiento:
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
\0;>;510! ,96! 01I;0>96! 31B1690496! D909!D10>4740! Y=1! ;I136;016! :1! :1,47;6! >13;016!:1!:0;896!3;!54;,137;6!6193!:10459:;6!9!=39!01:! D2K,4B9! :1! 9D;?;! D909! D0151340!4371809,>1371! ,9! 0143B4:13B49F! 13! 51U! :1! 610!13549:;6! 9! D0464R3F! 9713:413:;! 96@! ,;6!I9B7;016! 6;B4;1B;3R>4B;6! Y=1! ,,1590;3! 9! ,9!B;>464R3!:1!16796!B;3:=B796#!!
RESUMEN EJECUTIVO6
Fotografía: Matías Torres. Fotógrafo de la Unidad de Comunicaciones, Gendarmería de Chile.
![Page 11: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
Elaboración y Evaluación de Políticas de Drogas:
a909374U90! ?! 9>D,490! ,9! D9074B4D9B4R3! 13! 1,!:461X;F! 4>D,1>1379B4R3! ?! 159,=9B4R3! :1! ,96!D;,@74B96! :1! :0;896! :1! ,9! 6;B41:9:! B454,! ?F!16D1B49,>1371F! :1! ,;6! ?! ,96! =6=904;6! :1!:0;896! 13B90B1,9:96F! :1! ,96! >=A1016F!D106;396! EabOF! 43:@81396F! 9I0;6! ?! ;70;6!61B7;016! :1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! Y=1! 167T3! 13!647=9B4;316!:1!5=,3109K4,4:9:!?!Y=1!C93!64:;!4>D9B79:;6! :16D0;D;0B4;39,>1371! D;0! ,96!D;,@74B96!:1!:0;896#!
E,1590! 9! B9K;! =3! :4983R674B;! 6104;! 13! B9:9!D9@6! Y=1! D10>479! 13713:10! ?! 939,4U90! ,;6!4>D9B7;6! ?! ,9! 1I4B9B49! :1! ,96! D;,@74B96! :1!:0;896! 9B7=9,16F! B;3! 1,! D0;DR647;! :1!:16900;,,90! 1! 4>D,1>13790! D;,@74B96! >T6!C=>9396F!1I4B9B16!?!A=6796#!!
c1A;090! ?! 9>D,490! ,;6! 64671>96! :1! 01B;Z,1BB4R3F! 64671>974U9B4R3! ?! 159,=9B4R3! :1! ,;6!:97;6! :1! ,9! A=674B49! D139,! ?! 9618=090! Y=1!;I4B49,16! :1,! 8;K4103;! ?! 1,! D2K,4B;! 713893!9BB16;! ;D;07=3;! 9! :4BC9! 43I;0>9B4R3#! .67;!610540T! D909! 9618=090! ,9! 159,=9B4R3! :1! ,9!D;,@74B9! :1! :0;896! ?! 6=6! 1I1B7;6F! D10;!79>K4S3! D909! ,;8090! :4983R674B;6! 9B1079:;6!6;K01!1,!D0;K,1>9!Y=1!61!K=6B9!9713:10#!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
RESUMEN EJECUTIVO 7
![Page 12: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
!
!
!
!
A34);214!B0037;1<3:64+!C6564!/6!/01234!5!6<73076:3?;6<)1!6<!D?E0;73!C3);<3F!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!(!.671!71V7;!16!=39!51064R3!016=>4:9!:1,!71V7;!:1!-C9D900;F!W#!d!\S01U!-;0019F!-#!M%$(*N#!W;K01:;646!B90B1,9049!?!D;,@74B9!:1!:0;896!:1!L>S04B9!E97439#!b;8;7TG!/1`=674B49!Z!-.//#!M.3!4>D01379N#!!
8 CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES
![Page 13: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
!
Introducción !
!!!!!!!!!!!9! ,4K1079:! 16! =3;! :1! ,;6! :101BC;6! >T6!4>D;0793716!D909!1,!610!C=>93;#!\;0!1,,;F!1,!D;:10!Y=1!741313!,;6!.679:;6!D909!D04590!9!,96!D106;396!:1!1671!:101BC;!:1K1!1A10B1061!:1!>93109! D0;D;0B4;39,F! ?! 6R,;! B;>;! 2,74>;!01B=06;#! .6! 31B16904;! 9618=090! =3! 1Y=4,4K04;!13701! 1,! :1K10! :1,! .679:;! :1! 8909374U90! ,9!618=04:9:!D2K,4B9!D;0!=3!,9:;F!?!1,!016D17;!9!,;6! :101BC;6! I=3:9>1379,16! D;0! 1,! ;70;#! W43!1>K908;F!,9!e8=1009!9!,96!:0;896f!:16D,189:9!13! ,96! 2,74>96! :SB9:96F! C9! 813109:;! =39!13;0>1! :467;064R3! 13! ,;6! 64671>96!B;36747=B4;39,16! ?! D139,16F! 9=>13793:;! 1,!=6;!:1,!D;:10!D=34745;!:1!,;6!.679:;6!?!:1!,9!BT0B1,!13!7;:;!1,!>=3:;F!D9074B=,90>1371!13!,;6! D9@616! :1! ! L>S04B9#! /1! 79,! I;0>9! Y=1! ,9!BT0B1,! 61! C9! B;351074:;! 13! ,9! D04>10!016D=1679! D909! 016;,510! =39! 61041! :1! 71>96!6;B49,16F!43B,=4:;!1,!B;36=>;!:1!:0;896#!
.3! 6=! >9?;0@9F! ,;6! 8;K4103;6! 13! L>S04B9!E97439!C93!9B1D79:;!,;6!1I1B7;6!3189745;6!:1!,96! D;,@74B96! :1! :0;896! K969:96F!D04>;0:49,>1371F!13!016D=16796!D=3474596#!.,!43I;0>1! 6;K01!1,! D0;K,1>9!:1! ,96!:0;896! 13!,96!L>S04B96F!D0161379:;!D;0!,9!H08934U9B4R3!:1!.679:;6!L>104B93;6!MH.LF!%$("NF!B;43B4:1!13!,9!31B164:9:!:1!13713:10!e1,!B;36=>;!:1!:0;896! B;>;!=39! B=1674R3! :1! 69,=:! D2K,4B9F!:1! 01:=B40! 1,! B;36=>;! B;3! B9>D9X96! :1!D01513B4R3! K969:96! 13! ,9! 154:13B49F! ?! :1!9,13790! ,9! 1VD104>1379B4R3! B;3! >;:1,;6! :1!018=,9B4R3! ,189,! :1! B410796! :0;896f#! Q;!;K679371F! 1,! D0161371! 167=:4;F! B;>;! ;70;6!:1,! -;,1B745;! :1! .67=:4;6! /0;896! ?! /101BC;!M-.//F! %$(gF! %$(%[! OQP! d! J;,9F! %$($N!>=167093! Y=1! ,96! 016D=16796! :1! ,;6! 8;ZK4103;6!,9743;9>104B93;6!I01371!!9,!!B;36=>;!!
!
:1! 6=6793B496! 4,@B4796! 648=13! 6413:;! D01Z:;>439371>1371! D=3474596! ?! 01D0164596F!9K;0:93:;! 1,! I13R>13;! :1,! B;36=>;! :1!:0;896!:1!=6;!4,@B47;!9!7095S6!:1!436747=B4;316!D139,16!?!B90B1,90496#! P3B,=6;F!1,! 43I;0>1!:1,!-.//F!e.3!K=6B9!:1!,;6!:101BC;6G!=6=904;6!:1!:0;896!?!,96!016D=16796!167979,16!13!L>S04B9!E97439f!M%$(gNF!>;670R!Y=1!923!13!,;6!D9@616!13!,;6!Y=1!1,!B;36=>;!3;!16!=3!:1,47;F!1V4671!=39! D1064671371! B04>439,4U9B4R3! C9B49! ,96!D106;396!=6=90496!:1!:0;896!4,@B4796#!!
.3! 1,! 167=:4;! eE9! L:4BB4R3! \=347459f!M^D04>3?F! a2U>93! d! \9009F! %$(%N! 61!>=16709! =39! 16B9,9:9! :1,! =6;! :1,! :101BC;!D139,! I01371! 9,! I13R>13;! :1! ,96! :0;896F! ,;!Y=1! C9! ,,159:;! 9! ,9! 4>D;64B4R3! :1! D1396!D045974596! :1! ,9! ,4K1079:! 6=>9>1371! 9,796! ?!:16D0;D;0B4;39:96!D909!693B4;390!7;:9!B,961!:1!B;3:=B796!01,9B4;39:96!B;3!:0;896!Z:16:1!,9!641>K09!C9679!,9!51379!?F!9!51B16F!43B,=6451!1,! B;36=>;Z#! .67;F! B;>;! 61! 43:4B9! 13! 1,!D0161371! 71V7;F! C9! B;3704K=4:;! 9! 9809590! ,9!B04646! :1! ,;6! 64671>96! D134713B4904;6! :1! ,9!0184R3#!L=3Y=1!:4BC9! B04646! 61! 1VD,4B9F! 13701!;70;6! I9B7;016F! D;0! =3! =6;! 1VB1645;! :1,!:101BC;! D139,! 13! 813109,F! ,96! D;,@74B96! :1!:0;896! 01D01613793! =3! >9?;0! 9K=6;! 13! ,9!9D,4B9B4R3!:1!1679!C1009>41379#!Q;!;K679371F!1,! 6;K01=6;!:1! 13B90B1,9>4137;F! 9:1>T6!:1!610!431I4B9U!D909!01:=B40!1,!9K=6;!:1!:0;896!;!B;>K9740!9,!B04>13!;08934U9:;F!C9! 4>D,4B9:;!13;0>16! B;67;6! ?! C9! D0;:=B4:;!B;361B=13B496! 9:510696! :1! :451069! @3:;,1F!4>D9B793:;! :1! I;0>9! :16>1:4:9! 9! 61B7;016!16D1B@I4B;6!:1! ,9!D;K,9B4R3F! B;>;!16!1,! B96;!:1! ,96! >=A1016F! ,;6! =6=904;6! :1! :0;896F! ,;6!AR51316F! ,96! B;>=34:9:16! 9I0;F! ,;6!B9>D1643;6! ?! ,96! D;K,9B4;316!>T6! D;K01! :1!,9!0184R3#!
9CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES
L
![Page 14: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
!
!
.,! D0161371! 43I;0>1! 16! =39! 6@371646! :1! ,;6!016=,79:;6! :1! 435167489B4;316! 019,4U9:96!6;K01! ,9! 01,9B4R3! Y=1! C9?! 13701! ,96! ,1?16! :1!:0;896! ?! ,;6! 64671>96! D134713B4904;6! 13! :41U!D9@616!:1!!L>S04B9G!L08137439F!b;,4549F!b0964,F!-;,;>K49F! -;679! _4B9F! .B=9:;0F! .679:;6!^34:;6F!cSV4B;F!\102!?!^0=8=9?!<1,9K;09:96!D;0!435167489:;016!:1,!-.//Z#!.,!71V7;!K=6B9F!D;0! =39! D9071F!>;67090! ,9! 647=9B4R3! :1! B04646!Y=1! 61! 5451! 9B7=9,>1371! 13! ,;6! 64671>96!D134713B4904;6! :1! ,9! 0184R3F! ,;6! 1I1B7;6!9:5106;6! Y=1! 74131! 1,! =6;! :16>1:4:;! :1!:4BC;! 64671>9! ?! ,;6! D0;K,1>96! 71R04B;6! Y=1!D0161379! ,9! 9B7=9,! 016D=1679! D139,! 9,!I13R>13;! :1! ,96! :0;896#! \;67104;0>1371! 61!939,4U93! ,96! I;0>96! :1! 018=,9B4R3! Y=1! 13!>971049! :1! :0;896! 61! 709:=B13! 13! =3! =6;!1VB1645;! :1,! :101BC;! D139,! ?! ,;6! 64671>96!D134713B4904;6#! h439,>1371F! =693:;! ,;6!016=,79:;6!:1!,96!435167489B4;316!D;0!D9@6F!16!D;64K,1! 167=:490! 1,! 4>D9B7;! Y=1! 741313! ,96!,1?16! :1! :0;896! 6;K01! ,;6! 64671>96!D134713B4904;6! :1! ,9! 0184R3[! ,96! D;K,9B4;316!9I1B79:96!?!,96!B;3:4B4;316!D134713B490496!13!,96!Y=1!54513[!,9!647=9B4R3!6;B4;1B;3R>4B9!:1!,96!D106;396!Y=1! 6;3!D0459:96!:1! ,9! ,4K1079:!D;0! 167;6! :1,47;6F! 6=! 809:;! :1! D9074B4D9B4R3!13! 1,! >10B9:;! :1! ,96! :0;896! 4,@B4796F! ?! ,;6!4>D9B7;6! Y=1! 741313! ,;6! 13B90B1,9>4137;6!
6;K01! D;K,9B4;316! 16D1B@I4B96#! \909! ,9!019,4U9B4R3!:1!,;6!71V7;6!39B4;39,16!61!K=6BR!43I;0>9B4R3! 1679:@674B9! :1! 9=7;04:9:16!D134713B490496! ?! ;70;6! 13716! 39B4;39,16F!9=3Y=1! B9K1! :1679B90! Y=1! 1V4671! =39! I9,79!3;79K,1!:1!:97;6! I4:1:483;6! 1! 4371809,16#! .3!,9!>9?;0@9!:1!,;6!D9@616!167=:49:;6!C9?!:97;6!D;B;! 64671>974U9:;6! ;! 431V46713716#! Q=16709!,9K;0!6=K09?9F!D;0!7937;F!,9!31B164:9:!:1!Y=1!,;6! 8;K4103;6! 39B4;39,16! 01B;D4,13! :97;6!64671>T74B;6! ?! :1! B9,4:9:#! \909! 6=D1090! 1671!;K67TB=,;F! B9:9! =3;! :1! ,;6! 435167489:;016!01B=004R!79>K4S3!9!I=13716!B;>D,1>13790496F!B;>;! 167=:4;6! 9B9:S>4B;6! ?! :1!;08934U9B4;316! 4371039B4;39,16F! 93T,4646! :1!1VD1:413716! A=:4B49,16! ;! 13701546796! B;3!I=3B4;3904;6F! 1VD107;6! ?! D106;396! D0459:96!:1!,9!,4K1079:#!!
.,!71V7;!61!;08934U9!:1!,9!648=41371!I;0>9G!13!,9! D9071! PP! 61! 1VD;31! ,9! 154:13B49! 1>D@04B9!Y=1! 3;6! ,,159! 9! 6;671310! Y=1! 1V4671! =39!6;K01:;646!:1!13B90B1,9>4137;!13!,9!0184R3!?!79>K4S3!61!D0161379!=3!D93;09>9!:1!,9!B04646!D134713B49049! 13! ,;6! D9@616! 167=:49:;6#! .,!710B10! 9D9079:;! 1VD;31! ,96! 09U;316!B;3B1D7=9,16! ?! 1>D@04B96! D;0! ,96! Y=1!B;364:109>;6! Y=1! 1,! =6;! D0159,1371! :1,!:101BC;!D139,F!?!13!D9074B=,90!:1!,9!BT0B1,F!C9!64:;! =39! D;,@74B9! 1Y=45;B9:9#! .679! 710B109!D9071!9D;079!154:13B496!Y=1! 6=841013!Y=1!1,!13B90B1,9>4137;! >9645;! D;0! :1,47;6! :1!:0;896! 16! =39! :1! ,96! D043B4D9,16! B9=696! Y=1!1VD,4B93! ,9! B04646! :1! ,;6! 64671>96!D134713B4904;6!13!,;6!D9@616!:1!L>S04B9#!!
.,! B=907;! 9D9079:;! D0161379! :97;6! 6;K01!Y=41316! 6;3! ,96! D106;396! 13B90B1,9:96! D;0!:1,47;6! :1! :0;896! 13! ,;6! D9@616! 167=:49:;6F!96@! B;>;! 43I;0>9B4R3!6;K01!6=6!:1,47;6!?! ,96!6=6793B496! Y=1! ,,1590;3! 9! 6=! 13B90B1,9Z
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES10
Fotografía: Oficina de Prensa y Comunicación. Ministerio de Justicia y Paz de Costa Rica.
![Page 15: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
>4137;#! .3! 1671! B9D@7=,;! D0161379>;6! =3!D93;09>9!813109,!6;K01!9,8=396!D;K,9B4;316!16D1B@I4B96! 13B90B1,9:96! D;0! :1,47;6! :1!:0;896G! >=A1016F! AR51316F! 1V7093A10;6F! B=,74Z59:;016[! D106;396! D;K016! ?! =6=904;6! :1!:0;896! Y=1! B;3743293! 6413:;! D0;B169:;6! ?!13B90B1,9:;6! 43A=679>1371F! D161! 9! Y=1! ,9!D;6164R3! D909! B;36=>;! ?! 1,! B;36=>;! :1!:0;896! C93! 64:;! :16D139,4U9:;6! 13! ,9!>9?;0@9!:1!,;6!D9@616!167=:49:;6#!
h439,>1371F! 61! D01613793! ,96! B;3B,=64;316! ?!=39!61041!:1!01B;>13:9B4;316!6;K01!D;,@74B9!D2K,4B9!13!:467437;6!16B13904;6!:1!01I;0>9!9!,9!D;,@74B9!:1!:0;896#!!
La cárcel como primera respuesta !.V4671! 9K=3:9371! ,471097=09! MLC90;36;3F!%$($[! ^0;69F! %$$+[! i9II90;34F! %$$&[! j=69kF!%$$'[! a90,93:F! %$$(N Y=1! :9! B=1379! :1! ,9!713:13B49! 9! >9V4>4U90! 1,! =6;! :1,! :101BC;!D139,! ?! ,9! BT0B1,! D909! 9I0;3790! :467437;6!D0;K,1>96!6;B49,16F!13701!1,,;6! ,;6!>10B9:;6!:1!:0;896!4,189,16#!E;6!8;K4103;6!:1!L>S04B9!E97439! 3;! 6;3! 9A13;6! 9! 1679! D01I1013B49#!-;>;! 016D=1679! 9! ,9! 43618=04:9:! ?! 54;,13B49!13! ,9! 0184R3F! I01B=1371>1371! C93! 01B=004:;!9,!:101BC;!D139,!B;>;!D043B4D9,!6;,=B4R3#!.3!5904;6! D9@616F! B;>;! cSV4B;F! -;679! _4B9F!b;,4549! ?!\102! 61!C93! 4>D=167;! 016704BB4;316!9!,9!,4K1079:!B;3:4B4;39,!;!61!C93!9=>1379:;!,;6! B96;6! Y=1! A=674I4B93! 1,! =6;! :1! ,9! D0464R3!D015137459! M_418;!d!/=B1F! %$$'N#! L64>46>;F!16! 5464K,1!Y=1! 61!C9!>937134:;!=3! 9=>137;!13! 9X;6! 9! ,96! D1396! 13! D0464R3! Y=1! 61!4>D;313! D909! :467437;6! :1,47;6# ^3! 93T,4646!:1,!D0;>1:4;!:1,!32>10;!:1!9X;6!:1!D0464R3!4>D=167;! D909! ,;6! :1,47;6! :1! 54;,9B4R3! ?!
C;>4B4:4;!>=167093!=3!9,U9!13!5904;6!D9@616!:1!L>S04B9! E97439!13701!(+*$!?!1,! 9X;!%$(%!M^D04>3?! !"# $%&! %$(%N#! .3! :4BC;! 167=:4;F! 16!D;64K,1! B;3679790! Y=1! D909! 1,! :1,47;! :1!C;>4B4:4;!C9?!=3!9,U9!13!1,!32>10;!:1!9X;6!D0;>1:4;!1679K,1B4:;!D909!1,!B96;!:1!b;,4549F!-;,;>K49! ?! cSV4B;#! b;,4549F! D;0! 1A1>D,;F!704D,4BR! ,9! D139! D0;>1:4;! 1679K,1B4:9! D909!C;>4B4:4;F!D9693:;!:1!)#)!9X;6!:1!D0464R3!13!(+*$!9!(%#)!13!%$(%%# .679! 713:13B49F! B;>;!61! >=16709! 13! 1671! 71V7;F! C9! ,,159:;! 9! =3!43B01>137;! 64671>T74B;! :1! ,96! D106;396! Y=1!61! 13B=137093! 13! 01B,=64R3F! ,;! Y=1! C9!;B964;39:;! =39! 80951! B04646! :1! :101BC;6!C=>93;6!Y=1!9I1B79!9! ,96!D106;396!D0459:96!:1! ,9! ,4K1079:#! \10;! Y=4UT6! 13! 1,! T>K47;!:;3:1! 16! >T6! 3;79K,1! 1671! 9=>137;! 16! 13!,;6!:1,47;6!01,9B4;39:;6!B;3!:0;896"#!!!
O13413:;! 13! B=1379! 1,! 79>9X;! D;K,9B4;39,F!1,! B;37431371! 9>104B93;! 74131! ,9! 7969! :1!13B90B1,9>4137;! >T6! 9,79! :1,! >=3:;#! .,!80TI4B;!Y=1!61!>=16709!9!B;3743=9B4R3!43:4B9!1,! 32>10;! :1! D106;396! 13B90B1,9:96! D;0!B9:9! ($$! >4,! C9K4793716! 13! ,;6! D9@616!61,1BB4;39:;6! D909! 1671! 167=:4;F! 13!B;>D909B4R3! B;3! ,;! ;B=004:;! 13! ;7096!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!%! .3! 1,! 93T,4646! :1! ,;6! B9>K4;6! ,1846,9745;6F! 1,! >9?;0!9=>137;! ,;! 7=5;! -;,;>K49F! D9693:;! :1! ((! 9X;6!D0;>1:4;! 13! (+*$! 9! %*#)! 13! %$(%#! .3! 1,! B96;! :1!L08137439F!.B=9:;0!?!b0964,!3;!61!;K61059!=3!9=>137;#!Q;!;K679371F! ,96!D1396!D0;>1:4;!1679K,1B4:96!13!16;6!D9@616! :16:1! (+*$! D909! ,;6! B96;6! :1! 54;,9B4R3F! 1093!6=D104;016! 9! ,96! 436747=4:96! 13! ,;6! ;70;6! D9@616!167=:49:;6#!"! .3! 6=! 71V7;! '$# $()**)+,# -.,)")/$F! _;:048;! ^D04>3?F!/4939!a=U>T3!?!`;081!\9009!>=167093!BR>;!C9!C9K4:;!=39! B,909! 1VD9364R3! 13! 1,! =6;! :1,! :101BC;! D139,! 13!>971049! :1! :0;896#! /1! 9B=10:;! B;3! 1,! 71V7;! B479:;F!:16:1!(+*$!L>S04B9!E97439!>=16709!=3!9=>137;!13!1,!32>10;! :1! 907@B=,;6! Y=1! 74D4I4B93! B;3:=B796!01,9B4;39:96! B;3! :0;896! 13! B9:9! =39! :1! ,96! ,1?16! :1!:0;896!01,1593716!;!C93!9=>1379:;!13!B9:9!907@B=,;!1,!32>10;!:1!B;3:=B796! 74D4I4B9:96!;! ,;6!510K;6!01B7;016!43B,=4:;6!D;0!907@B=,;#!M^D04>3?!!"#$%0!%$(%F!D#%$Z%%N#!!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES 11
![Page 16: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
0184;316F! 61823! ,;6! :97;6! >T6! 01B413716!:46D;34K,16! 13! 1,! J;0,:! \046;3! b041I#! E9!>9?;0@9!:1!,;6!D9@616!B=?;6!:97;6!6;3!=69:;6!13!1671!167=:4;F!B;3!1VB1DB4R3!:1!L08137439!?! .B=9:;0F! 741313! 79696! :1! 13B90B1,9>4137;!
6=D104;016!9!,96!:1!B=9,Y=410!;70;!B;37431371!:1,! >=3:;F! 9=3Y=1! 79>K4S3! 16! 01,159371!3;790!Y=1! ,;6!D9@616! 939,4U9:;6!D;0! 1,! -.//!741313! 79696! 43I104;016! 9,! D0;>1:4;! :1! ,9!L>S04B9! M1VB1D7=93:;! .679:;6! ^34:;6N#
"#$%&'(!)*!+,-,!./!/0',#'/1,2&/03(!4(#!',.,!)55!2&1!6,7&3,03/-!/0!1(-!4,8-/-!-/1/''&(0,.(-9!/0!'(24,#,'&:0!'(0!/1! #/-3(!./1!2;0.(*!<,3(-!2$-! #/'&/03/-!.&-4(0&71/-!/0!/1!=(#1.!>#&-(0!?#&/%!./1!@A>B*!
.,! B;37431371! 9>104B93;! 3;! 6R,;! 16! 1,! Y=1!>T6! 13B90B1,9! 9! 6=! D;K,9B4R3F! 643;! 79>K4S3!:;3:1! >T6! 0TD4:;! C9! B01B4:;! ,9! D;K,9B4R3!B90B1,9049!:=09371!1,! 648,;!llP#!c4137096!Y=1!13!,;6!D9@616!:1!L>S04B9!,9!D;K,9B4R3!813109,!B01B4R! (*m! :=09371! 1671! D10@;:;F! 6=!D;K,9B4R3! 13! BT0B1,16! B01B4R! g(mF! 16! :1B40F!%#g! 51B16!>T6! 0TD4:;#! .VB,=?13:;! 9! .679:;6!^34:;6F! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! Y=1! 61! 13B=13709! 13!D0464R3!13!D9@616!:1! !L>S04B9!C9! B01B4:;!=3!($'mF!16!:1B40F! &#"! 51B16!>T6! 0TD4:;!Y=1! ,9!D;K,9B4R3! 813109,#! W4! K413! .679:;6! ^34:;6!
74131! ,9! 7969!:1!13B90B1,9>4137;!>T6!9,79F!9!D90740! :1! %$$'! 61! C9! 1679K4,4U9:;F! 1! 43B,=6;!:46>43=4:;! ,48109>1371#! .B=9:;0! 79>K4S3!7=5;!=3!:16B136;!:1,!"*m!13701!%$$*!?!%$$+F!016=,79:;!:1!,;6!43:=,7;6!9D,4B9:;6!9!eB;001;6!C=>93;6fF!96@!B;>;!13701!%$(g!?!%$()!D;0!,9!01I;0>9! 9,! -R:48;! \139,#! W43! 1>K908;F!:16D=S6! 9=>137R!D;0! 13B4>9!:1! ,;6! 3451,16!D0154;6! M\9,9:4316F! %$(&9F! D#! %&Z%'N#! .3!B9>K4;F!13!1,!0167;!:1!,;6!D9@616!167=:49:;6F!9!D90740!:1!,9!618=3:9!>479:!:1!,;6!3;513796F!,9!7969!:1!13B90B1,9>4137;!434B4R!=39!B900109!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES12
Fuente: Tasas globales de encarcelamiento por continente tomadas de Coyle, Fair, Jacobson & Walmsley (2016, p. 18). Tasas por países basadas en ICPS. World Prison Brief. Junio de 2016.
![Page 17: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
Y=1!B;374329!13!96B136;!C9679!1,!:@9!:1!C;?#!.3! b0964,! ,9! 7969! :1! 13B90B1,9>4137;! 61!43B01>137R!')+m!:16:1!(+*([!13!-;679!_4B9F!""gm!:16:1! (+*%[! 13!^0=8=9?F! %&"m!:16:1!(+*)[! 13! \102F! %$*m! :16:1! (+*)[! 13!.B=9:;0F!('%m!:16:1!(+*%[!13!cSV4B;F!(*)m!:16:1!(+*%[!13!b;,4549F!("gm!:16:1!(+'*[!13!-;,;>K49! ?! L08137439F! *gm! ?! &gm!016D1B7459>1371!:16:1!(+*%g#!!
.,! B;37431371! 9>104B93;! 74131F! 9:1>T6F! =3!3451,! :1! 54;,13B49! 6=D104;0! 9! ;7096! 0184;316!:1,! >=3:;#! E9! 7969! :1! C;>4B4:4;6F! D;0!1A1>D,;F! 16! ,9!>T6!9,79!:1,!>=3:;F! B;3!=39!7969! :1! (&#"! D106;396! D;0! B9:9! ($$! >4,!C9K4793716#! E1! 648=1! nI04B9! B;3! =39! 7969! :1!(%#)[!.=0;D9!?!HB193@9F!B;3!=39!7969!:1!"F!?!L649F! B;3! =39! 7969! :1! %#+! M^QH/-F! %$(gF! D#!%%Z%gN#! /1370;! :1,! B;37431371F! L>S04B9!-13709,! 16! ,9! 6=K0184R3! >T6! 54;,1379F! B;3!D9@616! B;>;! j;3:=096! Y=1! >93741313! =39!7969! :1! +$#g! C;>4B4:4;6! D;0! B9:9! ($$! >4,!C9K4793716[! ,1! 648=1! b1,4B1! B;3! =39! 7969! :1!gg#*[! .,! W9,59:;0F! B;3! g(#%F! ?! cSV4B;F! B;3!=39!7969!:1!%(#)#!E9!618=3:9!6=K0184R3!>T6!54;,1379! :1,! B;37431371! 16! L>S04B9! :1,! W=0F!B;3! D9@616! B;>;! o131U=1,9! Y=1! >=167093!!=39!7969!:1!)"#*!C;>4B4:4;6!D;0!B9:9!($$!>4,!C9K4793716[!-;,;>K49F!Y=1!74131!=39!7969!:1!"$#'F!?!b0964,F!Y=1!>9374131!=39!7969!:1!%)#%!M^QH/-F!%$("F!D#!%%Z%gN#!!
^39! D018=379! 01,159371! 16! 64! ,96! 9,796! 79696!:1!13B90B1,9>4137;!13!,9!0184R3!016D;3:13!9!1679!647=9B4R3!:1!54;,13B49!;!64!6;3!D0;:=B7;!:1! =3! =6;! :16D0;D;0B4;39:;! :1,! :101BC;!D139,! ?! :1! ,96! BT0B1,16! B;>;! >1:4;! :1!B;370;,! 6;B49,#! .671! 71V7;!K=6B9!>;67090! Y=1!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!g!J;0,:!\046;3!b041I#! P-\W#!/97;6!C467R04B;6!:46D;34K,16!9!A=34;!:1!%$(&#!
=39! D9071! 4>D;079371! :1,! B01B4>4137;! :1! ,9!D;K,9B4R3!B90B1,9049!016D;3:1!9!,9!9D,4B9B4R3!:1! ,96! 9B7=9,16! ,1?16! B;3709! ,96! :0;896! Y=1!;0:1393! >9?;016! 016704BB4;316! D909! 9D,4B90!>1:4:96! B9=71,9016! :=09371! ,;6! D0;B16;6F!613713B496! ;K,4897;0496! >@34>96! ?! Y=1!D10>4713! 1,! 13B90B1,9>4137;! >9645;! :1!B;36=>4:;016!13!,9!0184R3#!L:1>T6F!B;>;!61!61X9,9!>T6!9:1,9371F!,96!693B4;316!:1!D0464R3!13!L>S04B9!E97439F!B;>;!13!;7096!D90716!:1,!>=3:;F! 6=1,13! 16790! :40484:96! 9! D;K,9B4;316!Y=1! ?9! 61! 13B;3709K93! 13! B;371V7;6! :1!5=,3109K4,4:9:! 6;B49,#! E9! 9D,4B9B4R3! :1! 16796!D1396! 64834I4B9! >13;016! ;D;07=34:9:16!6;B49,16! D909! 7;:;6! ,;6! >41>K0;6! :1! ,9!I9>4,49! :1! Y=413! 16! 13B90B1,9:;#! -;>;!>=16709! 1,! 167=:4;! eE96! >=A1016! 435464K,16f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
^3;! :1! ,;6! D0;K,1>96! Y=1! I01B=1371>1371!61!61X9,93!13!1,!167=:4;!6;K01!,;6!D0;K,1>96!:1!,;6!64671>96!D134713B4904;6!13!L>S04B9!16!1,! =6;! :1! ,9! D0464R3! D015137459#! /16D=S6! :1!nI04B9F! 1,! B;37431371! 9>104B93;! 16! 1,! ,=890!:;3:1!C9?!=3!>9?;0!D;0B1379A1!:1!D106;396!13B90B1,9:96! 643! 01B4K40! 613713B49#! .3! ,9!0184R3! :1! W=:9>S04B9! ?! 13! ,9! >479:! :1! ,;6!D9@616! 167=:49:;6F! ,;6! 3451,16! :1! :1713B4R3!D015137459!6=D1093!1,!D0;>1:4;!:1!B=9,Y=410!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES 13
![Page 18: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
B;37431371#! .3!L08137439F!b;,4549F!^0=8=9?! ?!\102!C9?!>T6!D106;396!13B90B1,9:96!D01513Z7459>1371! Y=1! 9Y=1,,96! Y=1! C93! 64:;!B;3:139:96#!.3!b;,4549F!C9679!C9B1!D;B;F!')!:1!B9:9!($$!D106;396!Y=1!61!13B;3709K93!13!D0464R3!3;!C9K@93! 01B4K4:;! 613713B49F! ,;! B=9,!,;!B;3541071!13!1,!618=3:;!D9@6!B;3!>9?;016!3451,16! :1! :1713B4R3! D015137459F! 6=D109:;!6;,9>1371! D;0! E4K49F! :;3:1! 234B9>1371! 1,!($m! :1! ,;6! D016;6! C9! 64:;! B;3:139:;)#! .3!7;:;6!,;6!D9@616!167=:49:;6F!B;3!,9!1VB1DB4R3!:1! .679:;6! ^34:;6F! 1,! 32>10;! :1! D106;396!13B90B1,9:96! 13! D0464R3! D015137459! C9!9=>1379:;#! -;>D9093:;! ,;6! :97;6! >T6!93748=;6! ?! >T6! 01B413716! D909! B9:9! D9@6F!B;>D013:413:;!!1,!D10@;:;!13701!%$$$Z%$(&F!16! D;64K,1! 9:510740! Y=1! ,9! 7969! :1! D106;396!:17134:96! D015137459>1371! 61! C9! 43B01>13Z79:;! 13! D0;>1:4;! =3! &g#*m#! .3! b0964,! ?! 13!\102! 1,! 43B01>137;! I=1! :1! (('m! ?! (%'mF! ,;!Y=1!>=16709! Y=1! ,1A;6! :1! B;00184061F! 1,! =6;!:1! ,9! D0464R3! D015137459! C9! 713:4:;! 9!980959061#!!
.,!=6;!:1! ,9!D0464R3!D015137459!16!;K,4897;04;!13! 5904;6! D9@616! D909! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896#! .3!cSV4B;F! D;0! 1A1>D,;F! ,9! -;36747=B4R3! 1679Z
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)! .67=:4;6! 01B413716! 6=841013! Y=1! 1,! D;0B1379A1! :1!D106;396!:17134:96!D015137459>1371!13!b;,4549!D=1:1!C9K10! :46>43=4:;! 9! 09@U! :1! ,9! D;,@74B9! :1! 43:=,7;6#! .,!a;K4103;! 1>474RF! :16:1! :4B41>K01! :1! %$(%F! B=970;!:1B017;6! D0164:13B49,16! D909! ,9! B;3B164R3! 1VB1DB4;39,!:1,!43:=,7;F!,;!Y=1!D10>474R!Y=1!gF"*g!D106;396!I=10;3!K131I4B49:96! C9679! :4B41>K01! :1! %$()#! .3! 1,! >16! :1!A=34;! :1! %$(&! I439,4UR! ,9! 54813B49! :1,! 2,74>;! :1B017;#!E;6!016=,79:;6!7;79,16!>=167093!Y=1F!1I1B7459>1371F!61!C9! ,;809:;! 01:=B40! 1,! D;0B1379A1! :1! D106;396! 13!:1713B4R3!D015137459F!:1!')m!13!1,!9X;!Y=1!61!1>474R!1,!D04>10!:1B017;F!9!&+m!13!%$(&#!W43!1>K908;F!3;!C9!C9K4:;! =39! >1A;09! 6=6793B49,! 13! 1,! C9B439>4137;#! W4!K413!C9!7134:;!=39!1I4B9B49!D90B49,!43:=:9K,1F!,9!D;,@74B9!:1! 43:=,7;6! C9! 64:;! B=1674;39:9! D;0Y=1!D;64K,1>1371!D0164;3R! D909! Y=1! ,96! D106;396! 643:4B9:96! 61!:1B,909093!B=,D9K,16!9!7095S6!:1!=3!D0;B16;!9K01549:;!MLBCTF!%$(&N#!
K,1B1!Y=1!,9!D0464R3!D015137459!D0;B1:10T!:1!>93109!;I4B4;69!D909!=3!B97T,;8;!:1!:1,47;6F!B;>;!,;6!01,9B4;39:;6!B;3709!,9!69,=:F!Y=1!,9!,1?! :1I439! B;>;! 809516&#! /1! 9B=10:;! 9,!907@B=,;! (+g! :1,! -R:48;! h1:109,! :1!\0;B1:4>4137;6! \139,16F! 7;:;6! ,;6! :1,47;6!01,9B4;39:;6!B;3!,96!:0;896!6;3!B;364:109:;6!809516F!B;3!1VB1DB4R3!:1,!:1,47;!:1!641>K09F!B=,745;! ;! B;61BC9! :1! D,93796! ,,9>9:96!p1310593716q! Y=1! 3;! 71389! D;0! ;KA1745;! ,9!D0;:=BB4R3F! 6=>434670;F! B;>10B4;F! 70TI4B;F!4370;:=BB4R3! ;! 1V709BB4R3! :1! 390BR74B;6! :1,!D9@6#! .3! B;361B=13B49F! B=9,Y=410! D106;39!9B=69:9! D;0! =3;! :1! 167;6! :1,47;6! :1K10T!D9690! 1,! D0;B16;! 13! ,9! D0464R3! :1! I;0>9!D015137459F! 9=3Y=1! 619! 43;B1371#! \10;!43B,=6;! 13! D9@616! :;3:1!3;! 16! ;K,4897;049! ,9!D0464R3! D015137459F! S679! 61! 9D,4B9! :1! I;0>9!1V713:4:9! D909! ,;6! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896#! .3!-;679! _4B9F! D;0! 1A1>D,;F! :1! 9B=10:;! B;3!-;07S6! M%$(&NF!1,! 93T,4646!:1!=39!>=16709!:1!1VD1:413716! A=:4B49,16! D;0! 167;6! :1,47;6!>;670R!Y=1!'$m!:1!,96!D106;396!B;3:139:96!167=5;! 13! D0464R3! D015137459F! B;3! =3!D0;>1:4;! :1! %((! :@96! :1! 13B90B1,9>4137;#!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!&! L07@B=,;! (+#! -;36747=B4R3! :1! ,;6! .679:;6! ^34:;6! :1!cSV4B;#! r.,! A=1U! ;0:1390T! ,9! D0464R3! D015137459F!;I4B4;69>1371F! 13! ,;6! B96;6! :1! :1,43B=13B49! ;08934ZU9:9F! C;>4B4:4;! :;,;6;F! 54;,9B4R3F! 61B=1670;F! 70979! :1!D106;396F! :1,47;6! B;>174:;6! B;3! >1:4;6! 54;,137;6!B;>;!90>96!?!1VD,;645;6F!96@! B;>;!:1,47;6!809516!Y=1!:1710>431!,9!,1?!13!B;3709!:1!,9!618=04:9:!:1!,9!39B4R3F!1,!,4K01!:16900;,,;!:1!,9!D106;39,4:9:!?!:1!,9!69,=:f#!!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES14
Fotografía: Matías Torres. Fotógrafo de la Unidad de Comunicaciones, Gendarmería de Chile.
![Page 19: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
Condiciones carcelarias en las Américas y derechos fundamentales !
E9! L69>K,19! a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
-;>;! ,;! C9! 61X9,9:;! ,9! -;>464R3! P3710Z9>104B939! :1! /101BC;6! j=>93;6! M-P/jNF!e,96! B;3743=96! 54;,9B4;316! 9,! :101BC;! 9! ,9!54:9! :1! ,96! D106;396! D0459:96! :1! ,9! ,4K1079:!B;36747=?13!=3;!:1!,;6!D043B4D9,16!D0;K,1>96!13! ,96! BT0B1,16! :1! ,9! 0184R3#! L3=9,>1371!B4137;6! :1! 01B,=6;6! 13! L>S04B9!>=1013! D;0!:46743796! B9=696F! D043B4D9,>1371! B;>;!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!*! H.LF! _16;,=B4R3! :1! ,9! L69>K,19! a13109,F! La]_.W#!%)($! MlllPlZH]$+NF! 9D0;K9:9! 1,! g! :1! A=34;! :1! %$$+[!H.LF!_16;,=B4R3!:1!,9!L69>K,19!a13109,F!La]_.W#!%g$"!MllloPPPZH]$'NF!9D0;K9:9!1,!("!:1! A=34;!:1!%$$'[!H.LF!_16;,=B4R3! :1! ,9! L69>K,19! a13109,F! La]_.W#! %%'"!MllloPPZH]$*NF!9D0;K9:9!1,!)!:1! A=34;!:1!%$$*F!?!H.LF!_16;,=B4R3! :1! ,9! L69>K,19! a13109,F! La]_.W#! %%""!MllloPZH]$&NF!9D0;K9:9!1,!&!:1!A=34;!:1!%$$&#!
B;361B=13B49! :1! ,9! 54;,13B49! B90B1,9049f!M-P/jF! %$((F! D#! ($)N#! O93! 6R,;! 13701! %$$)! ?!%$($F! ((! D9@616! 13! L>S04B9! 01D;0790;3! ,9!>=1071!54;,1379!:1!%F)g+!D106;396#!/1!16796F!(F'&)! ;B=00410;3! 13! B1370;6! D134713B4904;6!:1! o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gF! D#! +*N#! .3! b0964,F! 13! 1679:;6!B;>;!\49=@!;!c909XR3F!,9!7969!:1!C;>4B4:4;6!16!(&!?!%%!51B16!>T6!9,79!13!,96!D0464;316!Y=1!D909! ,9!D;K,9B4R3!13!813109,! M/1D9079>137;!\134713B4904;!Q9B4;39,!:1!b0964,F!%$(&F!D#!)"N#!.3!cSV4B;F!:=09371!%$$'F! ,9!D0;K9K4,4:9:!:1!>;040! 13! =3! B1370;! D134713B4904;! 109! B43B;!51B16! 6=D104;0! 9,! :1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! 813109,#! L!D1690! :1! Y=1! 13! %$$+! 1679! D0;K9K4,4:9:!:46>43=?RF!B;3743=R!6413:;!>T6!:1,!:;K,1!:1!,9! Y=1! 61! ;K6105R! 13! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! 813109,!McSV4B;!.59,29F!%$($N#!!!.3!7S0>43;6!:1!69,=:F!,96!BT0B1,16!016=,793!=3!137;03;! :1! 9,7;! 04168;! :1! B;37984;! :1!:4510696! 13I10>1:9:16#! .V4671F! D;0! 1A1>D,;F!=39! 1,159:9! D0159,13B49F! >T6! Y=1! 13! ,9!D;K,9B4R3!13!813109,F!:1!oPj#!.67;!61!:1K1!9!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES 15
![Page 20: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
B410796!D0TB74B96!B;>;!1,!=6;!B;>D9074:;!:1!98=A96!D909!1,!B;36=>;!:1!:0;896F!1,!797=9A1!B;3!1Y=4D;!B9610;!?!3;!167S04,F!1,!61V;!:1!9,7;!04168;! ?! ,96! 54;,9B4;316! 61V=9,16#! .,!C9B439>4137;F!1,!1670S6F! ,9!:163=704B4R3!?F!1,!9K=6;! :1! :0;896! :1K4,4793! 1,! 64671>9!43>=3;,R84B;!C9B413:;!Y=1!,96!D106;396!Y=1!54513! B;3! oPj! 6193! >T6! 6=6B1D74K,16! 9!B;370910! 13I10>1:9:16#!L=3!96@F! ,;6!D0;809Z>96!:1!D01513B4R3!:1,!oPj!3;!6=1,13!9713:10!9! ,;6! 437103;6F! ?! >=BC96! D106;396! D0459:96!:1! ,9! ,4K1079:! 3;! 741313! 9BB16;! 9,! 70979Z>4137;! 937400170;5409,! 34! 9713B4R3! >S:4B9!9:1B=9:9!ML5107F!%$()N#!H3=64:9!1674>9!Y=1!,96!79696!:1!D0159,13B49!:1!oPj!6;3!13701!:;6!?! B43B=1379! 51B16!>T6!9,79!13!D0464;316!Y=1!13!,9!D;K,9B4R3!813109,#!.3!.679:;6!^34:;6!,9!D0159,13B49! :1! oPj! 16! %#g! >9?;0! ?! 13!L08137439! ($! 51B16!>T6! MH3=64:9F! %$(gF! ! D#!gN#! .3! 1,! 1679:;! :1! _@;! a093:1! :1,! W=0! 13!b0964,F!,9!7969!:1!D0159,13B49!:1!oPj!,,189!9!,9!9,90>9371!B4I09!:1!)"$!B96;6!D;0!B9:9!($>4,!D106;396!D01696F!16!:1B40F!("!51B16!,9!7969!:1!D0159,13B49! 813109,! 13! 1,! D9@6!M/1D9079>137;! \134713B4904;! Q9B4;39,! :1!b0964,F!%$(&F!D#!)&N#!!
!
!
.67=:4;6!B;>D909745;6!K969:;6!13!=3!93T,4646!:1! ,9! ,471097=09! 4371039B4;39,! 1V4671371! C93!>;6709:;!79>K4S3!Y=1!,9!7969!:1!D0159,13B49!
:1!7=K10B=,;646!13!D0464;316!16!13!D0;>1:4;!%"! 51B16! >T6! 9,79! Y=1! 13! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! 13!813109,!Mb9=6693;F!J4,,49>6F!Q=33F!b188497;F!h1:1,4!d!WB93;&!%$($N#!W1823!:97;6!;I4B49,16F!13!b0964,! ,96!D106;396!D0459:96!:1!,9! ,4K1079:!741313! =39! D0;K9K4,4:9:! %'! 51B16! >9?;0! ,9!D;K,9B4R3! 13! 813109,! :1! B;370910!7=K10B=,;646! M/1D9079>137;! \134713B4904;!Q9B4;39,!:1!b0964,F!%$(&F!D#!))N#!/1!9B=10:;!9!167=:4;6! B;>D4,9:;6! D;0! ^QH/-F! 13!^0=8=9?F!13!%$$'F!,9!D0159,13B49!:1!oPj!?!:1!j1D974746! b! 13701! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! Y=1! 61!13B=13709!13!BT0B1,16!109!:1,!;0:13!:1,!)#)m!?!'#)m!016D1B7459>1371#!.3!cSV4B;F!13!%$(%F!1093!:1!&#*mF!g#gm[! ,9!:1!j1D974746!-!109!:1!($mF!>=BC;!>T6!9,79!Y=1! ,9!:1! ,9!D;K,9B4R3!13!813109,'#!h439,>1371F!1V4671!=39!9,79!7969!:1! D0159,13B49! :1! 70967;03;6! D64Y=4T704B;6F!B;>;! ,9! K4D;,904:9:F! :1D0164R3F! 16Y=4U;I01Z349F!70967;03;6!D64BR74B;6F!13701!;70;6F!13!,;6!B1370;6! :1! 01B,=64R3! Y=1! 3;! 6;3! 9713:4:;6!:1K4:9>1371! MW719:>93F! H6C10F! _;KK436F!-961!d!W9>=1,6F!%$$+F!D#!*&(Z*&)N#!
E;6! 04168;6! 9! ,9! 69,=:! Y=1! 01D01613793! ,96!BT0B1,16! 6;3! 9:1>T6! B;>D9074:;6! D;0! ,9!D;K,9B4R3!D=1371!MY=41316!5464793!;!709K9A93!13! ,;6! 01B,=6;04;6N#! \;0! 1A1>D,;F! 13!%$($! 61!13B;370R! Y=1! ,96! D0464;316! I=10;3! 1,! D=37;!:1! B;37984;! D909! '#"m! :1! ,;6! B96;6! :1!7=K10B=,;646!13!,;6!D9@616!:1!9,7;6!438016;6!?!D909!&#"m!:1!,;6!B96;6!13!,;6!D9@616!:1!K9A;6!438016;6! Mb9=6693;! !"# $%F! %$($F! D#! &$N#! .,!04168;! :1! 13I10>1:9:! 16! 79,! Y=1! 43B,=6;! 61!C9!D,93719:;!Y=1!=3!43B01>137;!:1!(m!13!,9!D;K,9B4R3! 13B90B1,9:9! D=1:1! 8131090! =3!43B01>137;! :1! $#"gm! 13! ,9! 7969! :1!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!'! .3! 1,! 6474;! ^QH/-! W7974674B6! 16! D;64K,1! B;36=,790! ,9!K961! :1! :97;6! 6;K01! 13I10>1:9:16! 70936>464K,16! 13!D0464;316F!?!16!:1!D10>931371!9B7=9,4U9B4R3#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]K47#,?]%8J_81B!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES16
Fotografía: Oficina de Prensa y Comunicación. Ministerio de Justicia y Paz de Costa Rica.
![Page 21: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
D0159,13B49! :1! 7=K10B=,;646! 13701! ,9!D;K,9B4R3! 813109,! MW719:>93! !"# $%F! %$$+F! D#!*&(Z*&)N#!
!!!.,! 13B90B1,9>4137;! 4>D,4B9! 9:1>T6! ;70;6!4>D9B7;6! 9:5106;6! D909! ,96! D106;396!Y=1! 61!13B=137093! 13! D0464R3F! D909! 6=6! I9>4,496! ?!D909! ,96! B;>=34:9:16!9! ,96!Y=1!D107131B13#!\909! ,96! D106;396! 13! D0464R3! 74131!B;361B=13B496!318974596!D909!6=!9=7;1674>9F!6=6! 01,9B4;316!6;B49,16!?!13! ,96!D;64K4,4:9:16!:1! ;K71310! =3! 1>D,1;! :1B1371! 1! 438016;6!9:1B=9:;6F! 7937;! :=09371! 1,! 13B90B1,9Z>4137;F!B;>;!D;67104;0>1371#!^3!167=:4;!:1!L:;,I;! W9BC64:9! ?! `;081! :1! c13:;3s9!>;670R!Y=1!13!,9!D0;543B49!:1!b0964,49F!b0964,F!,;6!1VB90B1,9:;6!D10B4K@93!C9679!"+m!>13;0!69,904;! Y=1! 1,! 0167;! :1! ,96! D106;396!1>D,19:96! MW9BC64:9! d!c13:;3s9F! %$$*F! D#!)$)N#! \909! ,96! I9>4,496F! 1,! 13B90B1,9>4137;!D=1:1! 4>D,4B90F! :16:1! =39! >9?;0!5=,3109K4,4:9:! 1B;3R>4B9! ?! 16748>974U9B4R3F!C9679! ,9! 0=D7=09! :1,! 32B,1;! I9>4,490! ?! ,9!D0164R3!D909!Y=1!9,8=3;6!:1!,;6!>41>K0;6!61!543B=,13! 13! 9B7454:9:16! :1,43B=13B49,16#!.67;6!B;67;6!6;3!16D1B49,>1371!61374:;6!D;0!,96!>=A1016F!Y=1!6;3!Y=41316!D043B4D9,>1371!5464793!?!D9893! ,;6!B;67;6!1B;3R>4B;6!:1! ,96!BT0B1,16! M\S01U! -;0019F! %$()N#! .,! 43710S6!
6=D104;0! :1! 34X;6! ?! 34X96! 79>K4S3! D=1:1!51061! 61049>1371! 9I1B79:;F! D=16! =39!B01B41371! ,471097=09! >=16709! B;>;! 1,,;6! ?!1,,96! D=1:13! 13I013790! 4>D9B7;6! 9:5106;6! ?!D1;016! 016=,79:;6! 1:=B9745;6! ?! :1! ;709!@3:;,1!B;3!1,!13B90B1,9>4137;!:1!6=6!D9:016!MW9951:096F! E9DD9:;F!b938;F!d!c1,,;F! %$(g[!_;K1076;3F! %$(%[! _;613K108F! %$$+[! O;>k43F!%$$+N#!E9!B;3B13709B4R3!:1,!13B90B1,9>4137;!13! D106;396! :1! B410796! D;K,9B4;316! ;!B;>=34:9:16F! 9:1>T6! :1! DS0:4:96!1B;3R>4B96F! D=1:1! 8131090! 1I1B7;6! :1!16748>974U9B4R3! ?! >9?;0! 54;,13B49! 13! 6=!B;3709!D;0!D9071!:1! ,96! 436747=B4;316!=!;70;6!>41>K0;6! :1! ,9! 6;B41:9:#! \;0! ;709! D9071F! 1,!13B90B1,9>4137;! D=1:1! 9809590! ,96! :164Z8=9,:9:16! 1V46713716! 13! =39! 6;B41:9:F!:17104;093:;!,9!>;54,4:9:!6;B49,F! ,9!B;C164R3!?!,9!B;3I493U9!13!,96!436747=B4;316+#!!.,! :1643710S6! :1! ,;6! .679:;6! D;0! >9371310!64671>96! D134713B4904;6! 9B;0:16! B;3! ,;6!167T3:9016! :1! ,;6! :101BC;6! C=>93;6! C9!;B964;39:;! =39! B04646! 64671>T74B9! :1!54;,9B4R3! 9! ,;6! :101BC;6! C=>93;6! :1! ,96!D106;396! D0459:96! :1! ,9! ,4K1079:F! ,;! Y=1! 61!01I,1A9!13!3451,16!9,7;6!:1!C9B439>4137;!?!13!,96! D01B90496! B;3:4B4;316! :1! 01B,=64R3F!43B;>D974K,16! B;3! ,9! :4834:9:! C=>939#! .679!D;,@74B9! 813109! B;67;6! :1! ;D;07=34:9:!13;0>16! 13! 1,! =6;! :1! ,;6! 01B=06;6! ?! =39!DS0:4:9! :1! ,18474>4:9:! :1! ,96! 436747=B4;316!:1,! 64671>9! :1! A=674B49#! W43! 1>K908;F! ,;6!4>D9B7;6! 13! 7S0>43;6! :1! 01:=BB4R3! :1! ,9!:1,43B=13B49! 6;3! B=1674;39K,16! 43B,=6;F!B;3709D0;:=B13716F! B=93:;! 61! 9D,4B93! 9! ,;6!:1,47;6!>13;016!?F!13!7;:;!B96;F!43I104;016!9!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!+! \909! =3! 93T,4646! :1! ,;6! 167=:4;6! Y=1! B=9374I4B93! ?!:;B=>13793! 167;6! ?! ;70;6! 4>D9B7;6! :1,! 13B90B1,9Z>4137;!13!.679:;6!^34:;6!D=1:1!B;36=,79061!1,!709K9A;!:1,!Q974;39,!_16190BC!-;=3B4,!M%$$(F!D#!()*Z"(+N!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES 17
Fotografía: Programa Libertas. Cárcel de Varones de San Sebastián. Departamento de Cochabamba, Bolivia. Celdas construidas improvisadamente sobre el techo de la prisión por motivos de hacinamiento.
![Page 22: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
,;6! Y=1! D=1:13! 01D01613790! ;7096! 9,7103974Z596!D909!9I0;3790!,;6!I13R>13;6!:1,4B745;6#!!!.3!,9!648=41371!61BB4R3!61!>=16709!Y=1!1,!=6;!D0159,1371! ?! 1V713:4:;! :1,! :101BC;! D139,!D909! 016D;3:10! 9,! I13R>13;! :1! ,96! :0;896!4,@B4796!16!=39!:1! ,96!D043B4D9,16!B9=696!:1! ,9!B04646! :1,! 13B90B1,9>4137;! >9645;! Y=1!D9:1B13!,;6!D9@616!:1!,9!0184R3#!!!
Encarcelamiento por delitos de drogas!
!
Los vicios de la política de drogas en el proceso penal !
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
/=09371! ,9! I961! :1! e*1)2),$%)3$*)+,#-1)2$1)$fF! 13! 1,! >;>137;! :1! ,9! :1I434B4R3!,1846,97459! :1! ,;6! :1,47;6! ?! ,96! D1396F! ,;6!.679:;6! :1K13! 016D1790! =39! 61041! :1!e4$1$,"5$6# -!,$%!6fF! B;>;! ,96! Y=1! 4>D;313!,;6! 43670=>137;6!:1!:101BC;6!C=>93;6!?! ,96!3;0>96! B;36747=B4;39,16! :1! B9:9! D9@6#! .6796!890937@96! B;3741313! ,@>4716! 9,! 1679K,1B4Z
>4137;!:1!D1396!K969:;6!13!,;6!D043B4D4;6!:1!,189,4:9:F! ,16454:9:F! D0;D;0B4;39,4:9:F!B=,D9K4,4:9:F! I439,4:9:! ?! 09U;39K4,4:9:! :1! ,9!D139#!.3! ,9!618=3:9!I961!:1!e*1)2),$%)3$*)+,#6!*.,($1)$fF! ?! :=09371! 1,! 1A10B4B4;! :1! ,9!435167489B4R3! :1! ,9! 016D;369K4,4:9:! D139,!MY=1! 79>K4S3! 43B,=?1! 9! ,;6! 9813716! :1!D;,4B@9NF!,9!9BB4R3!:1,!.679:;!:1K1!6=A179061!9!=39! 61041! :1! e4$1$,"5$6# -17*!6$%!6f! Y=1!13>90B93! ,;6! 01Y=4647;6!Y=1!:1K13!01=340! ,9!435167489B4R3! ?! 1,! D0;B16;! D139,! D909! 610!,18@74>;6! ?! B;>D974K,16! B;3! ,;6! :101BC;6!I=3:9>1379,16#! h439,>1371F! 1V4671! =39! 61041!:1!D043B4D4;6! B;36747=B4;39,16! ?!:1!:101BC;6!Y=1! :1K13! 610! 016D179:;6! 13! ,9! e*1)2)8,$%)3$*)+,#"!1*)$1)$fF!167;!16F!13!,9!I961!:1!,9!1A1B=B4R3! :1! ,9! D139! M-;>464R3! L616;09! :1!\;,@74B9!-04>439,F!%$(%F!D#!(*N#!!
Criminalización primaria !
.3!,9!I961!:1!,9!B04>439,4U9B4R3!D04>9049!61!C9!B=1674;39:;! 64! 1,! 1679K,1B4>4137;! :1! 74D;6!D139,16! D909! 693B4;390! B410796! B;3:=B796!01,9B4;39:96! B;3! :0;896! 16! B;>D974K,1! B;3!5904;6! :1! ,;6! D043B4D4;6! :1,! :101BC;! D139,!M^D04>3?F! a=U>T3F! d! \9009F! %$("F! D#! %(N#!^3;! :1! 16;6! D043B4D4;6! 16! 1,! :1! ,16454:9:F! ;!9374A=04:4B4:9:! >971049,#! -;3I;0>1! 9! 1671!D043B4D4;F! 6;,;! D=1:13! 610! B04>439,4U9:96! ?!693B4;39:96! D139,>1371! B;3:=B796! Y=1!1I1B7459>1371! 5=,31013! ;! D;3893! 13! 04168;!K41316!A=0@:4B;6!I=3:9>1379,16F!13!,9!>1:4:9!13!Y=1!D0;71A93!,;6!:101BC;6!?!,4K1079:16!:1!,96! D106;396! ;! B;3:4B4;316! 1613B49,16! :1,!;0:13!6;B49,#!.67;!64834I4B9!Y=1F!13!=3!.679:;!:1>;B0T74B;! Y=1! 016D179! 1,! D,=09,46>;! ?! 1,!,4K01! :16900;,,;! :1! ,9! D106;39,4:9:F! 3;! 6;3!D=34K,16! B;>D;079>4137;6! Y=1! D=1:13! 610!D1,480;6;6! D909! ,9! D106;39! Y=1! ,;6! 019,4U9! ;!,;6! Y=1! 6193! B;364:109:;6! 43>;09,16! D;0!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES18
![Page 23: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
9,823! 61B7;0! :1! ,9! 6;B41:9:F! D10;! Y=1! 3;!01D01613793! <13! 6@! >46>;6<! =3! B;>D;079Z>4137;! ,1645;!D909! 710B10;6#! .,,;F! D;0! B4107;F!3;!64834I4B9!Y=1!1,!.679:;!3;!:1K1!4371051340!D909! D0;71810! ,9! 69,=:! :1! ,96! D106;396F! 643;!Y=1! 3;! :1K1! C9B10,;! =693:;! 1,! :101BC;!D139,#!
E9! 74D4I4B9B4R3! B;>;! :1,47;! :1! ,96! B;3:=B796!01,9B4;39:96! B;3! :0;896! 4,@B4796! K=6B9!D0;71810! ,9! 69,=:! D2K,4B9#! W43! 1>K908;F!9=3Y=1! 61! 70979! :1! =3! K413! A=0@:4B;!4>D;079371F! 13! 813109,! ,96! B;3:=B796!01,9B4;39:96! B;3! :0;896! 4,@B4796! 3;! 6=1,13!8131090!:9X;6!B;3B017;6!?!:1!>93109!:401B79!6;K01! :4BC;! K413#! W4! 9B96;F! D=1:1! 1V46740! =3!:9X;! 6;K01! ,9! 69,=:! :1! ,9! D106;39! Y=1! C9!:1B4:4:;! B;36=>40! 5;,=379049>1371! 9,8=39!6=6793B49#! \10;F! B;>;! 61! C9! 01B;3;B4:;! 13!5904;6! D9@616F! 1,! B;36=>;! :1! :0;896! 16! =39!9B7454:9:! D;0! ,9! B=9,! =39! D106;39! D=1:1!;D790! ,4K01>1371F! 9>D909:9! 13! :101BC;6!I=3:9>1379,16!B;>;!,9!9=7;3;>@9!43:454:=9,!?!1,!,4K01!:16900;,,;!:1!,9!D106;39,4:9:F!09UR3!D;0! ,9! Y=1F! :1! 343823! >;:;F! :1K10@9! 610!;KA17;! :1! 693B4R3! D139,! M\S01U! -;0019F!^D04>3?F! d! -C9D900;F! %$(&N#! WR,;! 016D1B7;!:1!>=?!D;B;6!74D;6!D139,16!01,9B4;39:;6!B;3!:0;896! 61! D;:0@9! 1679K,1B10! ,9! 1V46713B49! :1!=3!:9X;!B;3B017;!?!:401B7;F!B;>;!13!1,!B96;!:1!6=>434670;!9!>13;016F!D=16!,9!:46704K=B4R3!:1! :0;896! 9! 34X;6F! 34X96! ?! 9:;,16B13716! 6@!D;:0@9! 4>D,4B90! =39! 9I1B79B4R3! :1! 6=! ,4K01!:16900;,,;!:1!,9!D106;39,4:9:!M^D04>3?!!"#$%&!%$(%F! D#! (gN#! E9! 8093!>9?;0@9! :1! B;3:=B796!693B4;39:96F!B;>;!,9!641>K09F!,9!D0;:=BB4R3F!,9! :46704K=B4R3! ;! ,9! B;>10B49,4U9B4R3F! >T6!K413!8131093!=3!04168;!9K6709B7;!1! 43:401B7;!Y=1! D=:4109! 9I1B790! ,9! 69,=:! D2K,4B9F! ,;! B=9,!3;! A=674I4B9! 1,! =6;! :1,! :101BC;! D139,! ?! ,9!B;3648=41371! 016704BB4R3! 9! ;70;! K413! A=0@:4B;!
793! 4>D;079371! B;>;! ,9! ,4K1079:! :1! ,96!D106;396! M?! ,;6! :1>T6! :101BC;6! Y=1!43:401B79>1371!6;3!9I1B79:;6N#!!!
!
!
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e9,# !:!*"7&# 1!6.%"$# *1.!%# !# ),;.2$,7# )2-7,!1# $# .,$#-!167,$# .,$# -!,$# <.!# ,7# 4.$1(!# .,$# 1$37,$=%!#-17-71*)+,# *7,# %$# 41$/!($(# (!# 6.# *7,(.*"$>#M^D04>3?!!"#$%&!%$(%F!D#()N#!.671!D043B4D4;!D=1:1!:454:4061!13!:;6G!9N! ;I13696! B;>D9097459>1371! 809516! :1K13! 610!B967489:96! B;3! 615104:9:! 64>4,90! !?! KN! :1K1!C9K10!=39!01,9B4R3! A=679!13701!1,! B96748;!;! 693B4R3! 4>D=1679!?!1,!:9X;!Y=1!61!K=6B9!154790!M-.//F!%$(%F!D#!(&*Z%$$N#!!!!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES 19
Fotografía: Mauro Tomasini
![Page 24: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
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
.6D1B@I4B9>1371F! ,9! 4>D;64B4R3! :1! D1396!D045974596!:1! ,9! ,4K1079:!D909! 693B4;390! 7;:9!6=1071!:1!B;3:=B796!01,9B4;39:96!B;3!:0;896!16! :16D0;D;0B4;39:9! 13! ;70;6! :;6! 61374:;6G!13! 61374:;! =74,47904;! ?! 13! 61374:;!B;36747=B4;39,! M^D04>3?! !"# $%&! %$("N#! .3!61374:;!=74,47904;F!,;6!B;67;6!Y=1!C9!813109:;!1671! :16K;0:9>4137;! D=34745;! 3;! 61!B;>D13693! B;3! ,;6! 16B96;6! K131I4B4;6! Y=1!01D;079#! .,! 167=:4;! :1,! -.//! M%$(gF! D#! ()*Z()'N!>;670R! Y=1! 8093! D9071! :1! ,;6! 01B=06;6!:1! ,96! D;,@74B9! :1! :0;896! 13! ,9! 0184R3! 61!:1674393!9! ,9! 01:=BB4R3!:1!B=9,Y=410! 74D;!:1!B;36=>;F!643!9713:10!:1K4:9>1371!,;6!B96;6!:1! B;36=>;! D0;K,1>T74B;#! .67;F! ,1A;6! :1!:46>43=40! 1,! B;36=>;F! C9! 7134:;! B;>;!B;361B=13B49! ,9! 16748>974U9B4R3! :1! =6=904;6!
?! ,9! 5=,3109B4R3!:1! 6=6!:101BC;6! I=3:9>13Z79,16#!.3!61374:;!B;36747=B4;39,F!D;0!6=!D9071F!61! 70979!:1!=39!>1:4:9!Y=1! ,4>479!:101BC;6!I=3:9>1379,16F! D10;! 3;! D901B1! =3!43670=>137;! 9:1B=9:;F! 31B16904;! ?!D0;D;0B4;39,! D909! 8909374U90! ,9! 69746I9BB4R3!:1! ;70;6! :101BC;6! I=3:9>1379,16! ;! :1!59,;016! 1613B49,16! :1! B;354513B49! 13! =39!:1>;B09B49#!!
Criminalización secundaria (punición en la etapa judicial) !
.3! ,9! >9?;0@9! :1! ,;6! D9@616! 167=:49:;6! ,9!:1I434B4R3!A=:4B49,!:1!,9!016D;369K4,4:9:!D139,!?!1,!>;37;!16D1B@I4B;!:1!,9!D139!M13!9X;6!:1!BT0B1,N!13!>971049!:1!:0;896! 61!B909B7104U93!D;0! ,9! 43I,1V4K4,4:9:F! ,9!B;3I=64R3!:1!:4510696!B;3:=B796! 13! =3! >46>;! 74D;! D139,! ?! ,9!615104:9:#! /4BC;6! 64671>96! 61! B909B7104U93!D;0! 71310! 018@>1316!16D1B49,16!:1!890937@96!,4>479:96! D909! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896F! =3! =6;!43:46B04>439:;! :1! ,9! D0464R3! D015137459! ?! ,9!D0159,13B49! :1! ,9! I,98093B49F! 13701! ;70;6#!.6796! :46D;64B4;316F! ;! ,9! I;0>9! ! 13! Y=1! 61!9D,4B93! D;0! ,;6! ;D109:;016! A=:4B49,16F!710>4393! D;0! 1A10B10! =39! >9?;0! D0164R3!6;K01!,;6!64671>96!D134713B4904;6#!!
!
!
!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES20
Fotografía: Matías Torres. Fotógrafo de la Unidad de Comunicaciones, Gendarmería de Chile.
![Page 25: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
.3! 7;:;6! ,;6! D9@616! 61! 1679K,1B13! D1396!>@34>96! ;K,4897;0496! D909! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896!:1! 9B=10:;! 9! I9B7;016! B;>;! ,9! 6=6793B49! 13!B=1674R3F!,9!B9374:9:F!,;6!>R54,16!?!I4316!:1!,9!B;3:=B79F! ,9! =34:9:! ;! D,=09,4:9:! :1! ,;6!9813716F! ,96!B40B=36793B496!:1!>;:;F! 741>D;!?!,=890!:1,!C1BC;!;B=004:;F!,96!B40B=36793B496!43:454:=9,16! :1! ,9! D106;39! 693B4;39:9[! 1,!3451,! :1! D9074B4D9B4R3! :1,! 9B=69:;F! 6=!9B1D79B4R3! :1! B=,D9K4,4:9:! ?! 6=6!9371B1:13716! D139,16#! .3! 9,8=3;6! D9@616! 1,!1679K,1B4>4137;! :1! D1396! >@34>96! 4>D4:1!Y=1! ,96! D106;396! B;3:139:96!D;0! :1,47;6! :1!:0;896! D=1:93! 01B4K40! K131I4B4;6! 13! ,9!1A1B=B4R3! :1! ,9! D139#! .3! \102! Mc9381,43BkV!`#F! %$("NF! D;0!1A1>D,;F!;!13!.B=9:;0F! 7096! ,9!01I;0>9! :1,! -R:48;!H08T34B;! P371809,! \139,F!5904;6! :1! 167;6! I9B7;016! 6;3! 7134:;6! 13!B=1379F! ,;! Y=1! 01:=B1! 1,! D0;K,1>9! :1! ,9!43:46743B4R3! 13! ,9! I4A9B4R3! :1! ,9! D139#! Q;!;K679371F! 13! ;70;6! D9@616! ,;6! B047104;6! Y=1!:1710>4393! ,9! I4A9B4R3! :1! ,9! D139! 6;3! >=?!016704384:;6F! B;>;! 16! 1,! B96;! :1! b;,4549F!cSV4B;!;!-;,;>K49#!E9!0143B4:13B49!13!5904;6!D9@616!16!=69:9!B;>;!=3!I9B7;0!01,159371!13!,9!:1710>439B4R3!:1! ,9!D139!;!D0;809>96!:1!9,7103974596! 9,! 13B90B1,9>4137;#! W43! 1>K90Z8;F! :9:9! ,9! B04646! :1! ,;6! 64671>96! D134713ZB4904;6! :1! ,9! 0184R3! ?! 6=! 43B9D9B4:9:! D909!,;8090! 1,! ;KA1745;! :1! ,9! 016;B49,4U9B4R3F!016=,79! B=1674;39K,1! =690! ,9! 0143B4:13B49!B;>;!908=>137;!D909!1VB,=40!9!=39!D106;39!:1! D0;809>96! :1! :165@;! ;! D909! 9809590! 6=!D139#!!
L,! B;364:1090! ,9! 615104:9:! :1! ,96! D1396F!1V46713!9,8=396!:46D;64B4;316!16D1B@I4B96!Y=1!D10>4713!,9!4>D;64B4R3!:1!D1396!>T6!6151096!D909! 693B4;390! ,;6! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896#! .3!b0964,F! D161! 9! ,9! 9:;DB4R3! :1! =39! 3=159!D;,@74B9! B04>439,! 13! ,9! -;36747=B4R3!:1! (+''F!
6=K64671! ,9! B9718;0@9! :1! :1,47;6! :13;>439:9!eB0@>1316! C1:4;3:;6fF! :1370;! :1! ,;6! B=9,16!167T! B;371>D,9:;! 1,! 70TI4B;! :1! :0;896F!434B49,>1371!13!1,! 907@B=,;!)tF! 43B46;!lEPPP! :1!,9!-;36747=B4R3F!?!D;67104;0>1371!:1I434:;!13!,9! E1?! 3#! '#$*%]+$((#! ! \909! 79,16! B0@>1316!167T3! D0;C4K4:;6! B4107;6! K131I4B4;6! B;>;! ,9!9>3467@9F!,9!809B49!;!43:=,7;!?!1,!9=>137;!:1,!D,9U;! D909! ,9! ,4K109B4R3! B;3:4B4;39,F! 9=3Y=1!D;67104;0>1371! 16796! :46D;64B4;316! I=10;3!:1B,909:96! 43B;36747=B4;39,16!D;0!1,!O04K=39,!W=D01>;#! Mb;471=VF! -C1034BC90;F! d! E1u;! :1!LY=43;F!%$(&N#!!
.3! A1:1?9;3F! 61823! 1,! 907@B=,;! "$(! :1,!-R:48;! \139,F! Y=41316! 6;3! B9D7=09:;6! 13!I,98093B49! 6R,;! D=1:13! 01B4K40! =3! B=907;! :1,!K131I4B4;! :1! 01:=BB4R3! :1! ,9! D139! Y=1!01B4K13! ,;6! 4>D=79:;6! 9,! 9B1D790! B908;6!9374B4D9:9>1371F! 16! :1B40F! =39! 01:=BB4R3!>TV4>9! :1,! (%#)m! :1! ,9! D139! ?! 3;! :1,! )$m!B;>;! B;371>D,9! 1,! 907@B=,;! ")(! :1,! -R:48;#!.67;! 016=,79! D9074B=,90>1371! :1651379A;6;!D909!1,! B96;!:1! ,96!D106;396!D0;B169:96!D;0!:1,47;6! :1! :0;896F! D=16! 1,! +g#+m! :1! ,96!B9D7=096! D;,4B49,16! D;0! 70TI4B;F! D;071! ;!I9K04B9B4R3!:1!167=D1I9B413716!61!019,4U93!13!I,98093B49F!>4137096!Y=1!D909!1,! 0167;!:1! ,;6!:1,47;6! 1679! B,961! :1! B9D7=096! :16B413:1! 9,!'"#gm#! .671! 96D1B7;! 4>D,4B9! =39! :1651379A9!13! ,9! 179D9! :1! A=:4B49,4U9B4R3! Y=1! A=189!D9074B=,90>1371! 13! B;3709! :1! ,96! D106;396!B9D7=09:96! D;0! 16796! B;3:=B796F! D=16F!43B,=6;! 64! 9B1D793! B908;6F! 01B4K40T3! =39!B;3:139!>T6! :=09! 9,! 3;! D;:10! K131I4B49061!:1! 01K9A96! >9?;016! M^D04>3?F! -C9D900;F! d!-0=UF!%$(&9N#!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!((!\909!C9B10!=3!93T,4646!>T6!:179,,9:;!:1! ,9! I48=09!:1!,;6! eB0@>1316! C1:4;3:;6f! 13!b0964,! D=1:1! B;36=,79061!1,!71V7;!:1!b;471=V!#!!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES 21
![Page 26: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
.3! >971049! :1! 890937@96! D0;B169,16F!L,1A93:0;! c9:09U;! ?! L37;34;! b90017;! C93!61X9,9:;!B;>;!,9!8=1009!B;3709!,96!:0;896!C9!A=674I4B9:;! 1,! >13;6B9K;! ?! 809:=9,!:1K4,479>4137;! :1! 59,;016! B;36747=B4;39,16!KT64B;6F! 43B,=4:96! ,96!890937@96!D0;B169,16!13!5904;6! D9@616! :1! ,9! 0184R3! Mb90017;! d!c9:09U;F! %$()N#! .3701! 167;6! *76"76#*7,6")".*)7,$%!6# :1! ,9! 8=1009! B;3709! ,96!:0;896! 167T! ,9! 4370;:=BB4R3! 13! ,9! :SB9:9! :1!,;6! ;BC13796! ?! 3;513796! 13! -;,;>K49! :1!018@>1316! A=:4B49,16! :1! 1VB1DB4R3! D909!016D;3:10! 9! ,9! 9>139U9! :1! ,;6! B9071,16! :1,!390B;70TI4B;#! .A1>D,;! :1! 1,,;! 16! 1,! .6797=7;!D909! ,9! /1I1369! :1! ,9! `=674B49F! Y=1! 01B;8@9!436747=B4;316!D0;B169,16!B;>;! ,9!eA=674B49!643!0;670;fF!=3!64671>9!Y=1!D10>47@9!,9!1V46713B49!13! 1,! D0;B16;! D139,! :1! A=1B16! ?! 716748;6!61B017;6F! 13701! ;70;6! 96D1B7;6!D0;K,1>T74B;6(%#! .59,=9B4;316! D;67104;016!61X9,90;3! ,;6! 8095@64>;6! B;67;6! Y=1! 79,!A=674B49!01D0161379K9!13!>971049!:1!890937@96!D0;B169,16F! Y=1! 9:1>T6! 3;! 1093!B;3709001679:;6!D;0!=39!>9?;0!1I4B9B49!13!,9!,=BC9! B;3709! 1,! B04>13! ;08934U9:;! M-1370;!Q9B4;39,! :1! c1>;049! j467R04B9F! %$("F! D#!%(*N#! ! H70;! 1A1>D,;! :1! B;67;6! B;36747=ZB4;39,16! 16! ,9! 4370;:=BB4R3! :1! =3! 0S84>13!1VB1DB4;39,! D909! B;>K9740! 9,! B04>13!;08934Z!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!(%!e.,!.6797=7;!D909! ,9!/1I1369!:1! ,9!`=674B49F!1VD1:4:;!D;0! 1,! 137;3B16! D0164:1371! -S690! a954049F! 01B;8@9F!9:1>T6! :1! ,9! A=674B49! 643! 0;670;F! ,96! 433;59B4;316! 13!>971049!D0;B169,!D=16796!13!>90BC9!D;0!,9!A=046:4BB4R3!:1! ;0:13! D2K,4B;! ?! 6=D;3@9! 0170;B16;6! 154:13716! 13!>971049! :1! 43:1D13:13B49! 4351674897459#! .671! 16797=7;!;7;089K9! 9>D,496! I9B=,79:16! :1! \;,4B@9! `=:4B49,! 9! ,96!h=10U96! c4,479016F! 9! ,9! D90! Y=1! 01679K9! B9D9B4:9:! :1!9B7=90! 9=7R3;>9>1371! 9,! -=10D;! OSB34B;! :1! \;,4B@9!`=:4B49,#!c4137096! ,96! D04>1096! D;:@93! 9:1,93790!27".#-17-1)7! 435167489B4;316! D01,4>439016F! 1,! 618=3:;! 6R,;!D;:@9! ,,1590! 9! B9K;! 9Y=1,,96! 435167489B4;316! Y=1! ,16!I=1093! B;>464;39:96! D;0! :1B464R3! :1,! A=1U! :1! H0:13!\2K,4B;f!M-1370;!Q9B4;39,!:1!c1>;049!j467R04B9F!%$("F!D#!%(*N#!
U9:;!13!cSV4B;#!L!D;B;!>13;6!:1!:;6!9X;6!:1! C9K10! :1B,909:;! ,9! 8=1009! B;3709! ,96!:0;896F! 1,! 1V! D0164:1371! >1V4B93;! h1,4D1!-9,:10R3! ,;80R! 1679K,1B10F! 9! 3451,!B;36747=B4;39,F! =3! 0S84>13! D139,! 16D1B49,!!!!!!!<:1! :101BC;6! 01:=B4:;6F! ?! D;:1016! ?!:46B01B4;39,4:9:! D;,4B49B;6! 9>D,4I4B9:;6F!D0;C4K4:;6! 13! 1,! 0S84>13! ;0:43904;<! D909!D10618=40!9,! eB04>13!;08934U9:;f#!/1370;!:1!1671! 0S84>13! 61! 13B=13709! ,9! I48=09! :1,!$11$)47&!K9A;!,9!B=9,!,96!D106;396!D=1:13!610!:17134:96F! 643! B;>=34B9B4R3! ?! 643! B908;6!I;0>9,16F! C9679! D;0! '$! :@96! 64! 61! B;364:109!31B16904;! D909! B=9,Y=410! 435167489B4R3! :1!eB04>13!;08934U9:;f("#!.,!=6;!:1,!900948;F!643!1>K908;F!3;!C9!64:;!1VB1DB4;39,!?!13!B964!,9!>479:!:1!,;6!B96;6!61!C4U;!=3!=6;!:1!,9!I48=09!D;0! I=109! :1! 6=! D0;DR647;! B;36747=B4;39,!M\S01U!-;0019!d!LU9;,9F!%$(%N#!!!
.3! D026<);<3F! :1! >93109! 01B41371F! 61!:1B,90RF!D;0!>1:4;!:1,!/1B017;!%%'!:1!%$(&F!,9! 1>10813B49! :1! 618=04:9:! D2K,4B9! 13! 7;:;!1,!710047;04;!39B4;39,!D;0!1,! ,9D6;!:1!=3!9X;F!B;3! D;64K4,4:9:! :1! D0R00;89(g#! E9! >1:4:9!74131!B;>;!;KA1745;!01510740! ,9!e647=9B4R3!:1!D1,480;! B;,1B745;f! B019:9! D;0! 1,! e:1,47;!B;>D,1A;! ?! 1,! B04>13! ;08934U9:;f#! b9A;! 1,!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!("! L:1>T6! :1,! $11$)47F! ,;6! 1,1>137;6! Y=1! B;3I;0>93!1671! 0S84>13! D909,1,;! 6;3G! 9N! ,9! D;64K4,4:9:! :1! =39!01713B4R3!D;,4B49,!9>D,49:9!9,!:;K,1!:1!741>D;!Mg!:@96N!Y=1! 13! 0S84>13! D139,! ;0:43904;F! 93716! :1! D;310,1! 9!:46D;64B4R3! 1,! A=1U! M907@B=,;! (&N[! KN! ,9! 43B;>=34B9B4R3!13! ,9! BT0B1,! M1VB1D7=93:;! ,9! B;>=34B9B4R3! B;3! 6=!9K;89:;!:1I136;0N!M907@B=,;!('N[!BN!,9!B;>D=089B4R3!:1!D1396!13!B1370;6!:1! 01B,=64R3!e16D1B49,16fF! 61D909:;6!:1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! 813109,! M907@B=,;! ('N[! :N! =39!9=7;04U9B4R3! D909! 1679K,1B10! >1:4:96F! 3;!16D1B4I4B9:96F!:1!5484,93B49!e16D1B49,f!M907@B=,;!('N!?!1N!?!643!:101BC;!9!69K10!Y=4S3!16!1,!9B=69:;0!M907@B=,;#!%$N!Mb90017;!d!c9:09U;F!%$()F!D#!())Z()&N#!(g!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77D6G]]vvv#K;,1743;I4B49,#8;K#90]D:I],43kw_]W%_)1>7/_>$01A80:Oo_1.C%ik^$:U$+!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES22
![Page 27: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
B97T,;8;! :1! :1,47;6! 61! 43B,=?10;3! 1,! 70TI4B;F!D0;:=BB4R3!?!I9K04B9B4R3!:1!167=D1I9B413716#!.3701! ,96! >1:4:96! Y=1! 1679K,1B1! 1,! :1B017;!I48=09!,9!9D0;K9B4R3!:1!r_18,96!:1!\0;71BB4R3!L10;16D9B49,rF! Y=1! 9=7;04U9! 9! ,96! h=10U96!L0>9:96! 9! r4:1374I4B90F! 9:510740F! 4374>4:90! ?!C9B10! =6;! :1! ,9! I=10U9! MB;>;! 2,74>;!01B=06;Nf! 9! 39516! 13! 1,! 16D9B4;! 9S01;!90813743;! Y=1! r713893! 1374:9:! 6=I4B41371!D909!xD107=0K90F!D;310!13!04168;!;!B9=690!=3!:9X;x! 13! 1,! 710047;04;! 39B4;39,r#! .6796!3;0>96F!B;3;B4:96!B;>;!eE1?16!:1!/1004K;f!741313! =39! 9>D,49! 709:4B4R3! 13! L>S04B9!E97439F!:;3:1!13!>=BC96!;B964;316!C93!64:;!9:;D79:96! D;0! :1B017;6! D0164:13B49,16F! ;!43B,=6;! 9B796! 0161059:96! :1! -;361A;6! :1!W18=04:9:F! B;>;! ;B=004R! 13! -;,;>K49! 13!!(++"! MO;k97,493F! %$$gN#! o90496! 5;B16! 61! C93!;D=167;! 9! ,9! 9:;DB4R3! :1! 1679! >1:4:9! 13!L08137439F!61X9,93:;!Y=1!16!43B;36747=B4;39,!D;0Y=1! 61! 70979! :1! =39! eD139! :1! >=1071!6=>9049! 13B=K41079fF! ?! Y=1! 61! C9!:1>;6709:;! Y=1! 1671! B9>43;! 3;! 16! 1I4B9U!D909! e:1690>90! 1,! B;>D,1A;!>10B9:;! :1! ,96!:0;896! 4,189,16! 34! 6=! 71A4:;! B;3! ,96!436747=B4;316! 167979,16! 435;,=B09:96! 13! ,96!01:16!:1!4,189,4:9:f!Mj9=610F!%$(&N!#!
.3! G60HF! ,9! -;36747=B4R3! Q9B4;39,! M907@B=,;!%#%g#IN! 61X9,9! Y=1! 13! ,;6! B96;6! :1! 70TI4B;!4,@B47;! :1! :0;896F! ,9! :1713B4R3! 13! -;>4690@9!D=1:1!610!C9679!:1!()!:@96F!13!B;>D909B4R3!B;3!1,!741>D;!>TV4>;!:1!%g!C;096!D909!;70;6!:1,47;6!Mc9381,43BkV!`#F!%$(&N#!
!
Criminalización terciaria: delitos de drogas y obligatoriedad de la cárcel !
.3!,;!Y=1!74131!Y=1!510!B;3!,9!I961!:1!1A1B=ZB4R3!:1!,9!D139F!9!,96!D106;396!D0;B169:96!;!B;3:139:96! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! 61! ,16!34189! B;3! I01B=13B49! 1,! 9BB16;! 9! D1396!9,7103974596! 9! ,9! D0464R3F! :1! ,96! B=9,16!:46D;313! ,;6! 9B=69:;6! D;0! ;70;! 74D;! :1!:1,47;6#! .3! b0964,F! B;>;! 61!>13B4;3R! 93716F!D;0! 70979061! :1! eB0@>1316! C1:4;3:;6fF! ,;6!:1,47;6! :1! :0;89! 167T3! 6=A17;6! 9! =3!>1B9346>;! >T6! 01D01645;! :1! B=>D,4>4137;!:1! D139! Y=1! D909! ;70;6! B0@>1316F! ,;! Y=1!4>D,4B9! Y=1! ,96! D106;396! :1K13! D9690!D;0B1379A16! >9?;016! :1! 741>D;! >@34>;! 13!D0464R3! B;>;! 01Y=4647;! D909! 6;,4B4790! ,9!709364B4R3! 9! 018@>1316! >T6! I95;09K,16!Mb;471=V!!"#$%F!%$(&N#!!
-;3I;0>1!9!,9!01:9BB4R3!;048439,!:1!,9!E1?!:1!/0;896! 13! b0964,F! ,9! 9D,4B9B4R3! :1! D1396!9,7103974596!M6=6747=74596!:1!,9!D0459B4R3!:1!,9!,4K1079:N!1679K9!D0;C4K4:9!D909!1,! B04>13!:1!70TI4B;!:1!:0;896F!D;0!:;6!09U;316G!9N!,9!D139!>@34>9!D0154679!D909!1671! 74D;!:1!:1,47;6!16!:1!B43B;!9X;6!:1!D0464R3!?! ,9! 6=6747=B4R3!D;0!D1396! 9,7103974596! 6R,;! 610@9! D;64K,1F! B;>;!018,9! 813109,F! D909! D1396! :1! C9679! B=970;!9X;6! MB;3I;0>1! 9,! 907@B=,;! gg! :1,! -R:48;!\139,N!?[!KN!13!1,!B96;!:1!,9!I48=09!:1,!70TI4B;!D0454,1849:;F! D0154679! 13! 1,! 907@B=,;! ""F! 61!61X9,9!Y=1! ,9!D139!D;:0@9!9,B93U90!C9679!=3!9X;! ?! ;BC;! >1616! :1! 01B,=64R3! 13! 6=!01:9BB4R3! ;048439,F! :;3:1! 1679K9!1VD0169>1371!D0;C4K4:9!1679! 6=6747=B4R3#!.3!%$(%F!1,!W=D01>;!O04K=39,!h1:109,! M9,! A=U890!1,! j9K196! -;0D=6! +*#%)&N! B;364:10R!43B;36747=B4;39,!79,!D0;C4K4B4R3F!908=>13793Z:;! ,9! 5=,3109B4R3! 9,! D043B4D4;! :1! 43:454:=9Z
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES 23
![Page 28: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
,4U9B4R3! :1! ,9! D139#! W43! 1>K908;F! 1,! D;:10!A=:4B49,! 3;! 641>D01! 648=1! 1,! B047104;! :1,!O04K=39,! h1:109,#! W1823!=3! 01B41371!167=:4;F!6R,;! 13! (%#%m! :1,! 7;79,! :1! ,96! 613713B496!939,4U9:96! MB;3709! =3! g&#'m! :1! B;3:1396! 9!D139! :1! D0464R3N! 61! 9D,4B90;3! D1396!9,7103974596! MP36747=7;! :1! \16Y=4696!.B;3R>4B96!LD,4B9:96F!%$()N#!
O9>K4S3!13! !\102F!9,8=3;6!K131I4B4;6!Y=1! ,9!E1?! B;371>D,9!13! ,9! I961!:1!1A1B=B4R3!:1! ,9!D139! D909! D106;396! B;3:139:96F! B;>;! ,9!,4K1079:!B;3:4B4;39,F!6;3!3189:;6!9!D106;396!693B4;39:96!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896#!P3B,=6;!13!^0=8=9?F! 1,! D9@6! B;3! ,9! ,1846,9B4R3! >13;6!D=347459! :1! ,;6! D9@616! 167=:49:;6F! ,9! 16B969!9D,4B9B4R3! :1! >1:4:96! 9,7103974596! 9618=09!Y=1!>=BC;6!:1,43B=13716!>13;016!:1!:0;896!61! >93713893! 13B90B1,9:;6! MOQP! d! J;,9F!%$($F!D#!&N#!
.3! -;,;>K49F! ,9! ,1846,9B4R3! D139,! B;371>D,9!,9! D;64K4,4:9:! :1! Y=1! ,96! D106;396! Y=1!B;>1713! :1,47;6! >13;016! 61! K131I4B413! :1!9,7103974596! 9,! 13B90B1,9>4137;F! B=93:;! 61!70979! :1! D106;396! Y=1! ?9! C93! 64:;!B;3:139:96F! ,9! ,1846,9B4R3! D139,! 61! 01I4101!B;>;! 6=K0;89:;6! D139,16! 9! ,96! 9,7103974596!:1,! 13B90B1,9>4137;F! D;0! 1A1>D,;F! ,4K1079:!B;3:4B4;39,! ?! 6=6D1364R3! B;3:4B4;39,! :1! ,9!1A1B=B4R3!:1!,9!D139#!W43!1>K908;F!01I;0>96!01B413716! B;>;! ,9! E1?! (*$+! :1! %$(g! C93!016704384:;! ,9!9D,4B9B4R3!:1!9,8=3;6!:1!167;6!6=K0;89:;6!D909!1,!B96;!:1!B4107;6!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896#! /1370;! :1! 16796! B;3:=B796! C9?! :;6!D;64K4,4:9:16! :1! 9D,4B9B4R3! :1! K131I4B4;6! 9!Y=41316!6193!B;3:139:;6!D;0!1,! 43B46;!%!:1,!907@B=,;!"*&!:1,!-R:48;!\139,()#!\909!1,!0167;!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!()! c1:49371! 1671! 43B46;! 61! :1I4313! ,;6! =>K09,16! :1!D;6164R3!:1!167=D1I9B413716!?!6=6!016D1B74596!D1396!:1!,9!648=41371!>93109G!eW4!,9!B9374:9:!:1!:0;89!3;!1VB1:1!
:1!,;6!:1,47;6!3;!C9?!,=890!9!3438=3;!:1!167;6!6=6747=745;6(&#! ^3! B;3:139:;! 13! 16796!B40B=36793B496! 6R,;! D=1:1! 9BB1:10! 9! ,;6!K131I4B4;6! :1! ,;6! 907@B=,;6! &g! ?! "'! a#! .67;!64834I4B9! 13! ,9! D0TB74B9! Y=1! =39! D106;39!B;3:139:9!D;0!70TI4B;F!D;071!;!I9K04B9B4R3!:1!167=D1I9B413716! 43I104;0! 9! >4,! 809>;6! :1!>904C=939F! %$$! 809>;6! :1! C9BC@6! ?! ($$!809>;6!:1!B;B9@39!:1K1!B=>D,40!=3!D10@;:;!:1710>439:;! :1! 01B,=64R3! 13! D0464R3F! D909!9BB1:10! 9! 9,8=3;! :1! 167;6! 6=K0;89:;6!D139,16#! .3! B96;! :1! 16790! B;3:139:;! D;0! 1,!618=3:;!43B46;!:1,!907@B=,;!"*&!61!:1K1!16790!13! 1,! B1370;! D134713B4904;! D;0! ,;! >13;6! "%!>1616F!643!B;379K4,4U90!1,!741>D;!Y=1!790:1!1,!A=1U! 13! :1B4:40! 6;K01! ,9! 6;,4B47=:! :1!9D,4B9B4R3!:1,!K131I4B4;#!.6!:1B40F!13!,9!>1A;0!647=9B4R3! D;64K,1F! =3! B;3:139:;! D;0! :1,47;6!:1! :0;896! 74131! Y=1! 16790! "%! >1616! D909!;D790! D;0! B=9,Y=410! K131I4B4;! D134713B4904;!M^D04>3?! !"# $%&# %$(&9N#! ^3! 93T,4646! :1!1VD1:413716! A=:4B49,16! 019,4U9:;! D;0! 1,!c43467104;! :1! `=674B49! ?! :1,! /101BC;F! 643!1>K908;F!>=16709!Y=1!6;3!>T6! ,;6!B96;6!13!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:1!(F$$$!809>;6!:1!>904C=939F!%$$!809>;6!:1!C9BC@6F!($$!809>;6!:1!B;B9@39!;!:1!6=6793B49!167=D1I9B41371!9!K961! :1! B;B9@39! ;! %$! 809>;6! :1! :10459:;6! :1! ,9!9>9D;,9F! %$$! 809>;6! :1! >179B=9,;39! ;! :0;89!6437S74B9F!,9!D139!610T!:1!B=970;!9!6146!9X;6!:1!D0464R3!?!>=,79!:1!:;6!9!($$!69,904;6!>@34>;6!,189,16!>136=9,16!54813716f#!-R:48;!\139,!-;,;>K493;F!907@B=,;!"*&#!(&! o9,1! ,9! D139! 0169,790! Y=1! 16796! 016704BB4;316! 3;!741313! 9D,4B9B4R3! B=93:;! 61! 70979! :1! =3! B;3:139:;!>9?;0! :1! &)! 9X;6F! B=93:;! 16! =39! >=A10! 9! ,9! Y=1! ,1!I9,793! :;6! >1616! ;! >13;6! D909! 1,! D907;! ;! Y=1! 167S!:1370;! :1! ,;6! 6146!>1616! 648=413716! 9,! 39B4>4137;! :1,!K1KS#! O9>D;B;! B=93:;! 1,! 4>D=79:;! ;! 9B=69:;!167=54101! 13! 1679:;! 80951! D;0! 13I10>1:9:F! D0154;!:4B79>13! :1!>S:4B;6! ;I4B49,16F! B=93:;! ,9! 4>D=79:9! ;!9B=69:9!I=101!>9:01!B9K1U9!:1!I9>4,49!:1!C4A;!>13;0!;!Y=1! 6=I04101! 43B9D9B4:9:! D10>931371F! 641>D01! ?!B=93:;! C9?9! 1679:;! K9A;! 6=! B=4:9:;#! .3! 9=613B49! :1!1,,9F! 1,! D9:01! Y=1! C989! 6=6! 51B16! 713:0T! 1,! >46>;!K131I4B4;F!B96;!13!1,!B=9,!16!31B16904;!D018=3790!9! ,;6!;D109:;016! :1! A=674B49! 6;K01! ,9! 9D,4B9B4R3! :1! 1679!3;0>9#!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES24
![Page 29: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
Y=1! ,;6! A=1B16! 341893! ,;6! 6=K0;89:;6! Y=1!9Y=1,,;6! 13! Y=1! ,;6! B;3B1:13#! E9!B;>K439B4R3! 13701! 3;0>96! 1! 43710D01Z79B4;316! A=:4B49,16! 016704B74596! 813109! =39!13;0>1! :16D0;D;0B4;39,4:9:! 13! 1,! >;37;! ?!,96! B;3:4B4;316! :1! 1A1B=B4R3! :1! ,9! D139F! ,;!Y=1!7;039!>=?!43A=67;!1,!64671>9!D139,!13!6=!016D=1679!9!,;6!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896#!
El encarcelamiento por drogas: una de las principales causas de la crisis penitenciaria !
.,! =6;! :1,! :101BC;! D139,! 6;K01! ;7096!016D=16796! 13! 1,! 71>9! :1! :0;896! C9!4>D,4B9:;! =39! D;,@74B9! >=?! B;67;69! B;3!1I1B7;6! M13! 7S0>43;6! :1! 01:=BB4R3! 13! 1,!9K=6;! :1! :0;896F! D0;71BB4R3! 9! ,9! 69,=:!D2K,4B9!;!43:454:=9,F!01:=BB4R3!:1,!79>9X;!:1!,;6!>10B9:;6! 4,189,16! ;! 6=! B;3704K=B4R3! 9! ,9!618=04:9:N!3=,;6!1F! 43B,=6;F!B;3709D0;:=B13Z716#!-;>;!61!>=16709!9!B;3743=9B4R3F!64!K413!,9! D;K,9B4R3! 13B90B1,9:9! C9! B01B4:;! 9! =3!047>;! 9,90>9371! 13! L>S04B9F! >9?;016! 9! ,;6!:1,! 0167;! :1,! >=3:;F! 1,! B01B4>4137;! :1! ,96!D106;396!13B90B1,9:96!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!C9!64:;!7;:95@9!>T6!9B1,109:;!13!,9!>9?;0@9!:1! ,;6! D9@616! M?! 13! D9074B=,90! 13! ,;6! >T6!8093:16N#!!
.,! 80TI4B;! Y=1! 61! D0161379! 9! B;3743=9B4R3!Ma0TI4B;! %N!>=16709! ,9! B;>D909B4R3! 13701! 1,!B01B4>4137;! D;K,9B4;39,F! 1,! :1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3!D134713B49049!?!1,!:1!,;6!D016;6!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896! 13! ,;6! D9@616! ,9743;9>104B93;6!167=:49:;6#! .,! 1A1! 4UY=410:;! >=16709! ,9!59049B4R3!D;0B137=9,!:1!,9!D;K,9B4R3!813109,F!,9! D;K,9B4R3! B90B1,9049! ?! ,;6! D016;6! D;0!:1,47;6! :1! :0;896! 13! 3=151! D9@616!,9743;9>104B93;6!13!,;6!2,74>;6!9X;6#!!
.3!7;:;6!,;6!D9@616F!B;3!1VB1DB4R3!:1!b;,4549F!,9! D;K,9B4R3! 13B90B1,9:9! D;0! :1,47;6! :1!:0;896!9=>137R!>T6!0TD4:;!Y=1!,9!D;K,9B4R3!13! 813109,F! 9! =3! 047>;! 13701! '! ?! ""! 51B16!>9?;0#! b;,4549! 16! 1,! 234B;! D9@6! 13! 1,! B=9,! ,9!D;K,9B4R3! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! :46>43=?RF!D0;K9K,1>1371! D;0Y=1! 9,8=396! D106;396!B;3:139:96!D;0!167;6!:1,47;6!61!I95;01B410;3!:1! 43:=,7;6(*#! .3! 6146! :1! ,;6! 3=151! D9@616! ,9!D;K,9B4R3! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! B01B4R! >T6!0TD4:;!Y=1! ,9!D;K,9B4R3!B90B1,9049#!.3!b0964,F!>4137096! Y=1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! B90B1,9049! 61!43B01>137R!13!))mF!,9!13B90B1,9:9!D;0!:1,47;!:1! :0;896! B01B4R! %&*mF! 16! :1B40F! 9! =3! 047>;!B43B;!51B16!>9?;0#!.3!-;,;>K49F!,9!D;K,9B4R3!B90B1,9049! B01B4R! (g(mF! D10;! ,9! D;K,9B4R3!13B90B1,9:9! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! 9=>137R!%'+m#
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!(*! -;>;! 61! >13B4;3R! 93716F! 1,! 8;K4103;! b;,45493;!1>474RF! :16:1! :4B41>K01! :1! %$(%F! B=970;! :1B017;6!D0164:13B49,16! D909! ,9! B;3B164R3! 1VB1DB4;39,! :1,!43:=,7;!Y=1!K131I4B4R!9!gF"*g!D106;396!C9679!:4B41>K01!:1!%$()#!!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES 25
![Page 30: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
!!
"#$%&'(!C*!D,#&,'&:0!/03#/! 1,!4(71,'&:0!E/0/#,19!4(71,'&:0!',#'/1,#&,!F!4(71,'&:0!',#'/1,#&,!4(#!./1&3(-!./!.#(E,-!/0!0;/G/!4,8-/-!1,3&0(,2/#&',0(-*!
I86<)6+! .,9K;09B4R3! :1,! -.//! B;3! K961! 13! :97;6! :1,! b93B;! c=3:49,#! MLX;! :1D13:1! :1,! D9@6F! 5S961! 80TI4B9! ?!C77DG]]:97;6#K93B;>=3:49,#;08]N!
.67;6!:97;6F!643!1>K908;F!3;!D10>4713!510!,9!D0164R3!D=347459!Y=1! 61!C9!1A10B4:;! 6;K01! ,9!D;K,9B4R3! 13! ,;6! D9@616! :1! L>S04B9! D;0! ,96!,1?16! :1! :0;896! 1V46713716F! 13! B;>D909B4R3!B;3! ;7096! D90716! :1,! >=3:;#! \909! 1,,;F! 1,!80TI4B;! Y=1! 61! D0161379! 9! B;3743=9B4R3!;I01B1! =39! B;>D909B4R3! 13701! ,96! 79696!D0;>1:4;! :1! 13B90B1,9>4137;! D;0! :467437;6!:1,47;6! 13! 590496! 0184;316! :1,! D,93179F! :1!9B=10:;! 9! ,;6! 01D;0716! Y=1! D01613793! ,;6!.679:;6! 9! ^QH/-#! .,! B;37431371! 9>104B93;!74131!,9!>9?;0!7969!:1!D106;396!13B90B1,9:96!D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896#! L,01:1:;0! :1! )(!D106;396! D;0! B9:9! ($$! >4,! C9K4793716! 167T!
13B90B1,9:9! D;0! 167;6! :1,47;6F! 13! B;>D909ZB4R3! B;3! %'! D;0! B9:9! ($$!>4,! 13! 1,!>=3:;#!E;6! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! 6;3F! 13! D0;>1:4;! 13!L>S04B9F! ,9! 710B109! B9=69!D;0! ,9!Y=1!>T6! 61!13B90B1,9! 9! ,9! D;K,9B4R3F! D;0! :170T6! :1! ,;6!:1,47;6!54;,137;6!?!B964!9,!>46>;!3451,!Y=1!,;6!:1,47;6! B;3709! ,9! D0;D41:9:#! .6! 01,159371!01B;0:90F! B;>;! 61! 1VD,4BR! 93716F! Y=1! ,;6!:1,47;6! :1! :0;896! 3;! 741313! =39! 5@B74>9!:401B79! 643;! Y=1! K=6B93! D0;71810! ,9! 69,=:!D2K,4B9!B;>;!K413!6;B49,#!
!
!
!
("m! 'm!%+m! (+m!
*m! &m! (*m! *m! (m!
g+m! ))m!&'m!
(g%m!("(m!
+'m!
*m!
g&m!
()m!
(%*m!
%&*m!
Z("m!
%'+m!
(%&m!
&"m!
(+m!
)&m!"+m!
Z)$m!
$m!
)$m!
($$m!
()$m!
%$$m!
%)$m!
"$$m!
")$m!
o9049B4R3!m!D;K,9B4R3!813109,! o9049B4R3!m!D;K,9B4R3!B90B1,9049!
o9049B4R3!m!13B90B1,9:;6!D;0!:0;896!
26 CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES
![Page 31: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
"#$%&'(!H*!+,-,!./!/0',#'/1,2&/03(!I4(#!',.,!)55!2&1!6,7&3,03/-J!/0!.&-3&03(-!'(03&0/03/-9!4(#!3&4(!./!./1&3(*
I86<)6+!^QH/-!M%$(&KF!D#!($%N!
.3701! ,;6! D9@616! 939,4U9:;6F! ,9! 7969! :1!13B90B1,9>4137;! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! 167T!13!3451,16!Y=1!593!:1!13701!(*!D;0!B9:9!($$!>4,!13!L08137439!C9679!($"!D;0!B9:9!($$!>4,!C9K4793716! 13! -;679! _4B9#! -;3! 1VB1DB4R3! :1!L08137439F! cSV4B;! ?! b;,4549F! ,9! 7969! :1!13B90B1,9>4137;! D;0! :0;896! 13! ,;6! D9@616!167=:49:;6! 6=D109! 1,! D0;>1:4;! :1! B=9,Y=410!B;37431371!:1,!>=3:;!:467437;!9,!:1!L>S04B9!Mb93B;!c=3:49,F!%$(&N('#!!
.,! 648=41371! B=9:0;! >=16709! ,;6! :97;6! >T6!01B413716! :46D;34K,16! D909! ,;6! ($! D9@616!167=:49:;6F! :1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! 13B90B1,9:9!813109,! ?! ,9! Y=1! 167T! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896F!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!('! oS961! C77DG]]:979#v;0,:K93k#;08! E;6! 9X;6! :1! B9:9!D9@6! 590@93#! \909! L08137439F! b;,4549F! b0964,F! .B=9:;0F!%$(g[!-;,;>K49F!%$()[!-;679!_4B9F!%$((F!cSV4B;F!\102!?!^0=8=9?F!%$("#!
96@! B;>;! ,9!D9074B4D9B4R3!D;0B137=9,!:1!1679!2,74>9! 13! 1,! 7;79,! :1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! B90B1,9049!13701!1,!9X;!434B49,!?!1,!9X;!I439,!16D1B4I4B9:;!D909!B9:9!D9@6#!!-;>;!61!>=16709!13!6146!:1!,;6! ($! D9@616! 167=:49:;6F! ,;6! :1,47;6! :1!:0;896! 01D01613790;3F! 13! 1,! 2,74>;! 9X;!01D;079:;F! =39!>9?;0! D9074B4D9B4R3! D;0B13Z7=9,! :1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! B90B1,9049! Y=1! 13! 1,!D04>10! 9X;! 01D;079:;#! /1! ,;6! >T6! :1! %#*!>4,,;316! :1! D106;396! 13B90B1,9:96! 13! 167;6!D9@616F! )*%! >4,! ,;! 167T3! D;0! :1,47;6! :1!:0;896F! ,;!Y=1!01D0161379!=39!:1!B9:9!B43B;!D106;396F!B;3!=39!,151!713:13B49!9,!96B136;#!E9!D9074B4D9B4R3!:1! ,;6!D016;6!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896! ;6B4,9! 13701! ($m! ?! 1,! %'m! :1! ,9!D;K,9B4R3!B90B1,9049F! ,;!B=9,! ,9! 64729!13701! ,9!618=3:9!?!,9!B=9079!B9=69!:1!>9?;0!13B90B1Z,9>4137;!13!167;6!D9@616#!!
!!!
!"#$%&'(!&()"%#*+!,(--!./01! (!
"#$%&'(!H*!+,-,!./!/0',#'/1,2&/03(!I4(#!',.,!)55!2&1!6,7&3,03/-J!/0!.&-3&03(-!'(03&0/03/-9!4(#!3&4(!./!./1&3(*
$K>D4>2!^QH/-!M$#(&KF!D"!(#$N!
.3701! ,;6! D9@616! 939,4U9:;6F! ,9! 7969! :1!13B90B1,9>4137;! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! 167T!13!3451,16!Y=1!593!:1!13701!(*!D;0!B9:9!(##!>4,!13!L08137439!C9679!(#%!D;0!B9:9!(##!>4,!C9K4793716! 13! -;679! _4B9"! -;3! 1VB1DB4R3! :1!L08137439F! dSV4B;! ?! c;,4549F! ,9! 7969! :1!13B90B1,9>4137;! D;0! :0;896! 13! ,;6! D9@616!167=:49:;6! 6=D109! 1,! D0;>1:4;! :1! B=9,Y=410!B;37431371!:1,!>=3:;!:467437;!9,!:1!L>S04B9!Mc93B;!d=3:49,F!$#(&N('"!!
.,! 648=41371! B=9:0;! >=16709! ,;6! :97;6! >T6!01B413716! :46D;34K,16! D909! ,;6! (#! D9@616!167=:49:;6F! :1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! 13B90B1,9:9!813109,! ?! ,9! Y=1! 167T! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896F!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!('! oS961! C77DG]]:979"v;0,:K93k";08! E;6! 9X;6! :1! B9:9!D9@6! 590@93"! \909! L08137439F! c;,4549F! c0964,F! .B=9:;0F!$#(a[!-;,;>K49F!$#()[!-;679!_4B9F!$#((F!dSV4B;F!\102!?!^0=8=9?F!$#(%"!
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m! ?! 1,! $'m! :1! ,9!D;K,9B4R3!B90B1,9049F! ,;! B=9,! ,9! 64729!13701! ,9!618=3:9! ?! ,9! B=9079! B9=69! :1! >9?;0!13B90B1,9>4137;!13!167;6!D9@616"!!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES 27
Homicidio intencionalOtros crímenes violentosDelitos contra la propiedadCrímenes financieros y corrupciónDelitos de drogasOtros delitos / No conocidos
![Page 32: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
!!
A;,.#(!)*!>(71,'&:0!',#'/1,#&,!3(3,19!4(#!./1&3(-!./!.#(E,-!F!4,#3&'&4,'&:0!4(#'/03;,1!./!4#/-(-!4(#!./1&3(-!./!.#(E,-!/0!1,!4(71,'&:0!',#'/1,#&,!/0!1(-!.&/K!4,8-/-!/-3;.&,.(-*!!!
! G19:37;J<!73076:30;3!KH:);?1!3L1!!06*10)3/1M!
#<73076:3/14!*10!/01234!KH:);?1!3L1!!
06*10)3/1M!
N6:;)14!*10!/01234!KH:);?1!3L1!!06*10)3/1O!PM!
! N6:;)14!*10!/01234!KG0;?60!3L1!06*10)3/1O!PM!
D026<);<3!KQRRQ>QRFSM! &+F$&$! *Fg")! ($#**m! y! *#$*m!
T034;:!!!!!!!!!KQRRU>QRFSM! &%%F%$%! (*gF%(&! %'#$$m! y! ((#'"m!
T1:;V;3!!!!!!!KQRRR>QRFWM! ("F&*%! %F)+%! ('#+&m! z! "&#*'m!
A1:1?9;3!!!KQRRR>QRFWM! (%$Fggg! %gF"*g! %$#%gm! y! (%#)*m!
A14)3!";73!KQRRU>QRFFM! (*F+*(! gF*g)! %&#g$m! z! %*#$&m!
#783/10!!!!KQRFR>QRFSM! %&F)+(! &Fg&*! %g#$$m! z! %+#)gm!
&EX;71!!!!!!KQRRQ>QRFYM! %)*F$(*! %&F$+'! ($#$$m! y! +#("m!
G60H!!!!!!!!!!!KQRRZ>QRFYM! &'F')'! (&F)%&! %g#$$m! y! %%#g&m!
%082835!!!!KQRR[>QRFYM! +F**(! (F%&)! ("#$$m! y! ($#*(m!
#4)3/14!%<;/14!KQRRU>QRFYM\! (F)*&F+)$! "$'Fg$$(+! (+#"(m! z! %%#+%m!
]1)3:! %F*'%F)"&! )*%F(('! %$#&m! y! (+#(m!
I86<)6+!.,9K;09B4R3!:1,!-.//!B;3!K961!13!:97;6!;I4B49,16#!!{E9! D;K,9B4R3! B90B1,9049! 7;79,! 13! .679:;6! ^34:;6! 43B,=?1! 6;,9>1371! ,96! BT0B1,16! I1:109,16! ?! 167979,16F! D10;! 3;! ,96!,;B9,16%$#!!!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!(+!WBC9II10!M%$(&F!D#!*N#!%$!-906;3!M%$()F!D#!%N#!
28 CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES
![Page 33: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
!
.,! =6;! :1! ,9! BT0B1,! D909! 016D;3:10! 9,!I13R>13;! :1! ,96! :0;896! :1K1! 159,=9061! 13!I=3B4R3! :1! 6=6! ;KA1745;6#! W4! ,;6! ;KA1745;6!D0;D=167;6! 3;! 61! 167T3! B=>D,413:;F! 016=,79!31B16904;!01D,937190!,9!016D=1679!167979,!?!,9!C1009>41379! =69:9#! .6! 4>D;079371! 01B;0:90!Y=1!1,!=6;!:1,!:101BC;!D139,!?!:1!,9!BT0B1,!13!1,! 71>9! :1! :0;896! 01B4K4R! =3! 4>D=,6;!:1B4645;! B;3! ,9! 43B;0D;09B4R3! :1! ,96!B;3513B4;316!4371039B4;39,16!:1!:0;896!9!,;6!-R:48;6! \139,16! :1! L>S04B9! E97439#!\909:RA4B9>1371F! 1,! S3I9646! D=34745;! Y=1! C9!9:Y=404:;! ,9! ,1846,9B4R3! :1! :0;896! :16:1!137;3B16F! C9! ,,159:;! 9! Y=1! 61! ;,54:1! Y=1! 1,!;KA1745;!I=3:9>1379,!:1!16796!B;3513B4;316!16!e,9!D0;71BB4R3!:1!,9!69,=:!?!1,!K41316790!:1!,9! C=>934:9:f%(0! .3! 3438=3;! :1! ,;6! D9@616!939,4U9:;6F!34!9!3451,!8,;K9,F!C9!:46>43=4:;!,9!D0159,13B49!:1!=6;6!D0;K,1>T74B;6!:1!:0;896!M9K=6;! ;! :1D13:13B49N! ;! ,96! >=10716! D;0!6;K01:;646!D;0!1I1B7;!:1!,;6!>9?;016!3451,16!:1! 13B90B1,9>4137;%%#! \;0! 1,! B;370904;F! 1,!1679K,1B4>4137;! :1! 693B4;316! D139,16! 61! C9!B;351074:;!13!=39!I=1371!:1!:46B04>439B4R3!?!>9?;016! 04168;6! B;3709! =6=904;6! :1! :0;896!M-.//F!%$(g[!Hj-j_F!%$()N#!.67;6!04168;6!61!1VD,4B93! D;0! ,9! 013=13B49! :1! ,;6! =6=904;6! 9!K=6B90!9646713B49! 693479049!13! ,9!D01D909B4R3!?! 1,! =6;! :1! :0;896! 43?1B79K,16! =! ;7096! D;0!71>;0! 9! 610! :17134:;6F! 16748>974U9:;6F!13B90B1,9:;6! ;! 6;>174:;6! 9! 70979>4137;! 13!B;3709! :1! 6=! 5;,=379:#! L:1>T6F! ,9!B04>439,4U9B4R3! :1! :46743796! B;3:=B796!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!%(!L6@!,;!1679K,1B1!1,!\01T>K=,;!:1!,9!-;3513B4R3!|34B9!6;K01! .67=D1I9B413716! :1! (+&(! ?! ,;! 0974I4B93! ,;6!43670=>137;6!D;67104;016#!%%!W;K01! ,96!016D=16796!:1,!.679:;!9,!=6;!:1!:0;896!13!,;6! D9@616! :1! ,9! 0184R3! D=1:1! B;36=,79061! 1,! 167=:4;!D0154;! :1,! -.//! e.3! b=6B9! :1! ,;6! /101BC;6G! =6=904;6!:1! :0;896! ?! 016D=16796! 167979,16! 13! L>S04B9! E97439f!M-.//F!%$(gN#!
D0164;39!9! ,;6!=6=904;6! 9! 9:Y=4040! ,96!:0;896!13! >10B9:;6! 4,189,16F! 1VD;34S3:;,;6! 9!04168;6! :1! 69,=:! ?! :1! 618=04:9:#!L:4B4;39,>1371F! ,9! 74D4I4B9B4R3! B;>;! :1,47;!:1!,9!:4I=64R3!:1!43I;0>9B4R3!6;K01!1,!=6;!:1!:0;896F! 13! D9074B=,90! 6;K01! ,96! D0TB74B96! :1!618=04:9:! 01,9B4;39:96! B;3! 1,! B;36=>;! :1!:0;896! ?! 01:=BB4R3! :1! :9X;6F! 3;! 16!B;>D974K,1!B;3!1,!:101BC;!9!,9!69,=:F!?9!Y=1!:4I4B=,79! ,9! B9D9B4:9:! :1! ,;6! 43:454:=;6! D909!7;>90! :1B464;316! 43I;0>9:96! 6;K01! 6=! 69,=:!?! B;37090@9! ,;! 1679K,1B4:;! 13! ,96! a=@96!P371039B4;39,16! 6;K01! oPj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
E9!D1061B=B4R3!D139,!?!1,!13B90B1,9>4137;!:1!D106;396! Y=1! C93! B;>174:;! :1,47;6! :1!:0;896! C93! 7134:;! 9:1>T6! B;67;6! 13;0>16#!.3!L08137439!1,!D016=D=167;!Y=1!61!8967R!13!%$(g!D909!>9371310!9! ,96!D106;396!D0459:96!:1! ,9! ,4K1079:! D;0! :0;896! 13! ,;6! B43B;!D043B4D9,16!61054B4;6!D134713B4904;6F!:;3:1!61!B;3B13709!1,!+$m!:1!,9!D;K,9B4R3!:1,!D9@6!D;0!
29CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES
![Page 34: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
167;! :1,47;6F! I=1! :1! 9D0;V4>9:9>1371! >4,!)%%! >4,,;316! :1! D16;6! 93=9,16F! ,;! Y=1!1Y=459,1!9!(+$#%!>4,,;316!:1!:R,9016!M-;0:9F!%$(&N#! .3! -;,;>K49! 61! 1674>9! Y=1! 1,! 8967;!Y=1! 61! 019,4UR! D909! >9371310! D01696! 9! ,96!D106;396! Y=1! B;>17410;3! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896!96B13:4R!9!%#"*!K4,,;316!:1!D16;6!B;36793716!13! %$(gF! 16! :1B40! (#('g!>4,,;316! :1! :R,9016!M^D04>3?! !"# $%&! %$(&9N#! E;6! 167=:4;6!019,4U9:;6! 13! .679:;6! ^34:;6! ;! 13! 1,! _143;!^34:;! 6;K01! B;67;Z1I1B7454:9:! 13! 7S0>43;6!:1! 01:=BB4R3!:1! ,9! 0143B4:13B49!D909!1,! B96;!:1! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! 6=841013! Y=1! 167;6!01B=06;6! 610@93! >1A;0! 1>D,19:;6! 64! 61!7096,9:9093!9!9,7103974596!:1!D139!:4I1013716!9,! 13B90B1,9>4137;F! 43B,=4:;6! D0;809>96!B;>=347904;6F! 70979>4137;! 0164:13B49,! ;!5484,93B49! 1,1B70R34B9! MQ974;39,! _16190BC!-;=3B4,F! %$$([! c9704V! }3;v,1:81! a0;=DF!%$$*[!JWP\\F!%$()N#!!
La política de encarcelamiento en cifras !
¿Quiénes son las personas encarceladas por delitos de drogas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
4,@B4796!M-.//F!%$(%N#!.3!D04>10!,=890F!1V46713!B4107;6!I9B7;016!I9B4,479:;016!;!43C4K4:;016!:1!I13R>13;6! B;>;! 1,! 9K=6;! :1! :0;896F! ,9!D0;:=BB4R3! ;! 1,! 70TI4B;! Y=1! C9B13! >T6! ;!>13;6! 5=,3109K,16! 9! 9,8=3;6! 710047;04;6! ?!D;K,9B4;316! MOC;=>4F! %$()N#! .3! 618=3:;F!D909!693B4;390!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!13!,9!0184R3F!,9! 9=7;04:9:! D=347459! :1! ,;6! .679:;6! 61! C9!1A10B4:;!61,1B7459>1371!B;3!,;!Y=1!D901B4109!=39!D;,@74B9!:1!:=0;!B;3709!,;6!>T6!:SK4,16!?!:SK4,! B;3709! ,;6! >T6! :=0;6! Ma90UR3F! %$()N#!!~w=4S316! 6;3! ,96! D106;396! Y=1! 167T3!13B90B1,9:96!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896�! ~-=T,16!6;3! 6=6! :1,47;6! ?! ,96! 6=6793B496! D;0! ,96! Y=1!6;3!D10618=4:;6�!!!.3! 1679! 61BB4R3! 61! D0161379! =39!B909B7104U9B4R3! :1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! 13B90B1,9:9!D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896F! 6=6! D10I4,16! ?! :1,47;6F!:97;6! 6;K01! B04>439,4U9B4R3! ?! 13B90B1,9Z>4137;! :1! =6=904;6#! E9! 618=3:9! D9071! 61!B13709!13!,9!647=9B4R3!:1!9,8=396!D;K,9B4;316!16D1B@I4B96G! >=A1016F! AR51316F! 1V7093A10;6! ?!;7096!D;K,9B4;316!5=,3109K,16#!!!E9! 43I;0>9B4R3! D0161379:9! 13! 1679! 61BB4R3!D0;54131! :1! ,;6! 43I;0>16! 39B4;39,16! MD;0!D9@6N! 1,9K;09:;6! D;0! ,;6! 435167489:;016! :1,!-.//! B;>;! D9071! :1! ,9! 435167489B4R3!e\106;396!D0459:96!:1! ,9! ,4K1079:!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896f#!E;6!43I;0>16!43:454:=9,16!D=1:13!610!B;36=,79:;6!13G!vvv#:0;896?:101BC;#;08#!!
!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES30
![Page 35: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
Pobreza y oportunidades en la ilegalidad: persecución y encarcelamiento de los más débiles !L=3Y=1! ,9! 43I;0>9B4R3! 6;K01! ,96!B909B710@674B96! :1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! 13B90B1,9:9!D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! 16! 16B969! ;! :1! :4I@B4,!9BB16;! 13! ,;6! D9@616! 167=:49:;6F! 16! D;64K,1!4:1374I4B90! 9,8=3;6! 0968;6! B;>=316! :1! ,96!D106;396! :17134:96! ?! 13B90B1,9:96! D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896#!.3!6=!>9?;0@9!61! 70979!:1!D106;396!B;3!16B969!1:=B9B4R3F!13!B;3:4B4R3!:1! D;K01U9! ;! B;3! 709K9A;6! :1! K9A9!01>=3109B4R3#! ^3! 4>D;079371! 32>10;! I=1!:17134:;!13!I,98093B49!?!3=3B9!93716!C9K@93!B;>174:;! :1,47;6#! .3! 7S0>43;6! :1! ,96!;08934U9B4;316! :1! 390B;70TI4B;F! B;>;! 61!>=16709! 13! 1671! 9D9079:;F! ,96! D106;396!13B90B1,9:96!;B=D93!,;6!16,9K;316!>T6!K9A;6!:1! ,9! B9:139! :1! ,96! :0;896! 4,@B4796F! ;! 6=1,1!70979061! :1! B;36=>4:;016! 1Y=4D909:;6! 9!>4B0;!513:1:;016#!!!
!!!.3! D026<);<3F! 61823! :97;6! :1,! W4671>9!Q9B4;39,! :1! .679:@674B96! 6;K01! .A1B=B4R3! :1!,9! \139! MWQ..\N! :1,!c43467104;! :1! `=674B49! ?!/101BC;6!j=>93;6!:1! ,9!Q9B4R3F! ,9!>9?;0@9!:1! ,96! D106;396! D0459:96! :1! ,9! ,4K1079:! 13!
%$("!3;!C9K@9!710>439:;!,9!61B=3:9049!M')mN!?! =3! D;0B1379A1! B;364:109K,1! 79>D;B;!710>43R! ,9! D04>9049! M"(mN[! '%m! 3;! 713@9! =3!709K9A;! :1! 741>D;! B;>D,17;! ?! ggm!3;! 713@9!D0;I164R3!=!;I4B4;[!&$m!01B4K4R!D1396!:1!7016!9! 3=151! 9X;6! :1! D0464R3F! ?! &+m! :1! 1,,;6!C9K@93! B;>174:;! =3! :1,47;! D;0! D04>109! 51U!M-;0:9F! %$(&N#! .3! 1,! %$(gF! =39! 13B=1679!019,4U9:9! D;0! 1,! W4671>9! \134713B4904;!h1:109,! MW\hN! ?! ,9! D0;543B49! :1!b=13;6!L4016!MW\bLNF! D10>474R! B;3;B10! Y=1! ,96! D106;396!13B90B1,9:96! B;36747=@93! =39! D;K,9B4R3!K9679371! C;>;8S319G! e6;3! >9?;0479049Z>1371! AR51316F! B;3! K9A;6! 3451,16! :1!43670=BB4R3!?!D0;513413716F!13!6=!>9?;0@9F!:1!I9>4,496! :161670=B7=09:96! ÄÅÇ! 1,! *(m! :1! ,;6!B;3:139:;6! 61! 13B;3709K93! 709K9A93:;!93716!:1!610!:17134:;6#!W43!1>K908;F!:4BC;6!709K9A;6! 1093! 813109,>1371! :1! =39! K9A9!B9,4:9:! 1B;3R>4B9! ;B=D9B4;39,f! Mb108>93F!c9661,;F!L0496F!h;3:154,,9!d!o4,9,79F!%$(gF!D#!*N#! .,! 43I;0>1! 980189G! e3;!C1>;6!:171B79:;!=3! 32>10;! 64834I4B9745;! :1! 01B,=6;6! Y=1!7=541093! D=167;6! 4>D;0793716! 13! 1,! B04>13!;08934U9:;#! W;3!>=?! D;B;6! ,;6! Y=1! :4048@93!9,8=39! ;D109B4R3! :1! 0;K;6! ;! :1! 70TI4B;! :1!:0;896! ;! Y=1! I=10;3! 9B=69:;6! D;0! B;>1710!:1,47;6! >4,,;3904;6#! .3! B9>K4;F! 9K=3:93! ,;6!:17134:;6! Y=1! I;0>93! D9071! :1,! 2,74>;!16,9KR3! :1! ,9! B9:139! ?! Y=1! 6;3! ,;6! >T6!ITB4,>1371! 011>D,9U9K,16! D;0! ;70;6! B=93:;!,;6!D04>10;6! 6;3!:17134:;6f! Mb108>93!!"#$%&!%$(gF!D#!*N#!!!.3!T034;:F!B;>;!13!;70;6!D9@616!:1!,9!0184R3F!1,!D10I4,!813109,!:1!,9!D;K,9B4R3!13!D0464R3!16!>9?;0479049>1371! :1! AR51316! MC9679! %g!9X;6NF! 9I0;:16B13:413716F! D;K016! ?! B;3!16B9696! ;D;07=34:9:16F! 6413:;! 1,! :1,47;! :1!70TI4B;! :1! :0;896! 1,! >T6! I01B=1371! 13701!
31CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES
Fotografía: Oficina de Prensa y Comunicación. Ministerio de Justicia y Paz de Costa Rica.
![Page 36: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
1,,;6#!!/1!,9!D;K,9B4R3!D0459:9!:1!,9!,4K1079:F!*)m!713@9!>TV4>;!D04>9049!B;>D,179!M%$(gN#!c4137096!Y=1!"%m!:1!,9!D;K,9B4R3!813109,!13!1,! D9@6! 74131! 1361X93U9! >1:49! B;>D,179F!D909! 1,! B96;! :1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! B90B1,9049! 6R,;!+#)m! C9K@9! B;3B,=4:;! 1671! 3451,!M/1D9079>137;! \134713B4904;! Q9B4;39,! :1!b0964,F! %$(&F! D#! g&N#! .,! D10I4,! 813109,! :1! ,;6!437103;6! D;0! 70TI4B;! :1! :0;896! 648=1!1V9B79>1371! ,9! ,R84B9! 1670=B7=09,! 61,1B7459!:1! B;370;,! 6;B49,! :1! ,9! D;K01U9#! E9! D;,4B@9!69K1! :R3:1! K=6B90! 9! ,96! D106;396! Y=1!Y=41013!B9D7=090G!13!,96!B;>=34:9:16!D;K016!:1!,9!D104I1049!?!13!,96!I951,96!Mb;471=V!!"#$%&!%$(&N#!!.3! A1:1?9;3F! 9! >9?;! :1! %$(&F! :1! 9B=10:;!B;3! :97;6! :1,! PQ\.-! M%$(&NF! *+#"m! :1! ,96!D106;396! D0459:96! :1! ,9! ,4K1079:! 3;! C9K@9!B;3B,=4:;! 6=! 1:=B9B4R3! >1:49! ?! g%m! 713@9!>TV4>;! D04>9049#! -9K1! 61X9,90! Y=1! ,;6!3451,16! :1! D;K01U9! D909! 1,! B96;! :1! ,96!I9>4,496! B=?;! A1I1! :1! C;890! 713@9! >TV4>;!1:=B9B4R3! D04>9049! ;! 61B=3:9049! 13! %$("!1093! :1,! ;0:13! :1! g(#+m! ?! %*#(mF!016D1B7459>1371!M/LQ.F!%$("F!D#!(gNF! ,;!Y=1!6=84101! Y=1! >=BC96! :1! 16796! D106;396!D0;541313! :1! I9>4,496! D;K016#! .3! =39!>=16709! :1! D106;396! B;3:139:96! D;0! 1,!:1,47;! :1! 70TI4B;F! D;071! ;! I9K04B9B4R3! :1!167=D1I9B413716! 13701! %$($! ?! %$(gF! 1,!c43467104;! :1! `=674B49! ?! :1,! /101BC;! D=:;!:1710>4390! Y=1! (+#gm! 1679K93!:161>D,19:96!?!,9!8093!>9?;0@9!61!:1:4B9K9!9! ;I4B4;6! 43I;0>9,16! :1! K9A9! 01>=3109B4R3#!W;,;! g#g(m! 61! :1:4B9K9! 9! =3! ;I4B4;F! =39!B900109! D0;I164;39,F! ;! 1679K93! 167=:493:;!Mc43467104;! :1! `=674B49! ?! :1,! /101BC;F! 13!4>D01379N#!!
!!!.3! 01,9B4R3! 9,! 0;,! :1! ,96! D106;396!Y=1! 167T3!:1370;! :1! 01:16! :1,43B=13B49,16F! 13! 1,! 9X;!%$(gF! *'#+m! :1! ,96! D106;396! 13B90B1,9:96!D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! C9K@93! B;>174:;! =39!B;3:=B79! :1,4B7459! D;0! D04>109! 51U! ?! 6R,;!"#+m!C9K@93!0143B4:4:;!:;6!51B16!;!>T6#!\;0!,;!>13;6!*'m!1679K93!01B,=4:96!D;0!B;>1710!=3! :1,47;! :1! :0;896F! 643! B;3B=06;! B;3! ;709!B,961! :1! :1,47;6#! E;6! B;3B=06;6! B;3! :1,47;6!54;,137;6F! 6193!;!3;!B;3!90>96!:1! I=18;!3;!6=D109K93!1,!(%m#!ÉF!D907413:;!:1!,9!D01>469!:1! Y=1! D909! B;364:1090! Y=1! =39! D106;39!D=1:1!71310!=39!D9074B4D9B4R3!4>D;079371!13!=39! ;08934U9B4R3! B04>439,F! :1K10@9! C9K10!64:;! B;3:139:9! ;! 16790! D0;B169:9F! 9:1>T6F!D;0! 1,! :1,47;! :1! B;3B4107;! D909! :1,43Y=40F!C9K0@9! Y=1! B;3B,=40! 137;3B16! Y=1! 6R,;! =3!&#)(m! :1! ,;6! 438016;6! 13! ,;6! 2,74>;6! B43B;!9X;6! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;89! 713:0@93! 1679!B909B710@674B9! M^D04>3?! !"# $%&! %$(&9N#! E9!D1061B=B4R3! D139,! :1! :1,47;6! B;>;! 1,!>937134>4137;! :1! D,9379B4;316! ;! 1,! 70TI4B;!13! D1Y=1X9! 16B9,9F! D10D1709:;6! 13! 6=!>9?;0@9! D;0! 16,9K;316! :SK4,16F! 16! >=BC;!>T6!1I4B41371!Y=1!1,!:1!;70;6!:1,47;6!B;>;!1,!,959:;! :1! 9B745;6F! :;3:1! 6=1,13! 16790! ,;6!eD1B16! >T6! 8;0:;6f! Mo4,,1896F! .6D43;69F! d!n381,F!%$("F!D#!"&Zg$N#!.3!%$(gF!+g#+m!:1!,96!B9D7=096!D;,4B49,16!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!1093!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES32
Fotografía: Mauro Tomasini
![Page 37: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
13! I,98093B49#! E;6! :1D9079>137;6! >T6!D;K016F!D9074B=,90>1371! ,;6!:1,! 6=0!:1,!D9@6F!713@93! =39! >9?;0! D0;D;0B4R3! :1! B9D7=096!D;0! B;3:=B796! B;>;! 1,! >937134>4137;! ;!I4393B49B4R3! :1! D,9379B4;316! M79>K4S3! D;0!70TI4B;! D909! D0;B169>4137;NF! >4137096! Y=1!,;6! :1D9079>137;6! :1! ,9! U;39! B9I17109! ?!L374;Y=49! 713@93! >9?;0! D9074B4D9B4R3! :1!B9D7=096! D;0! 70TI4B;! :1! 167=D1I9B413716!M^D04>3?!!"#$%&!%$(&9N#!!.3! A14)3! ";73F! =39! >=16709! :1! %F$(%!1VD1:413716! B;3:1397;04;6! D;0! :1,47;6! :1!:0;896! 13! %$(gF! 939,4U9:9! D;0! ,;6!435167489:;016! :1,! -.//! M-;07S6F! %$(&NF!>=16709!Y=1!1,!3451,!1:=B9745;!:1!,9!>9?;0@9!:1! ,96! D106;396! D0459:96! :1! ,9! ,4K1079:! D;0!:0;896! 16! :1! D04>9049! B;>D,179! M""mNF!618=4:;! D;0! ,;6! Y=1! 741313! D04>9049!43B;>D,179! M%*#"mN! ?! 61B=3:9049! 43B;>D,179!M%(mN#! W;,9>1371! &#'m! 710>43R! ,9!61B=3:9049F! gm! B;3B,=?R! 167=:4;6!=34510647904;6!?!(#*m!3;!69K1!,110!34!16B04K40#!E96! ;B=D9B4;316! D043B4D9,16! 590@93! 61823! 1,!61V;F!?9!Y=1!)"m!:1!,96!>=A1016!6;3!9>96!:1!B969F! ?! (*m! B;>10B493716F! >4137096! Y=1!13701! ,;6! C;>K016! =3! ('m! 16! B;>10B49371F!618=4:;! D;0! :161>D,19:;6! ?! B;3670=BB4R3!M(%m!9>K;6N#!H7096!;B=D9B4;316! 01846709:96!13! ,;6! 1VD1:413716! 61X9,93! Y=1! ,96!>=A1016!6;3! 1674,46796F! B;B431096F! 1>D,19:96! ?!13I10>1096F! 7;:;6! B;3! D;0B1379A16! >=?!K9A;6#! .3701! ,;6! C;>K016! 61! ;K610590;3! ,;6!709K9A;6!:1!D;0719:;0F!D1R3!980@B;,9F!BC;I10F!>1BT34B;F! 70936D;074679F! ,959! B900;6! ?!618=04:9:F!13701!;70;6#!.3!>13;6!:1!,9!>479:!Mg"mN! :1! ,;6! B96;6! 61! >13B4;393!9371B1:13716! :1! B;36=>;! :1! :0;896F!7;>93:;! 13! B=1379! Y=1! D909! ()m! :1! ,;6!B96;6!167;!3;!61!01D;07R!13!1,!1VD1:41371#!!
.3!&EX;71! 79>K4S3! ,;6! :97;6!>=167093! Y=1!,9! D;K,9B4R3! 13! 01B,=64R3! 16! K9679371!C;>;8S319F! 7097T3:;61! D043B4D9,>1371! :1!C;>K016! AR51316! D0;513413716! :1! 61B7;016!1B;3R>4B;6!?! 6;B49,>1371!13!:1651379A9#! E9!\04>109! .3B=1679! _19,4U9:9! 9! \;K,9B4R3!P371039! 13! -1370;6! h1:109,16! :1!_19:9D79B4R3!W;B49,! M\S01U!-;0019!d!LU9;,9F!%$(%F! D#! *N! 43:4B9! Y=1! ,;6! 437103;6!613713B49:;6! 13! 1,! 64671>9! D134713B4904;!I1:109,! 6;3! D043B4D9,>1371! C;>K016! ?!>=A1016!AR51316!M>9?;0479049>1371!:1!13701!"(! ?! g$! 9X;6NF! B;3! C4A;6! M*'#'m! :1! ,;6!C;>K016! ?! ''#gm! :1! ,96! >=A1016N! ?! B;3!I=10716! :1651379A96! 6;B49,16#! E9! >9?;0@9!D0;54131! :1! B;371V7;6! 54;,137;6! ?! B=13793!B;3!16B969!1:=B9B4R3G!)"#*m!:1!,;6!C;>K016!437103;6! ?! &$m! :1! ,96! >=A1016! 3;!B;>D,1790;3! ,9! 61B=3:9049! ?! )&#&m! :1! ,;6!C;>K016!?!g)#"m!:1!,96!>=A1016!:4A10;3!Y=1!,9! 09UR3! D;0! ,9! Y=1! 3;! B;3743=90;3!167=:493:;! I=1! ,9! 31B164:9:! :1! 709K9A90#! .3!,9! -4=:9:! :1!cSV4B;! ?! 1,! B;3=0K9:;! .679:;!:1! cSV4B;! ,;6! :97;6! >=167093! 1,! >46>;!D10I4,G! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! D134713B49049! 16! =39!D;K,9B4R3! A;513F! D043B4D9,>1371! >96B=,439F!B;3! 16B;,904:9:! ,48109>1371! D;0! :1K9A;! :1,!D0;>1:4;! :1! 6=! ,;B9,4:9:! Mb108>93! !"# $%F!%$(gF! D#! ($Z((N#! E;6! :97;6! :1! 1679! 13B=1679!>;67090;3! Y=1! =3;! :1! B9:9! B=970;! 437103;6!61! I=1! :1! 6=! B969! 93716! :1! B=>D,40! Y=43B1!9X;6F! ?! 1,! >;745;! >T6! I01B=1371! :1,!9K93:;3;! :1,! C;890! I=1! ,9! 54;,13B49! 43709ZI9>4,490#
!
!
!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES 33
![Page 38: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
Delitos y sustancias de las personas privadas de la libertad !-;>;! 61! >13B4;3R! 93716F! ,96! D106;396!13B90B1,9:96! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! 13!L>S04B9! E97439F! ;B=D93! 13! 6=! >9?;0@9! ,;6!16,9K;316! >T6! K9A;6! :1! ,9! B9:139! :1! ,96!:0;896! 4,@B4796! ?! 6=1,13! :161>D1X90!I=3B4;316!:1!K9A;!3451,!13!,96!;08934U9B4;316#!.3! 813109,F! 3;! 61! 70979! :1! ,96! D106;396! Y=1!>T6! 61! 1304Y=1B13! :1! ,96! 9B7454:9:16!01,9B4;39:96!B;3!:0;896F!643;!:1!Y=41316!6;3!ITB4,>1371! 011>D,9U9K,16! 13! ,96! 9B7454:9:16!Y=1! 019,4U93#! L:1>T6F! :1K4:;! 9! ,9! I;0>9! 13!Y=1! 61! 018=,9! ,9! D;6164R3F! 6=1,1! 70979061! :1!=6=904;6! Y=1! D;6113! 643! 43713B4R3! :1!B;>10B49,4U90! ;! Y=1! 6;3! 1Y=4D909:;6! B;3!513:1:;016! :1! D1Y=1X96! B9374:9:16F!79>K4S3! B;3;B4:;6! B;>;!>4B0;709I4B93716! ;!390B;>13=:46796#!!!.3!T034;:F! 13!=39! 435167489B4R3! 019,4U9:9!D;0!,9! ^3451064:9:! :1! W9;! \9=,;! M`16=6F! HPF!_;BC9F! d! E989779F! %$((N! 61! 939,4UR! 9! &&*!I,98093716! B9D7=09:;6! 13701! 3;541>K01! :1!%$($! ?! 1310;! :1! %$((! 13! ,9! B4=:9:! :1! Wu;!\9=,;#! .3! 167;6! B96;6F! 9! &%#("m! ,16! I=10;3!13B;3709:;6! >13;6! :1! ($$! 809>;6! :1!9,8=39! 6=6793B49#! E9! >904C=939! I=1! ,9!6=6793B49!>T6!B;>23!M)*#&(mNF!?!13!&(m!:1!,;6! B96;6! 61! 13B;37090;3! >13;6! :1! "$!D9D1,1796#! .3! 1,! B96;! :1! ,9! B;B9@39F! 13! *$m!:1!,;6!B96;6!I=10;3!43B9=79:;6!>13;6!:1!($$!809>;6!:1! ,9!6=6793B49#!.3!)&m!:1! ,;6!B96;6!I=10;3!13B;3709:;6!13701!=3;!?!"$!D9D1,1796!:1!D9679!K961#! .3!16;6! B96;6F!"$#&&m!:1! ,96!D106;396! 9,1890;3! 610! =6=904;6F! %$#'m! 318R!,9! D0;D41:9:! :1! ,9! :0;89F! (%#$gm! 318R! 1,!70TI4B;F! &#%(m! :4A;! 6;K0154540! :1,! 70TI4B;! ?!(#g&m! :4A;! 019,4U9K93! 70936D;071! :1! :0;896#!
O;:;6! 167;6! B96;6! I=10;3! 693B4;39:;6!D139,>1371! D;0! 70TI4B;#! /1! 9B=10:;! B;3!b;471=V! ?! J41Bk;! M%$$+NF! ,96! 613713B496!B;3:1397;0496! 1>474:96! D;0! 70TI4B;! 13701!%$$&! ?! %$$'! 13! _@;! :1! `93140;! ?! b0964,49!B;3I40>93! Y=1! ,9! >904C=939! ?! ,9! B;B9@39!I=10;3! ,96! 6=6793B496! >T6! D01613716! 13! ,96!43B9=79B4;316! 13! ,96! :;6! B4=:9:16F! 6413:;!K9A96!,96!B9374:9:16!:1!:0;896!43B9=79:96#!.3!b0964,49F!&'#*m!:1!,;6!B96;6!435;,=B090;3!=39!B9374:9:!:1!>904C=939!43I104;0!9!($$!809>;6!?! 13! 01,9B4R3!9! ,9! B;B9@39F! ,9!>9?;0@9!:1! ,96!613713B496! M%'#'mN! 435;,=B09! B9374:9:16! :1!($$!809>;6!9!(!k8#!.3!_@;!:1!`93140;F!13!)$m!:1! ,;6! D0;B16;6! ,9! B9374:9:! :1! >904C=939!D0161379:9! I=1! :1! >13;6! :1! ($g! 809>;6#!E,9>9! ,9!9713B4R3!1,!32>10;!:1!D0;B16;6!13!,;6! Y=1! 61! 7097R! :1! D1Y=1X96! B9374:9:16G!")#(m!:1!,;6!B;3:139:;6!D;0!B;B9@39!713@93!13! 6=! D;:10! C9679! ($! 809>;6F!>4137096! Y=1!+m!D;079K93!C9679!($!809>;6!:1!>904C=939#!.67;! 6=84101! Y=1! D;:0@93! 610! =6=904;6!:17134:;6! D;0! ,9! D;,4B@9! B;>;! 709I4B93716!Mb;471=V!d!J41Bk;F!%$$+N#!!.3!A14)3!";73F!,9!09UR3!D043B4D9,!D;0!,9!Y=1!61!1A1B=790;3! 613713B496! D;0! :1,47;6! 74D4I4B9:;6!13! ,9! E1?! :1! \64B;70RD4B;6! I=1! ,9! e51379! :1!:0;896fF!B;3!=3!)'#gm!:1,!7;79,F!618=4:;!D;0!1,! e70TI4B;]70936D;071! :1! :0;896fF! B;3! =3!(%#&m#! /1! 7;:;6! ,;6! B96;6F! =3! &(#+m!;K7=5410;3!D1396!:1!B43B;!9!>13;6!:1!64171!9X;6!:1!D0464R3F!,;!Y=1!B;43B4:1!B;3!,96!D1396!D;0!D0;B16;6!9K01549:;6!Y=1!6=1,1!;I01B10!,9!h46B9,@9F! 43:4B93:;! Y=1! 13! ,9!>9?;0@9! :1! ,;6!B96;6!1V4671!154:13B49!6=I4B41371!D909!Y=1!,96!D106;396!9B=69:96!61!:1B,9013!B=,D9K,16!B;3!79,!:1! 01B4K40! B;3:1396!>T6!K9A96F! 643!D;:10!96@! K043:90! =39! :1B,909B4R3! 13! =3! A=4B4;!I;0>9,! M-;07S6F! %$(&N#! L64>46>;F! >13;6! :1!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES34
![Page 39: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
,9! >479:! :1! ,;6! B96;6! Y=1! 43801690;3! 9! ,9!h46B9,@9! \139,! :1! L:=,7;6! D;0! 54;,9B4R3! 9! ,9!E1?! :1! \64B;70RD4B;6! 13701! %$$"! ?! %$("!710>4390;3! 13! 613713B496! B;3! D1396!D045974596! :1! ,4K1079:! D;0! D9071! :1! ,;6!`=U89:;6!\139,16!M-;07S6F!%$(&N#!!
!!
E9!>9?;0@9! :1! ,96! D106;396! 13B90B1,9:96! 13!161!D9@6! 13701!%$$&!?!%$((! I=1!9B=69:9!D;0!B=970;! B;3:=B796G! 51379! M""mNF! 70936D;071!M%$#%mNF! 43I09BB4R3! 9! ,9! ,1?! :1! D64B;70RD4B;6!M%(#*mN! ?! 71313B49! ]! D;6164R3! M(*#'mN#! E9!59049K,1! Y=1! >T6! 9=>1379! 16! ,9! e51379fF!B;3:=B79! Y=1! 61! 704D,4BR! 13! 1671! >46>;!D104;:;#! .,! 93T,4646! :1! ,9! >=16709! :1!1VD1:413716! D139,16! >=16709! Y=1! 13! B10B9!:1,! *$m! :1! ,;6! B96;6! 015469:;6! 61! D016137R!=3! D0;B1:4>4137;! 9K01549:;F! B;3! D1396! :1!B43B;!9X;6!?!B=970;!>1616!M")#)mNF!6146!9X;6!M(&#)mN!?!64171!9X;6!M&#*mN#!^39!B=9071!D9071!B=>D,1! B;3:1396! :1! D0464R3! :1! ;BC;! 9X;6!M%g#"mN! ?! 6;,9>1371! =3! )m! 01B4K1! D1396!>9?;016! 9! S6796#! \161! 9! 1,,;F! B10B9! :1,! '$m!167=5;! 13! D0464R3! D015137459F! B;3! =3!D0;>1:4;! :1! %((! :@96! :1! 13B90B1,9>4137;F!C9K413:;! =39! >9?;0@9! M%"mN! Y=1! D96R! ('$!:@96! 13! D0464R3! D015137459#! E9! 51379! 9,!>13=:1;! 01D0161379! =3! &'#'m!:1! 7;:;6! ,;6!B96;6! :1! 13B90B1,9>4137;! D;0! :1,47;6! :1!
:0;896! 939,4U9:;6! 13! 1679! >=16709! :1!1VD1:413716#!.671!:1,47;!01D0161379!B10B9!:1,!'$m! :1! ,96! B;3:=B796! D;0! ,96! Y=1! ,;6!C;>K016! 167T3! 13B90B1,9:;6F! >4137096! Y=1!13701! ,96! >=A1016! ,,189! 9,! &$m#! ^3! C1BC;!B909B710@674B;!:1!7;:;6!167;6!B96;6!16!Y=1!61!019,4U9! 51379! B;370;,9:9! ;! 1VD104>1379,! D;0!D9071! :1! 9813716! 13B=K4107;6! ;!B;,9K;09:;016! B;3I4:13B49,16#! W;,;! 13! "#+m!:1! ,;6! B96;6! 61! 61X9,R! Y=1! ,9! D106;39!13B90B1,9:9! 109! ,@:10! ;! A1I1! :1! =39!;08934U9B4R3!:1:4B9:9!9!,9!51379!:1!:0;896F!?!:1! S6796! >T6! :1! ,9! >479:! 01B4K4R! D1396!>13;016! 9! ,;6! ;BC;! 9X;6F! 64>4,9016! 9! ,96! :1!,;6!16,9K;316!>T6!:SK4,16!M-;07S6F!%$(&N#!!
.3! ,;6! B96;6! :1! D106;396! B;3:139:96! D;0!51379! 9,! >13=:1;F! 61823! 1,! 93T,4646! :1! =39!>=16709!:1!1VD1:413716!D139,16F!,9!:0;89!:1!>9?;0! D01613B49! I=1! 1,! B9339K46F! 9=3Y=1!13701! ,96!>=A1016! I=1!1,! B09Bk#!.3!1,!&$m!:1!,;6! B96;6! :;3:1! I=1! D;64K,1! ;K71310!43I;0>9B4R3! 6;K01! 1,! D16;! :1! ,96! 6=6793B496!435;,=B09:96F! 61! 43B9=790;3! >13;6! :1! ($!809>;6! ?! 13! '$m! >13;6! :1! )$! 809>;6! :1!9,8=39!6=6793B49!M-;07S6F!%$(&N#!!!.3! A1:1?9;3F! 61823! :97;6! :1! ,9! \;,4B@9!L374390BR74B;6F! +"m! :1! ,96! D106;396! Y=1!I=10;3! B9D7=09:96F! 9Y=1,,96! 9D01C13:4:96!D;0! ,9! D;,4B@9! Y=1! 3;! 641>D01! ,,1893! 9!436793B496!:1!,9!I46B9,@9F!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!13! %$("F! 713@93! >13;6! :1! %)$! 809>;6! :1!>904C=939F! B;B9@39F! D9679! K961! ;! K96=B;!Mc43467104;!:1! `=674B49! ?! :1,!/101BC;F! %$(&N#!W1823! 1,! 93T,4646! :1! =39! >=16709! :1!1VD1:413716! A=:4B49,16! B;3:1397;04;6! 13701!%$((!?!%$(g!D;0!1,!:1,47;!:1!70TI4B;F!D;071!;!I9K04B9B4R3F!*%#+gm!:1!,;6!B96;6!435;,=B090;3!=39! 6;,9!:0;89! 4,189,F! ?! 6R,;!13!%%)m!:1! ,;6!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES 35
Fotografía: Oficina de Prensa y Comunicación. Ministerio de Justicia y Paz de Costa Rica.
!!!
!"#$%&'(!&()"%#*+!,(--!./01! +!
B04>439,4U9:;F! ,9! D;6164R3! ;! 71313B49F! 96@!B;>;! ;7096! 9B7454:9:16! 31B1690496! D909! Y=1!,96! D106;396! D=1:93! 1A10B10! 6=! :101BC;! 9!=690! :0;896! 64! ,;! 167T3F! 9=3Y=1! :1! I;0>96!:4I1013716! 13! B9:9! D9@6"! .,! B=9:0;! 648=41371!
>=16709! ,9! 018=,9B4R3! :1,! =6;! ?! ,9! D;6164R3!:1! :0;896! 13! ,;6! 3=151! D9@616!,9743;9>104B93;6!167=:49:;6"!!
!
!
A;,.#(! C*! L/E;1,'&:0! ./1! '(0-;2(! F! ! 4(-/-&:0! ./! .#(E,-! /0! 1(-! 4,8-/-! 1,3&0(,2/#&',0(-!/-3;.&,.(-*!
País Consumo Posesión Regulación (síntesis)
Argentina No Sí
La posesión o tenencia simple y la tenencia con fines están tipificadas como delito. El artículo 14 de la Ley 23.737 tipifica la posesión para consumo como delito. Sin embargo, la Corte Suprema declaró la inconstitucionalidad del segundo párrafo del artículo 14 siempre que "se realice en condiciones tales que no traigan aparejado un peligro concreto o un daño a derechos o bienes de terceros". (Véase Corte Suprema de Justicia de la Nación Argentina, Fallo Arriola -A. 891. XLIV-).
Bolivia No Sí
La posesión para consumo es delito de acuerdo con el artículo 49 de la Ley 1008, sancionable con tratamiento forzoso. Sin embargo, en la práctica esta disposición no se aplica. En caso de que un examen médico determine que la persona aprehendida porta más de lo necesario para su consumo personal e inmediato, debe ser procesada por tráfico de drogas.
Brasil No Sí
La posesión para consumo y la posesión simple están tipificadas como delito. El artículo 28 de la Ley 11.343/06, señala que el juez determina cuando la sustancia se considera para consumo personal tomando en cuenta, entre otras cosas, la “naturaleza” de la sustancia, la cantidad y los antecedentes de la persona. Las sanciones para posesión por consumo no incluyen penas privativas de libertad. Artículo 33 de la Ley 11.343/06
Colombia No Sí
El consumo está prohibido constitucionalmente, pero la Corte Suprema de Justicia ha sostenido, con base en la doctrina de la dosis de aprovisionamiento, que el porte para consumo no está penalizado, incluso si sobrepasa la dosis personal (Ver Corte Constitucional de Colombia, Sentencia C 221). Sin embargo, la posesión simple sí está tipificada como delito24.
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!$a!.3!,9!W13713B49!-Za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aN! 9! )#F>4,! 69,904;6!>@34>;6!,189,16!>136=9,16!54813716"!
![Page 40: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
B96;6!61!7097R!:1!D106;396!Y=1!D;61@93!:;6!;!>T6! 9,! >;>137;! :1! 6=! B9D7=09#! .3701!Y=41316! D;079K93! =39! 6=6793B49F! ,9! >T6!I01B=1371! I=1! ,9! B;B9@39F! B;3! g*#%%m!:1! ,;6!B96;6F!618=4:;!:1!,9!>904C=939F!B;3!gg#('m#!.,! D;0B1379A1! 01679371! 61! :46704K=?1! 13701!B96;6! 13! Y=1! ,9! 6=6793B49! 435;,=B09:9! 109!9,823!436=>;!D909!1,!D0;B169>4137;F!C10;@39!;! 43B,=6;! C;A9! :1! B;B9#! .3! 7S0>43;6! :1! ,96!B9374:9:16! 435;,=B09:96!13!1,!:1,47;F!D909!1,!B96;! :1! ,9! B;B9@39F! ,9! >9?;0! D9071! 61!B;3B13709!13!B96;6!Y=1!435;,=B093!>13;6!:1!%$! 809>;6! M,;6! B=9,16! 01D01613790;3! 1,!%$#*)m! :1! 7;:;6! ,;6! B96;6! 13! ,;6! Y=1! 167T!435;,=B09:9!=39!6;,9!6=6793B49!4,189,!?!1,!g"m!:1! ,;6! Y=1! 435;,=B093! 234B9>1371! B;B9@39N#!\909!1,!B96;!:1!,9!>904C=939F! ,9!D1061B=B4R3!61! B;3B13709! 13! B96;6! :1! >13;6! :1! %$$!809>;6! M,;! Y=1! 01D01613793! 1,! %"m! :1! ,;6!B96;6!:1!=39!6;,9!6=6793B49!?!1,!)%m!:1!7;:;6!,;6! Y=1! 7=5410;3! Y=1! 510! B;3! >904C=939N!Mc43467104;! :1! `=674B49! ?! :1,! /101BC;F! 13!4>D01379N#!!!.3! &EX;71F! :1! 9B=10:;! B;3! ,9! \04>109!.3B=1679!13!-1370;6!\134713B4904;6!h1:109,16!M-P/.NF! 019,4U9:9! 13! %$(%F! &%m! :1! ,96!D106;396! 43710396! 613713B49:96! 13! :4BC;6!B1370;6! ,;! 1679K93! D;0! :1,47;6! B;3709! ,9!69,=:#! /1! S6796F! )'#*m! C9K@93! 64:;!613713B49:96!D;0!=3!:1,47;!01,9B4;39:;!B;3!,9!>904C=939!?!"'#)m!D;0!1,!:1,47;!:1!D;6164R3!M70910! B;3648;N#! -0=U93:;! ,;6! :97;6! :1! ,9!13B=1679! 016=,79! Y=1! ($#%m! :1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3!13! 01B,=64R3! 613713B49:9! 13! B1370;6!I1:109,16! 1679K9! 613713B49:9! 6;,9>1371! D;0!B;3:=B796! 01,9B4;39:96! B;3! eB;36=>40f! ;!e70910! B;3648;f! >904C=939! M\S01U! -;0019! d!_;>10;F! %$(&N#! .67;! 64834I4B9! Y=1! 13! %$((!C9K@9! (F)$+! 437103;6! 613713B49:;6! D;0!
eB;36=>40f! ;! e70910! B;3648;f!>904C=939#! .3!,;6! 1679:;6F! ,9! >904C=939! 79>K4S3! 9D901B1!B;>;! ,9! D043B4D9,! 6=6793B49! D10618=4:9#! .3!,;6! ((! 1679:;6! Y=1! D0;D;0B4;390;3!43I;0>9B4R3! D909! ,9! 435167489B4R3! :1,! -.//!13! cSV4B;F! &%#%gm! :1! ,96! :1713B4;316!01D;079:96! I=10;3! D;0! >904C=939F! 618=4:96!D;0! B;B9@39! M%%#&"mN! ?! >1793I179>4396!M("#%gmN!M\S01U!-;0019!d!_;>10;F!%$(&N#!!.3!G60HF!,9!>9?;0@9!:1!,;6!D016;6!D;0!:0;896F!9!>90U;!:1!%$(gF!C9K@9!64:;!:17134:;6!D;0!1,!:1,47;! :1! 70TI4B;! 4,@B47;! M74D;! K961N! Mg+#+mN#!.679! B9718;0@9! 6=1,1! 43B,=40! 13! 6=!>9?;0@9! 9!D106;396! Y=1! 70936D;0790;3! D1Y=1X96!B9374:9:16!:1!:0;896!Mc9381,43BkV!`#!F!%$(&N[!!,1! 648=13! 9Y=1,,;6! Y=1! 1679K93! D;0! I;0>96!980959:96!:1! 70TI4B;! 4,@B47;! M%'#+m!:1,! 7;79,NF!D0;>;B4R3! ;! I95;01B4>4137;! :1,! 70TI4B;!M(%#'mN! ?! >4B0;! B;>10B49,4U9B4R3! M'#%mN#!_16=,79! D01;B=D9371! Y=1! 13701! ,;6! Y=1!1679K93! D;0! 70TI4B;! C9?! =3! 9,7;! 32>10;! :1!437103;6! >9?;016! :1! &$! 9X;6! M"#+mN#! .3!7S0>43;6! :1! 3451,! 1:=B9745;F! +(#'m! :1! ,;6!437103;6! D;0! :0;896! 713@93! 1:=B9B4R3!61B=3:9049! B;>D,179! ;! >13;6#! W1823!435167489B4;316! :1! D139,46796! ?! :1! ,9!-;>464R3!.D46B;D9,!:1!LBB4R3!W;B49,!M%$()F!D#!("NF! e9,! 167=:490! 1,! 3451,! 1:=B9745;! ?! ,9!D0;I164R3! :161>D1X9:9! D;0! 1,! D9:01! ?! ,9!>9:01F! Y=1:9! B,90;! Y=1! 9! ,9! BT0B1,! 648=13!?13:;F! 1613B49,>1371F! 709K9A9:;016! D;K016F!C4A;6! 9! 6=! 51U! :1! 709K9A9:;016! D;B;!B=9,4I4B9:;6! ?! 643! 167=:4;6f#! .6796!435167489B4;316! 61X9,93!Y=1! ,9! 8093!>9?;0@9!:1! ,96! D106;396! D0459:96! :1! ,9! ,4K1079:!D0;B1:13! :1! I9>4,496! :161670=B7=09:96! ;!3=>10;696F! ?! Y=1! C93! 5454:;! 13! ,9! B9,,1!M-;>464R3!.D46B;D9,!:1!LBB4R3!W;B49,F!%$()N#!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES36
![Page 41: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
!!!.3! %082835F! 1,! D;0B1379A1! :1! 0143B4:13716!:1370;!:1,!7;79,!:1!,9!D;K,9B4R3!D0459:9!:1!,9!,4K1079:!16!9,7;!M)+#&m!13!%$(%N!?!C9!5134:;!13! 9=>137;#! /1! B9:9! ($! D106;396! D0;B169Z:96!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!70TI4B;!:1!:0;896!13!%$(gF!:;6! 61! 13B;3709K93! :16;B=D9:96! ;! D1364;Z39:96! 9,! >;>137;! :1,! D0;B169>4137;F! 6146!019,4U9K93! 9,823! ;I4B4;! 13! D;64B4;316! :1!D01B9041:9:! ,9K;09,! MeBC93896fF! A;039,10;6F!13! e,9K;016fF! 13! ,9! D0;6747=B4R3F! =! ;70;6N! ?!6;,;! :;6! 1093! 167=:493716F! 1>D,19:;6!D0459:;6!;!D2K,4B;6! Mb90:9U93;!d!W9,9>93;F!%$(&N#!!!Usuarios de drogas: criminalización y encarcelamiento !
\161!9!Y=1!B9:9!51U!7;>9!>T6!I=10U9!,9!4:19!:1! Y=1! 1,! B;36=>;! :1! :0;896F! ?! ,96!B;3:=B796! 31B1690496! D909! 019,4U90,;F! 3;!:1K1! 610! 70979:;! B;>;!=3! 96=37;! :1! @3:;,1!D139,F! 643;! =3;! :1! 69,=:[! 13! 1,! >=3:;F! ?!16D1B49,>1371! 13! ,9! 0184R3! ,9743;9>104B939F!61! B;374329! D10648=413:;! ?! 693B4;39:;!D139,>1371!9! ,;6!=6=904;6#! W1823!:97;6!Y=1!,;6!.679:;6!01D;0793!9!^QH/-F!1,!32>10;!:1!B9D7=096! D;,4B49,16! D;0! B;3:=B796! 96;B49:96!9,! B;36=>;! :1! :0;896! 4,@B4796! 6=D109! ,96! :1,!70TI4B;#!L=3Y=1!D909! 1,! B96;!:1! ,;6! =6=904;6!
,9! 7969! :1! B;3:1396! M16! :1B40F! 1,! D;0B1379A1!:1!,;6!B9D7=09:;6!Y=1!710>4393!B;3:139:;6N!16! >13;0! Y=1! D909! ,;6! :1,47;6! 01,9B4;39:;6!B;3!1,!70TI4B;F!7;:95@9!61!648=1!B;3:1393:;!?!13B90B1,93:;!9!=6=904;6!:1!:0;896!Mc1799,!d!E;4F!%$(&N#!/1!C1BC;F!^QH/-!1674>9!Y=1!B964!=39! B=9079! D9071! :1! ,96! D106;396! Y=1! 61!13B=13709!13!D0464R3!13!1,!>=3:;!D;0!:1,47;6!:1! :0;896F! ,;! 167T! D;0! B;3:=B796!01,9B4;39:96! B;3! 1,! B;36=>;F! 3;! B;3! ,9!D0;:=BB4R3F! 70TI4B;! ;! B;>10B49,4U9B4R3! :1!:0;896!4,@B4796!M^QH/-F!%$(&KF!D#!($%N#!!!
\;0! ,96! :1B,909B4;316! D;,@74B96! Y=1! C93!6=6B047;!,;6!.679:;6!:1!L>S04B9!13!1,!61374:;!:1! Y=1! 1,! =6;! :1! :0;896! :1K1! 610! 70979:;!K9A;! =3! 13I;Y=1! :1! 69,=:! D2K,4B9! ?! 3;! B;3!>1:4:96! 01D0164596F! B9K0@9! 16D1090! Y=1! 13!,;6! D9@616! 939,4U9:;6! 1671! I13R>13;! I=109!1VB1DB4;39,%"#! W43! 1>K908;F! B;>;! 61!>13B4;3R! 937104;0>1371F! ,96! 016D=16796! :1!,;6!8;K4103;6!13!L>S04B9! I01371!9,! B;36=>;!:1!6=6793B496!:1!=6;!4,@B47;!B;3743293!6413:;!D01:;>439371>1371! D=3474596! ?! 01D0164596!M-.//F! %$(gN#! .67;! 6=B1:1! D;0Y=1F! 9! D1690!:1! Y=1! 1,! =6;! :1! :0;896! 3;! 167T! B04>439,4Z
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!%"! L,! 016D1B7;! D=1:13! B;36=,79061! ,9! /1B,909B4R3! :1!L3748=9F!a=971>9,9F!9:;D79:9!1,!&!:1!A=34;!:1!%$("F!?!1,!43I;0>1!e.,!\0;K,1>9!:1!,96!/0;896!13!,96!L>S04B96f!MH.LF! %$("NF! ,;6! B=9,16! 01D01613790;3! =3! 840;! 13! ,9!D;67=09! :1! ,;6! .679:;6#! \;67104;0>1371F! 61! C93!D0;:=B4:;! ,96! 648=413716! :1B,909B4;316! Y=1! C93!0974I4B9:;! ,9! 5;,=379:! 01I;0>4679G! o464R3! _184;39,! :1!^396=0!D909!^QaLWW!%$(&[!/1B,909B4R3!:1!w=47;!:1!,9!-.EL-F! 016=,79:;! :1! ,9! PP! 01=34R3!c434671049,! 6;K01! 1,!D0;K,1>9! >=3:49,! :1! ,96! :0;896[! /1B,909B4R3! :1!b0964,49! 6;K01! \=37;6! :1! -;3510813B49! :1! ,;6! .679:;6!\9071! ?! L6;B49:;6! :1!c._-HW^_! I01371! 9! ,9! ^QaLWW!%$(&#! \909! B;36=,790! 16796! ?! ;7096! :1B,909B4;316! 61!D=1:1!9BB1:10!9G! !C77DG]]4:DB#317]16]9,1076]%$()]$+]D04>10ZK;009:;0ZD909Z,9Z=38966Z%$(&Z9D;079B4;316Z:1Z1679:;6Z>41>K0;6Z?Z;089346>;6Z0184;39,16!!
!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES 37
Fotografía: Oficina de Prensa y Comunicación. Ministerio de Justicia y Paz de Costa Rica.
![Page 42: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
U9:;F! ,9!D;6164R3!;!71313B49F!96@!B;>;!;7096!9B7454:9:16!31B1690496!D909!Y=1!,96!D106;396!D=1:93!1A10B10!6=!:101BC;!9!=690!:0;896!64!,;!167T3F!9=3Y=1!:1! I;0>96!:4I1013716!13!B9:9!
D9@6#! .,! B=9:0;! 648=41371! >=16709! ,9! 018=,9ZB4R3! :1,! =6;! ?! ,9! D;6164R3! :1! :0;896! 13! ,;6!3=151!D9@616!,9743;9>104B93;6!167=:49:;6#!!
!
!
A;,.#(! C*! L/E;1,'&:0! ./1! '(0-;2(! F! ! 4(-/-&:0! ./! .#(E,-! /0! 1(-! 4,8-/-! 1,3&0(,2/#&',0(-!/-3;.&,.(-*!
País Consumo Posesión Regulación (síntesis)
Argentina No Sí
La posesión o tenencia simple y la tenencia con fines están tipificadas como delito. El artículo 14 de la Ley 23.737 tipifica la posesión para consumo como delito. Sin embargo, la Corte Suprema declaró la inconstitucionalidad del segundo párrafo del artículo 14 siempre que "se realice en condiciones tales que no traigan aparejado un peligro concreto o un daño a derechos o bienes de terceros". (Véase Corte Suprema de Justicia de la Nación Argentina, Fallo Arriola -A. 891. XLIV-).
Bolivia No Sí
La posesión para consumo es delito de acuerdo con el artículo 49 de la Ley 1008, sancionable con tratamiento forzoso. Sin embargo, en la práctica esta disposición no se aplica. En caso de que un examen médico determine que la persona aprehendida porta más de lo necesario para su consumo personal e inmediato, debe ser procesada por tráfico de drogas.
Brasil No Sí
La posesión para consumo y la posesión simple están tipificadas como delito. El artículo 28 de la Ley 11.343/06, señala que el juez determina cuando la sustancia se considera para consumo personal tomando en cuenta, entre otras cosas, la “naturaleza” de la sustancia, la cantidad y los antecedentes de la persona. Las sanciones para posesión por consumo no incluyen penas privativas de libertad. Artículo 33 de la Ley 11.343/06
Colombia No Sí
El consumo está prohibido constitucionalmente, pero la Corte Suprema de Justicia ha sostenido, con base en la doctrina de la dosis de aprovisionamiento, que el porte para consumo no está penalizado, incluso si sobrepasa la dosis personal (ver Corte Constitucional de Colombia, Sentencia C 221). Sin embargo, la posesión simple sí está tipificada como delito24.
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!%g!.3!,9!W13713B49!-Zg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g! ! 9! )$F$$$! 69,904;6!>@34>;6!,189,16!>136=9,16!54813716#!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES38
![Page 43: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&'(!&()"%#*+!,(--!./01! (!
Costa Rica No No
Ni la posesión para consumo ni la posesión simple son delito. La posesión sólo es delito si se determina que la intención de la persona es para que "distribuya, comercie, suministre, fabrique, elabore, refine, transforme, extraiga, prepare, cultive, produzca, transporte, almacene o venda las drogas, las sustancias o los productos referidos en esta Ley, o cultive las plantas de las que se obtienen tales sustancias o productos" (Artículo 58 de la Ley 8204). La posesión está tipifica y sancionada tratándose de semillas “con capacidad germinadora u otros productos naturales para producir las referidas drogas." (Ley 8204 en el Artículo 58).
Ecuador No Sí
La posesión simple y para uso están tipificadas como delito, pero cuando la posesión es para consumo no es sancionada (artículo 220 del Código Orgánico integral Penal). La posesión simple se materializa por encima de los umbrales25.
México No Sí
La posesión para consumo personal es un delito, pero no se procede penalmente, siempre que no se exceda de los umbrales máximos establecidos por la Ley General de Salud (artículo 479), no sea en lugares como escuelas o cárceles y se trate de alguna de las sustancias contempladas en la LGS. La posesión simple es delito26.
Perú No Sí La posesión para consumo no es punible siempre que no exceda los umbrales de cantidad permitidos o se encuentre en posesión de dos o más tipos de sustancias. Por encima de los umbrales es punible.
Uruguay No Sí
La posesión para consumo no es delito. El juez, de acuerdo a las “reglas de la sana crítica”, decide cuando una sustancia será destinada a consumo personal. En el caso del cannabis, se entiende para consumo hasta 40 gr de marihuana o seis plantas (Artículo 7, Ley 19.172). La posesión simple es delito, salvo que se cuente con autorización legal del artículo 5 de la Ley 19.172.
$K>D4>2!M\S01U!-;0019F!-;0:9!e!c;471=VF!$#()!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!$)! _16;,=B4R3! ##(! -HQW.\Z-/Z$#(%! Y=1! 1679K,1B1! ,96! B9374:9:16! >TV4>96! 9:>464K,16! :1! 71313B49! :1! 6=6793B496!167=D1I9B413716!?!D64B;70RD4B96!D909!B;36=>;!D106;39,"!W18=3:;!W=D,1>137;!_"H"!Q;"!(+Z!$#!:1!A=34;!:1!$#(%"!!$&!.,!907@B=,;!a**!9!,9!E1?!b13109,!:1!W9,=:!1679K,1B1!,9!D;6164R3!64>D,1!B=93:;!9,8=413!D;611!9,8=3;!:1!,;6!f390BR74B;6!61X9,9:;6!13!,9!79K,9!13!B9374:9:!>13;0!9!,9!Y=1!016=,71!:1!>=,74D,4B90!D;0!>4,!,96!D01546796!13!:4BC9!79K,9g!?!fB=93:;!D;0! ,96!B40B=36793B496!:1,!C1BC;!79,!D;6164R3!3;!D=1:9!B;364:109061!:167439:9!9!B;>10B49,4U90,;6!;!6=>43467090,;6F!9=3!8097=479>1371g"!/4BC9!B;3:=B79!16!693B4;39K,1!B;3!D1396!:1!13701!f:41U!>1616!9!7016!9X;6!:1!D0464R3!?!C9679!;BC1379!:@96!:1!>=,79g"!!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES 39
En términos normativos, la posesión o tenencia suele distinguirse entre a) la posesión con fines de distribución (que puede ser comercial o gratuita) y b) la posesión que no se realiza con esos fines. Esta última, a su vez, se distingue entre aquella que se presume que es para consumo estrictamente personal (conocida como posesión para consumo) y la posesión que, sin exigir que tenga fines de distribución, no es tolerada. Este último tipo de posesión es conocida como posesión simple (Pérez Correa et al, 2015).
Las conductas relacionadas con drogas pueden estar reguladas de tres posibles formas: a) la conducta está tipificada como delito y es sancionada, b) está tipificada como delito pero no es sancionada y, c) no está ni tipificada ni penalizada. El tráfico, comercio, siembra y distribución son regulados de la primera forma, pues se consideran delitos y, por lo tanto, son sancionados. El consumo, en cambio, suele caer en la tercera de estas tres categorías: ni es delito ni está sancionado. Los distintos tipos de posesión, por el contrario, suelen oscilar entre la primera y segunda forma de regulación, dependiendo de cada
!!!
!"#$%&'(!&()"%#*+!,(--!./01! (!
Costa Rica No No
Ni la posesión para consumo ni la posesión simple son delito. La posesión sólo es delito si se determina que la intención de la persona es para que "distribuya, comercie, suministre, fabrique, elabore, refine, transforme, extraiga, prepare, cultive, produzca, transporte, almacene o venda las drogas, las sustancias o los productos referidos en esta Ley, o cultive las plantas de las que se obtienen tales sustancias o productos" (Artículo 58 de la Ley 8204). La posesión está tipifica y sancionada tratándose de semillas “con capacidad germinadora u otros productos naturales para producir las referidas drogas." (Ley 8204 en el Artículo 58).
Ecuador No Sí
La posesión simple y para uso están tipificadas como delito, pero cuando la posesión es para consumo no es sancionada (artículo 220 del Código Orgánico integral Penal). La posesión simple se materializa por encima de los umbrales25.
México No Sí
La posesión para consumo personal es un delito, pero no se procede penalmente, siempre que no se exceda de los umbrales máximos establecidos por la Ley General de Salud (artículo 479), no sea en lugares como escuelas o cárceles y se trate de alguna de las sustancias contempladas en la LGS. La posesión simple es delito26.
Perú No Sí La posesión para consumo no es punible siempre que no exceda los umbrales de cantidad permitidos o se encuentre en posesión de dos o más tipos de sustancias. Por encima de los umbrales es punible.
Uruguay No Sí
La posesión para consumo no es delito. El juez, de acuerdo a las “reglas de la sana crítica”, decide cuando una sustancia será destinada a consumo personal. En el caso del cannabis, se entiende para consumo hasta 40 gr de marihuana o seis plantas (Artículo 7, Ley 19.172). La posesión simple es delito, salvo que se cuente con autorización legal del artículo 5 de la Ley 19.172.
$H>D4>2!M\S01U!-;0019F!-;0:9!e!c;471=VF!$#()N"!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!$)! _16;,=B4R3! ##(! -HQW.\Z-/Z$#(%! Y=1! 1679K,1B1! ,96! B9374:9:16! >TV4>96! 9:>464K,16! :1! 71313B49! :1! 6=6793B496!167=D1I9B413716!?!D64B;70RD4B96!D909!B;36=>;!D106;39,"!W18=3:;!W=D,1>137;!_"H"!Q;"!(+Z!$#!:1!A=34;!:1!$#(%"!!$&!.,!907@B=,;!a**!9!,9!E1?!b13109,!:1!W9,=:!1679K,1B1!,9!D;6164R3!64>D,1!B=93:;!9,8=413!D;611!9,8=3;!:1!,;6!f390BR74B;6!61X9,9:;6!13!,9!79K,9!13!B9374:9:!>13;0!9!,9!Y=1!016=,71!:1!>=,74D,4B90!D;0!>4,!,96!D01546796!13!:4BC9!79K,9g!?!fB=93:;!D;0! ,96!B40B=36793B496!:1,!C1BC;!79,!D;6164R3!3;!D=1:9!B;364:109061!:167439:9!9!B;>10B49,4U90,;6!;!6=>43467090,;6F!9=3!8097=479>1371g"!/4BC9!B;3:=B79!16!693B4;39K,1!B;3!D1396!:1!13701!f:41U!>1616!9!7016!9X;6!:1!D0464R3!?!C9679!;BC1379!:@96!:1!>=,79g"!!
!!!
!"#$%&'(!&()"%#*+!,(--!./01! +!
B04>439,4U9:;F! ,9! D;6164R3! ;! 71313B49F! 96@!B;>;! ;7096! 9B7454:9:16! 31B1690496! D909! Y=1!,96! D106;396! D=1:93! 1A10B10! 6=! :101BC;! 9!=690! :0;896! 64! ,;! 167T3F! 9=3Y=1! :1! I;0>96!:4I1013716! 13! B9:9! D9@6"! .,! B=9:0;! 648=41371!
>=16709! ,9! 018=,9B4R3! :1,! =6;! ?! ,9! D;6164R3!:1! :0;896! 13! ,;6! 3=151! D9@616!,9743;9>104B93;6!167=:49:;6"!!
!
!
A;,.#(! C*! L/E;1,'&:0! ./1! '(0-;2(! F! ! 4(-/-&:0! ./! .#(E,-! /0! 1(-! 4,8-/-! 1,3&0(,2/#&',0(-!/-3;.&,.(-*!
País Consumo Posesión Regulación (síntesis)
Argentina No Sí
La posesión o tenencia simple y la tenencia con fines están tipificadas como delito. El artículo 14 de la Ley 23.737 tipifica la posesión para consumo como delito. Sin embargo, la Corte Suprema declaró la inconstitucionalidad del segundo párrafo del artículo 14 siempre que "se realice en condiciones tales que no traigan aparejado un peligro concreto o un daño a derechos o bienes de terceros". (Véase Corte Suprema de Justicia de la Nación Argentina, Fallo Arriola -A. 891. XLIV-).
Bolivia No Sí
La posesión para consumo es delito de acuerdo con el artículo 49 de la Ley 1008, sancionable con tratamiento forzoso. Sin embargo, en la práctica esta disposición no se aplica. En caso de que un examen médico determine que la persona aprehendida porta más de lo necesario para su consumo personal e inmediato, debe ser procesada por tráfico de drogas.
Brasil No Sí
La posesión para consumo y la posesión simple están tipificadas como delito. El artículo 28 de la Ley 11.343/06, señala que el juez determina cuando la sustancia se considera para consumo personal tomando en cuenta, entre otras cosas, la “naturaleza” de la sustancia, la cantidad y los antecedentes de la persona. Las sanciones para posesión por consumo no incluyen penas privativas de libertad. Artículo 33 de la Ley 11.343/06
Colombia No Sí
El consumo está prohibido constitucionalmente, pero la Corte Suprema de Justicia ha sostenido, con base en la doctrina de la dosis de aprovisionamiento, que el porte para consumo no está penalizado, incluso si sobrepasa la dosis personal (Ver Corte Constitucional de Colombia, Sentencia C 221). Sin embargo, la posesión simple sí está tipificada como delito24.
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!$a!.3!,9!W13713B49!-Za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aN! 9! )#F>4,! 69,904;6!>@34>;6!,189,16!>136=9,16!54813716"!
![Page 44: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
!
D9@6#! L6@F! >4137096! Y=1! 343823! D9@6! 74D4I4B9!B;>;!:1,47;!1,!B;36=>;!:1!6=6793B496!:1!=6;!4,@B47;F! 13! 7;:;6! ,;6! D9@616F! 69,5;! -;679! _4B9F!,9! D;6164R3! 61! 13B=13709! 74D4I4B9:9! B;>;!:1,47;F! 13! 9,8=39! :1! ,96! >;:9,4:9:16!>13B4;39:96! 9004K9! M\S01U! -;0019! !"# $%&!%$()N#!!
L,! 74D4I4B90! ,9! D;6164R3! B;>;! :1,47;! 61!>9374131! 9! ,;6! B;36=>4:;016! :1370;! :1! ,9!16I109! D139,! ?9! Y=1! 7;:;! B;36=>4:;0F! D909!D;:10! B;36=>40F! :1K1! 93716! D;6110! ,9!6=6793B49#! ÉF! 9=3! 13! 1,! 6=D=167;! :1! Y=1! ,9!D;6164R3! D909! B;36=>;! 3;! 61! B967489!D139,>1371F! 6;3! D;,4B@96F! I46B9,16! ;! A=1B16!D139,16F!16!:1B40F!9813716!:1,!64671>9!D139,F!Y=41316! :1710>4393! ,9! I439,4:9:! :1! ,9!D;6164R3#!E;6!B;36=>4:;016!6;3!9001679:;6!?!I01B=1371>1371! ,,159:;6! 9! ,96! I46B9,@96! D909!:1710>4390!6=!B9,4:9:!:1!B;36=>4:;016F!B;3!7;:;6! ,;6! 04168;6! Y=1! 167;! 4>D,4B9! 13! 1,!B;371V7;! ,9743;9>104B93;F! >90B9:;! D;0!B;00=DB4R3F! 9K=6;! 13! ,9! :46B01B4;39,4:9:! ?!1VB16;!13!1,!=6;!:1!,9!I=10U9#!!
c1B9346>;6!B;>;!,9!:1I434B4R3!:1!=>K09,16!D909!:467438=40!,9!D;6164R3!D909!=6;!D106;39,!:1! 9Y=1,,9! ;041379:9! 9! ;70;6! I4316F! 3;! C93!64:;!6=I4B413716!D909!154790!1671!04168;%*#!E;6!
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
:97;6! :1,! -.//!>=167093! Y=1! 13! ,;6! D9@616!167=:49:;6! 61! 648=1! :1713413:;! ;!D0;B1693:;! 9! =6=904;6! :1! :0;896#! É! B=93:;!7;:;6! ,;6! B;370;,16! 9:>4346709745;6! ?!A=:4B49,16! D909! :467438=40! 9! 9Y=1,,;6! Y=1!D;6113! D909! B;36=>40! :1! Y=41316! ,;! C9B13!D909!709I4B90!;!513:10!I9,,93F!61! ,,189! 43B,=6;!9! B;3:1390! ?! 13B90B1,90! 43A=679>1371! 9!=6=904;6!:1!:0;896!1Y=4D90T3:;,;6!B;3!>4B0;!513:1:;016#!!
.3! D026<);<3F! :1! 9B=10:;! B;3! ,9! >T6!01B41371! 435167489B4R3! :1,! -.//! M-;0:9F!%$(&NF! 13! %$(g! ,9! \0;B=09:=0@9! :1!Q90B;B04>439,4:9:! M\_H-^QL_N! :1! ,9!\0;B=09B4R3! a13109,! :1! ,9! Q9B4R3! D016137R!=3! 43I;0>1! 13! 1,! B=9,! 43:4BR! Y=1! 13! 1,! 9X;!%$(%!61!018467090;3!+Fg(g!B9=696!D;0!1,!:1,47;!:1! 71313B49! :1! 167=D1I9B413716! D909!B;36=>;! D106;39,! D;0! ,;6! I46B9,16! I1:109,16!:1!7;:;!1,!D9@6!M"'#%m!:1,!7;79,NF!6413:;!1679!,9! 09UR3! D;0! ,9! Y=1!>T6! B9=696! 61! 434B490;3!M\0;B=09:=0@9!:1!Q90B;B04>439,4:9:F!%$(%N#!L!1671!32>10;! 61!:1K13! 6=>90! ,96! B9=696!D;0!1,! >46>;! :1,47;! Y=1! 61! 018467093! 13! ,96!I46B9,@96! :1! ,9! \0;543B49! :1! b=13;6! L4016F!710047;04;! :;3:1! 43710541313! ,96! 9813B496!D139,16! ,;B9,16#! .3! %$$'! C=K;! *Fg'g! B9=696!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!;70;6! B96;6F! B;>;! 13! -;,;>K49! B;3! ,9! :;B70439! :1! ,9!:;646! :1! 9D0;5464;39>4137;! :16900;,,9:9! D;0! ,9! -;071!W=D01>9! :1! `=674B49F! 61! 1V4813! 1,1>137;6! 9:4B4;39,16!D909! 613713B490! 9! =39! D106;39! B=93:;! 61! 6;K01D9693!,;6!=>K09,16!D10>474:;6F!B;>;!D;0!1A1>D,;F!1679K,1B10!43713B4;39,4:9:! :1! 51379! ;! :46704K=B4R3#! W43! 1>K908;F!923!13!1671!16B13904;F!1,!=6=904;!Y=1:9!K9A;! ,9!16I109!:1!,96!436747=B4;316!D139,16F!6413:;!>971049!:1!D;,4B@96!?!I46B9,16!?!3;!:1!436747=B4;316!:1!69,=:!B;>;!61!9I40>9!:46B=06459>1371#!O13413:;!13!B=1379!Y=1!,;6!=>K09,16!D=1:13! 610! 90>96! :1! :;K,1! I4,;F! 1,! -.//! C9!01B;>13:9:;!=690,;6!641>D01!B;>;!D46;6F!D;0!:1K9A;!:1!,;6!B=9,16!3;!61!D=1:9!61X9,90!9!=39!D106;39!B;>;!513:1:;09F!?!3;!B;>;!71BC;6!D;0!13B4>9!:1!,;6!B=9,16!61!,1!D016=>9!B;>;!390B;>13=:4679!;!>4B0;709I4B9371!M\S01UZ-;0019!!"#$%&!%$()N#!
40 CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES
![Page 45: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
D;0! 71313B49! D909! B;36=>;! D106;39,!434B49:96! D;0! ,;6! I46B9,16! :1! ,9! \0;543B49! :1!b=13;6! L4016! M\0;B=09:=0@9! :1!Q90B;B04>439,4:9:F! %$(gN#! eO13413:;! 13!B=1379!Y=1!16796!B9=696!648=410;3!B01B413:;!9! D90740! :1! :4BC;! 9X;F! 16! D;64K,1! 43I1040! Y=1!:=09371!1,!%$(%!61!C9K0@93!01846709:;!>T6!:1!Y=43B1! >4,! B9=696! D;0! 71313B49! D909!B;36=>;! D106;39,[! 167;! D10>471! D13690! 13!=3! 32>10;! 48=9,! ;! >9?;0! :1! =6=904;6!9,B93U9:;6! D;0! 1,! 64671>9! D139,! 13! 7;:;! 1,!D9@6f!M-;0:9F!%$(&N#!/1!C1BC;F!!,96!B9=696!P34Z!
!
!
!
!
B49:96!D;0!1671!>;745;!01D01613793!>T6!:1!,9!>479:! :1,! 7;79,! 13! A=046:4BB4;316! B;>;!-R0:;K9! M&$mNF! ! c13:;U9! M)%mN! ?!_1646713B49! M)(mN! M\0;B=09:=0@9! :1!Q90B;B04>439,4:9:F! %$(%N#! L=3Y=1! 3;! C9?!43I;0>9B4R3! D909! B;3;B10! ,9! I;0>9! 13! Y=1!710>4390;3! 16796! B9=696F! 6@! 16! D;64K,1!:1710>4390!Y=1! 61!C93!D0161379:;! B96;6!:1!B;3:1396!B;3709!=6=904;6F!96@!B;>;!79>K4S3!B;3709!9=7;!B=,7459:;016! M_154679!Oj-F!%$("F!%$(%!?!%$((N#!
!
!
!
!
!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES 41
Fotografía: César Acuña. Prisión en Ecuador.
![Page 46: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
!
!
.3! T034;:F! =39! :1! ,96! C4DR71646! 6;K01! 1,!9=>137;!:1!D106;396!D0459:96!:1!,9!,4K1079:!9!D90740!:1!,9!3=159!E1?!:1!/0;896!16!Y=1!=3!4>D;079371! 32>10;! :1! =6=904;6! AR51316!167T3!6413:;!B;3:139:;6!B;>;!709I4B93716!!
!
D;0!D;0790!D1Y=1X96!B9374:9:16#!.67;!D901B1!610!1,!B96;!13!_@;!:1!`93140;F!b0964,49!Mb;471=V!d! J41Bk;F! %$$+NF! ?! W9;! \9=,;! M`1626! !"# $%F!%$((N#!
FW!203?14!/6!?30;(83<3O!?^4!/6!7;<71!?6464!/6!*0;4;J<!
^3!B96;!Y=1!7=5;!>=BC9!01D10B=64R3!D2K,4B9F!;B=004:;!13!,9!\0;543B49!:1!W937498;!:1,!.6710;!13!L08137439F! >=16709! Y=1! ,;6! =6=904;6! D=1:13! 710>4390! 13! D0464R3#! /467437;6! >1:4;6! 80TI4B;6!01B;8410;3!1,!B96;!:1!=3!A;513!:1!514374:R6!9X;6!Y=1!C9K@9!64:;!13B;3709:;!9!>1:49:;6!:1!%$("!B;3!()!809>;6!:1!>904C=939F!09UR3!D;0!,;!Y=1!167=5;!:17134:;!D;0!>T6!:1!B43B;!>1616#!^3!9X;!:16D=S6! 61! 1679K,1B4R! Y=1! 6=! 71313B49! 109! D909! B;36=>;! D106;39,#! .,! B96;! I;0>R! D9071! :1,!:;B=>1379,!eE9!>TY=439!:1!C9B10!D101A4,16f!?!=3!9DS3:4B1!Y=1!61!D=K,4BR!13!%$(gF!9>K;6!167T3!:46D;34K,16!13!É;=O=K1#!
-;3!16796!I=13716!61!D=1:1!01B;3670=40!,9!C467;049G!7;:;!B;>13UR!9!D043B4D4;6!:1!%$("!B=93:;!1,!A;513! I=1! :17134:;! B;3! ()! 809>;6! :1! B9339K46F! 434B493:;! =3! D0;B16;! D139,! :;3:1! C9K0@9!D9074B4D9:;!=3!D;,4B@9! B;3!1,! B=9,! 7=5;!=3! 9,710B9:;!937104;0#! E96! 9813B496! A=:4B49,16F! 13! 51U!:1!B4790,;! 9! :1B,9090! B;>;! ,1! C9K@93! :4BC;F! ,;! B;>13U90;3! 9! 4351674890! D;0! 1,! :1,47;! :1!B;>10B49,4U9B4R3!:1!167=D1I9B413716#!
-;>;! D9071! :1! ,9! 435167489B4R3F! 1,! (+! :1! A=34;! :1! %$("! 61! 9,,93R! 1,! D=167;! :1! :4904;6! I9>4,490!:;3:1!709K9A9K9!1,! A;513F!9,!B=9,! 61! ,1! 43B9=790;3!()!809>;6!:1!>904C=939#!W1823!1,! 01,97;!:1,!:17134:;F! 9,! >;>137;! :1,! 9,,939>4137;! =3;! :1! ,;6! 43718093716! :1! ,9! I=10U9! :1! 618=04:9:! Y=1!43710543;!C9K@9!9B;>D9X9:;!9! ,9!D106;39!Y=1! ,1!513:4R!169!>46>9!6=6793B49! ,9!3;BC1!937104;0#!\161! 9! ,;! 1V48=;! :1! 169! 6=6793B49! 61!>937=5;! :17134:;! 9,! A;513! 9D;?T3:;61! 13! ,;6! 6=D=167;6!1,1>137;6!B;,1B79:;6!Y=1!43:4B9K93!Y=1!,9!513:@9#!\;67104;0>1371!01B=D10R!6=!,4K1079:!1,!%&!:1!3;541>K01!:1!%$("!?!1,!($!:1! A=34;!:1!%$(g!61!B;364:10R!Y=1!61! 70979K9!:1!=39! 71313B49!D909!B;36=>;!D106;39,#!
W4!K413!3;!C9K0@9!5=1,7;!9!,9!BT0B1,F!1,!D0;B16;!D139,!3;!61!B100R#!.,!>46>;!A;513!61X9,R!Y=1!13!1,!>90B;! :1! 161! 1VD1:41371! :1K@9! I439,4U90! 167=:4;6F! 019,4U90! 790196! B;>=34790496! ?! C9B10!01C9K4,479B4R3F!1V4813B496!Y=1!61!4>D;313!B;>;!9,7103974596!9,!9593B1!:1,!D0;B16;!D139,#!
_16D1B7;!:1!,9!4>D;64B4R3!:1!,9!01C9K4,479B4R3F!,9!D0;D49!D106;39!6;67=5;!Y=1!109!=39!e7;37109f!?!01I404RG!e?;!3;!6;?!=3!13I10>;!D;0Y=1!B;36=>;!>904C=939f#!W43!1>K908;F!61!4>D;31!B;>;!=3;!:1! ,;6!01Y=4647;6!D909!154790! ,9!D;64K4,4:9:!:1! ,9!B;3743=9B4R3!:1,!D0;B16;F!1! 43B,=6;F!:1!5;,510!9!D0464R3#!
I86<)6+!M-;0:9F!%$(&N!
42 CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES
![Page 47: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
.3! T1:;V;3! 3;! C9?! =39! B9374:9:! 1679K,1B4:9!:1! :0;896! :1! =6;! 4,@B47;! M=>K09,N! Y=1! :1K1!B;364:109061! D909! B;36=>;! D106;39,!43>1:497;F! 643;! Y=1! ,9! >46>9! :1K1! 610!:1710>439:9!D;0!=3!1V9>13!>S:4B;#!/1,!9X;!%$($! 9,! %$(%F! "F)%)! D106;396! I=10;3!9D01C13:4:96!D;0!,9!h=10U9!.6D1B49,!:1!E=BC9!B;3709! 1,! Q90B;70TI4B;! D;0! ! D;6164R3! :1!9,8=39!6=6793B49!B;370;,9:9#!.3!1,!70936B=06;!:1,! 9X;! %$(&F! 1,! 'm! :1! ,;6! (F*)"! B96;6! D;0!:1,47;6!:1!6=6793B496!B;370;,9:96! I=10;3!D;0!71313B49! D909! 1,! B;36=>;F! ?! (+m! D;0!6=>434670;! :1! :0;896F! :1,47;! D;0! 1,! Y=1!6=1,13!610!D0;B169:;6!,;6!B;36=>4:;016#!
.3! A1:1?9;3F! ,9! -;071! W=D01>9! :1! `=674B49!:16900;,,R! ,9! :;B70439! :1! ,9! :;646! :1!9D0;5464;39>4137;F!:1!9B=10:;!B;3!,9!B=9,!64!=39! D106;39! 16! B9D7=09:9! B;3! =39! B9374:9:!,151>1371! 6=D104;0! 9! ,9! :;646! D106;39,! 3;!:1K1! 610! D139,4U9:9F! 641>D01! Y=1! 6=!D0;DR647;! 3;! 619! :46704K=40,9F! 643;!B;3610590,9! D909! 6=! D0;D4;! B;36=>;%'#! .3!;709!613713B49!01B41371F!,9!-;071!W=D01>9!C9!4:;!>T6! 9,,T! ?F! 13! 61:1! :1! B969B4R3F! ,;! B=9,!C9B1! 79,! D01B1:1371! :1! ;K,4897;04;!B=>D,4>4137;! D;0! ,;6! ;D109:;016! A=:4B49,16F!1679K,1B4R! Y=1! e,9! B9374:9:! :1!167=D1I9B41371!Y=1!61! ,,151!B;3648;!3;!16!1,!234B;! 1,1>137;! :1I4347;04;! :1! ,9!9374A=04:4B4:9:F!643;!6R,;!=3;!>T6!:1!,;6!Y=1!C9K0T3! :1! 59,;090! ,;6! A=U89:;016! 9! I43! :1!:1710>4390! ,9! ,4B47=:! :1! ,9! I439,4:9:! :1,!D;071f%+#! O13413:;! 13! B=1379! Y=1! >=BC;6!B96;6! ,,1893! 9! 613713B49F! 3;! 16! :1! 1V709X90!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!%'! -;071! W=D01>9! :1! `=674B49#! W9,9! :1! B969B4R3! D139,#!W13713B49! :1,! ('! :1! 3;541>K01! :1! %$$'#! \0;B16;!Q;#!%+('"#! c43467104;! \2K,4B;! Mc\N#! `;6S! E1;34:96! b=67;6!c907@31U#!!!%+! -;071! W=D01>9! :1! `=674B49#! W9,9! :1! B969B4R3! D139,#!_9:4B9B4R3! QÑ! g%&(*#! c\#! a=6795;! .304Y=1! c9,;!h103T3:1U#!
Y=1F! B;>;! 61! C9! >;6709:;! 13! 937104;016!435167489B4;316! M-.//F! %$(gNF! =39! K=139!D9071! :1! ,96! ;BC1379! >4,! D106;396! Y=1! ,9!\;,4B@9! B9D7=09! 93=9,>1371! M1679! B4I09! 61!01I,1A9! 13! %%(! B9D7=096! :490496! ;! 3=151!B9D7=096! B9:9!C;09N! 6193!=6=904;6! M^D04>3?!!"# $%&! %$(&9N#! \10;! 9:1>T6F! 61823! =39!>=16709! :1! 1VD1:413716! B;3:1397;04;6! D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896F!13701!%$((!?!%$(gF!"$#*(m!:1! ,96!B;3:1396! I=10;3!D;0!e,,1590!B;3648;fF!16! :1B40F! D;0! D;071! ;! D;6164R3! 64>D,1! :1!:0;896F!643!Y=1!61!D0;K909!Y=1!,96!6=6793B496!713@93! I4316! :467437;6! 9,! =6;#! .3! 9,8=3;6! :1!167;6! B96;6F! 43B,=6;! 61! B;3:13R! 9! D106;396!B;3! D;6164R3! :1! B9374:9:16! 43I104;016! ;!,48109>1371! 6=D104;016! 9! ,9! :;646! D106;39,!Mc43467104;! :1! `=674B49! ?! :1,! /101BC;F! 13!4>D01379N#!!
!
!.3!#783/10F! 64! K413! 1,! 907@B=,;! "&g! :1! 6=!-;36747=B4R3!B;364:109!Y=1!1,!=6;!;!B;36=>;!:1! :0;896! 3;! 16! =3! :1,47;! ?! Y=1! 167T!D0;C4K4:9! 6=! B04>439,4U9B4R3F! 13! ,;6! C1BC;6F!,9! 6;,9! e71313B49f! ;! eD;6164R3f! D909! 1,!B;36=>;! 6@! ,;! C9! 64:;! 61823! 1,! :10;89:;!907@B=,;!&%!:1!,9!E1?!($'!;!1,!%%$!:1,!-R:48;!H08T34B;! P371809,! \139,! M-HP\NF! C;?!5481371#!.,!''#'m!:1!,96!D106;396!01>474:96!9,!64671>9!D139,!D;0! ,96!9813B496!D;,4B49,16!6;3!9D01C13:4:96! D;0! 9B7;6! :1! 71313B49! ;!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES 43
Fotografía: Oficina de Prensa y Comunicación. Ministerio de Justicia y Paz de Costa Rica.
![Page 48: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
D;6164R3#! .3701! %$$*! ?! %$(gF! ,9! /1I136;0@9!\2K,4B9! :1698018R! 13701! 6=6! :1I13:4:;6! ,9!648=41371! B4I09! :1! :17134:;6! 13! :1,47;6!01,9B4;39:;6!B;3!,96!:0;896G!%"%!D;0!1,!:1,47;!:1!B;>10B49,4U9B4R3!;!1,9K;09B4R3F!)()!D;0!1,!:1,47;!:1!70TI4B;! 4,@B47;!?!()F)"%!D;0!1,!:1,47;!:1! 71313B49! ;! D;6164R3#! .3! ;7096! D9,9K096F!C=K;! =3! D0;>1:4;! :1! %F%%$! D106;396!:17134:96!9,!9X;!D;0!71313B49!;!D;6164R3!:1!:0;896! Y=1! 01Y=40410;3! :1I1369! D2K,4B9!M\9,9:4316F!%$(&9F!D#!%%N#!!E9! 13709:9! 13! 54813B49! :1,! 3=15;! -R:48;!H08T34B;! P371809,! \139,F! 167;! 16F! 1,! ($! :1!98;67;!:1!%$(gF! D10>474R! :=09371!=3! 9X;! ,9!01:=BB4R3! :1! ,96! D1396! ?! 1,! 1679K,1B4>4137;!:1! B047104;6! >T6! B,90;6! D909! ,;6! B96;6! :1!70TI4B;! 13! >@34>9F! >1:4939F! 9,79! ?! 8093!16B9,9#! .3!>90U;!:1,! 9X;!%$()F! ,9!D;K,9B4R3!B90B1,9049!:1,!.B=9:;0!61!9B10BR!9!,96!%gF"+(!D106;396! D0459:96! :1! ,9! ,4K1079:! M\9,9:4316F!%$(&KF! D#! %*NF! :1! ,96! B=9,16! gF()&! I=10;3!B;3:139:96!D;0!:1,47;6! 01,9B4;39:;6! B;3! ,96!:0;896F! 643! B;3790! Y=41316! 713@93! D0;B16;6!D13:413716#!j=K;!137;3B16!"Fgg*!C;>K016!?!*$+!>=A1016!B;3!613713B49#!.3!1,!B96;!:1!,96!>=A1016F!>T6!:1!g&&!I=10;3!,4K109:96!D;0!1,!D043B4D4;! :1! I95;09K4,4:9:! ;! :1! =39! ,1?!D;67104;0! >T6! K134839F! 01:=B413:;! 13! =3!&&m! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! I1>13439! Y=1! 61!13B;3709K9!13!,9!BT0B1,!D;0!:0;896#!!W43!1>K908;F!=3!9X;!:16D=S6!:1! ,9! 54813B49!:1,! -HP\F! 1,! 8;K4103;! 1B=97;0493;! 019,4UR!01I;0>96! D909! 43B01>13790! 3=159>1371! ,96!D1396! 13! ,;6! B96;6! :1! >@34>9! ?! >1:4939!16B9,9F! 16! :1B40F! 13! ,;! Y=1! ,;6! 4>9843904;6!6;B49,16! B;3;B13! B;>;! e>4B0;70TI4B;f#! .,!I,=A;!:1!D106;396!Y=1!61!K131I4B490;3!B;3!,96!D1396! 01I;0>9:96! D;0! ,9! D0;>=,89B4R3! :1,!
-HP\! <1! 43B,=6;! B;3! 6=! ,4K109B4R3<! B;43B4:4R!B;3! 1,! :1! D106;396! Y=1! 9C;09! 4380169K93!K9A;!,96!3=1596!01I;0>96#!L6@F!9!>1:49:;6!:1!%$()!.B=9:;0! B;379K9!B;3!'F)+*!D016;6!D;0!:0;896! M.,! O1,S809I;F! %+! :1! A=34;! :1! %$()NF!B10B9!:1,!"$m!:1,!7;79,!:1!D106;396!D0459:96!:1!,9!,4K1079:!13!6=!>;>137;"$#!
.3!#4)3/14!%<;/14! 1,!:101BC;!D139,!C9! 64:;!=69:;!D909!01:=B40!,9!;I1079!?!,9!:1>93:9!:1!:0;896F! D;0! ,;! B=9,! ,9! 7969! :1! 13B90B1,9Z>4137;!D;0!D;6164R3!:1!:0;896!B01B4R!B964!13!,9! >46>9! D0;D;0B4R3! Y=1! ,96! D106;396!13B90B1,9:96! D;0! 70TI4B;! M-9=,k436! d!-C93:,10F! %$$&N#! .3! %$(gF! '"m!:1! 7;:;6! ,;6!900167;6!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!B;0016D;3:@9!9!D;6164R3! :1! :0;896#! L:1>T6F! %$(g! I=1! 1,!D04>10! 9X;! :16:1! %$$+! 13! Y=1! 61!43B01>137R! 1,! 32>10;! :1! 900167;6! D;0!B9339K46F! ,,1893:;! 9! &(+F'$+! B96;6#! /1K4:;!9,! 64671>9! :1! I4A9B4R3! :1! D1396F! >=BC96! :1!,96! B;3:1396!>T6! :09B;349396! D;0! D;6164R3!7=5410;3!,=890!9!3451,!167979,#!!
.3!&EX;71F! :1! 9B=10:;! B;3! ,9! \0;B=09:=0@9!a13109,! :1! ,9! _1D2K,4B9F! 13701! %$$&! ?! %$(g!I=10;3! :17134:96! g)"F$&+! D106;396! 13! 1,!T>K47;!I1:109,!D;0!:1,47;6!B;3709!,9!69,=:#!/1!S6796F! (*)F++"! I=10;3! :17134:96! D;0!D;6164R3! M13! 6=6! :4510696! >;:9,4:9:16N! ?!()&F('+! D;0! B;36=>;! M9! D1690! :1! Y=1! 1,!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"$! .,! 7;79,! :1! D106;396! D0459:96! :1! ,9! ,4K1079:! 9!>1:49:;6! :1! %$()! I=1! :1! %*F&)*! D106;396F! B4I09!;K7134:9!13!1,!\0;809>9!e-;379B7;!/401B7;f!:1,! B939,!.B=95469!:1,!(!:1!A=,4;!:1!%$()#!E9!B4I09!1V9B79!:1,!7;79,!:1! D106;396! D0459:96! :1! ,9! ,4K1079:! :1K1! 610!704938=,9:9!B;3!,96!13701546796!:1!I=3B4;3904;6!D2K,4B;6!?! D=K,4B9B4;316! :1! D01369F! D=16! 3;! 1V46713! 13! 1671!61374:;! 01D;0716!D2K,4B;6! ?! D104R:4B;6!:1! ,4K01! 9BB16;!D909!,9!B4=:9:93@9!D;0!D9071!:1,!c43467104;!:1!`=674B49F!/101BC;6!j=>93;6!?!-=,7;6!:1,!.B=9:;0#!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES44
![Page 49: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
B;36=>;!3;!16!=3!:1,47;N"(#!.67;!64834I4B9!Y=1!*"#"m! :1! ,96! D106;396! :17134:96! 9! 3451,!I1:109,! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! I=10;3!:17134:96! D;0! 1,! :1,47;! :1! D;6164R3! ;!B;36=>;#!!\909!,9!435167489B4R3!6;K01!D106;396!D0459:96!:1! ,9! ,4K1079:!13!cSV4B;!61! 019,4U90;3!590496!6;,4B47=:16! :1! 43I;0>9B4R3! 9! ,;6! 1679:;6!MD0;543B496N! 6;K01! D106;396! D0459:96! :1! ,9!,4K1079:! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896#! L=3Y=1! 3;!7;:96! ,;6! .679:;6! :1,! D9@6! :410;3! :4BC9!43I;0>9B4R3"%F! ! :1! ,96! 016D=16796! 01B4K4:96F!*"F! ++%! D106;396! C9K@93! 64:;! :17134:96! D;0!:1,47;6! B;3709! ,9! 69,=:! 13! ('! 1679:;6! Y=1!:410;3! 43I;0>9B4R3! 13701! ,;6! 9X;6! %$(%! ?!%$(g#! L64>46>;F! 9=3Y=1! ,9! >9?;0@9! :1! ,;6!1679:;6! 6R,;! 01D;0790;3! :1,47;6! B;3709! ,9!69,=:!13!813109,!643!16D1B4I4B90!,;6!:1,47;6F!13!($!1679:;6!6@!,;6!16D1B4I4B90;3#!/1!,;6!("F$g+!:17134:;6! 13! 16;6! ,=89016F! &F(*%! Mg*mN!I=10;3! :17134:;6! D;0! D;6164R3! 64>D,1! ?!(Fg"%! M((mN!D;0!D;6164R3!D909! B;36=>;#!.3!;7096! D9,9K096F! )'m! :1! ,96! :1713B4;316! :1!:0;896! 13! 167;6! 1679:;6! 13701! %$(%! ?! %$(g!I=10;3!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!D;6164R3!D909!B;36=>;!;!D;6164R3!64>D,1#!L:1>T6F!,9!>9?;0@9!:1!,96!:1713B4;316!61!:410;3!D;0!>904C=939! M\S01U!-;0019!d!_;>10;F!%$(&N#!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"(! W;,4B47=:! :1! 43I;0>9B4R3! 5@9! P3I;>1VF! \a_F! I;,4;!$$$(*$$$*%%()#!"%! /1! ,;6! "%! 1679:;6F! 6R,;! ('! D0;D;0B4;390;3!43I;0>9B4R3! 6;K01! ,;6! :1,47;6! 16D1B@I4B;6! :1! :0;896G!b9A9! -9,4I;0349F! -9>D1BC1F! -C49D96F! -C4C=9C=9F!-;9C=4,9F!/467047;!h1:109,F!/=0938;F!a=10010;F!j4:9,8;F!`9,46B;F! Q=15;! E1R3F! H9V9B9F! \=1K,9F! w=437939! _;;F!W439,;9F!W93!E=46!\;7;6@F!O,9VB9,9!?!i9B971B96#!
!!
!
.3!G60HF!1,!-R:48;!\139,!D10=93;!3;!D139,4U9!,9!D;6164R3!:1!D1Y=1X96!B9374:9:16!:1!:0;89!D909! 1,! =6;! D106;39,! M907@B=,;! %++N#! W43!1>K908;F! ,9! \;,4B@9! Q9B4;39,! :1,! \102!I01B=1371>1371! :174131! 4,189,>1371! 9!=6=904;6!:1!:0;896#!.3701!1,!%$$$!?!1,!%$("!,9!\;,4B@9! :17=5;! 9! g"F)()! D106;396! D;0!B;36=>;! ;! D;6164R3F! ,;! B=9,! 01D0161379! 1,!))#)m!:1,!7;79,!:1!:1713B4;316!D;0!:0;896""#!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!""! E9! 436747=B4R3! A=674I4B9! 79,16! :1713B4;316! 13! ,;6!648=413716!7S0>43;6!e61!B;,481!Y=1!:4BC;!9BB4;390!167T!13>90B9:;! ?! 016D9,:9:;! D;0! ,9! 3;0>97454:9:! 5481371[!96@!B;>;!D;0! ,;6!c93=9,16!?!a=@96!:1!\0;B1:4>4137;6!HD109745;6!.V46713716!ÄÅÇ!1,!D106;39,!D;,4B49,!019,4U9!=3!D0;B1:4>4137;! ;D109745;! D909! ,9! 43710513B4R3! :1,!B4=:9:93;! Y=1! D;611! :0;896F! B;3! ,9! I439,4:9:! :1!4:1374I4B90,;F!1679K,1B10!Y=S!74D;!:1!:0;896!D;611!?!64!,9!B9374:9:! 16! D=34K,1! ;! 3;#! .,,;! B;3,,159! 9! ,9! 31B164:9:!:1!019,4U90!D0=1K96!:1!:16B9071!:1!,9!6=6793B49!?!D169A1!:1! ,9! >46>9! ?! 13! 9,8=3;6! B96;6! 9:1>T6! 6;,4B4790,1!1V9>13! 7;V4B;,R84B;F! 93T,4646! Y=@>4B;F! 9371B1:13716!D;,4B49,16!?!01Y=4647;0496F!17B#[! ,96!B=9,16!3;!61!019,4U93!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES 45
Fotografía: Programa Libertas. Cárcel de Varones de San Sebastián. Departamento de Cochabamba. Bolivia. Festejo de Navidad de 2016, dirigido niños que visitan a sus padres en dicha celebración.
![Page 50: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
L,8=3;6! :1! 167;6! B96;6! ,,1890;3! C9679! ,96!h46B9,@96! .6D1B49,4U9:96G! 13701! %$$+! ?! %$("!,,1890;3!"F)''!B96;6!D;0!B;36=>;!;!D;6164R3!9! B;3;B4>4137;! :1,! D;:10! A=:4B49,! M)#gm! :1!,;6!B96;6!D;0!:0;896N!Mc9381,43BkV!`#!F!%$(&N#!.3701! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! 13! D0464R3F! 1,! 9,7;!D;0B1379A1! :1! D106;396! D0459:96! :1! ,9!,4K1079:! D;0! >4B0;B;>10B49,4U9B4R3F! 6=>9:;!9! ,9! 1V46713B49! :1! 9,8=3;6! B96;6!:1!=6=904;6!13B90B1,9:;6! D;0! 1671! :1,47;F! C9! ,,159:;! 9!9,8=3;6!9! 6=81040!Y=1!590496!:1! ,96!D106;396!13B90B1,9:96! D;0! 1679! B9=69! 610@93! =6=904;6!Mc9381,43BkV!`#!F!%$(&N#!!
.3! %082835F! ,96! 435167489B4;316! 019,4U9:96!6;K01! ,9! A=046D0=:13B49! :1! ,;6! 704K=39,16! :1!9D1,9B4;316! 13! ,;! D139,! B;3! 01,9B4R3! 9! ,9!43710D0179B4R3! :1! ,9! 1V4>1371! :1! D139! D909!,9! 71313B49! :167439:9! 9,! B;36=>;! D106;39,F!>=167093! =3! B047104;! 016704B745;! Y=1! C9!713:4:;! 9! ,9! B04>439,4U9B4R3! :1! B9374:9:16!>13;016! Mb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g#!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!13! 1,! ,=890! :1! ,9! 43710513B4R3! ?! D10>4740T3!D;67104;0>1371! Y=1! 1,! 01D0161379371! :1,! c43467104;!\2K,4B;! 1679K,1UB9! ;! 3;! ,9! B;>464R3! :1! =3! 4,@B47;f!M\;,4B@9!Q9B4;39,!:1,!\102F!%$()N!!"g! .,! O04K=39,! 61X9,R! Y=1! 1,! B96;! :1K@9! 1V9>439061!713413:;! 13! B=1379! ,9! ,1?! (+#(*%F! Y=1! 1V4>1! :1!016D;369K4,4:9:!9!9,8=3;6!B=,7459:;016F!D;0!70979061!:1!=39! ,1?! D;67104;0! >T6! K131I4B4;69! D909! ,9! 13B9=69:9#!W43! 1>K908;F! 1679K,1B4R!Y=1! ,9!D106;39!13B9=69:9!3;!
.3701! %$((! ?! %$(gF! 9! :4I1013B49! :1! ,;!;B=004:;! B;3! ,;6! D0;B169>4137;6! A=:4B49,16!D;0!1,!:1,47;!:1!70TI4B;!Y=1!B9?10;3!13!))mF!9Y=1,,;6! 01,9B4;39:;6! B;3! D;6164R3]=6;!B01B410;3!(*m#!.3!7;79,F!:=09371!1671!D10@;:;!&F(&(! D106;396! I=10;3! D0;B169:96! D;0!D;6164R3F! ,;! B=9,! 01D0161379! 1,! )'m! :1! ,;6!D0;B169>4137;6!D;0!:1,47;6!01,9B4;39:;6!B;3!167=D1I9B413716#! ^3;! :1! B9:9! B=970;!D0;B169:;6! 01B4K4R!B;3:139#!L!:4I1013B49!:1!,;6! B;3:139:;6! D;0! 70TI4B;F! ,96! D106;396!B;3:139:96! D;0! D;6164R3]=6;! ,;! I=10;3F! 13!6=! >9?;0@9F! D;0! D;6164R3! :1! >904C=939!MggmNF! 618=4:9! D;0! B;B9@39! M""mN! ?! D9679!K961!M%(mN#!/1!B9:9!:41UF!6146!6;3!C;>K016!?!B=970;!6;3!>=A1016! Mb90:9U93;!d!W9,9>93;F!%$(&N#!!!E9! 1VB1DB4R3! 9! ,;! :16B047;! 16! A14)3! ";73F!:;3:1! 3;! 1V46713! =>K09,16! D909! B;36=>;!D106;39,F!643;!=3!>;:1,;!:46B01B4;39,!Y=1!61!K969! 13! ,9! 154:13B49! ?! ,;6! I9B7;016!9713=93716! :1! ,9! B;>464R3! :1! =3! :1,47;#!Q;0>9,>1371F! ,9! h46B9,@9! a13109,! :1! ,9!_1D2K,4B9! C9! :1710>439:;! :161674>90! ,;6!B96;6!:1!B;36=>;!154793:;!96@!Y=1!,9!D;,4B@9!9001671! 9! D106;396! =6=90496! M-;07S6F! %$("N#!.67;! C9! 4>D,4B9:;! Y=1! ,;6! D;,4B@96! 3;!90016793!9!=6=904;6F! 643;!Y=1F!9,!13B;37090!9!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!D=1:1!9B;81061!9!,9!1V4>1371!:1!016D;369K4,4:9:G!eÅ34!13!1,!0S84>13!937104;0!34!13!1,!5481371!=39!D106;39!Y=1!74131! =3! /)/!17! B;3! %+! D,93796! :1! >904C=939F! ,=U!9074I4B49,F! 7;,:;6! D909! ;B=,790,96! ?! D0;71810,96F! 74131!1VD,4B9B4R3! 34! A=674I4B9B4R3! 9,8=39! D909! 16790! 1VB,=4:9!:1,!01D0;BC1!D139,#!Q4!64Y=4109!16!D;64K,1!B;364:1090!,9!D,9379B4R3! B;>;! 31B169049! D909! 6=! B;36=>;! ?9! Y=1!1VB1:1! ,96! 6146! D,93796! :1!>904C=939! :1! Y=1! C9K,9! ,9!E1?f#! W43! D10A=4B4;! :1! 1,,;F! e13! ,;! 97431371! 9! ,9! D139!4>D=1679! 9! ,9! 01I104:9! 13B9=69:9F! ,9! >46>9! 610T!9K974:9! 9,! >@34>;! ,189,F! 167;! 16! 514371! >1616! :1!D0464R3F!13!9713B4R3!9!,9!397=09,1U9!:1,!4,@B47;!4>D=79:;F!B40B=36793B496! 9,197;0496F! D1,480;64:9:! ?! D106;39,4:9:!:1,!981371f!MOL\!gF!W137#!(g$]%$(gF!(*#$*#%$(gN#!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES46
![Page 51: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
9,8=413! B;36=>413:;! 13! ,9! 5@9! D2K,4B9F! ,;6!01Y=469! ?! :1B;>469! ,9! 6=6793B49F! 643! 610!B;>23! Y=1! ,;6! :1713893#! .67;F! 9:1>T6F! 59!9D901A9:;! B;3! :401B704B16! :1! D0TB74B96!436747=B4;39,16! D909! 3;! B04>439,4U90! 9! ,;6!=6=904;6!M\S01U!-;0019!!"#$%&!%$()F!D#!*Z'N#!W43!1>K908;F! 13! 1,! 93T,4646! :1! =39! >=16709! :1!1VD1:413716!D139,16!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!13!-;679! _4B9F! 1,! g+m! :1! ,;6! B;3:139:;6! D;0!51379! 9,! >13=:1;! 1093! 79>K4S3!B;36=>4:;016!:1!:0;896#!E9!:0;89!:1!>9?;0!B;36=>;!13701!1679!D;K,9B4R3!16!1,!B9339K46F!618=4:9! D;0! B09BkF! B;B9@39! ?! 9,B;C;,#! .67;!>=16709! Y=1! =3! 80=D;! 64834I4B9745;! :1!D106;396! 513:13! ,9! >46>9! :0;89! Y=1!B;36=>13! B;>;! =39! I;0>9! :1!9K9671B4>4137;! D106;39,F! 96@! B;>;! :1!6=K646713B49! 1B;3R>4B9! M-;07S6F! %$(&N#! ^3!1A1>D,;! 61! 13B=13709! 13! ,;6! 3451,16! >T6!K9A;6! :1,!>10B9:;! :1! B;B9@396! I=>9K,16! :1!-;679!_4B9F!B;3;B4:;!B;>;!,;6!e_;K;76fF!Y=1!=6=9,>1371! 6;3! D106;396! AR51316! B;3!:1D13:13B49! 9,! B09Bk! ?! Y=1! 01B4K13! B41079!B9374:9:!:1!1679!>46>9!6=6793B49!B;>;!D98;!D;0! 6=! 51379#! E;6! e_;K;76f! 6;3! ,;6! Y=1! 61!1VD;313! >T6! 9! ,9! 54;,13B49! :1,! >10B9:;!4,@B47;!?!:1,!.679:;!M-;07S6F!%$()N#!!
Poblaciones específicas !
Mujeres L=3Y=1! ,9! >9?;0@9! :1! ,96! D106;396!13B90B1,9:96! D;0! :0;896! 6;3! C;>K016F! 1,!13B90B1,9>4137;! 813109! 4>D9B7;6!:4I1013B49,16! ?! :16D0;D;0B4;39:;6! 6;K01! ,96!>=A1016! MJHELF! P/\-F! /1A=674B49! d! -PcF!%$(&N#! E9! D;64B4R3! :1! 5=,3109K4,4:9:!1B;3R>4B9! ?! I9>4,490! Y=1! ,96! >=A1016!13I013793! 13! ,9! 6;B41:9:! 61! 9809593! B;3! ,9!
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bF!01B4K13!613713B496!:1!>=BC;6!9X;6!:1! D0464R3#! h439,>1371F! 1V46713! 4>D9B7;6! :1!8S310;!Y=1!741313!Y=1!6;D;0790!:1370;!:1!,9!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!")! eE;6! 34X;6F! 34X96! ?! 9:;,16B13716! Y=1! 741313! 9! 6=6!D9:016! ;! >9:016! 13B90B1,9:;6! D=1:13! 13I013790!647=9B4;316! 64>4,9016! :1! 5=,3109K4,4:9:[! 3;! ;K679371F!C9?!=39!B9374:9:!4>D;079371!:1!,471097=09!Y=1!:1679B9!9,8=3;6!96D1B7;6!16D1B@I4B;6!B=93:;!16!,9!>9:01!Y=413!167T! D0169#! .,! 709K9A;! D=K,4B9:;! D;0! -,9=:49! W71,,9!M%$$+NF! 7=5;! B;>;! 6=A17;6! D0454,1849:;6! :1! 6=!01,159>4137;!9! ,;6!C4A;6!:1!D01696F!13!1,!13713:4:;!:1!Y=1!1V4671!=3!B;3:4B4;39>4137;!C467R04B;!D;0!1,!B=9,!1,!B=4:9:;! :1! ,;6! 34X;6! 641>D01! 167=5;! 9! B908;! :1! ,9!>=A10#! L39,4U93:;! :97;6! :1! B136;6! D134713B4904;6F!61X9,9! Y=1! ,;6! :97;6! 1679:@674B;6! :1! ,9! ,471097=09!4371039B4;39,!>=167093!Y=1!B=93:;!1,!D9:01!167T!D016;!,9!>9?;0@9!:1!,;6!34X;6!B;3743293!6413:;!B=4:9:;6!D;0!6=6! >9:016F! 643! 1>K908;F! B=93:;! 61! 70979! :1! =3!13B90B1,9>4137;! >97103;F! 9D1396! 1,! ($! m! Y=1:9! 9!B908;!:1!6=6!D9:016f!MW9951:09!!"#$%&!%$(gF!D#!"gN#!!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES 47
![Page 52: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
BT0B1,! 13! 1,! >90B;! :1! =3! 64671>9!D134713B4904;!:461X9:;!D909!,;6!C;>K016F!96@!B;>;! ,;! Y=1! 741313! Y=1! 6=I040! B=93:;!01B=D1093! 6=! ,4K1079:F! D=16! ,96! :4I4B=,79:16!D909!13B;37090!=3!1>D,1;!:1B1371!710>4393!D;0! D10D17=90! 1,! B@0B=,;! 54B4;6;! :1! D;K01U9F!543B=,9B4R3! 9! >10B9:;6! :1! :0;896! ?!13B90B1,9>4137;#!!
!
!
P3B,=6;! B=93:;! 6=6! I9>4,49016! 6;3!13B90B1,9:;6F! ,96!>=A1016!741313!Y=1!96=>40!590496! 016D;369K4,4:9:16! 13! 6=! B=4:9:;! Y=1!01D10B=713!13! 6=6!54:96F! ,;! B=9,! B;3541071! ,9!693B4R3! D139,! 13! =3! B96748;! 3;! 6R,;! B;3709!,;6! 43:454:=;6F! 643;! B;3709! ,96! I9>4,496! ?F! 13!D9074B=,90F!B;3709!,96!>9:016F!C4A96!?!16D;696!:1!,;6!437103;6!M\S01U!-;0019F!%$()N#!L371!,96!B9013B496!:1! ,;6!64671>96!D134713B4904;6F!6;3!1,,96!Y=41316!>93741313!9! ,;6!?! ,96! 43710396F!Y=41316!,96!5464793!590496!51B16!D;0!61>939!?!Y=41316!,96!543B=,93!B;3!1,!1V7104;0#!O9>K4S3!:1K13!96=>40!,;6!B;67;6!:1!6=!:1I1369!,189,F!D=16! 13! 64671>96! D134713B4904;6! B;00=D7;6!709K9A93!D909!D9890!,;6!6;K;03;6F!?!D909!Y=1!6=6! I9>4,49016! D=1:93! 9BB1:10! 9! K41316!KT64B;6!B;>;!98=9F!B;>4:9!;!>1:4B9>137;6#!L:1>T6F! 1,! 16748>9! Y=1! 813109! 1,!13B90B1,9>4137;! :1! =3! I9>4,490! 4>D,4B9! =39!9I1B79B4R3! 31897459! 9! 6=6! 01,9B4;316!
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
E9! D;K,9B4R3! I1>13439! Y=1! 61! 13B=13709! 13!D0464R3!13!,;6!D9@616!:1!L>S04B9!C9!B01B4:;!>T6!0TD4:;! Y=1! ,9! :1! C;>K016#! \10;! :1370;! :1! ,9!D;K,9B4R3! B90B1,9049! I1>13439F! ,9! 01B,=4:9! D;0!:1,47;6! :1! :0;896! C9! B01B4:;! 9! =3! 047>;! >T6!0TD4:;!13!,9!>9?;0@9!:1!,;6!D9@616#!.3!L08137439!?! b;,4549F! D;0! 1A1>D,;F! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! I1>13439!D0459:9! :1! ,9! ,4K1079:! D;0! :0;896! C9! B01B4:;!D;0B137=9,>1371!>T6! 0TD4:;!Y=1! ,9!>96B=,439!01B,=4:9!D;0!167;6!:1,47;6#!E;6!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!6;3F! 13! 7;:;6! ,;6! D9@616! 167=:49:;6F! B;3!1VB1DB4R3! :1! cSV4B;F! ,9! D043B4D9,! B9=69! :1!13B90B1,9>4137;! I1>1343;G!>4137096! Y=1! D909!,9! D;K,9B4R3! 13! 813109,! ,;6! D016;6! D;0! :0;896!01D01613793! 13701! 'm! ?! "$m! :1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3!B90B1,9049F! ,96! >=A1016! D0459:96! :1! ,9! ,4K1079:!D;0!:0;896!01D01613793!13701!%gm!?!'$m!:1! ,9!D;K,9B4R3! I1>13439! 13B90B1,9:9#! .3! b0964,F!-;679!_4B9F!\102!?!L08137439!M9!3451,!I1:109,N!,96!>=A1016! D01696! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896!01D01613793! >T6! :1,! &$m! :1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3!I1>13439F! >4137096! Y=1F! 9! 3451,! 8,;K9,F! 61823!,96! 1674>9B4;316! :1! ^QH/-F! 6R,;! (%m! :1! ,96!>=A1016! 13! D0464R3! ,;! 167T3! D;0! :1,47;6! :1!:0;896! M^QH/-! b;,4549F! %$(&N#! .67;! 64834I4B9!Y=1! 13! 167;6! D9@616! ,9! D9074B4D9B4R3! :1! ,96!>=A1016! 13B90B1,9:96! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896!6=D109!13701!B43B;!?!6146!51B16!,9!>1:49!8,;K9,#!
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES48
Fotografía: César Acuña. Prisión en Ecuador.
![Page 53: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES 49
Número de encarcelados
por drogas (hombres y mujeres)
% encarcelados por drogas en relación
al total
% Aumento población
en prisión por drogas
Número de mujeres
encarceladas por delitos de drogas
% Mujeres encarceladas por
drogas en relación al total de mujeres
% Aumento población carcelaria
de mujeres por drogas36
ARG37 6,979 (2013) 10.88%
113.35% (2002/2013)
51338 (dic/2012)
65%39 (dic/2012)
271%(1989/2008)
BOL40 3,939 (2013) 27.32%
- 17%(2000/2013) 82741 48%42 114.38%
(2003/2013)
BRA43 146,276 (jun/2013)
25.94% (jun/2013)
344.87%(2005/2013)
289.2%(2000/2015)
16,489 (jun/2013)
60.63% (jun/2013)
290% (2005/2013)
COL44 23,141 (2014)
21% (2014)
-
- -
-
3,830(2014)
45%(2014)
211% (2000/2014)
CR45 4,645 (dic/2011)
26.4% (dic/2011)
225.52% (2006/2011)
944 (dic/2011)
75.46%(dic/2011)
189.18% (2006/2011)
MEX47 26,098(2013)
10% (2013)
19% (2011/2013)
Federales1,547(2014)Locales
528 (2013)
44.8%(ago/2014)
14.2%(mayo/2013)
ND
2.3%(2011/2013)
ECU46 4,156(2015)
17% (2015) 709 43%
50%(2008/2014)
35% (2008/2014)PER48 19,329
(jul/2014)27%
(jul/2014)2,679
(jul/2014)60.6%
(jul/2014)
URU49 1,265(2013)
12.9%(2013) 205
24%(2013)
36El aumento se calcula sobre el número absoluto de mujeres encarceladas.37SNEEP, Informe anual de la República Argentina. Estos datos son de las cárceles federales.38www.oas.org/es/cim/docs/WomenDrugsAmericas-ES.pdf>, cálculo hecho con datos de la p. 34.39Idem.40Instituto Nacional de Estadística (INE)41http://www.oas.org/es/cim/docs/WomenDrugsAmericas-ES.pdf42Idem.43DEPEN, Departamento Penitenciario Nacional, Brasil.44Instituto Nacional Penitenciario y Carcelario – INPEC. Diciembre de 2014.45Cálculo hecho a partir de los datos del Observatorio de la Violencia del Ministerio de Justicia y Paz http://sisvi.mj.go.cr/-SISVI/46Ministerio de Justicia del Ecuador.47Conforme a los datos del Censo Nacional de Gobierno, Seguridad Pública y Sistemas Penitenciarios Estatales, a diciembre de 2014, 252mil personas estaban privadas de la libertad por delitos del fuero común (239,667 hombres –el 95.1%- y 12,233 mujeres –el 4.8%-), de las cuales 11,488 (4.5%) lo estaban por narcomenudeo (10,614 hombres –el 92.3%- y 874 mujeres –el 7.6%-). En el fuero federal había privadas de la libertad 35,679 personas (33,000 hombres –el 92.4%- y 2,679 mujeres -el 7.5%-), de las cuales 13,794 (38.6%) lo estaban por delitos contra la salud (12,581 hombres –el 91.2%- y 1,213 mujeres –el 8.7%-). Esto quiere decir que 25,282 personas estaban presas por delitos de drogas (8.7% del total). De ellas 2,087 eran mujeres (el 8.2% del total). Sin embargo las mujeres detenidas por drogas representaban el 13.9% de las mujeres encarceladas (aunque en el fuero federal representaban el 45% del total y en el común el 7%). Disponible en: http://www.inegi.org.mx/lib/olap/consulta/general_ver4/MDXQueryDatos.asp?c=. 48INPEC, Informe Estadístico (Julio 2014).49Informes de Actuación y Evaluación del Sistema Penitenciario Nacional. Poder Legislativo. Comisionado Parlamentario.
Fuente: Botieux (2015, p.3).
Cuadro 3. Indicadores de encarcelamiento femenino por delitos de drogas en los nueve países estudiados de América Latina.
![Page 54: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
!!!E96! >=A1016! 13B90B1,9:96! D;0! :1,47;6! :1!:0;896! 6;3! I01B=1371>1371! :17134:96! D;0!019,4U90! 790196! :1! K9A;! 3451,F! D10;! :1! 9,7;!04168;F!B;>;G!!
• W10540! :1! D;079:;096! D909! 1,! 70TI4B;!4371039B4;39,F! 437103;F! ;! D909! 43801690!:0;896!9!,96!BT0B1,16#!
• W10! 513:1:;096! 13! D1Y=1X9! 16B9,9F!B=,7459:;096F!;!D0;B169:;096#!
• _19,4U90! ,9K;016! :1! 9D;?;! :;>S674B;F!B;>;! ,9! D01D909B4R3! :1! 9,4>137;6! ;! ,9!,4>D41U9! D909! 80=D;6! :1! :1,43B=13B49!;08934U9:9#!
• h=3840! B;>;! ;D1090496! :1! ;709! B,961! :1!790196! :1! K9A;! 3451,! 79,16! B;>;!9,>9B139>4137;! :1! 6=6793B496! 4,@B4796F!70936>464R3! :1! 43I;0>9B4R3! ;! I=3B4;316!:1!43710>1:49B4R3#!
• W10! =6=90496! :1! :0;896! Y=1! D;0793!D1Y=1X96! B9374:9:16! :1! 6=6793B496!4,@B4796F! 9!D1690!:1!Y=1!13! ,9!>9?;0@9!:1!,;6! D9@616! :1! ,9! 0184R3! 1,! =6;! 3;! 167T!D139,4U9:;!MJHEL!!"#$%&!%$(&N#!!!
c=BC96!:1!16796!>=A1016!B01B13!13!137;03;6!D0;D4B4;6! D909! 1,! 435;,=B09>4137;! 13!9B7454:9:16! 4,@B4796! ?! 3;! B=13793! B;3! ,;6!>1:4;6! ;! 1,! B9D479,! 6;B49,! D909! 8131090!9,7103974596#!L371!1679!647=9B4R3F!,96!01:16!:1!70TI4B;! C93! ;D79:;! D;0! 6=6747=40F! :1! I;0>9!B01B41371F! 9! Y=41316! B913! B9D7=09:;6!:16900;,,93:;! 9B7454:9:16! :1! K9A;! 3451,! D;0!>=A1016!13!647=9B4R3!:1!31B164:9:F!,;!B=9,!C9!,,159:;! 9! C9K,90! :1! =39! I1>434U9B4R3! :1! ,;6!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!Y=1!713:0@9!01,9B4R3!:401B79!B;3! ,9!I1>434U9B4R3!?! ,9!B04>439,4U9B4R3!:1! ,9!D;K01U9! M-94B1:;F! %$()N#! .,! >T6! 01B41371!167=:4;! :1! JHELF! P/\-F! /1A=674B49! d! -Pc!M%$(&N!9I40>9!Y=1!>=BC96!:1!,96!>=A1016!!
435;,=B09:96!13!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!01B;3;B13!C9K1061!435;,=B09:;!D;0!6=!D0;D49!5;,=379:!?!610! B;36B413716! :1! ,;6! 04168;6! Y=1! 1679K93!B;00413:;#! W43! 1>K908;F! B;3! 01,97459!I01B=13B49F! 61! D0161379! ,9! B;9BB4R3! :1!1V709X;6F! :1! ,9! D901A9! ;! :1! =3! I9>4,490! D909!435;,=B09061F! D;0! ,;! Y=1! 1,! 43I;0>1! 79>K4S3!9D=379! 9! Y=1! 9,8=396! :1! 16796! >=A1016!I=10;3!1389X9:96F!?!3;!713@93!B;3;B4>4137;!:1! ,;! Y=1! 1679K93! C9B413:;! ;! :16B;3;B@93!,;6! 04168;6! Y=1! 1679K93! 7;>93:;#! P3B,=6;F!9,8=396! >934I416793! C9K10! 01B4K4:;!9>139U96! D;0! >41>K0;6! :1! ,96!;08934U9B4;316! B04>439,16F! D909! ;K,4890,96! 9!019,4U90! ,9! B;3:=B79! D;0! ,9! Y=1! I=10;3!693B4;39:96#! .67;6! I9B7;016F! 3;! 6=1,13! 610!7134:;6! 13! B=1379! 9,! :4B790! 613713B49F! ,96!B=9,16! 016=,793! 1VB16459>1371! ,90896! ?!:16D0;D;0B4;39:96! MJHEL!!"# $%&! %$(&F! D#! 'Z("N#!!
.3! 5904;6! D9@616F! 9:1>T6F! ,96! >=A1016!D107131B413716! 9! D=1K,;6! 43:@81396! ?!>43;0@96!S734B96!741313!>T6!D0;K9K4,4:9:16!:1!610!:17134:96F!D0;B169:96!?!B;3:139:96!D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896#! \;0! 1A1>D,;F! 13!.679:;6! ^34:;6F! ,96! >=A1016! 9I0;9Z>104B9396! 741313! 64171! 51B16! >T6!D0;K9K4,4:9:16!:1!610!13B90B1,9:96!Y=1!,96!>=A1016! K,93B96! M}136?F! W71381,F! Q;=8410F!d!b40843F!%$(%N#!\;0!16796!?!;7096!09U;316!16!Y=1! 61!C9! 61X9,9:;!Y=1! ,9! 8=1009! B;3709! ,96!:0;896! 16! 79>K4S3! =39! 8=1009! B;3709! ,96!>=A1016!M-C1631?ZE43:F!%$$"N#!-;>;!6=B1:1!D909!,;6!C;>K016F!,96!:46B04>439B4;316!Y=1!13I013793! 13! ,9! 54:9! 6;B49,! 61! 7096,9:93! ?!1V9B10K93!13!,9!BT0B1,#!!
.3!D026<);<3F! B;3! ,9! 13709:9!13! 54813B49!:1!,9!E1?!%"#*"*!,9!D;K,9B4R3!I1>13439!:17134:9!
50 CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES
![Page 55: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! B01B4R! 9! =3! 047>;!>=BC;!>T6!9B1,109:;!Y=1!13!1,! B96;!:1! ,;6!C;>K016F! 7937;! 13! 1,! 64671>9! I1:109,! B;>;!13! ,9! D0;543B49! :1! b=13;6! L4016#! .3701! 1,!D10@;:;! (+'+Z%$$'F! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! I1>13439!01B,=4:9! D;0! 167;6! :1,47;6! 13! 1,! 64671>9!I1:109,! 9=>137R! %*(mF! >4137096! Y=1! ,9! :1!C;>K016! B01B4R! ((%m#! Q=151! :1! B9:9! ($!1V7093A1096! 13B90B1,9:96! D;0! :1,47;6! :1!:0;896! 13! D0464;316! I1:109,16! ,;! I=10;3! D;0!610! eB;001;6! C=>93;6f[! :1! 1,,96F! 1,! +&m!B;>17410;3! =39! B;3:=B79! :1,4B7459! D;0!D04>109! 51U! ?! B964! 7;:96! 167T3! 13! 1,! 2,74>;!16,9KR3!:1!,9!B9:139!:1,!390B;70TI4B;!M-1370;!:1! .67=:4;6! E189,16! ?! W;B49,16F! %$((N#! .3701!%$$)! ?! %$(%F! 1,! 32>10;! :1! >=A1016!13B90B1,9:96!13!,9!\0;543B49!:1!b=13;6!L4016!D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! B964! 61! :=D,4BRF!D9693:;! :1! &$$! 9! (F(*+#! -;3! ,9!4>D,1>1379B4R3!:1!,9!(!6:!(!1$%)3$*)+,!13!,9!D1061B=B4R3!D139,!:1!,;6!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!13!%$("F! 1,! D;0B1379A1! :1! >=A1016! D01696! D;0!167;6! :1,47;6! B01B4R! 0TD4:9>1371! 13! 590496!D0;543B496!B;>;!-R0:;K9!M%+mN!?!W9,79!M*'mN!13701! %$(%! ?! %$("! M-;0:9F! %$(&N#! .3! =39!13B=1679! 019,4U9:9! 9! >=A1016! Y=1! 61!13B=137093! 13!D0464R3!D;0! :1,47;6! :1!:0;896!13!:46743796!D90716!:1,! D9@6! 61! 13B;370R!Y=1!*'m! 1093! >9:016! ?! )'#)m! 3;! B;3545@9! B;3!=39!D901A9!93716!:1!,9!:1713B4R3#!.,!'$#)m!:1!,96! >=A1016! 13B=1679:96! 9I40>R! 610! 1,!D043B4D9,! 6=67137;! :1! 6=! C;890! M\0;B=09B4R3!\134713B49049! :1! ,9! Q9B4R3F! %$(gF! DD#! "%(Z"%'N#! L:4B4;39,>1371F! 5904;6! 167=:4;6! C93!:;B=>1379:;! 54;,9B4;316! 9! ,;6! :101BC;6!C=>93;6! :1! ,96! >=A1016! 13B90B1,9:96! ?! 1,!9=>137;! :1! ,96! B;3:4B4;316! :1!5=,3109K4,4:9:! :1! 6=6! 9,,189:;6! M-1370;! :1!.67=:4;6! E189,16! ?! W;B49,16F! %$(([! -;>47S!
B;3709! ,9! O;07=09! :1! ,9! -;>464R3! \0;543B49,!D;0!,9!c1>;049F!%$("F!D#!('"N#!!
!
!
.3!T034;:F!,96!>=A1016!13!D0464R3!D;0!:1,47;6!:1! :0;896! 3;! ;B=D93! D;64B4;316! :1! 9,7;!3451,!13!1,!>10B9:;!4,@B47;#!-10B9!:1!))m!:1!1,,96! 6;3! 9I0;:16B13:413716F! =3! )*m! 6;3!6;,71096! ?! )$m! 74131! >13;6! :1! %+! 9X;6#!-=93:;! 6;3! 13B90B1,9:96F! 9:1>T6! :1! 610!9K93:;39:96! D;0! 6=6! B;>D9X10;6F! 6;3!9,1A9:96!:1!6=6!C4A;6F! ,;6!B=9,16!13!6=!8093!>9?;0@9!D9693!9!610!B049:;6!D;0!9K=1,;6!;!7@96! MB=93:;! 3;! 6;3! 13549:;6! D909!9:;DB4R3N#! E96! >=A1016! 1>K909U9:96! 13!D0464R3!C93!7134:;!Y=1!6;D;0790!647=9B4;316!B;>;!610!16D;69:96!13!1,!D907;F!;!:90!9!,=U!13! =3! I=08R3! D;,4B49,! ;! 13! ,9! D0464R3!MB=93:;!1,!70936D;071!3;!,,189!9!741>D;N#!.,!D10I4,! :1! ,96! >=A1016! 13! 647=9B4R3! :1!>971034:9:! 13! ,9! D0464R3! 43:4B9! Y=1! *'m!6;3! AR51316! 13701! ('! ?! %%! 9X;6F! **m! 6;3!>=A1016! 318096F! *)#&m! 3;! D;6113! ,9!1361X93U9! D04>9049! B;>D,179F! ?! +#'m!:1B,90R! 3;! 69K10! ,110! 34! 16B04K40#! E9!>479:!>93713@93! 1>D,1;6! D01B904;6! M')m! 643! =3!:;B=>137;! ;I4B49,N! ?! ,9! >9?;0@9! 109!016D;369K,1! :1,! 6;67134>4137;! :1,! C;890#!.,!*$m!C9K@9!B;>174:;!D;0!D04>109!51U!=3!
51CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES
Fotografía: César Acuña. Prisión de Máxima seguridad en Latacunga, Ecuador.
![Page 56: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
:1,47;#! E9! 8093! >9?;0@9! C9K@9! 64:;!B;3:139:9! 9! D1396! 13701! B43B;! ?! 3=151!9X;6! Mgg#gmN[! ?! ""#"m! :1! ,;6! B96;6!01B4K410;3!D1396!:1!>13;6!:1!B=970;!9X;6!Mb;471=V!!"#$%&!%$(&N#!!
.3! T1:;V;3! =3! 43I;0>1! :1! ,9! h=3:9B4R3!-;3670=40F! K969:;! 13! =39! >=16709! :1!>=A1016!13B90B1,9:96! 61X9,9!Y=1F!13!B=937;!9,! 1679:;! B454,F! )$m! :1! ,96! >=A1016! 545@9! 13!=34R3! B;3?=89,F! 643! 1>K908;F! 6=6! D901A96!I=10;3! 9,1AT3:;61! B;3! 1,! 13B90B1,9>4137;[!6R,;!"&#'!m!C9K@93!B;3B,=4:;!1,!K9BC4,,1097;[!"'m! :1! ,96! >=A1016! D0;513@93! :1! C;89016!:46I=3B4;39,16!;!I=10;3!9K93:;39:96!D;0!6=6!I9>4,49016#! W1! 70979F! 13! 6=! >9?;0@9F! :1!>=A1016!D;K016!Y=1!K=6B93!6;K0154540!13!,;6!D139,16!?!>9371310!9!6=!I9>4,49#!\10;!13!,;6!01B437;6! D134713B4904;6! 1,! 7097;! Y=1! 01B4K13!16! :46B04>4397;04;! ?! 6R,;! B=13793! B;3! =39!B1,:9! 64! 741313! :4310;! D909! D9890,9!Mh=3:9B4R3!-;3670=40F!%$(gN. !
.3! A1:1?9;3F! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! I1>13439! 13!BT0B1,16! :16:1! (++(! C9679! 1,! %$()! 61!>=,74D,4BR! D;0! B43B;F! >4137096! Y=1! ,9!>96B=,439! B964! Y=1! 61! 704D,4BR#! -964! B43B;! :1!B9:9! :41U! >=A1016! 13! D0464R3! ,;! 167T! D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896#!/1!16796F! 6R,;!=39! ,;!167T!D;0!C9K10!B;>174:;!=39!B;3:=B79!54;,1379!;!D;0! D107131B10! 9! =39! ;08934U9B4R3! B04>439,#!/1,! 7;79,! :1! >=A1016! Y=1! 43801690;3! 9! ,96!BT0B1,16! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! 13701! %$($! ?!%$(gF! +"m! 713@9! C4A;6F! >4137096! Y=1F! 13! 1,!B96;! :1! ,;6! C;>K016F! ,;6! Y=1! 713@93! C4A;6!01D0161379K93! 1,! *&m! :1,! 7;79,#! .,! 80=D;!>9?;047904;!:1!438016;6!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!D909! 1,! B96;! :1! ,96! >=A1016! 13701! %$((! ?!%$(g! I=1! 1,! :1!>9:016! 6;,71096! Mg"! :1! B9:9!($$NF!>4137096! Y=1! D909! ,;6! C;>K016! I=1! ,9!=34R3! ,4K01! Mg(!:1!B9:9!($$N#!\909!1,!)%#'!m!
:1! ,96! >=A1016! M:45;0B49:96F! 61D909:96F!6;,71096! ?! 54=:96N! Y=1! 43801690;3! D;0! 167;6!:1,47;6F! 1,! 13B90B1,9>4137;! 61! :4;! 13!B40B=36793B496! 13! ,96! Y=1! 3;! B;379K93! B;3!=3]9! B;>D9X10;]9! :1,! 32B,1;! I9>4,490! Y=1!,96! 9D;?909! 13! 1,! B=4:9:;! :1! 6=6! C4A;6[!>4137096!Y=1!D909! ,;6!C;>K016!167;!;B=004R!13! 1,! %*#%! m! :1! ,;6! B96;6#! .V46713! 6168;6!4>D,@B47;6!13!,9!D1061B=B4R3!D139,!D;0!:1,47;6!:1! :0;896! B;3709! ,96!>=A1016! Y=1! 7413:13! 9!980959061! B;3! 1,! 741>D;G! 64! K413! 1,,96! 6R,;!C93! 1679:;! 435;,=B09:96! 13! 9,01:1:;0! :1,!($m!:1!,96!3;74B496!B04>439,16!Y=1!,,1890;3!9,!64671>9! D139,! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! 13701!%$$'! ?! %$()F! :=09371! 1671! >46>;! D10@;:;F!13701! 1,! (gm! ?! 1,! %%m! :1! ,96! 613713B496!B;3:1397;0496! D;0! 167;6! :1,47;6! 61!D0;I40410;3!B;3709!>=A1016#!.3701!1,!%$$$!?!1,!%$(gF! 1,! .679:;! B;,;>K493;! 8967R! g$$! >4,!>4,,;316! :1! D16;6! D909! >9371310! 9! 16796!>=A1016!13!D0464R3F!16!:1B40F!(g$!>4,,;316!:1!:R,9016! 13! %$(g! M^D04>3?F! c907@31UF! -0=UF!-C9D900;F!d!-C9D900;F!%$(&KN#!!
.3! A14)3! ";73F! ,;6! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! 6;3! ,9!D043B4D9,! B9=69! :1! 13B90B1,9>4137;!I1>1343;#! W1823! ,;6! :97;6! :1,! W4671>9! :1!P3I;0>9B4R3! 13! o4;,13B49! MWPWoPN! :1,!HK610597;04;! :1! ,9! o4;,13B49! :1,! c43467104;!:1! `=674B49! ?! \9UF! D909! 1,! %$((! 1,,96!01D0161379K93!=3!*)#)m!:1,!7;79,!:1!>=A1016!Y=1! 61! 13B;3709K93! D0459:96! :1! ,9! ,4K1079:#!\10;! 61823! 43I;0>9B4R3! >T6! 01B41371F!01D;079:9! 79>K4S3! D;0! 1,! c43467104;! :1!`=674B49! ?! \9UF! ,96! >=A1016! 01B,=4:96! D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!01D0161379K93!13!%$(g!=3!)"#'m!:1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! I1>13439!D0169! 13!1,!0S84>13! 436747=B4;39,! M16! :1B40F! 13!1679K,1B4>4137;6! B90B1,904;6N#! ! .679!:46>43=B4R3! 13! 7S0>43;6! 01,9745;6! D=1:1!71310! Y=1! 510! B;3! ,9! B;>D909B4R3! 13701!
52 CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES
![Page 57: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
018@>1316! M436747=B4;39,F! 61>4Z436747=B4;39,F!13701! ;70;6N! D10;! 79>K4S3! D;0! ,9! D0;8016459!43B;0D;09B4R3!:1!=3!13I;Y=1!:1!8S310;!13!,9!D;,@74B9! B04>439,! ?! D134713B49049! 13! 1,! 71>9!:1!:0;896! M-;07S6F!%$(&N#! .3!1,! 9X;!%$(%F! ,9!/1I1369! \2K,4B9! 019,4UR! =3! 167=:4;! Y=1!>;6709K9! Y=1! &)m! :1! ,96! >=A1016!13B90B1,9:96!1679K93!613713B49:96!D;0!,9!E1?!:1! \64B;70RD4B;6! ?! :1! S6796! =3! %"#)m! C9K@9!64:;!613713B49:9!D;0! 4370;:=BB4R3!:1!:0;896!9!B1370;6!D139,16[!9:1>T6F!1,!)$m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`=U89:;!:1!.A1B=B4R3!:1!,96!\1396F!I=10;3! 13B90B1,9:96! >T6! :1! ()$! >=A1016!B;3:139:96! D;0! 1671! :1,47;F! Y=41316! 61!K131I4B490;3! :1! ,9! D;64K4,4:9:! :1! 01B4K40!D1396!9,7103974596!13!9D,4B9B4R3!:1,!D043B4D4;!:1!,9!,1?!>T6!I95;09K,1!M-;07S6F!%$(&N#!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)$!.67;6!B047104;6!43:4B93!Y=1!,9!>=A10G!9N!W1!13B=13709!13! B;3:4B4R3! :1! D;K01U9[! KN! .6! A1I9! :1! C;890! 13!B;3:4B4R3! :1! 5=,3109K4,4:9:[! BN! O4131! K9A;! 6=! B908;!D106;396! >13;016! :1! 1:9:F! 9:=,796! >9?;016! ;!D106;396! B;3! B=9,Y=410! 74D;! :1! :46B9D9B4:9:! Y=1!9>10479! ,9! :1D13:13B49! :1! ,9! D106;39! Y=1! 74131! 9! 6=!B908;[! ?];! :N! .6! =39! D106;39! 9:=,79! >9?;0! 13!B;3:4B4;316!:1!5=,3109K4,4:9:#!!
W43! 1>K908;F! 9! D1690! :1! ,;6! 9593B16F! ,96!>=A1016! :1! 9Y=1,! D9@6! 648=13! 6413:;!B;3:139:96! D;0! ;709! B,961! :1! :1,47;6! :1!:0;896!13!D0;D;0B4;316!>9?;016!9,!D0;>1:4;!:1!6=!D9074B4D9B4R3!13!;70;6!:1,47;6#!.3!%$((F!'"#&m!:1!,96!>=A1016!Y=1!61!13B;3709K93!13!D0464R3! I=10;3! 613713B49:96! D;0! :1,47;6! :1!:0;896! :467437;6! 9! ,9! 4370;:=BB4R3! :1! :0;896!13! B1370;6! D134713B4904;6#! .3701! ,96!>=A1016!13! D0464R3! D;0! 167;6! :1,47;6F! g&m! 713@9!>T6!:1!B=901379!9X;6F!>4137096!Y=1!,;6!C;>K016!13B90B1,9:;6! Y=1! 6=D109K93! 1679! 1:9:!01D0161379K93! 1,! "+m! :1,! 7;79,F! ,;! B=9,!D,93719!Y=1!13!1,!B96;!I1>1343;!61!7413:1!9!13B90B1,90!>T6!9!,96!>=A1016!:1!>9?;0!1:9:F!?!13! ,;6!C;>K016!9! ,;6!>T6! AR51316! M-;0716F!%$(&N#! .,! 93T,4646! :1! =39! >=16709! :1!1VD1:413716! B;3:1397;04;6! :1! 64171!D0;543B496! :1,! D9@6F! 13! 6=! >9?;0@9!D;67104;016! 9,! %$$'F! 0974I4B9! 16796!B;3B,=64;316! ?! D,93719! Y=1! C9?! =39!:4I1013B49! 13! 1,! 74D;! :1! ;B=D9B4;316! :1! ,96!D106;396! Y=1! 61! 435;,=B093! 13! 16796!9B7454:9:16F!9=3Y=1!13!9>K;6!B96;6!61!70979!:1!709K9A;6!D01B904;6!1!431679K,16G!)"m!:1!,96!>=A1016! 6;3! 9>96! :1! B969! ?! (*m!B;>10B493716F! 13! 7937;! Y=1! 13701! ,;6!C;>K016! =3! ('m! 16! B;>10B49371F! 618=4:;!D;0! :161>D,19:;6! ?! B;3670=BB4R3! M(%m!9>K;6N#!H7096!;B=D9B4;316!01846709:96!13!,;6!1VD1:413716! :1! ,96! >=A1016! 6;3! 1674,46796F!B;B43109F! 1>D,19:9! ?! 13I10>109! M-;07S6F!%$(&N#! .67;! D,93719! ,9! 31B164:9:! :1!B;364:1090! 9,7103974596! 9,! 13B90B1,9>4137;!D;0! B;3:=B796! :46743796! 9! ,9! 4370;:=BB4R3! :1!:0;896! 13! B1370;6! D134713B4904;6F! D=16!79>K4S3!61!70979!:1!>=A1016! M?!C;>K016N!13!D;64B4;316! :1! 5=,3109K4,4:9:F! B=?;!13B90B1,9>4137;! D;B;! B;3704K=?1! 9,!
53CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES
![Page 58: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
:16>;371! :1! ,96! ;08934U9B4;316! :1,! 390B;Z70TI4B;#!!
.3! &EX;71F! :1! 9B=10:;! B;3! ,9! \04>109!
.3B=1679! 9! \;K,9B4R3! P371039! 13! -1370;6!h1:109,16! :1! _19:9D79B4R3! W;B49,# M\S01U!-;0019! d! LU9;,9F! %$(%A&# :1! ,96! >=A1016! 13!01B,=64R3F!''m!741313!C4A;6F!>4137096!Y=1!13!1,! B96;!:1! ,;6!C;>K016! ,;6! 74131!*'m!:1! ,;6!13B=1679:;6#! W;K01! ,9! 1:9:! :1! D0;B019B4R3F!&)m!:1! ,96!>=A1016!:4A;!Y=1! 7=5;! 6=!D04>10!C4A;!13701!,;6!()!?!,;6!(+!9X;6#!.3!B;3709671F!13!,9!D;K,9B4R3!>96B=,439F!,9!1:9:!:1,!D04>10!C4A;!61!B;3B13709!13701! ,;6!(*!?! ,;6!%"!9X;6#!/1!,9!>46>9!>93109F!,9!13B=1679!>;670R!Y=1!,96! >=A1016! 13! D0464R3! 741313! =3! >13;0!D0;>1:4;! :1! 16B;,904:9:! Y=1! ,;6! C;>K016#!L64>46>;F! e,96! >=A1016! 13! D0464R3! 13!813109,F! ?! ,96! >=A1016! 13B90B1,9:96! D;0!:1,47;6! :1! :0;896! 13! D9074B=,90F! 6=1,13!B;>D90740! ,96! 648=413716! B909B710@674B96G! 6;3!D;K016F! D0;B1:13716! :1! C;89016! ?!B;>=34:9:16! >908439:96F! B;3! K9A;6! 3451,16!1:=B9745;6!?!643!9371B1:13716!D139,16#!L3716!:1! :161>D1X90! I=3B4;316! 543B=,9:96! B;3!:0;896! 4,@B4796F! ,9! >9?;0@9! C9! 709K9A9:;! 13!3=>10;696! 9B7454:9:16! 43I;0>9,16F! B;>;!,4>D41U9! :1! B9696F! ,959:;! ?! D,93BC9:;! :1!0;D9F! 1,9K;09B4R3! :1! 9,4>137;6F! 51379!43I;0>9,!13!61>TI;0;6F!17B#!É!9,8=396!741313!=39!C467;049!:1!54:9!>90B9:9!D;0!,9!54;,13B49F!43B,=?13:;! ,9! :1! 74D;! 61V=9,f! Ma49B;>1,,;!d!b,96F!%$(&F!D#!%N#!
.3!G60HF!6146!:1!B9:9!:41U!>=A1016!13!D0464R3!C93! B;>174:;! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896#! E9!D9074B4D9B4R3! :1! ,96!>=A1016! D10=9396! 13! ,9!43:=67049!:1!,96!:0;896!C9!9=>1379:;!?!167;!C9! 016=,79:;! 13! =3! >9?;0! 32>10;! :1!>=A1016!D0;B169:96!?!13B90B1,9:96!D;0!167;6!:1,47;6#!.,!K9A;!3451,!:1!1:=B9B4R3F!,9!D;K01U9!
?! ,9! 1VB,=64R3! 6;B49,! 6;3! ,;6! I9B7;016!D01:;>4393716! Y=1! B;3704K=?13! 9! 1671!I13R>13;#! .6796! >=A1016! 7413:13! 9! 71310!0;,16! >13;016! :1370;! :1! ,9! B9:139! :1!B;>10B49,4U9B4R3F! 7097T3:;61! I01B=1371Z>1371! :1! D;079:;096! ;! :1! 43710>1:490496!D909! ,9! B;>D09! ?! 51379! :1! :0;896! 4,@B4796#!.3701! %$$'! ?! %$("! 1,! 70TI4B;! D96R! :1!01D01613790!=3!"gm!9!=3!g+m!:1!,96!B9D7=096!D;,4B49,16! :1! >=A1016F! 618=4:9! :1,! B;36=>;!M%*mN! ?! ,=18;! ,9! >4B0;! B;>10B49,4U9B4R3!M%gmN#!.3!01,9B4R3!B;3!,96!>=A1016!D01696!D;0!:0;896F! 1,! g&m! 61! 13B;3709K9! D0459:9! :1! ,9!,4K1079:! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! 70TI4B;! 4,@B47;! ?! 6R,;!%*m!D;0!I;0>96!980959:96#!.3!\102!6;3!>T6!,96! >=A1016! 13! D0464R3! Y=1! 167T3! 643:4B9:96!Y=1!,96!Y=1!167T3!B;3:139:96!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896G! 13! 1,! %$$'! ,96! D04>1096!01D0161379K93!*%m!:1,!7;79,F!D;0B1379A1!Y=1!C9! B9@:;! 9! )gm! 13! %$("F! D10;! 648=1! 6413:;!1VB16459>1371!9,7;!Mc9381,43BkV!`#!F!%$(&N#!!
.3! %082835F! ,96! >=A1016! 741313! =39! >9?;0!D9074B4D9B4R3! 13! ,;6! >10B9:;6! :1! :0;896!96;B49:;6! B;3! B;371V7;6! :1! >9?;0!>908439,4:9:F! >4137096! Y=1F! 13701! ,96!D106;396! B;3:139:96!D;0! 70TI4B;!:1! B;B9@39!?!>904C=939F! 01D01613793! =39! Y=4379! ?! =39!710B109!D9071!016D1B7459>1371F!13!1,!B96;!:1,!70TI4B;! :1! D9679! K961F! B=970;! :1! B9:9! ($!B;3:1396! 6;3! B;3709! >=A1016#! .67;! 016=,79!D9074B=,90>1371! D01;B=D9371F! 713413:;! 13!B=1379!Y=1!:16:1!%$()!1,!\;:10!.A1B=745;!C9!4>D,1>1379:;! =39! 1670971849! D;,4B49,! :1!B;>K971!9!,96!K;B96!:1!51379!:1!D9679!K961F!B;>;! I;0>9! :1! >1A;090! ,;6! 3451,16! :1!618=04:9:#!.6!:1B40F!,9!D04;04:9:!61!=K4B9!13!,9!D1061B=B4R3! :1,! >4B0;70TI4B;! ?! 1,!390B;>13=:1;! 13! 1,! >10B9:;! :1! :0;896!4,189,16!>T6!D01B904;F!1,!:1! ,9!6=6793B49!>T6!K90979F! 13! :;3:1! ,9! D9074B4D9B4R3! :1! ,96!
54 CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES
![Page 59: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
>=A1016! 16! >9?;0! Mb90:9U93;! d! W9,9>93;F!%$(&N#!!!
Mujeres con hijos en prisión !
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b938k;k!9,413793!9! ,;6! .679:;6! 9! 4>D;310! 13! 1,! B96;! :1! ,;6!:1,47;6!3;!54;,137;6!34!809516F!e613713B496!3;!D045974596!:1! ,9! ,4K1079:!9! ,96!1>K909U9:96!?!,96! >=A1016! Y=1! 713893! 34X;6! 9! B908;f)(#!!L64>46>;F! 13! 6=! 43I;0>1! 6;K01! 1,! =6;! :1! ,9!D0464R3! D015137459! 13! L>S04B9F! ,9! -P/j!61X9,R! Y=1! e13! I=3B4R3! :1,! 43710S6! 6=D104;0!:1,! 34X;F! ,96! 9=7;04:9:16! A=:4B49,16!B;>D1713716! :1K10T3! 9D,4B90! B;3! >9?;0!048=0;64:9:! ,;6! B047104;6! :1! 31B164:9:F!D0;D;0B4;39,4:9:! ?! 09U;39K4,4:9:! 9,!>;>137;! :1! B;364:1090! ,9! 9D,4B9B4R3! :1! ,9!D0464R3! D015137459! 13! 1,! B96;! :1! D106;396!Y=1! 713893!34X;6!9! 6=!B908;#!.3!167;6!B96;6!:1K1! D;713B49061! 1,! 1>D,1;! :1! ;7096!>1:4:96! B9=71,9016! 3;! D045974596! :1! ,9!,4K1079:#! E9! -;>464R3! C9! ;K61059:;F! D;0!1A1>D,;F! Y=1! 13! ,;6! C1BC;6! =3! 9,7;!D;0B1379A1! :1! ,96! >=A1016! D0459:96! :1! 6=!,4K1079:!Y=1!741313!9!6=!B908;!34X;6F!C93!64:;!:17134:96! D;0! :1,47;6! 3;! 54;,137;6F! B;>;! 1,!>4B0;70TI4B;!:1!:0;896f!M-P/jF!%$("F!D#!'&N#!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)(! -I0#! _18,96! :1! ,96! Q9B4;316! ^34:96! D909! 1,!70979>4137;!:1!,96!01B,=696!?!>1:4:96!3;!D045974596!:1!,9!,4K1079:!D909!,96!>=A1016!:1,43B=13716#!_18,9!Q;#!&g#!!
.3! D026<);<3F! 13! %$$+F! >1:49371! ,9! E1?!\0;543B49,!("#+g"!61!>;:4I4BR!1,!907@B=,;!()+!:1,!-R:48;!\0;B169,!\139,!:1! ,9!\0;543B49!:1!b=13;6!L4016!?!61!43B;0D;0R!,9!D;64K4,4:9:!:1!154790! ,9! D0464R3! :=09371! 1,! D0;B16;! D909!>=A1016! 1>K909U9:96! ;! B;3! C4A;6! >13;016!:1!B43B;!9X;6!:1!1:9:#!.,!>46>;!9X;F! ,9!E1?!Q9B4;39,!%&#g*%!>;:4I4BR!1,!-R:48;!\139,!?!,9!E1?! :1! .A1B=B4R3! :1! ,9! \139! \04597459! :1!E4K1079:F! ?! D10>474R! ,9! D0464R3! :;>4B4,49049!D909! >=A1016! 1>K909U9:96F! B;3! C4A;6!>13;016! :1! B43B;! 9X;6! ;! D106;396! B;3!:46B9D9B4:9:! K9A;! 6=! B=4:9:;#! W1823! ,;6!:97;6! :1,! WQ..\F! 923! 1V4671! =3! 32>10;!4>D;079371!:1!34X;6!?!34X96!13! ,96!D0464;316!:1! L08137439#! W4! K413! 9X;6! 970T6! C9K@9!9D0;V4>9:9>1371! %$$! >=A1016! B;3545413:;!B;3! 6=6! C4A;6! ;! C4A96F! 9! D90740! :1,! 9X;! %$$+!;6B4,93! 9,01:1:;0! :1! ()$F! 643! =39! B,909!713:13B49!9,!:16B136;#!.3!%$("!C9K@9!(&g!13!1679!647=9B4R3!M-;0:9F!%$(&F!D#!"$N#!
!
L=3Y=1! 61! C93! B;3B1:4:;! 9,7103974596! 9! ,9!D0464R3F!13!>=BC;6!B96;6!61!648=13!31893:;#!.3! 1,! 43I;0>1! %$(g! 6;K01! BT0B1,16F! :1! ,9!\0;B=09B4R3! \134713B49049! :1! L08137439!1V4671!=3!9D9079:;!:1:4B9:;!9!1679!B=1674R3!13! ,9! Y=1! 61! 61X9,9G! eB;374329! 016=,793:;!D01;B=D9371!,9!:46B04>439B4R3!Y=1!6=K?9B1!9!,;6! 908=>137;6! 16804>4:;6! D;0! 1,! D;:10!A=:4B49,F! 13! ,96! :131897;0496! :1! ,;6! D1:4:;6!
55
Fotografía: César Acuña. Prisión en Ecuador.
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES
![Page 60: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
:1! 900167;6! :;>4B4,4904;6)%#! E9! B;3:4B4R3!6;B49,!:1!,96!>=A1016!6;,4B4793716!B;36747=?1!9!>13=:;! 1,! 1A1! B13709,! :1! ,;6! I=3:9>137;6!A=:4B49,16! Y=1! ;K679B=,4U93! 1,! 9BB16;! 9,!436747=7;#!/1!1671!>;:;F! ,96!>=A1016!Y=1:93!43>10696F! 3=159>1371F! 13! =39! D1,480;69!U;39! >908439,! B=93:;! 1,! D;:10! A=:4B49,! ,16!34189!1,!D,13;!1A10B4B4;!:1!6=!>971034:9:!13!5407=:! :1! 6=! ;04813! 6;B4;1B;3R>4B;f!M\0;B=09B4R3! \134713B49049! :1! ,9! Q9B4R3F!%$(gF! D#! ""gZ"")N#! P8=9,>1371F! 016=,79!D01;B=D9371! Y=1! =3! 907@B=,;! :1! D01369! :1,!9X;! %$(g! :16B04K4109! ,96! B;3:4B4;316! :1!:1713B4R3!:1!,96!>9:016!B;3!6=6!C4A;6!1!C4A96!13! ,96!BT0B1,16!:1!\0;543B49!:1!b=13;6!L4016!?! 01,979K9! 1,! B96;! :1! =3! 34X;! :1! %(! :@96! :1!39B4:;! Y=1! I9,,1B4R! 13! D0464R3#! -;3!D;67104;04:9:!9,!C1BC;!,96!>9:016!D=K,4B90;3!=39! B9079! :;3:1! D1:@93! Y=1! ,9! =34:9:!693479049! B;37909! B;3! =39! 9>K=,93B49! 13!B;3:4B4;316! Y=1! 61! D=1:9! =74,4U90! :1! I;0>9!1VB,=6459! D909! 61054B4;6! 69347904;6! ?! Y=1! 619!>931A9:9! D;0! D106;39,! :1! 69,=:! M-;61BC9!_;A9F!%$(gN#!!
.3! A1:1?9;3F! ,96! >=A1016! 1>K909U9:96!13I013793!>2,74D,16! K9001096! D909! 9BB1:10! 9!61054B4;6! :1! 69,=:! 9:1B=9:;6! 13! ,9! BT0B1,!M-;,1B745;! `=939! `=,49! a=U>T3F! %$$+N! ?! 13!;B964;316! 6=I013! 79>K4S3! 1,! 16748>9! D;0!D9071! :1! ;D109:;016! A=:4B49,16! ;! D106;39,!D134713B4904;F!Y=41316!,96!B9,4I4B93!:1!e>9,96!>9:016f!Mc1A@9F!%$(gN#!\909! ,96!>=A1016!B;3!C4A;6! 13! D0464R3! 61! C93! B019:;! 8=90:10@96! 9,!437104;0! :1! ,96! BT0B1,16F! D10;! 3;! C93! 7134:;!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)%!.6!4>D;079371!61X9,90!Y=1!1,!=6;!16704B7;!:1,!900167;!:;>4B4,4904;! 3;! 16! 6=I4B41371F! ?9! Y=1! ,96! >=A1016! Y=1!6193!K131I4B490496!:1!,96!9,7103974596!9!,9!D0464R3!:1K13!B;3790! B;3! 1,! D10>46;! 16D1B49,! D909! 709K9A90! I=109! :1!6=!C;890F!?9!Y=1F!64!3;!D=1:13!9713:10!,96!31B164:9:16!:1! 6=6! C4A;6F! 1,! K131I4B4;! D=1:1! 71310! 4>D9B7;6!64>4,9016!9!,9!BT0B1,F!;!8131090!=39!0143B4:13B49#!
,;6! 016=,79:;6! 16D109:;6! D=16! ,96! >9:016!741313!9BB16;!>=?!016704384:;!9!1,,96F!?9!Y=1!3;! 61! ,16! D10>471! 435;,=B09061! :1! >93109!9B7459!13!1,!D0;B16;!:1!B0493U9F!9:1>T6F!6=6!C4A;6!:1K13!610!01>474:;6!9!,;6!7016!9X;6!B;3!=3! I9>4,490! ;! 436747=B4R3! 1V71039! Y=1! D=1:9!C9B1061!B908;!:1!1,,;6!M^QPh.cF!%$$&F!D#!ggN#!E9! -;>464R3! L616;09! :1! \;,@74B9! -04>439,!M%$(%F! D#! (&"N! ?! ;08934U9B4;316! 6;B49,16! C93!C1BC;!=3!,,9>9:;!=081371!D909!43B;0D;090!,9!D106D1B7459! :1! 8S310;! 13! 1671! ?! ;70;6!96D1B7;6! :1! ,9! D;,@74B9! B04>439,! ?!D134713B49049!M^D04>3?!!"#$%F!%$(&KN#!!
.3! G60HF! ,96! >=A1016! 43710396! B;3! C4A;6!01D01613793! 1,! )#%! m! :1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! D139,!I1>13439#!L6@F!D909!9K04,!:1!%$("F!C9K@9!%$+!>9:016! B;3! =3! 7;79,! %(%! 34X;6!>13;016! :1!7016! 9X;6#! W1823! 1,! 907@B=,;! 'Ñ! :1,!_18,9>137;!:1,!-R:48;!:1!.A1B=B4R3!\139,F!,9!D0;71BB4R3! :1! ,96! 43710396! 816793716F!43B,=?13:;! 1,! 9,=>K09>4137;! 1! C4A;6! Y=1!B;354593! B;3! 1,,96F! B;3,,159! Y=1! 01B4K93!9713B4R3! >S:4B9! 13! 1679K,1B4>4137;6!D2K,4B;6!:1!69,=:!;!13!9>K413716!9:1B=9:;6!:1,! 1679K,1B4>4137;F! 96@! B;>;!D0;809>96!:1!69,4:9! D909! ,;6! 34X;6#! .,! 907@B=,;! (%Ñ! D015S!Y=1!9! ,96!>=A1016!D0459:96!:1!6=! ,4K1079:!61!,16! 016D171! 1,! :101BC;! :1! D10>931B10! 13! 1,!1679K,1B4>4137;! D134713B4904;! B;3! 6=6! C4A;6!C9679!Y=1!167;6!B=>D,93! 7016!9X;6!:1!1:9:F!;D;07=34:9:!13!,9!B=9,!610T3!1370189:;6!9!,9!D106;39! Y=1! B;0016D;3:9! :1! B;3I;0>4:9:!B;3!,9!3;0>97454:9:!6;K01!,9!>971049F!;!13!6=!:1I1B7;! 61! D0;B1:10T! D;0! ,9! 5@9! ,189,!B;0016D;3:41371! 9! ,9! B;,;B9B4R3! I9>4,490! =!;709! 436747=B4R3! 7=71,90! B;3I;0>1! 9! ,;!:46D=167;! D;0! 1,! -R:48;! :1! ,;6! Q4X;6! ?!L:;,16B13716!Mc9381,43BkV!`#!F!%$(&N#!!
56 CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES
![Page 61: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
.3!%082835F! 01B41371>1371F! 13! 1,!>90B;!:1!,9! :46B=64R3! 9B10B9! :1,! 7096,9:;! :1! ,96!01B,=696! B;3! C4A;6! D1Y=1X;6! 9,;A9:96! 13! .,!c;,43;! M=39! 436747=B4R3! D1Y=1X9! :167439:9!1VB,=6459>1371!9!9,;A90!9!>9:016!?!6=6!C4A;6!B;3! =39! B9D9B4:9:! D909! "$! 01B,=696! ?! 13! ,9!B=9,F! 9! :4B41>K01! :1! %$()F! 61! 13B;3709K93!9,;A9:;6!%*!34X;6N! ,9! P36747=B4R3!Q9B4;39,!:1!/101BC;6! j=>93;6! C9! 61X9,9:;! ,;!D10A=:4B49,! Y=1! 16! 1679! >1:4:9! D909! ,96!>=A1016!?!6=6!C4A;6F!96@!B;>;!,9!31B164:9:!:1!01B=0040! 9! 6;,=B4;316! 9,7103974596! 9,!13B90B1,9>4137;! D909! >9:016! B;3! C4A;6!D1Y=1X;6F! 13! ,=890! :1! 618=40! 9=>13793:;!,96! D,9U96! B;3! 1679! I439,4:9:! 13!1679K,1B4>4137;6! 439:1B=9:;6! Mb90:9U93;! d!W9,9>93;F!%$(&N#!!
H70;6! D9@616! 79>K4S3! B;371>D,93! ,=89016!16D1B49,16! 13! ,96! BT0B1,16! D909! Y=1! ,96!>9:016! 167S3! B;3! 6=6! C4A;6F! 643! 1>K908;F!610@9! D01I104K,1! ;D790! D;0! >1:4:96!9,7103974596!9! ,9!D0464R3!13! ,96!Y=1!61!K043:1!9D;?;! 6;B4;1B;3R>4B;! B=93:;! I=109!31B16904;F!D=16!13!167;6!6474;6!34! ,96!>9:016!34! 6=6! C4A;6! 1! C4A96! B=13793! B;3! B;3:4B4;316!9:1B=9:96#! .3! 1,! B96;! :1! ,;6! :1,47;6! :1!:0;896! 16! :4I@B4,! A=674I4B90! 64Y=4109! 1,! =6;! :1,!:101BC;! D139,#! O;>93:;! 13! B=1379! ,9!80951:9:! :1! ,;6! B;67;6! Y=1! 813109! 1,!13B90B1,9>4137;F! ,;6! .679:;6! :1K13!43B;0D;090! ?! D0;>;510! ,9! 9:;DB4R3! :1!>1B9346>;6! Y=1! D10>4793! 9! ,96! >9:016!43I09B7;096!:1! ,9! ,1?! ,9!B=67;:49!:1!6=6!C4A;6F!K9A;! B;3:4B4;316! 13! ,96! Y=1! 61! D0;71A93! ,;6!:101BC;6! :1! 9>K;6)"#! .3! ,;6! B96;6! :1!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)"!/;6!1VD10413B496!:1!01I1013B49!6;3G!(N!13!L08137439F!,9! L6;B49B4R3! :1! h9>4,49016! :1! /17134:;6! 13! -T0B1,16!h1:109,16! MLB4I9:NF! 74131! B;>;! ;KA1745;! D0;71810! ,;6!:101BC;6! 6;B49,16! :1! ,;6! C4A;6]96! :1! D106;396!13B90B1,9:96#! .679! ;08934U9B4R3! :1I13:4R! B;3! SV47;! ,9!
>=A1016! 1>K909U9:96! ?! B;3! D106;396!:1D13:413716! 9! B908;F! 1,! 13B90B1,9>4137;!:1K10@9! 610! 1,! 2,74>;! 01B=06;F! 43B,=6;F!:1K10@9! 15479061! D;0! B;>D,17;! MJHEL! !"# $%&!%$(&N#!!
Jóvenes y adolescentes E96! D;,@74B96! D0;C4K4B4;346796! C93! ,,159:;! 9!Y=1!>4,16!:1!9:;,16B13716!?!AR51316)g!:1!,96!L>S04B96! 6193! D10618=4:;6! ?! 13B90B1,9:;6F!70=3B93:;! 6=6! D0;?1B7;6! :1! 54:9! 1!4>D4:413:;! Y=1! D=1:93! 167=:490#! L:1>T6F!,96! >46>96! B;3:4B4;316! :1! 04168;! Y=1! 61!:16B04K410;3! 13! ,9! D04>109! 61BB4R3F! 79>K4S3!1V46713! 13! ,;6! B1370;6! :1! :1713B4R3! D909!>13;016#! .67;6! AR51316! 513! 6=! 69,=:!5=,3109:9! ?! 6;3! 1VD=167;6! 9! 647=9B4;316! :1!54;,13B49! ?! =6;! :1! 6=6793B496! 4,@B4796#! /;6!0968;6! B909B7104U93! ,9! 647=9B4R3! :1! 167;6!9:;,16B13716! ?! AR51316G! (N! ,9! 1V46713B49! :1!=39! D10B1DB4R3! 6;B49,! 31897459! ?!:46B04>4397;049! C9B49! 1,,;6! ?! 1,,96F! 9! Y=41316!61! 16748>974U9! B;364:10T3:;,16! B;>;!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!31B164:9:!:1!019,4U90!1,!D98;F!D;0!D9071!:1,!.679:;F!:1!,9! eL64839B4R3! =3451069,! D;0! C4A;f! 9! ,96! I9>4,496! B=?;!D043B4D9,! D0;511:;0! 1B;3R>4B;! 16! ,9! D106;39!13B90B1,9:9#! .679! 964839B4R3! 16! =3! D98;! >136=9,!;7;089:;!9!,;6!34X;6!?!,96!34X96!Y=1!6;3!B4=:9:93;6!:1!L08137439F! ?! B=?96!>9:016! ?! D9:016! 3;! 709K9A93! 13! ,9!1B;3;>@9!I;0>9,[!%N!13!.679:;6!^34:;6F!13!1,!.679:;!:1!Q=159! É;0kF! `=674B1j;>1! 16! =3! D0;809>9! D0;D4B49:;!D;0! ,9! L6;B49B4R3! :1! \0464;316! :1! c=A1016! MJ;>13q6!\046;3! L66;B4974;3F! J\LN! B;>;! =39! 9,710397459!16D1B@I4B9!:1!8S310;!9,! 13B90B1,9>4137;!D909!>=A1016!B;>D0;>174:96!B;3!C9B10!B9>K4;6!13!6=!54:9#!L!7095S6!:1,!D0;809>9F!,96!>=A1016!6;3!61,1BB4;39:96!D909!54540!13! 6=6! B9696F! B;3! 6=6! C4A;6F! ?! D9074B4D90! 13! :4I1013716!D0;809>96! :1! 70979>4137;F! 1:=B9B4R3! ?! 1>D,1;F! 13!,=890! :1! 610! 13B90B1,9:96! 13! ,9! I;0>9! 709:4B4;39,!MJHEL!!"#$%&!!%$(&F!D#!"*N#!!)g! .3! L>S04B9! E97439! 61! :13;>439! 9:;,16B13716! 9! ,96!D106;396!Y=1!61!13B=137093!13701!,;6!(%!?!C9679!93716!:1! B=>D,40! ,;6! ('! 9X;6! :1! 1:9:#! .3713:1>;6! D;0!AR51316!9! ,96!D106;396!Y=1! 741313!13701!('! ?!")!9X;6!:1!1:9:!MLBCTF!!%$()N#!!
57CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES
![Page 62: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
D0;B,4516!9,!:1,47;!?! ,9!54;,13B49#!.67;! 4>D,4B9!Y=1! ,9! B9089! 01D016459! :1! ,96! D;,@74B96! :1!:0;896!6=1,93!4>D9B790!6;K01!1679!D;K,9B4R3[!?!%N!6=!D9074B4D9B4R3!>908439,!;!13!,;6!3451,16!6=K9,7103;6!:1!,96!01:16!:1!70TI4B;!:1!:0;896!MLBCTF!%$()F!D#!"N#!!!
.3! A1:1?9;3F! "(#+m! :1! ,96! D106;396!9D01C13:4:96!D;0!70TI4B;F!D;071!;!I9K04B9B4R3!61!13B=137093!13701! ,;6!('!?! ,;6!%)!9X;6!:1!1:9:F! ?! %)#'m! 741313! :1! %&! 9! "g! 9X;6#! /1!9B=10:;! B;3! ,;6! :97;6! ;K7134:;6! D;0! 1,!-.//F!g$#*(m!:1!,;6!437103;6!13!,96!BT0B1,16!B;,;>K49396! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! 741313!13701! ('! ?! %+! 9X;6#! .3! T1:;V;3F! 7;>93:;!B;>;! >=16709! ,9! BT0B1,! :1! \9,>96;,9! 13! 1,!/1D9079>137;!:1!W9379!-0=UF!Y=1!16!,9!BT0B1,!>T6!D;K,9:9!:1,!D9@6F! 13701! ,96!D106;396!:1!(&! 9! %(! 9X;6F! ,;6! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! 6;3! ,9!710B109!B9=69!:1!13B90B1,9>4137;#!.3!T034;:F!D161!9!Y=1!,9!D;K,9B4R3!Y=1!74131!13701!('!?!"g! 9X;6! 01D0161379! 1,! %*m!:1,! 7;79,F! :1370;!:1,!64671>9!D134713B4904;!01D01613793!1,!*gm!M/1D9079>137;! \134713B4904;! Q9B4;39,! :1!b0964,F! %$(&N#! .3!A14)3!";73F! 61823!:97;6! :1!%$((F! ($#ggm! :1! ,;6! 437103;6! K9A;! ,9! E1?!'#%$g!61!C9,,9K9!13701!,96!1:9:16!:1!('!9!%g!9X;6F!>4137096!Y=1!('#$*m! 713@9!13701!%)!9!%+!9X;6#!.3!&EX;71F!9!3451,!I1:109,F!&)#%m!:1!,96! D106;396! 613713B49:96! 13! %$(%! D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!1093!D106;396! AR51316F!:1!13701!('!?!"g!9X;6!:1!1:9:#!.3!G60HF!'%#)m!:1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! D139,! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896!74131! 13701! %$! ?! g+! 9X;6#! .3! %082835! ,9!>9?;0!D0;D;0B4R3!:1!D106;396!D0;B169:96!61!B;3B13709!13!,96!1:9:16!B;>D013:4:96!13701!,;6!%)!?!,;6!"g!9X;6!:1!1:9:G!13!,;6!:1,47;6!:1!70TI4B;! 1,! 618=3:;! 709>;! 17904;! B;>D013:1!13701! ,;6! ")! ?! ,;6! g$! 9X;6F! 13! 7937;! Y=1! 13!,;6! :1,47;6! :1! D;6164R3! 16! :1! ('! 9! %g! 9X;6!MLBCTF!%$()F!D#!gN#!!
.3! 01,9B4R3! B;3! ,;6! 9:;,16B13716F! ?! :1!9B=10:;! B;3! 1,! HK610597;04;! _184;39,! :1!`=674B49!\139,!`=5134,F!,;6!AR51316!D0459:;6!:1!,9! ,4K1079:! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! D9074B4D93!13!,;6!3451,16!>T6!K9A;6!:1,!70936D;071F!?!6;3!Y=41316! 61! 435;,=B093! 13! 1,! >4B0;70TI4B;F!9:1>T6F! 13! =3! 9,7;! D;0B1379A1! 6;3!B;36=>4:;016! Y=1! 513:13! :0;896! D909!6=6713790! 6=!D0;D4;!B;36=>;F!?! 6;3!Y=41316!I;0>93! D9071! :1! ,;6! 3451,16! >T6! K9A;6! :1,!390B;70TI4B;#!W=!=74,4U9B4R3!B;>;!6;D;071!:1,!>10B9:;! :1! :0;896! 16! =39! 713:13B49!B01B41371! 13! 5904;6! D9@616! MW4671>9!W=K0184;39,! :1! P3I;0>9B4R3! 1! P35167489B4R3!6;K01! /0;896F! %$($N#! E9! 647=9B4R3! 61! 980959!D;0! ,9! 43B9D9B4:9:! :1,! 1679:;! :1!4>D,1>13790! :1K4:9>1371! ,9! `=674B49! \139,!D909! L:;,16B13716#! .67TF! D;0! D043B4D4;F!:1K4109! 71310! =39! I=3B4R3!I=3:9>1379,>1371! 1:=B97459#! W43! 1>K908;F!>=BC;6! :1! ,;6! 64671>96! :1! ,9! 0184R3! C93!710>439:;!D;0!D10:10!1679!I=3B4R3!?!8131090!9I1B79B4;316! >T6! 809516! 6;K01! ,96!709?1B7;0496! :1! 54:9! :1! ,;6! 9:;,16B13716! 13!B;3I,4B7;!B;3!,9!,1?))#!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!))! \;0! 1A1>D,;F! 13! -;,;>K49F! 159,=9B4;316! 01B413716!:1,! W4671>9! :1! _16D;369K4,4:9:! \139,! D909!L:;,16B13716! 61X9,93! Y=1! 13! 6=! 4>D,1>1379B4R3! e,9!,R84B9!:1!693B4;390!9!=3!:1,43B=1371!D04>9!6;K01!,9!:1!=3! D0;B16;! A=:4B49,! Y=1! :1K10@9! 9?=:90! 9! I;0>90! =3!6=A17;!:1!:101BC;6F!Y=413!96=>1!016D;369K,1>1371!6=!1A10B4B4;!?!9!Y=413!61!,1!D0;D4B49!=3!9>K41371!9:1B=9:;!D909!01D9090!1,!:9X;!B9=69:;!9!6=!D0;?1B7;!:1!54:9F!1,!:1! 6=6! 5@B74>96! ?! ,9! B;>=34:9:! 9I1B79:9f! M_=K4;F!%$("N#!L:1>T6F!e,9!D;,@74B9!6;B49,!16B969>1371!D131709!,;6!>=0;6!:1,!W_\LG!6;3!B;379:;6!,;6!B=06;6!Y=1!;I01B1!1,! W1054B4;!Q9B4;39,! :1!LD013:4U9A1F! D;0! 1A1>D,;#! -964!3=,;6! 6;3! ,;6! 70979>4137;6! D909! ,9! 9713B4R3! :1! ,96!9:4BB4;316! ;! :1! D0;K,1>96! D64Y=4T704B;6! B9=69:;6! D;0!,96!>46>96#!W;3! 431V46713716! ,;6!>;:1,;6! I,1V4K,16!Y=1!8909374B13! 1,! :101BC;! 9! =39! 1:=B9B4R3! B;3! B9,4:9:! ?!D1074313B49f! MPK@:#F! %$("N#! b9A;! 16796! B;3:4B4;316! ,9!D0459B4R3! :1! ,9! ,4K1079:! D410:1! 7;:9! I=3B4R3!D1:98R84B9#!
58 CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES
![Page 63: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
.3!&EX;71O! ,96! B;3:=B796! 01,9B4;39:96! B;3!:0;896!I=10;3!,9!D04>109!B9=69!:1!:1713B4R3!:1! 9:;,16B13716F! 13! A1:1?9;3! ,9! 618=3:9! ?!13!T034;:O!,9!710B109!MLBCTF!%$()N#!.3!G60HF!1,!32>10;! :1! 9:;,16B13716! :17134:;6! D;0!:0;896! 13701! %$$'! ?! %$(%! 9=>137R! *"m#!/=09371! 1671! D10@;:;! =3! 7;79,! :1! "F())!9:;,16B13716! I=10;3! :17134:;6! D;0! 16796!B;3:=B796F! :1! ,;6! B=9,16! 1,! )%m! I=1! D;0!B;36=>;!;!D;6164R3!Mc9381,43BkV!`#! F!%$(&N#!E9! 01,9B4R3! 13701! 1,! =6;! :1! :0;896! ?! ,9!9B7454:9:!:1,4B7459!13!1,!B96;!:1!9:;,16B13716!167T!543B=,9:9!9!,9!I9,79!:1!,9U;6!I9>4,49016!;!9I1B745;6F! 9! ,9! I9,79! :1! ;D;07=34:9:16! ?! 9!;7096! B9013B496! Y=1! 6=I01! =39! D9071! :1! ,9!D;K,9B4R3! 9:;,16B1371F! 643! 1>K908;F! ,96!016D=16796!648=13!K96T3:;61!13!,9!01D0164R3#!.3! #783/10F! D;0! 1A1>D,;F! 61823! 1,!HK610597;04;! _184;39,! :1! `=674B49! \139,!`=5134,! Y=1! B479! 9,! -;361A;! :1! ,9! Q4X1U! ?! ,9!L:;,16B13B49F! '$m!:1! ,96! D106;396!>13;016!:1! 1:9:! :17134:96! D;0! B;3:=B796! :1,4B74596!3;! 74131! I9>4,49F! ;! 13! 9,8=3;6! B96;6F! 6=6!D9:016! 6;3! >48093716F! 13! ;70;6! ,;6! C93!9K93:;39:;!;!C9K@93!I9,,1B4:;!MLBCTF!%$()N#!
!
!
W1823! 1,! HK610597;04;! _184;39,! :1! `=674B49!\139,! `=5134,F! 13! A1:1?9;3! %)#gm! :1! ,;6!9:;,16B13716! 590;316! ?! "$#(m! :1! ,96!
9:;,16B13716! >=A1016! D0459:;6]96! :1! 6=!,4K1079:! B=>D,13! B;3! ,;6! B047104;6! :1!:1D13:13B49! :1! 6=6793B496[! 964>46>;F! 13!%$(%! 13! A14)3! ";73F! 9,! >13;6! '$m! :1! ,9!D;K,9B4R3!Y=1!1679K9!D0459:9!:1! 6=! ,4K1079:!13! 1,! -1370;! :1! h;0>9B4R3! `=5134,! i=0Y=@!D0161379K9! D0;K,1>96! :1! B;36=>;! :1!:0;896#! E9! ;I1079! :1! 70979>4137;! ?!01C9K4,479B4R3! D909! 9Y=1,,;6! Y=1! 9K=693! :1!:0;896! 79>K4S3! 74131! 610496! :1I4B413B496!MW4671>9! W=K0184;39,! :1! P3I;0>9B4R3! 1!P35167489B4R3!6;K01!/0;896F!%$($N#!
Extranjeros !
.3701! ,;6! 1V7093A10;6! D0459:;6! :1! ,9! ,4K1079:!13! ,;6!D9@616!167=:49:;6F!?!13! ,;6!Y=1!1V4671!43I;0>9B4R3! 9,! 016D1B7;F! ,;6! :1,47;6! >T6!I01B=13716! 6;3! ,;6! 01,9B4;39:;6! B;3! :0;896#!L:1>T6! :1! ,96! :4I4B=,79:16! :10459:96! D909!9,8=3;6!:1!1,,;6!D;0! ,9!:4I1013B49!:1! 4:4;>9F!,96! D106;396! 1V7093A1096! 79>K4S3! 13I013793!D0;K,1>96!D909!>9371310!1,!B;379B7;!B;3!6=!I9>4,49! ?! D909! 01B4K40! 5464796F! 713413:;! 13!B=1379! Y=1!>=BC96! :1! 1,,96! 3;! 01B4K13! =39!6;,9! 546479! :=09371! 1,! 741>D;! Y=1!D10>931B13!13!D0464R3#!L64>46>;F!13I013793!=39! I9,79! :1! 9D;?;! D;0! D9071! :1! ,;6!B;36=,9:;6!:1!6=6!D9@616F!9!,;!Y=1!61!6=>9!1,!:16B;3;B4>4137;! :1,! :101BC;! 5481371F! ,9!:4I4B=,79:!D909!;K71310!9BB16;!9!=39!:1I1369!D139,! 1I1B7459! ?! 9! K131I4B4;6! D;0! 3;! 71310!=39!:401BB4R3! I4A9F! 709K9A;!D0154;F!17B#!.3! ,;6!D9@616! Y=1! ,;! D10>4713F! ,;6! 70T>4716! :1!01D97049B4R3! 9! 6=6! ,=89016! :1! ;04813! 6=1,13!610!,137;6!?!138;00;6;6#!!
.3!D026<);<3F!61823!,9!DT8439!:1!43710317!:1,!W4671>9! \134713B4904;! h1:109,! MW\hNF! D909!I1K010;! :1! %$()! C9K@9! (F("(! D106;396! :1!;70;6! D9@616! :17134:96! 13! 01,9B4R3! 9! 167;6!
59
Fotografía: César Acuña. Prisión en Ecuador.
CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES
![Page 64: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/64.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
:1,47;6F!,;!Y=1!01D0161379K9!1,!)%#""m!:1!,96!D106;396! :1! ;70;6! D9@616! 13! 161! 61054B4;#!W1823!,9!>46>9!I=1371F!D909!I1K010;!:1!%$()!C9K@9!%F(&(!D106;396!:1!;70;6!D9@616F!,;!B=9,!01D0161379!1,!%$#"m!:1,!7;79,!:1!,9!D;K,9B4R3!13! ,96! BT0B1,16! I1:109,16#! E9! >46>9! I=1371!0974I4B9! Y=1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! 13! BT0B1,16!I1:109,16! ;04=3:9! :1! ;70;6! D9@616! 6=I01! 1,!13B90B1,9>4137;! D01513745;! 13! >9?;0!>1:4:9G!1,!*$#&&m! M(F)%*!D106;396N!1679K93!D0;B169:96F!13!7937;!Y=1!1,!%+#"gm!M&"gN!61!13B;3709K93! B;3:139:96#! L64>46>;F! :1370;!:1! ,9!D;K,9B4R3!1V7093A109!9,;A9:9!13!1,!W\hF!,96! >=A1016! 01D01613793! =3! D;0B1379A1!>9?;0! B;>D909:;6! B;3! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! :1!1V7093A10;6! 13! 813109,#! .,,96! 9,B93U93! 1,!(%#&"m!M%*"N!:1!,9!D;K,9B4R3!:1!;70;6!D9@616!Y=1!545@93!13!161!61054B4;F!B964!:=D,4B93:;!1,!&#+m! :1! >=A1016! 13! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! 813109,#!O9>K4S3! 61! 9:541071F! 9! D90740! :1! ,9!43I;0>9B4R3! :1,! W\hF! Y=1! 1,! D;0B1379A1! :1!>=A1016!:1!;70;6!D9@616!:17134:96!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!16!>T6!9,7;!Y=1!13!B=9,Y=410!;709!D;K,9B4R3G!>4137096!Y=1!13701!,;6!C;>K016!1,!D;0B1379A1! 16! :1,! g'#'"m! M+%%! D106;396NF!13701! ,96!>=A1016!16!>=BC;!>9?;0G!9:1>T6F!*&#)&m!:1! ,96!>=A1016!:1!;70;6!D9@616!167T3!13! ,96! BT0B1,16! I1:109,16! D;0! :1,47;6! :1!:0;896[!9,!>16!:1!I1K010;!:1!%$()!C9K@9!%$+!>=A1016!13!1,! W4671>9!\139,!h1:109,! M-;0:9F!%$(&N)&#!
.3! T034;:F! 13! %$(g! C9K@9! %F&%)! D106;396!D0459:96! :1! 6=! ,4K1079:#! E9! >9?;0@9! M)"mN!D0;513@93! :1! D9@616! :1! L>S04B9F! :16D=S6!618=@9! nI04B9! M%+mNF! 6413:;! Q481049! M""$N! ?!\9098=9?! M"()N! ,96! 39B4;39,4:9:16!1V7093A1096!>T6!B;>=316!13701! ,9!D;K,9B4R3!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)&!E9!43I;0>9B4R3!I=1!6=6709@:9!:1!,9!DT8439!:1!,9!W\hF!?!61!D=1:1!B;36=,790!13G! !C77DG]]vvv#6DI#8;K#90]vvv]43:1V#!!
4371039! 13! b0964,F! 618=4:;6! :1! b;,4549! M"(%!D106;396NF! \102! M%ggN! ?! -;,;>K49! M(+'N#! E;6!:97;6!>T6!01B413716!:45=,89:;6!13!01,9B4R3!9!,9! D;K,9B4R3! :1! 1V7093A10;6! D;0! 8S310;F!61X9,93!Y=1!13!%$(gF! :1! ,96! %F**'!D106;396!D01696! D0;513413716! :1! ;70;6! D9@616F! %F('%!1093! C;>K016! ?! )+&! 1093! >=A1016#! ^39!435167489B4R3!019,4U9:9!13!Wu;!\9=,;!:1679B9!,9!647=9B4R3!:1!1V701>9!5=,3109K4,4:9:!5454:9!D;0!,96!:17134:96!1V7093A1096!MP36747=7;!O1009F!O09K9,C;! 1! -4:9:9349F! %$((N#! L! D1690! :1! 3;!1V46740!:97;6!;I4B49,16!13!01,9B4R3!9,!:1,47;!D;0!1,! B=9,! 6;3! 9B=69:;6! ,;6! 1V7093A10;6! ?! ,96!1V7093A1096! :17134:96! 13! b0964,F! :45106;6!167=:4;6!61X9,93!9,!70TI4B;!:1!:0;896!B;>;!1,!D043B4D9,! :1,47;F! ,;! Y=1! 16! =39! 019,4:9:!B;>23! 13! :45106;6! D9@616! ,9743;9>104B93;6#!.3! 1,! >46>;! 61374:;F! 01B41371>1371! ,9!/1I136;0@9! \2K,4B9! h1:109,! C9! 0151,9:;! Y=1!>T6! :1,! +$m! :1! ,;6! 1V7093A10;6! D016;6!9713:4:;6! D;0! 1671! R0893;! B=>D,@93! D1396!D;0!1,!B04>13!:1!70TI4B;!:1!:0;896!Mb;471=V!!"#$%&!!%$(&N#!!!
.3! G60HF! 9! :4B41>K01! :1! %$("F! ,;6! D016;6!1V7093A10;6! 01D0161379K93! 1,! "m! :1! ,9!D;K,9B4R3! D134713B49049! 7;79,#! L,01:1:;0! :1,!+$m! :1! 16796! D106;396! C9K@9! 64:;! :17134:9!D;0! 70TI4B;! 4,@B47;!:1!:0;896! 13! ,9!>;:9,4:9:!:1! K=0010;! ;! eB;001;6! C=>93;6f#! .6796!D106;396! D0;513@93! :1! >T6! :1! *$! D9@616F!9=3Y=1! ,9! >9?;0@9! 1093! B;,;>K493;6!M(*#&mNF! 618=4:;! :1! 16D9X;,16! M(*#(mNF!>1V4B93;6! M($mNF! K;,45493;6! M)mNF!D;07=8=1616! Mg#&mNF! 1B=97;0493;6! Mg#gmNF! ?!C;,93:1616!M"#"mN#!.3!813109,!1,!K=0010;!6R,;!4371054131! 13! 1,! 70936D;071! ?! 16! 9A13;! 9,!32B,1;! :1! D106;396F! 4371809:96! ;! 3;! 9! =39!;08934U9B4R3! B04>439,F! Y=41316! ,;! B9D790;3!1!C4B410;3! D;64K,1! 1,! 9B7;! :1! 70936D;071#! W=!,9K;0! 61! B40B=36B04K1! 9! 7096,9:90!
60 CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES
![Page 65: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/65.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
43670=>1379,>1371! ,9! :0;89F! 643! 437101690,1!D;0!B=1379!:1!Y=4S3!019,4U9!1,!70936D;071#!E9!D139!D909!=3!K=0010;!6=1,1!610!:1!6146!9X;6#!W43! 1>K908;F! 64! ,9! B9374:9:! :1! :0;896!
6;K01D969! ,;6! ($! k8F! ,9! D139! D=1:1! 610! :1!C9679! ()! 9X;6! D;0! 70979061! :1! =39! I;0>9!980959:9!Mc9381,43BkV!`#!F!%$(&N#!
!
#:!)0^2;71!/64);<1!/6!]3<;3!
L!I439,16!:1!;B7=K01!:1,!%$$+F!O9349!_;:0@8=1U!LK09371F!:1!%(!9X;6F!?!6=!C10>939!c1,;:?F!:1!('F! 9>K96! :1! 39B4;39,4:9:! 16D9X;,9F! 549A90;3! 9! \102! B;3! ,9! 43713B4R3! :1! 13B;37090! 709K9A;#!\;B96! 61>9396! :16D=S6! I=10;3! :17134:96! 13! 1,! 910;D=107;! `;081! -CT51U! B=93:;! 4371379K93!70936D;0790!=3!k4,;!:1!B;B9@39!9:C104:;!9!6=6!B=10D;6#!O9349!?!c1,;:?! I=10;3!613713B49:96!9!6146!9X;6!:1!D0464R3!?!,=18;!4371039:96!13!1,!1679K,1B4>4137;!D134713B4904;!D909!>=A1016!o40813!:1! hT74>9! ME4>9N#! W1823!1,! PQ\.F! O9349!3;! 61! 9:1B=9K9!9,! 0S84>13!D134713B4904;! ! MB=93:;!13!019,4:9:!6=I0@9!:1!=39!D0;I=3:9!:1D0164R3N!?F!D;0!169!09UR3!I=1!7096,9:9:9!13!I1K010;!:1,!%$((!9,! L31V;F! 1,! 1679K,1B4>4137;! D134713B4904;! :1! >=A1016! :1! >TV4>9! 618=04:9:F! A=37;! B;3! ,96!>=A1016!Y=1!1679K93!D01696!D;0!7100;046>;#!
.,! 7096,9:;! 9,! L31V;! ?! ,9! 61D909B4R3! :1! 6=! C10>939! 6R,;! 1>D1;090;3! 6=! 69,=:! >1379,#! LC@!B;3;B4R!9!OC946!P69U4F!;709!16D9X;,9!:17134:9!13!;B7=K01!:1,!%$$+!B=93:;!713@9!(+!9X;6#!OC946!79>K4S3!6=I0@9!:1!:1D0164R3!?!93641:9:#!.,!("!:1!;B7=K01!:1,!%$(%F!OC946!61!6=4B4:R!13!6=!B1,:9F!,;!Y=1!98095R!923!>T6!1,!1679:;!:1D01645;!:1!O9349#!.671!>46>;!>16F!O9349!437137R!6=4B4:9061!D;0!D04>109!51U#!.,!*!:1!1310;!:1,!%$(gF!O9349!018016R!9!6=!D9K1,,R3!?!61!9C;0BR!B;3!6=!BC9,439#!
O9349! 713@9! %)! 9X;6! :1! 1:9:! ?! ?9! ,,159K9! B=970;! 9X;6! 01B,=4:9F! D=16! :1K@9! B;>D=0890! =39!B;3:139!:1!6146!9X;6#!j9K@9!4371379:;!6=4B4:9061!13!;7096!:;6!;D;07=34:9:16#!
I86<)6+!Mc9381,43BkV!`#!F!%$(&N!
!
^3! D0;K,1>9! 435464K,1! 16! 1,! :1! ,;6!,9743;9>104B93;6! Y=1! 6;3! 13B90B1,9:;6! D;0!:1,47;6! :1! :0;896! 13! ;70;6! D9@616#! .3!A1:1?9;3F! D;0! 1A1>D,;F! 61! 1674>9! Y=1!9,01:1:;0! :1! (gF%$$! B;,;>K493;6! ?!B;,;>K49396! 167T3! :17134:;6! 13! :4I1013716!BT0B1,16!:1,!>=3:;F! (%'!:1!1,,;6! 13! B9:139!D10D17=9! ;! ()! B;3:139:;6! 9! D139! :1!>=1071#!W1823!1,!:4904;!.,!O41>D;G!e,96!01:16!!
!
!
:1!390B;70TI4B;!C93!5467;!13!D9@616!964T74B;6!=3!:16743;!D909!,9!B;B9@39F!?!D909!D;310,9!9,,@!=693! ,96! ,,9>9:96! p>=,96q! ;! pB;001;6!C=>93;6q#!_1D;0716!;I4B49,16!:4B13!Y=1!B9:9!>16!7016!D106;396!6;3!6;0D013:4:96!13!-C439!B;3!:0;89F!?! ,9!>9?;0@9!6;3!:1,!.A1!-9I1710;!?! 1,! o9,,1f! M.,! O41>D;F! %$()N#! c=BC96! :1!16796! D106;396! 9I40>93! C9K10! 64:;! D=16796!B;>;!!eB9039:96f!!D;0!!!,;6!!!709I4B93716!!!D909!!
61CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES
![Page 66: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/66.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
:4670910! ,9! 9713B4R3! ?! ,;8090! Y=1! ;7096!D106;396!,,18=13!B;3!,9!:0;89!9!6=6!:16743;6!I439,16#!
Otras poblaciones !
E96! 435167489B4;316! :1,! -.//! 13! B9:9! D9@6!D=6410;3! :1! 01,4151! ,9! 019,4:9:! D;0! ,9! Y=1!D9693! ;7096! D;K,9B4;316! D0459:96! :1! ,9!,4K1079:! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896F! ,96! B=9,16!6=I013! 647=9B4;316! :1! 5=,3109K4,4:9:! ?!:46B04>439B4R3! 13! ,;6! 64671>96! D134713ZB4904;6#!!!
^3! B;,1B745;! Y=1! >101B1! 610! 939,4U9:;!:1370;!:1! ,96!D106;396!Y=1!167T3!13!D0464R3!D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! 6;3! ,96! D106;396!709368S310;#! W4! K413!3;! 016=,793!3=>10;696F!01D4713! 64>4,9016! ;! D1;016! 647=9B4;316! :1!5=,3109K4,4:9:F! 9! ,;! Y=1! 16! D;64K,1! 6=>90! ,9!:46B04>439B4R3! Y=1! 923! D10:=09! 6;K01! 1671!B;,1B745;! ?! Y=1! 61! 980959! D;0! 16790! 13!D0464R3#!W1823!,9!43I;0>9B4R3!:1!,9!DT8439!:1!43710317!:1,!W4671>9!\134713B4904;!h1:109,!:1!D026<);<3F! 9! I1K010;! :1! %$()F! C9K@9! %)!D106;396! 13! ,9! B9718;0@9! eO09368S310;f#! .,!1Y=4D;! :1! 8S310;! ?! :451064:9:! 61V=9,! :1! ,9!\0;B=09B4R3! \134713B49049! :1! ,9! Q9B4R3!43I;0>R!Y=1!13!=3;!:1! ,;6!1679K,1B4>4137;6!D134713B4904;6! :1,! W\h! C9K@9! 64171! D106;396!70936F!?!Y=1!6146!:1!1,,96!1679K93!D;0!:1,47;6!B;3709! ,9! ,1?! :1! :0;896#! .3! %$(%F! L08137439!693B4;3R! ,9! E1?! :1! P:1374:9:! :1!aS310;! MQÑ!%&#*g"NF! ,;! Y=1! 64834I4BR! =3! 9593B1! 13! 1,!01B;3;B4>4137;!:1! ,;6!:101BC;6!:1!:467437;6!B;,1B745;6#! \161! 9! 1671! 9593B1F! 13! B4107;6!>1:4;6!:1!B;>=34B9B4R3!61!6=1,1!01D0;:=B40!1,! B;3B1D7;! e390B;70951674f#! E96! 3;74B496! :1!D01369! >=167093! Y=1! 13! ,9! >9?;0@9! :1! ,;6!B96;6! 01846709:;6! 79,! B9718;0@9! 61! 9704K=?1! 9!>=A1016!70936!Y=1!1A10B@93!709K9A;!61V=9,F!?!9!
,96! B=9,16! 61! ,16! C9! 13B;3709:;! 513:413:;!D1Y=1X96! B9374:9:16! :1! 167=D1I9B413716!M-;0:9F!%$(&N#!/1!9B=10:;!B;3!,9!\0;B=09B4R3!\134713B49049! :1! ,9! Q9B4R3! M%$(&F! D#! ($NF! :1!%*! >=A1016! 70936! 01B,=4:96! 13! BT0B1,16!I1:109,16F! (+!167T3!:17134:96!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896F! ,;! Y=1! 01D0161379! *$m! :1! 16796!D106;396!:17134:96#!!
.3! ,;6! D9@616! D0;:=B7;016F! B;>;! G60HO!T1:;V;3O!&EX;71! 5!A1:1?9;3O! ,96! D;K,9B4;316!0=09,16F! 43:@81396F! 9I0;6! ?! B9>D1643;6! C93!64:;! 709:4B4;39,>1371! B04>439,4U9:96! D;0!543B=,9061F! B;>;! =39! I;0>9! :1!6;K0154513B49F! 9,! B=,745;! :1! D,93796! Y=1!640513! :1! 436=>;! D909! ,9! D0;:=BB4R3! :1!167=D1I9B413716F! B;>;! B;B9F! >904C=939! ?!9>9D;,9#! .3! -;,;>K49F! 1,!>9?;0! D;0B1379A1!:1! 437103;6! D;0! 1,! :1,47;! :1! B;361059B4R3! ?!I4393B49>4137;!:1!D,9379B4;316! ,;! 741313! ,;6!:1D9079>137;6! :1! L374;Y=49F! Q;071! :1!W93793:10! ?! -C;BR! MY=1! 709:4B4;39,>1371!C93!7134:;!D01613B49!:1!B=,745;6!>937134:;6!D;0! D;K,9B4;316! B9>D164396N! ?! ,;6! >9?;016!@3:4B16! :1! B9D7=096! D;0! 167;6! :1,47;6! ,;6!01D;0793! ,;6! :1D9079>137;6! :1,! W=0! :1!-;,;>K49! M^D04>3?! !"# $%&! %$(&9N#! E9!D1061B=B4R3! D139,F! 6=>9:9! 9! 16709718496!B;>;! ,9! 96D1064R3! 9S019F! C9! 813109:;! =3!961:4;! D10>931371! 6;K01! 16796! D;K,9B4;316!?! 647=9B4;316! :1! :16B;3I493U9! 13! 1,! .679:;F!Y=1! D;:0@93! 610! 15479:96! K9A;! ;70;! 74D;! :1!9D0;V4>9B4;316F! K969:96! 13! =3! 13I;Y=1! :1!:16900;,,;! 0=09,! 4371809,! Y=1! 01:=UB9! ,96!5=,3109K4,4:9:16! Y=1! 13I013793! MP3:1D9UF!%$()[!c936I41,:F!%$(&N#!
!
!
62 CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES
![Page 67: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/67.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
!!161! 9! Y=1! ,9! 0184R3! ,9743;9>104B939! C9!,4:109:;!1,!:1K971!:1!01I;0>96!9!,96!D;,@74B96!:1! :0;896! 9! 3451,! 8,;K9,F! ?! C9! D0;>;54:;! ,9!31B164:9:! :1! B;364:1090! 9,7103974596! 9,!13B90B1,9>4137;! 13! >971049! :1! :0;896F! 1,!=6;! :1,! :101BC;! D139,! ?! :1! ,96! 693B4;316!D045974596! :1! ,9! ,4K1079:! 61! C93! 1V9B10K9:;!13! ,;6! 2,74>;6! 9X;6#! .V4671! 96@! =39!4>D;079371! K01BC9! 13701! 1,! :46B=06;! :1!01I;0>9! D;0! D9071! :1! ,;6! .679:;6! ?! ,;6!437137;6! :1! 9593U90! 13! 016D=16796! >13;6!01D0164596F!B;3!=3!13I;Y=1!:1!69,=:!D2K,4B9F!:101BC;6! C=>93;6! ?! :1! :16900;,,;! C=>93;!Y=1F! 69,5;! B;379:96! 1VB1DB4;316F! C93! 64:;!100T74B;6#! .3! 9,8=3;6! D9@616F! B;>;! .B=9:;0F!167;6!16I=10U;6F!43B,=6;F!61!C93!0151074:;#!
.3! ,9!>9?;0@9! :1! ,;6! D9@616! :1! ,9! 0184R3F! 1,!9=>137;! D;0B137=9,! :1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3!13B90B1,9:9! D;0! :1,47;6! :1! :0;896! C9! 64:;!>=BC;! >9?;0! Y=1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! 813109,!13B90B1,9:9! D;0! ;70;6! :1,47;6F! ?! ,;6! :97;6!>=167093! Y=1! 16796! 713:13B496! B;3743293! 9!,9! 9,U9#! L:1>T6F! 13! 5904;6! :1! ,;6! D9@616!167=:49:;6! 1,! 13B90B1,9>4137;! D;0! 167;6!:1,47;6! 16! 1,! D043B4D9,! I9B7;0! Y=1! 1VD,4B9! 1,!B01B4>4137;!:1!,9!D;K,9B4R3!B90B1,9049#!!
E96! 79696! :1! 13B90B1,9>4137;! 13! L>S04B9!E97439! 61! 13B=137093! D;0! 13B4>9! :1,!D0;>1:4;! >=3:49,#! E9! 43I;0>9B4R3!D0161379:9!13!1671!43I;0>1!>=16709!I9B7;016!B,9516! Y=1! 1VD,4B93! 1679! 647=9B4R3G! D1396!:16D0;D;0B4;39:9>1371! 9,796F! 1,! =6;! :1!613713B496! >@34>96! ;K,4897;0496F! 1,! =6;!;K,4897;04;! :1! ,9! D0464R3! D015137459! D909!167;6!:1,47;6!;!6=!6;K01=6;F!,9!I9,79!:1!=6;!:1!9,7103974596!9,!13B90B1,9>4137;F!13701!;70;6#!W4!K413F!L>S04B9!E97439!16!=39!:1!,96!0184;316!>T6! 54;,13796! :1,!>=3:;F! 1,! 9=>137;! 13! 1,!=6;! :1! BT0B1,16! 3;! D901B1! 016D;3:10! 9! 1679!
647=9B4R3F! ?9! Y=1! 6;3! ,;6! :1,43B=13716!>13;016! ,;6! Y=1! D043B4D9,>1371! 6;3!B9D7=09:;6!13!I,98093B49!?!Y=41316!01B4K13!1,!D16;! :1,! 64671>9! D139,#! .3! 1,! B96;! :1! ,;6!:1,47;6! :1! :0;896F! ,;6! 167=:4;6! :1,! -.//!>=167093! Y=1! ,;6! =6=904;6! 6;3!I01B=1371>1371! :17134:;6F! 1V7;064;39:;6! 1!43B,=6;! 13B90B1,9:;6! B;>;! >4B0;!513:1:;016! ;! >13=:46796! D;0! D;0790!B9374:9:16! :1! :0;896! D;0! 13B4>9! :1! ,96!7;,109:96#! .,,;! >=16709! Y=1! 1,! :46B=06;! :1!D0;71BB4R3! 9! ,9! 69,=:! :1! ,;6! =6=904;6! 61!Y=1:9!13!1,!D9D1,F!>4137096!Y=1!,96!D;,@74B96!:1! :0;896! D=16796! 13! D0TB74B9! B;3743293!13I013793:;! 1,! D0;K,1>9! :1! =6;! :1! :0;896!4,@B4796!:16:1!1,!:101BC;!D139,#!!
E9! 6;K01! D139,4U9B4R3! D909! B0@>1316!01,9B4;39:;6!B;3!:0;896!3;!C9!7134:;!343823!4>D9B7;! 13! ,9! 01:=BB4R3! :1! ,9! D0;:=BB4R3F!70TI4B;!;!=6;!:1!:0;896!B;364:109:96! 4,@B4796#!L,! B;370904;F! Y=41316! 6;3! 13549:;6! 9! D0464R3!6=1,13!610!,;6!9B7;016!>13;016!:1,!70TI4B;!:1!:0;896F!I=384K,16!?!96;B49:;6!9!1B;3;>@96!:1!6=K646713B49! =! ;7096! B;3:4B4;316! :1!5=,3109K4,4:9:#! O9>D;B;! C9! B;3704K=4:;! 9!>1A;090! ,9! 69,=:! D2K,4B9! ;! 43:454:=9,#! E96!BT0B1,16! 13! L>S04B9! E97439! 6;3! ,=89016!:;3:1! 1V4671! 6;K01D;K,9B4R3F! 16B9616! :1!01B=06;6! ?! B;3:4B4;316! 1V701>96! :1!54;,13B49#! E9! I9,79! :1! C484131F! :1! 98=9!D;79K,1F! 1361016! KT64B;6! ?! 16D9B4;6!6=I4B413716!B;3704K=?13!9!Y=1!1V4679!=39!9,79!D0159,13B49! :1! 13I10>1:9:16! B;37984;696!Y=1!D;313!13!04168;!,9!69,=:!:1!,;6!437103;6F!:1! 6=6! I9>4,49016! ?! :1! ,;6! 1>D,19:;6! :1! ,;6!B1370;6! :1! 01B,=64R3#! .,! =6;! :1! ,96! BT0B1,16!D909!9713:10!1,!D0;K,1>9!:1!,96!:0;896F!,1A;6!:1!D0;71810! ,9!69,=:F! ,9!5=,3109#!/46>43=40!1,!=6;! M;! 9K=6;N! :1! 1679! C1009>41379! D139,!9?=:90@9! 9! >1A;090! ,96! B;3:4B4;316!
C O
N C
L U S I O
N E S Y R
E C O
M E N
D A
C I O
N E S
CO
NC
LU
SIO
NE
S Y
RE
CO
ME
ND
AC
ION
ES
P
63CONCLUSIONES Y RECOMENDACIONES
![Page 68: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/68.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
B90B1,90496F! 9,! ,4K1090! ,;6! 01B=06;6! Y=1!1V46713#!
E9! 16748>974U9B4R3! ?! ,9! BT0B1,! 9I1B793! :1!I;0>9! :4674379! 9! ,96! D106;396! 01B,=4:96! D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!?!9!6=6!I9>4,496F!:1!9B=10:;!9!B047104;6!B;>;!1,!61V;F! ,9! 4:1374:9:!61V=9,F!,9! B;3:4B4R3! S734B9! ?! ,9! 647=9B4R3!6;B4;1B;3R>4B9#! E9! BT0B1,F! D;0! 1A1>D,;F!74131! 4>D9B7;6! :4I1013B49,16! ?! :16D0;ZD;0B4;39:;6! 6;K01! ,96! >=A1016#! L=3Y=1! 1,!32>10;! 7;79,! :1! >=A1016! 13! ,96! BT0B1,16! 16!>=?! 43I104;0! 9! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! >96B=,439F! ,;6!3451,16! :1! 13B90B1,9>4137;! :1! ,96! >=A1016!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!167T3!9=>13793:;!9!=3!047>;!9,90>9371!?F!813109,>1371F!;B=D93!,;6!0938;6! >T6! K9A;6! :1! ,9! B9:139! :1,! 318;B4;!:1! ,96! :0;896#! E9! 8093! >9?;0@9! :1! 16796!>=A1016! 741313! D;B9! 1:=B9B4R3! ?! 54513! 13!B;3:4B4;316!:1!D;K01U9[!>=BC96!6;3!>9:016!6;,71096#! .,! 13B90B1,9>4137;! :1! >=A1016!>9:016! ?! B=4:9:;096! 13! D9074B=,90F! D=1:1!71310! B;361B=13B496! :159679:;096! D909! 6=6!I9>4,496#! \;0!;709!D9071F! ,96!:46B04>439B4;316!Y=1!6=I013!D106;396!D107131B413716!9!80=D;6!D;K,9B4;39,16! 709:4B4;39,>1371! >908439:;6!D;0! I=109! :1! ,9! D0464R3F! 6=1,13! 7096,9:9061! ?!1V9B10K9061!:1370;!:1!1,,9#!!
E96!>=A1016! 1V7093A1096F! Y=1! 9!>13=:;! 6;3!D0459:96! :1! 6=! ,4K1079:! D;0! 610! eB;001;6!C=>93;6fF! D=16! ,,1593! :0;896! D909! ;709!D106;39! ;! =39! 01:! B04>439,F! 13I013793! =39!647=9B4R3! D9074B=,90>1371! 80951! :1K4:;! 9! ,9!:4I4B=,79:! B;3! 1,! 4:4;>9! ?! D909! >9371310!B;379B7;! B;3! 6=6! I9>4,496F! ?! 71310! 9BB16;! 9!=39!:1I1369!D139,!1I1B7459#!.3!,;6!D9@616!Y=1!,;! D10>4713F! ,;6! 70T>4716! :1! 01D97049B4R3!6=1,13!610!,137;6!?!138;00;6;6#!
-;3! 016D1B7;! 9! ,;6],96! AR51316! ?! ,;6],96!9:;,16B13716! 435;,=B09:;6!13!:0;896F!D161!9!Y=1! 6;3! D0;B169:;6! 13! 64671>96! D139,16!:4I1013716F! 6=1,13! 71310! B909B710@674B96! ?!D0;K,1>96! B;>=316! 9,! 64671>9! :1! 9:=,7;6#!^39! :1! 1,,96! 16! Y=1! 34! 9:;,16B13716! 34!AR51316! 6=1,13! D107131B10! 9! ,;6! 3451,16! :1!,4:109U8;!:1!,96!>9I496!390B;709I4B93716F!643;!610! D9071! :1! ,;6! 16,9K;316! >T6! :SK4,16! ?!011>D,9U9K,16! :1,! 318;B4;#! W43! 1>K908;F! 9!D1690! :1! 169! D9074B4D9B4R3! >13;0! 61!13B=137093! 13701! ,;6! 80=D;6! Y=1! >T6!D9:1B13!,;6!4>D9B7;6!:1!,9!B9089!D=347459!:1!,96!D;,@74B96!:1!:0;896#!O9>K4S3!61!;K61059!,9!9=613B49!:1,!.679:;!13!>971049!D015137459!?!,9! I9,79! :1! D;64K4,4:9:16! :1! 9BB16;! 9!70979>4137;! ?! 01C9K4,479B4R3! :1,! =6;! :1!:0;896!D909!9Y=1,,;6! AR51316!?!9:;,16B13716!Y=1F! :1K4:;! 9,! B;36=>;! 018=,90F! 61!>93741313!13!1,!B@0B=,;!:1,4B745;#!!.3! B;3B,=64R3F! 13! 7;:;6! ,;6! D9@616!167=:49:;6F! ,96! 435167489B4;316! :1,! -.//!>=167093! =3! 8093! 32>10;! :1! D106;396!13B90B1,9:96!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!>13;016!?! 3;! 54;,137;6F! Y=41316! 3;! :1K10@93! 16790!D0459:;6!:1!6=!,4K1079:#!E9!BT0B1,!:1K10@9!610!=3! 01B=06;! :1! .%")2$# 1$")7[! 643! 1>K908;F!9C;09!,9!BT0B1,!16!,9!D043B4D9,!C1009>41379!13!1,! B;370;,! :1! :0;896! 13! ,96! 39B4;316! :1!L>S04B9#!!
.6! 31B16904;! 09B4;39,4U90! 1,! =6;! :1,! :101BC;!D139,!?!:1!,9!BT0B1,!13!1,!>90B;!:1!,9!D;,@74B9!:1!:0;896#!\;0!79,!09UR3F!13!,;!01I101371!9!,96!B;3:=B796! 01,9B4;39:96! B;3! 1,! B;36=>;! :1!:0;896F!B;364:109>;6!D04;047904;!?!31B16904;F!13! ,@319! B;3! ;7096! 5;B16! 13! 1,! :1K971F!6=6747=40! ,9! 016D=1679! D139,! D;0! =3! 13I;Y=1!>T6!9>D,4;!:1!:16900;,,;!C=>93;!?!:1!69,=:!D2K,4B9F!!Y=1!D10>479!9593U90!C9B49!016D=16Z
CONCLUSIONES Y RECOMENDACIONES64
![Page 69: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/69.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
796! >T6! C=>9396! ?! 1I1B74596! I01371! 9! ,9!B01B41371!543B=,9B4R3!:1!,96!D106;396!B;3!,;6!>10B9:;6! 4,189,16! :1! :0;896#! .3! D9074B=,90F!B;364:109>;6! 43:46D1369K,1! Y=1! 61! 019,4B1!=39!:16D139,4U9B4R3!1I1B7459!:1,!B;36=>;!:1!6=6793B496! 4,@B4796#! .,,;! 4>D,4B9F! 3;! 6R,;!8909374U90!1,!9BB16;!9!,96!:0;896!Y=1!C;?!6;3!B;364:109:96! 4,189,16! <:1! >;:;! Y=1! 61!01:=UB93! ,;6! :9X;6! Y=1! D=1:1! B9=690! 7937;!1,! 9K=6;! :1! :0;896! B;>;! ,96! D;,@74B96!54813716<F! 643;! 79>K4S3! ,9! :16D139,4U9B4R3!:1! ,9! D;6164R3! D909! B;36=>;#! h01371! 9! ,;6!1I1B7;6! :9X43;6! Y=1! ;B964;39! 1,! =6;! :1,!:101BC;! D139,! ?! ,96! BT0B1,16F! ,9!:16D139,4U9B4R3! 1I1B7459! :1,! B;36=>;! ?! :1!,;6! B;36=>4:;016! 16! ,9! ;DB4R3! >T6! S74B9#!L:1>T6F! 1,,;! 9?=:90@9! 9! 016;,510! ,9! B04646! :1!6;K01D;K,9B4R3! M?! ;70;6! D0;K,1>96!:10459:;6N! Y=1! 9709541693! ,;6! 64671>96!D134713B4904;6!13!L>S04B9#!!
.671!:;B=>137;! 61X9,9! <B;3!:97;6<! ,9! B04646!D134713B49049! 1V4671371! 13! L>S04B9! E97439! ?!,;6!1I1B7;6!9:5106;6!Y=1!,96!9B7=9,16!,1?16!:1!:0;896! C93! 7134:;! 6;K01! ,9! 647=9B4R3!D134713B49049! 39B4;39,#! .,! :;B=>137;!>=16709F! 9:1>T6F! Y=1! ,9! 9D,4B9B4R3! :1! ,9!D;,@74B9! :1!:0;896! <?! 6=6! 1I1B7;6! 3189745;6<3;! 6;3! 01D9074:;6! :1! 48=9,! I;0>9! 13! ,9!6;B41:9:F! 643;! Y=1! D10A=:4B93! 9! B4107;6!61B7;016! Y=1! ?9! 61! 13B;3709K93! 13! =39!647=9B4R3!:1!5=,3109K4,4:9:!6;B49,#! !L371!1679!019,4:9:F!?! 7;>93:;!13!B=1379!1,! 709K9A;!:1!,;6! 43I;0>16! 43:454:=9,16! :1,! -.//F! 61!D0;D;313!,96!648=413716!01B;>13:9B4;316!:1!D;,@74B9!D2K,4B9F! ,96! B=9,16! 741313!D;0!;KA17;!,;8090! =39! D;,@74B9! :1! :0;896! >T6! A=679F!016D17=;69!:1!,;6!:101BC;6!I=3:9>1379,16!?!13I;B9:9! 9! D0;71810! ,9! 69,=:! D2K,4B9! :1! ,96!6;B41:9:16!,9743;9>104B9396#!
Recomendaciones
Reformas Legales:
LA=6790! ,9! 01D=1679! D139,! D909! Y=1! 619!D0;D;0B4;39,! 9,! :9X;!;B964;39:;! ?! 01I;0>90!,96! ,1?16! :1! :0;896! D909! :467438=40! 13701!:1,47;6!:1!>13;0F!>1:49!?!9,79!16B9,9[!13701!3451,16!:1!,4:109U8;!13!,96!01:16!B04>439,16F!?!13701!:1,47;6!54;,137;6!?!3;!54;,137;6#!
W=D04>40! ,96! D1396! >@34>96! ;K,4897;0496F!154790! ,9! :1713B4R3!D015137459!13!1,! B96;!:1!:1,47;6! :1! :0;896! >13;016! ?! D10>4740! 1,!9BB16;!9! ,;6!K131I4B4;6!D0;B169,16F! 96@! B;>;!9!,96!;D;07=34:9:16!:1!D1396!9,7103974596#!!
-;364:1090! ,9! 9D,4B9B4R3! :1! 9>3467@96!16D1B49,16! M43:=,7;6NF! D909! ,96! D106;396!613713B49:96!D;0!:1,47;6!>13;016!:1!:0;896F!D;0! :1,47;6! 3;! 54;,137;6F! 96@! B;>;! D909!D106;396! 643! 9371B1:13716! D139,16! ;!613713B49:96!6;,9>1371!D;0!:1,47;6!>13;016!:1!:0;896#!
\0;>;510! 1,! 1679K,1B4>4137;! :1! >10B9:;6!,189,16! ?! 018=,9:;6! :1! B9339K46F! 43B,=?13:;!B,=K16! :1! B9339K46F! ?! 1VD,;090! ;DB4;316! :1!9BB16;! 018=,9:;! D909! ;7096! 6=6793B496!:1B,909:96!4,@B4796#!!
65
Fotografía: Matías Torres. Fotógrafo de la Unidad de Comunicaciones, Gendarmería de Chile.
CONCLUSIONES Y RECOMENDACIONES
![Page 70: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/70.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
Uso de drogas y la ley:
/16B04>439,4U90! 1,! B;36=>;! :1! :0;896! ?!:171310!7;:9!B,961!:1!D1061B=B4R3!B;3709!,;6!B;36=>4:;016F! 43B,=?13:;! ,9! D;6164R3F!641>K09F! B=,745;! ?! B;>D09#! .6! :1B40F! 61!01B;>413:9! 69B90! :1,! :101BC;! D139,! 7;:96!,96!B;3:=B796!31B1690496!D909!,,1590!9!B9K;!1,!B;36=>;F! 96@! B;>;! :1A90! :1! =690! 9! ,;6!B=10D;6! :1! D;,4B@96! M=! ;7096! 436793B496!618=04:9:N! B;>;! D04>1096! 436747=B4;316! :1!9B10B9>4137;!9!,;6!B;36=>4:;016#!!
^690!=>K09,16!D909!I4A90!B9374:9:16!>@34>96F!K969:96! 13! 9713B4R3! 9! ,96! D0TB74B96! :1! ,;6!B;36=>4:;016F!D;0!:1K9A;!:1!,96!B=9,16!3;!61!D=1:9! 1679K,1B10! 9B7454:9:! :1! B;>10B4;F!D10;! 643! D10>4740! Y=1! D;0! 13B4>9! :1! :4BC96!B9374:9:16! ,96! D106;396! D=1:93! 610!693B4;39:96! D;0! :46704K=B4R3! ?! 70TI4B;#! .3!7;:;6!,;6!B96;6F!1,!.679:;!:1K1!D0;K90!Y=1!,9!43713B4R3! :1! ,9! D;6164R3! 16! ,9! 51379! ;!:46704K=B4R3! B;>;! B;3:4B4R3! D909! 693B4;390!:4BC9!B;3:=B79#!!
HI01B10!61054B4;6!:1!70979>4137;!5;,=37904;!?!8097=47;! 9! ,96! D106;396! Y=1! D01613793! =6;!D0;K,1>T74B;! :1! :0;896F! 7937;! B=93:;!B;>1713!;70;6!:1,47;6!B;>;!B=93:;!3;#!.671!70979>4137;! 3;! :1K1! 16790! 6=A17;! 9! ,9!9>139U9!:1!=39!693B4R3!D139,!;!4371039B4R3!B;>D=,6459#! /4BC;6! 70979>4137;6! :1K13!6=671379061! 13! 154:13B49! B4137@I4B9F! B;3! =3!13I;Y=1!:1!01:=BB4R3!:1!:9X;6F!?!:1K13!610!,,159:;6!D;0!D0;I164;39,16!:1!,9!69,=:F!3;!D;0!A=1B16!D139,16#!!
Mujeres y encarcelamiento:
_1:=B40! 64834I4B97459>1371! ,;6! 3451,16! :1!13B90B1,9>4137;! :1! >=A1016F! ?9! 619! D;0!>1:4;! :1! ,9! 9D,4B9B4R3! :1,! D043B4D4;! :1!
D0;D;0B4;39,4:9:! ;! D;0! ,9! 9:;DB4R3! :1!9,7103974596! :4I1013716! 9,! 13B90B1,9>4137;F!7937;! 13! 6=6747=B4R3! :1,! =6;! :1! ,9! D0464R3!D015137459F! B;>;!13! 1,! B=>D,4>4137;!:1! ,96!613713B496#!
Q;! 13B90B1,90! 9! ,96! >=A1016! 1>K909U9:96! ?!>9:016!:1!>13;016!:1!1:9:!B;3:139:96!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!3;!54;,137;6#!.3!1,!B96;!:1!16796! >=A1016F! :1K1! B;364:109061! ,9!9D,4B9B4R3! :1! 9,7103974596! 9,! 13B90B1,9Z>4137;#!
L618=090! Y=1! ,;6! ;D109:;016! :1! A=674B49!713893! ,9! I,1V4K4,4:9:! :1! 7;>90! 13! B=1379F!:=09371! 1,! D0;B16;! ?! :1710>439B4R3! :1! ,9!613713B49F! ,;6! I9B7;016!:1!5=,3109K4,4:9:!?! 64!,9!9B=69:9!74131!:1D13:413716#!!
Jóvenes y adolescentes:
P>D,1>13790! D;,@74B96! D2K,4B96! 4371809,16!:40484:96!9!,;6!?!,96!AR51316!?!9:;,16B13716F!?!9593U90!C9B49!=3! B9>K4;!:1,! 9B7=9,! 13I;Y=1!16748>974U9:;0! ?! :1! B04>439,4U9B4R3! Y=1!1V4671!6;K01!1,,;6#!!LD,4B90F! 13! ,;6! B96;6! :1! AR51316F! ,;6!K131I4B4;6!?! ,96!9,7103974596!Y=1! ,96! ,1?16!:1!1A1B=B4R3!:1!D1396F!:1!,;6!:4I1013716!D9@616F!1679K,1B13!D909!169!I093A9!179049#!!-=>D,40! B;3! ,96! ,1?16! Y=1! 1679K,1B13! ,;6!64671>96!:1!`=674B49!\139,!D909!L:;,16B13716F!,;6! B=9,16! 018=,93! ,9! 016D=1679! 167979,! D909!:1,47;6! B;>174:;6! D;0! D106;396!>13;016! :1!('!9X;6F!?!Y=1!1679K,1B13!Y=1!,9!D0459B4R3!:1!,9! ,4K1079:!:1! ,;6!9:;,16B13716!:1K1!610!6R,;!=39! 1VB1DB4R3[! 9:1>T6F! 61! :1K1! B;364:1090!Y=1!,96!>1A;016!693B4;316!13!167;6!B96;6!6;3!9Y=1,,96! Y=1! 3;! 4>D,4B93! 13B4100;F! 79,16!B;>;! ,9! ,4K1079:! 964674:9! ;! ,9! D01679B4R3! :1!
CONCLUSIONES Y RECOMENDACIONES66
![Page 71: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/71.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
61054B4;6! 9! ,9! B;>=34:9:F! 96@! B;>;! ,;6!:45106;6! 01B=06;6! Y=1! ,96! ,1?16! 1679K,1B13!D909!016;,510!,;6!B96;6!I=109!:1!,9!5@9!A=:4B49,F!?! 9! 7095S6! :1! ,9! A=674B49! 01679=097459#!L64>46>;F! :1K13! 9B;079061! ,96! D1396!>TV4>96! D909! :1,47;6! B;>174:;6! D;0!>13;016! :1! 1:9:F! ?! :1! 1679! >93109! 3;!1VB1:10! ,;6! 1679K,1B4:;6! 13! 43670=>137;6!4371039B4;39,16#!!/;790! :1! 01B=06;6! 6=I4B413716! 9! ,;6! 64671>96!:1!`=674B49!\139,!D909!L:;,16B13716F!9! I43!:1!Y=1! I=3B4;313!:1! I;0>9! 16D1B49,4U9:9F! A=679!?! 1I4B41371F! 648=413:;! ,;! 1679K,1B4:;! D;0! ,9!-;3513B4R3! 6;K01! ,;6! /101BC;6! :1,! Q4X;! ?!;70;6! 167T3:9016! 4371039B4;39,16! 6;K01! ,9!>971049#!!Alternativas al encarcelamiento:
_19,4U90! ,96! 01I;0>96! 31B1690496! D909!4>D,1>13790!9,7103974596!9,!13B90B1,9>4137;!B;3! 16704B7;! 9D18;! 9! ,;6! :101BC;6! :1! ,96!D106;396! 435;,=B09:96! 13! ,9! B;>464R3! :1!B;3:=B796! 01,9B4;39:96! B;3! :0;896F!D907413:;!:1!=3!:4983R674B;!9:1B=9:;!6;K01!B=T,16! 610@93! ,96! >1:4:96! Y=1! D10>47410;3!;D74>4U90! ,;6! 01B=06;6! :46D;34K,16! 13! B9:9!D9@6F! ?! B;3! 1,,;! 01:=B40! 1,! C9B439>4137;!B90B1,904;F! 96@! B;>;! ,9! 0143B4:13B49! 13! ,9!B;>464R3!:1!:1,47;6#!!
L618=090F! 13! ,9! >1:4:9! :1! ,;! D;64K,1F! 1,!:165@;! 93716! :1! Y=1! ,;6! B96;6! 137013! 13! 1,!64671>9! D139,F! ,;! B=9,! D=1:1! D10>4740! =3!>1A;0! =6;! :1! ,;6! 01B=06;6! :1,! .679:;! ?!>9?;016! ;D;07=34:9:16! :1! K41316790! ?!1>D,1;!D909!Y=41316!61!13B=137093!13!16796!647=9B4;316#!!
\0;>;510! ,96! 01I;0>96! 31B1690496! D909!D10>4740! Y=1! ;I136;016! :1! :1,47;6! >13;016!:1!:0;896!3;!54;,137;6!6193!:10459:;6!9!=39!01:! D2K,4B9! :1! 9D;?;! D909! D0151340!4371809,>1371! ,9! 0143B4:13B49F! 13! 51U! :1! 610!13549:;6! 9! D0464R3F! 9713:413:;! 96@! ,;6!I9B7;016! 6;B4;1B;3R>4B;6! Y=1! ,,1590;3! 9! ,9!B;>464R3!:1!16796!B;3:=B796#!!
Elaboración y Evaluación de Políticas de Drogas:
a909374U90! ?! 9>D,490! ,9! D9074B4D9B4R3! 13! 1,!:461X;F! 4>D,1>1379B4R3! ?! 159,=9B4R3! :1! ,96!D;,@74B96! :1! :0;896! :1! ,9! 6;B41:9:! B454,! ?F!16D1B49,>1371F! :1! ,;6! ?! ,96! =6=904;6! :1!:0;896! 13B90B1,9:96F! :1! ,96! >=A1016F!D106;396! EabOF! 43:@81396F! 9I0;6! ?! ;70;6!61B7;016! :1! ,9! D;K,9B4R3! Y=1! 167T3! 13!647=9B4;316!:1!5=,3109K4,4:9:!?!Y=1!C93!64:;!4>D9B79:;6! :16D0;D;0B4;39,>1371! D;0! ,96!D;,@74B96!:1!:0;896#!
E,1590! 9! B9K;! =3! :4983R674B;! 6104;! 13! B9:9!D9@6! Y=1! D10>479! 13713:10! ?! 939,4U90! ,;6!4>D9B7;6! ?! ,9! 1I4B9B49! :1! ,96! D;,@74B96! :1!:0;896! 9B7=9,16F! B;3! 1,! D0;DR647;! :1!:16900;,,90! 1! 4>D,1>13790! D;,@74B96! >T6!C=>9396F!1I4B9B16!?!A=6796#!!
c1A;090! ?! 9>D,490! ,;6! 64671>96! :1!01B;,1BB4R3F! 64671>974U9B4R3! ?! 159,=9B4R3! :1!,;6!:97;6!:1! ,9! A=674B49!D139,! ?! 9618=090!Y=1!;I4B49,16! :1,! 8;K4103;! ?! 1,! D2K,4B;! 713893!9BB16;! ;D;07=3;! 9! :4BC9! 43I;0>9B4R3#! .67;!610540T! D909! 9618=090! ,9! 159,=9B4R3! :1! ,9!D;,@74B9! :1! :0;896! ?! 6=6! 1I1B7;6F! D10;!79>K4S3! D909! ,;8090! :4983R674B;6! 9B1079:;6!6;K01!1,!D0;K,1>9!Y=1!61!K=6B9!9713:10#!
! !
67CONCLUSIONES Y RECOMENDACIONES
![Page 72: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/72.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
LBCTF!_#!c#!M%$(&N#!.,!43:=,7;!?!,;6!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896G!,;6!016=,79:;6!:1!,9!9D,4B9B4R3!:1,!43:=,7;!13!b;,4549!?!6=!4>D9B7;!6;K01!,96!D106;396!13B90B1,9:96!K9A;!,9!E1?!($$'#!cSV4B;!/#hG!-;,1B745;!:1!.67=:4;6!/0;896!?!/101BC;#!
LBCTF!_#!c#!M%$()N#!`R51316!?!9:;,16B13716!D0459:;6!:1!,4K1079:!D;0!:0;896!13!L>S04B9!E97439#!cSV4B;!/#hG!-;,1B745;!:1!.67=:4;6!/0;896!?!/101BC;#!
LC90;36;3F!.#!!M%$($N#!\0;Zc43;047?#!-04>439,4U974;3!93:!7C1!O0936I;0>974;3!;I!o464;36!;I!-474U136C4D!43!-;371>D;090?!E4K109,!/1>;B09B416G!L!-0474Y=1#!B!C#D1)2),$%#'$C#E!/)!CF#G,#H,"!1,$")7,$%#$,(#H,"!1()6*)-%),$1I#J7.1,$%0F!o;,#("F!DD#!%'&Z"$'#!
L5107#!M%$()N!\046;3106!93:!jPo]LP/W#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]vvv#95107#;08]D0;I1664;39,6]C45Z6;B49,Z466=16]k1?Z9II1B71:ZD;D=,974;36]D046;3106ÖI;;73;7101I)Ü="U;6,0#!
b93B;!c=3:49,#!!M%$(&N#!\;K,9B4R3#!/46D;34K,1!13G!:979#v;0,:K93k#;08]43:4B97;0]W\#\H\#OHOE!
b90:9U93;F!a#!d!W9,9>93;F!P#!M%$(&N#!\0459B4R3!:1!,4K1079:!?!,1846,9B4R3!6;K01!:0;896!13!^0=8=9?#!cSV4B;!/#hG!-;,1B745;!:1!.67=:4;6!/0;896!?!/101BC;#!
b90:9U93;F!a#!M%$(%N#!W1!D016=>1!B=,D9K,1#!W;K01!,9!A=674I4B9B4R3!:1!,96!:1B464;316!A=:4B49,16!01,974596!9!,9!43710D0179B4R3!:1,!907@B=,;!"(!:1,!/1B017;!E1?!(g#%+g!13!6=!01:9BB4R3!:9:9!D;0!,9!E1?!(*#$(&#!.3!LL#ooF!G-71"!#K,)/!16)"$1)7#$%#L!=$"!#B$*)7,$%#67=1!#L174$6F!DD#!"+Z&(#!!c;37154:1;G!-WP-Z^/.EL_#!
b90017;F!L#!d!c9:09U;F!L#!M%$()N#!E;6!B;67;6!B;36747=B4;39,16!:1!,9!8=1009!B;3709!,96!:0;896G!:;6!167=:4;6!:1!B96;!:1!,96!70936I;0>9B4;316!:1!,96!B;>=34:9:16!D;,@74B96!:1!,96!L>S04B96#!H67,725$&!Mg"NF!DD#!()(Z(+"#!
b9=6693;F!P#F!J4,,49>6F!b#F!Q=33F!\#F!b188497;F!c#F!h1:1,4F!^#!d!WB93;F!h#!M%$($N#!O=K10B=,;646!43:4:13B1!43!D046;36G!L!W?671>974B!_1541v#!M'7N#O9(0!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]K47#,?]%CgVCP+!!
b108>93F!c#F!c9661,;F!/#F!L0496F!-#F!h;3:154,9F!a#!d!o4,9,79F!-#!M%$(gN#!/1,47;F!>908439,4:9:!?!:161>D1X;!436747=B4;39,!13!,9!L08137439G!016=,79:;6!:1!,9!13B=1679!:1!D016;6!B;3:139:;6#!WT13U!\1X9G!^3451064:9:!Q9B4;39,!:1!O016!:1!h1K010;#!
b;471=VF!E#F!-C1034BC90;F!E#F!d!E1u;!:1!LY=43;F!L#!E#!M%$(&N#!/0;896!?!D0464R3G!1,!4>D9B7;!:1!,9!01D0164R3!D139,!9,!70TI4B;!:1!:0;896!13!1,!6=D1013B90B1,9>4137;!13!b0964,!M%$$&Z%$(&N#!cSV4B;!/#hG!-;,1B745;6!:1!.67=:4;6!/0;896!?!/101BC;#!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!B I B
L I O G
R A
F Í A
BIBLIOGRAFÍA
BIB
LIO
GR
AF
ÍA
68
![Page 73: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/73.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
b;471=VF!E#!M%$()N#!c=A1016!?!13B90B1,9>4137;!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896#!cSV4B;!/#hG!-;,1B745;!:1!.67=:4;6!/0;896!?!/101BC;#!/46D;34K,1!13G! !C77DG]]vvv#:0;896?:101BC;#;08]D=K,4B9B4;316]D=KZD045]E=B4939Ü5$'#D:I!
b;471=VF!E#F!d!J41Bk;F!.#!M%$$+N#!O0TI4B;!:1!:0;896!?!-;36747=B4R3#!b0964,49G!c43467104;!:1!,9!`=674B49#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]K47#,?]%C*7B3"!
b;471=VF!E#!M%$$&N#!L!3;59!,14!9374:0;896!1!9=>137;!:9!D139!:;!:1,47;!:1!70TI4B;!:1!137;0D1B13716!Ä^39!3=159!,1?!9374:0;896!?!1,!9=>137;!:1!,9!D139!D909!1,!:1,47;!:1,!70TI4B;!:1!167=D1I9B413716Ç#!P7%!")2#HPD*1)20!(&*!M(gNF!;B7=K01F!DD#!'Z+#!
-94B1:;F!E#!\#!M%$()N#!E9!647=9B4R3!D9074B=,90!:1!,96!>=A1016!01B,=4:96!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896#!.Y=46!`=674B49!D909!,96!c=A1016[!-;0D;09B4R3!j=>939!:1!-;,;>K49!?!-C4,1#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]vvv#C=>9396#;08#B;]90BC45;6]W47=9B4;3D9074B=,90>=A101601B,=4:96D;0:1,47;6:0;896#D:I!
-906;3F!.#!L#!M%$()N#!\0464;3106!43!%$(g#!^#W#!/1D907>137!;I!`=674B1!HII4B1!;I!`=674B1!\0;809>6!b=019=!;I!`=674B1!W7974674B6#!/46D;34K,1!13G! !C77D6G]]vvv#KA6#8;5]B;37137]D=K]D:I]D(g#D:I!
-9=,k436F!`#!d!-C93:,10F!W#!M%$$&N#!E;38Z0=3!7013:6!43!43B90B10974;3!;I!:0=8!;II13:106!43!7C1!^#W#!-04>1!d!/1,43Y=13B?F!DD#!&(+Z&g(#!/46D;34K,1!
13G!C77DG]]A;=039,6#6981D=K#B;>]:;4!]D:I]($#((**]$$(((%'*$)%'g*+"!
-.//#!M%$(gN#!.3!K=6B9!:1!,;6!:101BC;6G!=6=904;6!:1!:0;896!?!,96!016D=16796!167979,16!13!L>S04B9!E97439#!cSV4B;!/#hG!-;,1B745;!:1!.67=:4;6!/0;896!?!/101BC;#!/46D;34K,1!13G!!C77DG]]K47#,?]%8J>5+4!!!
-.//#!M%$(%N#!`=674B49!:16>1:4:9!D0;D;0B4;39,4:9:!?!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!13!L>S04B9!E97439#!cSV4B;!/#hG!h;379>909!Z!-;,1B745;!:1!.67=:4;6!/0;896!?!/101BC;#!
-1370;!:1!.67=:4;6!E189,16!?!W;B49,16!M-.EWN#!M%$((N#!c=A1016!13!\0464R3G!,;6!9,B93B16!:1,!-96748;#!c43467104;!\2K,4B;!:1!,9!/1I1369!:1!,9!Q9B4R3[!\0;B=09B4R3!\134713B49049!:1!,9!Q9B4R3#!b=13;6!L4016G!W48,;!o14374=3;#!
-1370;!Q9B4;39,!:1!c1>;049!j467R04B9#!M%$("N#!áb9679!É9à!c1>;0496!:1!a=1009!?!/4834:9:#!b;8;7TG!-1370;!Q9B4;39,!:1!c1>;049!j467R04B9#!
-C9D900;F!W#!d!\S01U!-;0019F!-#!M%$(*N#!!W;K01:;646!B90B1,9049!?!D;,@74B9!:1!:0;896!13!L>S04B9!E97439#!b;8;7TG!/1`=674B49Z-.//#!M.3!4>D01379N#!
-C1631?ZE43:F!c#!M%$$"N#!P>D046;3438!v;>13G!7C1!=343713:1:!54B74>6!;I!>966!4>D046;3>137#!.3!c#!-C1631?!E43:F!d!c#!c9=10!M.:6#N#!H,/)6)=%!#-.,)6;2!,"F#";!#*7%%$"!1$%#*7,6!<.!,*!6#7:#2$66#)2-1)67,2!,"0!Q1v!É;0kG!Q1v!\0166#!
BIBLIOGRAFÍA 69 69
![Page 74: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/74.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
-P-L/ZH.L#!M%$()N#!P3I;0>1!7SB34B;!6;K01!9,7103974596!9,!13B90B1,9>4137;!D909!,;6!:1,47;6!01,9B4;39:;6!B;3!:0;896#!b;8;7TG!H08934U9B4R3!:1!.679:;6!L>104B93;6#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]K47#,?](W$QjCA!!
-P/j#!M%$("N#!P3I;0>1!6;K01!1,!=6;!:1!,9!D0464R3!D015137459!13!,96!L>S04B96#!J96C4387;3!/#-G!HLW!Z!-P/j#!/;B=>137;6!;I4B49,16#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]vvv#;96#;08]16]B4:C]DD,]43I;0>16]D:I6]43I;0>1ZDDZ%$("Z16#D:I!
-P/j#!M%$((N#!P3I;0>1!6;K01!,;6!:101BC;6!C=>93;6!:1!,96!D106;396!D0459:96!:1!,9!,4K1079:!13!,96!L>S04B96#!J96C4387;3G!HLW!Z!-P/j#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77D6G]]vvv#;96#;08]16]B4:C]DD,]:;B6]D:I]\\E%$((16D#D:I!
-;,1B745;!`=939!`=,49!a=U>T3#!M%$$+N#!E9!69,=:!61V=9,!?!01D0;:=B7459!13!,96!BT0B1,16!:1!>=A1016!13!-;,;>K49#!b;8;7T#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]vvv#B;,1B745;:19K;89:;6#;08]B9A90Ü;,:]6D4D#DCD!�9074B,1(*&"!
-;>464R3!L616;09!:1!\;,@74B9!-04>439,#!M%$(%N#!/4983R674B;!?!D0;D=1679!:1!,4319>4137;6!:1!D;,@74B9!B04>439,!D909!1,!.679:;!B;,;>K493;#!b;8;7TG!c43467104;!:1!`=674B49!?!:1,!/101BC;#!
-;>464R3!.D46B;D9,!:1!LBB4R3!W;B49,#!M%$()N#!E;!Y=1!=3!981371!:1!D967;09,!:1!BT0B1,16!:1K10!B;3;B10#!E4>9G!.Y=4D;!Q9B4;39,!:1!\967;09,!:1!-T0B1,16#!
-;>47S!B;3709!,9!O;07=09!:1!,9!-;>464R3!\0;543B49,!D;0!,9!c1>;049#!M%$("N#!
P3I;0>1!93=9,!%$(%#!.,!64671>9!:1!,9!B0=1,:9:!oPP#!
-;0:9F!L#!M%$(&N#!E9!1670971849!I9,,4:9#!.3B90B1,9>4137;6!D;0!:1,47;6!01,9B4;39:;6!B;3!167=D1I9B413716!13!L08137439#!cSV4B;!/#hG!-;,1B745;!:1!.67=:4;6!/0;896!?!/101BC;#!
-;07S6F!.#!M%$(&N#!\;,@74B9!-04>439,!?!13B90B1,9>4137;6!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!13!-;679!_4B9#!cSV4B;!/#hG!-;,1B745;!:1!.67=:4;6!/0;896!?!/101BC;#!
-;07S6F!.#!M%$()N#!-;>D093:;!>41:;#!\106;396!=6=90496!:1!B09Bk!13!-;679!_4B9#!W93!`;6SG!ELQ\^/#!
-;07S6F!.#!M%$("N#!-;370;,!6;B49,!:1,!B;36=>;!:1!:0;896!13!-;679!_4B9G!D909!;0413790!,96!D;,@74B96!39B4;39,16!:1!:0;896!C9B49!1,!13I;Y=1!:1!:101BC;6!C=>93;6#!W93!`;6SG!^3451064:9:!D909!,9!-;;D109B4R3!P371039B4;39,#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]K47#,?]%C*>9(V!
-;61BC9!_;A9#!M&!:1!A=34;!:1!%$(gN#!-R>;!54513!,;6!34X;6!13!,9!BT0B1,#!-;61BC9!_;A9#!/46D;34K,1!13G! !C77DG]]K47#,?]%8BI`83!!
-;?,1F!L#F!h940F!j#F!`9B;K6;3F!`#!d!J9,>6,1?F!_#!M%$(&N#!P>D046;3>137!J;0,:v4:1#!OC1!B=00137!647=974;3!93:!93!9,710397451!I=7=01#!b0467;,G!\;,4B?!\0166#!
/LQ.#!M%$("N#!\;K01U9!>;3179049!?!>=,74:4>1364;39,#!b;,17@3!:1!D01369#!b;8;7T#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77D6G]]vvv#:931#8;5#B;]43:1V#DCD]1679:4674B96ZD;0Z71>9]D;K01U9Z?Z
BIBLIOGRAFÍA70
![Page 75: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/75.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
B;3:4B4;316Z:1Z54:9]D;K01U9Z?Z:1648=9,:9:]D;K01U9Z>;3179049Z?Z>=,74:4>1364;39,Z%$("ÖD;K01U9Z>;3179049Z?Z>=,74:4>1364;39,Z13ZB;,;>K49Z%$("!
/1I1369!\2K,4B9!:1!-;679!_4B9#!M%$(%N#!.67=:4;!:1!,9!/1I1369!\2K,4B9!6;K01!1,!D10I4,!:1!,9!D;K,9B4R3!I1>13439!D0459:9!:1!,4K1079:!D;0!4370;:=B40!:0;89!9!,;6!B1370;6!D139,16!9!9K04,!:1!%$(%#!W93!`;6SF!-;679!_4B9#!
/1D9079>137;!\134713B4904;!Q9B4;39,!:1!b0964,#!M%$(&N#!E159379>137;!Q9B4;39,!:1!P3I;0>9sâ16!\134713B490496!P3I;D13!Z!/1U1>K0;!%$(g#!b0964,49G!c43467S04;!:9!`=674B9!:;!b0964,#!/46D;34K,1!13G! !j77DG]]K47#,?]%8,^D3)!!
.,!O1,S809I;#!M_1:9BB4R3!`=674B49N#!M%+!:1!A=34;!:1!%$()N#!r"*'#g"'!K4,,;316!:1!:;646!:1!:0;89!43B9=79:96!13701!%$$*!?!%$()#!/46D;34K,1!13G! !C77DG]]vvv#1,71,1809I;#B;>#1B]3;74B496]A=674B49](]"*'Zg"'ZK4,,;316Z:1Z:;646Z:1Z:0;89Z43B9=79:96Z13701Z%$$*Z?Z%$()!
.,!O41>D;#!M%$()N#!j9?!(gg!B;,;>K493;6!B;3:139:;6!9!>=1071!;!9!B9:139!D10D17=9!13!1,!>=3:;#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]vvv#1,741>D;#B;>]D;,474B9]A=674B49]B;,;>K493;6ZB;3:139:;6Z9ZD139Z:1Z>=1071Z;ZB9:139ZD10D17=9Z13Z;70;6ZD94616]()"g(**)!
h=3:9B4R3!-;3670=40#!M%$(gN#!\0464R3!D015137459!?!:101BC;6!C=>93;6G!
167=:4;!:1!B96;!13!BT0B1,16!:1!E9!\9U#!E9!\9U#!
a90,93:F!/#!M%$$(N#!OC1!-=,7=01!;I!-;370;,G!-04>1!93:!W;B49,!H0:10!43!-;371>D;090?!W;B417?F!-C4B98;G!^34510647?!;I!-C4B98;!\0166#!
a90UR3F!`#F!-#!M%$()N#!O;=8C!;3!7C1!v19kF!v19k!;3!7C1!7;=8CG!:0=8!,9v6!93:!D;,4B438#!J96C4387;3!/#-G!J;;:0;v!J4,6;3!P37103974;39,!-13710!I;0!WBC;,906#!
a49B;>1,,;F!-#!d!b,96F!P#!M%$(&N#!\0;D=16796!:1!01I;0>9!13!B96;6!:1!>=A1016!13B90B1,9:96!D;0!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!13!cSV4B;#!cSV4B;!/#hG!.Y=46!`=674B49!D909!,96!c=A1016!Z!PQL-P\.#!
j9=610F!P#!M%&!:1!1310;!:1!%$(&N#!^3!01BC9U;!>=,74D9074:904;!9!,9!1>10813B49#!M@4),$#QR#!/46D;34K,1!13G! !C77DG]]K47#,?](}'KCK.!!
j=69kF!/#!M%$$'N#!!H510B04>439,4U974;3G!OC1!E4>476!;I!7C1!-04>439,!E9v#!HVI;0:G!HVI;0:!^34510647?!\0166#!
P3:1D9U#!M%$()N#!o4B4;6!D139,16#!-=,7459:;016!:1!B;B9F!9>9D;,9!?!>904C=939!13!,9!C;09!:1!6=!:16D139,4U9B4R3#!b;8;7TG!P3:1D9U#!!
/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]K47#,?]%CCl`k`!!
P36747=7;!Q9B4;39,!\134713B4904;!MPQ\.N#!M%$(gN#!P3I;0>1!1679:@674B;!%$(g#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]K47#,?]%AAbaY3!
P36747=7;!Q9B4;39,!\134713B4904;!?!-90B1,904;!:1!-;,;>K49!MPQ\.-N#!M%$(&N#!.679:@674B96!D134713B490496#! !
BIBLIOGRAFÍA 71
![Page 76: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/76.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
/46D;34K,1!13G! !C77DG]]vvv#43D1B#8;5#B;]D;079,]D981]D;079,]P3D1B]P36747=B4;3].679:m./674B96].679:4674B96].679:m./674B96!
P36747=7;!Q9B4;39,!\134713B4904;!?!-90B1,904;!:1!-;,;>K49!MPQ\.-N#!M%$(gN#!P3I;0>1!.679:@674B;#!/4B41>K01!%$(g#!/46D;34K,1!13G! !C77DG]]vvv#43D1B#8;5#B;]D;079,]D981]D;079,]P3D1B]P36747=B4;3].679:m./674B96].679:4674B96]P3I;0>16m%$?m%$b;,174316m%$.679:m./674B;6]PQhH_c.m%$/P-P.cb_.m%$%$(gÜ$#D:I!
P36747=7;!Q9B4;39,!\134713B4904;!?!-90B1,904;!:1!-;,;>K49!MPQ\.-N#!M%$(gN#!P3I;0>1!.679:@674B;F!`=,4;!%$(g#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]vvv#43D1B#8;5#B;]D;079,]D981]D;079,]P3D1B]P36747=B4;3].679:m./674B96].679:4674B96]P3I;0>16m%$?m%$b;,174316m%$.679:m./674B;6]PQhH_c.m%$_..c\ELiH`^EPHm%$%$(g#D:I!
P36747=7;!:1!\16Y=4696!.B;3R>4B96!LD,4B9:96#!M%$()N#!E9!9D,4B9B4R3!:1!D1396!?!>1:4:96!9,7103974596#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]K47#,?]%8J5aY'!!
P36747=7;!O1009F!O09K9,C;!1!-4:9:9349#!M%$((N#!c=A1016!1V7093A1096!13!647=9B4R3!:1!B;3I,4B7;!B;3!,9!E1?#!\10@;:;G!3;541>K01!:1!%$($!9!3;541>K01!:1!%$((#!W9;!\9=,;#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]K47#,?]%C,1C3w!!
`1626F!c#!a#F!HPF!L#F!_;BC9F!O#!d!E989779F!\#!M%$((N#!\0464R3!\0;546;049!?!E1?!:1!/0;896G!=3!167=:4;!6;K01!,;6!I,98093716!:1!70TI4B;!:1!:0;896!13!,9!B4=:9:!:1!W9;!\9=,;#!W9;!\9=,;G!Q.oZ
^W\#!/46D;34K,1!13G! !C77DG]]K47#,?]%8/j\Qj!!
}136?F!`#F!W71381,F!-#F!Q;=8410F!c#!d!b40843F!_#!M%$(%N#!/0=8!\;,4B?!93:!J;>13G!L:0166438!7C1!Q1897451!-;361Y=13B16!;I!j90>I=,!/0=8!-;370;,#!P37103974;39,!/0=8!\;,4B?!-;36;074=>#!/46D;34K,1!13G! !C77DG]]K47#,?]%CCÉb+*!!!
c9381,43BkVF!`#!M%$(&N#!E=BC9!B;3709!,96!:0;896!13!\102G!=39!K979,,9!D10:4:9#!E4>9G!-;,1B745;!:1!.67=:4;6!/0;896!?!/101BC;F!-1370;!:1!P35167489B4;316!13!/0;896!?!/101BC;6!j=>93;6#!
c9381,43BkVF!`#!M%$("N#!.,!D043B4D4;!:1!D0;D;0B4;39,4:9:!13!,;6!D0;B16;6!D;0!70TI4B;!4,@B47;!:1!:0;896!13!1,!\102#!.3!`#!\9,9:4316!M-;;0:#N#!9%#9<.)%)=1)7#M!1()(7F#(174$6#I#-17-71*)7,$%)($(#!,#%$6#S.6")*)$6#(!#G2T1)*$&#DD#!%")Z"$$#!w=47;G!/1I136;0@9!\2K,4B9!:1,!.B=9:;0#!
c936I41,:F!/#!M%$(&N#!c46=3:106793:438!7C1!P371061B74;3!b17v113!/151,;D>137!\;,4B416!93:!/979!-;,,1B74;3G!-961!W7=:?F!LI8C9346793[!LI710!7C1!/0=8!J906#!E!-71"#7:#";!#'N9#9U-!1"#V17.-#7,#";!#9*7,72)*6#7:#L1.4#M7%)*IF!DD#!(%*Z(g$#!E;3:;3G!E;3:;3!WBC;;,!;I!.B;3;>4B6!93:!\;,474B9,!WB413B1#!
c9704V!}3;v,1:81!a0;=D#!OC1!.B;3;>4B!B961!I;0!93:!9894367!D046;3#!E;3:;3G!c9704V!}3;v,1:81!a0;=DF!%$$*#!
c1A@9F!W#!M%$(gN#!E96!K9001096!:1!9BB16;!9,!:101BC;!I=3:9>1379,!9!,9!69,=:!:1!,9!>=A10!1>K909U9:9!01B,=4:9!13!
BIBLIOGRAFÍA72
![Page 77: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/77.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
-;,;>K49!13!D106D1B7459!:1!:101BC;6#!G,$%!*"$#M7%5")*$F!o;,#g!M*NF!DD#!"(+Z"g"#!
c1799,F!\#!d!E;4F!o#!M%$(&N#!O13:13B416!43!v;0,:!4>D046;3>137!I;0!:0=8!01,971:!B04>1#!cSV4B;!/#hG!-;,1B745;!:1!.67=:4;6!/0;896!?!/101BC;#!
cSV4B;!.59,29#!M%$($N#!ä3:4B1!:1!/161>D1X;!:1,!W4671>9!\139,!%$($#!cSV4B;G!cSV4B;!.59,29#!
c43467104;!:1!`=674B49!?!:1,!/101BC;#!L3T,4646!:1!96D1B7;6!D0;B169,16!?!D970;316!:1!A=:4B49,4U9B4R3!D;0!1,!:1,47;!:1!70TI4B;!:1!:0;896!13!-;,;>K49!?!:1!,9!D0;D;0B4;39,4:9:!13!,96!D1396!4>D=16796#!c43467104;!:1!`=674B49!?!:1,!/101BC;#!M.3!4>D01379N#!
c43467104;!:1!`=674B49!?!:1,!/101BC;#!.679:@674B96!6;K01!B04>439,4:9:!13!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896#!M()!:1!A=,4;!:1!%$(&N#!/46D;34K,1!13G! !C77DG]]vvv#>43A=674B49#8;5#B;]\;079,6]$]c43467104;]W4671>9Z43:4B9:;016]W4671>9Z43:4B9:;016]B04>439,ZD;,:0;8#C7>,#!
Q974;39,!_16190BC!-;=3B4,#!M%$$(N#!P3I;0>438!L>104B9q6!\;,4B?!;3!P,,189,!/0=86G!JC97!J1!/;3q7!}3;v!}11D6!j=07438!^6#!-#h!c936k4F!`#o!\1DD10!?!-#o#!\17041!M.:6#N#!J96C4387;3!/#-G!Q974;39,!LB9:1>?!\0166#!
Hj-j_#!M%$()N#!W7=:?!;3!7C1!4>D9B7!;I!7C1!v;0,:!:0=8!D0;K,1>!;3!7C1!13A;?>137!;I!C=>93!048C76#!"$7C!j=>93!_48C76!-;=3B4,!W1664;36#!!
H3=64:9#!M%$(gN#!OC1!a9D!_1D;07#!^3471:!Q974;36#!/46D;34K,1!13G!!C77DG]]K47#,?]%C,'"oD!!!
H08934U9B4R3!:1!.679:;6!L>104B93;6!MH.LN#!M%$("N#!.,!D0;K,1>9!:1!,96!:0;896!13!,96!L>S04B96#!/46D;34K,1!13G! !C77DG]]K47#,?]%8BD"v$!!
H08934U9B4R3!:1!.679:;6!L>104B93;6!MH.LN#!_16;,=B4R3!:1!,9!L69>K,19!a13109,F!La]_.W#!%)($!MlllPlZH]$+NF!9D0;K9:9!1,!g!:1!A=34;!:1!%$$+#!
H08934U9B4R3!:1!.679:;6!L>104B93;6!MH.LN#!_16;,=B4R3!:1!,9!L69>K,19!a13109,F!La]_.W#!%g$"!MllloPPPZH]$'NF!9D0;K9:9!1,!("!:1!A=34;!:1!%$$'#!
H08934U9B4R3!:1!.679:;6!L>104B93;6!MH.LN#!_16;,=B4R3!:1!,9!L69>K,19!a13109,F!La]_.W#!%%'"!MllloPPZH]$*NF!9D0;K9:9!1,!)!:1!A=34;!:1!%$$*#!
H08934U9B4R3!:1!.679:;6!L>104B93;6!MH.LN#!_16;,=B4R3!:1!,9!L69>K,19!a13109,F!La]_.W#!%%""!MllloPZH]$&NF!9D0;K9:9!1,!&!:1!A=34;!:1!%$$&#!
\9,9:4316F!`#!M%$(&9N#!.3!K=6B9!:1!,9!D01513B4R3!D10:4:9G!01I;0>9!?!B;3709001I;0>9!:1!,9!D;,@74B9!:1!:0;896!13!.B=9:;0#!w=47;G!h01:104BC!.K107!W74I7=38#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]K47#,?]%C4$.:v!!!
\9,9:4316F!`#!M%$(&KN#!-T0B1,!?!:0;896!13!.B=9:;0G!.,!B96748;!:1!,;6!>T6!:SK4,16#!P3I;0>1!.B=9:;0#!-.//#!/46D;34K,1!13G! !C77DG]]vvv#:0;896?:101BC;#;08]I4,16].-^L/H_(#D:I!
BIBLIOGRAFÍA 73
![Page 78: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/78.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
\S01U!-;0019F!-#F!d!_;>10;F!`#!M%$(&N!c904C=939G!-R>;#!Q1V;6!Ä13!,@319Ç#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]K47#,?]%8,^L(\!!!
\S01U!-;0019F!-#F!^D04>3?F!_#F!d!-C9D900;F!W#!M%$(&N#!_18=,974;3!;I!\;661664;3!93:!7C1!-04>439,46974;3!;I!/0=8!^6106!43!E9743!L>104B9#!.3!`#!-;,,436#!G:"!1#";!#L1.4#W$160#E!-71"#7:#";!#'N9#9U-!1"#V17.-#7,#";!#9*7,72)*6#7:#L1.4#M7%)*IF!DD#!"$Z"+#!b;8;7TG!E;3:;3!WBC;;,!;I!.B;3;>4B6!93:!\;,474B9,!WB413B1#!
\S01U!-;0019F!-#F!-;0:9F!L#F!d!b;471=VF!E#!M%$()N#!E9!018=,9B4R3!:1!,9!D;6164R3!?!,9!B04>439,4U9B4R3!:1!,;6!B;36=>4:;016!13!L>S04B9!E97439#!cSV4B;!/#hG!-;,1B745;!:1!.67=:4;6!/0;896!?!/101BC;#!
\S01U!-;0019F!-#!M%$()N#!E96!>=A1016!435464K,16G!,;6!510:9:10;6!B;67;6!:1!,9!D0464R3#!b93B;!P37109>104B93;!:1!/16900;,,;#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77D6G]]D=K,4B974;36#49:K#;08]K4767019>]C93:,1](("(+]*%")]P-WÜ/\ÜE96m%$Ü>=A1016Ü435464K,16#D:I�61Y=13B1ã(!
\S01U!-;0019F!-#F!d!LU9;,9F!.#!M%$(%N#!_16=,79:;6!:1!,9!\04>109!.3B=1679!9!\;K,9B4R3!P371039!13!-1370;6!h1:109,16!:1!_19:9D79B4R3!W;B49,#!cSV4B;!/#hG!-P/.#!
\;,4B@9!Q9B4;39,!:1,!\102#!M$+!:1!I1K010;F!%$()N#!j;A9!:1!167=:4;!?!;D434R3!$($Z%$()#.caZ\Q\]/P_LWH\.Z/Poh\.#!E4>9G!.caZ\Q\!/P_LWH\.#!
\;,4B@9!Q9B4;39,!:1,!\102#!M%$(gN#!\0;7;B;,;6!:1!O09K9A;!-;3A=37;!13701!c43467104;!\2K,4B;!?!\;,4B@9#!/46D;34K,1!13G!!C77D6G]]vvv#>43A=6#8;K#D1]vDZB;37137]=D,;9:6]%$()]$(]"Z\0;7;B;,;6Z:1ZO09K9A;Z-;3A=37;Z13701Z1,Zc43467104;Z\m-"mbLK,4B;Z?Z\;,4Bm-"mL/9#D:I!
\0;B=09B4R3!\134713B49049!:1!,9!Q9B4R3#!M%$(gN#!P3I;0>1!L3=9,!%$("G!E9!647=9B4R3!:1!,;6!:101BC;6!C=>93;6!13!,96!BT0B1,16!I1:109,16!:1!,9!L08137439#!b=13;6!L4016#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]K47#,?](EBE\C/!!
\0;B=09B4R3!\134713B49049!:1!,9!Q9B4R3#!M%$(&N#!P3I;0>1!1679:@674B;!6;K01!>=A1016!:17134:96!D;0!43I09BB4R3!9!,9!,1?!:1!:0;896!13!1,!W\h#!b=13;6!L4016G!\0;B=09B4R3!\134713B49049!:1!,9!Q9B4R3#!
\0;B=09:=0@9!:1!Q90B;B04>439,4:9:!M\_H-^QL_N#!M%$(gN#!E1?!:1!:16I1:109,4U9B4R3!D90B49,!:1!,9!B;>D1713B49!D139,!13!>971049!:1!167=D1I9B413716!ME1?!QÑ!%&#$)%N#!b=13;6!L4016G!\0;B=09:=0@9!a13109,!:1!,9!Q9B4R3#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]vvv#>DI#8;K#90]D0;B=390]I4,16]%$(g]$g]P3I;0>1ÜE1?Ü:1Ü/16I1:109,4U9B4m-"mb"3Ü)Z)#D:I!!
\0;B=09:=0@9!:1!Q90B;B04>439,4:9:!M\_H-^QL_N#!M%$(%N#!P3I;0>1!1679:@674B;!6;K01!390B;B04>439,4:9:#!W;K01!,9!:46704K=B4R3!:1!B9=696!434B49:96!D;0!167=D1I9B413716F!D;K,9B4R3!?!1>D,19:;6!13!1,!c43467104;!\2K,4B;!h46B9,F!LX;!%$(%#!b=13;6!L4016G!\0;B=09B4R3!a13109,!
BIBLIOGRAFÍA74
![Page 79: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/79.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
:1!,9!Q9B4R3#!/46D;34K,1!13G! !C77DG]]K47#,?]%8Bg}//!!
_154679!Oj-#!M%$("N#!^39!,1?!Y=1!>979#!_154679!Oj-!M&)N#!
_154679!Oj-#!M%$(%N#!.,!43Y=464:;0!:1!W93!P64:0;#!_154679!Oj-!M)$N#!
_154679!Oj-#!M%$((N#!/1,!E9:;!:1!9:1370;#!_154679!Oj-!Mg)N#!
!"#$%&'()'*'+,-#&'.)'/01123)'45"6"78'!"#$#%&'$()*)"#+,"-()!",.#/(0)!#%(0)!"#$%&'()*#+*,("*-#!.*/0*)(1"#2#!"#$!"%&'()$*+,)-&')./0+12'3"4+1"-&#/+!"#$%&'!()%#!"#*'%&(+(,#!"#-,%#!"#$%&'()!
_;K1076;3F!H#!M%$(%N#!-;354B7;6!B;,97109,16G!34X;6!?!34X96!:1!D0;81347;016!D016;6#!_1B;>13:9B4;316!?!K=1396!D0TB74B96!:1,!-;>47S!:1!,96!Q9B4;316!^34:96!6;K01!,;6!/101BC;6!:1!,9!Q4X1UF!13!1,!:@9!:1!/1K971!a13109,!%$((#!a431K09G!E9!_1D0161379B4R3!-=TY=109!9371!,96!Q9B4;316!^34:96#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]vvv#Y=3;#;08]64716]:1I9=,7]I4,16]016;=0B16].W\LQm--m'"HEÜ-;,,97109,m%$-;354B76Ü_1B;>>13:974;36m%$93:m%$8;;:m%$D09B74B1#D:I!
_;613K108F!`#!M%$$+N#!E9!34X1U!79>K4S3!31B16479!:1!6=!D9DTG!C4A;6!1!C4A96!:1!D9:016!13B90B1,9:;6#!a431K09#!E9!_1D0161379B4R3!-=TY=109!9371!,96!Q9B4;316!^34:96#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]vvv#Y=3;#;08]64716]:1I9=,7]I4,16]016;=0B16].W\LQm--m'"HEÜ-C4,:013m%$311:m%$:9:6m%$7;;#D:I!
_=K4;!W10093;F!_#!M%$("N#!.,!W4671>9!:1!_16D;369K4,4:9:!\139,!D909!L:;,16B13716G!=3!I09B96;!016;39371!?!BR>;!01>1:490,;#!E$3+,#M.=%)*$#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]K47#,?]%kV-o/v!
W9951:09F!.#F!E9DD9:;F!\#F!b938;F!c#!d!c1,,;F!h#!M%$(gN#!P35464K,16F!~C9679!B=T3:;�!-C=0BC!J;0,:!W1054B1!?!a=04616!^34:;6!/46D;34K,1!13G! !C77DG]]K47#,?](oWg)'&!!
W9BC64:9F!L#!?!c13:;3s9F!c`#!M%$$*N#!.VZ-;354B76!h9B1!c=,74D,1!E9K;0!c90k17!\=346C>1376G!.674>9716!;I!\110Za0;=D!93:!W748>9!.II1B76!^6438!.Y=974;36!;I!_17=036!7;!WBC;;,438#!_154679!.B;3;>@9#!o;,#!*M"N#!
WBC9II10F!L#!M%$(&N#!.3701!,9!017R04B9!?!,9!01I;0>9#!_1I;0>9!:1,!W4671>9!:1!`=674B49!\139,!:1!,;6!..#^^#!J96C4387;3!/#-G!J;,9!Z!-;,1B745;!:1!.67=:4;6!/0;896!?!/101BC;#!!
W4671>9!W=K0184;39,!:1!P3I;0>9B4R3!1!P35167489B4R3!6;K01!/0;896#!M%$($N#!E9!_1,9B4R3!/0;89!?!/1,47;!13!L:;,16B13716!P3I09B7;016!:1!,9!E1?#!/46D;34K,1!13G! !C77D6G]]vvv#=3;:B#;08]:;B=>1376]D10=93:1B=9:;0]\=K,4B9B4;316]E9Ü_1,9B4;3Ü/0;89#D:I!
W719:>93F!j#!`#F!H6C10F!h#!-#F!_;KK436F!\#!-#F!-961F!b#!d!W9>=1,6F!W#!M%$$+N#!\0159,13B1!;I!6104;=6!>1379,!4,,3166!9>;38!A94,!43>9716#!M6I*;)$"1#N!1/0!o;,#!&$!M&NF!DD#!*&(Z*&)#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]D6#D6?BC4970?;3,431#;08]:;4]I=,,]($#((*&]D6#%$$+#&$#&#*&(!
BIBLIOGRAFÍA 75
![Page 80: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/80.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
!OC;=>4F!h#.#!M%$()N#!/1K9716!?!D909:48>96!:1!,96!D;,@74B96!:1!:0;896!13!1,!>=3:;!?!,;6!:169I@;6!D909!-;,;>K49#!b;8;7TG!LB9:1>49!-;,;>K4939!:1!-413B496!.B;3R>4B96#!
OQP!d!J;,9#!M%$($N#!W4671>96!6;K01B9089:;6#!E1?16!:1!:0;896!?!BT0B1,16!13!L>S04B9!E97439#!J96C4387;3!/#-#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]K47#,?]%C4'+_>!!
O;k97,493F!`#!a#!M(%!:1!>9?;!:1!%$$gN#!.,!>47;!D10D17=;#!M@4),$#QR0!/46D;34K,1!13G!!C77DG]]K47#,?](I."AK9!
O;>k43F!`#!M%$$+N#!j=S0I93;6!:1!,9!A=674B49G!b=6B93:;!1,!43710S6!6=D104;0!:1,!>13;0!B=93:;!61!13B90B1,9!9!6=!D0;81347;0M9NG!=3!93T,4646!,189,#!a431K09G!E9!_1D0161379B4R3!-=TY=109!9371!,96!Q9B4;316!^34:96#!/46D;34K,1!13G! !C77DG]]vvv#Y=3;#;08]64716]:1I9=,7]I4,16]016;=0B16].W\LQm--m'"HEÜH0DC936m%$;Im%$`=674B1#D:I!
^QLP/W#!M%$((N#!P37103974;39,!a=4:1,4316!;3!jPo]LP/W!93:!j=>93!_48C76#!^3471:!Q974;36#!
^QPh.c#!M%$$&N#!c=A1016!?!D0464R3!13!-;,;>K49G!93T,4646!:16:1!=39!D106D1B7459!:1!:101BC;6!C=>93;6!?!8S310;#!b;8;7T#!^34I1>#!
^QH/-!b;,4549#!M%$(&N#!E9!^QH/-!9K;89!D;0!>1:4:96!6=6747=74596!9,!13B90B1,9>4137;!D909!:1,47;6!>13;016!?!3;!54;,137;6!01,9B4;39:;6!B;3!,96!:0;896F!13!16D1B49,!D909!,96!>=A1016#!/46D;34K,1!13G!!C77DG]]K47#,?]%C*7A\v!!!
^QH/-#!M%$(&9N#!WD1B49,!/979!-;,,1B74;3!;3!\106;36!C1,:!43!\046;36!M%$($Z%$(%N#!/46D;34K,1!13G! !!C77DG]]K47#,?]%8JL+6J!!
^QH/-#!M%$(&KN#!J;0,:!/0=8!_1D;07!%$(&#!Q1v!É;0kG!^3471:!Q974;36#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]K47#,?]%+gH;a^!!
^QH/-#!M%$()N#!P3I;0>1!c=3:49,!6;K01!/0;896#!_16=>13!.A1B=745;#!o4139#!Q9B4;316!^34:96#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]K47#,?](}1%$v-!!!
^QH/-#!M%$(gN#!a,;K9,!W7=:?!;3!j;>4B4:1!%$("#!o4139G!^3471:!Q974;36#!/46D;34K,1!13G! !C77D6G]]vvv#=3;:B#;08]:;B=>1376]:979Z93:Z939,?646]67974674B6]aWj%$("]%$(gÜaEHbLEÜjHcP-P/.ÜbHH}Üv1K#D:I!
^D04>3?F!_#F!-C9D900;F!W#F!d!-0=UF!E#!h#!M%$(&9N#!/1,47;6!:1!:0;896!?!6;K01:;646!B90B1,9049!13!-;,;>K49#!b;8;7TG!-;,1B745;!:1!.67=:4;6!/0;896!?!/101BC;#!
^D04>3?F!_#F!c907@31UF!c#F!-0=UF!E#F!-C9D900;F!W#F!d!-C9D900;F!Q#!M%$(&KN#!c=A1016!\;,@74B96!:1!/0;896!?!.3B90B1,9>4137;#!^39!8=@9!D909!,9!01I;0>9!:1!D;,@74B96!13!-;,;>K49#!b;8;7TG!/1A=674B49!<!J;,9!Z!HD13!W;B417?!h;=3:974;36#!
^D04>3?F!_#F!a=U>T3F!/#F!d!\9009F!`#!M%$("N#!\1396!9,=B4393716#!E9!:16D0;D;0B4R3!:1!,9!D139,4U9B4R3!:1!,96!:0;896!13!-;,;>K49#!b;8;7TG!/1A=674B49#!
^D04>3?F!_#F!a=U>T3F!/#F!d!\9009F!`#!M%$(%N#!E9!9:4BB4R3!D=347459#!E9!
BIBLIOGRAFÍA76
![Page 81: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/81.jpg)
!!!
!"#$%&#'!! "!
:16D0;D;0B4R3!:1!,1?16!:1!:0;896!13!L>S04B9!E97439#!b;8;7TG!L370;D;6#!
^0;69!_#F!aL#!M%$$+N#!L,8=396!01I,1V4;316!13!01,9B4R3!B;3!1,!e/101BC;!D139,!:1,!131>48;f!:1370;!:1,!B;371V7;!39B4;39,#!E!/)6"$#(!#%$#X$*.%"$(#(!#L!1!*;7#(!#OTU)*70!o;,#&(!M%))NF!DD#!*(Z+"#!/46D;34K,1!13G! !C77D6G]]01546796ZB;,9K;09B4;3#A=04:4B96#=39>#>V]43:1V#DCD]015ZI9B=,79:Z:101BC;Z>V]9074B,1]541v]%+$)(]%&%$)!
o4,,1896F!a#F!c#F!.6D43;69F!`#F!_#F!d!L381,#!h#F!`#!M%$("N#!P36747=B4;316!?!390B;70TI4B;#!E9!81;809I@9!A=:4B49,!:1!,;6!:1,47;6!:1!:0;896!13!-;,;>K49#!b;8;7TG!L370;D;6#!
JHELF!P/\-F!/1A=674B49!d!-Pc#!M%$(&N#!c=A1016F!D;,@74B9!:1!:0;896!?!13B90B1,9>4137;#!^39!8=@9!D909!,9!01I;0>9!:1!D;,@74B96!13!L>S04B9!E97439!?!1,!-904K1#!J96C4387;3!/#-#!/46D;34K,1!13G!C77DG]]K47#,?]%8BI(A8!!
J;0,:!\046;3!b041IF!P36747=71!I;0!-04>439,!\;,4B?!_16190BC!MP-\WN#!M%$(&N#!/97;6!C467R04B;6#!/46D;34K,1!13G! !vvv#D046;367=:416#;08!!
JWP\\#!M%$()N!JC97!J;0k6!93:!JC97!/;16!Q;7�!b131I47Z-;67!h43:4386!I0;>!JWP\\#!J96C4387;3!/#-G!J96C4387;3!W7971!P36747=71!I;0!\=K,4B!\;,4B?#!
i9II90;34F!.#!_#!M%$$&N#!.,!131>48;!13!1,!:101BC;!D139,#!c9:04:G!/?k436;3#!
!
BIBLIOGRAFÍA 77
![Page 82: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/82.jpg)
![Page 83: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/83.jpg)
![Page 84: Revista Pensamiento Penal - CASTIGOS IRRACIONALES: Leyes de … · 2021. 8. 1. · Colectivo de Estudios Drogas y Derecho Informe Regional 2017 Sergio Chaparro Catalina Pérez Correa](https://reader035.vdocuments.site/reader035/viewer/2022070223/6141dd282035ff3bc7624ce5/html5/thumbnails/84.jpg)
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
)
!
2017
";!<-;+%/$=-!#+!"*/9#$-*!)1-02*!:!)+1+%>-!V!+..W!1+?'+!$'=+*/$02#-1+*!@+'!*9!72:-142!A91$*/2*@!#+!'9+=+!524*+*!;2/$'-27+1$%2'-*(!B10+'/$'2C!D-;$=$2C!D12*$;C!
<-;-7E$2C!<-*/2!F$%2C!"%92#-1C!GHI$%-C!J+1?!:!K19092:L!6759;*2#-!5-1!$'$%$2/$=2!#+!MN8B!:!OP6C!+;!<"))!/$+'+!%-7-!-EA+/$=-!51$'%$52;!2'2;$Q21!+;!$752%/-!#+!;2!;+0$*;2%$&'!5+'2;!:!;2!51R%/$%2!A914#$%2!+'!72/+1$2!#+!#1-02*C!E9*%2'#-!0+'+121!
$'3-172%$&'!*-E1+!;2*!%212%/+14*/$%2*!:!;-*!%-*/-*C!*+2'!*-%$2;+*!-!+%-'&7$%-*C!#+!;2*!5-;4/$%2*!+'!72/+1$2!#+!#1-02*!+'!B7H1$%2!82/$'2C!:!%-'!+;;-!3-7+'/21!9'!#+E2/+!$'3-172#-!*-E1+!;2!+3+%/$=$#2#!#+!;2*!5-;4/$%2*!2%/92;+*!:!1+%-7+'#21!
2E-1#2A+*!2;/+1'2/$=-*!5212!5-;4/$%2*!7R*!A9*/2*!:!+3+%/$=2*L!
!
J212!7R*!$'3-172%$&'!=$*$/2!!MMMJ*/"01,2*$/$%3"J"/0)
!
"*/2!59E;$%2%$&'!39+!5-*$E;+!012%$2*!2;!3$'2'%$27$+'/-!#+!!!AF$5)>"%'$&2)Q"-5*1&'"5,)
2017