mussels, starfish and insects as feed protein sources · 2019-07-05 · mussels, starfish and...

17
JAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD ASSOC. PROFESSOR DEPARTMENT OF ANIMAL SCIENCE AARHUS UNIVERSITY, FOULUM, DENMARK MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES

Upload: others

Post on 31-May-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES · 2019-07-05 · MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES. NEW PROTEIN SOURCES JAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD NEW PROTEIN

JAN VÆRUM NØRGAARDASSOC. PROFESSORDEPARTMENT OF ANIMAL SCIENCEAARHUS UNIVERSITY, FOULUM, DENMARK

MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES

Page 2: MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES · 2019-07-05 · MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES. NEW PROTEIN SOURCES JAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD NEW PROTEIN

NEW PROTEIN SOURCESJAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD

NEW PROTEIN SOURCES

2

› Agenda is based on current research projects› Insects› Blue protein: blue mussels + starfish

› Purpose is to provide overview› Why produce it?› Use as feedstuff› Future

Page 3: MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES · 2019-07-05 · MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES. NEW PROTEIN SOURCES JAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD NEW PROTEIN

NEW PROTEIN SOURCESJAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD 3

INSECTS

Page 4: MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES · 2019-07-05 · MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES. NEW PROTEIN SOURCES JAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD NEW PROTEIN

NEW PROTEIN SOURCESJAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD 4

INSECTS› Industrial production is possible› Black soldier fly› Common and lesser mealworm

› Why mealworms› Already natural habitants› Already produced in 100 ton-scale› Turns low-value biomass into high-value biomass› High nutrient efficiency – low climate/environment impact› Simple to produce at hobby scale› Great potential for upscaling and big business!› Food vs. Feed: Large scale = feed = impact !

Page 5: MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES · 2019-07-05 · MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES. NEW PROTEIN SOURCES JAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD NEW PROTEIN

NEW PROTEIN SOURCESJAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD 5

INSECTS› Nutrient content shows potential as protein source

Page 6: MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES · 2019-07-05 · MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES. NEW PROTEIN SOURCES JAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD NEW PROTEIN

NEW PROTEIN SOURCESJAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD 6

INSECTS› Current EU legislation:› Intact insects OK for human food› 7 species OK in aquaculture› Meal to pigs and poultry not allowed – but alive is OK› Long way to EU-approval for pigs and poultry› Production should be automised› Feed for beetles and larvae should be low-value and EU approved› Processing should handle potential zoonotic hazzards

Page 7: MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES · 2019-07-05 · MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES. NEW PROTEIN SOURCES JAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD NEW PROTEIN

NEW PROTEIN SOURCESJAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD 7

INSECTS› Current research: › inVALUABLE (Innovationsfund Denmark, DTI lead)› Exp 1: Growing pigs fed 5 species of insects to evaluate nutrient value for human and pigs› Exp 2: Piglets fed black soldier fly, common and lesser mealworm +› Exp 3: Chickens fed black soldier fly, common and lesser mealworm› …. to evaluate impact on growth and health

Page 8: MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES · 2019-07-05 · MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES. NEW PROTEIN SOURCES JAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD NEW PROTEIN

NEW PROTEIN SOURCESJAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD

BLUE PROTEIN: MUSSELS

8

Page 9: MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES · 2019-07-05 · MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES. NEW PROTEIN SOURCES JAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD NEW PROTEIN

NEW PROTEIN SOURCESJAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD

BLUE PROTEIN: MUSSELS

9

› Blue mussels grown on lines/nets› Farmed in waters with high nutrient load=algae› Great production: 60 ton wet weight/hectar› Removes 600-900 kg N/hectar/year› Removes 30-40 kg P/hectar/year

› Future concept: Mitigation mussels› Farms (aquaculture, pigs, poultry) excrete N+P› Farmers or municipalities invest in mussel farms› Feed mussel to fish, pigs, poultry› … Closing the N+P nutrient cycle

Page 10: MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES · 2019-07-05 · MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES. NEW PROTEIN SOURCES JAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD NEW PROTEIN

NEW PROTEIN SOURCESJAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD

› Very close to fishmeal:› 58-68% crude protein, 10-16% fat, 9-10% ash in dry matter› SID crude protein of 83-86%› The lipids may be interesting but can cause challenges. Season dependent

10

BLUE PROTEIN: MUSSELS

Page 11: MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES · 2019-07-05 · MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES. NEW PROTEIN SOURCES JAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD NEW PROTEIN

NEW PROTEIN SOURCESJAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD

› Current research:› MuMiPro (Innovationfund Denmark, DTU-AQUA lead)› Exp 1: Feeding egg layers mussel meal with/without shells› Exp 2: Feeding organic piglets mussel meal› Exp 3: Using mussel silage to stimulate feed intake of piglets

11

BLUE PROTEIN: MUSSELS

Page 12: MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES · 2019-07-05 · MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES. NEW PROTEIN SOURCES JAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD NEW PROTEIN

NEW PROTEIN SOURCESJAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD

BLUE PROTEIN: STARFISH

12

Page 13: MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES · 2019-07-05 · MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES. NEW PROTEIN SOURCES JAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD NEW PROTEIN

NEW PROTEIN SOURCESJAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD

› Starfish predates on mussels = a pest for the mussel industry› Easy and gentle to catch› Simple and fairly easy to make into starfish meal› STARPRO (GUDP funding, DTU-AQUA lead)› Problem -> research -> solution + product

13

BLUE PROTEIN: STARFISH

Page 14: MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES · 2019-07-05 · MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES. NEW PROTEIN SOURCES JAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD NEW PROTEIN

NEW PROTEIN SOURCESJAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD

› Chemical composition› 29-45% (70%!) crude protein› 35-57% ash› 10-18% calcium› 5-9% fat

14

BLUE PROTEIN: STARFISH

Page 15: MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES · 2019-07-05 · MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES. NEW PROTEIN SOURCES JAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD NEW PROTEIN

NEW PROTEIN SOURCESJAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD

› 3 pig experiments at AU Foulum› Exp 1: SID crude protein is 80%› Exp 2: pilot scale; 5% = fish meal› Exp 3: full scale; 5% = fish meal› Recommendation: analyze and dose up to max calcium

15

BLUE PROTEIN: STARFISH

Page 16: MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES · 2019-07-05 · MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES. NEW PROTEIN SOURCES JAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD NEW PROTEIN

NEW PROTEIN SOURCESJAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD 16

› Great opportunities for industry and society› Great challenges regarding practical issues› Current development is driven by society needs/research› Industry should start now to prepare for the future markets

NEW PROTEIN SOURCES

Page 17: MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES · 2019-07-05 · MUSSELS, STARFISH AND INSECTS AS FEED PROTEIN SOURCES. NEW PROTEIN SOURCES JAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD NEW PROTEIN

NEW PROTEIN SOURCESJAN VÆRUM NØRGAARD

THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION!› Underlying projects:› Mealworm: inVALUABLE (Innovation Fund Denmark) www.invaluable.dk› Blue mussel: MuMiPro (Innovation Fund Denmark) www.mumipro.dk› Starfish: STARPRO (GUDP) www.skaldyrcenter.dk› Seaweed: Tang.nu (Velux Foundation) www.tangnu.dk

› Jan Værum Nørgaard› Aarhus University, Foulum, Denmark› [email protected]

17