7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

1/54

Investigating the Impact of aGamified Unit of Instruction onStudent Learning and Motivation

An Action Research Project By

N. Kainoa Bowman

University of Hawai!i at M

"noa

Kea!au, Hawai!i

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

2/54

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 78$%$"*$8 92/

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

3/54

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 :;42$".$

!"#$%&$' ))* +,-."# /012"% 3 4567 48$$ 908 #011$8#"2. ,&$ 3 :0 2;8"-,

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

4/54

!"#$%&$' ))* +,-."# /012"% 3 4567 48$$ 908 #011$8#"2. ,&$ 3 :0 2;8"-,

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

5/54

!"#$%&$' ))* +,-."# /012"% 3 4567 48$$ 908 #011$8#"2. ,&$ 3 :0 2;8"-,

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

6/54

!"#$%&$' ))* +,-."# /012"% 3 4567 48$$ 908 #011$8#"2. ,&$ 3 :0 2;8"-,

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

7/54!"#$%&$' ))* +,-."# /012"% 3 4567 48$$ 908 #011$8#"2. ,&$ 3 :0 2;8"-,

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

8/54!"#$%&$' ))* +,-."# /012"% 3 4567 48$$ 908 #011$8#"2. ,&$ 3 :0 2;8"-,

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

9/54!"#$%&$' ))* +,-."# /012"% 3 4567 48$$ 908 #011$8#"2. ,&$ 3 :0 2;8"-,

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

10/54:A82=;&/"BC/"D/,,$8.2(@BE+(8$:@2>$ FGH 1$"$82. IDD 9JBCDBE: FGHK 2,' =L ?/4 9(>$8

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 ?+$ 78/=@$,

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

11/54

!,' =L6 M2.(84/ N2=$8(*/

!,' =L6 O(#24 N2%=/"(

!,' =L6 1;2@@(;,$ 9@(".+(84

!,' #2( 7;=@2. O/,(2"

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 ?+$ 78/=@$,

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

12/54

!,' #2(6 P-$"D@2-:8*

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 ?+$ 78/=@$,

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

13/54

!,' #2(6 7;=@2. O/,(2"

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 ?+$ 78/=@$,

?0@ >0 AB

5>>8$&& 8$=,"8$1$%C&

D$2#E .0@F2#E"$G$8&

)E2..$%H$ E"HEF

2#E"$G$8&

A%#8$2&$ CE$ #0%C$%C

CE2C "& #0G$8$>

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

14/54Are you motivated by competition?

IE"& J.$ "& 2 @08K 09 2 &2".08 08 $1L.0M$$ 09 CE$ NOPO :2GMQ C2K$% 08 12>$ 2& L28C 09 CE2C L$8&0%R& 0S#"2. >,$82. H0G$8%1$%CQ CE$ "12H$ "& "% CE$ L,-."# >012"%O

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 :;42$".$

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

15/54Are you motivated by choice?

IE"& J.$ "& ."#$%&$> ,%>$8 CE$ )8$2

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

16/54

IE$ L,8L0&$ 09 CE"& 2#

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

17/54

!,' #2(6 E*$#$ 7$*8;.$@@2

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 O$#$@/-,$"*

U21"J#2$8-028>&

D$@28> PM&C$1&

!,' #2(6 Q$R8/

)E0"#$ Z.$1$%C&

I2&K&

I0L"#&

+80>,#C&

! & & + ! 0 1 23 4 5 2 O @

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

18/54

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 O$#$@/-,$"*

N%"C A%#.,>$&

)0%C$%C' 5%#"$%C

ZHMLC

I$#E A%C$H82

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

19/54

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 O$#$@/-,$"*

I2&K _$%,

!"%K& C0 C2&K&E$$C&

P$G$% L0&&"-.$

C2&K& 5."H%$> C0 :)PP

P0#"2. PC,>"$&

&K"..&

P,HH$&C$>

C0L"#&

! & & *+ ! * 0 1 23 4 5 2* O @ *

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

20/54

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 O$#$@/-,$"*

5#E"$G$1$%C !"&C

5#E"$G$1$%C

8$=,"8$1$%C&

+0"%C C0C2.&

:"%$C$$% C0C2.

2#E"$G$1$%C&

! & & *+ ! * 0 1 23 4 5 2* O @ *

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

21/54

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 O$#$@/-,$"*

!$2>$8-028> !$G$.&

Z"HEC .$G$.&

!"&C 09 .$G$.

8$@28>&

5."H%$> @"CE

ZHML

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

22/54

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 O$#$@/-,$"*

!$2>$8-028>& !$2>$8-028>& L$8

#.2&& L$8"0>

U82>$ .$G$. I0L

T*

PC,>$%C &$.$#C$>

2."2&$&O

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 O$,/'8(-+2.%

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

23/54

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 O$,/'8(-+2.%

%`a*T' bcF_2.$Q deF4$12.$

5H$&' aaFaT

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 S$*+/4%

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

24/54

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 S$*+/4%

N%"C P,8G$M ad "C$1&

A1L2#C& 0%

10

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

25/54

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

Factors impacting motivation to complete

required number of tasks.

Experience Points Leaderboards

Choice Rewards

!,' #2(6 T@U$2"$>$" !,' #2(6 V,2'4(

!,' #2(6 7;=@2. O/,(2" !,' #2(6 7;=@2. O/,(2"

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

26/54

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

Factors impacting motivation to complete

required number of tasks.

ExperiencePoints Leaderboards

Choice Rewards

4.3 4.2

4.44.5

!,' #2(6 T@U$2"$>$" !,' #2(6 V,2'4(

!,' #2(6 7;=@2. O/,(2" !,' #2(6 7;=@2. O/,(2"

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

27/54

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

Factors impacting motivation to complete

required number of tasks.

Experience Points Leaderboards

Choice Rewards

4.3 4.2

4.44.5

!,' #2(6 T@U$2"$>$" !,' #2(6 V,2'4(

!,' #2(6 7;=@2. O/,(2" !,' #2(6 7;=@2. O/,(2"

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

28/54

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

Factors impacting motivation to complete

more than the required number of tasks.

Experience Points Leaderboards

Choice Rewards

4.1 4.1

4.24.3

!,' #2(6 T@U$2"$>$" !,' #2(6 V,2'4(

!,' #2(6 7;=@2. O/,(2" !,' #2(6 7;=@2. O/,(2"

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

29/54

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

Factors impacting motivation to complete

more than the required number of tasks.

Experience Points Leaderboards

Choice Rewards

4.1 4.1

4.24.3

!,' #2(6 T@U$2"$>$" !,' #2(6 V,2'4(

!,' #2(6 7;=@2. O/,(2" !,' #2(6 7;=@2. O/,(2"

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

30/54

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

31/54

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

_$2%`bOf

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

32/54

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

_$2% ` bOf

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

33/54

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

Q12: What was your favorite thing about the

Ancient Egypt unit?

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

34/54

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

Q12: What was your favorite thing about the

Ancient Egypt unit?

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

35/54

' ' -

Q13: What was your least favorite thing

about the Ancient Egypt unit?

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

36/54

' ' -

Q13: What was your least favorite thing

about the Ancient Egypt unit?

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

37/54

' ' -

Q13: What was your least favorite thing

about the Ancient Egypt unit?

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

38/54

' ' -

Task Completion Data

Ta

ee

bc

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

39/54

' ' -

Projects Completed By Low-Achieving Students

! # $%

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 M$%;@*%

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

40/54

Projects Completed By High-Achieving Students

! # $&

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 O2%.;%%2/"

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

41/54

!,' #2(6 W/"$JQ

Were the gamification elements motivating?

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 O2%.;%%2/"

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

42/54

!,' #2(6 W/"$JQ

Were the gamification elements motivating?

!,' #2(6 7;=@2. O/,(2"

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 O2%.;%%2/"

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

43/54

Was the choice element motivating?

!,'% #2(6 7;=@2. O/,(2"

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 O2%.;%%2/"

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

44/54

Was the choice element motivating?

!,'% #2(6 7;=@2. O/,(2"

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 O2%.;%%2/"

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

45/54

Which element had the greatest perceivedimpact on motivation?

!,' #2(6 7;=@2. O/,(2"

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 O2%.;%%2/"

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

46/54

/"> Ag 5>>8$&& 8$=,"8$1$%C&

D$2#E .0@F2#E"$G$8&

)E2..$%H$ E"HEF2#E"$G$8&

A%#8$2&$ CE$ #0%C$%C CE2C "& #0G$8$>

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 O2%.;%%2/"

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

47/54

/"> Ag 5>>8$&& 8$=,"8$1$%C&

D$2#E .0@F2#E"$G$8&

)E2..$%H$ E"HEF2#E"$G$8&

A%#8$2&$ CE$ #0%C$%C CE2C "& #0G$8$>

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 O2%.;%%2/"

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

48/54

/"> Ag 5>>8$&& 8$=,"8$1$%C&

D$2#E .0@F2#E"$G$8&

)E2..$%H$ E"HEF2#E"$G$8&

A%#8$2&$ CE$ #0%C$%C CE2C "& #0G$8$>

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 O2%.;%%2/"

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

49/54

/"> Ag 5>>8$&& 8$=,"8$1$%C&

D$2#E .0@F2#E"$G$8&

)E2..$%H$ E"HEF2#E"$G$8&

A%#8$2&$ CE$ #0%C$%C CE2C "& #0G$8$>

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 O2%.;%%2/"

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

50/54

/"> Ag 5>>8$&& 8$=,"8$1$%C&

D$2#E .0@F2#E"$G$8&

)E2..$%H$ E"HEF2#E"$G$8&

A%#8$2&$ CE$ #0%C$%C CE2C "& #0G$8$>

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 O2%.;%%2/"

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

51/54

A1L."#2 C0

10$%C&

:0C 0%$F&"h$FJC& 2.. !,' #2(6 2(4/8$(--@$+$(4

!"#$%&'(&"' *+$ !,-(.* /0 ( 1(,23$4 5"2*6 N2,2*(&/"%

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

52/54

!"1"C$> @"%>0@ 908>2C2 #0..$#$%C &$.9F

8$L08C$> 8$&L0%&$& :0C $%0,HE >2C2 C0

>$C$81"%$ "1L2#C&

0% .$28%"%H

!"#$%&$' ))* +,-."# /012"% 3 4567 48$$ 908 #011$8#"2. ,&$ 3 :0 2;8"-,

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

53/54

_2E2.0

)8"

7/23/2019 Investigating the Impact of a Gamified Unit of Instruction on Student Learning and Motivation

54/54

6,$&