puppy smuggling - inside the black market
DESCRIPTION
An article on the black market for smuggled puppies in the U.S. Originally published in DVM Newsmagazine.TRANSCRIPT
Newsmagazine
p 16 Reinventing
education Consortium starts
national dialogue on educational reform
raquo
The Voice of Ve ter in ar y News April 200
Anew attitude Study examines changing personality types among incoming veterinary students BY R AC ItAEI WHITCOMB - r w s eO IT OR
AT10NAL REPORT - Its not just yea rs that l re defiDing gen era tional differences - personalities actually arc according to a ne study of veteri nary students
Aftcra lJ when it comes to the veleri middot nar y profession fundamental changes have been going on for years eXln tgt say More women continue to enter the profession and the m arket contil]ues to brcak from its roots in ag riculture to companiOJl -nnimal ca re Technology and CO[ll ll1Ullication is aiso cha nging th e land SCll pe
TI e result is at tracting a different ki 1lel (veterinaria n explains Joseph Tahoadn
CONT INUED ON PAGE 24 raquo
Inside the black market New ammaJ health
risks posed by growing illegal
dog importation
BY CHRIS Swm NfY C () NTHllilI T I J I ll lllnll
N ATIONAL REPORT - It s syn01lymous with weapon and drugs But the black market dog trade in the United Slates is vast and ome helieve it s growing
Across the USllkxican bord er and through the airports a st ream or illegal puppies arc crossing Us horders l3ig profits arc made important humanilltlrian buc ignored and signitkant health risks propagated with each illtgltll dog that is trafficked into the cou ntr ) - CONTINUED ON lI ( c 28 raquo
p 3 Yelp and extortion claims p 12 First blood test unveiled for canine cancer
p6 Top honors dvm360com and DVM Newsmagazine win two coveted journalism honors laquo
p22 Whistleblower Dr Dean Wyatt GAO call for welfare reform
p43 An associates perspective So you are a doctor Now what
AN ADVANSTAR PUBLICATON
DVM Newsmagazine I dvm360(om 28 IApril 2010
A lt11l111l1Hmiddot SPI (fAf
Inside the black mdrket raquo CD KTINUED FIWv1 PAGE 27
collec t evidence that puppies were in fact being smuggled into the United States Officers from the tas k force worked hand in hand with Immigra-tion and CutOJ11S Enforcemenl offi-cials for two-week periods scvcn days a wcek two shifts a day
The effort is to sh)w t he powers that be that this is a ver) serious issue the most serious aspcct being the health problems including zoonot ic issues an the fact that tlwsc puppiescnu up in our
RI PURl
kids beds Reyes says Among the dogs being smuggled in
from Mexico parvolirus and distemper are rampant says Karen Ehncrt senior veterinarian lor the County of Los An-geles Department of Public Health
nd while legitimate breeders and pet stores would advise consumers on how to properly care (or and vaccinate a new pet someone selling smuggled dogs on the street isonl) looking to makea quick buck and is not Ii kcly concerned about the animals well-being after it is sold
We tend to vaccinate our distemper and parvo but in Mexico vac-cinesarcnt given that often The mother is not vaccinated so shes not passing along an) immunity to thc puppies Elmert says
Butlvlexico is not the only place pup-pies are being smuggled (rom and Ehnert has documented the problem of dog coming into the US from around the world through Los Angelcs International Airport
During the Summcr of 2008 we
I
started getting reports from the air-port ofpuppie hcing dead she ay Over a month period we had about four and normally we would sec only one or two per year
Ehnert and colleagues conducted till) full c(muses at the airport the most recent in August 2009 and says the bulk o(the puppies werc being shipped from Suuth Korea though a lot of singletons were coming in from Australia and Bulldogs from Hungary FI)ing from Korea to Los Angeles call be strain f(l r humans let alone 6-week 01lt1 puppies and Ehner points out that many of the pups were dying from hypoglyctmia while in transit
And thcrcs pmbablyagenetic compo-nent t here as t he ani mals used ft)r breed-ing have genetic problems Ehnert says
While documentation and verifica-tion ofa dogs age is needed to ship dogs into the United State Elmert a)s the censuses at the airport showcd that falsi-ned paperwork was rampant
People fignred out that if the) pre-sented paperwork showi ng t he dog was 4 mont hs old or older there wou Id he no restrictions after they were imported she says
As the nUlllherofcollntries shipping dogs into Ihe United Slates increases the risk of diseases more harrnfulthan distemper and larvu increases
CDCs biggest concern with these imported dogs is the risk of rabies says G Gale Galland a vcterinarv with thc Center for Disease Control lt11d Preven-tion Exacerhating the threat of rabies is Ihe fact that most of the dogs being shipped arC too young 10 evcn he vacci-nated lor rabies Owr the past few ycars there have xCn a handful ofcases of rabid dogs beingsmuggled in but enlorcement both at border crossings and airports is proving difficult
Thc Border Puppy Task I orce relies on grants to conduct their censuses Reyes says that while the task force has not been able to conduct any recent border censuses it has been cracking down on
Isellers within the cities and takinga monmiddot
I
localizcd approach to addressing the problem When like Reyes and Ehners are not at t he borders and
theres dearth oft rained an-mal health prolessionals tht can identity sick and underage animals
Mike Carne) deputy special agent in charge at Immigrations and Cus-[oms Ent(lrccmcnt Office of Invcsti -
--------- D V M Newsmagazine I dVnl160coll1 2010 I 29 -
gatio n readil) admits that national required lor all dogs entcn ng the countr) and drugs takc precedent An idea l situation would be to have spc-
over illegal puppies cia II) trained inspectors at major points I middotOur biggest threat bereon the south - of cntr) but such an arrangement would
vest border is narcotics from Mexico be costly and resource intensivc I and we haw a 101 of resources dedicated Reycs rcached out to the local veteri-to that Carncy sa)s middotmiddotBut we do have a nary community to raise awareness and dedicated group of investigators at the IXllstcr support for the issue I Ie spoke at border ca lled our Commercial Fraud nKlingsofthc Soulhem C11ilomiaVetclc
Group which focuses on preTnting inar) iIOOical issociationandsays many contrahand introduced in to the United vets were llIJlware ofthc problem Stales and that s where the pUpP) smug- It was a hock to the animal health gling Calls under communit) he says We uncowreJ
Carne) SJ)S l liling to declare puppies and srnuggling them is a federal fclony that could come with as much as 20 )ears in jail While national security and narcotics are the agellcy lop nmccrn Ca rne) sa)s the agency is parlicularly concerned with thewdfareofthc animals and the possibilit) ofn(wJiseascs being introduced in thcregion addingthatthe agency isnt taking completeiyciinical approach to the problem C Ulle) sug-
thaI fCver dogs have hem smugglL during the past two)carswhen COrnpItli with pre vious years but harJ accu rate statistics arc dimwit to gather Ca rne) attrmiddotibut e the supected decline to the weak economy as well as heightened s(eurit) and beefed-up cnilfccmenl
Customs and Borders protect ion just silllply has to prioriti ze and hang on I(lrthe ride Rc)es sa)s lauding the agende5 wi IliJ)gncss to collaborate wit h The Border Puppy Task Fore When )oure dealing wilb tens of thousands of a day that 110 easy task
T he t ramckees wbo arc able to slip tbrough the borderwilh puppies stand to r maKe a he llthy prollt from sdli ng t helll A )orkie can be purchased in Mexico for jusl a few hund red doilars and resold fi r more than $1000
We buslxl big loca l sick and Ull -
(k rage puppy smuggler in our jurisdic-tion This person had $40000 in cash receipts for pllpp) salcs in nne Illonth This is just one inlividua] I think it is sa l to amp1V that it is a mulli -million dollar imjllstr)gt Rt)ts sols
Both Reyes and Ehner agree that a Illulti -prong approach is nttxled to admiddot d ress the issue Ehnert suggests that re-quiring mk rochips for all dogs brought into the United Stales could help better Ulon itor theSItoation and she also recom-mends th ilt health certificates should he
something that is wr) disturbing RaIT) Dorian DV lvi oflhe San Diego-
based Market Street Veterinary Clinic sa)s one problem is that clients are sbeep-ish when it comes toadmilting that they purchased a dog from someone on the st reel Puppies with distemper and paro art common at his practice but unless thecticnt open I) admits that the dog was I
from Mexico theres no wa) of determining the animals origin
The veterinary has to understand the big picture and implica-
tions of this unscrupuic)us industry of smuggling in sick and underage pup-pies Reyes says If Lhey dont they stand to lose as well
The stream of illega I puppies cannot simply be dammed Consumers need to be educated lawrna kers need to take ac-lion 1I1d vetrinarians need to be alert in order to prevent the prohlem from swelling into an ocean dvm
Mr SWPenoy Is ImelBnce Chicago
DVM Newsmagazine I dvm360(om 28 IApril 2010
A lt11l111l1Hmiddot SPI (fAf
Inside the black mdrket raquo CD KTINUED FIWv1 PAGE 27
collec t evidence that puppies were in fact being smuggled into the United States Officers from the tas k force worked hand in hand with Immigra-tion and CutOJ11S Enforcemenl offi-cials for two-week periods scvcn days a wcek two shifts a day
The effort is to sh)w t he powers that be that this is a ver) serious issue the most serious aspcct being the health problems including zoonot ic issues an the fact that tlwsc puppiescnu up in our
RI PURl
kids beds Reyes says Among the dogs being smuggled in
from Mexico parvolirus and distemper are rampant says Karen Ehncrt senior veterinarian lor the County of Los An-geles Department of Public Health
nd while legitimate breeders and pet stores would advise consumers on how to properly care (or and vaccinate a new pet someone selling smuggled dogs on the street isonl) looking to makea quick buck and is not Ii kcly concerned about the animals well-being after it is sold
We tend to vaccinate our distemper and parvo but in Mexico vac-cinesarcnt given that often The mother is not vaccinated so shes not passing along an) immunity to thc puppies Elmert says
Butlvlexico is not the only place pup-pies are being smuggled (rom and Ehnert has documented the problem of dog coming into the US from around the world through Los Angelcs International Airport
During the Summcr of 2008 we
I
started getting reports from the air-port ofpuppie hcing dead she ay Over a month period we had about four and normally we would sec only one or two per year
Ehnert and colleagues conducted till) full c(muses at the airport the most recent in August 2009 and says the bulk o(the puppies werc being shipped from Suuth Korea though a lot of singletons were coming in from Australia and Bulldogs from Hungary FI)ing from Korea to Los Angeles call be strain f(l r humans let alone 6-week 01lt1 puppies and Ehner points out that many of the pups were dying from hypoglyctmia while in transit
And thcrcs pmbablyagenetic compo-nent t here as t he ani mals used ft)r breed-ing have genetic problems Ehnert says
While documentation and verifica-tion ofa dogs age is needed to ship dogs into the United State Elmert a)s the censuses at the airport showcd that falsi-ned paperwork was rampant
People fignred out that if the) pre-sented paperwork showi ng t he dog was 4 mont hs old or older there wou Id he no restrictions after they were imported she says
As the nUlllherofcollntries shipping dogs into Ihe United Slates increases the risk of diseases more harrnfulthan distemper and larvu increases
CDCs biggest concern with these imported dogs is the risk of rabies says G Gale Galland a vcterinarv with thc Center for Disease Control lt11d Preven-tion Exacerhating the threat of rabies is Ihe fact that most of the dogs being shipped arC too young 10 evcn he vacci-nated lor rabies Owr the past few ycars there have xCn a handful ofcases of rabid dogs beingsmuggled in but enlorcement both at border crossings and airports is proving difficult
Thc Border Puppy Task I orce relies on grants to conduct their censuses Reyes says that while the task force has not been able to conduct any recent border censuses it has been cracking down on
Isellers within the cities and takinga monmiddot
I
localizcd approach to addressing the problem When like Reyes and Ehners are not at t he borders and
theres dearth oft rained an-mal health prolessionals tht can identity sick and underage animals
Mike Carne) deputy special agent in charge at Immigrations and Cus-[oms Ent(lrccmcnt Office of Invcsti -
--------- D V M Newsmagazine I dVnl160coll1 2010 I 29 -
gatio n readil) admits that national required lor all dogs entcn ng the countr) and drugs takc precedent An idea l situation would be to have spc-
over illegal puppies cia II) trained inspectors at major points I middotOur biggest threat bereon the south - of cntr) but such an arrangement would
vest border is narcotics from Mexico be costly and resource intensivc I and we haw a 101 of resources dedicated Reycs rcached out to the local veteri-to that Carncy sa)s middotmiddotBut we do have a nary community to raise awareness and dedicated group of investigators at the IXllstcr support for the issue I Ie spoke at border ca lled our Commercial Fraud nKlingsofthc Soulhem C11ilomiaVetclc
Group which focuses on preTnting inar) iIOOical issociationandsays many contrahand introduced in to the United vets were llIJlware ofthc problem Stales and that s where the pUpP) smug- It was a hock to the animal health gling Calls under communit) he says We uncowreJ
Carne) SJ)S l liling to declare puppies and srnuggling them is a federal fclony that could come with as much as 20 )ears in jail While national security and narcotics are the agellcy lop nmccrn Ca rne) sa)s the agency is parlicularly concerned with thewdfareofthc animals and the possibilit) ofn(wJiseascs being introduced in thcregion addingthatthe agency isnt taking completeiyciinical approach to the problem C Ulle) sug-
thaI fCver dogs have hem smugglL during the past two)carswhen COrnpItli with pre vious years but harJ accu rate statistics arc dimwit to gather Ca rne) attrmiddotibut e the supected decline to the weak economy as well as heightened s(eurit) and beefed-up cnilfccmenl
Customs and Borders protect ion just silllply has to prioriti ze and hang on I(lrthe ride Rc)es sa)s lauding the agende5 wi IliJ)gncss to collaborate wit h The Border Puppy Task Fore When )oure dealing wilb tens of thousands of a day that 110 easy task
T he t ramckees wbo arc able to slip tbrough the borderwilh puppies stand to r maKe a he llthy prollt from sdli ng t helll A )orkie can be purchased in Mexico for jusl a few hund red doilars and resold fi r more than $1000
We buslxl big loca l sick and Ull -
(k rage puppy smuggler in our jurisdic-tion This person had $40000 in cash receipts for pllpp) salcs in nne Illonth This is just one inlividua] I think it is sa l to amp1V that it is a mulli -million dollar imjllstr)gt Rt)ts sols
Both Reyes and Ehner agree that a Illulti -prong approach is nttxled to admiddot d ress the issue Ehnert suggests that re-quiring mk rochips for all dogs brought into the United Stales could help better Ulon itor theSItoation and she also recom-mends th ilt health certificates should he
something that is wr) disturbing RaIT) Dorian DV lvi oflhe San Diego-
based Market Street Veterinary Clinic sa)s one problem is that clients are sbeep-ish when it comes toadmilting that they purchased a dog from someone on the st reel Puppies with distemper and paro art common at his practice but unless thecticnt open I) admits that the dog was I
from Mexico theres no wa) of determining the animals origin
The veterinary has to understand the big picture and implica-
tions of this unscrupuic)us industry of smuggling in sick and underage pup-pies Reyes says If Lhey dont they stand to lose as well
The stream of illega I puppies cannot simply be dammed Consumers need to be educated lawrna kers need to take ac-lion 1I1d vetrinarians need to be alert in order to prevent the prohlem from swelling into an ocean dvm
Mr SWPenoy Is ImelBnce Chicago
--------- D V M Newsmagazine I dVnl160coll1 2010 I 29 -
gatio n readil) admits that national required lor all dogs entcn ng the countr) and drugs takc precedent An idea l situation would be to have spc-
over illegal puppies cia II) trained inspectors at major points I middotOur biggest threat bereon the south - of cntr) but such an arrangement would
vest border is narcotics from Mexico be costly and resource intensivc I and we haw a 101 of resources dedicated Reycs rcached out to the local veteri-to that Carncy sa)s middotmiddotBut we do have a nary community to raise awareness and dedicated group of investigators at the IXllstcr support for the issue I Ie spoke at border ca lled our Commercial Fraud nKlingsofthc Soulhem C11ilomiaVetclc
Group which focuses on preTnting inar) iIOOical issociationandsays many contrahand introduced in to the United vets were llIJlware ofthc problem Stales and that s where the pUpP) smug- It was a hock to the animal health gling Calls under communit) he says We uncowreJ
Carne) SJ)S l liling to declare puppies and srnuggling them is a federal fclony that could come with as much as 20 )ears in jail While national security and narcotics are the agellcy lop nmccrn Ca rne) sa)s the agency is parlicularly concerned with thewdfareofthc animals and the possibilit) ofn(wJiseascs being introduced in thcregion addingthatthe agency isnt taking completeiyciinical approach to the problem C Ulle) sug-
thaI fCver dogs have hem smugglL during the past two)carswhen COrnpItli with pre vious years but harJ accu rate statistics arc dimwit to gather Ca rne) attrmiddotibut e the supected decline to the weak economy as well as heightened s(eurit) and beefed-up cnilfccmenl
Customs and Borders protect ion just silllply has to prioriti ze and hang on I(lrthe ride Rc)es sa)s lauding the agende5 wi IliJ)gncss to collaborate wit h The Border Puppy Task Fore When )oure dealing wilb tens of thousands of a day that 110 easy task
T he t ramckees wbo arc able to slip tbrough the borderwilh puppies stand to r maKe a he llthy prollt from sdli ng t helll A )orkie can be purchased in Mexico for jusl a few hund red doilars and resold fi r more than $1000
We buslxl big loca l sick and Ull -
(k rage puppy smuggler in our jurisdic-tion This person had $40000 in cash receipts for pllpp) salcs in nne Illonth This is just one inlividua] I think it is sa l to amp1V that it is a mulli -million dollar imjllstr)gt Rt)ts sols
Both Reyes and Ehner agree that a Illulti -prong approach is nttxled to admiddot d ress the issue Ehnert suggests that re-quiring mk rochips for all dogs brought into the United Stales could help better Ulon itor theSItoation and she also recom-mends th ilt health certificates should he
something that is wr) disturbing RaIT) Dorian DV lvi oflhe San Diego-
based Market Street Veterinary Clinic sa)s one problem is that clients are sbeep-ish when it comes toadmilting that they purchased a dog from someone on the st reel Puppies with distemper and paro art common at his practice but unless thecticnt open I) admits that the dog was I
from Mexico theres no wa) of determining the animals origin
The veterinary has to understand the big picture and implica-
tions of this unscrupuic)us industry of smuggling in sick and underage pup-pies Reyes says If Lhey dont they stand to lose as well
The stream of illega I puppies cannot simply be dammed Consumers need to be educated lawrna kers need to take ac-lion 1I1d vetrinarians need to be alert in order to prevent the prohlem from swelling into an ocean dvm
Mr SWPenoy Is ImelBnce Chicago