Drunk And Destructive Sterling Thompson, Lauren Kolb, Devonta

Mitchell, Rebecca Dickinson

Key Figures Michael Kralek,Yvonne Auclaire,Steve

Haines,Jodi PorterBill and Jane BrownJonathan AllenEd RiceCheryl Knotts

Events The festival is planned and

the committee is not concerned with checking I.Ds

The four teenagers go to the festival and plan on drinking

They consume large amounts of alcohol

They decide to go to the opposite side of Lake Helen

Events Continued Yvonne cuts her foot on a sharp rockMichael suggests going in to the cabin to get a

bandage for her footThey break into the cabin and they start

throwing things at each other.Steve throws up on the carpet and soon after

they leave the cabin

Events Continued Three days later the owners of the cabin, Bill

and Jane Brown, return home.Their cabin was destroyed and the estimated

damage was $10,000.The damage was reported and the police

contacted Ed Rice because he was the one selling the beer to minors and remembered the four teenagers.

Events Continued The teenagers were identified and charged

with breaking and entering, vandalism, and underage drinking

The Teenagers had to pay $400 as well as serve 80 hours of community service.

Once the Browns learned that the committee did not plan to check IDs they decided to sue the festival committee.

Affidavits and Depositions Ed Rice revealed that he was not instructed

to check IDs or refuse to serve people who were already intoxicated

Cheryl told the attorney that the committee knew of the issue of underage drinking ,but decided to drop it because it was too much of a hassle

Affidavits and Depositions

Jonathan Allen said that he did not instruct the servers to check IDs and he revealed that the committee did not plan on changing that in the future because it was too hard.

The four teenagers admitted that what they did was wrong, however they all felt strongly that had they not been drunk they would not have committed the crime.

Subdivision 1. Consumption and Subdivision 2

It is illegal for anyone to sell alcohol to anyone under the age of 21

It is illegal for anyone under 21 to drink alcohol

The teenagers in this case were sold alcohol and drank it.

Any state,USA Statute: Persons under 21; illegal acts related to alcohol

Civil Damages Act 1994 Subdivision 1 Cause of actionIf someone suffers an injury by an intoxicated

person, the person who received the injury can sue the person who caused the intoxication

The Browns have the right to sue the committee because they provided the minors with alcohol, which resulted in the damage.

Jones v. Any town Raceway, Inc.

Ruled that in order for someone to sue for negligence the plaintiff must prove the dependent had the responsibility that he or she did not meet

The festival committee had a responsibility to follow e laws and not sell alcohol to minors and they failed to do that

Hacker v. Any town American Legion No. 600Ruled that when an intoxicated person causes

harm to somebody else after consuming alcohol that was purchased illegally the person that provided the alcohol can be held responsible for the damages.

The committee should be held responsible because they provided alcohol to underage teenagers ,which resulted in property damages

Relevant FactsAlcohol use often precedes violent events,

including vandalism.Violent acts including vandalism are more

likely in an enviroment where alcohol is readily available.

Social polices at discourage alcohol useppear to reduce the yes of violence

OutcomeThe Browns should win the suit because the

festival committee provided minors with alcohol which led to the damages.

The committee should be held responsible for all damages and should be required to change the rules for future festivals regarding checking IDs

Videohttp://

www.youtube.com/watch?v=Po7xp-lwrK8&safe=active

Picture Citationshttp://sayalihatsendiri.blogspot.com/http://

www.worldofstock.com/stock-photos/small-town-festival-at-plant-city-florida/TAU4042

http://www.giantbomb.com/cabin/3035-2367/