on the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · on the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum...

33
On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin. On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum. Calcolo, Springer Verlag, 2003, vol 40, no 3, pp 163-194. <hal-00003439> HAL Id: hal-00003439 https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00003439 Submitted on 1 Dec 2004 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destin´ ee au d´ epˆ ot et ` a la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publi´ es ou non, ´ emanant des ´ etablissements d’enseignement et de recherche fran¸cais ou ´ etrangers, des laboratoires publics ou priv´ es.

Upload: others

Post on 17-Jul-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum

Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin

To cite this version:

Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin. On the use of symmetrizing variables forvacuum. Calcolo, Springer Verlag, 2003, vol 40, no 3, pp 163-194. <hal-00003439>

HAL Id: hal-00003439

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00003439

Submitted on 1 Dec 2004

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open accessarchive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come fromteaching and research institutions in France orabroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, estdestinee au depot et a la diffusion de documentsscientifiques de niveau recherche, publies ou non,emanant des etablissements d’enseignement et derecherche francais ou etrangers, des laboratoirespublics ou prives.

Page 2: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

�������������� ����� ���������������������������� �"!#���$!#%�&������ (')�*!#&,+-�.������!#/����

02143658797$:<;)=?>6>A@CBED5GFIH)JLKC5M=?N�O.PQ=?7SRUTWV587X=M7XY�H�Z [�JL\]3^RI@C>^=C_]`�5GaCB43AN�H

bdcfeMgihkj�lnmogipMqj�r?jtsulovXhkjweMx�jky�z�j�e8polnj�rMj�{U|}po~dqj���|Xpng��8�Mjwm�j�pfr�� ��e8�AvIlo�)|}pogi�8�Mjky� |X�Cvkl�|}povIg�lnj�r�� ��e�|}���8mnjky8�4vk�Cvk�ivk�Ig�jdjwp�s4lovI��|X�Mgi�igipMqj�m���c#{U�Wz��#�f�)�I�k�I�My

�k�"lo�Mj��Ivk�igivkp�z��?logijky��$�X�8�k�2{U|Xlnmoj�gi�i�ij�x�j�r?j�� �9�?yG¡4�*���#zd¢�8|X�i�ivk�Mjwp�£fx���g�¤ �MeMgihI���¥lom9¤ �¦lL�4j���§4¨X�X�o�M�2�k���k�"�G�

© q¢u��jwx�polng�xwg�pMqj�rMjª¡?l�|}eMx�jkyC«fg�h8gimogivIe��dj�x¬~Mj�lnx¬~Mjªjwp�«Uqjwhkj��ivk�?��j��]j�e8p9y«Uqj���|Xlnpoj��]j�e8p�{Wqj�x9|}eMgi�8�Mj�rMj�m#¡��i�MgirMj�mdjwpd�­l¬|XeMm®�Aj�lnpom��d~?j�lo�]g��8�Mjwm9y

�"�8��|Xg�¯ |Xpogij�l$yG°I±X�8¨M��z�~�|Xpnvk��xwj�rMj���y�¡4�d����zd¢~Mjwl�|Xlnr�£fx���g�¤ �MeMgihI����lom$¤ �Al���~Mj�l¬|XlorC£�x¬~Mg¦±I¨X�M²�¤ rMj�l$¤ jwr8��¤ �Almnj��k�?g�eC£�x¬~Mg¦±I¨X�M²�¤ rMj�l$¤ jwr8��¤ �Al��­jw�^§d�.���k¨¥±k°2°k¨2�k°

³ª´Cµ¬¶�·¬¸k¹X¶º4»8¼�½G¾w½¿¼nÀ�ÁÃÂ�ÄI¼¬Å9Æ$Ç�¼¬Ä�Ç�Æ�Ç6»G¼fÈ�Æ$Éf½kÊ8Ç�¾9Ç6ÁÃÆwË)ÆwÌ�Â6»G¾wÍÎÍÃÆ�Ï4ÐAÏ4¾$Ç�¼nÀ�¼�Ñ$Ê8¾9Ç6ÁÃÆwËGÂ�Ò¦ÆwÀdÓ�ÊkÍünÀd¼¬Ñ$ÊG¾$Ç6ÁÃÆ�Ë8ÂoÔ

Ï4»G¼nË�Ê8Â6ÁÎËGÕfÂ�Æ9É�¼�¾�½I½kÀoÆ�Ö$ÁÃÉ�¾$Ç�¼�×�ÆXÄXÊkË8Æ�Å�Â�È®»G¼¬É�¼�Ȭ¾wÍÎÍü�Ä2Ø�Ù�ÚLÆX¼$ÛSÏu»G¼n˪Ç6»G¼uÜGÆ�ÏÝÉ�¾�Þ*ÁÎËGÈnÍÎÊGÄI¼�ÄXÀoÞ¾�Ào¼¬¾$ÂLÒ¦ÆwÀ­Å$¼nÀoÞdÍÃÆ�Ï,Äk¼nËGÂ6ÁÃÇ6Þ�Ào¼¬ÕwÁÃÆ�Ë8ÂoÔnß�º4»kÁÃÂ�ÁÃÂ�¾9È®»kÁü¬Å9¼¬Ä�ÏuÁÃÇ6»�»G¼nÍνªÆwÌMÂ�Æ9É�¼LÂ�ÞXÉ�É�¼¬Ç6À�ÁÃàoÁÎË8Õ�Å�¾�À�ÁþwákÍü¬Â¬ßº4»G¼fÏ4»GÆwÍü�¼nËG¾wákÍü¬Â�Ç�Æ�ÁÎË8Â6ÊkÀo¼�Ç6»8¼�Ä}ÁÃÂ�ÈoÀo¼¬Ç�¼f½kÀo¼¬Â�¼nÀoÅ�¾$Ç6ÁÃÆ�ËUÆwÌ�½MÆ$Â6ÁÃÇ6ÁÃÅ9¼�Åw¾�À�ÁþwákÍü¬Â�Æ�Ë¥ÁÎËkÇ�¼nÀ�̦¾$È�¼¬Â¬ÛC¾�Ë8ÄÉ�¼�¾wËkÏ4»IÁÎÍüdÇ�Æ�ȬÆ9Éf½IÊGÇ�¼�Å�¾9ÈnÊIÊGÉWÆXÈ�ÈnÊIÀo¼oË8Ȭ¼dÆ�À�½kÀoÆw½G¾$Õ9¾$Ç6ÁÃÆ�Ë�ÆwÌ�Â6»8ÆXÈ�âªÏ4¾�Å$¼¬Â�Æ�Å$¼nÀ­Ë8¼¬¾�À�ÐAÅw¾9ÈnÊkÊ8É2ß�ãÂ6»GÆwÀoÇLÂ�¼¬È¬Ç6ÁÃÆ�Ë2ÁÃÂL¾wÍÃÂ�Æ#ÄI¼¬ÄXÁÃȬ¾9Ç�¼¬Ä2Ç�Æ�Ç6»8¼�ËGÆw˪ȬÆ�Ë8Â�¼oÀoÅw¾9Ç6ÁÃÅ$¼d»kÞ$½M¼nÀ�áMÆ�ÍÎÁÃÈ�¼¬Ñ$ÊG¾$Ç6ÁÃÆ�Ë8Â�¾wÀ�ÁÃÂ6ÁÎËGÕ"Ï4ÁÃÇ6»kÁÎË�Ç6»8¼ÌiÀo¾9É�¼�ÆwÌ�ÆwËG¼nÐA¼¬Ñ$ÊG¾$Ç6ÁÃÆ�ËUÆwÀEÇ6Ï4Æ�Ð6¼�Ñ$Ê8¾9Ç6ÁÃÆwË)Ç6ÊIÀ�ákÊIÍüoËkÇfȬÆ9Éf½kÀo¼¬Â�Â6ÁÎáIÍü�É�ÆXÄk¼nÍìßd䥾�ËkÞ"ËXÊGÉ�¼nÀ�ÁÃȬ¾�Í4Ç�¼�Â�Ç�ÂȬÆ�ËIåkÀoÉQÇ6»G¼�Ȭ¾�½8¾�áIÁÎÍÎÁÃÇ6Á�¼¬ÂdÆwÌæÇ6»8¼�Â�È®»G¼¬É�¼9ÛI¾�Ë8ĪÉ�¼¬¾9Â6ÊIÀo¼dÆ�Ì�ç4èL¼nÀ�ÀoÆ�À4Ë8Æ�ÀoÉéÁÎËêÂ�Æ$É�¼L½8¾�ÀoÇ6ÁÃÈnÊIÍþ�À�Ȭ¾$Â�¼�¼nËG¾wákÍü¬ÂdÇ�Æ�Äk¼¬Ç�¾�ÁÎÍ�Ç6»G¼d¾$ȬÇ6ÊG¾wÍ�Ào¾9Ç�¼dÆwÌ�È�ÆwËkÅ$¼oÀoÕ$¼nËGȬ¼$ß

ë2ì$íXîLïkðnñXò�ódô eMgipoj�hIvk�i�M��jdmnx¬~Mj���jIy�|X�?�MlovX�8gi�)|}poj#õtvGr?�MeMvXh¥mox¬~Mjw��jkyC�dgij��)|}eMe¥�Mlnvk�M�ij��,y8��vImogipogihkj�hk|}logö�|}�M�ij�m9y?mo�8���]j�polng�÷wg�e?�#hk|}log¦|X�?��jwm9¤

�feø|X�MlngirM�kj�rùhIj�lomng�vIeùvX��po~Mjú��|X�Cj�l�~C|Xm��Cj�j�eé�Mloj�mnj�e8poj�rQr?�MlogieM�Ýpn~Mj �9�}po~ù�����f�zd¡4«z�vke¿�Aj�lojweMx�jû �������ü��|X�Cj�l��I¨k¨M�.�®�I�k°I¨ký

Page 3: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

þ ÿ����������� ��������d~Mj¥�C|X�Cj�l�j��M|X��gieMjwm#pn~Mj2mo�Mgip�|}�Mgi�ig�p���v}��movI��jª|}�M�MlovX�8gi�)|}poj�õ�v8rM�Me?vXh)mnx¬~Mj���jwm�pov�rMj9|}���dg�pn~ xwvk���?�8�p¬|XpogivIe v}��j�gipo~Mj�l"mo~�|}���iv����E|}poj�l�jw�G�C|XpogivIeMm�vkl2¢4�M�ij�l�j��8��|}pogivke?m û gieMx��i�Mr?g�e?�)pn�Mlo�?�M�ij�eMx�j]��v8rMj��4vkl"eMvkp¬ý�d~Mjwe�hk|Xxw�M�M� v8x�xw�Mlomdgie2po~Mjfmovk�i�Mpngivke�¤��d~?g�m��)|$��~�|X�?��j�e]gie¥po~Mjd�¦|Xpnpoj�lu�Al�|}��j �d~Mj�e�mnpolnvkeM��r?vk�M�M�ijdl¬|Xl��j¬��|Xx�png�vIe��E|$hIj�m��MlovI��|X�8|XpojIykvIl��d~Mj�e]movk�]jdmo~Mv8x¬²��d|$hkjdj��8��|}eMrMm�vXhkj�l�|"rMln�ê|}loj9|?¤4��e¥po~Mj*�Avkln��j�l4�6l�|X�]jkygip�gim���j��i��²8eMv��deÝpo~�|}p�po~?j)�?moj�v}��po~Mj]j��M|Xx�p¥õ�v8rM�Me?vXh mnx�~?j���j������oy4vIl�vkpn~Mj�l¥|X�M�MlnvX�8g���|Xpnjê�*g�jw�)|Xe?emnvk�ihkj�lnm�~�|}lorM�i�Ý�MlnvXh8g�r?j�m¥m�|}pogim��^|}x�povIlo� loj�mn�M�ipom��d~Mj�eù�M�i���ø�Cv8rMgij�m�|XlnjU�Mlnj�moj�e8p]g�eùpn~Mj�x�vk�]�M�Mp�|}pogivkeC|X�rMvI�)|}g�e�� �8y��My��Cy��My�� �oy�vkl��d~?j�eÝx�vk�]�M�Mpng�e?��!�v��dm�gie,m�|S�Aj�p��,hk|X�ihkj�mf�AvIl�gieMmop¬|XeMxwjk¤��d~8�Mm$y���j¥�Mlnvk�Cvkmoj~Mjwloj�gie<|Xe |}��pnj�loeC|XpogihIj#"%$�& ì9ð�')(+*-, �d|$� pnvUrMj9|}�.�dg�pn~Ýhk|Xx��?�M� g�e j9|Xx¬~ x9|XmnjkyL��|}moj�rùvIeÝpo~Mj]�Mmoj�vX�#|}e|}�M�MlovX�8gi�)|}poj¥õ�v8rM�MeMvXh,mox¬~Mjw��j�xwvk�¥�MgieMj�r/�dgipn~ |U��|}lopng�xw�M�¦|Xl�x¬~MvIg�xwj�vX��mo�8��jwpologi÷�gieM��hk|}log¦|X�M�ij�m$¤U�d~Mj�]j�po~Mv8rÝ|Xgi��m�|Xp��MlnvXhGgirMgieM�]mo�Mgip¬|X�M�ij2g�e8pnj�l��^|}x�j¥hk|X�i�Mjwm#v}�Emnp�|}poj�m$yL|XeMr���j¥jw���M~�|}mogi÷�j2po~�|}p�gip�rMv8j�m�eMvIpgi���?���2po~C|Xpdx�j��i��hk|X�i�Mj�mdv}�­mop¬|Xpnj�m#|}loj��M~8�8mogix9|}�i����|}rM��gimnmogi�M�ijdrM�Mj�pov¥pn~Mjª|$hIj�l�|}�kgieM�2�Mlov8x�j�r?�Mlojky0�d~Mgix¬~�gimeMvIp�|2�Mlov21¬j�x�png�vIe���j�pn~Mv8r û �?eM�ig�²Ij3�d~MjweU�MmogieM�2po~?j�j��M|Xx�p�õtvGr?�MeMvXh¥mox¬~Mjw��j9ýw¤4 |}x��M�M� ��|$��vX��x�vI�Mlomnj�vGxwx��Ml�logi�kvIlovk�?mo�i�5�d~?j�e¥�Av8x��?mogieM��vIe�mo~C|X�i�iv��6�d|Xpojwl�j��8��|}pogivke?m9yImogieMx�jfpo~Mj7�E|}poj�l~Mjwg��I~8p��)|$��j�gipo~?j�lª�Cj�x�vI��j¥e8�M�i���d~Mjwe�!�v�� g�m"��j$|$hGgieM��mnvk��j¥|Xlnj9|My��d~Mgix¬~Ýgim��Mmo�C|X�i�i�Ux�vke?eMj�x�pnj�r8�dg�pn~�Mlnj�mojweMx�j,vX�#hk|}log¦|XpngivkeMm2gie povI��vI�kl¬|X�M~8�8y4vkl¥�)|$�ú��j |úlojw��jwhk|Xe8p¥gieMgipog¦|X�LxwvkeMrMgipng�vIe�y4�6vkl2g�e?mop�|}eMx�j��d~Mj�emng��¥�?� |}pogieM��movI��j¥r�|}� �Mlnj9|X²8rMv��de�¤ ¯Ýj�j��]�M~�|Xmngi÷�j�pn~�|Xp¥pn~Mj�mo�Mgip�|}�Mgi�ig�p��úvX�#pn~MjU¢4�M�ij�l¥j��8��|}pogivke?mªpnv�MlnvXh8g�r?j�x�vIlolojwx�p�rMjwmox�lng��?pogivkeùvX��pn~Mj9!�v�� gieMx��i�Mr?g�e?�U�iv�� r?j�eMmogip��Ýlnj��kgivke?m û vkl2eMj9|}lªhk|}x��M�M��ý�gimªe?vkp¥|mng��i�i�Ý|Xmomn�M���?pogivke�yL|}eMr pn~�|Xp¥gip2x9|Xe ~�|XlnrM�i�Ý��j�lnj��M�¦|Xx�jwr��8�Ýmng��¥�?� |}pogivke,vX�3:�vk�ipn÷��)|}eMeÝj��8��|XpngivkeMm$yLgie��|Xe8��x�giloxwvk��mnp�|}eMx�j�m$yM�MeM�ij�mnm�pn~Mj��)|}g�e2��|}lop�vX��po~?j#�?~G�8mng�xwm�gie8hkj�mnpogi�G|}poj�r]gim�rMgimnloj��8|Xlor?j�r�¤4�d~8�Mm�x��Mlolnj�e8p�Mlnvk�M�ij��]m4mo~MvI�M�ir¥eMvkp4�Cjdx�vke8�6�Mmoj�r9�dgipo~2po~MvImoj3�d~?j�lojfpo~Mjdl¬|Xloj ô j�r��8|XmL|X�?�Mlov8|Xx¬~¥mo~MvI�M�ir¥��jd�?loj¬�Ajwloj�r û giepn~�|Xp�x9|XmnjkyMmnvk�]jdmox¬~Mj��]j�mdmo�Mx¬~U|Xm�po~?j#«��M{Uzù�]j�po~?vGr¥��|$�ªv}��x�vk�?lomoj��Cj��Mlogih8gi��jw�kj�r�y8|Xe?r�po~?j#lnj9|Xr?j�ldgimlnj¬�Aj�lnloj�r�pov"loj�h8gij��dmL�Cj�lop¬|XgieMgieM��pnv�po~�|}p ô j��ir;�ΰ2�oy%�α<�Aý�¤��d~Mjd�Mlnvk�M�ij�� vX��po~?jdx�vk�M�?��gieM��v}�­¢4�M�ij�lLj��8��|}pogivke?m�dgipo~�:�vk�ipo÷���|XeMe"j��8��|Xpng�vIeMm9y-�d~Mgix�~¥mnj�j��]m­gieMr?j�j�r�|f�MlovI��gimogieM�.�d|$�f�Avkl4gi���?lovXh8��j�e8p�v}���ivGx$|X�M�Mlnj�rMgix�png�vIev}��!�v��dm9yCgim�|X�imov¥�Cj��IvkeMr,po~Mj2moxwvk�Cj¥vX�Lpo~Mj2�Mlnj�moj�e8p���vkln²�yæ|}eMr,x9|XeMe?vkp��Cj2g��]��vImoj�r�gieU��|Xe8��gieMrM�?mopog¦|}�mng�pn��|XpngivkeMm$y4mogieMx�j�hk|Xxw�M�M� vkeM�i�Ý|Xlng�mnj�m¥gieÝmovI��j¥mo�Cj�x�g ô x�x9|}moj�m$yd|Xpª|úx�j�lnp�|Xgie pogi��j¥gieÝpo~?j�mogi�¥�M�¦|}pogivke�ygieùpo~Mjúx��ivkmojúhGgix�gieMgip��Ýv}�t�C|Xlopngix��M�¦|Xl¥lnj��kgivke?m9¤W�d~MjU�Mlnvk�M�ij�� vX��pn~MjUx9|}��|X�Mgi�igip��ÝvX��x��Mlolnj�e8p�x�vk�]�M�Mpojwl�^|}x�gi�ig�pngij�m�pnv)xwvk�Cj��dg�pn~ |}e8�)l¬|XeM�Ij¥vX�L��~Mgi�k~¿�>=�e8�MrMmnj�eÝe8�M�¥��jwl#�¥�?mop#|}�imov��Cj�|Xxwx�vk�Me8pnj�r,�Avkl$y�|XeMr,po~Mj|}x�x��Ml¬|Xx��Ýv}��po~Mj¥�]v8rMj��4mo~MvI�M�ir e?vkp���j¥xwvke8�A�?moj�r��dg�pn~ pn~Mj¥|Xx�x��?l�|Xxw�ÝvX�deG�?��j�lng�x$|X���]j�po~?vGr?m#gie8hkvI�ihkj�rgie,x�vk�]�M�Mp�|}pogivke?m9¤2¯Ýjê|}�imov�j�hkjweGpn��|X�i�i�U�Me?rMj�lo�igieMj¥pn~�|Xp�pn~Mj¥�Mlnvk�M�ij�� vX�dhk|Xx��M�?��Cj�x�vk�]j�m�j�hIj�eÝ��vIlojx�ln�Mx�g¦|X���d~MjweUpoln�GgieM�¥pnv�x�vI���M�?poj�movI��j���|Xlnpogix��M�¦|}l��MeMmnpoj9|}rM��x9|Xmnj�m�|Xlng�mngieM�¥gie)pn~Mj"�Al�|}��j�v}�Lp?��v¥�M~C|Xmoj!�v��dm$ykjwmo�Cj�x�g¦|X�i�i���d~Mj�e �Av8x��MmogieM�"vke�!��Mgir�!�v��dm�g�e¥e8�Mxw��j$|XlL�Cv���jwl��M�¦|}eGpnm9¤4¡MvIlLgieMmop¬|XeMxwjky8po~Mjf�MlovI�M�ij�� v}��Mlnj�rMgix�png�e?��!æ|}mo~MgieM�@!�v��dm�gie]m�|$�6j�p���hk|X�ihkj�m û �d~?g�x¬~��)|$�2lojw�G�?g�lnjªpnv¥�Mmoj2¢4�M�ij�ldj��8��|}pogivkeMm.�dgipn~)xwvk���?��jw�¢�A���vIl#|}��pnj�loeC|XpogihIj��i��po~?j�B�vI��vk�Ij�eMj�vI�Mm��djw� |}�M|XpogivIe){�v8rMj��¦ý ô �i�ij�r;�dgipn~)�?loj�mnmo�Mlng�mnj�r/�d|Xpojwl�gim�|2�kv8v8rx¬~�|}���ij�e?�kjd�6vkl���j�vI�M�ij3��vkln²GgieM�"g�e]po~Mjfe8�M��j�lngix9|X�Cx�vk�]�¥�MeMgip��ky$mogieMxwj#�Cvkpn~�~Mgi�I~¥rMj�eMmng�p���|XeMr¥�iv��<r?j�eMmogip��lnj��kgivke?m�|Xloj"�Mloj�mnj�e8p�gie�po~Mj ô jw��r�¤� ô lomnp�mojwx�pogivke�gim�r?j�rMgix9|Xpnj�rUpnv¥po~Mj��kjweMj�l�|}�4�Mloj�mnj�e8p�|}pogivkeUv}�Lpo~Mj�|X�?�MlovX�8gi�)|}poj#õtvGr?�MeMvXh¥mox¬~Mjw��j�eMgix¬²k�e�|}��j�r 4 ¡­�*v8j6�Î�8y#�$¨8y��k�����d~Mj�eø|}�M�M�i�8gieM�,�Avkl¥e?vke<x�vIeMmojwlohk|Xpngihkj,hk|Xlog¦|}�M�ij�m9¤W��p�lnj��8�Mgiloj�m�mnvk�ih8g�e?� |�igieMj9|}logimoj�rU�*g�jw�)|Xe?e¥�MlovI�M�ij�� |}pdj9|Xx¬~�gie8poj�l®�^|Xx�j"g�e]vklnrMj�l�pnv¥j�hk|X�i��|}poj�|XeU|X�M�?lovX�8gi�)|XpnjdgieGpnj�l���|Xx�j�mnp�|}pojDCpn~Mj�eG�?��j�lng�x$|X�E!��M�Ýgim¥po~Mjwe�r?j ô eMj�rù�8�Ýx�vI���M�MpngieM�Upo~?j)jw�¿|}x�p�!��M�,�6�MeMx�png�vIeÝ�AvIlª�Igihkj�eù|X�M�MlnvX�8g���|Xpnjgie8poj�l®�^|Xxwj¥mop�|}pojk¤2�d~Mgim*�Avkln�)|X�igimo� mo~MvI�M�ir eMvIp���j2x�vke¿�A�Mmojwr/�dg�pn~ õ�v8rM�Me?vXhk��p��8��j2mox¬~Mjw��j�m$yF�d~Mgix¬~ ~�|$hIj�Cj�j�e�gie8polov8rM�?x�j�r�gie;���$�<�­|XeMr]loj��8�Mgilnj�x�vIeMmogimopnj�eMx����dgipo~¥pn~Mj�gieGpnj��kl¬|X�?�Avkln� vX�­pn~Mj�xwvkeMmnj�lohk|}pogivke]� |2�<|}eMrx�vIeMmogimnpoj�eMxw�6�dgipo~Ýpn~Mj�j�e8polovI�8� gieMj��8��|}�ig�p��8¤�� ô lnmop2hkj�lnmogivke vX��pn~Mj¥�AvIlo�]j�l�mox¬~Mjw��j¥~�|}mª�Cj�j�eù�Mmnj�r pnvgie8hkj�mnpogi�G|}poj�|�l�|}po~Mj�l.�dgirMjfhk|Xlng�jwp��ªv}��g�e?rM�Mmopnlog¦|X��|X�?�M�ig�x$|XpogivIeMmLx�vI���M�MpngieM��¢4�M�ij�l�j��8��|Xpng�vIeMm �dg�pn~�~Mjw���¥v}�hk|}log¦|X�M�ij û �2G�H0I+J�ILKCý�¤4�d~Mj���|Xgie�girMj9|2gie�po~?g�md�C|X�Cj�l�x�vIeMx�j�lneMm�po~Mj"�Mmoj�v}�Lmovk�]j�mo�8���]j�polng�÷wg�e?��hk|Xlng |}�M�ij�mpnv¥rMj�pojwlo��gieMj�|}e)|X�?�MlovX�8gi�)|}pojdgie8poj�l®�^|Xx�j"mop�|}poj��8���igieMj9|}logi÷�gieM��pn~Mj�mo�8�]��j�pnlogix��Avkln� vX�4po~Mj�mn�Gmnpoj��,¤4¯Ýj

Page 4: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

lnj�x9|X�i��po~�|}pdpo~Mj�mn�8����jwpologimnj�r2�Avkln� vX� ô lomnp�vIlorMj�lfmoj�pfvX�LsL«�¢ gim�|}m��Avk�i�iv��dm9§M û)N ýPO NORQTS�U ûVN ýDO NO0WYX ¨ û �$ý�d~Mjwloj N g�m�pn~Mjªmn�8����jwpologi÷�gieM�2hk|Xlng¦|X�M�ijky�|Xe?r M ûVN ý û |XeMr U ûVN ýoýflnj�mo�Cj�x�png�hIj��i� mnp�|}eMrMmf�AvklfmovI��j�mn�G� ��]j�polng�x��Cvkmng�pngihkj�r?j ô eMgipojú�)|Xpnlogi� û lojwmo�Cj�x�pogihIj��i�<mo�8���]j�polngix¥�)|Xpnlogi�Mý�¤ ¯ÝjU|X�imov,loj�x$|X�i��pn~�|Xp¥�MmngieM�Ýpo~Mj�¦|Xpnpoj�l"hk|Xlog¦|}�M�ij�m�j�e�|X�?��jwmªpnvU�MlovXhIjªpn~Mj�vIloj�png�x$|X�dj��8gimopnj�eMx�j]vX�#|]�ig�e?j9|Xlng�m¬|Xpng�vIe gie,po~Mj¥mnj�eMmnj)v}�*�*v8j;���$�<�oy�d~Mgix¬~Ýgim�mopnlovIeM�k�i�U�igieM²kjwr/�dg�pn~ pn~Mj�jw�Ggimnpoj�eMxwj)v}�*|}eÝj�e8polnvk�8�U�6�MeMx�png�vIeU�6vkl�~8�8��jwlo�Cvk�igix¥mo�8mopnj���m��?eMrMj�lx�vIeMmojwlohk|Xpngihkj"�Avkln� ¤L�fj�hkjwlopo~?j��ij�mom$y�pn~Mj�� |}loj�mnj��irMvk�]���¥�?moj�r,gie)e8�M�]j�logix9|}���]j�po~Mv8rMmdgieU�?l�|Xxwpogix�j�j��8x�jw�Mp�Cj�lo~C|X�Mm7�d~Mj�e��?�Mgi��r?g�e?�ªs�j�polnvXhk�oõ�|}��jwlo²8gieMj3��j9|X²2�6vklo�¥�?� |}pogivke?m��Mmng�e?�ªpn~Mj�¡�gieMgipnj�¢4�ij���j�e8pd{�j�pn~Mv8r û moj�j�AvIl�g�e?mop�|}eMx�j;�i���2�Aýw¤ª¯Ýj"j����M~C|Xmogi÷�j2po~C|Xp�pn~Mjªpnj�x¬~MeMgi�8�Mj¥�Mlnj�moj�e8pnj�rù~Mj�loj¥gim�rMj�hIvkpnj�rÝpovU¡�gieMgipoj 4 vk�i�M�]j|}�M�MlovX�8gi�)|}pogivke?m9yk|}eMr�po~Mj�mo�?g�p¬|X�Mgi�igip��ªv}�Lpo~Mj�x¬~Mvkgix�j"vX�­mn�8��j�pnlogi÷�gieM�2hk|Xlog¦|}�M�ij�mZ�dgi�i�C��j�r?g�mnx��Mmnmoj�r�¤�*�Apoj�l��E|}lorMm$y�pn~Mjú�Al�|}��j���vkln² vX��mn~�|X�i�iv��[�d|Xpnj�l�j��8��|XpngivkeMm]g�m]�Mlogij\!C��jw�¿|}��gieMj�r8�d~Mjweølnj�mopnlogix�pogieM�ùpnvmn�G�]��j�pnlogi÷�gieM��hk|Xlng |}�M�ij�m��i�9¨ � û J�I¬�D]�ýw¤���p��dgi�i�k�Cj�mn~Mv��de�pn~�|Xp�eG�?��j�lng�x$|X�khk|}x��M�M� |}�M�Cj9|Xlnmu|}p�pn~MjLgie8poj�l®�^|Xx�jj��M|}x�po�i�^�d~Mj�e�lnj9|X�8hk|}x��M�M�Wv8x�x��MlnmLgie#pn~MjLx�vIe8pogie8�Mvk�Mm�movI���?pogivke�¤��d~MjLmo�Cj�x�g ô x�x9|}moj^���$�8y8�9�<�_�d~?j�loj���vIpopnvk�mn��vI��jwmdmo~MvI�M�ir��Cjt|}x�x�vI�Me8poj�r��6vkl û �d~Mgix¬~�lnj�mo�M�ipnmdg�e]po~Mjf�^|}x�p�po~�|}pdpo~Mj^�d~MvI��jfmo�8mopnj�� g�m�eMv2�ivkeM�Ij�l��?eMrMj�lx�vIeMmojwlohk|Xpngihkj"�Avkln�)ý�gim�rMgimnx��Mmomnj�rÝgie�rMj�p�|}gi�­gie | x�vk�]��|Xe?g�vIe���|}��jwl`�i�$°<�®¤*�d~Mjªpn~MgilorUmnj�x�png�vIe gimfrMj�hkvIpoj�rpnv�po~Mj�¢4�M�ij�l�j��8��|XpngivkeMm��dgipn~�|Xlo�?g�pnl�|}lo�2j��8��|Xpng�vIeªv}��mop¬|XpojIy8po~MvI�M�k~¥�Ml¬|Xx�pngix9|X�Ce8�M��j�lngix9|X�8j��M|X�]�M�ij�m��Av8x��MmvIe��Cj�l��Ajwx�pd�G|}mE¢4�8��|}pogivke¥v}�­�8p�|}poj û ¢�A��Mýw¤M{�vklnj�j��]�M~�|XmngimLgim��Ig�hIj�e¥vke¥pn~Mgim�mnj�x�png�vIe�yM|Xe?r¥�Av8x��Mm�gimL�kgihIj�evIe¥hk|Xlog¦|}�M�ij ûba I\J�IbK�ýw¤���pE�dg��i�8�Cj�mojwj�e�pn~�|Xp�|tx�vkeMr?g�pngivke"�c�d~Mgix¬~¥gimLmo�igi�k~8pn���"��vklnj�lnj�mopnlogix�png�hIj�pn~�|Xe¥pn~Mj�vIeMjrMjwrMgix9|Xpnj�r�pnv#jw�¿|}x�pLhk|}x��M�M�üvGxwx��MlojweMx�j¬��jwe�|X�M�ij�m�pov�gieMmn�Mlojd�Cvkmng�pngihGgip���vX��gie8poj�l®�^|Xx�jdhk|}�i�Mj�m4vX��rMj�eMmngip��ê|}eMr�Mlnj�momn�MlojI¤��ùmn~MvklnpLmoj�xwpogivke¥x�vI���M�ij�pnj�m4po~Mjd�C|X�Cj�lL�8���6vGxw�MmogieM��vke2po~?jdx�vke8hkjwx�pogihkjd�C|Xlop4v}��|*�AvI�Ml4j��8��|Xpng�vIe�]vGr?j���|XlngimogieM���d~Mjwe¥x�vk�]�M�MpogieM��x�vI���Mlnj�momngi�M�ij.=���j��Mmngi��vIe¥��v8rMj��im$¤���e¥pn~MgimLx9|Xmnj�pov8v�yIe8�M��j�lngix9|X�8hk|Xxw�M�M���|$�)v8x�xw�Ml�gie pn~Mj¥movI�i�Mpogivke,|Xp�po~Mj¥gie8pojwl��^|}x�j¥��j.�Avklnj¥g�p�v8x�x��?lom�gie,po~Mj¥j��M|}x�p�movI�i�MpogivkeúvX�dpo~Mj��*g�jw�)|Xe?e�Mlnvk�M�ij��,yX�M�Mpd|"mox9|}� |}l�xwvkeMrMgipng�vIe2���d~Mgix¬~�gim�eMvkp��¥�Mx¬~¥x�vkeMmnpol¬|XgieMgieM�X�4j�e�|}�M�ij�mdpov�gieMmn�Mloj��Cvkmng�pngihkjdhk|X�i�Mjwmv}�u�]j9|Xe¥r?j�eMmogip��8yM�]j9|Xe¥�Mlnj�momn�Mloj¥|Xe?r)pn�Mlo�?�M�ij�e8p�²8gieMj�pogixfj�eMj�ln�k�U|Xpdpn~Mj�g�e8pnj�l��^|}x�jk¤�fx�po��|}�i���8y4po~?j�loj�gimê|ú�klnj9|Xp¥mngi��gi�¦|Xlogip���gie |X�i� dG¢4�M�ij�l®�^p��8�Cj�dÝmo�8mnpoj��]mªrMgimnx��Mmomnj�r<~Mjwloj�gie�¤Ý�d~?j)pn~Mlojwj)v}�pn~Mj�� lnj��8�Mgiloj�pn~�|Xp�vkeMjfmox9|}� |}lLx�vIeMrMgipogivke2vke¥gieMgipng |}�Mr�|}p�|�~MvI�irMm ûoû ���8ý��Avkl�¢4�M�ij�lLj��8��|}pogivke?mL�AvIl4g�e?mop�|}eMx�j9ýwyvIpo~Mj�l��dgimoj�hk|}x��M�M� v8x�x��Mlnmªgie,po~Mj¥j��M|}x�p�movI�i�Mpogivke�¤êz�vIeMmogirMjwlogieM��po~MjweÝpo~Mj¥�Mlnvk�M�ij�� vX��|X�M�?lovX�8gi�)|XpngieM�mnvk�i�MpogivIeMmªv}�#pn~Mj�� |}popnj�l9y�gipªxw��j$|Xlo�i� |}�M��j$|Xlom]po~�|}pê|}�i��|X�M�MlnvX�8g���|Xpnjê�*g�jw�)|Xe?eÝmovk�ihIj�lom¥�Mmn��|X�i�i�,g�e8hIvk�ihkjgie8poj�ln��j�r?g |}pojfmop�|}poj�m7�d~Mgix¬~ §û g ý�r?v¥eMvkp�m�|}pogim��A�]�Mlojwmoj�lnhk|XpogivIeUvX�L�dgij��)|}eMe¥gie8hk|Xlog¦|}eGpnmLpo~?lovk�?�k~�po~Mj"x�vke8p�|}x�pdrMgimoxwvke8pogie8�Mgip��2�^gö�L|Xe8�I�.yû g�g¦ý�loj��8�Mgilojdpn~�|Xp�e�f�rMgimopogieMxwp­mnx9|X�¦|}l�x�vIeMrMgipogivke?m­mn~Mvk�?��r"��j��A�?� ô ���ij�r�gie�vIlorMj�l�pov�gieMmn�Mlojdpn~�|Xp�e�f û j��8�Cj�x�pojwr�ý�Cvkmng�pngihkj�x�vk�]��vIeMj�e8pomd|Xlnj�eMvIe8�^e?j��G|}pogihkjk¤�d~Mj"�MlovI��vImoj�r�mopnl�|}poj��I� |}gi��m�|}pd�MlovXh8girMgieM��mnvk��jfloj��]j�rM�]pov¥po~C|Xp��^|}g��i�Mlnjk¤�d~Mgim�|}�M�Mlov8|Xx¬~U|X�imov¥xwvkeMx�jwloeMm^��vklo²Ij�lomfgie�po~?j ô j��ir�vX�Lmop¬|Xpng�mnpogix9|}��rMj�mnx�logi�Mpngivke�vX�Lpo�?lo�M�M�ij�e?x�jkyC�MmogieM�2�6�M�i��*j��8eMvk�irMmdmnpolojwmom�x��ivkmn�Mloj�m�|XeMr�¡�|$h8lnjt|$hIj�l�|}�kgieM�2�Mlov8x�jwmom9¤

g hji�k����ml9�n� ���.�<lpo2qr��s�tvu8wx�qyk��>z�q|{}q7k¯Ýj2�Mlogij\!C�Uloj�x$|X�i�L~Mj�lnj�gie pn~Mj¥��|}mogim�vX� 4 ¡­�*v8jªmnx�~?j���j��dgipo~UeMvIe xwvkeMmnj�lohk|}pogihkj¥hk|}log¦|X�M�ij�m$¤�¯Ýj�lojwmopolngix�p�AvIl�pn~Mjªm¬|X²Ij�vX��mngi���M�igix�gip��ªpnv�lnj��k�M�¦|}l���jwmo~Mj�m�v}�umngi÷�j`~ W mo�Mx¬~,po~�|}p9§3~ W X W����7��@� W��L�.�� yF� �#�2yG|}eMrrMjweMvkpnjª|Xmd�Mmn��|X��~ Q po~?j�pogi��jdmnpoj���y%�d~Mj�lnj`~ Q X Q�� � b � Q�� y0���9� ¤¯Ýj�rMj ô eMj��r�9����pn~Mj�j��M|Xxwpdmovk�i�Mpngivke�v}�Lpo~Mj�eMvIe)r?j��kj�e?j�l�|}poj�r,~8�G�Cj�ln��vI��gix�mo�8mnpoj��,§� O �ORQjS O0� û �øýO0W X ¨� û W I¬¨ký X ��f û W ý

Page 5: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

�dgipo~ � û �øý*g�e����k¤ � j�p�� �� �Cjªpn~Mjê|}�M�MlnvX�Ggi��|Xpojfhk|X�i�Mj�v}� �~ W��/�P� � ��� ��� ��� û W I Q � ý�� W ¤f��eGpnj��kl¬|Xpng�e?��vXhkjwl� W��L� �� C W��V� �� ���#� Q�� C Q�� � b?�­�MlnvXh8g�r?j�m9§� � � b� X � �� � ~ Q~ W���� ��V� �� � � ��b� ��- �d~Mjwloj � ��V� �� mop¬|XeMr?m��Avkl�po~Mj�e8�M�]j�logix9|}�%!��?��po~?lovk�?�k~�pn~Mj�gieGpnj�l���|Xx�j�¡ W��V�7���¢ �#� Q�� C Q�� � b?�o¤4�d~Mj�pogi��jdmnpoj��gim�gie |X�Iloj�j��]j�e8p3�dgipo~úmovk�]jªzd¡ � x�vIeMrMgipogivIeUgieUvklnrMj�l�pnv��G|}gieUmop¬|X�Mgi�igip��G¤d�d~8�Mm � ��V�7�� vIeM�i��rMj��Cj�eMrMm�vIe� �� |XeMr�� ��V� b �d~?j�e�loj�mnpologix�pngieM�¥pov ô lomnp�vIlorMjwldmox¬~Mj��]j�m9¤4¯<~C|Xpojwhkj�ldpn~Mj�mnx�~?j���jfg�m$y8po~Mjfe8�M��j�lngix9|X��!��M�x�vI���M�igij�m �dgipo~�xwvkeMmng�mnpoj�e8pfx�vkeMr?g�pngivke û mnj�j� �2�Aý�§

� û?£ I £ ý X � û¤£ ý¯Ýj4�Mlnj�moj�e8pLe?v�� |}�M�MlovX�8gi�)|}poj4õ�v8rM�MeMvXh !��?�Gjwm � û �p¥�I<��¦uý�|}momnvGxwg |}poj�r��dgipo~�po~?j��9« �dgij��)|}eMe��?lovk�?��jw� §§¨© ¨ª O �ORQ S O0� û �øýO«W X ¨� û W I¬¨ký Xj¬ � ¥ gö� W9­ ¨� ¦ vIpo~Mjwl��dgimoj û �Iý

|}eMr�g�e?g�png¦|X�Cx�vkeMr?g�pngivke�§E�p¥ X � � |XeMr��p¦ X � �V� b y%�n�p�2¤4 ¡­�*v8j�mox¬~Mj��]j�gim#|}e |}�M�MlnvX�Ggi��|Xpoj�õ�v8rM�MeMvXh]mox¬~Mj��]j^�d~Mj�loj2po~?jê|}�M�MlovX�8gi�)|}pojdhk|}���?jt|}p�pn~Mj�gie8poj�l®�^|Xx�j�Cj�p?��j�j�e2p?��vdx�jw���im�g�m�xwvk���?�Mpoj�r�|}m�rMj�p�|}gi��jwr#�Cj��iv���¤ � j�p��Mm�x�vke?mogirMj�l�movk�]j4x�~C|XeM�IjLvX�8hk|Xlog¦|}�M�ij N X N)û �øýgie�mn�Mx¬~U|��d|$�¥po~�|}p3��® ¯ ûVN ýLgim�g�e8hIj�lopng��?��jI¤4�d~Mj�x�vk�Me8pnj�lo��|}lopdv}�u|X�CvXhkjfmo�8mopnj�� �Avkl�loj��I�M�¦|Xldmnvk�i�MpogivIeMmLgim9§O NORQ°S8U ûVN ý O NO0WYX ¨�d~Mjwloj U ûVN ý X û �#® ¯ ûVN ýoý � b\± û � û)N ýoý>�#® ¯ ûVN ý û ± û �øý�mnp�|}eMrMm��6vkl�po~?jL�G|}x�vk�Mg¦|}e��)|}pologi��vX��!��M� � û �øýoýw¤�fv���y8po~Mj�e8�M�]j�logix9|}�%!C�M� � û � ¥ I<� ¦ ý�gimdvk�?p�|XgieMjwr��8��mnvk�ih8g�e?�ªpn~Mj���gieMj$|Xlogi÷�jwr)~8�8�Cj�lo�Cvk�igix�mo�8mopnj�� §§¨© ¨ª O NO�Q S8U û%²N ý O NO0W X ¨N�û W I�¨Iý X ¬ N ¥ X N�û ��¥�ý gö� W�­ ¨N ¦ X N�û �p¦�ý�vIpo~Mjwl��dgimoj û �Iý

�d~Mjwloj ²N |X�Iloj�jwm3�dgipo~�po~?j#xwvkeMrMgipng�vIe�§ ²N�û)N ¥�I N ¥�ý X N ¥LyM|}eMrU|X�imov ²N�ûVN ¥�I N ¦Lý X ²N�û)N ¦3I N ¥æýw¤AfeMx�j�pn~Mj�j��M|}x�p�mnvk�i�Mpng�vIe N�³kû � ´ C N ¥ I N ¦ ýuvX��po~?g�m�|X�M�MlnvX�8g���|XpnjL�MlovI�M�ij�� gimLvk�Mp¬|XgieMj�r�ykpn~Mj�e8�M�]j�logix9|}��!��M�gimdrMj ô eMj�r |}m9§

� û � ¥ I<� ¦ ý X � û � û)N ³ û ¨�C N ¥ I N ¦ ýoýoý� j�pd�Mm�moj�p�µ¶¸· yR¹º · |}eMr µ» · y%e X �DI2¼¸¼¸¼½IbK�y$�ij¬�Ap�j�gi�kjweGhIj�x�pnvklom$yMj�gi�Ij�e8hk|X�i�Mj�md|XeMr¥lngi�k~8p�jwg��Ij�e8hkj�xwpovklnmdvX�4�)|Xpnlogi�U û N ý�loj�mn��jwx�pogihkjw���8¤4�d~MjLmnvk�i�Mpng�vIe N`³Iû � ´ C N ¥ I N ¦ ý�vX�Mpn~MjL�igieMj9|Xl4�dgij���|XeMef�MlovI�M�ij��øgim�rMj ô eMjwrªj�hIj�lo���d~Mjwlojû j��8x�j��Mp�|X�ivIeM� � ´ X ¹ º · ý�§ N ³ � W Q C N ¥ I N ¦   X N ¥ Sr¾¿ ÀPÁFÂÃ�Ä û ´ µ¶½· ¼ ûVN ¦ � N ¥ ýný µ» ·

X N ¦ � ¾¿ À-ÅFÂÃ�Ä û ´ µ¶¸· ¼ û)N ¦ � N ¥ ýný µ» ·�

Page 6: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

z�vI�¥�MgieMgieM��po~Mj��¦|}mop�j��8��|X�igipogij�mdj�eC|X�M�ij�mfpov��dlogipoj�po~?j��¦|Xpopnj�ldgie)|2mn��gi�I~Gpn�i�¥rMgÆ�æj�lnj�e8p��Avkln� §N ¦ � N ¥ X ¾· Ç b ® � û ´ µ¶ · ¼ ûVN ¦ � N ¥æýný µ» · X ¾·�Ç b ® �|ÈÉ · µ» · û �8ý

mnj�popng�e?��§ ÈÉ · X ´ µ¶¸· ¼ ûVN ¦ � N ¥ ý�¤:�j¬�AvIloj��IvkgieM��vIe�yD��j�loj�x$|X�i��po~�|}p�pn~Mj^:E|}mogix 4 ¡4�dv8j�mox¬~Mjw��j3�d|Xm ô lnmopd�Mlnvk�CvkmojwrUgie;���$±<�oyM|XeMr9�E|}m���|}moj�rvIeUpo~Mj"x�~?vkgix�j N�û �øý X � |XeMrúpo~8�Mm U û N ý X ± û �øýw¤ û ��j�lnj�x9|X�i�4po~C|Xp3± û �øý*g�mfpo~Mj"�G|Xxwvk�Mg¦|Xeú�)|Xpnlogi�v}� � û �øýwy�|XeMr;��j�eMvIpoj2po~Mlnvk�M�I~Mvk�?p�po~?jª��|}��jwl9§ � ¥%¦ X û � ¥ S � ¦Lý�Gk���d~C|Xpojwhkj�l � gim�ýw¤�Afpo~?j�l�x�~?vkgix�j�m�AvIl�¢4�M�ij�ldj��8��|}pogivke?md~�|$hkj�|X�ilnj9|XrM�¥�Cj�j�eúj��M|X��gieMjwr#�Î�<�oy½�i�$�\�o¤Bfj�eMx�jkyCpn~Mj�j��8�M�igix�gipL�6vklo� vX�Lpo~Mj�¡�gieMgipoj 4 vI���?��jd��jwpo~Mv8r�x$|X�i�ij�r 4 ¡­�*v8j��dgi�i���Cjk§� � � b� � � �� S ~ Q~ W�Ê � û � û)N ³ û ¨%C N �� I N ���� b ýoýoý � � û � ûVN ³ û ¨�C N ��b� b I N �� ýoýný?Ë X ¨«fj�mn�Mgipoj��Alnvk� gipom¥e�|}��jky�g�p¥gim¥j��]�M~�|}mogimoj�rùpn~�|Xp 4 ¡­�*v8jUmox¬~Mj��]j�mo~MvI�M�ir�e?vkp¥�CjUx�vke¿�A�MmojwrÌ�dgipo~ùpo~Mj|}�M�MlovX�8gi�)|}poj2logij���|XeMe,movI��hIj�l��Mlnvk�Cvkmnj�rù�G�Ýs4¤ � ¤��*v8jk¤�¯Ýj¥eMv�� j��M|X�]g�e?jªmn��j�xwg ô x)mnx¬~Mj���jwmªvI�Mp�|}g�e?j�r�d~MjweUrMj9|}��gieM���dgipo~]mo�8���]j�polng�÷wg�e?��hk|Xlng |}�M�ij�m9¤Í Îzi�o<o��7Ï[Ð�ÏÑi^��qÒ�vq7Ó9�i|�������kÔ.Õ�Ö ×ÌØFÙ Ú�Û%Ü7Ý�Ü.ÞßÚ�à.á7â�ã%Ý�Ø�Ü3ä��eù|�vkeMj]rMgi��j�e?mogivke�|}�4�Al¬|X��j<��vIlo²�y�mn~�|X�i�iv����?�E|}poj�l�j��8��|}pogivkeMm2�)|$�ú��j9�dlogipopnj�eùg�eÝxwvkeMmnj�lohk|}pogihkj �Avkln� y�MmngieM��x�vIeMmojwlohk|Xpngihkj2hk|Xlog¦|}�M�ij5� X ´ ûLå I å J�ýwyCeMvkpng�e?� å po~Mj��d|Xpnj�l�~Mj�gi�k~8p$yæJ,|Xe?r#ç X å JUpn~Mj�hkjw��v8x�gip��|}eMr�po~Mj���vI��j�e8pn�M� û vkldrMgimox¬~�|}lo�Ij9ýdlnj�mo�Cj�x�png�hIj��i�GyC|XeMr9è�pn~Mj��kl¬|$h8g�p��2x�vIeMmop¬|Xe8p9§å ® ´ S ûbå JCý\® � X ¨ û �k|Iý

ûLå J�ý ® ´ Sêé å J © S è å ©�9ë ® � X ¨ û �X�Cý

4 |}x��M�M�m�dgi�i�Lv8x�x��Ml��d~Mj�eÝ�Cvkpn~Ý��vI��j�e8po�?�|XeMr/�d|Xpnj�l�~Mj�gi�I~Gp"hk|XeMgimo~�§ å X å J X ¨?¤���vkpnj¥po~�|}p�giepn~Mgim#x$|Xmoj�Júg�mf�MeMrMj ô eMj�r�¤�Afpn~Mj�l��dgimnj¥po~Mj�mnvk�i�Mpng�vIeUvX�Lpn~Mjê|}momnvGxwg |}poj�rÝ�dgij���|XeMe]�MlovI�M�ij���gim�x�vI���Cvkmnj�rv}�­po~?loj�j�rMgimopngieMx�pdmop¬|Xpnj�mdmoj��C|Xl�|}poj�r��8�¥p?��vêõ�jweG�?g�e?j��i�ª�fvke � gieMj9|Xl ô j��irMm9¤4�d~Mjfmo�Cj�j�rUv}�­pn~Mj�p?��v5�d|$hkjwm|}loj�J � ]"|XeMr/J S ]"loj�mn��jwx�pogihkjw���8y�eMvIpogieM��|Xm��?mo��|}�Z] Xíì è å ¤��d~Mj2gieGpnj�lo�]j�rMg¦|Xpnj�mop�|}poj¥gim�gieMr?j��8j�r �8�mn�M�Mmoxwlogi�Mpª�I¤��fvkpng�e?� å b Xïî�ð �?ñ �ò yG|}eMrpç b X å b J b y8po~?j#mnp�|}eMr�|Xlnr�mnvk�i�MpogivIe¥vX�­pn~Mj¥�9«W�dgij���|XeMe2�MlovI�M�ij��x�vIeMmogimnpom�g�e¥pn~Mlojwj#r?g�mnpogieMx�p�mop�|}poj�m.�dgipn~ªmn�M�Mmoxwlogi�Mpom � y��f|XeMr�� mojw��|Xl¬|Xpojwr)�8�2l�|}loj¬�^|}x�pogivIe��E|$hIj�mLvkl�mo~Mv8x¬²�d|$hkj�m�|}mdloj�x$|X�i�ij�r��G�]po~Mjt�Avk�i�iv��dgieM� ô �k�Mlnj¥�k¤�d~Mj"vkeMj�r?g��]j�eMmng�vIe�|X���dgij���|XeMe¥�?lovk�?��jw��~�|Xm�|2�Me?g��8�Mj"j�e8polovI�8�)xwvkeMmng�mnpoj�e8pfmovk�i�Mpngivke��dgipo~�eMv¥hk|Xxw�M�M�v8x�x��?loj�eMxwj¥�MlovXh8girMj�r]po~�|}pdg�e?g�png¦|X�Cr�|Xp¬|2m�|Xpngim ô j�mfpo~Mjf�AvI�i��v��dgieM��x�vIeMrMgipogivIe�§J ¦ � J ¥ ­ � û�ó è å ¦ S ó è å ¥ ý û �Iý

Page 7: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

Ô.Õ¤ô õ ö3÷Ñ÷ÑÚøã_Û%Ý�ùFÝ?Ü.ÞúÙnâ�Û%Ý�â�û3ü�Ú�ä�d~Mgim2mo�8mopnj�� �)|$�U�Cj�dlng�pnpoj�eùgieÝpojwlo��m2vX��e?vke xwvkeMmnj�lohk|}pogihkj]hk|Xlog¦|}�M�ij N�û �øý X ´ û �D]�I\JCý�gie�|�mn�G� ��]j�polng�÷wj�r]�Avkln� moj�pnpogieM�¥gie û �$ý�§

U ûVN ý X é J ]]ýJ ë |XeMr M ûVN ý X é � ¨¨ � ë{U|}polng�� U û)N ý*gimdx��ij9|Xln����mn�G�]��j�pnlogix#|}eMr M û)N ýdgimdpo~?jªgirMj�e8png�p��]�)|}pologi���d~Mgix¬~Uv}�uxwvk�Mlnmoj2g�mfmo�8���]j�polngix�Cvkmng�pngihkj�rMj ô e?g�pnjk¤

Ô.ÕbÔ þ8ÿ7ÿ3Û%Ø��3Ý�÷Ñâ�ã%Ú8×ÌØ��3á7Ü3ØFÙÑä����7Ú�÷ÑÚ�� �8Ø.Ú á7ä�Ý�Ü.ÞíäPö3÷Ñ÷êÚ0ãRÛ�Ý�ùFÝ?Ü.Þ8Ù�â�Û%Ý�â�û7ü�Ú¯Ýjdpn�Mloe¥eMv�� pov�pn~Mj�|Xmnmov8x�g¦|Xpnj�r¥�igieMj9|Xlngimoj�r¥�Mlnvk�M�ij��,yX|XeMr¥mnj�pL�6vklL|Xe8���8��|}eGpngip����d§ û ~ �Lý¤¥%¦ X ��¦ � ��¥L¤�d~Mj2x�vI���M�Mp¬|Xpng�vIe�vX��pn~Mjªgie8pojwlo��jwrMg¦|Xpoj"mop�|}poj2gieUpo~Mj2�igieMj9|Xlngimoj�r,movI��hIj�l#|}p�j9|}x¬~ gie8poj�l®�^|Xxwjª�Cj�p?��j�j�eÝp?��vx�jw���imd�¦|X�Cj��i�ij�r��.I��Wg�mdmnpol¬|Xgi�k~8p��6vkl��d|Xlnr û ��j�mojwp�~Mj�lnjk§ ²N X N ýw§J b X J ¥�¦ � û ~�]�ý ¥%¦ |XeMr ] b X ] ¥%¦ � û ~�J�ý ¥%¦

��fvkpojfpo~�|}p4po~Mjf��gieMj$|Xlogi÷9|}pogivke"~�|XmL�Cj�j�e]�)|}rMjE|}lovI�MeMr¥po~?jdmop�|}poj û � ]$y JCý�¤��d~Mjde8�M��j�lngix9|X��!C�M��po~8�Mm �dlogipnj�m9§ç b X û ] b ýo©�� bè |}eMr é å � © S è å ©� ë b X û ] b ý © � û � b ýo© S û ] b ýn©� èÔ.Õ�� õ.Ø�÷ÑÚÌÿ7Û%Ø�ÿ�Ú�Û�ã%Ý�Ú�ä�dðnï��Mì9ð��Aí��Xó�4 |Xx��M�?� |Xlngimoj�m�gie,po~Mj]gieGpnj�lo�]j�rMg¦|Xpnjªmnp�|}poj¥vX�d�igieMj9|Xlngi÷�j�r õ�v8rM�Me?vXhUmovI��hIj�l�gö�*|}eMrÝvkeM�i�Ugö�gieMgipog¦|}�Mr�|Xp¬|f�)|X²Ij�m4hk|Xx��?�M� vGxwx��Ml�g�e¥pn~Mj�jw�¿|}x�p�movk�i�Mpngivke2vX��po~?j��dgij��)|}eMe2�MlovI�M�ij�� |}momov8x�g¦|}poj�r9�dg�pn~¥po~MjeMvIe���gieMj$|Xl�moj�pfvX�­jw�G�C|XpogivIeMm9§ J ¦ � J ¥ ­ � û ] ¥ S ] ¦ ý û °Iý�dðnï9ï���ó �fx�po�C|X�i�i�Gy2�d~Mj�et�Av8x��MmogieM�fvke�po~?j�mnvk�i�MpogivIe#v}�Mpo~MjLjw�¿|}x�pL�dgij���|XeMef�MlovI�M�ij�� y¬hk|}x��M�M�Q��|$�dvkeM�i��v8x¬�x��?lZ�d~Mjwe¥g�e?g�png¦|X�8r�|Xp¬|�gimLmo�?x�~¥pn~�|Xp�p?��v�l¬|Xlnj¬�^|Xxwpogivke��d|$hkj�m�rMj�hkjw��vI��¤4�dgij��)|}eMe�gie8hk|Xlng |}e8pom­|}lojf�Mloj�mnj�lohIj�rgie�po~�|}pdx9|XmnjkyC~Mj�eMxwj5J S �D] û lnj�mo�Cj�x�pngihkj��i�;J � �D]�ý�gimdx�vIeMmop¬|Xe8p�gie]po~Mj��.�^l¬|Xlnj¬�^|Xxwpogivke��d|$hkj û loj�mn��jwx�pogihkjw���pn~Mj��$��l�|Xlnj¬�^|}x�pogivke��d|$hkj9ý7C8gö��mo�M�?mox�lng��?pª�floj¬�Ajwlom�pnv¥po~Mj�gie8poj�ln��j�r?g |}pojdmnp�|Xpnj�gie�pn~Mj ì �P*D(!� movk�i�Mpngivke¥vX�4po~Mj�*g�jw�)|Xe?e¥�MlovI�M�ij�� yIpo~Mjwe�§ J ¦ � �D] ¦ X J b � �D] bJ ¥ S �D] ¥ X J b S �P] b�d~MjwlojUmn�M�Mmoxwlogi�Mpom � |}eMr�� loj.�Aj�l¥pov,hk|X�i�Mjwmªv}�#gieMgipog¦|X��r�|}p�|úg�eÝpn~MjU�dgij���|XeMeÝ�Mlnvk�M�ij��,¤,c�mogieM�,movI��j|}���Ij��Ml¬|2j�e�|X�?��jwmdpov¥loj<�dlogipoj�pn~Mj��¦|Xpopnj�l�|Xm$§J b X J ¦ S J ¥

� � û ~�]�ý ¥%¦ |}eMr ] b X ] ¥ S ] ¦� � û ~�JCý ¥�¦

� ¼AfeMj]�)|$��~Mj�lnj)x¬~Mjwx�²Ýpn~�|Xp"�M~8�Gmngix9|X�i�i�Ulojw��j$|$hk|Xe8p�mop¬|Xpnj�m û �dgipo~Ý�Cvkmogipng�hIj¥hk|X�i�Mj�m"vX��] b ýtg��]�M�i��po~�|}p�po~Mj�AvIlo�]j�ldx�vke?rMgipogivke û �ký*g�m*�A�M� ô �i�ij�r�¤�{ vkloj2vXhkjwl9yCgip�x9|}eU��j2j9|}mogi�i��mojwj�eÝpo~�|}p�pn~Mgim�x�vI�M�M�ij û J b I+] b ý�jw�¿|}x�po�i�lnj��Mlojwmoj�e8pom,po~?j gie8poj�ln��j�r?g |}poj�mop¬|Xpnj �MlnvXh8g�r?j�r<�8�ùpo~Mj,�ig�e?j9|Xlng�mnj�rø|}�M�MlovX�8gi�)|}poj�õ�v8rM�MeMvXh mox¬~Mj��]j#��j�

Page 8: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

�Av8x��?mdvke�¤��d~Mgim�xwvk���?��jwpoj�mLpn~Mj��Mlov8v}��vX�­�?lovk�Cj�lnp��U�k¤4�d~8�Mm9y8pn~Mj��?loj�mnj�e8p��igieMj9|Xlngi÷�j�r¥movI�ihkj�l�gimZ��j��i��mn�Mgipoj�rpnv)~C|XeMrM�ij2rMvk�?�M�ij�l�|}loj¬�^|}x�pogivIe#�d|$hkj�m�gie,po~Mj2movI���?pogivkeUv}��po~?j¥j��M|Xx�p��dgij���|XeMe��Mlnvk�M�ij��,y�|Xp��ij9|}mop^�d~Mj�e�Mlnj�rMgix�png�e?�#gie8pojwl��^|}x�jLhk|X�i�Mjwm9¤4«��?jLpovfpo~Mj�|$hIj�l�|}�kgieM�d�Mlnv8x�j�rM�MlnjkyIg�p�rMv8j�moe�� p���j9|}e�|Xe8���E|$�fpo~�|}p�x�j��i�8hk|X�i�Mjwmv}�Z�E|}poj�lf~Mj�gi�k~8pfloj���|Xgie���vImogipogihkjIy�mngieMx�j2po~Mj ô lomop�vIlorMj�l�mnx�~?j���j�r?vGjwm#e?vkp�xwvkeMmnpolo�?x�p�po~?jª�Mlnv�1¬j�xwpogivkeUv}�pn~Mj�|X�M�?lovX�8gi�)|XpnjLmovI�i�Mpogivke�¤����M�Cj�eMr?g��¥°#""~Mv���j�hkjwl­mn~Mv��dmLpn~�|XpLxw��vImojdpnvt||�E|}���8�Cvk�Me?r�|Xln�GyXpn~Mjdx�j��i�Chk|X�i�Mjv}�n�d|Xpnj�l�~?j�gi�k~8pdloj���|XgieMm���vImogipogihIj��d~?j�e |2hkjwlo��mopnlovke?�¥l�|Xlnj¬�^|}x�pogivke��E|$hIj#r?j�hkj��ivI�Mm û j����d~Mj�e$� ¼ �&%ø¨?y�d~Mjwloj��,rMj�eMvIpoj�m�pn~Mj��Me?g�pfvk�Mp?�d|XlnrUeMvIlo�)|}��hkj�xwpovkl�|}p�po~?j��E|}�i���Cvk�MeMrC|Xlo�Mýwyæ|}momn�M��gieM�2mop¬|XeMr�|}lorÝzd¡ �x�vIeMrMgipogivIe(' � � X ¨%¼Î�M¤Ô.Õ*) +úá3÷êÚ�Û%Ý��Fâ�ü^Û%Ú�ä�á3ü?ã%ä�d~Mj2x�vI���M�Mp¬|Xpng�vIe�|X��lnj�mo�?��pnm�rMj�moxwlogi��jwrÝ��j��iv��Qx�vIlolnj�mo�CvkeMrÝpnv)|]�dgij��)|}eMe��MlovI�M�ij��x�dgipo~Upn~Mj��AvI�i��v��dgieM�gieMgipog¦|}��r�|}p�|?§ å ¥ X å ¦ X �9¨ |}eMr J ¥ X � J ¦ X � �$�%¼z�vIeMmop¬|Xe8p�ètgim4mojwpLpov��M¤��d~MjEzd¡ � e8�M�¥�Cj�l�gimL¨%¼ �G�?yX|XeMr�pn~Mjdlojw�k�M�¦|Xl4�]j�mo~�xwvke8p�|}g�e?mu�I¨k¨I¨deMv8rMj�m$¤­¡�gi�k�?loj�m�2mn~Mv��øpn~Mjª|}�M�MlovX�8gi�)|}pogivke2vX���d|Xpnj�ld~Mj�gi�k~8p$yMrMgimox¬~�|}lo�Ijª|XeMr��iv8x9|X��hIj��iv8x�gip���d~Mgix¬~�~�|$hkj��Cj�j�eUvI�Mp�|}g�e?j�r�MmngieM�¥po~Mj���|}mogix ô lomnp�vIlorMj�lfmox¬~Mj��]jk¤�*j�x9|X�i��po~�|}pdpo~Mj��C|Xmogixª|}rMhk|Xe8p¬|X�kjfvX�Lpo~?j�mo�8���]j�polngix9|X�Cx9|Xmnjªgimdpn~�|Xpdgipd�MlnvXhGgirMjwm�movI��jf�kv8v8r)girMj$|2vX�Lpo~Mj�Cj�~�|$h8givk�Ml�vX��po~Mjdmnx�~?j���jdx��ivImojdpov@�E|}���8�Cvk�Me?r�|Xln�ªx�vIeMrMgipogivIeMm��d~Mj�e�|X�?�M�i�GgieM�f�AvIl4po~Mjd�]g�lnlovIl�pojwx�~?eMgi�G�?jk¤�d~MvI�M�k~ùpn~Mj�mox¬~Mj��]j)gim¥mnp�|X�?��jIyZ��j�eMvkpnjU|Xe8���E|$�Ýpn~�|Xp�|}�M�MlovX�8gi�)|}poj2hk|X�i�Mj�m¥v}�#hIj��ivGxwg�p�� gie po~?j)e?j9|Xlhk|}x��M�M� ÷wvkeMj û jw�¥po~Mj�j�eMr�v}�­po~?jê�.�^l¬|Xlnj¬�^|Xxwpogivke9�E|$hIj�vkl�po~?j���jw�kgieMeMgieM��v}�­pn~Mj��$��l�|Xlnj¬�^|}x�pogivke9�E|$hIj9ý�|Xloj�Cv8vklo�i��|Xx�x��?l�|Xpnjk¤¯Ýj¥�Ig�hIjª�Cj��iv�� vIe ô �k�?loj�m¥�]movk�]jª�]j9|Xmn�Mloj¥v}�Epn~Mj,��b2eMvkln�vX�dpo~?j�j�lnlovkl$y��d~Mgix¬~ gim��M�ivIpopojwr,�Avkl�p?��vx9|}moj�mdgieMxw���?rMgieM��po~?j�mo~?vGx¬²¥pn�M��jfx9|Xmnj#|}eMr�mn�G�]��j�pnlogix9|}�Gr?vk�M�M�ijdl¬|Xloj.�^|Xx�pngivke�d|$hkjdr?g�mnx��Mmnmoj�rU|X�CvXhkjIyG|}eMrgieMx��i�Mr?j�m�xwvk���C|Xlogimnvke��dgipo~¥lnj�mo�?��pnmLvk�?p�|XgieMjwr¥�MmogieM��pn~Mjd��|}mogix�õ�v8rM�MeMvXh"mox¬~Mj��]j������o¤��d~Mj��]j9|Xmn�Mlojwrªl¬|Xpojv}��x�vke8hIj�lo�Ij�eMx�j]g�m�x��ivImoj2povU¨%¼Î±k�2gieU�Cvkpn~ x$|Xmojwm9y��d~Mgix¬~Ugim�mo�igi�k~8po�i��mn�)|}���ij�lfpo~�|}eUj��8�Cj�x�pojwrø�ky��M�Mp�gim�gie|}�klojwj���j�e8p �dgipo~��]j9|Xmn�Mlojw��j�e8pom��MlnvXhGgirMjwr�gie#�Î�2��gie�pn~Mjf�Al�|}��j.��vklo²¥v}�u¢4�?��jwldj��8��|Xpng�vIeMm �d~Mj�e]�Av8x��Mmng�e?�vIe)�Cj�l®�Aj�x�pf�G|Xm�¢EA#��¤�d~Mj"�Mloj�mnj�e8p�movI�ihkj�lf~�|Xm�|X�imov¥�Cj�j�e,�MmojwrUmo�Mxwx�j�mom®�A�M�i�i�;�d~Mj�e,x�vI���M�MpngieM�ªmn~�|X�i�iv����?�E|}poj�l�j��8��|XpngivkeMm7�dg�pn~pnvk�Cvk�kl¬|X�M~8�/�i�9°<�o¤f�d~Mjª��|Xgie��?lovk�?��jw��g�eúpo~�|}p#x$|Xmoj2gim�pn~�|XpfvkeMj2eMj�j�r?m�gie |XrMr?g�pngivke�pov�|Xx�x�vI�Me8pf�AvklfmovX�x9|}�i��jwrUmovI�Mlox�j2pojwlo��m�|}momnvGxwg |}poj�r��dgipo~���j$|Xe��kl¬|XrMgij�e8p�v}�L��vIpopovI�-jw��jwhk|XpogivIe�¤��d~Mgim���j$|XeMmdgie���|Xlnpogix��M�¦|}lpn~�|Xp�vkeMjd~C|XmLpnv��MlovXh8girMjdmnvk��jdr?g�mnx�lojwpoj�|X�M�?lovX�8gi�)|XpngivXe�gieªmn�Mx¬~)|^�d|$�ªpn~�|Xp�mopoj$|XrM�¥mnp�|Xpnj�md|Xlojf��jwl��Aj�xwpo�i��Mlnj�mojwlohkjwrøvIe�|Xe8�Ý�]j�mo~ mogi÷�jk¤ù�d~Mj��]j�po~Mv8r loj��igij�m¥vke po~Mj�mnvX��x9|X�i�ij�r6��j��i�ö�^�C|X�¦|XeMxwj�r mnx�~?j���jky�|Xm ô lnmopgie8polnvGr?�Mx�j�rQ�8�ù�ª¤.-¥¤ � j�lnvk�M�ø|}eMrWx�v�|}�Mpo~MvIlom6�i�$�<�®y@���$�<���Mloj�h8givk�?mo�i�Gy�|Xe?r<p�|}²kj�mU|Xr?hk|Xe8p�|}�kjUv}�ªpo~Mj�Cvkpnj�e8pog¦|X�igipogij�m�vX��po~Mj¥�Mlnj�mojweGp¥|X�?�MlovX�8gi�)|}poj�õ�v8rM�MeMvXh�mnx�~?j���jk¤2¯Ýj2vkeM�i�U�?lovXh8girMjª�Cj��iv��QmovI��j2loj�mn�M�ipom|}momov8x�g¦|}poj�r��dgipo~�|�l¬|Xpo~?j�ldrMg0/�x��M�ipLpnj�mopfx9|Xmnjky��d~Mgix¬~�x�vIeMmogimopnm�gie¥j��]�Mp��8g�e?�ª|�lnj�mojwlohkvIgildx�vke8p�|}gieMgieM��movI��j�M�?���¥�MeMr?j�ldpo~Mj�gieMgipog¦|}�8�Alojwj#mn�Ml���|Xx�jkyC|XeMr]gieMgipog¦|X�i�i�ª|Xp�lojwmop9¤��d~Mj��ij¬�6p��Cvk�Me?r�|Xln�¥x�vkeMr?g�pngivke�xwvklolnj�mo�Cvke?rMmpnvÝmovk�]j��E|}�i��x�vIeMrMgipogivIe�yL|XeMrùpn~Mj�logi�k~8p2��vI�MeMr�|}lo�Ýx�vIeMrMgipogivke j�e�|}�M�ij�m¥pov,j����?p�� pn~Mj�x�vk�]�M�Mp�|}pogivkeC|X�rMvI�)|}g�e�¤��d~Mj�loj��I�M�¦|Xl2��j�mn~Ýx�vke8p�|}gieMm)�$¨k¨I¨�eMv8rMj�m$y�|Xe?r po~?j�rMgimoxwloj�png�mnj�r<�M�?���Ý�Mlnv ô �ij�xwvke8p�|}g�e?mê�I¨k¨x�jw���im$¤Ý�d~Mj)zd¡ � e8�M�¥��jwlª~Mjwloj��E|}mªmnj�p¥povݨ%¼ �8�M¤U�d~?j�gieMgipog¦|X��x�vIeMrMgipogivkeÝgim$§ å�û W I Q X ¨Iý X ¨%¼Î�MyL|}eMrç û W I Q X ¨ký X ¨M¤4�d~Mj7!�v��Q|Xlnvk�Me?r�po~?j�mopnj9|XrM�]mop¬|Xpoj"g�mdmn�Mx¬~�po~�|}pdeMv��E|}poj�ld�C|Xmomnj�m�vXhkj�l�po~?j��M�M�]��¤

°

Page 9: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

1 2Yo�qÒ�vq3Ó9i^��������k�.Õ�Ö ×ÌØFÙ Ú�Û%Ü7Ý�Ü.ÞßÚ�à.á7â�ã%Ý�Ø�Ü3äõ�vXhIj�loe?g�e?�ê¢4�?��jwldj��8��|Xpng�vIeMm��)|$� ô lomnpd��j^�dlogipnpoj�e�gie�x�vIeMmojwlohk|Xpngihkjf�Avkln� g�e]poj�ln��m�vX�4po~Mj���j$|Xe�r?j�eMmogip��HCyMpo~?j���j9|}e¥�Mlojwmomo�?loj^K�yMpn~Mj���j9|}e�hIj��ivGxwg�p��Jú|XeMr�po~?j#pnvkp¬|X��j�eMjwlo�k��3 |Xm��6vk�i�iv��dm9§O �O�QjS O«� û �øýO«W X ¨ û ±Iý

mnj�popng�e?��§

� X 45 HH�J3 67|XeMr � û �øý X 45 H_JH_JC© S KJ û 3 S KCý 67

�d~Mjwloj(3 X H û b © JC© S98 ý�¤��6� 8 rMj�e?vkpojwmªpn~Mj�gie8poj�lne�|X��j�eMj�ln�k�8y4po~Mj�eÝmnvk�]jª�¦|2� gim�lnj��8�Mgiloj�rÝpnvUx��ivkmnj¥po~Mj�d~MvI�ij#mn�8mopojw� § K X K û H0I 8 ý û �Iýmn�Mx¬~�po~C|Xp�po~Mjf�G|Xxwvk�Mg¦|Xe2�)|}polng��"�)|$����jfrMg¦|X�Ivke�|}��gi÷�jwrªgie��ù�AvklÒ�r�;:�y�: pn~Mj�mnj�p�vX�­|Xr?��gimomng��?��j�mop�|}poj�m$ymnv¥po~�|}p ²< û K�I�HGýVK>=<¨My�H =<¨My��d~?j�lojk§

H�]�© û K�I�HGý X ²< û K�I�H8ýVK X ? O 8O KA@ BDC � b ? K H � H O 8O H.@ � C¯Ýj�|X�imnvªeMjwj�rUpov¥gie8polnv8rM�Mx�j�j�e8polnvk�8� a X aIû K�I�H8ý.�d~Mgix¬~��¥�?mop�x�vk�]�M�i�5�dgipo~�§

²< K O aO K�@ B S H O aO H.@ � X ¨ û �9¨Iý

Bfj�loj�gie�yF]*mop�|}eMrMm*�Avkl�po~Mj"mo�Cj�j�rUv}�ur?j�eMmogip��9�E|$hIj�m9¤�d~Mj"�G|Xxwvk�Mg¦|Xe]�)|}pologi��± û �øý X O0� û �øýO � �)|$�2��j^�dlogipnpoj�e�§

± û �øý X 45 ¨ � ¨E � JC© J û � � eMý eû E �GF ý�J Fê� e%J�© J û � S eMý 67

mnj�popng�e?� F XIH � �B y�e X bB O KO 8 @ B y E X ]�© S e û J�© �9F ý�¤�¢ug��Ij�e8hk|X�i�Mj�m�v}�Epn~Mj��8|Xx�vI�Mg¦|Xe,�)|Xpnlogi��± û �øýlnj9|Xr�§ º b X J � ]�I�º © X J�I�ºKJ X J S ]�*j�x9|X�i��po~�|}pªpn~MjÝ�¬�?�E|$hIj�|XeMr po~Mj��$�?�E|$hIj�|Xlnj õtj�e8�MgieMj��i� �fvke � gieMj9|}l ô j��irMm�|}eMr pn~�|Xp�pn~MjU�$�?�E|$hIj¥gim� g�e?j9|Xln����«fj��kj�e?j�l�|}poj�r8�Î�k¨<�o¤L�Qmn²kj�pnx�~úvX�Lpo~Mj"movk�i�Mpngivke�vX�4po~Mj��$« �*g�jw�)|Xe?e¥�MlovI�M�ij��-gimdlnj�x9|X�i�ij�rU�Cj��iv��û moj�j ô �k�Mlnj��MyF�d~?g�x¬~Ýx�vIeMmogimnpom�gieú�Avk�Ml�mnp�|Xpnj�m2� |}��jw��jwr � yL�DI¬��|}eMr �ümnj���|Xl¬|Xpnj�r �8�Ul¬|Xloj.�^|Xx�pngivke��E|$hIj�m9ymn~Mv8x�²8m�|XeMr�x�vIeGp¬|Xx�pfrMgimox�vIe8pogie8�Mgip��Gy8rMjw��j�e?rMgieM�¥vke�po~?j�gieMgipog¦|X�Cx�vke?rMgipogivke�¤���eU|XeU|X�ipojwloe�|}pogihkj^�d|$�Gy8¢4�M�ij�lj��8��|}pogivke?md�)|$�2��j��dlngipopojwe)gie�|2eMvke�x�vIeMmoj�lnhk|Xpng�hIjf�Avkln� yP�d~Mj�e�loj�mnpolng�xwpogieM��pnv¥mo�]vGvIpo~¥mnvk�i�MpogivIeMm9¤

±

Page 10: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

�.Õ¤ô õ ö3÷Ñ÷ÑÚøã_Û%Ý�ùFÝ?Ü.ÞúÙnâ�Û%Ý�â�û3ü�Ú�ä�feMvkpn~Mj�l3�d|$�¥pov¥lnj��dlogipnjª¢4�M�ij�ldj��8��|}pogivke?mdg�mdpnv¥�Mmoj�mn�G�]��j�pnlogi÷�gieM��hk|}log¦|X�?��jwm9§N�û �øý X ´ ûba I\J�IbK�ýrMj ô eMgieM�¥�)|}polng�xwj�m U ûVN ýd|Xe?r M ûVN ý�§

U ûVN ý X 45 J ¨ ¨¨ J ²< K�H ²< K¨ ²< K J 67

|Xe?r M û)N ý X 45 � ¨ ¨¨ ²< K%H ¨¨ ¨ �

67 ¼Af�8h8g�vI�Mmo�i� U ûVN ý4gimLmn�G�]��j�pnlogixd|XeMr M û)N ý4gim�mn�8����jwpologixL�CvkmngipogihkjdrMj ô eMgipojky8�?lovXh8girMj�r¥�Cvkpo~¥r?j�eMmogip���|}eMr�Mlnj�momn�Mloj2lojw�)|Xgie]��vImogipogihkjI¤L�dgi�k~8pLj�gi�Ij�e8hkj�x�pnvklnm�vX� û M ý � b ûVN ý U û)N ýd|}lojk§» b ûVN ý X 45 ¨

bB� ] 67 I » © ûVN ý X 45 �¨¨

67 I » J û)N ý X 45 ¨bB] 67 ¼

�.ÕbÔ þ8ÿ7ÿ3Û%Ø��3Ý�÷Ñâ�ã%Ú8×ÌØ��3á7Ü3ØFÙÑä����7Ú�÷ÑÚ�� �8Ø.Ú á7ä�Ý�Ü.ÞíäPö3÷Ñ÷êÚ0ãRÛ�Ý�ùFÝ?Ü.Þ8Ù�â�Û%Ý�â�û7ü�Ú�4�MlneMgieM��eMv��Ýpnv�po~Mj��ig�e?j9|Xlng�mnj�r��Mlnvk�M�ij��,y$g�p��)|$�d�Cjdj9|Xmngi����x¬~Mj�x¬²Ij�r¥po~�|}p�j�gi�Ij�e8hk|X�i�Mj�m4vX� û M ý � b û N ý U û N ý|}lojk§ Ⱥ b X J � È]Xy Ⱥ © X J�y Ⱥ J X J S È]XyCmoj�pnpogieM�/C H û È]wýo© X ²< K�¤d�d~?jªrMjwx�vk�]��vImogipogivke�v}� N ¦ � N ¥ vIeUpo~Mj��|}mogim4vX��lngi�k~8p�j�gi�Ij�e8hkj�x�pnvklnmLvX� û M ý � b û N ý U û N ý��MlnvXh8g�r?j�m4g�e8pnj�lo�]j�rMg¦|XpnjLmop¬|Xpojwm­v8x�xw�MlogieM��gie�pn~Mj���gieMj$|Xlogimnj�r�*g�jw�)|Xe?e��Mlnvk�M�ij��,¤�¯é~Mgi��j�mnj�popng�e?�¥�AvIl�|Xe8���G�C|Xe8pogip��(�*§ û ~ �Lý?¥�¦ X ��¦ � ��¥Ly0�d~Mj�lnjªmn�M�Mmnx�logi�MpnmL�ÒI �lnj¬�Aj�l�pov]po~Mj2�ij¬�Ap�|XeMrUlngi�k~8pdmogirMj2vX�Lpo~?jªgieMgipog¦|}��rMgimox�vIeGpngieG�?g�p��8yMxwvGjM/�x�gij�e8pom ÈÉ b |XeMr ÈÉ J |Xm�gie8polnv8rM�Mx�j�r,giepn~Mj��Mlnj�h8g�vI�Mmdmojwx�pogivke,|Xloj�eMv���§

ÈÉ b X �� µ ] û H µ ] û ~�J�ý ¥%¦ � û ~^K�ý ¥%¦ ý |Xe?r ÈÉ J X �� µ ] û H µ ] û ~�J�ý ¥%¦ S û ~^K�ý ¥%¦ ý�¼�d~Mj��igieMj9|}logi÷9|XpngivkeÝ~�|}m¥��j�jwe<�)|}rMj�|Xlnvk�MeMr po~Mjúmop�|}poj û HCy J�y KMý�¤�B�jweMx�jkydpn~Mj�p?��v,gie8poj�ln��j�rMg¦|}poj�mnp�|}poj�mN b I N © v8x�xw�MlogieM�¥gie�po~Mj�mnvk�i�MpogivIe�vX�Lpn~Mj ,½' " ì\*Ið�'iò�ì¬ñ �dgij���|XeMe¥�Mlnvk�M�ij���|Xlnj�po~Mj��6vk�i�iv��dg�e?��§

N b X 45 a ¥J�¥ S ÈÉ b bBK�¥ � ÈÉ b µ ]67|XeMr N © X 45 a ¦J%¦ � ÈÉ J bBK%¦ � ÈÉ J µ ] 67 ¼

J © X J b X J � �� H µ ] û ~^KCý ¥%¦ û �k�$ýK © X K b X K � H µ ]� û ~�JCý?¥%¦ û �9�Iý4 |}�i�Mj�m�J b X J © |XeMr7K b X K © g�r?j�e8pogö�A�3�dgipn~�gieGpnj�lo�]j�rMg¦|XpnjLhk|X�i�Mjwm�x�vI���M�Mpnj�r��8�t|}e8� 4 ¡4�dv8j�mnx¬~Mj���jE�dg�pn~

hk|}log¦|X�M�ij N X ´ û ¼¸I\J�IbK�ý û mnj�j��Î�2�F�d~Mj�e]�Av8x��Mmng�e?�ªvIe N X ´ û ��G�H0I+J�IbK�ýoýw¤���e8pnj�lo�]j�rMg¦|Xpnjdhk|X�i�Mj�m a b X a ¥ |}eMra © X a ¦ |Xlnj#vI�8hGgivI�Mmo�i�2�M~8�Gmngix9|X�i�i�ªlnj��ij9|$hk|Xe8p$¤4�d~Mj�g�e8pnj�lo�]j�rMg¦|Xpnj��Mlnj�momn�Mloj û povI�kj�pn~Mj�l3�dgipn~�hkjw��v8x�gip���|}eMrrMjweMmogip��Mý�g�m�moj�p4pnv�gipom���gieMgi��|X�$hk|X�i�Mj4gö�DK b g�m���jw��v��Ýpn~Mj�|}rM��gimomngi�M�ij­l¬|XeM�Ijk¤��d~Mgim���gieMgi�2�M�ùgim­¨��6vkl��Cj�l��Ajwx�p�8|XmL¢�A�� û vIlu|*��gi�8po�MlnjLvX���Cj�l��Ajwx�pL�G|}moj�m¬ý�yIvklL|X�ipnj�loe�|}pogihkjw��� � KON �Avkl4�L|X�]�)|$e�¢�A�� û 8�X � �KP �RQî P�� b ñ B ý�¤��d~Mgimmn~Mvk�M�irUe?vkpd�Cj�x�vke¿�A�Mmojwr;�dgipo~�po~Mj"mop�|}eMr�|}lorUx��igi�M�MgieM��|}�M�MlnvX�Ggi��|XpogivXe��d~Mgix¬~�h8g�vI�¦|Xpojwm û �dgipo~�lojwmo�Cj�x�p�pnvpng��]j9ý�po~Mj�x�vIeMmoj�lnhk|Xpng�hIj��AvIlo� v}�­rMgimoxwloj�pnjªj��8��|}pogivke?m9¤

Page 11: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

�.Õ�� õ.Ø�÷ÑÚÌÿ7Û%Ø�ÿ�Ú�Û�ã%Ý�Ú�ä�dðnï��Mì9ð��Aí>SGó�*RT ��e8poj�ln��j�rMg¦|}poj2hk|X�i�Mj�v}�E�Mlnj�momn�Mloj�K b X K © lnj��)|}gieMm��Cvkmng�pngihkj2�MlovXh8girMj�rÝpn~�|Xp�po~?j¥g�e?g�png¦|X�x�vIeMrMgipogivIeMmdvX�4po~Mjª�*gij��)|}eMeª�?lovk�?��jw� |}�klojwj��dgipo~�xwvkeMrMgipng�vIe�§û ~�JCý ¥�¦ ­ � KH µ ] û �9�IýU T ��eGpnj�lo�]j�rMg¦|Xpnj�hk|}�i�Mj�m4vX��r?j�eMmogip���H b |}eMr�H © lnj��)|}g�e"��vImogipogihkj��MlnvXhGgirMjwrªpn~Mjd�¦|Xpopnj�lLx�vIeMrMgipogivIe�gimLgieMmo�Mlnj�r�¤�dðnï9ï���ó�*�T �d~Mj"�Mlov8vX�4gimdvk�8h8g�vI�Mm�mogieMx�j3K b g�e û �9�ký�gimd��vImogipogihIj#gö�L|XeMr]vkeM�i�¥gö� û �$�ký�~Mvk�irMm$¤U T ��e8pnj�lo�]j�rMg¦|Xpnj#mnp�|}poj�mfvX�­r?j�eMmogip���|X�klnj�j��dgipo~�§H b X H ûba b IbK b ý X H ûba ¥ ILK b ý�|XeMr H © X H ûLa © ILK © ý X H ûLa ¦�IbK © ý

�d~8�Mm$yMpo~?jt|}rM��gimnmogi�Mgi�ig�p��"vX�æK b X K © gieMmo�?loj�mdpn~Mjª|Xr?��gimomng��?g��igip���v}�­�Cvkpo~�H b |XeMr�H © ¤�d~Mgimdx�vIeMrMgipogivIe¥mo~MvI�M�ir��Cj�x�vk�]��|Xlnj�r��dgipo~]po~Mj�x�vIeMrMgipogivke]vX�4j��8g�mnpoj�e?x�jª|Xe?r��MeMgi�8�Mj�e?j�momfvX�­pn~Mj�movI���?pogivkev}�#po~?j �*gij��)|}eMeÝ�MlovI�M�ij�� �AvIlê¢u�M�ij�l¥j��8��|XpngivkeMm��dgipo~ù|Xe8� ¢�A�� û |}eMrùeMv hk|}x��M�M� vGxwx��MlojweMx�j9ý9�d~Mgix¬~gim��Î�k¨<�oy¸�Î�\�o§

û ~�JCý ¥%¦ ­WV ¥ S V ¦ �d~Mj�loj V � X � B �f ] û H«I a � ýH �DH0¼ û ���8ý

¯Ýj¥~Mjwloj ô lomnpªlnj�mopnlogix�p¥pnvU��jwl��Aj�xwp¥�G|Xm2¢�A�� û K X û < � �9ý?H�X$y�� ­ < ­ �Iý�¤U¡?v8x��MmogieM�úvkeÝgieMgipog¦|X��x�vke8�rMgipng�vIe mn�Mx¬~�pn~�|Xp¥|úrMvk�M�?��j�mn�G�]��j�pnlogix9|}�Ll�|}loj¬�^|}x�pogivIe6�d|$hkj�r?j�hkj��ivI�Mm û pn~�|Xp2gimU§ N ¥ X ´ ûba I\J�ILKCýª|}eMrN ¦ X ´ ûLa I � J�IbK�ý@�dg�pn~ÌJ ­ ¨Iý�yLpn~MjUx�vIeMrMgipogivIe û �9�Iý2gimª�]vkloj]loj�mnpolng�xwpogihkjUpn~�|Xe gipom¥x�vI�Me8poj�ln��|Xlnp û �w�Gý¬y�Me?��gi²Ij3�d~Mj�eúrMj9|X�igieM���dgipn~)mn~�|X�i�iv��8�E|}poj�ldjw�G�C|XpogivIeMm9¤L{�vIloj��Mlnj�x�gimoj��i�8yMe8�M�]j�logix9|}��hk|}x��M�M� û gie�pnj�lo�]m�v}��Mlnj�momn�Mloj$ý2vGxwx��Mlom¥|Xp�pn~Mj¥gieGpnj�l���|Xx�j¥�MmngieM� 4 ¡4�dv8j2mox¬~Mj��]j�|Xm�mov8vke |}m�J«GP]Y=-��G < y��d~Mj�loj$|Xm�e8�M�]j�logix9|}�hk|}x��M�M� û gieUpojwlo��m�v}�E�Mlnj�momn�Mloj]vkl�rMj�e?mogip��Mý�v8x�xw�Mlom¥|Xp�po~?jªgie8poj�l®�^|Xxwj��dg�pn~ �*v8jªmnx�~?j���j��Î�<�E|Xm�mov8vIe |}mJC©�GP]�©Z=��PG û < û � � < ýoýf|XeMr�hk|}x��M�M� lnj9|X�i�i�)|}logimojwm.�d~Mj�e#J0GD]A=��DG û < � �$ý�¤���vke?j�po~Mjw��jwmom9yø�d~Mj�e��M�ivkpnpogieM�pn~Mj�l¬|XpogivK � � ´\[*]_^R` ð [ G<K |Xmª|)�A�MeMx�pngivkeÝvX�ba Jca GD]Xy�gip�x��ij9|}lo�i� |}�M�Cj9|Xlnmªpn~�|Xp2��vIpo~Ýx��?lohkjwmê|}momov8x�g¦|}poj�r��dg�pn~õ�v8rM�?eMvXhUmox¬~Mjw��j�|Xe?r 4 ¡­�*v8j¥mox¬~Mj��]jê|}loj¥��vIeMvkpnvkeMj"rMj�x�lnj9|Xmng�e?��y��d~Mj�lnj9|Xm2po~?j¥vkeMj¥x�vIeMeMj�xwpoj�r��dg�pn~�*vGj2mox¬~Mjw��j¥gim�rMj�x�lnj9|Xmng�e?���Avkl�¨ ­ a Jda GD] ­ �2Gk��|Xe?r pn~Mj�eÝgieMx�lnj9|Xmng�e?��¤2�d~8�Mm9y�po~MvI�M�k~,po~?j¥x�vkeMmnpol¬|Xgie8p�MlnvXh8g�r?j�rù�G� �*v8j�mox¬~Mjw��j�pov,vk�Mp¬|XgieÝlojw��j$|$hk|Xe8p¥gieGpnj�l���|Xx�j�hk|X�i�Mjwmªv}���Mloj�mnmo�Mlnj |}eMr r?j�eMmogip�� g�m2�ij�mom¥lnj¬�mnpologix�pngihkj�pn~�|XeÝpn~Mj�vIeMj¥�kgihIj�e �8� 4 ¡4�dv8j¥mnx�~?j���jky4pn~Mj¥�kjweMj�l�|}�d��jw~�|$h8g�vI�Ml�vX�ZK � � ´\[e]�^f` ð [ G<K,hGm�a Jda GP]�gimgie �Cj�pnpoj�l�|X�klnj�j��]j�e8p5�dgipo~ùpn~Mj�j��M|Xx�p��*g�jw�)|Xe?e mnvk�i�MpogivIe �Î�<�3�d~Mj�e<|X�?�M�i�GgieM� 4 ¡4�dv8j�mnx¬~Mj���jI¤ �fm�|lnj�mo�M�ip$y8x�vk�]�M�Mp�|}pogivke?m�vX��m¬|$�Ajwp��ªhk|}��hIj�m��dgipo~2mo�M�Cj�lomnvkeMgix��Cj�~�|$h8givk�MlL|Xlnvk�Me?r¥po~Mjfj��8g�p��)|$���?��v�� �M���d~Mj�e�MmngieM�ê�*v8jdmox¬~Mj��]j#|Xp�po~?j3�d|X�i���Cvk�?eMr�|Xln�ªgieMmnpoj9|}r�v}�uõ�v8rM�Me?vXh�mox¬~Mj��]j û vkl 4 ¡4�dv8j�mnx¬~Mj���j$ý�y8�Mmng�e?��po~Mj�]g�lnlovIl�pnj�x¬~MeMgi�8�Mj�g�e�|X�i��x9|}moj�m$¤L��e8���d|$�GyIj�hkjwep�d~?j�e�x�vkeMr?g�pngivke û �9�Iý�g�m��A�M� ô �i�ij�r�yIpo~?j�loj�gimdeMv2po~?j�vklng�pngix9|X��Mlnv8vX��pn~�|Xpfx�j��i�Lhk|X�i�Mjwm�vX�L�Mlnj�momn�Mloj�K �� lnj��)|}gie��Cvkmogipng�hIjky0�d~Mj�e,�MmogieM�]po~Mj 4 ¡4�*vGj"mox¬~Mj��]j û vkl�pn~Mj¥�dv8jmnx�~?j���j9ýw¤4��vIeMj�po~?j��ij�mom$yæ|}�M�Cj�eMrMgi�¥°#gdmn~Mv��dm�po~Mj�gi���Cvklnp�|Xe8p��^|}x�p�pn~�|Xp�x��ivkmnj�pnvê|^�d|X�i�C��vI�MeMr�|}lo� û �d~Mj�lojeMj$|Xl���hk|Xxw�M�M� |}���]vkmnpt|}�¸�E|$�8mª|}�M��j$|Xlom¥gieÝ�Ml¬|Xx�pngix�j9ý�y�pn~Mj�x�jw���dhk|}�i�Mj�v}���Mloj�mnmo�Mlnj;�dgi�i��lnj��)|}g�e,�Cvkmogipng�hIj�d~Mjwe | hkj�ln�)mnpolnvkeM�]l�|Xlnj¬�^|}x�pogivke��E|$hIj�rMj�hIj��ivk�Mm û po~C|Xp�gimfpov�m¬|$���d~Mj�e�Z¼ �h%ø¨My0�d~Mj�lnj`�,r?j�eMvkpnj�m�po~Mj�Me?g�pdvI�Mp?�d|Xlor]eMvkln�)|}��hIj�x�povIl#|}pdpo~Mj��Cvk�MeMrC|Xlo�Mýwy�|Xmnmo�M�]gieM��mop¬|XeMrC|XlorUzd¡ � x�vIeMrMgipogivkei' � � X ¨�¼Î�M¤�6����j#pn�MloeúeMv��øpnv¥�L|X����|}e�� mL¢�A���§ 8�X � �KP �RQî P_� b ñ B û |}eMr�po~8�Mm a X û K S KON¥ý û H8ý ��P ý�y���j�j��]�M~�|Xmngi÷�j�po~�|}pj��8��|}pogivke û �9�ký���|$�ª�Cj�loj9|}r |Xm�K © S KON X K b S KON X K S KjN � B�k ð© û ~�JCý?¥%¦�¤�Bfj�eMx�j�hk|}x��M�M� ��|}popojwloeMmû �d~Mgix�~Ýpn�Mloe?mªpnvU��j�K S KON X ¨��d~?j�e,�Av8x��Mmng�e?�UvkeÝpn~Mgimt¢EA#�?ýª|}loj¥mogi�]g��¦|}l�po~C|XeÝgie pn~Mj��Cj�l®�Aj�x�p2�G|}m�Al¬|X�]j���vIlo²�¤4�dj�mn�M�ipomdvke�rMgimnx��MmomngivkeU|X�CvXhkj�po~8�Mmd~?vk�ir�pnlo�Mjk¤

�$¨

Page 12: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

�d~Mj�mox¬~Mjw��jd|X�imovf��j�e?j ô pom��Alnvk�Qpo~?jL�AvI�i��v��dgieM���Mlnvk�Cj�lopng�jwm9y8mo~C|Xlojwrª�8�ª|}��� 4 ¡4�dv8j�mox¬~Mj��]j�mL�MmngieM��hk|}log¦|X�M�ijN X ´ û ¼¸I\J�IbK�ýw§�dðnï��Mì9ð��AíZlGó ���M�MlnvX�8g���|Xpnj­hk|}�i�Mj�m4vX��gieGpnj�lo�]j�rMg¦|XpnjLmop¬|Xpnj�m�v8x�xw�MlogieM��gieªpn~Mjd�igieMj9|Xlngi÷�j�r¥�dgij��)|}eMe��MlovI�M�ij���Mlnj�mojwlohkj2gie8hk|Xlog¦|}eMx�j�v}� û J�ILKCýLhk|}log¦|X�M�ij�m�po~?lovk�?�k~�po~Mj�e8�M�]j�logix9|}��x�vke8p�|}x�pdrMgimoxwvke8pogie8�Mgip��G¤�d~Mj"�Mlov8vX��g�mdpnlogih8g¦|X��mngieMx�j�gieMmnj�lopng�e?�pJ�¥ X J%¦ povI�kj�pn~Mj�l^�dgipo~�K%¥ X K�¦ùg�e�j��8��|}pogivke?m û �I� � �9�ký*loj�mn�M�ipomgie�§�J b X J © X J�¥ X J%¦ù|XeMrU|}��mnv�K b X K © X K�¥ X K%¦d¤�dðnï��Mì9ð��Aínm?ó ��mnmo�M�]g�e?�ªpn~Mj�mop¬|Xpnj#�¦|2�<p¬|X²Ij�m�pn~Mjf�Avkln� §H 8�Xpo û K�ý S "PH S g�d~Mjwloj�"#|}eMr�g4|XlnjLloj$|X�8x�vke?mop�|}e8pom9y}po~Mj�e2x�j��i�Ihk|X�i�Mj�m4|X��|}lop��6lovk�Q|���vXh8gieM��x�vke8p¬|Xx�p�rMgimox�vIeGpngieG�?g�p��f�Mlojwmoj�lnhkjgie8hk|Xlng |}eMx�jfvX�L��vIpo~�hkjw��v8x�gip���|}eMr��Mloj�mnmo�Mlnjªhk|}log¦|X�?��jwm9¤�d~Mj2�MlnvGv}�E��|$�¥��j"�AvI�MeMr,g�e,|X�M�Cj�eMrMgi�U±M¤��fvkpnjªpn~�|Xp�po~?jª�¦|Xpnpoj�lf�^|}��gi�i�ªv}��gie8poj�lne�|X�LjweMj�lo�Igij�m�g�e?x��i�MrMj�meMvIpdvkeM�i�]��j�l®�Aj�x�pf�G|}m�¢�A���yC�M�Mp�|X�imnvª�L|X�]�)|}eê¢�A���|Xe?r)�L|}g�pd¢�A�� û 8�X �î P�� b ñ B S ± û bB � bî B ñrq ýoýw¤L�d~Mjlnj9|XrMjwl#gim�|X�imov¥lnj¬�Aj�lnloj�r,pov]loj�x�jweGp^��vkln²)�8���M|X�Mlnj��L|XeMr��f�M�kl¬|X�i�Z�Î�M�����Avkl�|XeU|X�ipnj�loe�|}pogihkj^�d|$��pnv�~�|}eMrM�ijx�vIe8p�|Xxwp�rMgimnx�vke8pogie8�Mgip����d~Mj�e�lnj�mopnlogix�png�e?�ªpnvªmnpogÆ�æjweMj�r��8|Xmd¢�A���yIvkl�pov�Î�k�<�oy0�Î�k�<�C�AvklL�]vklnjdx�vk�]�M�ij��ª¢�A���¤�.Õ*) +úá3÷êÚ�Û%Ý��Fâ�ü^Û%Ú�ä�á3ü?ã%ä�<�Cj�l®�Aj�x�p��G|}m­mnp�|}poj��¦|2�Ý~�|}mL�Cj�j�e��?moj�r¥pnvk�kjwpo~Mj�l �dgipo~�§ < Xtsu ¤�¯Ýj ô lnmopL�?lovXh8girMjdmovI��jLlnj�mo�M�ipnm�vI�Mp�|}g�e?j�r�MmngieM�¥gieMgipog¦|X�Cr�|Xp¬|�gie�mo~?vGx¬²]po�M�Cj�j��8�Cj�logi��jweGpnm9y��d~Mgix�~]�kj�e?j�l�|}poj�hk|}x��M�M�,¤�Bfj�eMx�jky0��j��Mmojk§H K J

� j¬�Ap � �$¨ u � �G¨I¨k¨�*g��I~8p � �$¨ u �8¨k¨I¨�d~Mgimfloj�mn�M�ipom�gie |2l¬|Xpn~Mj�l^�dgirMj�÷�vkeMj2vX�Lhk|}x��M�M�,¤L��xwpo��|}���i�8y8po~Mj"��gi�]g�p�{U|Xx¬~Ue8�M�¥�Cj�ldgieU|2mo�8���]j�polng�x$|X�rMvI�M�M�ijLl¬|Xloj.�^|Xx�pngivke^�E|$hIj4g�m ©P�� b û �d~Mgix¬~�gim�po~8�Mm�j��8��|X�Ipov���~Mjwloj9ýwy��d~Mj�lnj9|Xm4gie�po~MjL�?loj�mnj�e8p­x$|XmojIyXpo~Mj�g�e?g�png¦|X�{U|}x¬~�e8�M�¥�Cj�lLgimE|}�M�MlnvX�Ggi��|Xpojw���]�k�D¼Î°?¤��d~Mj�xwvk���?�Mp�|}pogivke�|}�Mlojwmo�M�ipom.��j�lnj#vI�Mp�|}gieMj�r¥�Mmng�e?�ªpn~Mjd�AvI�i��v��dgieM�zd¡ � eG�?�¥��j�l$§ ' � � X ¨%¼ �G�?y­|}eMr | ô eMj�lnj��k�?� |}lª�]j�mo~��dgipo~<�9�I±k¨I¨�eMv8rMj�m û ô �k�Mlnj�m��kýtloj�mn��j�xwpogihkj��i�8¤4 jw��v8x�gip����Mlnv ô �ij�m�~�|$hIj���jwj�eÝ�M�ivkpnpoj�rUpn~Mvk�?�k~,po~Mj��,|Xloj9& ì\* " ' "#v ,�ìwò�ò gie�po~Mj¥hk|}x��M�M��|Xlnj9|M¤���p��¥�Mmnpd��jj��]�M~�|}mogi÷�j�rUpn~�|Xp�eMv]x��igi�M�MgieM�)|}�M�MlnvX�Ggi��|XpogivIe¥g�mf�MmojwrÝ~Mj�lojI¤ª{�gieMgi�¥�M� hk|X�i�Mjwm#v}�LrMj�eMmng�p��úvkl��Mlojwmomo�?lojgie�po~Mj�hk|}x��M�M��|Xlnj9|¥|Xlnjt|}�M�MlnvX�Ggi��|Xpojw���]�9¨ � bewt|}eMr �$¨ � b�bdlnj�mo�Cj�x�png�hIj��i�G¤�d~Mj�mnj�x�vke?r�mnj�logij�m¥v}��loj�mn�M�ipom û ô �k�Mlnj�m�°ký"x�vIlolojwmo�CvkeMrMm]povUpn~Mj�x�vk�]�M�Mp¬|XpogivIe v}�#|UmnpolovIeM�,mo~Mv8x¬²/�E|$hIj�Mlnvk��|}�G|}pogieM�2vXhkj�l û eMj9|Xl¬ýdhk|}x��M�M�,¤���e�po~Mgimdx9|}mojky?po~Mj�gieMgipng |}��rC|Xp�|"vX�Lpn~Mj��dgij��)|}eMe¥�Mlnvk�M�ij�� lnj9|Xr?m9§H K J

� j¬�6p � �$¨ u ¨�dgi�k~8p �DI¬�k��¼i�9¨ � s �9¨ � © ¨�d~Mj]movIeMgixª�Cvkgie8p�gie pn~Mj �.�^l¬|Xlnj¬�^|Xxwpogivke��E|$hIj¥loj��8�Mgilnj�mªgie8polnv8rM�Mx�gieM�U|XeÝjweGpnlovI�G�,x�vIlolojwx�pogivke�¤��d~Mj�zd¡ �

e8�M�¥�Cj�l�gim]po~MjUm¬|X�]j |}m�g�eù�Mlnj�h8givk�Mm�x9|}moj�m$¤ �d~MjU��jwmo~<x�vIe8p�|XgieMm��k�I¨k¨,eMv8rMj�m�~Mjwlojk¤ü�d~Mj�mnjÝg�e?g�png¦|X�x�vIeMrMgipogivIeMm�p��G�?g�x$|X�i�i��lojwmo�M�ip�gie |]�M�iv��Q�M�,vX��pn~Mj2x�v8rMj��d~Mj�e,�MmogieM��mnp�|Xe?r�|Xlnr hk|}log¦|X�M�ij N X ´ û�x I+J�IbK�ýû �d~Mj�loj x X bB ýd|Xmd�?mo��|}���i�¥rMvIeMj��Î�<�­gieMmopnj9|Xr�v}�­po~?j�x��Mlnloj�e8p�mn�8����jwpologi÷�gieM��hk|}log¦|X�M�ijk¤

�I�

Page 13: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

�d~Mjf�¦|Xmop4mnj�logij�mdv}�ælnj�mo�M�ipnm û ô �k�Mlnj�md±ký4x�vIlolnj�mo�CvkeMr?mdpov�pn~Mj�x�vI���M�?p�|Xpngivke�v}��|�mnpolnvkeM��r?vk�M�M�ijdmn~Mv8x�²��d|$hkjIy�d~Mgix¬~,mo~Mv��dmª|}�G|}g�eú~Mv�� pn~Mj¥mox¬~Mj��]jª�Cj�~�|$hIj�m��d~MjweÝx�vk�]�M�MpogieM�¥gi�]�MgieM�kgieM�.1¬j�pnm�vke��E|}�i�­�Cvk�?eMr�|Xlngij�m9¤��e�po~?g�mdx$|XmojIy�pn~Mj�gieMgipog¦|X�Cr�|Xp¬|�v}�Lpo~Mj��dgij���|XeMe¥�?lovk�?��jw�-lnj9|XrMm$§H K J

� j¬�Ap � �9¨ u �$¨k¨�*g��I~8p � �9¨ u � �9¨I¨

�d~Mj"loj��I�M�¦|Xld��jwmo~�mnpogi�i��x�vke8p¬|XgieMm��k�I¨k¨�e?vGr?j�m9¤�4v�xwvkeMx��i�Mr?j¥po~Mgim���|Xlnp9yF��j�|X�8|XgieU�MlnvXh8g�r?j���jw��v��üpo~Mj¥pnlo�Mj2l�|}poj¥v}��x�vke8hIj�lo�Ij�eMx�j]vk�Mp¬|XgieMj�r��d~Mj�e,x�vk� ��M�?pogieM��pn~Mj�mnp�|Xe?r�|Xlnr)�8v8r¥mo~?vGx¬²¥pn�M��jfx9|XmnjkyM|"rMvk�M�?��jdl¬|Xlnj¬�^|Xxwpogivke��d|$hkj�|}eMr¥j�hkjweGpn��|X�i�i�¥|�rMvk�?�M�ijdmo~Mv8x¬²�d|$hkjky}�MmogieM� ô lnmopLvIlorMj�l û lojwmo�Cj�x�pogihIj��i�¥moj�x�vIeMr�vIlorMjwl�ý4hIj�lomng�vIeªv}�æpn~Mjdmox¬~Mjw��jk¤�¯Ýj�lnj�x9|}���?g�e?g�png¦|X�8x�vke?rMgipogivkey��d~Mgix�~]loj�mn��jwx�pogihkjw���,|XlojI§ H ¥ H ¦ K ¥ K ¦ J ¥ J ¦

�8v8r�mn~Mv8x¬²)pn�M�Cj � ¨�¼��$�k� �9¨ u �$¨Rw ¨ ¨«fvk�M�?��jfl�|}loj¬�^|}x�pogivIep�d|$hkj � � �9¨ u �$¨ u � �9�k¨I¨ �9�I¨k¨«fvk�M�?��jfmo~Mv8x¬²�d|$hkj � � �9¨ u �$¨ u �k¨k¨ � �I¨k¨�d~Mj2mojwx�vkeMr¿�^vIlorMj�l2mox¬~Mjw��j2g�mf��|Xmnj�rÝvkeúmoj�x�vIeMr8��vklnrMj�l¥�d�MeM�Ij¬�?=#�?pop�| pogi��j"g�e8pnj��kl¬|XpogivIeUx�vk�¥�?g�e?j�r��dg�pn~

mnp�|Xe?r�|Xlnrø{�c#�?z � ��p��G�CjUlnj�x�vke?mopoln�Mx�png�vIeøv}�#hk|}log¦|X�M�ij�m�H0I+J�IbK gieMmng�r?j)j$|Xx¬~<x�j��i��¤øsu��vIpopng�e?� v}�y�Eb�j�lolnvklx�vIlolnj�mo�CvkeMr?m¥povUrMjweMmogip��,��mo�8��|Xlnj�m���y4hkjw��v8x�gip��ú�^pnlog¦|Xe?�k�ij�m��#|}eMrÝ�Mlnj�momn�Mloj���x�giloxw��jwm���¤U�8pol¬|Xgi�k~8p��igieMj�m�xwvklolnj¬�mn��vIeMrÝpovUpn~Mj ô lnmop���vklnrMj�l2mox¬~Mj��]jky4|XeMr,po~Mj¥rC|Xmo~?j�rÝ�ig�e?jªlnj¬�Aj�lnmªpnvUpo~Mj¥mnj�x�vIeMr8��vklor?j�lªmnx¬~Mj���jI¤��dj�mn�M�ipomû moj�j ô �I�Mlojwm#�kýf|XlnjªgieMrMjwj�rUhkjwlo��x��ivkmnjªpnv�po~?vkmoj"�MlovXh8girMj�rUgie |2�?loj�h8givk�Mm^��vkln²#�Î�<���d~Mj�eU�MmngieM��hk|}log¦|X�M�ijN X ´ û�x I+J�ILKCý�yP�d~Mj�lnj x X bB ¤4��e]g��]��vIlop¬|Xe8p4��vIg�e8p�pov2j����?~�|Xmng�÷wj�gim�pn~�|Xp�po~?j���j$|Xe¥rMj�e?mogip���x�vIe8hkj�ln�kj�mmn��v���j�ldpn~�|Xe��Cvkpo~ú�Mloj�mnmo�Mlnjê|}eMr�hkj��iv8x�gip��¥hk|Xlng¦|X�M�ij�m$y8�MeM�ij�momfpo~Mj"x9|Xmnj�gimdmo�8���]j�polng�x û ô �k�?loj�m��"logi�k~8pdpovI�|}eMr���vIpopovI�)ýw¤��d~Mgimdgim�rM�?j#pnv¥po~Mj�mn��j9|}logieM��v}�­po~?j#xwvke8p�|}x�p�rMgimnx�vke8pogie8�Mgip��¥|Xmomnv8x�g¦|Xpojwr;�dgipo~�jwg��Ij�e�hk|X�i�Mjº X J�y�po~Mlnvk�M�I~/�d~Mgix¬~ pn~Mjªr?j�eMmogip��,hk|Xlng�jwm9yF�d~Mjwloj9|}m���vIpo~Ý�Mlnj�momn�Mloj�|XeMr,hkjw��v8x�gip��Ur?v)e?vkpf�^vIl�|Xp��ij9|Xmnpmn~Mvk�M�ir¥eMvIp9yImogieMx�jfpo~Mjf�¦|Xpopnj�l�|}loj#�*gij��)|}eMe�gie8hk|Xlog¦|}eGpnm4po~Mlnvk�M�I~¥po~Mgim��d|$hkj¬��¤��d~Mjdl�|}poj�gimLxw��vImojfpov�� �d~Mj�elnj�mopnlogix�pogieM�2pov�J�I z y��d~Mj�e¥�MmngieM��po~MjfmovX��x9|}���ij�r2mojwx�vkeMr¿�^vIlorMj�ldmnx¬~Mj���jIyk|XeMr¥gim�|f�Mgip4�iv���jwl4�Avkl4pn~MjdrMj�eMmngip��Gyj�mn��jwx�g¦|X�i�i��d~Mj�e �Av8x��MmogieM�2vke�pn~Mjª�8v8r�mn~Mv8x¬²)pn�M�Cj#�?lovk�?��jw� ¤{ |Ñzq~} { ���q3o)ZÕ�Ö ×ÌØFÙ Ú�Û%Ü7Ý�Ü.ÞßÚ�à.á7â�ã%Ý�Ø�Ü3äõ�vXhIj�loe?g�e?��j��8��|}pogivkeMm�vX��pn~Mjdx�vke8hIj�x�pogihIjd��|Xlnp­v}�æpn~Mj =ø�]vGr?j��8�)|$��vIeM�i����j.�dlng�pnpoj�e¥gie�e?vke2x�vkeMmnj�lohk|}pogihkj�AvIlo�,¤��d~Mjwmoj��Mmn��|X�i�i��|X�?��j9|}l.�dlogipopnj�eUgie�pnj�lo�]mdvX�4po~Mj��]j9|Xe¥r?j�eMmogip���H�y8pn~Mj��]j9|Xe]��vk�]j�e8po�M��H_J�y8po~Mj�]j9|Xe]povkp¬|X��j�eMj�ln�k��3 |XeMr�po~?j#pn�Mlo�?�M�ij�e8p�²8gieMj�pogix�j�eMjwlo�k� E |}m��Avk�i�iv��dm9yP�d~Mj�e �Av8x��MmogieM�2vke��Cj�l��6j�x�p��G|}m¢�A���§ O �O�Q S O«� û �øýO«W S ' û �øý O �O«W X ¨mnj�popng�e?��§

� X4��5 HH�J3E 6���7 |}eMr � û �øý X

4��5 H_JH�J�© S K S ��� JJ û 3 S K S � � J ýJ E 6���7�$�

Page 14: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

�dgipo~,' û �øý O �O«W X ´ é ¨%I¬¨%I¬¨%I¬� E � O JO0W ë yM|XeMr¥eMvIpogieM�n3 X H b© JC© S H 8�S E ¤�B�jwloj�gie�y 8 rMj�e?vkpojwm�pn~Mj��]j9|Xegie8poj�lne�|X��j�eMj�ln�k�8¤4�d~Mj�¢�A��]�AvIl�pn�Mlo�M�?��jweGpf��jwl��Aj�xwp��G|}moj�mfgim9§K X K û H0I 8 ý X û < � �$ý?H 8�d~Mj"mo�Cj�j�rUv}�­��j$|Xe�r?j�eMmogip��9�E|$hIj�mdgimd��v8rMg ô j�r¥�8��pn~Mj��Mlojwmoj�eMxwj¥vX�­pn�Mlo�?�M�ij�eMx�jk§] © û K�I�H«I E ý X < � B S �$¨ �� B��e8polnv8rM�Mx�gieM�U§ �

X Eû HGý��� |Xe?r a X K

û HGý P ¼gip�g�m�|Xe�j$|Xmo�¥��|Xpnpoj�lLpnv�x¬~Mj�x¬²�pn~�|Xp�po~Mgim�mo�8mopnj��-gim�|teMvke]mopolngix�po�i�¥~8�8��j�ln��vI�ig�xfmo�8mopnj�� ¤4�dj$|X�Cj�gi�kj�e8hk|X�i�Mjwm|}lojk§ º b X J � ]�I%º © X º J X J�I%º w X J S ]-¼|}eMr |Xmnmov8x�g¦|Xpnj�r,logi�k~8p�jwg��Ij�e8hkj�xwpovklnm�mo�C|Xe;����w8¤7:�vIpo~,po~Mj��¬�?�E|$hIj�|XeMrUpn~Mj2�X�?�E|$hIjª|Xlnjªõ�j�e8�MgieMj��i����vIe� g�e?j9|Xl$y��d~Mj�loj$|Xm2po~Mj��$���X�?�E|$hIjªgim � g�e?j9|Xln���,«�jw�kj�eMjwl�|Xpnj�r�¤,�dgij��)|}eMe,g�e8hk|}log¦|Xe8pomfpo~Mlnvk�M�I~ pn~Mj¥x�vke8p¬|Xx�prMgimnx�vke8pogie8�Mgip�� |}loj,� X K S � E GI�)|}eMr6J�¤��dgij���|XeMeUgie8hk|Xlng¦|Xe8pom�po~?lovk�?�k~Ýpo~?jU�¬�?�E|$hIjê|}lojk§ a X K%H �KP y�X E H � u � J y J S� yC|XeMr a y � y J � � pn~MlovI�M�k~�pn~Mj��X�?�E|$hIjky��d~Mgi�ij�mojwpopogieM�C§� � X � B �f ] û H«I a � I

�� ýH �PH

{�vIloj�vXhIj�l9yC|Xmnmo�M�]g�e?��po~�|}pdpo~Mjf�AvI�i��v��dgieM��1¬�?���¥x�vIeMrMgipogivke?md~Mvk�ir�pn~MlovI�M�k~�mn~Mv8x�²8m û�� rMjweMvkpnj�m�pn~Mj�mo�Cj�j�rv}�upn~Mj�rMgimox�vIe8pogie8�Mgip��¥moj���|}l�|}pogieM�¥mop¬|Xpnj�m3�dgipo~�mn�M�Mmoxwlogi�Mpom��ù|XeMr���ý�§

� � � H�� ¥%¦ S � H_JR� ¥%¦ X ¨� � � H_JR��¥�¦ S � H�J�© S K S © �J �V¥%¦ X ¨� � ��37� ¥%¦ S � J û 3 S K S © �J ýc� ¥%¦ X ¨� � � E �V¥%¦ S � J E ��¥�¦ S © ���R�J � J��V¥%¦ X ¨��j�loj�x9|}�i��� �}�2�Epn~�|Xp2po~?j �.�^r?g��]j�eMmng�vIe�|X�L�*g�jw�)|Xe?e �Mlnvk�M�ij�� |Xmomnv8x�g¦|Xpojwr �dgipn~Ýpo~Mj��¦|Xpnpoj�l2�MlovI�M�ij�� |}eMr�Ig�hIj�e�gieMgipng |}��rC|Xp�|2|Xr?��gipom�|2�?eMgi�G�?j�movI�i�Mpogivke9�dgipo~�e?v¥hk|Xx��M�?� v8x�x��Mlnj�eMx�j2�MlovXh8girMj�r�pn~�|Xp�po~Mjf�AvI�i��v��dgieM�x�vIeMrMgipogivIe�~MvI��r?m9§ J%¦ � J�¥ ­ � ¥ SW� ¦ û �9�Iý)ZÕ¤ô õ ö3÷Ñ÷ÑÚøã_Û%Ý�ùFÝ?Ü.ÞúÙnâ�Û%Ý�â�û3ü�Ú�ä�feMvkpn~Mj�l3�d|$�2pov��dlogipnj#pn~Mj��¦|Xpopnj�l�j��8��|Xpng�vIeMmdgim�pnv¥�Mmoj�mnvk��jfmo�8���]j�polngim�|Xpngivke�hk|}log¦|X�M�ij�m$¤4¯Ýjd�Av8x��?md~Mj�lojvIe N]û �øý X ´ û J�I���I

� I a ý�¤��d~G�?mdx�vk�]j�m9§M û)N ý O NORQ S�U ûVN ý O NO0W X ¨

�$�

Page 15: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

�dgipo~�§U û)N ý X

4��5 HG©2]�©�J H_]�© ¨ ¨H�]�© J ¨ ¨¨ ¨ J ¨¨ ¨ ¨ J

6���7 |}eMr M û)N ý X4��5 HG©2]�© ¨ ¨ ¨¨ � ¨ ¨¨ ¨ � ¨¨ ¨ ¨ �

6���7 IU û)N ýtg�m�mn�G�]��j�pnlogixª|}eMr M û)N ý�gim�mo�8���]j�polngix#�Cvkmngipogihkj¥rMj ô eMgipojky��MlnvXhGgirMjwr pn~�|Xp���j$|Xe,rMj�eMmng�p��8y��]j9|Xepn�Mlo�M�?��jweGp�²8gieMj�pogix�j�eMj�ln�k��|}eMr¥��j9|}e��Mlnj�momn�Mloj�lojw�)|Xgie2��vImogipogihIjk¤­�*gi�k~8p�j�gi�Ij�e8hkj�x�pnvklnm�v}� û M ý � b ûVN ý U ûVN ý|}lojk§

» b ûVN ý X4��5 bB� ]¨¨

6���7 I » © ûVN ý X4��5 ¨¨�¨

6���7 I » J ûVN ý X 4��5 ¨¨¨�

6���7 I » w ûVN ý X 4��5 bB]¨¨

6���7 ¼)ZÕbÔ þ8ÿ7ÿ3Û%Ø��3Ý�÷Ñâ�ã%Ú8×ÌØ��3á7Ü3ØFÙÑä����7Ú�÷ÑÚ�� �8Ø.Ú á7ä�Ý�Ü.ÞíäPö3÷Ñ÷êÚ0ãRÛ�Ý�ùFÝ?Ü.Þ8Ù�â�Û%Ý�â�û7ü�Ú¯Ýj�vke?���¥�?lovXh8girMj�~Mj�loj"po~Mj��)|}gie¥g�e?�klojwrMgij�e8pomdpov¥xwvkeMmnpolo�?x�p�po~Mj�mox¬~Mjw��jk¤

ÈÉ b X �� µ ] û H µ ] û ~�JCý?¥%¦ � û ~ ��ý¤¥%¦Lý |Xe?r ÈÉ w X �� µ ] û H µ ] û ~�J�ý¤¥%¦ S û ~ ��ý?¥�¦uý<¼�d~Mj"��gieMj$|Xlogi÷9|}pogivke�gimd�)|}rMj�|Xlnvk�MeMrúpo~Mj�mnp�|}poj û HæI JFI K�I E ý�¤.Bfj�eMx�jky�po~Mj�p?��v¥gie8poj�ln��j�rMg¦|}poj�mop¬|Xpojwm N b I N ©v8x�x��?logieM��gie]po~Mj�mnvk�i�Mpng�vIe�v}�­po~?j ,¸' " ì\*kð<'iò�ì�ñ �dgij���|XeMe¥�?lovk�?��jw�-|Xlnj#pn~Mj��AvI�i��v��dgieM�C§

N b X4��5 J ¥ S ÈÉ b bB� ¥ � ÈÉ b µ ]

� ¥a ¥ 6 ��7 |XeMr N © X4��5 J ¦ � ÈÉ w bB� ¦ � ÈÉ w µ ]� ¦a ¦ 6 ��7 ¼

J © X J b X J � �� H µ ] û ~ ��ý ¥%¦ û �9�Iý� © X � b X � � H µ ]� û ~�JCý ¥%¦ û �9°Iý)ZÕ�� õ.Ø�÷ÑÚÌÿ7Û%Ø�ÿ�Ú�Û�ã%Ý�Ú�ä

�d~Mj�õ�v8rM�?eMvXhªmnx¬~Mj���j7��vI�M�ir¥e�|Xpn�Ml�|}�i���2gieMmo�?loj�pn~�|Xp E b I E © I�H b I�H © |}eMr)|}�imov�� b X � © lnj��)|}gie¥��vImogipogihkjIy|}momo�?��gieM�2po~Mj�mox$|X�¦|Xldx�vIeMrMgipogivIe û �$�ký�~MvI�irMmdpoln�Mjk¤4��v��ú��j#e?vkpoj�pn~�|Xp�§�dðnï��Mì9ð��Aí��Ió/*RT ��e8poj�ln��j�r?g |}poj¥hk|}���?j¥vX�dpovkp¬|X���Mlojwmomo�?loj�� b X � © lojw�)|XgieMm��Cvkmng�pngihkj¥�MlnvXhGgirMjwrÝpo~�|}p�po~MjgieMgipog¦|}��x�vIeMrMgipogivIeMmdvX�4po~Mjª�*gij��)|}eMeª�?lovk�?��jw� |}�klojwj��dgipn~�§û ~�J�ý ¥%¦ ­ � �H µ ] û �9±IýU T ��eGpnj�lo�]j�rMg¦|Xpnj¥hk|X�i�Mj�m"vX�drMj�eMmng�p��/H b y E b yFK b |Xe?r/H © y E © yFK © lnj��)|}g�e,�Cvkmogipng�hIj¥�MlovXh8girMj�rÝpn~Mj��¦|}popojwlx�vIeMrMgipogivIe�gimdgieMmo�Mlnj�r�¤

�w�

Page 16: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

�dðnï9ï���ó |S���d~Mgimdx��ij9|Xln�i�2�Avk�i�iv��dmL�6lovk� j��8��|Xpng�vIe û �9°kýw¤�8����eGpnlov8rM�Mxwg�e?� E b X

� ¥ H u�� Jb |}eMr�K b X a ¥ H P b gie�j��8��|}pogivke�� b =<¨ û rM�Mj"pov¥x�vIeMrMgipogivke û �9±kýný�j�e�|}�M�ij�m�pnvx¬~Mj�x¬²,po~�|}p��Cvkmng�pngihkj�mnvk�i�MpogivIeUvX��è û H b ý�§ X ©J� ¥ H u�� Jb S a ¥ H P b � � b X ¨ j��8gimopom�|}eMr gimf�MeMgi�8�MjkyCmogieMx�j@èUgim

|]��vIeMvkpnvkeMj�gieMx�lnj9|XmngieM�¥�A�?eMx�pogivIeU�Alnvk� �Ψ%I��T��pov�� � � b I S �T�o¤7B�j�eMxwj2�Avk�i�iv��dmd��vImogipogih8gip���vX� E b y�K b ¤��mng��]gi� |}lLlojwmo�M�ipd~MvI��r?m��Avkl H © y E © y�K © vIe�pn~Mj�vkpn~Mj�ldmng�r?j#v}�Lpo~Mj�x�vIeGp¬|Xx�pfrMgimox�vIe8pogie8�Mgip��G¤AfeMx�j�|X�8|Xgie�yCx�vke?rMgipogivke û �9±Iý�gim���vIloj�lnj�mopnlogix�png�hIj�pn~�|Xe,gipom�x�vke8png�e8�MvI�Mm�x�vk�?eGpnj�lo�C|Xlop û �9�Iý�C�po~Mgim��)|$�]��jj9|}mogi�i��x¬~Mj�x¬²Ij�rÝ~�|$h8gieM�ê| �k�¦|Xe?x�j�|Xp�pn~Mjª�*g�jw�)|Xe?e��Mlnvk�M�ij��ï�dgipo~ |2rMvI�M�M�ij�mn�G�]j�polngix#l¬|Xlnj¬�^|Xxwpogivke;�d|$hkjI¤4 ¡­�*v8j�mox¬~Mjw��j3�dgipn~ N�û �øý X ´ û J�I ��I

� I a ýL|}�imov�j�eC|X�M�ij�m�pov2�Mlojwmoj�lnhkj�gie8hk|Xlng |}eMx�jdv}��g�e8hk|}log¦|Xe8pom.�U|XeMrJpn~MlovI�M�k~�po~?j�e8�M��j�lngix9|X�Cx�vke8p¬|Xx�pfrMgimox�vIeGpngieG�?g�p����d~?j�e�x�vk�]�M�MpogieM�"po~Mj�gie8pojwl��^|}x�j�mop�|}poj�m$¤�dðnï��Mì9ð��Aí �Ió ��mnmo�M�]j#pn~�|XpdgieMgipng |}��rC|Xp�|2gie]po~Mj��dgij���|XeMe¥�?lovk�?��jw� |}�klojwj�m3�dgipo~�§J�¦ � J�¥ X ¨��¦ � ��¥ X ¨�d~Mjwe¥g�e8pnj�lo�]j�rMg¦|XpnjLmop¬|XpojwmL�MlovXh8girMj�r"�G� 4 ¡4�dv8j�eMxwh�mox¬~Mj��]jE|}�klnj�j.�dgipo~�pn~Mjdx�vke8png�e8�MvI�Mm�xwvkeMrMgipng�vIeªmngieMx�jk§J © X J b X J ¥ X J ¦� © X � b X � ¥ X � ¦�d~Mj"�Mlov8vX�4gimdvk�8h8g�vI�Mm�v��dg�e?�ªpnvªgieMmnj�lopng�vIe�vX�Z~�J ¥�¦ X ¨¥|Xe?r�~ � ¥%¦ X ¨2g�e û �$� � �$°kýw¤��fv�� §�dðnï��Mì9ð��Aí��wó ��mnmo�M�]g�e?�ªpn~Mj�mop¬|Xpnj#�¦|2�<p¬|X²Ij�m�pn~Mjf�Avkln� §H 8�Xpo û K�ý S "PH S g�d~Mjwloj�"#|}eMr�g4|XlnjLloj$|X�8x�vke?mop�|}e8pom9y}po~Mj�e2x�j��i�Ihk|X�i�Mj�m4|X��|}lop��6lovk�Q|���vXh8gieM��x�vke8p¬|Xx�p�rMgimox�vIeGpngieG�?g�p��f�Mlojwmoj�lnhkjgie8hk|Xlng |}eMx�jfvX�L��vIpo~;J�|XeMr��4¤�d~Mj]�Mlov8v}��g�m"hkj�ln�Ýmogi��gi�¦|XldpnvUpo~Mj]�Mlov8v}��vX���Mlnvk�Cj�lop��Ý� |}eMrÝpo~8�Mm2gim�eMvIp�rMj�p¬|Xgi�ij�rÝ~Mj�lnjk¤,�d~Mgim���j9|}eMmpn~�|XpLpn~Mjdx�vIeGp¬|Xx�p�rMgimoxwvke8pogie8�Mgip���g�m���j�l®�Aj�x�pn�i�¥�Mloj�mnj�lohIj�r�d~?j�e�lnj�mopnlogix�pogieM�"pov�pn�Mlo�M�?��jweGp���j�l®�Aj�x�p��G|}m�¢�A���¤�Y�Mì " ��ï2( $ ò�' "�v ï " � $ ð U $ ,iì " ��ðoì\*�, v *Xò��L���K������'iò���ðoïM�¿ì$ðD�6í " ï9,iï "#v ì9ðZ�Mï�,iñXò ¤�d~MvI�M�k~,eMvIp#r?g�mnx��Mmnmoj�rÝ~Mjwlojky�gip#gim7��vIlopo~,��jweGpngivkeMeMgieM�¥pn~�|Xp��Mmnjªv}�EvIpo~Mjwl#mn�8��j�pnlogi÷�gieM��hk|}log¦|X�?��jwm�mo�?x�~|}m û �ZI�z.I E I a ýfrMv8j�m"eMvkp�jwe�|X�M�ij2povUgieMmn�Mloj¥�Cvkmngipogihkj¥hk|}���?j�m�vX�drMj�eMmng�p��8y���j9|}eU�Mlojwmomo�?lojU|XeMr,po�?lo�M�M�ij�e8p²8gieMj�png�x�j�e?j�lo�I� |}pdpo~Mj�gie8poj�l®�^|XxwjkyM�Me?��jwmom�vIeMj�loj��8�Mgilnj�m�hIj�lo�]~�|Xlnr)xwvkeMmnpol�|}gieGpnm�vIe�gieMgipog¦|X�Cx�vIeMrMgipogivke?m9¤)ZÕ*) +úá3÷êÚ�Û%Ý��Fâ�ü^Û%Ú�ä�á3ü?ã%ä��e ô �I�Mlojwm#�$¨�|Xlnjd�M�ivkpopnj�r¥lojwmo�M�ipom�vke�|t��j�mn~5�dgipo~��I¨k¨fx�j��i�im9y8mnj�popngieM� < X �DIn��y��dgipo~¥pn~Mj��AvI���iv��dgieM�fg�e?g�png¦|X�x�vIeMrMgipogivIeMm9§ H K J E

� j.�Ap � �$¨ u ¨ �$¨k¨�dgi�I~Gp ¨%¼i�9�I� �$¨Rw ¨ �9¨I¨k¨�  j����.o2k��<����d~Mj"�Mmoj�v}�Lmo�8���]j�polng�÷wg�e?��hk|Xlng |}�M�ij�m�po~8�Mm#|}�i��v��dm�x�vI���M�Mp¬|Xpng�vIe¥vX�Ll�|}po~Mjwl�rMg0/�x��M�ip !�v��éx�vke ô �k�Ml¬|XpogivIeMm9¤��pLgimLjw���M~�|}mogi÷�j�r¥pn~�|Xp�|X�i�Mmox¬~Mjw��j�m�rMgimox��?momojwr)~?j�loj�gie]loj��i�2vke¥po~?j�¡�gieMgipnj 4 vk�i�M�]jLpoj�x¬~Me?g��8�Mjwm9y�|}eMr�|X�?�M�i�

�$�

Page 17: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

�AvIlªhIj�lo�Ýmngi���M�ij�|X�?�MlovX�8gi�)|}poj¥�dgij��)|}eMe,movk�ihIj�lom¥|Xp2j9|Xx¬~ g�e8pnj�l��^|}x�j���jwp?��j�jwe�p?��v,eMj�gi�k~8�Cvk�Mlng�e?�Ux�j��i�im9¤�d~Mj��]j�po~Mv8r]~�|Xmd�Cj�j�e�mo�?x�x�j�mnm��A�M�i�i�U|X�M�?��gij�r �Avkl�mo~C|X�i�iv�� �d|Xpnj�ldj��8��|}pogivkeMm$yM¢4�M�ij�ldj��8��|}pogivke?m9y8po�?lo�M�M�ij�e8px�vI���Mlnj�momngi�M�ij�x��ivkmn�Mloj�m"��|Xmnj�rUvkeúvkeMj�vIl�p?��v}�^j��8��|}pogivke��]vGr?j��im�� �}�2�oy��Î�k�<� û �6vkldmojwx�vkeMr¿�^vIlorMj�l2�dj��8eMvI��r?mmnpolojwmom�x��ivkmn�Mloj�m$ydmojwjUloj¬�6j�loj�e?x�jD�Î�k�P�Aýw¤ù�d~Mj���j�pn~Mv8r ~�|}m��Cj�j�e<�MlnvXhkj�rùpnvÝ��jU|Xm�|}x�x��Ml¬|Xpnj |Xm]�Mloj�h8givk�?m|}�M�MlovX�8gi�)|}poj¥õ�v8rM�MeMvXh,mox¬~Mjw��j�m2gieGhIj�mopngi�G|Xpnj�rÌ�Î�<�oyL|XeMrÝ�]j9|Xe��d~Mgi�ijªgim��]vklnj¥lovk�?�Mmop2po~�|}eÝmogi��gi�¦|Xl�|X�8��MlnvX�8g���|XpnjEõ�v8rM�?eMvXh�mox¬~Mjw��j�mLgie¥mnvk��j�mo�Cj�x�g ô xfx9|Xmnj�mdgieMx��i�MrMgieM��j�gipn~Mj�lLlnj9|X�Chk|Xx��?�M� û �d~Mj�e2�6vGxw�MmogieM��vIemn~�|X�i�iv��6�d|Xpnj�lLj��8��|}pogivkeMm¬ý�yIvklLe?j9|Xl®�^hk|}x��M�M� û �d~?j�e�rMj$|X�igieM�^�dg�pn~ê¢u�M�ij�l�jw�G�C|XpogivIeMm4�AvIl­xwvk���?loj�mnmogi�M�ijd�G|}mrM�8e�|}��gix�m¬ý�¤�{�j$|Xmo�?loj�v}�æpn~Mj���bLj�lolnvkl�eMvkln� gie�mnvk��j�mo�Cj�x�g ô xfx9|Xmnj�mLx�vIe ô ln��m4po~�|}p4po~MgimLmnvk�ihkj�l4gimL|XmL|Xxwx��8�l¬|Xpoj�|Xm�õtvGr?�MeMvXh�mnx�~?j���j û mo~�|}���iv����E|}poj�lLjw�G�C|XpogivIeMm�ýL|}eMr¥vX��xwvk�Mlnmoj��¥�?x�~2x¬~Mj9|}��j�l$¤L�8gi��gi�¦|Xl�x�vk�]��j�e8pom~MvI�ir��d~Mj�e¥po�?loeMgieM��pnvª¢4�M�ij�l�j��8��|Xpng�vIeMm9¤4�d~?vk�M�I~ªvIeMj��]g��I~8p�po~?g�e?²�po~�|}pLpo~?g�m�²GgieMr¥v}��|}�M�MlnvG|Xx¬~¥gimL�¥�Mx¬~�]vklojdgie2�^|$hIvk�Ml�vX��po~?j�polnj9|Xpn��j�e8p�vX��l¬|Xloj.�^|Xx�pngivke�d|$hkjwm9yIg�p�eMvkeMjwpo~Mj��ij�mnm��Cj�lo�]gipomLrMj$|X�igieM���dgipo~��*g�jw�)|Xe?e�Mlnvk�M�ij��]mLgieMx��i�MrMgieM�"mopolnvkeM�¥r?vk�M�M�ijfmo~Mv8x¬²��E|$hIj�m9¤4�d~?j#lnj9|Xmnvke9�d~G�¥pn~Mj�mox¬~Mj��]j�x�vIe8hkj�ln�kj�mdpnv��E|}lorMm�po~Mjlng��I~8p3��j9|X²]movk�i�MpngivkeMm$yMrMj�mn�Mgipoj"�AlovI�-pn~Mj��^|}x�p�pn~�|Xpdgipf�Mmoj�m�mnv¥x9|X�i�ij�rUeMvIe�x�vkeMmnj�lohk|}pogihkj2hk|Xlng¦|X�M�ijky8gimdrM�Mjpnv¥po~Mj���|Xx�p�po~�|}pdgipdg�m.�dlngipopojwe)�?eMrMj�lfx�vkeMmnj�lohk|}pogihkjf�AvIlo�,¤�d~Mjwmoj#|}�M�MlnvX�Ggi��|XpojL�*g�jw�)|Xe?e#mnvk�ihkjwlom4gieMrMj�j�r¥mnj�j��ü�MlovI��gimogieM�dpnv#xwvk���?�Mpoj�|}�M�MlnvX�Ggi��|XpogivIeMm�vX��xwvk���?��jw�mnj�pomfvX�­jw�G�C|XpogivIeMm�mn�Mx¬~U|Xmdpo~?vkmoj�|}logimogieM��gie]p?��v2�M~�|}moj7!�v��<�]vGr?j��i��gieM���Î�k°<�oy0�Î�M���oy«�Î�I±2�oy¸� �I�\�oy0�Î�k¨<�o¤���e�pn~Mgim�Al¬|X�]jkyXpo~?j�x�vI�Me8poj�ln��|XlnpdvX��loj$|X��hk|Xxw�M�M� �)|$��v8x�x��Ml û �d~Mj�e]vkeMjf�M~�|Xmnj�rMgim¬|X�M�Cj9|Xlnm�ýwyM|Xm ��j��i��|XmLpn~Mj�e?j9|Xlhk|}x��M�M�x�d~Mjwe mnpolovIeM��l�|}loj¬�^|}x�pogivIe#�d|$hkj�mfrMj�hIj��ivk��¤��d~Mjwmoj¥��v8rMjw��mdgieMr?j�j�r,loj��Mlnj�mojweGp¥|¥~C|Xlor,x¬~�|X�i�ij�eM�Ijmng�e?x�j�po~?j��)|}��mnv¥gieGhIvk�ihkjd��|Xe8�2rMgÆ�æj�lnj�e8p�png��]j�mnx9|X�ij�m$¤¡>¢!£¥¤d¦K§�¨�©�ª¬«j­$©�¤¬®R¯R°�d~Mj�po~Mgilor�|}�Mpo~MvIl�~�|}m���jweMj ô pnpoj�r"�AlovI� ô e�|XeMxwg |}�Xmo�M�?��vIlop��?eMrMj�l4¢L«�¡��oz��#�f�fx�vke8pol¬|Xx�p4z.A��k°k°I¨#±}�#¢L¢L�I°k¨}��¤wxq7sDq.��q|���.q7k��� � ²d³0´(³cµ�¶�·¬¸¥¹¬¶jºLy��WrMgÆ��j�loj�e?x�jª�]j�po~?vGr �Avkl�e8�M��jwlogix9|X�Cx9|}��xw�M�¦|XpogivIe�vX�4rMgimox�vIe8pogie8�Mvk�Mmdjw�G�C|XpogivIeMm�v}�~G�8rMlnv8rM�8e�|X�]g�xwm9y�» *��\¼½� U ¼ y��9�k�I�MyI�M��¤C�k°M�M¾¿�I¨k¨M¤I��eU�d�Mmnmog¦|Xe�¤� � � ¿L³0À�³ZÁ�¶¥Â¥¶Ly�à '¦ì & * "%" ò�ï�,ÅÄ9ì$ð¬ò* " ñ "%$�& ì9ð�')(+*-, & ì!�Å�Mï$ñXòn��ïkðZÆ $ '¦ñ ñkí " * & ')(�ò yd�8�Mlng�e?�kj�l 4 jwlo�¦|X�Cy�9�k�I°M¤� � � Çy³½¿�Èr¹¥ÉËÊKÌ#·¬Í�νÏb³0Ð,³½Ñ;¸¥¹¬ÒOÎÔÓn³0ÕÖ³Ô×�¶¥ÊhØ¥¹¥·ÙÇ�³½²�Ú¥Û¶¬ÜÝÂ¥Ê�Ê�¹Ly0Afe õtvGr?�MeMvXhI�^p��8�Cj���j�pn~Mv8rMm�e?j9|Xl��v��érMj�eMmng�pngij�m9yÝÞ ¼.ßLï & �¥¼¬���Mí$òD¼ y��9�I�M�kyIhkvI��¤G�I�$�o�My8�M��¤M�I°k�f¾¿�k�I�M¤� �-� ×b³�àc³cÕ¬ÊjánÊOâ�¸¥Ê�yOã@$�& ì$ð�'V(\*�, » ì!���?ï9ñ}ò���ïIð�ßLï " ò�ì9ð�Ä�*��L'¦ï ",ä *kî4ò y�:�g�ln²8~¬å|X�Mmnj�l�� 4 j�ln�¦|X��y�:E|}moj���y��9�k�I¨M¤� � � ¿L³½µ�¶¥·¬Ì�Ê�æ,ç�è¬È.Ø¥¹¥·ÙÓL³�éi³½×�Ø#º¥ÈêØ¥Â�ÍLy¥ã�$�& ì9ð<'V(\*�,�*M�#��ðoïë�P' & *#�b'¦ï " ï_���Mí��Mì9ð U ï-,½'V(�ò�í$òD�6ì & ò�ï_��(�ï " Tò.ì$ðDÄ2*#�b'¦ï " ,¸*kî4ò yM�8�MlngieM�kj�l 4 j�lo�¦|X�Cy��9�I�k�M¤� � � ÓL³0ÕÖ³K×�¶�Ê�yX���?�MlovX�8gi�)|}pojL�dgij���|XeMefmovk�ihIj�lom$yX��|Xl¬|X�]j�poj�l�hkj�xwpovklnmL|XeMr�r?g���j�lnj�eMx�jdmnx�~?j���j�m$y�Þ ¼¬ßLï & �¥¼���Mí$òD¼ y��$�k±M�Iy8hkvI�^¤I�G�?y8�M��¤M�I�k°!¾M�k°I�M¤� ° � µ(³�é(³ìÇ�ÈêÂ¥·�yR» ï�,iì+( $ ,½*Ið v *}òEñIí " * & 'V(wò3* " ñY���?ì�ñP'¦ðoì\(!�Cò ' &5$ ,½*��L' ï " ï_� v *Xò¥Æ�ïkî4ò ykz��¦|Xlnj�eMrMvIe�yDAf�I�Avklnrc3=¥y��9�I�X��¤� ± � ¿L³0²pín¥إ¹�ÎyÏb³0´(³AínîÙØ¥¹¥·ïÇ�³0ð�³ZÏ�ñ¬òKñ¬è�yL«fgiloj�x�p¥�8gi�¥�M�¦|XpngivkeU{�vke8pnj¬�®zd|}lo�iv�§"loj�xwj�e8p�|XrMhk|}eMx�j�m|XeMr�|X�M�M�igix9|}pogivkeMm$y�ó^"%" ¼ à ìëÄ!¼Lï_��ôE, $ '¦ñ » ì+(���¼ y��9�I�k±?ykhIvk��¤M�k¨?y8�M��¤8�G¨I�!¾8�k���I¤� � � Áb³ZÇ�¸¥É�ÉDإ¥·ÖÎõÁb³LµnØ¥Ì#Ì�¶¥¸�ÛÊ�ÍïØ¥¹¥·ïàc³0Ñö³L÷WøÊ�¥إ¥·�y���mojw�G�?j���povÝ|,lovk�?�k~�õtvGr?�MeMvXhÝmox¬~Mjw��jk¤���M�M�igix9|}pogivke¥pnv¥loj9|}���G|}m !�v��dm9y ßLï & � $ �Aì$ð¬ò�* " ñYôE, $ '¦ñXò yC�k¨k¨I¨MyIhkvI�^¤8�k�S�®°?y8�M��¤M±?�9�!¾M±X�8°M¤

�$�

Page 18: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

�i�9¨ � Áb³AÇÖ¸¥É�ÉDإ¥·�Î�Á ³�µnØ¥Ì�Ì˶�¸�ÛÊ�ÍùØ¥¹¥·úàd³0Ñ�³A÷GøÊ�¥إ¥·�y4� e�|}g�hIjêõtvGr?�MeMvXh,mox¬~Mj��]j¥povUx�vI���M�?poj¥|eMvke8��x�vIeMmoj�lnhk|Xpng�hIj�~G�8�Cj�lo�Cvk�igix�mo�8mopnj�� yjû\" ��¼c��ì$ð�'¦ìwò ã�$�& ¼ » *#�Å��¼ y��9�I�k±MyIhkvI��¤��$�k�My8�?��¤��9�I�!¾æ�$�k±?¤�i�k� � Áb³�µnØ¥Ì#Ì˶�¸�ÛÊ�Í�Îcàc³0Ñö³Ý÷WøÊ�¥إ¥·Ø¥¹¥·ýü,³Ý²�ÊOÜݸ¥Èê¹Ly �Cï & ì�ðoì\(¬ì " �¬ô ' " 'ê�6ì�þMï-, $�& ìtò (��Mì & ì�ò��Aï�(¬ï & T� $ �Aì�� $ ,iì9ð�ì�ÿ $ *��L'¦ï " ò $ ò�' "#v ðnì+*-, v *}òd���.� y � �L��sU�*j���vIlop4¨k¨$�o¨k�?�ky¬cfeMgihkj�lnmogipMqjLr?jEs4lnvXhkj�e?x�jkyk¡?l�|}eMx�jk¤�Aï�*M�#�Mì+*Ið5' ",û\" ��¼ Þ ¼���ïkð ã@$_& ¼ » ì!���K¼�' " ôE, $ '¦ñXò yC�k¨k¨I¨M¤�i�9� ��é(³A÷�Ø¥ÂËÍ¥ÊK¹�ÎyÓL³0Ð,³�ÕÝØ��ùØ¥¹¥·ïÇ�³�áÔØ¥¹ïÕÝÊ�Ê�ÂLyZAfe �M�Mmopnloj9|}� rMgÆ��j�loj�e?x�gieM� |XeMr õtvGr?�MeMvXhI�^p��8�Cjmox¬~Mj��]j�m��Avkld~8�8�Cj�lo�Cvk�igix�x�vkeMmnj�lohk|}pogivke��¦|2�dm9y � û ó�» à ì!Ä2'¦ì9î y��9�k±I�MyIhkvI�^¤M�I�My8�M��¤M�k�!¾M�M�I¤�i�9� ��é(³Ý÷�Ø¥Â�Í¥Ê�¹LyFAfe)pn~Mj�mn�G�]��j�pnlogix��AvIlo� v}�­mo�8mnpoj��]m�vX�4x�vke?moj�lnhk|XpogivIe)�¦|2�dm.�dgipo~]j�e8polnvk�8�GyÝÞ ¼�ßLï & �¥¼���Mí$òD¼ y��$�k±k�?y8hkvI�^¤I�G�?y8�M��¤��$�M��¾��9�}��¤�i���-� ´(³¥à�Ø¥¹¬ç�Ê�¹�νðÖ³¥àj¶¥î¥Ø¥¹¥¹9Ø¥¹¥·pÁb³�àc³0×b³Ý÷�¸¬ÜÝî¥ÊOçIy8�����M�ij��]j�e8p�|Xpngivke2vX�­|"vkeMj�j��8��|}pogivke¥pn�Mlo�M�?��jweMx�j��v8rMj��P�dg�pn~Mgieª|fmop¬|X�Mgi�igi÷�j�r ô e?g�pnj�jw��jw��j�e8p��Avkln�¥�M�¦|Xpng�vIe�v}�æ|dmn�G�]��j�pnlogix�|}rMhkj�xwpogihkj¬��rMgÆ���Mmogihkj�mo�8mnpoj��,yßLï & � $ �\¼ » ì!���?ï9ñ}ò ó ���«,�¼ » ì\( �K¼¬� "#v ð v ¼ y��9�k�I�MyIhkvI�^¤C�9¨I�My8�M��¤8�G¨k�f¾G�8�k�M¤�i�9� ��àd³0Ñ�³jµnÂ¥Ê�ÊK¹¥òOÊ�Â¥ÜØ¥¹¥·Wé(³��(³�Õ¬Êh×�¶¥¸��Ly8�Ì��j��i�M��|}�¦|XeMx�jwr¥mox¬~Mj��]j��AvklLpn~Mjde8�M��jwlogix9|X�?�Mlov8x�j�mnmogieM�vX�­mnvk�Mlnx�j�pnj�lo�]mdg�e]~8�G�Cj�ln��vI��gix�j��8��|}pogivke�y � û ó�» Þ ¼ ã@$_& ì$ðD¼ ó^" *�,ż y��9�I�k�My8hIvk��¤8�k�$���kyI�M��¤���¾��9�M¤�i�9� ��é(³��i³.ÕÝÊ�×�¶¥¸��LyL«fgimox�lMqj�pogim¬|XpogivIe rMjwm�poj�ln��j�m"movk�?lox�j�m2l�|}girMj�m�r�|Xe?m��ij�m��MlovI�M���j���j�m�~8�8��jwlo�Cvk�igi�G�?j�m9y��e ��í$òD���ì & ìwòL�?í��¿ì$ð U ï�,¸'êÿ $ ìwòêó ã ï $ Ä9ì\* $ �úò�(��ì & *}òêì!� " ï $ Ä9ì<,V,�ìwò*����«,¸'V(\*#�b'¦ï " ò ¤ q¢ux�vk�ij�mªzd¢u�d�o¢L«�¡�����#�d�����n�MlovI�M���j���j�m]eMvkeW�igieEqj9|Xgilnj�mU|X�M�M�igi�8�dqj�m�d�yf���#�d��� �*vGxw�G�?j�eMx�vI�Mlop û ¡Ml¬|XeMxwj9ý�y2{U|Xlnx�~ �9�I�k±?¤��hk|Xgi�¦|X�?��jdvIe� ������������������������ ��!#"�$&% '(���*),+�! -.)/�10 2 3�),45"(6��7��"18�2 % 9;:��<% 45$;+���:>=;!#2 3 )?4�"(6�!# ;���*2Ãy8��eU¡Mlnj�eMx¬~�¤�i�9° � Áb³jµnØ¥Ì�Ì˶¥¸�ÛÊKÍ�άàc³0Ñö³ì÷GøÊK¥إ¥·$Ø¥¹¥·9üõ³ì²�ÊOÜݸ¥Èê¹Ly �Cï & ì�*����æðoï!�D' & *��Aì*@dï9ñ $�" ï#Ä�ò�(��Mì & ìwò��6ï5(¬ï & T� $ �Aì]ò_�%*-,V,�ïIîcToî�*��Aì$ðªì�ÿ $ *#�b'¦ï " ò�îE'ê���G�AïM�¿ï v ð�*����Mí y4¢L«�¡��o«���« �*j��Cvklop@B��6�o±M�ë±I¨M�!±k¨k��±X�2y �6ï#*M�#�Mì+*Ið' " ßLï & � $ �6ì9ð.ò�* " ñbôE, $ ' ñXò yM�k¨I¨M�k¤�i�9± � Áb³�µnØ¥Ì#Ì˶�¸�ÛÊ�ÍWØ¥¹¥·Wàc³0Ñ�³ÝÑ;جç�Ê�Ì#Ì�ØLy8�ølnvk�M�I~�õ�v8rM�MeMvXh"mox¬~Mj��]jky ß�¼ à ¼ ó (\*kñ�¼¥�«(2'ê¼¥�.*Ið�'iò yM�9�I�k�?yhkvk��¤I�6�®�I�k�?yk�M��¤�°k°f¾¿±}��¤�i�9� � Áb³�ÇÖ¸¥É�ÉDإ¥·�ÎÔÁb³ÝµnØ¥Ì�Ì˶¥¸�ÛÊKÍ Ø¥¹¥·9àd³�Ñö³Ý÷WøÊ�¥إ¥·�y8�feU|X�M�MlnvX�8g���|XpnjEõ�v8rM�?eMvXhªmnx¬~Mj���jfpov2x�vk� ��M�Mpoj�pn�Mlo�M�?��jweGpfloj9|}���G|}m !�v��ø�]v8rMj��im9y�ó�ûeó�ó �%*��Mì9ð A1ARTel�lfm�A y4�9�k�I�M¤�Î�k¨ ��àd³Ý²�B�¶¥Ì�Ì#Ê�ÂLy �Ë�?ï�(�C�î�*#Ä$ìwò�* " ñ)ðnì\*D(!�L'¦ï " ñD' D $ ò�'¦ï " ì�ÿ $ *��L'¦ï " ò y��8�?logieM�kjwl 4 j�ln�¦|X��y��$�k±I�M¤�Î�M� � ×b³Ô²�ØO¸¥Â¥ÊKÌ;Ø¥¹¥· ×b³céyòìÜÝ¥إÌ#ÌCyC� mogi�]�M�ij���jwpo~Mv8r]�Avklfx�vk�]�Mlojwmomogi�M�ij��¥�M�ipogÆ!��?g�r�!�v��dm9y � û óZ» Þ ¼�«(�'r¼�ßLï & �¥¼ y��$�k�I�MyIhkvk��¤8�M�.�®�?y8�M��¤��k�I�9�f¾æ�k�w�G�?¤�Î�k� � ´(³0Ñö³ì²�îjñ¬¸¥Ê�y8�8!��Mgir2��gi�8po�MlnjLp��8��j�|}�i�kvklngipo~M�W�AvIl4x�vk�]�Mloj�mnmogi�M�ij��¥�M�ipogix�vk�¥�Cvke?j�e8p0!�v��6�dgipo~ 4 |}erMj�ld¯ø|I|X�im�jw�G�C|XpogivIe)v}�­mnp�|Xpnjky¬Þ ¼�ßLï & �¥¼¥���Mí$òD¼ y��9�k�I�MyIhkvI�^¤��$�k�?yk�M��¤M�G�f¾¿±I±M¤�Î�k� � Áb³.µnØ¥Ì�Ì˶¥¸�ÛÊKÍ�Î�àd³�Ñö³A÷GøÊK¥إ¥·ýØ¥¹¥·úü,³.²�ÊOÜݸ¥Èê¹Lycó^" �Mí U ð�'¦ñ ò (��Mì & ì,�6ï;(¬ï & � $ �Aì�(¬ï " �L*P(ë�fñD'iò�T(�ï " �b' "%$ 'ê�b'¦ì�ò^' " � $ ,iì9ðfò�í$òD�Aì & ò yM¢L«�¡��o«#�f«Q�dj��Cvklnp.B��6�o±M�!±k¨M�!±k¨?�k�ë±}�ªy � $ U & 'ê���6ì�ñZ��ïkðÔ� $ U ,½')(+*��L' ï "My�k¨k¨?�k¤�Î�X�-��é(³ÝÀ�¶¥Â¥ÊjçDÍ¥ÈêÊKÂ�ÎOàc³0Ñ�³Ý÷GøÊK¥إ¥·WØ¥¹¥·FE(³dÕd¶¥¸¥È\çIy8� õ�v8rM�Me?vXhªp��8�Cj#mnvk�ihkjwl�pnvªx�vI���M�?pojdpo�?lo�M�M�ij�e8px�vk�]�Mloj�mnmogi�M�ij.!Cv��dm9y ß�¼ à ¼ ó (\*kñ�¼c�«(2'ê¼¥�.*kð�' ò y��$�k�I°My8hkvI��¤k�6�o�k�}��y8�M��¤M�?�9�f¾¿�k�I�M¤�Î�k� ��àd³0Ñ�³Ô÷GøÊK¥إ¥·ÖÎ.é(³ÖÀ½¶�Â¥ÊOç�Í¥ÈêÊ�Â9Ø¥¹¥·GEi³.Õc¶¥¸¥È\çIydóï" ï " òD�6ð�'V(!�V,iín�Mí��Mì9ð U ï-,½'V(2ò�í$òD�Aì & �6ï�ñkìwò�(9ð�' U ì(�ï & ��ðoìwò¬ò ' U ,iìn� $ ð U $ ,�ì " (¬ì yM¢�«#¡��o«�¢L�ø�*j��Cvklop7B#¢������!±k�}�˱k¨?�k�!±X�ªy?�9�k�}��¤�Î�k� � Ïb³ÔÇ�Ê�Â�ͥ¥¹�ÎAÀ�³ÔÏ�¶¬â�¸¥Ê�ÌìÎ.àc³0Ñö³Ô÷WøÊ�¥إ¥·pØ¥¹¥·ùÑ�³IH�î¥Ì1B�Ø¥¹¥¹Ly���eÝ|X�M�?lovX�8gi�)|Xpnj�mnvk�i�MpogivIe)v}�po~Mjª�*gij��)|}eMe��Mlnvk�M�ij�� �AvIl#|¥lnj9|X�igi÷9|}�M�ij#mnj�x�vIeMr �]vk�]j�e8pLpo�Mln�M�M�ij�e8p�x��ivkmn�Mlojky �Ë�?ï�(�C��9*#Ä$ì�ò y��k¨I¨k�?yhkvk��¤C�k�Iy8�M��¤M�X�8�!¾M�k�k�?¤

�$°

Page 19: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

�Î�k° � Áb³.µnØ¥Ì�Ì˶¥¸�ÛÊKÍ�Î�àd³0Ñ�³.÷WøÊ�¥إ¥·ÙØ¥¹¥·ïü,³.²�Êjܬ¸¥Èr¹Ly4��eÝ|X�ipoj�lne�|Xpngihkj��d|$�Upov�rMj9|}�Z�dgipn~ p?��v9!��Mgir��v8rMj��im9y�ó�ûeó�ó �%*��Mì9ðKJË�!TeS��#��l y��k¨I¨M�k¤�Î�k± ��àd³ÔµnÌ�ÈLBMB Î�Ð,³.²�Ø¥Ì�ͬÒ�Ø¥¹¥·úÐ,³0÷,³.²�î¥Ø¥Â�N�y��.��v��M~C|Xmoj@!�v��Q�]vGr?j��i��gieM�¥v}�E|�!C�Mgir �]g��8gieM�2�¦|$�kj�l$yÞ ï $ ð " *�,�ï���ôE, $ '¦ñ » ì\(��%* " 'V(wò y��9�I�k�My8hIvk��¤8�k°k±?y8�M��¤��I�9�!¾����8�M¤�Î�k� ��á(³Ý×ZØ¥¹¬çë¶OB Ø¥¹¥·pÐ,³0ÕÖ³½÷�ÈQPjèdçIyDBf�G�Cj�ln��vI��gix�p?��vX���Mloj�mnmo�Mlnj���v8rMjw��mu�Avkl�p?��v}�^�?~�|Xmnj.!�v���yjÞ ¼�ßLï & �¥¼���Mí$òD¼ y��$�k±X�Cy8hkvI�^¤8�k�S�.�Iyk�?��¤��$�X�R¾��9�?�k¤�Î�k¨ � Ñö³0×b³KÇ�Ø¥Ê�Â&Ø¥¹¥· àc³�Rt³Kü�¸¥¹¬ÒRÈrØËͬ¶�yX�ùp?��vf�M~�|}moj���gi�8po�Mlnj­pn~Mj�vIlo���AvIl4po~Mj�rMj\!æ|}�kl¬|XpogivIe�povfrMj�povIe�|$�pogivke û «#«f��ý4pnl�|}eMmogipogivIe¥g�e¥lnj9|Xxwpogihkj��kl¬|Xe8�M�¦|Xl4��|Xpojwlog¦|X�im9y û+" ��¼ Þ ¼ »�$ ,Å�L' � �%*}ò�ì�ôE,�ïkî y��$�k±k�?yXhkvI��¤M�9�S�®�?y�M��¤M±k�?��¾M±k±k�?¤

�$±

Page 20: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

S hjq^ziUT�<����v��s8�.q3o�oVT^i�o2q3k �q3i|�xÏ i@o�oXW�������i^����q3k¯Ýjfg�e8pnlov8rM�Mx�jfgieMgipog¦|X�MxwvkeMrMgipng�vIeMmLv}�­|��dgij���|XeMe2�MlovI�M�ij��ß�d~Mgix¬~��kjweMj�l�|}poj�mo�8�]��j�pnlogix9|X�8rMvI�M�M�ijdl�|}l�|S�^|Xx¬�png�vIe�d|$hkj�m$ykpn~8�Mmd��gi��göx¬²GgieM�fpo~Mjfj��M|Xx�pd�Cj�~�|$h8givk�?l�v}��po~Mj�|X�?�MlovX�8gi�)|}pojdõ�v8rM�MeMvXh2mox¬~Mj��]jkyM|Xe?r��vkeMrMjwl�d~Mjwpo~Mj�lfj��8��jwx�poj�r,�Cvkmogipng�hIj�hk|}���?j�m û po~�|}p�gim$§��E|}poj�ld~Mjwg��I~8p û �Avkl�mo~�|}�i��v��8�d|Xpnj�ldj��8��|XpngivkeMm¬ý�C8rMj�e?mogip��)|}eMr�Mlnj�momn�Mloj û �6vkl�¢4�M�ij�ldjw�G�C|XpogivIeMm�ýnýdlojw�)|Xgie¥�Cvkmng�pngihkjkyF$�" ñIì9ð�(�,¸*Xò¬ò�'V(\*�,�߬ô ä T?,¸'YCIì�(¬ï " ñP'ê�L' ï "ݧ' � � X £7Z ` � º X ¨�¼ � û �9�Iý�d~Mgi�ij�moj�pnpogieM�º X [ ´\ y�|}eMr £7Z ` � po~?j#��|X�8gi�¥�M�Qmo�Cj�j�rúvX���E|$hIj�m9¤] Õ�Ö õ��3â�ü�ü�Ø�^_^#â�ã%Ú�Û8Ú�à.á7â�ã%Ý�Ø�Ü3ä¯ÝjU|X�?�M�i� po~?jUx��¦|Xmnmogix9|X�f��gilolnvkl2mop¬|Xpojúpoj�x¬~MeMgi�8�Mjky�|Xe?r |}momn�M��j�po~C|Xp�pn~MjUgieMgipog¦|}��x�vIeMrMgipogivIe�gieùx�j��i�`eMjwg��I~8��vI�MlogieM��pn~Mj3�d|X�i�C��vI�MeMr�|}lo�2gim ûbå �a X å ID� �a X � �#ýwyM|XeMr¥pn~G�?m�pn~�|Xp���gilolnvkl4mop¬|Xpnj#gie¥pn~Mj ô xwpogipogivk�?mx�jw����vke,po~Mj¥lng��I~8p#mngirMjªv}�Epn~Mj��d|X�i���Cvk�Me?r�|Xln� gim¥§ ûLå �Z X å ID� �Z X �#ýwy�|Xmnmo�M�]gieM��pn~�|XpY�ï= ¨?¤¥�dj�x9|}�i�pn~�|Xp2hk|Xx��?�M� vGxwx��Mlom�|}pªpn~Mj�d|X�i�L�Cvk�?eMr�|Xln�Ýgö�#� ì è å X �D] % �ªy4vkpn~Mj�l��dgimnj�eMvIp9¤U�f�M�M�i�8gieM���AvIl�po~Mj|}�M�MlovX�8gi�)|}poj�õ�v8rM�?eMvXh¥mox¬~Mj��]j�loj�mn�M�ipom�gie�po~?j��6vk�i�iv��dg�e?��hk|X�i�Mj å � � ba |}pdpo~Mj�j�e?rUvX�4po~Mj�pngi��jdmopnj���§å � � ba � å S º ûLå �#ý X ¨|}eMrUpo~8�Mm å � � ba girMjweGpng ô j�m3�dgipn~U�MlojwrMgix�pogivkeúvX�Eõ�v8rM�?eMvXh�mnx�~?j���jk¤*��vkpngieM�¥po~�|}p#zd¡ � lnj�mopnlogix�png�vIe e?j�x�j�m®�m¬|Xlogi�i�¥gi���M�igij�mLpn~�|Xp3º�� ­ ��gieMmn�Mloj�mfpo~�|}p å � � ba gim��Cvkmngipogihkjk¤

] Õ¤ô b�á7ü�Ú�Û�Ú�à.á7â�ã%Ý�Ø�Ü3äc^6Ý?ã��xÿ�Ú�Û1d�Ú¬�0ã�ÞZâ�äXbce8õ�d~Mj¥¢�A��úg�m�|Xmnmo�M�]j�r�pov���j"��j�l®�Aj�x�p"�G|Xm�¢�A���yC~Mj�eMxwjU§�z X û < � �$ý û 3 � ��GI��HK�#©�ý�y0�dgipo~ � ­ < ­ �?¤¯Ýj�mnpogi�i�4�Mmoj2po~Mj2��gilnlovkldmnp�|}poj2poj�x¬~MeMgi�8�Mjky�|XeMrUpn~8�Mm�g�e?g�png¦|X��x�vIeMrMgipogivke § û H �a X H«I�� �a X � �ZI z �a X z"ýgie,po~Mj�!��?g�r,x�j��i�im�vke,po~Mj¥�ij¬�6p#mngirMj¥vX��pn~Mj��d|X�i��yæ|}eMr û H«I��ZI�z�ýfgieUpo~Mj¥�]gilolovIl�x�jw����vke,po~Mj¥lng��I~8p#mngirMjªv}�pn~Mj�d|X�i��y­|}momn�M��gieM��po~C|Xp � = ¨?¤U�d~Mgim���|$�U��j]gie |X�klnj�j��]j�e8p��dgipo~ û < � �9ýM� ­ � ó < z.G�H,��gieÝpo~�|}px9|}moj]eMv�hk|Xx��M�?�v8x�x��Mlnmê|}p�po~?j��E|}���4�Cvk�Me?r�|Xln�k��y�vkl�eMvkp$¤¥�d~Mgim�gieMgipog¦|}��r�|}p�|�x�vIlolnj�mo�CvkeMr?mªpnvUpo~Mj¥x$|Xmojx9|}�i��jwrݯÌ:Ezügie,po~Mj¥��|XgieU��|}lop�v}�Epn~Mj���|}��jwl9yL|Xe?r |}��mnv�povUpn~Mj¥�Al¬|X�]j���vIlo²�vX��|XeC|X�i�8mogim�x�vkeMr?�Mx�pojwr gielnj¬�Aj�lnj�eMx�j�Î� �®¤4�8j�pnpogieM� M X �ZGP]XyM|Xe?r¥�MmogieM��pn~Mj#|}�M�MlnvX�Ggi��|Xpojdõ�v8rM�Me?vXhªmnx�~?j���j 4 ¡­�*v8j3�dgipo~¥hk|}log¦|X�M�ijN ´ X ûLa ID� I z�ýwykpn~Mj��Mlnj�rMgix�pnj�rUhk|X�i�Mj�|Xpdpn~Mj��d|X�i��gie8pojwl��^|}x�j�g�mdmngi���M�i��§a ³ X akû H«I�z�ý�I.� ³ X ¨�Idz ³ X z û � � < M ýgö� < M ­ �kyM|}eMr�vkpn~Mj�l��dgimnjk§ a ³ X aIû H0I z"ý�I.� ³ X ¨�Idz ³ X ¨Bfj�eMx�j2po~Mj��M�Cr�|}poj�rUxwj��i��hk|X�i�MjfvX�4rMj�eMmng�p��9H � � ba |X�Iloj�j�m7�dgipo~ݧH � � ba � H S º û H���ý X ¨|}eMrÝpo~8�Mm�mnpogi�i�4j��8��|X�im�gipom"x�vk�Me8pnj�lo��|}lop�vI�Mp�|}gieMj�r/�dgipo~,po~Mj¥jw�¿|}x�pªõ�v8rM�?eMvXhUmox¬~Mjw��jk¤¥� mogi��gi�¦|Xldlnj�mo�M�ip~MvI�irMm��Avkl�povIp�|}��j�eMjwlo�k�8y8mogieMxwj�§ 3 � � ba � 3 S º û � û 3 S z"ýoý X ¨

�$�

Page 21: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

�fvkeMj�pn~Mj��ij�mnm9yC�MlojwrMgix�poj�r,hk|X�i�MjfvX�4��vk�]j�e8po�M�üvke�x�j��i��x��ivkmoj�pnv¥po~Mj^�d|X�i�û H��#ý � � ba � û HK�#ý S º ûnû HK� © ý S z ³ � z"ý X ¨rMgÆ��j�lom2�6lovk� pn~Mj�vIeMj�vI�Mp�|}g�e?j�r6�dgipo~Ýjw�¿|}x�p¥õ�v8rM�MeMvXh,mox¬~Mj��]jky4mogieMxwj)hk|}�i�Mj�m�v}�#�Mlnj�momn�Mloj�vke po~Mj9�E|}�i�

�Cvk�Me?r�|Xln�)|Xlnj�rMgimopogieMxwpª§�z ³ ­ z ³fhg<i.j � glk ¤�d~Mj2|X�CvXhkj#zd¡ � �^�igi²kjfx�vkeMr?g�pngivke���|$�ª�Cj�lnj��dlogipopnj�e |}m9§L�Dº0] û � S M ý X �k¤û � ¨ ­ < M ­ �ky8mnpol¬|Xgi�k~8p��6vkl��d|Xlnr�x9|}�ix��M�¦|Xpng�vIeMm�mo~Mv��Wpo~�|}p�§H � � ba z � � ba X HËz� û � S M ý © è û M ý�d~Mjwloj�§ è û M ý X ± S � û � � < ý M S M © û � � � < S � û < ý © ý S � < û < � �9ý M J�d~Mgix¬~Ýgim�vk�8h8g�vI�Mmo�i���Cvkmogipng�hIj5�d~?j�e M = ¨?y�mogieMxwj)|X�i���AvI�Ml�x�v8j�/�x�gij�e8pom2gie pn~Mj¥��vI�i�Ge?vk��g¦|}��j��8�Mloj�mnmogivke

|}loj��Cvkmng�pngihkj3�d~?j�e � ­ < ­ �M¤û � < M =Q�kyM|"mogi��gi�¦|XlLlnj�mo�?��pd��|$�ª�Cj�vI�Mp�|}g�e?j�r�y8mogieMxwj�§H � � ba z � � ba X H�z å�û M ý�d~Mjwloj å�û M ý X û � �nm � ì î P�� b ñ � î © P ñ© î b � m ñ ý û � �om � ì î P�� b ñ � î © P ñ© î b � m ñ ý�¤

�I¨

Page 22: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

p q �{}q.�����.i@oÌl9�nq7k�q.��T�i^������� ��srT5q7o���.� �tsýi��� l��q7k�kE���q ��z�����vu�z��zq �.������i@� �[����k��.�������2���\�tsý�2� 2 o�q.� q7Ó9i^�������k¯Ýj]�Av8x��Mm¥~?j�lojUvIeùg�e?g�png¦|X�Lx�vIeMrMgipogivIeMm¥vX��|Ý�dgij��)|}eMeÝ�Mlnvk�M�ij��,y��dg�pn~ �Me?gÃ�6vklo� hkj��iv8x�gip�� |XeMrù�Me?gÃ�6vklo��Mlnj�momn�MlojI¤<�8x¬~Mj���jwmªgie8hkj�mnpogi�G|}poj�r ~Mj�lnj)x$|Xe �Cj�r?j�logihkjwr �6lovk� pn~Mj]�Avkln�)|X�igimo��v}� 4 ¡4�dv8j]eMx�hÝmox¬~Mjw��jky�dgipo~�hk|}log¦|X�M�ij2§ N X ´ ûQw I+J�ILKCý�d~Mjwloj w X w�û H0I a ý ûba rMj�e?vkpojwmdpo~Mjfmo�Cj�x�g ô x�j�e8pnlovk�8�Mý��¥�MmopL�Cj�gieMr?j���jweMr�|Xe8pdv}���Mloj�mnmo�Mlnj3K û �Avkl�gieMmop¬|XeMx�jw X a I�H«I x I�¼¸¼¸¼Îý�¤�¢4�?��jwl�j��8��|}pogivkeMm�|}loj�loj<�dlogipopnj�eUgie�pnj�lo�]mdvX� N X ´ ûQw I+J�ILKCý�|}m9§N ® ´ S ± û)N ý N ® � X ¨�d~Mjwloj�§

± X 45ßJ H w ® B ¨¨ J H � b¨ ²< K J 67

�d~Mj"j�gi�kj�e8hk|X�i�MjwmE|}loj û ]�mnp�|}eMrMm��AvIldpo~Mj�movI�MeMr�mo�Cj�j�rCýª§º b X J � ]�I�º © X J�I�º J X J S ]|}eMr�po~Mj�|Xmnmov8x�g¦|Xpnj�rUlng��I~8pdj�gi�kj�e8hkjwx�povIlom#|}loj¥§

» b ûVN ý X 45 � bð w ® BbB� ] 67 I » © û)N ý X 45 �¨¨

67 I » J û)N ý X 45 bð w ® BbB] 67¯Ýj�lojwx9|X�i��pn~�|Xp û moj�j"moj�x�pngivke��«¼Î�ký N b |XeMr N © loj9|}r §N b X N ¥ S ¹ É b µ» bN © X N ¦ � ¹É J µ» J�d~Mjwloj�§ ¹É b X � �� È] ~�J S �

� ÈH È] © ~^K¹É J X �� È] ~�J S �� ÈH È] © ~^K

eMvIpogieM��~ û ¼Îý X û ¼Îý¤¦ � û ¼Îý?¥L¤ N b |XeMr N © rMv2eMvkp�rMj��Cj�eMr�vIe�po~?j#x¬~MvIgix�j�vX� w ¤4��eMgipog¦|X�Cx�vIeMrMgipogivke?m��Ij�eMj�l¬|Xpoj|}e)�?eMmopnj9|XrM��x�vIe8p�|XxwpdrMgimox�vIeGpngieG�?g�p���§~�J X ~^K X ¨ x ¹ É b X ¹É J X ¨x N b X N ¥,|XeMr N © X N ¦�d~Mjwmojdj��8��|}��gipng�jwm­|XlnjLm�|}pogim ô j�rê|}p�j9|}x¬~ªgie8poj�l®�^|Xxwj�v}��po~Mj���j�mn~�¤�Bfj�eMx�jIykgö�%��j�rMj�eMvIpoj.H �V� b � © pn~MjLe8�M�]j�logix9|}�rMjweMmogip���vX�Lpo~?jª�igieMj9|}logimoj�rU�*g�jw�)|Xe?e��Mlnvk�M�ij���|Xpfpo~Mj�gie8pojwl��^|}x�j`� S ��GI�My%J0f�|XeMr9K«f�gieMgipog¦|}��hkj��iv8x�gip��)|}eMr�Mlnj�momn�MlojIy�po~Mj�¡�gieMgipoj 4 vI���?��jdmox¬~Mjw��j�|X�M�?��gij�r]pov¥pn~Mj��)|}momLxwvkeMmnj�lohk|}pogivkeUjw�G�C|XpogivIe��kgihIj�m�§H � � b� X H �� � ~ Q~ W ûnû H_JCý �V� b � © � û H_JCý �b� b � © ýX H �� � ~ Q~ W J0f û H �V� b � © � H �L� b � © ý

�?�

Page 23: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

�fv���y8gÃ����j2|X�M�M�i�¥pn~Mj�¡�gieMgipnj 4 vk�i�M��jdmnx¬~Mj���j�pnv¥po~Mj���vI��j�e8pn�M� x�vIeMmojwlohk|Xpngivke�j��8��|Xpngivke�y���j��kj�p�§û H_JCý � � b� X û H_JCý �� � ~ Q~ W ûoû H_J © S K�ý ��� b � © � û H_J © S K�ý �b� b � © ýX û H_JCý �� � ~ Q~ W ûoû H �V� b � © J ©f S K0f9ý � û H �b� b � © J ©f S K0f9ýný

X û H_JCý �� � ~ Q~ W J ©f û H ��� b � © � H �b� b � © ýX J0f é H �� � ~ Q~ W J«f û H �V� b � © � H �b� b � © ý ëX J0f\H � � b��d~8�Mm$y«J � � b� X J f y1yF���;��¤�4v�mnpo�Mr?� pn~Mjªr?g�mnx�lojwpoj��?loj�mnj�lohk|}pogivke,vX���?loj�mnmo�MlnjkyL�ij�pf�Mm��dlogipnjªpn~Mjê¡�gieMgipoj 4 vI���?��j�mox¬~Mj��]jê|}�M�M�igij�rUpnvj�e?j�lo�I�)xwvkeMmnj�lohk|}pogivke�j��8��|}pogivkeݧ3 � � b� X 3 �� � ~ Q~ W ûoû J û 3 S K�ýný �V� b � © � û J û 3 S KCýoý �b� b � © ýX 3 �� � ~ Q~ W J«f û 3 �V� b � © � 3 �L� b � © ý¢4e?j�lo�I�)gimdrMj ô eMj�rU�8�,3 X H 8.S b© H_JC©X¤4�d~8�Mm$§

û H 8 ý � � b� X û H 8 ý �� � ~ Q~ W J0f ûoû H 8 ý �V� b � © � û H 8 ý �b� b � © ý� j�p��Mm�|}momn�M��jfpo~�|}pdpo~Mj�jw�G�C|XpogivIe�vX�Lmnp�|Xpnj�x9|Xe��Cj��dlogipopnj�e��MeMrMjwl�po~?j��Avkln�§H 8�Xpo û K�ý S g\H S ] û �k¨Iý�d~Mjwloj g#|}eMr;]�|Xloj�lnj9|X�4x�vIeMmop¬|Xe8pom$y�|Xe?r o |2gie8hkj�lnmogi�M�ijf�A�MeMx�pngivke û �AvIldgieMmop¬|XeMx�j"��j�l®�Aj�x�p��8|Xm�¢�A���y?�u|}�¥���|XeMe�¢�A���y�¤i¤i¤Îý�¤��6����j#gie8polnv8rM�Mx�j�pn~Mgim�jw�G�C|XpogivIe)v}�­mnp�|Xpnj�gie�pn~Mj��Mlnj�h8g�vI�Mmdj��8��|}pogivke�y8gipd�Ig�hIj�m�§

û o û K�ý S g\H S ]�ý � � b� X û o û KCý S g\H S ]�ý ��� ~ Q~ W J f ûoû o û K�ý S g H S ]wý �V� b � © � û o û KCý S g\H S ]�ý �L� b � © ýo û K � � b� ý S g\H � � b� S ] X o û K f ý S g\H �� S ]� ~ Q~ W J f ûoû o û K f ý � o û K f ýoý S g û H �V� b � © � H �b� b � © ý S û ] � ]�ýoýo û K � � b� ý X o û K«fXý�d~8�Mm$yDK � � b� X K0fX¤Bfj�eMx�jky �MlnvXh8g�r?j�rÝpo~�|}p#| mop�|}poj¥�¦|2�Wx9|Xe,��j��dlogipnpoj�e,�MeMrMjwl#pn~Mj"�Avkln� û �k¨Iý�yCpo~?j�e | 4 ¡4�dv8j�e?x�hUmox¬~Mjw��jky�dgipo~�hk|}log¦|X�M�ij û�w I+J�IbK�ý�yI�)|}gieGp¬|XgieMm4�MeMgö�AvIlo� hIj��iv8x�gip��)|Xe?r��Mlnj�momn�Mloj2�Mlov ô �ij�m9¤

�I�

Page 24: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

u+cu-c

t

x

RQ

Q11h

L h RQhL

¡�gi�k�?loj¥�k§4�8vk�i�Mpngivke�v}�­pn~Mj��9«Q�*gij��)|}eMe¥�MlovI�M�ij�� vX�u�¿¯�j��8��|}pogivkeMm

�I�

Page 25: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

0.0 1000.0z 2000.0z 3000.0z 4000.0z 5000.0z0.0

2.0

4.0

6.0

8.0

10.0

0.0 1000.0z 2000.0z 3000.0z 4000.0z 5000.0z−200.0

−100.0

0.0

100.0

200.0

0.0 1000.0z 2000.0z 3000.0z 4000.0z 5000.0z−20.0

−10.0

0.0

10.0

20.0

¡�gi�k�Mlnj��M§4«flo�ª|}loj9|?§��E|}poj�lL~?j�gi�k~8p û �ij¬�ApLpnvk��ýwyk�]vk�]j�e8po�M� û lng��I~8p­pnvk��ýwykhIj��iv8x�gip�� û �Cvkpnpovk��ý�yk|}m4�A�Me?x�pogivke?mv}� W

�}�

Page 26: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

−10.0{ −9.0| −8.0} −7.0~ −6.0� −5.0�Ln(h)�−10.0

−9.0

−8.0

−7.0

−6.0

−5.0

−4.0

Ln(

erro

r)

Shallow water equations : Godunov, VFRoe (shock tube)�L1 error norm ( )

VFRoe : error hVFRoe : error QGodunov : error hGodunov : error Q

−9.0� −8.0� −7.0� −6.0� −5.0�Ln(h)�−8.0

−7.0

−6.0

−5.0

−4.0

−3.0

Ln(

erro

r)

Shallow water equations : Godunov, VFRoe (double rarefaction wave)�L1 error norm ()

VFRoe : error h�VFRoe : error Q�Godunov : error h�Godunov : error Q�

¡�gi�k�Mlnjt�?§���b�eMvIlo� v}�­pn~Mj�j�lnlovkl

�I�

Page 27: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

0�

10�

20�0.00

0.10

0.20

0.30

0.40

0.50

t = 0s�t = 10s�t = 20s�t = 100s�t = 1000s�

¡�gi�k�?loj���§L«flo��|}loj9|2v8x�xw�MlogieM�9�d~Mj�e�j����?p��GgieM�2|2loj�mnj�lohIvkgil û �E|}poj�ld~Mjwg��I~8p�|Xm�|t�A�MeMx�pngivke�vX�4�¿ý

�I�

Page 28: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

t

x

x

ρ

2

WR

L

W

WL

W1

ρ

ρ1ρ2

¡�g��I�Mloj��?§­�8vI�i�Mpogivke]vX�4po~Mj��$«Q�dgij���|XeMe¥�Mlnvk�M�ij�� �AvIlE¢4�?��jwl�j��8��|}pogivkeMm

�I°

Page 29: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

0.0 5000.0z 10000.0z 15000.0z−4000.0

−2000.0

0.0

2000.0

4000.0

0.0 5000.0z 10000.0z 15000.0z−0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

0.0 5000.0z 10000.0z 15000.0z0.0

20000.0

40000.0

60000.0

80000.0

100000.0

0.0 5000.0z 10000.0z 15000.0z−10000.0

−5000.0

0.0

5000.0

¡�gi�k�Mlnjê�?§ 4 |Xx��M�?�v8x�x��Mlnj�eMx�jI§���vI��j��2po�?� û �ij¬�Ap�pnvk��ýwy�rMj�eMmngip�� û lng��I~8p#pnvk��ýwy��Mlnj�momn�Mloj û �ij¬�Ap��Cvkpopnvk��ý�yhIj��ivGxwg�p�� û lng��I~8p��Cvkpnpovk��ý�y8|Xm��A�?eMx�pogivIeMmdvX� W

�I±

Page 30: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

0.0 1000.0z 2000.0z 3000.0z 4000.0z0.0

50.0

100.0

150.0

0.0 1000.0z 2000.0z 3000.0z 4000.0z0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

0.0 1000.0z 2000.0z 3000.0z 4000.0z0.0

20000.0

40000.0

60000.0

80000.0

100000.0

0.0 1000.0z 2000.0z 3000.0z 4000.0z0.0

500.0

1000.0

1500.0

2000.0

0.0 1000.0z 2000.0z 3000.0z 4000.0z0.0

100000000.0

200000000.0

300000000.0

¡�gi�k�Mlnj °?§ �8~Mv8x¬²Ì�d|$hkjUvXhIj�l�hk|}x��M�M�,§,��vk�]j�e8po�M� û ��j.�Ap�povk�Cý�yfrMj�eMmng�p�� û logi�k~8p�povI��ý�yd�?loj�mnmo�Mlnj û �ij¬�6p�]g�r?rM�ij9ý�yIhkj��iv8x�gip�� û lngi�k~8pd��girMrM�ij9ýwykmn��jwx�g ô x�j�e8polnvk�8� û ��vIpopnvk�)ýwyG|}m��A�MeMxwpogivkeMmdv}� W

�I�

Page 31: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

0.0 1000.0z 2000.0z 3000.0z 4000.0z−100.0

−50.0

0.0

50.0

100.0

0.0 1000.0z 2000.0z 3000.0z 4000.0z1.00

1.10

1.20

0.0 1000.0z 2000.0z 3000.0z 4000.0z100000.0

110000.0

120000.0

130000.0

140000.0

150000.0

¡�gi�k�Mlnj)±?§ê«fvI�M�M�ij¥mo~Mv8x¬²/�d|$hkjk§2��vI�¥j�e8po�M� û �ij¬�Ap�pnvk��ýwy4rMj�eMmng�p�� û logi�k~8p�pnvk��ýwy4�Mlojwmomo�?loj û ��vIpopovI�)ýwy­|}m�A�?eMx�pogivIeMmdvX� W

�I¨

Page 32: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

−8.00 −7.00 −6.00 −5.00 −4.00 −3.00 −2.00 −1.00Log(h)�−8.00

−7.00

−6.00

−5.00

−4.00

−3.00

−2.00

−1.00

0.00

Lo

g(L

1−

Err

or)

Rho�up�

−8.00 −7.00 −6.00 −5.00 −4.00 −3.00 −2.00 −1.00Log(h)�−8.00

−7.00

−6.00

−5.00

−4.00

−3.00

−2.00

−1.00

0.00

Lo

g(L

1−

Err

or)

Rho�up�

−8.00 −7.00 −6.00 −5.00 −4.00 −3.00 −2.00 −1.00Log(h)�−8.00

−7.00

−6.00

−5.00

−4.00

−3.00

−2.00

−1.00

0.00

Lo

g(L

1−

Err

or)

Rho�up�

¡�gi�k�Mlnjê�?§���b�j�lolnvkl�eMvIlo� ���8v8r mn~Mv8x�²úpo�M�Cj û �ij¬�Ap�pnvk��ýwy�rMvI�M�M�ij�l�|}loj¬��|Xx�png�vIe#�d|$hkj û logi�I~GpfpovI��ý�yCrMvI�M�M�ijmn~Mv8x�²��d|$hkj û �Cvkpopnvk��ý

�?�

Page 33: On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum · On the use of symmetrizing variables for vacuum Thierry Gallouet, Jean-Marc Herard, Nicolas Seguin To cite this version: Thierry

0�

50�

100�

150� 200�0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

0�

50�

100�

150� 200�0

100

200

300

0�

50�

100�

150� 200�0

20000

40000

60000

80000

1e+05

1.2e+05

1.4e+05

0�

50�

100�

150� 200�0

1000

2000

3000

4000

¡�gi�k�Mlnj¥�9¨M§��4�Mlo�?�M�ij�e8pE�8v8r]mo~Mv8x¬²�pn�M��jI§LrMj�e?mogip�� û �ij¬�Apdpnvk��ýwy8hkj��iv8x�gip�� û logi�I~Gp�povI��ý�y�K û?� ý�|XeMr�K S � E Gk�û �L�®ý û �ij¬�Apd�Cvkpopnvk��ý�y E û logi�k~8p���vIpopnvk�)ýwyM|Xm��A�?eMx�pogivIeMm�v}� W

�I�