klpd vill by unit m/s hearing... · = proceedings of the public hearing conducted for porposed 45...

= Proceedings of the public Hearing conducted for porposed 45 KLPD

Molasses/Grain based distillery (Ethanol) at Vill & P.O.- Maihaulia,Distt- West Champaran by existing unit M/s Majhaulia Sugarlndustries, Pvt. Ltd.

VRNUE: Sugar Mill Ground of Majhaulia Sugar lndustries,Vill & P.o- Majhaulia, Dist-West Champaran (Bihar)

Date & Time 12'nJanuary; At: 2.00 P.M

The Following official attended the Public Hearing:

L. Md. Ansar Ahmad, Additional District Magistrate, Dist: West Champaran.

2. Sri Anil Kumar, Regional Officer, BSPC Board, Muzaffarpur.3. Dr. G.K. Mandal, A.S.O., BSPC Board, Muzaffarpur.

4. Sri K. K. Bharti, General Manager, DlC, West Champran.

The Following proponents/ Officials/ representatives attended thepublic hearing:

L. Sri S.K Sharma, President, M/s Vardan EnviroNet, Gurgaon.2. Sri Kunain Sidqui, Technical Manager, M/s Vardan EnviroNet, Gurgaon.3. Sri C. L. Shukla, Chief General Manager, Majhaulia Sugar Industries Pvt.

Ltd. (Ethanol Distillery Unit).4. Sri R. K. Dwivedi, General Manager (Project), Majhaulia Sugar lndustries

Pvt. Ltd. (Ethanol Distillery Unit).

Number of persons attended the public hearing is enclosed as

Annexure-1.Sri. Anil Kumar, Regional Officer, BSPC Board, Muzaffarpur Welcome

the Additional District Collector, West Champaran, Representatives ofproject proponent, public and other participants in the meeting andinitiated with introduction about the project and importance of PublicHearing.

He lntimated that as per MoEF and C.C., New Delhi notification dateL4.09.2016 the Ethanol Distillery units are required to obtain Environment

k;,tLgryTt Fnrrmn

of 5

Annexure X

293

/

Clearance and the present proponent applied for Environment clearance to

the MoEF & CC accordinglY.

The MoEF & CC has issued the terms of references (ToR) and directed

for public hearing.The Additional District Collector Welcome all the Stakeholders/

participants and expressed his views related to the project and emphasized

on the need for addressing environmental concern of the project. Then Sri

Anil Kumar lnvited the project Proponent's representative to explain

regarding the project from environments point of view as follow:

The vardan EnviroNet, Gurgaon has prepared environment impact

assessment / environment management plan. lt has carried out the base

line data collection for month of March, April & May 20L6. Consultant of the

project has explained about water and air pollution due to proposed

distillery unit and provisions made in EIA Report to control these

envi ron menta I asPects.

Sri Kunain Sidqui delivered a presentation and highlighted the Following

Components.1-. Explained about project background and its need for installation of

molasseslgrain based ethanol distillery of 45 KLPD Capacity'

2. Described about the project salient Features;

3. Discussed about baseline environmental conditions;

4. Explained the likely impact on environmental and its mitigation measures

5. Extent of land acquisition and social impact due to the project

6. Applicable guidelines related to environmental and resettlement and

rehabilitation; and

7. Benefits to be extended to the project affected persons.

ffi'r{ q{srT€€i+*Jv

?fl x{-rryT-+rx. *fry{l I

of 5

Annexure X

294

Response of the Public & their opinion:ln the public hearing following persons have expressed their views/opinionsas given below:

sr i,-ti- .1r !i:

*+ s&11-r..;,. *ftrrtf e

o-qs@[T

qT.{ \r(i qill IEI rlrlI gT{ {Elsmr oqf,e Ergr ttqrTIqI Wfl-E

L. fi sq{r gqn,-is)fuqr

il6r$ d dtri Qqqr drq 3il{ ET-fr

EYqlt ril-q q MfuqT ur$ 1 \'fffue( ge1fr-6 e-{riti ro afto.r(l qrfiFTq;tq-t, gqcrT

fr.nn dd mqTurf.n r

{s qRqlsfl-d f,tri ${erT+q dH m\ n-d.rrqfrAqrrffi qer$ tEi ,ft .1-qi qrft MrrTsfrw{{nqsqcr'Im-{q o-q ord ftqru{rxgr: svolrr t urfr gqqBs{rq W vsr 51dq-',

tqft qflq q,t qr$.ft I

2.

sp-Sq,il-q-ffiqT

+fr ftrq erfi-r {fl .f,rd e oiiErt{qr6 tfl atslgffi tfrrilTkd q-& E).r?

+ft gfl. d. q[qt, q{fl=I

fraqrEic, i qril fu qs tot$ qEffi n--n qfrftffiifttqig qqqtr|. o\ o-qm-{idtuq{ssfrdrfrzrT ETt.rt ftNrS qgq"T

of qTtrT, frEI( vt\'q qgq"T

fuiilT qfq d frqruHT{t o-q e).ft r

3. +ft f,tr{q eqT(ffi,qr-q<i-6wfrq

$T wid of reryqqt GTTrr q=tflr Cqql--q'fl dI+Imq1?

+1T gs. d. s[ql, q{il{{+qr+d, 1o-6rfu{sq\i-dcttrHCt-u-iftlfr+ql silq Gnrflqr$ d .Trq\

dfu{ vs em dd-dq15 dr€r qfr qt' g-d fudqrfi

I

h-;LlL of 5

Annexure X

295

fr vs. d. YlqI, q-{fl=I

{c.qT{ic,io-EIfu{seltnc t Fro-ni qI-e qdqffi e\ MEE & lncineration

Boiler g1u re-fr{ fuqT qr+In t

Efl qr€ t ot$ qBsnq eri{ffin Tfr ftqT q-qlnl

qrf,r .TET qft ft-Sffid fuqTqrirn z

fr gt{. d. YlqI, ffi-flq{qqT{ie,io-dlfu{fle-Hqz t FIq,Ti qt-A 'Ttqffi o\ MEE & lncineration

Boiler gm sfl fuqT qrlq-r t

{s wr€ t ot$ eB+rrq qr6-{

FrtrIkd Tfr fuqT wfr'n t

q6r d-$ qffi qrf,{ FrwrRdq-fr fuqT urt'qT d q-qEI

s{rq *i ol @ti Yq{ TSsdflI I

frr{aq qrt Eql-Aqqq Ei.ft z

gql. d. Y[qI, qE(l=T

$ilqT{icioerfuqwrB-aqffisqT t ot$ q-6ffi .hT

T€t Fro-dfi I qrg qgq"T o\oq ft-{i + ft\ { Ts. fr.drTt-qr qT+'.Tr ffi qgq"T

q,t qTeT, fuEI{ qgq"T ft'qaurqd-( + qFrfi d er5su *fi r

d-i qrd qTg qqwT

et toenq dfr atqr*fi e

* Eiqtgert

.i;ir"j i-f,; r:-3.,. .,",..**.-.1"r!q {!',r.,.r.'ttJtc ,'?ji?;.a?:irli.

*&iq=l q

k*!" lk

of 5

Annexure X

296

Sri, Anil Kumar of BSPCB Requested the public for any further views andopinion. However no public came forward to express their views further.Hence the CGM of the project expressed vote of thanks to all present there.Then public hearing concluded and came to an end.Conclusions:

The Public of Surrounding Villages, Who participated in the hearingwelcome the project in their area and have not made any adversecomments from environmental point of view.

The proceedings of the public hearing are recorded, photographs andvideo taken and the same will be submitted to the concern authority ofMoEF & CC and all concern for necessary action.

hJL )-r-^ oa_(Anil Kumar)'Regional OfficerBSPCB, Muzaffarpur

['ta. {neer ,S-,-"")(

ADM,West Champaran, . =."1,, .:,"*,.1!

r 1 _ ): .-ir_iJ...limrrf t

of 5

Annexure X

297

4-,^'t I'lFX t-JA e -

srroe_Hto ffikrn Er^rr ffi.r srg fro, ,rr*mrrr, qFqq iildrr{ur gryrq-srfuo ffi E6-rS- ( Eerrifm ) qffirqr d q-qie-{ot-q €qftEg RcTT,r 2.o1.2o12 E'r 2:oo e-S srq-Trq;1 q qrq-+riro-dg;$z,Bar-qR'qq qr=.rrqrrr fr errdrfrra drEE €qElg d *rr-r sqftersqE'r3"rrdi

=,r EA:EE'OHO =TTTT rr-r ^ rTqr EffiIET{

1. (4 4l</>_) I

3*lnt,/tt')D ?il

/ u'' l-

2 l9i*t .F.-eR €l#l1{?X{s*(, D'C:M. u r+;s, r*

,?61s-I4\, +l.rf{ ltft{ (-,) ,:-- - r"\ *-i> *>)*r --:{\t-- .rt -o=---.--- \ /1 i!

3.{ \-,1r u,f>1\_Ettl/t)a t ,rtrir -tq yt#,f,rrrr 1;&,-r ,*-"*,{ "?t?Y

4. V i<,0,';f ll

-1C<1"\ (:1t,-t, ! t*1*,

dlr ii\ ?/\ /\! r?-

5 \a J -r\zi vtlr,r. t Ir r 1 .-r ,: (- /t ; ../

,/ tJft.6. ('\ / . .Jt*lc* {ry Sl,n'u 5'*f "* U'L='-7. h,l fr-,,", A4'^J tufi, rtFqr- ck ^a*^a. ':l..: jl- Lf r' o /]Spt[5,17',s uL

b;,**-a-r-^ l\ol-a, L0, Mal dr10. b{>n /v\s$L €€--ffi1'1. '{i(,fr-M 't"*t"f,tl*mffi* nYtnM,,,,12: -1a1 :5 q l]-- '), i

- -T,\ lll:tl-t-'l/t t.-.-- {- Ltt

13. t i, V*pr.te.\uof l-ur,,1ir$a} Anad , plA$&l lqet.,,14.

r"+*\ riii-,:* ) ,1i \\= 'r

.i-. '

_. */,'..:= _:lr

15.

€j, ,;^'--t.r^11 tn .r. .J - f ( ftt\JI16. I r tr / Ilt - * jrt-vr, $6^<{'ffC?dtu G417. (o-. J; g'r-*7h L^4*d-' oN**.- / -,''1r/\

-r'l7z18.

#1.*f "l**\-r _>crr( ?) E19-

l{+^r"'{" I l, *4., fr 6 n /n".h*"t20.

*tA f- CI b jk> C )" o,.1- &,, ---''21. I I\\

C' J r !'l I-\ s-ut.,.ir+ ','a-t*a s*-1 6o"\kc., lnH{d

Annexure X

298

/-

22. !ar{iL1'<rry/: ^\

>/bV,lf?l ,'/.1 'rr \ :'\

\'ry< t/ 7,l

!,,-iV-#4,,/{/ z;-

.13. ;jl-\.-] 4I'Hr( (:lLiJ"-j

\

ri it'i 2{ j 71.b j l(-3 )i i /Jl<W,TlA,-ttl tt lt-l

i z+. -l lr <.}Z: )e I_-1,- z:1 .t I *' ,t-, / '

i 25.il

/',\;.t-L**- >HL

l',- i .)-+.-.',' r,-,ti

z1 /'-rfr -.-r4--i'" -; v_,i i

26. ' ttit p(i;t t>, r< lrr ,?,[ |-l

)) )i,).r\r"\7,.27. ,;ti+.'-, c. )) t \

L-tt r_, v 4- i = G--,ir\i r.1l il_. I

;t)n24. \. ./l ll

-+1-> r ;'lJ--7-,-1 -i n t t't, 'L

,

)i29.

t+TP cto"U-y E$,r**L i p-) 1au*

30. .1J id ( },1-l F-J1 (

^\r.r

n -{* Xa1-

.11

31. r{qc-ri }q'.p,t 1)(,t ,.1 tri . .-!" )'"-l:> .t'F<?(-'r i-?=i D.f - /

32.'-, 6',--t VL--*,U2" y Vt 4-, [^. n;

i*rvtu,/"\ {". l'/)' ,['. '. t 1l

33. tr/ {fr,fl{t{g it-4,ty ] r* *r,34 r*;*r- *T,i-i\;,r

F.-3.k?rr n"4

35 r \.(tr d(-er ({' & {(\p ,.ry(,--/

l.:(t/;-/ C*i {( A"i ci i 'a{kry tu

36. rlr. trB[CL1T

-,^)f{ s-t.Lr4l

t. nr_/. ru<s>t-t,Lf"t37. a r. -tr. vrl

\r\L T\> \\ rt

\I x"38. YaaT .Exrll6lal/\_/ \ / .ii a?ld{/ t'*r*39.

frat-4iVli(')-{)ruryn#la)7'ttl/ av{rytTo lVts

40. '3.t-t V ?Et(4V ,a\

+-tr*r i 'lrrz'7' [0 6 er7,qr(-41. 61 c4 U7 l,f:Rt !*;.rlt4 +).J.I-1ra t-

\-.t),litl1qrrtl (Vfi*

l-/-- /-'42. [cl rLl,'t **) l( q)<4 q I rcYr./,7 ilf/ /(

J

43. tT;*t --.-TI-r\ tI[:".:l.iC--i1 ^?rfrFig=.?-r\t44.

tfu#,lruLrtfr.uw1 t4' ftaffip,ts- /Ytldl*twttwt45. 1 \'/git f xqt;t it{6* vt{w

t L_.

V--5/ ti, xnrf,*iq146.' 4+e<i e1}+r4 c'*i I l4Cl1 Q -l L *ry-r*t 1-brr 1

Annexure X

299

----).-:\47. <-l )/ /+;191_ ( ) ,l 1r n-r IIt(

^<r l

!,,:./48. / \l 4

Vf= t \!-/<1rti-i

-7/c/ l;v(\ ta

49 tsr +;i ?\ -.-}i l2$ )r, i €;r1a -t>); ii*r'i \

ft'\r'ri; i _'\ \-a.'.- ^1'v'+'-1 i- 2. '.ri L,' " - \1Aa{-- L-t:- -"

51. **?6\9 *t/(A e{ /i'rr>r(Vj{( frw+wvry

52 ^C..r'- L rtfrw^*Zu rr ), ( !" J r'f &tc t{ t>-+$*\i;'f- (-/c-tl{ , IL r j _ lr r-L.

r/7\-';ad 7'*t*,zPu',n,--J'-r*-))-f

53. U '"er-d"** k, St"ll+ VLRP. \ Qfr-*u*-

54. Jr;ri I eto-or-2a \/&qqf( vfizrq+t" rtLi"9-

,

55 r(tt CLL, .t v r1.| rt.HLf rl ,/ t

-

';t

56 ..\i,rl c4 gfrT\ tffit< q6l "t-l l >/lt))'t7g;--X'bY:o*4

57 t\. i t . ,7(:i 'rr r -f--.. ,_\ ^\ I|"J^* \*r ,1"l

58 *r/ri'J- €'!r( =tl\Ktt//,r

alror u(# frl 4kt59. :r''rfq ,P,' Lt1 Yyrik. .$ruqS60 K4 elwr/{*s\

61.L L',*h*SL..-I/{*\g.nl \(L-r't fl,+, i#bd__

62. {.\:_.\ fi }1 6lYI qITEY63. -1 rY r\qrl ,ffi f Ft )t 2l 7 A|*"q-}'(64. A{477e et€ry )/ ecl / 4a t

65. (*\ ,1-iffi

^-Wtart)t111-

ty/cDr g)1'a / '/)w7

btf,.__-Y+t

v ,34, L- rreg i

,/'u,/L-Jx-'-'-';r^i\ ,/67 ) to

t'ol \rrni A* i $. l'(-.,( iol't.,- r' BJ64. lo,- Ir;fI &i,:7 Y€.r,-$]f nw*69, ir*,1, il.<-r r/ v \*-/ P'cllr-c** r .( -:

=\r ,-*k-*

74. T !,:ir,t,iL I\rrr l+ Z t .rr3i 6 i.re" {

71. f{i--"rt*l *r\.'* Pr^r,,o.- I"tiL-*Lr^* W

Annexure X

300

72.

-

Lh act l'H 1,.,1 t j_ft--1.11\\ 151

! ^

Ar

1-*l<Juff*-*73.

\ /l>-f Ir\\t

74. {{t t / <?.1-".1 J / rl ct)iil )-----ft )-\\-3\ J

75 .j t [ {'-.' 1 grai./ 2,:9<- I } If, i

f-) '\*t r >. _t t! lq+iFd< t, t t,

n,\

/o. t t-l'i'i t//q <{1 ;J si, < ,} Ll Jt- u i '..

,-J-

77, -Jl q/ ;t$.i r +i-l^-al!/i\

e+.t*btl rim\-fitrt -//Il1cl.(l.l,,tti/ t.r..-i+vvLr

7A. | leti'z; t ,r /l/ r>)

79. '.3"/'/r/ c'l /Prf ?;2 v&Aq / s7 / 4 -(-k2yr7ao. rtwtr fta rv' ;7

\-ffalfrfl/n'W:Ai) tgffto ft[rY){ti /

81. .?(o '1\-* --=)/ grt l>/lt!t \ v-l l\rl t t. fr'vffir, t

42.? ) 1l (f1 'l , '\=r'

t {\g\l,r:,r \2-r w\i \'&> -t z ?)lj \4'//Yy43. 1 rti I

G}'\r\i l- - l-.-4)e-L<y .n L.c4frf-rt{ V1.!411,lr . r

$C4r Lc"'ko\44. fir*-2 1,j(rt=,Qt

t/

GS' \' -'

.3Y)A \ c\'--\ { \ rr -? (. S'il1tJi85 e <.-'*1 (1 lw '-r' ,>ttiri b lg. ,j!F.c)r ( )tt'ii,46.

itu I ti {*J:- \ l.- i\ * - ._(r-t',-l br.6*-5----* .\^"1-.---'-

7.,F.i, r,r$7 - 11- {, -" r} t-,,'--1;-a1] r.,- . "&^*

aa" N /r>1 q," I,I/i -{:h{/ir--

49."\\ A- _, t-I .\ \. i\1\ira_ . (_.-

.{

<4 L_i's-

90. Gt ;]r { (i,;, 1

\t a l'r '\ I

!--.- *.4 -

-; t -/l1l rq-vt

.'"1,r a'}o1ri.191. [r {\ t-r.t' frT,\t'yr"rf,1p i tpr-/,wt{&t,l92 -\li

,5."T1 {-,l}FA\ \Iffi\ '@4-"'-

93 --Z .i ;-r, -l ) / '.\.\' -_-_\ ) *.n\rr;;ttTlht$aft

94. '"/( / la)'4;j lo)4q95. ,*trT'pq a' $ -t.ril<-ag:ra ^ ;-)*u>r u !g96. Al'S.l \tf)^:. , i"l^ *.\r 9', {Rt",t \_

t-r ,i, ? \t, t---'

Annexure X

301

-.97. a*/ \:,{ I '*-\ 0}1k |54 c;t1 :i/i-ry2-

i

9a .)dr{,.t I {f1

I

G)-ffv/<,lri7. tj i ii rj ,r,l=.1 -)i "

i 100 Zl r:i,; Yi a?ii -i (j; ,.2i=_

fl- ! \(

rr r-t 1-€1 d, (

^t;

Ft t-t,s5rs\./

101 ( (a ( *6 t1t( KiE-^--3

t\

'a't d q7 fttf"

)1/ 'Ys ifi'r,\t -=_\ .r

a (\,) *vv. L .l c)^''.-rt,J\ (-tlCh]l--\

c\i * 11 \t .t Tt\l

t :.1 l</, l.l i!.l---r,ct 7 /r/ ( r\-t,/ /

103 !'/*t))rC-l t'I -r) ltTt

a^nq/c/ Giilt,L

I

104 ) fi 11{ €1 # .rti'/\

.)1 ( c1 lr)"r .ql-

f105 .d1)1d11 I 21

,' I \ (

Y fQ)(n'tv/t

'4 ) "'t h,'),tl--\ \ r'

106 1c-1. -r1-l-t a?7rt <l h,tt-

qJlc-rl-.t\q

I \_\l , (

107 r';r\{ (a I lqa -c<+ iry.r<. \ j-\ \-Di/ rei i \qj*104 wffir"w

.d!'109 i r c1'>z\c'tfc\- .{.trt1T Sgl\ I,)l{

t>r

V!:-c-:-.110 (: \i1,\\,,$\ 'hxJr k\*\'S=q'*-\ q-F"r

A!' r\111 '41b_tDa\ !\\21 G\AL\ %ie?,:?t'QY1 P112

d;r:xip,*?Frr"'rEl lJ

-'<;lqt*qq/e-$ i-;yh!fi_)>113 -i^.1-*-{_Jp;tiltf L' n^

{frs-l Ur -)\ rt, I -

i 114i

I

'.,';-[ (Tr Ll\-rtbNr ifi 6 1-) 't

4r|c,*Lfa---tiY rt-

115 65q,4;;$,) ,4-t*r fa S; /,

116 -, wli *,- t.*-Lb"-"-'117 -f .)0/J 1 2llir ?

\q zcIC\ ''41

ar118 _\ )l\F )ll,qtt q<vlt'tl

t{ /'11.'to r'/{{7 ( 1':t / {,{

|4_l{,r 7 t,?/ 2-/

'F /e/ /1n120 ,1 s' t.t.t-t-€\1{'L-t\ / 1n'rl tdLtJ 31."il Gtl-L * t-\t!

121 f(q l.{t- L\-zr i-tr (t i /- _-:

"-tK{ { "<t}

Annexure X

302

klpd vill by unit m/s hearing... · = proceedings of the public hearing conducted for porposed 45...

Documents