journal selection report - 이나고 · 2019. 9. 5. · global health (cabi) helminthological...
TRANSCRIPT
Journal Selection Report
An Award-Winning Organization Committed to Supporting the Research
Community across the World
Message from the Journal Expert
Thank you for choosing Enago to assist you in selecting the most suitable journals for
your paper. We have carefully reviewed your manuscript and have shortlisted five
journals that are best suited to your paper. The selection and order of
recommendation are based on a subjective opinion that takes into account the
specifics of your article and various relevant journal characteristics. On the below
pages, I have provided a comparison of the most relevant journal characteristics that
may aid the submission and publication process, along with my comments to help
you improve your manuscript. I have also provided a summary for each journal.
Please check all the details presented in the summary and visit the webpages of the
journals before making your decision.
Once you select a journal, you may also request our recommended services to help
ensure that your submission meets all guidelines mentioned by the journal of your
choice. Thank you again for choosing Enago to help you!
Delivery Checklist
Items Status
Journal Seletion Report Delivered
Enago | Disclaimer: This report was compiled by our Journal Expert(s) after careful consideration of your manuscript considering several parameters. The author(s) should read the report carefully to choose the target
journal. This report is based on our expert’s assessment of the manuscript and should not be considered as a guarantee
of acceptance in any of the listed journals.
3
Manuscript Details
Journal Recommendations
The following journals have been shortlisted by our subject-area expert following a
careful evaluation of your manuscript. The selection and order of recommendation
are based on a subjective opinion which takes into account the specifics of your
article and various relevant journal characteristics. Some of these characteristics,
along with other information which may aid the submission and publication process
are listed below.
Most Recommended Journal
Journal Name Land Use Policy; The International Journal Covering All Aspects of
Land Use
Journal Homepage http://www.journals.elsevier.com/land-use-policy/
Reason for this Journal
This is a SCI indexed journal with a medium-low impact factor. With
your given requirement for fast publication, this is best suited with
regard to acceptance, journal quality, and publication frequency.
It is international and interdisciplinary; it is a source used in other
articles that are similar to this one.
Assignment Code ABCDE-1 Word Count 3345
Enago | Disclaimer: This report was compiled by our Journal Expert(s) after careful consideration of your manuscript considering several parameters. The author(s) should read the report carefully to choose the target
journal. This report is based on our expert’s assessment of the manuscript and should not be considered as a guarantee
of acceptance in any of the listed journals.
4
Journal Details
Journal Quality
Impact Factor = 2.292
Article Influence = 2.1
H-Index = 71
Article is suitable as Original Article
Compatibility of paper with journal
guidelines
Yes, but some minor changes are required. For example,
the paper should be double spaced. However, the current
one is single spaced. Also the references need to be limited
to 20.
Review type Peer Reviewed
Approximate time for peer review 30 days
Issues published per year 12
Databases where journal is indexed SCImago, Scirus, Scopus, SOCOLAR, Zetoc
Publisher and country Blackwell, USA
Accessibility Hybrid
ISSN code 4560-223563
Enago | Disclaimer: This report was compiled by our Journal Expert(s) after careful consideration of your manuscript considering several parameters. The author(s) should read the report carefully to choose the target
journal. This report is based on our expert’s assessment of the manuscript and should not be considered as a guarantee
of acceptance in any of the listed journals.
5
Highly Recommended Journal
Journal Name Journal of Land Use Science
Journal Homepage http://www.tandfonline.com/action/aboutThisJournal?show=aimsScope&journalCode=tlus20
Reason for this Journal
This journal is highly recommended because It is relevant for the topic of
the article; it has a broad scope. However, although this journal is listed in
CAB Abstracts database, it is not an SCI listed journal.
Journal Details
Journal Quality
Impact Factor = 1.12
Article Influence = 2.0
H-Index = 32
Specific topics covered
The dynamics of change; the integration and feedbacks between land use,
climate, socio-economic, and ecological systems; the resilience,
vulnerability,
adaptability and sustainability of land use systems; the linkages of natural
and human systems; relationships between land use and land cover; spatial
and temporal scale issues; accuracy issues; evolving public and private land
and participatory approaches.
Article is suitable as Original Article
Compatibility of paper
with journal guidelines
The word count limit excluding references and abstract for this journal is
3000. Thus, some word count may need to reduce if you opt for this journal.
Review type Peer reviewed
Approximate time for
peer review 60 days
Enago | Disclaimer: This report was compiled by our Journal Expert(s) after careful consideration of your manuscript considering several parameters. The author(s) should read the report carefully to choose the target
journal. This report is based on our expert’s assessment of the manuscript and should not be considered as a guarantee
of acceptance in any of the listed journals.
6
Issues published per
year 12
Databases where journal
is indexed CAS, Citebase
Publisher and country Wiley Online Library (USA)
Accessibility Subscription-based
ISSN code 5467567-124
Highly Recommended Journal
Journal Name Land Economics
Journal Homepage http://uwpress.wisc.edu/journals/journals/le.html
Reason for this Journal
This journal’s topics covered math the papers’ topic well. It is published by a
major research university; the journal has a long history (published since
1925); its rankings are good; the scope is
International. However, this is a high impact journal compared to others so
the chances of rejection are higher.
Journal Details
Journal Quality
Impact Factor = 2.292
Article Influence = 2.1
H-Index = 71
Enago | Disclaimer: This report was compiled by our Journal Expert(s) after careful consideration of your manuscript considering several parameters. The author(s) should read the report carefully to choose the target
journal. This report is based on our expert’s assessment of the manuscript and should not be considered as a guarantee
of acceptance in any of the listed journals.
7
Specific topics covered
International applied research on such topics as transportation, energy, urban
and rural land use, housing, environmental quality, public utilities, and natural
resources.
Article is suitable as Original Article
Compatibility of paper
with journal guidelines
Yes, but minor changes are required. For example, a detailed cover page
needs to be prepared which should include the paper title, author names,
author affiliations, running title, no. of words and figures/tables, address for
correspondence and financial disclosures, if any.
Review type Peer Reviewed
Approximate time for
peer review 30-60 days
Issues published per
year 10
Databases where journal
is indexed
Abstracts on Hygiene & Communicable Diseases (CABI)
Academic Search (EBSCO Publishing)
Academic Search Premier (EBSCO Publishing)
Agroforestry Abstracts (CABI)
BIOBASE: Current Awareness in Biological Sciences (Elsevier)
Biological Abstracts (Thomson Reuters)
BIOSIS Previews (Thomson Reuters)
CAB Abstracts® (CABI)
CAB HEALTH (CABI)
CABDirect (CABI)
CAS: Chemical Abstracts Service (ACS)
Chemical Hazards in Industry (RSC)
CSA Biological Sciences Database (ProQuest)
CSA Environmental Sciences & Pollution Management Database
(ProQuest)
Current Contents: Clinical Medicine (Thomson Reuters)
Dairy Science Abstracts (CABI)
Embase (Elsevier)
Forest Products Abstracts (CABI)
Forestry Abstracts (CABI)
Global Health (CABI)
Enago | Disclaimer: This report was compiled by our Journal Expert(s) after careful consideration of your manuscript considering several parameters. The author(s) should read the report carefully to choose the target
journal. This report is based on our expert’s assessment of the manuscript and should not be considered as a guarantee
of acceptance in any of the listed journals.
8
Helminthological Abstracts (CABI)
Horticultural Science Abstracts (CABI)
Immunology Abstracts (ProQuest)
Index Medicus/MEDLINE (NLM)
Index Veterinarius (CABI)
InfoTrac
Journal Citation Reports/Science Edition (Thomson Reuters)
Laboratory Hazards Bulletin (RSC)
Leisure Tourism Database (CABI)
Leisure, Recreation & Tourism Abstracts (CABI)
MEDLINE (NLM)
Nutrition Abstracts & Reviews Series A: Human & Experimental (CABI)
Ornamental Horticulture (CABI)
Pig News & Information (CABI)
Postharvest News & Information (CABI)
Protozoological Abstracts (CABI)
PubMed Dietary Supplement Subset (NLM)
Research Alert (Thomson Reuters)
Review of Agricultural Entomology (CABI)
Review of Aromatic & Medicinal Plants (CABI)
Review of Medical & Veterinary Entomology (CABI)
Review of Medical & Veterinary Mycology (CABI)
Review of Plant Pathology (CABI)
Rural Development Abstracts (CABI)
Science Citation Index (Thomson Reuters)
Science Citation Index Expanded (Thomson Reuters)
Soybean Abstracts Online (CABI)
Sugar Industry Abstracts (CABI)
The RECAL Legacy (National Centre for Prosthetics & Orthodontics)
Tropical Diseases Bulletin (CABI)
Veterinary Bulletin (CABI)
Weed Abstracts (CABI)
Wheat, Barley & Triticale Abstracts (CABI) Abstracts on Hygiene &
Communicable Diseases (CABI)
Academic Search (EBSCO Publishing)
Academic Search Premier (EBSCO Publishing)
Agroforestry Abstracts (CABI)
BIOBASE: Current Awareness in Biological Sciences (Elsevier)
Biological Abstracts (Thomson Reuters)
BIOSIS Previews (Thomson Reuters)
CAB Abstracts® (CABI)
Enago | Disclaimer: This report was compiled by our Journal Expert(s) after careful consideration of your manuscript considering several parameters. The author(s) should read the report carefully to choose the target
journal. This report is based on our expert’s assessment of the manuscript and should not be considered as a guarantee
of acceptance in any of the listed journals.
9
CAB HEALTH (CABI)
CABDirect (CABI)
CAS: Chemical Abstracts Service (ACS)
Chemical Hazards in Industry (RSC)
CSA Biological Sciences Database (ProQuest)
CSA Environmental Sciences & Pollution Management Database
(ProQuest)
Current Contents: Clinical Medicine (Thomson Reuters)
Dairy Science Abstracts (CABI)
Embase (Elsevier)
Forest Products Abstracts (CABI)
Forestry Abstracts (CABI)
Global Health (CABI)
Helminthological Abstracts (CABI)
Horticultural Science Abstracts (CABI)
Immunology Abstracts (ProQuest)
Index Medicus/MEDLINE (NLM)
Index Veterinarius (CABI)
InfoTrac
Journal Citation Reports/Science Edition (Thomson Reuters)
Laboratory Hazards Bulletin (RSC)
Leisure Tourism Database (CABI)
Leisure, Recreation & Tourism Abstracts (CABI)
MEDLINE (NLM)
Nutrition Abstracts & Reviews Series A: Human & Experimental (CABI)
Ornamental Horticulture (CABI)
Pig News & Information (CABI)
Postharvest News & Information (CABI)
Protozoological Abstracts (CABI)
PubMed Dietary Supplement Subset (NLM)
Research Alert (Thomson Reuters)
Review of Agricultural Entomology (CABI)
Review of Aromatic & Medicinal Plants (CABI)
Review of Medical & Veterinary Entomology (CABI)
Review of Medical & Veterinary Mycology (CABI)
Review of Plant Pathology (CABI)
Rural Development Abstracts (CABI)
Science Citation Index (Thomson Reuters)
Science Citation Index Expanded (Thomson Reuters)
Soybean Abstracts Online (CABI)
Sugar Industry Abstracts (CABI)
Enago | Disclaimer: This report was compiled by our Journal Expert(s) after careful consideration of your manuscript considering several parameters. The author(s) should read the report carefully to choose the target
journal. This report is based on our expert’s assessment of the manuscript and should not be considered as a guarantee
of acceptance in any of the listed journals.
10
The RECAL Legacy (National Centre for Prosthetics & Orthodontics)
Tropical Diseases Bulletin (CABI)
Veterinary Bulletin (CABI)
Weed Abstracts (CABI)
Wheat, Barley & Triticale Abstracts (CABI)
Publisher and country Elsevier, USA
Accessibility Hybrid
ISSN code 327567-124
Recommended Journal
Journal Name Applied Economics
Journal Homepage http://www.tandfonline.com/action/aboutThisJournal?show=aimsScope&journalCode=raec20
Reason for this Journal
The journal publishes empirical studies in various applied areas; the scope is
broad. However, the publications per year are fewer compared to the other
journals. Also there is a higher chance of rejection as the journal quality is
high vis-à-vis the study is question.
Journal Details
Journal Quality
Impact Factor = 3.52
Article Influence = 2.8
H-Index = 51
Specific topics covered
Application of economic analysis to specific problems in both the public
and private sectors; economics; finance, business & industry;
macroeconomics
Enago | Disclaimer: This report was compiled by our Journal Expert(s) after careful consideration of your manuscript considering several parameters. The author(s) should read the report carefully to choose the target
journal. This report is based on our expert’s assessment of the manuscript and should not be considered as a guarantee
of acceptance in any of the listed journals.
11
Article is suitable as Original Article
Compatibility of paper
with journal guidelines
Yes, as this journal has few formatting requirements that have been
met in the paper.
Review type Peer Review
Approximate time for
peer review 90 days
Issues published per
year 3
Databases where journal
is indexed Science Citation, IndexSCImago
Publisher and country Wiley Blackwell (UK)
Accessibility Open-Access
ISSN code 312367-665
Recommended Journal
Journal Name Asian Survey
Journal Homepage http://ucpressjournals.com/journal.php?j=as
Enago | Disclaimer: This report was compiled by our Journal Expert(s) after careful consideration of your manuscript considering several parameters. The author(s) should read the report carefully to choose the target
journal. This report is based on our expert’s assessment of the manuscript and should not be considered as a guarantee
of acceptance in any of the listed journals.
12
Reason for this Journal
This is a eSCI indexed journal with a low impact factor. With your
given
requirement for fast publication, this is best suited with regard to
acceptance, journal quality, and publication frequency.
It is international and interdisciplinary; it is a source used in other
articles that are similar to this one.
Journal Details
Journal Quality
Impact Factor = 4.64
Article Influence = 3.1
H-Index = 78
Specific topics covered
Ranges from diplomacy, disarmament, missile defense, military, and
modernization, to ethnicity, ethnic violence, economic nationalism,
general elections, and global capitalism; contemporary political, social,
economic, and strategic developments in South, Southeast, and East
Asia; the countries and/or regions ranging from Russia and Japan to
the northeast and east, Sri Lanka and Indonesia to the south and
southeast, and Pakistan to the west. "Contemporary" is defined
narrowly to mean recent, which is incorrect.
Article is suitable as Original Article
Compatibility of paper
with journal guidelines Yes. All requirements are met.
Review type Peer Reiewed
Approximate time for
peer review 90 days
Issues published per
year 6
Databases where journal
is indexed Science Citation Index, Scopus
Enago | Disclaimer: This report was compiled by our Journal Expert(s) after careful consideration of your manuscript considering several parameters. The author(s) should read the report carefully to choose the target
journal. This report is based on our expert’s assessment of the manuscript and should not be considered as a guarantee
of acceptance in any of the listed journals.
13
Publisher and country Elsevier (USA)
Accessibility Subscription-based
ISSN code 435768-224
Enago | Disclaimer: This report was compiled by our Journal Expert(s) after careful consideration of your manuscript considering several parameters. The author(s) should read the report carefully to choose the target
journal. This report is based on our expert’s assessment of the manuscript and should not be considered as a guarantee
of acceptance in any of the listed journals.
14
Specific comments of the Journal Expert
Our subject-area expert also offers the following suggestions which may
improve the manuscript and/or expedite publication.
Are various parts of the paper
(abstract, introduction etc.)
suitably written?
Yes, for the most part, the content of the sections is fine. I would
suggest that in the introduction, the author should bring out more
of the point about the negative consequences of land acquisition
(Discussed on p. 7). That is, the author should tie in this point a
little more with concepts and ideas that are laid out in the
introduction.
Are the motivation for work
and significance of results
clearly explained?
Yes, this is relatively clear in terms of the concepts, but the
expression is very weak. This aspect of the paper requires a lot of
attention. It is difficult to follow the author’s line of thought
because of the lack of clarity at the sentence level: missing
words, misuse/lack of articles, punctuation errors, issues with
verb tense, and grammatical and mechanical errors. The
formatting also could use some work, as it also hinders
understanding. Some of the lists should possibly be bulleted. The
sections and paragraphs could be made smoother, too, with
better transitions and more explanations that tie together the
author’s thoughts. The writing is choppy, in other words, and this
also contributes to the difficulty in understanding the paper.
Is the manuscript stating the
findings appropriately?
The subject matter is intriguing, and the examples and
supporting evidence are illustrative and engaging. Another
observation is that the references seem “thin,” and the paper
could be strengthened in this regard, too—more sources and
more current sources (some of the journals listed in the
References don’t seem to exist any longer, as I could not find any
websites for them online; other sources seem outdated). Also, it’s
not entirely clear what some of these sources actually are. All of
this is to say, the level of scholarship could be raised/improved.
Is the manuscript ready for
publication in its current
state? If no, what do the
authors need to work on?
In its current state, the manuscript is not ready for publication.
The author included limitations of the study at the end, as is the
convention. However, an improved statement can be made in the
introduction, especially regarding the time period being
considered and what the paper can actually provide in terms of
Enago | Disclaimer: This report was compiled by our Journal Expert(s) after careful consideration of your manuscript considering several parameters. The author(s) should read the report carefully to choose the target
journal. This report is based on our expert’s assessment of the manuscript and should not be considered as a guarantee
of acceptance in any of the listed journals.
15
practical results, i.e., recommendations for action. We suggest
the scope be specified more clearly in the text. The figures are
based on varying time periods; therefore, some clarification
would be helpful. There was no explicitly stated hypothesis, and
this was appropriate for the topic. However, more could be
mentioned about what the results indicate that the Japanese
tourism industry should do to solve its seasonal problems.
Is the length compatible to all
the suggested journals?
Yes, except as stated above.
Are all the findings
appropriately stated and
backed by substantial
evidence?
Please note that Figure 3 is neither present in the manuscript nor
mentioned in the text. Please check if Figures 4, 5, 6… should be
renamed as Figures 3, 4, 5…. There is much repetition in the
paper, and we have reduced most of it.
Is the research novel to this
field?
This study sheds considerable light to the existing literature;
however, the abovementioned changes are necessary to be
made.
Recommendations for
improving the manuscript
The paper requires Advance Editing to remedy the many
sentence-level errors as well as the lack of cohesiveness. I think
there is much that is good about the paper in terms of the
author’s ideas and the supporting details that are provided. The
subject matter is intriguing, and the examples and supporting
evidence are illustrative and engaging. Another observation is
that the references seem “thin,” and the paper could be
strengthened in this regard, too—more sources and more current
sources (some of the journals listed in the References don’t seem
to exist any longer, as I could not find any websites for them
online; other sources seem outdated). Also, it’s not entirely clear
what some of these sources actually are. All of this is to say, the
level of scholarship could be raised/improved.
Enago | Disclaimer: This report was compiled by our Journal Expert(s) after careful consideration of your manuscript considering several parameters. The author(s) should read the report carefully to choose the target
journal. This report is based on our expert’s assessment of the manuscript and should not be considered as a guarantee
of acceptance in any of the listed journals.
16
Our Commitment
Enago recognizes the need to deliver high-quality services and to
guarantee the security of your information at all times. This belief is
reflected in our commitment to establishing and maintaining
systems and processes that are compliant with the ISO quality and
IT security management standards.
Our relationship with you does not end here. This is just the
beginning!
Enago is committed to help you get your research published and we will ensure that your future needs
are met. For any assistance, simply mail us at [email protected]. Your dedicated assignment
manager will be happy to help you with all your needs and queries.