iisl moot court programme 2016 draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy...

28
:?E6C?2E:@?2= :?DE:EFE6 @7 DA246 =2H &) HT &MZRFQP =MOT_ DDMOQ =Mc &CCH 4CaFH 4CYDQHUHUCZ &% H@C=5 7:?2=D & &- DQDHQYNQF &% AMFMZUZRC PQ XM FZUbQF_UPMP PQ 8aMPMXMVMFM 8aMPMXMVMFM &QdUOC THHD.ccc"UU_XcQN"CFSXMOT_YCCH

Upload: others

Post on 05-Mar-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

:?E6C?2E:@?2= :?DE:EFE6 @7DA246 =2H

&) T MZR QP =MOT_D MOQ =Mc 4 a4 Y Q U U Z & %

H@C=5 7:?2=D& &- DQ QYNQ & %

AM MZUZR PQ XM FZUbQ _UPMP PQ 8aMPMXMVM M 8aMPMXMVM M QdUO

T . ccc"UU_XcQN" S XMOT_Y

Page 2: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

FZUbQ _U e R U__U__U U DOT X R =Mc

@dR P U__U__U U, FZU QP D M Q_ HUZZQ _ R H XP 7UZMX & %) Q a_MXQY :_ MQX

Page 3: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

4 Z QZ _

ETQ :Z Q ZM U ZMX :Z_ U a Q R D MOQ =Mc &3 M P R 5U QO _ '

4 a 4 YYU QQ )aPSQ MZR QP =MOT_ETQ 4 Y Q U U Z ,DaYYM e R TQ A NXQY %AM UOU MZ _ UZ TQ CQSU ZMX C aZP_ %&HUZZQ _ R TQ CQSU ZMX C aZP_ %aPSQ_ R TQ H XP 7UZMX_ %A S MY H XP 7UZMX_ MZP ::D= 2ZZaMX 5UZZQ %-2cM P_ R H XP 7UZMX_ &4 Z MO 5Q MUX_ R TQ CQSU ZMX C aZP_ &'2PP Q__Q_ &'D Z_ _ &(7a TQ CQMPUZS &

4@AJC:89E & % h ::D=" 2== C:89ED C6D6CG65.

Page 4: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

ETQ :Z Q ZM U ZMX :Z_ U a Q R D MOQ =Mc7 aZPQP UZ %- TQ :Z Q ZM U ZMX :Z_ U a Q R D MOQ =Mc ::D= U_ MZ UZPQ QZPQZ Z ZS bQ ZYQZ MX SMZUfM U Z PQPUOM QP R _ Q UZS TQ PQbQX YQZ R _ MOQ XMc" ETQYQYNQ _TU R TQ :Z_ U a Q U_ O Y _QP R UZPUbUPaMX_ MZP UZ_ U a U Z_ R Y Y Q TMZ R eO aZ UQ_ QXQO QP Z TQ NM_U_ R TQU O Z UNa U Z_ TQ RUQXP R _ MOQ XMc TQ _ OUMX_OUQZOQ_ QXM QP _ MOQ MO UbU UQ_" :Z MPPU U Z _ QO UbQ YQYNQ _TU U_ QZ _ aPQZ _MZP e aZS RQ__U ZMX_ cU T M PQY Z_ M QP UZ Q Q_ UZ _ MOQ XMc"

ETQ a _Q_ MZP NVQO UbQ_ R TQ ::D= UZOXaPQ TQ Y U Z R Ra TQ PQbQX YQZ R_ MOQ XMc MZP Qd MZ_U Z R TQ aXQ R XMc UZ TQ Qd X M U Z MZP a_Q R a Q _ MOQ RQMOQRaX a _Q_ TQ T XPUZS R YQQ UZS_ O XX aUM MZP O Y Q U U Z_ Z Va UPUOMX MZP _ OUMX_OUQZOQ M_ QO _ R _ MOQ MO UbU UQ_ TQ Q M M U Z O YYU__U ZUZS R _ aPUQ_ MZP Q _TQ aNXUOM U Z R N W_ OQQPUZS_ Q _ MZP _U U Z M Q _ MZP TQ O Q M U Z cU TM UM Q UZ Q ZM U ZMX SMZUfM U Z_ MZP ZM U ZMX UZ_ U a U Z_ UZ TQ RUQXP R _ MOQ XMc"

ETQ ::D= T XP_ MZ MZZaMX 4 XX aUaY M TQ :Z Q ZM U ZMX 2_ ZMa UOMX 4 ZS Q__" 5a UZS TU_4 XX aUaY TQ ?MZPM_U U M_QZ aXUeMZM QeZ Q XQO a Q MWQ_ XMOQ M_ cQXX M_ M _ QOUMX_Q__U Z R J aZS DOT XM _" :Z MPPU U Z TQ :Z_ U a Q SMZUfQ_ M bM UQ e R O ZRQ QZOQ_ Z_ MOQ XMc T aST a TQ eQM UZ X OM U Z_ MXX bQ TQ c XP" : aNXU_TQ_ MZ MZZaMX b XaYQ R::D= A OQQPUZS_ cU T M Q _ MZP Q _ R MXX MO UbU UQ_ Pa UZS TQ eQM "

DUZOQ %--& TQ ::D= SMZUfQ_ TQ MZZaMX MZR QP =MOT_ D MOQ =Mc 4 a4 Y Q U U Z" ETQ O Y Q U U Z U_ NM_QP Z M Te TQ UOMX _ MOQ XMc OM_Q c U QZ Ne ::D=YQYNQ _ UZ cTUOT M aZP _Ud e _ aPQZ QMY_ R Y aZUbQ _U UQ_ UZ ? T 2YQ UOM 6a Q2_UM AMOURUO MZP 2R UOM M UOU M Q" QYNQ _ R TQ :Z Q ZM U ZMX 4 a R a_ UOQ VaPSQ TQH XP 7UZMX R TQ O Y Q U U Z YMWUZS U aZU aQ UZ TQ c XP"

ETQ ::D= U_ MZ RRUOUMXXe QO SZUfQP N_Q bQ M _Q__U Z_ R TQ FZU QP ?M U Z_ 4 YYU QQ ZTQ AQMOQRaX F_Q_ R @a Q D MOQ MZP U _ DOUQZ URUO EQOTZUOMX MZP =QSMX DaNO YYU QQ_"

7a TQ UZR YM U Z QSM PUZS TQ ::D= OMZ NQ R aZP M ccc"UU_XcQN" S"

2

Page 5: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

GUOQ A Q_UPQZ" "C" D UPTM M a TU :ZPUM

6dQOa UbQ DQO Q M e 2__ " A R" 5 " 5UMZQ 9 cM P

FZU QP D M Q_

E QM_a Q " 5QZZU_ " 3a ZQ 6_ "

FZU QP D M Q_

3 M P R 5U QO _ & %) & %

@RRUOQ _

GUOQ A Q_UPQZ A R" MU FcQ DOT SX

8Q YMZe

A Q_UPQZ2__ " A R" EMZVM =" M__ Z KcMMZ

ETQ ?Q TQ XMZP_

3

Page 6: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

5U QO _A R" DQ _aW 2 WU M MZ

A R" 5 " @XMb 3U QZO a 3 MfUX

A R" A" " 3X aZ FZU QP D M Q_

A R" 5 " 7 MZ_ b Z PQ 5aZW ETQ ?Q TQ XMZP_ FZU QP D M Q_

5 " M O 7Q MffMZU : MXe

A R" 5 " D QbQZ 7 QQXMZP 2a_ MXUM

A R" MZZQ :" 8MN eZ cUOf FZU QP D M Q_

5 " JM_aMWU 9M_TUY M MZ

A R" 5 " D Q TMZ 9 NQ 8Q YMZe

A R" 5 " MTaXQZM 9 RYMZZ 4fQOT CQ aNXUO

_ 4 UZZQ SQZ_ Z FZU QP D M Q_

A R" 5 " DQ SU M OTU_U : MXe

A R" =Q_XQe MZQ DYU T FZU QP UZSP Y

5 " UX Z “DWU ” DYU T FZU QP D M Q_

A R" 5 " Ma QQZ HUXXUMY_ F 2 SQZ UZMA R" KTQZVaZ KTMZS 4TUZM g

4

Page 7: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

5

5 " M TM QVíM MU_Q " =Q_XUQ :"EQZZQZ 6_ " _" QXU__M " 7 OQ 6_ "QdUO 8Q YMZe FZU QP D M Q_ FZU QP D M Q_

_ =aXa MWM QXM " G" 8 MXMW U_TZMZ _" M UM GU UM “8UaSU4M YUZM U 6_ "

D a T 2R UOM :ZPUM FZU QP D M Q_

CQSU ZMX @ SMZUfQ CQSU ZMX @ SMZUfQ CQSU ZMX @ SMZUfQR 2R UOM R 2_UM AMOURUO R ? T 2YQ UOM

4 4TMU _

4 a 4 YYU QQ & %) & % .

QYNQ _

Page 8: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

5 " KTQZVaZ KTMZS4TUZM

" MYQ_ 5" CQZPXQYMZ 6_ "mFZU QP D M Q_

6

A R" DQ SU M OTU_U " aYM 2NTUVQQ " ?M TMZ TZ_ Z: MXe :ZPUM FZU QP D M Q_

64D= 4TMU YMZ 2__ OUM Q CQSU ZMX @ SMZUfQ 2__ OUM Q CQSU ZMX @ SMZUfQCQSU ZMX @ SMZUfM U Z R 2_UM AMOURUO R ? T 2YQ UOM

5 " UX Z DWU DYU TFZU QP D M Q_

Page 9: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

aPSQ MZR QP =MOT_MZR QP =MOT_ cM_ N Z UZ %-%( UZ A XMZP" 9Q QM ZQP M 5 O M Q R =Mc_ M TQ 4 MO cMSUQXX ZUMZ FZUbQ _U e MZP TQXP _QbQ MX MOMPQYUO _U U Z_ UZ 2a_ UM MZP TQ FZU QP UZSP Y MZPXM Q QZ Q QP TQ c XP R PU X YMOe Q Q_QZ UZS A XMZP"

2R Q TQ _T OW R TQ DQO ZP H XP HM MZR QP =MOT_ MO QP Z NQTMXR R TU_ O aZ e M TQ AM U_AQMOQ 4 ZRQ QZOQ UZ %-( W M UZ TQ ?a QYNQ S UNaZMX MZP _Q bQP M_ Q Q_QZ M UbQ RA XMZP TQ FZU QP ?M U Z_" MZR QP =MOT_ U_ TQ ZXe Q _ Z UZ TQ F? TU_ e TMbQ NQQZQXQO QP T QQ UYQ_ M_ TQ 4TMU YMZ R 4 YYU QQ G: =QSMX R TQ 8QZQ MX 2__QYNXe"

MZR QP =MOT_ OTMU QP TQ =QSMX DaNO YYU QQ R TQ FZU QP ?M U Z_ 4 YYU QQ Z TQ AQMOQRaXF_Q_ R @a Q D MOQ MZP cM_ PQQ Xe UZb XbQP UZ TQ PQNM Q_ MZP P MR UZS R TQ RU _ YaX UXM Q MX_ MOQ QM e TQ @a Q D MOQ E QM e R %- "

:Z %- M TQ MSQ R )' MZR QP =MOT_ NQOMYQ TQ e aZSQ_ QXQO QP VaPSQ R TQ :Z Q ZM U ZMX4 a R a_ UOQ UZ ETQ 9MSaQ MZP cM_ Q QXQO QP cUOQ R MZ aZ QOQPQZ QP T QQ Q Y_ Z TQ4 a " 9Q MX_ Q_UPQP Z TQ 4 a R Y %- ' %- "

aPSQ =MOT_ cM_ A Q_UPQZ R TQ ::D= R Y %-- aZ UX TU_ PQM T UZ %--'" 9Q Ma T QP YMZe M UOXQ_MZP N W_ MY ZS TQY iETQ =Mc R @a Q D MOQ. 2Z 6d Q UQZOQ UZ 4 Z QY M e =McMWUZSj %- & cTUOT TQ ::D= Q aNXU_TQP UZ & % OQXQN M Q U _ ) T MZZUbQ _M e"

9Q YMe ZQbQ TMbQ UYMSUZQP TM MR Q TU_ PQM T TU_ ZMYQ c aXP NQ a_QP cU T TQ Q YU__U Z R TU_RMYUXe R TQ _ MOQ XMc Y O a O Y Q U U Z R TQ ::D= MZP Ta_ NQ QYQYNQ QP Ne _ YMZe_ MOQ XMc _ aPQZ _ MZP TQ Q _ Z_ UZb XbQP UZ TQ O Y Q U U Z"

aPSQ_ MZR QP =MOT_ D Q TQZ " DOTcQNQX MZP 8UXNQ 8aUXXMaYQcU T UX Z kDWU l DYU T XQR UST UZ TQ RU _ ::D= 4 a 4 Y Q U U Z

HM_TUZS Z 5"4" %--&

7

Page 10: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

ETQ 4 Y Q U U Z

ETQ MZR QP =MOT_ D MOQ =Mc 4 a 4 Y Q U U Z U_ SMZUfQP MZZaMXXe Ne TQ :Z Q ZM U ZMX:Z_ U a Q R D MOQ =Mc ::D= "

ETQ RU _ O Y Q U U Z cM_ SMZUfQP R XMc _ aPQZ _ R Y ? T 2YQ UOM Ne TQ 2__ OUM U Z R FDQYNQ _ R TQ ::D= 2FD ::D= Pa UZS TQ RU _ H XP D MOQ 4 ZS Q__ TQXP UZ HM_TUZS Z 5"4"

FD2 UZ %--&" @ZQ eQM XM Q TQ 4 Y Q U U Z cM_ Qd QZPQP UZOXaPQ 6a QMZ _ aPQZ _" :Z& TQ 2_UM AMOURUO C aZP cM_ MPPQP MZP TQ 2R UOMZ CQSU Z cM_ UZMaSa M QP UZ & %%"

A QXUYUZM e O Y Q U U Z_ M Q TQXP NQ cQQZ 2 UX MZP aZQ UZ QMOT QSU Z" ETQ cUZZUZS QMY_ R TQQSU ZMX aZP_ YQQ UZ TQ H XP 7UZMX_ cTUOT M Q TQXP UZ O ZVaZO U Z cU T TQ MZZaMX ::D=4 XX aUaY Z TQ =Mc R @a Q D MOQ" ETQ 7UZMX C aZP U_ MPU U ZMXXe VaPSQP Ne T QQ VaPSQ_ R TQ:Z Q ZM U ZMX 4 a R a_ UOQ" ETU_ aZU aQ RQM a Q YMWQ_ TQ MZR QP =MOT_ 4 a ZQ R TQY _ Q_ USU a_ Y O a O Y Q U U Z_ UZ TQ c XP"

ETQ O Y Q U U Z U_ NM_QP Z M Te TQ UOMX _ MOQ XMc PU_ a Q NQR Q TQ :Z Q ZM U ZMX 4 a Ra_ UOQ" ETQ A NXQY U_ c U QZ Ne M QYNQ R TQ ::D= a Z UZbU M U Z Ne TQ @ SMZUfUZS4 YYU QQ R TQ 4 Y Q U U Z MX Q ZM UZS NQ cQQZ TQ PURRQ QZ QSU Z_" ETQ & % Te TQ UOMXA NXQY U_ QZ U XQP TQ k4M_Q 4 ZOQ ZUZS D MOQ 5QN U_ 4 YYQ OUMX D MOQRXUST DQ bUOQ_ MZP =UMNUXU e3MZOTé b CM_ MXUM " ETQ A NXQY Q_QZ _ U__aQ_ QXM UZS TQ O QM U Z R NU MX PQN U_QYQ SQZOe XMZPUZS R M O QcQP _ MOQO MR MZP TQ Q a Z R Q _ ZZQX"

CQSU ZMX C aZP_ Ya_ O Y Xe cU T TQ @RRUOUMX CaXQ_ R TQ 4 Y Q U U Z MP QP Ne TQ ::D= 3 M PR 5U QO _" AM UOU M UZS QMY_ M Q Q aU QP _aNYU M i QY UMXj M_ R YMX c U QZ M SaYQZ _ RN T TQ 2 XUOMZ D M Q MZP TQ CQ_ ZPQZ D M Q Z TQ XQSMX U__aQ_ R TQ Te TQ UOMX OM_Q"

:Z TQ QSU ZMX A QXUYUZM e C aZP_ QMOT QMY cU T c _ QMWQ _ Q_QZ _ @ MX 2 SaYQZ _ NQR QMZQX_ R T QQ VaPSQ_" QY UMX_ MZP @ MX 2 SaYQZ _ QMOT OM e M cQUST R ) R TQ MX_O Q R M QMY" ETQ R a cUZZUZS QMY_ R TQ QSU ZMX A QXUYUZM e C aZP_ Y bQ Z TQ 7UZMXC aZP_"

ETQ Qd QZ_Q_ R TQ QMY_ MWUZS M UZ TQ 7UZMX C aZP_ M Q N ZQ Ne TQ M MZ 2Q _ MOQ6d X M U Z 2SQZOe 2I2 TQ 6a QMZ 4QZ Q R D MOQ =Mc 64D= ?2D2 TQ DQOa Q H XP7 aZPM U Z @NMRQYU 2c X c FZUbQ _U e MZP TQ D a T 2R UOMZ 5Q M YQZ R E MPQ MZP :ZPa_ e"EQMY_ M Q MXX cQP QbU_Q TQU QY UMX_ NQR Q TQe Q_aNYU TQY R TQ 7UZMX C aZP_" 2MZQX R VaPSQ_ QbUQc MZP S MPQ TQ QY UMX_ MZP TQ _O Q_ M Q a_QP PQ Q YUZQ TQ QMYMU UZS_ R TQ _QYU RUZMX_ MX M SaYQZ _" ETQ_Q MX M SaYQZ _ M Q O ZPaO QP UZ OX _QP _Q__U Z_NQR Q T QQ VaPSQ MZQX_ MZP TQ c cUZZUZS QMY_ aMXURe R TQ 7UZMX"

ETQ &) T MZR QP =MOT_ D MOQ =Mc 4 a 4 Y Q U U Z cUXX NQ TQXP UZ 8aMPMXMVM M QdUO "ETQ DQYU RUZMX_ cUXX NQ O ZPaO QP UZ OX _QP _Q__U Z_ Z EaQ_PMe & DQ QYNQ & % " ETQ 7UZMX U_M aNXUO QbQZ MZP cUXX MWQ XMOQ Z ETa _PMe &- DQ QYNQ M TQ FZUbQ _U e R 8aMPMXMVM M2XNQ SM MX AM MZUZR NQR Q M MZQX R aPSQ_ R TQ :Z Q ZM U ZMX 4 a R a_ UOQ UZ ETQ 9MSaQ

" 8

Page 11: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

& % 6a QMZ CQSU ZMX C aZP 8XM_S c DO XMZP

9

& % 2R UOMZ CQSU ZMX C aZP A Q UM D a T 2R UOM

Page 12: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

DaYYM e R TQ A NXQY4M_Q 4 ZOQ ZUZS D MOQ 5QN U_ 4 YYQ OUMX D MOQRXUST DQ bUOQ_

MZP =UMNUXU e

3MZOTé b CM_ MXUM

ETQ CQ aNXUO R 3MZOTé MZP TQ CQ aNXUO R CM_ MXUM M Q ZQUSTN UZS O aZ UQ_ MZP N T M Q_ MOQ RM UZS ZM U Z_ MYNU U a_Xe O YYQ OUMXUfUZS TQU _ MOQ MO UbU UQ_" 3MZOTé TM_ M_ U _YMUZ M SQ bUPQ O YYQ OUMX _ MOQRXUST _Q bUOQ_ UZ TQ UZ Q ZM U ZMX YM WQ " CM_ MXUMU_ MX_ YMWUZS Qd QZ_UbQ a_Q R _ MOQ QOTZ X SUQ_ R bM U a_ a _Q_" ETQ_Q cO aZ UQ_ cQ Q T _ UXQ UZ TU_ e T aST UZ TQ XM_ RQc eQM _ TQ QXM U Z_TU TM_ UY bQP"3MZOTé TM_ X ZS QSM PQP CM_ MXUM M_ M YMV UbMX UZ TQ _ MOQ YM WQ MZP _ UXX YMUZ MUZ__ UO Qd O Z X_ bQ TUST QOTZ X SUQ_ MSMUZ_ CM_ MXUM" 3 T O aZ UQ_ M Q M UQ_TQ F? 4TM Q @a Q D MOQ E QM e CQ_OaQ 2S QQYQZ CQSU_ M U Z 4 ZbQZ U Z MZP=UMNUXU e 4 ZbQZ U Z"

M P Z EQOT" 4 " = P" k M P Zl M _M QXXU Q O Y MZe QSU_ Q QP UZ CM_ MXUM XMaZOTQP U _RU _ _OUQZ URUO _M QXXU Q =Mb % UZ & &, MZP TQ _M QXXU Q a_QP MZ aZ Q_ QP O Y _U QcTUOT U_ TQ XM Q_ Q_QM OT MOTUQbQYQZ R M P Z" 7 a Y Z T_ XM Q TQ _M QXXU Q_aPPQZXe OQM_QP RaZO U Z NQOMa_Q R M M Q _ XM cUZP_ Y" M P Z RMUXQP MX Q=Mb %j_ NU MZP CM_ MXUM _ M QP TM TQ _M QXXU Q cM_ R MSUXQ R U NQ OM a QPNe MZe R U _ _ MOQ NVQO _" CM_ MXUM PQOXM QP =Mb % M PQ QXUO MZP TQZ 3MZOTéMZZ aZOQP U _ UZ QZ U Z QY bQ U R Y NU cU T a U M bMX Ne CM_ MXUM" 2 TU PO aZ e _ XUM U_ M TUSTXe MPbMZOQP _ M Q UZ _ MOQ QOTZ X SUQ_ MZP TM_ NQQZ WQQ UZSOX _Q MOW R =Mb % NQR Q MZP MR Q TQ YMXRaZO U Z"

D XM Q E MbQX DQ bUOQ_ = P" kD XM Ql M O Y MZe QSU_ Q QP UZ _ XUM TM_ U _ UZOU MXRRUOQ UZ 3MZOTé" D XM Q _aOOQ__RaXXe aMXURUQP TQ _ MOQO MR 4 aXQa R O YYQ OUMX_ MOQRXUST _Q bUOQ_ UZ 7QN aM e & &)" D XM Q _T XU_ QP c Q _ Z_ T aST _QXQO U Z M

_ XUMZ OU UfQZ ZMYQP _" 6 UZ AMaXM MZP M CM_ MXUMZ OU UfQZ ZMYQP " 2ZP Qc MYQ_MY ZS M ZaYNQ R M XUOMZ _ R U _ PQNa XMaZOT cU T M 3MZOTé M_ ZMa ZMYQP "M U 3 _OT M_ 4 aXQa j_ O YYMZPQ " " 3 _OT R YQ Xe c WQP UZ TQ UZU_ e R

?M U ZMX 5QRQZ_Q R 3MZOTé"

10

Page 13: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

:Z & &, TQ 3MZOTé S bQ ZYQZ _USZQP M O Z MO cU T D XM Q cTUOT _ U aXM QP TM4 aXQa MWQ a TQ V N QY bQ =Mb % R Y U _ Oa QZ NU " :Z & &- 4 aXQa_aOOQ__RaXXe QMOTQP U _ _OTQPaXQP NU MZP _ M QP QY bUZS =Mb %" 9 cQbQ=Mb % N WQ UZ c _QSYQZ _ cTQZ 4 aXQa cM_ eUZS S M XQ TQ _M QXXU Q" :ZPQ PQ NU TQ TQ UQOQ R =Mb % TM QYMUZQP UZ NU 3MZOTé PQOUPQP

MO UbM Q TQ QbU a_Xe _QO Q 8@52 =DCD cTUOT Q_aX QP UZ M OM_OMPQ R PQN U_ R MSYQZ _PaOQP Ne TQ Qd X _U Z R TQ _M QXXU Q QXXMZ " DQbQ MX YUZa Q_ XM Q 4 aXQa cM_

_ aOW Ne M PQN U_ R MSYQZ cTUOT _Q U a_Xe PMYMSQP TQ Z YMX RaZO U ZUZS R 4 aXQa "4 YYMZPQ 3 _OT PQOUPQP YMWQ MZ a SQZ XMZPUZS" ETQ 4 aXQa PaQ TQ PMYMSQU _ WQe O YYaZUOM U Z_ M M M a_ XMZPQP UZ TQ Q U e R CM_ MXUM" 5a UZS TQ XMZPUZS

OQ__ M UQOQ R _ MOQO MR _TQXX PMYMSQP Ne TQ PQN U_ O XXU_U Z PQ MOTQP MZP TU MOMY _U Q ZQM =MWQ EMU OMa_UZS TQ PQM T R ZQ CM_ MXUMZ " 5MbQ ET YM_" ETQaZ_OTQPaXQP XMZPUZS MX_ OMa_QP TQ PQM T R MZ TQ CM_ MXUMZ " 3M Z cT _aRRQ QP MRM MX TQM M MOW cTUXQ cU ZQ__UZS TQ 4 aXQa M__ bQ TQMP" 7QM UZS TM TQ 8@52 YMeQXQM_Q MPUM U Z CM_ MXUM QbMOaM QP TQ M QM cU TUZ ' WY R =MWQ EMU TQ QbMOaM U ZXM_ QP ' PMe_"

3MZOTé Q aQ_ QP UYYQPUM Q Q a Z R O Qc MZP O MR " CM_ MXUM PQYMZPQP QUYNa _QYQZR TQ O _ _ MZP PMYMSQ_ UZOa QP M_ M Q_aX R 4 aXQa j_ XMZPUZS 3MZOTé QRa_QP TU_PQYMZP MZP UZ_U_ QP Z TQ Q a Z R 4 YYMZPQ 3 _OT cT MO aU QP _QZ_U UbQQOTZ X SUQ_ MZP UZR YM U Z Pa UZS TU_ _Q bUOQ UZ TQ UZU_ e" CM_ MXUM QbQZ aMXXe Q a ZQP_" AMaXM 3MZOTé Na QRa_QP Q a Z TQ 4 aXQa MZP Q MUZQP 4 YYMZPQ 3 _OT

cT MXXQSQPXe M_WQP R XU UOMX M_eXaY UZ CM_ MXUM MZP cM_ RRQ QP M TUST S bQ ZYQZ_U U Z UZ CM_ MXUM"

ETQ & % 4M_Q cM_ Ma T QP Ne A R" JaZ KTM 4TUZM

11

H XP 7UZMX & %( E Z 4MZMPM

Page 14: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

AM UOU MZ _ UZ TQ CQSU ZMX C aZP_

2R UOM.

6a Q.

MWQ Q FZUbQ _U e MY MXM FSMZPM

aZ QZeM FZUbQ _U e ETUWM QZeM

?USQ 5QX M FZUbQ _U e HUXNQ R OQ :_XMZP ?USQ UM

@NMRQYU 2c X c FZUbQ _U e 4U e R :XQ :RQ ?USQ UM

FZUbQ _U e R A Q UM 7MOaX e R =Mc A Q UM D a T 2R UOM

7MOaX e R =Mc FZUbQ _U e R 4 X SZQ 4 X SZQ 8Q YMZe:Z Q ZM U ZMX :Z_ U a Q R 2U MZP D MOQ =Mc =QUPQZ FZUbQ _U e =QUPQZ ETQ ?Q TQ XMZP_TZ AMaX :: 4M T XUO FZUbQ _U e R =aNXUZ =aNXUZ A XMZP

=Qa TMZM FZUbQ _U e =oZQNa S 8Q YMZe?M U ZMX M PU_ UMZ FZUbQ _U e 2 TQZ_ 8 QQOQ?M U ZMX FZUbQ _U e R EQOTZUOMX MZP 2PYUZU_ M UbQ DOUQZOQ_ 3aOTM Q_ C YMZUMFZU Z FZUbQ _U e =Mc DOT X 3QXS MPQ DQ NUMFZUbQ _U e R 3aOTM Q_ 3aOTM Q_ C YMZUMFZUbQ _U e R 6PUZNa ST 6PUZNa ST FZU QP UZSP YFZUbQ _U e R 8QZ M 8QZ M : MXeFZUbQ _U e R 9QX_UZWU =Mc 9QX_UZWU 7UZXMZPFZUbQ _U e R 9Q R P_TU Q 9M RUQXP FZU QP UZSP YFZUbQ _U e R = Pf =Mc MZP 2PYUZU_ M U Z = Pf A XMZPFZUbQ _U e R =adQYN a S =adQYN a S =adQYN a SFZUbQ _U e R D M TOXePQ 8XM_S c FZU QP UZSP YFZUbQ _U e R GUQZZM GUQZZM 2a_ UMFZUbQ _U e R HM _Mc HM _Mc A XMZP

12

Page 15: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

7X UPM D M Q FZUbQ _U e 4 XXQSQ R =Mc EMXXMTM__QQ 7X UPM FD2

8Q SQ cZ FZUbQ _U e =Mc 4QZ Q HM_TUZS Z 5"4" FD2

8Q SQ HM_TUZS Z FZUbQ _U e HM_TUZS Z 5"4" FD2

O8UXX FZUbQ _U e :Z_ U a Q R 2U MZP D MOQ =Mc Z QMX BaQNQO 4MZMPM

D " ET YM_ FZUbQ _U e DOT X R =Mc UMYU 7X UPM FD2

FZUbQ _U e R 9McMUU HUXXUMY D" CUOTM P_ Z DOT X R =Mc 9 Z XaXa 9McMUU FD2

FZUbQ _U e R U__U__U U DOT X R =Mc @dR P U__U__U U FD2

FZUbQ _UPMP ?MOU ZMX 2a Z YM PQ QdUO F?2 QdUO 4U e QdUO

FZUbQ _U e R ?QN M_WM 4 XXQSQ R =Mc =UZO XZ ?QN M_WM FD2

FZUbQ _U e R ?QbMPM =M_ GQSM_ =M_ GQSM_ ?QbMPM FD2

FZUbQ _U e R @ McM @ McM @Z M U 4MZMPM

FZUbQ _U e R HM_TUZS Z DQM XQ HM_TUZS Z FD2

13

AM UOU MZ _ UZ TQ CQSU ZMX C aZP_

? T 2YQ UOM.

Page 16: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

2PQXMUPQ =Mc DOT X FZUbQ _U e R 2PQXMUPQ 2PQXMUPQ 2a_ MXUM2Q _ MOQ CQ_QM OT :Z_ U a Q R TQ UZU_ e R DOUQZOQ CQ_QM OT EQOTZ X Se EQTQ MZ :"C"R : MZ4TUZM FZUbQ _U e R A XU UOMX DOUQZOQ MZP =Mc 4FA= 3QUVUZS 4TUZM4T U_ FZUbQ _U e 3MZSMX Q :ZPUM4 XXQSQ R =QSMX D aPUQ_ FZUbQ _U e R AQ XQaY MZP 6ZQ Se D aPUQ_ FA6D 5QT MPaZ :ZPUM4a UZ FZUbQ _U e AQ T 2a_ MXUM8aVM M ?M U ZMX =Mc FZUbQ _U e 8MZPTUZMSM :ZPUM:ZPUMZ =Mc D OUQ e =Mc 4 XXQSQ :=D AaZQ :ZPUM:7: =Mc 4 XXQSQ 3MZSMX Q :ZPUMM TYMZPa DOT X R =Mc Aa NMZOTMX FZUbQ _U e M TYMZPa ?Q MX"D" CMYMUMT 4 XXQSQ R =Mc 3MZSMX Q :ZPUM

?M U ZMX =Mc :Z_ U a Q FZUbQ _U e 3T MX :ZPUM?M U ZMX =Mc DOT X R :ZPUM FZUbQ _U e ?=D:F 3MZSMX Q :ZPUM?M U ZMX =Mc FZUbQ _U e 5QXTU :ZPUM?M U ZMX =Mc FZUbQ _U e @PU_TM 4a MOW :ZPUM?M U ZMX FZUbQ _U e R 2PbMZOQP =QSMX D aPUQ_ ?F2=D OTU :ZPUM?M U ZMX FZUbQ _U e R DUZSM Q DUZSM Q DUZSM Q?M U ZMX =Mc FZUbQ _U e PT a :ZPUMDOT X R 6dOQXXQZOQ UZ =Mc ETQ EMYUX ?MPa 5 " 2YNQPWM =Mc FZUbQ _U e 4TQZZMU :ZPUMDOT X @R =Mc CMRRXQ_ FZUbQ _U e ?QQY MZM :ZPUMDeYNU _U_ =Mc :ZPUM DOT X AaZQ :ZPUMEMYUX ?MPa ?M U ZMX =Mc DOT X E UOTe :ZPUMFZUbQ _U M_ :_XMY :ZP ZQ_UM J SeMWM M :ZP ZQ_UMFZUbQ _U M_ M XUW AM MTeMZSMZ 3MZPaZS :ZP ZQ_UMHQ_ 3QZSMX ?M U ZMX FZUbQ _U e R a UPUOMX DOUQZOQ_ XWM M :ZPUMGUbQWMZMZPM :Z_ U a Q R A RQ__U ZMX D aPUQ_ ?Qc 5QXTU :ZPUM

14

AM UOU MZ _ UZ TQ CQSU ZMX C aZP_

2_UM AMOURUO.

Page 17: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

& % ? T 2YQ UOMZ CQSU ZMX C aZPHM_TUZS Z 5"4" FZU QP D M Q_

15

& % 2_UM AMOURUO CQSU ZMX C aZP 3MZSMX Q :ZPUM

Page 18: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

& % HUZZQ _ R TQ CQSU ZMX C aZP_

2R UOM.

@NMRQYU 2c X c FZUbQ _U e 4U e R :XQ :RQ ?USQ UM

D aPQZ _. _" E XacMX Q @XacM NU 5MPM _. : QZQ :ZQYQ_U 6W PMZP " ATUXU _ EUYUXQTUZ 2PQWQYU

7MOaX e 2PbU_ . 5 " @PaZ XM 2WUZcMXQ @ UR c Y

2_UM AMOURUO.

4a UZ FZUbQ _U e AQ T 2a_ MXUM

D aPQZ _. _" CMOTQX @’ QM M _" OQXeZ HM _ MZP " CUOM P ?M Q7MOaX e 2PbU_ . A R" 5 " GQ Z Z ?M_Q

6a Q.

?M U ZMX MZP M PU_ UMZ FZUbQ _U e R 2 TQZ_ 8 QQOQ

D aPQZ _. _" 8Q SUM 6XQZU 6dM OT a _" 7UXM Q U 7UXM Q a aUY fUMZP _" D RUM D QXXM a

7MOaX e 2PbU_ . A R" 8Q SQ 5" e UMW aX _7MOaX e 2PbU_2__U_ MZ . _" 8Q SUM M UM MX SU a

? T 2YQ UOM.

:Z_ U a Q R 2U MZP D MOQ =Mc O8UXX FZUbQ _U e Z QMX 4MZMPMD aPQZ _. " aXUa_ 5aZ Z " EQP 2" ?Qc_ YQ " 2 MY 5" Q W ZUMZ7MOaX e 2PbU_ . A R" 5 " CMY D" MWTa7MOaX e 2PbU_2__U_ MZ . _" M UM MZ XU

16

Page 19: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

aPSQ_ R TQ H XP 7UZMX_

aPSQ_ R TQ 7UZMX

9"6" aPSQ AQ Q E YWM :Z Q ZM U ZMX 4 a R a_ UOQ9"6" aPSQ IaQ 9MZ UZ :Z Q ZM U ZMX 4 a R a_ UOQ9"6" aPSQ U UXX 8Qb SUMZ :Z Q ZM U ZMX 4 a R a_ UOQ

aPSQ E YWM aPSQ IaQ aPSQ 8Qb SUMZ

17

H XP 7UZMX & ' 3 QYQZ 8Q YMZe

Page 20: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

aPSQ_ R DQYURUZMX_

7 @ MX AXQMPUZS_

5 " FX UWQ " 3 TXYMZZ 8Q YMZe 2PYUZU_ M R D M QSe 5Q M YQZ 6a QMZ D MOQ2SQZOe AM U_ 7 MZOQ

" 5QZZU_ " 3a ZQ 6_ " FZU QP D M Q_ 2PVaZO A RQ__ D MOQ 4eNQ MZPEQXQO YYaZUOM U Z_ ==" " A S MY FZUbQ _U e R ?QN M_WM 4 XXQSQ R =Mc FD2

A R" 5 " DQ SU M OTU_U : MXe A RQ__ M FZUbQ _U e DM UQZfM R C YQ : MXe

A R" 5 " =Q_XQe MZQ DYU T F A RQ__ M =Qa TMZM FZUbQ _U e =üZQNa S 8Q YMZeD XUOU

5 " UX Z ‘DWU ’ DYU T 6_ " FZU QP D M Q_ AM ZQ M DTQ YMZ 9 cM P ==4 4 X MPD UZS_ 4 X MP FD2

A R" JaZ KTM 4TUZM 9QMP R 5Q M YQZ R =Mc ETQ FZUbQ _U e R 9 ZS ZS 4TUZM

7 QY UMX_5 " UOTMQX 4TM fU MZMSU U_ 8 QQOQ =QSMX 4 Z_aX MZ R 2Q TQ _ MOQ 4 Z_aX MZ _ 4e a_

5 " ATUXU 5Q MZ 3QXSUaY DQZU CQ_QM OTQ MZP =QO a Q M FZUbQ _U e R =QabQZ 3QXSUaY

_" :OT QMX _cQ 3 _cMZM 4 aZ_QX R QMX _cQ =QSMX 4 Z_aX UZS D a T 2R UOM

A R" 5 " =U DT a UZS 4TUZM 5U QO R :Z_ U a Q R D MOQ =Mc 3QUVUZS :Z_ U a Q REQOTZ X Se 4TUZM

" Ma e " QOTMZUOW 6_ " FZU QP D M Q_ 4 aZ_QX M HTU Q 4M_Q ==A HM_TUZS Z5"4" FD2

_" DTQ XQZQ Z SMYe D a T 2R UOM 5U QO R =QSMX DQ bUOQ_ 5Q M YQZ R DOUQZOQ REQOTZ X Se A Q UM D a T 2R UOM

_" M OUM DYU T FZU QP D M Q_ A Q_UPQZ R D MOQ MZP EQOTZ X Se A XUOe 8 a FD2

5 " Ja U EMWMeM FYQTM M M MZ A RQ__ M NQ FZUbQ _U e M MZ

18

Page 21: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

H XP 7UZMX

&.' "Y" 3a_ R Y TQ 6d 8aMPMXMVM M TQ AM MZUZR 6Z U aQ 5UMf PQ=Q Z R TQ FZUbQ _U e R 8aMPMXMVM M"

3a_ XQMbQ_ M &.() "Y" _TM "

'.%) "Y" 2XX SaQ_ _ NQ _QM QP"

:Z PaO U Z Ne 5 " M TM QVUM MU_Q 4 4TMU =MOT_4 a 4 YYU QQ

HQXO YQ Ne A R" : fOóM X E ZM UaT 3 Mb AMPUXXM 4TMZOQXX R TQ

FZUbQ _U e R 8aMPMXMVM Mg MZP QMPUZS R TQ NXQY

(. "Y" @ MX C aZP_

).& "Y" 5QXUNQ M U Z_

. "Y" 2ZZ aZOQYQZ R TQ cUZZUZS QMY_ MZP Q_QZ M U Z R McM P_"

.' "Y" 5Q M a Q ::D= 5UZZQ M TQ AMXMOU aZUOU MX 5Q KM MZ

CQSU_ Q QP SaQ_ _ ZXe

::D= 2ZZaMX 5UZZQ

. Y 5 UZW_ M TQ AMXMOU aZUOU MX 5Q KM MZ

8. "Y" ::D= 2ZZaMX 2cM P_ 5UZZQ M TQ AMXMOU aZUOU MX 5Q KM MZ

% .' "Y" 3a_ MZ_ NMOW TQ 6d 8aMPMXMVM M MZP T QX_

19

Page 22: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

2cM P_ R H XP 7UZMX_

HUZZUZS EQMYA Q_QZ M U Z R =MOT_ E Te=QQ = bQ 2cM P R 3Q_ EQMY4 YYQY M UbQ AXM aQ4Q URUOM Q_ QMY YQYNQ _

CaZZQ a4 YYQY M UbQ AXM aQ4Q URUOM Q_ QMY YQYNQ _

AM UOU MZ _ UZ DQYURUZMX_4 YYQY M UbQ AXM aQ4Q URUOM Q_ QMY YQYNQ _

3Q_ QY UMX_6UXQZQ " 8MXX cMe 2cM P R 3Q_ QY UMX_E Te AXM Q DOT X4Q URUOM Q_ QMY YQYNQ _

3Q_ @ MXU_D Q Z_ MZP EQZZQZ 2cM P R 3Q_ @ MXU_E Te AXM Q DOT X4Q URUOM Q HUZZQ

2XX D aPQZ AM UOU MZ _ UZ TQ 7UZMX_=Mc N W_ P ZM QP Ne 6XQbQZ :Z Q ZM U ZMX AaNXU_TUZS=Mc N W_ P ZM QP Ne 3 UXX M UZa_ ?UVT RR=Mc N W_ P ZM QP Ne D UZSQ

20

Page 23: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

2H2C5D5C" 6:=6?6 " 82==@H2J %- & - cM_ M XQSQZP UZ TQ RUQXP_ R _ MOQ XUOe MZP _ MOQXMc TMbUZS NQQZ UZ_ aYQZ MX UZ TQ R YM U Z R TQ ?M U ZMX 2Q ZMa UO_ MZP D MOQ2PYUZU_ M U Z ?2D2 " 7 Y %-(% %- ) _TQ c WQP R TQ F"D" 4 ZS Q__ M_ M _ MRRYQYNQ R TQ =QSU_XM UbQ CQRQ QZOQ DQ bUOQ XM Q TQ 4 ZS Q__U ZMX CQ_QM OT DQ bUOQ MZP cM_OMXXQP a Z Ne TQZ DQZM Q MV U e =QMPQ =eZP Z 3" TZ_ Z MPbU_Q TUY Z T c Q_ ZP

TQ D bUQ FZU Z _ XMaZOT R D a ZUW % Z @O NQ ( %-) " DTQ M__U_ QP DQZM TZ_ Z M_cQXX M_g TQZ D QMWQ R TQ 9 a_Q TZ O4 YMOW UZ O MR UZS TQ ?M U ZMX 2Q ZMa UO_ MZPD MOQ 2O cTUOT O QM QP ?2D2" DTQ MOO Y MZUQP DQZM TZ_ Z TQ FZU QP ?M U Z_ cTQZTQ Q Q_QZ QP TQ FZU QP D M Q_ UZ QO YYQZPUZS O QM U Z R cTM U_ Z c WZ cZ M_ TQ4 YYU QQ Z TQ AQMOQRaX F_Q_ R @a Q D MOQ 4@AF@D " DTQ cM_ MZ RRUOUMX N_Q bQ M4@AF@D R Y %- %--(" DTQ cM_ M R aZPUZS YQYNQ R TQ ::D= U _ GUOQ A Q_UPQZ%- %- - MZP MZg9 Z M e 5U QO %- - & - " DTQ MX_ TQX QP Q_ MNXU_T DQO U Z (D OUMX DOUQZOQ_ g R TQ :Z Q ZM U ZMX 2OMPQYe R 2_ ZMa UO_ :22 " DTQ QOQUbQP YMZeMcM P_ Na cM_ Q_ QOUMXXe aP R TQ 2ZP Qc 8" 9MXQe 8 XP YQPMX TM _TQ QOQUbQP R Y TQ::D= UZ %- ," ETQ 8MXX cMe 2cM P U_ _ Z_ QP Ne _" M OUM D" DYU T"

CD" =66 " =@G6 cM_ M U ZQQ UZ Q UZS Z FZU QP ?M U Z_ QRR _ QZ_a Q TQ QMOQRaXa_Q_ R a Q _ MOQ R bQ ( eQM _" DTQ c Q MN a TQ FZU QP ?M U Z_ 4 YYU QQ Z TQAQMOQRaX F_Q_ R @a Q D MOQ 4@AF@D R Y U _ QM Xe PMe_" 9Q Q _ ZMX QXM U Z_ cQ Q _OX _Q cU T O YYU QQ YQYNQ _ TM _TQ NQOMYQ ZQ R TQ bQ e RQc Q XQ cT cM_ MNXQT _ QOQ U Z_ cU T PQXQSM Q_ R Y N T TQ FZU QP DM Q_ MZP TQ R YQ D bUQ FZU Z UZ UZR YMX_Q UZS_ Y Q aZPQ _ MZPUZS Pa UZS TQ 4 XP HM eQM _" 3e TQ UYQ _TQ XQR TQ F"?" =QQTMP O bQ QP YMZ _ RXUST _ UZ _ MOQ MZP TQ Y Z MZP Q QP Z M SaYQZ _ bQ cT cZQPTQ UST _ a Q _ MOQ _QM_ MZP _M QXXU Q NU _" DTQ M QZPQP TQ MZZaMX :Z Q ZM U ZMX2_ ZMa UOMX 4 ZS Q__ MXX bQ TQ c XP MZP cM_ YQYNQ R TQ :Z Q ZM U ZMX :Z_ U a Q R D MOQ=Mc" ETQ =QQ = bQ 2cM P R YQYNQ _ R TQ cUZZUZS QMY UZ TQ MZR QP =MOT_ _ MOQ XMcY O a O Y Q U U Z cTUOT _TQ _a QP MZP M QZPQP QMOT eQM cU T UYYQZ_Q XQM_a Q MZPUZ Q Q_ cM_ Q_ MNXU_TQP UZ TQ T Z a Ne TQ RMYUXe MZP U_ _ Z_ QP Ne TQ M TQc MZP =QQ= bQ 7 aZPM U Z" DTQ M__QP McMe UZ & ,"

A2EC:4:2 " DE6C?D =6D=:6 :" E6??6?" :Z %-- RUbQ eQM _ MR Q TQ O Y Q U U Z _ M QPAM UOUM D Q Z_ MZP =Q_ EQZZQZ R TQ =Mc @RRUOQ_ R D Q Z_ MZP EQZZQZ UZ AT QZUd 2 Uf ZM

_QP TM MZ McM P NQ Q_QZ QP TQ NQ_ MXU_ R TQ H XP 7UZMX"ETQ 3 M P R 5U QO _MOOQ QP TU_ _MX SQ TQ cU T TQU RRQ g _ Z_ TQ McM P cTUOT TM_ _UZOQ NQO YQQ ZeY a_" AM UOUM MZP =Q_ TMbQ NQQZ MO UbQ YQYNQ _ R TQ :Z_ U a Q MZP TMbQ M UOU M QP UZ::D= O XX aUM R Y Q TMZg T QQ PQOMPQ_"g AM UOUM _Q bQP M_ M aPSQ A EQY R TQ M UO M4 aZ e Da Q U 4 a MZP MR Q _Q bUZS M_ M YQYNQ R TQ 3 M P gcM_ QXQO QP M_ MZ 9 Z M e5U QO R TQ ::D=" =Q_ Oa QZ Xe _Q bQ_ M_ 4 4TMU R TQ 4 a 4 YYU QQ MZP M_ =QSMX4 aZ_QX R TQ :Z Q ZM U ZMX 2OMPQYe R 2_ ZMa UO_ 9Q cM_ M UZ QP c Q Y_g M_ M4 YYU__U ZQ Z TQ 2 Uf ZM D MOQ 4 YYU__U Z MZP U_ M R YQ YQYNQ R TQ 3 M P R5U QO _ R TQ ::D=" 21

Page 24: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

E96 2?7C65 =249D EC@A9J

@Z Q YMZQZ PU_ XMe :Z Q ZM U ZMX 4 a R a_ UOQETQ 9MSaQ ETQ ?Q TQ XMZP_

22

Page 25: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

4@?E24E 56E2:=DC68:@?2= C@F?5D27C:42.=249D @@E 27C:421::D=H63"@C8

2D:2 A24:7:4.=249D @@E 2D:2A24:7:41::D=H63"@C8

6FC@A6.=249D @@E 6FC@A61::D=H63"@C8

?@CE9 2 6C:42.=249D @@E ?@CE92 6C:421::D=H63"@C8

255C6DD6D

:?E6C?2E:@?2= 2DEC@?2FE:42= 4@?8C6DD & % .6d 8aMPMXMVM M2bQZUPM M UMZ @ Q %(-- 8aMPMXMVM M () ) QdUOEQX. )& ' % ))

H@C=5 7:?2= @7 E96 @@E 4@FCE 4@ A6E:E:@?.AM MZUZR 6Z U aQ 5UMf 5Q =QóZ R TQ a_Q 5Q 2 Q_ FZUbQ _UPMP 5Q 8aMPMXMVM M2b" aá Qf ? " - ) 4 X ZUM 4QZ 4"A" ((% 8aMPMXMVM M MXU_O édUO

::D= 5:??6C.AMXMOU aZUOU MX 5Q KM MZ 2b 9UPMXS %)% KM MZ ()% MXU_O

23H XP 7UZMX & 9ePQ MNMP :ZPUM

Page 26: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

D Z_ _ R CQSU ZMX HUZZUZS EQMY_

24

? T 2YQ UOMZ EQMY.

2R UOMZ EQMY.

6a QMZ EQMY.

2_UM AMOURUO EQMY.

Page 27: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

�25

2PPU U ZMX D Z_ _

Page 28: IISL Moot Court Programme 2016 Draft 1 copy · dayymertqanxqy 4m_q4zoqzuzsdmoq5qnu_4yyqoumxdmoqrxustdqbuoq_ mzp=umnuxue 3mzot ébcm_mxum etqcqanxuor3mzot é mzptqcqanxuorcm_mxummqzqustnuzsoazuq_mzpntmq

7a TQ CQMPUZS

n 5E: D@FE9 27C:42

HHH"5E:"8@G"K2n 6=6G6? :?E6C?2E:@?2= AF3=:D9:?8.

HHH"6=6G6?AF3"4@n 6FC@A62? 46?EC6 7@C DA246 =2H 64D= .

HHH"6D2":?E DA64:2=D 64D=

n 6FC@A62? DA246 286?4J 6D2 .9EEA. HHH"6D2":?E 6D2

n 6I42=:3FC 2= 2K

HHH"6I42=:3FC2= 2K"4@n 96:?=6:? AC:K6

HHH"96:?=6:?AC:K6"4@n :?E6C?2E:@?2= 2DEC@?2FE:42= 7656C2E:@?.

HHH":272DEC@"@C8n :?E6C?2E:@?2= 4@FCE @7 FDE:46.

HHH":4 4: "@C8

n :?E6C?2E:@?2= :?DE:EFE6 @7 DA246 =2H ::D= .HHH"::D=H63"@C8

n 2A2? 26C@DA246 6IA=@C2E:@? 286?4J 2I2 .HHH" 2I2" A

n 2?7C65 =249D DA246 =2H @@E [email protected]"::D=H63"@C8 =249D @@E

n 2CE:?FD ?: 9@77 AF3=:D96CD.

HHH"3C:=="?=n @@? 6IAC6DD.

HHH" @@?6IAC6DD"4@n ?2D2

HHH"?2D2"8@G

n @3276 : 2H@=@H@ F?:G6C:EJHHH"@2F:76"65F"?8

n D64FC6 H@C=5 7@F?52E:@?.HHH"D64FC6H@C=57@F?52E:@?"@C8

n DC:?86C.

HHH"DAC:?86C"4@ gg

n F?:G6CD:EJ @7 8F252=2 2C2

HHH"F58" I

=249D @@E. HHH"72463@@ "4@ DA246 @@E

=249D @@E. EH:EE6C"4@ DA246=2H @@E

::D=. gg HHH"72463@@ "4@ DA246=2H

::D=. g 9EEA. HHH"=:? 65:?"4@ 8C@FAD08:5/%&( ) EC / J8LF8CAL@GC::D=. g 9EEAD. EH:EE6C"4@ ::D=LDA246

26