high-power stabilized lasers and optics of gw detectors
DESCRIPTION
High-Power Stabilized Lasers and Optics of GW Detectors. Rick Savage LIGO Hanford Observatory. Overview. In general, issues and hardware solutions from a LIGO perspective because of familiarity. - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
1LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
High-Power Stabilized Lasers and Optics of GW Detectors
Rick SavageLIGO Hanford Observatory
2LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Overview In general, issues and hardware solutions from a LIGO perspective
because of familiarity.» Other GW interferometers (GEO, LCGT, TAMA, Virgo) face similar
issues and have developed their own solutions Lasers
» Initial LIGO - ~10 watts– Requirements, performance
» Advanced LIGO ~ 200 watts– Concept, status
Optics» Initial and advanced LIGO core optics – test masses
– Requirements, performance
» Excess absorption in H1 interferometer optics– Efforts to identify absorption site
3LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
GW detector – laser and optics
Laser
end test mass
4 km (2 km) Fabry-Perotarm cavity
recyclingmirror input test mass
beam splitter
Power RecycledMichelsonInterferometerwith Fabry-PerotArm Cavities
Power RecycledMichelsonInterferometerwith Fabry-PerotArm Cavities
signal
4LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Closer look - more lasers and optics
5LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Pre-Stabilized Laser System
Laser source
Frequencypre-stabilizationand actuator forfurther stab.
Compensation for Earth tides
Power stab. inGW band
Power stab. at modulation freq.(~ 25 MHz)
6LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Initial LIGO 10-W laser Master Oscillator Power Amplifier
configuration (vs. injection-locked oscillator)
Lightwave Model 126 non-planar ring oscillator (Innolight)
Double-pass, four-stage amplifier» Four rods - 160 watts of laser diode pump
power
10 watts in TEM00 mode
7LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
LIGO I PSL performance
Running continuously since Dec. 1998 on Hanford 2k interferometer
Maximum output power has dropped to ~ 6 watts
Replacement of amplifier pump diode bars had restored performance in other units
Servo systems maintain lock indefinitely (weeks - months)
8LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Frequency stabilization Three nested control loops
» 20-cm fixed reference cavity
» 12-m suspended modecleaner
» 4-km suspended arm cavity Ultimate goal: f/f ~ 3 x 10-22
9LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Power stabilization In-band (40 Hz – 7 kHz) RIN
» Sensors located before and after suspended modecleaner
» Current shunt actuator - amp. pump diode current
3e-8/rtHz
RIN at 25 MHz mod. freq.» Passive filtering in 3-mirror
triangular ring cavity (PMC)
» Bandwidth (FWHM) ~ 3.2 MHz
10LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Earth Tide Compensation Up to 200 m over 4 km Prediction applied to ref.
cav. temp. (open loop) End test mass stack
fine actuators relieveuncompensated residual
100m
prediction residual
11LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Concept for Advanced LIGO laser
10 x 30W@ 808 nm
Master
Slave II
diode-boxes
power supplys contro lPC
2 x 30W@ 808 nm
output
Slave I
10 x 30W@ 808 nm
10 x 30W@ 808 nm
10 x 30W@ 808 nm
Pound-Drever-Hall Locking - Electronicoscilla tor, m ixer, phase-splitter, servo
Being developed by GEO/LZH
Injection-locked, end-pumped slave lasers
180 W output with 1200 W of pump light
12LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Brassboard Performance LZH/MPI Hannover Integrated front end based on
GEO 600 laser – 12-14 watts High-power slave – 195 watts
M2 < 1.15
13LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Concept for Advanced LIGO PSL
m ed iump ow ersta ge
hig hp ow ersta ge
susp end e dm od e cle a ner
NPR O
refe re nceca vity
AOM
tid al fee d b ackD ia gno stic
sp atia lfi lte r
ca vity
I 4
I 1
I 2
I 3
I 5
1 2 3
4
FS S- A2
FS S
ILS2
ILS1 PS S2
PS S3
FS S- A1
PM C 1
PM C 2
PS S1
14LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Core Optics – Test Masses Low-absorption fused silica substrates
» 25 cm dia. x 10 cm thick, 20 kg Low-loss ion beam coatings Suspended from single loop of music wire (0.3 mm) Rare-earth magnets glued to face and side for
orientation actuation Internal mode Qs > 2e6
15LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
LIGO I core optics
Caltech data RITM ~ 14 km (sagitta ~ 0.6 ) ; RETM ~ 8 km
Surface uniformity ~ /100 over 20 cm. dia. (~ 1 nm rms) “Super-polished” – micro-roughness < 1 Angstrom Scatter (diffuse and aperture diffraction) < 30 ppm Substrate absorption < 4 ppm/cm Coating absorption < 0.5 ppm
16LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Adv. LIGO Core Optics LIGO recently chose fused silica over sapphire
» Familiarity and experience with polishing, coating, suspending, thermally compensating, etc. – less perceived risk
Other projects (e.g. LCGT) still pursuing sapphire test masses Thermal noise in coatings expected to be greatest challenge
sapphirefused silica38 cm dia., 15.4 cm thick, 38 kg
17LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Processing, Installation and Alignment
Experience indicatesthat processing andhandling may besource of optical loss
gluingvacuum bakingwet cleaningsuspendingbalancingtransporting
18LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Thermal Issues Circulating power in arm cavities
» ~ 25 kW for inital LIGO
» ~ 600 kW for adv. LIGO Substrate bulk absorption
» ~ 4 ppm/cm for initial LIGO
» ~ 0.5 ppm/cm ($) for adv. LIGO Coating absorption
» ~ 0.5 ppm for initial & adv. LIGO Thermo-optic coefficient
» dn/dT ~ 8.7 ppm/degK Thermal expansion coefficient
» 0.55 ppm/degK “Cold” radius of curvature of
optics adjusted for expected “hot” state
radius
dept
h
Surface absorption
Bulk absorption
19LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Coating vs. substrate absorption
0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1 0.12 0.14-1.4
-1.2
-1
-0.8
-0.6
-0.4
-0.2
0x 10
-6
radius (m)
OP
D (
m)
Optical Path Difference in Transmission for 1 W absorbtion
CoatingSubstrate
0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1 0.12 0.14-1.4
-1.2
-1
-0.8
-0.6
-0.4
-0.2
0x 10
-7
radius (m)
OP
D (
m)
Surface Distortion in for 1 W absorbtion
CoatingSubstrate
Optical path difference Surface distortion
OPD almost same for same amount of power absorbed in coating or substrate Power absorbed in coating causes more surface distortion than same power
absorbed in bulk
20LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Thermal compensation system
CO2 Laser
?
Over-heat Correction
Inhomogeneous Correction
Under-heat Correction
ZnSe Viewport ITM
PRM
SRM
ITM
ITM
Compensation Plates
Adv. LIGOconcept
21LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Anomalous absorption in H1 ifo.
ITMY
ITMX
Negative values imply annulusheating
Significantly more absorption in BS/ITMX than in ITMY
How to identify absorption site?
TCS power is absorbedin HR coatings of ITMs
22LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Need for remote diagnostics
Water absorption in viton spring seats makes vacuum incursions very costly.
» Even with dry air purge, experience indicatesthat 1-2 weeks pumping required per 8 hours vented before beam tubes can be exposed to chambers
Development of remote diagnostics to develop which optics responsible of excess absorption
23LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Spot size measurements
ITMX
ITMY
BeamView CCD cameras in ghost beams from AR coatings
Lock ifo. w/o TCS heating Measure spot size changes as ifo.
cools from full lock state Curvature change in ITMX path
about twice that in ITMY path
24LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Arm cavity g factor changes Again, lock full ifo. w/o TCS heating, break lock, lock single arm and
measure arm cavity g factor at precise intervals after breaking lock g factor change in Xarm larger than Yarm by factor of ~ 1.6 Calibrate with TCS (ITM-only surface absorption)
25LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Results and options Beamsplitter not significant
absorber ITMX is a significant
absorber~ 25 mW/watt incident
ITMY absorption also high~ 10 mW/watt incident» Factor of ~5 greater than
absorption in H2 or L1 ITMs Options
» Try to clean ITMX in situ
» Replace ITMX
» Higher power TCS system 30-watt TCS laser presently
being tested
ITM bulk
ITM surface
ET
M s
urfa
ce
26LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Measurement Technique
Dynamic resonance of light in Fabry-Perot cavities (Rakhmanov, Savage, Reitze, Tanner 2002 Phys. Lett. A, 305
239). Laser frequency to
PDH signal transfer function, H(s), has cusps at multiples of FSR and features at freqs. related to the phase modulation sidebands.
27LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Misaligned cavity
Features appear at frequencies related to higher-order transverse modes. Transverse mode spacing: ftm = f01- f00 = (ffsr/ acos (g1g2)1/2
g1,2 = 1 - L/R1,2
Infer mirror curvature changes from transverse mode spacing freq. changes. This technique proposed by F. Bondu, Aug. 2002.
Rakhmanov, Debieu, Bondu, Savage, Class. Quantum Grav. 21 (2004)
S487-S492.
28LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
H1 data – Sept. 23, 2003
• Lock a single arm
• Mis-align input beam (MMT3) in yaw
• Drive VCO test input (laser freq.)
• Measure TF to ASPD Qmon or Imon signal
• Focus on phase of feature near 63 kHz
2ffsr- ftm
29LIGO-G050251-00-W 2005 CLEO/QELS Joint Symposium on Gravitational Wave Detection
Data and (lsqcurvefit) fits.
Assume metrology value for RETMx = 7260 mMetrology value for ITMx = 14240 m
ITMx TCS annulus heating decrease in ROC (increase in curvature)
R = 14337 m R = 14096 m