harrah's entertainment, inc
DESCRIPTION
Case Analysis of Harrah's Entertainment Inc. using Harvard Business Case Study Model and Lewin's Action Research Model.TRANSCRIPT
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.:
Rewarding Our People
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.:
Rewarding Our People
2
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding Our People
Agenda
• Background• Front Burner Issue• External Environment• Internal Environment• HR Gap Analysis• Strategic Issues Facing The Firm• Action Research Model• Conclusion• References
3
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding Our People
Background
• Harrah’s History– Fortune 500 public gaming corporation– Headquarters based in Paradise, Nevada– Annual revenues of $8.9 billion
• New operating strategy in 1997– From service driven to customer focus
• Key Personnel: – Phil Satre becomes President / COO in 1991 & CEO in
1994– Gary Loveman was hired COO / CMO in 1999 & current
CEO since 2004– Marylin Winn, offered VP of HR in 1999
(Source: Delong & Vijayaraghavan, 2003) (Source: Wikipedia, 2013)
4
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding Our People
Front Burner Issue
How to motivate employees with current incentive plan or newly designed
programs to improve customer service metrics at each of Harrah’s
establishments?
“How do you change the working premise of our people from being controlled by the limitations
to realizing their possibilities”By Gary Loveman, Chief Operating Officer, Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc. (Source:
Delong & Vijayaraghavan, 2003)
5
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding Our People
External Environment: Key Success Factors
• Service Differentiation Customer Service
• Brand Recognition• Customer Loyalty• Attractions• Marketing• Number & Type of Game Offerings• Physical Environment & Atmosphere
6
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding Our People
External Environment: PEST Analysis
• State regulations influence who can gamble, where, and what types
Political & Legal
• Fluctuations can impact business
• Labor market demographics
Economic
• September 11Social/Cultural
• Information Management Systems
• Player equipmentTechnological
7
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding Our People
External Environment: Porter’s 5 Forces
Substitutes
Suppliers
Buyers New Entrants
Rivalry
Moderate
Weak Moderate
Weak-Moderate
Strong
•Internet gambling/ gaming•Resort vacations•Cruises
•Low switching costs•Harrah’s buys in high volumes
•Consumers•Price sensitivity•Economic conditions
•High barriers to entry •Economic conditions• Regulations•Highly profitable industry
•MGM Mirage•Park Place•Strong brand recognition
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding Our People
Internal Environment
Bbmbnmm,m,mjkj
8
Strengths
Competitive
MindsetRewarding Hard WorkLowering TurnoverIncreased Customer Satisfactio
n
WeaknessHigh Expectations
Impacted Psychological Contract
No Ties to Operating IncomeCompetitors Copying
StrategyOpportunities
Re-evaluate Incentive Program
Create Ties to Operating Income
Set targets for Customer Satisfaction
Solicit Feedback From Employees
Threats Maintainin
g a Competiti
ve Advantage
Intense Competiti
onLegal and Regulator
y Environme
ntOnline
Gaming
SWOT(Source: Delong &
Vijayaraghavan, 2003) (Source: Datamonitor ,
2007)
9
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding Our People
HR Gap Analysis
• Harrah’s HR Gap Analysis– Is a tool used to compare actual employee satisfaction
with potential employee satisfaction.– Is Harrah’s HR strategy bringing the company to the
next level?
• How effective is Harrah’s HR Strategy?• Where does Harrah’s HR strategy want to be in the
future?“
"My job is to make money for Harrah's Entertainment by creating a great climate for
customers and employees.“By Marilyn Winn, VP of HR, Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc. (Source: Abowitz, 2010)
10
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding Our People
HR Gap Analysis
• How effective is Harrah’s HR Strategy?– Reduce the turnover rate– Implemented job application and interview processes– A new reward system was instituted – The entire property had to increase its scores to benefit– To maximize customer’s positive experiences
• Where does Harrah’s HR strategy want to be in the future?– Needs to motivate, encourage, solicit buy-in from all employees– Remove blinders from decision-making by self-analyzing the
strategy – Must develop a feedback loop mechanism – Implement a reward system that would recognize employees’
contribution (Source: Young, 2011)
11
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding Our People
Strategic Issues Facing The Firm
• How to implement Harrah’s customer relationship strategy?
• How to maintain a competitive advantage by utilising key performance indicators in the gaming industry?
• How to implement a gain-sharing program that would recognize employees contribution based on the achieved target?
• How does Harrah’s decrease its volatility by predominantly being in the in the U.S. market?
12
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding Our People
Action Research Model - Step 1: Gathering DataType of Information
Needed• How employees
view management• What motivates
employees• Who wants to learn
what• Why headquarters
and operations do not get along how to integrate the two cultures
How to get the Info
• Employee and management surveys
• Observation• Interviews • Company document
reviews• Anonymous
employee comment drop boxes
13
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding Our People
Action Research Model - Step 2: Feedback
The “What” of Feedback• Important findings from data gathering such as:– Management’s view of themselves vs. Employee’s view– Potential causes of problems– Correlations between customer service and financials
The “How” of Feedback– Comparison charts– Compilation of best and worst sample surveys and interview
notes– “Sandwich Critiquing”– Comments and ideas always welcome (open
communication)
14
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding Our People
Action Research Model - Step 3: Diagnosis
• Management acts strictly like management leadership?
• Employees feel demotivated by compensation system difficulty reaching incentives
• Employees want intrinsic as well as extrinsic rewards; i.e. Pride in company and monetary rewards
• Headquarters and management are decreasing productivity due to lack of communication and collaboration
15
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding Our People
Action Research Model - Step 4: Action Planning
• Communicate to everyone why, how, and when changes are going to occur
• Hire new employees that fit learning culture• Implement job rotation and job shadowing to
encourage leadership potential• Succession planning• Create realistic performance objectives• Provide leadership training to management• Educate operations personnel and
headquarters personnel
16
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding Our People
Action Research Model - Step 5: Action Taking/ Interventions
Organizational Learning Interventions– Encourage learning as part of culture – Job rotation & job shadowing
• 5 Disciplines to Becoming a Learning Organization1. Personal Mastery2. Building a Shared Vision3. Mental Models4. Team Learning5. Systems Thinking
(Source: Senge, 1990)
17
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding Our People
Action Research Model - Step 5: Action Taking/ Interventions
Structural Interventions Geared Towards Becoming a Learning Organization
• Define performance objectives – Goal setting interventions: instructs employees about the
goal setting process and how to set specific goals (Source: Saks & Haccoun, 2010)
• Have employees help create these objectives– Self-coaching: reflection of one’s own performance to
establish performance maintenance and improved goals– Upward feedback: providing employees with data on the
frequency with which they displayed desired behaviors (Source: Saks & Haccoun, 2010)
18
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding Our People
Action Research Model - Step 5: Action Taking/ Interventions
Management Development Interventions
• Educate managers on their functions:1. Controlling (less)2. Organizing3. Planning4. Leading (Emphasis)• Interpersonal Skill Assessment• Interpersonal Skill Learning• Interpersonal Skill Practice• Interpersonal Skill Transfer
(Source: Saks & Haccoun, 2010)
19
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding Our People
Action Research Model - Step 6: Evaluation
• Follow up with all managers and employees
• Communicate : (open communication)–Outcomes on a daily basis debriefing at
end of shifts/ workdays–Debriefing at end of week, month, year–Areas still in need of improvement– Take any suggestions on how to improve–Outline where improvements have been
made
20
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding Our People
Action Research Model - Step 6: Evaluation
Monitor and Evaluate• Productivity• Revenues• Employee Turnover/Retention Rates• Customer Satisfaction- Surveys• Employee Satisfaction- Surveys• Compare employee comment box items• Change where needed
21
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding Our People
Conclusion
• At the heart of any company’s successful strategies, employees are always the key.
• Employees are the ones who carry out the plans crafted by upper management.
• Not enough to incentivize employees to partake in organizational strategies.
• Corporate strategic plans must have a set target.
22
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding Our People
Questions?
23
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding Our People
References
Abowitz, R. (2010, May 25). The Movable Buffet: Rallying with Marilyn Winn. Retrieved March 21, 2013, from Los Angeles Times: http://articles.latimes.com/2010/may/25/entertainment/la-ca-vegas-20100523
Business Week. (2006). Top 10 Casino Racetracks in the U.S. Retrieved March 19, 2013, from http://images.businessweek.com/ss/07/06/0604_racetracks/source/8.htm
Datamonitor . (2007, January). Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Company Profile. Retrieved March 21, 2013, from Datamonitor : https://wiki.umn.edu/pub/Carter/WebHome/Harrahs.pdf
Delong, T., & Vijayaraghavan, V. (2003). Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding Our People . Boston: Harvard Business School Publishing.
Kim, R. ( 2012, July 31). Info 563 Reflection: Harrah's . Retrieved March 19, 2013, from http://kimdongoug.blogspot.ca/2012/07/info-563-reflection-harrahs.html
Saks, A., & Haccoun, R. (2010). Managing performance through training and development. 5th Edition. Toronto: Nelson Education.
Seeklogo. (2008). Harrah's - Logo Vector Download . Retrieved March 19, 2013Senge, P. (1990). The fifth discipline: The art and practice of the learning organization. New York:
Doubleday.Wikipedia. (2013, March 18). Caesars Entertainment Corporation. Retrieved March 20, 2013, from
Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caesars_Entertainment_Corporation
Young, M.-L. (2011, April 27). Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc.: Rewarding our People. Retrieved March 21, 2013, from Word Press: http://michaellouisyoung.wordpress.com/2011/04/07/harrahs-entertainment-inc-rewarding-our-people/