catching rays in the bahamas - stanford...

43
Catching Rays in the Bahamas Acoustic Detection of Ultra-High Energy Neutrinos http://hep.stanford.edu/neutrino/SAUND/ Justin Vandenbroucke Stanford / Berkeley [email protected] Rome October 3, 2003

Upload: others

Post on 26-Aug-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Catching Rays in the BahamasAcoustic Detection of Ultra-High Energy Neutrinos

http://hep.stanford.edu/neutrino/SAUND/

Justin VandenbrouckeStanford / Berkeley

[email protected]

RomeOctober 3, 2003

Page 2: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Thanks to my SAUND collaborators:Current:

M. Buckingham (Scripps)G. Gratta (Stanford)J. Vandenbroucke (Stanford, now at Berkeley)

Past:S. Adam (Stanford, now at Cornell)T. Berger (Scripps)N. Lehtinen (Stanford, now at Hawaii)Y. Zhao (Stanford)

And to AUTEC and the U. S. Navy:D. BelascoJ. CecilD. DeveauD. KapolkaT. Kelly-Bissonnette

Page 3: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Cosmic ray spectrum

Page 4: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

The Greisen-Zatsepin-Kuzmin (GZK) cutoff

1 event / km2 / century → detector innovation key!

Page 5: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Cosmic ray showers

Page 6: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

So what?

A crossroads of exciting physics- active galactic nuclei- gamma ray bursts- grand unified theories- topological defects (magnetic monopoles, cosmic strings, domain walls)- supersymmetry- dark matter- Lorentz invariance violation- extra dimensions- gravity at a TeV

All key to understanding the universe!

Page 7: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Charged particles in fluids → sound!

- first discussion of the ideaG. A. Askaryan Sov. J. Atom. Energy 3 (1957) 921

- extensive theoretical analysisJ. G. Learned Phys. Rev. D 19 (1979) 3293

- experimental confirmationL. Sulak et al. NIM 161 (1979) 203

- sensitivity studies towards a neutrino telescopeN. Lehtinen et al. Astroparticle Physics 17 (2002) 279—292

- growing interest in acoustic arraysStanford workshop on acoustic cosmic ray and neutrino detection,September 2003 http://hep.stanford.edu/neutrino/SAUND/workshop

Page 8: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Expected neutrino signal

Page 9: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Ocean as particle detector

N. Lehtinen

Page 10: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Extreme pancakes

Page 11: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

The Tongue Of The Ocean (TOTO)

Page 12: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

The Atlantic Undersea Test and Evalutation Center (AUTEC)

Page 13: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

AUTEC hydrophones

SAUND (7 km2)

Page 14: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

The SAUND array

Page 15: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Hydrophones on sea floor

Page 16: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Site 3

Page 17: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Site 3

Page 18: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

DAQ

Page 19: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

DAQHardware- 1.7 GHz Pentium 4- ADC card- 60 GB external hard drive

Software- digital matched filter- variable threshold- 179 kHz sampling- 60 events/minute target- 1-2 GB / 24 hrs

Page 20: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Adaptive threshold

Page 21: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Calibration sources

Page 22: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

21 events per lightbulb

Page 23: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Sea surface reflection

Page 24: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Sea floor reflection

Page 25: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Direct signal

Page 26: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Lightbulb positions reconstructed

Page 27: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Lightbulb positions reconstructed

Page 28: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Lightbulb depths reconstructed

Page 29: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Lightbulb energies reconstructed

Bulb Depth (m) P (kPa) E0 (J)1 160 1563 2342 107 1047 1573 139 1360 2044 166 1626 2445 126 1237 1866 101 990 1487 86 838 1268 135 1324 1999 188 1842 276

10 290 2846 427

Page 30: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Integrated livetime

- 70% duty cycle- 211 days live- 25 million events- 350 GB

Page 31: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Five-phone coincidence

Require1) Events obey causality: tij < dij /vsound

2) Geometry consistent with pancake (2D circle) shape:

accepted:

rejected:

Page 32: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

AUTEC sound velocity profile (SVP)

Page 33: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Refraction

Page 34: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Refraction shadow

Page 35: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Refracted pancake

Page 36: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Time difference of arrival (TDOA) localization achieved

Page 37: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Localization → energy reconstruction

Page 38: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Example of a five-phone event

Page 39: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Example of a five-phone event

Page 40: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Page 41: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Neutrino flux limits

...SAUND limits coming soon

Page 42: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Conclusions

What we have learnedRefraction significant > 1 kmcsound = clight / 200,000 !!(Distinguishable) backgrounds exist~1021 eV threshold (1.5 km array spacing)

What is nextEfficiency checksFlux limits

Onward and downward (SAUND-II)On to more phones, collecting area (250 km2), computingDown to the Gaussian floor

Page 43: Catching Rays in the Bahamas - Stanford Universitysaund.stanford.edu/saund1/talks/vandenbroucke_roma.pdf · October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

October 3, 2003 Justin Vandenbroucke Rome

Thanks to my SAUND collaborators:Current:

M. Buckingham (Scripps)G. Gratta (Stanford)J. Vandenbroucke (Stanford, now at Berkeley)

Past:S. Adam (Stanford, now at Cornell)T. Berger (Scripps)N. Lehtinen (Stanford, now at Hawaii)Y. Zhao (Stanford)

And to AUTEC and the U. S. Navy:D. BelascoJ. CecilD. DeveauD. KapolkaT. Kelly-Bissonnette

More information:http://hep.stanford.edu/neutrino/SAUND

[email protected]