ankush report
TRANSCRIPT
A
Project Report
On
Training & Development
At
D.S. Kulkarni Developers Limited
Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirement for the award of degree of
Master in Personnel Management
Submitted to
University of Pune
By:
Ankush Agarwal
MPM
Sinhgad Business School, Pune City, Pune
September 2009
1
BONAFIDE CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that Mr. Ankush Agarwal studying in the third semester of
Masters of Personnel Management programme of University of Pune is a
Bonafide student of Sinhgad Business School, Pune City.
Director
Sinhgad Business School.
Pune City.
2
STUDENTS DECLARATION
I hereby declare that project entitled Training and development at
DSK TOYOTA submitted in the partial fulfillment for the degree
of MPM to PUNE UNIVERSITY, India is my original Work and
not submitted for the award of any other degree, follow ship or any
other
Similar title.
ANKUSH AGARWAL
PLACE: PUNE
DATE:
3
APPROVAL CERTIFICATE
The Project Report of
Mr. Ankush Agarwal
D.S. Kulkarni Developers Limited-Training & Development
is approved and is acceptable in quality and form.
Internal Examiner External Examiner
Signature: __________ Signature: ___________
Name: _____________ Name: ______________
4
PREFACE
Training and Development is a field concerned with workplace
learning to improve performance. Such training can generally be
categorized as On-the-Job training and Off-the job training.
On-the-job training describes it as a training, which is given in a
normal working situation using actual tools, documents,
equiptments or materials that is used when fully trained. It is
effective for vocation work.
Off the job training takes place away from normal work situation,
which means that employee is not regarded as productive worker
when training process takes place. An advantage of this type of
training is that it allows people to get away from work and totally
concentrate on training being given. This is most effective for
training attitude, concepts and ideas.
5
GUIDE`S CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that the Project Report entitled
D.S. Kulkarni Developers Limited-Training & Development
Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirement for the award of degree of
Master of Personnel Management
Of
University of Pune
Ankush Agarwal
has worked under my supervision and guidance and that the project report is
the original work of the student.
CERTIFIED
6
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I owe a deep sense of gratitude to all those people from whom i
received help and advice in completing this project. Though it is
impossible to return what I have received during my project at
DSK TOYOTA., remembering them through this
acknowledgement is a humble endeavor to convey my gratitude
towards them.
I am very thankful to Mr. DHANANJAY PACHPOR DGM -
HRD for giving his precious time to help me.
I am also thankful to Mr. SHIRISH KULKARNI EXECUTIVE
DIRECTOR for his guidance and timely advice at every stage
towards completion of the project.
I am again thankful to all employees of D.S. KULKARNI
DEVELOPERS LTD. for their co-operation in completion of the
project.
Last but not the least I extend my heart felt gratitude to my faculty
members for their valuable suggestion and help.
7
INDEX
SERIAL NUMBERS
CONTENTSPAGE
NUMBERS
1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY a) Introduction 9
b) Objectives of Study 10
c) Research Methodology 11-13
d) Findings 14
e) Suggestions 14
f) Conclusion 15
g) Theoretical Aspects of Training 16-25
2 COMPANY PROFILE 26-32
3 PROJECT OVERVIEW
a) Objectives of Study 33
b) Quality Procedure of Training 37
c)Different Training Procedures at DSK
TOYOTA42
d) Questionnaire 46
e) Findings 63
f) Suggestions 65
g) Conclusion 68
5 BIBLIOGRAPHY 83
6 ANNEXURE 84
8
INTRODUCTION
Convergence of theory into practice has its mere objective that it should
provide resultant factor as desired factor. Observing certain perceptions
through some practical training is the domain of management courses and it
has its very strong and vital importance. It exposes me towards the actual
work situation and gives me, some influence and inference of the various
processes that flows in manufacturing industry and service industries. Sixty
days practical training is though a requirement for the degree of Master of
Personnel Management, yet it played a great advantageous role to me.
The object of the project is to study “What is the effect of Training &
Development towards employees in an organization like DSK TOYOTA”.
While undergoing the project I was able to understand how organizations
work for the development of the employees and while doing so also abide to
the laws of the Union of India for the same purpose.
Contribution of T&D towards Business Success at DSK Toyota covers all
the aspects relating to the development of the employees as well as workers.
Every month there is a training program for each and every member of the
organization.
9
During my project I got a great chance to measure the Contribution of
Training & Development in DSK TOYOTA.
10
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
OBJECTIVE OF STUDY:
1. Primary Objective:
a. To obtain the required knowledge of the subject as a
student of management.
b. To study the existing training System of the
company.
c. To study the different types of training program
being followed at DSK TOYOTA.
d. Give suggestions to improve the existing procedure and
hence improve the effectiveness of the Training
Program..
11
Research methodology
Research is the systematic design, collection, analysis, reporting
and interpretation of a specific problem or situation. The research
methodology for this project is as follows:-
Research refers to a search of knowledge. It is a scientific and
systematic search for pertinent information on a specific topic.
It is an art of scientific investigation.
Movement from known to unknown.
Voyage of discovery.
Original contribution to the existing stocks of knowledge
making for its advancement.
Research Types:
1. Descriptive Research.
2. Exploratory Research.
3. Analytical Research.
4. Applied Research.
12
5. Fundamental Research.
6. Quantitative Research.
7. Qualitative Research.
8. Conceptual Research.
9. Empirical Research.
I have chosen descriptive research to study The Effect of Training
& Development on employees at DSK Toyota.
Descriptive research is an attempt to describe systematically a
situation, problem, service or program and provide information of
living condition of a commodity or decision and attitudes towards
issue. The objective of such a study is to answer the “who, what,
when, where, and how” of the subject under investigation.
Type of data
Primary data
Primary data are original data gathered by the researchers for the
project at hand. Primary data can be collected by two methods
13
observation and communication. Primary data are gathered for a
specific research project.
Method of research
Observation method
In this method fresh data can be gathered by observing relevant
sets and settings. The data are collected through observations. We
may observe and record observations.
Instrument used for data collection
Questionnaire method
A questionnaire consists of questions presented to the respondents
for their answers. In this project I used structured interview
questionnaire. It contained open & closed ended questions.
14
FINDINGS
Training is conducted very effectively at DSK TOYOTA. TEI is found
as around 75% against the targeted 70%.
2 Gaps in existing Training Procedure
Sometimes Training is conducted on activity base
Training group formed is not at the same knowledge base
The groups of employees formed to attend the training program
are not at the same knowledge base. Some employees who already
have desired knowledge end up in sitting for a full-day training
session where only half of the information is relevant to them. This is
a loss in productivity of the company
SUGGESTIONS
Competency Based Approach to Training Needs Analysis.
Six critical steps are there for identifying the training needs.
1. Identify competency or success factors.
2. Build profiles
3. Assess employees
4. Identify gaps
5. Identify development options
6. Follow through
15
CONCLUSION
Training is conducted very effectively in DSK TOYOTA. The
training effectiveness for month of July is at 75% as compared to
70%. With some initial effort of planning DSK TOYOTA can
create a useful and relevant process for assessing employees and
jobs in order to pinpoint development needs
16
THEORETICAL ASPECTS OF TRAINING
TRAINING AND DEVELOPMENT
Training and Development - refers to imparting specific
skills, abilities and knowledge to an employee.
Need for training and development is determined by the
employee’s performance deficiency, which is computed as-
Training - It is a process of imparting skills that are specific in
nature.
Development- Learning opportunities designed to help employees
grow. It is more knowledge oriented and less skill oriented. It is
more about business environment and human relations.
Training and Development Need = Standard Performance – Actual Performance
17
Distinguish between training and development.
Training
Short term
Generally for non-managerial
personnel
It is basically organized for
technical and mechanical
operations
Training for specific job-
related purpose
Development
Long term
Used for managerial personnel
Theoretical, conceptual ideas
Development is for enhancing
general knowledge
18
Need For Training
The need for the training of employees is mainly for the following
purposes:
Newly recruited employees require training so as to perform
their tasks effectively.
Training is necessary to prepare existing employees for
higher-level jobs (promotion).
Existing employees require refresher training so as to keep
abreast of the latest developments in job operations.
Training is necessary when a person moves from one job to
another (transfer).
Training is necessary to make employees mobile and
versatile.
19
Importance of training
Training makes employees more effective and productive. It
is actively and intimately connected with all the personnel or
managerial activities. It is an integral part of the whole
management program.
Training is a practical and vital necessity because it enables
employees to develop and rise within the organization, and
increase their market value and job security.
The training process
The important steps in a typical training process are as under:
Assessment
Implementation
Evaluation
20
Needs assessment diagnoses present problems and future
challenges to be met through training and development.
Needs assessment occurs at two levels- group and individual.
An individual needs training when his/her performance falls short
of standards. It may be due to lack of skill or knowledge or any
other problem, which can be remedied by imparting training.
Assessment of training needs occurs at group level too. Any
change in the organization’s strategy necessitates training of
groups of employees.
Training needs can be identified through the following types of
analysis:
Organizational analysis: involves the study of entire organization
in terms of its objectives, its resources, etc
Task or role analysis: this is a detailed examination of a job, its
component, it's various operations and conditions under which it
has to be performed.
Manpower analysis: the focus is on the individual in a given job.
21
Identify Training Objectives
Once the training needs are identified, objectives should be set
to begin meeting these needs.
Objective
Innovative
Anticipating problems
Team building sessions with the depts.
Problems Solving
Training clerks to reduce complaints
Training supervisors in communications to reduce grievances.
Regular
Orientation
Recurring training of interviewers.
Refresher courses on safety procedures
22
Training Methods
Training methods are usually classified by the location of
instruction. Some of the widely used training methods are:
Lectures: Verbal presentation of information by an instructor to a
large audience. It can be used for very large groups and the cost
incurred is low. Mainly used in colleges and universities.
Audio visuals: includes television slides, films, etc. these are
generally used to provide a wide range of realistic examples of job
conditions and situations in the condensed period of time.
On-The-Job Training (OJT) majority of the industrial trainingthe
OTJ type. OJT is conducted at the work site and in the context of
the job. Often it is informal, as when an experienced worker shows
a trainee how to perform the job tasks.
Programmed instruction (PI) This training is offered without the
intervention of a trainer. Information is provided in blocks, either
in a book form. After reading through the material the trainee must
answer a question about it.
23
Simulation: It is an attempt to create a realistic decision-making
environment for the trainee.
Case study: A written description of an actual situation in business,
which triggers the thought process of the reader.
Role-playing: Focuses on emotional issues rather than actual ones.
It creates a realistic situation where trainees assume the parts of
specific personalities in the situation.
Vestibule training: utilizes equipment, which closely resembles the
actual ones used on the job. The training takes place away from the
work environment.
Sensitivity training: This is done in order to make the trainees
aware of their and other’s behavior. Here the trainer is passive.
Implementation of the training programme
Once the training programme has been designed it needs to be
implemented
24
Programme implementation involves action on the following lines:
1. Deciding location and organizing training and other facilities.
2. Scheduling the training programme
3. Conducting the programme
4. Monitoring the progress of trainees.
Evaluation of the programme
The last stage in the training process is the evaluation of results.
Usefulness of the training is judged/determined in this stage.
Need For Evaluation
The main objective of evaluation is to determine the
accomplishment of specific training objectives that is correcting
performance deficiencies. It also predicts the cost effectiveness of
the programme.
Evaluation is useful to explain programme failure, should it occur.
The credibility of training is greatly enhanced when it is proved
that the organization has been benefited from it.
25
Methods of evaluation:
Various methods can be used to collect data on the outcomes of
training, some of these are:
Questionnaires: questionnaires could be used to obtain
opinions, views, etc
Tests: standard tests can be conducted whether trainees
have learnt or not?
Interviews : It can be organized to know the usefulness of
training.
Studies: Studies can be carried out to elicit the opinions and
judgments of trainers
Human Resource Factors: Training can be evaluated by
analyzing employee satisfaction
Cost Benefit Analysis: The cost incurred for the training
can be compared with its value in order to evaluate a
training programme
Feedback: the training evaluator should follow it up to
ensure effective implementation of training programme
26
Reason For Selection Of
The Topic
In today’s era of competitive market, there are many
manufactures for the same product. To ensure the named
position in the market the organization needs to improve the
quality of the product and provide the best quality product to
the customers at the cheapest rates. This will result in more
sales, more sales means more profit.
To achieve this strategy, the organization has to train
and develop its most valuable resource i.e. Human Resource.
Only a well-trained human resource can introduce quality
products.
In view of the above, I have decided to study the
“Training and Development” activities in an organization
27
which will help me to work in the HR field and contribute
my best efforts in the organization where I’ll be working in
the future.
The project includes a detail study of the Employee
Training & Development Programs conducted in DSK
Toyota. This does a study on the Training Process, i.e. how
the Training Program is conducted in DSK Toyota.
The project includes the study of the different types of
Training Programs conducted & also to whom the Training
is given.
The project also includes the detail study of the
effectiveness of the Training Programmes conducted in DSK
Toyota. Training is considered successful only if the desired
outcome is achieved.
28
COMPANY PROFILE
29
The DSK group, a 1500 crore group, headed by the dynamic
D.S. KULKARNI, has started business in 1970. They ventured
In the field of construction since 1981 and various other business
Like Information Technology, Car Dealership, Hotels,
Engineering, Chemical, Trading House Imports and Exports since
1996.
MISSION STATEMENT
“We are committed to provide personalized, error free & quality service to all our customers with speed & smile.”
30
Values of DSK TOYOTA In order to realize the Company’s mission, and play an effective role in the
emerging operating environment, DSK Toyota made Corporate Values an
integral part of our decision making process. The Company aims to:
Consistently provide top quality products with prompt and efficient
service to ensure customer satisfaction.
Be cost effective and emphasize on high productivity and profitability.
Expedite redressal of employee, customer and shareholder grievances.
Motivate employees for professional and social advancement at all levels
in a participative environment.
Develop capabilities and enhance effectiveness of employees through
training and career planning.
Reward shareholders with consistently good returns.
31
New Land Cruiser
The Pride of the World : The legendary Land Cruiser, a truly dominant 4WD vehicle, has been routinely taming the wildest terrains on earth for over 50 years. In the process, it has become an essential part of the lives of a wide variety of people around the world. The legend continues with the new Land Cruiser, the natural successor to the line and a continuing symbol of strength and reliability. And like its forebears, the new kind of 4WD is fully aware of its responsibility to do no harm to Mother Earth.......
Altis Sport
Sport the Envy : Aerodynamics exteriors meet aesthetic interiors to shape an athletic new sedan. The Limited Edition Altis Sport, outlined with bold new design cues you’d love to sport. Dressed in a suave new metallic grey and a cool metallic silver. And just to keep it ultra-exclusive, there are only 300 cars. For the discerning few that play the big game.......
Innova
32
Innovating to provide All you desire : TOYOTA KNOWS THE ROADS OF THE WORLD. This unmatched expertise and experience has been combined with a deep understanding of what owners look for in their cars to giva shape to a never-before automobile, The Toyota Innova. The Innova is a result of a unique process that has broken new grounds in the way automobiles are created. The Innova brings together qualities never before seen together in an automobile. Fantastic ride quality and luxury coupled with versatile space; superior performance and driving pleasure with world class safety, advanced styling with solid durability.......
Camry
Toyota's flagship Prestige sedan. It delivers the highest standards of driving refinement and performance. The Camry's spacious, luxurious and quite cabin has a finely crafted interior that provide unparalleled comfort. The driver and passengers are provided with an array of thoughtful amenitities designed for....
33
Corolla Altis
Once in a lifetime, comes a car that redefines luxury and style. Which looks and feels like it belongs to a class above. And provides a driving experience so far beyond anything you’ve experienced, that you’ll either be overcome with awe, or stunned by envy. The all-new Corolla Altis.....
34
By Integrating sales, after-sales service and serviceparts storage in a single
convenient location, 3S delears contribute to the High level of quality associated with Toyota throughout the
World.
35
Objectives of Study
36
The training system process of DSK Toyota is as follows: -
1. IDENTIFICATION OF TRAINING NEEDS:
The training need is divided into following:
i. Individual Needs: Every individual may be required to be
provided in training to develop some of growth learns. It is
provided to any employee on the basis of present level of
knowledge, skill, attitude and behavior towards work. It
helps in making better decision and effective problem
solving and self-development and self-confidence. It is
done through two ways: -
a. Annual appraisal: Appraisal of each and every
employee is done every year and training need required
by him or her is known. If the performance of the
individual is not satisfactory according to their
specified standard then required training is imparted to
improve their performance.
b. Change in job / process: Whenever any employee is
change from one department to another or is made to
work on other machine, training is required so that he is
able to equip with changes being done. Change in job
means employee has to rotate from one place to other in
case of transfer of promotion or due to introduction of
new technology.
37
ii. ORGANISATIONAL NEED:
It means training of the overall organization employees.
Organization need is determined by PHRDC meetings i.e.
Plant Human Resource Department Meetings which are
being held once in a year. It is the apex body of the
organization for providing training related matters. It is
done through following ways: -
a) New policies: Whenever a new policy is introduced in
DSK Toyota Ltd. to make the employees acquaint with
it training is required. For e.g. ISO Certification
introduction, then training has to be provided to
understand the policy.
b) Multi-skilling – It means to perform more than one
responsibility in an organization and increasing all
round of competence.
iii. TPM PILLARS
TPM stands for Total Productivity Method. TPM policy
says "it is our policy to induce changes in all employees
by the delegation, empowerment & motivation to achieve
total participation towards zero failure, zero defect and
zero accident." Various department such as equipment
planning, operating department and maintenance
38
department implement TPM. Its main aim is to maximize
equipment effectiveness as well as overall effectiveness.
The 8 pillars of TPM are:
a. Individual improvement b. Planned maintenance c. Initial flow management system d. Education and training e. Autonomous maintenance f. Quality maintenance g. Office TPMh. Safety hygienic & environment
iv. SKILL EVALUATION
There are four different level of skill evaluation. They
are:-
a. Can't do
b. Can do
c. Can do well
d. Can teach
It is being applied that each and every employee should be
in at least level three. Training is imparted to those who
are in level 1 & 2. So that they could reach to level 3.
2. MAKING ANNUAL & MONTHLY PLAN
39
The organization of training program based on monthly
training takes into account following issues :
It has to be decided whether training program will be in house
or the employee will be send outside for the training. For
external training the place of training, overall cost of training,
duration of training has to be taken.
For in house training, training Committee has to decide whether
will be from within the organization or has to be arranged from
outside.
3. TRAINING EFFECTIVESS
Efficiency of training provides:
i. Participants Feedback:
Participants are expected to share their opinion on
usefulness of training.
ii. Pre Training & Post Training
If the training program is of mire than 16 hour
then a pre training test is conducted and also a
post-training test is conducted to know the
efficacy of each employee for technical training.
This is done to know whether the employee is
able to learn during the training period or not.
40
iii. Department Feed back: During the PHRD
meeting the head of training department gives his
opinion on the effectiveness of the training
imparted to personal who have attended the
programme.
iv. Survey: Training survey assembled all the
information obtained from various sources to
provide a comprehensive basis for the
development of training strategy and its
implementation mainly for behavior and
technological training.
4. Evaluating Training Effectiveness:
It is necessary to evaluate the extent to which training
program have achieved the aim for which they were deigned.
Such an evaluation would provide useful information about
the effectiveness of the training as well as about future
training program. Evaluation of training effect9iveness is the
process of obtaining information on the effects of training
program and assessing the value of training in the light of
that information, It involves controlling and correcting the
training program. The basis of evaluation and mode are
determined when the training program is designed.
41
Training effectiveness is the degree to which trainees are able
to learn and apply the knowledge and skills acquired in
training program. It depends on attitude, interest, value and
expectations of the trainees and training environment.
42
Quality Procedure of
Training
43
QUALITY PROCEDURE FOR TRAINING COVERAGE
PURPOSE: - (1) to identify training needs to meet org.
requirements and objectives associated with quality policy of the
company.
SCOPE :
a) The method of identifying training needs of individual whose
performance & fulfillments of job requirements & responsibility
offer product quality.
b) Monitoring reviewing and control of process related to training.
This is done through
a) In house programme
b) On the job Program.
c) Orientation Program for new recruits
d) Up to m4 grade
e) Mass-coverage training
f) Nominees are external institution.
44
COVERAGE
This procedure is reviewed & approved by management
representative & issued by head of quality system.
This procedure is applicable to all personnel covering our function
affecting quality.
CONSTITUTION OF PLANT HRD COMMITTEE :
Following members are members of HRD Committee :
a) COO
b) MR
c) HRD Head,
d) Production Head
e) QA Head,
f) Maintenance Head
g) TSD head
h) UTIC head
i) Personnel & Administration head
j) Any other authority as may be required from time to time.
45
PHRDC Meeting :- They normally meet once in a period of 6
month & in any case will meet for at least two times in a period of
12 months.
PROCEDURE STEPS :
1. Identification of Training Module:
HRD head identifies generic modules based on passed
experience and requirement arising out of identified training
needs. Plant HRD committee may also recommend or approve
training modules to be developed.
2. Decision & Development of Training Modules
For in-house programme HRD department design and develop
the training modules. Here the faculty who is assigned the task
of training carries out design and development. For external
programme HRD head will review and select such program that
will meet specified identified training needs.
3. Approved Modules
These modules are maintained on hard copy. A list of training
programme with code numbers is circulated to all HOD once in
a years. HOD's are free to identify training needs that may or
may not form parts of approved list of modules selected.
46
4. Identification of Training needs
The training needs of the COO are identified by himself.
Representative senior identifies the training needs of HOD
including MR. The HOD shall identify the needs for all
employees reporting to them. The training needs of personal
carrying out internal quality audit are identified by MR.
Training needs associated with awareness of quality policy are
identified by HRD head.
5. Identification of Training needs for on Job Training:
HODS identify the training needs, which are to be met
internally within the department. The design of such training is
approved by HOD concerned. Training is imparted within the
organization and record of attendance is sent to HRD
department.
6. Planning for providing training : HRD head evaluates an
annual training plan and the monthly training plan for
effectively meeting the identified training needs.
7. Providing Training
Based on training needs HRD head decides on mode of
providing training:
47
i. Through in house program
ii. Through on job training
iii. Through nomination to external program
Where on job training is to be provided by HRD head organizes
with the department for the conduct of such program and
approves for on job training.
8. Approval for Resource Person
HRD head reviews the Bio-data qualification, experience,
profile of the resource person as declared by them in prescribed
format and approved their engagement as faculty members for
any given topic.
In case of external source selection is done on the basis of
reputation and by virtue of their selection engagement stands
approved.
9. Efficacy of Training Provided
Passed program feedback is obtained in respect of in house
program for the program exceeding duration of two days. Pre &
post tests are conducted to know efficacy of all technical
training of more than two days duration.
48
Participants to external program are required to furnish post
program feed back in prescribed format. Past program feedback
is analyzed by HOD, HRD head and corrective action is taken
and preventive action are decided for implementation.
The efficacy of training imparted to the personal that have
attended the program is based on the Head identified by their
HOD. Any recommendations are prescribed to the PHRDC for
review and decision.
10. Retaining for Personal performing Special process:
HRD maintains record of result performing special processes.
Based on evaluated result and if the personal carrying out
special processes is recommended for retraining. HRD
department organizes on job training.
49
DIFFERENT TRAINING
PROGRAMES IN DSK
TOYOTA
1. For Workers.
2. For managerial Person.
1. FOR WORKERS:-
a) Basic Technical Training (BTT):- Management of DSK
assumes that every worker must know about whole processes
which are carried out in a work shop. So, DSK provides training
related to various operations.
Under BTT, following topics are covered.
Basic math e.g. Multiplication, decimals, fractions etc.
Engineering drawing e.g. How to use scale, drawing
board, drafter, etc.
Use of calculator
50
How to use measuring tools like micrometer, vernier
Processes related to furnace wire drawing and rope
making
Basics of electricity etc.
Effectiveness of training is measured by a test. In BTT
test there are 60% theory and 40% practical.
b) Self Certification Training (SCT):- There are many
areas that need accuracy and concentration in performing a
particular task. For that the highly skilled and experienced
workers are required so that others they are trained and
certified in their respected areas for accurate and perfect
jobs. Some of the areas are:-
Use of micro meter etc.
Filling job cards.
Lubrication etc.
As manufacture of ropes and wires required a very systematic and
accuracy. In order to get that this training is provided to the
employees so that there will be up gradation and improvement in
there skills and they are re-certified every year and are trained
under latest technology in order to get the best results. The tests are
being conducted in the same way as 60% theoretical and 40%
51
practical. This training not only for skill upgrading but also acts as
a highly motivated factor for them.
c) Advance Technical Training (ATT):- To up to date the
technical knowledge of the workers is mainly based on the study of
engineering degree where is taught every subject as common in the
first year and then them from the second year they treated as
special subjects. In the same way some works should be done by
every one and then they are trained to their specialized areas. This
is the continuation of the BIT and specially designed for the fitters.
Following topics were added in ATT. They are:-
1. Power Transmission
Belt Drive
Chain Drive
Gear Drive
Coupling
2. Lubrication
3. Limits fits and tolerance
4. Bearing
5. Pneumatic
6. Pump
7. Clutch and Break
52
Following Infrastructures were added to ATT:-
Cut model of different types of drive.
Directional valve double solenoid valve
Port to single solenoid
Port to double solenoid valve
Port to single solenoid return valve
Variables delivery piston pump
Valve pump
FRI unit
Torque wrench
Effective of this training is also tested through written and practical
tests conducted by the HRD and its efficacy is calculated.
d) Skill Development Training (SDT):- After feeling the need of
TPM, they identified four levels of skills:-
L1= Cannot do.
L2= Can do.
L3 = Can do well
L4 = Can teach also.
53
Skill Mapping is then on the basis of data collected after the tests
and feedback. This is a very effective tool imp measuring the
efficacy of any training. This shows the real picture of the
trainees where it shows the improvement in skills or the trainees
require re-training or where the training program is lacking or is
very effective active the training is of more than 16 hours, the pre
test and post test are conducted to measure the effectiveness of
trainings provided to different areas or departments.
e) Micrometer and Vernier Training: - This is mainly for the
accuracy and precision of work which requires a lot of
concentration and a minute mistake can cause a huge problem and
ultimately will lead to reduced productivity and quality.
f) Multi-schilling Training: - This training came into existence
when there was a problem in Furnace which is 300 mts long and
divided into three parts:
Input part
Middle i.e. processing part
Take-up i.e. out-put part
The workers engaged in particular part cannot do the work of
other part and hence lead to a big problem when a person from
54
any part is absent, the other parts will also stop working. This
will create the complete shutting of machine and will hamper
the productivity. Thus to avoid such type of situations the
training of multiple skill started and workers were trained to
do work in any part or machine no matter they belong to which
specialized area. This was also done in case of welders, fitters
and Brazers who are trained to any these three jobs
g) Resistance Butt Welding Training: - During processing of
wires it is very necessary to join the broken wires so that further
process can be carried in smooth way. To do so this training is
provided in wire section to so that this can be done by anyone
and hence the flow of process will not stop. For this training
also certificate is issued every year to minimize the accidents
and breakdown. Even tests are also conducted for certifying the
trainees.
h) Electrical safety Training: - In order to handle high voltage
switches a particular training is provided to the operators so that
there will not be any accidents and workers will be safe. Thus
the preventive measures are necessary to be taught to the
operator’s handlings such type of operation.
55
i) Training Related To TPM: - TPM in DSK Toyota is just
like medical science of machines. The objectives of TPM are
taught so that every one will be well aware of this. As
mentioned later how TPM is highly effective for UML and even
increased the productivity and many more improvements.
j) One Point-Lesson (OPL):- If there is one problem it can
lead to another as most of the processes are connected to each
other. Training is provided with the help of diagrams part and
assembly. Over these diagrams names are mentioned in both
Hindi and English so as to make convenient to the workers.
56
QUESTIONAAIRE
57
TRAINING EFFECTIVENESS QUESTIONNAIRE (Date: --------------)
Program Name: Enhancing Managerial Effectiveness
Name:__________________Division_____________ Grade:_________
Dear Respondent,
Please mark your responses to the following questions as given below:
Attribute Rating
A) STRONGLY DISAGREE 1
B)
C)
DISAGREE
NEUTRAL
2
3
D) AGREE 4
E) STRONGLY AGREE 5
ITEMS Ratings (1 To 5)
1. The programme helped me to understand the concept of effectiveness.
2. The program increased my awareness about the importance of effectiveness in managerial roles.3. I feel I can develop into a better employee after completion of my training program.4. I recommend this course to all of my other colleagues
5. My job offers adequate opportunity to apply some or all the concepts that I have learnt.6. The programme helped me perform better at work.7. The programme taught me the ways & means through which effectiveness can be brought into a managerial role.8. My superiors & colleagues have acknowledged my improved knowledge in the field.9. I believe I have been able to take more effective decisions after undergoing the course.10. I could apply some or all of the knowledge gained.
58
Suggestions, if any for improving the effectiveness of the training programme: -
Enhancing Managerial Effectiveness
Qust.1 Qust.2 Qust.3 Qust.4 Qust.5 Qust.6 Qust.7 Qust.8 Qust.9 Qust.10 Total
Strongly
Disagree 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Disagree 1 1 2 1 0 0 2 1 1 2 11
Neutral 3 4 4 2 1 0 4 3 4 2 27
Agree 7 5 5 6 10 12 9 11 7 11 83
Strongly
Agree 14 15 14 16 14 13 10 10 13 10 129
Total 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 250
TEI for the programme Enhancing Managerial Effectiveness is 85
59
TRAINING EFFECTIVENESS QUESTIONNAIRE (Date: --------------)Program Name: Reduction in T & D Losses
Name: ____________________ Division _____________ Grade: _________
Dear Respondent,
Please mark your responses to the following questions as given below:
Attribute Rating
A) STRONGLY DISAGREE 1
B)
C)
DISAGREE
NEUTRAL
2
3
D) AGREE 4
E) STRONGLY AGREE 5
ITEMS Ratings (1 To 5)
1. The programme helped me understand the concepts for reducing the T & D Losses
2. The program increased my awareness about the importance of reduction in T & D Losses
3. I shared the knowledge I gained with my other colleagues.
4. I recommend this course to all of my other colleagues
5. My job offers adequate opportunity to apply some or all the concepts that I have learnt.
6. The programme helped me perform better at work.7. The programme taught me the ways & means through
which the loss in T& D can be reduced8. My superiors & colleagues have acknowledged my
improved knowledge in the field.9. I believe I have been able to take more effective decisions
after undergoing the course.10. I could apply some or all of the knowledge gained.
Suggestions, if any for improving the effectiveness of the training programme: -
60
Reduction in T & D Losses
Qust. Qust.2 Qust.3 Qust.4 Qust.5 Qust.6 Qust.7 Qust.8 Qust.9 Qust.10 Total
Strongly
Disagree 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Disagree 0 1 3 1 0 0 2 3 1 2 13
Neutral 3 1 4 2 1 3 1 2 4 3 24
Agree 10 4 6 5 10 10 11 5 10 9 80
Strongly
Agree
12 19 12 17 14 12 11 15 10 11 133
Total 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 250
TEI for the programme is Reduction in T & D Losses 85.8%
61
TRAINING EFFECTIVENESS QUESTIONNAIRE (Date: --------------)
Program Name: Sharpening Customer Focus
Name: ____________________ Division _____________ Grade: _________
Dear Respondent,
Please mark your responses to the following questions as given below:
Attribute Rating
A) STRONGLY DISAGREE 1
B)
C)
DISAGREE
NEUTRAL
2
3
D) AGREE 4
E) STRONGLY AGREE 5
ITEMS Ratings (1 To 5)
1. The programme helped me understand the concept of sharpening customer focus.
2. The program increased my awareness about the importance of sharpening customer focus
3. I shared the knowledge I gained with my other colleagues.
4. I recommend this course to all of my other colleagues
5. My job offers adequate opportunity to apply some or all the knowledge that I have learnt.
6. The programme helped me perform better at work.7. The programme taught me the ways & means through
which customer focus can be done better.8. My superiors & colleagues have acknowledged my
improved knowledge in the field.9. I believe I have been able to take more effective decisions
after undergoing the course.10. I could apply some or all of the knowledge gained.
Suggestions, if any for improving the effectiveness of the training programme: -
62
Sharpening Customer Focus
Qust. Qust. Qust.3 Qust.4 Qust.5 Qust.6 Qust.7 Qust.8 Qust.9 Qust.10 Total
Strongly
Disagree 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1
Disagree 0 2 0 1 0 0 3 2 2 3 13
Neutral 2 0 3 7 1 3 0 2 3 1 22
Agree 11 8 7 4 10 10 11 11 10 8 90
Strongly
Agree 12 15 15 13 14 12 10 10 10 13 124
Total 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 250
TEI for the programme Sharpening Customer Focus is 86.2%
TRAINING EFFECTIVENESS QUESTIONNAIRE (Date: --------------)
63
Program Name: New Product Launch Training
Name: ____________________ Division _____________ Grade: _________
Dear Respondent,
Please mark your responses to the following questions as given below:
Attribute Rating
A) STRONGLY DISAGREE 1
B)
C)
DISAGREE
NEUTRAL
2
3
D) AGREE 4
E) STRONGLY AGREE 5
ITEMS Rating(1 To 5)
1. The programme helped me understand the concept of effectiveness.
2. The program increased my awareness about the importance of effectiveness in managerial roles.
3. I shared the knowledge I gained with my other colleagues.
4. I recommend this course to all of my other colleagues
5. My job offers adequate opportunity to apply some or all the concepts that I have learnt.
6. The programme helped me perform better at work.7. The programme taught me the ways & means through
which the power management can be done better.8. My superiors & colleagues have acknowledged my
improved knowledge in the field.9. I believe I have been able to take more effective decisions
after undergoing the course.10. I could apply some or all of the knowledge gained.
Suggestions, if any for improving the effectiveness of the training programme: -
Reactive Power Management
64
Qust.1 Qust. Qust.3 Qust.4 Qust.5 Qust.6 Qust.7 Qust.8 Qust.9 Qust.10 Total
Strongly
Disagree 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Disagree 0 0 2 1 0 0 4 2 1 2 12
Neutral 2 0 0 2 0 2 0 0 0 0 6
Agree 10 6 9 5 11 10 11 13 12 9 96
Strongly
Agree 13 19 14 17 14 13 10 10 12 14 136
Total 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 250
TEI for the programme Reactive Power Management is 88%
Training Effectiveness Index for the month July’08 is 86.49
TRAINING EFFECTIVENESS QUESTIONNAIRE (Date: --------------)
Program Name: Develop your own Potential
65
Name: ____________________ Division _____________ Grade: _________
Dear Respondent,
Please mark your responses to the following questions as given below:
Attribute Rating
A) STRONGLY DISAGREE 1
B)
C)
DISAGREE
NEUTRAL
2
3
D) AGREE 4
E) STRONGLY AGREE 5
ITEMS Rating(1 To 5)
1. The programme helped me understand the concept of developing our own potential.
2. The program increased my awareness about the importance of developing our own potential.
3. I shared the knowledge I gained with my other colleagues.
4. I recommend this course to all of my other colleagues
5. My job offers adequate opportunity to apply some or all the concepts that I have learnt.
6. The programme helped me perform better at work.7. The programme taught me the ways & means through
which the development of potential can be done better.8. My superiors & colleagues have acknowledged my
improved knowledge in the field.9. I believe I have been able to take more effective decisions
after undergoing the course.10. I could apply some or all of the knowledge gained.
Suggestions, if any for improving the effectiveness of the training programme: -
Develop your own Potential
66
Qust.1 Qust. Qust.3 Qust.4 Qust.5 Qust.6 Qust.7 Qust.8 Qust.9 Qust.10 Total
Strongly
Disagree 1 0 2 2 0 0 2 0 2 4 13
Disagree 6 2 6 6 4 4 3 2 1 2 36
Neutral 1 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 2 0 5
Agree 8 16 8 7 9 12 11 13 10 9 103
Strongly
Agree 9 7 9 10 10 9 9 10 10 10 93
Total 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 250
TEI for the training programme Develop your own Potential Is 79.5%
TRAINING EFFECTIVENESS QUESTIONNAIRE (Date: --------------)
Program Name: Team Building & Conflict Management
67
Name: ____________________ Division _____________ Grade: _________
Dear Respondent,
Please mark your responses to the following questions as given below:
Attribute Rating
A) STRONGLY DISAGREE 1
B)
C)
DISAGREE
NEUTRAL
2
3
D) AGREE 4
E) STRONGLY AGREE 5
ITEMS Ratings (1 To 5)
1. The programme helped me understand the concept of Team Building & Conflict management.
2. The program increased my awareness about the importance of effectiveness in managerial roles.
3. I shared the knowledge I gained with my other colleagues.
4. I recommend this course to all of my other colleagues
5. My job offers adequate opportunity to apply some or all that I have learnt.
6. The programme helped me perform better at work.7. The programme taught me the ways & means through
which the team building & Conflict management can be done better.
8. My superiors & colleagues have acknowledged my improved knowledge in the field.
9. I believe I have been able to take more effective decisions after undergoing the course.
10. I could apply some or all of the knowledge gained.
Team Building & Conflict Management
68
Qust.1 Qust. Qust.3 Qust.4 Qust.5 Qust.6 Qust.7 Qust.8 Qust.9 Qust.10 Total
Strongly
Disagree 0 0 1 0 2 0 0 0 0 2 5
Disagree 2 3 4 6 4 3 4 2 1 6 35
Neutral 1 3 1 0 0 4 0 3 1 0 13
Agree 10 4 10 8 11 10 11 10 11 9 94
Strongly
Agree 12 15 9 11 8 8 10 10 12 8 103
Total 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 250
TEI for the training programme Team Building & Conflict Management 79%
TEI for the month August’08 is 82.38
TRAINING EFFECTIVENESS QUESTIONNAIRE (Date: --------------)
Program Name: Advance Technology Training
69
Name: ____________________ Division _____________ Grade: _________
Dear Respondent,Please mark your responses to the following questions as given below:
Attribute Rating
A) STRONGLY DISAGREE 1
B)
C)
DISAGREE
NEUTRAL
2
3
D) AGREE 4
E) STRONGLY AGREE 5
ITEMS Ratings (1 To 5)
1. The programme helped me understand the concept of new Technologies
2. The program increased my awareness about the importance of Advance Technology Training.
3. I shared the knowledge I gained with my other colleagues.
4. I recommend this course to all of my other colleagues
5. My job offers adequate opportunity to apply some or all that I have learnt.
6. The programme helped me perform better at work.7. The programme taught me the ways & means through
which the work can be done better.8. My superiors & colleagues have acknowledged my
improved knowledge in the field.9. I believe I have been able to take more effective decisions
after undergoing the course.10. I could apply some or all of the knowledge gained.
Suggestions, if any for improving the effectiveness of the training programme: -
______________________________________________________________
Advance Technology Training
70
Qust.1 Qust. Qust.3 Qust.4 Qust.5 Qust.6 Qust.7 Qust.8 Qust.9 Qust.10 Total
Strongly
Disagree 1 2 1 1 2 0 1 0 0 2 10
Disagree 4 3 2 8 4 3 3 2 1 6 36
Neutral 4 4 2 2 4 0 0 2 0 0 18
Agree 8 7 9 6 7 12 11 11 12 9 92
Strongly
Agree 8 9 11 8 8 10 10 10 12 8 94
Total 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 250
TEI for the proagramme Advance Technology Training is 75%.
TRAINING EFFECTIVENESS QUESTIONNAIRE (Date: --------------)
Program Name: Labour Management
71
Name: ____________________ Division _____________ Grade: _________
Dear Respondent,
Please mark your responses to the following questions as given below:
Attribute Rating
A) STRONGLY DISAGREE 1
B)
C)
DISAGREE
NEUTRAL
2
3
D) AGREE 4
E) STRONGLY AGREE 5
ITEMS Ratings (1 To 5)
1. The programme helped me understand the concept of Labour management.
2. The program increased my awareness about the importance of labour management.
3. I shared the knowledge I gained with my other colleagues.
4. I recommend this course to all of my other colleagues
5. My job offers adequate opportunity to apply some or all that I have learnt.
6. The programme helped me perform better at work.7. The programme taught me the ways & means through
which the labour management can be done better.8. My superiors & colleagues have acknowledged my
improved knowledge in the field.9. I believe I have been able to take more effective decisions
after undergoing the course.10. I could apply some or all of the knowledge gained.
Suggestions, if any for improving the effectiveness of the training programme: -
Labour Management
72
Qust.1 Qust. Qust.3 Qust.4 Qust.5 Qust.6 Qust.7 Qust.8 Qust.9 Qust.10 Total
Strongly
Disagree 1 0 1 0 2 0 0 0 2 1 7
Disagree 3 6 5 6 4 3 2 2 2 6 39
Neutral 0 4 3 0 3 0 2 0 0 0 12
Agree 9 2 7 8 9 12 11 13 11 9 91
Strongly
Agree 12 13 9 11 7 10 10 10 12 9 103
Total 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 250
TEI for the training program Labour management is 81%
TRAINING EFFECTIVENESS QUESTIONNAIRE (Date: --------)
Program Name: Industrial Safety Management
73
Name: ____________________ Division _____________ Grade: _________
Dear Respondent,
Please mark your responses to the following questions as given below:
Attribute Rating
A) STRONGLY DISAGREE 1
B)
C)
DISAGREE
NEUTRAL
2
3
D) AGREE 4
E) STRONGLY AGREE 5
ITEMS Ratings (1 To 5)
1. The programme helped me understand the concept of Industrial Safety management.
2. The program increased my awareness about the importance of industrial safety management.
3. I shared the knowledge I gained with my other colleagues.
4. I recommend this course to all of my other colleagues
5. My job offers adequate opportunity to apply some or all that I have learnt.
6. The programme helped me perform better at work.7. The programme taught me the ways & means through
which the industrial safety management can be done better.8. My superiors & colleagues have acknowledged my
improved knowledge in the field.9. I believe I have been able to take more effective decisions
after undergoing the course.10. I could apply some or all of the knowledge gained.
Suggestions, if any for improving the effectiveness of the training programme: -
Industrial Safety Management
74
Qust.1 Qust. Qust.3 Qust.4 Qust.5 Qust.6 Qust.7 Qust.8 Qust.9 Qust.10 Total
Strongly
Disagree 4 0 1 0 2 0 0 0 0 2 9
Disagree 6 4 5 6 4 3 3 2 1 3 37
Neutral 0 3 0 3 0 3 4 1 0 0 14
Agree 7 3 10 5 11 9 9 12 12 9 87
Strongly
Agree 8 15 9 11 8 10 9 10 12 11 103
Total 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 250
TEI for the training programme Industrial Safety Management is 79%
TRAINING EFFECTIVENESS QUESTIONNAIRE (Date: --------------)
Program Name: Problem Solving Tools
75
Name: ____________________ Division _____________ Grade: _________
Dear Respondent,
Please mark your responses to the following questions as given below:
Attribute Rating
A) STRONGLY DISAGREE 1
B)
C)
DISAGREE
NEUTRAL
2
3
D) AGREE 4
E) STRONGLY AGREE 5
ITEMS Ratings (1 To 5)
1. The programme helped me understand the concept of problem solving tools.
2. The program increased my awareness about the importance of problem solving tools.
3. I shared the knowledge I gained with my other colleagues.
4. I recommend this course to all of my other colleagues
5. My job offers adequate opportunity to apply some or all that I have learnt.
6. The programme helped me perform better at work.7. The programme taught me the ways & means through
which the problem solving can be done better.8. My superiors & colleagues have acknowledged my
improved knowledge in the field.9. I believe I have been able to take more effective decisions
after the training program.10. I could apply some or all of the knowledge gained.
Suggestions, if any for improving the effectiveness of the training programme: -
Problem Solving Tools
76
Qust.1 Qust. Qust.3 Qust.4 Qust.5 Qust.6 Qust.7 Qust.8 Qust.9 Qust.10 Total
Strongly
Disagree 2 0 2 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 6
Disagree 3 5 2 6 4 3 3 2 3 6 37
Neutral 0 3 0 0 0 2 2 0 3 0 10
Agree 10 2 10 8 11 10 9 13 10 9 92
Strongly
Agree 10 15 11 11 8 10 11 10 9 10 105
Total 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 250
TEI for the training programme Problem solving Tools is 79%
77
FINDINGS
Training is conducted very effectively at DSK
TOYOTA. TEI is found as around 82% against the
targeted 80%.
2.Gaps in existing Training Procedure
Sometimes Training is conducted on activity base
Training at DSK TOYOTA is activity based and not at
need based, as is the form.
Sometimes, an employee does not get training in all the needs
specified by him. This might be due to a variety of reasons
ranging from his being busy with some other work to being
away on sick leave.
78
This happens due to absence or due to his non-
availability the HOD sends someone else in his place to
attend the training program. In this way the department’s
needs are fulfilled but the individual’s needs are not.
Training group formed is not at the same knowledge base
The groups of employees formed to attend the training
program are not at the same knowledge base. Some
employees who already have desired knowledge end up in
sitting for a full-day training session where only half of the
information is relevant to them. This is a loss in productivity
of the company.
When the training group is not on the same knowledge
base it also tends to confuse the trainer. The trainer doesn’t
know at which level to start the training with. If the trainer
starts with the basics then those who already know the basics
tend to get bored and distracted. However, then those
employees with an elementary knowledge of the subject tend
to feel lost.
79
SUGGESTIONS
Competency Based Approach to Training Needs Analysis.
Six critical steps are there for identifying the training
needs.
7. Identify competency or success factors.
8. Build profiles
9. Assess employees
10. Identify gaps
11. Identify development options
12. Follow through
1) Identify competency or success factors.
Competencies or success factors are the knowledge,
skills, abilities, behaviours and characteristics that represent
the fundamental skill or behavioural components of a job.
Typical approaches are based on some form of job
analysis. Analysts gather responsibility, task, skill and
80
behaviour information for a particular job or job family and
then identify the competencies or other factors required for
successful performance.
2) Build profiles
Most useful job profiles start with the establishment
of two important criteria, the criticality of each success factor
& the proficiency level for each factor.
The result of this proves is a picture of the most
important success factors and the degree to which each needs
to be mastered by jobholders.
3) Assess employees
You can develop reasonably accurate pictures of
employee strengths and weakness by
building on the competency and success factor models.
4) Identify gaps
Now, you can compare reasonably it to the previously
established job profile in order to identify the most logical &
most critical gaps in development.
5) Identify development options
81
Development can be linked to three primary sets of
activities:
1. Formal, in-house training programs specifically
designed to provide training and development
options.
2. External programs such as workshops, seminars
and formal classes that also address the identified
competencies of success factors.
3. Internal, on-the-job experiences that have been
identified as a source of development and growth.
3) Follow through
Many organizations fail to follow through after
development activities. The message they send to the
employees is that process stops with job analysis or employee
assessment.
If employees are expected to take part in on-going
development programs, they should see some tangible
outcomes or rewards for their undertakings.
If managerial participation is crucial to long-
term development and maintenance of employee skill
levels. Including employee development on a
manager’s list of yearly goals may be the best way to
institutionalise the message of development.
82
CONCLUSION
The process and methods of training have been rapidly changing in
industries, which are now market driven and open to the global
competition. It is very essential as a student of management that
they should be near to the world of work as possible. The student
should be made aware of the development being made in industry,
during their studies. So there is a need to bridge gap between the
world of work and study being imparted to students.
After studying the training system in DSK TOYOTA, I came up
with a very specific idea about HRD, which acts as guiding force
for the workers and employees to increase the quality and quantity
of the product.
I also found that the DSK TOYOTA management is also carrying
about behavioral development or personality program.
Training is conducted very effectively in DSK TOYOTA. The
training effectiveness for month of July is at 75% as compared to
70%.
83
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. Human Resource and Personnel Management
- K. Aswathappa
2. Principle and practices of Management
- L. M. Prasad
3. Human Resource Management
- V. S. P. Rao
4. Personnel Management
- C. B. Mamoria
5. www.dskdevelopers.com
6. www.google.com
84
EMPLOYEE ETD NEED IDENTIFICATION FORM
Name of the Employee: Employee Number: Grade:
Division: Department:
Division: Department:
Signature of Immediate Superior Signature of HOD
Title : Training Need Identification
Employee or his immediate superior (in consultation with the employee) may fill in
his education, Training & Development requirements for his performance
Enhancement and self-development for the financial year in the space given below:
Sr. No ETD Need
Department head / Immediate superior of the employee may list the approved ETD
needs below, from those requested by the employee in the above space. Department
head or immediate superior may choose these needs in consultation with the employee
Before approval.
Approved ETD Needs
Department Head may give a list of other ETD needs for the employee in the space
below:
Sr No: ETD Need
85
TRAINING EFFECTIVENESS QUESTIONNAIRE (Date: --------------)
Program Name:
Name: ____________________ Division _____________ Grade: _________
Dear Respondent,
Please mark your responses to the following questions as given below:
Attribute Rating
A) STRONGLY DISAGREE 1
B) DISAGREE 2
C) AGREE 3
D) STRONGLY AGREE 4
ITEMS Ratings (1 To 4)
1. The programme helped me understand the concept of the subject.
2. The program increased my awareness about the importance of the subject
3. I shared the knowledge I gained with my other colleagues.
4. I recommend this course to all of my other colleagues
5. My job offers adequate opportunity to apply some or all that I have learnt.
6. The programme helped me perform better at work.7. The programme taught me the ways & means through
which the work can be done8. My superiors & colleagues have acknowledged my
improved knowledge in the field.9. I believe I have been able to take more effective decisions
86
after undergoing the course.10. I could apply some or all of the knowledge gained.
87