vivek vichar may 2015

Upload: vivekananda-kendra

Post on 03-Feb-2018

223 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    1/52

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    2/52

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    3/52

    {ddoH {dMma & _o 2015 & 3

    {ddoH mZX H|mMo gmH {VH _m{gH

    {ddoH {dMmadf30 do - AH 7 dm - n>o52

    demI-`o>/`wJmX 51164 _o 2015

    RNI NO. 46869 / 85,"{ddoH {dMma' ho _m{gH_mbH , "{ddoH mZX H| _amR>r H meZ {d^mJ'`mMogmR>r _wH d H meH YZO` gy der `mZr{{gOZ qQ>g, X{ZH VU ^maV, 19/20,

    Ammo{JH dgmhV, hmoQ>Jr amoS>, gmobmnya `oWoN>mnyZ, {ddoH mZX H| , 165, aodo bmBg,gmobmnya `oWyZ {g Ho bo.

    gnmXH - {gmam_ anm nmQ>rb

    n`dhmamMm nmm

    {ddoH {dMmamam - {ddoH mZX H| ,

    165, aodo bmBg, gmobmnya-413 001.Xy0217 - 2315949 (gm`7 Vo 8.30)

    email : [email protected]` oQ> m

    vivekvichar.vkendra.org

    _y` - 15 n o

    gnmXH{gmam_ . nmQ>rb

    _w` gnmXH

    lr. nr. na_odaZ

    ^maVr` g_mO`dWoMr Zmi WoQ> Jmodemer OmoS>bobr Amho. doXH mimnmgyZ F fr - _wZtZr JmonmbZmMo _hdAmoiIyZ Jm`rbm dXZr` _mZbo.

    boImZwH _

    ^maVr` Jm` - MmbVr {\ aVr S>mQ>a

    Jmode VH arMm XheVdmXmda n[aUm_38

    5 gnmXH s`

    6

    S>m. Am~oS>H aAm{U JmogajU

    9

    Agm qOH bmEo{Vhm{gH bT>m

    HwVHAm{U dmV{dH Vm

    14

    Jm odkm{ZHZS>onH mH m

    ~Xr AgyZhrJmoYZ KQ>bo

    21 24

    _hmam>mV AmH mambm oVmo`EH H mVrH maH Hfr`moJ 26

    35

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    4/52

    4 & {ddoH {dMma & _o 2015

    Jmodem`m AZoH OmVr _mg {Z`mVr_wio Zm_eof Pm`m. Varhr Cm_ Ago 33 Jmode AmO {Q>Hy Z AmhoV.{edm` H _Agb Aem eoH S>mo OmVr AmhoV.

    AmerdMZ4 & {ddoH {dMma & _o 2015

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    5/52

    {ddoH {dMma & _o 2015 & 5

    ggnmnm

    XX sH s

    ``

    dmMH ~Yy ^{JZr,{ddoH {dMmaMm hm JmoYZ {deofmH AZoH AWmZr _hdmMm Amho. Zoh_r`m

    dJUrXmam{edm` _hmamQ>mVrb gw_mao 10 hOmamhZ A{YH JmdmZm hm {deofmH go_ oQ>

    hUyZ nmR>d`mV oV Amho. _hmam>mVrb eoH S>mo bmoH mZr `mgmR>r Am{WH `moJXmZ {Xbo.`m_wioM ho e` Pmbo. hr ~m~ {ddoH {dMma M_yMm Cgmh dmT>dUmar Amho.

    _hmamQ> gaH maZo Jmode h`m~XrMm H m`Xm bmJy H aVmM dV:bm go`wbahUdUm`m _S>itZr AZoH Vamd Z `m {ZU mbm {damoY gw Ho bm. g` PmH moiyZQ>mH `mMmM hm `Z hmoVm. Aem doir JmoYZm{df`rMo dmVd g_mOmg_moa _mS>`mMm`Z {ddoH {dMma H aV Amho. `m `Zmg A{VWr gnmXH AmMm`JmoqdXXod {Jar dH Uoar`m {g{Jar _R>mMo A` H mS>{goda _hmamO `mMo _mJXeZ bm^boAmho.

    JmoYZ hm {df` A{Ve` `mnH Amho. AbrH S>`m H mimV Jmo_y, Jmo_` Am{U

    JmoXY mdarb dkm{ZH gemoYZmdahr EImXm ~hX JW hmoD eHob. nU XY XoUmam mUr`mnbrH S>o Jm`rMo _hd Amho, hr ~m~M g_mOmg_moa, eoVH `mg_moa AmUbr JobrZmhr. Vgm Angm `Z `m AH m`m _m`_mVyZ Ho bm Amho.

    S>m. ~m~mgmho~ Am~oS>H a, dmV`dra {d. Xm. gmdaH a, _hm_m JmYr m`mgma`m_hmnwfmMm Iw~rZodmna H aV Jmoh`oMo g_WZ H aUm`m d mrbmhr CKS>onmS>bo Amho.

    ^maVr`mZm ^maVmH S>o ^maVr` Q>rH moZmVyZ nmh`mMr Q>r gdW_ dm_r{ddoH mZXmZr {X`mMo _V `mV {dMmadV Ya_nmb `mZr Zm|XdyZ R>odbo Amho. nUH mhr {dZgVmofr bmoH dm_r {ddoH mZX `mZmM Jmoh`oMog_WH hUyZ nwT>oAmU`mMm`Z H aVmZm {XgVmV.

    g_mO H gm {dH {gV hmoV OmVmo, ho gmJVmZm dm_rOr EH m {R>H mUr hUVmV,^maVmV \ ma nydu H YrVar Jmoh`m hmoV hmoVr. d{XH H mimV Jmoo_mg Imbm Om`Mm.nU ZVa hiyhiy g_mO OmJ H hmoV Jobm. OoXY XoV, Oo _mZdOmVrbm Cn`w V Amho,`mbm Zmhr _mam`M, hm {dMma ~i hmoV Jobm. `oWodm_rOtZr Hw R>ohr Jmo h`oMo g_WZHobo bo Zmhr. _XmZmda OmD Z \w Q>~mb Ioim hUOo JrVm MmJbr g_Oob, Ago dm_rOrhUVmV Vohm JrVobm {damoY H aUo hm `mMm Coe ZgVmo. nU `m XoemVrb d`Kmo{fVgo`wba _S>ir _m Vgm C\ amQ>m AW emoY`mMm IQ>mQ>mon H aVmV.

    XH mimV wHo Zo VS>\ Sy>Z eoH S>mobmoH _`w _wIr nS>V AgVmZm `m`mgmR>r H mhrhrgodm Z H aUmao VWmH {WV Jmoo_r nmhZ dm_rOtZr MrS> `V H aUo dm^m{dH MAmho. XH mimV _aUmao bmoH `m`m H _mZo _aVmhoV Ago{ZRy>a ~mo b EoHy Z dm_rOrhUVmV, _J Jm`tZmhr `m`m H _mZo _ m. `mVyZ `mMr Jar~mVrMr H iH iM{XgyZ `oVo. `oWo VoJm`rbm ZmH maV ZmhrV, ho g_OyZ KoVbo nm{hOo. nU Jm`rgmaIm^mdZmYmZ {df` KoD Z H mhr bmoH Jmoh`obm `mo` R>adVmV, ho MwH sMo Amho. Jm` hr_mZdOmVrbm CnH maH Amho. mMrZ H mimnmgyZ ^maVr`mZr ho AmoiIb. AmOhrJm` ^maVr` AW`dWoMm, Amamo``dWoMm H Um ~Zy eH Vo. `mgmR>rM OZOmJaUH a`mMm `Z `m AH mVyZ H aV AmhmoV.

    OZmdam`m g`oV ^maV OJmV n{h`m WmZmda Amho; _m, XY CnmXZm_`o _mJo Amho.

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    6/52

    6 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

    VwH mam_ qMMUrH anT>anya8888838863

    gm`dmmZr {Z {~Q>remZrqhXWmZ`m B{VhmgmMo{dH VrH aU H a`mMoOoqZXZr` `Z Hobo,`mbm dmMm \ moS>`mMo H m`

    `m `m {dmZmZr Ho bo`mV ~m~mgmho~XoIrb`oVmV. Jmoh`oMo _yi^maVmV {~Q>remZrM amodbo

    `mMoR>gR>erV nwamdo AmOCnbY AmhoV. JmYrdmXr{dMmadV {Z B{VhmggemoYH m`mnH Y_nmb`mZr `m~m~V {dbjU

    A`mg H Z ^maVr`Jmoh`oMo _yi {~Q>reH mimV `m JWmMr {Z{_VrHobr Amho.

    {dmm, `mgJ, Mm[a`gnVm hrM `mMr JwUd{e>`o Vo~m~mgmho~ ! qhXWmZ`m B{Vhmgm_`o `m r-nwfmZrOrdZ^a dVW amhZ {doMr AmamYZm Ho br, mV ~m~mgmho~mMo ZmdR>iH nUo `mdobmJob. ~m~mgmho~mMm `mgJ hm Mm\oa hmoVm. _mM2015 _`o _hmam>mV Jmodeh`m ~Xr A{Y{Z`_ H a`mV Ambm.`mda AZoH mZr AZoH H ma`m {V{H`m Zm|Xd`m. `m_wio m~m~VrV Amn`m am`KQ>ZoMo {Z_mVoS>m. ~m~mgmho~ mMo {dMma H m`AmhoV ho nmhUo Amd`H Amho.

    JmYrdmXr {dMmadV {Z B{Vhmg gemoYH m`mnH Y_nmb `mZr{dbjU A`mg H Z ^maVr` Jmoh oMo _yi {~Q>re H mimV

    `m JWmMr {Z{_Vr Hobr. {OkmgyZr Vmo JW dmMmdm. ~m~mgmho~mZrhrJmogajU m {df`mda AgoM gemoYZ mnyduM Ho bo hmoVo Am{U Amn`m~YmV `mZr Vo H Q>hr Ho bo Amho.

    1948 _`o {b{hbo`m The Untouchables: Who WereThey and Why They Became Untouchables, `m JWmV S>m.~m~mgmho~ Am~oS>H a `mZr AmnboqMVZ H Q> Ho bo Amho . ~m Y_AgmoH s d{XH gHVr, XmohrV Jmoh`oMm {ZfoYM H a`mV Ambm Amho.

    S>m. Am~oS>H a Am{U JmogajU

    _w`boI

    Jmodem`m gdYZmVyZ {_iUmaoCnZ Am{U _mZdr hmVmZm {_iUmao H m_ bjmV KoVm Anman[aH D Omjo,XY`dgm` Am{U eoVrnyaH CmoJ `mVyZ \ ma _moR>r Am{WH H mVr KS>dUo e` hmoBb.

    6 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    7/52

    {ddoH {dMma & _o 2015 & 7

    dVwV: ~m~mgmho~ Va n>M gmJVmV H s Jmoh`o`m{damoYmV ~wmZrM R>mog nmCbo CMbbr AmhoV.

    ~m~mgmho~ hUVmV, The Buddhistsrejected animal sacrice, particularly of the

    cow. The objection to the sacrice of the

    cow had taken a strong hold of the minds

    of the masses as they were an agricultural

    population and the cow was a very useful

    animal.

    ~m Y{_`mZr newh`m {deofV: Jm`tMr h`mZoh_rM ZmH mabr Amho. Jm` hm \ ma Cn w mUr

    Ag`m_wio Am{U XoemV eoVr H aUm`mMr g`m_moR>r Ag`m_wio newh o`m {damoYmVbm {dMmaAm{U `mV`m `mV Jm`t`m H mbtMm {damoY OZVoV

    MmJbmM n m Pmbm hmoVm.KQ>ZoMo _w` {enH ma Agbo`m ~m~mgmho~mZr

    JmonyOZmMo gmH {VH , Am{WH , Eo{Vhm{gH _hdAmoiIbo hmoVo . `m`m `mM ~YmV Vo hUVmV,The Hindoo devotion to the Cow has been an

    enigma to most of the foreigners and aboveall has been an efcient lore in the hands

    of those half-baked theological failures

    who go to India to conduct their missionary

    propaganda for blackmailing the Hindoo.

    The origin of cow worship is as much

    economic as that Roman practice of not

    offering wine to the Gods from unpruned

    vines. The cow and for that matter all draft

    animals, is the soul of the farmers. The cow

    gives birth to oxen which are absolutely

    necessary to the cultivation of the farm. If

    we kill the cow for meat, we jeopardize our

    agricultural prosperity. With full foresight,

    the ancient Hindoos tabooed cow-esh and

    thus prevented cow killing.

    qhX`m _ZmVbm Jm`r{df`rMm ny`^md honaXoer`mZm Zoh_rM EH JyT> dmQ>V Ambo Amho. `mV`m`mV ^maVmV oD Z namonH mam`m Zmdmda Y_gmaH aUm`m AYdQ> Y_dmmZm hr ~m~ Am`VrM hmVrgmnS>br Amho {O`mmam Vo qhXZm bH _ob H arVAgVmV. ^maVmVbr JmonyOoMr nVr {VVH sM Am{WHAmho, {OVH s _emJV Z Ho bo`m mjm`m dobtMo _

    Xodmbm AnU Z H a`mMr amo_Z bmoH mMr nVr Amho.Jm` Am{U A` H mhr Cn w OZmdao hr eoVH `mZmAmnbm mU dmQ>V AgVmV. Jm` ~bmZm O_ XoVo Oo

    ~b eoVr H a`mgmR>r Cn`moJr oV AgVmV. AmnUJm`tMr _mgmgmR>r H mb H am`bm bmJbmo Va Amn`mH {f g_rer VS>OmoS> Ho `mgmaIo hmoBb. Ow`mH mimV`m qhXZr Xa>r R>odyZ Jmo_mg ImUo d R>adbo Amho Am{U `mgmR>r Jm`t`m h`mZm {V~Y

    Ho bm Amho.^maVr` am`KQ>Zm {Z JmogajUAmVm AmnU `m~m~VrV g{dYmZ H m` hUVo Vo

    nmh. ~m~mgmho~ ho g{dYmZmMoboIH Ag`mZo`mZrg{dYmZmV JmogajUmgX^mV Xa>rZoM VaVwXr H ZR>od`m hmo`m. `mZr g{dYmZ dmMbo Agob `mZmho _m{hVr Agob H s g{dYmZmZo `oH ZmJ[aH mbm

    _w`boI

    Jm` hm mUr _wimVM n`mdaU - {_ Amho. Xoer Jm` Va CQ>o - IaH Q>o, ^mOrMr XoR>o, {eio AZ, {_iobVo JdV, H mS>r - H Mam B. ImD Zhr {ZamoJr amh eH Vo.

    {ddoH {dMma & _o 2015 & 7

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    8/52

    8 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

    H mhr _wb yV A{YH ma {Xbo AmhoV. BVHo M ZmhrVa `mM~amo~a H mhr Xm{`dhr nma nmS>`mggm{JVbr AmhoV. `mZm AmnU _yb yV Xm{`d AgohUVmo. CXmhaUmW am>dOmMm _mZ amIUodJao. _wb yVA{YH ma {Z Xm{`dm~amo~aM H mhr _mJXeH Vdogwmgm{JVbr AmhoV. mM Vdm_`oVwV {df`mgX^mVImbrb _mJXeH Vd g_m{d> Ho bo Amho.

    The Directive Principle article 48 of

    the Constitution states that The State shall

    endeavor to organise agriculture and animal

    husbandry on modern and scientic lines

    and in particular take steps for preserving

    and improving the breeds and prohibiting

    the slaughter of cows and other milch and

    draught cattle.''

    ^maVr` am`KQ>Zo`m _mJXeH Vdm`m48 `m H b_mV hQ>bo Amho H s, gaH ma eoVrAm{U newnmbZ ho `dgm` AmYw{ZH Am{Uemr` nVrZo gK{Q>V H a`mgmR>r `mg H arb.

    {deofV: Jm` Am{U A` X Vr OZmdao`m`m {d{dYOmVtMo OVZ Am{U gdYZ H arb. `mgmR>r Jm`t`mh`mda ~Xr Kmbrb Am{U A` X `m VgoM ^mH S>OZmdamMrhr H mb Q>mi`m`m {XeoZonmdbo Q>mH sb.

    hUOo darb Vd ~m~mgmho~m`m _ZmVboMhoVyn> H aVo . gmdaH amZrXoIrb `mM {>H moZmVyZJmogajU _mS>bo, nU `m`m `m boImMm Iyn MwH sMm{Z gmo rZwgma AWKoCZ gmdaH amZm Jmoh`oMog_WHg_O`mMr KmoS>MyH AZoH OU H aVmV.

    WmoS>`mV H m` Va KQ>ZmH maXoIrb Omo {df`R>mgyZ _mS>VmV Vmo {df` Amhr _m Ho di Ym{_H

    {>H moZmVyZ qH dm A`mp_H {>H moZmVyZM nmhVmo`AgoXedyZ Amhr Am_MmM KmV H Z KoVmo AmhmoV.H maU ~m~mgmho~ qH dm BVahr KQ>ZoMo g_WH Oohmhm {df` _mJXeH Vd hUyZ g{dYmZmV _mS>VmVVohm Z sM `m_mJMr Am{WH , gmH {VH , amOH s`{Z BVa AZoH Jmo>r bjmV KoD ZM ho Vd `mZr_mS>bo Agmdo. eHo bm OmJm Agm`MoH maUM Zmhr.

    ***

    S>m. dUbVm {^erH a (r H Wm), dmZXnwS>, {ddoH mZX H| m`m amQ>r` Cnm`j ~r.{Zdo{XVm `m`m _wbmIVrMm Xgam ^mJ, am_H U

    dMZm_V, _yb{Zdmgr ImoQ>r gH nZm, ^VharMo{ZVreVH , ghOgdmX, hbH \w bH , ~mb{dhma,nydmMbmV`m Zm|Xr.

    hr gXao / boI OyZ`m AH mV Zoh_r_mUo{g hmoVrb, `mMr dmMH mZr H n`m Zm|X `mdr.

    gnmXH

    JmoYZ {deofmH m_wionwT>rb gXao /boI `m AH mV KoVm AmboZmhrV.

    ^maVmMr gwIg_r Jm` Am{U Jmodem`mg_rdaM Adb~yZ Amho. JmoajU H aUohUOo^maVmVrb gd _y H g>rMo ajU H a`mgmaIo

    hmo`. qhXWmZmV qhXgmo~V amhZ Jmoh`m H aUohUOo qhXMr h`m H a`mgmaIoM.

    _hm_m JmYr

    _mg ImUo gmoSy >Z m. _mg ImUo ho_nmZm_mUoM hmZrH maH Amho. hOaV C_mZn{hbm hrg gmBVmVyZ Jm`rMo Vyn Am{U XYVw_`m Amamo`mgmR>r A V Amd`H Amho. {VMo_mg hmZrH maH Amho.

    nJ~a gmho~, Zm{e`mVhmXr nwVH mVyZ

    _w`boI

    Jm`rMoeoU - _y ho eoVO{_ZrVM OmVo Am{U O{dH g_Vmob amIVo.Jm`rMo eoU ho{H aUmo gmamMo100 Q>Ho amoYZ H aVo .

    8 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    9/52

    {ddoH {dMma & _o 2015 & 9

    AmYr AmnU hoOmUyZ `m H s, maVmV 3600 H mbIm`mH S>o Jm`H mnm`Mo nadmZoAmhoV. m`m{edm` 36000 H mbImZo ~oH m`Xm gw

    AmhoV. Xadfu XrS> H moQ>r Jm`tMr H mb Ho br OmVo. EH Vo gdm H moQ>rhetMoAm{U XmoZ Vo VrZ H moQ>r Sw>H amMr H mb Ho br OmVo.

    eom, ~moH S>, H m|~S>m, H m|~S>m AmXr N>moQ>m m`mMr g`mhrH moQdYr Amho, `mMr _moOXmX Ho br OmD eH V Zmhr. Va maV EHAgm Xoe AmhoOoWo H mbM H mb Ho br OmVo. `m_wioOohm ho ghZPmbo Zmhr Vohm 1998 _`oamOrd Xr{jV Am{U `m`m gma`m H mhrg_{dMmar bmoH mZr gdm}M `m`mb`mV Ymd KoVbr.

    A{Ib maVr` JmogodH gK Zmdm`m gWoer amOrd Xr{jV OmoS>bo

    JobohmoVo . gWoMo_w` H m`mb` amOrd Xr{jV m`m ehamVM (dYm)Amho. VgoM EH Xgar gWm Amho. Aqhgm Am_u Q>Q> `m gWoMoZmd.Va m Xmohr gWmZr gdm}M `m`mb`mV IQ>bm XmIb Ho bm. Am{UZVa H iboH s JwOamV gaH mahr `m IQ>`mV gh^mJr Pmbr Amho.

    Jm` Am{U JmodemMr h`m hmoD Z`o, Ago `m IQ>`mV `mMohUUohmoVo. Va g_moa ~gbo`m ImQ>H mZr hQ>bo H s, Jm` d JmodemMrH m h`m hmoD Z`o? Oa hm`bm hdr. amOrd Xr{jV `mZr gdm}M

    gH bZ d da AZwdmX

    Anmgmho~ hmmioboImgmR>r gX^ gdm}M `m`mb` dS>m`bmJ B{S>`mMo gHo VWi

    Agm qOH bm gdm}M`m`mb`mVrb Eo{Vhm{gH bT>mgdm}M `m`mb`mZo

    hQ>bo H s, ^maVmVrb34 am`m`m gaH mamMrAmnmn`m am`mV

    Jm`rMr H mb ~X H aUohr O~m~Xmar Amho.H moU`m am`mV Jm`rMrH mb hmoV Ag`mg`m am`mMo _w`_r,am`nmb, _w` g{Md hoAmnbr O~m~Xmar Am{UAmnboH m_ nyU H aV

    ZmhrV. hr am`mMrhr

    g{dYm{ZH O~m~XmarAmho Am{U ZmJ[aH mMohrgm{dYm{ZH H V` Amho.

    {ddoH {dMma & _o 2015 & 9dmVd

    Xhr : hoAZr XrV H aUmao , X`mbm {`, nmpQ>H d dmVZmeH AgVo.

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    10/52

    10 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

    `m`mb`mV Anrb Hobo H s ho EH , XmoZ `m`mYremMoH aU Zmhr, mgmR>r ~|M WmnZ H amdr. VrZ, Mma df}gdm}M `m`mb`mZodrH maM Ho bm Zmhr. ZVa _m`Ho bo H s, `mgmR>r H mpQ>Q>yeZb ~|M ~Zdbo OmBb.WmoS>m {Xdgmnydu _w` `m`mYrenXr am{hbobo lr.Ama. gr. bmhmoQ>r `mZr Amn`m A`jVoImbr gmV`m`_yVvMr EH H mpQ>Q>yeZb ~|M WmnZ Ho br.

    2004 nmgyZ gQ>|~a 2005 n`V IQ>`mMrgwZmdUr Mmbbr. ImQ>H m`m ~mOyZo ^maVmVrb_moR>_moR>odH sb hmoVo, Oo 50 - 50 bmI ewH KoVmV.gmobr gmoam~Or `mMr \ s drg Va H {nb {g~b mMr\ s 22 bmI Amho. am_ OoR>_bmZr mMo{MaOrd _hoeOoR>_bmZr `mMr \ s 32 Vo 34 bmI n`oAmho . hogd _moR>_moR>odH sb ImQ>H m`m ~mOyZo hmoVo.

    amOrd XmXm `m`m dVrZo bT>Umam H moUVmhr_moR>m dH sb ZhVm. \ s m`bm VodT>o ngo hmoVo Hw R>o. amOrd Xr{jV `mZr `m`mb`mbm gm{JVboH s,Am_`mH S>o dH sb Zmhr, Va H m` H ? Va

    `m`mb`mZo {dMmabo H s, Amhr dH sb XoD H m?Va amOrd Xr{jV hUmboH s, dH sb {X`mg CnH mahmoVrb, Oa Amhmbm wpVdmX H a`mMr gYr {X`mgAmUIr _moR>oCnH ma hmoBb. `mda `m`mb`mZo hQ>boH s, AmnUM `wpVdmX H am Am{U Amhr VwhmbmE_ B E`war hUOo dH sb XoD . Am{U Amhr hm IQ>bmbT>dm`bm gwdmV Hobr. m IQ>`mV ImQ>H mmao Jm`

    H mn`mgmR>r Vo gmao HwVH gm{JVboJobo Oo H Yr eaXndma ~mobboAWdm `m XoemmVrb A{YH {eH bo`mbmoH mH Sy>Z ~mobbo OmVo. VgoM XoemMo n{hbo nVYmZ

    Odmhabmb Zoh `mZr hQ>bo hmoVo.ImQ>H mMm n{hbm Hw VH : Jm` Oohm d hmoVo

    Vohm `mbm OJd`mV H mhr \ m`Xm Zmhr. `mMrH mb H Z {dH UoM MmJbo. VgoM Amhr ^maVm`mAW`dWobm _O~wV H aV AmhmoV. H maU AmhrJm`rMo _mg {Z`mV H aV AmhmoV.

    Xgam Hw VH :^maVmV Jm`r`m Mm`mMr H _VaVmAmho. Cnmer _a`mnojm `mMr H mb H Z {dH Uo

    MmJboAmho.{Vgam HwVH :^maVmV bmoH mZm amh`mgmR>r O_rZ

    Zmhr. Jm`rbm H moR>oR>odmb?MmWm HwVH : `m_wio naXoer MbZ {_iVo. VgoM

    gdmV YmoH m`Xm` HwVH ImQ>H mH Sy>Z H a`mV AmbmH s, Am_`m Y_mV Bbm__`o Jm`rMr h`m H am,Ago {b{hbo Amho. (This is our religious right).

    Im{Q>H H moU AmhoV, ho AmnU OmUVm ? _wgb_mZ

    g_mOmV EH Hwaoer g_mO Amho Omo gdm{YH OZmdamMrh`m H aVmo. `m`mH Sy>Z ho Hw VH _mS>`mV Ambo.

    amOrd Xr{jV `mZr A{Ve` g {_VnUod IwnMY`mZo `m gdHw VH mMr VH nydH Cmao {Xbr. n{hbmHwVH H s Jm`r`m _mg {dHsVyZ XoemMm Am{WH\ m`Xm hmoVmo. amOrd Xr{jV `mZr gJio AmH S>ogdm}M `m`mb`mg_moa R>odbo. EH Jm` H mn`mZVa`m`m earamVyZ {H Vr _mg {ZKVo? {H Vr aV {ZKVo?

    {H Vr hmS>o {ZKVmV?EH m MmJ m Jm`rMo dOZ VrZ Vo gmS>oVrZ pdQ>b

    AgVo. Oohm `mbm H mnVmo Vohm `m`m earamVyZHodi 70 {H bmo _mg {ZKVo . EH {H bmo_mg Oohm^maVmVyZ {Z`mV hmoVoVohm `mMr qH _V {_iVo gw_mao50 n o. Va 70 {H bmobm 50 Zo JwUm. 70 Jw{Ubo 50- 3500 n`o. `mVyZ {ZKUmao aV gw_mao 25 {bQ>a

    gdm}M `m`mb`

    dmVd

    bmoUr : ho {hVH a, ewH YmVyMr VmH X dmT>dUmao, ApZdYZ H aUmao, _Ywa {dnmH s, {XmofmZm gVw{bV H aUmaoAgVo. `m{edm` gmX` dmT>dVo. H mVr COi H aVo. Am`w` d VmH X dmT>dVo.

    10 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    11/52

    {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 & 11

    AgVo. `mVyZ EHy U H _mB 1500 Vo 2000 n`ohmoVo. nwhm hmSo30 Vo 35 {H bmo {ZKVmV. Or1000 Vo 1200 n`mn`V {dH br OmVmV. VaEHy UM EH m Jm`rMr H mb H Z _mg, hmS>oAm{U aVmgh {dH `mg gaH mabmAWdm H mb H aUm`mbm 7000n`mhZ A{YH ngo {_iVZmhrV. `m_wioamOrd XmXmH Sy>Z`m`mb`mg_moa CbQ>m Z{dMma`mV Ambm H s, `mMJm`rMr h`m Z Ho br Va

    H m` {_iVo?Amhr `mMr H mb Ho br

    Va 7000 n`o {_iVrb Am{U `mbm OrdVRodbo {H Vr {_iVrb? Va `mMr AmH S>odmarAer Amho. EH MmJbr Jm` {Xdg^amV 10{H bmo eoU XoVo Am{U XrS> Vo VrZ {bQ>a _y XoVo.Jm`r`m EH {H bmo eoUmnmgyZ 33 {H bmo IV~ZVo, `mbm g|r` IV hUVmV. `mda `m`_yVu

    hUmbo, ho H go e` Amho ?amOrd Xr{jV gm{JVboH s, AmnU Amhmbm doi

    m Am{U WmZ gmJm Amhr hoM {g H Z XmIdy.`m`mb`mZo AmXoe {X`mZVa amOrd Xr{jV `mZm{g H Z XmIdbo. Am{U `m`mb`mbm gm{JVbo H s,Am`. Ama.gr.`m emkmZm ~mobdm Am{U MmMUrH am. Va `m`mb`mZoJm`rMo eoU MmMUrgmR>r nmR>dbo.emkmZr gm{JVboH s, m`mV 18 _m`H mo`yQ>rEQ>g

    (nmofH Vd) AmhoV. eoVmVrb _mVrgmR>r Amd`HOgo _Jo{ZO, \ m\ ag, nmoQ>{eA_, H pe`_, Am`Z,H mo~mQ>, {g{bH mZ Am{X gdKQ>H `mV AmhoV.

    amgm`{ZH IVmV _wpH brZoVrZM KQ>H AgVmV.Va Jm`rMo IV amgm`{ZH IVmnojm 10 nQ> A{YHj_VoMr Amho. Vo `m`mb`mZo_m` Ho bo. amOrd Xr{jV`mZr gm{JVboH s, Amn`m amO{eQ>mMmam`m {damo-

    YmV Zgob Va AmnU Am_`mgmo~V MbmAm{U nmhm H s, Amhr HwR>oHw R>o EH {H bmo eoUmnmgyZ 33 {H bmoIV ~ZdV AmhmoV.amOrd Xr{jV `mZr gm{JVbo H s _r _m`m

    JmdmV ho IV ~ZdVmo. _mPo AmBdS>rbXmoKohr eoVH ar AmhoV. Jo`m

    15 dfmnmgyZ Amhr Jm`r`meoUmnmgyZ eoVr H aVAmhmoV. EH {H bmo eoUAg`mg 33 {H bmo IV~ZVo. VgoM EH {H bmoIVmMm

    AmVaamQ>r` ~mOmamVrb ^md6 n`o Amho. Va amoO 10 {H bmo

    eoUmZo 330 {H bmo IV ~Zob. `mMr 6 n`oXamZo{dHs Ho `mg amoO 1800 Vo 2000 n`o Jm`r`meoUmnmgyZ {_iVmV. Jm` eoU Xo`mbm H moUVmhra{ddma AWdm gmVm{hH gwQ>r ZgVo. XaamoO eoU{_iVo. Va dfmbm {H Vr? 1800 bm 365 ZoJwUm.1800 Jw{Ubo365 - 657000 n`o dfmbm.

    Jm`rMo gmYmaU Am`w` 20 dfo Amho. VrOrdZm`m A{V_ {Xdgmn`V eoU XoVo. Va AmnU1800 Jw{Ubo 365 Jw{Ubo 20 H am. \ VeoUmnmgyZ EH H moQ>rnojmhr A{YH n`o {_iVrb.hOmamo, bmImo dfmAmYr Amn`m emm_`o{b{hboAmho H s, Jm`r`m eoUmV b_r dmg H aVo. Am{U_oH mboMo _mZgnw Oo AmYw{ZH {ejU KoVbo AmhoV`mZm Amnbm Y_, gHVr d g`Vm gd nmIS>

    dmQ>Vo. gVV MoQ>m H aVmV H s, hmhmhm hmhm Jm`r`meoUmV b_r dmg H aVo. Va ho `m gdmZm MnamHAmho. H maU AmO hr JmoQ> {g hmoV Amho H s,Jm`r`m eoUmZoeoVr H Z Ym` {nH dyZ ngo H _mdVm`oD eH Vo Am{U gnyU ^maVmMo nmoQ> ^aVm `oVo.

    AmVm _ym{df`r ~moby. amoO XmoZ VogdmXmoZ {bQ>a_y {_iVo. `m`mZo AmfYo ~ZVmV. S>m`~o{Q>g

    Vo 2000 n`om {ZKVmV. Orr OmVmV. Va_mg, hmS>o

    mabm0

    YmV ZgobAm{U nmeoUmnmgyamOrd Xr

    JmdmVXmo

    dmVd

    Vyn : hon{d, gw _Jb AgyZ Mdrbm amoMH , gwJYr d {Xgm`bm VoOdr AgVo. `m_wio VoamoO ImUo Amamo`mbm gdm}m_ AgVo.

    {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 & 11

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    12/52

    12 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

    (_Yw_oh) Mo AmfY ~ZVo. AWm {Q>gMoAmfY ~ZVo.~mH m`{Q>g, ~mH m`H b AW_m, Q>w~a`wbm{ggAmXr 48 amoJmdarb AmfYo~ZVmV.

    Jm`r`m EH {bQ>a _ymMo~mOmamVrb AmfYm`m nmVrb qH _V 500 n`o Amho. Vohr ^maVr`~mOmamV. AmVaamQ>r` ~mOmamV Va mnojm OmV Amho.Amn`mbm _mhrV Amho? A_o[aHoV Jmo_ymMo noQ>Q> Amho.A_o[aH m gaH ma Xadfu ^maVmVyZ Jmo_y Am`mV H aVoAm{U `m`mnmgyZ H gaMr _o{S>{gZ ~ZdVo. _Yw_

    ohmMr AmfYo ~ZdVmV. A_o[aHo V Jmo_ymda AZoH noQ>Q>AmhoV. A_o[aHo `m ~mOmamZwgma {heo~ Ho`mg EH {bQ>a

    Jmo_ymMo 1200 Vo 1300 n`o hmoVrb. Va amoOJmo_ymnmgyZ 3000 n`mMo CnZ Amho. EH m dfmbm3000 x365 = 1095000 Am{U 20 dfmbm 30Jw{Ubo 365 x 20 = 21900000 ho Va Jm`rMo eoUAm{U _ymMoPmbo. Am{U mM Jm`r`m eoUmnmgyZ EHJg {ZKVo `mbm {_WoZ hUVmV Am{U {_WoZ VmoMJg AmhoOo AmnU Amn`m d`nmH KamV {gqbS>admnaVm. JaO ^mg`mg JmS>rhr Mmbdy eH Vm.

    MmaMmH s JmS>rhr. Oer EbnrOr JgZo JmS>r MmbVo Ver {_WoZ JgZohr JmS>r MmbVo. Va `m`mb`mbm{ddmg dmQ>bo Zmhr. Va amOrd Xr{jV `mZr hQ>bo H s, Oa AmnU AmXoe {X`mg Amn m H mabm {_WoZJgMo {gqbS>a bmdy eH Vmo. AmnU MmbdyZ nmhm.Am{U `m`_yVv`m AmXoemZwgma amOrd Xr{jV `mZrH mabm {gqbS>a ~gdbo. `m`_yVvZr VrZ _{hZoJmS>rMmbdbr. Am{U `mZr hQ>bo, BQ> BO EgbQ>.H maU

    IM hmoVmoHo di {V{H bmo_rQ>a 50 Vo 60 ngo Am{U{S>Pobbm `oVmo {V{H bmo_rQ>a 4 n`o. {_WoZ JgZoJmS>r Mmbd`mg {~Hw b Yya {ZKV Zmhr. {S>PobZoMmbd`mg YyaM Yya. {_WoZda MmbUm`m JmS>rMm{~Hw b AmdmO `oV Zmhr Am{U {S>Pobdarb JmS>rMmAmdmO `oVmo OUy H mZ \ mQ>Vrb. Va ho gd `m`_yVv`m bjmV Ambo. _J Amhr hUmbmoH s, amoO 10

    {H bmoeoU EH Ho `mg EH m dfmV {H Vr {_WoZ Jg{_iob? Am{U 20 dfmV {H Vr {_iob?

    ^maVmV 17 H moQ>r Jm` AmhoV. gd Jm`tMo eoUEH mMdoiog EH Ho bo Am{U `mMm dmna Ho `mgXoemMr 1 bmI 32 H moQ>r n`mMr ~MV hmoBb.{dZm{S>Pob Am{U {dZmnoQ>mob Amhr gnyU XiUdiUH eHy . Aa~ XoemZm ^rH _mJm`Mr Amd`H VmZmhr Am{U noQ>mob, {S>PobgmR>r A_o[aHoH Sy>Z S>mbaIarX`mMr JaO Zmhr. Amnbm n`mhr _O~yV ~Zob.Va BVH m gmam {heo~ amOrd Xr{jV `mZr Hobm Vohm`m`_yVvZr _m` Hobo H s, Jm`rMr h`m H a`mEodOr

    `mbm dmMdUoAm{WH Q>m A{YH \ m`Xoera Amho.Oohm `m`mb`mMo _V Ambo Vohm hoImQ>H ^S>H bo.

    Jm`rMr H mb Ho `mg 7000 n`mMo CnZ Am{UamOrd Xr{jV `mZr Va {g H Z XmIdbo H s H mbZ Ho `mg bmImo, H moQ>dYr n`mMo CnZ {_iob._J Vo nwhm Amnbm S>md Q>mH bm. `mZr hQ>bo H s,Jm`rMr H mb H aUo hm Am_Mm Ym{_H A{YH ma Amho.`mda amOrd Xr{jV `mZr `m`mb`mbm gm{JVbo H s,

    Oa hm mMm Ym{_H A{YH ma Amho Va B{VhmgmV nmhmH s, H moUH moU`m _wpb_ amOmZr Amn`m `m Ym{_HA{YH mamMm dmna Ho bm? Va `m`mb`mZo hQ>boH sR>rH Amho. EH Am`moJ Zo_m Am{U B{VhmgH mamZm~mobdm Am{U OodT>o_wpb_ amOo ^maVmV hmoD Z Jobo`mMm B{Vhmg Am{U XVmdoO H mT>m. H moUH moU`mamOmZo Amn`m `m Ym{_H A{YH mamMm dmna Ho bm?OwZoXVmdoO H mT>bo Va H ibo H s ^maVmV OodT>o

    _wpb_ amOo Pmbo `mVrb EH mZohr Jm`rMr H mb Ho brZmhr. mCbQ> H mhr amOmZr Jm`tMr H mb amoI`mgmR>rH m`Xo ~Zdbo. `mV EH Zmd hmoVo ~m~a. ~m~amZoAmnbo nwVH ~m~aZm_m_`o{b{hbo Amho H s, _m`m_`yZVahr Jm`rMr H mb Z H a`mMm H m`Xm Omaramhrb. `mMm _wbJm h_m`wZZohr `mMo nmbZ Ho bo Am{U`mZVa OodT>o_wKb amOoPmbo `m gdmZr `m H m`mMo

    dmVd

    qeJ : _V Jm`r`m EH m qeJmnmgyZ V`ma Ho bobo IV EH mdoir EH EH a jomgmR>r nwaVo.

    12 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    13/52

    {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 & 13

    nmbZ Ho bo. AmaJOo~mgh. VgoM X{jU maVmVhr EHamOm hmoVm hXa Abr. {Q>nygwVmZMm ~mn. `mZo EHH m`Xm ~Zdbm hmoVm H s H moUr Jm rMr H mb Ho `mg

    hXa `mMm {eaN>oX H aob Am{U hXaZo Aem eoH S>moIm{Q>H mMm {eaN>oX Ho bm hmoVm. `mZVa hXa AbrMm_wbJm {Q>ny gwbVmZ amOm Pmbm. `mZo m H m`mbm WmoS>ogm` Hobo Am{U H m`Xm ~Zdbm H s, Jm`rMr h`mHo `mg hmV VmoS>bo OmBb. {Q>ny gwVmZ`m H mimVH moUr Jm` H mnm`Mm Va `mMohmV H mnbo Om`Mo.

    Oohm hoXVmdoO `m`mb`mg_moa Ambo Vohm amOrdXr{jV `mZr `m`_yVvZm hQ>bo H s, AmnU gmJm, Oa

    Bbm__`o Jm`rMr H mb hm Ym{_H A{YH ma AgVmVa ~m~a hm Va H >a Bbm_r hmoVm, nmMdoim Z_mOnS>m`Mm. h_m`wZhr hmoVm. AmaJOo~ Va gdm{YH H >ahmoVm. Va `mZr H m Jm`rMr H mb H {Xbr Zmhr?Am{U Jm`rMr H mb amoI`mgmR>r H m`Xo~Zdbo? H mhXa AbrZohQ>bo H s, Jm`tMr H mb H aUm`mMr Vmo hmV VmoS>ob? amOrd Xr{jV mZr `m`mb`mbm gm{JVboH s, AmnU AmXoe {X`mg Amhr ho Hw amU ear\ ,

    hXrg, Am{X OodT>r nwVHo AmhoV Vo `m`mb`mVgmXa H Am{U `mV Hw R>oJm`rMr H mb H am, ho {b{hbo Amho, ho OmUyBpN>Vmo. Bbm_`m H moU`mhrYm{_H nwVH mV {b{hbo Zmhr H s, Jm`rMr H mb H am.hXrg_`o Va {b{hboAmho H s, Jm`rMr ajm H am,H maU Vr Vw_Mr ajm H aVo. nJ~a _h_X `mMo hUUoAmho H s, Jm` A~mob OZmda Amho. `mgmR>r `mdaX`m H am. VgoM EH m {R>H mUr {b{hbo Amho H s, Jm`rMr

    H mb Ho bmV Va XmoPH _`ohr O_rZ {_iUma Zmhr.`mMm AW OhZw__`ohr O_rZ {_iUma Zmhr.amOrd XmXmZr `m`mb`mbm hQ>bo H s, Hw amU

    Ago gmJVo, _wh_X AgogmJVmV, hXrg AgogmJVoVa Jm`rMr H mb hm Ym{_H A{YH ma H YrnmgyZPmbm? {dMmam `m ImQ>H mZm? Va Im{Q>H Jm|Yibo.eodQ>r `m`mb`mZo `mZm EH _{h`mMr AdYr {XbrH s Om Am{U XVmdoO emoYyZ AmUm `mV Jm`rMr

    H mb H aUo hm Bbm_Mm _yi A{YH ma Amho, Ago{b{hbo Amho. Amhr _mZy. Am{U EH _{h`mn`VH moUVmhr XVmdoO {_imbm Zmhr. `m`mb`mZohQ>bo,

    AmVm Amhr OmXm doi XoD eH V Zmhr. eodQ>r26 AmQ>mo~a 2005 amoOr {ZH mb {Xbm. AmnU{ZH mbmMr V www.supremecourtcaselaw.comda OmD Z S>mD ZbmoS> H eH Vm. hm 66 nmZmMm{ZH mb Amho. gdm}M `m`mb`mZo EH B{Vhmg~Zdbm Am{U hQ>boH s, Jm`rbm H mnUo gm {dYm{ZHAm{U Ym{_H nmn Amho. gdm}M `m`mb`mZohQ>bo,Jmoajm H aUo, gdYZ H aUo, ho Xoem`m `oHZmJ[aH mMogm{dYm{ZH H V` Amho. gaH maMo H V`Va AmhoM, ZmJ[aH mMohr H V` Amho. AmVmn`VVa gm{dYm{ZH H V` hmoVo, g{dYmZmMo nmbZH aUo, amQ>r` dOmMo g_mZ H aUo, Hm{VH maH mMmg_mZ H aUo, XoemMr EH Vm, AIS>Vm `mbmH m`_ R>odUo Am{X Am{X. AmVm `mV JmoajmhrOmoS>bo Jobo Amho. AmVm H m`Xo XmoZ Vamda ~ZdboOmVmV. EH H| gaH ma ~ZdyeH Vo Am{U EH 35am`mMr gaH mao Amnmn`m am`mV ~Zdy eH VmV.

    H| gaH maZoM H m`Xm ~Zdbm Va H moU`mhram`mbm H m`Xm ~Zd`mMr JaO Zmhr. H| gaH maMmH m`Xm gnyU Xoe^amV bmJy hmoBb. `m_wio AmnUgdAmVm H| gaH mada X~md Q>mH m. X~md H gmQ>mH m`Mm? Amn`mbm hOmamo, bmIm|`m g`oZonVYmZ, amQ>nVr AWdm am`mMo_w`_r `mZm n{bhmdo bmJob. BVH m X~md Q>mH m H s {ZdS>UwH mV bmoH`mM njmbm _VXmZ H aVrb H s, Jmoh`o{damoYmVrbgdm}M `m`mb`m`m `m {ZH mbmbm gnyUXoe^amVbmJy H aob. eodQ>r Vmo _hmZ Hm{VH maH _Jb nmS>oB{VhmgmV A_a Pmbm, Omo \ merda MT>bm naVwJm`rMr Ma~r Agbobr H mS>Vyg Vm|S>mZoImobbr Zmhr.Am{U `m BJO A{YH m`mZo `mbm `mgmR>r ^mJnmS>`mMm `Z Ho bm `m`mda Jmoir PmS>br. VaAmhr gm{JVbo hmoVo H s, dmV`bT>mMm B{Vhmggw hmoVmo VmoJmoajoZo. ***

    dmVd

    JmoamoMZ : qeJmMo _m`_mVyZ gy {H aUmmao{H m hmo D Z JmoamoMZ {nmme`mV O_m hmoVo. ho \ V Zg{JH [a`m_V Pmbo`m JmB_`oM {_iVo.

    {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 & 13

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    14/52

    14 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

    VWmH {WVmZr Ho bobo VH Am{U `mbm {Xbobo wmanwT>rb_mUo -

    1) _hmam>mV _mg {dH s H aUmao XrS> bmI bmoH ~oamoOJma hmoVrb.Cma : Jmo nmbZ hm XoIrb EH MmJbm `dgm` Amho. `m

    `dgm`m_wioHo di Jm`rMo gajU hmoBb Ago Zmhr Va `mnmgyZ

    nm{>H XwYhr {_iob. Oo Amamo`mbm \ m`mMo R>aUma Amho. `m{edm`Omo `Vr ~oamoOJma hmo`mMr e`Vm Amho, `mbm `mH So> `dgm`hUyZhr nmhVm `oBb. `m_wio Ym{_H gmhmXhr dmT>rg bmJob dg_mOmbm emVVm bm ob.

    2) Jmo _mg J[a~mM moQ>rZ Amho. ~XrZo Amamo`mda Xn[aUm_hmoVrb.

    Cma :dmV{dH nmhVm Jmo_mg hm J[a~mMm AmhmaM Zmhr. Xmi,^mV, MnmVr, mH ar, mOr hm `mMm _wI Amhma Amho. R>amdrH dJZOaog_moa R>oD Z gd J[a~mZm Jmo_mgmhmar Xe{d`mMm {ZaWH `Zgw Amho. Omo Ho di EH _yInUm Amho. EH {H bmo Jmo _mgmgmR>r150 Vo 200 n`o _moOmdo bmJVmV; _m VodT>mM {H _VrV 2 {H bmoXmi {_iVo. EH {H bmo Jmo_mgmV Ho di Mma ` sMo OodU hmoDeH Vo, naVw 2 {H bmoXmirV H _rV H _r 16 Vo 20 ` s OodU H eH VmV. _mgmhmamVyZ {_iUm`m moQ>rZ_wio nmoQ>mer g~{YV AZoHAmOma hmoD eH VmV. emH mhma hm earamgmR>r AZwHyb R>aVmo.

    _hmam> Am{U h[a`mUmgaH maZo Jo`m _{h`mV Jmode h`m~XrH m`Xm bmJy Hobm.`mZVa Xoe^amVrbVWmH {WV {dMmadVmZr`m {damoYmV AmnboHwVH _mS>m`bm gw dmV

    Hobr. hm H m`Xm bmJyPm`mZVa VWmH {WVgo`wba Am{U_mZdm{YH madmmMrPmonM CS>mbr. `m_wiog_mOmVrb Aem `mVWmH {WV {dMmadVmZr`m{damoYmV Hw VH mMo amZoCR>dbo. `m_wioamZmV

    dmT>bobo A\ doMo VUdoirM ImoSy>Z H mT>Uo_hdmMoAmho.

    bIoda MderZmJnya9604382632AZwdmX gmJa gwadgo

    Hw VH Am{U dmV{dH Vm

    Zmomar

    Jmo_` : EH mMm H Mam ho Xg`mMo nmofH ` `m {Z`_m_mUoIV hUyZ Jm`r`m eo UmMm AZmXr H mimnmgyZdmna hmoV Amho.

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    15/52

    {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 & 15

    3) Jmo h`m ~Xr H m`Xm hm Ang`H g_mOmdaA`m` Amho. H maU Jmo _mg ho `mMo _w` OodU Amho.

    Cma :_Zw` hm d^mdV:M _mgmhmar Zmhr. VmoemH mhmarAmho. Vmo _mgmhmamnojm Jm`rMo XY JhU H eH VmonMdy eH Vmo. `m_wio Jmo_mg ho Ang`H g_mOmMo_wI A Amhohm Ho di EH `w{ dmX R>aVmo. EHJm` Am`w`^a _Zw`mbm XyY XoD Z `mMo ^aUnmofUH aVo, _m _Zw` `mM Jm`rbm {V`m CVmad`mVH gm`mH So> XoVmo. HodT>m hm H VZnUm.

    4) XY Z XoUmar, ^mH S> Jm` O{_Zrdarb gd Mmamgndob. `m_wio BVa OZmdamZm Mmam amhUma Zmhr.

    Cma : Jm` Mmam Im`m~amo~aM eoUm`m nmZoZg{JH eoUIVmMr {Z{_VrXoIrb H aVo. `mIVm_wioO{_ZrMm CnOmD nUm dmT>Vmo. `m eoUIVmMmO{_Zrbm dm _Zw`m`mbm H gbmhr YmoH m Zmhr.eoUIV KmV`mZo IMmVhr H nmV hmoVo VgoM,{nH mda {H S>rMm mX mdhr hmoV Zmhr. `m_wio_hmJS>r {H Q>H ZmeHo IaoXr H a`mMm IMhr dmMVmo.naXoemVyZ amgm`{ZH IVmMm hmoV Agbobm

    _mamXoIrb H _r H aVm `oD eH Vmo. _hdmMhUOo, `m Jm`r ^mH S> Pmbo`m AgVmV `m`meoUmnmgyZhr IV{Z{_Vr H aVm `oD eH Vo.

    5) H m`m_wio Ang`H m`m A{YH mamda JXm.Cma : ~hg`H bmoH m`m A{YH mamMmXoIrb

    Ho hmVar _mZ amIbm Jobm nm{hOo. `m XoemV~hg`H hr amhVmV. `mMoXoIrb `m XoemgmR>r`moJXmZ Amho. Jmoh`m ~Xr H m`m_wio ~hg`H

    g_mO Iyf hmoV Agob Va `mV dmdJH m` Amho?6) Jmo h`m H aUm`mbm 10 dfmMr {ejm,

    ~bmH ma H aUm`mbm 7 df}. Jm` _{hbo`merbmnojm A{YH _hdnyUAmho?

    Cma : Amhr Va ~bmH mar ` sbm O_R>ononmgyZ \ merMr {ejm Xo`mMr _mJUr H aVmo._m, go`wbadmmVrb H mhr _hm^mJ `m`mgmR>r

    _mZdm{YH mamMm H Q>moam KoD Z `mMr {ejm _m\H amdr Aer ^rH _mJVmV. go`wbadmmH Sy>Z_mZdm{YH mamMr Am{U \ merda ~XrMr _mJUr hUOo_moR>m S>m_m Amho.

    7) Jmo_mg `mnmamV qhXXoIrb gh^mJr Amho?Cma :Jmo h`m H aUmam hm JwhoJma Amho. _J Vmo

    qhX, pZ dm _wgb_mZ Agob. Jmo_mgmMr gdm{YH{Z`mV _wpb_ XoemV hmoVo.

    8) Jm`rda BVH o_ Va _J a`mda H m gmoS>Vm?Cma : mMrZ H mimV amOo bmoH Jm`rbm gajU

    Xo`mgmR>r JmoemioMr `dWm H aV hmoVo. _m,

    AmOMo emgZH V} ghH m`m`m ZmdmImbr Jmo_mg{Z`mV H a`mgmR>r AZwXmZ XoVmV. am`H `mMm{damoYm^mg nmhm, _VXoh nwa`mgmR>r _moR>-_moR>oX\ Z y_r qH dm H ~VmZ ~Zd`mgmR>r gaH ma AZwXmZXoVo. Jmo_mVogmR>r _m WmoS>rer O_rZ Am{U MmamXoIrbXoV Zmhr. Oa H m eham`m ZOrH Jm`rgmR>r O_rZAm{U Mmam {Xbm Va Jm` ehamV ^Q>H V {\ aUma Zmhr.

    9) Jmo_mgmda ~Xr hUOo ^moOZ dmV`mMm KmV.

    Cma : _Zw` H _ H a`mgmR>r dV Amho. VgMgm_m{OH {Z`_mMo nmbZ H aUo ho `m`mgmR>r~YZH maH Amho. a`mda Vwhr nm{hOo Ver H maMmbdyeH Vm. _m Vwhr {Z`_ nmibo ZmhrV Va H m`hmoBb? XKQ>ZmXoIrb hmoD eHob. a`mda AnKmVhmoD Z`o. _mUyg gwa{jV amhmdm hUyZ dmhVyH sMo{Z`_ Ambo. a`mdarb {Z`_mMo nmbZ H aUo hmdmhZMmbH m`m dmV`mda JXm AmUUo Zho, Va

    g_mO`dWm gwairV Mmb`mgmR>r _hdmMo Amho.`m_mUoM ^moOZm`m dmV`mMm AW Xg`m

    ` s`m _m`Vobm `mo` Vmo g_mZ XoD Z ^moOZ JhUH aUo hmo`. `m H maUm_wio g_mOmV AVa, VUmd{Z_mU hmoBb Ago H m` H aVm H m_m Z`o.

    ***

    Zmomar

    Jmo_y : ho A`V AmfYr Amho. ho EH agm`Z Amho. _Zw`mMoVgo {nH mMo amo J ~aohmo VmV. AZr XrVH aUmao, H \ d dmVXmofmMoe_Z H aUmao Amho. EHyU 148 amoJm`m {ZdmaUmgmR>r `mMm \ m`Xm hmoVmo.

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    16/52

    16 & {ddoH {dMma & _o 2015

    gmobmnya OZVm ghH mar ~H {b, gmobmnya

    gwdU_hmogdr dfma^ gmoh`mg _w`_r _m.lr.Xod| \ S>Udrg `mMr CnpWVr

    gmobmnya OZVm ghH mar ~H {b. (_Q>rQ>oQ> eoS>wS> ~H ) Mo gwdU_hmogdr df21 E{b 2015nmgyZ gw hmoV Amho. `m{Z{_m gnyU df amgmR>r ~Ho Mr Am{WH JVr, ~Ho Mr gm_m{OH ~m{YbH s,g^mgX H `mU, {d{dY g_ma d H m H _, _Zw`~i {dH mg d `j g_mamoh `m nbyda ~HoZobjH|{V Ho boAmho.

    ~HoMr gm_m{OH ~m{YbHs - m_ o PmonS>n>r mJmVrb {dm mgmR>r emV A m{gHm, EHm

    dVrMm

    gdHf {dHmg, bmoH {ejU B. Mm g_mdoeAgob.

    X mOHmMo gmX HaU, djgdYZ, dN>Vm A{ mZ

    CnH _. Anman[aH DOm A{ mZ, g_mOmgmR>r_mobmMo

    moJXmZXoUm m pVgmR>rdgWmgmR>rnwaHma.

    {d{dYg_ma^dHm H_-gwdU_hmogddfma^

    gmohim, ghHma jomVrb _m damMr EH n[afX,

    {Za{Zam m emImMo dYmnZ{XZ, VrZ {Xdgr` gJrV

    g_mamohB.

    _Zw ~i {dHmg - JwUm_H

    dmT> - m_ o H_Mmar {ejU, m mZ_mbm, gwdU _hmogdr JW

    (S>m w_|Q>ar)d_m{hVrnQ>,B.Mmg_mdoe

    AgUmaAmho.

    ~HoMrAm{WHJVr - m_ o

    emIm {dVma Rupay Debit Card,

    SMSBanking,B.C.P.F. moOZm,

    Hmnm}aoQ> ~[HJ,N>moQ>mbmoHmMr_moR>r

    ~H, _{hbm ~MV JQ>mgmR>r Micro

    FinanceMmg_mdoeAgob.

    gwdU_hmogdr dfd gmJVm g_ma -_m. nVYmZ `mMoCnpWVrV H aUoMm _mZg Amho.

    g mgXH mU- oQ>dVy, AnKmVr{d_mgajU.

    JmBMo XY hoAmB`m XYm_mUo gd AZKQ>H - OrdZgdo Agbobo Amho. bhmZ _wbmgmR>r Vogdm}m_ Amho.

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    17/52

    {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 & 17

    Jmo_mVm, Jm`, H m_YoZyAem AZoH {dY ZmdmZr Jm`rbm g~moYboOmVo. dfmZwdf} Jmo_mVoMr nyOm H aUmam ^maV Xoe AmO Amn`mMXoemVrb dmWu amOH ma`m_wio Jmo_mVoMo gajU H a`mg Ag_WVmXmIdV Amho. gdmeoH moQ>r`m `m XoemV 100 H moQ>r qhX amhVmV;_m Varhr ^maVmV Jm`tMr VH ar Am{U Jmo_mg {Z`mV CKS>nUo gwAmho. Ag H m hmoV ? hm AmnU gm`mZr dV:bm {dMmam`bmhdm. H maU `m mVM `mMoCma XS>bobo Amho.

    Jmo h`m~Xr H m`Xm Am{U dVypWVr_hmam> Am{U h[a`mUm gaH maZoJmode h`m~Xr H m`Xm bmJyHo bm

    Amho. dmV{dH nmhVm `m AmYrhr AZoH am`mV hm H m`Xm H a`mVAmbobm Amho, _m Varhr `m{R>H mUr Jmoh`m Am{U Jmo_mVoMr VH aramOamognUo gw Amho . PmaIS>, {Xr, CmaXoe, nOm~ Am{U AmVmZ`mZo_hmam>, h[a`mUmV hm H m`Xm bmJy Pmbm Amho, _m pWVr OgoWoM Amho! _`Xooe, N>mrgJS>, JwOamV Am{U amOWmZ m{R>H mUrhrhm H m`Xm bmJy Amho. `m am`mV Jmoh`m Pm`mMr CXmhaUo Eo{H dmVZmhrV, _m VH ar gw M Amho. {~hma_`o _m Jmode h`m ~Xr

    Jmo-{dkmZ AZwgYmZH|m`m nMJ`{M{H go_wio Jmo_yAH mMonmMhZ A{YHAmVaam>r` noQ>Q> {_imboAmhoV. ho{dmVrb

    gdm{YH lo> AmfYhUyZ nwT>oAmbo Amho.

    gwZrb _mZqghH mZmJnya

    eXmH Z boIoda Mder

    KamKamV Jm`,JmdmJmdV Jmoemim

    {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 & 17OmJa

    JmB`m earamVyZ Cg{OV hmoUmao na_mUy emVr Am{U dmg` `mZr ^m[aV AgVmV.

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    18/52

    18 & {ddoH {dMma & _o 2015

    Zmhr. VgM `m{R>H mUr {dZmnadmZm H mbIm`mVAdYnUo Jm`t`m H mbr Ho`m OmVmV.

    ~r\ AWmV Jmode Am{U hg m`m _mg {dH s_

    `o _moR>m _mUmV dmT> hmoV Amho. Jo`m Mma dfmV`mV Xhm Q>`mZr dmT> Pmbr Amho. 2011 gmbr~r\ Mm In 20.4 bmI Q>Z BVH m hmoVm. 2014 gmbmVVmo22.5 bmI Q>Z BVH m Pmbm. `mMm n[aUm_ hUyZnewJUZoZwgma XoemV JmodemMr g`m 2012 _`o4.1 Q>`mZo KQ>br. `mV nwhm Xoer Jm`r`m g`oVOdinmg 9 Q>o BVH s H _VaVm Pmbr Amho . `m_wioHo di Jmoh`m~Xr H m`Xm H Z H mhrhr gm` hmoUma

    Zmhr. H maU nmo{bg, emgZmVrb A{YH mar Am{UJmoh`m H aUm`m`m A^ `wVr_wio Jmo h`m Am{UJmoVH ar H aUm`mMm H ma^ma XoemVrb BVa am`mVgw M Amhoo. {deofV: Cma ^maVmVrb AZoH am`mVyZamoO _moR>m _mUmV hr VH ar hmoVo.

    Q>H _YyZ AdYnUo ~mJbmXoem`m gr_oda Jm`rnmR>{d`m OmV AmhoV. `m_wio AmVm JmoajH mg_moa EHn`m` Amho Vmo hUOo, Jm`tZm Jmoh`m H aUmao qH dm

    Jm`rMr VH ar H aUm`mn`V nmohmoMyM m`MoZmhr.AmVm Zmhr Va H YrM ZmhrJmoh`m, Jmo VH ar Am{U Jmo _mg {Z`mVrMo _mU

    nmhVm, Jmo ajUmgmR>r, "A^r Zht Vmo H r Zht' AerMpWVr Amho. `mgmR>r `mnH _mUmda OZOmJVrMrAmd`H Vm Amho. Jmo-nmbZmMo \ m`XoH m` AmhoV,ho A{YH m{YH bmoH mn`V nmohmoM{dUo Amd`H Amho.

    VmoQ>mV MmbUmam H fr `dgm`, `m_`oH moQ>dYreoVH `mMm g_mdoe Amho; `mZm Jmo-nmbZmnmgyZA{YH m{YH bm^ H go {_idVm `oVrb `mg~Yr

    _m{hVr Am{U {ejU Xo`mMr Amd`H Vm Amho.JmoajUmMoH m` ho Jmoemiomao e` Amho. JmoemioV

    Jm`r Am`w`^a gwa{jV amheH VmV. {VWo AZoH CnmXZH m`mV Jm`tMm ^mdr dmna Ho bm OmD eH Vmo. AZoHJmoemim_`oVgo H m` hmoV Amho . `mgmR>r gwgm AemJmoemim {Z{_Vrda ^a XoUoJaOoMoAmho. `oH JmdmVH _rVH _r EH Jmoemim Am{U `oH KamV {H _mZ EHJm` Agmdr, m {>Zo `mnH A{^`mZ am~{dUo JaOoMo

    Amho. oH JmdmV Jm`t`m Mm`mgmR>r Amd`HVodT>m O{_Zr Agm`bm h`mV. mgmR>r emgZ Am{UJmdH `mZr {_iyZ `moOZm AmIm`bm hdr.

    Jmo nmbZmMo bm^Amn`m XoemV Jmo AmYm[aV OrdZ`dWm hmoVr.

    Amn`m gH VrZo Amn`mg_moa "Jmo_` dgVo b_r'Am{U "Jmo_y dmVoA_V' hr gH nZm R>odbr Amho.`m_wio AmnU Jm`rbm Jmo_mVm, H m_YoZy qH dm

    Jmob_rgwm ~mobVmo. `m_mJo AZoH dkm{ZH H maUoAmhoV. JmonmbZ {ZgJmMo ajU Am{U gdYZmgmR>r JaOoMAmho. Jm`rMo XY `m``mZo eara, _Z, ~wr _O~yVamhVo. Jm`r`m eoUmnmgyZ IV, Jmo_y Am{U qb~m`mnm`mnmgyZ H sQ>ZmeH ~ZVo. Jmo_wmnmgyZ ~ZdbobmAH Am{U nMJ`mnmgyZ ~Z{dbo`m AmfYmnmgyZAZoH H ma`m amoJmMm BbmO Ho bm OmVmo. `m{edm`Jm`rMo XY, Xhr, bmoUr, Vyn `mnmgyZ AZoH H ma`m

    dm{X> {_R>mB ~Z{d`m OmVmV. `mMm AmZX^maVmgh gnyU OJ KoV Amho.

    nMJ` {M{H gmnMJ`mMr {Z{_Vr ^maVr` OmVr`m Jm`r`m

    XY, Xhr, Vyn, Jmo_y Am{U eoUmnmgyZ Ho br OmVo.nMJ`m_wioearamVrb amoJ{VH maH e s dmT>d`mg_XV hmoVo. VgoM AZoH amoJmnmgyZ _w s {_idVm `oD

    OmJa

    JmBMo d dmgamMo h~aUoEo H `mg _mZ{gH AmOma, _Zmo{dHVr Xa hmoVmV.

    18 & {ddoH {dMma & _o 2015

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    19/52

    {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 & 19

    eH Vo. nMJ` Am`wd}X CnMma hoAmnbo mMrZ d dAm`wd}XmMm` MaH , gwlwV AmXt`m kmZmVyZ {dH {gVPmbobr Amho. nMJ` {M{H goMr _hVr Am{U

    {dmgmhVm AmO OZ_mZgmV ngabobr Amho, H maU`m`m _wimer _m{UH Vm Am{U gonUm Amho.

    XodimnyapWV Jmo-{dkmZ AZwgYmZ H| mmaonMJ` CnmXZmV AH, Amgd, KZdQ>r, haXo MyU, _m{be Vob, _b_, gm~U, XV_OZ, CQ>>U,Yyn Aem AZoH H ma`m CnmXZmMr {Z{_Vr Ho brOmV Amho. `m AmfYmnmgyZ Agm` _mZ`m OmUm`mamoJmdaXoIrb BbmO hmoVmZm {XgV Amho. `m_`o

    gmoam`grg, EpO_m, nmoQ>mMo {dH ma, {H S>ZrMo AmOma,Ae nUm, nmT>ao S>mJ, a Xm~, _Yw_oh, bhmZ _wboAm{U _{hbmZm hmoUmao AmOmamda hr AmfYo ^mdrR>a`mMo{XgV Amho .

    Jmo AmYm[aV emV eoVr^maVmVrb H fr y_r gmYmaU 1960 n`V amgm`{ZH

    IV{da{hV hmoVr. AmVm hr y_r amgm`{ZH IVm`mAmo`mImbr X~br Jobr Amho. Vr AmVm AmOmar nS>br

    Amho. {VMr VmH X AmVm bmon nmdV Mmbbr Amho.`m_wioM eoVrVyZ Ano{jV CnmXZ hmoV Zmhr.

    gaH mar AmH S>mZwgma Jo`m Xhm dfmV 98 bmIeoVH `mZr eoVr H aUo ~X Ho bo Amho. Xoe^amV`m264 {OmVrb ObVa Imbmdbm Amho.EH m Xm`mnmgyZ bmImo Xm`mMr {Z{_Vr H aUmam~iramOm AmO gmdH mar H OmZo Jmgbm Amho. am>r`JwhoJmar aoH mS>> H m`mb`m`m _m{hVrZwgma 1997 Vo

    2013 n`V XoemV EHy U 1 bmI 82 hOma 936eoVH `mZr Amnbr OrdZ`mm gndbr Amho. BVamZmOrdZ XoUm`m ~iramOm`m OrdZmV Zam` Am{UbmMmarnUm ngaV Amho. mVyZ EH Jmo> g_moa oVoVr,H {f{df`H `moOZmMm A^md Am{U amgm`{ZH eoVrMoXn[aUm_ `m_wio hogd KS>V Amho .

    `m gd dmVmdaUmV Jmo AmYm[aV O{dH eoVrnV

    hrM EH _od Cnm` Amho. JmonmbZm{edm` O{dHeoVr Ae` Amho. gy_Ord Am{U JmSw>i hoH R>rUO{_Zrbm wg werV ~Z{dVmV; `m_wio nrH dmT>m`bm

    _XV hmoVo. Jm`r`m 1 J_ eoUm_`o AemH maMo300Vo 500 H moQ>r gy_ Ord AgVmV, Am{U hogy_OrdO{_ZrVrb JmSw>imZm gH s` H a`mMo H m_XoIrbH aVmV. `m_wio JmSw>i O{_Z wg yerV H a`mgg{H hmoVmV. `m_wioAg hQ>b Job Amho H s, eoU hoOrdm_V, gy_ OrdmMo _hmgmJa Amho. md Z ho n>hmoVo H s, JmoAmYm[aV eoVrMm CnOmD nUm AmOrdZamhVmo. O{_ZrMr eVr dmT>`mZo nrH Omo_Xma `oVo.

    VgoM O{_ZrVrb nm`mMr nmVirXoIrb dmT>Vo. `m_wioZam`mH So> PwH bo`m eoVH `mbm ZdgOrdZr {_iob.

    A`mgH _ Am{U OmJ H VmJmo AmYm[aV O{dH eoVr, JmonmbZ Am{U nMJ`Mo

    _hd ej{UH A`mgH _mV `m`bm hdo. H{_HnmR>nwVH mV Vo m`bm hdoV. VoJaOoMo Amho . A`WmAmn`m XoemM ho AZoH dfmM Aj` kmZ bmon nmdob.`m gmo~VM eoVH `mgmR>r {ejU H|mMr {Z{_Vr

    hmoUo JaOoMoAmho. doimodoir eoVH `mZm {e{jV H aVamhUo JaOoMoAmho. Aem hOmamo-bmImo H m`H `mMr{Z{_Vr H aUo JaOoMo Amho Oo, JmonmbZ, Jmo AmYm[aVeoVrMr {Z{_Vr H a`mMo Cnm` Jmdm JmdmV, Kam KamVnmohMdVrb. Jmo {dkmZ AZwgYmZ H| AmOXoemVrb {d{dY jomVrb eoVH `mZm Jmo AmYm[aVeoVr, JmonmbZ VgoM nMH _mgmR>r bmJUm`m CnmXZ{Z{_VrgmR>r {e{jV H aV Amho. AmO`m KS>rbm

    AZoH eoVH ar Amn`m _`m{XV OmJoV A{YH m{YHeoVr {nH dV Amho. Vohr {ZgJmbm H moU`mhr H maMmY m bmJUma Zmhr Aem nVrZo.

    `m AmnU gH n H mV, "KamKamV Jm`,JmdmJmdmV Jmoemim''`m `m A{^`mZmV gh^mJrhmD m. Amnbrhr JmonmbZ nr g{_Ym JaOoMr Amho.

    ***

    OmJa

    JmB`m XYmVrb Hoamo{Q>Z ho AZo H amoJmda JwUH mar AgVo. `m Hoamo{Q>Z_wioM XYmbm {ndim aJ `oVmo.

    {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 & 19

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    20/52

    20 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

    'Vishwa Karma', 529/3, Parvati, Sinhagad Road, Next To Ramkrishna Math,Pune - 411 030. : 24334657, 24335531, 24334006e-mail Address : [email protected]

    Sadhana Ladies Hostel"Vishwa Karma", 529/3,Parvati, Sinhagad Road,Pune - 411030.: 24328531

    Bhargav health club10, Sneh-Nagar, Bibvewadi,Behind Market Yard,Pune - 411037.: 24267389

    Kulkarni Constructions Pvt LtdKulkarni Constructions Pvt. Ltd.

    With Best Compliments

    Engineers, Builders & Developers

    SU SIDI RIES

    SUBSIDIARIES

    H Q>b\w S> _MQ>, 6, Hw ma dog emqnJ g|Q>a,OmoS>^mdr noR>, gmobmnya 413007

    XadZr : 2733950^_UdZr : 9422459495, 9421061570

    e-mail : [email protected]

    nwgmam_ am_oda H admnwgmam_ am_oda H admgd H maMo newIm {dHo Vm

    nMJ`mnmgyZ 2500 AmfYmMr {Z{_Vr e`.

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    21/52

    {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 & 21

    Zmam`U Xodamd nmT>arnmS>o. `dV_mi {OmVrb nwgX`oWrb EH gdm}X`r eoVH ar. {Z>mdmZ JmYrdmXr Am{U

    gdm}X`r Hw _manm `mMo AZw m`r Agbobo Zmam`Uamd AmO h`mVZmhrV. h`mV AgVo Va AmO `mMo d` eVH m`m C~aR>mnmeram{hbo AgVo. nYam-gmoim dfmnydu `m`m KarM `mZm oQ>`mgmR>rJobmo hmoVmo. Vohm `mZr d`mMr AmR> XeHo nwar Ho br hmoVr. dN>gwVr YmoVa Am{U gXam n[aYmZ H aUmao Zmam`Uamd nmT>arnmS>o `m`mH m`mZo AOam_a PmboAmhoV. Jmodem`m {df`r Anma lm Va `mZr

    ~miJbrM, nU VodT>mda Wm~bo ZmhrV. nMJ`m`m Cn`wVVo{df`r`mZr gImob gemoYZ Hobo Am{U `moJ{g dkm{ZH Vo`m Vamda Vr{g Ho br. am>r`M ZhoVa AmVaam>r` nmVirda Jmode {dkmZm`mAm{U g|r` eoVr`m jomV Vo "ZS>onH mH m' ZmdmZo `mVr nmdbo.JmBMo amoOMo eoU, JmoR>m- eoVmVbm H mS>rH Mam Am{U KamVbmd`nmH KamVrb Amobm H Mam {d{e> AmH mam`m (3 \y Q> 3 \y Q> 3 \yQ>) IS>S>>mV gmR>dV Jobo Va XmoZ Vo VrZ _{h`m`m H mimV CH >H maMoH nmoQ>> IV V`ma hmoVo. EHyU df ^amMm {heo~ Ho bm Va 70

    Vo 80 Q>Z hUOo70 Vo 80 hOma {H bmo EdT>o V`ma hmoUmao ho IV EHn`m {H bmo `m XamZo{dH bo Var `mVyZ dm{fH 70 Vo 80 hOma n`oH _m{dVm `oVmV. ho Zmam`UamdmZr dV:`m KamV Ho bo`m `moJmVyZ{g Ho bo. `mhrnwT>o OmD Z Jmo_y Am{U Jmo_` `m`mVrb Cn`wKQ>H mdahr `mZr gemoYZ Ho bo. `mZr {b{hbo`m emoY{Z~YmMr WoQ>O_ZrVrb {V[R>>V {dkmZ gWm Am{U {Z`VH m{bH mZr XIb KoVbr.ho gmao H m` `mZr C^mabo Vo EH m {dbjU AZw dmnmgyZ oaUm KoD Z.

    Jmodkm{ZH ZS>onH mH m

    AU H a_aH a`o> nH maR>mUo.9321259949

    am>r`M Zho Va AmVaam>r`nmVirda Jmode {dkmZm`mAm{U g|r` eoVr`m jomV Vo"ZS>onH mH m' `m ZmdmZo `mVrnmdbo. JmB`meoUmnmgyZ Kam`mM AmdmamVV`ma Hobobo IV dV`mZmdmVrb AmmjamZrM (ZmS>on-Nadep) `mZr gm[aVHobo. EH Jm`, {V`m XYmMmW|~hr {dH V Zmhr Varhr,EH m eoVH `m`m HwQw >~mbmdm{fH 70 Vo 80 hOma n`mMoCn {_idyZ XoD eH Vo, hoZmam`UamdmZr dV`m

    KamVM `moJ H Z {gHobo.

    ZnoS>H mH m

    AZw d amoH S>m

    `mo` arVrZo nmibo`m 90 Jm`r 16 dfmV 450 Jm`tZm O_ XoVmV. EdT>oM ZhoVa `m`mnmgyZ hOmamo n`mMoXY d IVhr {_iVo. Jm` gnmrMr amUr Amho.-~aH V d gaH V_YyZ (gH bZ : hOaV _moh_X- _mbm \ mIr)

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    22/52

    22 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

    `m`mM Vm|SyZ> hm AZw d EoH m`bm {_imbm.Pmbo Vo Ago 1990-91 `m gw_mamg

    Zmam`UamdmZm EH m AnKmVmbm gm_moao Omdo bmJbo. m

    AnKmVmZo `m`m CO`m Immda Agm H mhr AmKmVHo bm H s `mMm g~Y hmV nyUnUo bwim nS>bm. nOmMr~moQ>ohr hbdVm oBZmV H s hmV CMbm`Mm Varhr Xg`mhmVmZo Y ZM CMbVm oBb. haVhoMo S>mQ>ar CnMmaPmbo, nU H mhrM \ aH nS>oZm. COdmM hmV nyUnUo{ZpH Pm`mZo eoVrMr H m_ohr H aVm `oBZmV.KamVM nSy>Z amh`mMr doi Ambr. {ZameoZo Koabo`mZm.KambJV Agbobo eoV Am{U Kam`m

    AmdmamVM Agbobm JmoR>m AWUmda nS>`m nS>`mgVV S>mo`mg_moa `oB. _wbo eoVr`m _emJVrH S>o,JmoR>m`m gm\ g\ mBH S>o nwaog bj XoV Zmhr`oVAg CJmMM dmQ>m`bm bmJb. ~m`H moda, _wbmdaCJmMM dVmJyZ Pmb. AJXrM MZ nS>oZm VohmEH {Xdg Zmam`Uamd {Va{VarZo CR>bo Am{U S>m`mhmVmV PmSy> KoD Z JmB`m JmoR>mV {eabo. JmoR>mPmS>V am{hbo. WH bo Vohm {VWoM H mhr doi Jm`r`m

    gm{`mV ~gyZ am{hbo. eodQ>r HQ>miyZ KamVnaVbo Vohm mZm Amn`m CO m hmVm`m ~moQ>m_`oH mhrgo MV` Am`mgmaIodmQ>bo . Vgo hQ>bo Vohm~m`H mo_wbmZr doS>mV H mT>bo. nU Zmam`UamdmZr _mEH doJimM `moJ Hobm. Xg`m {Xder gH minmgyZg`mH min`V `mZr Jmo_`mMm - eoUmMm bon CO`mImmnmgyZ ~moQ>mn`V g~Y hmVmda WmnyZ R>odbm. nwT>oXhm - nYam {Xdg Vo AgoH aV am{hbo Am{U AmM`

    KS>bo! `m`m hmVm_`o MmJbmM gw Yma Pmbm.hiyhiy `mMm `mZm VmoAmVm AJXr Imm`m aofon`VCMbVmhr `m`b bmJb. JmBM eoU Am{U JmBMmghdmg `m`m `m {dbjU n[aUm_m_wioVo AmZXrhrPmboAm{U AV_wIhr. _J `mZr PnmQy>Z `mda gemoYZH a`mMo H m_ KoVbo. `m`m Ag bjmV Amb H seoUmV Agbo`m CUVoMr nmVir CH i`m nm m`m

    Vn_mZmnojmhr {H VrVar nQ> OmV AgVo. _m, Varhrho ghOVoZo hmVmiVm `oVo. `mMm AWeoUm`m AJrEH {dbjU CUVmamoYZ e s (BgwboqQ>J H no{gQ>r)

    AgVo. eoUmZogmadbobr O_rZ WS> amhVohm AZw dhmoVmM. `mM {XeoZo A{YH {dMma H Z `mZr eoUmMmCn`moJ H Z q^VrZm bmdVm `o`mgmaIm aJ ~Zdbm.Vmo q^VtZm bmdbm Am{U bjmV Ambo H s Oi_Q>oHoir>Ho hmoV ZmhrV. {edm` ImobrV Vn_mZhr _mZdrJaOoer gwgJVM amhVo. _J eoUm_`odJmi Ho bobr_wbVmZr _mVr {_giyZ mZr gm~UmMr dS>r ~Z{dbr.gwJYr `odm H {_ aJ Z dmnaVm V`ma Ho bo`m `m

    gm~UmMm dmna Ho bm H s dMm _wbm`_ Am{U VOobXma~ZVo`mMmhr emo Y bmJbm. eoUmnmgyZ Zmam`UamdmZrYynH mS>r ~Z{dbr. hr CX~mr bmdbr H s H sQ>H ,nmIao`m`mda MmJbo {Z`U amhVo. {edm` CX~mrOiyZ Jo`mZVa {VMr amI Cm_ XV_OZ hUyZ dmnaVm`oVo. AmVm Zmam`Uamd A{YH R>m_nUo eoVH `mZm gmJybmJbo, "Jm` nmim, {VMo XY KamV dmnam, OmVam{hbo Va eoOm`mZm dmQy>Z Q>mH m, {dHy ZH m.

    XYm{edm` Jm` OoXoVo `mda Amam_mV M[aVmW Mmbob.KambJV Agbo`m eoVmV Zmam`UamdmMo gwnw _bmKoD Z Jobo. amgm`{ZH IVmMm dm H sQ>H ZmeH mMm{Vi_m dmna Z H aVm Hodi g|r` H nmoQ> IVm`mOmoamda CJ{dbo`m dmar`m VmQ>mZr C oeoV S>mobVhmoVo. ^aJ H Ugo `mda Sw>bV hmoVr... _mZdrOrdZmgmR>r Agm gdmJrU CnH maH Cn`moJ Agbo`mJm`r~m~V (qhX) g_mOm`m _ZmV Anma H VkVoMm

    Am{U loMm ^md {Z_mU Pmbm ZgVm VaM Zdb.ZnoS> H mH m`m `m gemoYZmnmgyZ oaUm KoD Z

    AH mobm `oWrb "AmXe gH ma _S>i' `m gWoZoAH mo`mnmgyZ 10-12 {H bmo_rQ>adarb hgnya\ mQ>m `oWo1999 nmgyZ EH Jmo{dkmZ AZwgYmZ H|Mmb{dbo Amho. (AmVm Va Xoem`m gd ^mJmV AerJmo{dkmZ H|o gw Pmbr AmhoV.) Jmo_`, Jmo_y, Xhr,

    AZw d amoH S>m

    CnbY newYZm`m AmYmao XoemV 70 bmI Q>Z noQ>mo{b`_Mr ~MV hmoVo. (~mOma^mdm_mUo 1400 AO n`o),60 AO n`mMoXY {_iVo, 30 AO n`mMog|r` IV Am{U 20 H moQ>r n`mMm Jmo~a Jg {_iVmo.

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    23/52

    {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 & 23

    Vyn m nMJ`mMm AmfYr Cn`moJ {g Am{U gm[aVH a`mMo H m_ `mnH _mUmV gw Pmbo Amho.ZmJnyaOdi`m Xodbmnma `oWrb H| mMo gMmbH

    gwZrb _mZqgJH m `mZr Va _moR>m n[al_mZo Jmo_ym`m R>m`r Agbo`m amoJ{V~YH e s dqJVH aUm`m KQ>H mMoAmVaam>r` noQ>Q> mHo bo Amho. Jmo_mVoMoeara hm Zg{JH D O}mm EH MS> moVAg`mMo gemoYZmVr

    {XgyZ AmboAmho. Jm` Amn`m earamVyZ_moR>m _mUmda Zd`m`wMo CgOZ H arV AgVo.`m_wio {VMm dmda Agbo`m amZmV`m{hadirda AZdmUr nm`mZoqhS>Uohr Amamo`mXm`r R>aVo.Jmo_ymnmgyZ V`ma Ho bobr H sQ>{Z`Ho ^aKmog Am{UH gXma {nH mgmR>r daXmZ {g Pmbr AmhoV. ewrHV({S>Q>rS>) Jmo_ymMo {Z`{_V meZ AZoH `mYtZm{V~Y H aVo, ho {XgyZ Ambo Amho. BVHoM H m`,

    Zg{JH ar`m _`y nmdbo`m Jm`rMm Xoh {OWo X\ ZHo bm OmVmoVo Wrb y_rhr A{YH gH g Am{U gwnrHH a`mg `m Jm`rMo H mVS>o, qeJo Am{U ZIohmV^mabmdVmV, hohr {g Pmb . hUyZM Hodi qOdVnUrM

    Zho Va _`yZVa _mZ`mMo nmofU H a`mMo H m_rJmo_mVm A{Ve` _hdnyU y{_H m {Z^mdVo. ^JdmZlrH U Am{U {dUwJw H m{Q>`mnmgyZ (MmU`)

    _hm_m JmYr - dmV`dra gmdaH amn`V gJ`m_hmZw dmZr Jmode gJmonZ Am{U gdYZmMmAmJh Yabm Vmo CJrM Zmhr. AJXrAmO`m H mimV `m AWH maUmbm_hd m Pmbo Amho `m`m

    > r H m o Z m V y Z{dMma Ho bm VarhrJmodemYm[aV AWaMZm

    {Zam_` g_rMm_hm_mJ eVH a`mMo gm_`

    ~miJVo AgoM hUmdo bmJob. n`mdaUm`mgJmonZmMr, Zg{JH ggmYZm`m OnUwH sMr VgoMI{ZO Vobmgma`m BYZm`m ~MVrMr hmH mQ>r g`mOJmV gd {nQ>br OmV Amho. `m gX^mVhr Jmode,nMJ` _mZdVo`m g_rgmR>r CnH maH R> eH Vmo.

    `m >rZo Jmode gdYZm`m ~m~VrVrb OmJVrbmAm{U gemoYZmVhr MS> JVr XoUohr {ZH S>rMr ~m~Amho.

    ***

    AZw d amoH S>m

    gH [aV dmgao Hw nmofUmbm ~ir nS>VmV, Or H mhr WmoS>r {ebH amhVmV Vr CU hdm_mZmV eoVrMr H m_o H eH V ZmhrV.

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    24/52

    24 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

    ^maVmV 29 nH s 11 am`o Aer AmhoV H s OoWoJm`, ~b,dmg , hg `mMr H mb H a`mda Am{U _mg Im`mda~Xr Zmhr. BVa 18 am`m_`o Jmoh`oda nyUnUoqH dm Am{eH ~XrAmho. ^maVmV 80 Q>`mhZ A{YH bmoH g`m qhXAmho . `mVrbA{YH me bmoH Jm`rbm nyOVmV. naVw OJmV gdm{YH ~r\ {Z`mVH a`m`m XoemV maVmMm g_mdoe Amho. Jmoh`og~YmV H moUVmhr H| r`H m`Xm Zmhr. doJdoJ`m am`mV doJdoJ`m H mao AZoH XeH mnmgyZJmoh`m~XrMm H m`Xm bmJy Amho.

    H m_ra, {h_mMb Xoe, nOm~, h[a`mUm, CmamIS>, Cma Xoe,amOWmZ, JwOamV, _`Xoe, _hmam>, N>mrgJS> hr 11 am`oAm{U{Xr d M{XJS> `m H| em{gV am`mV nyUnUo Jmoh`m~Xr bmJyAmho.`m H m`mMo CKZ Ho`mg H S>H {ejoMr VaVyXhr `m am`m_`oAmho. h[a`mUmV gdm{YH {ejm hUOoEH bmImMm XS> Am{U 10dfm`m H mamdmgmMr {ejm Aer VaVyX Amho Va _hmam>mV Jmoh`mHo `mg 10 hOma XS> Am{U 10 df}VwJdmg. N>mrgJS> dJiVm `mA` am`m_`oher`m H mbrda ~Xr Zmhr.

    Jmoh`oda Am{eH {V~X hUOo Ho di Jm` Am{U dmgam`mh`oda nyU ~Xr. ~b, diyAm{U hetMr h`m Am{U _mg Im`mMrnadmZJr Amho. nU `mgmR>r {\ Q> \ ma bmQ>a g{Q>{\ Ho Q> AgUoAmd`H AgVo. ho g{Q>{\ HoQ> newMod`, H m_ H a`mMr j_VmAm{U OZZj_Vm nmhZ {Xbo OmVo . H m`mMoCKZ H aUm`mZm

    ~Xr AgyZhr JmoYZ KQ>bo

    ^maVmV EHy U 3600H mbImZoZJanm{bH mH Sy>ZMmbdbo OmVmV. `m{edm` 42H mbImZoAmb B{S>`m _rQ>

    AS> bmBdQ>mH EgnmoQ>gAgmo{gEeZH Sy>Z MmbdboOmVo. `oWrb _mg \ {Z`mVH a`mV `oVmo. 32 H mbImZo^maV gaH ma`m EH m{d^mJm`m A{Yn`mImbr`oVmV. _hmam>, nOm~ Am{UCma Xoe `m VrZ am`mVyZ

    m_w`mZo her`m _mgmMr{Z`mV hmoVo. EH m CmaXoemV317 Zm|XUrH V H mbImZoAmhoV.

    (boImgmR>r gX ~r~rgr qhXr gHo Wi)

    mg{JH

    Jmo_ymV Zm`Q>moOZ, H m~m}{bH A{gS>gmaIr Am{U X `m Jm`r`m _ymV bQ>moO, g\ a, A_mo{Z`m, Vm~o,nmoQ>{e`_, _JZrO, y[a`m, _rR>, AZoH jma, Cn`wV AmboAgVmV.

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    25/52

    {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 & 25

    {H aH moi {eHo Mr VaVyX Amho. XS> OmVrV OmVhOma n`o Am{U ghm _{hZo Vo XmoZ dfmMr {ejm.Am{eH ~Xr Agbobr AmR> am`o- {~hma, PmaIS>,Amo{S>em, VobJUm, AmYXoe, Vm{_iZmSy>, H ZmQ>H ,Jmodm Am{U Mma H| em{gV am`o - X_U d Xrd, XmXaAm{U ZJa hdobr, nm{S>Moar, AX_mZ Am{U {ZH mo~ma.

    nwT>rb Xhm am`mV _m H moUVrhr ~Xr Zmhr.Ho ai, n{_ ~Jmb, Amgm_, AUmMb Xoe,_{Unya, _oKmb`, {_Pmoam_, ZJmbS>, {nwam,{gH s_ Am{U EH H| em{gV am` bjrn_`o Jmoh`oda H moU`mhr H maMr ~Xr Zmhr. 2011 `mOZJUZoZwgma `mVrb AZoH am`m_`o dZdmgrOZOmVtMo _mU 80 Q>`mhZ A{YH Amho. Am{U`mVrb A{YH me am`mV Y_mVam_wiopZ ~Zbo`mMrg`mhr OmV Amho.

    ~r\ Mo CnmXZ : 2014 Mr AmH So>dmar5.783 : H moQ>r _oQ>rH Q>Z

    (OJmVrb EHy U ~r\ CnmXZ)

    1.12 : H moQ>r _oQ>rH Q>Z - A_o[aH m69.7 bmI _oQ>rH Q>Z- MrZ22.5 bmI _oQ>rH Q>Z- ^maV

    (moV: BQ>aZeZb _rQ> goHoQ>o [a`Q>)

    2013-14 _`o ^maVmVyZ 26,457.79 H moQ>t`m~r\ Mr {Z`mV Pmbr. ~moH S> Am{U _|T>m`m _mgmMr{Z`mV 694.10 H moQ>r n`mMr hmoVr. gnyU OJmVherMo_mg {Z`mV H a`mV nwT>o Agbo`m ^maVmV

    ~r\ Mm In 3.89 Q>o Amho . A_o[aH m, ~mPrb,`yamonr` gK Am{U MrZ_`o 58 Q>o ~r\ Imm OmVmo.1951 _Yrb newJUZoZwgma XoemV JmodemMo

    _mU 53.04 Q>o hmoVo . 2012 _`o ho _mU37.28 Q>`mn`V Kga`mMo {Xgbo. ^maVmV OaJmoh`m ~Xr AmhoVa Jm`tMo _mU BVHo H _r Pmbo H go ? ApIb maVr` Jmogodm _wI eH aamb `m`m

    _VmZwgma Jm`rH So> Ho di XY XoUmam ney BV`mM_`m{XV >rZonm{hbo Jobo . Jm`rMo BVa _hd Xb{jboJo`m_wio H m`mVyZ nidmQ> H mT>V Jm`tMr _moR>m_mUmV H mb hmoV am{hbr.

    Amb B{S>`m _rQ> ES> bmBdQ>mH EgnmoQ>gEgmo{gEeZMo _hmg{Md S>r~r g^admb `m`m_VmZwgma ^maVmV ~r\ `m ZmdmImbr herMo_mgM {dH boOmVo. 1947 ZVa ^maVmV A{YH VnUoJm` H mnbr OmV Zmhr. `m_wioJmoh`m ~XrMm ~r\{Z`mVrda H mhrhr n[aUm_ hmoUma Zmhr. maVmVyZ {Z`mVhmoUmam ~r\ hm e a Q>o herMmM _mg AgVmo._mg `mnmamer g~{YV `mnmar gmJVmV H s m YmVHodi EH mM Y_mMo bmoH ZmhrV. 28 H moQ>r n`m`m`m `mdagm`mV Ja_wgb_mZmMo _mUhr \ ma _moR>o Amho.

    Aao{~`Z EgnmoQ>, AVwb g^admb `mMr AbH ~ra EgnmoQ>g, AO` gyX `mMr Ab Zya EgnmoQ>,_hoe OJXmbo AS> H nZr ~r\ EgnmoQ> AmXr Zmdmd Z`mZmV `oVo H s ~r\ `dgm`mer EH mM Y_mMobmoH{ZJ{S>V ZmhrV.

    ***

    mg{JH

    JmB`m eoUmV nQ>H sMo (H mbam) OVy ZQ> H a`mMr j_Vm Amho. - S>m. qH J, MoZB

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    26/52

    26 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

    \ Am{U \ g|r` eoVrMm Adb~. EH EH amV`m Xhm qH dmdrgM JwR>m`m jomda mOrMr bmJdS>. Kam-Hw Qw>~mVboM4-5 gX` _`mMr _emJV H aVmV. VmOr mOr {ZdSy>Z, nH H Z_`mVyZ WoQ> JmhH m`m KamV. `m `dhmamVyZ EH Vo XrS> EH a eoVr

    Agbo`m eoVH `mbm _{h`mbm nmg Vo gmR> hOma n`mMo Cn{_iVo`. Am{U Aem `mdgm{`H `epdVoMo g_mYmZ AZw^dUm`meoVH ar Hw Qw>~mMr g`m nMdrg hOmam`m nwT>o Jobr`.

    dmMVmZm, EoH VmZm A{ddgZr` dmQ>Umaoho {M Jobr 4-5 df}`jmV gmH ma Pmbo`, Vohr Am`Q>r nmH m PJ_JmQ>r jombm AJXrIoQy>Z. `m AZmo`m ^mgUm`m H {f{ddmMo dUZ EdT>md ZhrWm~V Zmhr. m {ddmV 127 ~MV JQ>m`m gw_maoXrS hOma _{hbmhrH V~Jmar JmOdVmhoV. `oH _{hbm dVMoAgo {XdgmH mR>r 200

    Vo 500 n`o H _mdVo`. m _{hbm dV JQ> H Z m`mMr H mT>Ur,{ZdS>Uo, dOZ H Z nmd {H bmo, AYm {H bmo`m {ne`m_`onHH aUo Am{U CM y gmogm`Q>m, _mg `m`m_`o OmD Z {dH Uohr gJir H m_o d`nyUVoZo H aVmV. OmVm, OmVm gmogm`Q>m_Yrb^{JZtZm {H MZ JmS>Z_`o ^m`m {nH {d`mMo {ejUhr XoVmV.^m`m`mM OmoS>rZo _mJUrZwgma Ym`o, H S>Ym`o, \ io, XY, JmB`mXYmMoMwbrda H T>dbobo Vyn, nZra B. dVwhr nwadVmV.

    AU H a_aH a`o> nH maR>mUo.9321259949

    _hmam>mMo _w`_r Xod|\ S>Udrg `m`m hVo7 _mMamoOr _hmam> qgMZ gh`moJ `mgWoV\} Am`mo{OV gmoim`mqgMZ n[afXoMo CXKmQ>Z Pmbo.Va 8 _mMamoOr Jm_rU {dH mgIm`m`m _r nH Om _wS>oAm{U ImgXma gw{`m gwio

    `m`m CnpWVrV `m n[afXoMmg_mamon Pmbm. {deof hUOo hrXmoZ VoAS>rM hOma eoVH `mMr{Zdmgr n[afX Zoa `m _wierVmbw`mV`m N>moQ>mem JmdmVPmbr. Zoa Am{U `mbJVMo_mU `m Jmdm`m n[agamVAmH mamg `oV Agbo`m EH m

    Hm{VH maH H fr `moJmMmg_mZ H a`mgmR>rM hrn[afX Pmbr...

    _hmam>mV AmH mambm `oVmo`

    EH H mVrH maH H fr`moJ

    _hmam>mV AmH mambm `oVmo`

    EH H mVrH maH H fr`moJ

    _yH H mVr

    Jm`r`m XYmV {H aUmogmar {dH saU (AQ>m{_H ao{S>EeZ) nmgyZ ajU H a`mMr gdm{YH eVr AgVo. -lr. eramo{dM, a{e`Z emk

    26 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    27/52

    {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 & 27

    bm{H H Q>m A{e{jV Agbo`m _{hbm-hr gj_ Am{U d`nyU Pm`m AmhoV. AmUIrEH CoIZr` ~m~ hUOo gmogm`Q>m_Yrb

    KamoKa`m _mJ`m EH m dVnUo {dH {gV Ho bo`mgmQ>doAa`m _m`_mVyZ hmBg "EgE_Eg'mao_mo~mBbda drH ma`m OmVmV.

    `m gm`m ~mJm`Vr eoVrbm hmoUmam nmUrnwadR>mHy nZ{bH m`m nm`mVyZ {R>~H Am{U Vwfma qgMZVmZo Ho bm OmVmo. nnmZm bmJUmam drOnwadR>m qgJb\oO H ZoeZmao hmoVmo . `m_wio nmUr, drO `mMrhrbjUr` ~MV hmoVo Am{U AmVm `m CnH _mbm

    gm_y{hH `dhmamMoA{^Zd n {X`mZo bm^H maHeoVr`dgm` eoH S>mo - hOmamo eoVH `mn`V{dVmaV Jobm`.

    _hmam> qgMZ gh`moJ, Am_m, Zm~mS>, H Zam ~HAem AZoH gWm Am_r`VoZo m CnH _m`m nmR>rerC`m am{h`m Am{U Am`Q>r nmH `m gm{`mV^mOrnm`mMm _im g_rZo \wbV Jobm.

    ghm - gmV dfmnydu nwUo {Om`m _wier

    Vmbw`mVrb _mU m JmdmVbr VrZ hOma EH a O_rZAm`Q>r nmH C^m H a`mgmR>r emgZmmaognm{XV Ho brJobr. `m ~amo~aM bJVMr qhOdS>r JmdmVbr XrS>eoEH a O_rZhr gnm{XV Ho br Jobr. AmO `m EHy U3200 EH a jomda B\ mo{gg, Q>mQ>m Q>oZmbmOrOn{gQ>Q>, gr_og B. H n`mgh N>moQ>m_moR>m AZoHCmoJmMm Am`Q>r nmH C^m Amho . (J_V hUOo 3200nH s VrZ hOma EH a O_rZ _mU Jmd`m eoVH `mMr,

    nU nmH Mo Zmd _m qhOdSr> nmH !) _mUMr Cd[aVhOma^a EH a EdT>r eoVO_rZ _m AmXmobZmZodmMdbr. AmXmobZ AWmVM {ZXeH eoVH `mdaJmoir~ma Hobm Om`mn`V noQ>bo hmoVo . `m AmXmobZmVVwJdmg ^moJbobm EH VU eoVH ar kmZoda ~moS>H aoAZ `mMm K{Z> {_ H bmg OmYd. `m Xmohr[_m_Ybo EH d{eQ>nyUgm` hUOo eoVr Am{U

    _hmam> qgMZ gh`moJ `m _m`VmmgWomao `mdfuMr gmoimdr qgMZ

    n[afX _wier Vmbw`mVrb Zoa `m N>moQ>memJmdr Pmbr. 7 Am{U 8 _mM 2015 `m XmoZ{Xdgm`m n[afXoV _hmam>m`m gd mJmVyZ XmoZVo VrZ hOma eoVH ar gh^mJr Pmbo hmoVo. Oo_Vo_VrZ-Mma hOma dVrMJmd. nU `m JmdmV`mVU eoVH `mZr `m n[afXoVbr Amd`H

    AgUmar amh`mOod`mMr gd `dWm-3000 eoVH `mMr - H a`mMr O~m~XmarAmnUhZ AJmda KoVbr. nana gh`moJmMm EHAmJim `moJ Jo`m ghm gmV dfmnmgyZ`edrnUo am~{d`m`m AZw dmVyZ Zoa bJVM_mU `m Jmd`m VU eoVH `mZr hr C_oX H _mdbr Amho. m `moJmMo Zmd Amho A{^Zd \ m_gb~. `m "b~' (_m` _amR>r ^mfoV eoVH ar

    _S>i) gH nZoZo BW`m eoVrV Am{U eoVH arHw Qw>~m_`o H m` {H _`m KS>dbr` ho nhm`mbm_mUbm oQ> m`bmM hdr. AZ "qgMZ gh`moJ'ZoAer oQ> Xo`mMm `moJ OwidyZ AmUbm.

    AmVaam>r` `mVrMo ObVk _hmam>mMo _mOr Obg{Md _mYdamd {MVio m`m nwT>mH mamZo1992 gmbr qgMZ gh`moJ `m gH nZoMrgwdmV Pmbr. qgMZ, Ob{Z`moOZ, eoVr-

    Mo `dWmnZ, Obg YmaU B. {df`r eoVH ar~mYdmMo ~moYZ H amdo, gaH mar ZmoH ar_`o{deofV nmQ>~Ymao {d^mJmV A{YH marnXmd ZH m_ H aVmZm Ambo`m AZw dmMm Am{U mPmbo`m AmH bZmMm bm^ eoVH `mn`Vd`godr nmVird Z nmoMdmdm `m hoVyZo gwHo bo`m m CnH_mZo Jo`m drg-~mdrg dfm`m

    W|~mMr H mVr

    _yH HmVr

    Q>Q>aMr, {Zat` IVmMr, H sQ>H ZmeH mMr eoVr ^maVmZo A{JH m Z`o. \ V Mmaeo dfmV A_o[aHo `m gwnrHO{_Zr `m_wioM aoVmS>, jmanS> Pm`m AmhoV. - S>m. Am~Q>AmBQ>mBZ

    {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 & 27

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    28/52

    28 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

    eoVrnyaH CmoJ H a`mMm `mZm Agbobm `mg.g`mMr n[apWVr, m XmoKmMo d` Am{U eoVO_rZ

    {dHy Z {_iyeH Um`m bmImo n`mMoAmH fH bmo ^ZB. nmd y_rda hm `mg AZmoImM hUm`bm hdm. nU

    Varhr Vmo`mg BVH m CH Q> H s kmZodaZo Hw Qw>{~`mMrZmamOr Am{U {hVqMVH mMo go Xmohr emVnUo~mOybmgm Z eoVrgmR>r ZmoH ar gmoS>`mMo YmS>g {OrZo nwT>oaoQ>bo. Va H bmgZo ^mdr gmgao~wdmZmhr "eoVr Am{UeoirnmbZ gmoS>Uma Zmhr. ho _m` Agob VaM _wbJrm' Ago~Omdbo . AmO `m XmoKmMohr Am `m`mH Vdm~m~V HVmW g_mYmZr Am{U A{^_mZr AmhoV.

    gmV`nyU dmQ>MmbrVyZ AmVm IynM `mnHd n YmaU Ho bo Amho. B.g. 2000 nmgyZ `mgWoV\} _hmam> Xoe nmVird Z qgMZ n[afXm^a{d`mg gwdmV Ho br. eoVH ar ~mYdmZr EH `mdo, XmoZ {Xdg EH ahmdo, Amnmn`m AZw dmMoAmXmZ-XmZ H amdo, {deof CnH _ am~dyZ eoVrVJVr KS>{dUm`m eoVH `mZm gdmg_moa `o`mMrgYr CnbY H Z mdr, Vk Am{U AZw^dr_S>itZm ~mobmdyZ `mMo _mJXeZ {_idmdo Ago`m XmoZ {Xdgr` H m`emimdn n[afXoMoEHyUdn AgVo. gwdmVrMr Mma df} AZwH_o na^Ur,H moH U (Xmnmobr), AH mobm (nOm~amd Xoe_wI)Am{U amhar `oWrb H fr {dmnrR>m m ghH m`mZo`m n[afXm {dmnrR>m`m AmdmamVM Am`mo{OVHo`m Jo`m. `mZVa Jm|{X`m, bmVya, ZmXoS>,AmaJm~mX, {eanya, gmobmnya Aem {d{dY eham_`o VoWrb EImm d`godr gWo`m ghH m`mZo`m n[afXm nma nS>`m. `oH n[afXoV gamgarXmoZ Vo nmM hOma EdT>m bjUr` g`oZo eoVH ar~mYd CnpWV amhVmV. `oH doir eoVr,nmUr,qgMZ B`mXrer g~{YV EImm {df`mda,nbyda bj H| {V Ho bo OmVo.

    `m n[afXm`m Am`moOZmMo AWH maUhrd{eQ>nyU Amho. gh^mJr hmoD BpN>Um`meoVH `mgmR>r XmoZ {Xdgm`m gd `dWmgmR>r`oH s 50 n`o ewH AmH mabo OmVo. _{hbm Am{U {dm`mgmR>r Va `oH s 20

    n`o BVHo M ewH KoVbo OmVo . emgH s`A{YH m`mH Sy>Z `oH s 500 n`o Va {ZdmemgH s` A{YH m`mH Sy>Z 200 n`oAgo ewHAmH mabo OmVo. dm^m{dH M {_V`` Am{Ugm`mM (nU n[anyU) `dWoda H Q>mj AgVmo.`m n[afXm~amo~a {Ohm- {d^mJ nmVirda EH

    kmZoda ~moS>Ho

    _yH HmVr

    CbQ>, ^maVmgma`m nmM hOma df} eoVr H arV Agbo`m XoemV O{_ZrMm gwnrH nUm amIbm Jobm Amho.- S>m. Am~Q>AmBQ>mBZ

    28 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    29/52

    {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 & 29

    hm`Q>oH eoVrkmZodaZo A`mYw{ZH VkmZmda

    AmYmabobr eoVr {H \ m`Vera H Z XmI{dbr. VwQ>nw`mO{_ZrdaMr nman[aH eoVr Am{U OmoS>rbm BVaeoVH `m`m eoVmVbr _Owar `m m ~imda kmZodaMoAmBdS>rb ggmamMm JmS>m aoQ>V hmoVo. `m_wio kmZodabm"EgEggr'`m nwT>o {ejU KoVm Ambo Zmhr. (dmV{dHEgEggr narjoV `mZo 83 Q>o JwU {_i{dbohmoVo. Varhr !) XmoZ ~{hUtnH s EH s`m bZmgmR>rd{S>bmZm nmM EH a eoVr Ho di nMdrg hOma n`mV{dH mdr bmJbr hmoVr. Aem pWVrV Am`Q>r nmH Mr

    ndUr gmYyZ Cabobr eoVrhr {dHyZ bjmdYr n`o{_i{d`mMm _moh hmoUo dm^m{dH hmoVo. nU kmZodaZoVmo H Q>mjmZo Q>mibm Am{U Amn`m EH EH am`mdmdamV nmbrhmD g C^mZ \wbmMr eoVr H a`mMm{ZM` Hobm. ghm bmI n`mMo H Zam ~Ho MoH O `mgmR>r H mT>`mMo doS>o gmhg Ho bo. dS>rbYmVmdbo hmoVo. nMdrg hmOmamgmR>r nmM EH a eoV`mZr J_mdbo hmoVo Am{U AmVm Va kmZoda ghm

    bmImMo H O H mT>V hmoVm. nU ho H O kmZodaZodf amVM \o S>`mMr {H _`m H Z XmI{dbr Am{UgJ`m`mM eH mHw eH mZm R>iH nyU{dam_ {Xbm.nmbrhmD g Am{U eoS>ZoQ>Mm N>moQ>mgm JmXrdm`mMm_im, EH Xoer Jm`, {V`mM _b_ymnmgyZ V`maHo bo`m barMo IV, {R>~H Am{U Vwfma qgMZmMr`Um Ago EH bmJdS>rMo _mS>obM {dH {gV Ho bo.`m _mS>ob_YyZ hmVr `oUm`m g_rMm `` Ambm

    Am{U _J `m `emMm bm^ AZoH mn`V nmoM{d`mMmMJ kmZoda - H bmg `m OmoS>rZo~mYbm. AmUIrH mhr eoVH ar VUmZm gmo~V KoD Z 15 AmJQ> 2004amoOr "A{^Zd \ m_g b~' `m eoVH ar _S>imMrWmnZm `mZr Ho br. 17 OUmZr `oH s 50 n`oJmoim H Z WmnZ Hobo`m `m _S>imbm ~Ho `m_m\ V Zm~mS>Mr _m`Vm {_imbr. Amn`m eoVrMr

    {XdgmMr qgMZ g_obZo JaOoZwgma Am`mo{OVH a`mV `oVmV. (AmVmn`V Aer drgoH g_obZoPmbr.)

    `m g_obZm`m {Z{_mmZo `m `mWmZmbJV Agbo`m YaU H nmMm dmT>{XdggmOam H a`mMm EH AZmoIm CnH_ gw H a`mVAmbm Amho. `m`moJo`m YaUm`m bm^jomVrbeoVH ar, `m H nmMogaH mar A{YH mar, AJXr`m H nm_wio WbmV[aV PmboboeoVH ar AemgdmMo EH rH aU, gdmX `m dmT>{Xdgm`mH m`H_mV KS>dyZ AmUbm OmVmo. Jo`m H mhrdfmnmgyZ `edr, bjUr` CnH _ am~{dUm`meoVH `mZm "qgMZ nwaH ma' Xo`mghr gwdmVH a`mV Ambr Amho. `oH n[afXo_`o gmXaPmbo`m {Z~YmMo gH {bV nwVH hr H m{eVH a`mV `oVo.

    Jo`m XmoZ-VrZ dfm_`o`m n[afXm {Ohm-H|o , VmbwH m H| o AmobmSy>Z EImm N>moQ>m JmdmVhmoD bmJ`m AmhoV. 2012 gmbr Voamdr qgMZn[afX gmJbr {OmV`m nU H ZmQ>H `mgr_oda bmJyZ Agbo`m Om{b`mZ Zmdm`m Jmdr^a{d`mV Ambr Am{U AmM`mMr ~m~ hUOoEH m ~mOybm H mhrer XJ_ AgUm`m m Jmd`mn[afXogmR>rhr AS>rM hOma eoVH ar ~mYdCnpWV am{hbohmoVo. `mdfu gmoimdr n[afX CVHfr `dWm `m {df`mda _wier Vmbw`mVrb_mU `m JmdmV Am`mo{OV Hobr Jobr. _mU Jmd,

    {VWbo eoVH ar Am{U CV H fr `dWm `m{df`mMo EH {d{e> ZmVoAmho- qH ~hZm Vo ZmVo `mZmV KoD ZM n[afX {VWoAm`mo{OV H a`mMm{dMma g`moOH mZr Ho bm. ho {d{e> ZmVog_OyZKoUogdmgmR>rM CX~moYH Amho.

    ***

    _yH H mVr

    Jm`rMo XY gdm}m_ nmpQ>H Amhma Amho. `mMo nMZ Ho di XmoZ VmgmV hmoVo. Va herMo XY nMm`bm 9Vmg bmJVmV.

    {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 & 29

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    30/52

    30 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

    _emJV H Z mOr, \w bmMo {nH `m `m eoVH `mZoM\wbdm`Mo, _m _mH} qQ>JMr `dWm EH {V H am`Mr.AmUIr EH . _Y`m gJ`m XbmbmZm nyUnUo gwQ>rXoD Z {dHs WoQ> JmhH mbm H am`Mr. IVo, ~r-{~`mUo,\ dmaUr `mMr IaoXrhr gm_y{hH nUoM H am`Mr.`m_wioJwVdUwH sV ~MV Pmbr. VmOm ^mOrnmbm WoQ>JmhH m`m KamV Am{U {dH sMo Cn amoI aH _o`m

    nmV WoQ> {nH {dUm`m`m hmVmV. n[aUm_r CndmT>bo. H gXma _mb KanmoM {_im`mZo JmhH dJIwe Pmbm Am{U {Z`{_V H O\oS> H Zhr CnmXHeoVH ar nwaogoCn {_idybmJbm. doioVM Zho Va_wXVrAmYrM H OmMr naV\oS> Pm`mZo ~H mhr AmZ{XVPm`m. bm{H H Am{U nV `m XmohtMm bm^ PmbmAm{U _J Zmdm_mUoM A{^Zd Agbo`m `m eoVH ar_S>im`m gH nZoMm doJmZo{dVma Pmbm. kmZodahr

    _moH ionUmZo `m gH nZoMo _mJXeZ JmdmoJmdr OmD ZH bmJbm. {XdgmMo 24 Vmg Am{U dfmMoVrZeo nmg> {Xdg `mbm nwaoZmgo Pmbo.

    Xoe^amV {dVmanmhVm nmhVm EH m Vmbw`m`m H mhr Jmdm`m

    nMHmoerV ~rOmamonU Pmbobm hm CnH_ am``mnrMZho Va Xoe`mnr Pmbm. AmO{_Vrbm Xoem`m

    gdrg am`m_`oWmnZ Pmbo`m137 eoVH ar _S>imMo {_iyZ VrZhOmamda eoVH ar g^mgX, EHy U

    2850 nmbrhmD ggoMr C^maUr,{d{dY ~H m_YyZ EHy U 700 H moQ>rn`m`m H OmMo eoVH `mZm {dVaUEdT>m MS> {dVma Pmbm Amho. mgJ`m {dVmamV _{hbmdJmMmdmQ>m _mobmMm Amho. _{hbm gj_rH aU `m gH nZobm `WmWVoZogmH ma Pm`mMm `` A{^Zd

    eoVH ar _S>imZo {Xbm Amho.kmZoda`m nZr nyOm ~moS>Ho `m`m

    A`jVoImbr WmnZ H a`mV Ambo`m ~MV JQ>mMrgoHo Q>ar AUm eoiHo Amnbm AZw d AJXr Zo_`meXmV ` H aVo. "^mOr, Ym`o, XY mgma`m dVyMmJmhH dJ~hVme _{hbmM Am{U nwadR>m H aUm`mhrAmhr _{hbmM. `m_wio `dgm`mVhr KaJwVrdmVmdaU {Q>Hy Z amhVo. IaoXrXma _{hbmZmhr H Yr

    H Yr Amhr eoVmda KoD Z `oVmo. gJir {H m `jnmhZ `m`mhr _ZmVbm {ddmg, OdirH dmT>Vo.Jnm_YyZ {hVJyO hmoVo. EH _oH mH Sy>Z ghOnUoAZoHZ`m Jmo>r {eH `m, {eH d`m OmVmV. Am_`mA{e{jV _{hbmZmhr JV OJmMr AmoiI hmoVo. KamV`m_wbm_mUgmg_moa Amhr A{YH Am_{ddmgmZodmdaVmo. eoVr`m H >mVyZ gm`m HwQw>~mVM gH mamMrOdU ghOnUo hmoVo. _{hbm ~MV JQ>mV`m Mmirg

    _{hbm EH m {e>_S>imVyZ ZwH `mM MrZbm OmD ZAm`m. AmJm_r H mhr {XdgmV H mhr OUr AemM~mPrbbm OmUma AmhoV. A{Ve` emVnUo, g _mZoEH _yH H mVrM KSy>Z `oVo` Ago hUUo A{Ve`mo sR> Z`o. AmVm H mhr _{hbmZr KaJwVr XiU`o IaoXrHobr AmhoV. JhmMo nrR> H Z XoVmV. H Yr Vo A{YHmoQ>rZ`w H Z, `mV gmo`m~rZ H iUr - {_giyZ

    _yH H mVr

    Jm` MaVmZm \ V nmZoVmo Sy>Z ImVo, _wimnmgyZ CnQy>Z ImV Zmhr. `m_wioPmS>o - Pw S>no, JdV ZQ> hmoV ZmhrV.

    30 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    31/52

    {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 & 31

    Amamo` Amhmahr ~ZdyZ XoVmV. A{hmomgmR>r Jmod`m,Jmo_y, JmBMo XY `m`mhr _mJ`m nwadVmV.

    XY `dgm`

    Hbmg OmYd ho m n[adVZ {H oMo Xgaoo Ad w._mUnmgyZ 5-6 {H bmo_rQ>ada Zoa `m Jmdr `mMr 5EH a eoVr Amho. ^mOr CnmXZmV Vo gh^mJr AmhoVM.nU m_w`mZoVo XY`dgm` gm miVmV. `pVJVnmVirda eoirnmbZ H aUm`m Hbmg OmYd `mZreoVH ar _S>im`m nmVirda `mhr ~m~VrV {dembdn gmH ma Ho bo Amho . e amda her Am{UdrgoH (Xoer) JmB `mMo {Ima Vo gm miVmV. amoO

    hOma^a {bQ>a XYmMoCnmXZ H aVmV. Cm_ dmUm`mnXmernmgyZ Mm`mMm XOm, Vmo Xo`mMo doimnH `mMremmo AmIUr H bmg OmYd `mZr Ho br Amho.Jmo_y, Jmo_` (eoU) mMmhr dkm{ZH VoZo dmna H a`mda`mMm AmJhr H Q>mj Amho. A{^Zd \ m_g b~MrXY`dgm`mMr ~mOy OmYd g_WnUo gm miVmhoV.7-8 _mM `m XmoZ {XdgmVrb am``mnr qgMZn[afX OmYd `m`mM {edmamV Zoa `oWogn Pmbo.

    {ha`mJma _`m`m Am{U newYZm`m gm{`mVXmoZ-AS>rM hOma eoVH `mgh AZoH _m`da _S>irXmoZ {Xdg am{hbr. _hmam> qgMZ gh`moJMo gWmnH

    _mJXeH _mYdamd {MVio VgoM gWoMo A`j S>m.{X. _m. _moao(nmQ>~ Ymao {d^mJmVrb {Zdm A{YH mar)ho Va AmR>dS>m^a Zoa-_mU n[agamVM _w m_ H aUma

    AmhoV. qgMZ gh`moJ m gWoMo gWmnH - _mJXeH_mYdamd {MVio VgoM gWoMo A`j S>m. {X. _m._moao (nmQ>~Ymao {d^mJmVrb {Zdm A{YH mar) ho VaAmR>dS>m^a Zoa - _mU n[agamVM _wH m_r hmoVo. qgMZgh`moJ `m gWo`m WmnZ Am{U gMmbZm_mJrbCoeM Zoa-_mU n[agamVrb `m eoVH ar _S>i CnH_mVyZ AmH mambm Ambm Ag`mMr `mMr ^mdZm Amho.

    {X. _m. _moao `m`m eXmV gmJm`Mo Va hr

    qgMZ eoVr_Yrb H mVr Amho. `m CnmXZmV gmV`Amho, n`mdaUmMo gajU Amho. O_rZ Am{U nmUr`m Zg{JH gmYZmMm {H _mZ dmna Amho. _{hbme sMm Am{U `m`m H me`mMm nwaonwa Cn`moJ Amho.AmYw{ZH VkmZmbm H doV Ko`mV Ambo Amho. `meoVrV gm_y{hH Vm, d{d` Amho. JmhH mer WoQ> gdmXAmho. BVamMo ~moYZ Amho. Xbmb hnma Pmbm Amho.Jm_rU OrdZmV W Ambo Amho. WbmVa Wm~bo

    Amho. {Zam_` Amamo`nyU _mZdr OrdZmMo gmWHnwZmrdZ Amho.

    ***

    O`nya ~mYUr, qgWo{Q>H , boZnmob d gd

    {S>PmBZa gmS>r, JmoQ>m, Hw XZ d bogMo ^` XmbZ

    bZ

    O`n

    {S>PmBZ

    `y {Z_bm gmarO

    AemoH Cnm o- 9890452899

    464, npM_ _Jidma noR>, MmQ>r Jr,maH m{Ye _{Xa Jr, gmobmnya.

    bZmMm ~Vm hmobgob ^mdmV

    _yH HmVr

    _wgb_mZmZmo, _wm Am{U {nam`m gmJ`mH So> bj ZH m XoD . qhXgmo~V emVVoZo amhm. qhXWmZgmR>r Jm` Am{U~b ho CnH mar Ord AmhoV. (A\ Jm{UVmZMo _mOr A_ra A_mZwmIm `m`m _w~BdmgmVrb d `mVyZ)

    {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 & 31

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    32/52

    32 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

    gJ 1100 dfmnyduMm Amho. Mmoi_ demMo am` hmoVo. gZ950 `m gw_mamg _Zmo{YZr Mmoi_ ZmdmMm amOm hmoVm. mZoamOdmS>m~mhoa KQ>m ~mYyZ Xmoar gmoS>br hmoVr. `mbm m` hdm `mZo`oD Z KQ>mZmX H am`Mm. EHo {Xder KQ>mZmX EoHy Z _Zmo{YZr ~mhoaAmbm. nhmVmo Va EH Jm` Vm|S>mV Xmoar Y Z KQ>m dmOdV hmoVr.godH mZr Jm`rbm hmH b`mMm `Z H aVmM amOmZo amoIbo. YmZmbmA{YH MmH er H a`mg gm{JVbo. MmH erAVr g_OboH s amOaWamOdmS>mH S>o AmUV AgVmZm `m Jm`rModmg MmH mImbr gmnSy>Z_aU nmdbo Amho. amOmZoHw _ma d`mVrb Amn`m _wbmg amOnWmdaPmondbo. `m`m AJmdZ aWmMoMmH Zo`mg gm{JVbo. Jmo> gnbr.

    Vr Iar H m ImoQ>r, Iar Ag`mg `mbm nwamdm H m` Agbm ~mbre {dMm ZH m. Jmo>rMm _{VVmWbjmV `m. Jm`rMm _mZ {H Vr hmoVm hobjmV `m. 12 `m eVH mV _wpb_ AmH _U gw hmo`mnydu Jmoh`mgmoS>mM, Vgm eX CmaUohr {Z{f hmoVo.

    ObmbwrZ AH ~amZo(1556 Vo 1605) Jmoh`oda ~Xr AmUbr.`m`mZVa Ohm{JaZo(1605 Vo 1627) Am{U Ah_X ehm gwar (1748Vo 1754) `mZo Jmoh`m~XrMm H S>H A_b Ho bm. AH ~amMr VwbZm

    AU am_VrWH a`o> nH magmobmnya

    h`m, aVnmV `mMmH gbmM {dYr{ZfoYZgbbo_wpb_ AmH mVm`m XoemV Am`mdaJmoh`og ma Pmbm.qhXy Jm`rbm nyOVmV. hoH i`mda dofmZo Jmoh`mgw Pmbr. nam^yV qhX`m

    Vm|S>mV gVrZo Jmo_mgH m|~yZ Y_mVa Pmbo.Jmo_mg M{d> AgVo, AgohUVmV. Agobhr. _w`H maU VoZmhr. qhXy nyOmH aVmV, `m`mlmWmZmdaAmKmV H am`Mm `m EH mM

    H maUmgmR>r VohmnmgyZAmmmn`V Jmoh`m MmbyAmhoV. JmonmbZ OgoloZohmoVo VV Jmoh`mhrYm{_H loZo hmoVo.

    Jmoh`m~XrH m` {_`m, H m` dmVd!

    naIS>

    nJw Am{U {Zn`moJr Pmbo`m newMr h`m hmoD Z`oAm{U gd mUr_m gwIr hmdoV, AgoCnm` emoYyZH mT>bonm{hOoV. -n{hbo am>nVr S>m. amO|gmX

    32 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    33/52

    {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 & 33

    Am~amo~a H aUmar KmofUm m`Mr Am{U AH ~amg_m` Zgbobr Jmoh`mhr H am`Mr `mV {dgJVr AmhoAgo Y_mYmZm dmQ>V Zmhr H m ?

    Xodio \ moSy>Z _yVu OZ H aUmam Am{U hrM AmMrgodm _mZUm`m AmaJOo~mZo Jmoh`og mogmhZ {Xbo.qhXMo _mZ{gH IrH aU H a`mgmR>r. N>nVr{edmOr _hmamOmZr qhXZm _mZ{gH C^mar Xo`mgmR>rJmoh`m H aUm`mMo Xmohr hmV VmoS>bo. nwT>o g mOr_hmamOmZr Am{U noe`mZr Jmoh`m hm JwhmM R>adbm.^JdmZ ~w, ^JdmZ _hmdra, gV JmS>Jo~m~m,VwH S>moOr _hmamO `mZr mUr h`obmM {damoY Ho bm.

    `mV Jm` AmbrM. AqhgoMm CnXoe H aUmao~w Am{U_hmdra. `m nH s _hmdramMo AZw`m`r `mCnXoemMo AmOhr H mQ>oH moa nmbZ H aVmV. _mdVbm ~wmZw`m`r hUdUmaoam_Xmg AmR>dbo Jmodeh`og nmqR>~m XoVmV. ho hm`mnXM Pmbo. 12 `meVH mn`V Jmoh`m hm eXhr An[a{MV hmoVm. `mZVa_wpb_ amOdQ>rV amOml`mZo Jmoh`m gw Pmbr. `m_wiohm A{VgdoXZerb {df` ~Zbm. 1857 Mo~S> AmR>dm.

    ~XH s`m H mS>Vwgmbm Jm`rMr Ma~r bmdbobr AgVo,ho H ibo hUyZ g{ZH {~Wabo. \ V Sw>H amMr qH dmKmoS>mMr Ma~r AgVr Va 1857 Mm gJm_ PmbmAgVm H m ?

    WmoS>oAbrH S>`m H mimV `oD . 1969 bm H mJogX Jbr. B{Xam JmYrMoAmgZ ApWa Pmbo. H mJognjmVyZ `mMr hH mbn>r Pm`mda `mZr Zdm njH mT>bm. `m njmMo {Mh hUyZ `mZr Jm`dmg M

    H m {ZdS>bo? _wJr, _mgm, ~oSy>H H m {ZdS>bm Zmhr.Z~rImZ Xm dmbm `m`m _wbmer bS>Z_`o OmD ZJwnMwn {ZH mh bmdyZ _wgb_mZ Pmbo`m B{Xam JmYr`mZm Jm`dmgamMo qhX`m _ZmVrb WmZ g_Obo nUB{XamOtZm _mZUmao H mJogdmbo AmR>db|Mo g_{dMmarR>aVmV.

    AmVm Xoe dV Pm`mda `m {df`mMo H m` Pmbo

    Vo nmh. KQ>Zm g{_VrV hm {df` Ambm Vohm R>mHy aXmg^mJd eoR> JmoqdXXmg, aKwZmW {dZm`H YwioH a `mZrgnyUXoemV Jmoh`m~XrMm H S>H H m`Xm hmdm, Aer

    _mJUr Hobr. KQ>Zm g{_VrMo A`j S>m. ~m~mgmho~Am~oS>H a `mZr g~warMm gm {Xbm. am`dma pWVrdoJir Amho. `m_wio Xoe^a bmJy hmoUmam H m`XmH a`mnojm AmnU am`mZm dmV` XoD . `mZm hmH m`Xm hdm `mZm VmoH a`mMm nyU A{YH ma mdm.KQ>Zo`m _mJXeH VdmV H b_ 48 _`o Jmodeh`m~XrMm H m`Xm H a`mMo am`mZr `Z H amdoV.`mZr Hobobm H m`Xm hm KQ>Zm_H Q>m nyUnUodY

    Agob, Ago MM}ZVa R>abo.`mZwgma AmVm _hmam>mgh {Xr, JwOamV,

    _`Xoe, amOWmZ `m am`mV Jmode h`m~XrMmH m`Xm Amho Va Bem`oH S>rb {_Pmoam_, _oKmb`,ZmJmXoe Am{U Hoai m am`mV ~Xr Zmhr. (hUyZMAmMaQ> _mgdmmZr {g Jw dm`wa`m lrHU_{Xa AmdmamV ~r\ nmQ>u Ho br) dmMH hmo, Jmo_mg hmeX _bm {bhm`bmhr ZH modmQ>Vmo. `m_wio _r ~r\

    hm eX dmnaVmo. ~Jmb, AmY XoemV H mn`mg mo`Ago_mUn Agob VaM H mb H aVm `oVo. _m,~r\ Mr ~Jmb_`o 7 A{YH V Am{U 3000 AZ{YHVH mbImZo AmhoV. AmY_`o 6 A{YH V Am{U 3100AZ{YH V H mbImZo AmhoV. m AZ{YH V H mbIm`mV_mUnmMr JaOM ZgVo. gamg Jm`r H mn`mOmVmV. _hmam>mV 1976 gmbr Jmoh`m~Xr Pmbr. nUVr H mJXmdaM. JmdmoJmdr Ag` ~oH m`Xm H mbImZo

    AmhoV. Xm~Xr_mUo Jmoh`m~Xr ho nmo{bgmZm bmMIm`mMogmYZ Pmbo Amho.

    ^a_gmR> AZ{YHV H mbIm`m_wio Xadfu XoemV36 Xebj Q>Z ~r\ V`ma hmoVo. `mnH s 16 XebjQ>Z ~r\ {Z`mV hmoVo. ~r\ CnmXZmV ^maV 5 `mH_mH mda _m, ~r\ {Z`mVrV W_ H _mH mda Amho.`mMm ZrQ> AW g_OyZ `m. BVa 4 Xoe `m`m JaOonwaVoM

    naIS>

    AmnU Jm`tMo ajU Ho bo Va Jm` Amnbo ajU H aob. - _hm_Zm n. _XZ_mohZ _mbdr`.

    {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 & 33

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    34/52

    34 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

    ~r\ H aVmV. AmnU _m JaOonojm OmV, {Z`mVrVyZngoH _md`mgmR>r ~r\ ~ZdVmo. ~r\ {Z`mVrVyZ ngm{_idmdm bmJVmo EdT>m Amnbm Xoe {^H mar Pmbm Amho

    H m ? gJioM bmmnX. `m XoemV 80 Q>o qhXyam-hVmV. _mH S>o H mQ>Oy, adr emr, {Jare H ZmS> `mgmaIo _moOHo O_qhX gmoS>bo Va ~mH sMo JmBMr nyOmH aV AgVmZm ~r\ Mr EdT>r {Z`mV ?

    _hmam> gaH maZo Ogm nm{hOo Vgm H m`Xm Ho bmAmho. 2 _mMnmgyZ A_bmV Ambm Amho. Jmode h`og~Xr, ~r\ gmnS>Uo hmhr Jwhm Amho. `mbm AmhmZXoUmar `m{MH m C `m`mb`mV Amho. `m`mb`mda

    Q>rH m H aUo `mo` Zmhr nU b{~V IQ>`mMr g`mdmT>V AgVmZm `m`mb`o doi H gm KmbdVmV `mMoho CXmhaU Amho. gnyU ~Xr KQ>Zo`m _mJXeH VdmVAmho. gnyU ~Xr KmbUo qH dm Jmoh`og nyU _w m `mMmgdm{YH ma am`mZm Amho. `mMm H m`Xm dYM AgVmo.1961 gmbr _h_X hZr\ Hw aoer {d {~hma gaH maAm{U AXb BH s{d {~hma gaH ma `m Xm`mVgdm} `m`mb`mZo gnyU ~Xr dY R>adbr Amho. Ago

    AgVmZm ~Xr Ho hmnmgyZ, ~Xr Jmodem`m h`oda _JBVa mUrh`oMo H m` Ago \ mQ>o `m mb` \ moS>V Amho.dVMm Am{U gaH maMm doi \wH Q> KmbdV Amho.

    `m H m`mV EH AZmd`H wQ>r Amho. h`ogmR>rJmodemMr dhmVyH hmoVmZm Jmoo_rZr nH S>br Va VoH m`mg ghm` hmoVo. _m, AmVm Vmo Jwhm R>aUmaAmho. H m`mbm _XV H aUo hm Jwhm H gm? nmo{bggj_ AgVrb Va Jmo> doJir. Jm`r H m|~bobm Q>H Vo

    nH S>Vrb nU bmM KoD Z gmoSy>Z XoVrb. _J H m`XmH mJXmonrM amhrb. H m`m~m~V wVr emgZ m_m{UHAgob Va hr wQ>r bJoM Xa H amdr. m nwT>o nH S>bo`mJm`r JmoemioV OmVrb. g`m gaH mar Jmoemim ZmhrV.godm^mdr gWm `m MmbdVmV. `mZm Am{WH _`mXmAmhoV. `mgmR>r `mZm e` Amho `mZr EHoH Jm`gm mibr Va Jmoemimda VmU oUma Zmhr.

    Jmoag, Jmo_y, Jmo~a `mMo Cn`moJ hm dV {df`Amho. ~m~m am_Xod `mMr nVObr gWm, Am`wd}X agemim, dZmW Aem gWm Vo H m_ H aV

    AmhoV. `mZm {VgmXhr {_iV Amho. Jmoh`m hm {dMmanaH s`, {~ZS>moH Am{U Y_mYVoMo VrH Amho VaJmonmbZ hr Amnbr hOmamodfmMr nanam, H{fYmZXoembm nyaH Agm {dMma Amho.

    {Vr qPQ>mMm AmXe_r ~r\ AmdS>rZo ImVmo hUUm`m O_qhXwH S>o

    Xbj H am. {Vr qPQ>m hr ZQ>r Amho. {VZo dIMmZo25 X `m Jm`r {dH V KoV`m. Zm{eH {OmVrb

    `odbm Vmbw`mV bhmZ bhmZ IoS>mV OmD Z Jar~KamV {X`m. AmJm_r XmoZ _{h`mgmR>r Mm`mMongo{Xbo. KoVbo \ V dMZ. H moU`mhr n[apWVrV Jm`{dH Uma Zmhr, Ago Vo dMZ. JmonmbZ Pmbo Am{UJar~ Hw Qw>~mZm Am{WH AmYma bm^bm. _mH S>o`H mQ>Oy H m` hUVmo, `m nojm {Vr qPQ>mZo H m` Ho bo`mMo AZwH aU H am.

    naIS>

    `Vmo Jmd: VVmo d`_ (Jm`r AgVrb, VaAmnU AmhmoV) ho dMZ gXd `mZmV Agy m.Jm` Amnwbr Am{U AmnU Jm`rMo, hr mdZm Z>Pm`mZoM Amnbr dV_mZH mimVrb XadWmPmbr Amho.

    lr eH amMm {eamoiH a dm_r _hmamO,gHoa _R>

    EH ~b _maUohUOo EH m _Zw`mMr h`mHo`m_mUo hmo`.

    BgmB`mh 66/3

    Jm`rMr h`m H am, Ago Bbm_ Y_mVgm{JVbobo Zmhr.

    \ Vdo w_m wZr, ^mJ 1, n> 360

    JmognXm Agon`V ^maV OJmMm AmXehmo Vm. JmognXm Z> hmoD bmJbr VohmnmgyZ ^maVmMm Jmadhr hiyhiyjrU hmoD bmJbm - maH mnrR>mYra eH amMm`g{XmZXVrWOr _hmamO

    34 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    35/52

    {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 & 35

    JmogdYZ `m {df`mV H m_ H aUmao H moU`mhr OmVrMoAgmoV, njmMoAgmoV Vo JmogodH Amnbo AmhoV. m`mVH m` CUrdm AmhoV, H m` MmJ`m Jmo>r AmhoV honmhUo Amnbo H m_Amho. Aem gdmMo gKQ>Z H aUoho gKmMo H m_ Amho. Amnbr Jm` hrMmbVr {\ aVr S>mQ>a Amho. Amn`mbm ~mhoa Om`mMr Amd`H Vm

    Zmhr. Amn`m gdamoJmMm BbmO Jm` H eH Vo. Amn`mbm `mda{ddmg hdm. _mPm AZw d Amho, _r Jo`m 56 dfmnmgyZ gVV (am.d.gKmMm nyUdoi MmaH hUyZ) {\ aV Amho. naVw _r AmOdaEH hr AbmonWrMr Jmoir KoVbr Zmhr. dfmV 360 {Xdg {\ aVmo, nyUXoemV {\ aVmo. naVw Jm`r`m H no_wio.

    H bH mm_`oKaMm `mnma Amho. VoWo AgVmZm Xoer Jm`rMo XYM{_imbo. AmO AZoH OUmZm `mYr OS>bo`m AmhoV. H mhr OUmZm{S>oeZMm AmOma Amho, H moUmbm na{bgrg Va H moUmbm Pmon `oV

    Zmhr, Q>m`\ mBS> Pmbm Amho. Vo _moR>m _mUmV BbmO H aVmV. naVw`m`mda MmJ`mH mao BbmO hmoD eH V Zmhr. EH N>moQ>mgm `moJH am. Xoer Jm`rMo XY, Xhr, bmoUr Am{U Vyn Aem Hs`oVyZ Ow`mnVrZwgma V`ma Hobobo Vyn amr PmonVmZm WmoS>ogoJa_ H Z VrZ -VrZ W|~ Xmohr ZmH nwS>mV gmoS>m. Cer Z KoVm Pmonm. nwT>rb 15 Vo20 {_ZrQ>mV `m ` sg JmT> Pmon `oBb. H mhr {XdgmV gd AmOmaH _r hmoVrb. hoH Z nhm. Oo hOmamo, bmImo n o IM H Zhr ~ao

    eXmH Z

    nwfmom_ H maH bgmobmnya.9860822283

    ^maVr` Jm`

    MmbVr {\ aVr S>mQ>a

    A.^m.Jmogodm _wI eH abmb hUVmV...

    eH abmbA{Ib ^maVr` Jmogodm _wI,

    am. d. gK

    _r Jo`m 56 dfmnmgyZgVV {\ aV Amho.naVw _r AmOda EH hrAbmonWrMr Jmoir KoVbr

    Zmhr. dfmV 360 {Xdg{\ aVmo, nyUXoemV

    {\ aVmo. naVw Jm`r`mHno_wio.

    {deof gdmX

    Ym{_H , Am{WH Am{U dkm{ZH , H moU`mhr {>H moZmVyZ nm{hbo Var `m g>rV Jm`rMoWmZ _mobmMo Amho,{deofV: ^maVmgma`m H {fYmZ XoemV. - dm_rlr h[aZm_XmgOr CXmgrZ

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    36/52

    36 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

    hmoV Zmhr Vo Aem N>moQ>m `moJmVyZ {R>H hmoVo. Amhr`moJ H aV amhVmo.

    AmO AZoH bmoH mZm A{gS>rQ>rMr g_`m Amho.

    H mhrhr ImV amhVmV, nmoQ>mV Aga hmoVmo. `mda XoerJm`rMoXY EH Xm CH iyZ `mbm WS> H Z IS>rgmIa{_giyZ Am{U XmoZ M_Mo Vyn gH mi g `mH mi`m ` sg nmOdmdo. nwT>rb 15 {XdgmV 90 Q>oA{gS>rQ>r H _r Pmbobr {XgyZ `oBb.

    AmO AZoH bmoH mZm dMm {dH ma AmhoV. S>mJ,ImO Amho. Xoer Jm`rMo eoU KoD Z `m OmJr bmdm,AYm Vmg ChmV ~gm, ZVa AmKmoi H am, EH m _

    {h`mV hr g_`m nyU ~ar hmoBb. J dVr _{hbmMr{gParZ eHs`m H aUma AgVrb Va dN> YwVboboH mnS> Xoer Jm`r`m eoUmV ~wS>dm. nYam {_ZrQ>mZr VoH mnS> H mTy>Z {nim, Ago XmoZ VrZ doim H am, VrgVo Mmirg J_ eoUmMoAH Am{U nmM VwierMr nmZo EH H Z O|hm gdnrS>m gw hmoBb `m _{hbobmnmOm. EH Vo XrS> VmgmV ImreranUoZm_b {S>boharhmoBb.

    ~mi Jmo`m aJmMo Agmdo Ago dmQ>V Agob VaMmXr`m H Q>moarV Xoer Jm`rMo XY XmgmR>r O_m H am.Vo Xhr XaamoO gH mir ZmVm H aVmZm `m J dVr_mVog {X`mg gwXa, ~wr_mZ, ~mbH - ~m{bH mhmoBb. H maU Xoer Jm`r`m XYmV dU ^_ Amho.720 brQ>a XYmV 10 J_ dU _ {ZKVo. `mXYmVrb {ndionUm hUOodU _ Amho . Jm`r`mXYmV Vm`mMm Ae Amho.

    Xoer Jm`rMo {H Vrhr XY {nbo, Vyn Imo VaH moboQ>mb dmT>Uma Zmhr. hX`{dH ma `oUmaZmhr. ~m`nmg gOar H amdr bmJUma Zmhr. ho VynearamV gmR>V Zmhr. AmnU ~mOmamV Jm`rMo VynKoVmo. Vo KoV`mZVa Vmn{d`mZVa bJoM {dViboVaVo Jm`rMo. Zmhr Va `mV Oa ogi Agob Va adm{XgyZ `oBb. `mZm H ga Amho `mZr Xoer Jm`rMo

    Jmo_y qH dm Jmo_y AH 20 J_, 40 J_ nmUr Am{U25 - 30 VwierMr nmZo dmQy>Z gH mi - g`mH miIm`mg VrZ _{h`mV Hga ~am hmoBb.

    AmnU nmM AmVaam>r` noQ>Q> Jmo_ymgmR>r KoVboAmhoV. nOm~mV Xod| qgh `mZm {hnQ>m`{Q>g ~r, grPmbm, H ga Pmbm, {Xr Eg_`o BbmO Ho bm.S>mQ>amZr gm{JVbo gaXmaOr AmnU Kar Om. Xhm{Xdg dmMVrb Ago S>mQ>amZr gm{JVbo hmoVo. H moUrVar gm{JVbo H s AmnU Jmo_y `m, `mZr KoVbo, VonyU ~ao Pmbo. `mZm dmQ>bo H s Jm`rZo dmM{dbo Amho,Jmoemim gw Ho br. AmOda 250 UmZm `mZr nyU

    ~ao Ho bo Amho. Aer AZoH CXmhaUoAmhoV. `mZm_Yw_oh Amho. ~obmMr nmM ghm nmZoJmo_y AH mg_doVdmQy>Z gH mi gm`H mir OodUmZVa EH {M_yQ>^a hoAm{U Vwier`m nmZmMr nmdS>a nm`m~amo~a KoVbo Va_Yw_oh ~am hmoBb. `mZm X_m, AW_mMm mg Amho,`mZr Jmo_ym~amo~a ASy>igm`m nmZmMm ag KoV`mgAmn`m X`mMm AmOma ~am hmoBb.

    `mMr {H S>Zr Iam~ Amho `mZr Jmo_ym~amo~a

    JwS>dobMr nmdS>a KoV`mg {H S>Zr {R>H hmoBb.hm`bS> oea, bmobS>oeaMr g_`m {R>H hmoBb.

    `mZm {\ Q>gMm mg Amho `mZr, Jm` {nmbmO_ {X`mZVa n{h`mXm eoU XoBb VoeoU dmidyZ`mMr wH Q>r H am, O|hm ` s {\ Q>g`oD Z H mogiobV|hm m wH Q>rMm dmg `mbm m. ewrV `oBb. H mhr{XdgmV g_ m ~ar hmoBb. Ago AZoH amoJ ~aohmoVmVAgm Am_Mm AZw d Amho.

    nydu H Yr H moUr AmOar nS>bo Va Vr ` s JmBg_moa OmD Z C^maV Ago. Jm` `mMm AmOma Amoi-IVo, Aer bmoH mMr lm hmoVr. Vr Jm` OJbmVOmD Z AmfYr dZnVr ImVo Am{U _J `m JmBMoXY {n`mZVa AmnU ~aohmD Agm bmoH mZm {ddmghmoVm. `mVyZ AmOma ~ar hmoV Ago. AmVm OJbmMo_mU H _r hmoV Amho, Jm`rhr H _r hmoV AmhoV.

    {deof gdmX

    ^JdmZ lram_mZoJmo {hV nm{hbo. `m_wioam_^ hr gXm Jmo {hVmbm mYm` XoVmV. am_^ ~Zm`Mo Va JmogodmAmd`H M. - lr am_mZwO gXm`mMm` lr amKdmMm` dm_r

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    37/52

    {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 & 37

    Jm`rMo eoU eoVrgmR>rhr Cn w Amho.IV, {~`mUo, AmfYo `m~m~VrV eoVH ard`nyUPmbm Va dmdb~r ~Zob. eoVrbm

    Cm_ ~Zdmdo bmJob. Am{U Vo hmoDeH Vo. nmM {H bmodQ>n`VMr drO JmB`meoUmnmgyZ ~Zdy eH Vm. `oH JmdmV Jmo~aJgnmgyZ drO{Z{_Vr hmoD eH Vo. {XrAm`Am`Q>rZo `mnmgyZ H ma ~Z{d`mMm{dMma Ho bm Amho

    ~S>moXmOdi ^aV^mB nQ>ob Zm_H ` sAmho. `mZr ~S>moXm JmdmV H maImZm gw

    Ho bm Amho. Xhm hOma {H bmo Jg XaamoOVo Jmo~anmgyZ V`ma H aVmV. EH {H bmoJgda 40 {H _rn`V H ma MmbVo. 60 n`o {H bmoXamZo {dH VmV. ^{d`mV Xo -embm Cn `mVyZ {_iy eH Vo. 10 bmIH moQ>r n`mMo {S>Pob, noQ>mob AmnU IMH aVmo. Jmo~a Jgda AmnU AZoH dmhZoMmbdy eH Vmo. Am{U Amnbm Xoe noQ>mob,

    {S>Pob`m ~m~VrV dmdb~r ~Zob. Jmo-COm `m {df`mV AZoH gemoYZogw AmhoV.104 H maMr CnmXZo Jmo~a VgoM Jmo_ym-nmgyZ ~Z{dVm `oVmV. `md Z JmdmJmdmVgm_m` ` sZm amoOJma {_iyeH Vmo .

    Jm`rda AbmonWr_mUo CnMma Z H aVmXoernVrZoM H amdoV. JmBZo bmpQ>H ImoAgob Va `mda AmnaoeZ H Z`o. 100

    J_ _moharMo (gagmo) Vob, 100 J_ qZ~mir(Zr_) Vob, 100 J_ VrimMo Vob Am{U100 J_ EaS>obMoVob d 50 J_ gYm Z_HEH H Z, 500 J_ VmOo VmH , 50 J_VwaQ>r, 25 J_ amB XmoZ {Xdg gH mi dg`mH mi WmoS>m WmoS>m _mUmV JmBbm{X`mg ~aohmoBb. ***

    _mZZr` gnmXH ,{ddoH {dMma,Amn`m AH mg ew oN>m XoVmZm Amhmg A{Ve` AmZX

    hmoV Amho. AmZX `mgmR>r H s {ddoH {dMmaMr `mVr \ ma_moR>r Ag`mZo JmoYZ~m~VMo AmMma/{dMma ghOmghOrgdmn`V nmohmoMdVm `oVrb.

    EH m Xoer Jm`r`m _y d eoUmMm eoVr_`o gw`mo` dmnaH Z MmJbo CnmXZ KoVm `oVo. `m _m`_mVyZ D g, Vya,

    ^mV AmXr {nH mMo OmJ{VH XOmMo CnmXZ {_imboAmho. lrjo {g{Jar _R>mZo Ho bo`m Xoer JmonmbZ Am{U `mMoH frjomVrb Cn`moJ `mdarb `edr `moJmZm AmVm {d{dYVamda _m`Vm {_imbr Amho. _R>m`m JmoemioV g`m22 H ma`m Jm`tMo gJmonZ, `m`m Cn`mo{JVoMm Mmad gma Hobm OmV Amho. VgoM _R>m`m EH m EH amVrb188 {nH m`m bmJdS>rVyZ dmdb~r bInVr eoVr `moJhr`edr R>abm Amho. mVyZ eoVH `m`m gd JaOm nyU hmoD Z

    amoO 300 n`mn`VMo CnZ {_iy eH Vo. `m_wioXoer Jm`gm miyZ g|r` eoVr Ho`mg A`n CnmXZ IMmV MmJboCnZ {_iy eH Vo. Aem nmd y_rda "{ddoH {dMma' ZoH mT>bobm JmoYZ {deofmH hm Am_`mgmR>r AmZXXm`r Amho.`m H m`mg Am_`m ew oN>m !

    - dm_r lr A` H mS>{goda,lr {g{Jar _R>, H Uoar, H mohmnya, gnH : 02312671998

    AmerdMZ

    {deof gdmX

    HwamU Am{U Aa~ Om Jmo h`oMo g_WZ H aV ZmhrV. - hH s_ AO_b Im

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    38/52

    38 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

    H{fYmZ ^maVmV Jm` `m m`mbm Xodd {Xbo Jobo. H maUJm` eoVH `mMm OrdZmYma R>abr. Jm` gH g XY XoVo, Jmo_y{ZOVwH sH aUmgmR>r, AmfYmgmR>r dmnabo OmVo. JmBMr {d>m eoUIVhUyZ eoVH ar dmn eH Vmo. Jm` {hadm nmbm, {Za{Zam`m H maMoJdV ImV Ag`m_wioeoUIV ho A`V gH g IV _mZbo OmVo.

    Jm` JamoXa am{hbr Var {d`mnydu hUOo ~miV hmo`mnydu Xhm{Xdgmn`V XY XoV amhVo Am{U Jm`t_wioM eoVH `mbm A`V Cn`moJrAgbo`m ~bmMm O_ hmoVmo. EHoH mir `m`mH So > JmBA{YH VmogdmV lr_V. EH aJm`m, EH nm`m hOmamo Jm`r amOo amOdmSo>EH _oH mbm oQ> XoV AgV. JmoYZ hr gnmr hmoVr.

    XoemVrb H moQ>dYr OZVobm Jm` AmYma XoVo hUyZ JmBbm Jmo_mVmhQ>bo OmVo d oH _mUyg Xod Amho Aer H nZm H Z JmB`mnmoQ>mV VohVrg H moQ>r Xod AmhoV, Aer lXm Onbr OmB.

    Jm` hm eoVH `mMm AmYma Amho . ^maVr` gHVrV JmBbmXodVoMo WmZ Amho. {Vbm Jmo_mVm hUyZ {VMo nyOZ Hobo OmVo.

    {~Jo{S>`a ho_V _hmOZnwUo.9096701253

    H mJog`memgZH mbmV nr.

    {MX~a_ ~mJbmXoe`mXm`mda JoboAgVmZm~mJbmXoeZo^maVr`gr_m gwajm Xb Am_`m

    ZmJ[aH mMr ZmhH h`mH aVo, Agm gmigyXH mJmdm Ho bm. `m_wioAm_`m `m VH mbrZ

    Jh_`mZr "JmoVH amdaI`m Jmo`m PmSy>Z`oV, Va a~ar ~wboQ>PmS>m`mV', Agm AmXoeH mT>bm hmoVm. `m_wio `m

    OdmZmMr AmUIrM _moR>rAS>MU Pmbr hmoVr.

    Jmode VH arMmXheVdmXmda n[aUm_

    38 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 am >ajm

    newam>m`m >rZo^maV Amnbm Jmad hadV Mmbbm Amho . (bmS> H PZ `mZo 1903 _`o{b{hbo`m nmVyZ)

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    39/52

    {ddoH {dMma & _o2015 & 39

    H {fYmZ ^maVmV JmBbm Ym{_H d gmH {VH WmZAg`m_wio ^maVmV Jmoh`m ~XrMm H m`Xm Amho.AZoH Xm Jmoh`odZ XoemV gKf hmoVmV.

    ~mJbmXoemV hmoUmar VH ar amoI`mMm AmXoe~mJbmXoe_`o hmoUmar JmodemMr VH ar amoIm,

    ~mJbmXoedm{g`mZm Jmo_mgmMm VwQ>dS>m ^mgy m,hUOo Vo Jmo_mg ^jU H aUo gmoSy>Z XoVrb, AgmAmemdmX H| r` Jh_r amOZmW qgh `mZr `Ho bm. ^maV-~mJbmXoe gr_oda VZmV Agbo`mgr_m gwajm Xbm`m g{ZH mZm Vo g~mo{YV H aVhmoVo. gr_m gwajm Xbm`m g{ZH mZr `mMr JV

    dmT>d`mZo ~mJbmXoemV hmoUmar JmodemMr VH ar`yZ Pmbr Amho. `m_wio~mJbmXoe_`o Jmo_mgm`m_y`mV 30 Q>o dmT> Pmbr Amho. gwajm XbmZo `mMrJV A{YH H S>H H Z JmodemMr VH ar gnyUnUoWm~d`mg ~mJbmXoe_Yrb Jmo_mgm`m _y`mV 70Vo 80 Q>o dmT> hmoBb Am{U ~mJbmXoeMo ZmJ[aHJmo_mg ^jU H aUo gmoSy>Z XoVrb. ~mJbmXoeg_doVAm_Mo _rnyU g~Y AmhoV. Amhmbm hr _r

    AOyZ dmT>dm`Mr Amho. ~mJbmXoe VH amH Sy>Z gr_mgwajm Xbm`m g{ZH mda AmH _Uo hmoV AmhoV. `mAmH _UmZm gSo>VmoS> Cma mdo. emgZ Hw R>`mhrn[apWVrV Vw_`m nmR>rer C o amhrb. A{YH VgymZwgma 2014 _`o ^maVmVyZ ~mJbmXoe_`o 17bmI JmodemMr VH ar Pmbr Amho, Ago H|r` Jh_ramOZmW qgh hUmbo.

    ^maVmVyZ JmB`m VH arMo dmVd

    OJmV ^maV hr _mg {Z`mVrMr gdmV _moR>r~mOmanoR> Amho. ^maV Jm` Am{U herMo _mg {Z`mVH a`mMr gdmV _moR>r ~mOmanoR> Amho. Oa ^maVmVyZAm`mV ~X Pmbr Va _mgmMr nyVVm VgoM _mgmda{d{dY {H m H Z ImnXmW ~Z{dUm`m H n`mM~X H am`m bmJVrb. naXoer Hn`m`m >rZo _mghm H m _mb Amho. `mda {H m H Z AZoH nXmW

    {Z_mU hmoV AgVmV. VgoM ^maVmVhr _moR>m g`oV_mgmhma H aUmaobmoH AmhoV Am{U `m`mgmR>r XadfubmImo JmB Am{U hetMr H mb Ho br OmVo. EH Va^maVmV _mgmhma H aUm`m`m nmoQ>mV ho _mg OmVo,A`Wm `m _mgmMr {Z`mV hmoVoqH dm VH ar hmoVo.

    JmodemMr _moR>r {Z`mV ~mJbmXoe, nm{H VmZ_ o~mJbmXoe Am{U nm{H VmZ hoXmohr Xoe _mg^jr

    AmhoV. `m_wioJmodemMr _moR>r {Z`mV m XmoZ XoemZmMhmoVo. hm H _ df^a gw M AgVmo. _mg H mT>`mZVaCabo`m Ad`dm`mhr VoWo {d{dY dVy V`ma Ho `mOmVmV. `m H maUm_wioM {dXoemVhr ^maVr` _mgmMr

    _mJUr dmT>VM Amho. m_w`mZo BXgma`m gUm`mdoir ^maVmVyZ bjmdYr ~H ao H gmBIm`mV OmVAgVmV. gaH maH So> hUm`bm ~Xr Amho, nU VrHodi H mJXmnwaVr. ^maVmVrb `m _moR>m ZmnwT>o ~mJbmXoe qH dm nm{H VmZmV OmVmV `m qH dmgm_w{H _mJmZo ho ~H ao~mJbmXoe Am{U nm{H VmZmVnmohmoMV AgVmV. `mMr XmoZ H maUo AmhoV. EH Va^maVmV `m dVyda {V~Y Amho, `mMr VH ar H Z

    Vmo_mb `m XmoZ XoemV OmVmo Am{U gmh{OH M `mMo_y` A{YH {_iV AgVo. _J m XmoZ XoemVyZ _`nydAm{U n{_o`m H mhr XoemV VH ar hmoVo. VH arMm YXmhm OmoI_rMm Ag`m_wio`mMo MT>o ^md {_iUmaM.VH ar CKS>H sg oD Z`o hUyZ Jm`, hg, ~H ao mMoVm|S> {edyZ ~X H a`mV `oVo. OoUoH Z `mMr AmoaS>EoH m`bm Om`bm ZH mo. ^maVm`m gr_mdVu ^mJmVamhUmao bmoH Aem VH arMo_moR>o dmhH AgVmV Am{U

    Vo hm _mb g~{YV XoemV nmohmoMd`mg _XV H arVAgVmV.

    gr_odarb Am_`m OdmZmZr Aem H mhr VH amZmmUmMr ~mOr bmdyZ nH S>bo, XmoKmZm R>ma _maboAm{U _moR>m _mUmV newYZ dmM{dboAgVm, `mZmeVrn Xo`mEodOr _mJ`m gaH maZo MmaOdmZmZmM {Zb{~V H Z Q>mH bo. hm H mi gnwAmMm.

    am>ajm

    m`m`m X~bVo~amo~aM, am>hr {Z~b hmoD bmJVo. - S>m. hoamS> _mZ

  • 7/21/2019 Vivek Vichar May 2015

    40/52

    40 & {ddoH {dMma & _o2015

    `mV Oo XmoZ VH a _mabo Jobo`m`m HwQw>~r`mZm E{e`Z w_ZH {_eZ `m gKQ>ZoZo nmM nmMbmI n`o {Xbo! OdmZmZm XS>Am{U VH amZm _{bXm hm gnwAmgaH ma`m H mimV `m` hmoVm.

    gr_m gwajm XbmMo H _mS>aCm_Hw_ma ~gb `mZr Amn`m{Zdmrnydu gaH mabm EH n{bhZ, gaH maZo `m VH arbmH m`Xoera d n mdo OoUoH Z

    `mZm Amhr nH S>Uma Zmhr.`mZm Jmode {Z`mV H a`mMo nadmZoM XoD Z Q>mH mdoV,Ago H idbo hmoVo. ^maV gaH ma`m `m {ZpHYmoaUm_wio BX`m AmYr ^maVmVyZ ~H ao, JmB,her {_iyZ 40 bmI newYZ ~mJbmXoebm {Z`mVHo bo OmVo. ~mJbmXoemVrb _wI dV_mZnmVM `mgJ`m ~mV`m N>mnyZ Am`m AmhoV. `mnojm _moR>mnwamdm AmUIr H moUVm hdm Amho? EH m d`godr

    gWoZoHo bo`m gh}jUmV hQ>bo Amho H s, ^m