vivek vichar february 2016

Upload: vivekananda-kendra

Post on 22-Feb-2018

229 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    1/52

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    2/52

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    3/52

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 3

    Ow{bAg Amonoho_aAUw ~m~MoOZH ,1904 Vo1967OJmVrb EH _hmZ ^m{VH

    emk

    nmMm` g`VoZobmdbo`m ~hVoHemoYmMo JyT> dUZ Amhmbm ^JdXJrVoV AmT>iyZ `oVo.

    hoIynM AmM`OZH Amho.^JdXJrVm hm ^maVmMm _hmZ JW Amho.

    {ddoH {dMma

    dm_r {ddoH mZXmMo {dMma : gddVw_mmMo R>m`r EH M Ba pWV Amho. Am{U hmM ZrVremmMm nm`m Amho.Xg`mg X:I XoD ZH m. gdmda Am_dV o_ H am.

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    4/52

    4 & {ddoH {dMma & \o~wdmar 2016

    _m

    {ddoH mZX H| mMogmH {VH _m{gH

    {ddoH {dMmadf31 do - AH 2 am - n>o52

    nmf - _mK / `wJmX 51164 \o ~wdmar 2016

    RNI NO. 46869 / 85,"{ddoH {dMma' ho _m{gH_mbH , "{ddoH mZX H| _amR>r H meZ {d^mJ'`mMogmR>r _wH d H meH YZO` gy der `mZr{{gOZ qQ>g, X{ZH VU ^maV, 19/20,Ammo{JH dgmhV, hmoQ>Jr amoS>, gmobmnya oWoN>mnyZ, {ddoH mZX H| , 165, aodo bmBg,

    gmobmnya oWyZ {g Hobo.gnmXH - {gmam_ anm nmQ>rb

    n`dhmamMm nmm

    {ddoH {dMmamam - {ddoH mZX H|,

    165, aodo bmBg, gmobmnya-413 001.Xy0217 - 2315949 (gm 7 Vo 8.30)

    email : [email protected]

    Ad` oQ> mvivekvichar.vkendra.org

    _y` - 15 n`o

    gnmXH{gmam_ ^. nmQ>rb

    _w` gnmXHlr. nr. na_odaZ

    AZoH mV EH d hrM {dmMr aMZm Amho.

    boImZwH _

    ... `mMr dJUr gnV AmhoAmn`mbm oUm`m "{ddoH {dMma'`m nm{H Q>mdarbn`m`m n{h`m AmoirMm eodQ> "201603' Agm Agob

    Va Vw_Mr dJUr _mM 2016 _ o gnV Amho. H n`mnwT>rb dfmMr dJUr ^am. `mdoir Amnbm dJUrXma H _mH(nm{H Q>mdarb n`mMr n{hbr Amoi) Ad` H idm.

    2021 nydu Amgm_,

    n. ~Jmb`m_w`_{nXr XmoZ~mmbmXoer ?

    5

    _mmV ZoH _oH m` Pmbo?

    6

    godmaV `{ `{am> H m hr mU h 11

    _wS>H mon{ZfX dmmV AUmMb ^oQ>rMm21 24

    EH PmS>,XmoZ (dV) njr

    bmoH mgmR>r OJU

    28

    36

    ~mb{dhma32

    Vm{O{H VmZmV XmT>r AZ~wa`mda Ambr ~Xr

    44

    OmUrdnydH XS>nbo hmoVoA`mo`oVrb g`

    46

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    5/52

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 5

    ~mmbmXoer KwgImoar ^maVm`m gwajog gdmV _moR>m YmoH m ho{~Jo{S>`a ho_V _hmOZ `mMo, maVr` {dMma gmYZm, nwUo,`mZr H m{eV Ho bobo, ~mJbmXoer KwgImoarMm B{Vhmg, AmOMo dn,CmMr AmhmZo gmJUmaogw~mo Y Am{U agmi nwVH Amho. {~Jo{S>`aho_V _hmOZ `mZm gajU Xbm_Yrb 37 dfm`m godoMr nm y_r

    Amho. VgoM {d{dY X{ZH Am{U _m{gH mgmR>r `mZr 1000 hZ OmVboIhr {b{hbobo AmhoV. {df`kmZ Va `mZm AmhoM nU ZoQ>`meXm_`oVo H g _mS>mdo, `mMr OmUrd gwm `m nwVH mV {XgyZ `oVo.dV: `wVk Ag`m_wionwVH mMr ^mfm AmoKdVr Amho . _ZmMrnH S> KoUmaodUZ Ag`m_wio nwVH amoMH PmboAmho. nwVH mMraMZm gwgJVdma Amho.

    1944 gmbMo ^maVmMo JhZa OZab bmS> dohobZr Amn`m"hmBgamBO OaZb' `m nwVH m_`o {b{hbo hmoVo H s "Amgm_Mo_w`_r _moh_X gXmCm ImZ ho _moR>m _mUmV ~JmbtMr KwgImoarAmgm__`oH a`mMm Am{U nm{H VmZMm mJ ~Zd`mMm `Z H aVhmoVo'. dm`` maVmV _wpb_ ~hg` am` Agmdohr H nZm _wpb_brJMo A`j _h_X B~mb mZr 1930 _`o_mS>br. OmZodmar1940 nmgyZ {OZm mZr qhX Am{U _wgb_mZmZm XmoZ am>o hUyZMAmoiI`mg gw dmV Ho br. nm{H VmZMo nVYmZ Pw\ sH ma Abr

    nwVH n[aM`

    2021 nydu Amgm_,n. ~Jmb`m _w`_{nXr

    XmoZ ~mmbmXoer ?

    _w` boI

    EH H m`H Vm_w~B

    OJmbm W_ hoH iy Xo "{dZme H ZH m.'{dXdgmda C^mabo`m H moU`mhr gwYmaUoZoAmOda OJmMo H mhrhr ^bo Pmbo Zmhr.

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 5

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    6/52

    6 & {ddoH {dMma & \o~wdmar 2016

    ^wmmo "{_W Am\ B{S>noSg' `m nwVH mV hUVmV,"Amgm_ (BWo Amgm_ hUOo Bem` ^maV Am{Un{_ ~Jmb) hm nm{H VmZMm ^mJ hm`bm nm{hOo.'

    eoI _w{O~wa aoh_mZ hUmbo hmoVo H s, nydnm{H VmZMr dmT>Vr bmoH g`m Am{U Amgm_MrOJb d I{ZO gnmr nmhVm, Amgm_Mm AV^md nydnm{H VmZmV H aUo hoAmn`mbm d`nyU ~Zd`m`m>rZo A`V Amd`H Amho. 1945 _`o Va "H{~ZoQ>{_eZ bZ' V`ma H Z, Amgm_bm nyd ~JmberH m`_Mo OmoSy>Z _wpb_ ~hg` H a`mMr `moOZmPmbr. gwXdmZoAmgm__Yrb ZoVo JmonrZmW ~maXmobmoB

    `mZr Vr `moOZm `edr hmoD {Xbr Zmhr._hm_m JmYtZrhr m A_`m{XVWbmVaUm~m~V`m g_`o{df`r qMVm ` HobobrhmoVr. _m Vmo bm|T>m amoI`mH aVm `mZr H mhrnmdbo CMbbr ZmhrV. nm{H VmZMo OZH {OZmmMo ImOJr g{Md _Zyb hH MmYar \ miUrZVa^maVmVM am{hbod `mZr H mJog njmV doe Ho bm.MmYar {OZmZm hUmbo H s, Xhm df} Wm~m, _rVwhmbm Amgm_ MmXr`m V~H mV AmUyZ ^oQ> XoBZ.

    {OZm`m g`md Z, nm{H VmZmVyZ Amgm_mVWm{`H hmo`mgmR>r `oUm`m ~oH m`Xm KwgImoamZm _XVH a`mgmR>rM MmYar Amgm_mV am{hbo.

    Zmoh|~a 1941 _`o dmV`dra {d. Xm.gmdaH amZr Amgm_Mm Xmam Ho bm. Vohm Amgm__`onydnm{H VmZt`m \ ma _moR>m KwgImoarH So> `mZrZoh Mo bj doYbo. _hm_m JmYr, Zoh nmgyZ gdmZrdmV`dramH So> Xbj Ho bo. {OZm, Pwp\ H ma Abr

    ^wmmo, eoI _w{O~ya ah_mZ, Am{U AZoH m`m _VmVEH g_mZ YmJm Amho. ~mJbmXoemer Amnbo{H Vrhr_rnyU g~Y AgyXoV, `m XoemnmgyZ g dV AgbobobmoH g`m_H AmH _U hmoVM amhrb.

    1950 gmbr ggXo_`o KwgImoarMm {df` {dMmamWKo`mV Ambm. H maU mMr J raVm Jh_r gaXma

    _mmV ZoH _o H m` Pmbo?Vgm nanaoZo _mXm hm _wpb_~hb {Ohm

    ZhVm. `mMr MrVr 1951 `m n{h`m gmd{H{ZdS>UwH mnmgyZ `oVo. 1951 _`o qhXMr g`m

    gw_mao 63 Q> o hmoVr, Va _wpb_ 37 Q> o hmoVo.1971 n`V ho _mU g_g_mZ Pmbo. H maU~mJbmXoemVyZ KwgImoarMm AmoK dmT>VM Jobm.2011 `m OZJUZoZwgma qhXMo _mU 47.99Q> o, Va _wpb_mMo 51.27 Q> o Ago am{hbo._mXmMo amOH s` {V{Z{Yd ho _wpb_mH So>M AgVo.

    EH m Wm{ZH Zo`mZoo{fV _h_Xm~b AZw{MVCXJma {S>g|~a _{h`mV H mT>bo hmoVo. ho {Z{_mH Z "AOw_Z Ahbo gwV D b O_mV' `m gKQ>ZoZn{_ ~Jmb`m _mXm {OmVrb H m{b`mMmH`m {R>H mUr _moR>r {ZXeZo H a`mMm KmQ> KmVbm. ho{R>H mU ~ZmdQ> ZmoQ>m ~Zd`mM qH dm ~mJbmXoemVyZVoWo KoD Z `o`mMo qhXWmZmVrb gdmV _moR> H| _mZb OmV. ~oH m`Xoera H `mV JwVbo`m gK{Q>V

    JwhoJmar Q>mo`mMo gm_m` `m ^mJmV Amho.gr_onbrH Sy>Z ~mJbmXoemVyZ ~oH m`Xm KwgImoar,gr_m gwajm Xb Wm~dy eH bo Zmhr. VH ar hmoVAgVoM. `m_wi gr_m gwajm XbmMr H madmB hr`m gK{Q>V Q>mo`mda gVVMr Q>mJVr Vbdma AgVo.H m{b`mMmH `oWo EH _{hZm AmYr Pmbo`m

    _w` boI

    {Za{Zamio Y_nW, {Za{Zam`m H maMr _Vo_mS>V Agbo Var, {Za{Zam`m CnmgZm nVr MmoImiV AgboVar,AVV: ho na_oam Vw`mVM oD Z nmohmoMVmV.

    6 & {ddoH {dMma & \o~wdmar 2016

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    7/52

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 7

    d^^mB nQ>ob `mZm OmUdbr hmoVr. {eV~bmoH emhr, am>m`m C^maUrMr j_Vm AgUmao dXa>r AgUm`m d^^mBZr H Vr H Z B{_JoeZ

    AQ>(EnbeZ \ m_ Amgm_) _Oya H Z KoVbm.nU bJoMM {S>g|~a 1950 _`o `m`m {ZYZmZVa hmH m`Xm EH _V XVmdoO ~ZyZ am{hbm.

    lr. \ H rZ Abr Ah_X `m`m ZoVdmImbrAm_Xmam`m EH m JQ>mZo Agm Mma gw Ho bm H sKwgImoa ~mhoa H mT>`mg H mJog nj Amgm__`oM dgnyU^maVmV _wbr_ _VmnmgyZ d{MV hmoBb. Am{UeodQ>r _VnoQ>r`m amOH maUmMm {dO` Pmbm. {h|eZ

    Am\ BZ{\ bQ>oeZ `moOZm' gmoSy>Z Xo`mV Ambr. lr\ H rZ Abr Ah_X `m`m ZoVdmImbr KwgImoarg_WH mMm {dO` Pmbm.

    H mJogMo A`j XodH mV ~mAmZr Ago Kmo{fVHobo hmoVo H s, `mMm nj Amgm_mV, AbrO AS>HwbrO' m`m _XVrZo, Zoh_rM {ZdS>UwH m qOH Vamhrb. mnH s AbrO hUOo ~mJbmXoer KwgImoaAm{U Hw brO hUOoMhm`m ~mJmVrb _Oya. Zoh -JmYr Kam`mVrb gX` ~r. Ho. Zoh 1960 ZVa

    Amgm_mV am`nmb hmoVo. ZmBg JmBO {\ {Ze goH S>'m `m`m Am_M[amV Vo{b{hVmV H s, {XrVrbVrZ amOH s` Zo`mZr Amgm_mVrb H mJog`m YmoaUmg{Xem {Xbr. Vo hmoVo XodH mV ~mAm, {OZmMo _mOrg{Md d H| r` _r _Zyb hH MmYar, Am{U AmUIrH|r` _r d am>nVr \ Hw rZ Abr Ah_X. B{XamJmYt`m gaH ma_`o H|r` _r Pmbobo _Zyb hHMmYar Am{U _mOr am>nVr \ Hw rZ Abr Ah_X,

    ho AZ{YH V ~mJbmXoer WbmV[aVm`m Wm{`Hhmo`mg H maUr^yV Ag`mMo gdlwVM hmoVo.n{_ ~JmbMo _w`_r ~wXod ^>mMm` mZr

    m g_`oH So> Jm r`mZonm{hbo, ZVa An[ahm` AmhohUyZ `m n[apWVrMm drH ma Hobm. ^mOnMoEb.Ho. AS>dmUr ho H| r` Jh_r AgVmZm, hm mg

    KQ>Zo~b {ZXeZo H a`mMm KmQ> Kmb`m_mJoJwhoJmar Q>mo`m d Vr gKQ>Zm `m`mV gJZ_VPmb hmoVo ho CKS> Amho. n{_ ~Jmb_Yrb

    _mXm {OmVrb H m{b`mMmH `oWo gmXm{`HqhgmMmamMm Omo CoH Pmbm Vmo C\y V ZhVm.hOmamo `wdH "Bbm_ IVao _|'`m ZmdmImbr

    O_m Ho boJobo. _mXm `oWo AS>rM bmI ~mJbmXoer_wpb_ a`mda CVabo. VoWrb nmobrg R>m`mda`mZr hm MT>dbm. {_XZmnya `oWo dmVmdaU VJH a`mV Ambo. {~hma_`ony{U m `o Wo AgoM bmI^aa`mda CVabo. VoWonmobrg R>m`mda hm MT>d`mVAmbm. nmobrg R>m`mVrb Q>rhr, gJUH , \ {ZMa,

    bmBQ>Mo ~moS> `mMr VmoS>\ moS> H a`mV Ambr. AmJbmd`mV Ambr. VoWo Agbobo nmobrg niyZ JobohUyZ ~Mmdbo. ~rEgE\ , nmobrg AmXt`m JmS>mZmAmJr bmd`mV Am`m. EH m nmobrg R>m`mbm AmJbmdbr Jobr. EH m VhgrbXma H m`mb`mbmhr AmJbmdyZ VoImH H a`mV Amb. _moR>r Ominmoi Pmbr.H moQ>dYtMr _mb_mm ~o{MamI H a`mV Ambr.eoH S>mo OU OI_r Pmbo . hoH m` ~S> Amho H m?nmo{bgmda `mMm BVH m amJ H emH [aVm? H s `mXoemVrb H m`Xm Am{U gw`dWm {~KS>dyZ Q>mH `mMmBamXm Amho? hm gJim qhgmMma `m XoemVrb gJiobmoH BV`m ghOnUo H gbrhr {V{H m, {ZfoY` Z H aVm H m ghZ H aV AmhoV? H m`m`mqMYS>m CS>{dUm`m `m KQ>Zmda n{m_ ~Jmb`m_w`_r __Vm ~ZOu, {~hma`m _w`_`mZr MH maeX H mT>bm Zmhr. mMo Vm|S> H emZo Jn Pmbo Amho?

    n{_ ~Jmb_`o AmJm_r H mimV {dYmZg^m

    {ZdS>UwH m AmhoV. `m_wio{VW`m gm_m` OZVobmdoR>rg YaV AemVVm _mO{d`mMo H maWmZ IoiboOmV Amho. _mXm `oWo Pmbo`m XJbrV ~mJbmKwgImoamMm, _Jba bmoH mMm hmV hmoVm. H m`m`mam`mda, emgZmda gai gai ~oXaH manUo ho hmoVAmhoV. gw`dWo`m qMYS>m CS>{d`m OmV AmhoV.

    _w` boI

    Vw_`m R>m`r gd e s AmhoV. Vwhmbm H moUVrhr Jmo> Ae` Zmhr. Vwhr gdH mhrhr H eH Vm.

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 7

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    8/52

    8 & {ddoH {dMma & \o~wdmar 2016

    H _r H a`mgmR>r H mhr nmdbo CMbbr hmoVr. nUH|mV 2004 gmbr `y.nr.E. gaH ma `oVmM `m`mH m`dmhrV e{W` Ambo.

    ^maVm`m nyd ^mJmVrb _wI boQ>ZQ> OZabO_rb _h_yX mZr 1990 ZVa`m H mimV, n{_~Jmb Am{U Amgm_Mo _w`_r Agbobo `moVr~gy Am{U {hVoa g{H m mZm Agm gm {XbobmhmoVm H s, Oa ~mJbmXoer KwgImoam{d H madmBHobr Zmhr Va, Bem` ^maVmV Amn`mbm ^maVm`mgr_mMo nwZb}IZ H amdo bmJob. `mZr bH am`m_w`mb`mbmhr m~m~V {b{hbo hmoVo H s, AX{g{bJwS>r H m[aS>maZOrH `m Yw~r `oWo H m_ragmaIrn[apWVr {dH {gV hmoV Amho.

    1983 gmbr B{Xam JmYr m`m H mimV Amgm_gmR>rAm`E_S>rQ>r (Illegal Migrants Determination byTribunals act, 1983)hm KmVH H m`Xm _Oya H a`mVAmbm. `mZwgma EImXm KwgImoa ~JbmXoer AmhoH m,ho {g H a`mMr O~m~Xmar VH ma H aUm`mda nS>br.Amgm_Mo am`nmb OZab {ghm mZr, ^maVm`mam>nVtZm Amgm_mVrb AZ{YHV WbmVamdarb

    Ahdmb Zmoh|~a 1998 _`o gmXa Hobm. m Xoeo_ram`nmbm`m Ahdmbmda am>nVr d gaH maZoH mhrMHobo Zmhr. 10 dfmZVa Amgm_Mo am`nmb OZabAO` qgJ `mZr nU AgmM Ahdmb gmXa Hobm.`mda nU H mhrM Pmbo Zmhr.

    Amgm__`o ~mJbmXoer bmoH g`m am`m`mEHyU bmoH g`o`m 30.9% hmoVr. nU EH mXeH mZVa {VMm dmQ>m 34.2% Pmbm. n{_

    ~Jmb_`o ~mJbmXoer bmoH g`oMm dmQ>m 2001_Yrb EHyU bmoH g`o`m 25.2% d Z, 2011_`o EHy U bmoH g`o`m 27% da nmohmoMbm Amho.AmVm ~oH m`Xm KwgImoa, OZJUZoVyZ {ZgQ>`mH aVmn{_ ~Jmb qH dm Amgm_mV ImoQ>o XV-EodO(_VXma H mS>) ~ZdyZ {Xr, _hmam>, Cma Xoe,

    XmXarVrb EH m H {WV KQ>Zod Z gJ`m Xoe^aAg{hUwVm {Z_mU Pm`mMm eI H aUmao Am{U amoOEH m_mJyZ EH nwaH ma naV H a`mMm gnmQ>m bmdUmao

    AmVm Myn H m AmhoV? H s `mMm `m gd qhgobmnmqR>~m Amho?

    ^mJmo{bH Q>m _mXm np_ ~Jmb am`mV,qhXWmZmV Agbo Var qhXWmZ-~mJbmXoegr_obJV Ag`mZo ~mJbmXoemer AOyZhr Zmi{Q>H dyZ Amho. EHoH mir E~rE KZrImZ Mm Yarho H mJogMo `o> ZoVo VoWrb gd}gdm hmoVo. nwT>o Vo_mXmMo ImgXma, H| r` aodo_r dJao Pmbo.`mZr Am{U ZVa BVa amOH s` Zo`mZr ~JbmXoerKwgImoarbm _XV Hobr. AJmoXaMo nyd nm{H VmZAm{U AmOMo ~mJbmXoe `o WyZ A`mhVnUo gr_

    oda AgUm`m H mbr`mMH _`o KwgImoar hmoVAgVmZm {XgVo. gnyU _mXm {OmVM ~mJbmXoer

    _wpb_mMr g`m {Xdg|{Xdg dmT>V Jobr. Vgm nanaoZo_mXm hm _wpb_~hb {Ohm ZhVm. `mMr MrVr1951`m n{h`m gmd{H {ZdS>UwH mnmgyZ `oVo.1951 _`o qhXMr g`m gw_mao 63 Q> o hmoVr, Va_wpb_ 37 Q> o Ago hmoVo. 1971 n`V ho _mUg_g_mZ Pmbo. H maU ~mJbmXoemVyZ KwgImoarMm AmoK

    _w` boI

    Amn`m_Yrb XoddmMo JQ>rH aU H am Am{U Vwhmbm {Xgob, H s `mo` `m Jmo>r AmnmoAmnM KSy>Z oVrb.

    8 & {ddoH {dMma & \o~wdmar 2016

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    9/52

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 9

    dmT>VM Jobm. 2011 `m OZJUZoZwgma qhXMo _mU47.99 Q> o , Va _wpb_mMo 51.27 Q> o Agoam{hbo._mXmMo amOH s` {V{Z{Yd ho_wpb_mH So>M AgVo.

    _mXmVrb Wm{ZH OZVm Am{WH {ZdmhmgmR>rA\yMr eoVr, ImoQ>o MbZ d _mZdr VH ar `mgm_m{OH Am{U Am{WH JwhoJmar`m X>MH mVgmnS>bobr Amho Am{U `mMm Ja\ m`Xm Wm{ZHnmVirdarb amOH s` ZoVo_S>ir CR>dV AgVmV.`m Wm{nV JwhoJmar Am{U amOH s` dMdmbmY m ~g`m_wio Wm{ZH bmoH mZm ^S>H d`mMoH m_ H mhr g_mOHQ>H mZr Hobo. `m gdmMm n[anmHhUOo_mXmVrb qhgmMma hmo`.

    `mnydu`m H| Am{U am` gaH mamZr (`mVgbJ 34 dfmMr H `w{ZQ> gmm) gr_obJVAm{U `mVhr ~mJbmXoegmaIm eoOmar Agbo`mgdoXZerb am`m~m~V XmIdbobr AZmWm Am{UHobobo Xbj `mVyZ {Z_mU Pmbobo Am{U AmVm{dH mi d n YmaU Ho bobo{H `oH g_moa `oVAmhoV Am{U Aem J ra n[apWVrMo AmH bZ-{dcofU H a`mEodOr H mhr PmboM Zmhr Ago _mZV_m`_mZr S>moio {_Q>bo AmhoV. gr_m ^mJmV V`maPmbobo _XaemMo Omio Am{U `mbm amOH s`-bmbgonmoQ>r {_iV Agbobo gajU, {d{dY ^mJmV`mnydu Pmbobo dmX, OZg`o`m AdmOdr dmT>rVyZhmoD KmVbobo So>_moJm{\ H ~Xb, Ab H m`Xmgma`mOmJ{VH XheVdmXr gKQ>Zog~{YVmZr Ho bobo~m~\ moQ>, qhXda, `m`m Ka-XH mZmda Pmboboho, `m y mJmV XJmnyOm _hdmMr _mZbr OmVo,{VWoM `m{df`r Pmbo`m {H `oH qZXZr` KQ>Zm.

    `mXr _moR>r Amho.`m XoemV Aem H maogm_m{OH emVVm Ymo`mVAmU`mMm H Q> H moUr H aV Agob Va Aer HVr_wirM ghZ Ho br OmUma Zmhr ho H R>moa H madmBVyZgmJ`mMr JaO Amho.

    - {~Jo{S>`a ho_V _hmOZ

    {~hma, Ho aimV d BVa am`mV nmR>dboOmV AmhoV.hm XdX{dbmg AmhoH s KwgImoamZr AmVm H mJogbm

    _Vo m``m EodOr Amnbm nj "E`yS>rE\ ' (Amb

    Amgm_ So>_mHo{Q>>H \ Q>) V`ma Ho bm. VrZ dfmnydu`m njmV\} AO_b ~rZ ho bmoH g^oH aVm {ZdSy>ZAmbo. g`m `m njmMoAmgm_`m {dYmZg^oV 18Am_Xma d bmoH g^oV 4 ImgXma AmhoV. ~oH m`XmKwgImoamZr ImoQ>mZmQ>m Cnm`mZr Am{U Wm{ZHemgZm`m ghH m`mZo ImoQ>oXV-EodO (_VXma H mS >)V`ma H Z KoVbobo AmhoV. ho AZ{YHV ~mJbmXoer{ZdS>UwH mV {ZUm`H KQ>H R>aV AgVmV. ^maVm_`ogamg gw Agbo`m ~mJbmXoer KwgImoam{damoYmV~mobm`bm ^maVmVrb am` gaH mao, ~hVoH amOH s`nj (^mOn Am{U {edgoZm gmoSy>Z), ZmoH aemhr Am{Udmno V`ma ZmhrV.

    Xoem_`o hmoUmar KwgImoar amoI`m_`o gaH maAnwaonS>`m~b gdm} `m`mb`mZo gaH mada AZoHdoim Vmeoaohr AmoT>bo AmhoV. 16 OyZ 2014 amoOrgdm} `m`mb`mZo ^maVm_`o bnbo`m ~mJbmXoerKwgImoamZm nH Sy>Z naV nmR>dbo Jobo nm{hOo , Ago

    AmXoe {Xbo AmhoV.Bem` ^maVmMo ~mJ-E-Bbm_rH aU, _wpb_

    ~hg`mH ~Zd`mMr "Xma-Cb-Bbm_'Mr `moOZm,bmoH g`m_H AmH _UmMm B{Vhmg, Amgm_, n{_~Jmb, Bem` ^maVmV d BVa ^maVmV ~mJbmXoerAmH _U, ~mJbmXoer KwgImoar_wio ^maVmV dmT>UmamqhgmMma, ~mJbmXoemVrb qhXMr AdWm Am{U `mMm~mJbmXoer KwgImoarda n[aUm_, gr_m `dWmnZm`m

    g_`m, Cnm``moOZm Am{U bmoH g`m_HAmH _Um{d gwMdbo`m Cnm`mMm gmame Cm_[a`m_mS>`mV Ambm Amho.

    _VnoQ>r`m amOH maUmbm {damoY H amdm bmJob.`mgmR>r gmV`mZo`m`m {damo YmV boIZ Am{U MmaH am`bm hdm. OZJUZo`m AmH So>dmarMm AmYma KoD Z

    _w` boI

    _mUgm D R> ! Vy{Z` ~w (kmZdn), Vy{Z` ew Amhog. AO_m, A{dZmer Amhog. Vygde{ _mZ Amhog. hogde s_mZm, D R> ! VwPo g` dn H Q> H a!

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 9

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    10/52

    10 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

    _VXmamMr g`m Omhra H amdr, _VnoQ>rMo amOH maUQ>mi`mgmR>r amOH ma`mZm AmdmhZ H aUoOar Amho.hr am>r` gwajoMr g_`m Amho, ho bjmV KoD Z gd

    amOH s` njmZr EH Ambo nm{hOo. gdY_u`mZr EH `oD Z `mZm g_WZ {Xbo nm{hOo.~mJbmXoetZm {S>Q>oQ> H aUo, `mMr Zmdo

    _VXma`mXrVyZ {S>{bQ> H aUo d `mZm ~mJbmXoemV{S>nmoQ>H aUo hmM `mda Cnm` Amho . ~oH m`Xm KwgImoarHo bo`m ~mJbmXoetZm nH Sy>Z ^maVm`m ~mhoanmR>d`mV `oBb, Ago Za| _moXr `mZr bmoH g^m{ZdS>UwH mXa`mZ gm{JVbo hmoVo. `mgmR>r Amn`mbm`m ^mJm_`oAgboboZeZb a{OQ>a \ ma {gQ>rPZ(EZAmagr) `mo` H mao VnmgUo Amd`H Amho .`m_`o `mMr ZmdoZgVrb `mZm VmH mi maVm`m~mhoa H mT>bo Jobo nm{hOo. `m {ZU mMr VmH miA_b~OmdUr H aUo hr am` gaH ma Am{U H| gaH maMr O~m~Xmar Amho. KwgImoar Oa Mmbyam{hbr Va 2021 nydu Amgm_ d n{_ ~Jmb`m

    _w`_{nXr ~mJbmXoer ~g`mMo nmh`mMr XXdrdoi Amn`mda `oBb.

    nVYmZ lr. Za| _moXtZr 6-7 OyZ 2015 bm

    ~mJbmXoeMm Xmam Ho bm. ~mJbmXoeer AZoH H amaH a`mV Ambo. Zwg`m dZaOZm_`o Z amhVm `mH amamMr A_b~OmdUr H er hmoVo ho nmhUo JaOoMoAmho. ~mJbmXoer KwgImoar H _r Pmbr VaM `m oQ>rbmEo{Vhm{gH _mZVm `oBb.

    ~mJbmXoer KwgImoar~b H mhr BJOr nwVHoAmhoV. _amR>rV `mda EH hr nwVH Zmhr. {~Jo{S>`aho_V _hmOZZr ~amM [agM H Z ho nwVH {b{hboAmho. OZ_mZg OmJV H a`mMm ImarMm dmQ>m CMbmdmAer Anojm Amho. Vr nwar H a`mMm `Z {H Vr`edr Pmbm Amhoho dmMH mZr R>adm`Mo.

    {dHsH| - ^maVr` {dMma gmYZm, nwUo,^m{dgm ^dZ, 1214/15, no JoQ> ^mdo Hw bOdi, nwUo-411030. Q>obr\ moZ - 020-24487225, _w` - 300/- ***

    ZmJnya & ^maVr` gH Vr, Y_, nanam dB{Vhmgmbm OmJ{VH nQ>bmda {V{>V H aUmaodm_r {ddoH mZX ho Iao Va ^maVmMo ` dnAg`mMo {VnmXZ {ddoH mZX H|mMo ApIb^maVr` H mofm`j E_. hZw_Vamd mZr Hobo . ZmJnyaemIo`m dVrZo {ddoH mZX O`Vr{Z{_m Am`mo{OV`m`mZgJr Vo ~mobV hmoVo. OZ_mZgmVrb{ddoH mZX hm `m`m `m`mZmMm {df` hmoVm.

    A`jWmZr _mohZ JYo hmoVo. Vo hUmbo, `wdHAmhmZmMm {h_VrZo gm_Zm H a`mg H MaVmV.dm_r {ddoH mZXmMo {dMma `wdH mZm gKfH a`mMroaUm XoVmV. H| H m`H Vm_hoe Jwm `mZr nlrA{U_m {ghm `m`m oaH OrdZH m`mMr _m{hVr{Xbr. gm{_ Xm^mobH a `mZr gwna 30 Mm OZH

    AmZXHw_ma m`m e j{UH jomVrb moJXmZm{df`r_m{hVr {Xbr. `mdoir ^maVr` gHVr narjm dJrVm {Z~Y nY}Vrb {dOo`mMm g_mZ H a`mVAmbm.

    `mgJr H|mMo ZJa gMmbH ZmJnya dH s`_hm{dmb`mMo AYrjH OJXre hoS>mD , ZJa_wIJmar Ioa `mMr _wI CnpWVr hmoVr. mVm{dHbIoe Mder `mZr Hobo . d d Omoer `mZr

    gygMmbZ Hobo . lo g Zo_mSo> `mZr JrV Jm{`bo.Hw. doXdVr {hZo dXo _mVa_ Jm{`bo. am> go{dH mg{_Vr`m _mOr _wI gMm{bH m {_bmVmB _oT>o,{Zdm H Zb gwZrb XoenmSo>, S>m. {dbmg XoenmSo>,{Zdm bmBJ Am{\ ga {edmbr XoenmSo> `m`mgh_m`da d ZmJ[aH CnpWV hmoVo.

    dm_r {ddoH mZX ho ^maVmMo ` dnH|dm

    _w` boI

    lm; lm, dV:darb lm, Bamdarb lm hoM _moR>onUmMo ah`.

    10 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    11/52

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 11

    {ddoH mZX H| H `mHw _marZo H| mMo gWmnH EH ZmW amZSo >`m`m O_eVr ndm{Z{_m m {e{~amMo Am`moOZ Ho bo hmoVo.dm_r {ddoH mZXmZr H `mHw _mar oWo VrZ gmJam`m gJ_mda 25, 26

    d 27 {S>g|~a 1892 m VrZ {XdgmV Vn Hobo hmoVo. `m Vn`}AIoadm_rOtZm Amnbo Or{dV`o Jdgbo. `m am>qMVZ ndH mimMoAm{M` `m {e{~ambm bm^bohmoVo. {ddoH mZX hUVmV, nm{d`m`mVoOmZo Pimibobo; Ba{Z>oMo dOH dM `mbobo, _J|mMr qh_VAgboboAmn`m nrS>V, X:pIV, nXX{bV g_mO ~mYdm{df`r H UmAgboboAgo bjbj `wdH `wdVr _ww sMm, ghH m`mMm, gm_m{OHCWmZmMm, EH m_VoMm gXoe XoV gm`m ^maV^a gMma H aVrbVohmM maVmMm ^m`moX` hmoBb. dm_rOt`m am>qMVZ ndH mimVrb

    ho {e{~a `m`m dZmVrb `wdH KS>Urgh `m`mV `mZm Ano{jVgodm^md OmJdUmaoR>abo .H `mHw _mar `oWrb gmJaVQ>mda {hadmBZoZQ>bobm {ddoH mZXnwa_Mm

    {dVrUAgm n[aga. `oWo 24 {S>g|~a amoOr Amgm_, AUmMbnmgyZJwOamVn`V`m, ha`mUmnmgyZ Ho ain`V`m VU - VUr PwwS>r -PwwS>rZoXmIb Pmbo`m. Zm|XUrZVa Xoe^amV`m {d{dY mVmVrb eha,

    Anmgmho~ hmmiogmobmnya9049290101

    godmaV `{ `{am> H m hr mU h

    25, 26, 27 {S>g|~a `mH mbmdYrV Xoe^amVrb`wdH mMoH `mHw _mar `oWogmWH `wdm g_W ^maVho{e{~a Pmbo. gnyUXoe^amVyZ 680 `wdH- `wdVr `mV gh^mJr

    PmbohmoVo. `wdm e sVrbgodm^md OmJdUm`m `m

    CnH _mMm doY KoUmam hmboI. VgoM `m {e{~amV{ddoH mZX H| m`mOrdZdVr H m`H `mZr_mJXeZ Hobo.`m`m `m`mZmZr`wdH m_`o amQ>godoMroaUm OmJdbr. `m`m`mZmMm gmame XoV

    AmhmoV...

    doXmV Vwhmbm {eH dVmoH s, W_ dV:da {dmg R>odm.

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    12/52

    12 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

    Jmdmdm_YyZ Ambo`m `m VU-VUr doJdoJ`m_S>b d JUe: {eVrZo ~gbo`m. ^OZg`oV

    Am|H mam`m EH {V CmamVyZ EH dmMo XeZ.Xa`mZ, gJ`mZr Amnmnbo _mo~mBb ~XAm{U Vo JU_wImH So> gwnyXH Z eara, _ZmZodKS>UrgmR>r {g Pmbobo.

    Xg`m {XdgmnmgyZ _w` {e{~ambm gwdmV.nhmQ>o gmSo>Mmabm CRy>Z `moJgmgmR>r V`ma Pmbobo.Amnmn`m JU_wIm`m _mJXeZmZwgma {eVrZoamJoV _mJW hmoVmhoV. nhmQ>o`m Zrad emVVoV H mZ

    Mbo ^mBH mZ Mbo, dm_rOr Hodra Mbo, ^maV_mVm H s O`, AmO Ho AmZX H s, O` {ddoH mZXH s Am{X CgmhnyUKmofUm, `mZVa _ WZ, JUe:MMm, _S>be: gmXarH aU, HsS>m`moJ, ^OZg `mAgo amr Xhmn`V {e{~amMm {XZH _. gmao H mhr{eVrV, doioda Am{U JU_wIm`m gyMZoZwggma,EH dmZo. dm_r {ddoH mZX hUVmV, gJ`mZr{_iyZ EH H m_ H aUoho Amn`m _wir d^mdmVMZmhr. `m Xmofm_wioM Va Amnbr hr XXem Pmbobr

    Amho. `mbm Amkm nmim`Mr H er Vo g_OVo,`mbmM Amkm H er md`mMr hog_OVo . W_V:AmkmYmaH nUm {eH m.

    {ddoH mZX H| mMo A`j nr. na_o aZ,Cnm`j ~mbH UZd 65 hOma VUmZm amoOJma

    godogmR>r g_nUmMr {Z`gmYZm H amdr bmJobnr. na_odaZ, A`j, {ddoH mZX H| , H `mHw _mar

    d{MVmMr godm H aUoho `oH _Zw`mMo H V`Amho. `mgmR>r `oH`Vrbm Amnbo OrdZg_{nV H amd`mMo Amho .Aem g_nUmMr {Z` gmYZmH amdr bmJob. Agm g_nU^md Amn`mV {d_mZ{X`dm`m AZw wVrZoM JQ>

    hmoVo. gdg_{nV H m`mMo moV Amn`m X`mMr oaUmAgVo. dm_r {ddoH mZXm`m AmXemZwgma EH ZmWOtZr{ddoH mZX H|mMr gnyUaMZm Ho br. `mVrb moJ, {ejU,Jm_rU {dH mg AgmoAWdm Zg{JH gmYZ gnmrMo gdYZd Amamo`, `mgmR>r Am`mp_H oaUm A{Zdm` Amho.

    `m {e{~amV gh^mJr `oH {e{~amWuH Sy>Z hrAnojm Amho H s, `mZr Amn`mbm bmoH m`m Anojm`mAZwn dV:bm CZV Am{U ^maV_mVo`m H m`mgmR>r

    g_{nV H amdo. `m`m gm_wXm{`H g_nUmdaM maV_mVoMo^{d` Adb~yZ Amho, Oo eodQ>r OJmMoM ^{d` Amho.^maV_mVm OJXJw Amho Am{U gVV am{hbr Amho. AmVmAmnU gd Amn`m godomao Amn`m S>mo`mZr nydunojmA{YH JmadmZo ^maV_mVm OJXJw `m qghmgZmda{damO_mZ Pm`mMo nmhm`Mo Amho.

    _r X~b Amho, nmnr Amho, XX}dr Amho AgohUUo hrM gdmV _moR>r KmoS>MyH Amho Ago doXmV gmJVmo.

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    13/52

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 13

    {Xbobo ^maV {dH mg JwnMo gWmnH A`j hZw_VJm`H dmS> `m`m _wI CnpWVrV {e{~amMo CmQ>ZPmbo. Jm`H dmS> `mZr {ddoH mZXm`m {dMmamZo

    OrdZmbm {Xem {_im`mMo gmJV Amn`m g\ bd gmWH OrdZmMoAZw d H WZ Ho bo . Va na_oaZ`mZr d{MV bmoH mMr godm H aUo hr `oH _Zww`mMoH V` Ag`mMo gm{JVbo. Vo hUmbo, H V` ho EH m {XdgmMo H m` ZhoVa g_nU d {Z` gmYZoZoH V` ^md JQ> hmoBb. Va ~mbH UZ hUmbo,Xoedm{g`m_`o `mJ d godm^md OmJV Pmbm VaM^maV OJ ~Zob.

    H| r` _r {Z_bm grVmam_Z `m`m

    _wI CnpWVrV {e{~amMm g_mamon Pmbm. `mZr_mJXeZmA^mdr VU _mJoamhV Ag`mMo gmJVmZmMHwQw>{~`mgh godmH m`mer OmoS>`mMo AmdmhZ Ho bo.

    `mdoir H|m`m Cnm`j ~r. {Zdo{XVm `mZr {edgwXaZdg_mO KS>d`mgmR>r Am{U am>mbm nwZd d mH Z Xo`mgmR>r g_{nV dmrZo godmH m` H a`mMo AmdmhZ Hobo .

    Xa`mZ, VrZ {XdgmV VU - VUtZr godm{df`H{d{dY Am`m_mda JUe: MMm Hobr. _S>be:gmXarH aUmVyZ VUmB`m {dH {gV `{ _dmMoXeZKS>bo. g\ bVm, gmWH Vm, godm H s AdYmaUm, _hmZ`mJ go _hmZ H m` `m {df`mMm _WZmV g_mdoe

    AmnUm gdmZm BWo (H `mHw _mar)nmhyZ Iyn AmZX dmQ>V Amho. `m H _rd`mV godoMr ^mdZm {Z_mU hmoUo _moR>r^m`mMr JmoQ> Amho. AmnU nydO_r

    Ad` {H `oH nw`H _ Hobo AgVrbH s `m_wio `m O_mV Amn`m _ZmVgodoMm ^md JQ> Pmbm Amho. Amn`mXoemV 60 Q>Ho `wdH AmhoV, hrXoemMr {deofVm Amho. OJmVrb mMrZV_Xoe ^maVAmOhr VU Amho, hr _moR>r JmoQ> Amho.

    Amn`mbm hobjmV `mdo bmJob H s {dXoerAmH_UmZVahr ^maV AmOhr dm{^_mZmZo C^mAmho. BJOmZr Amn`mda Iyn A`mMma Hobo .

    BVHo H s XoemVrb _rR>mda H a bmXbo Am{UBJOmZr ~ZdboboM _rR> IaoXr H a`mg mJ nmS>bo.`m {damoYmV _hm_m JmYr `mZr _rR>mMm g`mJhHobm. Jm YrOtZr Amn`m `m g`mJhmbm gYrVnmVa Ho bo. `mZr Xoedm{g`mZm gK{Q>V H a`mMm

    {dS>m CMbbm. Amn`mgmR>rhr Xoembmgm_`embr ~Zd`mMoAmhmZ hr EHgYr Amho. gYr H Yrhr H moUmMr dmQ>nmhV Zmhr. {_imbo`m gYrbm H Yrhr

    gmoSy> Z`o. AmnU ^maVmbm H go g_W~Zdy, Amn`m OrdZmbm H go gmWH~Zdy? `mda gdmZm {dMma H amdmbmJob. OrdZm`m `oH jomVrb

    g\ bVoMr CMr JmRy>Z `mbm nma H amdo bmJob.Hfr, {ejU Agmo dm {dkmZ AWdm n`mdaU joAgob. Amn mbm `oH {XeoZo g\ bVm {_idmdrbmJob.

    `oH mV g\ b hmo`mMr BN>m AgVo. `oH OU

    100 QHo `edr hmoD BpN>Vmo. ho R>rH hr Amho.OrdZmV ngo H _mdUo OarMo Amho. naVw ngm hoMgd H mhr Zmhr. g\ bVm _Zw` OrdZmMm n{hbmA`m` Am{U gmWH Vm Xgam A`m` Amho.AYo _mJ g\ bVm Va AY} _mJ gmWH Vm Amho.

    "d` gwnwm A_V` ZyZ' Mm gXoe KoD Z Om~mbH UZ, Cnm`j, {ddoH mZX H|, H `mHw _mar

    dmmV

    Ogm Vwhr {dMma H amb, VgoM Vwhr ~Zmb. Vwhr dV:bm X~b g_Omb Va X~b ~Zmb. CbQ> Oa Vwhr dV:bme sembr g_Omb Va Vwhr e sembr hmb.

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    14/52

    14 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

    `m_wio AmnU g_mOmH Sy>Z OodT>o {_idbo Amho`mnojm A{YH naV H am`bm hdo. AmnU H|mWZoV hUVmo, "OrdZo `mdXmXmZ , `mV XmZVVmo{YH _&' g_mOnr BdamZo _bm {Xbo Amho ,`mbm naV H am`Mo Amho, hm ^md hdm. AemH mao{dMma H aVmZm `m JmoQ>rMm {dMma hmdm H s, _rhrBdamMmM Ae Amho- "d` gwnwm A_V` ZyZ&'

    Amn`mbm g\ bVm, gmWH Vogh gm_`mMrhrJaO Amho. Omon`V Amn`m X`mV "`mJ dgodo'Mm ^md OmJV hmoV Zmhr Vmon`V Amnbo OrdZgmWH hmoD eH V Zmhr. H m`H `m`m _ZmV `mJAm{U godoMm AmXe Agm`bmM hdm. `mMdoiog`m`m AmMaUmZo g_mOmV `mJ d godoMm ^mdOmJV hmoBb. `mJ d godm hUOoM _mZdVm hmo .Xg`m{df`r MmJbo {dMma H a`mZo Amn`mVrbXJwU Xa hmoVmV. dm_r {ddoH mZXmZr hQ>bo Amho,

    `mJ d godm hoM Amnbo amQ>r` AmXe AmhoV.Amn`mbm `m AmXemZwnM OJm`Mo Amho. OohmgnyU Xoedm{g`m`m _ZmV `mJ d godoMm ^mdOmJV hmoBb VohmM ^maV OJXJw ~Zob.

    AmnU nmhVmo H s, Am`EgAm`EgMo bmoHHy anUo{ZXm}f bmoH mMo IyZ H Z aV dmhdV AmhoV.

    `m XheVdmm_`o H mhr X` Zmhr. `m`mVH moUVrhr OrdZ_y`o ZmhrV. H m`, hr XheVdmXrgKQ>Zm OJmMoH `mU H eHo b? MwHw Zhr Zmhr.Oa OJmbm H moUVm Xoe emVrMm gXoe XoD eH VAgob Va Vmo Amnbm ^maV XoeM Amho. ^maVmMmgXoe Amho - `moJ. `moJ gdmZm OmoS>Vmo. dm_r{ddoH mZXmZr 25, 26, 27 {S>g|~a 1892 amoOr oWoamQ>m{df`r `mZ Ho bohmoVo. Vohm `mZr ^maVm`mAdZVrMr H maUo emoYbr Am{U `mZm g_OboH s, Am`mp_H eVr`m JQ>ZmVyZM ^maVOmJV hmoBb. `mZr Xoe^a ^_Vr H aV "gKQ>Z'Mm gXoe {Xbm. amQ>qMVZmZVa gKQ>Z{df`HoaUm XoUm`m dm_rOtZr _Zw` {Z_mU Am{UAm`mp_H OmJaUm`m gXoemda a {Xbm. maVmZoOJmbm gXoe {Xbm ""gdo ^dVwgw{IZ:''. Amhr_Zw`m`m aJ, n, doe^yfm mH S>o nmhV Zmhr. Amhr

    _Zw`mVrb Bdadmbm nmhVmo. H `mHw_marhZOmVmZm Amhr EH gH mam_H _ KoD Z OmD- "d` gwnwm A_V` ZyZ&' _r `oH H m`mVg\ b hmoD eH Vmo H maU _r BdamMm AeAmho. Amn`mV {d_mZ eVrMm dmna H am.Zmhr hUy ZH m.

    hmoVm. VgoM g\ bVm gogmWH Vm, {edgwXa Zdg_mO{dd h_ JT>|, _Z, dmMm, H _ go gXd EH n hmo,ZdJmad B{Vhmg aM| A~ AnZr hr ~mar h`mda ~r.

    {Zdo{XVm, H|mMo ga{MQ>Urg ^mZwXmg YmH g, {e{~a_wI gm{_ nwOmar `mMo ~m{H Pmbo.

    H| mMo gWmnH EH ZmW amZSo> `m`mO_eVr{Z{_m H|mZo `wdm H me` {dH mgmMmH m`H_ AmIbm hmoVm. `mAVJV H Wm{ebm_maH mMr `mdarb nrnrQ>r,^maVr` gH Vr narjm AmXrCnH _mVyZ H|m`m AZoH {dY godH m`mV ghm _{hZoH m`aV VU - VUtMr `m {e{~amgmR>r {ZdS> Hobr

    hmoVr. O_eVr ndmMm g{_Ym H m`H_mZo `mnyduMg_mamon Pmbm Agbm Var `m {e{~amZo `mMm I`mAWmZo g_mamon Pmbm. {e{~amVrb {Vg`m {Xder

    EH ZmWOt`m g_mYrWmZr g_nUmMo Am`moOZH a`mV Ambo hmoVo. godmH m`mZo am>r` ^mdZm dgmH {VH ~Y K> H aUm`m `m H _ mo`m`mg_mYrWimda ZV_VH hmooVmZm gh^mJr ~Yy, ^{JZr_Zmo_Zr `m {e{~amMo JrV JwUJwUV hmoVo,

    godm h`kHw S> g{_Ym g_ h_ Obo&`o _hmgmJa _| g[aVn h_ {_bo&bmoH moJjo_ hr am> A^`JmZ h&godmaV `{ `{ am> H m hr mU h& ***

    dmmV

    OwZm Y_hUVmo `mMm Bamda {dmg Zmhr Vmo ZmpVH . ZdrZ Y_ hUVmo , `mMm dV:da {dmg Zmhr VmoZmpVH hmo .

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    15/52

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 15

    123 dfmnydu VrZ {Xdg, VrZamr `mZ H Z dm_r {ddoH mZXmZr^maVm`m CWmZm{df`r JhZ qMVZHobo. Xoedm{g`m{df`r AJmY Amp_`Vm~miJUm`m dm_rOtZr Xoemg_moa`mJ d godoMm _hmZ AmXe R>odbm.H moUVohr godmH m` Agmo `m_mJo XmoZ

    H ma`m oaUm H m` H aV AgVmV: 1) Amp_`Vm Am{U 2) gOJVm :Amp_`Vm Aer H s hm _mPm Xoe Amho, hm _mPmg_mO Amho Am{U `m`m C`ZmV _mPohr `moJXmZAgm`bm hdo. hm g_mO _mPmM AJ Amho. OohmAJR>m XIy bmJVmo Vohm AmnU AJR>mbm H mnyZ\oH V Zmhr Va Vo XIUo H _r H a`mMm `Z H aVmo.AJR>mM XIU _mP XIUAmho . g_mOmMo X:I _mPoX:I Amho, hm md hUOo Amp_`Vm hmo . A{bH So>M

    MoB_Yrb Amnmrdoir EH m `wdH mZo 300 OUmMmOrd dmMdbm. EH m XY{dHsMm `dgm` H aUm`m_{hboZo nwam_wio wHo ZoH moU`mhr ~mimbm mg hmoD Z`oAm{U `m_wio H moU`mhr ~mimMm Ord OmD Z`ohUyZVemVhr KamoKar XY nmohmoMdbo. hr gdoXZerbVmMAmp_`Vm Amho. AemH maoM Amn`mbm g_mOm`mdVwpWVr{df`r gOJ amhm`bm hdo. g_mOmVrbJar~, d{MVmMr H miOr KoUo, `m`m CWmZmgmR>r

    `Z H aUo, ho Amn`m gOJVoMo bjU Amho.gOJVoV AmUIr EH _hdnyU Am`m_ Amho {dn(^{_V/ ^aH Q>bo`mZm) bmoH mZm `mo` _mJ XmIdUo.

    godoMo VrZ H ma gm{JVboAmhoV. _hm^maVmVhr`mMm CoI Amho.

    1) A, d, {Zdmam `m mW{_H JaOmMr nyVVm

    H aUo. 2) _Zw`mbm Am_{Z^a ~ZdUo.3) Am_~moYm`m kmZmmao _Zw`m`mAmp_`VoMm narK {dVmaUo.

    AWmV g_mOmVr ` s`mgdoXZerbVobm dmT>dUo. _mZZr`EH ZmWOtZr `m VrZ godm`m nwT>rb{dMma H aV Amn`mnwT>o Mm`m

    H ma`m godoMm AmXe R>odbm. Aemg_mOmMr {Z{_Vr OoWo Amp_`Vm VgoMgOJVo_wio gdm`m AmH mjmMr nyVVm hmoBb Am{UgodoMr Amd`H VmM amhUma Zmhr. Aem AmXeg_mOmMr aMZm H aUo hoM {ddoH mZX H| mMo H m` Amho. AmO godoMr gH nZmM ~Xbbr Amho. bmoHAZmWmb`, dml_ C^ma`m`m H m`mbmM godm hUybmJbo AmhoV. H| m`m godoMr gH nZm hrM AmhoH s, Aem g_mOmMr aMZm H aUo OoWo AZmWmb` AWdm

    dml_mMr Amd`H VmM amhUma Zmhr. Vmn` hoMH s oH KamV `o>mMm g_mZ hmdm Am{U H moUmdaAZmW hmo`mMr doi `oUma Zmhr. Amn`mg_moaJmodm_r VwbgrXmg `m`m OrdZmVrb CXmhaU Amho.`mMm O_ EH m {R>H mUr Pmbm Va `mMo nmbZnmofU,{ejU Xg`m {R>H mUr Pmbo. g_mOmZoM `m`mnmbZnmofU d {ejUmMo Xm{`d KoVbohmoVo . Aghm`,d{MVm`m CWmZmbm Amnbo Xm{`d _mZUmam g_mO

    Amn`mbm KS>dm`Mm Amho. Agm g_mO Omo Amn`mgm_m{OH H V`m{df`r AmV Agob. {ddoH mZXH|m`m _yb^yV godoMm AmXehmM Amho .

    AmnU nmhVmo H s Am`EgAm`EgMo XheVdmXrAmnbo OrdZ XheVdmXr H `mgmR>r PmoHy Z XoVmV.Bbm_r _VmYm[aV {dm`m n[aH nZo`m dZmgmR>r

    {edgwXa Zdg_mO {dd Amhr KS>dy~r. {Zdo{XVm,Cnm`j, {ddoH mZX H| , H `mHw _mar

    dmmV

    {dmg hUOo dmWu, gHw {MV {dmg Zho. H maU doXmV hUOo Amho EH m_VoMo Vd.

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    16/52

    16 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

    XheVdmXr qhgH H `o H aVmV. pVr {_eZ`mZmhrdmQ>Vo H s, \ ~m`~bM `mo` Amho. H `w{ZQ>Jar~mVr H {WV ghmZw yVr Am{U lr_Vm{df`r da^md

    ~miJVmV. H `w{ZQ>mMm AmXe _mAmoMr nwVHo AmVm MrZ_`o Zm_eof Pmbr AmhoV. Vr ar ~ZbrAmhoV. Oohm EImXm dmMH nwVH IaoXr H am`bmOmVmoVohm MrZ_Yrb nwVH {dHoVo gmJVmV, _mAmodmMm`Mm Agob Va ar`m XH mZmV AWdm OoWo OwZrnwVHo {_iVmV Vo Wo Om. Ago H m? H maU _mAmoMr{dMmaYmam _mZUm`m bmoH mZr MrZ, a{e`m_ o H {WVg_mZVo`m ZmdmImbr H moQ>dYr bmoH mMr h`m

    Hobr. H `{ZQ>m`m OrdZmMm AmYma ^m{VH VmAmho. H `w{ZQ>mZr _mZdr _Zm`m dmV`mMo hZZHobo. XgarH So> YZdmZmMm AmYma Ho di ngo H _mdUoAmho. VmoH moU`mhr _mJmZo `odmo, \ Am{U \ `mZm YZ hdo. `m_wioho {dMma {Q>Hy eH bo ZmhrV.`mMr drH mamo s gnV Jobr. `mgmR>r Amn`mbm hrJmo> g_OyZ `mdr bmJob H s OoWoA{VdmX Amho VoWoAmXe Zmhr. Vw_Mo H m` g_mO VmoS>UmaoZgmdo . maVr`g_mOmZo H Yrhr hQ>boZmhr H s, _mPmM ^JdmZ lo>Amho. CbQ> gdm`m lmWmZm{df`r lXm ~miJbr.

    AZoH AmH _Um`m ZVahr Amnbo am> A{dMbAmho. H maU Amnbm gmH {VH nm`m n m Amho.Amn`mbm Ho di `mV H mbmZwn ~Xb H aV {edgwXaZdg_mO KS>dm`Mo Amho. {ed Omo gXd H `mUH mar,_JbH mar Amho. Am{U gwXa hUOoM g_embr,Am_{Z^a.

    B{VhmgmV Amn`m am>mMm CoI IynM Jmadembr

    Amho. H nZmVrV YZ Am{U Zg{JH gnmrZo gnam> Aer Amnbr `mVr am{hbr Amho. Oohm 1823_`o BJOmZr ^maVmMm ej{UH gd} Ho bm Vohm^maVmVrb 72 Q>o OZVm {e{jV Ag`mMo AmT>ibo.BJOmZr emofUm`m Zr{Vmao ^maVmMr _moR>r Am{WHbyQ> Hobr. `mZVa ^maVmV ej{UH nVZ gw Pmbo

    Am{U {ejU jomV AmnU 72 Q>`mdZ 17Q>`mn`V Kgabmo. Amn`mbm bjmV R>odm`bm hdoH s amHoQ> (jonUm), gemo YZ Am{U bmpQ>H

    gOar Am{U e`{M{H gm hr ^maVmMr XoUJr Amho.Jwbm_r`m H mimVhr AmnU Amnbr Ap_Vm,Amnbo dm{^_mZ hadbo Zmhr. `m XoemV em`mMrH moUVrhr H _VaVm Zmhr. 26/11 `m h`mVVwH mam_ Am|~mio `mZr draVmnydH XheVdmXr AO_bH gm~ `mbm nH S>bo hmoVo. {Z:e AgyZhr Amn`mearamda 54 Jmo`m PobyZ VwH mam_ `mZr `mbmnH S>bo, ho `m`m em Am{U Xoe^VrMo VrH

    Amho. VwH mam_ `m`m n[admambm `mMm Jd Amho.`mMr _wbJr hUVo, {V`m d{S>bmZr H V`^mdZoZo~{bXmZ {Xbo. Amn`mbm AmO H mbmZwn MmbUmam,g_`mZwHw b {edgwXa Zdg_mO KS>dm`Mm Amho. `mZdg_mOm`m gH nZobm AmnUmg g_OyZ `mdobmJob. Oohm X{bVmZm `m` {_idyZ m`Mo hmoVoVohm S>m. ~m~mgmho~ Am~oS>H a `mZr nwT>mH ma KoVbm.`mZr `mZm `m` {_idyZ Xo`mgmR>r gKf Hobm.gKfmMm _mJ {ZdS>Uo `mH mir Amd`H hmoVo. naVwAmVm gKfmMm _mJ C{MV Amho H m, `mda {dMmahm`bm hdm. AmO ~m~mgmho~m`m ZmdmImbrg_mOmV gKfmMo dmVmdaU {Z_mU Ho bo OmVo. naVwAmVm gKfmMr Zho, gmhmmMr Amd`H Vm Amho, hogdmZr g_OyZ `m`bm hdo.

    _wKbmZr maVmda AmH_U Ho bo Vohm `mZr nm{hboH s, ^maVmV _y{VH bm d Wmn`H bm Ma_moH fmdaAmho. hboImoamZr OZgm_m`mda ZmZm{dY A`mMma

    Hobo . naVw H bm{dXmMm Ord KoVbm Zmhr. H bm{dXmZmHX H Z hboImoamZr Amn`m XoemV Am{U ^maVmV_{eXr ~Zd`m, `m`mH Sy>Z H bm {eH br. maVmbmZQ> H a`mg Ambobo hboImoahr `oWyZ {eHyZ OmVmV,Agm JwUgnZ Xoe Amnbm am{hbm Amho. B{VhmgmV^maV Ogm Jmadembr d d dembr hmoVm Vgm `mbm

    dmmV

    oH Am`m`m {R>H mUr Xodd gwnUo dmg H aV Amho.

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    17/52

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 17

    Jmadembr d d dgnZ ~ZdUo`m gH nZobm amQ>nwZWmZ hUVmV. Amnbr godm {Zo` Zmhr.{ddH `mUmgmR>r ^maVmMo CWmZ ho Am_Mo b`

    Amho. naVw AmM`mMr JmoQ> Amho H s, AmOH mb_y` KoD Zhr C{MV godm Ho br OmV Zmhr. gaH ma doVZXoVo, H _Mmar `mbm AZwn godm XoV ZmhrV.

    dmgmXa`mZ, AZoH bmoH {dMmaVmV H s, AmnUH m` H aVm?

    _r hUVo, "_r {ddoH mZX H|mM H m_ H aVo.'hUOo H m` H aVm?_r hUVo, "godH m`'

    nwhm Vo {dMmaVmV, H| mMo {H Vr AZmWml_ VgoMdml_ AmhoV?_r hUVo, EH hr Zmhr.Vo hUVmV, _J godm H gbr?_r hUVo, Amhr Aem g_mOm`m aMZo`m

    godmH m`mV AmhmoV OoWoAZmWml_mMr Amd`H VmM^mgUma Zmhr.

    Amhmbm godo`m `m ^m_H g_OwVrbm ~Xbm`bmhdo Am{U {Z:dmWgodo`m gH nZobm g_mOOrdZmV{VpR>V H amdo bmJob. Amhmbm H moUmmao godoMo

    _mUn ZH mo Amho. H|m`m godoMr H nZm CXmmAmho. ho `mo` Amho H s nya, ^yHn Aem Zg{JHAmnmrdoir Amp_`VoZo gnyU Xoe gh`moJmgmR>r nwT>o`oVmo. Aem H R>rU gJr {ZpMVM Agohm`bm hdo,naVw Amp_`Vm Ho di H R>rU H mimVM JQ> hmoDZ`o. g_mOm{df`r Amp_`Vm hr gXd Agm`bm hdr.godm hr `moOZm~ Agm`bm hdr. KamV Q>weZ KoD Z_wbmZm {eH dUo hr `pVJV godoMo CXmhaU Amho.

    naVw AmnU gK{Q>V hmoD Z gH ma dJ, AmZXmb`,dm`m` dJ, moJ dJm`m _m`_mVyZ gm_yXm{`H ar`mgodm H . EImXo - XgaoZho , gK{Q>Var`m AZoH mMrgodm H aUo Amnbm _mJ Amho . Amhr Amnbrj_Vm dmT>dy, Amnbm d^md AmXeAgmdm. {edgwXaZdg_mO AmnU C^o H . ***

    _r H moU Amho? _m`m `m OrdZmV_mPr H m` ^y{_H m Amho Am{U `mdoir_r H m` H aV Amho? `mda Amn`mbm{dMma H amdm bmJob. AmnU gdgodmaV H m`H `m`m ^y{_Ho V AmhmoV.

    Ogo `m {e{~amMr Wr_ Amho, ""godmaV`pV `pV amQ> H m hr mU h&''AmnU {dmWu AmhmoV AWdm {ejH ,`mdgm{`H AmhmoV VgoM H _Mmar, naVw AmnUho g_OyZ `mdo H s godmaV `Vr`m nmV _r^maVmMm mU Amho. H m` {OVHo _hmZ Amho {VVHo M

    Amn`mbmhr _hmZ ~Zmdo bmJob. _hmZH m`mgmR>r CXmm M[amMr Amd`H VmAgVo. hoVohmM e` Amho Oohm AmnUXohm_ ~moYmnmgyZ Xoem_ ~moYmH S>oC_wIhmoD . amQ>mMm mU hmo`mgmR>r Amd`H

    JwU A{OV H amdo bmJVrb. hm JwU Amho_Z, dMZ, H _ `mV EH dm`Vm Agy Xo.

    dm_r {ddoH mZXmZr Amnbo JwR>mHw a lr am_HU na_hg `mZm Amn`mgmR>r{Z{dH n g_mYrMo AmerdmX _m{JVbo hmoVo. naVw_mVo`m H m`mgmR>r, ^maVmbm OmU`mgmR>r `mZr

    _Z, dmMm, H _ gXd EH Agy Xo^mZwXmg YmH g, _hmg{Md, {ddoH mZX H|, H `mHw _mar

    dmmV

    AmV[aH d ~m HVrda {dO` {_idyZ Vo gw Xodd JQ> H aUo ho M OrdZmMo o ` hmo .

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    18/52

    18 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

    AmnboKa - Hw Qw>~ VgoM Jw ~YyZm gmoSy>Z Xa OmD Zn[admOH AdWoV Xoe^a ^_Vr Ho br. nmMm`{dmZm`m_`o ^maVmbm {VpR>V H a`mgmR>r

    dm_rOr EH Q>oM {ZKmbo. gd AS>MUtZm gmogV,gd AmhmZmda _mV H aV `mZr OmJ{VH nQ>bmda^maVmMr {VR>m {Z_mU Hobr. dm_rOtMr {Z{dH ng_mYrMr Amg Xohm_ ~moYmZo o[aV hmoVr, naVw_mVoMo H m` H a`mMm gH n Xoem_ ~moY Amho.dm_r {ddoH mZXmZr EH m nmV`m Xmohr _Z:pWVrMo dUZHobo Amho . Xohm_ ~moYmnmgyZ

    Xooem_ ~mmoYmMm _mJ H moUVmAmho? Vmo _mJ Amho - _Z,dmMm, H _gXd EH Agy m.Ago hmoBb Vohm Xoem_ ~moYJQ> hmoBb, naVw hogmono Zmhr.

    _Z, dmMm, H _mgX^mVam_m`UmV XmoZ _hdnyUgJmMm CboI Amho. 1.EH Xm _hfu {ddm{_ amOm

    XeaWmbm ^oQ>m`bm Jobo._hfv`m XeZmZoVV XeaWmZohQ>bo, ""_hfu AmO AmnU Oo_mJmb Vo _r lmnydH AmnUmgXmZ XoBZ.'' Vohm XeaWmZo _ZmnmgyZ dMZ {Xbo hmoVo. naVw Oohm _hfu {ddm{_mZohQ>boH s, ""XS>H ma`mV amjgmMr XheV dmT>br AmhoAm{U k gH Vr Ymo`mV Amho. m {df_ n[apWVrV

    F fr Am{U `k gH Vr`m ajUmgmR>r Amnbr XmoZ_wbo am_ d b_UmMr Amd`H Vm Amho. AmnU H mhrH mimgmR>r `m Xmohr _wbmZm _m`mH S>o gmondm.''_hfv`m `m AmJhmbm Xmohr _wbo AOwZ bhmZAg`mMo H maU gmJV `mZr Q>mi`mMm `Z Hobm.ho amjgmMm gm_Zm H eH V ZmhrV. AmnU hdo Va

    _mPr gnyUgoZm KoD Z Om, _bmhr KoD Z Mbm. naVw_m`m _wbmZm BWoM amhm. _Z d dMZmZo gH nHoboboamOm XeaW nw_mohm_wio Amnbo H V` {dgZ

    OmVmV. `mMo H _ ~XbVo. Vohm `mZm bjmV AmUyZmdobmJVo H s, aKwHw b ar{V gXm Mbr AmB , mU OmEna dMZ Z OmB& XeaWmZo _ZmZo hQ>bo hmoVo , dMZmZohQ>bo hmoVo H s Oo _mJmb Vo XoBZ. naVw Oohm H VrH a`mMr doi Ambr Vohm Vo _mJo hQ>bo. Amnbohr

    AgoM hmoV Agmdo.Xgam gJ lram_m`m

    dZdmgmMm Amho. H Ho r amJmV

    hmoVr Vohm XeaWmZohQ>bo H s,AmnU Oo hUmb Vo _r H aoZ.naVw am_m`m 14 dfm`mdZdmgmMr JmoQ> EoH VmMXeaW Imbr H mogibo.Oohm am_ `m`mgmR>r N>,Mm_a AmXr Ambo hmoVoVo gdZmH mZ dZdmgmbm Om`mMrV`mar H aVmV. _Z, dmMm

    VgoM H _mZo gXd EH nhmo`mMm _hmZ AmXe AmhoV- _`mXm nwfmom_ lram_._ZM gdH mhr H aVo. _Zm`m_XVrZoM AmnU nwT>o OmD

    eH Vo. _Z Amn`mbm nwT>o KoD Z OmD eH VmoAm{UVoM Amn`mbm Imbrhr nmSy> eH Vo. `mgmR>r _ZmbmgmYmdo bmJob, H maU _Z `mo` {XeoZo J{V_mZ hmoBb.

    `mV dmUrdarb g`_ _hdmMoAmho. `mgmR>r dmUrMoVn OarMo Amho.grVm emoY Am{U bH m XhZmZVa Oohm _hmdra

    hZw_mZ naVboVohm Vo {dMma H bmJboH s lram_mZm _mVm OmZH sMm gXoe H moU`m eXmV m`bmhdm. bH mXhZmMm gJ AmYr gmJy H s grVm_mVo`m

    H m` {OVHo _hmZ Amho{VVHo M Amn`mbmhr

    _hmZ ~Zmdo bmJob. _hmZH m`mgmR>r CXmm M[amMrAmd`H Vm AgVo. ho VohmM

    g d Amho Oohm AmnUXohm_ ~moYmnmgyZ Xoem_~moYmH S>o C_wI hmoD .amQ>mMm mU hmo`mgmR>rAmnUmg Amd`H JwU

    A{OV H amdo bmJVrb. hmJwU Amho_Z, dMZ, H _mZogXd EH n hmoUo.

    dmmV

    Xg`mg _XV H aUo, OJmMo ^boH aUo ho M Amnbo H V` hmo .

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    19/52

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 19

    Agr_ Y mMo dUZ? naVw "~w{_Vm d[aR>' Aem_hmdramZo dmUrMm g`_ VgoM VnmMm _hmZ AmXeKmbyZ {Xbm. hZw_mZmZo lram_mZm hQ>bo, ""Q>dm -

    Xo{I', hUOo_r grVm_mVoMm XeZ KoVbmo. hZw_mZm`mVm|Sy>Z {ZKmbo`m m n{h`m dm`mZoM lram_mMr {dahdoXZm g_mV Pmbr, `m`m AV:H aUmV _mOboboAmXmobZhr gnbo.

    AmUIr EH CXmhaU Amho. dm_r {ddoH mZXAmn`m OrdZm`m eodQ>`m {XdgmV ^{JZr {Zdo{XVm`m`m ^moOZmZVa dV: nmUr KmbV `mZm hmVYwdm`bm bmdbo hmoVo . Vohm ^{JZr {Zdo{XVm `mZr

    dm_rOtZm amoI`mMm `Z Ho bm. naVw dm_r{ddoH mZXmZr Ago Va Bgm _grhmZohr Ho bohmooVo, AgogmJV ^{JZr {Zdo{XVm `mZm hmV Yw`mgmR>r nmUrKmVbo. ^{JZr {Zdo{XVm EH X_ VY am{h`m. `mZmAmR>dbo H s, `m {Xder BgmZo^VmZm hmV Ywdm`bmbmdbo hmoVo Vmo `mMm eodQ>Mm {Xdg hmoVm. naVw^{JZr {Zdo{XVm `mZr Amn`m dmUrda g _ amIVAmn`m _ZmVrb JmoQ> ~mhoa `oD {Xbr Zmhr. `mZrAmn`m _Zmo mdmbm _ZmV YmaU Hobo, naVw Vo A`

    Jw ~Yy`m nwT>o `V Ho boZmhr. ho dmUr`m g _mMo _moR>o CXmhaU Amho.

    dmUrMr VnM`m VgoM g`_mZoM H m`nwT>oOmBb.

    H _ kmZ|{`o d H _]{`mVyZ `V hmoVo. _ZmV CXmm^md AmhoV. Vo dMZmVyZ `Vhr hmoVmV, naVwVo H VrVJQ> hmoV ZmhrV Va hr IynM qMVmOZH ~m~ Amho.

    Ago Pm`mg AmV doJio Am{U ~mhoa doJio AerJmoQ> amhrb. moUmMm`mZr Amn`m {e`mZm EH Xm"g`dX' nmR> AmR>d`mg gm{JVbo. Xg`mM {Xder`w{YpR>ambm gmoSy>Z gd {e`mZr gm{JVboH s, "g`dX' AmR>dbo. H mhr {XdgmZVa `w{YpR>amZo gm{JVboH s, AmVm _bm AmR>dbo. Oohm `mZm {dMmaboJobo H s "g` dX' Mm nmR> AmR>dm Ago gm{JV`mZVaVwbm VoAmR>dm`bm BVHo {Xdg H go bmJbo? Vohm

    Y_amO `w{YpR>amZo hQ>bo, ""_m`m _ZmVrb {dMmaOmon`V _m`m HVrV Ambo ZmhrV Vmon`V _r "g` dX' OmUbmoho _r H go hUy eH Vmo.'' AmVm Oohm_m`m _ZmMo {dMma _m`m H VrV JQ> hmoV AmhoVVohmM _r "g`dX' AmR>dbo, ho _r gmJV Amho .

    EH _{hbm Amn`m bhmZ _wbm`m Jyi Im`m`mgd`r_wiodVmJbr hmoVr. `mZr R>mHwa lram_H UmZmhQ>boH s, AmnU `m _wbmbm Jyi Z Im`mMm gbmm. Vmo Amn`m gmJ`mdZ Jyi ImUo gmoSy>Z XoBb.

    15 {Xdg amoO _{hbm R>mHwamOdi `oD Z ho gmJVhmoVr, naVw R>mHw amZr `m _wbmbm Jyi Im`mnmgyZamoIbo Zmhr. R>mHw a am_H U na_hg Oohm dV: Jyi

    dmmV

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    20/52

    20 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

    Im`mMr gd` gmoS>boVohm `mZr `m _wbmbm A{YHJyi ImD Z`o, Agogm{JVbo.

    _Z, dmMm, H _mZo OrdZmV gm`VVm `oVo. Oa

    AmnU Amnbo OrdZ ~Xbm`bm V`ma AmhmoV VaAmn`mVrb wQ>r gwYmam`m bmJVrb, Amn`m dmBQ>gd`tZm gmoS>mdo bmJob. wQ>r XmIdUm`m qZXH m`mgyMZmMm {dMma H Z Amn`mV gwYmaUm H am`bmhdr. Oohm _mZZr` EH ZmWOtZm BVamH Sy>Z H iboH s `m`m d^mdmV H R>moaVm Amho. VoamJrQ> AmhoVVohm `mZr Amn`m d^mdmbm _X ~Zd`mgmR>r^anya `Z Ho bo. Vo `mV edr R>abo. EH ZmWOt`m

    gmpZ`mV am{hbobo H m`H Vo `m`m _mVX`mern[a{MV AmhoV. AmnU Amn`m dmUrda {Z`U R>odm.^JdXJrVm _Zmbm gmY`mMo Cnm` gmJVo. JrVo`mAZwgma AmnU A`mg VgoM dam`mZo _Zmbm gmYyeH Vmo.

    dm_r {ddoH mZXmZr Amn`mbm dXoe _ {Xbm,`mV `mZr hQ>bo, "" ho ^maV ! ho {dg ZH moH s, Vw`m p`mMoAmXe - grVm, gm{dr, X_`VrAmhoV. {dg ZH mo H s, VwPo Cnm` - gd`mJr

    C_mZmW eH a AmhoV. {dg ZH moH s, VwPm {ddmh,VwPr YZ - gnmr, VwPo OrdZ Ho di B{` -gwImgmR>r, Amn`m `pVJV gwImgmR>r Zmhr. {dgZH mo H s, Vy O_V:M _mVogmR>r ~ir hUyZ R>odbmJobobm Amhog. {dg ZH moH s, VwPm g_mO `m {damQ>_hm_m`oMr N>m`m Amho. {dg ZH moH s, ZrM, AkmZr,X[a, AS>mUr, Mm ma, _ohVa ho gd VwPo aV_mgAmhoV, VwPo~ Yy AmhoV.

    ho dra ! gmhgmMm Aml` Ko, {Z^uH ~Z VgoMJdmZo ~mob H s _r ^maVdmgr Amho. VgoM `oH^maVdmgr _mPm ~YyAmho . VyJdmZo hU H s, AkmZr

    ^maVdmgr, X[a VgoM nr{S>V ^maVdmgr, ~mU^maVdmgr, MmS>mb ^maVdmgr _mPo ~Yy AmhoV.Vyhr EH m \ S>`mZoAmn`m earamMr bOm PmHy Z

    Ko VgoM JdnydH CM damV CXKmof H a, `oH^maVdmgr _mPm ^mD Amho, ^maVdmgr _mPo mUAmhoV. ^maVm`m gd XodrXodVm _mPo Bda AmhoV.^maVmMm g_mO hm _m`m ~mbnUrMm qhXmoim,Vm`mMo ZXZdZ, dmnH mimVrb H mer Amho.

    _m`m ~Yy ! hU H s, ^maVmMr _mVr _mPm dJAmho. ^maVm`m H `mUmVM _mPo H `mU Amho.VgoM am{Xdg On H a H s, ho JmarZmW! ho OJX~o!

    _bm _Zw` ~Zd. _mPr X~bVm Xa H a. _mPm `mS>nUmXa H a. VgoM ho _mVo, _bm _Zw` ~Zd.dm_rOt`m `m dXoe _mZwn _mPo OrdZ Amho?

    Amn`mbm hohr `mZmV R>odmdo bmJob H s _m`m`o`mZwn _mPo {_ AmhoV H m? _m`m `o mZwn_r JrV JwUJwUVmoH m? EH ZmWOtZr hQ>boM AmhoH s, AmnU g_mOmbm XmoZ S>mo`mZr nmhVmo, g_mOAmn`mbm hOmamo S>mo`mZr nmhVo. EH ZmWOtZm`mMoEH {_ dfmV EH Xm HwS>Vm m`Mo Am{U Vo Vo

    n[aYmZ H am`Mo. Oohm bmoH hUm`bm bmJbo H s,EH ZmWOr {gH Hw S>Vmdmbo AmhoV Va `mZr {gHHwS>Vm n[aYmZ H aUo gmoSy>Z {Xbo. hU`mMo Vmn`hoM H s, H moUr Amn`m HVr AWdm H nS>m{df`r~moQ> CMbyZ`o, `mMr AmnU H miOr `mdr. AmnUH| mWZoV JmVmo, ""^mo ! Xo{h Xoho ~b Y`_V:&''~bmOZ H aVmZmM AmnU CXmm {dMmamMm A{JH maH Z Y mZo Amn`m AmXem`m AZwn OJmdo. Vohm

    Am`mp_H eVtMo EH rH aU hmoBb Am{U amQ>nwZWmZmMo H m`{ZaVa nwT>o OmBb.gH bZ : bIoda Mder, ZmJnya

    dmmV

    Omo _Zw` H moU`mhr _mo~X`mMr Anojm Z R>odVm AJXr {Zanoj ^mdmZo H m_ H aVmoVmo M nyU`edr _mUyg hmo `.

    20 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    21/52

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 21

    ma `m Cn{ZfXmMo VrZ A`m` AgyZ, `oH A`m`mMo XmoZ IS>

    AmhoV. `m boImV W_ A`m`mMo{ddoMZ Amho.

    gd Xodm_`o W_ ~m Cn Pmbm. Vmo gnyU{dmMm H VmAmho. hUOo `m`mnmgyZM gd XodVm, _hfu Am{U OmnVrCn Pmbo. `mZoAmnbm `o> nw AWdbm gd {dmMm AmYmaAgbobr ~{dm gm{JVbr. hr ~{dm AWdmZo AJrambm, AJramZo^amO Jmomon g`dhbm Vr gm{JVbr; Am{U ZVa g`dhmZo VrAJragmbm gm{JVbr. `m ~{doMo "nam' Am{U "Anam' Ago XmoZ^mJ AmhoV.

    emZH ZmdmMo EH _hfu hmoVo. Vo EH H mao EH m {demb {dmnrR>mMo

    HwbJw M hmoVo . nwamUm_`o Ago gm{JVboAmho H s, `m`m JwHwbmV88 hOma {dmWu hmoVo. `m _wS>H Cn{ZfXmV emZH mbm "_hmemb'Ago {deofU bmdbobo Amho . "_hmemb' hUOo _moR>m JwHw bmMmA{Y>mVm. VmoemZH {d{YnydH AJragmH So> Ambm Am{U `mZm Hobm H s, "H m` OmUbo AgVm, gd H mhr OmUbo OmVo ?'- ho _bmAmnU g_OmdyZ gmJm.

    AmoiI Cn{ZfXmMr

    _wS>H mon{ZfX

    _m. Jmo. dZmJnya.09881717809

    _wS>H mon{ZfX AWddoXmerg~{YV Amho. _wS>Z H aUo`m AWmZo`oWo "_wS>Z' eX

    Ambobm Amho. nU S>mo`mMo_wS>Z Zmhr. _ZmMo _wS>Z._ZmMo {dH ma Zmhrgo H ZA{donmgyZ _Zmbm _w

    H aUmao ho "_wS>Z' Amho. `mCn{ZfXmV g`mg Y_mMr_hVr gm{JVbobr Amho.`k`mJmXr H _H mS>mMm `mVn> {ZfoY Ho bm Amho.

    oH Ordmg, ZaZmarg BanmV nmhm.

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 21

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    22/52

    22 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

    Anam {dm`mMm EoH `mda AJrag F fr hUmbo, XmoZ

    {dmMokmZ Agbo nm{hOo , Ago ~domo gmJVmV. EHAgVo "nam' {dm Am{U Xgar AgVo "Anam' {dm.Anam {dm hUOo F doX, `Owd}X, gm_doX, AWddoX`mMo kmZ; VgoM {ejm (hUOo doX_ hU`mMm{dYr), H n (hUOo VrZ H maMo gyJW - lmVgy,Y_gy Am{U Jgy `m`m g_w`mbm "H ngy'Ago hUVmV), `mH aU, {Z (hUOo eX-Cn{mem), N>X (dmo) Am{U `mo{Vmem, `mgdmMo kmZ. Vmn` Ago H s doX Am{U doXmJmMo kmZ

    hUOo "Anam' {dm. "nam' {dm hUOo A{dZmerna_oamMo, na_m`mMokmZ.

    na~hm na_oa hUOoM na~ hmo`. Vona~ A` d

    AJm AgVo. hUOoVo Amn`m B{`m`m AmQ>mo`mV`oV Zmhr. `mbm Jmo Zmhr, aJ n Zmhr, S>moio, H mZ,

    hmV, nm` ZmhrV. Vo {Z` AgVo. gd`mnH AgVo.gd CnpWV AgVo. VoA`V gy_ AgVo. H YrhrZme Z nmdUmao AgVo. Oo Iao kmZr AgVmV, `mZm

    H iVoH s hoM gd {dmMo Cn{mWmZ Amho.`m_mUo H moir VVy Cn H aVmo Am{U nwZ: Vo

    naV KoD eH Vmo, `m_mUo n drda dZnVr CnhmoVmV, qH dm earamda ~marH ~marH Hog hUOo bdqH dm amo_ Cn hmoVmV, `m_mUo m Aja ~mnmgyZOJ {Z_mU hmoVo. lr_XAm eH amMm` `m _mdarbAmn`m ^m`mV, Ago n> H aVmV H s, `m_mUoH moir, Amn`m earamV Agbo`m VVyZm ~mhoa H mTy>Z

    Vonga{dVmo Am{U ZVa nwZ: {JiyZ Q>mH Vmo, `m_mUona_oa dV:`m {R>H mUrM gy_ nmZo Agbo`mOS>-MoVZ n OJmbm, g>r`m Ama r Cn H aVmoAm{U b`H mbr, nwZ: dV:VM brZ H Z KoVmo,qH dm ndr `m_mUoJdV, dj, dobr B`mXtZm CnH aVo, `mM_mUo na_oa OrdmZm {^ {^ `moZt_`oCn H aVmo. `m OJm`m CnmrMr doi Ambr H s,na_oa Amn`m gH n nr VnmZo m`mgmR>r ACn H aVmo. AmZVa mU, `mZVa _Z, `mZVa

    nM_hm^yVo, VgoM gd bmoH m`m H _mZw n gwI dX:IoCn H aVmo . hm na_oa gdk, Wyb d gy_OmUUmam, AgyZ Vmo kmZ_` Vn H aVmo. `mnmgyZ Zm_ nm_H g>r Am{U A {Z_mU hmoVo.

    `oWo W_ IS> g_m hmoVmo.{Vr` IS>~w{_mZ F ftZm, Oo g` Amho, Vo doXmVrb

    _m_`o {Xgbo. hUOo _m_`o Or H _} gm{JVbr

    AmhoV, Vr H _} doXm_wio gw Pmbr. `m H _mMo \ i m H a`mMr Vw_Mr BN>m Agob, Va Vr H _}Vwhr {Z` H am. hUOoVwhr A{hmo dV drH mam.doXm_`o Oohm, XodVmZm hdr nmoM{dUmam Ar XrhmoVmo, hUOo `m Ar`m dmim da CR>VmV,`mV XodVmZm CoeyZ AmhVr m`mV. A{hmo

    AmoiI Cn{ZfXmMr

    Vwhr H moUmbmhr _XV H eH V Zmhr. Vwhr \ `mMr godm H eH Vm.

    22 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    23/52

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 23

    drH mabo`mgmR>r H mhr {Z`_ AmhoV. A_mdm`m dnm{U_obm `k Hobm nm{hOo. hUOo Ar d{bVH Z `mV AmhVr Q>mH `m nm{hOoV. Omoho H arV

    Zmhr, MmVw_mgmV `k H arV Zmhr, A{VWrMm gH maH arV Zmhr, XodVmMr nyOm H arV Zmhr, `kmMm Omo{dYr {Z{V Amho, `mMo nmbZ H arV Zmhr, `m`mgmV {nT>mMm Zme hmoVmo, Ago`mV IS>m`m ma rgm{JVboboAmho .

    Ar`m gmV {O^mAr`m gmV {O^m AmhoV. `mMr Zmdo Aer

    - 1) H mbr (H m`m aJmMr), 2) H ambr (CJ),

    3) _ZmoOdm (_Zm_mUo doJdmZ qH dm MMb), 4)gwbmo{hVm (gwXa bmb aJmMr), 5) gwYy_dUm(Ywam`maJmgmaIr), 6) \wq{JZr ({R>U`m Agbobr), 7){dMr (gd ~mOyZr H me_`). Ar`m `m gmVdmim_`o, Omo`mo` doir AmhVr XoVmo, `mbm, `mdmim gy`mMr {H aUo~ZyZ BbmoH mV KoD Z OmVmV.gy`mMr {H aUo~Zbo`m `m dmim, `O_mZmbm, "`o,`o' Ago dmJV H arV dJbmoH mV nmoM{dVmV.

    naVwho bjmV `m H s, gmoim F pdO, `O_mZ

    d `mMr nZr Aem AR>am OUmZr {_iyZ Ho bobo ho `kH _ hUOoggmagmJa V Z Om`mgmR>r mo{Obo`mX~i ZmHo _mUo Amho. hUOo ggma nr gmJa V ZOm`mgmR>r Cn`w Zmhr. naVw AkmZr bmoH hoMlo`H a hUyZ `m ZmHo Mm Aml` KoVmV Am{U

    `m_wio `mZm Oam (hmVmanU) Am{U _`y dmadmam hmoV AgVmo.

    ho bmoH A{doV a__mU hmoUmao AmhoV. VodV:bm

    _moR>on{S>V g_OVmV; nU VodVwV: Am Y`mbm KoD ZOmUm`m AmY`m_mUo BVVV: ^Q>H V AgVmV.A{doV a_Umao ho bmoH dV:bm H VmW g_OVmV;nU Iao hUOo Vo Ak bmoH AmhoV. Vo Iao VdOmUrV ZmhrV. `m_wioVo X:Ir hmoD Z nVZ nmdVmV.

    ~{dogmR>rho _yI bmoH `k`mJmXr H _}, VgoM bmoH mgmR>r

    {d{har, Y_emim B`mXr bmoH mon`moJr H `oM lo>

    hmoV, Ago _mZVmV. m H`m_wio `mZm dJ {_imbm,Var nwZ: hrZ `moZrV `mdoM bmJVo. naVw Oo dmZWqH dm g`mgr gmYH Aa`mV amhZ Vn d CnmgZmH aVmV, VgoM Oo kmZr emV dmrZo {^jm _mJyZ OrdZ`mnZ H aVmV, Voew Xod mZ _mJmZo OmVmV Am{U OoWoVmo A`` nwf (na_oa) Amho, VoWo pWa hmoVmV.hUOoM `mZm ~bmoH m hmoVmo. H _mZom hmoUmaobmoH nmhZ kmZr ` s`m {R>H mUr dam` Cn hmoVo.H _mZr _moj {_iV Zmhr, ho`mbm H iVo. `m H [aVm

    I`m kmZmMr Amd`H Vm AgVo; d `mgmR>r ~{Z>km`m Jw bm, Z_nUo, eaU Omdo bmJVo. Jw ZohrAmbo`m {e`mbm, `mZo {Mmewr d dam` m Ho boAmho, honmaIyZ, ~{dm gmJmdr. m {R>H mUr n{hbmA`m` g_m hmoVmo. (H _e:)

    AmoiI Cn{ZfXmMr

    oH Ord_mmV {ed Amho. Xgam H moUVmhr Xod Zmhr. Omo OrdmMr godm H aVmo VmoM IamoIar XodmMr CnmgZm H aVmo.

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 23

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    24/52

    24 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

    JwdmhmQ>rbm OmUm`m {d_mZmMr dmQ> ~KVmZm CgwH Vm VmUbrOmV hmoVr. Amhr H mhr Egm`Q>oS> dJao hmoVmo. H mhrgogmeH hr. H maU Amgm_, AUmMb `m mVm{df`r ~`mM {H dXVrEoH bo`m. H mhrgoJyT>. AZoH H maUmZr M{MV Agbobo Am{U Iyngo

    AZmoiIr.Ago Agbo Var gd `dpWV hmoBb, `mMm {dmg Z s hmoVm.

    H|mMo OrdZdVr noe^`m Jobr XmoZ XeHo `m mVmV H m_ H aVAmhoV. `mZr H m`H _mMr AmIUr Hobr hmoVr. `m_wio qMVoMoH maUM ZhVo. eH m hmoVr Vr {VW`m gVV ~XbUm`m hdm_mZmMr.gobmnmgbm ~\d>r Va hmoUma Zmhr? AMmZH `oUm`m nmdgmVH mOraJm YyVb Job Va? gobmnmgda H moUmbm AmpgOZMr JaOnS>br Va? Am_`m g_yhmV d` df12 Vo 80Aem ` s hmo`m.

    J_V hUOo mV bhmZJm CH f Am{U _moR>m _mYdrVmBho XmoKo IynCgmhr Ag`mZoAmhr gmao D OmdmZ am{hbo.JwdmhmQ>rbm Am_`m g_yhmV _`XoemVrb CmZ `oWyZ Ambobo

    VrZ gX` gm_rb Pmbo. MM}V EH Z s Pmbo H s gobmnmg,H mOraJm, naewam_ HwS> ho Zmhr Pmbo Var Mmbob. IaoXr Zmhr O_brVar haH V Zmhr. WmoS>r Ymdni hmoBb, Vrhr Mmbob. nU {ddoH mZX

    Omhdr Ho iH ag mOrZJa9561251102

    dmmV AUmMb ^oQ>rMm

    20 \o~wdmar : AUmMb {XZ

    16 Zmoh|~a 2015.N>nVr {edOr{d_mZVi _w~B. Amhr15 OU g mOrZJa(AmaJm~mX),

    Zm{eH , nwUo `oWyZEH Ambobmo. AmYrMrAmoiI ZgVmZmhr EH m

    Zoh~YmZoOmoS>bobmo. Vmo~Y hmoVm {ddoH mZX Ho H `mHw_marMm. hm dmgHwR>`m H nZrZo ZhoVa H|H m`H `m`m_XVrZo Am{U _mJXeZmVAmIbobm hmoVm.

    VdmJ ehamMo {ZgJgmX`

    `m {dmVrb oH AUyaoUw_ o, oH Ord_mmV Vwhr dV:g nhmd`mg {eH m Am{U EH Xm H m hogm` Pmbo H s oH Jmo>rda A_`mX o_, H Um Ho `m{edm` OJyM eH Uma Zmhr, hmM Vmo`j `mdhm[aH doXmV.

    24 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    25/52

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 25

    H|mMr {dmb`o Am{U H nmZm ^oQ>r m`MoM. H maU`m dmgmMm _yi CoeM Vmo hmoVm.

    H| mMr {dmb`o hm {Ohm`mMm {df` Am{Uam>mbm A{^_mZ dmQ>mdm Ago H m` Amho, Ago_bmdmQ>Vo. AmOnmgyZ gmSo>VrZ XeH mnydu `m ^mJmVrb~mYdm`m n[apWVrMo AmH bZ Ho bo AgVm OmUdobH s, ^maVmMm hm gm m`mbH ma Xb{jbobm hmoVm.gy mMr {H aUo n{h`mXm neH aVmV Aer hr ^y_r.nU `m dZdmgr ~mYdm`m IS>Va OrdZmV ^m{VHJVr Va XaM {ejUmMr `moVhr noQ>br ZhVr. AemVY_mVaUmgmR>r {_eZar Q>nyZ ~gbobo. {ejUmnojmY_mVaUmdaM `mMm ^a. MrZhr bMHo VmoS>`mgmR>rAmgwgbobm. Aem {df_ n[apWVrV {ddoH mZX H| mMo

    gWmnH _mZZr` EH ZmWOtZr H| m`m OrdZdVtZm{ejU {X`mZVa n{h`m VwH S>rbm bJoM `mAZmoiIr mVmV H m`mgmR>r nmR>dbo. `m mVVbodoimodoir EoH bobo AZw dM Am_`m `m dmgmMroaUm hmoVr.

    W_ ~{KVboVo H| mMo {VZgw{H m oWrb {dmb`.ho{dmb` {Zdmgr Am{U Wm{ZH {dm`mgmR>r Amho.{Zdmgmbm 90 {dmWu AmhoV. ho {dmb` _wbo d _wbr

    Xmohm|gmR>r Amho. Amhr VoWohmoVmo Vmo {Xdg `moJm`moJmZo_mZZr` EH ZmWOt`m O`VrMm hmoVm. {dmb`mVAmX`m {Xder`m AIS> am_m`UmMr gmJVm hmoVr.`k, AmhVr, _mVnyOm Am{U gmX (^moOZ) AgmH m`H _ hmoVm. {dm`mMr AZwem{gV Ymdni,H m`H _mMo {Z`moOZ, gOmdQ> IynM ^mdr. {ejH mMohgV_wImZodmJV H aUo dmgmMm erU Xa H aUmam.HwR>ohr AmaS>mAmoaS>, JS>~S>, Jm|Yi Zmhr. {Zdmg d^moOZmMr `dWm {dmb` n[agamVM hmoVr. n[agaIynM _moR>m, nUdN>. Amn`m nm`mbm doe{_imdm `mgmR>r `oWrb nmbH CgwH AgVmV.

    `oWo {dmb`m{edm` bhmZ-bhmZ d`mVyZH| H m`H `mH Sy>Z AmZXmb`o Mmbdbr OmVmV.dVrV`m _wbm-_wbtZm g`mH mir 2 VmggH ma Am{U A`mg Ago Xhoar H m_ `mVyZ hmoVo.{VgwH s`m `oWrb 10-12 AmZXmb`mnH s EH mbmAmhr ^oQ> {Xbr. 4 Vo 12 d`moJQ>mVrb gw_maonmg

    _wbm-_wbtMo gy Z_H ma, Ioi, JrV, mWZm AmXrgw hmoVo. Mhm`m ~mJoV H m_ H aUm`m A{e{jV_OwamMr Vr dVr. _hm{dmb`rZ {ejU KoUmam EHVU Am{U EH VUr `mgmR>r {Z`_rV doi XoVmV.Amhmbm ~KyZ dVrVrb H mhr ~m`H m Am{U dhrAmbo. `m`mH Sy>Z H iboH s, ho XmoKo amr _moR>mMmhrdJ KoVmV. `mMr bhmZ _wbo gH m[aV hmoV AmhoVM.nU _moR>mMo Xm Mo `gZhr H _r hmoV Amho. VoWrb

    _XmZmV `m _wbmgmo~V Ioi`mMm _moh Am_`mVrb_moR>mZmhr Amdabm Zmhr. `mZr _wbmZm ZdrZ Ioi{eH dbo. mMm AmZX m _wbm`mMoh`mda ~KyZ D a^ Z Ambm.

    Xgao{dmb` nm{hbo Vo V\ amJm_Mo . {Ohm bmo{hV.1980 _`o gwdmVrbm _wbtMo{Zdmgr {dmb` gw

    dV: ew hmoUo, n{d hmoUoAm{U gdmMo {hV H aUohoM nyOoMo _w` gy Amho.

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 25

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    26/52

    26 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

    Pmbo. `oWrb AZw d IynM AmZ{XV H aUmam Am{UVoWrb H m`H `m~b AmXa dmT>dUmam. AmO aVoZrQ> AmhoV. dZdmgr ~aoM {e{jV Amho. Varhr

    Amn`mH S>rb gmo`r `oWo ZmhrV. 35 dfmnydu H m`pWVr Agob `mMm {dMma Hobm H s, `oWrb IS>VaH m_mMr H nZm ghO `oVo. gw{dYmnyU N>mmdmg,{ejH mgmR>r {ZdmgmMr gmo` Am{U hogd JmdmnmgyZXa. `m doiog ho {dmb` gw Ho bo `mdoi`mOrdZdVr Am{U H m`H `mZr Hobobo `mJ, H > `mMogwXa n AmO nmhm`bm {_iVo.

    {Vgar MmWr`m N>moQ>m JmoS>_wbr `m dmVmdaUmbmAmZXr H aV hmo`m. {VWo EH XrS> Vmg H gm Jobm hoH iboM Zmhr. VodT>m doioMm gXn`moJ Am_`mVrbndZoeOtZr `m _wbtZm d{XH J{UV {eH dyZ Ho bm._wbtMr CgwH Vm Am{U AmZX ~K`mgmaIm hmoVm.dg{VJhmV _wbtMm `dpWVnUm H mVwH mnX hmoVm.VoWyZM godm{Zdm Pmobobo nU H| H m`mMr Vi_iAgbobo mMm`, {ejH _mJXeH mMr ^y{_H m~OmdVmV. `m`m~amo~a gdmX H aVmZm OmUdbrVr {dmb`m~b Agbobr AmnwbH s. `mJ.

    g_mYmZ. A{YH me {ejH Xg`m mVmMo. KamnmgyZXa Ambobo. {dmWu _m {VWboM. Amhr {VWo OodUH Z {ZKmbmo. AWmV nm` {ZKVm {ZKV ZhVo.

    dmQ>oV dmH mo `oWo H| mMo `dgm` {ejU H| ~{KVbo. {VWo hmV_mJmda H mnS> {dUm`Mo m`{jHnm{hbo. VoWoZD _wbr amhVmV. JmdmVrb _wbr {ejUKo`mg `oV hmo`m. `m N>moQ>m JmdmV d Odinmg`mn[agamV `m {ejU H|mV {dUbo`m H mnS>bm

    MmJbr _mJUr AgVo. `oWo `m _wbtZro_mZo ^mV,^mOr Va Ho brM, Am_`mgmR>r nmo`mgwm Ho`m.Am_`m~amo~a Agbo`m _mYdrVmBZr godm{ZdmrZVa`oWo {ejU {XboAm{U BVa {dmb`mV godmH m`hrHobo Amho.

    {S>~wJT>`m {dmb`V amr _w m_ nS>bm.

    A{Zdmgr` Wm{ZH {dm`mgmR>rMo ho {dmb`.1981 nmgyZ gw Agbo`m `m emioV n{hbr Vo~mamdrn`VMo dJ AmhoV. hOma Vo ~mameo {dmWu.Cm_ ^dZ. gwgpmV n[aga. dmMZmb`, `moJemimAgbobo. mM`m`m Kar OodU KoD Z gH mir {ZKmbmo.

    EH {dmb` ~K`mMr Iyn CgwH Vm hmoVr, VohUOoeoaJmd. doQ> H q_J {Ohm. 1981 _`o gwPmbobo {dmb`. H| mMo W_ OrdZdVr `oWoAmbo Vo emgH s` {dmb`mV. H|mMo H m_ H aV ho {dmb`gw Ho bo. Vohm AmOmar _wbtZm nmR>rda KoD Z 5 Vo8{H bmo_rQ>a Omdo bmJo. OJbmVrb hmr n[agamV `oV.Aem n[apWVtZm Vm|S> XoV C^o Ho bobo ho {dmb`AmO hm`a goH S>ar VamMoAmho. _wbmgmR>r {Zdmgrgw{dYm Amho. Wm{ZH _wbtZm doe d{ejU gw{dYmAmho. AmOhr JmdmnmgyZ Xa Agm emV n[aga. gd{ejH mZm, mM`mZm ^oQ>bmo. {dmb`mV H sS>m {XZAg`mZo_wbo_XmZmV V`marV hmoVr. {ejH mgmR>rMrH m_Z _ IynM H nH nVrMo d {dmWuH| r hmoVr.BWohr AJ`mZo ^moOZ Pmbo. `m_wio `oH {R>H mUrdoi OmV hmoVm, nU OdiyZ g_Om`bm _XVhr Pmbr.

    EH {dmb` nm{hboVdmJ_Yrb H sQ>nr `o Wrb.ho `mV`m `mV AbrH So> gw Hobobo {dmb`.

    `wdm H m`H Vm [aMr Zmoa~yMo `ZmZo. Vo {dmb`mMo MoAa_Z AmhoV. 28 {dmWmZm KoD Z 1990 _`oho {dmb` gw Pmbo. AmO 100 _wbr, 125 _wbo{eH VmV. _wbtgmR>r {Zdmgr gw{dYm Amho. _wbtZrgmH {VH H m`H_ gmXa Ho bo. Wm{ZH Z`, JmUr,mWZm gd Cm_M. XmoZ {e{jH m `m BW`mM _mOr

    X[ar, X~b, Cno{jVm_ oOmo Ba nmhVmo Vmo M Iar {edmonmgZm H aVmo.

    26 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    27/52

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 27

    {dm{WZr. ^oQy>Z N>mZdmQ>bo.

    AUmMb Xoe

    Am{U Amgm__`oH|m`m gw_mao 50 emim AmhoV.`mVrb _moO`m5-6 {dmb`mZm^oQ>r {X`m. OoH mhrdmQ>bo Vo eXmV `H aUo e` Zmhr.gH ma, `{ _

    d KS>UrMo `edr `Z Am{U Vohr gXa mVmV!Amhmbm `oH {dmb`mV {_imbobr AmnwbH sZ {dgaVm `oUmar. Am{U {VWo ^oQ>bobo BVa mVmMo{deofV: amOWmZ, _hmam>, {~hmaMo {ejH . `mZrgm{JVboboAZw d Am{U Vo Wo H m_ H a`mMog_mYmZho gmao {ddoH mZX H| hr Am`mp_H gKQ>Zm Amho ,`mMr {MVr XoUmao hmoVo.

    ghO H moUrVar EH m {ejH mZm Hobm.

    hmo_{gH Zmhr dmQ>V? Cma hmoVo, Ago AgVo VaBWo AmbmoM ZgVmo.' hoM Ka Am{U ho gd n[admaAgbobo {ejH . OmoS>rZo `mM {dmb`V H m` H aUmaoH mhr. V\ amJm_ `oWrb dV_mZ mMm`m H| mMr \ maerAmoiI ZgVmZm H bH m`mbm _{UrMm BQ>ayhUyZ~amo~a Jobr. ~mbH UZOtZr {hMmhr BQ>ay KoVbm.{ZdS> Pmbr. KaMm WmoS>m {damoYhr Pmbm. nU ~Kw`mhUyZ Ambr. {VMo gwdVrMo AZw d EoH `mgmaIo

    AmhoV. Vr VoWo Ambr Vohm {VWo Agbobo _mZZr`{dmgOr (g`m _hmam> mV gKQ>H ) `mZr boH s_mUoH miOr KoVbr. H| m`m ZohmZo Vr BWbrM Pmbr.Ago {H VrVar AZw d EoH m`bm {_imbo.

    JwdmhmQ>rVrb H| H m`mb`mV W_ _w m_ hmoVm.VoWo{ddoH mZX H| BpQ>Q>yQ> Am\ H Ma m gWo`m

    _m`_mVyZ H m`gw Amho. VoWrb OZOmVt`m T>r,nanam `mda gemoYZ H aUo, `m~b AmWm {Z_mUH aUo Ago H m_ gw AgVo. {_eZ`mH Sy>Z hmoUmar

    {Xem^yb Wm~d`mMoH m`hr mVyZ hmoVo. H| H m`m_wio\ gdyZ hmoUm`m Y_mVambm _moR>m _mUmV AQ>H mdPm`mMoAZoH Wm{ZH H m`H `mZr gm{JVbo.

    EH AZw d H m`H `m`m `moOH VoMr {MVrXoUmam R>abm. EH m amrMo ^moOZ Wm{ZH bmoH m`mKar R>odbo hmoVo. AUmMb`m bmo{hV {OmVrb VoOyJmdr _w m_ hmoVm Vohm Mma g_yhmV Mma Kar moOZmgJobmo. `oH mMo AZw d EoH VmZm Iyn _m{hVr {_imbr.

    dmgmMr gnyU AmIUr Am{U _mJXeZ VrZgw{H m`oWogodmaV Agbo`m noeOtZr Ho bo hmoVo. `m`mer\ moZ Am{U _ob hoM gnH mMo _m`_ hmoVo . `oH{R>H mUr H m`H `mZr AmnwbH sZo Hobobr `dWmH m`_ AmR>dUrV amhrb. {Zdmg Am{U ^moOZmMrgmo hr e` Vohm H| H m`mb` qH dm {dmb`mVMH a`mV `oV hmoVr. H mhr doiog hmQ>ob_YyZhr `dWmPmbr. Am_`mnH s `oH OU H| _ZmV KoD ZMH|mOdi Jobm hmoVm. `m_wio dmg Iyn gmo`r

    gw{dYmMr Anojm ZhVrM. WmoSogm_O` Am{U g`_`m_wionyU AZw d A{d_aUr` R>abm. EH VrW`mmHo`mMo g_mYmZ XoUmam R>abm. `oH mZo {VWo OmD ZH| AZw dmdo. _J Amnbo _Z {VWo AgVoM. `mVyZO_ob VgoVZ Am{U YZ XoUohmoBbM.

    nyUdmgmV {ZgJmer OdirH gmYbr. g>r gmX`S>mo`mVyZ AVH aUmV gm_mdob. Vo gXd emVr XoBbhm {dmg Amho. ~mo_S>rbm Vo VdmJ gobmnmgd Z OmUo

    - `oUoAm{U gobmnmg `o Wo Amn`m g{ZH mZm ^oQ>Uo,`m`mer Jmo>r H aUo, CM {eIamda Jw JmoqdXqgJO`Vrbm g{ZH m`m JwmamV OmUo, `mZr o_mZod AmJhmZo {Xbobm MH a gmX KoUo Ago AZoHA{d_aUr` jU `m dmgmV bm^bo.

    ***

    OmoBVamgmR>r gddmMm `mJ H aVmo `mgM _w s m hmoVo.

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 27

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    28/52

    28 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

    WmoS> nU _mobmM {bhZ _amR>r dmL>_`mV Img WmZ{_idUmaoboIH lr. {dlm_ ~oS>oH a AmO OJmV ZmhrV.

    {d^mdar {eaH a `m Zmdmao ~S>Imoa boIZ H Z Amn`m doJionUmMmR>gm C_Q>dUm`m _mbVr~mB~oS>oH ahr AmO OJmV ZmhrV. `m XmoZ_Zdr ` sZr Ceram {ddmh Ho bm. XmoKmerhr gdmX H a`mMm,`m`m Kar Om`mMm `moJ _bm AZoH Xm Ambm. XmoKmMhr dmL>_`_m`m {der-nM{derV _r PnmQ>`mgmaI dmMb . naVw AmO `mdmL>_`m~b _r {b{hV Zmhr Va n{VnZr hUyZ `m H maM ZmVXmoKm_`o OmUdb `m~b {bhrV Amho.

    gdmV eodQ>r `mMr ^oQ> Pmbr Vo nw`m`m S>o Z {O_Im`mda

    \ `wgZ`m JrV Vo amhm`bm Ambo Vohm. _mbVr~mBZr `mdoirAmn`m d{S>bmda Iao _mVa `m ZmdmM nwVH {b{hb hmoV. Vo`mZr {bhm`bmM ZH mohmoV. `m {df`mda {dlm_ Amn`m ~moM`m,CnhmgJ^ ebrV {Z`m_mUo ~o~mOr H arV hmooVo. _mbVr~mB `m~moMaonUmH S>o gd`rZo Xbj H aV hmo`m. `m WH bo`m d`mVhr

    EH PmS>,XmoZ (dV) njr

    S>m. dUbVm {^erH akmZ~mo{YZr, hamir8888802628

    gm`mM Am__ZQ>g_mQ>mZm `m`mgmo{eH -g_Og "gaH ma'^oQ>VmV Ag Zmhr. Hw Ur Ka

    XoVm H m Ka? Aer AmV

    _mJUr Aer dmXiH aVAgVmV. nU Or Xrn`moVrAmn`m emV H memZo

    `m`mgmR>r Ka {Z_mUH aVo, {VMr AmR>dU `mZm~ohmofr`m H VdH mbmVH _rM AgVo. Vr Jo`mda_m `mZm \ ma nmoaHdmQ>V. nU Vr Agon`V

    Vo {Vbm JhrVM YZMmbboboAgVmV.

    r - H Wm

    gd g_d hoM doXmVmMo gma Amho.

    28 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    29/52

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 29

    Am`mJo`mMr XIb KoV hmo`m. ho `m`mH S>MZoh_rM {M hmoV.

    EHo H mir _mbVr~mB gmobmnyabm g_mOH `mUA{YH mar hUyZ _moR>m A{YH mamV dmdaV AgV.gmobmnwamV `mMr OmJm ~{XV Ho bobr hmoVr, Aem_mJ JmS>r g_mOm`m {dH mgmMr O~m~Xmar `m`mdaemgZmZo gmondbr hmoVr. _moR>Ka, ZmoH a MmH a Agm`mMm WmQ> hmoVm. `mdoir {dlm_ `mVr nmdboboZhVo. H mhr {deof H aV ZhVo Am{U `m H V~Jma~m`H mo_wio H mhrgm `yZJS>hr `m`m _ZmV {Z_mUPmbm Agmdm Am{U Vmo AhJS>m`m nmZo ` hmoVAgo. ZVa `e {_im`mdahr {dlm_mMr AhH| {Vdmr VerM am{hbr. `m`m Kar Amhr Jobo H s

    MMm _mbVr~mB`m dmL>_`mda H _r, {dlm_m`mdmL>_`mda dm A` dmL>_`rZ Zmda A{YH hmoVAgo. dV:`m Xoh~mobrVyZ, eX~mobrVyZ {dlm_

    _mbVr~mB`m~m~V Or ZH mam_H ^mdZm ` H aVVr _bm Zoh_rM ~moMV-IQ>H V Ambr.dmV{dH {dlm_ Am{U _mbVr~mB ho Xmohr \ ma

    X{_i JwUg_w` hmoVo. Vo nanamZm nyaH hmoVoAg hUVm oUma Zmhr. {dlm_ ~oS>oH a m`m Am_H WZnanwVH mM Zmd "EH PmS> Am{U XmoZ njr' Ag Amho.dV:`m `{ dmMo XmoZ ^mJ H Z, Omo gmjr Vmo`j OJUm`m~b {b{hb Amho Aer `mVbr^y{_H m Amho. naVw Hw Qw>~OrdZ ho Oa PmS> g_Ob Va `m XmoZ VmH Xr`m boIH mZr n{VnZr`m Zm`mZoEH m PmS>mda dVr Ho br. naVw "VwPm Am{U _mPmAmho doJim dmg' `m Jmo>rMr OmUrd `mZm Am{U`mZm nmhmUm`m BVamZm `m`m~b Pm`mdmMyZamhmV Zgo.

    "da Vy {dhJ A~amV {dhaUmam, de{h derH aUVwbm ghO OmXJmam' Aem H maM `{ _d{dlm_mM hmoV. Va _mbVr~mBda `o`dmXr d{S>bmMm

    Am{U qhJ`m`m dmVmdaUmMm ^md hmoVm. e~arZmdm`m _mbVr~mB`m EH m H mX~arV `m {^H Vr`m ` s`m _Y`m VmUVUmdmM XeZAmn`mbm KS>V. g_mOmV`m Cno{jVmM AVaJ_mbVr~mBZr Hodi OmUbM Zmhr Va `m`mgmR>r`mZr H m_ Ho b. {dlm_mMr Vab ~wXr {Q>iH -AmJaH am_Y`m ^md{ZH -dMm[aH gKfmMm nmoVVnmgV hmoVr.

    dV:`m AZw dmVyZ _mbVr~mB rOrdZm{df`r{bhrV hmo`m. Vo H mhr o__Ywa H m` ZhV Va EH mgdoXZerb _ZmZo nMdbobo {dfnobo hmoVo. EH Xm `m`m`m Zm`mV`m EH m r~b gmJV hmo`m. {VMonVr _`XoemVrb EH m Zm_dV gemoYZ gWoMo _wIhmoVo. hr r gwXm {dkmZmVrb EH m O{Q>b emIoV

    r - H Wm

    lo>dmMr H nZm hm _mZdmbm Agbobm emn Amho.

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 29

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    30/52

    30 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

    gemoYZ H aV hmoVr. XmoZ gemoYH mZr o_{ddmhHobm. `m emk _{hboMo emoY{Z~Y AmVaam>r`{Z`VH m{bH m_YyZ {gX hmoV. _mbVrVmBH S>o Vr`oBVohm {H `oH Xm AJmda _mamMo dU AgV. Vrbnd`mMm `Z H ar. _mbVr~mB{MSy>Z hUV, H mhm A>mhmg EH amhm`mMm? `m emk, ndVrrZo `m ZmM Cma H YrM {Xb Zmhr, ho gmJVmZm_mbVr~mBMm da doXZoZo^Z OmB .

    _mbVr~mB`m`m n[aM`mVrb AmUIr EH m rMrH hmUr gmJV. ho n{VnZr XmoKohr S>mQ>a. nZr ramoJVk. dV:M gy{VJh, Umb`. nVtMr pQ>g{deof MmbV Zgo. `mM H m_ _w`V: nZrZo {_idbobongo _moO`mM Am{U CYi`mM. S>mQ>arU~mBM ho Jh{N> \ maM WmoS>mZm _mhrV hmoV. XZ nmhUm`mZmEH H V~Jma r S>mQ>a Am{U {VMm H _r H V~JmaZdam `mMm ~`mnH s Mmbbobm ggmaM {XgV Ago.nU _wbmZr Oonm{hb `mMo Imob Mao_wbm`m _Zmda

    C_Q>bo hmoVo. {Xdgm`m eodQ>r _wH mQ>mZo d{S>bmnwT>onemMr {nedr [aVr H aUmar AmB! d{S>bm`m~obJm_ BN>mnwT>o {Z_yQ>nUo _mZ VwH dUmar AmB!Am_g_mZmda Kmd nS>V AgVmZm Vo _wH mQ>mZoPobUm`m {`m hr _mbVr~mBMr Imob doXZm hmoVr.

    {ddmhm`m doir Or gnXr hmoVo `mV nVr

    hUVmo, gIm gnXr ^d! gm _m_ AZwdVm ^d&EH Mmbbob gmVd nmD b OrdZ^am`m AIS>,CH Q> ZohmgmR>r AgV. H mimMr nmdb nwT>o nS>VmV,

    Vm`mMo ~ha gm`-erVb hmoVmV, earamMo AmdoJemV hmoVmV `mdoir Oo {ebH amhm`bm hd Vog_Og, {Zanoj o_. naVw {H Vr n{VnZr~m~V AghmoV?

    EoZ H Vdm`m H mimV, XmoKohr Amnmn`m jomV`emMr {eIa JmR>V AgVmV `mdoir nanam`mH VdmMm AmXa, OmoS>rXmamgmR>r nyaH ^y{_H m KoU{H VrXmn`mZm e` hmoV? Hw gw_mJO hUVmV Vg-"H moUrnmD b HwUr nm`ar' Ag Agob VaM {Zd}Y ghOrdZe` hmoVH m? Eadr Vo e` Zmhr H m? Amn`mOrdZm`m OmoS>rXmamH S>o Amn`m AmH m jm`m,BN>m`m nyVuM gmYZ hUyZ Oo nmhmVmV Vo {VMm dm`mMm dV ` s hUyZ {dMma H eH V Zmhr.H moUmbm Var Am{U ~hYm rbmM Am`w`^a X`_^y{_H m KoD Z OJm`bm bmJV. "{R>U`mnojm VS>OmoS>~ar' Aem {dMmamZo ~hVoH {`m `m VS>OmoS>rbm V`mahmoVmV.

    `oH ` s-r qH dm nwf ho doJi KS>bob agm`Z Amho. doJionUm hUOo H _rOmVnUm Zmhr._Zw`mM {ejU ho Ia Va `m`m J^VoMr IyUAgbr nm{hOo. nU Amn`mbm {_iUma {ejUAmn`mbm _mZdr g~Ym_Ybr J^Vm {eH dVZmhr. Xg`mMm AmXa H gm H amdm, Xg`m`m^md^mdZm OmUyZ H em `m`mV, `mo` {VgmX H gmmdm ho Amn`mbm {ejUm_YyZ H iV Zmhr. AbrH S>o

    B_moeZb BQ>o{bOgMr MMm ~arM Mmbbobr Amho.Vmo hUOo Xga {VgaH mhr ZgyZ _mZdr g~Ym_YbrJ^Vm hoM Amho.

    hr J^Vm H moUmOdi ghOM AgVo. H moUrn[apWVrbm {VgmX XoVm XoVm Vr {ddoH mZo{_i{dbobrAgVo. Am{U H mhr bmoH _m bm{H H jomV _moR>o

    r - H Wm

    _mPo JwXod _bm Zoh_r gmJV, OmodV:bm X~b g_OVmoVmo X~bM ahmVmoAm{U ho Iao M Amho.

    30 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    31/52

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 31

    namH _ H aVmV nU ZmVo-g~YmV \ ma EH mH samhmVmV. gm`mM Am__ ZQ>g_mQ>mZm `m`mgmo{eH -g_Og "gaH ma' ^oQ>VmV Ag Zmhr. Hw Ur Ka

    XoVm H m Ka? Aer AmV_mJUr Aer dmXi H aVAgVmV. nU Or Xrn`moVr Amn`m emV H memZo`m`mgmR>r Ka {Z_mU H aVo, {VMr AmR>dU `mZm~ohmofr`m H VdH mbmV H _rM AgVo. Vr Jo`mda_m `mZm \ ma nmoaH dmQ>V. nU Vr Agon`V Vo{VbmJhrVM YZ Mmbbobo AgVmV. Hw gw_mJOmMr EHgwXa H {dVm Amho.-

    g_O Oar _r ^_anUmZoagJYmMo `mbmoX{hdaAemVem`m gamBV dmg_O Q>oH bmo `m a`mdaAgob `m gdmVyZ gmhgX~bVobm H amd`mMo_aUm`m N>m`o_{Y AWdmWmoS>o `mXm OJmd`mMoAgob qH dm Zgob Vohrdm _mVrMr \ CYmUo

    Agob qH dm nmoH iVoda

    {dUmd`mMoa{JV JmUonaVw `m gdmn{bH S>Mm_r Oa VwObm H ibmo Zmhr

    hUoZ n[aM` Pmbm AnwbmnaVw AmoiI Pmbr Zmhr-Ahmo_hmZ H {damO, Vwhrhr VoM hUV AmhmV

    H s {VZo Vwhmbm OmUyZ `m`M! `mZo{Vbm OmUm`M H s Zmhr? H Yr OmUm`M? Hw Ur HwUmMr IarAmoiI H Z `m`Mr? n{VnZr XmoKmZr nanamZmOmUm`bm ZH mo? dV `{ _d hUyZ nanamMmAmXa H am`bm ZH mo? r Va \ maM {MV ^_anUmMdmV` KoVo. {Z>m Am{U g_nU ho ~hVme ^maVr`{`mMo OrdZda AmOhr AmhoV.

    Hw Qw>~OrdZm`m PmS>mda nanam`m ghdmgmMmAmZX KoV XmoKmZmhr JJZ^amar KoVm `oD Xo. `mgmR>rEH _oH mZm nwaog dmV` Am{U AmYma XoV JVrH a`mMr H bm {`mZm Am{U nwfmZm {eH m`bmbmJob. Vo nmhZ `mMr _wbhr Vr H bm {eH Vrb.Vr `mMr dmr hmoBb. Ag KS>md Aer Vi_i_mbVr~mB ~oS>oH a `mZm hmoVr. H moUmhr {dMmar

    _mUgmbm mhZ doJi H m` hUm`MAgUma? ***

    gmobmnya - A bH moQ> amoS> E_.Am`.S>r.gr. ^mJmVrb H| m`mZ`mZogw Pmbo`m {dVmamV JrVmO`Vr gmOar Pmbr. YZO`gy der `mZr _mJXeZ Hobo . `mdoir n|Q>nm J>_, ZXHw _ma{MVmnyao, a{d H Q>br, lr. _oaJy AmXr _m`da CnpWV hmoVo.

    VobwJy mVVar`H m`H Vm {ejU {e{~a{ddoH mZX H| H `mHw _mar VobwJy

    mVm`m dVrZo 25 {S>g|~a 2015 Vo 1OmZodmar 2016 `m H mbmdYrV {Vr`mVVar` H m`H Vm {ejU {e{~a Ko`mV

    Ambo. `mV 12 ~Yy - ^{JZtMm gh^mJhmoVm. am`bgr_m {d^mJ _wI _mVr_mohZ ao>r `m`m hVo CmQ>Z Pmbo. `mZr`moJg, gH ma dJ d dm`m` dJ H go`mdo `m{df`r _mJXeZ Ho bo. AmhVr gmVmV _wI Or. M_mbr mZr _mJXeZ Ho bo.

    H| dm

    r - H Wm

    ~bgn hm! eya hm ! gm_ Am{U gm_ hrM AmOMr Amd`H Vm Amho. gm_ hoM OrdZ. X~bVm hmM_ y. CR>m ! YrQ> ~Zm ! ~bgn hm.

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 31

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    32/52

    32 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

    _r ^maVmV`m {g WimnH sEH Amho. Amo{S>em am`mVrb nwar oWo_mPo dmV` Amho. 13 `m eVH mVamOm ZqghXod `mZr _mPr {Z{_Vr Ho br.

    _r H qbJ ebrV gy Xodm`m aWm`mdnmV Amho. aWmbm ~mam OmoS>m MH AgyZgmV KmoS>oAmhoV. _r {enmH VtgmR>r {g Amho ._bm BJOrV "bH nJmoS>m' hUVmV. 1984 _ o wZoH moZo OmJ{VH dmagm Wi hUyZ _bm Kmo{fVHobo . _m Xa`mZ`m H mimV _mPm H mhr ^mJCXdV Pmbm Amho. `mMo H maU dmVwXmof Am{U_wpb_ AmH _U ho am{hbo Amho. oWrb Wm{ZH

    bmoH gy Xodmbm {~aMr Zmam`U hUVmV. nwamUmZwgmalrH UmMm _wbJm gm~ `mZo _m`m J JhmVrbgy Xodm`m _yVuMr WmnZm Hobr. Vr gy Xodm`mearam`m ^mJmnmgyZ Xod{enr {ddH _m `mZo~Zdbr hmoVr. `m_wio ho WmZ n{d _mZbo OmVo.H mhr B{VhmgH mam`m _Vo_mmm {Z_mUH Vm amOmZqghXod `m`m AH mbr _ y_wio _m`m {Z{_VrMoH m I{S>V Pmbo. `m_wio AnyU~mYH m_ nS>bo.

    naVw `mbm H moUVmhr Eo{Vhm{gH AmYma Zmhr. amOmZqghXodZo 1282 n V am` Ho `mMo Vm_nmdZg_OVo. `m_wio AnyUH m_m_wio _r CXdV Pmbmo,ho VHgJV Zmhr. 1508 _ oH mbmnhmS>Zo AmH _UH Z _bm CXdV Hobo .

    _r H moU?

    ~mb{dhma

    gw~moY dob 7gyMZm `m dobrda Amho dm_r {ddoH mZXmMm

    gw{dMma. H_mH mZwgma g_mZmWu eX {bhm. gw{dMmadmMm. AmMaUmV AmUm d AmZX {_idm.

    gwaoIm H mUo, g^mOrZJa. \ moZ 0240-2328217

    Cma`mMAHmVBVa

    ~mb{dhma

    ,

    ,

    ,,

    ,`fnmhrdc

    ,

    rdqodms.

    ,.

    .

    , (+)=

    ,

    ,

    ,

    gm_ ho M nw`. X~bVm hoM nmn.

    32 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    33/52

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 33

    _hmamO lr_V g`mOramd Jm`H dmS>({Vgao),O_Zmd Jmonmiamd H meramd Jm`H dmS>,(10 _mM 1863 - 6 \o ~wdmar 1939) ho1875 Vo 1939 gmbmXa`mZ ~S>moXm gWmZmMoA{YnVr hmoVo. Vo yVnyd ~S>moXo gWmZmMo A VnwamoJm_r dmrMo, H VddmZ gWm{ZH (H maH sX: 1881 - 1939) hmoVo. ~S>moXm gWmZmVrbOo`m H `mUmgmR>r Hobo`m H m`mH aVm Vo

    {deofdmZo AmoiIbo OmVmV. Ammo{JH H bm{ejUmH [aVm "H bm wdZ'hr gWm WmnZ Ho br. `mZr "m` {dm_{Xa' `m gWo`m dVrZomMrZgHV JWmMo gemoYZ d H meZ H a`mg CmoOZ {Xbo. g`mOramdmZr

    "lrg`mOr gm{h`_mbm' d "lrg`mOr ~mb kmZ_mbm' `m XmoZ _mbm_YyZCm_ JWmMr ^mfmVao {g Ho br. `mZr gWmZmV JmdmoJmdr dmMZmb oWmnZ Hobr. {\ a`m dmMZmb`mMrhr gmo Ho br. `mZm dmgmMr A VAmdS> hmoVr d `mZr OJ^a dmg Ho bm. OoWo OoWo Oo Oo MmJboAgob, Vo VoMmoIXinUo drH m Z Amn`m gWmZmMr gdmJrU a^amQ> H a`mMm `mZrgVV `Z Hobm. bS>Zbm ^abo`m n{h`m XmoZ Jmob_oO n[afXmZmhr VohOa hmoVo. bmo. {Q>iH , ~m~yAaqdX Kmof `m Wmoa Zo mer `mMm K{Z> g~YhmoVm. kmZdr, g_mOgwYmaUm d {eV~ emgZ `m gdM ~m~VtV Vo`edr R>abo. "qhXWmZmVrb eodQ>Mm AmXeamOm' m eXmV `mMo Wmo{MVdUZ n{S>V _XZ_mohZ _mbdr `mZr Ho boAmho. _w~B oWo`mMo {ZYZ Pmbo.

    _hm_m Omo{V~m \wbo (11 E{b 1827- 28 Zmoh|~a 1890) ho _amR>r boIH , {dMmadVAm{U g_mOgwYmaH hmoVo. `mZr g`emoYHg_mOmMr WmnZm Ho br; eoVH ar Am{U ~hOZ g_mOm`mg_`mZm H|WmZr R>oD Z nwamoJm_r {dMmamMr _mS>UrHobr. _hmam>mVrb r {ejUmMr _whV_oT> amodbr.

    23 gQ>|~a1873 amoOr _hm_m \wbo `mZrg`emoYH g_mOmMr WmnZm Ho br. VWmH {WV

    CdUu`m`m A`m`mnmgyZ, A`mMmamnmgyZ d Jwbm_{JarVyZ eym{Vey

    g_mOmMr _w Vm H aUo d `mZm h mMr OmUrd H Z XoUo hog`emoYHg_mOmMo o hmoVo. _amR>rV _Jbm>Ho aMbr. g_mOmVrb {df_Vm Z> H aUod VimJmimVrb g_mOmn V {ejU nmohMdUo ho g`emoYH g_mOmMo ohmoVo. OmoVramdmZr `m`m nZr gm{dr~mBZm {ejU XoD Z {ejUH m`mgdm Ho bo. emio`m _w`m`mnH nXr Am T> Pmbobr ^maVmVrb n{hbr_{hbm hUOo gm{dr~mB. `mM_mUo dVnUo \ {`mgmR>r emimH mT>Umao_hm_m \w bo n{hbo ^maVr` hmoV.

    AmoiIm nmhAmoiIm nmh : _mJrb AH mMr Cmao

    ~mb{_mZmo, AmYw{ZH^maVm`m OS>UKS>UrV

    _mobmMo `moJXmZ XoUmar XmoZ`pV_doAmo iIm. `mgmR>r

    {_, {ejH , KamVrbd{S>bYm`mMr _XV `m.Am{U `m`m{df`r `oH s50 Vo60 eXmV _m{hVr

    {bhZ nmR>dm. Vr `m gXamV{g H .

    (A)

    (~)

    ~mb{dhma

    AkmZm`m ngm`mda ~m~_mUo H mogiUmam Cn{ZfXmVrb EH Am{U EH _m eX H moUVm Agob Va Vmo hUOo{Z Vm ! Am{U hmM Y_{eH d mMr AmO JaO Amho.

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 33

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    34/52

    34 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

    AgoM EH Xm EH m Zoh_r`m JmdmV Zoh_r`m Kar Jobo. H m`H_nyd{Z`mo{OV hmoVm. R>abm `m doir `m Ka`mM bmoH mZr A`VAJ`nydH dmJVmMm XadZrhr Hobm hmoVm. Zoh_r`m gAmnwbH s`m gd`rZwgma H sVZH ma Kar nmohMbo Va KaMo dmVmdaU

    AJXrM doJir.gJirH S>o emVVm, dmVmdaUmV VmUd H moUrM H mhr ~moboZm.Z_H mamVhr AmnMm[aH VmM hmoVr. H sVZH ma ~wdmZm ho Ag Pmbo.KamV H mhr A_Jb KS>boH m? n{hbr eH m dmBQ>mMrM `oVo. nU Vgog d ZhVo. MwHy Z AgVoM Va Am`moOH mZr BVa `dWm HobrAgVr. nU Vgohr KS>boZmhr. _J Zo_Ho KS>bo Var H m`? hr H m|S>r\ moS>m`Mr H er?

    H sVZH mamMo_mZgemr` kmZ ~iH Q> hmoVo. `mZm _m{hVr hmoVoH s Aemdoir bhmZ _wbo hmM _mJ Amho. KamV Mma emiH mar _wbo

    hmoVr. `mZm gJ`mMr ZmdonmR> hmoVr. hmH m _mam`bm gwdmV Hobr._mYd! VmoAmbm nm`m nSy>Z Jobm. har! Vmohr VgmM. JmoqdXm!

    JmoqdXmhr Ambm, Z_H ma H Z ~mOybm C^m am{hbm. eodQ>Mr hmH_mabr Jmonmi. {VgmX Ambm Zmhr. nwhm hmH _mabr Jmonmi! AaoJmonmi! Va JmoqdXmM hUmbm Vmo Zmhr `oUma!

    H miOr AmYr H am,ZVa Zho

    {dmdmMnnVrm. dmZX JOmZZ nwS>dUr, {O. `dV_mi.9822644611

    EH H sVZH ma hmoVo.gwXaebr, g{JVmMrAVr_ OmU, gImobA`mg, A`m_m`m

    gwJ_ {ZnUmMr hmVmoQ>r`m gJ`mMoM EH rH aUAg`mZobmoH {`Vm hm

    dm^m{dH n[aUm_ hmoVm.AZoH JmdmV dmadma OmUo

    hm`Mo. AmnmoAmnM `m `mJmdmV OZgnH XmS>Jm hmoVm.AZoH mer KaJwVr g~Y hmoVo.

    dmadma `mM KamV CVaboAg`mZoAJXr KamVrbM

    EH PmbohmoVo.

    H amdm {dMma

    ^`JVVm hrM gm`m AdZVrMr, gm`m nmnmMr OZZr Amho.

    34 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    35/52

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 35

    H m ao H m` Pmbo `mbm?H sVZH mamZr ghO {dMmabo. `mdaJmoqdX hUmbm. AmO Am_Mm embo`

    narjoMm {ZH mb bmJbm. JmonmiZmnmg Pmbm Amho.

    H sVZH ma ~wdmZm jUmV gJimCbJS>m Pmbm. VUmdmMo H maUH iob. CXmgrM _yi gmnS>bo.

    `mZr nwhm _mYd Am{U harbm~mobmdbo. gH minmgyZ gJ`mMr~mobUr ImD Z V Pmbobr _wbo

    g_moa Ambr. ~wdmZr _mYdbm JwU{dMmabo. 90% `mMoCma. harbm?85%. ~aoJmoqdXm Vwbm ao . _hmamO 95% {VKmZmhrAmnboJwU gm{JVbo.

    _J ~wdmZr _moR>mZm ~mobmdbo, ~wdm hUmbo AmhoH m` Vwhr bmoH nU? KamVrb 4 nH s 3 _wbo CmrUPmbr. Ka 75% Zr nmg Pmbo, Pmbm EH Zmnmg.dmBQ>M Amho. nU `mMr {ejm `m nmgdm`mZmH m?`mMo H m` MwH bo. {VKmMohr Mohao COibo . 75%

    VUmd {Zdibm. KaMohr _moR>o Za_bo. `mZmhr MyHbjmV Ambr.

    _J `mZr Jmonmibm ~mobmdbo, Vmo XmamAmS>yZ gJio

    EoH V hmoVmM. ~wdm Amn`m ~mOyZo~mobV AmhoV hQ>`mda nwT>oAmbm.~wdm hUmbo {H Vr {df`mV Zmnmg

    Pmbmg ao! Vmo H mHwiVrZo hUmbmEH mM ~mH s {df`mV 90`m daAmhoV. ~wdmZr _moR>mH S>o nm{hbo.`mMo MohaobhmZ Pmbo hmoVo.

    OmD Xo! Pmbo Vo Pmbo! nwT>`mdfu OmV A`mg H aerb Zm? hmoZ s, n{hbm `oD Z XmIdrZ. `mZoVmH mi Cma {Xbo. em~mg hUV

    ~wdmZr `mbm ~mhaonmR>dbo ._J _moR>mH S>o diV hUmboAmVm `mbm ~mobyZ H m` Cn`moJ. n[ajonydr Vwhr`m`m `m EH m {df`mH S>o bj {Xbo H m? gJiemV, ~wdm hUmboo MMm n[aUm_mVr hmoVo. H maUmH S>oAmnU Xbj H aVmo. n[aUm_mMr Zmhr Va H maUmMrH miOr _hdmMr Am{U H miOr hr H a`mMr ZmhrVa Ko`mMr Jmo> Amho.

    ZVa H miOr H aUoH m_mMo Zmhr Va AmYr H miOr

    KoUo _hdmMo AgVo ho`m Ka`mZm Va nQ>bo AmnboH m`?

    ***

    _hmS> & g_mOmMo ZoVd H aUm`mMr {V_m dN>Agmdr, Ago {VnmXZ am_H U _R>mMo gwaoe {^So>

    `mZr Ho bo. {ddoH mZX H| H `mHw_mar _hmS> emIo`mdVrZo dm_r {ddoH mZX O`Vr{Z{_m MdXma Vio oWrblram_ _{XamV Am`mo{OV `m`mZgJr Vo ~mobV hmoVo.

    {^So> hUmbo, {~{Q>em`m H mimV qhX Y_m~b dmBQ> ~mobboOm`Mo . qhX Y_mda Q>rH m Ho brOm`Mr. qhX Y_mbm VwN> boIbo Om`Mo. naVwdm_r

    {ddoH mZXmZr {eH mJmo `oWrb ^mfUmV gd OJmMr_Zo qOHyZ KoVbr. BVa Y_mda Q>rH m Z H aVm qhX

    Y_mMr lo>Vm nQ>dyZ {Xbr.`mdoir H|m`m R>m`m`mgMm{bH m {dmVmB ZmZb, gKQ>H gwOmVm Xidr,`y Bpbe Hyb d `w{ZAa H mboOMo{_qbX XoenmSo >,lr_Vr {H aU _moao `mMr _wI CnpWVr hmoVr.mVm{dH lr_Vr KmQ>UoH a, {_Zmjr gmXbJrH a `mZrgygMmbZ Hobo . lr_Vr JmYr `mZr Am^ma _mZbo.

    ZoVd H aUm`mMr {V_m dN> AgmdrH| dm

    H amdm {dMma

    gm_ hmM OrdZmVrb gdlo> _mJXeH Jw hmo . BVa gdJmo>t_mUo AmnU Y_mVhr {_i{_irVnUm, X~io nUmgmoSy>Z m. `mMoH mhrM H m_ Zmhr.

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 35

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    36/52

    36 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

    _{U: emUmocrT>: g_a{dO`r ho{V{ZhVmo &_X jrUmoZmJ: ea{X g[aV: `mZnw{cZm: &&H ceof: gwaV_{XVm ~mcccZm &&V{Zm emo VoJ{cV{d^dmm{Wfw Z nm: && 44 &&

    dm_Zn{S>VmZr `m bmoH mMm Ho bobm g_bmoH s AZwdmX Agm AmhoemUmocoI O`m Agm _{U aUt Omodra Km`micm&g moJ| {eUcr Aer Zd dYy hVr Z _Vmdcm &&`mMr dN> eaXVyV nw{cZ| `m {ZZJm Mhr &~rOoMm ^wnmXmYZ Omo ho emo ^Vr gdhr && 44 &&

    OJmV`m H mhr Jmo>r MmJ`m AgVmV Am{U H mhr Jmo>r dmBQ>AgVmV, AgAmnU gagH Q> g_OV AgVmo. nU gJimM Jmo>t`m~m~VrV Agm `m` H aVm `oV Zmhr. H mhr Jmo>r daH aUr dmBQ>{XgV Ag`m Var `mM MmJcqH dm dmBQ>nU ho Vr Jmo> H moU`mH maUmgmR>r Ho cocr Amho `mda Adc~yZ AgV. EImm _mUgmcm~XwH s`m Jmoim KmcyZ R>ma _maU dmBQ>M hQ>c nm{hOo. EImm

    eham`m ^a a`mV EH m _mWo{\ ZH moUmcm Var ~XwH s`m JmoimKmcyZ R>ma Ho c Va `mcm nmocrg nH S>Vrc, `m`mda IQ>cm aVrcAm{U `m`mc`mV `mcm _`wXS>mMr {ejm \ _mdcr OmBc. nUEImm g{ZH mZ Amn`m Xoem`m gr_oM ajU H aVmZm H mhr cmoH mZm~XwH s`m Jmoim KmcyZ R>ma Ho c Va `mcm _m _hmdra MH qH dmna_dra MH XoD Z Jmadc OmBc. KQ>Zm EH M Amho, naVw {V`m

    A_VdmUr 30

    bmoH mgmR>r OJU

    AaqdX Omoergmobmnya.9370408926

    ^VharMo Zr{VeVH

    earamda ^anya OI_mPmcocm EImXm _mUyg VgmH moUm`mM JmadmMm {df`hmoUma Zmhr, naVwVmoMOa aUmJUmV cT>VmZmOI_r Pmcm Agoc VaVmo Jmadmg nm R>aVmo.ZXr XwWS>r ^ Z dmhVoVohm Va MmJcr {XgVoM.

    nU XwWS>r ^ Z dm{hcocnmUr eoVm_`odmnacOmVAm{U ZVa Vr ZXr _XnUo

    dhm`cm cmJVo, VohmVr A{YH gwXa {XgVo.H maU Vr Amn`m nm`mMeoVmcm XmZ H Z jrU

    Pmcocr AgVo. XmZm_wi{VMr {jUVm gwm a_Ur`

    dmQ>m`cm cmJVo.

    Amn`m Zgm ~bXS> ~Zdm. hdo AmhoV bmoIS>mMo ~mh Am{U nmobmXm`m Zgm `mV Amho dOmMo_Z, gm_ ,

    nwfmW, jm - dr - ~ - VoO.

    36 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    37/52

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 37

    _mJMH maU ~Xcc H s {VMo n[aUm_hr ~XcVmV. n{h`m_mUgmcm IwZr hQ>c OmBc

    Am{U Xwg`m _mUgmcm draOdmZ hQ>c OmBc. EImXrdVy XJS>mda KmgU hUOo{Vcm gndUM Amho. naVwEImXm {ham ghmUoda KmgcmVa _m Vmo A{YH ncyXmahmoVmo. ghmUoda Kmg`mMr{H m VrM Amho naVw hoVw~Xccm H s, {V`mH S>~K`mMm X>rH moZhr ~XcVmo.earamda ^anya OI_m PmcocmEImXm _mUyg Vgm H moUm`mMJmadmMm {df` hmoUma Zmhr,naVw VmoM Oa aUmJUmV cT>VmZm OI_r Pmcm AgocVa Vmo Jmadmg nm R>aVmo. ZXr XwWS>r ^ Z dmhVoVohm Va MmJcr {XgVoM. nU XwWS>r ^ Z dm{hcocnmUr eoVm_`o dmnacOmV Am{U ZVa Vr ZXr _XnUo

    dhm`cm cmJVo, Vohm Vr A{YH gwXa {XgVo. H maUVr Amn`m nm`mM eoVmcm XmZ H Z jrU PmcocrAgVo. XmZm_wi {VMr {jUVm gwm a_Ur` dmQ>m`cmcmJVo. nm{U_oMm M Va gdmZmM _mo{hZr KmcVAgVmo, _m nyUM hUOo A_VmMm KQ>. m KQ>mVcA_V XodmZr meZ Ho`mZVa M IJm`cm cmJVmo.hUyZM {VnXoMr MH moa chmZ AgVo. naVwhr chmZMH moa gwm XodmZm A_VnmZmM gwI {X`m_wioXoIUr

    {Xgm`cm cmJVo. WH cr ^mJcocr VUr Ver gwXa{XgVM Zmhr, naVwaVrl_mZ WH cr Agoc Va {VMmcmZnUm A{V gwXa {Xgm`cm cmJVmo. VrM n[apWVramOmMr Amho. amOm hm gn AgVmo. Jar~ amOmqH dm {ZYZ g_mQ> H Yr AgVM ZmhrV. _m EImXmamOm gwm ^UJ hmoD eH Vmo. VmoVgm H em_wi Pmcm

    Amho `mcm _m _hd Amho.EImXm amOm `mMH mZm gVVXmZ XoD Z {ZYZ Pmcm Agoc

    Va `m`m Eod`mnojm gwm`mcm XmZY_m_wi Amcoc Xm[a A{YH emo yZ {XgV.EH XarV amOm ^Vhar `mZXmZY_ Am{U cmoH mgmR>r OJUH g gwXa AgV ho m cmoH mVgm{JVc Amho. mOVmM PmS> ho Aem Xo`mgmR>r{g AgV. mOVm`mPmS>mda ^anya \w c \w ccrH s Vo PmS> emo{^dV {Xgm`cmcmJV. naVw nhmQ>o nhmQ>oho PmS> Amn`m OdiMr

    \ wc O{_Zrcm XmZ hUyZ XoD Z Q>mH V Am{U gy`m}X`m`m doir mOVm`m PmS>mImcr \wcmMm gwXagS>m nS>cocm {XgVmo. \w cco`m PmS>mnojm gwm hmgS>m nmSy>Z nwnhrZ Pmcoc mOVmM PmS> A{YH

    _Zmoha {XgV, Vo `m`m O{_Zrcm {Xco`m \w cm`mXmZm_wi{XgV . na_odamZ _mUgmcm ~wr, AV:H aUAm{U ^mdZm {Xco`m AmhoV. `m `mMgmR>r {Xco`mAmhoV. _mUgmZAmn`mH S> Oo Amho Vo BVamZm XoVJoc nm{hOo. Amn`mH S> Oo Amho Vo Amn`mH S>MR>odU `mV _mUgmM _mUygnU Zmhr, Va Amn`mH S>Oo AmhoVo BVamZm Xo`mV _mUygnU Amho. Omo BVamZmgVV XoV amhVmo, `m _mUgmMr ZamMm Zmam`U

    hmo`mH S>Mr dmQ>Mmc gw Pmcocr AgVo. Amn`mB{Vhmgm_`o Am{U nwamUm_`o XmZeya `VtMrM ZmdAOam_a Pmcocr AmhoV. XmZeya H U hm Va OmoS>eXM Pmcm Amho. nw`cmoH A{h`mXodr hmoiH a mgwm XmZeyanUm_wiA_a Pmco`m AmhoV.

    ***

    ^VharMo Zr{VeVH

    ho_mZdm, X~b amh ZH mog. Cn{ZfXo ho OJmVrb EH _od gm{h` Amho . `mV A^r: & {Z hm ! Agm gXoe {Xbm Amho.

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 37

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    38/52

    38 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

    _mVamZm ImobrV {eaVmZm nmhVmM lram_HU _moR>mZo hgVhgV `m nmoamZm hUmbo, Aao`m, AmboV h nwhm! EoHy ZgdMOU hgybmJbo . _mVamZr O{_Zrbm S>moHo Q>oH dyZ dXZ Ho bo dVo OdiM ~gbo. W_ Vo\ C`mZoM hmV OmoSy>Z Z_H ma H arV.BJOr {eH bobo bmoH H aVmV `m_mUo. AmO Vo qhXnXVr_mUo S>moHo

    Q>oH dyZ Um_ H am`bm {eH bo. _mVa Amn`m OmJr ~g`mZValram_HU Amn`m hg`mMo H maU Za| dJao^ mZm g_OmdyZ gmJybmJbo.

    EH Xm PmbH m` H s, H moUr EH mZ EH m _moambm Mma dmO`m`m~oVmbm EH {Xdg WmoS>r A\y Mmabr. `mZVa Xg`m {Xder Z sMmam`m R>mo`mbm _moamMr dmar {VW hOa-AmX`m {XderMr A\yAJmV `oD Z {VMr MQ>H bmJbr. AJXr doioda `oD Z Q>nH br dmarA\yIm`bm! (gdM hgVmV)

    _mVa Amn`merM hUybmJbo , ho hUVmV VoH mhr ImoQ> Zmhr!Kar OmVmo, nU _Z H g gXmZH Xm `m`mnmerM nS>bob AgV.Hohm EH Xm `mZm nmhrZ Ag hmoD Z nMmU `mHw i hmoVmV. BWoHwUr OUyH m` IoMyZ AmUV ! BN>m Agbr Var XgarH So> Om`mMrgmo` Zmhr, BWoM `oU^mJ nS>V !' _mVa BH So > Amn`merM Agm{dMma H arV AmhoV Va lram_H U {VH So> `m _wbm~amo~a hm`{dZmoX

    _mM_{h`mMr 6 dr VarI,gmo_dma. H mb`mgmaIrAmOhr gwQ>r hmoVr. Xnmar

    VrZ dmOVm _mVaX{jUoar hOa! lram_

    HU `mM nydn[a{MVImobrV ~gbo AmhoV.O{_Zrda MQ>BAmWabobr,Vrda Za|o, ^dZmW dAmUIrhr XmoKoMmKoOU

    ~gbo AmhoV. ~hVoHgdM nmoagdXm AO_mgoEH moUrg drg dfmMo.lram_HU hgV_wImZo

    N>moQ>m nbJS>rda ~gyZ `m_wbm~amo~a _moR>m AmZXmZog mfU H arV AmhoV.

    AmVm dmX KmbUma

    Var H emMm!

    lram_H U dMZm_V

    Omo Y_ gm_`mMr oaUm XoV Zmhr VmoY_M Zho. gm_ hUOo Y_, Y_ hUOo gm_ . H emMohr ^` ~miJyZH m._J nhm Vw_`m hmVyZ HodT>r _moR>r H m }hmo VmV Vr !

    38 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    39/52

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 39

    H a`mV JwJ. OUyH mhr gdOU AJXr g_d`H M !hm`mMo _O`mda _Obo MT>V hmoVo. OUy AmZXmMrnoR>M dg{dUo MmbboAmho .

    _mVa M{H V hmoD Z Vmo AVa` H ma ~KVAmhoV. Vo {dMma H bmJbo, mZmM H m` H mbg_mYrV {Z A>nyd o_mZXmV nm{hb hmoV ? VrM` s H m` AmO gmYmaU _mUgm_mUo `dhma H arVAmho? mZrM H m` _mPm n{h`m {Xder CnXoe Xo`mModoir {VaH ma Hobm hmoVm ? hoM H m` _bm Vwhr _mkmZr Ag hUmbo hmoVo? mZrM H m` gmH ma {ZamH maXmohr g`, Ag gm{JVb hmoV? `mZrM H m _bm

    {eH {dbH s, BaM g` Am{U ggmamVrb ~mH s gma gma A{Z`? `mZrM H m` _bm ggmamV Xmgr_mUoamhm`bm gm{JVb hmoV?

    lram_H U AmZXmV JH Pmbo AmhoV. AYyZ_YyZ_mVamH S>o >r \o H sV AmhoV. `mZm {XgyZ Ambo H s,_mVa M{H V hmoD Z VY ~gyZ AmhoV. Vo nmhZ_J am_bmbmZm g~moYyZ Vo hUmbo , ~{KVbg Zm?`mM d` Oam OmV Amho Zm, hUyZ A_i J ra!hr nmoa BVH s pIXiV AmhoV, nU m`m Vm|S>mda

    gwaHwVrgwm Zmhr! _mVamMo d` hmoVo `m doirgmmdrg`m Odinmg.

    g mfUm`m AmoKmV na_^V hZw_mZm{df`r~mobUo {ZKmbo. hZw_mZmMo EH {M lram_H Um`mImobrV EH m q^Vrda Q>mJbobo hmoVo . lram_H UhUmbo, hZw_VmMm ^md ~K`mgmaIm Amho. YZ,_mZ, XohgwI - `mbm H gbrM dmN>m Zmhr. hdm\ EH ^JdmZ ! \ {Q>H V md Z ~m KoD Z

    Vmonimbm, `m doir _XmoXar ZmZm H maMr \ i nwT>o H Z `mbm bmo XmIdy bmJbr. {~Mmarbm dmQ>b,dmZamMr OmV, \ im`m bmo mZ Imbr `oD Z ~mQ>mHy Z XoBb. nU VmoH m` Agm ^wbVmo hmo ! `mZ Cma {Xb, "_bm H m` \ imMm H m A^md Amho J !C^m O_ g\ i hmoBb Agb \ i bm^b Amho_bm.

    _moj\ im`m dj gmjmV am_ _m`m X`r Amho !lram_H ndjmImbr _r Amam_mZ ~gyZ amhVmo, Oohm`m \ imMr hUyZ dmN>m H aVmo Vohm Vo \ i {_iyZ

    OmV _bm. _bm \ imMm bmo ^ XmI{dVo Amhog Vy,_XmoXar, nU AJ\ imMr ^rH BW hdr Amho Hw Umbm!ho ~K, _bm bmbyM XmI{d`m`m Vw`m H`mM MmJb \ i XoVmo _r Vwbm - ~K, hm Mmbbmo_r !''

    lram_HU gwamda darb Ame`mMo JmUo hUy bmJbo.naV VrM g_mYr ! {ZHn Xoh, pV{_V bmoMZ, JmopWa! nmbIQ> _m Z ~gbo AmhoV - \ moQ>moV {XgVmV`m_mUo. ^ JU Ammm WmoS>m doimnydu EdT>o hgV

    hmoVo, AmVm gdM EH _VmZo lram_H UmMr Vr AX wVAdWm {Z{Z_of ZomZr {ZarjU H arV AmhoV. g_mYrpWVr ~K`mMm _mVamMm hm Xgam gJ.

    ~`mM doimZVa `m AdWoV ~Xb hmoD bmJbm.eara {e{Wb Pmbo, VmR>anUm H _r hmoV Mmbbm._wImda hm` PiHy bmJbo. B{`o nwhm gwairVnUoAmnmnbr H m_oH bmJbr. S>mo`m`m H mon`mVyZAmZXmly dmhVmhoV, _wIr am_Zm_!

    _mVa naV ~wMH `mV nS>bo. hmM _hmnwf

    H m` `m nmoam~amo~a hm`{dZmoX H arV hmoVm? VohmOUy H m` EImX nmM dfmM ~mbH M ! lram_HUEhmZm nyUnUo Xoh^mZmda `oD Z gmYmaU _mUgm_mUo`dhma H bmJbo hmoVo. _mVamZm d Za|mZm g~moYyZVohUmbo , Vwhr XmoKoOU BJOrV JnmJmo>r, dmX{ddmXH am. _r EoHo Z!

    Vo XmoKohr ho EoHy Z hgy bmJbo . XmoKohr AmngmVH mhrVar g mfU H bmJbo, nU ~JmbrV. lram_

    HUmXoIV dmX{ddmX H aUo_mVamZm BV:nV Ae`MhmoVo, `mMm VH{dVH mMm H nm lram_H Um`mHnoZo EH H mao ~XM hmoD Z Jobm hmoVm. AZ AmVmdmX KmbUma Var H emMm! lram_H UmZr nwhm EH XmAmJh H Z nm{hbm, nU BJOrV dmX{ddmX _m hmoDeH bm Zmhr. ***

    lram_H U dMZm_V

    OJmVrb gm`m X:ImMo _yi Amho^rVr, ^` hrM gdmV _mo R>r AYlm Amho.

    {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016 & 39

  • 7/24/2019 Vivek Vichar February 2016

    40/52

    40 & {ddoH {dMma & \o ~wdmar 2016

    dada nmhVm ho gmao C\y VnUo KS>V Ag`mMo

    ^mgdbo OmV AgboVar `m_mJo `m Xoembm pIipIio H a`mMo _moR>o fS>` Amho. N>nVr {edmOr _hmamOmMoZmd `m`Mo Am{U H Vr _m ~m~a, AmaJOo~,A\ PbImZ, {Q>ny `mZm gmOoer H am`Mr. Zmd S>m.~m~mgmho~ Am~oS>H a `mMo `m`Mo Am{U HVrVyZ _mAm~oS>H am`m {dMmamer moh H am`Mm. Aem fS>`mbmIVnmUr Kmb`mMo H m_ {_eZar, Zgbr Am{U{OhmXr e s nS>m_mJyZ H aV AmhoV. Y_dra g mOr_hmamO, N>nVr {edmOr _hmamO, S>m. ~m~mgmho~

    Am~oS>H a `mMr Zmdo gKQ>Zobm {X`m_wio H mboOMrVUmB AmngyH M `m JQ>mH So> AmH fbr OmVo. mgmR>rXmoZ Mma n`mMr {MQ>moarN>mn nwVHo N>mnbr OmVmV.`mVyZ H mod`m VUmB`m _ZmV qhXY_m~b {dfH mbdbo OmVo. hXam~mX oWrb amo{hV do_wbm hm VUhrXXdmZo Aem gmn`mV AS>H bm. eodQ>r `mbm Zam`Ambo Am{U `mZoAm_h`m Ho br. m Am_h`obmhrOmVrMm aJ MT>d`mV Ambm.

    amo{hV do_wbm `mZo Am_h`m H a`mnydu {b{hbobon IynM X`neu Amho. `m nmV VmohUVmo H s,_r Jo`mda _m`m {_mZm dm eyZm mg ZH m XoD .''

    `mMognyU n dmMbo H s `mZmV oVo , AmYrMm amo{hV`m`m OrdZm`m eodQ>`m {XdgmV IynM ~XbbobmAgbm nm{hOo. amo{hV {Zame H m Pmbm, Am_h`m

    H a`m`m {dMmamZo `mMm Vm~m H gm KoVbm, hog_OyZ Ko`mgmR>r WmoSo> _mJoOmUo Amd`H Amho . amo{hVhm `mHy ~ _o_Z `m A{Vao`m`m \ mer`m {damoYmVhmoVm. Vmo EEgE (Am~oS>H a Qy>S>Qg Agmo{gEeZ)Mm gX` hmoVm. Xoem`m {damoYmV `w nwH maUm`m`mHy~Mr \ mer a hmdr `mgmR>r EEgEZo `w{Zh{gQ>rHng_`o EH m mWZm g^oMo Am`moOZ Ho bo hmoVo .Vw_ {H VZo`mHy ~ _mamoJo? ha Ka _| `mHy ~ {ZH b|Jo 'Ago {b{hbobo \ bH PiH dbo Jobo. {dmnrR>mVrb`m Xoemohr {ZXeZm{d ApIb ^maVr` {dmWun[afXo`m gw{eb `m {dm`mZo `m`m \og~wHdmbda naIS> {V{H m {b{hbr Am{U {ZfoY Hobm.`mMm amJ _ZmV Y Z EEgEMo 30 Vo 40 VUgwerb`m dgVrJhmV Kwgbo. gwerbbm O~a _mahmUHobr. \o g~wH darb Vr nmoQ> {S>{bQ> H am`bm bmdbr

    Am{U O~aXVrZo _m\ sMm nmoQ> {b{h`mg mJ nmS>boJobo. J ra OI_r Pm`mZo gw{ebbm hmpnQ>b_`oAS>{_Q> H amdo bmJbo. hr KQ>Zm AmJQ> 2015 _YrbAmho.

    _J gw{eb`m AmBZo {dmnrR>mV OmD Z VH maHobr. _mahmU H aUm`m {dm`mZm H moQ>mV IoMb.`mda {dmnrR>mZoamo{hV Am{U `m`m 4 gmWrXmamZmdgVrJhmVyZ H mTy>Z Q>mH b. nU dJmV ~g`mMr

    Am{U JWmb` dmnam`Mr nadmZJr {Xbr. `m gJ`mKQ>ZmH _mV amo{hV hm S>m. ~m~mgmho~ Am~oS>H a `mMo{dMma _mZUmam hmoVm, Ago H go hUVm `oBb?H mboOMo, {dmnrR>mMo {Z`_ Ym`mda ~gdyZ JwS>{JarH aUm`m {dm`mda H madmB H am`Mr Zmhr H s H m`?`m {R>H mUr X{bV Am{U gdUMm g~Y `oVmoM Hw R>o?

    g_mOm`m ^i^i`mOI_oda Q>dH s _maVmhoV

    go`wba {JYmS>o

    KQ>ZmMH

    Zr{V_mZ hm. eyadra hm. AJXr