uts greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 du… · david eager, hasti hayati and imam...

36
UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research Professor David Eager University of Technology Sydney

Upload: others

Post on 31-Aug-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research

Professor David Eager

University of Technology Sydney

Page 2: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Dubbo greyhounds racing track

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

Page 3: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Track specification at a glance

Bends: 51 m

Length of straight sections: 63 m

Inner track cross fall for bends apexes: 7.76% (4.44°)

Inner track cross fall on the straights: 3.79% (2.17°)

Track path has no transition between straight and bend

Track has a combination of straight and bend starts

Dubbo greyhound racing trackTrack overview

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

Finish 400 m

516 m

318 m

Catchingpen

600 m Dubbo

Page 4: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

UTS injury category

Rating IncapacitationPeriod

Typical injury types

Minor injuries-1 (MINa) 0 days Mild skin abrasion/grazes

Minor injuries-2 (MINb) 1-10 days Grade 1 muscle injuryMild skin laceration

Medium injuries (MED) 11-21 days Join/ligament sprainSkin laceration

Grade 2 muscle injury

Major injuries (MAJ) Greater than 21 days Grade 3 muscle injuryBone fracture

Catastrophic (CATb) Euthanised post-race Euthanised post-race, unable to be retired or unable to raceNB: does not include all data

(deaths)

Catastrophic (CATa) Deceased or euthanised on race day

Severe skull or spinal traumaComplex / Open / Join

fracture

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

Page 5: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Injury levels

CATa + CATbLevel 1

CATa + CATb + MAJLevel 2

CATa + CATb + MAJ + MEDLevel 3

CATa + CATb + MAJ + MED + MINa + MINbLevel 4

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

Page 6: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Dubbo greyhound racing trackInterventions date

Hoop lure introduced on 29th June 2017 at Dubbo track

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

Page 7: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

Level 1 normalised injuries in 2017

Num

ber

of

inju

ries

per

100

0 st

arts

NSW Tracks

c

Page 8: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

c

Level 1 normalised injuries in 2016N

umber

of

inju

ries

per

100

0 st

arts

NSW Tracks

Page 9: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Level 2 normalised injuries in 2017N

umber

of

inju

ries

per

100

0 st

arts

NSW Tracks

Page 10: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Level 2 normalised injuries in 2016

Num

ber

of

inju

ries

per

100

0 st

arts

NSW Tracks

Page 11: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Dubbo greyhound racing trackLevel 1 injuries 2016 and 2017

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

Page 12: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Dubbo greyhound racing trackLevel 2 injuries 2017 and 2016

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

Page 13: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Dubbo greyhounds racing trackInjury locations 2016 and 2017

Page 14: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Dubbo greyhounds racing trackInjury locations 2016 and 2017

Page 15: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Dubbo greyhounds racing trackInjury locations 2016 and 2017

Page 16: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Greyhounds stride analysis

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

Page 17: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Greyhounds stride pattern Acceleration data acquisition

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

Sandy-loam track way (≈ 7.9% or 4.5° cross fall)

Greyhound

Jacket

Fore-legs

Fc

FV

X

YZ

Page 18: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Greyhounds stride analysis Straight running

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

Left foreleg Right

foreleg Flight compressed Right

hindleg Left hindleg Flight

extended

40 80 120 160 200 240 280Time (ms)

4640

5448

4452

Page 19: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Greyhounds stride analysis Straight running

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

Left foreleg

Right foreleg

Flight compressed

Right hindleg

Left hindleg

Flight extended

0 3 6

Distance (m)

2.22 2.930.8 5.36

Left foreleg

0.0

Page 20: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Track design investigation

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

Page 21: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Track design investigationGreyhounds on the bends

Acceleration of a greyhound on the bend top view

Major forces acting on a greyhound on the straight side view

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

ax Forward accelerationay Centripetal accelerationa Resultant acceleration

Weight of greyhound

Frictional forceFrom the track /Shear strength of track Normal force from the ground

Reference frameZ

X

Y

ay

a

ax

Page 22: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Track design investigationGreyhounds on the bends

Forces acting on a greyhound on the bend front view

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

Greyhound’s weight

Greyhound’s centre of gravityCentrifugal force

Friction from the ground (!") / ground’s shear strength

≈ 57° greyhound’s lean

Reference frame

Track cross fall (#) ≈ 7.9% (4.5°)Normal force from the ground

Track width ≈ 5m

Track bend 51m

Y

ZX

Page 23: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Track design investigationWhat can be done for cross falls at the tracks

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

Maximum leaning relative to the ground

High cross fall

Horizontal components of normal force and friction provide centripetal force

Normal force

Friction

Horizontal component of normal force provides centripetal force

Normal force

No leaning relative to the ground

Low cross fall

Track bend (m)

Track cross falls (%)

Track cross falls (deg)

45 78.1 38

50 70 35

55 62.5 32

60 57.7 30

65 53.2 28

70 46.6 25

Optimum

Current

Optimum cross falls

Page 24: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Track design investigationWhat can be done for cross falls at the tracks

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

Track surface grades from surveyed data

Track surface grades existing

Track surface grades improved

Page 25: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Track design investigationContinuity of a track path

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

A

Second order

A

First order

Page 26: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Track design investigationStraight to bend path types in GRNSW tracks

No transition (N)

Part transition (P)

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

Track straight sectionTrack straight section

Page 27: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Track design investigationCase study Richmond 400 m starts immediate bend

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

Page 28: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Most injury prone GRNSW tracks starts and corners

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

Page 29: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Most injury prone GRNSW tracks starts and corners in 2016Worst five starts and corresponding corners

1. Grafton 480 m starts Back turn exit corner

2. Nowra 365 m starts Back turn exit corner

3. Grafton 305 m starts Home turn in corner

4. Casino 484 m starts Back turn in corner

5. Gosford 515 m starts Back turn in corner

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

Page 30: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Most injury prone GRNSW tracks starts and corners in 2016Grafton 480 m starts Back turn exit corner

480mstart

Catchingpen

Finish

Backturn

Hometurn

Backstraight

Homestraight

Number of starts: 847Number of races: 111

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

CatastrophicMajor injuryMedium injuryMinor injury

Page 31: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Most injury prone GRNSW tracks starts and corners in 2016Nowra 365 m starts Back turn exit corner

365mstart

Catchingpen

Finish

Backturn

Hometurn

Backstraight

Homestraight

Number of starts: 2396Number of races: 311

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

CatastrophicMajor injuryMedium injuryMinor injury

Page 32: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Most injury prone GRNSW tracks starts and corners in 2016Grafton 305 m starts Home turn in corner

305mstart Catching

pen

Finish

Backturn

Hometurn

Backstraight

Homestraight

Number of starts: 1071Number of races: 138

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

CatastrophicMajor injuryMedium injuryMinor injury

Page 33: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Most injury prone GRNSW tracks starts and corners in 2016Casino 484 m starts Back turn in corner

484mstart

Catchingpen

Finish

Backturn

Hometurn

Number of starts: 1943Number of races: 252

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

CatastrophicMajor injuryMedium injuryMinor injury

Page 34: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Most injury prone GRNSW tracks starts and corners in 2016Gosford 515 m starts Back turn in corner

515mstart

Catchingpen

Finish

Backturn

Hometurn

Backstraight

Homestraight

Number of starts: 2130Number of races: 277

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

CatastrophicMajor injuryMedium injuryMinor injury

Page 35: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

UTS phase I recommendationsAverage injury rate for Level 2 injuries 2016

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018

12% difference

Injuries per 1000 starts

Straight starts

Bend starts

Page 36: UTS greyhounds safety and welfare research 04 15 Du… · David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018 Catastrophic Major injury Medium injury Minor injury. UTS phase

Q & A

David Eager, Hasti Hayati and Imam Hossain – April 2018