utilization of solid waste fuels through fluidized bed ......utilization of solid waste fuels...

19
UTILIZATION OF SOLID WASTE FUELS THROUGH FLUIDIZED BED COMBUSTION HENRY S. KWON Dorr-Oliver, Inc_ Stamford, Connecticut JOHN F. LAUKAITIS Keeler/Dorr-Ol iver Williamsport, Pennsylvania JEAN-PAUL LEGLISE OTV Paris, France ABSTRACT Low grade anthracite coal waste has been successfully burned in a fluidized bed combustor for steam generation_ Fluidized bed cl'mbustors capable of burning either wood waste or coal are being designed and built to generate hot water for district heating_ Emissions of air pollutants from these fuels are low. IN TRODUCTION Fluidized bed combustion offers an environmentally acceptable means of utilizing various solid waste fuels for the generation of heat for industrial use. Anthracite coal waste called culm has been accumulating above ground in Pennsylvania for over the last 100 years, polluting the en- vironment and contributing to generally depressed condi- tions. Although its potential as an energy source has long been recognized, actual use of this fuel has not material- ized because conventional combustion devices such as stokers cannot effectively burn the fuel due to its ex- tremely high ash content. In 1978 the Department of Energy awarded a contract to the Shamokin Area In- dustrial Corporation ( S A IC) of Shamokin, Pennsylvania to design, construct and operate a fluidized bed boiler using the culm waste as fueL The boiler was designed and built for S A IC through a joint effort of a fluidized bed supplier, Dorrliver, Inc. and a boiler manufacturer, E. Keeler Company (now the Keeler/Dorr-Oliver Boiler Com- pany). In the summer of 1981, the boiler was started-up and burned this waste fuel for 10, 000 hr generating steam until April 1983 when the plant was shut down due to the lack of funding. Sulfur capture was better than ex- pected and emissions of CO and NO x were found to be very low. OTV, the French licensee of Dorr- Oliver, Inc. was awarded a contract to design and construct two fluidized bed boilers for the Cite de ClairVivre to generate hot water for district heating. The boilers are designed to burn saw- dust and wood chips and alternatively to burn bituminous coal, when wood wastes are not available. The Cite is a public institution with a population of over 1000, in- cluding professional and administrative staffs. Current heating systems consist of small oil burning boilers and stoves located in various parts of the institution. Annual oil consumption is approximately 700,000 gal (2200 t). The institution is located in the middle of a forest land where wood wastes have been accumulated over the years. The institution realized that the wastes are a potential source of energy for heating. At the same time, it hopes to reduce the impact of the wastes on the surrounding en- vironment. The criteria for the selection of boiler system was not only economic justification, but energy efficiency and multifuel burning capability. The dispersed heating systems are currently being centralized and the two fluid- ized bed boilers are designed to supply heat to the new central heating system. The boilers are scheduled to start up early in 1984. 282 SHAMOKIN CULM BURN IN G BOILER DESIGN CRITERIA The boiler was designed to generate 23,400 lb/hr (10,620 kg/h) of 200 psig (1,380 kpa) saturated steam with a turndown capability of 2.5 to 1 . The steam gen- erated was intended for consumption at a nearby paper manufacturer 24 hr/day. The culm supplied to the boiler plant is mine breaker residue rejects from an anthracite coal mine s ized to

Upload: others

Post on 29-Mar-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Utilization of Solid Waste Fuels Through Fluidized Bed ......UTILIZATION OF SOLID WASTE FUELS THROUGH FLUIDIZED BED COMBUSTION HENRY S. KWON Dorr-Oliver, Inc_ Stamford, Connecticut

UTILIZATION OF SOLID WASTE FUELS THROUGH FLUIDIZED BED COMBUSTION

HENRY S. KWON Dorr-Oliver, Inc_

Stamford, Connecticut

JOHN F. LAUKAITIS Keeler/Dorr-Ol iver

Williamsport, Pennsylvania

JEAN-PAUL LEG LISE OTV

Paris, France

ABSTRACT

Low grade anthracite coal waste has been successfully burned in a fluidized bed combustor for steam generation_ Fluidized bed cl'mbustors capable of burning either wood waste or coal are being designed and built to generate hot water for district heating_ Emissions of air pollutants from these fuels are low.

IN TRODUCTION

Fluidized bed combustion offers an environmentally acceptable means of utilizing various solid waste fuels for the generation of heat for industrial use. Anthracite coal waste called culm has been accumulating above ground in Pennsylvania for over the last 100 years, polluting the en­vironment and contributing to generally depressed condi­tions. Although its potential as an energy source has long been recognized, actual use of this fuel has not material­ized because conventional combustion devices such as stokers cannot effectively burn the fuel due to its ex­tremely high ash content. In 1978 the Department of Energy awarded a contract to the Shamokin Area In­dustrial Corporation ( S A IC) of Shamokin, Pennsylvania to design, construct and operate a fluidized bed boiler using the culm waste as fueL The boiler was designed and built for S A IC through a joint effort of a fluidized bed supplier, Dorr-Oliver, Inc. and a boiler manufacturer, E. Keeler Company (now the Keeler/Dorr-Oliver Boiler Com­pany). In the summer of 1981, the boiler was started-up and burned this waste fuel for 10, 000 hr generating steam until April 1983 when the plant was shut down due to the lack of funding. Sulfur capture was better than ex­pected and emissions of C O and NOx were found to be very low.

OTV, the French licensee of Dorr-Oliver, Inc. was awarded a contract to design and construct two fluidized bed boilers for the Cite de ClairVivre to generate hot water for district heating. The boilers are designed to burn saw­dust and wood chips and alternatively to burn bituminous coal, when wood wastes are not available. The Cite is a public institution with a population of over 1000, in­cluding professional and administrative staffs. Current heating systems consist of small oil burning boilers and stoves located in various parts of the institution. Annual oil consumption is approximately 700,000 gal (2200 t). The institution is located in the middle of a forest land where wood wastes have been accumulated over the years. The institution realized that the wastes are a potential source of energy for heating. At the same time, it hopes to reduce the impact of the wastes on the surrounding en­vironment. The criteria for the selection of boiler system was not only economic justification, but energy efficiency and multifuel burning capability. The dispersed heating systems are currently being centralized and the two fluid­ized bed boilers are designed to supply heat to the new central heating system. The boilers are scheduled to start up early in 1984.

282

SHAMOKIN CULM BURN IN G BOILER

DESIGN CRITERIA

The boiler was designed to generate 23,400 lb/hr (10,620 kg/h) of 200 psig (1,380 kpa) saturated steam with a turndown capability of 2.5 to 1. The steam gen­erated was intended for consumption at a nearby paper manufacturer 24 hr/day.

The culm supplied to the boiler plant is mine breaker residue rejects from an anthracite coal mine sized to

Page 2: Utilization of Solid Waste Fuels Through Fluidized Bed ......UTILIZATION OF SOLID WASTE FUELS THROUGH FLUIDIZED BED COMBUSTION HENRY S. KWON Dorr-Oliver, Inc_ Stamford, Connecticut

minus 4 in. (100 mm). The specified fuel had heating values ranging from 3000 to 5000 Btu/lb (5975 to 11,625 kJ/kg) with approximately 0.6 percent sulfur con­tent. The typical fuel analysis is given in Table 1. The de­sign parameters for the fluidized bed boiler are sum­marized in Table 2.

PLANT DESCRIPTION

Plant design was based on laboratory combustion tests using culm. Test objectives were to determine optimal feed size, bed temperature, calcium to sulfur ratio, and the effects of ash reinjection.

CULM AND LIMESTONE FEED

The laboratory test results showed that the culm had to be sized to minus 4 mesh in order to achieve good com� bustion. This requirement necessitated the installation of a culm preparation system consisting of culm crushing and screening prior to feeding the culm to the boiler.

The limestone supplied was from a local limestone quarry and was mainly mine rejects with no commercial value. The combustion tests also showed that the lime­stone should be of minus 1/4 in. size. Schematics of feed preparation and storage are shown in Fig. 1 .

Both culm and limestone were fed to the boiler with screw feeders. Two 9 in. (230 mm) feeders were used for the culm and one 4 in. (100 mm) for the limestone. Vari­able speed motor drives were used on each feeder to allow culm feed rate to follow steam demand and combustion temperature and to permit limestone feed rate to respond to the S02 emission control requirements.

FLUIDIZED BED BOILER SYSTEM

The primary objective of the project was to demon­strate the feasibility of industrial boiler operation using waste culm as a sole fuel. Emphasis was placed on the development of a boiler design which would offer availa­bility, reliability, Simplified operation, and ruggedness re­quired for commercial use. Figure 2 shows schematic of the boiler system. The boiler is of water wall design with in-bed vertical tubes and a convection section. It was de­signed to generate approximately half of the steam in the in-bed tubes and the waterwall tubes and the other half in the convection section by recovering heat from the combustion gases.

Combustion air is introduced at the bottom of fluid­ized bed through air distributing tuyeres. The windbo"x is divided into three zones to aid in start-up and turndown

operation. Each zone has its own air supply line leading from a common combustion air blower. One zone cover­ing 64 percent of the bed area is the first bed area to be fluidized at start-up and remains fluidized during opera­tion. Each of the remaining two zones covers 18 percent of the bed area and contains four in-bed tubes. Either or both of these sections can be defluidized during turndown conditions. The boiler also contains an internal convection bank dust hopper with a flapper valve for recycling col­lected dust.

Further ash recycling and particulate control are ac­complished through a two stage cyclone system where ashes collected in the primary cyclone are recycled back to the boiler.

An oil fired burner is also included to serve as a preheat bu�ner during start-up. The burner raises the bed tempera­ture up to the combustion temperature of bituminous coal. BituminouS- coal then brings the bed temperature further up to the culm combustion temperature.

AIR PREHEATER

Combustion gases leave the cyclones at 660°F (349°C). To improve the overall efficiency of the boiler system, heat is recovered by indirect gas to air heat exchange in the air preheater. It is a conventional shell and tube type heat exchanger. The combustion gases cool down to 350°F (177°C) and the combustion air is heated to 425°F (218°C).

ASH COOLER AND ASH CONVEYING

Ashes from the fluidized bed and the cyclones are cooled to approximately 250°F (121 0c) in the ash cooler. The ash cooler is a fluidized bed cooling device containing in-bed cooling tubes for more efficient cooling.

The water in the cooling coils is boiler feedwater. This system recovers some of the sensible heat from hot ash and transmits it to the feed water. The ash cooler is equipped with its own fluidizing blower and cyclone. The ash is discharged through rotary valves to the pneumatic ash conveying system which transports the ash to the ash silo.

BAG FILTER

A conventional pulse-jet bag filter is used as the final particulate control device. The bag fllter has an air-to-cloth ratio of 6 to 1 and the bag material is Nomex felt.

283

Page 3: Utilization of Solid Waste Fuels Through Fluidized Bed ......UTILIZATION OF SOLID WASTE FUELS THROUGH FLUIDIZED BED COMBUSTION HENRY S. KWON Dorr-Oliver, Inc_ Stamford, Connecticut

N

00

"""

Cu

lm

P

il

e

L�

-

-')�

F

ro

nt

E

nd

L

oa

de

r

Li

me

st

on

e

Si

lo

Vi

br

at

in

g

Ho

pp

er

Sc

re

w

Co

nv

ey

or

Be

lt

C

on

ve

yo

r

Bu

ck

et

E

le

va

to

r

To

L

im

es

to

ne

F

ee

d

Bi

n

Cu

lm

C

ru

sh

er

Vi

br

at

in

g

Sc

re

en

Bu

ck

et

E

le

va

to

r

i S

cr

ee

ne

d

Cu

lm

S

il

o

Sc

re

w

Co

nv

ey

or

FIG

.1

FE

ED

PR

EP

AR

AT

ION

AN

D S

TO

RA

GE

(S

HA

MO

KIN

AF

B B

OIL

ER

)

Bu

ck

et

El

ev

at

or

To

C

ul

m

Fe

ed

B

in

Page 4: Utilization of Solid Waste Fuels Through Fluidized Bed ......UTILIZATION OF SOLID WASTE FUELS THROUGH FLUIDIZED BED COMBUSTION HENRY S. KWON Dorr-Oliver, Inc_ Stamford, Connecticut

tv

00

lJl

Li

me

st

on

e

Cu

lm

Cu

lm

F

ee

d

Bi

n

Sc

re

w

Fe

ed

er

Li

me

st

on

e

Fe

ed

B

in

St

ea

m

Fl

ui

di

ze

d

Be

d

Bo

il

er

Cy

cl

on

e

As

h

Co

ol

er

Pr

eh

ea

te

d

Ai

r

To

B

oi

le

r �(- A

ir

P

re

he

at

er

To

A

sh

S

il

o

---To

ph

er

e

Ba

gh

ou

se

--- I

.D.

Fa

n

-----�

As

h

Di

sp

os

al

Pr

eh

ea

te

d

Ai

r

Fr

om

A

ir

P

re

he

at

er

FIG

.2

BO

ILE

R S

YS

TE

M (

SH

AM

OK

IN A

FB

BO

ILE

R)

Fl

ui

di

zi

ng

B

lo

we

r

As

h

Co

ol

er

F

lu

id

iz

in

g

Bl

ow

er

Page 5: Utilization of Solid Waste Fuels Through Fluidized Bed ......UTILIZATION OF SOLID WASTE FUELS THROUGH FLUIDIZED BED COMBUSTION HENRY S. KWON Dorr-Oliver, Inc_ Stamford, Connecticut

OPERATING EXPERIENCE

Plant start-up and shakedown lasted three months. During this period many mechanical bugs were corrected and computer control systems were adjusted. The start-up procedure was also revised as required. After this period, the boiler was in continuous operation until the project was terminated, except for several scheduled shutdowns.

START-UP AND SHA KEDOWN

During the start-up it was found that the preheat burner did not have enough capacity to raise the bed temperature to the culm combustion temperature. As a result, bitumi­nous coal was added to obtain a bed temperature at which culm combustion could be sustained. After attaining the culm combustion temperature it was also learned that the bed temperature could not be maintained with only culm. Spot check of culm samples taken during this period in­dica ted that the culm had only 3100 Btu/lb (7208 kJ /kg) heating value and 72 percent ash. For this low heating value, bed heat transfer was simply too excessive.

In order to balance the lower heating value of the culm with the culm combustion temperature in-bed heat transfer was artificially reduced by adding refractory to parts of the in-bed water walls. The combustor was then able to sustain the culm combustion temperature with culm only.

One recurring problem was in the culm crushing and screening operation. Heavy rains or cold weather coupled with high moisture content, which sometimes exceeded 10 percent, caused screen blinding which limited fuel feeding capacity. Once the culm was crushed and screened, wetness of the culm did not affect culm combustion in the fluidized bed_

BOILER PERFORMANCE

Culm fuel composition fluctuated a great deal and ac­cordingly cUl-':fl feed rate was frequently adjusted to maintain bed temperature. Table 3 shows the actual fuel analysis during the parametric tests. Often the culm ex­hibited a heating value of around 3000 Btu/lb (6975 kJ/kg), which required culm feeding in excess of the design feed rate. In spite of the wide variation in fuel properties, steam output remained essentially a linear function of culm feed rate (Fig. 3). Combustion efficien­cies expressed as carbon burn-up, generally remained around 90 percent as shown in Fig. 4. The figure also shows that culm burn-up is lower, when burning culm at lower bed temperatures.

286

BOILER TUBES

As mentioned earlier, the boiler is of waterwall design with 8 vertical in-bed tubes. Although pilot plant tests showed no sign of tube metal wastage, tubes were pre­selected for periodic measurements of tube thickness. The preselected tubes are 2 in-bed tubes, 3 sidewall tubes, 2 convection screen tubes, and 4 convection outlet tubes. Point locations for measurements were selected where erosion would be most likely. Ultrasonic technique was used for the measurements. After 10,224 hr of operation the measurements indicated that there was virtually no erosion in any of the tubes tested. The in-bed tubes and the sidewall tubes were polished in the areas which were affected by turbulent action of the bed. However, actual measurements showed minimal amount of change in thickness, as indicated in Table 5. These tubes had been suspected of being most likely candidates for erosion. The surfaces of the convection screen tubes and the convection outlet tubes appeared to maintain their original state.

EMISSIONS

In spite of the low combustion efficiencies experi­enced with the culm, CO emissions did not exceed 125 ppm .during the 10,000 hr of operation. Low volatile content of the culm may have attributed to the low CO emissions. S02 emissions were maintained at 100 ppm except when sulfur capture was studied as a function of calcium to sulfur ratio. S02 removal in excess of 90 percent was readily attainable at a calcium to sulfur ratio greater than 2.5. S02 removal efficiency as a function of Ca/S ratio is shown in Fig. 5. N Ox emissions ranged from 50 to 300 ppm. Figure 6 shows that NOx emissions tend to increase with excess air. Lower excess air means higher CO emission, which in turn contributes to lower NOx emission. Particulate emission tests were run in April 1983 according to the EPA Method 5. The results showed an average 0.079 Ib/million Btu (34 ng/J) of particulate emission at the stack.

CLAIRVIVRE WOOD/COAL BURN IN G BOILERS

ECONOMIC CONSIDERATION

In 1982 the annual fuel bill in the district amounted to over 6 million francs ($705,800) at the current rate of heating oil consumption. Wood wastes can be obtained at a cost of 90 francs ($ 10.5) per metric ton (t) including transportation, which means an annual fuel cost of only 1 million francs ($ 117,600) with wood wastes_ Therefore, an annual saving of 5 million francs ($588,200) can be realized from fuel alone.

Page 6: Utilization of Solid Waste Fuels Through Fluidized Bed ......UTILIZATION OF SOLID WASTE FUELS THROUGH FLUIDIZED BED COMBUSTION HENRY S. KWON Dorr-Oliver, Inc_ Stamford, Connecticut

30,

00

0

o

25,

00

0

o

0 -'"

20

,0

00

I

0 �

I ..

..........- 0 - Cf.l

1

!Xl

t-l

0 0

H

15,

00

0

:::>

tv

p...

()O

H

0 -.J

::

:> 0

0

0

� 10

.0

00

000

,.

... 0

0

H

0

<0 0

-Cf.l

.J

TY- 0

0 I

5,

00

0

200

0

40

00

6

00

0

800

0

10,

00

0

12;

00

0

FU

EL

IN

PU

T,

LB

S/

HR

FIG

.3

ST

EA

M P

RO

DU

CT

ION

VS

FE

ED

IN

PU

T (

SH

AM

OK

IN A

FB

BO

ILE

R)

Page 7: Utilization of Solid Waste Fuels Through Fluidized Bed ......UTILIZATION OF SOLID WASTE FUELS THROUGH FLUIDIZED BED COMBUSTION HENRY S. KWON Dorr-Oliver, Inc_ Stamford, Connecticut

10

0

90

.J

o Oc:O

O 0

0 -f"'.

0

0

0 -

....,

0

00

8

0

J 0

0

0

0

0

70

60

50

p..

tv

40

00

I

00

Z

30

z

0

20

� u

10

o

140

0

14

50

15

00

15

50

16

00

1

65

0

170

0

BE

D

TE

MPE

RAT

UR

E

of

FIG

.4

CA

RB

ON

BU

RN

-UP

VS

BE

D T

EM

PE

RA

TU

RE

(S

HA

MO

KIN

AF

B B

OIL

ER

)

Page 8: Utilization of Solid Waste Fuels Through Fluidized Bed ......UTILIZATION OF SOLID WASTE FUELS THROUGH FLUIDIZED BED COMBUSTION HENRY S. KWON Dorr-Oliver, Inc_ Stamford, Connecticut

DESIGN CRITERIA

Two boilers are being designed and installed to gener­ate, during the period of peak demand for heat, hot water equivalent to 12 million Btu/hr (3.5 MW) and 20 million Btu/hr (5.8 MW) each. Heat demand varies de­pending on weather conditions and each boiler is capable of operating at a turndown ratio of 4. Hot water is to be distributed to the various buildings and shops through a central heating network.

The wood wastes are rejects from wood harvesting and processing. Moisture content is found to be up to 50 per­cent by weight and heating value to be 4200 Btu/Ib (9765 kJ/kg) on as-received basis. Table 6 shows the typical fuel analysis for wood wastes and coal. The de­sign parameters for the 20 million Btu/hr (5.8 MW) unit are summarized in Table 7.

PLANT DESCR IPTION

The plant consists of fuel preparation for wood wastes, fluidized bed boilers, and gas clean-up equipment. A com­mon feed system can handle both fuels and change-over

. offuel can be made during operation without interruption of heat supply.

FUEL PREPARATION AND STORAGE

Wood wastes are delivered unprocessed by truck to the site. After weighing, the wastes are stored on the open ground. A front end loader moves the material to a trans­fer hopper. It is then conveyed to a screen where material larger than 1 � in. (30 mm) is screened out for size reduc­tion. Feed material passing through the screen is then stored in two silos. The screen rejects are recycled to a hammer crusher where the size is reduced.

Coal is delivered presized to minus 1 � in. (30 mm) and stored on the open ground adjacent to the storage silos. When needed, the coal is loaded into the silo. Fuel preparation and storage systems are shown in Fig. 7.

FUEL FEED

Feed material is extracted from the storage silos and conveyed to a feed hopper. A short screw conveyor then feeds the material into the feed chute of each boiler. The fuel is gravity fed into the fluidized bed.

289

FLUIDIZED BED BOILER SYSTEM

The boilers are required to operat� continuously sup­plying hot water, as demanded, without interruption even during change-over of fuel. In addition, reliability, rugged­ness, and simplified operation are also required. Figure 8 shows schematic of the boiler system. The boiler itself is comprised of a fluidized bed furnace and a convection bank. The furnace is designed to operate at bed tempera­tures ranging from 1300°F (700°C) to 1650°F (900°e) depending on type of fuel. Cooling coils in the bed con­trol the bed temperature by removing excess heat. The cooling tubes are vertically arranged between the lower and the upper water headers along the combustion walls. Depending on heat input, bed height is controlled to main­tain the bed temperature at design conditions. The con-o vection bank recovers sensible heat from combustion gases. The water circuits in the boiler are of forced circu­lation type and recycled water from the heating system is boiler feed water . The temperature of gases leaving the bank is sufficiently low for the baghouse.

Combustion air is first distributed through sparge pipes which are located under the bed. The air is further dis­tributed into multiple tuyeres attached to each sparge pipe. The sparge pipes are equipped with shut-off valves, which enable partial slumping of the bed for turndown operations. Secondary air is introduced, as necessary, over the bed to enhance freeboard burning. Elutriated ashes are partially collected in the convection bank hopper and are recycled back to the bed.

A burner is included to serve as a preheat burner during start-up. The burner heats the initial bed of sand up to the combustion temperature of the fuel. When fuel is fed into the bed, the burner is turned off.

ASH COOLIN G

When ash is excessively built up in the bed or it is necessary to lower the bed height, bed ash is drained out by gravity and cooled for disposal or reuse at a later date.

GAS CLEAN-UP

Combustion gases are initially cleaned in a cyclone. Collected ashes can be recycled back to the bed if neces­sary. Final particulate emission control is accomplished by a conventional bag filter 0 OPERATING EXPERIEN CE

The boilers are scheduled to start up early in 1984 and operating experience will be presented during the June 1984 conference.

Page 9: Utilization of Solid Waste Fuels Through Fluidized Bed ......UTILIZATION OF SOLID WASTE FUELS THROUGH FLUIDIZED BED COMBUSTION HENRY S. KWON Dorr-Oliver, Inc_ Stamford, Connecticut

REFEREN CES ceedings of the 7th International Conference on Fluidized Bed Combustion, Volume 1, p. 567, October 25-27,1982.

[1] D. G. Chiplunker and H. S. Kwon, "Performance of a

Fluidized Bed Steam Generator Burning Anthracite Culm," Pro-[2] Dorr-oliver Internal Memo, "Final Report on Shamokin

Boiler Tube Metal Thickness Measurement," September IS, 1983 .

,

• Key Words: Boiler . Emission. Energy. Fluidized Bed • Solid. Waste Control. Wood

TABLE 1 ULTIMATE ANALYSIS OF CULM (DESIGN BASIS, % WT)

Ca rbon

Hydrogen

Nitrogen

Oxygen

Sulfur

Ash

Heating Value

HHV

27.02

1.42

0.66

3.48

0.57

66.85

4,198 Btu/lb

(9,760 kj/kg)

---------------------------.----

290

Page 10: Utilization of Solid Waste Fuels Through Fluidized Bed ......UTILIZATION OF SOLID WASTE FUELS THROUGH FLUIDIZED BED COMBUSTION HENRY S. KWON Dorr-Oliver, Inc_ Stamford, Connecticut

100

90

o

o

80

70

rz:I

p:::

60

0

E-I � U

p:::

50

� H

tv

0

40

\0

U)

......

I •

30

20

10

1 2

3 4

5

6

CA

/s

M

OL

AR

RA

TIO

FIG

.5

S

UL

FU

R C

AP

TU

RE

VS

CA

/S R

AT

IO (

SH

AM

OK

IN A

FB

BO

ILE

R)

Page 11: Utilization of Solid Waste Fuels Through Fluidized Bed ......UTILIZATION OF SOLID WASTE FUELS THROUGH FLUIDIZED BED COMBUSTION HENRY S. KWON Dorr-Oliver, Inc_ Stamford, Connecticut

o

o o C"')

o

o lI"'I N

o o N

o

6> o

o

o lI"'I ,...,

Wdd 'SNOISSI� xON

292

o o ,...,

o

o

o

o lI"'I

o

o

o

o o ,...,

o 00

o '"

o N

o

-

a: w ..J -

o !Xl !Xl u.. « z -

a: -

« (I) (I) w U X w (I) > (I) Z o -(I) (I) -

� W x

o Z \Q • (!' -

u..

Page 12: Utilization of Solid Waste Fuels Through Fluidized Bed ......UTILIZATION OF SOLID WASTE FUELS THROUGH FLUIDIZED BED COMBUSTION HENRY S. KWON Dorr-Oliver, Inc_ Stamford, Connecticut

tv

\0

W

Tr

uc

k

Un

lo

ad

in

g ,

'-�

'-�

"

"0.

Fr

on

t

En

d

Lo

ad

er

0.

II I

Tr

an

sf

er

H

op

pe

r

Fe

ed

D

is

tr

ib

ut

iul

llt S

cr

ew

s

I � T

o

Bo

il

er

Cr

us

he

r

r i Tr

an

sf

er

C

on

ve

yo

r

t T

o

Bo

il

er

Ma

gn

et

ic

S

ep

ar

at

or

Me

ta

l

I , R

ej

ec

ts

Sc

re

en

ed

F

ee

d

... ,

Sc

re

en

..

.... ..

....

Re

je

ct

s

fo

r

Re

cy

cl

e

St

or

ag

e S

il

os

Co

al

P

il

e

Fe

ed

D

is

ch

ar

ge

D

ev

ic

e

FIG

.7

FE

ED

PR

EP

AR

AT

ION

AN

D S

TO

RA

GE

(C

LA

IRV

IVR

E A

FB

BO

ILE

RS

)

Page 13: Utilization of Solid Waste Fuels Through Fluidized Bed ......UTILIZATION OF SOLID WASTE FUELS THROUGH FLUIDIZED BED COMBUSTION HENRY S. KWON Dorr-Oliver, Inc_ Stamford, Connecticut

tV

\0

Feed

Bi

n I

• ..

. ,

' : .. • • •

• • • • • � • . . ! •

• •

• l·· . �

.. • .. I .. ··

· .

• • • .L

Hot

Wate

r C

nvec

tion

Ban

k l'

.-L

•.

.

,.

p"

..

.. ,

.,

' .. J �

.

• • • .. .

. «

' T

' -' • • • •

LU.

U. ..

. U. t-

1.1"

... �/ 1

..

. ,. "

••

• • •

1 • •

• I

I I

• •

L �_

<-

r T

o B

agho

use

..

• : e

yclo

ne

..

• •

'. T

'

Wat

er T

ubes

\·J

a ter

Mete

ri ng

Sc

rew

Feed

Ch

ute

• • • .. � '. • • • .. .. .' . , , '.' • • • • .' .

'", •

- -

Bed

I .. · .. .. • i '. : '"

I • I • • ' 1'·:- · ' . • • · . • • •

,. K • I':· • • • • •

· I�'

· .

• •

..

. I:'·· �.

A

• · . •

• � .

' #.

Rein

ject

ion

Wate

r ..

Scre

w

: ) .. .

i':: :;

;:J'. -. -:

: -:: :.

--..

:':

C b

·: .

....

...

...

.... ,

v . • -..

. ........

... ,

I /

om

.. .

.....

. .., . . ·A

•• ··. ,'·

: :··.·

: ... .. .

. , ••

••• '�

./

us

10

nL

••

.•

"

' ......

........ .

'4'",

Ai

r �I

I

, . ....

-,

.v To

Ash

Coo

ler

FIG

.8

FL

UID

IZE

D B

ED

BO

ILE

R (

CL

AIR

VIV

RE

AF

B B

OIL

ER

S)

� \,} �

Ash

or

Re

inje

ctio

n As

h Di

spos

al

Page 14: Utilization of Solid Waste Fuels Through Fluidized Bed ......UTILIZATION OF SOLID WASTE FUELS THROUGH FLUIDIZED BED COMBUSTION HENRY S. KWON Dorr-Oliver, Inc_ Stamford, Connecticut

TABLE 2 DESIGN PARAMETERS (SHAMOKIN AFB BOILER) -------------------------------------------------------------------BOILER

Steam Flow

Steam Condition

Culm Feed Rate

Culm Feed Size

Culm Heating Value

Limestone Feed Rate

Limestone Feed Size

Bed Temperature

Bed Height

Excess Air

Turndown (Steam)

Fluidizing Velocity

EMISSIONS

Particulates (State)

S02

295

23,400 lb/hr (10,620 kg/h r)

200 psig sat. (1,380 kpa)

8,188 lb/hr (3,714 kg/h r)

Minus 4 mesh

4,198 Btu/lb (9,7 60 kj/kg)

983 lb/hr "(446 kg/h r)

Minus 1/4 inch (6.3mm)

1,450-1,650°F (788-900°C)

3-6 ft (0.91-1.82m)

20-50%

2.5: 1

3.5-6 fps (1.07-1.82 m/s)

0.4 lb/million Btu (172 ng/j)

0.33 lb/million Btu (142 ng/j)

Equivalent to 88% capture

140 ppm

Page 15: Utilization of Solid Waste Fuels Through Fluidized Bed ......UTILIZATION OF SOLID WASTE FUELS THROUGH FLUIDIZED BED COMBUSTION HENRY S. KWON Dorr-Oliver, Inc_ Stamford, Connecticut

TABLE 3 ACTUAL COMPOSITION OF CULM (% WTI

Carbon

Hydrogen

Nitrogen

Oxygen

Sulfur

Ash

Heating Value

HHV

296

24.15 - 26.59

0.89 - 1.04

0.47 - 0.56

3.06 - 5.33

0.73 - 0.94

67.3 - 69.3

3,918 - 4,164 Btu/lb

(9,109 - 9,680 kj/kg)

Page 16: Utilization of Solid Waste Fuels Through Fluidized Bed ......UTILIZATION OF SOLID WASTE FUELS THROUGH FLUIDIZED BED COMBUSTION HENRY S. KWON Dorr-Oliver, Inc_ Stamford, Connecticut

TABLE 4 ACTUAL BOILER OPERATIN G CONDITIONS (SHAMOKIN AFB BOILER)

Steam Flow

Turndown (Steam)

Steam Condition

Culm Feed Rate

Culm Heating Value

Bed Temperature

Bed Height

Fluidizing Velocity

5,500 - 24,500 lb/hr (2,500-11,120

kg/hr)

4.5: 1

200 psig sat (1,380 kpa)

Up to 11,000 lb/hr (4,990 kg/hr)

3,918 - 4,164 Btu/lb (9,109-9,680 kj/kg)

3 - 5 ft (0.91 - 1.52m)

3.5 - 5.3 fps (1.07 - 1.62 m/s)

297

Page 17: Utilization of Solid Waste Fuels Through Fluidized Bed ......UTILIZATION OF SOLID WASTE FUELS THROUGH FLUIDIZED BED COMBUSTION HENRY S. KWON Dorr-Oliver, Inc_ Stamford, Connecticut

Operating Hours

2,629

4,493

7,470

10,224

Operating Hours

2,629

4,493

7,470

10,224

TABLE 5 TUBE METAL THICKNESS AS MEASURED

inch

.175

.184

.17 3

.167

IN-BED TUBES

inch

.3742

.3775

.3762

.3747

A

(mm)

(9.504)

(9.588)

(9.555)

(9.517)

inch

.3775

.3770

.3776

.3743

B

(mm)

(9.588)

(9.575)

(9.591)

(9.506)

SIDEWALL TUBES

A

(mm) inch

(4.445) .169

(4.67 3) .17 3

(4.394) .162

(4.242) .154

B

(mm) inch

(4.292) .172

(4.394) .178

(4.115) .170

(3.911) .170

c

(mm)

(4.369)

(4.521)

(4.318)

(4.318)

Note: 1. Nominal thickness of in-bed tubes, 0.375 inch (9.525 mm)

2. Nominal thick ness of sidewall tubes, 0.180 inch (4.572 mm)

298

Page 18: Utilization of Solid Waste Fuels Through Fluidized Bed ......UTILIZATION OF SOLID WASTE FUELS THROUGH FLUIDIZED BED COMBUSTION HENRY S. KWON Dorr-Oliver, Inc_ Stamford, Connecticut

TABLE 6 ULTIMATE ANALYSIS OF FUEL (elAI RVIVRE AFB BOI lER, DESIGN BASES, % wTl

Carbon

Hydrogen

Nitrogen

Oxygen

Sulfur

Ash

Moisture

Heating Value

HHV

299

Wood Waste

25.0

2.7

0.1

19.55

0.05

2.6

50.0

4,200 Btu/lb

(9,7 65 kj/k g)

Coal

72.8

4.9

1.4

6.5

0.5

8.9

5.0

12,735 Btu/lb

(29,610 k j/kg)

Page 19: Utilization of Solid Waste Fuels Through Fluidized Bed ......UTILIZATION OF SOLID WASTE FUELS THROUGH FLUIDIZED BED COMBUSTION HENRY S. KWON Dorr-Oliver, Inc_ Stamford, Connecticut

TABLE 7 DESIGN PARAMETERS (CLAIRVIVRE AFT BOI LER, 5.8 MW) -----------------------------_._-_ . . _ . _ _ ._---•. _-

Boiler

Heat Absorbed

Hot Water Condition

Woodwaste Feed

Woodwaste Feed Size

Feed Heating Value

Bed Temperature

Bed Height

Excess Air

Turndown

Furnace Cross Section

Emissions

Particulates

S02

NOx (for wood)

300

20x106 Btu/hr (5.8 MW)

230° F (llOOC)

7,280 lb/hr (3,300 kg/h r)

Minus Ii inch (30mm)

4,200 Btu/lb (9,765 kj/k g)

1300 - 1650 of (700-900°C)

2 - 4 ft (0.61-1.22m)

40 - 60%

4: 1

80.5 ft2 (7.5 m2)

0.1 lb/million Btu (43 ng/j)

1.2 lb/million Btu (520 ng/j)

not required (Expected to be less

th an 0.3 lb/million Btu or 130

ng/ j)