user instructions for the policy analysis ......user instructions for the policy analysis model for...

USER INSTRUCTIONS FOR THE POLICY ANALYSIS

MODEL FOR ASEAN (PAMA)

Prepared for

UNITED NATIONS ENVIRONMENT PROGRAMME

By

INTERNATIONAL INSTITUTE FOR ENERGY CONSERVATION - ASIA 12th Floor, United Business Center II Building, 591, Sukhumvit Road,

Wattana, Bangkok – 10110 THAILAND

September 2016

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

This manual was prepared by the International Institute for Energy Conservation (IIEC), for the

United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP)–Global Environment Facility (GEF) en.lighten

initiative as part of the Association of South East Asia Nations Standards Harmonization Initiative for

Energy Efficiency (ASEAN SHINE) project.

IIEC and UNEP would like to thank the EU Switch-Asia Regional Policy Support Component and the

Australian Government for funding the development of this document, as part of the ASEAN SHINE –

Lighting project.

ASEAN Regional Efficient Lighting Market Assessment Prepared by IIEC for UNEP

September 2016|i

Table of Contents

INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................... 1

STEP-BY-STEP INSTRUCTIONS ..................................................................................... 4

Step 1 – Open spreadsheet tool ...................................................................................................... 4

Step 2 – Menus selection ................................................................................................................ 4

Step 3 (Optional) – User Inputs ....................................................................................................... 9

APPENDIX A. MODELLING METHODOLOGY .................................................................. 14

Overview of the Policy Analysis Model for ASEAN ....................................................................... 14

Modelling Methodology ................................................................................................................ 15

National Lamp Stock Module ...................................................................................................................................... 15

National lamp shipment Module ................................................................................................................................ 18

Energy Efficiency Policy Measure Module .................................................................................................................. 20

Model Inputs and Assumptions .................................................................................................... 22

Model Inputs and References ..................................................................................................................................... 22

Model Assumptions .................................................................................................................................................... 25

APPENDIX B. EXAMPLES OF MODEL USAGE .................................................................. 28

EX1. Multiple policy intervention scenarios .................................................................................. 28

EX2. Build-up regional data by using PAMA model ...................................................................... 30


September 2016|ii

LIST OF FIGURES

Figure 1: Summary Page on the PAMA Model ................................................................................ 2

Figure 2: User Inputs Page on the PAMA Model ............................................................................. 3

Figure 3: Worksheet Tab on the PAMA Model ................................................................................ 4

Figure 4: Country Drop-down Menu on PAMA Model .................................................................... 4

Figure 5: Economic Growth Drop-down Menu on PAMA Model .................................................... 5

Figure 6: Percentage of Economic Growth Used in the PAMA Model ............................................ 5

Figure 7: Analysis Year Drop-down Menu on the PAMA Model ..................................................... 6

Figure 8: Policy Scenarios Drop-down Menu on the PAMA Model ................................................. 6

Figure 9: Policy implementation tick box on the PAMA Model ....................................................... 7

Figure 10: Sample of Selection of Drop-down Menus ..................................................................... 7

Figure 11: Result Display of Lamp Stock in Myanmar, 2016 ........................................................... 8

Figure 12: Result Display of Lamp Shipment in Myanmar .............................................................. 8

Figure 13: Result Display of Cumulative Savings in 2021-30 .......................................................... 8

Figure 14: Result Display of Electricity Consumption from Selected Policy Measure ..................... 9

Figure 15: Optional Fields for Annual Lamp Sales Data Customization ........................................ 10

Figure 16: Optional Fields for Regulated Sales Data Customization ............................................. 10

Figure 17: Optional Fields for Sectoral Electricity Consumption Data Customization .................. 11

Figure 18: Optional Field for Income PPP growth data customization ......................................... 11

Figure 19: Optional Fields for In-country Lighting Data Customization ........................................ 12

Figure 20: Optional Fields for Lamp Technology Substitution Data Customization ...................... 13

Figure 21: Flow chart of the residential sector’s calculation ........................................................ 16

Figure 22: Flow chart of the professional and street & outdoor lighting sectors’ calculation ...... 18

Figure 23: Flow chart of the lamp shipment calculation ............................................................... 20

Figure 24: Model Results Example from Viet Nam’s MEPS Scenario ............................................ 21

Figure 25: Flow chart of lighting electricity consumption calculation in each policy measure .... 22

Figure 26: Impact gained from MEPS for non-directional lamps policy in Myanmar ................... 29

Figure 27: Impact gained from MEPS for linear fluorescent lamps policy in Myanmar ............... 30

Figure 28: Regional Lamp Stock by Sector and Technology, 2014 ................................................ 31

Figure 29: Regional lamp stock by manually adding of the national lamp stock ......................... 31

Figure 30: Regional lamp shipment projection from 2015-2030 .................................................. 32

Figure 31: Regional lamp shipment projection by manually adding of the national lamp

shipment ..................................................................................................................... 32

Figure 32: Regional lighting electricity consumption projection ................................................... 33

Figure 33: Regional lighting electricity consumption projection by manually adding of the

national electricity consumption ................................................................................ 34


September 2016|iii

LIST OF TABLES

Table 1: Explanations for each Policy Scenario ............................................................................... 6

Table 2: Summary of Data Collection from Household Surveys .................................................... 23

Table 3: Assumption on Lamp Wattages in 3 different Sectors in ASEAN .................................... 25

Table 4: Assumption on Operating Hours and Utilisation ............................................................. 26

Table 5: Lamp Technology Substitution Year on Year ................................................................... 26


September 2016|1

INTRODUCTION

The Policy Analysis Model for ASEAN (PAMA) is a self-contained spreadsheet model that provides both

a user-oriented analysis and a national cost-benefit analysis of lighting policies. The model uses country-

specific data and indices (population, GDP, per capita income, electrification and distribution rates, etc.),

in combination with product-specific data (lamp shipment by types, efficacies and lifetimes) to construct

estimates of impacts from multiple energy efficiency policy scenarios.

This model was designed as a user-friendly tool for policy-makers to view:

1) Total number of lamps installed in each country with projections up to 2030;

2) Lamp shipments from first purchases1 and replacements based on economic forecasts and

lighting technology adoption in each country with projections up to 2030 and;

3) Energy saving, CO2 emission reductions, and financial savings achieved through the

implementation of energy efficiency policy measures.

The analyses can be customized to produce specific results without additional user inputs, through the

use of drop-down menus located on the Summary page (see Figure 1).

1 First purchase is a new installation of lamps. In other words, it is defined as new light points gained from new construction,

refurbishment, or renovation projects.


September 2016|2

Figure 1: Summary Page on the PAMA Model

In addition, this model was populated with up-to-date key market and survey data by IIEC between 2014

and 2015 from various sources. More up-to-date data can also be added through the User Inputs page

for better accuracy of projections (see Figure 2). Details on how to adjust this are located in Step 3.


September 2016|3

Figure 2: User Inputs Page on the PAMA Model

The following is a step-by-step guide for using and customizing this tool.

User Inputs

Energy data

Year Sales (units) Default (units)

2030 43,902,803

2029 41,547,408 Country Name Residential Commercial Industrial Public Others Entry Check

2028 39,350,668 Brunei Darussalam

2027 37,298,551 Default BRN 38% 15% 18% 29% 0%

2026 35,377,786 Cambodia

2025 33,575,458 Default KHM 26% 28% 20% 4% 22%

2024 31,878,857 Indonesia

2023 30,274,420 Default IDN 41% 18% 35% 3% 3%

2022 28,749,694 Lao PDR

2021 27,287,558 Default LAO 38% 15% 41% 6% 0%

2020 25,885,622 Malaysia

2019 24,510,737 Default MYS 18% 34% 43% 1% 4%

2018 23,225,141 Myanmar

2017 21,876,913 Default MMR 33% 20% 44% 3% 0%

2016 21,021,797 Philippines

2015 19,686,205 Default PHL 28% 24% 27% 7% 14%

2014 19,098,116 Singapore

2013 17,986,606 Default SGP 15% 37% 43% 5% 0%

2012 16,875,095 Thailand

2011 16,132,802 Default THA 24% 30% 44% 2% 0%

2010 15,390,509 Viet Nam

2009 14,084,832 Default VNM 36% 5% 54% 4% 1%

2008 12,779,154

2007 11,473,477 Economic data

2006 10,167,800

2005 8,862,123 Income PPP growth (%)

2004 7,556,446

2003 6,250,769

2002 4,945,092 The residential sector

2001 3,639,415

No. of light point per

household8.56 units

2000 2,333,737

1999 2,247,205 The commercial sector

1998 2,160,376

%share of electricity

from lighting15%

1997 2,070,686

1996 1,983,151 The industrial sector

1995 1,889,579


from lighting4.5%

1994 1,823,984

1993 1,757,441 Street & Outdoor lighting sector

1992 1,686,959

%share of street

lighting from the total

electricity consumption

1.0%

1991 1,619,067

1990 1,544,482 Lamp technology substitution

1989 1,504,816

1988 1,465,584

1987 1,426,819 Incandescent

1986 1,388,485 Halogen

1985 1,350,288 CFL

1984 1,312,010 LFL - T5

1983 1,272,632 LFL - T8

1982 1,232,678 LFL - T12

1981 1,188,733 LFL - Circular

1980 1,148,135 HID

Regulated

sales (%)

% annual decrease of lamp

Sectoral Electricity Consumption (%)

Shipments Data

Househol and market survey data


September 2016|4

STEP-BY-STEP INSTRUCTIONS

STEP 1 – OPEN SPREADSHEET TOOL

Open the spreadsheet file. Make sure that the security level in Excel is set to enable macros (How to

enable macro: https://support.office.com/en-us/article/Enable-or-disable-macros-in-Office-documents-

7b4fdd2e-174f-47e2-9611-9efe4f860b12).

STEP 2 – MENUS SELECTION

Navigate to the Summary worksheet tab (see Figure 3).

Figure 3: Worksheet Tab on the PAMA Model

Select the “Country” drop-down menu to select the country you wish to analyse (see Figure 4).

Figure 4: Country Drop-down Menu on PAMA Model

Select the “Economic Growth” drop-down menu to select the economic scenario. There are

three options under the economic growth drop-down menu i.e., 1) “High Growth (OECD)2,” a

high growth option under economics stability; 2) “Conservative (ADB)3,” a lower growth rate

predictive assumption; and 3) “Custom growth (user input),” a customising option in which GDP

growth can be manually input by the user (see Figure 5). The default value of the Economic

Growth is “High Growth (OECD)”.

2 Estimates of GDP growth in this scenario are based on the OECD Development Centre, MPF-2016 (Medium-Term

Projection Framework). Reference: OECD. (2016). Economic Outlook for Southeast Asia, China and India 2016:

Enhancing Regional Ties. Paris: OECD Publishing. For more information on MPF, please visit

www.oecd.org/dev/asiapacific/mpf. 3 Estimates of GDP growth in this scenario are based on the negative scenario projected by ADB’s Economics and

Research Department. Reference: ADB. (2014, December). The ASEAN Economy in the Regional Context:

Opportunities, Challenges, and Policy Options. Retrieved from Asian Development Bank (ADB). For more

information, please find http://www.adb.org/sites/default/files/publication/152830/reiwp-145.pdf.

https://support.office.com/en-us/article/Enable-or-disable-macros-in-Office-documents-7b4fdd2e-174f-47e2-9611-9efe4f860b12

https://support.office.com/en-us/article/Enable-or-disable-macros-in-Office-documents-7b4fdd2e-174f-47e2-9611-9efe4f860b12

http://www.oecd.org/dev/asiapacific/mpf

http://www.adb.org/sites/default/files/publication/152830/reiwp-145.pdf


September 2016|5

Figure 5: Economic Growth Drop-down Menu on PAMA Model

When selecting the ‘Custom growth (user input)’ option from the “Economic Growth” drop-down menu,

user needs to enter the expected GDP growth in percentage in the green column next to the drop-down

menu (Shown in Figure 5).

Forecasts of economic growth rate for each ASEAN member state in high and conservative scenarios

used in the PAMA model are shown in Figure 6, and these data are presented in the CountryData page

(tab).

Country High growth

(OECD, 2016) Conservative (ADB, 2014)

BRN 1.8% 1.2%

KHM 7.3% 4.0%

IDN 5.5% 2.5%

LAO 7.3% 3.5%

MYS 5.0% 2.5%

MMR 8.2% 4.0%

PHL 5.7% 3.0%

SGP 2.6% 1.0%

THA 3.6% 2.0%

VNM 6.0% 3.5%

Figure 6: Percentage of Economic Growth Used in the PAMA Model

Then, select the “Analysis Year” drop-down menu. The “Analysis Year” is default to 2016; users can

select any desired year to see total number of installed lamps and shipment in any selected year.


September 2016|6

Figure 7: Analysis Year Drop-down Menu on the PAMA Model

After that, select the desired Policy Scenario for analysis.

Figure 8: Policy Scenarios Drop-down Menu on the PAMA Model

Table 1 provides explanations for each of the three scenarios as follows:

Table 1: Explanations for each Policy Scenario

Policy Scenario Explaination

1) Business as usual (BAU) A scenario where lighting markets naturally and

gradually shift towards energy efficient lighting

technologies, without any policy stimulus.

2) Energy Efficiency (EE) A scenario where lighting markets are actively

stimulated by more stringent standards and

simultaneously encouraged by labelling schemes.

By default, in this scenario, incandescent lamps are

initially set to be banned after 2020 and MEPS for

compact fluorescent lamps, fluorescent lamps, and

high intensity discharge lamps are also established

in the same year.

However, users can select each scenario one by

one by ticking each box of the “Policy

implementation” function (see Figure 9).

3) Best available technology (BAT) An ideal scenario in which lighting markets across

ASEAN member states shift towards the best

available energy efficient type of lamps (i.e., LEDs).

In this scenario, a vast majority of lamps are set to

be replaced by LED technology by 2030.

If the user selects the “Energy Efficiency” option from Policy Scenario drop-down menu, then it

is required to select specific energy efficiency policy implementation to be implemented from

the following list as shown in Figure 9. By default, all policies are pre-selected, and users should

de-select the boxes of any policy that is not being considered.

The model is designed to be interactive and can be used for decision making purposes. By

comparing one policy implementation against the others, user can assess the highest impact

policy intervention (See Appendix B – Examples of model usage for customisation guidelines).


September 2016|7

Figure 9: Policy implementation tick box on the PAMA Model

Figure 10 below shows the sample of selected menus: Myanmar is the selected country, with “High

Growth (OECD),” “2016,” and “Energy Efficiency” as the selected settings, with all policy

implementation selected.

Figure 10: Sample of Selection of Drop-down Menus

After selection, the page (see Figure 10) will show the specific data for each country selected under the

section of “Country Profile at a Glance”, which contains the following information:

Population and Projected Growth (from the UN Secretariat, population division and National

Census). Available at https://esa.un.org/unpd/wpp/Download/Standard/Population/

Per Capita Income (Gross National Income, adjusted for Purchasing Power Parity) from the

World Bank, 2015. Available at http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.PP.CD

Electrification Rate and Transmission and Distribution losses (most recent data from respective

organisations in each ASEAN country)

CO2 emission factors (kg CO2 per kilowatt hour electricity, IEA 2013 and List of Grid Emission

Factors created by Kentaro Takahashi and Akihisa Kuriyama). Available at

https://www.iea.org/publications/freepublications/publication/CO2EmissionsFromFuelCombust

ionHighlights2015.pdf and

http://enviroscope.iges.or.jp/modules/envirolib/view.php?docid=2136

Figure 11; Figure 12; Figure 13; and Figure 14 provide examples of graphical results data on estimates of

lamp stock and shipment, cumulative savings in 2021-30 and electricity consumption from selected

policy measures in Myanmar.

Policy implementation(EE scenario only)

Prohibition of ILs MEPS for CFLs MEPS for LFLs MEPS for HID Labelling programme for CFLs

https://esa.un.org/unpd/wpp/Download/Standard/Population/

http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.PP.CD

https://www.iea.org/publications/freepublications/publication/CO2EmissionsFromFuelCombustionHighlights2015.pdf

https://www.iea.org/publications/freepublications/publication/CO2EmissionsFromFuelCombustionHighlights2015.pdf

http://enviroscope.iges.or.jp/modules/envirolib/view.php?docid=2136


September 2016|8

Figure 11: Result Display of Lamp Stock in Myanmar, 2016

Figure 12: Result Display of Lamp Shipment in Myanmar

Figure 13: Result Display of Cumulative Savings in 2021-30

0.0

5.0

10.0

15.0

20.0

25.0

30.0

35.0

40.0

45.0

50.0

Residential Professional Street and Outdoor Total

Lam

p s

tock

(in

mill

ion

un

its)

HID

LED

Linear fluorescent

CFL

Halogen

Incandescent

0

5,000

10,000

15,000

20,000

25,000

30,000

35,000

40,000

45,000

50,000

2030 2020 2010 2000

Lam

ps

in t

ho

usa

nd

s '0

00

Year

First Purchase

Replacements

Total Sales


September 2016|9

Figure 14: Result Display of Electricity Consumption from Selected Policy Measure

STEP 3 (OPTIONAL) – USER INPUTS

In this step, any data obtained by the user that is specific to their country can be incorporated into the

model to update or replace the default values and estimates provided with the model. The spreadsheet

allows data input for several parameters, including lamp shipment data, and the rates of change in lamp

technologies present in the market. All areas for user input are located on the User Inputs sheet. The

cells that allow users to update data are highlighted in green.

Shipments data

By default, the spreadsheet model forecasts the number of lamp shipment in any given year by a

mathematic model that takes into account growth in ownership (due to economic growth), and

declining function for lamp replacements (due to expected longer lifetime of lamps). The user can

deliberately adjust the shipment value in any given year and the model will automatically predict the

shipment in the remaining years by the input value(s).

By navigating to the User Inputs sheet (tab), users can input actual historical sales data for years prior to

2015 and projected figures for years 2016 onwards (in numerical value) in the area highlighted in green.

Consecutive or complete data sets are not mandatory for this field; non-sequential sets of data can also

be input as long as they are gathered from reliable sources.

Note: The model uses predictive algorithm to forecast shipment values based on historical sales data,

GDP growth rate, Income PPP growth rate, lamp retirement function, and assumption of lamp

technology substitution; the forecast values (new installation and lamp replacement) will be predicted

per these input.

0.0

1.0

2.0

3.0

4.0

5.0

6.0

7.0

8.0

2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016 2018 2020 2022 2024 2026 2028 2030

Tera

wat

t-h

ou

rs

Residential Commercial Industrial

Street and Outdoor Energy Efficiency BAU


September 2016|10

Figure 15: Optional Fields for Annual Lamp Sales Data Customization

Regulated Sales (%)

If there is an economic or market-based mechanism implemented in the country, the user can

customise the national sales volume in percentage. By default, the regulated sales for all policy

scenarios is default to 100%, by customising this data the country would have implemented some

market campaign that directly impact the sales of lighting products. For instance, giveaway programme

would make the surplus shipment around 5% in the year of implementation. So, the input data will be

105%.

Figure 16: Optional Fields for Regulated Sales Data Customization

Energy data

The model is designed to use sectoral electricity consumption statistics as a key input for stock model in

the commercial and industrial sector. The sectoral electricity consumption is the share of electricity

consumption by each major sector in percentage. By default, the model relies on official data reported

from respective ministries or national utilities in each country. The default data is based on the most

recent data available in 2014 – 20154. Figure 17 shows how to input data into this table, sectoral

electricity consumption in Myanmar are input as an example.

By default, the model has used official electricity statistics in each country for the period 2014 to 2015

as indicated in Figure 17. By updating this data, users must not leave any of the 5 sectors blank. It is

required to enter 0% in case of no data. The automatic entry for "Others" will ensure that the

4 Information sources are flagged in the CountryData page (tab), Electricity Consumption (TWh) section.

Year Sales (units) Default (units)

2030 43,902,803

2029 41,547,408

2028 39,350,668

2027 37,298,551

2026 35,377,786

2025 33,575,458

2024 31,878,857

2023 30,274,420

2022 28,749,694

2021 27,287,558

2020 25,885,622

2019 24,510,737

2018 23,225,141

2017 21,876,913

2016 21,021,797

Shipments Data

Regulated

sales (%) 105.00%


September 2016|11

summation of the total consumption is equal to 100%, and the “Entry Check” will provide an error

notification if incomplete data input is occurred.

Figure 17: Optional Fields for Sectoral Electricity Consumption Data Customization

Economic Data

The growth of Gross National Income per capita at purchasing power parity (PPP) effects the new

installation of lamps. By default, this parameter is assumed to be equal to GDP growth rate which is

cross-reference to any economic growth scenario selected by the user. The user can customise Income

PPP growth if there is data available.

Figure 18: Optional Field for Income PPP growth data customization

Household and market survey data

Actual surveyed data from each country are used to determine the total number of lamps installed in

each sector, which are key model parameters. The percentage share of electricity from lighting in each

sector is used to determine the energy consumption in kWh for the sector. This figure is then divided by

the unit energy consumption (UEC) of lamp in each sector by the model so the number of installed

Country Name Residential Commercial Industrial Public Others Entry Check

Brunei Darussalam

Default BRN 38% 15% 18% 29% 0%

Cambodia

Default KHM 26% 28% 20% 4% 22%

Indonesia

Default IDN 41% 18% 35% 3% 3%

Lao PDR

Default LAO 38% 15% 41% 6% 0%

Malaysia

Default MYS 18% 34% 43% 1% 4%

Myanmar 30% 22% 45% 2% 1% ok

Default MMR 33% 20% 44% 3% 0%

Philippines

Default PHL 28% 24% 27% 7% 14%

Singapore

Default SGP 15% 37% 43% 5% 0%

Thailand

Default THA 24% 30% 44% 2% 0%

Viet Nam

Default VNM 36% 5% 54% 4% 1%

Sectoral Electricity Consumption (%)

Economic data

Income PPP growth (%) 4%


September 2016|12

lamps can be calculated. For instance, the number of light points per household is an average number

of lamps found in the residential sector of the country of interest. This number is then multiplied with

the total number of electrified household in the same country by the market model. The by-product of

this is the estimated number of lamp installed in the residential sector. By default, the model uses the

average number of light points per household based on the household survey conducted in 20155.

Figure 19 shows the sample of data entered into each optional field.

Figure 19: Optional Fields for In-country Lighting Data Customization

Lamp Technology substitution

Overtime, it is envisaged that the uptake of energy efficient lamps will happen naturally and gradually in

any market without any policy stimulus, as these products mature and their prices decline. The lamp

technology substitution forecast is used to project the installed lamp stock in the future under each

policy scenario. If the user wishes to change the forecast, they must select from the drop down menu

the annual percentage decrease of lamps (which is a negative value) and the user-input values will then

supersede the default values in the Database sheet.

5 Singapore is only the country where this data is not available, the number presented in the model was taken

from Policy Analysis Modelling System developed by CLASP and LBNL at 29 light points per household.

Surveyed data

The residential sector

No. of light point per

household 10

The commercial sector


from lighting 10%

The industrial sector


from lighting 5%

Street & Outdoor lighting sector

%share of street

lighting from the total

electricity consumption 2%


September 2016|13

Figure 20: Optional Fields for Lamp Technology Substitution Data Customization


September 2016|14

APPENDIX A. MODELLING METHODOLOGY

Lamp Stock and Shipment Model for ASEAN

OVERVIEW OF THE POLICY ANALYSIS MODEL FOR ASEAN

The Policy Analysis Model for ASEAN (PAMA) was developed in response to the agreement made by

ASEAN member states to collaborate on a regional transition to energy efficient lighting. The PAMA

model will assist policy makers to determine the scope of lighting technologies that are widely used in

the region, as well as to identify and provide information on economic benefits when the supporting

policies are implemented.

This model was developed as a market forecasting, spreadsheet-based tool that incorporates multiple

energy efficient lighting policy scenarios and provides the estimated benefits of policy implementation,

including minimum energy performance standards (MEPS) and appliance labelling programmes.

Moreover, the model estimates the highest saving potential when best available technology (BAT) is

applied throughout the region. The model was designed to be used by the ASEAN member states. In

addition, the outputs from different policies applied individually by each state can be summed to

estimate the regional impacts. The model includes the following modules:

National Lamp Stock module – This module estimates the total number of lamps installed in

each country with projections up to 2030. It utilises different approaches to estimate the

installed lamp stocks in different end-use sectors. Lamp stocks for the national residential sector

are compiled from data obtained through country household lighting surveys, while lamps

stocks for commercial, industrial, and street and outdoor lighting sectors were developed based

on shares of lighting consumption in the national electricity consumption data provided by each

ASEAN member state.

National Lamp Shipment module – This module estimates the lamp shipments from first

purchase and replacements based on economic forecasts and lighting technology adoption in

each country with projections up to 2030. The annual lamp shipments are estimated based on

mathematical models. The module also fundamentally relies on official data, preliminary

studies, surveyed data, with only marginal reliance on assumptions. This use of national data

also allows the module to estimate regional impacts by summing up individual country results.

Energy Efficiency Policy Measure module – This module calculates energy saving, CO2 emission

reductions, and financial savings achieved through the implementation of energy efficiency

policy measures. The module is designed to operate with the widest possible range of policies,

with minimal need for adjusting country data if there is no major update available.


September 2016|15

MODELLING METHODOLOGY

Although there are a number of fixed parameters (e.g., population, electricity consumption, average

lamp wattages, operating hours) integrated into PAMA, variable parameters (e.g., sectoral electricity

consumption, average number of light points for each household, percentage share of electricity

consumption from lighting) are listed for future revision. The User Inputs worksheet is designed for

more accurate country-specific insight where available, and this can be easily customised.

NATIONAL LAMP STOCK MODULE

Residential Sector

Estimation of the total lamp stock installed in the residential sector in each ASEAN member state is

based on the data from the in-person household surveys and official reports from the member states6.

The estimated stock of lamps was derived from the average number of lamps found in the survey; this

figure was then multiplied by the number of electrified households in each member state to arrive at

the installed lamp stock. The number of electrified households was extrapolated by combining official

census report data, updated status of electrification rate, and population growth rate in each country.

The lamp wattages and operating hours were also collected and used to construct the total electricity

consumption model (see Table 2). The total installed lamps function is calculated based on surveyed

data and official statistics; given by:

Lamp Stock

Where: Lamp Stock is the units installed of lamps;

Lp is the number of light point per household, collected from household surveys,

Np is the number of population, officially reported by the country,

ElecR is the electrification rate, officially reported by the national utility or ministry of energy, and

HHs is the household size, based on UN Habitat or most recent country census report.

Note: Users can input more accurate or up-to-date average light point data if there is more reliable data

available.

6 Brunei Darussalam and Singapore are omitted from the scope of the field surveys, data presented in the model is

taken from preliminary studies


September 2016|16

Figure 21: Flow chart of the residential sector’s calculation

Professional (Commercial and Industrial) Sector

Lamp stocks in the professional sector in each ASEAN member state were estimated using a top-down

computation model7 with the following key parameters: percentage share of electricity consumption by

lighting applications in each sector; penetration of different lighting technologies; and typical lamp

wattages and operating hours8. The estimation of electricity share from lighting (in kWh per year) was

based on sectoral electricity use statistics and energy audit reports that provide electricity shares by

lighting applications in the commercial and industrial sectors. The penetration rate of each lighting

7 The top-down model uses electricity consumption data by the commercial sector in each country, together with

parameters from industry interviews and energy audit reports to estimate the total commercial lamp stock in

each country. 8 Approaches for citing and references these parameters were based on best available data obtained from each

country. Sources of data were classified into four levels based on their credibility: 1) Published data officially

released by the governments; 2) Energy audit reports from prestigious institutions; 3) Publications, journal

articles or reports; and if none of the above can be found the model utilises 4) data from the similar geographical

location and GDP size country.


September 2016|17

technology was based on data provided by the lighting industry associations in each country. Typical

lamp wattages and operating hours were developed based on industry interviews and available through

energy audit reports. In cases where the aforementioned data were not available for a specific member

state, data from other neighbouring member states with similar purchasing power parity (PPP),

infrastructure, and culture were used by the model to generate outputs.

Note: If there is an absence of the electricity shares by lighting data in any country, the research reported

by the most similar country (in purchasing power parity, infrastructure) is then substituted.

Public Lighting (Street and Outdoor) Sector

Estimation of installed lamp stock for street and outdoor lighting applications in each ASEAN member

state was also based on a top-down computation model, similar to the model used for the professional

sector. The estimation of annual electricity used by street lighting (in kWh) was based on the official

statistics reported by each member state, and shares of different lighting technologies in street and

outdoor lighting applications used data available from utilities and municipalities. For the member

states where these data were not available, assumptions based on industry interviews and general

market observations were used as the input parameter.

The total installed lamps function in professional and public lighting sectors are calculated based on

surveyed data and official statistics; given by:

Lamp Stock

Where: Lamp Stock is the units installed of lamps;

ElecC is the total electricity consumption of the country in TWh,

L(%) is the share usage of electricity from lighting in each sector, by statistics / audit reports,

Wl is the weighted average wattages of lamps used in each sector, and

Ha is the annual operating hours of lamps in each sector, obtained from surveys or preliminary studies

or national utility reports.

Figure 22 illustrates the estimated number of lamp stock’s calculation process, with default data and

user inputs in professional and street and outdoor lighting sectors.


September 2016|18

Figure 22: Flow chart of the professional and street & outdoor lighting sectors’ calculation

NATIONAL LAMP SHIPMENT MODULE

Determination of economically-driven appliance ownership rates allowed for the calculation of the

goods delivered to consumers. Calculations of shipments (annual sales volume) are important, since this

model determines the fraction(s) of lamps that will be affected by policy scenarios at any point in the

policy timeframe.

Changes in lamp shipments are typically driven by the change (increase or decrease) in lamps ownership

per household that results from the economic expansion, electrification, and population increase or by

the replacement of failed lamps. The mathematical models used to quantify the shipments are credited

to the Policy Analysis Modelling System (PAMS) developed by LBNL. The cumulative retirement

probability is used as a function of the lamp shelf life, given by:


September 2016|19

;

Where: age is the given appliance age

Pr (age) is the probability of retirement after a given number of years of use,

age0 is the average lifetime of all lamp types, and

is the mean deviation of replacement ages, which vary by country.

Replacements in each year are given by the relationship

REP

;

Stock(y,age) is the number of products of vintage age remaining in each year. While, Linc is the

incremental of lifetime factor that affects the lamp replacement, assumed to be 97% annually. The

increment of lifetime will reduce the lamp replacement overtime after the analysis year (2015).

In developing countries, the first purchase (or new installation) of lamps could be the dominant driver of

sales, while this figure could be marginal (based on new building only) in developed countries.

The function for the first purchase (FP(y)) is given by:

The projections of annual lamp shipments towards 2030 employed the GDP growth rate (conservative

rate) and the number of shipments in the baseline year, where data were collected from industry

interviews and/or from the Customs Department in each country.

Finally, the total shipments for the current year are provided by:

Figure 23 presents lamp shipment’s calculation process, with default data and user inputs.


September 2016|20

Figure 23: Flow chart of the lamp shipment calculation

ENERGY EFFICIENCY POLICY MEASURE MODULE

An example of the outputs produced by the energy efficiency policy measure module is shown in Figure

24, which summarises electricity savings that could be achieved from MEPS and labelling policy

measures in 2030. Economic benefits and environmental benefits are also calculated based on the

savings from reduced electricity use.


September 2016|21

Figure 24: Model Results Example from Viet Nam’s MEPS Scenario

The projections of impacts by different energy efficiency policy measures were developed based on

country level data, estimated GDP growth, electricity consumption forecast, and lamp technology

substitution assumptions. The module provides different policy measures and market stimulating

programmes. The savings potential assumes that the MEPS and labelling are implemented by 2020

(Details are given in Section 3). The projections of electricity consumption from lighting employed the

estimated number of installed lamps in each sector and unit energy consumption in each type of lamp;

given by:

Lighting Electricity Consumption

Annual Unit Energy Consumption is given by the relationship:

Annual UEC =

Where: L (%) is the share usage of electricity from lighting in each sector, by statistics / audit reports,

Wl is the weighted average wattages of lamps used in each sector (W), and

Ha is the annual operating hours of lamps in each sector (h), obtained from surveys or preliminary

studies or national utility reports.

Figure 25 illustrates calculation of electricity consumption in each policy measure.


September 2016|22

Figure 25: Flow chart of lighting electricity consumption calculation in each policy measure

MODEL INPUTS AND ASSUMPTIONS

This section describes some of the key input variables and assumptions used in the model. While the

most up-to-date, reliable data and information on the market status and characteristics were available

across the ten ASEAN member countries, information gaps remained. The model assumptions

presented here reflect these gaps.

MODEL INPUTS AND REFERENCES

Population Data (2015): World Population Prospects: The 2015 Revision, Key Findings and

Advance Tables (UN-DESA 2015).

http://esa.un.org/unpd/wpp/publications/files/key_findings_wpp_2015.pdf

Household Size: UN Habitat and census reports from each of the member states

Electrification Rate (2014-15): Collated from official sources of individual country (For more

information on references: navigate to the ‘Country data’ sheet (tab) of the model)

Transmission and Distribution Loss Factor: collected from the IEA and reports issued by each

national utility.

http://esa.un.org/unpd/wpp/publications/files/key_findings_wpp_2015.pdf


September 2016|23

Income PPP and GDP (in USD): Calculated using GDP/population. GDP in current US$ (data for

2010) is taken from the World Bank (The World Bank 2016).

Income/economic Growth: Based on OECD report ‘Economic Outlook for Southeast Asia, China

and India 2016’ (OECD 2016) and ADB report “The ASEAN Economy in the Regional Context:

Opportunities, Challenges, and Policy Options” (ADB 2014).

Country High growth (OECD, 2016)

Conservative (ADB, 2014)

BRN 1.8% 1.2%

KHM 7.3% 4.0%

IDN 5.5% 2.5%

LAO 7.3% 3.5%

MYS 5.0% 2.5%

MMR 8.2% 4.0%

PHL 5.7% 3.0%

SGP 2.6% 1.0%

THA 3.6% 2.0%

VNM 6.0% 3.5%

Electricity Tariffs: collated from official sources (national electric utilities, Bureau of statistics).

Energy and Environment Data

Sectoral Electricity Consumption: Collated from official sources of individual country (For more

information on references: navigate to the ‘Database’ sheet (tab) of the model).

Transmission and distribution losses: IEA and published data by national utility in each country.

CO2 Emission Factor: IEA (2013), and List of Grid Emission Factors created by Kentaro Takahashi

and Akihisa Kuriyama (IGES, 2015).

Lighting Data

Estimates of the installed stock of lamps were collated from household surveys in 2015, lighting

industry and relevant government agencies and electric utilities in each member state.

Table 2: Summary of Data Collection from Household Surveys

Country No. of surveyed HHs

AVG no. of light points found and used

Wattages Operating hours

IIEC Survey

Secondary resources

Brunei Darussalam

N/A N/A 23 (Ahmad, 2014)

Provided by Brunei Darussalam National

Energy Research Institute (BNERI)

Assumed by using similar geographical location and GDP size country

(Malaysia)

Cambodia 73 8.1 N/A Collected by lamp types from HH survey

Collected by lamp types from IIEC HH survey

Indonesia 50 7.3 N/A Collected by lamp types from HH survey


Lao PDR > 1000 (nationwide)

7.2 7.17 (EdL, 2014)

EdL Nationwide HH Surveys

EdL Nationwide HH Surveys

Malaysia 50 19.6 N/A Collected by lamp types Collected by lamp types


September 2016|24

Country No. of surveyed HHs

AVG no. of light points found and used

Wattages Operating hours

IIEC Survey

Secondary resources

from HH survey from IIEC HH survey

Myanmar 73 8.6 N/A Collected by lamp types from HH survey

Collected by lamp types from HH survey

Philippines 50 6.0 N/A Collected by lamp types from HH survey

Collected by lamp types from HH survey

Singapore N/A N/A 29.94 (PAMS) Assumed by using similar geographical

location and GDP size country (Malaysia)

Assumed by using similar geographical location and GDP size country

(Malaysia)

Thailand 71 14.1 18 (EGAT and KMUTT, 2015)


(Have compared with EGAT HH Surveys –

Similar results)


Viet Nam 50 13.6 14.7 (Pham Thi Huyen et. al.,

2013)


(Have compared with the surveys done by

ISPONRE, 2013 – Similar results)


Estimates of the typical lamp wattage, operating hours, lamp lifetime, installation labour and

other factors were developed for countries based on industry consultations, internet research

and country feedback.

Estimates of the shares of the electricity use from lighting were collated from official published

data or energy audit reports of each member state.

Baseline lamp unit prices: per reference from the retailer surveys in 2014 and provided by in-

country consultants in 2015 as well as on-line resources.

Historical shipments of lamps: collected from interviews with various stakeholders including

lamp manufacturers, importers or wholesalers, lighting associations in each member state.


September 2016|25

MODEL ASSUMPTIONS

Lamp Wattages

Lamp wattages were assumed in the commercial, industrial and street and outdoor lighting sectors,

while survey data were used in the residential sector. Table 33 provides the wattages for all lamp types

used commonly in ASEAN9.

Table 3: Assumption on Lamp Wattages in 3 different Sectors in ASEAN

Assumed typical wattage

Lamp type Commercial (W) Industrial (W) Outdoor (W)

Incandescent 60 60 100

Halogen 50 50 80

CFL 14 24 25

LFL - T5 26 26 28

LFL - T8 32 36 32

LFL - T12 40 40 40

LFL - Circular 28 32 28

LED omnidirectional 7.2 10 16.5

LED tube 14.0 16.0 16.5

LED others 14.0 20.0 16.5

HID - HPS 120 150 180

HID - Mercury Vapour 120 150 180

HID - Metal Halide 120 150 180

LED street light 30 70 90

Operating Hours and Utilisation

Operating hours is an important factor that reflects the usage pattern of each lamp type. In high income

households, the ownership of lamps (number of light points per household) tends to be higher, but the

usage per light point tends to be lower when compared to less affluent households. This hypothesis is

likely to be true since the operating hours of lamps in the residential sector of low to middle income

countries based on GDP per capita reported by the World Bank10 (i.e., Cambodia, Lao PDR, Myanmar,

Philippines and Viet Nam) are found to be significantly longer than in higher income countries

(Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand) (The World Bank 2016). The operating hours recorded from household

owners in ASEAN were used for the residential modelling.

For other sectors, the best available data were applied for all building sectors in all member states.

Utilisation percentages of different lighting technologies in each end-use sector were estimated, based

on the working days per year that are normalised by several factors, e.g. planned maintenance, holidays.

Table 4 provides a summary of the assumptions and utilisation in each country for each lamp

technology.

9 Average common wattages were estimated based on retailer and household surveys conducted by IIEC in 2015,

interview with government agencies and utilities including energy audit reports (Ballast losses determined in

fluorescent and street lighting applications). 10

Based on the World Bank GDP per capita database: http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD


September 2016|26

Table 4: Assumption on Operating Hours and Utilisation

Operating Hours (applied to commercial, industrial and street lighting sectors)

Annual Utilisation Factor by Sector

(%)

Lamp type BRN KHM IDN LAO MAS MYM PHP SGP THA VNM Com Ind Street

Incandescent 6.5 7.1 7.1 7.1 7.1 7.1 7.1 6.5 7.1 7.1 66% 88% 100%

Halogen 9 9.4 9.4 9.4 9.4 9.4 9.4 9 9.4 9.4 66% 88% 100%

CFL 9.5 10.7 10.7 10.7 10.7 10.7 10.7 9.5 10.7 10.7 66% 88% 100%

LFL - T5 11.1 11.1 11.1 11.1 11.1 11.1 11.1 11.1 11.1 11.1 66% 88% 100%

LFL - T8 9.5 10.5 10.5 10.5 10.5 10.5 10.5 9.5 10.5 10.5 66% 88% 100%

LFL - T12 2.5 9.1 9.1 9.1 9.1 9.1 9.1 2.5 9.1 9.1 66% 88% 100%

LFL - Circular 9.3 9.3 9.3 9.3 9.3 9.3 9.3 9.3 9.3 9.3 66% 88% 100%

LED omnidirectional

11.4 11.4 11.4 11.4 11.4 11.4 11.4 11.4 11.4 11.4 66% 88% 100%

LED tube 12.9 12.9 12.9 12.9 12.9 12.9 12.9 12.9 12.9 12.9 66% 88% 100%

LED others 11.8 11.8 11.8 11.8 11.8 11.8 11.8 11.8 11.8 11.8 66% 88% 100%

HID - HPS 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 66% 88% 100%

HID - Mercury Vapour

11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 66% 88% 100%

HID - Metal Halide 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 66% 88% 100%

LED street light 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 11.5 66% 88% 100%

Lamp Technology Substitution Before and After Policy Year

It is envisaged that the uptake of energy efficient lamps will happen over time naturally and gradually in

the market, as these products mature and prices decline, without any policy stimulus. This substitution

scheme is applied to the business as usual (BAU) scenario during period 2000 – 2030 by the model, using

2015 as a baseline year. The annual decline of sales of conventional lamp types (in percentages) is

shown in Table 5Error! Reference source not found.11. These figures were derived from the historical

import/export trend data in ASEAN. The efficient lamps will replace the existing stock of lamps according

to this rate and the future unit energy consumption associated with this circumstance will be calculated

by the model.

Table 5: Lamp Technology Substitution Year on Year

11

Technology substitution option is available for user modification in the ‘User Inputs’ sheet (tab)

Technology substitution

Incandescent -7.0%

Halogen -3.1%

CFL -2.0%

LFL - T5 -1.5%

LFL - T8 -3.1%

LFL - T12 -35.0%

LFL - Circular -2.3%


September 2016|27

HID -0.4%


September 2016|28

APPENDIX B. EXAMPLES OF MODEL USAGE

EX1. MULTIPLE POLICY INTERVENTION SCENARIOS

The model allows the user to compare impact gaining from each policy intervention.

Example: a policy maker would like to compare between implementation of MEPS for non-directional

products and MEPS for linear fluorescent lamps, whether which lighting policy intervention will better

serve the department to reach goals in energy and environment.

Step I: Select the country, economic growth, and desired policy options

Figure 26 provides examples of graphical results data on estimates of electricity consumption from

implementation of MEPS for non-directional products in Myanmar.


September 2016|29

Figure 26: Impact gained from MEPS for non-directional lamps policy in Myanmar

Step II: Select another policy option to compare with the previous option

Figure 27 provides examples of graphical results data on estimates of electricity consumption from

implementation of MEPS for linear fluorescent lamps in Myanmar.


September 2016|30

Figure 27: Impact gained from MEPS for linear fluorescent lamps policy in Myanmar

It is shown that the implementation of MEPS for linear fluorescent lamps policy potentially has higher

savings in comparison to the implementation of MEPS for non-directional lamps in Myanmar.

The users can apply this approach to any desired policy option for comparison and decision making

purposes.

EX2. BUILD-UP REGIONAL DATA BY USING PAMA MODEL

PAMA model is designed to serve as a national lighting market forecasting tool, broader decision making

process such as quantifying the whole ASEAN region, can also be done through manual data

customisation.

Regional lamp stock:

Based on the PAMA model, the total number of lamps installed in various end-use sectors in all ASEAN

member states is estimated at around 1.9 billion lamps in 2014 (see Figure 28).


September 2016|31

Figure 28: Regional Lamp Stock by Sector and Technology, 2014

To construct this regional lamp stock chart, it is required consistency of the setting especially for key

parameters (e.g. economic growth, year, and policy scenario) in order for data homogeneity.

First, the users select the “Country” one by one and navigate to Policy Scenarios worksheet, then copy

cell B295:F303 or values from a table (see Figure 29) and paste it into the newly created blank sheet.

The users then select the other countries and apply the same approach until complete all countries.

Figure 29: Regional lamp stock by manually adding of the national lamp stock

After that, the users sum all countries’ values on the blank sheet, then generate a sum of those values

and create a chart from the selected range of cells manually.

Regional lamp shipment:

By using PAMA model, lamp shipments in ASEAN is projected that annual lighting product shipments will

rise from around 567 million lamps in 2014 to around 829 million lamps in 2030 (See Figure 30).


September 2016|32

Figure 30: Regional lamp shipment projection from 2015-2030

To construct the regional lamp shipments chart similarly as above, the users can manually build it up by

selecting the “Country” one by one and navigating to “Base Stock” worksheet.

Then select a range of cells: column E to G (‘First purchase’, ‘Replacements’, and ‘Total Sales’) and row

7 to the desired rows or projection period (e.g. 2014-2030 – row 7:24) (see Figure 31). The users copy

the selected cells and paste it into a blank worksheet.

Figure 31: Regional lamp shipment projection by manually adding of the national lamp shipment

The users apply this approach until complete all countries, then sum all countries’ values on the blank

sheet and manually create a regional lamp shipments chart from those values.

Regional Lighting Electricity consumption:


September 2016|33

According to projection of the regional lighting electricity consumption (TWh), it is projected that the

impacts gained from implementation of multiple policy intervention options in the energy efficiency

scenario is projected to be 18.5 TWh in 2030 (See Figure 32).

Figure 32: Regional lighting electricity consumption projection

The users can manually build up this chart by selecting a country from the dropdown list and navigating

to Policy Scenarios sheet, then copy cell G172:M203 and paste into a blank worksheet.

0.0

20.0

40.0

60.0

80.0

100.0

120.0

140.0

160.0

180.0

2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016 2018 2020 2022 2024 2026 2028 2030

Tera

wat

t-h

ou

rs

Residential Commercial Industrial

Street&outdoor EE scenario BAU


September 2016|34

Figure 33: Regional lighting electricity consumption projection by manually adding of the national electricity consumption

The users then select the other countries and apply the same approach until complete all countries. The

users will do the sum and create a projection chart manually from the sum of all countries’ values.

user instructions for the policy analysis ......user instructions for the policy analysis model for...

Documents