united states district court eastern district of … · 4 alexander, james 17-cv-03017 5 alford,...

26
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA In Re: Oil Spill by the Oil Rig “Deepwater Horizon” in the Gulf of Mexico, on April 20, 2010 This Document Relates To: Remaining Cases in the B3 Pleading Bundle * * * * * MDL 2179 SECTION: J(2) JUDGE BARBIER MAG. JUDGE WILKINSON ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE RE: COMPLIANCE WITH PTO 66 The “B3” pleading bundle includes all claims, of any type, relating to post- explosion clean-up efforts asserted against defendants not named in the B1 master complaint, as well as all claims for personal injury and/or medical monitoring for exposure or other injury occurring after the explosion and fire of April 20, 2010. (Pretrial Order No. 25, Rec. Doc. 983 at 2) The B3 bundle includes contract claims related to the oil spill response. On February 22, 2017, the Court issued Pretrial Order No. 63 (“PTO 63”, Rec. Doc. 22295), which ordered all plaintiffs who had timely filed a claim in the B3 pleading bundle and had not released their claims to submit a sworn statement regarding the status of their claim. PTO 63 also required certain B3 plaintiffs to file an individual lawsuit. The B3 claims of those who failed to comply with PTO 63 were dismissed with prejudice. (Rec. Docs. 23047, 23735) Plaintiffs who were deemed compliant with PTO 63 were subject to further proceedings of this Court. Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875 Filed 09/20/18 Page 1 of 5

Upload: others

Post on 26-Sep-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

EASTERN DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA

In Re: Oil Spill by the Oil Rig

“Deepwater Horizon” in the Gulf

of Mexico, on April 20, 2010

This Document Relates To:

Remaining Cases in the B3

Pleading Bundle

*

*

*

*

*

MDL 2179

SECTION: J(2)

JUDGE BARBIER

MAG. JUDGE WILKINSON

ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE RE: COMPLIANCE WITH PTO 66

The “B3” pleading bundle includes all claims, of any type, relating to post-

explosion clean-up efforts asserted against defendants not named in the B1 master

complaint, as well as all claims for personal injury and/or medical monitoring for

exposure or other injury occurring after the explosion and fire of April 20, 2010.

(Pretrial Order No. 25, Rec. Doc. 983 at 2) The B3 bundle includes contract claims

related to the oil spill response.

On February 22, 2017, the Court issued Pretrial Order No. 63 (“PTO 63”, Rec.

Doc. 22295), which ordered all plaintiffs who had timely filed a claim in the B3

pleading bundle and had not released their claims to submit a sworn statement

regarding the status of their claim. PTO 63 also required certain B3 plaintiffs to file

an individual lawsuit. The B3 claims of those who failed to comply with PTO 63

were dismissed with prejudice. (Rec. Docs. 23047, 23735) Plaintiffs who were

deemed compliant with PTO 63 were subject to further proceedings of this Court.

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875 Filed 09/20/18 Page 1 of 5

Page 2: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

2

An updated list of PTO 63-compliant plaintiffs (i.e., the “Remaining B3 Plaintiffs”)

appears at Rec. Doc. 24268.

On April 9, 2018, the Court issued Pretrial Order No. 66 (“PTO 66,” Rec. Doc.

24282), which required all Remaining B3 Plaintiffs (as identified in Rec. Doc.

24268) to complete, sign, and serve a Particularized Statement of Claim (Exhibit A

to PTO 66) on counsel for BP and the Plaintiffs’ Steering Committee (“PSC”) by July

9, 2018. Many Remaining B3 Plaintiffs sought and received an extension up to and

including August 8, 2018 to comply with PTO 66. (Rec. Doc. 24671) PTO 63 warned

that “[a]ny Remaining B3 Plaintiff who fails to comply with his or her obligations

under this Order may be required to show cause to this Court why his, her, or its

claims should not be dismissed with prejudice.” (PTO 66 at 2 (emphasis omitted))

The deadlines for responding to PTO 66 have now passed. Pursuant to the

Court’s instruction, BP has submitted in camera to the Court and the PSC lists

identifying which plaintiffs BP in good faith believed complied with PTO 66 and

which did not. The Court has reviewed these lists, which are attached to this Order

and described below.

EXHIBIT 1 to this Order is a list of 825 plaintiffs that BP believes made

submissions in response to PTO 66 that complied with the requirements of PTO 66.1

The plaintiffs appearing on EXHIBIT 1 are not required to respond to this Order.

The plaintiffs appearing on EXHIBIT 1 are subject to further proceedings of this

Court.

1 The Court removed one plaintiff, Aaron Wallace (No. 13-cv-06153), from BP’s list because his case was severed

from MDL 2179 after PTO 66 issued, mooting the issue of whether Wallace complied with PTO 66. (Rec. Doc.

24578; Rec. Doc. 9 in No. 13-6153)

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875 Filed 09/20/18 Page 2 of 5

Page 3: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

3

EXHIBIT 2 to this Order is a list of 48 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs that appear

to have failed to respond to PTO 66. IT IS ORDERED that any plaintiff

appearing on EXHIBIT 2 must show cause in writing on or before October

11, 2018 why this Court should not dismiss his/her/its B3 claim(s) with

prejudice for failing to comply with the requirements of PTO 66.

EXHIBIT 3 to this Order is a list of 4 plaintiffs who did not respond to PTO

63 (and therefore are not “Remaining B3 Plaintiffs”), but who did submit a response

to PTO 66. IT IS ORDERED that any plaintiff appearing on EXHIBIT 3

must show cause in writing on or before October 11, 2018 why this Court

should not dismiss his/her/its B3 claim(s) with prejudice for failing to

comply with the requirements of PTO 63 and/or find that his/her/its B3

claims(s) were previously dismissed for failing to comply with PTO 63.

EXHIBIT 4 to this Order is a list of 107 plaintiffs that made some form of

submission in response to PTO 66, but whose submissions BP believes are

materially deficient for one or more identified reasons. IT IS ORDERED that any

plaintiff appearing on EXHIBIT 4 must show cause in writing on or before

October 11, 2018 why this Court should not dismiss his/her/its B3 claim(s)

with prejudice for failing to comply with the requirements of PTO 66.

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that any response by BP to the show cause

responses shall be filed by October 25, 2018.

[Note to plaintiffs required to show cause on or before October 11, 2018:

Because PTO 66 did not require plaintiffs to file their Particularized Statement of

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875 Filed 09/20/18 Page 3 of 5

Page 4: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

4

Claim in the Court’s record, the Court will not in most instances be able to examine

the docket to determine if a plaintiff responded to PTO 66 or what they submitted.

Therefore, plaintiffs may need to attach proof of what they submitted with their

show cause responses. Show cause responses should be filed in the MDL master

docket, 10-md-2179, not in the docket for the individual case.]

New Orleans, Louisiana, this 20th day of September, 2018.

______________________________

United States District Judge

Note to Clerk: Mail copies of this Order with Exhibits 1-4 to the following

plaintiffs, who appear to be pro se:

Evans, Robert (Engineers & Filmmakers

Computer Users Group) 16-03966

DeBose, Karen Ann 17-03670

Fetterhoff, Carol L. 17-03350

Fetterhoff, Chelsea 17-03350

Fetterhoff, Chayton Lee 17-03350

Watson, Esther Marie 16-15259

Baker, Edward Joseph 17-03685

DeBose, Chrishawn Derrick 16-10335

Wesley, Charles William Jr. 17-03326

Merchant, Raymond Joe 15-04290

Thompson, Joe 17-02854

The Queen Esther Commercial Fishing 16-15255

McBride, Richard 16-06635

Burkett, Craig Michael 17-03681

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875 Filed 09/20/18 Page 4 of 5

Page 5: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

5

DeBose, Jimmy Raymond 17-03675

Keyes, Ellis 14-02211

McBride, Rico 16-15255

Bruce, Shane Maddox 18-02626

Dean, Michael 17-06800

Thompson, Ashley 17-02854

Note to BP: If John Earl Miller, Jr. (listed on Exhibit 3) or his counsel (if

represented) provided a return address with his PTO 66 submission, BP

shall promptly mail a copy of this Order and Exhibit 3 to him or his

counsel.

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875 Filed 09/20/18 Page 5 of 5

Page 6: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

EXHIBIT 1 - 825 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs with Materially Compliant PTO 66 Submissions - Alphabetical by Name

Row Plaintiff Name Case No.1 Abdelfattah, Khaled 17-cv-034432 Adams, Rosia 17-cv-030003 Aguinaga, Steven Ray 17-cv-031734 Alexander, James 17-cv-030175 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-030186 Allen, Basil 17-cv-034477 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-034798 Amaya-Rodriguez, Denis 17-cv-041279 Anderson, Bernice 17-cv-0302010 Anderson, Christopher 17-cv-0302311 Anderson, Latonya 17-cv-0302212 Anderson, Shuanise 17-cv-0302413 Antoine, Jintrin 17-cv-0388514 Armstrong, Cynthia 17-cv-0302115 Arrington, Rico 17-cv-0302516 Ash, Marcus 17-cv-0302617 Askew, Bruce 17-cv-0362618 Aubert, Teandra 17-cv-0362819 Bachi, Christian 17-cv-0412920 Bachi, Colton 17-cv-0412921 Bachi, Sabrina 17-cv-0412922 Backstrom, David 17-cv-0302923 Baggett, Vernon 17-cv-0303024 Bailey, George 17-cv-0303125 Baltimore, Marilyn 17-cv-0303226 Banks, Christopher 17-cv-0303327 Barkley, Joni Marie 13-cv-0099528 Barkley, Ulysses Napoleon 13-cv-0099829 Barksdale, Donald 17-cv-0303430 Barlow, Torrey 12-cv-0224831 Barnes, Kate 17-cv-0303532 Barnes, Krystal 17-cv-0362933 Barnes, Orlander 17-cv-0303634 Barnes, Susan 17-cv-0363035 Barrington, Chadwick 17-cv-0363236 Bass, Samuel 17-cv-0303737 Beacham, Lathaddeus Omar 17-cv-0303838 Beachem, Cedric Taiwan 13-cv-0100339 Bean, John 17-cv-0363440 Becnel, Lisa 17-cv-0363541 Beeler, Austin 17-cv-0303942 Bell, Fabian 17-cv-0304043 Belton, Roderick 17-cv-0348044 Belvin-Fleming, Terrie 17-cv-0399045 Bendolph, Donell 17-cv-0304146 Bengson, Joshua 17-cv-0321047 Bennett, Gwendolyn 17-cv-0304248 Benyard, Natalie 17-cv-0304349 Berry, Justin Paul 17-cv-0304450 Bertrand, Russell James 13-cv-0024851 Beverly, Cleophus 17-cv-0348252 Beverly, Joy 17-cv-0304553 Bice Jr., Arthur R 14-cv-0115554 Bice, Elizabeth Dae 14-cv-01155

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875-1 Filed 09/20/18 Page 1 of 16

Page 7: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

EXHIBIT 1 - 825 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs with Materially Compliant PTO 66 Submissions - Alphabetical by Name

Row Plaintiff Name Case No.55 Bice, Elizabeth Nicole 14-cv-0115556 Binder, Sammie 17-cv-0363657 Bivins, Clarance 17-cv-0413058 Black, Jamarcus 17-cv-0348359 Black, Lesia 17-cv-0304760 Blackston, Kaden 17-cv-0413161 Blackston, Kermit 17-cv-0363762 Blackston, Savannah 17-cv-0413163 Blackston, Victor 17-cv-0304864 Blackwell, Cherrae 17-cv-0349065 Blakley, Ashley 17-cv-0349266 Bland, Daray 17-cv-0304967 Blanks, Romond 17-cv-0305068 Boatright, Michael E 17-cv-0311169 Bodiford, Thomas 17-cv-0334170 Boggs, Charles Archibald 16-cv-1347671 Boler, Sterling 17-cv-0349972 Bolton, Jonathan Joe 17-cv-0413273 Bonvillain, Wayde 17-cv-0413474 Booker, Willie 17-cv-0305275 Booth, Chianti 17-cv-0305376 Bosarge, Dennis 17-cv-0363977 Bosarge, Lorinda 17-cv-0363978 Bowden Jr, William 17-cv-0350679 Bowden, Teresa 17-cv-0350580 Bowens, Charles 17-cv-0305481 Boyles, Patricia Diane 17-cv-0324382 Bradley, Eric 17-cv-0413683 Bradley, Ervin 17-cv-0305584 Braggs, Michael 17-cv-0388785 Branch, McKinley 17-cv-0305686 Brandon, Ta'Tanisha 17-cv-0413787 Brandon, William 17-cv-0305788 Brazzle, Velma 17-cv-0307889 Brehm, William H 17-cv-0341290 Brewer, Crystal 17-cv-0413891 Brewer, John 17-cv-0307992 Brewer, Thimus 17-cv-0350893 Bridges, Clarence 17-cv-0308094 Briggs, Jimmy 17-cv-0308395 Brimage, Iesha 17-cv-0364096 Brister, Courtney 17-cv-0465297 Brister, Darrell 17-cv-0465298 Britney, Micheln 17-cv-0443799 Broadway Jr, Floyd 17-cv-03087100 Brock, Krista Meja nka Fountain, Krista 17-cv-04139101 Brooks, JT 17-cv-04655102 Brooks, Karen 17-cv-03088103 Broughton, Dewayne Nero 17-cv-03090104 Brown, Arthur 17-cv-03093105 Brown, Cher 17-cv-03516106 Brown, Donna 17-cv-04141107 Brown, Estate of Bryan 17-cv-04140108 Brown, Jamie 12-cv-02333

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875-1 Filed 09/20/18 Page 2 of 16

Page 8: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

EXHIBIT 1 - 825 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs with Materially Compliant PTO 66 Submissions - Alphabetical by Name

Row Plaintiff Name Case No.109 Brown, Joseph 12-cv-02333110 Brown, Lena 17-cv-03097111 Brown, Ray S 17-cv-03099112 Brown, Regina 17-cv-04142113 Brown, Rennell 17-cv-03101114 Brown, Reynard 17-cv-03104115 Brown, Rochelle 17-cv-04143116 Brown, Shah 17-cv-03641117 Brown, Shonte 17-cv-03519118 Brumfield, Curtis 17-cv-04499119 Brumfield, Deja'Jana 17-cv-04562120 Brumfield, Herbert 17-cv-03107121 Brunet Jr., Levy J 17-cv-02672122 Bruton, Joseph 17-cv-03110123 Bryant, Eric 17-cv-03114124 Buckingham, Kathy Elaine 17-cv-04649125 Buckley, Barbara 17-cv-03115126 Bueno-Alba, Jose 17-cv-03523127 Bunch, John 17-cv-04144128 Burns, Albert 17-cv-03117129 Bush, Douglas 17-cv-03118130 Butler III, Milton 17-cv-03075 131 Butler, Debra 17-cv-03077132 Butler, Lakesha 17-cv-04145133 Butler, Michael 17-cv-04153134 Byrd, Brandon 17-cv-03073135 Byrd, George 17-cv-03070136 Byrd, Jennifer 17-cv-03642137 Cambre, Andoche 17-cv-03643138 Campbell, Sharon 17-cv-03119139 Campbell, Trevor 17-cv-03524140 Cantillo, Dwaine 17-cv-03226141 Caraway, Michael 17-cv-03120142 Card, Lora Ann 17-cv-03121143 Cargill, Markeelin 17-cv-03644144 Carpenter, Otis 17-cv-03645145 Carter, Charles 17-cv-03123146 Caser Jr, Willie 17-cv-03525147 Castleberry, Jackie 17-cv-04154148 Castleberry, Jeffrey 17-cv-04154149 Castleberry-Ford, Jancey 17-cv-04154150 Catchings, Dawn 17-cv-03124151 Causey, Roy 17-cv-03888152 Chambers, Brianne 17-cv-04067153 Chapman, Shata 17-cv-04155154 Chapman, Tatyana 17-cv-04155155 Charles, Corey 17-cv-03125156 Chatman, vonshea 17-cv-03646157 Cheramie, Estate of Rodney Joseph 17-cv-04507158 Cheramie, Gabrielle 17-cv-04502159 Cintra, Elvis 17-cv-03889160 Clay, Christopher 17-cv-03526161 Coastal Water Cleaners and Environmental Services, LLC 11-cv-02621162 Colbert, Edward 17-cv-03647

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875-1 Filed 09/20/18 Page 3 of 16

Page 9: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

EXHIBIT 1 - 825 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs with Materially Compliant PTO 66 Submissions - Alphabetical by Name

Row Plaintiff Name Case No.163 Colburn, Rita 17-cv-03648164 Cole, Willie 17-cv-03649165 Coleman, Barbara 17-cv-03127166 Coleman, Charles 17-cv-04157167 Coleman, Herbert 17-cv-03128168 Coleman, Lillie 17-cv-03130169 Coleman, Steve 17-cv-04158170 Collier, Nicholas W 17-cv-03356171 Collier, Patrick 17-cv-03131172 Conley, Fred 17-cv-03650173 Coon, George 17-cv-03686174 Cotton, Cillo 17-cv-03132175 Cotton, Gary 17-cv-03133176 Craig, Anthony 17-cv-03134177 Cranmer, Danielle 17-cv-03688178 Crawford, Olivia 17-cv-03135179 Crawford, Patrick 17-cv-03136180 Crosby, Melton III 17-cv-03689181 Crumpton, Carolyn 17-cv-03527182 Cuevas, Dean 17-cv-03137183 Culberson, Renell 17-cv-04159184 Curbelo, Ivan 17-cv-03690185 Dailey, Lucy 17-cv-03528186 Dang, Anh Ngoc 17-cv-02387187 Daniel, Dana 17-cv-04160188 Daniel, Eileen 17-cv-04309189 Daniels, Estee 17-cv-04392190 Daniels, Robert Jr. 17-cv-04394191 Danos, Jorey Tristan 17-cv-03113192 Danos, Richard Thomas 17-cv-03240193 Dardar Sr, Benny 17-cv-03138194 Darrington, Lequaita 17-cv-03139195 Dasco, Leif 17-cv-03531196 Davenport, Kevin 17-cv-03725197 Davenport, Larry 17-cv-03726198 Davis, Luke III 17-cv-04310199 Davis, Mary 17-cv-03141200 Davis, Michael 17-cv-04664201 Davis, Sedija 17-cv-04312202 Davis, Travis 17-cv-04313203 Davison, Sandra 17-cv-03142204 Davis-Sherrod, Myesha 17-cv-04314205 Dawkins, Frederick 17-cv-03533206 DeBose, Chrishawn Derrick 16-cv-10335207 DeBose, Jimmy Raymond 17-cv-03675208 DeBose, Karen Ann 17-cv-03670209 Dedeaux, Yolanda 17-cv-03143210 Deese, Eric 17-cv-03144211 Delmar, Karis 17-cv-04648212 DeLoach, Robert 17-cv-03149213 DePaz, Susana 17-cv-03892214 Dial, Jack 17-cv-03150215 Dill, Johnny 17-cv-04315216 Dinkins, Michael 17-cv-04319

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875-1 Filed 09/20/18 Page 4 of 16

Page 10: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

EXHIBIT 1 - 825 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs with Materially Compliant PTO 66 Submissions - Alphabetical by Name

Row Plaintiff Name Case No.217 Dixey, Heather 17-cv-04320218 Dixey, Jordan 17-cv-04321219 Dixon, Michael 17-cv-03900220 Do, Yen 17-cv-03903221 Dobbs, Terresa 17-cv-03152222 Doom, Christian Michael 17-cv-04395223 Doom, Danielle 17-cv-04395224 Doom, Gavin 17-cv-04395225 Doom, Kathryn 17-cv-04395226 Doom, Paul Matthew 17-cv-04395227 Doom, Paul Raymond 17-cv-04395228 Dorsey, Wilbert 17-cv-03154229 Doud, Elizabeth 17-cv-03534230 Ducksworth, Vantavious L. 17-cv-03157231 Duke, Tiffany Savage 16-cv-13873232 Dukes, Marshall 17-cv-03159233 Dumas, David P. 17-cv-03160234 Dumas, Hakim 17-cv-04322235 Durden, Angela Laverne 17-cv-03536236 Durham, Keith E. 17-cv-03537237 Durr, Mario 17-cv-03538238 Dykes, Wendell 17-cv-04323239 Easterling, Tonnie 17-cv-03913240 Edwards, Al 17-cv-04324241 Edwards, Junior 17-cv-03928242 Edwards, Natasha 17-cv-03957243 Ellzey, Eric D. 17-cv-03163244 Elzey, Estate of Johnny 17-cv-03985245 England, Thomas M. 17-cv-03180246 English, Elizabeth Sibley 17-cv-03182247 English, Jr., Eugene 17-cv-03182248 English, Mervin 17-cv-04325249 Estate of Alan Henderson 17-cv-03273250 Estate of Alvin Holifield 17-cv-03284251 Estate of Chavis Allen 17-cv-03019252 Estate of Joe May, Jr. 17-cv-04550253 Estate of Kimlyn Preatto 17-cv-04556254 Estate of Leona Austin 17-cv-04128255 Estate of Raymond Lirette 17-cv-03333256 Estate of Sherrie McKinley 17-cv-04562257 Evans, Keywaski 17-cv-04326258 Evans, Robert 16-cv-03966259 Expose, Bernard 17-cv-03986260 Fairley, Alford 17-cv-03184261 Fairley, Freddie 17-cv-03988262 Fairley, Royce 17-cv-03188263 Fast, William 17-cv-03989264 Favorite, Carl 17-cv-03192265 Ferguson, Minnie 17-cv-04327266 Fielder, Cheryl 17-cv-03193267 Fitzgerald, Nathan Joseph 13-cv-00650268 Fleming, James 17-cv-03195269 Flournoy, David Allen Sr. 17-cv-04396270 Flournoy, Jr., David 17-cv-04396

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875-1 Filed 09/20/18 Page 5 of 16

Page 11: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

EXHIBIT 1 - 825 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs with Materially Compliant PTO 66 Submissions - Alphabetical by Name

Row Plaintiff Name Case No.271 Flournoy, Nancy 17-cv-04396272 Ford, Leslie 17-cv-03198273 Fountain, John 17-cv-03200274 Fountain, Mary 17-cv-03202275 Fountain, Reginald 17-cv-03204276 Fowler, Julian 17-cv-03208277 Foxworth, Jackulin 17-cv-03991278 Foxworth, Tiffany 17-cv-04328279 Francisco, Mark 17-cv-03212280 Franichevich, Andrew 17-cv-03992281 Franklin, Jr., Charles M. 17-cv-03215282 Franks, Robert 17-cv-03216283 Fugatt, Curtis Carl 13-cv-01014284 Fuller III., Robert Dewery 13-cv-05372285 Gaines, Shawndaius 17-cv-04329286 Gainey, Carolyn 17-cv-03993287 Gainey, Estate of Russell 17-cv-03993288 Gamble, James 17-cv-03994289 Gara, Dennis 17-cv-03223290 Garcia, John 17-cv-03541291 Gardner, Sandra 17-cv-03224292 Garlow, Clarence 17-cv-04330293 Gaspard, Jamie Lee 13-cv-04437294 Gathers, Renee 17-cv-03229295 Gentry, Brandon 17-cv-03995296 Gilliam, Earl 17-cv-03234297 Gilmore, Arthur 17-cv-03236298 Giusti, Jr., Ernest 17-cv-03996299 Godfrey, Scott 17-cv-04331300 Goldsmith, Marcine 17-cv-03256301 Gomes, Tevon 17-cv-04332302 Gonzales, James 17-cv-04333303 Granier, Stephen 17-cv-02674304 Grant, Marcus 17-cv-04334305 Graves, Carl 17-cv-04335306 Gray, Michael 17-cv-04336307 Gray, Princess 17-cv-04660308 Green, Birmella 17-cv-04337309 Green, Timothy 17-cv-03997310 Griffin, Alice Mae 17-cv-03244311 Griffin, Marshall D. 17-cv-03259312 Guess, Serena 17-cv-03260313 Hakenjos, Jamerson 17-cv-04338314 Hall, Lanycha 17-cv-03998315 Halsell, Edwin 17-cv-03262316 Hamilton, Terrence 17-cv-03263317 Hampton, Jerry Paul 13-cv-03929318 Hardy, Ronnie 17-cv-04339319 Harewood, Kirk 17-cv-04340320 Harmon, James 17-cv-04341321 Harris Jr, Ezzard 17-cv-04344322 Harris, Al'Terryal 17-cv-04342323 Harris, Cedric 17-cv-03264324 Harris, Charles 17-cv-03265

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875-1 Filed 09/20/18 Page 6 of 16

Page 12: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

EXHIBIT 1 - 825 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs with Materially Compliant PTO 66 Submissions - Alphabetical by Name

Row Plaintiff Name Case No.325 Harris, Derry 17-cv-04343326 Harris, Elvis 17-cv-03266327 Harris, Rushion 17-cv-03267328 Harris, Terrance 17-cv-04345329 Harris, Tyron 17-cv-03268330 Harrison, Kennard 17-cv-04346331 Harry, Jerome 17-cv-04347332 Harvey, Khristi 17-cv-03269333 Hasdorff, Beverly Ann Painton 17-cv-03235334 Hasdorff, Terri 17-cv-03233335 Hatcher, Dana 17-cv-04348336 Hatcher, Daniel Veryle 17-cv-03179337 Hayes, Isaac 17-cv-04397338 Hayes, Isaiah 17-cv-04397339 Hayes, Mary 17-cv-04397340 Hayes, Rodney 17-cv-04349341 Haynes, Alexander 17-cv-03271342 Haynes, Almetis 17-cv-04350343 Haynes, Willie 17-cv-03272344 Heathington, Thomas 17-cv-04353345 Hebert, Paul Anthony 11-cv-01200346 Henderson, Wayne 17-cv-03275347 Hendrix, Mitchell 17-cv-04354348 Henson, Sr James 17-cv-03277349 Hicks, Keundra 17-cv-04356350 Higginbotham, Dorothy Clayton 17-cv-03315351 Hill, Robyn Lyn 17-cv-03252352 Hillard, Julius 17-cv-03279353 Hines, Thomas Jr. 17-cv-03280354 Hockaday, Edison 17-cv-03281355 Hodge, Charlie 17-cv-03282356 Hohnadell, Alec 17-cv-03999357 Holder, Dane II 17-cv-03283358 Holifield, Eric 17-cv-04358359 Holifield, Gollie 17-cv-04359360 Horne, Haley 17-cv-04568361 Horne, Karem 17-cv-03285362 Houser, Bruce 17-cv-04360363 Howard, Larry 17-cv-03543364 Howell, Frank Morris 17-cv-03232365 Howell, Patricia 17-cv-03287366 Huddleston, Carson Cortez 17-cv-03289367 Hudley, Daniel Robert 10-cv-04200368 Hudson, Mark 17-cv-04361369 Hudson, Travis 17-cv-04362370 Hughes, William Robert 17-cv-04363371 Hundley, Clamus 17-cv-03290372 Hunt, Bruce Donald 13-cv-01017373 Hunter, Dale Anthony 13-cv-03147374 Hurd, Shikiah 17-cv-04364375 Hurd, Steven 17-cv-04000376 Hurd, Theresa 17-cv-03545377 Huynh, Trong 17-cv-03291378 Hye, Ella 17-cv-03292

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875-1 Filed 09/20/18 Page 7 of 16

Page 13: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

EXHIBIT 1 - 825 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs with Materially Compliant PTO 66 Submissions - Alphabetical by Name

Row Plaintiff Name Case No.379 Hye, Terry 17-cv-03293380 Isom, Cedric 17-cv-04365381 Jackson, Anthony 17-cv-03294382 Jackson, Brenda 17-cv-03295383 Jackson, Christola 17-cv-03296384 Jackson, Greogry 17-cv-03297385 Jackson, Marcus 17-cv-03298386 Jackson, Sharon 17-cv-03299387 Jackson, Tarus 17-cv-04366388 Jacobs, Euweeka 17-cv-03300389 Jacquez, Jose 17-cv-03301390 Jenkins, Chris 17-cv-03303391 Jenkins, Terri 17-cv-04367392 Jesco Construction Corporation of Delaware 11-cv-00911393 Johns, Joan 17-cv-03304394 Johnson Jr, Travis 17-cv-04399395 Johnson, Beaux 17-cv-03305396 Johnson, Carl 17-cv-04369397 Johnson, Carmine 17-cv-03306398 Johnson, Chestere 17-cv-03307399 Johnson, Deborah 17-cv-04370400 Johnson, Gena 17-cv-04371401 Johnson, Grady 17-cv-03308402 Johnson, Lisa;Williams, Lisa Allean 17-cv-04372403 Johnson, Reginald 17-cv-04647404 Johnson, Roderick 17-cv-04373405 Johnson, Stephen 17-cv-04374406 Johnson, Victoria 17-cv-04399407 Johson, Aaron 17-cv-04368408 Joiner, Richard 17-cv-03310409 Jones, Al'Lisha 17-cv-04375410 Jones, Andre 17-cv-04376411 Jones, Brandon 17-cv-04378412 Jones, Charlene 17-cv-03312413 Jones, Cynthia 17-cv-04377414 Jones, Edward 17-cv-04379415 Jones, Howard 17-cv-04380416 Jones, Larry 17-cv-04381417 Jones, Marvin Earl 17-cv-04382418 Jones, Tekira 17-cv-04384419 Jones, Travis 17-cv-04385420 Joseph, Eldridge 17-cv-04386421 Jourden, Forest 17-cv-04569422 Kalinowski, Kevin 17-cv-04387423 Kaoui, Peter M. 17-cv-03313424 Kenner, Taijahrell 17-cv-03314425 Keyes, Christine Cook 14-cv-02211426 Keys, Ernestine 17-cv-04389 427 Kidd, Larry 17-cv-04390 428 King, Clifton 17-cv-04393 429 King, Dewayne 17-cv-04398430 King, Tai-Keysha 17-cv-04398 431 Kolian, Stephan R 17-cv-03108432 LaBrosse, Jeremiah 17-cv-04401

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875-1 Filed 09/20/18 Page 8 of 16

Page 14: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

EXHIBIT 1 - 825 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs with Materially Compliant PTO 66 Submissions - Alphabetical by Name

Row Plaintiff Name Case No.433 LaForce, Allen Bradley 17-cv-04402434 Landers, Jason Eugene 13-cv-01019435 Landry, Cy 17-cv-03317436 Laneaux, Eureaka 17-cv-04403437 Lartigue, Roger 17-cv-03353438 Laster, Patrick Jr 17-cv-03319439 Lawrence, Jamie 17-cv-04654440 Lawson, Telly 17-cv-04404441 Lawton, Diana 17-cv-03320442 Le, Trinh 17-cv-04001443 Le, Trinity 17-cv-04001444 Learn, Cherry 17-cv-03321445 Leathwood, Charles 17-cv-04405446 Lee Jr, Elbert 17-cv-04406447 Lee, Ava 17-cv-04558448 Lee, Kathy 17-cv-04407449 Lee, Terrance 17-cv-04558450 Lenard, Dalan 17-cv-03546451 Lepoma, Mary 17-cv-04408452 Lett, Hibbard 17-cv-04409453 Leverette, Clyde 17-cv-03324454 Lewis Jr, Ulyses 17-cv-03330455 Lewis, Glenda 17-cv-03325456 Lewis, Lashona 17-cv-04410457 Lewis, Sherrie 17-cv-03329458 Loftus, Wesley 17-cv-03339459 Lopez, Irene 17-cv-04415460 Lucky, Ethel 17-cv-03340461 Lundy, Luke 17-cv-04417462 Lutin, Frederick 17-cv-04419463 Mackles, Duke 17-cv-04002464 Mackles, Shane 17-cv-04003465 Macon, Willie 17-cv-03548466 Maddox, Jeffery 17-cv-04560467 Maddox, Josephine 17-cv-04560468 Magee, Andrea 17-cv-04399469 Magee, Richard 17-cv-03549470 Magee, Virdee 17-cv-04561471 Magee, Whitney 17-cv-04561472 Magee, Xavier 17-cv-04561473 Maneen, Rachel Renee 17-cv-03183474 Mann, Maxie 17-cv-04421475 Manning, Anthony 17-cv-04422476 Manquel Liddell, Kendrick Sharonta 17-cv-03332477 Marler, Gregory Lee 17-cv-03206478 Marshall-Reech, Angie 17-cv-04564479 Martin, Chris Albert 17-cv-03228480 Martin, Clifton 17-cv-04004481 Martin, Flint 17-cv-03358482 Martin, Lizzie 17-cv-04424483 Martin, Sterling 17-cv-03249484 Martin, Tatasha 17-cv-04429485 Martin, Trudy 17-cv-03360486 Matthews, Cleveland 17-cv-04005

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875-1 Filed 09/20/18 Page 9 of 16

Page 15: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

EXHIBIT 1 - 825 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs with Materially Compliant PTO 66 Submissions - Alphabetical by Name

Row Plaintiff Name Case No.487 Matthis, Shawna 17-cv-03550488 Matulonis, Anthony Jason 13-cv-01512489 Maurras, Douglas John 17-cv-03185 490 May, Derrick 17-cv-04068491 Mayfield, Anthony 17-cv-03364492 McArthur, Corey 17-cv-03371493 McCall, Verda 17-cv-03551494 McCammon, Larry 17-cv-03375495 McCann, Missouri 17-cv-04006496 McClendon, Dorothy 17-cv-03379497 McConaghy, Kade 17-cv-03116498 McConaghy, Kara 17-cv-03116499 McConaghy, Kent 17-cv-03116500 MCConaghy, Kohl 17-cv-03116501 McCray, Anthony 17-cv-03552502 McDaniel, Ronald 17-cv-04069503 McDonald, Bobby 17-cv-04432504 McDonald, David 17-cv-04434505 McDougle, Derrick 17-cv-03386506 McElroy, Alexis 17-cv-04070507 McGill, Erik 17-cv-03392508 McGill, Jeremy 17-cv-03395509 McGill, Ray 17-cv-04071510 McInnis, Jr., Jacques 17-cv-03555511 McInnis, Sr., Jacques 17-cv-03556512 McInnis, Traci 17-cv-04436513 McKay, Melina 17-cv-04072514 McMeans, Charles 17-cv-03558515 McMillan, Jeffari 17-cv-03396516 McQueen, Henry 17-cv-03563517 Meadows, Alton Rockford 13-cv-01746518 Medel, Jesse 17-cv-03564519 Merchant, Raymond Joe 15-cv-04290520 Michael, III, Frank 17-cv-04563521 Michael, Trai 17-cv-03565522 Mickles, Shantae 17-cv-03566523 Millender, Raymond 17-cv-04439524 Miller, Carolyn 17-cv-04441525 Miller, James 17-cv-02678526 Miller, Jerry 17-cv-04444527 Miller, Taschet 17-cv-03569528 Miller, Timothy Bennett 17-cv-03398529 Mills, Kenneth 17-cv-04448530 Milsap, Angela 17-cv-04449531 Milsap, Dennis 17-cv-04451532 Minor, Michael 17-cv-04073533 Minton, Lee 17-cv-03400534 Moore, Albert B III 17-cv-03571535 Moore, Albert R IV 17-cv-03572536 Moore, Anthony 17-cv-04453537 Moore, Anthony W 17-cv-04454538 Moore, April 17-cv-04456539 Moore, Charles 17-cv-03573540 Moore, Cheryl 17-cv-04657

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875-1 Filed 09/20/18 Page 10 of 16

Page 16: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

EXHIBIT 1 - 825 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs with Materially Compliant PTO 66 Submissions - Alphabetical by Name

Row Plaintiff Name Case No.541 Moore, Cynthia 17-cv-04074542 Moore, Dennis 17-cv-03574543 Moore, Felicia 17-cv-03576544 Moore, Kendall 17-cv-03402545 Moore, Sandra 17-cv-04457546 Moorere, Holly 17-cv-04461547 Morgan, James 17-cv-03187548 Morgan, Taccari 17-cv-03579549 Murray, Kelvin 17-cv-03582550 Nance, Jimmy 17-cv-04462551 Naquin, Bryant 17-cv-03584552 Naquin, Velma 17-cv-03586553 Nelson, Robert Jr 17-cv-04075554 Nestle, Stephen 17-cv-04463555 Netherland, Gabriella 17-cv-04559556 Netherland, Jonathan 17-cv-04559557 Newton, Brandon 17-cv-03588558 Ngo, Phieu 17-cv-04464559 Nguyen, Hillary 17-cv-04465560 Nguyen, Hung Van 17-cv-04467561 Nguyen, Kha 17-cv-04468562 Norris, Daphne 17-cv-04565563 Norswearthy, Chester Jr 17-cv-03590564 Norwood, Austin 17-cv-03203565 Novelozo, Ulric Adriel 13-cv-01033566 Olds, Joe Annie 17-cv-03591567 O'Neal, Estate of Richard 17-cv-04076568 Orange, Tony 17-cv-03592569 Osbey, Christopher 17-cv-04470570 Pace, Linda 17-cv-04471571 Packer, Patrick 17-cv-04077572 Paige, Cynthia 17-cv-03594573 Parker, Edward 17-cv-04078574 Patterson, Dana 17-cv-04079575 Patton, Carlos 17-cv-04473576 Payton, Alexzander 17-cv-04474577 Paz, Cesar 17-cv-04557578 Paz, Cesar Andrew Jr. 17-cv-04557579 Paz, Isreal 17-cv-04557580 Paz, Keren 17-cv-04557581 Peairs, Marcus 17-cv-03596582 Pearson, Barbara 17-cv-03597583 Pejic, Nenad 17-cv-04475584 Penn, Tavarish 17-cv-04080585 Pennington, Kathy 17-cv-04280586 Perdomo, Henry Giovanni 17-cv-03346587 Perkins, Isaac 17-cv-04476588 Peters, Rhett 17-cv-04479589 Pettaway, Denise 17-cv-03404590 Pettway, Delrick 17-cv-04481591 Pettway, Sandra 17-cv-04146592 Phillips, Angela 17-cv-04163593 Phillips, Bryant 17-cv-04281594 Pickett, George 17-cv-04482

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875-1 Filed 09/20/18 Page 11 of 16

Page 17: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

EXHIBIT 1 - 825 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs with Materially Compliant PTO 66 Submissions - Alphabetical by Name

Row Plaintiff Name Case No.595 Picou, Donna 17-cv-03207596 Plummer, Edna 17-cv-04483

597 Poirson, Patrick17-cv-0317717-cv-03378

598 Polk, Felton 17-cv-04282599 Polk, Tonta 17-cv-03600600 Porter, Scott Alan 17-cv-03344601 Pough, Ervin 17-cv-04164602 Powe, Andre 17-cv-04484603 Powell, Donald 17-cv-04489604 Powell, Whirlee 17-cv-04283605 Prest Sr, Kirk Edgar 17-cv-03409606 Prestenbach, Anthony 17-cv-04570607 Price, Calvin Sr 17-cv-04571608 Price, James 17-cv-04572609 Quiroz, Robert 17-cv-04166610 Ramey, Robert 17-cv-03405611 Ranson, Ron 17-cv-04168612 Rawls, Derrick 17-cv-04509613 Reeb, Michael 17-cv-03602614 Reech, Riley 17-cv-04564615 Reed, Antonio 17-cv-04174616 Reed, Chester 17-cv-03603617 Regan, Laura 13-cv-02378 618 Regan, Robert 13-cv-02378619 Revels, Carl 17-cv-04175620 Richard, Tyrone 17-cv-04284621 Richardson, A'Donna 17-cv-03407622 Richoux, Denise Malcombe 17-cv-03186623 Riddell-Hare, Teresa 17-cv-04177624 Riley, Darren 17-cv-04304625 Roan, Kenneth 17-cv-04178626 Roberson, Raynard 17-cv-04286627 Roberts, Cynthia 17-cv-03605628 Roberts, Frances 17-cv-04513629 Robertson, Carrie 17-cv-04573630 Robinson, Brian 17-cv-03606631 Robinson, Ricco Jr. 17-cv-04536632 Rogers, Betty 17-cv-04575633 Rooks, Darla 17-cv-04400634 Rooks, Todd 17-cv-04400635 Ross, Erica 17-cv-04287636 Ross, Vanessa 17-cv-04288637 Rounds, Gregory 17-cv-04576638 Rye, Patricia Marie 17-cv-03155639 Sanchez, Victoria Angelina Avila 12-cv-00164640 Saxton, Latonya 17-cv-04577641 Scaief, Veronica 17-cv-04242642 Scarborough, Michael 17-cv-04243643 Schexnayder, Farrell D 17-cv-03207644 Schexnayder, Gary Lane 17-cv-03207645 Schexnayder, Larry 17-cv-03207646 Schmidt, Michelle 17-cv-04279647 Schmidt, Rachel 17-cv-04179

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875-1 Filed 09/20/18 Page 12 of 16

Page 18: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

EXHIBIT 1 - 825 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs with Materially Compliant PTO 66 Submissions - Alphabetical by Name

Row Plaintiff Name Case No.648 Scott, Barbara 17-cv-03608649 Scott, Codie 17-cv-04578650 Scott, Corey 17-cv-04554651 Scott, Joliegh 17-cv-04554652 Scott, Matthew 17-cv-04554653 Scott, Nakia 17-cv-03609654 Scott, Nicole 17-cv-04554655 Seay, Sharitye 17-cv-04244656 Sebastian, Herbert 17-cv-04355657 Sellers, Terrance 17-cv-03610658 Sewell, Carolyn 17-cv-04245659 Sewer, Misha 17-cv-04581660 Shade, Twinella 17-cv-04246661 Shannon, Tory 17-cv-03611662 Shearon, Jr. Ronald Franklin 17-cv-03155663 Shearon, Karla June 17-cv-03155664 Shearon, Kenzie Joy 17-cv-03155665 Shepard, Lori 17-cv-04582666 Sherrod, Christopher 17-cv-03410667 Siegel, Barton J 13-cv-00768668 Simmons, Blake 17-cv-04553669 Simmons, Gayla 17-cv-04248670 Simmons, Kevin 17-cv-04553671 Simmons, Kevin II 17-cv-04553672 Simmons, Tony 17-cv-04583673 Simon, Jamie Marie 11-cv-01432674 Sketteno, Samuel Jr 17-cv-04181675 Slaughter, Bobby 17-cv-04584676 Sledge, Raymond 17-cv-04249677 Smith, Cindy 17-cv-04180678 Smith, LaJoy 17-cv-04250679 Smith, Lee A. 17-cv-04586680 Smith, Linda Trotter 17-cv-04251681 Smith, Tyrone 17-cv-04551682 Sonnier, Jason 17-cv-04252683 Spencer, Rita 17-cv-04253684 Spencer, Trellis 17-cv-04254685 Sproat, Nancy Lee 17-cv-04255686 Spurlock, Deedra 17-cv-04256687 St. Ann, John 17-cv-04257688 Stallworth, Beste 17-cv-04566689 Stallworth, Gloria 17-cv-03411690 Stallworth, III, Ben 17-cv-03612691 Stallworth, Josiah 17-cv-04514692 Stallworth, Marlon 17-cv-04183693 Stanton, Patrick 17-cv-04258694 Stennis, Ernest 17-cv-04590695 Stephens Jr, Thomas 17-cv-04520696 Stephens, Randi 17-cv-04294697 Stephens, Sr., Thomas 17-cv-04592698 Stepleton, Charles 17-cv-04588699 Stewart, Alpenaton 17-cv-04184700 Stewart, Elizabeth 17-cv-04299701 Stewart, Jr., Lloyd 17-cv-03613

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875-1 Filed 09/20/18 Page 13 of 16

Page 19: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

EXHIBIT 1 - 825 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs with Materially Compliant PTO 66 Submissions - Alphabetical by Name

Row Plaintiff Name Case No.702 Stockstill, Damien 17-cv-04400703 Stockstill, Daniel 17-cv-04400704 Storey, Daniel 17-cv-04593705 Stovall, Lambert 17-cv-04640706 Strauss, Robert 17-cv-03615707 Street, Carrington 17-cv-04259708 Street, Corey 17-cv-03619709 Street, Don 17-cv-04300710 Street, Shadronica 17-cv-04260711 Stricklin, Samhouston 17-cv-04552712 Stubbs, Estate of Jesse 17-cv-04261713 Summerall, Tara 17-cv-04643714 Swaney, Julie 17-cv-04186715 Swanier, Marqueda 17-cv-04644716 Tabokka Chapman, Jr 17-cv-04155717 Tate, Curtis 17-cv-04264718 Taylor, Charles William 17-cv-03222719 Taylor, Jeremy 17-cv-04190720 Taylor, Kimberly 17-cv-04603721 Taylor, Robert Vaughan 17-cv-03201722 Taylor, Shana 17-cv-04191723 Tebbs, Sheila 17-cv-04606724 Terrebonne, Jr., Gary 17-cv-04192725 Terrebonne, Sr., Gary 17-cv-04549726 The Queen Esther Commercial Fishing 16-cv-15255727 Thomas, Carlos 17-cv-04608728 Thomas, David Jr. 17-cv-04556729 Thomas, Kendrick 17-cv-04195730 Thomas, Kennedy 17-cv-04301731 Thomas, Lakesha on Behalf of the Estate of Jimmie Thomas 17-cv-04547732 Thomas, Raymond 17-cv-04595733 Thompson, Adonis 17-cv-04198734 Thompson, Brian 17-cv-04265735 Thompson, Christopher 17-cv-04609736 Thompson, DeForrest 17-cv-04611737 Thompson, Randy 17-cv-04202738 Tickell, Rebecca Harrell 17-cv-03169739 Timmons, Frances 17-cv-04266740 Tobias, Warren 17-cv-04613741 Toler, Juanita 17-cv-04267742 Tolliver, Michael 17-cv-04268743 Torres, Esmerelda 17-cv-04204744 Townser, Frank N. III 17-cv-04519745 Townser, Jr., Frank 17-cv-04205746 Traylor Evans, Gabrielle 17-cv-04302747 Trotter, Marvin Kenneth 17-cv-03621748 Troxler, Jr., Clifford 17-cv-04207749 Turner, Gregory Scott 17-cv-03225750 Turner, Tonie 17-cv-04214751 Turner, Vickey 17-cv-04616752 United States Environmental Services, LLC 17-cv-03370

753United States Maritime Services, Inc. d/b/a United States Maritime Services, LLC

17-cv-0338217-cv-03388

754 Upchurch, Amanda Johnson 17-cv-03413

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875-1 Filed 09/20/18 Page 14 of 16

Page 20: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

EXHIBIT 1 - 825 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs with Materially Compliant PTO 66 Submissions - Alphabetical by Name

Row Plaintiff Name Case No.755 Vaughan, Jeff R 17-cv-03250756 Vazquez, Jr., Eric 17-cv-04617757 Veal, Ernest 17-cv-04215758 Vickers, Michael Brandon 13-cv-00456759 Vicknair, Rachel Rost 17-cv-04517760 Villere, Jane 17-cv-04217761 Waddell, Tyrell 17-cv-04271762 Wade, James 17-cv-04624763 Walker, Allen 17-cv-03012764 Walker, II, Rodney 17-cv-04219765 Walker, Lisa 17-cv-03622766 Wallce, Guy Hillyer 13-cv-01039767 Walter, Shanavia 17-cv-04273768 Ward, Jennifer 17-cv-04220769 Ware, Mia 17-cv-04221770 Warren, Larry D 17-cv-04626771 Washington, Janel 17-cv-04296772 Washington, Victoria 17-cv-04297773 Watkins, Archie 17-cv-04274774 Watson, Esther Marie 16-cv-15259775 Watts, Derek 17-cv-04627776 Watts, Jeremy 17-cv-04298777 Waxman, David 17-cv-04222778 Weathersby, Sherlyon 17-cv-04295779 Webb, Dalisha 17-cv-04223780 Wellington, Jada 17-cv-04542781 Wellington, Janya 17-cv-04542782 Wellington, Melissa 17-cv-04542783 Wells, Rabell 17-cv-04224784 Wensel, Betsy 17-cv-04629785 Wheaton, Don 17-cv-04226786 White, Alexis 17-cv-04227787 White, Rashawn 17-cv-03623788 White, Ricardo 17-cv-04229789 Whitfield, Chelsea 17-cv-04230790 Whittiker, Timothy 17-cv-04231791 Whittinghill, Clay 10-cv-01984792 Wilcox, Dennis 17-cv-04232793 Williams Jr., Herman 17-cv-02675794 Williams, Angelinia 17-cv-04632795 Williams, Ashley N 13-cv-01041796 Williams, Auron 17-cv-04633797 Williams, Charetta 17-cv-04233798 Williams, Charles 17-cv-04277799 Williams, Clarence 17-cv-04234800 Williams, Darlene 17-cv-03207801 Williams, Dawarren 17-cv-04291802 Williams, Gregory 17-cv-04306803 Williams, Holly 17-cv-04307804 Williams, Jahnia 17-cv-04634805 Williams, Jr., James 17-cv-04235806 Williams, Kaneika Naylor 17-cv-04636807 Williams, Pricilla 17-cv-04660808 Williams, Rachel 17-cv-03207

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875-1 Filed 09/20/18 Page 15 of 16

Page 21: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

EXHIBIT 1 - 825 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs with Materially Compliant PTO 66 Submissions - Alphabetical by Name

Row Plaintiff Name Case No.809 Williams, Randy 17-cv-04236810 Williams, Roy 17-cv-04516811 Willis, Aaron 17-cv-04597812 Wilson, Bernice 17-cv-04239813 Wilson, Cossie 17-cv-04659814 Wilson, Mark 17-cv-04278815 Wright, Andre 17-cv-04241816 Wunstell, John 10-cv-02543817 Wynne, Gisele Reese 17-cv-03230818 Wynne, Gregg Lawrence 17-cv-03230819 Wynne, Marlee Addison 17-cv-03230820 Wynne, Monette Renee 17-cv-03230821 Wynne, Ranger Cade 17-cv-03230822 Yarbrough, Daniel 17-cv-04293823 Yarbrough, Rebecca 17-cv-04292824 Yerkes III., Joseph E 17-cv-03194825 Zayzay, Freddie 17-cv-04637

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875-1 Filed 09/20/18 Page 16 of 16

Page 22: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

EXHIBIT 2 - 48 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs Who Made No PTO 66 Submissions - Alphabetical by Name

Row Plaintiff Name Case No.1 Abdelfattah, Yahya Omar 17-cv-034462 Aguinaga, Stephane 17-cv-031733 Baird, Bryan Joshua 17-cv-031784 Boose, Lawyer Jr. 17-cv-041355 Chelsea Co., LLC 12-cv-026506 Claery, Robert 17-cv-028557 Conerly, Jeffery 17-cv-031708 Dorgan, Sheri Allen 17-cv-033679 Duong, Thanh Chan 16-cv-0395310 Evans, Glyn 17-cv-0316711 Ferrell, Donald Lane 17-cv-0285012 Fonseca, Kim Joseph 17-cv-0334313 Hackney, David 17-cv-0317514 Harris, Tishia Maria 17-cv-0465015 Helmholtz, Michael 17-cv-0293216 Howard, Alfred 17-cv-0328617 Iames, Sandra Ann 17-cv-0321718 Johnny Tran, LLC 17-cv-0335119 Kelly, Billy Ray Jr. 17-cv-04388 20 Gortney, Brian W. II 15-cv-0104721 Kinler, Charles Bernard 13-cv-0238722 Lim, Seng 17-cv-0309523 Luckes, Bernard 17-cv-0293324 Ly, Anh 16-cv-0395725 Masters, James 12-cv-0233226 McKinley, David 17-cv-0456227 Mielke, Blair Christopher 17-cv-0320528 Moreau, Elizabeth Renee 16-cv-0575429 Nguyen, Dai V. 16-cv-0395230 Nguyen, Loc 16-cv-0395531 Nguyen, Nghia Ngoc 16-cv-0395432 Norwood, Margaret 17-cv-0320333 Odom, Terry Louise 16-cv-1597434 Padgett, Linda 13-cv-0235735 Phan, Hanh Van 16-cv-0395636 Reece, Kevin 17-cv-0317237 Reed, Germaine 17-cv-0316538 RMC General Contractors, LLC 11-cv-0252739 Rodriguez, Ramon Luis 17-cv-0456740 Salter, Christopher F. 17-cv-0428941 Sample, James A. 17-cv-0429042 Scott, Donald Joseph II 17-cv-0455443 Simmons, Candice 17-cv-0424744 Taylor, Mary S. 17-cv-0320145 Valdivieso, Sergio 12-cv-0200446 Veillon, John R. 17-cv-0461947 Waddle, Jan Michael 16-cv-0408348 Whitted, Roderick Deon 17-cv-04631

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875-2 Filed 09/20/18 Page 1 of 1

Page 23: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

EXHIBIT 3 - 4 PTO 66 Submissions by Persons and Entities Other than Remaining B3 Plaintiffs - Alphabetical by Name

Row Plaintiff Name Case No.1 Bruce, Shane Maddox 18-cv-026262 Dean, Michael 17-cv-068003 Miller Jr., John Earl4 Thompson, Ashley 17-cv-02854

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875-3 Filed 09/20/18 Page 1 of 1

Page 24: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

Exhibit 4 -107 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs with Materially Deficient PTO 66 Submissions - Alphabetical by Name

Row Plaintiff Name Case No. Untimely Unsigned Missing Pages

Failed to Respond to Damages Question

Failed to Respond to Other Key Questions

GRG Confirmed

Class Member

1 Alvarado, Sergio A 13-cv-01778 No No No No No Yes2 Assi, Mohammed 17-cv-03027 No Yes No No No No3 Baker, Edward Joseph 17-cv-03685 No No No No Yes Yes4 Baldo, Lisa Marie 17-cv-03368 No No No Yes No No5 Bank, Ryan Clayton 17-cv-03372 No No No Yes No No6 Benoit, Bernice Ann 17-cv-03323 No No Yes Yes No No7 Benoit, Roy Paul 17-cv-03328 No No No Yes No No8 Bonilla, Sara 17-cv-04133 No No Yes Yes Yes No9 Booker, Dondy 17-cv-03051 No No No Yes No No10 Bradley, Charles 17-cv-03164 No No No No Yes Yes11 Brown, Michael Todd 17-cv-03366 No No No Yes No No12 Burkett, Craig Michael 17-cv-03681 No No No Yes No No13 Cage, Patrick 17-cv-03174 No No No No No Yes14 Caldwell, Stephon 13-cv-01007 No No No No Yes No15 Coco, III, Malcolm Alphonse 17-cv-03393 No No No Yes No No16 Collier, James 17-cv-03415 No No No No No Yes17 Couture, Jr., Raymond 17-cv-03373 No No No Yes No No18 Danos, Janice Marie 17-cv-03240 No No Yes Yes Yes No19 Davis, Frederick 17-cv-03140 No No No No Yes No20 Dwyer, Derek Thomas 13-cv-01010 No No No No Yes No21 Elliott, Cynthia Anne 13-cv-01011 No No No No Yes No22 Elrod, Aiden Connor 17-cv-03334 No No No Yes Yes No23 Elrod, Jarod Shane 17-cv-03331 No No No Yes Yes No24 Estate of Lula Richardson 17-cv-04285 No No No No Yes No25 Fetterhoff, Carol Lynn 17-cv-03350 No No No Yes No No26 Fetterhoff, Chayton Lee 17-cv-03350 No No No Yes No No27 Fetterhoff, Chelsea Lynn 17-cv-03350 No No No Yes No No28 Flair, Kimberly 17-cv-03161 No No Yes Yes Yes No29 Frazier, Debra 17-cv-03219 No No No No Yes No30 Gonzalez, Hector 17-cv-03257 No No No No Yes No31 Gooding, John 17-cv-03238 No No No No Yes No32 Green, Christopher Alan 17-cv-03191 No No No No Yes No33 Griffin, Kacey W. 17-cv-03258 No No No No Yes No34 Hall, Lorinzo 17-cv-03261 No No No No Yes No35 Hawthorne, Ayana 17-cv-03270 No No No No Yes No36 Henson, Jr James 17-cv-03276 No No No No Yes No37 Hicks, Ronald 17-cv-03176 No No No No No Yes38 Hill, Sherry 17-cv-03278 No No No No Yes No

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875-4 Filed 09/20/18 Page 1 of 3

Page 25: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

Exhibit 4 -107 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs with Materially Deficient PTO 66 Submissions - Alphabetical by Name

Row Plaintiff Name Case No. Untimely Unsigned Missing Pages

Failed to Respond to Damages Question

Failed to Respond to Other Key Questions

GRG Confirmed

Class Member

39 Hinton, Arlene 17-cv-04357 No No No No Yes No40 Hohnadell, Gale 17-cv-03999 No No No No Yes No41 Hohnadell, Kimberly 17-cv-03999 No No No No Yes No42 Hooker, Jarvis 17-cv-04065 No No No No Yes No43 Howard, John L 17-cv-03347 No No No No No Yes44 Howze, Alfonso Cardell 17-cv-03288 No No No No Yes No45 Jaouhari, Hilal 17-cv-03302 No No No No Yes No46 Johnson, Patricia 17-cv-03309 No Yes No No No No47 Jones, Sammie 17-cv-04383 No Yes No No No No48 Keller, Brian Edward 13-cv-01018 No No No Yes No No49 Kendrick, Jared Lee 13-cv-03928 No No No No Yes No50 Kiff, Hank J. 12-cv-02715 No No No No No Yes51 Kirkland, Christopher 17-cv-04391 No No No No Yes No52 Kizzee, Anthony 17-cv-03158 No No No No Yes Yes53 Landrieu, David Joseph 17-cv-03161 No No No No Yes No54 Lawson Environmental Services, LLC 12-cv-00740 No No No Yes No No55 Learn, Michael 17-cv-03322 No Yes Yes Yes Yes No56 Lee, Tiffany Monique 16-cv-13874 No No No Yes No No57 Liddell, Quient 17-cv-04411 No No No No No Yes58 Locke, Joe 17-cv-04413 No No No No No Yes59 Louisiana Workers' Compensation Corporation 17-cv-03199 No No No Yes Yes No60 Martin, Jennifer Ann 17-cv-03228 No No Yes Yes Yes No61 McBride, Richard 16-cv-06635 No No No No No Yes62 McBride, Rico O 16-cv-15255 No No No Yes No Yes63 McIntosh, William Dante 13-cv-01020 No No No No Yes No64 Miles, Debra L. 13-cv-02715 No No No Yes No No65 Morris, Demetria 17-cv-04459 No No No No No Yes66 Murphy, Lorinzo 13-cv-01031 No No No No Yes No67 Naples, John 12-cv-02564 No No No No Yes No68 Nehlig, Chris Emile 17-cv-03376 No No No Yes Yes No69 Odoms Jr., Alonzo 13-cv-02386 No No Yes Yes No No70 Peschlow, Mark 17-cv-03598 No No Yes No No No71 Pettaway, John 17-cv-03599 No Yes Yes Yes Yes No72 Phillips, Shunna 17-04305 Yes No No Yes Yes No73 Pinell, Richard J DBA Billy Sue, Inc 17-cv-03349 No No No No No Yes74 Pritchett Jr., Wilbert Devon 17-cv-03231 No No Yes Yes Yes No75 Robin, III, Charles Raymond 17-cv-03381 No No No Yes No No76 Robin, Jr., Ricky R 17-cv-03383 No No No Yes Yes No

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875-4 Filed 09/20/18 Page 2 of 3

Page 26: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF … · 4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017 5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018 6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447 7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479 8 Amaya-Rodriguez,

Exhibit 4 -107 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs with Materially Deficient PTO 66 Submissions - Alphabetical by Name

Row Plaintiff Name Case No. Untimely Unsigned Missing Pages

Failed to Respond to Damages Question

Failed to Respond to Other Key Questions

GRG Confirmed

Class Member

77 Robin, Ricky Raymond 17-cv-03389 No No No Yes No No78 Robinson, Crystal 15-cv-06131 No No No Yes No No79 Robinson, Patrick 17-cv-04574 No No No Yes No No80 Santiny, Laila 17-cv-04555 No No No No Yes No81 Santiny, Nicole 17-cv-04555 No No No No Yes No82 Santiny, Zana 17-cv-04555 No No No No Yes No83 Scott, Katrina 17-cv-04579 No No No No Yes No84 Steiner, Machelle F 17-cv-03387 No No No No No Yes85 Summers, Andrea 17-cv-04262 No No No No Yes No86 Sunseri, Anthony 17-cv-04263 No No No No Yes No87 Taylor, Eric 17-cv-04600 No No No No No Yes88 Tebbs, Michael 17-cv-04605 No No No No Yes No89 Terrebonne, Betty Ann 17-cv-04549 No No No Yes Yes No90 Thompson, Alvin 17-cv-03156 No No No Yes No Yes91 Thompson, Joe L 17-cv-02854 No No No No Yes No92 Treme, Josh 17-cv-04269 No No No No Yes No93 Triplett, Danny 17-cv-04270 No No No No Yes No94 Turner, Judy A. 17-cv-04614 No Yes Yes Yes Yes No95 Turner, Michael 17-cv-04210 No No No No Yes No96 Turner, Michael Anthony 13-cv-01035 No No No No Yes No97 Vaughan, Rochelle Avila 17-cv-03250 No No Yes Yes Yes No98 Walker, Cynthia 17-cv-04272 No No No No Yes No99 Walker, Glynn 17-cv-04645 No No No No Yes No

100 Walker, Roxanne 17-cv-03012 No No Yes Yes Yes No101 Weathersby, Terry 17-cv-04275 No No No No Yes No102 Webb, John 17-cv-04276 No No No No Yes No103 Wensel, April 17-cv-04225 No Yes No No No No104 Wesley, Charles 17-cv-03326 No No No Yes No No105 Williams, Armis 17-cv-03414 No No No No Yes No106 Williams, Viola 17-cv-04237 No No No No Yes No107 Woodland, Antonio 17-cv-04240 Yes No No No No No

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 24875-4 Filed 09/20/18 Page 3 of 3