the bankruptcy code without safe harbors

8/13/2019 The Bankruptcy Code Without Safe Harbors

1/24Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1569627Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1569627

"

!"# %&'()*+,-. /01# 23,"0*, 4&5# 6&)70)8

#$%&'%( )* +,--%(.

/( &0120 3204 / '56% 507,%8 $'5$ $'% 8%0165$16% 9:5;% '50-20:< 1( $'% =5(40,&$>?

@28% :'2,A8 -% %1$'%0 0%&%5A%8B"

20 5$ A%5:$ 70%5$A? 0%8,>%8 1( :>2&%*C

D'1:507,E%($ 1: -5:%8 2( $'% E1:E5$>' -%$3%%( $'% :5;% '50-20: 5(8 $'%10 :$5$%8 725A F0%8,>1(7 :?:$%E1> 01:4*G /(8%%8B $'% :5;% '50-20: 50% A14%A? $2 1(>0%5:% :?:$%E1> 01:4-? ;2:$%01(7 5 0,( 2( $'% -5(4*H I20%26%0B 5;$%0 CJJK $'% :5;% '50-20: 50% :2 -0258$'5$ $'%? 50% A14%A? $2 :%012,:A? 81:$20$ >0%81$20 -%'56120B 0%:,A$1(7 1( :2>15AA?35:$%;,A %;;20$: $2 0%:',;;A% $05(:5>$12(: 1( 208%0 $2 ;1$ 31$'1( $'%:% %L>%&$12(: $2$'% =5(40,&$>? @28%*K

.M5(1%A )* I220% N02;%::20 2; +53B #%$2( O5AA P(16%0:1$? #>'22A 2; +53* @201((%

=5AAB N%$%0 @A5&&B Q1>'508 +%61(B I504 Q2%B I14% #1E4261>B :%6%05A 3'2 31:'%8 $20%E51( ,((5E%8B 5(8 )%((1;%0 Q,$' O2?8%( 5AA '%A&%8 E% 31$' $'1: &5&%0B 5(8 / 5E705$%;,A*"#$%&'%( )* +,--%(B !"#"$% '(" )$*" +$,-.,/0 "R S*=*/* +* Q%6* F TCJ"JU*C#$%&'%( )* +,--%(B 1",23$'23"/ $45 6$47,8#'9:; ,::12( 2;350%'2,:% A25(: 1( N50$ //B 24*,$*



C

=,$ ,&2( 0%&%5A 2; $'% :5;% '50-20:B 3'5$ '5&&%(: (%L$e /: 1$ :,;;1>1%($ $2 0%E26%$'% :5;% '50-20: ;02E $'% =5(40,&$>? @28%B 20 E,:$ $'% @28% -% ;,0$'%0 585&$%8 $20%;A%>$ $'% &0%65A%(>% 2; 8%0165$16%: $'02,7'2,$ $'% %>2(2E?e S(8 1; 0%&%5A 1: (2$%(2,7'B 3'5$ 41(8: 2; 1::,%: :'2,A8 $'% =5(40,&$>? @28% A%71$1E5$%A?5>>2EE285$%B 5(8 3'5$ 1::,%: 50% :1E&A? 81:7,1:%8 6%0:12(: 2; $'% 7%(%05A &A%5 2;

5AA >0%81$20: $2 -% %L>,:%8 ;02E $'% (20E5A >2(:%f,%(>%: 2; 8%;5,A$e

D'1: :'20$ &5&%0 %L5E1(%: $'%:% 5(8 2$'%0 0%A5$%8 f,%:$12(:B 5(8 -%71(: $2 :4%$>' 50258E5& ;20 0%;20E1(7 $'% @28%g: '5(8A1(7 2; ;1(5(>15A >2($05>$:*

/( N50$ /B / -%71( 31$' 5 0%61%3 2; $'% :5;% '50-20:B 5(8 $'% 507,E%($: 5751(:$ $'%101(>A,:12( 1( $'% =5(40,&$>? @28%* N50$ // $'%( :$50$: 5;0%:' 2( $'% 1($%0:%>$12( 2;-5(40,&$>? 5(8 8%0165$16%:* / %L5E1(% $'% A%71$1E5$% 1::,%: $'5$ 501:% ;02E $'%7023$' 2; 8%0165$16%: :1(>% $'% @28% 35: ;10:$ %(5>$%8 1( "W]R* / 5A:2 81:>,:: $'2:%&,$5$16% 1::,%: $'5$ 50%B ,&2( ;,0$'%0 0%;A%>$12(B (2$ 0%5A >2(>%0(:*

Z20 %L5E&A%B / %L&A51( '23 $'% 62A5$1A1$? 2; 8%0165$16%: E54%: $'%E ,(:,1$%8 $2 $'%(20E5A 958%f,5$% &02$%>$12(< 0,A%: 1( $'% =5(40,&$>? @28%B 1(5:E,>' 5: 5 (2(^8%-$20 >2,($%0&50$? E17'$ -% >2E&%AA%8 $2 ;1A% 5( 58%f,5$% &02$%>$12( E2$12(5AE2:$ %6%0? 85? 5 >5:% 35: &%(81(7* h( $'% 2$'%0 '5(8B / :,-E1$ $'5$ $'%8%0165$16%: 1(8,:$0?g: >2(>%0(: 5-2,$ 562185(>% 5>$12(: F A14% &0%;%0%(>% 5(8;05,8,A%($ $05(:;%0 5>$12(: F 50% A507%A? 26%0-A23(B 31$' 5 ;%3 A1E1$%8 %L>%&$12(:*

/( N50$ ///B / 2,$A1(% $'% 35?: 1( 3'1>' $'% =5(40,&$>? @28% E17'$ ;5>1A1$5$% $'%A%71$1E5$% >2(>%0(: 051:%8 1( N50$ //* /8%5AA? $'%:% >'5(7%: 32,A8 -% %(5>$%8 5: &50$2; 5 -0258%0 A%71:A5$16% E26% $2 0%&%5A $'% :5;% '50-20:* =,$ E20% 1E&20$5($A?B N50$/// 8%E2(:$05$%: $'5$ $'% :5;% '50-20: 50% (%1$'%0 $'% 2(A? (20 $'% -%:$ 35? $2

5880%:: $'% 0%5A1$? $'5$ 8%0165$16%: '56% -%>2E% 5 :,-:$5($15A &50$ 2; E28%0(>20&205$% ;1(5(>%*

/* M%0165$16%: 5(8 $'% #5;% O50-20:M%0165$16%: 50% 5 41(8 2; :%>2(8 208%0 >2($05>$B 8%0161(7 1$: 65A,% ;02E 2$'%0&01E50? 5::%$:*V Z20 %L5E&A%B 5 >0%81$ 8%;5,A$ :35& T@M#U &02618%: $'% -,?%0 31$' 5&5?2,$ 1; :2E% ,(8%0A?1(7 8%-$ F 1::,%8 -? $'% 90%;%0%(>% %($1$?< F 8%;5,A$:*] D'%

V@#i @20&* 6* @'1A80%(_: /(6* Z,(8 I7E$* TPjU ++NB KVC Z* #,&&* C8 K""B K"WT#*M*[*k* CJJRU* )"" $%/.I504 S* Y,1(( \ l1AA15E +* O506%?B



G

65A,% 2; $'% @M# 1: %($10%A? 8%&%(8%($ 2( $'% &02&%0$1%: 2; $'% ,(8%0A?1(7 0%;%0%(>%2-A175$12(:*R

+14%31:%B 5 $2$5A 0%$,0( :35& 1(62A6%: 5 >2($05>$ $'5$ $05(:;%0: 5AA 2; $'% %>2(2E1>5:&%>$: 2; 5 &50$1>,A50 1(6%:$E%($ >2($05>$B 31$'2,$ $05(:;%001(7 A%75A 23(%0:'1&*W

D'% 65A,% 2; $'% :35& 31AA 8%&%(8 2( $'% ,(8%0A?1(7 1(6%:$E%($ 1(:$0,E%($B&%0'5&: :,-m%>$ $2 :2E% ;,0$'%0 58m,:$E%($ $2 0%;A%>$ $'% >0%81$^01:4 2; $'% &50$?:%AA1(7 $'% $2$5A 0%$,0( :35& 5(8 1$: 5-1A1$? $2 &%0;20E 2( $'% :35&*"J D'1: A5$$%0 01:41: 4(23( 5: 9>2,($%0&50$? 01:4*? 93@#AB#&) /C4 D)3-#8 E 3' 7&838 +03',8 F9#7G HIIJ E 9#7G HI;IK

).8,9"; 6%..@-",B ED

D'% $%0E 98%0165$16%:< 5A:2 1(>A,8%: A%:: E?:$1;?1(7 1(:$0,E%($:* Z20 %L5E&A%B 3%AA^4(23( 8%0165$16% &028,>$: 1(>A,8% ;,$,0%:B 2&$12(:B 5(8 ;203508:*""M%0165$16%: 2;5(? :20$ >5( -% ,:%8 %1$'%0 5: 5 '%87% T1*%*B 1(:,05(>%U 20 ;20 :&%>,A5$12(*"C S051A0258 >5( ,:% 8%0165$16%: $2 A2>4 1( $'% &01>% 2; 81%:%A ;,%A ;20 $'% >2E1(7 ?%50B3'1A% $'% :5E% 8%0165$16%: >5( -% ,:%8 -? 1(6%:$20: $2 -%$ 2( $'% 810%>$12( 2; ;,%A&01>%:*

RS((5 Y%A&%0(B 1.@"/'29 6.45/0 ?,"52' 1",23$'23"/0 $45 '(" A"L' ,:: 1( N50$ //*"J)2'( M* =%>4B ?$/(24B K4 F' ' +* Q%6*"C]KB "CRK^RV TCJJWU*"")""O%(0? D*@* O,B J2/845",/'..5 1",23$'23"/;


4/24

H

D0581$12(5AA? 8%0165$16%: '56% -%%( $058%8 926%0 $'% >2,($%0< F $'5$ 1:B $'%? 50%-1A5$%05A >2($05>$: (%72$15$%8 810%>$A? -%$3%%( $'% &50$1%:*"G Z2AA231(7 $'% ;1(5(>15A>01:1:B 1( &50$1>,A50 $'% 81:0,&$12( >5,:%8 -? +%'E5( 5(8 S/Yg: >2AA5&:%B $'%0% '5:-%%( 1(>0%5:%8 0%7,A5$20? &0%::,0% $2 E26% 8%0165$16% $058%:B &50$1>,A50A? @M#

$058%:B $2 %L>'5(7%: 20 5$ A%5:$ 1(>0%5:% $'% >%($05A >A%505(>% 2; :,>' $058%:*"H

`6%(31$' $'%:% %;;20$:B 1$ :%%E: A14%A? $'5$ 5 :,-:$5($15A (,E-%0 2; 8%0165$16% $058%: 31AA0%E51( hD@B -1A5$%05A $05(:5>$12(:B -%>5,:% $'% &50$1%: 31AA 35($ $2 >,:$2E1c% $'%$%0E: $2 $'%10 :&%>1;1> (%%8:*

Z02E 5 &,0% -5(40,&$>? &%0:&%>$16%B 3'%( 5 &50$? $2 5 8%0165$16% $058% ;1A%: 5-5(40,&$>? &%$1$12(B $'%:% >2($05>$: 50% m,:$ A14% 2$'%0 %L%>,$20? >2($05>$:*"K =,$@2(70%::B 5;$%0 E,>' A2--?1(7 ;02E $'% ;1(5(>15A >2EE,(1$?B 1(>A,81(7 $'% Z%8%05AQ%:%06% 5(8 $'% ZM/@B >2(>A,8%8 $'5$ 8%0165$16%: :'2,A8 (2$ -% $0%5$%8 5: 0%7,A50>2($05>$: 1( -5(40,&$>?*"V D'1: A%58 $2 $'% %(5>$E%($ 2; $'% :5;% '50-20:B 81:>,::%8-%A23*

Z20 >'5&$%0 "" &,0&2:%:B 1$ 1: 5A:2 1E&20$5($ $2 (2$% $'5$ E5(? 8%0165$16%$05(:5>$12(:B &50$1>,A50A? $'2:% 5E2(7 ;1(5(>15A 1(:$1$,$12(: 5(8 1(6%:$20:B 1(62A6%5( %A%E%($ 2; :%>,0%8 A%(81(7* Z10:$B &50$1%: $2 8%0165$16% $05(:5>$12(: $?&1>5AA?%L>'5(7% 9E504 $2 E504%$< >2AA5$%05A $2 0%8,>% $'% >2,($%0&50$? 01:4 2; 5$05(:5>$12(*"] D'1: 1(62A6%: $'% $05(:;%0 2; 5::%$: $2 $'% &50$? 2( $'% 31((1(7 :18% 2;$'% $05(:5>$12( F 2;$%( >5AA%8 $'% 91( $'% E2(%?< &50$? F $2 %(:,0% $'% 92,$ 2; $'%E2(%?< &50$?g: &%0;20E5(>%*"R S: 5 E5$$%0 2; -%:$ &05>$1>%:B $'% -5A5(>% 2; $'%E504 $2 E504%$ >2AA5$%05A :'2,A8 -% 58m,:$%8 31$' :2E% ;0%f,%(>?B 5A$'2,7' $'%0%50% 1(81>5$12(: $'1: 35: (2$ 5A35?: $'% >5:% -%;20% +%'E5(g: >2AA5&:%*

"GD'% 4%? %L>%&$12( -%1(7 >2EE281$? ;,$,0%:B 3'1>' 50% 0%7,A5$%8 5(8 $058% 2(%L>'5(7%:*"H @%($05AA? >A%50%8 $0581(7 1(62A6%: $058%: >A%50%8 $'02,7' 5 >%($05A >2,($%0&50$?B3'1>' 5::,E%: 0%:&2(:1-1A1$? ;20 $'% >2,($%0&50$? &%0;20E5(>% 2; -2$' :18%: 2; 5$058%* D'5$ 1:B $'% >%($05A >2,($%0&50$? -%>2E%: 5 9E188A%E5(< 1( $'% $05(:5>$12(*@'01:$15( S* )2'(:2(B


5/24

K

/( 5881$12(B A507% ;1(5(>15A 1(:$1$,$12(: '56% '1:$201>5AA? 0%f,10%8 $'%10 >A1%($: $2 &2:$5881$12(5A >2AA5$%05AB $%0E%8 9/(8%&%(8%($ SE2,($:< 1( $'% /#MS 82>,E%($5$12(B $20%;A%>$ $'% 81:&501$? 1( >0%81$ 05$1(7: -%$3%%(B ;20 %L5E&A%B 5 82,-A%^S 05$%81(6%:$E%($ -5(4 5(8 5( ,(05$%8 '%87% ;,(8*"W S;$%0 +%'E5( =02$'%0:g >2AA5&:%B

3'%( :%6%05A '%87% ;,(8: ;2,(8 $'%E:%A6%: 5: ,(:%>,0%8 >0%81$20: :%%41(7 $'%0%$,0( 2; $'1: >2AA5$%05A 1( $'% +2(82( 58E1(1:$05$12( &02>%%81(7 2; +%'E5(g:`,02&%5( :,-:18150?BCJ$'%0% '56% -%%( E26%: $2 %1$'%0 0%8,>% $'% 5E2,($ 2; $'1:9,& ;02($< >2AA5$%05A 20 &A5>% 1$ 1( $'% '5(8: 2; 5 (%,$05A &50$?*C"

$P 1;1> >2(>%0(: 5-2,$ $'% 1($%05>$12(2; -5(40,&$>? 5(8 >%0$51( ;1(5(>15A &028,>$:B $2 $'% 318%^2&%( &0261:12(: %(5>$%8 1(CJJK*CC Z2AA231(7 $'% CJJK 5E%(8E%($: $2 $'% @28%BCG1$ 1: '508 $2 %(61:12( 5

8%0165$16% $'5$ 1: (2$ :,-m%>$ $2 :&%>15A $0%5$E%($*CH

D'% :5;% '50-20: >26%0 5 318% 05(7% 2; >2($05>$: $'5$ E17'$ -% >2(:18%0%88%0165$16%:B 1(>A,81(7 :%>,01$1%: >2($05>$:BCK>2EE281$1%: >2($05>$:BCV;203508

"W)""0 "PBP0 "WWH /#MS @0%81$ #,&&20$ S((%L T#%>,01$? /($%0%:$ ^ [%3 k204 +53U*CJSA$'2,7' $%0E%8 9>2AA5$%05AB< $'% ;,(8: 5(8 :%>,01$1%: 1( f,%:$12( 3%0% >2E1(7A%831$' +%'E5(g: 23( ;,(8: 5(8 1( E5(? >5:%: 0%'?&2$'%>5$%8 T1*%*B ,:%8 5: >2AA5$%05A1( +%'E5(g: 23( $05(:5>$12(:U* )""@'01:$15( )* )2'(:2(B 1",23$'23"/ $45!"(:#.'("9$'2.4 =$2%8,"; K'M/ Q;RR DPJP0 1. S.8 T4.> O("," S.8, ?.%%$'",$% K/UB GWS01c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

CKGB CRC TCJJWU*CKD'% 8%;1(1$12( 2; b:%>,01$1%: >2($05>$b 1( :%>$12( ]H"T]U 1(>A,8%:a

5 >2($05>$ ;20 $'% &,0>'5:%B :5A%B 20 A25( 2; 5 :%>,01$?B 5 >%0$1;1>5$% 2; 8%&2:1$B5 E20$757% A25( * * * 20 2&$12( 2( 5(? 2; $'% ;20%721(7B 1(>A,81(7 5( 2&$12( $2&,0>'5:% 20 :%AA 5(? :,>' :%>,01$?B >%0$1;1>5$% 2; 8%&2:1$B E20$757% A25( * * *1(>A,81(7 5(? 0%&,0>'5:% 20 0%6%0:% 0%&,0>'5:% $05(:5>$12( 2( 5(? :,>':%>,01$?B >%0$1;1>5$% 2; 8%&2:1$B E20$757% A25( * * *


6/24

V

>2($05>$:BC]0%&,0>'5:% 570%%E%($:BCR5(8B E2:$ 1E&20$5($A?B :35& 570%%E%($:*CWD'% A5$$%0 '5: -%>2E% 5 41(8 2; 9>5$>'^5AA< 8%;1(1$12( $'5$ >26%0: $'% 3'2A% 2; $'%8%0165$16%: E504%$B &0%:%($ 5(8 ;,$,0%*

D'% 8%;1(1$12( 2; b:%>,01$1%: >2($05>$b 35: 5E%(8%8 1( CJJK $2 >2(;20E $2 $'%8%;1(1$12( 1( $'% Z%8%05A M%&2:1$ /(:,05(>% S>$* D'% $%0E 9:%>,01$?< 1: 1$:%A; 8%;1(%81( p"J"THWU*CV"" P*#*@* p]R"THU* S: %L&A51(%8 1( ?.%%2",X/a

D'% E%5(1(7 2; $'% $%0E b>2EE281$? >2($05>$b 81;;%0: 8%&%(81(7 ,&2( $'%$?&% 2; >2EE281$? -024%0 5$ 1::,%* S >2EE281$? >2($05>$ 31$' 0%:&%>$ $2 5;,$,0%: >2EE1::12( E%0>'5($ 1: 5 >2($05>$ ;20 $'% &,0>'5:% 20 :5A% 2; 5>2EE281$? ;20 ;,$,0% 8%A16%0? 2(B 20 :,-m%>$ $2 $'% 0,A%: 2;B 5 >2($05>$ E504%$20 -2508 2; $058%* #,>' 5 >2($05>$ 1: 4(23( 1( $'% >2EE281$1%: $058% 5: 5b>2EE281$? ;,$,0%: >2($05>$*b S >2EE281$? >2($05>$ 31$' 0%:&%>$ $2 5

;20%17( ;,$,0%: >2EE1::12( E%0>'5($ 1: 5 ;20%17( ;,$,0%B 5(8 31$' 0%:&%>$ $25 A%6%057% $05(:5>$12( E%0>'5($ 1: 5 A%6%057% $05(:5>$12(* S >2EE281$?>2($05>$ 31$' 0%:&%>$ $2 5 >A%501(7 2075(1c5$12( 1: %1$'%0 5 >2EE281$? ;,$,0%:>2($05>$ $'5$ 1: >A%50%8 -? :,>' >A%501(7 2075(1c5$12( 20 1: 5 >2EE281$?2&$12( $058%8 2(B 20 :,-m%>$ $2 $'% 0,A%: 2;B 5 >2($05>$ E504%$ 20 5 -2508 2;$058% $'5$ 1: >A%50%8 -? :,>' >A%501(7 2075(1c5$12(* S >2EE281$? >2($05>$31$' 0%:&%>$ $2 5 >2EE281$? 2&$12(: 8%5A%0 1: 5 >2EE281$? 2&$12(*

@2AA1%0 2( =5(40,&$>? q]V"*JK T;22$(2$%: 2E1$$%8U* @2EE281$? 1: 8%;1(%8 1(p]V"TRU $'02,7' >02::^0%;%0%(>% $2 $'% @2EE281$? `L>'5(7% S>$ Tb@`SbU* @`Sp"5THU 8%;1(%: b>2EE281$?b $2 1(>A,8% 5701>,A$,05A &028,>$: b5(8 5AA 2$'%0 7228:

5(8 50$1>A%:B %L>%&$ 2(12(: 5: &02618%8 1( :%>$12( "G^" 2; $'1: $1$A%B 5(8 5AA :%061>%:B017'$:B 5(8 1($%0%:$: 1( 3'1>' >2($05>$: ;20 ;,$,0% 8%^A16%0? 50% &0%:%($A? 20 1( $'%;,$,0% 8%5A$ 1(*b D'% 20171(: 2; $'% 5E,:1(7 92(12(< %L>%&$12( 50% 8%$51A%8 1('$$&add333*$1E%*>2Ed$1E%dE575c1(%d50$1>A%dJBW"]"BRW"G""BJJ*'$EA* #%6%05A2$'%0 &50$: 2; @28% p]V" 5A:2 >02:: 0%;%0%(>% $'% @`S* )""hA?E&1> [5$,05A Y5:B CWHZ*G8 ]G]B ]HJ^H" TK$' @10* CJJCU TbD'% $%0E _>2EE281$? >2($05>$_ _%(>2E&5::%:&,0>'5:%: 5(8 :5A%: 2; >2EE281$1%: ;20 ;,$,0% 8%A16%0? 2(B 20 :,-m%>$ $2 $'% 0,A%: 2;B5 >2($05>$ E504%$ 20 -2508 2; $058% * * * *_ /( >2($05:$B _;203508 >2($05>$:_ 50%_>2($05>$: ;20 $'% ;,$,0% &,0>'5:% 20 :5A% 2; >2EE281$1%: $'5$ 50% (2$ :,-m%>$ $2 $'%0,A%: 2; 5 >2($05>$ E504%$ 20 -2508 2; $058%*_2($05>$ 1: 8%;1(%8 1( p"J"TCKUB $2 1(>A,8% >2($05>$: T2$'%0 $'5(

>2EE281$? >2($05>$:B :%% /8#,$(2$% CVU ;20 $'% &,0>'5:%B :5A% 20 $05(:;%0 2; 5>2EE281$? 5$ A%5:$ $32 85?: 1( $'% ;,$,0%B 5(8 1(>A,8%: 95 0%&,0>'5:% 20 0%6%0:%0%&,0>'5:% $05(:5>$12( * * * >2(:17(E%($B A%5:%B :35&B '%87% $05(:5>$12(B 8%&2:1$BA25(B 2&$12(B 5AA2>5$%8 $05(:5>$12(B ,(5AA2>5$%8 $05(:5>$12(B 20 5(? 2$'%0 :1E1A50570%%E%($*'5:% 570%%E%($ 20 90%&2B< 1: %::%($15AA? $'% :5A% 2; 5;1(5(>15A 1(:$0,E%($ >2E-1(%8 31$' 5 ;203508 >2($05>$ $2 0%&,0>'5:% $'% :5E%* D'%1(1$15A 9-,?%0< 1: >2E&%(:5$%8 -? $'% 9:%AA%0< $'02,7' 5 81;;%0%(>% -%$3%%( $'%


7/24

]

S &02$%>$%8 >2($05>$B $'5$ 1: 2(% $'5$ ;5AA: 31$'1( 2(% 2; $'% ;20%721(7 >5$%7201%:B 1:2(A? &02$%>$%8 1; $'% '2A8%0 1: 5A:2 5 &02$%>$%8 &%0:2(B 5: 8%;1(%8 1( $'% =5(40,&$>?@28%* Z1(5(>15A &50$1>1&5($:GJF %::%($15AA? 6%0? A507% ;1(5(>15A 1(:$1$,$12(: F 50%5A35?: &02$%>$%8* S(8 31$' 0%7508 $2 %5>' >A5:: 2; &02$%>$%8 8%0165$16% >2($05>$

$'%0% 1: 5A:2 5 E20% :&%>1;1> >A5:: 2; &02$%>$%8 &50$1%:*G"

/( :2E% >5:%: $'%:% A5$$%0 >5$%7201%: '56% :2E% 0%5A E%5(1(7* Z20 %L5E&A%B ;203508>2($05>$: 50% 2(A? :,-m%>$ $2 $'% :5;% '50-20: 31$' 0%7508 $2 ;1(5(>15A &50$1>1&5($:5(8 9;203508 >2($05>$ E%0>'5($:*< S ;203508 >2($05>$ E%0>'5($ E%5(: %1$'%0 5Z%8%05A Q%:%06% =5(4 20 5( %($1$? 93'2:% -,:1(%:: >2(:1:$: 1( 3'2A% 20 1( &50$ 2;%($%01(7 1($2 ;203508 >2($05>$:*,00%($ 8%;1(1$12(: 2;90%&2 &50$1>1&5($1&5($,2,:B 0%f,101(7(2$'1(7 E20% $'5( $'% &%0:2( 1( f,%:$12( -% &50$? $2 5 0%&2 20 :35& 31$' $'%8%-$20* /( :'20$B 5(?2(% 3'2 1: 5 &50$? $2 $'%:% :20$: 2; >2($05>$: 1: 5&$ $2 -% 5&02$%>$%8 &%0:2( 31$' 0%7508 $2 $'%:% >2($05>$:*

D'% :5;% '50-20: &02618% (2(^-5(40,&$ >2,($%0&50$1%: 31$' $'% 5-1A1$? $2 %L%0>1:%>2($05>$,5A 017'$: 5AA231(7 A1f,185$12(B $%0E1(5$12( 20 5>>%A%05$12( 2; 8%0165$16%>2($05>$: ,&2( -5(40,&$>?BGK$'% 017'$ $2 :%$ 2;; 20 (%$ 8%0165$16% >2($05>$: ;0%% 2;

1(1$15A &5?E%($ 5(8 $'% ;1(5A &5?E%($* D2 f,5A1;? ,(8%0 $'% @28%g: 8%;1(1$12(B $'%0%&,0>'5:% 2-A175$12( E,:$ 2>>,0 31$'1( 2(% ?%50B -,$ $'% 8%;1(1$12( %L&0%::A?%L>A,8%: 5 0%&,0>'5:% 2-A175$12( 1(62A61(7 5 &50$1>1&5$12( 1( 5 >2EE%0>15A E20$757%A25(* [2$%B '23%6%0B $'5$ $'%:% $?&%: 2; 0%&2: E17'$ >2(:$1$,$% 5(2$'%0 $?&% 2;&02$%>$%8 >2($05>$B &50$1>,A50A? 5 :35& 20 :%>,01$1%: >2($05>$* )""/( 0% O5E1A$2(D5;$ \ @2*B ""H Z*G8 WW" TW$' @10* "WW]U*CW"" P*#*@* p"J"TKG=U* D'% 8%;1(1$12( 1(>A,8%: (2$ 2(A? 2-612,: :35&:B A14% @M#B1($%0%:$ 05$% :35&:B 5(8 >,00%(>? :35&:B -,$ 5A:2 5(? 1(:$0,E%($ 92; 5 $?&% $'5$ '5:-%%(B 1: &0%:%($A?B 20 1( $'% ;,$,0% -%>2E%:B $'% :,-m%>$ 2; 0%>,00%($ 8%5A1(7: 1( $'%:35& E504%$:< 1(>A,81(7 95 ;203508B :35&B ;,$,0%B 2&$12( 20 :&2$ $05(:5>$12( 2( 2(%20 E20% 05$%:B >,00%(>1%:B >2EE281$1%:B %f,1$? :%>,01$1%:B 20 2$'%0 %f,1$?1(:$0,E%($:B 8%-$ :%>,01$1%: 20 2$'%0 8%-$ 1(:$0,E%($:B f,5($1$5$16% E%5:,0%:5::2>15$%8 31$' 5( 2>>,00%(>%B %L$%($ 2; 5( 2>>,00%(>%B 20 >2($1(7%(>? 5::2>15$%831$' 5 ;1(5(>15AB >2EE%0>15AB 20 %>2(2E1> >2(:%f,%(>%B 20 %>2(2E1> 20 ;1(5(>15A1(81>%: 20 E%5:,0%: 2; %>2(2E1> 20 ;1(5(>15A 01:4 20 65A,%*< /( :'20$B %6%0?>2(>%165-A% 8%0165$16% >2($05>$*GJ"" P*#*@* p"J"TCCSU T8%;1(1(7 9;1(5(>15A &50$1>1&5($,01$1%: >2($05>$:UB KKV T;203508 5(8 >2EE281$1%: >2($05>$:U


8/24

R

$'% 5,$2E5$1> :$5?BGV5(8 -0258 1EE,(1$? ;02E 562185(>% 5>$12(:*G] D'%:%&02$%>$12(: 5A:2 %L$%(8 $2 8%0165$16% $05(:5>$12(: (%:$A%8 ,(8%0 5 E5:$%0570%%E%($B %6%( 1; $'% E5:$%0 570%%E%($ 5770%75$%: 81:&505$% $?&%: 2; 8%0165$16%>2($05>$:*GR #%>,01$? 570%%E%($: 5(8 2$'%0 >0%81$ %('5(>%E%($: 50% 5A:2%(>2E&5::%8 31$'1( $'% 8%;1(1$12(: 2; &02$%>$%8 >2($05>$:B 5(8 $',: :,-m%>$ $2 $'%

:5;% '50-20:*GW

-P 5$12(: ;20 $'% ;20%721(7 :5;% '50-20&0261:12(:* Z10:$B $'% &0261:12(: 50% :518 $2 &02'1-1$ ,(;510 9>'%00? &1>41(7< 2;

KKW T0%&,0>'5:% 20 90%&2< 570%%E%($:UB KVJ T:35&:U* D'% %L>%&$12(: 5&&A? $2 5b>2($05>$,5A 017'$Bb 3'1>' 1(>A,8%: 017'$: &02618%8 ;20 1( 5 0,A% -? 65012,: $058%2075(1c5$12(: 20 %L>'5(7%:*

GV"" P*#*@* ppGVCT-UTVU T:%>,01$1%: >2($05>$:B ;203508: 5(8 >2EE281$? >2($05>$:UBGVCT-UT]U T0%&2:UB GVCT-UT"]U T:35&:U* )"" $%/."" P*#*@* ppGVCT2U T%L%0>1:% 2;017'$: ,(8%0 $'% ;20721(7 &0261:12(: (2$ :,-m%>$ $2 5(? :$5?:UB KKV T;203508: 5(8>2EE281$? >2($05>$: &02$%>$%8 &50$1%:_ 017'$ $2 E5071( &5?E%($: ,(8%0 $'2:%>2($05>$: :'5AA (2$ -% :$5?%8B 56218%8 20 A1E1$%8UB KVJ T,(8%0 5 :35& 017'$ $2 2;;:%$20 (%$^2,$ 5(? $%0E1(5$12( 65A,%: 20 &5?E%($ 5E2,($: :'5AA (2$ -% :$5?%8B 56218%820 A1E1$%8U*G]"" P*#*@* ppKHVT%UB T;UB T7UB TmUB KHRT8UTCUT=UB T@UB TMU* D'% ;20%721(7 :%>$12(: 2;:%>$12( KHV &02'1-1$ $'% -01(71(7 2; 562185(>% 5>$12(: ,(8%0 :%>$12(: KHHB KHKB KH]BKHR T5UT"UT=UB 5(8 KHR T-U 2; $'% =5(40,&$>? @28%* D'% ;20%721(7 &0261:12(: 2;:%>$12( KHR &02618% $'5$ 5 8%0165$16%: >2,($%0&50$? 5A35?: $54%: ;20 65A,%B

&2$%($15AA? >2E&A1>5$1(7 5( 5$$%E&$ $2 0%>26%0 5 $05(:;%0 5: 5( 5>$,5A ;05,8,A%($$05(:;%0* "" P*#*@* pKHRT>U* D'1: 5,$'20 1: 5$ 5 A2:: $2 %L&A51( '23 5 8%0165$16% E17'$-% 5 :$5$,$20? A1%( ,(8%0 :%>$12( KHK* D'%:% &0261:12(: 82 (2$ :%%E $2 &02'1-1$ $'%A1;$1(7 2; $'% 5,$2E5$1> :$5? $2 5AA23 5 >0%81$20 $2 -01(7 5( 562185(>% 5>$12( ,(8%0:$5$% 20 ;%8%05A (2(^-5(40,&$>? A53B :2 A2(7 5: $'% >0%81$20 818 (2$ -01(7 :,>'5>$12( 2( -%'5A; 2; $'% %:$5$%* ?** "" P*#*@* pKHHT-UT"U*GR"" P*#*@* ppGVCT-UTC]U T5AA23: :%$2;;: 5(8 (%$$1(7 ,(8%0 E5:$%0 (%$$1(7570%%E%($:U KV" T017'$ $2 $%0E1(5$%B 5>>%A%05$% 20 A1f,185$%B 20 $2 2;;:%$B 20 (%$$%0E1(5$12( 65A,%:B &5?E%($ 5E2,($: 20 2$'%0 $05(:;%0 2-A175$12(: 501:1(7 ,(8%0 201( >2((%>$12( 31$' 2(% 20 E20% :%>,01$1%: >2($05>$:B >2EE281$? >2($05>$:B ;203508>2($05>$:B 0%&,0>'5:% 570%%E%($:B :35& 570%%E%($: 20 E5:$%0 (%$$1(7 570%%E%($:B

:'5AA (2$ -% :$5?%8B 56218%8 20 A1E1$%8 -? 2&%05$12( 2; $'% -5(40,&$>? >28% 20 -?208%0 2; 5 >2,0$ 20 58E1(1:$05$16% 57%(>?U* )"" $%/."" P*#*@* pp"J"TGRSU T8%;1(1$12(2; 9E5:$%0 (%$$1(7 570%%E%($A,8% 95 E5:$%0 570%%E%($< $'5$ 1(>A,8%: $'% 8%;1(%8 >2($05>$:* [2$% $'%:A17'$ 81;;%0%(>% 1( $%0E1(2A27? -%$3%%( 9E5:$%0 570%%E%($< 5(8 9E5:$%0 (%$$1(7570%%E%($*,A50B $'% :5;% '50-20: 5: >,00%($A? %(5>$%8 3%0% &02E2$%8 -? $'%8%0165$16%: 1(8,:$0? 5: (%>%::50? E%5:,0%: $2 :,&&20$ 9>A2:% 2,$ (%$$1(7*5A $%0E ;20 %(;20>%E%($ 2; 2#/. *$9'.T1*%*B-5(40,&$>? $%0E1(5$12(U >A5,:%: 5(8 :%$2;; 2; $'% 0%:,A$1(7 E5:: 2; >A51E: 0%:,A$1(7;02E $'% $%0E1(5$%8 8%0165$16% >2($05>$:*HG S>>2081(7 $2 $'% ;1(5(>15A >2EE,(1$?B2(A? 31$' >A2:% 2,$ (%$$1(7 >2,A8 >'%00? &1>41(7 5(8 :?:$%E1> 01:4 -% 56218%8*

D'% >'%00? &1>41(7 507,E%($ 0%:$: 2( $'% -%A1%; $'5$ 1$ 1: :2E%'23 1(%f,1$5-A% ;20 58%-$20 $2 0%$51( ;56205-A% 8%0165$16%: 3'1A% 0%m%>$1(7 ,(;56205-A% >2($05>$:*HH h;>2,0:%B $'1: 5-1A1$? $2 8%>18% 3'%$'%0 $2 $0%5$ 5 >2($05>$ 5: 5( 5::%$ 20 5 8%-$ 1: 4%?$2 $'% 2&%05$12( 2; :%>$12( GVKB 5(8 5&&A1%: $2 5AA :20$: 2; >2($05>$:*HK /$ $',:1E&2:%: (2 :&%>15A -,08%( 2( 8%0165$16% >2($05>$:*HV I20%26%0B $'% :5;% '50-20::1E&A? 716% $'% (2(^8%-$20 &50$? 5( 2&$12( $2 $%0E1(5$% ,&2( 5 -5(40,&$>? F 3'1>'

5E2,($: $2 >'%00? &1>41(7 ;02E $'% 2$'%0 :18% 2; $'% 8%5A*H]

HJ)""/( 0% `(02(B /(>*B GHW =*Q* WVB "JV T=5(40* #*M*[*k* CJJVU*H")""#$%6%( +* #>'350>cB ):/'"@29 !2/7B W] Y%2* +*)* "WGB "WVFCJH TCJJRU T8%;1(1(7:?:$%E1> 01:4 5:a 9$'% 01:4 $'5$ T1U 5( %>2(2E1> :'2>4 :,>' 5: E504%$ 20 1(:$1$,$12(5A;51A,0% $0177%0: T$'02,7' 5 &5(1> 20 2$'%031:%U %1$'%0 TiU $'% ;51A,0% 2; 5 >'51( 2;E504%$: 20 1(:$1$,$12(: 20 TkU 5 >'51( 2; :17(1;1>5($ A2::%: $2 ;1(5(>15A 1(:$1$,$12(:BT11U 0%:,A$1(7 1( 1(>0%5:%: 1( $'% >2:$ 2; >5&1$5A 20 8%>0%5:%: 1( 1$: 5651A5-1A1$?B 2;$%(%618%(>%8 -? :,-:$5($15A ;1(5(>15A^E504%$ &01>% 62A5$1A1$?


10/24

"J

D'% :?:$%E1> 01:4 507,E%($ ;20 $'% :5;% '50-20: 1: -5:%8 2( $'% -%A1%; $'5$ $'%1(5-1A1$? $2 >A2:% 2,$ 5 8%0165$16% &2:1$12( -%>5,:% 2; $'% 5,$2E5$1> :$5? 32,A8 >5,:%5 851:? >'51( 2; ;51A,0% 5E2(7:$ ;1(5(>15A 1(:$1$,$12(:*HR D'% &02-A%E 31$' $'1:507,E%($ 1: $'5$ 1$ ;51A: $2 >2(:18%0 $'% 01:4: >0%5$%8 -? $'% 0,:' $2 >A2:% 2,$&2:1$12(: 5(8 8%E5(8 >2AA5$%05A ;02E 81:$0%::%8 ;10E:*HW [2$ 2(A? 82%: $'1:

>2($01-,$% $2 $'% ;51A,0% 2; 5( 5A0%58? 3%54%(%8 ;1(5(>15A ;10EB -? ;2:$%01(7 5 0,( 2($'% ;10EB -,$ 1$ 5A:2 '5: >2(:%f,%($ %;;%>$: 2( $'% E504%$: 7%(%05AA?B 5: &50$1%: 0,:'$2 :%AA $058%: 31$' $'% 8%-$20 5(8 -,? >200%:&2(81(7 &2:1$12(: 31$' (%3>2,($%0&50$1%:*KJ /$ 1: (2$ >A%50 $'5$ $'1: A5$$%0 81:0,&$12(B >0%5$%8 -? $'% :5;% '50-20%L>%&$12(: $2 $'% 5,$2E5$1> :$5? 5(8 $'% 8%-$20g: 562185(>% &23%0:BK"1: (2$:?:$%E1>5AA? E20% 1E&20$5($ $'5( $'% 01:4 $'5$ 1: &,$ ;20$' 1( :,&&20$ 2; $'% :5;%'50-20:B &50$1>,A50A? 1; 2(% >2(:18%0: $'5$ $'% 5,$2E5$1> :$5? >5( 5A35?: -% A1;$%8 -?$'% -5(40,&$>? >2,0$*KC S(8 3'1A% 1$ 1: :2E%$1E%: :518 $'5$ 0%&%5A1(7 $'% :5;%'50-20: 31AA :1E&A? E26% $'% 0,( 2( $'% 8%-$20 $2 $'% &0%^-5(40,&$>? &%0128B $'1:(%7A%>$: $'% %;;%>$ 2; $'% 8%-$20g: 5-1A1$? $2 -01(7 5 &0%;%0%(>% 5>$12(*KGP(A%:: $'%(2(^8%-$20 >2,($%0&50$? &A5(: $'%10 0,( WJ 85?: 1( 5865(>% F 5(8 >5( >2(61(>% $'%

8%-$20 (2$ $2 ;1A% 8,01(7 $'% 1($%01E F $'1: 507,E%($ 82%: (2$ :%%E &A5,:1-A%*KH

/(8%%8B $'% >,00%($ :5;% '50-20: 32,A8 :%%E $2 -% $'% :2,0>% 2; >2(:18%05-A% 8%583%17'$ 5(8 :?:$%E1> A2::%:* D'%:% A2::%: %;;%>$ -2$' $'% -5(40,&$>? %:$5$% 810%>$A?5(8 A507%0 f,%:$12(: 2; :2>1%$5A 3%5A$'*

HR/$ 1: 5A:2 :2E%$1E%: :,77%:$%8 $'5$ $'% E%0% 5>$ 2; 5 ;1(5(>15A ;10Eg: -5(40,&$>?

;1A1(7 >0%5$%: :?:$%E1> 01:4B -,$ $'5$ :%%E: $2 >2(;,:% $'% &02>%:: 2; -5(40,&$>?31$' $'% 7%(%05A 0%5A1$? 2; 8%;5,A$* )%5( O%A3%7%B =24$492$% =2,@ 6$47,8#'9: $45):/'"@29 !2/7B CJ )* /($gA Z1(* I504%$:B /(:$1$,$12(: \ I2(%?B Z%-* CJ"JB 5$ "B CT507,1(7 $'5$ -5(40,&$>1%: 2; ;1(5(>15A ;10E: 950% :?E&$2E5$1> 2; >2EE2( ;5>$20: 1(&20$;2A12: $'5$ A%58 $2 3%5A$' A2::%: 0%7508A%:: 2; 3'%$'%0 5(? &50$1>,A50 ;10E ;1A%:;20 -5(40,&$>??*KC"" P*#*@* pGVCT8U* Y16%( $'% (,E-%0: 2; >2($05>$: 1(62A6%8 1( $'% >'5&$%0 "" >5:%2; 5 A507% ;1(5(>15A 1(:$1$,$12(B 1$ E5? -% $'5$ $'% -5(40,&$>? >2,0$ 32,A8 '56% $20,A% 2( %($10% >A5::%: 2; 8%0165$16%:B 5-:%($ ,(1f,% ;5>$: 0%75081(7 5 :&%>1;1>$05(:5>$12( $'5$ E17'$ 35005($ A1;$1(7 $'% :$5?*KG"" P*#*@* pKH]*KH?*P/( 0% `(02( @0%81$20: Q%>26%0? @20&*B HCC =*Q* HCG T#*M*[*k* CJJWU T(2(^2081(50? >2,0:% $%0E1(5$12( 2; >2EE%0>15A &5&%0 2( %6% 2; -5(40,&$>? (2$562185-A% -%>5,:% 2; :5;% '50-20 &0261:12(:U*


11/24

""

93:*)# H< !0,&L M#,*)' 4N&+ !)&'8&-,30'

Z20 %L5E&A%B 1E571(% +%'E5( =02$'%0: '5: 1($%0E%815$%8 5 $2$5A^0%$,0( :35& 2( 5E1AA12( :'50%: 2; =hYSQD@h :$2>4KK3'%0% N50$? S 0%>%16%: 5(8 +%'E5( &5?: $'%

=hYSQD@h 0%$,0(* =hYSQD@h :'50%: 50% >,00%($A? $0581(7 5$ rHJ* S$ $'% :5E%$1E%B N50$? = &5?: $'% 0%$,0( 2; =hYSQD@h 5(8 +%'E5( 0%>%16%: $'% 0%$,0( 2;=hYSQD@h ;20 :2E% &%0128 2; $1E%B 31$' +%'E5( %50(1(7 5 0%$,0( 2( $'% 81;;%0%(>%20 :&0%58 -%$3%%( $'% $32 65015-A% 1($%0%:$ 05$% A%7: 2; $'%:% $05(:5>$12(:*

l'%( +%'E5( %($%0: -5(40,&$>?B $'1: $05(:5>$12( 1: 5( 5::%$ 2; $'% %:$5$%B -%>5,:%1$ %50(: 5 65A,5-A% 0%$,0( ;20 +%'E5(* =,$ $'5$ 5::%$ 1: 8%:$02?%8 ,(8%0 $'% :5;%'50-20:B 3'1>' &%0E1$ 5(8 %(>2,057% $%0E1(5$12( 2; $'% 8%5A* I20%26%0B 3'%(N50$? S $%0E1(5$%: 1$: 8%5A 31$' +%'E5( ,(8%0 $'% :5;% '50-20: 5(8 '5: $2 0%&A5>%'1: A2(7 :35& 2( $'% E1AA12( :'50%:B 1E571(% '% :%(8: '1: $%0E1(5$12( (2$1>% $'% 85?+%'E5( ;1A%: 5(8 -,?: $'% 2(% E1AA12( :'50%:^^'1: -,?1(7 &,:'%: $'% :$2>4 &01>% ,&

;02E HJ $2 HC 82AA50: 5(8 '% &5?:B 2( 56%057%B H" ;20 '1: (%3 :'50%:*

N50$? = 1: 1( S:15 5(8 1$ $54%: '%0 5 ;%3 5881$12(5A 85?: $2 5>$B 5(8 '%0 $%0E1(5$12((2$1>% 72%: 2,$ 5 3%%4 A5$%0* #'% $'%( 0%%:$5-A1:'%: '%0 &2:1$12(B 3'1>' 1: :'20$=hYSQD@hB 5(8 :%AA: '%0 =hYSQD@h :'50%: 5(8 &,:'%: $'% &01>% ;02E HJ $2 GR

KKS: E? :$,8%($: 3%AA 4(23B =hYSQD@h 1: $'% A%581(7 '?&2$'%$1>5A E5(,;5>$,0%02; $0%(>'>25$: 5(8 ;%8205:* )""+,--%(B /8#,$(2$% C*


12/24

"C

31$' 56%057% 2; GW* `5>' &50$? $'%( ;1A%: 5 &022; 2; >A51E ;20 r" E1AA12(B $'%100%:&%>$16% A2:%:B ;20 5 $2$5A 2; rC E1AA12( 5751(:$ $'% %:$5$%* D'1: 5E2,($ &A,: $'%A2:: $2 +%'E5( 1: $'% $2$5A 3%5A$' 8%:$02?%8 -? $'% :5;% '50-20:*

/$ :%%E: >A%50 $'5$ 1$ 32,A8 -2$' 0%8,>% :?:$%E1> 01:4 5(8 %('5(>% $'% 0%$,0( $2 $'%

8%-$20g: >0%81$20: $2 81:&2:% 2; 5 ;1(5(>15A ;10Eg: 8%0165$16% &20$;2A12 5: 5 3'2A%B&%0'5&: 5: &50$ 2; 5 f,1>4 pGVG :5A% 2; $'% 8%-$20g: %($10% -,:1(%::B 05$'%0 $'5( :%%1$ 81:E%E-%0%8 1( 5 &5(1> 1( $'% :5A%: -%;20% 5(8 1EE%815$%A? 5;$%0 5 >'5&$%0 "";1A1(7* /( :'20$B $'% :5;% '50-20: 32,A8 :%%E $2 &02E2$% $'% &0%E5$,0% A1f,185$12(2; 5 8%-$20B 31$' -58 %;;%>$: ;20 $'% A507%0 ;1(5(>15A E504%$:* j(231(7 $'5$ $'% :5;%'50-20: 50% 1( &A5>%B &2$%($15A 8%-$20: 31$' A507% 8%0165$16% &2:1$12(: 50%%(>2,057%8 $2 56218 >'5&$%0 "" ;20 5: A2(7 5: &2::1-A%B E%5(1(7 $'5$ 3'%( $'%? 82;1(5AA? %($%0 -5(40,&$>? $'%? 50% A14%A? $2 '56% 81::1&5$%8 $'%10 32041(7 >5&1$5A 5(80%5>'%8 5 &21($ 2; %L$0%E% 1AA1f,181$?*

D'% :?:$%E1> 01:4 m,:$1;1>5$12( ;20 $'% :5;% '50-20: 5A:2 82%: (2$'1(7 $2 %L&A51( 3'?

$'%? 5&&A? $2 5AA 8%-$20:B (2 E5$$%0 '23 :?:$%E1>5AA? ,(1E&20$5($*

=%>5,:% $'% :5;% '50-20: :%%E $2 A5>4 7228 m,:$1;1>5$12(:B 5(8 50% 5$ $'% 6%0? A%5:$26%0-0258B / '56% 507,%8 $'5$ $'%? :'2,A8 -% 0%&%5A%8 20 805:$1>5AA? 5E%(8%8* D'%0%E51(8%0 2; $'1: &5&%0 %L5E1(%: $'% 1::,%: $'5$ 501:% ;02E :,>' 5 0%&%5A*

//* M%0165$16%: 5(8 $'% =5(40,&$>? @28%Y16%( $'5$ $'% -0258 m,:$1;1>5$12(: ;20 $'% :5;% '50-20: '56% -%%( ;2,(8 35($1(7B$'1: :%>$12( %L5E1(%: $'% 1::,%: $'5$ 501:% ;02E $'% 1($%05>$12( 2; 8%0165$16%: 31$'

>'5&$%0 "" :&%>1;1>5AA? 5(8 $'% =5(40,&$>? @28% 7%(%05AA?* D'% 725A '%0% 1: $28%6%A2& 5 A1:$ 2; $'% 0%5A 1::,%: $'5$ E%01$ 5$$%($12(B 5 A1:$ $'5$ 31AA 8016% $'%81:>,::12( 2; &2::1-A% >'5(7%: $2 $'% @28% :%$ ;20$' 1( N50$ ///*

/(1$15AA?B >2(:18%0 5 :&%>1;1> 1(:$5(>% 3'%0% $'% 9>'%00? &1>41(7< 507,E%($ E17'$ -%E20% &%0:,5:16%* /$ 1: :2E%$1E%: :518 $'5$ $'% :5;% '50-20: '56% 5 :&%>15A :5A1%(>%31$' 0%7508 $2 >%($05AA? >A%50%8 8%0165$16% >2($05>$:B A14% >2EE281$? ;,$,0%:* /(&50$1>,A50B -%>5,:% 5 >%($05A >A%501(7 57%(>? 1: %L&2:%8 $2 >2,($%0&50$? >0%81$ 01:4;02E %5>' 2; 1$: &50$1>1&5($:B $'% :5;% '50-20: 50% :518 $2 0%8,>% $'% 01:4 $'5$ $'%>%($05A 57%(>? E17'$ ;51A* S(8 1$ 1: $0,% $'5$ $'% %50A? :5;% '50-20: 3%0% 2(A?5&&A1>5-A% $2 >%($05AA? >A%50%8 8%0165$16%:B 5 &21($ @2(70%:: :%%E: $2 '56% ;2072$$%(

5: 1$ %L&5(8%8 $'% :5;% '50-20: $2 hD@ $05(:5>$12(:*

[%6%0$'%A%::B 1$ 1: (2$ >A%50 $'5$ :5;% '50-20: &02618% 5(? 0%5A :?:$%E1> &02$%>$12(%6%( 1( $'1: >2($%L$* @%($05A >A%501(7 2; 8%0165$16%: '5: -%%( &02E2$%8 :1(>% $'%;1(5(>15A >01:1: 5: 5 $22A ;20 0%8,>1(7 :?:$%E1> 01:4B 5: $'% >%($05A >A%501(7 57%(>? >5(,:% 1$: &2:1$12( 1( $'% ',- 5: 5 E2(1$20 2; $'% %L&2:,0% 2; $'% &50$1%: 1$ $058%: 31$'


13/24

"G

5(8 &02618% 1(;20E5$12( $2 0%7,A5$20: 5-2,$ E504%$ 1( 7%(%05A*KV #?:$%E1> 01:4 1:0%8,>%8 -? ;20>1(7 5 A507% 62A,E% 2; $058%: $2 -% >%($05A >A%50%8B 5(8 $'%( 0%f,101(7E%E-%0: 1( $'% >A%501(7 2075(1c5$12( $2 &2:$ >2AA5$%05A 5(8 %($%0 1($2 2-A175$12(: $2;,(8 $'% >%($05A 57%(>? 1( $1E%: 2; >01:1:B 3'%( $'% >2AA5$%05A 20 E5071( 5>>2,($:E5? (2$ &02618% :,;;1>1%($ A1f,181$?* #5;% '50-20: 32,A8 :%%E $2 ,(8%0E1(% $'1:

:$0,>$,0% -? 8,AA1(7 $'% >%($05A 57%(>?g: 1(>%($16%: $2 E2(1$20 1$: E%E-%0: F $'%>%($05AA? >A%501(7 57%(>? E,:$ '56% :2E% 8%70%% 2; >2,($%0&50$? 01:4B :2 $'5$ 1$ '5:1(>%($16%: $2 ,:% 1$: &2:1$12( $2 0%8,>% 26%05AA :?:$%E1> 01:4* #5;% '50-20: $'5$ 5AA23$'% >%($05A >A%501(7 &50$? $2 0%E26% 1$:%A; ;02E $'% E188A% 2; $058%: 50% 810%>$A?>2($050? $2 $'% 725A: 2; 1(>0%5:%8 >%($05A >A%501(7*

S E20% :,-:$5($15A :%$ 2; >2(>%0(: 1(62A6%: $'% &%0128 2; $1E% -%$3%%( $'% 8%-$20g:-5(40,&$>? ;1A1(7 5(8 1$: 8%>1:12( $2 5::,E% 20 0%m%>$ 5 &50$1>,A50 8%0165$16%*K] Z20%L5E&A%B >2(:18%0 5( 91( $'% E2(%?< >5AA 2&$12( $'5$ %L&10%: 5 3%%4 5;$%0 $'%&%$1$12( 85$%*KR D'% (2(^8%-$20 >2,($%0&50$? 31AA '56% A%71$1E5$% >2(>%0(: 5-2,$$'% 8%-$20g: 31AA1(7(%:: $2 &%0;20E 5(8 1$: 5-1A1$? $2 82 :2 31$'2,$ >2,0$

5,$'201c5$12(*KW S(8 1; $'% (2(^8%-$20 &50$? '5: $2 :%%4 5 >2,0$ 208%0 $2 >2E&%A $'%8%-$20g: &%0;20E5(>% 20 5,$'201c% $'% :5E%B $'% :$014% &01>% 2; $'% >5AA '5:%;;%>$16%A? -%%( 1(>0%5:%8 -? $'% 5E2,($ 2; $'% A%75A ;%%: 1(>,00%8* l'1A% $'%:%>2(>%0(: 50% :2E%3'5$ $0,% 2; 5AA >2($05>$,5A >2,($%0&50$1%:B $'%? :%%E A14%A? $2501:% 31$' 70%5$%0 ;0%f,%(>? 31$' 0%:&%>$ $2 8%0165$16% $05(:5>$12(:B 716%( $'%0%A5$16%A? :'20$ 8,05$12(: 5(8 :'%%0 (,E-%0 2; >2($05>$: $'5$ E17'$ -% 1(62A6%8B5(8 8%-$20 9:$2(%35AA1(7< 1: 5&$ $2 '56% 7056%0 >2(:%f,%(>%:*

#1E1A50A?B 5A$'2,7' 8%0165$16% $05(:5>$12(: 50% 1(>0%5:1(7A? :%>,0%8 -? &2:$%8>2AA5$%05AB $'%:% $05(:5>$12(: 50% ,(A14% E2:$ 2$'%0 :%>,0%8 8%-$: 1( $'5$ $'% 65A,%:5$ :$54% >'5(7% 851A?B 5(8 2;$%( >'5(7% f,1$% 805E5$1>5AA?* D'1: 62A5$1A1$? 1: A14%A? $2

-% %L5>%0-5$%8 -? $'% >'5&$%0 "" ;1A1(7 2; 5 A507% 8%5A%0* D'% @28% 0%>27(1c%: $'%017'$: 2; 5 :%>,0%8 >0%81$20 $2 958%f,5$% &02$%>$12(< 3'1A% $'%? 50% :$5?%8 ;02E0%5A1c1(7 2( $'%10 >2AA5$%05ABVJ-,$ 1$: :$0,>$,0% 82%: (2$ 5($1>1&5$% $'% &2::1-1A1$? 2; 5>A51E $'5$ E17'$ >'5(7% 1( 65A,% 2( 5 851A? 20 '2,0A? -5:1:*

/(8%%8B $'% =5(40,&$>? @28% 1: 8%:17(%8 $2 5880%:: >2AA5$%05A 65A,% ;A,>$,5$12(:B (2$>A51E 65A,% ;A,>$,5$12(:B 3'1>' 1: 3'5$ 1: 0%5AA? 5$ 1::,% 31$' 0%7508 $2 8%0165$16%:*D'% @28% 35: 8%:17(%8 31$' 5 ;1L%8 A25( 2-A175$12( 1( E1(8B 5(8 $'% >2(>%0( 35:$'5$ $'% >2AA5$%05A :,&&20$1(7 $'5$ A25( E17'$ 8%$%01205$% 8,01(7 $'% 8%A5? >5,:%8 -?$'% -5(40,&$>? >5:%* D'% >2AA5$%05A &2:$%8 1( 5 8%0165$16% $05(:5>$12( 1: 2;$%( >5:'

KV'$$&add333*;$*>2Ed>E:d:dJd%R">GC>J^JJ]]^""8;^-KJ-^JJ"HH;%5-8>J*'$EAK]"" P*#*@* pGVKT8UTCU T9/( 5 >5:% ,(8%0 >'5&$%0 WB ""B "CB 20 "G 2; $'1: $1$A%B $'%$0,:$%% E5? 5::,E% 20 0%m%>$ 5( %L%>,$20? >2($05>$ 20 ,(%L&10%8 A%5:% 2; 0%:18%($15A0%5A &02&%0$? 20 2; &%0:2(5A &02&%0$? 2; $'% 8%-$20 5$ 5(? $1E% -%;20% $'%>2(;10E5$12( 2; 5 &A5( * * *


14/24

"H

20 '17' f,5A1$? :%>,01$1%:B 5(8 $',: (2$ %:&%>15AA? A14%A? $2 8%>A1(% 1( 65A,%B -,$ $'%8%-$20g: &2$%($15A A15-1A1$? 2( $'% 8%0165$16% 1(:$0,E%($ >'5(7%: 05&18A?* D'% @28%%L&0%::A? 0%>27(1c%: $'5$ 5 8%0165$16% >2($05>$ E17'$ -% 65A,%8 &2:$^&%$1$12( $2>5A>,A5$% 0%m%>$12( 85E57%:BV"-,$ 1$ 82%: (2$'1(7 $2 :2A6% $'% 0%A5$%8 58%f,5$%&02$%>$12( &02-A%E*VC D'1: 0%&0%:%($: 5 4%? 1::,% $2 -% 5880%::%8 ,&2( 0%&%5A 2;

$'% :5;% '50-20:*

D'% 8%0165$16%: >2EE,(1$?g: 1($%0%:$ 1( :5;% '50-20: 1: $1%8 $2 $'% -%A1%; 1( $'%-%(%;1$: 2; >A2:% 2,$ (%$$1(7B 3'1>' 1(62A6%: $'% $%0E1(5$12( 2; 5AA 8%0165$16%: 31$' 5&50$1>,A50 8%-$20 5(8 $'% :%$$1(7 2;; 2; :%$$A%E%($ &5?E%($: 23%8 ,(8%0 $'2:%>2($05>$:* h; >2,0:%B 1; $'% :5;% '50-20: 50% 0%&%5A%8B $'%0% 31AA -% ;%3%0 >2($05>$:$%0E1(5$%8* =,$ $'%0% 0%E51(: 5 &2::1-1A1$? $'5$ E5(? :%$2;; :1$,5$12(: 31AA 501:%(2(%$'%A%::B 5: $'% 8%-$20 0%m%>$: ,(;56205-A% 8%0165$16% $058%: -,$ $'%>2,($%0&50$? 8%8,>$: $'% -0%5>' 85E57%: ;02E &5?E%($: 23%8 $2 $'% 8%-$20 2(2$'%0 $058%: $'5$ $'% 8%-$20 5::,E%:*

h(% &2$%($15A &02-A%E ;20 ;,$,0% :%$2;;: 1: $'% 7%(%05A 0,A% $'5$ 5 :%$2;; 1: (2$5&&02&015$%A? %;;%>$,5$%8 5751(:$ $32 81;;%0%($ 8%-$20:B %6%( 1; $'2:% 8%-$20: 50%&50$ 2; 5 :1(7A% >20&205$% %($%0&01:%*VG D',:B 5 '%87% ;,(8 3'2 %($%0: 1($2 5 &,$2&$12( 2( 5 &50$1>,A50 >2E&5(?g: :'50%: 31$' M%-$20 =024%057%B /(>* 5(8 5 $2$5A0%$,0( :35& 2( $'% :5E% :'50%: 31$' M%-$20 #&%>15A Z1(5(>1(7B /(>* 1: ,(5-A% $22;;:%$ $'%:% $32 &2:1$12(: 1( -5(40,&$>?B %6%( $'2,7' $'%? A14%A? 3%0% 8%:17(%8 5: 5:1(7A% $058% 2( $'% ,(8%0A?1(7 :'50%:* D'1: &02-A%E 1: ;,0$'%0 %L5>%0-5$%8 1( >5:%:A14% +%'E5( =02$'%0:B 3'%0% $'% 8%-$20 %($1$1%: E17'$ '56% -5(40,&$>? >5:%:&%(81(7 1( 81;;%0%($ >2,($01%:*VH

=,$ 1$ 1: (2$ >A%50 $'5$ $'1: &02-A%E (%%8: 20 35005($: 5 -5(40,&$>? :2A,$12(*VK

/(:$%58B $'% %5:? 5(:3%0 1: ;20 A507%0 8%0165$16%: 8%5A%0: $2 >2(8,>$ 5AA 2; $'%10$058%: $'02,7' 5 :1(7A% :,-:18150?B 7161(7 >2,($%0&50$1%: $'% >2E;20$ $'5$ $'%10:%$2;; 017'$: 31AA -% &0%:%06%8 1; $'% 320:$ '5&&%(:*

V"SA$'2,7' $'% >5:%: 50% :&A1$ 2( $'% 1::,%B E5(? >2,0$: '2A8 $'5$ -0%5>' >A51E: 2($0581$12(5A >2($05>$: 50% 95: 2;< $'% &%$1$12( 85$%*VC"" P*#*@* pKVC*VG/( 0% #%E@0,8%B +*N*B GWW =*Q* GRR T=5(40* M* M%A* CJJWU* 68' /""I50$1( )*=1%(%(:$2>4 %$ 5A*BF," 2&% 2; $'1: 50$1>A%B $'1: :,77%:$: 5 (%%8 $2>22081(5$% :,>' 5,$'201$? 5>02:: $'% 4%? ;1(5(>15A m,01:81>$12(: F 5$ $'% 6%0? A%5:$B[%3 k204 5(8 +2(82( (%%8 $2 -% 1($%705$%8 1( $'1: 0%7508*VK)""/( 0% =%61AAB =0%:A%0 \ #>',AE5( S::%$ I7E$* @20&*B RWV Z*C8 KHB K] TG8 @10*"WWJU T9:%$2;; 1: 5$ 288: 31$' 5 ;,(85E%($5A &2A1>? 2; -5(40,&$>?B %f,5A1$? 5E2(7>0%81$20: ***


15/24

"K

S62185(>% 5>$12(: 50% 5A:2 5( 2-612,: >2(>%0( ;20 $'% 8%0165$16%: 1(8,:$0?B1(5:E,>' 5: 5 ;05,8,A%($ $05(:;%0 20 &0%;%0%(>% 5>$12( '5: $'% &2$%($15A $2 9,(82< 5:%%E1(7A? >2E&A%$% 5(8 :%$$A%8 $05(:5>$12(*VV =,$ E5(? :$5$%8 >2(>%0(: 5-2,$562185(>% 5>$12(: 5&&%50 $2 -% 1(;A5$%8B 2(>% >A2:%A? %L5E1(%8* Z20 %L5E&A%B E2:$>2EE2( 8%0165$16% 2&%05$12(: 32,A8 :%%E $2 -% &02$%>$%8 5751(:$ &0%;%0%(>%

5$$5>4 -? $'% @28%g: 92081(50? >2,0:% 2; -,:1(%::< 8%;%(:%B 3'1>' &02$%>$:$05(:5>$12(: $'5$ 50% 0%7,A50 %1$'%0 5: $2 $'% &50$1%: 20 $'% 0%A%65($ 1(8,:$0?*V]

h( $'% 2$'%0 '5(8B 5 &50$? $'5$ 5$$%E&$: $2 ;20>% 5( %50A? %L1$B 31$'2,$ %1$'%0>2($05>$,5A 017'$ 20 1(8,:$0? &05>$1>% $2 -5>4 1$ ,&B :'2,A8 ;5>% 5( 562185(>%5>$12(*VR S(8 $'% @28% 31AA '56% $2 7,508 5751(:$ 5$$%E&$: $2 705- E5::16% 5E2,($:2; >2AA5$%05A 2( $'% %6% 2; -5(40,&$>?B 1( 5 35? $'5$ 1: ,(0%A5$%8 $2 $'% ,(8%0A?1(765A,% 2; $'% $058%: -%1(7 >2AA5$%05A1c%8* Z20 %L5E&A%B 1(>0%5:%8 >2AA5$%05A &2:$1(72-A175$12(: $'5$ 50% $1%8 $2 $'% 8%-$20g: >0%81$ 05$1(7 :'2,A8 (2$ -% 8%%E%8 2081(50?>2,0:%B 5: / 81:>,:: 1( 70%5$%0 8%$51A 1( $'% (%L$ &50$ 2; $'% &5&%0*

/$ 1: >2(>%165-A%B '23%6%0B $'5$ &0%^-5(40,&$>? 58'%0%(>% $2 >%0$51( 8%0165$16%$%0E: E17'$ A%58 $2 5 615-A% >A51E 2; ;05,8,A%($ $05(:;%0* Z20 %L5E&A%B :2E%8%0165$16%: >2($51( 935A4^535?< &0261:12(: $'5$ &02618% $'5$ 5 -0%5>'1(7 &50$? F5(8 ;1A1(7 5 >'5&$%0 "" &%$1$12( >2(:$1$,$%: 5 -0%5>' F 1: (2$ %($1$A%8 $2 5(? &5?E%($,&2( $%0E1(5$12( 2; $'% 8%0165$16%*VW D2 $'% %L$%($ $'1: (2(^-0%5>'1(7 &50$? 0%$51(:65A,% $'5$ 1: 70%5$%0 $'5( 1$: 85E57%:B $'%0% 1: 5( 507,E%($ $2 -% E58% $'5$ $'1:>2(:$1$,$%: 5 $05(:;%0 2; $'% 8%-$20g: &02&%0$? ;20 A%:: $'5( 0%5:2(5-1A1$? %f,165A%($65A,%B 5(8 1: $',: 562185-A%*]J h( $'% 2$'%0 '5(8B 1; $'% (2(^8%-$20 >5( &21($ $2:2E% 65A,% 716%( 5$ $'% 1(>%&$12( 2; $'% $05(:5>$12(B $'%( $'% $05(:5>$12( 1: (2$562185-A%*]" /( :'20$B 1$ 1: (2$ >A%50 $'5$ $'%0% 1: 5 0%5A &02-A%E '%0%B 5(8 ;02E 5

VV#$%&'%( )* +,--%(B 6":.45 UTCU*VR)"" /( 0% `(02( @0%81$20: Q%>26%0? @20&*B HCC =*Q* HCG T#*M*[*k* CJJWU T(2(^2081(50? >2,0:% $%0E1(5$12( 2; >2EE%0>15A &5&%0 2( %6% 2; -5(40,&$>? (2$562185-A% -%>5,:% 2; :5;% '50-20 &0261:12(:U*VWD'% %(;20>%5-1A1$? 2; b35A4^535?b &0261:12(: 1: &0%:%($A? -%1(7 A1$175$%8 1( $'%>2($%L$ 2; :%6%05A 586%0:50? &02>%%81(7: 1( $'% +%'E5( =02$'%0: O2A81(7: /(>* 5(8+%'E5( =02$'%0: #&%>15A Z1(5(>1(7 /(>* -5(40,&$>? &02>%%81(7:* )"" "PBP0 +%'E5(=02$'%0: #&%>15A Z1(5(>1(7 /(>* 6* O5001%0 Z1(5(>% +$8* T/( 0% +%'E5( =02$'%0:O2A81(7: /(>*UB @'* "" @5:% [2* JR^"GKKKB S86* [2* JW^J"CH" T=5(40* #*M*[*k* CJJWU

T0%75081(7 $'% %(;20>%5-1A1$? 2; 5 >0%81$ 8%;5,A$ :35& b35A4^535?b &0261:12(U* #2E%2; $'% 586%0:50? >5:%: '56% -%%( :%$$A%8 31$'2,$ 5 8%>1:12(* 68' /""M0%L%A=,0('5E +5E-%0$ N028:* @20&* 6* I18A5(8 =5(4 N+@B "WWC P*#* M1:$* +`i/# C"CCGT#*M*[*k* [26* WB "WWCU T:1E1A50 &0261:12( ;2,(8 %(;20>%5-A%U*]J"" P*#*@* pKHRT5UT"UT=U*]"I%AA2( =5(4B [*S* 6* I%$02 @2EEg>(:B /(>*B WHK Z*C8 VGKB VH] TG8 @10* "WW"U* /($'% >2($%L$ 2; @Mh:B 05$1(7: 57%(>1%: 2;$%( 8%E5(8%8 $'%:% &0261:12(: $2 &02$%>$$'% :&%>15A &,0&2:% %($1$? ;02E 1(>,001(7 5 A507% &5?E%($ 2-A175$12(*


16/24

"V

&2A1>? &%0:&%>$16% 1$ :%%E: 82,-$;,A $'% =5(40,&$>? @28% :'2,A8 72 2,$ 2; 1$: 35? $25>>2EE285$% 5 >2($05>$,5A $%0E $'5$ :%%E: 8%A1-%05$%A? 8%:17(%8 $2 :$01& 5::%$:;02E $'% %:$5$%*]C

h; >2,0:%B %6%( 1; $'%0% 1: (2 A%75A -5:1: ;20 5( 562185(>% 5>$12(B >2,($%0&50$1%: :$1AA

'56% $2 3200? 5-2,$ 5 :,1$ -02,7'$ $2 1(8,>% 5 :%$$A%E%($* D'1: 1: &50$1>,A50A? $0,%5: 5( 1(>0%5:1(7 (,E-%0 2; >'5&$%0 "" &A5(: 50% 2;;%01(7 ,(:%>,0%8 >0%81$20: 50%>26%0? $'5$ 1: >2($1(7%($ 2( $'% 0%:,A$: 2; A1$175$12(* D',: 562185(>% 5>$12(:B3'1A% (2$ 5 &01E50? >2(>%0(B 82 &0%:%($ :2E% 0%5A 01:4 $2 $'% 8%0165$16%: E504%$: 1($'% ;20E 2; ,(>%0$51($?*

Z1(5AA?B $'% 1($%05>$12( 2; >'5&$%0 "" 31$' $'% 0%&2 E504%$: (%%8: $2 -% 5880%::%8*=,$ ;10:$B 3% (%%8 $2 >2(:18%0 $'% -0258 05(7% 2; $05(:5>$12(: $'5$ >2E% ,(8%0 $'%'%581(7 2; 90%&,0>'5:% 570%%E%($:*% 5E2,($: $2 1($%0%:$B 5(8 $'% 05$%: 2( 26%0(17'$ 0%&2: 50% ,:,5AA?f,1$% >A2:% $2 05$%: 2( 26%0(17'$ A25(: 1( $'% ;%8%05A ;,(8: E504%$* /( 5881$12( $2>'5071(7 1($%0%:$B $'% A%(8%0d&,0>'5:%0 1( 5 0%&2 $05(:5>$12( $?&1>5AA? 2(A? &02618%:>5:' %f,5A $2 5 ;05>$12( 2; $'% >2AA5$%05A 65A,% 9:2A8< 1( $'% $05(:5>$12( F 3'1>'&02618%: 5( %L$05 E5071( 2; &02$%>$12( 1( >5:% 2; 8%;5,A$*]H

D'%:% $0581$12(5A 0%&2: &A5? 5( 1E&20$5($ 02A% 1( $'% ;,(>$12(1(7 2; ;1(5(>15AE504%$:*]KD'%? 50% 318%A? ,:%8 -? :%>,01$1%: 8%5A%0: 5(8 $'%? &02618% 5 35? ;20E,$,5A ;,(8:B 8%&2:1$20? 1(:$1$,$12(:B 5(8 2$'%0: $2 %50( 5 0%$,0( 2( ;,(8: $'5$ 50%

5-26% $'% 8%&2:1$ 1(:,05(>% A1E1$: ;20 $0581$12(5A -5(4 5>>2,($:* Q%&2: 50% 5A:2;0%f,%($A? ,:%8 1( 2&%( E504%$ 2&%05$12(: -? $'% Z%8%05A Q%:%06%B :1(>% $'%?&02618% 5 >2(6%(1%($ 35? $2 588 20 :,-$05>$ >5:' 0%:%06%: ;02E $'% ;1(5(>15A:?:$%E*]V

]C"C P*#*@* p"RC"T%UTRUTYU Tb35A4^535?b &0261:12(: ,(%(;20>%5-A% ,(8%0 $'%Z%8%05A M%&2:1$ /(:,05(>% S>$U*]G#$%&'%( S* +,E&41(B !"#8,9($/" $45 !"3",/" !"#8,9($/" FB,""@"4'/B 1( D/IhDOks*@hhj S[M Qh=`QD j*+SQh@O` `M#*B/[#DQPI`[D# hZ DO` Ih[`k ISQj`D >'*VT"WWGU*]HD'1: 81:>2,($ 20 9'510>,$< 35: %L$0%E%A? :E5AA -%;20% CJJ]B -,$ -%75( $2 7023B&50$1>,A50A? ;20 '2,:1(7^0%A5$%8 5::%$:B 5: >2,($%0&50$1%: -%75( $2 82,-$ $'%10

5-1A1$? $2 &02&%0A? 65A,% $'% 5::%$:* h-612,:A? $'% 7023$' 2; $'%:% '510>,$: >5(>0%5$% 5 A1f,181$? >0,(>' ;20 5( 1(:$1$,$12( $'5$ 1: '%561A? 0%A15($ 2( $'% 5-1A1$? $2-20023 5751(:$ E20$757%^-5>4%8 :%>,01$1%: $2 ;1(5(>% 851A? 2&%05$12(:* )""Y50?Y20$2(0 [8"/'2.4/ $45 F4/>",/ F-.8' '(" =24$492$% ?,2/2/B "C^"G TCJJWUT'$$&add333*;>1>*726d85?CdY20$2(*&8;U*]K)""j%((%$' @* j%$$%01(7B )"98,2'2Z$'2.4 $45 K'/ 12/9.4'"4'/;


17/24

"]

D'% 0%&2 E504%$ 5: $',: 8%:>01-%8 &A5?: 5( 1E&20$5($ 02A% 1( $'% ;1(5(>15A :?:$%E$'5$ (%%8: $2 -% &02$%>$%8* I20%26%0B -%>5,:% 2; $'% %L>%%81(7A? :E5AA E5071(:1(62A6%8 1( $'%:% $058%:B 1E&2:1$12( 2; -5(40,&$>? >2:$: 2( $'% E504%$ E17'$ '56%:%012,: ,($23508 >2(:%f,%(>%:* S>>2081(7A?B $'1: 1: 5( 1::,% $2 -% 5880%::%8 1; $'%

:5;% '50-20: 50% 0%&%5A%8*]]

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m,:$ 5: 7228 2; >2AA5$%05A 5: $'5$ ,:%8 1(92A8 ;5:'12(%8< 0%&2 5005(7%E%($:*]W

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

Z10:$B $'% $0581$12(5A 9350%'2,:% A25(< ,:%8 -? E20$757% 20171(5$20: 35:$05(:;20E%8 1($2 5 0%&2 570%%E%($ $'5$ 0%>%16%8 $'% &02$%>$12(: 2; $'% :5;%'50-20:*RJ D0581$12(5A 350%'2,:% A25(: 3%0% :'20$^$%0E A25(: :%>,0%8 -?

E20$757%: 0%>%($A? 20171(5$%8* D'% A25( &02618%8 $'% 20171(5$20 31$' A1f,181$? ,($1A%(2,7' E20$757%: '58 -%%( 20171(5$%8 $2 ;20E $'% -5:1: ;20 5 :%>,01$1c5$12(* N2:$CJJKB 350%'2,:% ;1(5(>1(7 5005(7%E%($: $?&1>5AA? '56% -%%( 82>,E%($%8 5:bE5:$%0 0%&,0>'5:% 570%%E%($:b ,(8%0 3'1>' 5( 20171(5$20 :%AA: E20$757% A25(: $21$: ;20E%0 A%(8%0 31$' 5 :1E,A$5(%2,: 570%%E%($ -? $'% 20171(5$20 $2 0%&,0>'5:%

]]/ 5&&025>' $'1: ;02E 5 -5(40,&$>? &%0:&%>$16%* /$ 1:B 2; >2,0:%B f,1$% &2::1-A% $'5$$'% :1c% 5(8 %L$%(:16% 0%A15(>% 2( $'% 0%&2 E504%$B %6%( 1( 1$: $0581$12(5A ;20EB0%&0%:%($ 5 :?:$%E1> 01:4 &02-A%E 1( (%%8 2; 5 0%7,A5$20? :2A,$12(* =,$ $'5$ :2A,$12(32,A8 (2$ 2>>,0 $'02,7' $'% =5(40,&$>? @28%*]R@A5,812 `* Q5885$cB O("4 '(" !23",/ !84 1,:; E2\8252': $45 '(" ]/" .* O(.%"/$%"

=845/ 24 '("


18/24

"R

;02E $'% A%(8%0* D'% 0%&,0>'5:% 1: $'%( >2(:,EE5$%8 3'%( $'% :%>,01$1c5$12('5&&%(:*

D'% %>2(2E1> %;;%>$ 2; $'% 8%5A 1: $'% :5E%B -,$ (23 $'% A%(8%0 (2 A2(7%0 '5: $23200? 5-2,$ -%>2E1(7 1(62A6%8 1( 5 -5(40,&$>? &02>%%81(7* D'1: E5? '56%

%(>2,057%8 %L>%::16% A%(81(7 $2 E20$757% 20171(5$20:*

93:*)# O< =4/D /0'1*3, 4,)*-,*)#

N%0'5&: E20% 1E&20$5($A?B ;2AA231(7 $'% CJJK SE%(8E%($:B 0%&,0>'5:%570%%E%($: -%>5E% E,>' E20% >2EE2( 1( 5::%$^-5>4%8 >2EE%0>15A &5&%0 TS=@NU>2(8,1$: 5(8 :$0,>$,0%8 1(6%:$E%($ 6%'1>A%: T#/n:UB $'% ;1(5(>15A :$0,>$,0%: $'5$3%0% 5E2(7:$ $'% ;10:$ $2 >2AA5&:% 1( $'% ;1(5(>15A >01:1:*R" S$ '%50$B 5( S=@N ;5>1A1$?1: 5 E%5(: 2; :%>,01$1c1(7 A23%0 f,5A1$? 5::%$: 1( 5 35? $'5$ 31AA 5AA23 $'% 20171(5$2020 -,?%0 2; $'%:% 5::%$: $2 1::,% '17'A? 05$%8 E2(%? E504%$ 1(:$0,E%($:B

$0581$12(5AA? 5E2(7 $'% >'%5&%:$ ;20E 2; >20&205$% ;1(5(>% 5651A5-A%*RC=5(4: 5(8

R"M%;5,A$: 1( $'1: E504%$ -%75( $2 2>>,0 E20% $'5( 5 ?%50 -%;20% $'% +%'E5(-5(40,&$>?* '$$&addE-5*?5A%*%8,d(%3:t%6%($:d&8;d;1(5(>15AuCJ>2(;^&5&%0uCJ"W*&8;RCZ05(4 N50$(2?B )($#"/(2*'24B ?.,#.,$'2.4/B ]V P* @'1* +* Q%6* CV"B CVR^VW TCJJWUT9S( #/n 1: :2E%$1E%: >5AA%8 5 9>2(8,1$< -%>5,:% 1$ 051:%: :'20$^$%0E ;,(8: 5(8>'5((%A: $'2:% ;,(8: 1($2 A2(7%0^$%0E 5::%$:* S( #/n_: -,:1(%:: E28%A 0%:%E-A%:


19/24

"W

:1E1A50 A%(8%0: ;2,(8 >2(8,1$: 5(8 #/n: 5$$05>$16% -%>5,:% $'%? 5AA23%8 $'%E $2>2($1(,% $2 2;;%0 $0581$12(5A 0%>%165-A%: ;1(5(>1(7 31$'2,$ $'% 0%7,A5$20?1E&A1>5$12(: 2; E541(7 5 A25( $'5$ 32,A8 5&&%50 2( $'%10 -5A5(>% :'%%$*RG

D'%:% 2;;^-5A5(>%^:'%%$ 6%'1>A%: 3%0% $',: '2A8%0: 2; A2(7^$%0E 5::%$: ;1(5(>%8

,:1(7 :'20$^$%0E &5&%0* D'1: &0%:%($%8 5( 2-612,: &02-A%EB :1(>% $'%0% 50%'1:$201>5A %L5E&A%: 2; &%0128: 3'%( >2EE%0>15A &5&%0 32,A8 (2$ 902AAB< :,>' 5:5;$%0 $'% N%(( @%($05A -5(40,&$>? ;1A1(7 1( "W]J*RH D2 26%0>2E% $'1: &02-A%EB $'%:&2(:201(7 -5(4 705($%8 5 >0%81$ A1(%B 20 9A1f,181$? -5>4:$2&B< $2 $'% >2(8,1$*RK

I20%26%0B 5;$%0 $'% CJJK 5E%(8E%($: $2 $'% @28%B 3'1>' 3%0% 5>>2E&5(1%8 -?>200%:&2(81(7 5E%(8E%($: $2 $'% 0%A%65($ -5(41(7 :$5$,$%:BRV:&2(:201(7 ;1(5(>15A1(:$1$,$12(: 1(>0%5:1(7A? ,:%8 0%&2 570%%E%($: $2 1(>0%5:% $'% >0%81$ 05$1(7 2; $'%S=@N 1::,%8 -? >2(8,1$: 5(8 #/n:* /; 5 0%&,0>'5:% 570%%E%($ &02618%8 ;20 ;,AA0%>2,0:% $2 5 '17'A? 05$%8 :&2(:20 F $'5$ 1: $'% 5-1A1$? $2 0%$,0( 5AA $'% 5::%$:R]F $'%S=@N >2,A8 -% 05$%8 -5:%8 2( $'% >0%81$ 05$1(7 2; $'% :&2(:20B 3'1>' :%%E%8 $2

0%E26% 5(? (%%8 $2 0%;A%>$ 2( $'% f,5A1$? 2; $'% ,(8%0A?1(7 5::%$: -%1(7 &A5>%8 1($'% >2(8,1$ F 5(8 $',: $'% 5-1A1$? $2 $,0( A%58 1($2 72A8B 20 :2 1$ :%%E%8*RR

$'5$ 2; 5 -5(4a 1$ :%%4: $2 %50( 5 :&0%58 -%$3%%( $'% 1($%0%:$ 05$% 5$ 3'1>' 1$-20023: 5(8 $'% 1($%0%:$ 05$% 5$ 3'1>' 1$ A%(8:*%165-A%:B 5,$2 A25( $05(:5>$12(:B 5(8 >0%81$ >508 0%>%165-A%: 3%0% $'%E2:$ >2EE2( 5::%$: ,:%8 1( E,A$1^:%AA%0 ;5>1A1$1%: F $'5$ 1:B ;5>1A1$1%: 3'%0% $'%:&2(:20 818 (2$ 7%(%05$% $'% 5::%$:* #%AA%0 ;5>1A1$1%: F 3'%0% $'% :&2(:20 7%(%05$%8$'% 5::%$: F 2;$%( 1(62A6%8 >0%81$ >508 0%>%165-A%: 5(8 E20$757%:*RH'$$&add333*$1E%*>2Ed$1E%dE575c1(%d50$1>A%dJBW"]"BR]RG]HBJJ*'$EAT9P($1A $'%>2AA5&:% 2; $'% N%(( @%($05AB >2EE%0>15A &5&%0 35: $'% (5$12(_: ;5:$%:$^70231(7$?&% 2; >0%81$B -,$ (23 1$ '5: -%>2E% 5 &01E% :2,0>% 2; ;1(5(>15A 3200?*2(8,1$35: ,(5-A% $2 02AA T1*%*B 0%;1(5(>%U $'% S=@N $'% 0%&2 >2,($%0&50$? 35: $'%(0%f,10%8 $2 0%&,0>'5:% $'% 5::%$: 5$ $'% 570%%8 ,&2( &01>%B 5(8 $'% >2(8,1$ 32,A8

,:% $'% &02>%%8: $2 0%&5? E5$,01(7 S=@N 5(8 $'% ;5>1A1$? 32,A8 >2E% $2 5( %(8*D'% :5;% '50-20: 756% 1(6%:$20: 5(8 05$1(7 57%(>1%: >2E;20$ $'5$ $'% 5::%$: >2,A8 -%:2A8 1; $'% :&2(:20 %L&%01%(>%8 ;1(5(>15A 81:$0%:: F 5( 5::,E&$12( $'5$ 0%:$%8 2( 5;51$' 1( $'% 5-1A1$? $2 :%AA $'% ,(8%0A?1(7 5::%$:* )""@5001>4 I2AA%(45E& \ I5072$N5$01>4B ?,"52' ?,849(; ?2'2B,.8# J.3"/ '. [8"%% )KN ?.49",4/B l5AA #$* )*B #%&$* ]B CJJ]B5$ @C*RR)""n105A n* S>'50?5 %$ 5A*B )"98,2'2Z$'2.4 O2'(.8' !2/7


20/24

CJ

D'%:% A5$$%0 %L$%(:12(: 2; 0%&2 570%%E%($: 50% 2-612,:A? ,(8%:%061(7 2; $22 E,>'>2(>%0(B 5(8 $',: 3'%( >2(:18%01(7 '23 $'% =5(40,&$>? @28% E17'$ 5>>2EE285$%$'1: E504%$ 5;$%0 0%&%5A 2; $'% :5;% '50-20:B 1$ -%>2E%: 1E&20$5($ $2 81:$1(7,1:'5E2(7 $'% 65012,: ;5>%$:*

/( :'20$B ;2AA231(7 $'% 0%&%5A 2; $'% :5;% '50-20: 1( $'% @28%B $'%0% 50% :%6%05A 4%?50%5: $'5$ (%%8 $2 -% 5880%::%8* S8%f,5$% &02$%>$12( 0,A%: 1( $'% @28% 50% 1AA%f,1&&%8 $2 '5(8A% 8%0165$16%:* D'1: >2,A8 A%58 $2 &02-A%E: 1; $'% 8%-$20 1: 716%( 5(%L$%(8%8 &%0128 2; $1E% $2 8%>18%8 3'%$'%0 $2 5::,E% 20 0%m%>$ ;1(5(>15A >2($05>$:*D0581$12(5A 0%&2 570%%E%($: &%0;20E ,:%;,A ;,(>$12(: 1( $'% ;1(5(>15A :?:$%E $'5$E5? -% A1E1$%8 1; $'% :5;% '50-20: 50% 0%&%5A%8 5(8 562185(>% 5>$12(:B &50$1>,A50A?&0%;%0%(>% 5>$12(:B >2,A8 -%(%;1$ ;02E :2E% 588%8 >A501$?* / 5880%:: %5>' 2; $'%:%1::,%: 1( 70%5$%0 8%$51A 1( $'% (%L$ &50$ 2; $'1: 50$1>A%B -,$ $'% A1:$ 2; 1::,%: 82%:1AA,:$05$% $'% :,-:$5($15A 26%0-0%58$' 2; $'% %L1:$1(7 :5;% '50-20 &0261:12(:B 3'1>'>26%0 %::%($15AA? $'% %($10% 8%0165$16%: E504%$:*

///* S>>2EE285$1(7 $'% Q%5A1$? 2; M%0165$16%:/( $'1: :%>$12( / :,77%:$ :&%>1;1> 5E%(8E%($: $2 $'% @28% $'5$ :'2,A8 5>>2E&5(?5(? 0%&%5A 2; $'% :5;% '50-20:* =,$ %6%( $'1: E5? -% $22 (50023B 1(5:E,>' 5: $'%1::,% 2; :5;% '50-20: 1: >A2:%A? $1%8 $2 $'% 8%-5$%: 26%0 $'% (5$,0% 2; $'% 90%:2A,$12(5,$'201$?< $2 ,(31(8 5 ;51A%8 ;1(5(>15A ;10E* Z20 %L5E&A%B 3'1A% / 81:>,:: &A5>1(7A1E1$: 2( $'% 8%-$20g: $1E% $2 5::,E% 20 0%m%>$ 5 8%0165$16%: >2($05>$B &A51(A? :,>'A1E1$: (%%8 $2 -% 1($%705$%8 31$' $'% $1E% &02618%8 ;20 $'% 0%2075(1c5$12(B0%>5&1$5A1c5$12(B 20 :5A% 2; $'% 8%-$20* Q%>27(1c1(7 $'5$ $'1: &5&%0 1: m,:$ 5 &1%>% 2;5( 26%05AA &,ccA%B / &02>%%8*

$P F5"\8$'" D,.'"9'2.4S: (2$%8 1( N50$ //B 5 4%? &02-A%E &0%:%($%8 -? $'% >,00%($ =5(40,&$>? @28% 3'%(5&&A1%8 $2 8%0165$16%: 1: $'5$ $'% @28% 1: 8%:17(%8 $2 5880%:: >2E&505$16%A? :$5-A%>A51E 65A,%: 1( $'% ;5>% 2; 8%>A1(1(7 >2AA5$%05A 65A,%:B -,$ (2$ $'% >2(6%0:%* D'1:$0581$12(5A ,(8%0:$5(81(7 2; 58%f,5$% &02$%>$12( 1: 022$%8 1( :1$,5$12(: 3'%0% $'%(2(^8%-$20 &50$?g: 2-A175$12(: 50% %::%($15AA? >2E&A%$% 5(8 (2(^%L%>,$20?B 5(8 1: 2;A1$$A% ,:% 1( $'% >2($%L$ 2; 5( 2(721(7B -1A5$%05A 0%A5$12(:'1&*

/( $'% 8%0165$16%: >2($%L$B / 507,% $'5$ 58%f,5$% &02$%>$12( :'2,A8 -%

>2(>%&$,5A1c%8 2( 5 &02&20$12(5$% -5:1:a $'% (2(^8%-$20 >2,($%0&50$? :'2,A8 -%&02$%>$%8 $2 $'% :5E% 0%A5$16% 8%70%% 5: $'%? 3%0% &02$%>$%8 2( $'% &%$1$12( 85$%*#2B 1; 5 8%-$20g: 2-A175$12(: 3%0% RJu :%>,0%8 31$' E504 $2 E504%$ >2AA5$%05A 2( $'%&%$1$12( 85$%B $'%? :'2,A8 >2($1(,% $2 -% RJu :%>,0%8 ,($1A $'% 8%-$20 8%>18%: $25::,E% 20 0%m%>$B %6%( 1; $'% :1c% 2; $'% 8%-$20g: 2-A175$12(: 1(>0%5:%* h( $'% 2$'%0'5(8B 1; $'% (2(^8%-$20 &50$? 35: 0%E1:: 1( 5AA231(7 $'% E504 $2 E504%$ >2AA5$%05A$2 801;$ -%A23 5( 5&&02&015$% A%6%AB &%0'5&: 1AA,:$05$%8 1( E? RJu >5:%B $'% (2(^8%-$20 &50$? 32,A8 (2$ -% 5-A% $2 :%%4 "JJu >26%057% 5;$%0 $'% -5(40,&$>? ;1A1(7*


21/24

C"

D'1: 32,A8 716% $'% (2(^8%-$20 &50$? 5&&02&015$% 1(>%($16%: $2 E2(1$20 5(80%58m,:$ >2AA5$%05A -%;20% $'% 2(:%$ 2; ;1(5(>15A 81:$0%:: F 5 >2,($%0&50$? 31$' 5 ;,AA?>2AA5$%05A1c%8 &2:1$12( 31AA >2($1(,% $2 E51($51( $'5$ &2:1$12( $'02,7'2,$ $'%>'5&$%0 "" >5:%B -,$ 5 >2,($%0&50$? 31$' 5 A%::%0 &2:1$12( 31AA (2$ -% 5-A% $2&0%m,81>% 2$'%0 ,(:%>,0%8 >0%81$20:* D'1: :'2,A8 716% &50$1%: 5( 1(>%($16% $2 58m,:$

$'%10 >2AA5$%05A 2( 5 851A? -5:1:B 31$' $'% 2-612,: -%(%;1$ 2; 0%8,>1(7 $'% :?:$%E1>%;;%>$: 2; 5 A507% 8%5A%0g: >2AA5&:%*RW

D'% >2($1(,5$12( 2; E504 $2 E504%$ >2AA5$%05A &2:$^&%$1$12( 32,A8 -% 5 &0%:,E&$12($'5$ 32,A8 0%E51( 1( &A5>% ,($1A $'% >2,0$ 208%0%8 2$'%031:%* D',:B 1; $'% 8%-$20 ;20:2E% 0%5:2( ;%A$ $'% >2($1(,%8 &2:$1(7 2; >2AA5$%05A 35: ,(35005($%8B 1$ >2,A8 72 $2>2,0$ $2 :%%4 5 >'5(7%* D'% &0%:,E&$12( 32,A8 -% $1%8 $2 5 ;,0$'%0 &0%:,E&$12($'5$ $'% 5,$2E5$1> :$5? 32,A8 -% A1;$%8 :'20$A? 5;$%0 $'% (2(^8%-$20 &50$? 716%:(2$1>% $'5$ 5 (%>%::50? >2AA5$%05A &2:$1(7 '5: (2$ -%%( E58%*WJ

I20%26%0B >2AA5$%05A >'5(7%: (2$ -5:%8 2( >'5(7%: 1( $'% ,(8%0A?1(7 5::%$ 65A,%: F

;20 %L5E&A%B >2AA5$%05A >5AA: -5:%8 2( $'% 8%-$20g: >0%81$ 05$1(7 F 32,A8 (2$ -%&02$%>$%8 ,(8%0 $'1: 0,A%* D'%? 5A:2 32,A8 (2$ -% &02$%>$%8 ,(8%0 $'% 562185(>%0,A%:B 5: / 81:>,:: 1( ;,0$'%0 8%$51A -%A23* /(:$%58B $'% 725A 32,A8 -% $2 &02$%>$ $'%&02&20$12(5$% 8%70%% 2; &02$%>$12( $'5$ $'% (2(^8%-$20 &50$? '58 5$ $'%>2EE%(>%E%($ 2; $'% >5:%*

S: &50$ 2; $'1:B @2(70%:: 5A:2 (%%8: $2 0%%L5E1(% :%>$12( KJ]T-U 2; $'% =5(40,&$>?@28%B 3'1>' &02618%: 5 :,&%0 &01201$? >A51E ;20 5 >0%81$20 3'2 35: 705($%858%f,5$% &02$%>$12( $'5$ $,0(%8 2,$ $2 -% 1(58%f,5$%* /( 5 320A8 31$' >2($02AA1(7:%>,0%8 -5(4 A%(8%0:B 31$' &%065:16% A1%(: 2( 5AA $'% 8%-$20g: 5::%$:B $'5$ 2;$%(-%>2E% >2($02AA1(7 >'5&$%0 "" M/N A%(8%0:B $'1: &0261:12( 1: 5&$ $2 -% A1$$A% >2E;20$B

5: :%>$12( GVHT>UT"U 716%: $'% M/N A%(8%0 5( %6%( '17'%0 &01201$?*W" @0%81$20: 2; 5AA$?&%: 8%:%06% -%$$%0 5(8 E20% 0%5A1:$1> &02$%>$12( 5751(:$ m,81>15A 65A,5$12( %0020:*

RW@,00%($A? >2AA5$%05A &2:$1(7 1: 5 ;,(>$12( 2; -2$' $'% %L&2:,0% 2; $'% 91( $'%E2(%?< &50$? T$'% 9#%>,0%8 N50$?< 1( /#MS $%0E:U 5(8 5(? 5&&A1>5-A% 9/(8%&%(8%($SE2,($:*< )"" /8#,$ (2$% "W* /( 5881$12(B $'% &50$1%: :2E%$1E%: 570%% $2 59$'0%:'2A8< ,(8%0 3'1>' >2AA5$%05A 31AA (2$ -% %L>'5(7%8B E%5(1(7 $'5$ >2AA5$%05A 1:

2(A? %L>'5(7%8 1; $'% 8%0165$16% &01>% E26%: 2,$:18% 5 41(8 2; 9$2A%05(>% 1($%065A*$ 2; 5AA231(7 2(721(7 E504 $2 E504%$ >2AA5$%05A 8,01(7 >'5&$%0"" 5$ $'% &0%^-5(40,&$>? 0%A5$16% A%6%A 32,A8 -% $2 E26% 5AA $'0%:'2A8: $2 c%02*WJS;$%0 ;1A1(7 $'% (2$1>%B $'% -5(40,&$>? >2,0$ 32,A8 '56% $2 '56% 5 :'20$ &%0128 2;$1E%B &%0'5&: CH '2,0:B $2 5880%:: 5(? >A51E: -? $'% 8%-$20 $'5$ $'% (2(^8%-$20&50$? '58 1E&02&%0A? 8%E5(8%8 $'% >2AA5$%05A 1( f,%:$12(*W")"" B"4",$%%: )5? +530%(>% l%:$-0224B


22/24

CC

-P !"'$2424B $ A$,,.>"5 !"#. )$*" +$,-.,/( &50$ // / 8%:>01-%8 '23 $'% %L&5(:12( 2; $'% :5;% '50-20: 31$' 0%7508 $20%&,0>'5:% 570%%E%($: '58 A14%A? >2($01-,$%8 $2 $'% 0%>%($ ;1(5(>15A >01:1:B ?%$ $'%0%1: 5 $0581$12(5A >20% 2; $'% 0%&2 E504%$ $'5$ :%%E: 320$'? 2; :561(7* D'1: 1:

&50$1>,A50A? 2-612,: 31$' 0%7508 $2 0%&2: ,:%8 -? $'% Z%8%05A Q%:%06% :?:$%E 5: 5(1(:$0,E%($ 2; E2(%$50? &2A1>?* I20%26%0B / :,77%:$%8 $'5$ $'% E5071(: 1(62A6%8 1($'%:% $0581$12(5A $05(:5>$12(: 50% :2 :A17'$ $'5$ $'%? E17'$ (2$ 0%581A? 5>>2EE285$%$'% 1E&2:1$12( 2; 5(? :%012,: -5(40,&$>? >2:$:*

D'% &02-A%E $'%( 1: $'% >,00%($ -0%58$' 2; $'% 0%&2 :5;% '50-20a 1$ >26%0: $'1(7:$'5$ A224 A14% 02,$1(% :%>,0%8 A25(: 5(8 7,505($%%:* l'%( ,:%8 5: :,>'B $'%0% 1: (20%5:2( 3'? $'% ;20E 2; $'% $05(:5>$12( :'2,A8 A%58 $2 :&%>15A $0%5$E%($ 2; $'% (2(^8%-$20 &50$?* D2 (50023 $'% &2$%($15A ;20 5-,:% 2; $'% :5;% '50-20:B / :,77%:$ $32>'5(7%: $2 $'% 8%;1(1$12( 2; 90%&,0>'5:% 570%%E%($< 1( $'% @28%*WC

Z10:$B $'% >,00%($ 8%;1(1$12( 5AA23: ;20 :&%>15A :$5$,: %6%( 1; $'% 0%&,0>'5:%2-A175$12( 1: ,& $2 5 ?%50 1( $'% ;,$,0%* D'% 5-1A1$? $2 ,:% 0%&2 570%%E%($: 5::,-:$1$,$%: ;20 2$'%0 :$0,>$,0%: 32,A8 -% 0%8,>%8 1; $1E% &%0128 3%0% :,-:$5($15AA?0%8,>%8B &%0'5&: $2 GJ 20 VJ 85?:*

#%>2(8B $'% CJJK SE%(8E%($:B 3'1>' 705($%8 :&%>15A :$5$,: $2 0%&2: -5:%8 2(:%>,01$1c%8 >2AA5$%05A F (5E%A? E20$757% A25( :%>,01$1%: F :'2,A8 -% 02AA%8 -5>4*Q%&,0>'5:% 570%%E%($: >2,A8 >2($1(,% $2 -% 301$$%( 2( 91(%A171-A%< >2AA5$%05AB -,$$'% &50$1%: 32,A8 5::,E% 70%5$%0 01:4: 1; $'%? 8%>18%8 $2 82 :2*

D54%( $27%$'%0B $'%:% >'5(7%: 32,A8 &0%:%06% $'% :5;% '50-20: ;20 $'% -%(%;1$ 2;

:'20$^$%0E >2($05>$: 301$$%( 2( '17'%0^f,5A1$? >2AA5$%05A*

9P 2,($%0&50$? 31AA -% :2E%3'5$ &02$%>$%8 ;02E $'%:% :20$: 2; 01:4: -?$'% >2($1(,5$12( 2; E504 $2 E504%$ >2AA5$%05A 5005(7%E%($:B 5: 8%:>01-%8 5-26%*=,$ ;20 $'2:% >2,($%0&50$1%: $'5$ A5>4 :,>' &02$%>$12(B 5(8 -%>5,:% 8%0165$16%: 2;$%(;20E &50$ 2; 5 A507%0 1(6%:$E%($ &A5( $'5$ E5? -% '%A8 1( 5-%?5(>% 3'1A% $'% 8%-$208%>18%: 3'5$ $2 82B 1$ E54%: :2E% :%(:% $2 A1E1$ $'% 5E2,($ 2; $1E% $'% 8%-$20 >5(

WC"" P*#*@* p"J"TH]U*


23/24

CG

$54% $2 E54% 1$: 8%>1:12(*WG D'5$ 1:B $'% @28% :'2,A8 &,$ 5( %L&105$12( 85$% 2( $'%8%-$20g: 2&$12(* D'% $1E% A1E1$ :'2,A8 5AA23 $'% 8%-$20 5 0%5:2(5-A% 2&&20$,(1$? $20%61%3 1$: &2:1$12(: 5(8 E54% 5 8%>1:12( 5: $2 3'%$'%0 5 &50$1>,A50 570%%E%($:'2,A8 -% 5::,E%8 20 0%m%>$%8B 3'1A% %(:,01(7 $'5$ $'% %L5E1(5$12( &02>%%8: 31$'5AA &2::1-A% '5:$%*WH

@A2:%A? 0%A5$%8 $2 $'1:B :%>$12( GVGT>U 2; $'% @28%B 3'1>' 5AA23: ;20 2&%05$12( 2; 5-,:1(%:: 8,01(7 -5(40,&$>? 91( $'% 2081(50? >2,0:%< 31$'2,$ &0120 >2,0$ 5&&0265AB:'2,A8 -% 5E%(8%8 $2 %L&0%::A? &02618% $'% 8%-$20 31$' $'% 5-1A1$? 5(8 .-%2B$'2.4$2 &%0;20E ,(8%0 1$: 8%0165$16% >2($05>$: &%(81(7 5 8%>1:12( $2 5::,E% 20 0%m%>$ $'%:5E%* Q%f,10%8 &%01281> &5?E%($: :'2,A8 -% E58%B :%>,01$1%: 8%A16%0%8B 5(8B 2;>2,0:%B >2AA5$%05A &2:$%8* [2(^&%0;20E5(>% :'2,A8 A%58 $2 f,1>4 $%0E1(5$12( 2; $'%5,$2E5$1> :$5?*

5P ?.52*:24B `H,524$,: ?.8,/"a $45 `!"$/.4$-%: G\823$%"4' N$%8"al'1A% / '56% 507,%8 $'5$ >2,($%0&50$1%: '56% A1$$A% $2 ;%50 ;02E $'% @28%g: 562185(>%5>$12(:B $'%0% 1: :2E% ,(>%0$51($? 5-2,$ $'% 8%;1(1$12( 2; >%0$51( 4%? $%0E:B 3'1>'E17'$ >0%5$% 5( 2&&20$,(1$? $2 -01(7 A1$175$12(B &50$1>,A50A? 1; 5 :,1$ 1: -02,7'$ -?>0%81$20: 31$' (2 2$'%0 :2,0>% 2; 0%>26%0?*

D'1: 1::,% 1: %5:1A? 0%E%81%8 -? &026181(7 :2E% 1($%0&0%$16% 7,185(>% 1( $'%=5(40,&$>? @28%* Z20 %L5E&A%B $'% @28%g: &0%;%0%(>% &0261:12(: &02618% 5 8%;%(:%;20 $05(:5>$12(: ,(8%0$54%( 1( $'% 92081(50? >2,0:% 2; -,:1(%::*A%50 $'5$ 5>$12(: $54%( 5>>2081(7 $'% %L&0%:: $%0E: 2; 5(1(8,:$0? :$5(8508 8%0165$16% >2($05>$ 32,A8 -% &0%:,E%8 $2 -% 1( $'% 92081(50?>2,0:%B< 32,A8 0%8,>% E,>' 2; $'% 1(>%($16% ;20 ,(35005($%8 &0%;%0%(>%

A1$175$12(*WV

#1E1A50A?B 9>2(:$0,>$16%< ;05,8,A%($ $05(:;%0 &0261:12(: ,(8%0 :$5$% 5(8 ;%8%05A A5350% -5:%8 2( $'% 18%5 $'5$ 5 &,0>'5:% 2; $'% 8%-$20g: 5::%$: ;20 A%:: $'5( 0%5:2(5-A?%f,165A%($ 65A,% >5( -% 56218%8* S &0261:12( 1( $'% @28% &026181(7 $'5$ 5 8%0165$16%$05(:5>$12( 82(% 2( 9E504%$ $%0E:< 1: &0%:,E&$16%A? ;20 90%5:2(5-A? %f,165A%($65A,%< 32,A8 -% :1E1A50A? ,:%;,AB 5(8 :'2,A8 0%8,>% $'% ,(>%0$51($? $'5$ $'%562185(>% &23%0: &0%:%($*

WGZ20 :%6%05A ?%50: $'% @28% '5: '58 5 :1E1A50 &0261:12( 31$' 0%7508 $2 (2(^0%:18%($15A 0%5A %:$5$% A%5:%:B 5A$'2,7' 507,5-A? $'% CJJK 5E%(8E%($: E5? '56%

26%0A? >2(:$01>$%8 $'% $1E% $'% 8%-$20 '5: 1( $'1: 0%7508* "" P*#*@* pGVKT8UTHU*WHl'1A% :'20$ $1E%A1(%: (2 82,-$ 31AA >5,:% $'% 8%-$20 $2 1(>,0 5881$12(5A&02;%::12(5A ;%%:B 3'1>' 0%8,>%: $'% 26%05AA 65A,% 2; $'% %:$5$%B $'% -5A5(>% 2; $'%%>2(2E1> A2::%: 32,A8 :%%E $2 $1A$ $23508 0%8,>1(7 $'% &%0128 2; ,(>%0$51($? ;20(2(^8%-$20:*WK"" P*#*@* pKH]T>UTCU*WVh; >2,0:%B $'1: >2,A8 (2$ %L$%(8 $2 2#/. *$9'.&0261:12(:B A%:$ $'% &0%;%0%(>%8%;%(:% -%>2E% 5 (%3 :5;% '50-20*


24/24

/n* @2(>A,:12(D'% :5;% '50-20 &0261:12(: 50% ,(A26%8B &50$1>,A50A? -? A%75A 5>58%E1>:* =,$ :1E&A%0%&%5A 2; $'2:% &0261:12(: E5? (2$ -% 5&&02&015$%B 1( $'5$ $'% ;1(5(>15A E504%$: 31AA

(%6%0 0%$,0( $2 "W]R* D'% =5(40,&$>? @28% (%%8: $2 0%;A%>$ $'% >,00%($ 0%5A1$? 2;>20&205$% ;1(5(>%B 5(8 $',: / '56% :,77%:$%8 :2E% 65A18 >2(>%0(: $'5$ 50% -,01%831$'1( $'% 26%0A? -0258 :5;% '50-20:* /; $'% :5;% '50-20: 50% 0%&%5A%8B $'1: &5&%0'17'A17'$: :2E% 1::,%: $'5$ 31AA '56% $2 -% >2(:18%0%8 5$ $'% :5E% $1E%*

the bankruptcy code without safe harbors

Documents