simulations+and+observations+of+the+icl+ · simulations+and+observations+of+the+icl+...

14
Simulations and Observations of the ICL Quantity, Morphology, and Optical Colors Chris Mihos (CWRU), Cameron McBride (Vanderbilt), Lucy Frey (LANL), Andrew Schectman Rook (Wisconsin), Matt McJunkin (Colorado) Chris Mihos (CWRU), Paul Harding (CWRU), Heather Morrison (CWRU), John Feldmeier (YSU), Steven Janowiecki (Indiana), Colin Slater (Michigan)

Upload: others

Post on 17-Oct-2020

11 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ · Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ Quantity,+Morphology,+and+Optical+Colors+ Chris+Mihos(CWRU),+Cameron+ McBride+(Vanderbilt),+Lucy+Frey+

Simulations  and  Observations  of  the  ICL  Quantity,  Morphology,  and  Optical  Colors  

Chris  Mihos  (CWRU),  Cameron  McBride  (Vanderbilt),  Lucy  Frey  (LANL),  Andrew  Schectman-­‐Rook  (Wisconsin),  Matt  McJunkin  (Colorado)     Chris  Mihos  (CWRU),  Paul  Harding  

(CWRU),  Heather  Morrison  (CWRU),  John  Feldmeier  (YSU),  Steven  Janowiecki  (Indiana),  Colin  Slater  (Michigan)      

Page 2: Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ · Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ Quantity,+Morphology,+and+Optical+Colors+ Chris+Mihos(CWRU),+Cameron+ McBride+(Vanderbilt),+Lucy+Frey+

¡  Hi-­‐resolution,  N-­‐body  simulations  of  cluster  assembly  

¡  As  cluster  evolves:  §  ICL  is  produced  §  ICL  morphology  evolves  

Page 3: Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ · Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ Quantity,+Morphology,+and+Optical+Colors+ Chris+Mihos(CWRU),+Cameron+ McBride+(Vanderbilt),+Lucy+Frey+

z=0.5  z=1  

z=0  z=0.2  

Page 4: Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ · Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ Quantity,+Morphology,+and+Optical+Colors+ Chris+Mihos(CWRU),+Cameron+ McBride+(Vanderbilt),+Lucy+Frey+

Rudick  et  al.  2006  

§  Binding  Energy  §  Kinematics  §  Surface  Brightness  §  Density  

Rudick  et  al.  2009  

⎟⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛ʹ′ʹ′ʹ′+ʹ′ʹ′ʹ′−=Φ ∫∫−

max

)()(4)(0

21r

r

r

rdrrrdrrrGr ρρπ

Rudick    et  al.  2011  

Dolag  et  al.  2010  Rudick  et  al.  2011  

Page 5: Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ · Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ Quantity,+Morphology,+and+Optical+Colors+ Chris+Mihos(CWRU),+Cameron+ McBride+(Vanderbilt),+Lucy+Frey+

¡  Different  definitions  give  VERY  different  answers!  §  10-­‐36%  for  the  same  cluster  

§  Even  more  scatter  when  you  consider  free  parameters  of  each  method  

§ Methods  vary  systematically  

Rudick  et  al.  2011  

Page 6: Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ · Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ Quantity,+Morphology,+and+Optical+Colors+ Chris+Mihos(CWRU),+Cameron+ McBride+(Vanderbilt),+Lucy+Frey+

Rudick  et  al.  2009  

¡  Much  of  the  ICL  forms  in  cold  tidal  streams  

¡  Streams  decay  to  form  diffuse  background  

Stre

am S

ize

[par

ticle

s]

Page 7: Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ · Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ Quantity,+Morphology,+and+Optical+Colors+ Chris+Mihos(CWRU),+Cameron+ McBride+(Vanderbilt),+Lucy+Frey+

¡  µV~29  mag.  sq.  arcsec  

¡  Fossil  Record  

Page 8: Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ · Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ Quantity,+Morphology,+and+Optical+Colors+ Chris+Mihos(CWRU),+Cameron+ McBride+(Vanderbilt),+Lucy+Frey+

¡  µV~29  mag.  sq.  arcsec  

¡  Fossil  Record  

Page 9: Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ · Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ Quantity,+Morphology,+and+Optical+Colors+ Chris+Mihos(CWRU),+Cameron+ McBride+(Vanderbilt),+Lucy+Frey+

¡  µV~29  mag.  sq.  arcsec  

¡  Fossil  Record  

Page 10: Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ · Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ Quantity,+Morphology,+and+Optical+Colors+ Chris+Mihos(CWRU),+Cameron+ McBride+(Vanderbilt),+Lucy+Frey+

Rudick  et  al.  2010a    

Rudick  et  al.  2010  

Page 11: Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ · Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ Quantity,+Morphology,+and+Optical+Colors+ Chris+Mihos(CWRU),+Cameron+ McBride+(Vanderbilt),+Lucy+Frey+

¡  Northern  edge  of  M87  

¡  Identify  streams  

¡  Differential  photometry  

¡  Compare  to  M87  envelope  

Rudick  et  al.  2010  

Page 12: Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ · Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ Quantity,+Morphology,+and+Optical+Colors+ Chris+Mihos(CWRU),+Cameron+ McBride+(Vanderbilt),+Lucy+Frey+

Rudick  et  al.  2010   ¡  A  §  B-­‐V~0.75-­‐1.05  §   µV~28.6  

¡  B  §  B-­‐V~0.8-­‐1.2  §   µV~29.2  

¡  C  §  B-­‐V~0.7-­‐1.0  §   µV~28.7  

¡  M87  §  B-­‐V~0.75-­‐0.85  §   µV~27.5  Streams  are  building  M87  halo  

Page 13: Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ · Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ Quantity,+Morphology,+and+Optical+Colors+ Chris+Mihos(CWRU),+Cameron+ McBride+(Vanderbilt),+Lucy+Frey+

ETH  ZURICH  Marcella  Carollo,  Anna  Cibinel,  Ewan  Cameron,  Ting  Lu,  Antonio  Pippino  

Coming  Soon!  

Page 14: Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ · Simulations+and+Observations+of+the+ICL+ Quantity,+Morphology,+and+Optical+Colors+ Chris+Mihos(CWRU),+Cameron+ McBride+(Vanderbilt),+Lucy+Frey+

① ICL  quantity  is  very  dependent  on  measurement  technique.  

② We  are  witnessing  M87’s  halo  being  built  via  tidal  disruption.