shorlisted consultants monitoring evalution of brt in pcmc

Tender no. Name of Firm(s)Country of Lead Firm

Total

1LEA Associates South Asia Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi

In JV with Centre for Environmental Planning & Technology, Ahmedabad

India 90

11 Consulting Engineering Services (India) Private Limited, New Delhi India 85

5 IBI Group, Toranto, Canada Canada 83

2Advanced Logistics Group (ALG), Spain

in JV withIntercontinental Consultants & Technocrats Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi

Spain 75

4 Halcrow Consulting India Pvt. Ltd, Noida India 73

9SRIE Infrastructure Finance Ltd., New Delhi

in JV withLeap Infrasys Private Ltd., Faridabad, Haryana

India 70

Shorlisted Consultants for Monitoring & Evalution of BRT in PCMC area

Tender no. Name of Firm(s)Country of Lead Firm

Total

1LEA Associates South Asia Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi


India 90

2Advanced Logistics Group (ALG), Spain


Spain 75

3 Administrative Staff College of India (ASCi), Hyderabad India 65

4 Halcrow Consulting India Pvt. Ltd, Noida India 73

5 IBI Group, Toranto, Canada Canada 83

6Mahindra Consulting Engineers Ltd., Chennai

in JV withSafeage Consulting Engineers, France

India 55

7Transport Research Laboratory (TRL), UK

in JV withIntegrated Transport Planning Ltd. (iTP), UK

United Kingdom 50

8Feedback Infrastructure Services Pvt. Ltd., Gurgaon

in JV withHamburg Consult, Germany

India 65

9SRIE Infrastructure Finance Ltd., New Delhi


India 70

10 Wapcos Limited, Gandhinagar India 35

11 Consulting Engineering Services (India) Private Limited, New Delhi India 85

12 Sungrace Engineering Projects Pvt. Ltd., Pune India 20

13ECORYS Netherland BV, Netherlands

in JV with ICRA Management Consulting Services Ltd., Noida & ARUP

Netherlands 68

14Sutra Consulting Pvt. Ltd, Orrisa

in JV withCentre for Management & Social Research (CSMR), Hyderabad

India 45

15 Ernst & Young Private Limited, Hyderabad India 25

16Wipro Consulting Services, Andheri, Mumbai

In JV with Innovative Transport Solutions Pvt. Ltd., Delhi

India 60

17Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Private Ltd, Gurgaon, Haryana

In JV withMVA Asia Limited, CBD, Belapur

India 65

18 TNS India Private Limited, Gurgaon India 45

Marks Obtained by All Consultants ‐ Monitoring & Evaluation of BRTS in PCMC area

Name of Firm

Address of firmPlace of Incorporation

of the Firm/Lead Member

Main CategorySub

CategoryOrganisation Structure

Marks per Category

Maximum Marks per

Sub ‐Category

Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)

A11 10 years & above 102 3 to 9 years 53 below 3 years 0A21 5 Crs. & above 102 1 to 4 Crs. 53 below 1 Crs. 0A31 51 & above 102 21 to 50 53 below 20 0

30 30

Main CategorySub

CategoryExperience

Marks per Category

Maximum Marks per Category

Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)

B1 (a)

1 10 & above 15

2 5 to 9 10

3 1 to 4 5

4 0 0

B

Shortlisting of Consultants for Monitoring & Evaluation of BRTS in PCMC areaLEA Associates South Asia Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi


B‐1/E‐27, Mohan Cooperative Industrial Estate, Mathura Road, New Delhi.

New Delhi

A

Age of the Firm

10 10 Registered on 21st October 1993 (17 years 8 months)

Average Annual Turn Over for last 3 years

10 10 Average annual turnover for last three financial years is 67.19 Crs.

Number of employees

10 10 As per Corporate Profile ‐ more than 1200 employees worldwide

Total Marks Obtained in Category 'A'

Experience of undertaking Public Transport Studies ‐ No. of Studies

15 15

1. Consultancy Services for Preparatory for GEF ‐ SUTP, 9 cities in India.2. BRTS studies, Phase I & II, Ahmedabad, India.3. BRTS, Surat, India.4. Benefit M & E for RUIDP, Rajasthan, India.5. Consultancy Services for M & E for Resettlement & Rehabilitation Construction Packages IV A, IV C, V B, GT Road Improvement Project, UP & Bihar, India.6. Consultancy Services for Preparation of Project Completion and Project Benefit M & E Report ADB ‐ I & ADB ‐ II Projects.7. Preparation of Benefit M & E Report Kakinda ‐ Rajanagram Road (SH), Andhra Pradesh.8. Preparation of Benefit M & E Report Varanasi to Shakti Nagar Road (SH), Uttar Pradesh.9. Preparation of Benefit M & E Report Rourkela to Sambhalpur Road (SH), Orissa.10. Preparation of Benefit M & E Report for Bangalore‐Karnataka / Tamilnadu border Section of NH 7, Karnataka.11. Preparation of Benefit M & E Report for Aluva ‐ Sherthalai section of NH 47, Kerala.12. Preparation of Benefit M & E Report for Achrol ‐ Kotputli section of NH 8, Rajasthan.13. Consultancy Services for Cat ‐ 2 Assignment ‐ Preparation of Development Plan for Pitampur ‐ Dhar ‐ Mhow Investment Region in MP subregion of DMIC ‐ Prefeasibility Study (BRTS for Investment Region including Ghata Bhilod Road).14. Revalidating Study and Overall Appraisal of the project for Four ‐ Lanning of selected Corridors in the State of Gujarat.15. Technical Assistance for Project Preparatory Consultancy Services for Implementation of Transport Infrastructure in MMR.16. Consultancy for Comprehensive Transportation Study for MMR.17. Comprehensive Traffic & Transportation Plan of Thane City.18. Preparation of Integrated Traffic & Transport Plan / Mobility Plan for KDMC.19. Preparation of Strategic Monorail Master Plan & Preliminary Feasibility Study Report select corridors in MMR.20. Traffic & Transportation Study for the Charkop ‐ Mankhurd Metro Link at Mumbai.21. Regional & Transport Perspective Strategy for DMIC influence Region in Maharashtra.22. Consultancy Services for Traffic & Transportation Study & Planning with respect to transport issues for the Dharavi Redevelopment Project.23. Preparation of DPR for Mumbai Metro Phase III Corridor: Mahim ‐ BKC‐ Kanjurmarg via Airpot.24. Consultancy Services for Preparation of Regional & Local Transport Connectivity Plan for Navi Mumbai International Airport.25. City Mobility Plan, Surat.

B1 (b)

1 In Asian Continent 102 Other than Asia Continent 53 None of the above 0

B2 (a)

1 10 & above 15

2 5 to 9 10

3 2 to 4 5

4 1 & below 0B2 (b)1 In Asian Continent 52 Other than Asia Continent 33 None of the above 0

B3 (a)

1 5 & above 10

2 1 to 4 5

3 0 0

B3 (b)


60 50

Main CategorySub

CategoryManpower

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)

1 above 10 years 102 10 & below 5

10 10100 90

B

Experience of undertaking Public Transport Studies ‐ Geographical Area of study

10 10 In india, Asian Continent

Experience of undertaking BRTS ‐ No. of Studies

15 5

1. BRTS studies, Phase I & II, Ahmedabad, India.2. BRTS, Surat, India.3. Consultancy Services for Cat ‐ 2 Assignment ‐ Preparation of Development Plan for Pitampur ‐ Dhar ‐ Mhow Investment Region in MP subregion of DMIC ‐ Prefeasibility Study (BRTS for Investment Region including Ghata Bhilod Road).

Experience of undertaking BRTS ‐ Geographical Area of study


10 Dr. S. Raghavachari (Ph.D in Transporatation Engineering with 52 years experience)

Experience of undertaking M & E related to Traffic & Transportation ‐ No. of Studies

10 10

1. Consultancy Services for Preparatory for GEF ‐ SUTP, 9 cities in India.2. Benefit M & E for RUIDP, Rajasthan, India.3. Consultancy Services for M & E for Resettlement & Rehabilitation Construction Packages IV A, IV C, V B, GT Road Improvement Project, UP & Bihar, India.4. Consultancy Services for Preparation of Project Completion and Project Benefit M & E Report ADB ‐ I & ADB ‐ II Projects.5. Preparation of Benefit M & E Report Kakinda ‐ Rajanagram Road (SH), Andhra Pradesh.6. Preparation of Benefit M & E Report Varanasi to Shakti Nagar Road (SH), Uttar Pradesh.7. Preparation of Benefit M & E Report Rourkela to Sambhalpur Road (SH), Orissa.8. Preparation of Benefit M & E Report for Bangalore‐Karnataka / Tamilnadu border Section of NH 7, Karnataka.9. Preparation of Benefit M & E Report for Aluva ‐ Sherthalai section of NH 47, Kerala.10. Preparation of Benefit M & E Report for Achrol ‐ Kotputli section of NH 8, Rajasthan.

Experience of undertaking M & E related to Traffic & Transportation ‐ Geographical Area of study


Total Marks Obtained in Category 'C'Total Marks

Total Marks Obtained in Category 'B'

C

Transport Planners with qualification of Master's Degree in Transport Planning ‐ experience in undertaking Public Transport studies 10

Name of Firm



Main CategorySub


Marks per Category

Maximum Marks per

Sub ‐Category

Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


30 25

Main CategorySub

CategoryExperience

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)

B1 (a)

1 10 & above 15

2 5 to 9 10

3 1 to 4 5

4 0 0

B

Shortlisting of Consultants for Monitoring & Evaluation of BRTS in PCMC areaAdvanced Logistics Group (ALG), Spain


Tanger 98, 3A, 08018, Barcelona, Spain

Not mentioned

A

Age of the Firm

10 10 20 years


10 5 Not mentioned anywhere in submission

Number of employees

10 10 120



15 15

1. BRT & Corridor Restructuring Implementation Study for Uttara ‐ Mohakhali ‐ Ramna ‐ Sadargahat Corridor in Dhaka (Bangladesh).2. Preparing the Greater Dhaka Sustainable Urban Transport Corridor (BRT), Bangladesh.3. Preparation of DPR for BRT, Delhi.4. Operational & Business Plan for Tshwane's BRTS, South Africa.5. Development of an Integrated Rapid Public Transport Network, South Africa.6. Operational Plan for Buffalo City BRTS, South Africa.7. Operational Plan for Polokwane BRTS, South Africa.8. Transport Planning & Restructuring studies for the Ist Phase of MRTS for Central District of Tegucigalpa, Honduras.9. Transportation & Operations Planning for the Integrated Collective Transport System, Guatemala.10. Feasibility Study for Restructuring the North East Corridor of the Transmetro, Guatemala.11. Transit & Transport Study in city of Trujillo, Peru.12. Feasibility Study for Introduction of BRT Line in Caracas, Venezuela.13. Design of Mass Urban Transport System in City of Arequipa, Peru.14. Mass Transit Omnibus system in the city of Arequipa, Peru.15. Feasibility Study for Public Transport Corridors in Baruta, Venezuela.16. Restructuring the public transportation network in Lima, Peru.17. Preparation of DPR for BRT Corridor Shastri Park to Karawal Nagar & 3 Link Roads, Delhi.18. Road Infrastructure Plan for Kalinganagar.19. Feasibility Study for rehabilitation & Stregthening, Nagpur ‐ Durg section of NH 6.20. Greater Gaborone Multimodal Transportation Study, Botswana.21. Strategic Planning for new public transport system in San Salvador.22. Mobility Plan of Popayan City, Colombia.23. San Cristobal Urban Transport System Study, Venezuela.24. Master Plan for MRTS in Panama City.25. Study of the Integrated Mobility System, Mexico.26. Study to restructure the public transport network, Mexico.27. New Structure & Fare Pricing System for the Urban Public Transport Network, Greece.28. Integrated Public Transport System, Czech Republic.

B1 (b)


B2 (a)

1 10 & above 15

2 5 to 9 10

3 2 to 4 5

4 1 & below 0

B2 (b)1 In Asian Continent 52 Other than Asia Continent 33 None of the above 0

B3 (a)

1 5 & above 102 1 to 4 53 0 0

B3 (b)


60 40

Main CategorySub

CategoryManpower

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


10 10100 75

B


10 10 In India, Asian Continent.


15 10

1. BRT & Corridor Restructuring Implementation Study for Uttara ‐ Mohakhali ‐ Ramna ‐ Sadargahat Corridor in Dhaka (Bangladesh).2. Preparing the Greater Dhaka Sustainable Urban Transport Corridor (BRT), Bangladesh.3. Preparation of DPR for BRT, Delhi.4. Operational & Business Plan for Tshwane's BRTS, South Africa.5. Operational Plan for Buffalo City BRTS, South Africa.6. Operational Plan for Polokwane BRTS, South Africa.7. Feasibility Study for Introduction of BRT Line in Caracas, Venezuela.8. Preparation of DPR for BRT Corridor Shastri Park to Karawal Nagar & 3 Link Roads, Delhi.



10 Mr.Rakesh Kumar Bajpai with M. Tech Transportation System with 29 years experience


10 0 No work related toi M & E


5 0 No work related toi M & E



C


Name of FirmAddress of firm

Place of Incorporation of the Firm/Lead

Member

Main CategorySub


Marks per Category

Maximum Marks per

Sub ‐Category

Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


30 25

Main CategorySub

CategoryExperience

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)

B1 (a)

1 10 & above 152 5 to 9 103 1 to 4 54 0 0

B1 (b)


B2 (a)1 10 & above 152 5 to 9 103 2 to 4 54 1 & below 0


B3 (a)

1 5 & above 102 1 to 4 53 0 0

B3 (b)


60 30

Shortlisting of Consultants for Monitoring & Evaluation of BRTS in PCMC areaAdministrative Staff College of India (ASCi), Hyderabad

Bella Vista Campus, Khairatabad

A

Age of the Firm

10 10 Established in 1956 (55 years)


10 10 Rs. 25.44 crs.

Number of employees

10 5 50 qualified experts


B


15 5

1. Preparation of DPR for BRTS, Vishakhapatanam.2. Preparation of DPR for BRTS, Vijaywada.3. Preparation of DPR for BRTS, Hyderabad.4. Indore Intelligent Transport System Plan.


10 10 In India, Asian Continent


15 51. Preparation of DPR for BRTS, Vishakhapatanam.2. Preparation of DPR for BRTS, Vijaywada.3. Preparation of DPR for BRTS, Hyderabad.




10 0 No work related to M & E




Main CategorySub

CategoryManpower

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


10 10100 65

10Prof. Raj Ponnaluri (M.S Transportation Engineering with 18 years

experience)


C




Member

Main CategorySub


Marks per Category

Maximum Marks per

Sub ‐Category

Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


30 30

Main CategorySub

CategoryExperience

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)

B1 (a)

1 10 & above 15

2 5 to 9 10

3 1 to 4 5

4 0 0

B1 (b)




B3 (a)

1 5 & above 102 1 to 4 53 0 0

B3 (b)


60 33

Shortlisting of Consultants for Monitoring & Evaluation of BRTS in PCMC areaHalcrow Consulting India Pvt. Ltd, Noida

B‐11, Sector IV, Noida, UP, India

New Delhi

A

Age of the Firm

10 10 Company Profile (August 2001 ‐ 10 years)


10 10 Rs. 31.16 crs.

Number of employees

10 10 355


B


15 15

1. Cardiff Core Bus Network, Wales.2. Clyde Fastlink (BRT), Glasgow.3. Leeds guided Bus, Leeds.4. Norwich Cross Valley Link Busway, England.5. Traffic & Revenue Forecast study for Hyderabad Metro Rail.6. Traffic & Revenue Forecast study for Mumbai Metro Line 2.7. Traffic & Transportation Study for the Airport Metro Link at New Delhi.8. Traffic Study for Implementation of Passenger Water Transport Project, Maharashtra.9. Vizag Coastal Corridor, AP.10. Traffic Revalidation Study for Four Lanning of Ahmedabad Ring Road Project.11. Traffic Study for Chennai Elevated Road.12. Traffic Study for Eastern Peripheral Expressway, Delhi.




15 51. Clyde Fastlink (BRT), Glasgow.2. Leeds guided Bus, Leeds.


5 3 Other than Asian Continent






Main CategorySub

CategoryManpower

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


10 10100 73

10 Mr. Shrinivas Chekuri (M.Tech Transport Planning with 20 years experience)


C




Member

Main CategorySub


Marks per Category

Maximum Marks per

Sub ‐Category

Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


30 30

Main CategorySub

CategoryExperience

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)

B1 (a)

1 10 & above 15

2 5 to 9 10

3 1 to 4 5

4 0 0

B1 (b)




B3 (a)

1 5 & above 102 1 to 4 53 0 0

B3 (b)


60 43

Shortlisting of Consultants for Monitoring & Evaluation of BRTS in PCMC areaIBI Group, Toranto, Canada

230, Richmond Street West, 5th floor, Toronto, Canada

Canada

A

Age of the Firm

10 10 As per Company Profile (Year of Establishment 1974 ‐ 37 years)


10 10 Rs. 988 crs

Number of employees

10 10 2600


B


15 15

1. Smart Transit Vehicle System Evaluation, Canada.2. Green house Gas reduction Benefits of ITS, Canada.3. Indore BRTS.4. Development (M & E) of a smart bus system for the city of Brampton.5. York region Transit System, Canada.6. Traffic Signal study for Attki, Greece.7. Vancouver ‐ Richmond BRT Evaluation Study, Canada.8. Transit Vehicle Detection System Evaluation.9. Comprehensive Public Transport Plan, Saudi Arabia.10. Arterial Roadway Capacity Optimization Study, UK.11. Grandriver Transit Urban Transport Showcase Program ‐ Transit Technology, Canada.12. Metrolink BRT Showcase Program, Canada.




15 51. Indore BRTS.2. Vancouver ‐ Richmond BRT Evaluation Study, Canada.3. Metrolink BRT Showcase Program, Canada.




10 5 1. Development (M & E) of a smart bus system for the city of Brampton.


5 3 Other than Asian Continent.


Main CategorySub

CategoryManpower

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


10 10100 83

10 Mr. Lee Sims (M.Sc Transportation with 47 years experience)


C


Name of Firm



Main CategorySub


Marks per Category

Maximum Marks per

Sub ‐Category

Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


30 20

Main CategorySub

CategoryExperience

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)

B1 (a)

1 10 & above 15

2 5 to 9 10

3 1 to 4 5

4 0 0

B1 (b)



B


15 0 No work related to BRTS



15 15

1. Technical Evaluation Study for Institutional Development & Capacity Building of Projects in the Road Transport Sector at Ganjam ‐ Icchapuram ‐ Km 233 of NH 5.2. Consultnacy Services for Technical Evaluation Study for Institutional Development & Capacity Building of Projects in the Road Transport Sector.3. Study of projects in the Road Sector ‐ Dhankuni to Kolaghat (NH 6), West Bengal.4. Engineering Consultancy Services for the proposed extension of Runway of Jammu Airport.5. Engineering Consultancy Services for the proposed extension of Runway of Khajuraho Airport.6. Engineering Consultancy Services for the proposed extension of Runway of Varansi Airport.7. Updating of the National Transport Plan for the 2008 ‐ 2013 period, Haithi.8. Technical Assistance to the Ministry of Maritime Affairs & Transport of the Republic of Montenegro, Montenegro.9. Assistance to the Ministry of Communications & Transport of Bosnia & Herzegovina to develop a state wide transport sector policy & strategy, Bosnia & Herzegovina.10. Engineering management of the TEO project, France.11. Engineering management of an exclusive bus lane between Parc Grandmont & Trousseau Hospital.12. Assistance to the Client in the project to divert utility networks prior to construction of the first Tramway line in Casablanca, Morocco.



10 10 Average Annual Turnover Rs. 9.65 crs.

Number of employees

10 0 Not mentioned anywhere in Submission

Shortlisting of Consultants for Monitoring & Evaluation of BRTS in PCMC areaMahindra Consulting Engineers Ltd., Chennai

in JV withSafeage Consulting Engineers, France

Mahindra Towers, Ground Floor, No. 17/18, Pattullous Road, Chennai.

Mumbai

A

Age of the Firm

10 10 October 1993 (18 years)



B3 (a)1 5 & above 102 1 to 4 53 0 0

B3 (b)


60 25

Main CategorySub

CategoryManpower

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


10 10100 55

B



C

Transport Planners with qualification of Master's Degree in Transport Planning ‐ experience in undertaking Public Transport studies 10 10 Mr. Emmanuel Djian (PG Urban Transport with 20 years experience)

Experience of undertaking M & E related to Traffic & Transportation ‐






Name of Firm



Main CategorySub


Marks per Category

Maximum Marks per

Sub ‐Category

Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


30 20

Main CategorySub

CategoryExperience

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)

B1 (a)

1 10 & above 15

2 5 to 9 10

3 1 to 4 5

4 0 0

B1 (b)




B3 (a)

1 5 & above 102 1 to 4 53 0 0

B3 (b)


60 30Total Marks Obtained in Category 'B'






15 5

1. Lagos BRT Evaluation, Nigeria.2. Documentation of BRT Experiences, Lagos, Johannasburg, Jakarta, Delhi, Ahmedabad, etc.3. Clean Technology options for BRT Buses in East Africa.4. International BRT Handbook for World Bank.


5 5 In Asian Continents.


B


15 10

1. Promoting Sustainable Transport Solutions in East African Countries.2. Lagos BRT Evaluation, Nigeria.3. Documentation of BRT Experiences, Lagos, Johannasburg, Jakarta, Delhi, Ahmedabad, etc.4. Evaluation of buses with high level of service.5. Clean Technology options for BRT Buses in East Africa.6. International BRT Handbook for World Bank.


10 10 In Asian Continents.

10 0 No details regarding the same in the submission

Number of employees

10 10 Page No. 3 (360 technical Specialist)

Shortlisting of Consultants for Monitoring & Evaluation of BRTS in PCMC areaTransport Research Laboratory (TRL), UK

in JV withIntegrated Transport Planning Ltd. (iTP), UK

Crowthrone House, Nine Mile Road, Wokingham, Berkshire, UK

Cardiff, UK

Age of the Firm

10 10 Certificate of Incorporation (Page No. 36) (29 Dec 1995 ‐ 15 years 6 months)


Main CategorySub

CategoryManpower

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


10 0100 50


C

Transport Planners with qualification of Master's Degree in Transport Planning ‐ experience in undertaking Public Transport studies 10 0 Qualification & Experience not mentioned

Name of Firm



Main CategorySub


Marks per Category

Maximum Marks per

Sub ‐Category

Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


30 30

Main CategorySub

CategoryExperience

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)

B1 (a)

1 10 & above 15

2 5 to 9 10

3 1 to 4 5

4 0 0

B1 (b)




B3 (a)1 5 & above 102 1 to 4 53 0 0

B3 (b)








15 0 1. BRT & Supply Optimization, Germany.




B


15 15

1. Feasibility Study & Preparation of Project Bid Documents for Construction, upgradation & improvement to 2 lane with paved shoulders of SH under SHDP Annuity Project under PPP Scheme, Gujarat 637.2 Kms.2. Operations & Maintenance of Bandra Worli Sea Link, Mumbai.3.Improving execution efficiency of highway project, Bihar.4. Long term Strategic association with PIDB for last 11 years, Punjab.5. Feasibility Study on Integrated Public Transit Systems for the City of Ahmedabad.6. Augsburg: Analysis & Optimization Bus Network, Germany.7. Bandung / Indonesia ‐ Trans Cikapundung MRT line ‐ Viabilty Study, Indonesia.8. Dubai Bus Master Plan, Dubai.9. BRT & Supply Optimization, Germany.10. Feasibility study for Bus Depot in Munich, Germany.



10 10 Average annual turnover Rs. 92.96 crs

Number of employees

10 10 1400 people

Shortlisting of Consultants for Monitoring & Evaluation of BRTS in PCMC areaFeedback Infrastructure Services Pvt. Ltd., Gurgaon

in JV withHamburg Consult, Germany

15th floor, Tower 9B, DLF Cyber city Phase III, Gurgaon

New Delhi

A

Age of the Firm

10 10 1990 (21 years)


Main CategorySub

CategoryManpower

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


10 10100 65


C

Transport Planners with qualification of Master's Degree in Transport Planning ‐ experience in undertaking Public Transport studies 10 10 Mr. R K Bhatnagar (M.Tech Transportation with 30 years experience)

Name of Firm



Main CategorySub


Marks per Category

Maximum Marks per

Sub ‐Category

Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


30 30

Main CategorySub

CategoryExperience

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)

B1 (a)

1 10 & above 15

2 5 to 9 10

3 1 to 4 5

4 0 0

B1 (b)




B

Shortlisting of Consultants for Monitoring & Evaluation of BRTS in PCMC areaSRIE Infrastructure Finance Ltd., New Delhi


D‐2, Southern Park, Saket Palace, Saket, New Delhi.

Kolkata

A

Age of the Firm

10 10 1989 ‐ 22 years


10 10 Rs. 874 crs.

Number of employees

10 10 776 employees



15 15

1. Consultancy Services for Preparation of DPR for 2 BRTS Corridors sanctioned under JNNURM in Vishakhapatanam.2. Preparation of Strategic Road Network Master Plan for UP.3. Comprehensive Mobility Plan for Vadodara.4. DPR for Lucknow MRTS.5. Light Rail Project, Kolkatta.6. MRTS project in Colombo, Srilanka.7. Development of non tollable Inner Ring Road at Agra under IURP on DBFOT basis, UP.8. Preparation of Techno ‐ Economic Feasibility cum Demand Assessment Study of Multi Facility International Bus Terminal in Jaipur.9. Financial Assistance to the Road Projects Satna‐Umaria of Rewa Tollway Pvt. Ltd., MP.10. Financial Assistance to the Road Projects NH 5 & NH 9 of Swarna Tollway Pvt. Ltd., AP.11. Preparation of DPR for Development of Internal Roads, Arunachal Pradesh.12. Hyderabad Metro (Urban Transport) project trackway design advisory.




15 01. Consultancy Services for Preparation of DPR for 2 BRTS Corridors sanctioned under JNNURM in Vishakhapatanam.



B3 (a)1 5 & above 102 1 to 4 53 0 0

B3 (b)


60 30

Main CategorySub

CategoryManpower

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


10 10100 70

B

10 Mr. T R Rao (Masters in Planning specilaization Transport Planning with 27 years experience)







C




Member

Main CategorySub


Marks per Category

Maximum Marks per

Sub ‐Category

Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


30 30

Main CategorySub

CategoryExperience

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)

B1 (a)

1 10 & above 152 5 to 9 103 1 to 4 54 0 0

B1 (b)




B3 (a)1 5 & above 102 1 to 4 53 0 0

B3 (b)


60 0

Shortlisting of Consultants for Monitoring & Evaluation of BRTS in PCMC areaWapcos Limited, Gandhinagar

703‐704, 7th floor, Abhishek Building, Sector ‐ 11, Gandhinagar

New Delhi

A

Age of the Firm

10 10 Certificate of Incorporation (26th June 1969 ‐ 42 years)


10 10 Rs. 222.33 crs.

Number of employees

10 10 700


B


15 0 No work related to Public Transport Studies


10 0 No work related to Public Transport Studies










Main CategorySub

CategoryManpower

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


10 5100 35

5 No CV with Master's in Transport planning with 15 years experience


C


Name of Firm



Main CategorySub


Marks per Category

Maximum Marks per

Sub ‐Category

Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


30 30

Main CategorySub

CategoryExperience

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)

B1 (a)

1 10 & above 15

2 5 to 9 10

3 1 to 4 5

4 0 0

B



15 15

1. Consultancy Services to identify black spots & design counter measures on the core state road network, India.2. Highway Financing Baseline Study: Future Financing of the National & State Highway in India.3. Development of Long term Plan for Expressways in India.4. Private Sector Participation in Expressway financing, Construction & Operation in India.5. Preparation of detailed design & Engineering report for BRTS at Nashik.6. Detailed Design & Engineering Report for BRTS at Hyderabad.7. Bus Rapid Transport for Jaipur City.8. Detailed Design & Engineering Report for BRTS at Vijaywada.9. Traffic Study for Metro Rail Connection to Kolkata Airport.10. Feasibility Study & Technical Assistance for MRTS for Nairobi Metropolitan Region, Nairobi.11. Consultancy Services for study on integrated public transit system for city of surat.12. Undertaking Road Surveys for M & E of Project Indicators, Punjab.13. Study for reforms in Passenger Road Transport Sector in UP through PPP.14. Study & Recommendations for improving STU's services in West Bengal.15. Consultancy Services for Project preparatory studies for Package I (Phase I), Feasibility, Environmental & Social Studies, Punjab.16. Comprehensive Study of Integrated Traffic Dispersal System for PCMC & PMC, Pune.17. Updation of Detailed Feasibility Report of Andheri ‐ Ghatkopar Alignment, Mumbai.18. Evaluation & Impact Analysis of Area Traffic Control Systems in Pune.19. Preparation of Detailed Project Report for the proposed MRTS for Thane city on BOT basis.20. Detailed Traffic Study & preparation of guideline plan for improving traffic condition in central zone of thane city.21. Preparation of Master Plan for Road Netwok improvement & Traffic Dispersal in Greater Mumbai.22. Consultancy services for Techno economic feasibility study for sky bus metro in mumbai.23. Feasibility Study for Mumbai Trans Harbour Link, Mumbai.24. Preparation of Comprehensive Mobility Plan for Amritsar and Pathankot city under Package I.25. Comprehensive Traffic Study for Kurnool Town, AP.26. Comprehensive Traffic Study for Tirupati Town, AP.27. Comprehensive Traffic Study for Indore, MP.28. Short Term Traffic & Transportation Improvement plan for the city of Jamnagar.29. Short Term Traffic & Transportation Improvement plan for the city of Rajkot.30. Comprehensive Traffic Study for Thiruanantapuram, Kerala.31. Comprehensive Traffic & Transportation Study for Jabalpur, MP.32.Comprehensive Traffic & Transportation Study for Vijaywada, AP.

10 10 Average Annual Turn Over Rs. 192 crs.

Number of employees

10 10 2000+

Shortlisting of Consultants for Monitoring & Evaluation of BRTS in PCMC area

Consulting Engineering Services (India) Private Limited, New Delhi

57, 5th floor, Nehru Palace, New Delhi

New Delhi

A

Age of the Firm

10 10 Established in 1969 (41 years)


B1 (b)




B3 (a)1 5 & above 102 1 to 4 53 0 0

B3 (b)


60 45

Main CategorySub

CategoryManpower

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


10 10100 85

B


In India, Asian Continent.


C

Transport Planners with qualification of Master's Degree in Transport Planning ‐ experience in undertaking Public Transport studies 10 10 Mr. C H Hanumantha Rao (M.Sc Transportation Engg. With 41 years experience)


10 5 1. Undertaking Road Surveys for M & E of Project Indicators, Punjab.




15 5

1. Preparation of detailed design & Engineering report for BRTS at Nashik.2. Detailed Design & Engineering Report for BRTS at Hyderabad.3. Bus Rapid Transport for Jaipur City.4. Detailed Design & Engineering Report for BRTS at Vijaywada.


5 5





Member

Main CategorySub


Marks per Category

Maximum Marks per

Sub ‐Category

Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


30 20

Main CategorySub

CategoryExperience

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)

B1 (a)

1 10 & above 152 5 to 9 103 1 to 4 54 0 0

B1 (b)




B3 (a)1 5 & above 102 1 to 4 53 0 0

B3 (b)












B


15 0 No work related to Public Transport


10 0 No work related to Public Transport

10 10 5 crs. As per Letter of Transmittal

Number of employees


Shortlisting of Consultants for Monitoring & Evaluation of BRTS in PCMC areaSungrace Engineering Projects Pvt. Ltd., Pune

Survey No. 19, H. No. (6+7)/5, Bavdhan, Khurd, Pune

Mumbai

A

Age of the Firm

10 10 (6th December 1990 ‐ 20 years 6 months)


Main CategorySub

CategoryManpower

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


10 0100 20


C

Transport Planners with qualification of Master's Degree in Transport Planning ‐ experience in undertaking Public Transport studies 10 0

No CV with Master's in Transport planning with 15 years experience

Name of Firm



Main CategorySub


Marks per Category

Maximum Marks per

Sub ‐Category

Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


30 20

Main CategorySub

CategoryExperience

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)

B1 (a)

1 10 & above 15

2 5 to 9 10

3 1 to 4 5

4 0 0

B1 (b)


B2 (a)

1 10 & above 15

2 5 to 9 10

3 2 to 4 5


B3 (a)1 5 & above 102 1 to 4 53 0 0

B

Shortlisting of Consultants for Monitoring & Evaluation of BRTS in PCMC areaECORYS Netherland BV, Netherlands

in JV with ICRA Management Consulting Services Ltd., Noida & ARUP

Watermanweg 44, 3067 GG Rotterdam, Netherlands

Netherlands

A

Age of the Firm

10 10 Company Profile (80 years)


10 0 Not specified anywhere in the submission

Number of employees

10 10 600



15 15

1. Strategic Plan for regeneration of all interchange nodes throughout province, South Africa.2. Assessment of Bus Network Performance, England.3. Planning & Assessment of Bus routes, Belfast.4. Planning & Assessment of BRTS, Swansea.5. Route Feasibility Studies for proposed BRT route connecting the DART rail & Luas Tram lines, South Easr Dublin.6. Route Development & Design for Docklands Rapid Transport (DRT) ‐ bus based public transport system, Dublin.7. Development of Master plan for a new community in Ardaun, Galway.8. South Yorshire BRT9. Consultancy Services for Comprehensive Traffic & Transportation Plan for Hubli Dharwad City in Karnataka.10. Consultancy Services for Comprehensive Traffic & Transportation Plan for Mysore City in Karnataka.11. Consultancy Services for Comprehensive Traffic & Transportation Plan for Ujjain, MP.




15 10

1. Assessment of Bus Network Performance, England.2. Planning & Assessment of Bus routes, Belfast.3. Planning & Assessment of BRTS, Swansea.4. Route Feasibility Studies for proposed BRT route connecting the DART rail & Luas Tram lines, South Easr Dublin.5. South Yorshire BRT.





B3 (b)


60 38

Main CategorySub

CategoryManpower

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


10 10100 68

B

10 Dr. Pradeep Kumar Sarkar (M.Sc in Transport Engineering with 34 years experience)





C


Name of Firm



Main CategorySub


Marks per Category

Maximum Marks per

Sub ‐Category

Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


30 15

Main CategorySub

CategoryExperience

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)

B1 (a)

1 10 & above 15

2 5 to 9 10

3 1 to 4 5

4 0 0

B1 (b)




B3 (a)

1 5 & above 102 1 to 4 53 0 0

B

Shortlisting of Consultants for Monitoring & Evaluation of BRTS in PCMC areaSutra Consulting Pvt. Ltd, Orrisa

in JV withCentre for Management & Social Research (CSMR), Hyderabad

N2/139, Nayapalli, IRC Village, Bhubaneshwar, Orrisa

Cuttack, Orrissa

A

Age of the Firm

10 10 Certificate of Incorporation (12th April 2000 ‐ 11 years 2 months)


10 5 As per Balance Sheets (Rs. 2.27 crs)

Number of employees




15 10

1. Study of public transport users in Orissa.2. Design & Pilot Study of public transport users in Andhra Pradesh.3. M & E of Resettlement & Rehabilitation Program of Andhrapradhesh State Highway Project, World Bank.4. Terminal Evaluation of Resettlement & Rehabilitation program,, Kerala State Transport Project.5. Independent End Term Evaluation Action Plan under UP State Project Roads.6. Evaluation & Settlement program of Mizoram State Roads Project.7. Mid Term Evaluation of Resettlement & Rehabilitation program of UP State Roads Projects.8. M & E of Resettlement & Rehabilitation program of AP State Highways Project.


10 10 In Asian Continent.






10 5

1. M & E of Resettlement & Rehabilitation Program of Andhrapradhesh State Highway Project, World Bank.2. M & E of Resettlement & Rehabilitation program of AP State Highways Project.

B3 (b)


60 30

Main CategorySub

CategoryManpower

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


10 0100 45

B

0 No CV with Master's in Transport Planning with 15 years experience


5 5 in India, Asian Continent.



C




Member

Main CategorySub


Marks per Category

Maximum Marks per

Sub ‐Category

Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


30 10

Main CategorySub

CategoryExperience

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)

B1 (a)

1 10 & above 152 5 to 9 103 1 to 4 54 0 0

B1 (b)


B2 (a)

1 10 & above 15

2 5 to 9 10

3 2 to 4 5


B3 (a)

1 5 & above 102 1 to 4 53 0 0

B3 (b)




10 0 No work in M & E


5 0 No work in M & E


15 0 No Work in BRTS


5 0 No Work in BRTS


B


15 5

1. Assistance in preparation of Urban Transport Comnprhensive Mobility Plan for Varanasi.2. Feasibility Study for City Bus Service in Gurgaon.3. Study of Investment Opportunities in Highways/Road Sector in India.4. Kolhapur City Integrated Road Developement Project.


10 10 In Asian Continent

10 0 No details regarding the same in the submission

Number of employees

10 10 1,44,000 employees and 750 offices all over the world

Shortlisting of Consultants for Monitoring & Evaluation of BRTS in PCMC areaErnst & Young Private Limited, Hyderabad

The Oval Office, 18, iLabs Centre, Hi‐tech City, Madhpur, Hyderabad

Not mentioned

A

Age of the Firm

10 0 Registration of the firm not mentioned anywhere in the submission


Main CategorySub

CategoryManpower

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


10 0100 25


C

Transport Planners with qualification of Master's Degree in Transport Planning ‐ experience in undertaking Public Transport studies 10 0 No person with Master's of Transport Planning with 10 years experience

Name of Firm



Main CategorySub


Marks per Category

Maximum Marks per

Sub ‐Category

Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


30 10

Main CategorySub

CategoryExperience

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)

B1 (a)

1 10 & above 15

2 5 to 9 10

3 1 to 4 5

4 0 0

B1 (b)


B2 (a)

1 10 & above 15

2 5 to 9 10

3 2 to 4 5

4 1 & below 0

B

Shortlisting of Consultants for Monitoring & Evaluation of BRTS in PCMC areaWipro Consulting Services, Andheri, Mumbai

In JV with Innovative Transport Solutions Pvt. Ltd., Delhi

Velocity Building, Logitech Park, Sakinaka, Andheri Kurla Road, Andheri (E)

Not Mentioned

A

Age of the Firm

10 10 Company Profile (25 years)



Number of employees




15 15

1. Case Studies for NMT in India.2. Traffic Operations Study at Lothian Intersection, S P Mukherjee Marg, Delhi.3. Techno Feasibility Study for Monorail in Patna.4. Assessment of the Transport in India.5. Traffic & Transport Plan for MCD Civic Centre Area, Delhi.6. Low Carbon Transport in India.7. Comprehensive Mobility Plan of Patna.8. Traffic & Transit assignment of GIFT city, Gujrat.9. Feasibility for BRTS on East West Corridor in Delhi.10. Traffic Study for Humayun Tomb, Delhi.11. DPR for BRTS, Patna.12. Prefeasibility Study for BRTS, Dhaka.13. Planning & Redeveloping of pedestrian and vehicular spaces around the various terminals at IGI, Delhi.14. BRTS Design Specifications, Delhi15. DPR for BRTS Design, Kolkatta.16. BRTS Design, Guwahati.17. BRTS Design, Solapur & Satara Road.18. BRTS for Ring Road, Rajkot.




15 10

1. Feasibility for BRTS on East West Corridor in Delhi.2. DPR for BRTS, Patna.3. Prefeasibility Study for BRTS, Dhaka.4. BRTS Design Specifications, Delhi5. DPR for BRTS Design, Kolkatta.6. BRTS Design, Guwahati.7. BRTS Design, Solapur & Satara Road.8. BRTS for Ring Road, Rajkot.


B3 (a)1 5 & above 102 1 to 4 53 0 0

B3 (b)


60 40

Main CategorySub

CategoryManpower

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


10 10100 60

B



10 Dr. Anvita Arora (Ph.D Transport Planning with 12 years experience)







C


Name of Firm



Main CategorySub


Marks per Category

Maximum Marks per

Sub ‐Category

Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


30 20

Main CategorySub

CategoryExperience

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)

B1 (a)

1 10 & above 15

2 5 to 9 10

3 1 to 4 5

4 0 0

B1 (b)




B3 (a)1 5 & above 102 1 to 4 53 0 0

B




15 51. Assistance in assessing, designing, evaluating & developing BRT corridor in selected city within India.2. Public Transport Planning, demand forecasting and Project Managment of Shenzhen BRT for Metro line 3, China.3. Public Transport Improvement & BRT Study for Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam.


5 5 In Asian Cointinent.



15 15

1. Assistance in assessing, designing, evaluating & developing BRT corridor in selected city within India.2. Structuring, Evaluation & Feasibility of proposed Hyderabad Multimodal Transportation system.3. Public Transport Planning, demand forecasting and Project Managment of Shenzhen BRT for Metro line 3, China.4. Evaluation of future Institutional Strategy & Options for Integrated Urban Transport Project in Kerala.5. Public Light Bus Review Study, hongkong.6. Restructuring of Bus network, Hongkong Island.7. Study for Integrated Ticketing of different public transport operators in Kuala Lumpur.8. Public Transport Integration Project for Transit link, Singapore.9. Restructuring of Bus Services for the Opening of the North East Line, Singapore.10. Bangkok Transit System Bus Integration Proiject, Thailand.11. Public Transport Improvement & BRT Study for Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam.12. Congestion Analysis of Transport System in London.


10 10 In Asian Cointinent.

10 10 mentioned in company profile ($26.1 Billions)

Number of employees

10 10 6000 employees in India

Shortlisting of Consultants for Monitoring & Evaluation of BRTS in PCMC areaDeloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Private Ltd, Gurgaon, Haryana

In JV withMVA Asia Limited, CBD, Belapur

Building 10, Tower B, 7th floor, DLF Cyber City, Gurgaon, Haryana

Mumbai

A

Age of the Firm

10 0 Not Mentioned in Company Profile or anywhere in submission


B3 (b)


60 35

Main CategorySub

CategoryManpower

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


10 10100 65

B



C

Transport Planners with qualification of Master's Degree in Transport Planning ‐ experience in undertaking Public Transport studies 10 10 Mr. Terence Bowker ‐ M.Sc Transportation Engg with 44 years experience (Page No. 69)





Member

Main CategorySub


Marks per Category

Maximum Marks per

Sub ‐Category

Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


30 30

Main CategorySub

CategoryExperience

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)

B1 (a)

1 10 & above 152 5 to 9 103 1 to 4 54 0 0

B1 (b)




B3 (a)1 5 & above 102 1 to 4 53 0 0

B3 (b)












B


15 5

1. Impact Assessment of PMGSY in Karnataka, UP, MP, Rajasthan & West Bengal.2. Assessing the financial impact of student passes issued by Bangalore Metropolitan Transport Corporation


10 10 In Asian Continent

10 10 Rs. 133.67 crs.

Number of employees

10 10 403 permanent staff

Shortlisting of Consultants for Monitoring & Evaluation of BRTS in PCMC areaTNS India Private Limited, Gurgaon

7th & 8th Floor, Block 4B, DLF Corporate Park, DLF City Phase III, Mehrauli Gurgaon Road, Gurgaon, Haryana

Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad

A

Age of the Firm

10 10Fresh Certificate of Incorporation (1st October 1993

17 years 8 months)


Main CategorySub

CategoryManpower

Marks per Category


Marks Obtained

Remarks (if any)


10 0100 45


C

Transport Planners with qualification of Master's Degree in Transport Planning ‐ experience in undertaking Public Transport studies 10 0

No CV with Master's in Transport planning with 10 years experience