r-cube.ritsumei.ac.jpr-cube.ritsumei.ac.jp/repo/repository/rcube/2694/dmuch5_02.pdf · in this...

6
Vol. 520117 Seismic Performance Evaluation of Yamada’s House Located in Arimatsu District, Nagoya City 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Kyosuke Mukaibo, Megumi Kitayama, Yosuke Fujiki, Kazuhiro Hirao, Ryosuke Kito, Wakako Morikami and Naohiko Yamamoto 1 525-8577 1-1-1 Assistant Professor, Dept. of Architecture and Urban Design, Ritsumeikan University 2 630-8506 Graduate Student, Graduate School of Humanities and Sciences, Nara Women’s University 3 616-8362 1 Associate Professor, Dept. of Design, Kyoto Saga University of Arts 4 525-8577 1-1-1 Professor, Dept. of Architecture and Urban Design, Ritsumeikan University 5 525-8577 1-1-1 Student, Dept. of Architecture and Urban Design, Ritsumeikan University 6 430-7725 111-2 SEKISUI HEIM Tokai Co., Ltd 7 630-8506 Associate Professor, Dept. of Residential Environment And Design, Nara Women’s University In this paper, the seismic performance of Yamada’s house located in Arimatsu district, Nagoya city is evaluated based on the measurement survey. The target house was built about 220 years ago, and experienced several minor changes of the plan. We investigated the arrangement of the seismic resisting walls, and calculated the weight of the whole building. In the first floor, many of the walls are positioned both sides of the building in the transverse direction, and there are few in the longitudinal direction. By a spectral response analysis, it was found that the seismic performance in the longitudinal direction may be insufficient. Keywords : Traditional timber building, Arimatsu district, Seismic performance evaluation, Response analysis 23491 1) -9-

Upload: voanh

Post on 14-Aug-2019

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

1

������� Vol. 5�2011 7�� ��

�������� ���������

Seismic Performance Evaluation of Yamada’s House Located in Arimatsu District, Nagoya City

����1������2�����3�� !"4�#$%&5�'(!)*6��+,-7 Kyosuke Mukaibo, Megumi Kitayama, Yosuke Fujiki, Kazuhiro Hirao,

Ryosuke Kito, Wakako Morikami and Naohiko Yamamoto

1./012345 67289:��;<=>2?�@525-8577 ABCDE�FGH1-1-1� Assistant Professor, Dept. of Architecture and Urban Design, Ritsumeikan University

2I%J*1212KLMNOPQ5 RSTUV?�@630-8506 I%CI%��WXHY� Graduate Student, Graduate School of Humanities and Sciences, Nara Women’s University

3Z�[\]^12_4`5 ]^28;<=>2?�@616-8362 Z�aZ��bZc[\deY1� Associate Professor, Dept. of Design, Kyoto Saga University of Arts

4./0124`5 67289:��;<=>2?�@525-8577 ABCDE�FGH1-1-1� Professor, Dept. of Architecture and Urban Design, Ritsumeikan University

5./01228f5 67289:��;<=>2?�@525-8577 ABCDE�FGH1-1-1� Student, Dept. of Architecture and Urban Design, Ritsumeikan University

6ghi=j=kHlmnop�@430-7725 qrCst�ucvXY111-2� SEKISUI HEIM Tokai Co., Ltd

7I%J*12_4`5 fwxy28zxy2?�@630-8506 I%��WXHY� Associate Professor, Dept. of Residential Environment And Design, Nara Women’s University

In this paper, the seismic performance of Yamada’s house located in Arimatsu district, Nagoya city is evaluated based on the measurement survey. The target house was built about 220 years ago, and experienced several minor changes of the plan. We investigated the arrangement of the seismic resisting walls, and calculated the weight of the whole building. In the first floor, many of the walls are positioned both sides of the building in the transverse direction, and there are few in the longitudinal direction. By a spectral response analysis, it was found that the seismic performance in the longitudinal direction may be insufficient. Keywords : Traditional timber building, Arimatsu district, Seismic performance evaluation, Response analysis

������

5 �{23 4�|}~��}91��c������9������c���9�c�~�������~������3������������������ ¡¢£�¤¥¦���§�¨©�ª«¬«����

9��­®«¨©�~¯°§±²���9�c~����¨©¢©�³}´�zµ�¶·�¸¹T��³�

��º»¢£�po�¼½~�¥����9���¾¿�ÀÁ�ÂÃÄ¢ÅÆ:¢£�Ç��������

�ÈÉ~ʧ�ËËÌ�ª ÍHlÎÏ©��Ð�ÑÒË}Ì��ÓÔCÕÖX�×c®t´Ø®tÙÚÒÛÜ��Ù¥��}ÝÞ¬

±1ßO~¬à¨áâ�ãä}¯C��Tåµæçè����Tåµæé袣­ê�Ò«¨���9

����䫨©�ª«¬«�®t�¿Ò«¨´���9�c~´����¨ë±²��������ìí

�Ç�«¨©�1)ªî�ïð~ñ«¨�zµ¦ò}Ì�Ø®t|óôõ¥�oÚ´�����|óôõ¥ö

Ç÷øÒÒ¯~�����~�àùwú­�û¨©�Òîü}Ì�ª 5 ýþ}�î�«ù���������~�«¨´�������9�����������Ò�6�

-9-

2

¢��� ­�õîÒ���¢©ª«¬«����c~ëà�9���­ñ�Ò«ù�����~����

���;��´�±�¢©ª�î}�+UV}´�®t�c��¯Ö©�����z �ÑÒË}Ì��!

æz ����"#$­%&~'ô©¨��îÒ}����c����9������­()*�ù��'

+;��Ò«¨�*�îÒ­,�Ò*�ª 5 �!æz ´�ÍHlÎ�*�-.~/Á«�0ç��19�234¢£�®t����56­7*µæ

}Ì�ªè8~��Ò9�3 �:;1791 ��9�}Ì�îÒ���}<±¬~��¨©�ªÙ¥��=æÒ«¨9����N~>®?�ì§û¨@AÒ¢¥��{15 ¬±´Bz?�©¢©CD�E©¨©�ªFGH�I´�@A�J�KLMv}N§�¨©���0O��P8���¿´QÒR£���¢�S~�

�¯��7û¨©��0é�ª�����UV�ÕÖX�~����´�T�56�÷�{~°*�¯�}

Ì¥��!æz ����UV�®t�c������9:�­WX«Y�¯�¬£�¬Z<}Ì�ªù[

«�9: W¬±\â¨�®t�c~ëà��¯Ö©���UV­�8~]*¯�Ò\â�ª

�������

��

0ç5 �!æz ÒÍHlÎ�/Á5 5 5 5 5 5 5 0O �.T�(ý8´KLMv}N§�¨©�)

0é5 ÷P�^*5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 0_ `a¥b�cd

������� !

ñ�9:���ó�-.�e=fë�ghi8c­jõkX­lmñ�Ò*�ª%&0në�gop¬±�

`a¥b��b�qb�r�b�vb�st�tbÒ©ûù�ub�ÃÁ­()«�bv��wb�x©­

y�«ù�0_�ª¢ë�%&}´zS{S�890|950mmQ}�ܱË~�Ìûù���&��¯\â±��ù��910mms���t}���â�ÒÒ¯~�%&{S­����¨��¤ûùªy�«ù�ub�ÃÁ­0�~]*ª0u�HW´r�b�SW´qb�����~Eõ��´PS¸�(mm)­5�«¨©�ª|ù��ub��ä�n�¨­ñ�Ò«¨X1|X13�Y1|Y11|}�¥Õ�­�û¨©�ª-�þ�­�¥S�H:þ�­àù�Ò*�ª

-10-

3

ç���ub�c�­��Ò��¥Sþ����.~`a¥�b��¢¥�9�P8�U~àù�þ�~

�b�QÒR£�ä«¢©îÒ�c¬�ªýþ�O�}´��þ�Ò¯�Q}~b�ÃÁ��¨ë¥�ç�

~���Ò�~�䫨©�îÒ�c¬�ªî�±´�ZYæ�bÃÁ~�õ�±��UVÒd�«¨ë¥�

Yæ�µæ���Ò¯�â�ª�¦���Ò«¨z ­��Ò�ñ�9:�}´�k�¢÷�¡z~´

150mm�5{�¢Q}���£�z~´105|120mm�3{5c|4{�¢�¯��¤©±�¨©�ªýþ�¥2)~��Ò�ZYæ�B÷�z´100|120mm¢Ò¦§��¨ë¥�k�¢Ff�k­�{*�÷�¡z´ZYæ�¥¯1~¢ �z�¤©±����£�z´ZYæÒ�Q}Ò¢û¨©�ª

"#

"$

"%

"&

"'

"#(

"##

)# )$ )* )+), )## )#%)-)% )& )' )#(

)#$

"*

"-

",

"+

./

01,%(

01#*( 01#*(

01#*(

01&((01&((

01#*(

01&*(

01&((

01&((

01&((

21,((

21,((

01$((

01&((

01#*(

01&*(

01-&(

34536#7$8

34

9:;4

9:;<=4>01?

9:;@4A<=4

BC;ADEFE

01GGG

01GGG21GGG

+#( +#( #%-* #%-* %-&( +#( $,%( %-&( +#(

H

IJK

L;M

)# )$ )* )+), )## )#%)-)% )& )' )#(

)#$

./NO

01$*(21,*(

01$*(21,*(

01$*(21,*(

01$*(21,*(

01#*( 01#*( 01$*( 01$*( 01$*(

01$*(

01$*(01$*(21'%(

01$*(

01$*(

01$*(

01$*(

01$*(

01$*(

01$*(

01$*( 01$*(

01$*(

01$*(

01$*(

21,*(

34

9:;4

9:;<=4>01?

9:;@4A<=4

BC;ADEFE

01GGG

01GGG21GGG

+#( +#( #%-* #%-* %-&( +#( $,%( %-&( +#(

$,%(

&**(

%-&(

+#(

%-&(

#$-%

PQRSTUU

a) ç�5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 b) O�

0� ���¨�ÃÁ

V�WXYZ

©~����"#$~멨��¢ª«¬��}Ì��ñ�9:���­­®�*�ª9:'¯S°�±

²84³ë�g�85³����UV2)~'ô©¨���{�¨�´/�­­Xç�Òë¥~µ�«�O¶}y

�«ù�ubë�g��·n¸�X¹n¸~º»¨�­­®�«ùª¼�½~`´��J~���ä�¾

��ùù��¼½~X¹�´/�­~´½~`®�980N/m2�­¿¤«¨©�ª|ù�%&0n�¥�X¹

Xç5 ´/�­

�n À, ´/�­ÁÂÃÄÅÆ

¼½~ǽ~`®ÈÇX¹n~Ë~È

ÉÊË

ÌX�wX¦ÇX¹n~Ë~È

ÍËË

`a¥b ÊÍË

vb ÎËË

st�tb ÏÐË

ÑÒ ÎËË

ÓÔ ÍÐË

v� ÎÕË

·Ü¥ ÎËË

¸Ö×� ��¤ ÏËË

b

ÑÒ�·

"#"$"%"'"+"#(

$-+(

$$*'

#(*[*

#($[,

0Ø5 �¸ÒX¹ÙÃ

-11-

4

Ùô5.5{ÙÃ��X´2.7{ÙÃÒ«��¸´çÚ�2690mm�2Ú�2258mmÒ«ù�0Ø�ªÛ(�¥�µ�¤��J9��­´�çÚ�291kN�OÚ�378kNÒ¢ûùªçÚ}´�X�90kN�Ò�ub�142kN���­�OÚ}´X¹�283kN�Ò�ub�85kN��1~¢Ü�­Ý�¨©�ª

\�]^_`�

O¶}y�«ù�ub�ÃÁ~'ô©¨�9��¿�Þßu­®�*�ª��ub�Þßu´����

¥3)­'¯Ò«������à^~Ứ�®«ùª'¯Ò«ùâ1820mmã¸�2730mm�´/Ff�k�ÞßuU�­0ä~]*ªr�bë�gqb´�'¯�`bwb¸��900mm}Ì�îÒ¬±�¸~ñ*�b`�¸���~Ứ�£��b´bv�~Ứ�®«ùª¢ë�,å�opø~�¥��ubë�g

�¦´���æ�}Ì�Òçè«�é ìTÌ�©´f�êT~���uë�ø´\Ä«¨©¢©ª|ù�

zìí�zì�îB¢£�ï�8��u´\Ä«¨©¢©��0ä�´/Ff�k�Þßu~´ðñ��¦

�òó¯ô|�¨©�ª

Ë

Î

Å

Í

Ð

Õ

Ï

õ

Ê

É

ÎË

Ë ËöËÎ ËöËÅ ËöËÍ ËöËÐ ËöËÕ ËöËÏ

ì÷¢ÁøùúÆ

ÞßuÁûÂÆ

`b

`bwb

��v�¥

st�tb

0ä5 '¯Ò«ù´/Ff�k�ÞßuU� Û(�¥�®«ù��ub�Þßu­ÚüÒ�þ�üÒ~ý®«ù9��¿�ÞßuU�­0þ��~]

*ª0u�Pmax´�1�u�CB´�1��i����­X*ª©²����¯�`a¥�b�k�¢�u�

¨Ò¢û¨ë¥���£��¨´�����¿�ÞßuU��çÜQ}Û�}Ì�ª|ù�O¶}��ùÒ

ë¥�çÚ~��¨OÚ�`a¥�b�­�©ù��OÚ�þ�1~¢�uÒ¢û¨©�ª

Ë

ÅÕ

ÕË

õÕ

ÎËË

ÎÅÕ

ÎÕË

ÎõÕ

ÅËË

ÅÅÕ

ÅÕË

Ë ËöËÎ ËöËÅ ËöËÍ ËöËÐ ËöËÕ ËöËÏ

ì÷¢ÁøùúÆ

ÞßuÁûÂÆ

9��¿ `a¥b`a¥r�b `a¥qbvb st�tb

Äù��ÎÊÊûÂ

��ËöÅÊ

�¥S

Ë ËöËÎ ËöËÅ ËöËÍ ËöËÐ ËöËÕ ËöËÏ

ì÷¢ÁøùúÆ

9��¿`a¥b`a¥r�b`a¥qbvbst�tb

Äù��ÏõûÂ

��ËöÎË

àù�

0þ5 çÚ�ÞßuU�

-12-

5

Ë

ÅÕ

ÕË

õÕ

ÎËË

ÎÅÕ

ÎÕË

ÎõÕ

ÅËË

ÅÅÕ

ÅÕË

Ë ËöËÎ ËöËÅ ËöËÍ ËöËÐ ËöËÕ ËöËÏ

ì÷¢ÁøùúÆ

ÞßuÁûÂÆ

9��¿

`a¥b`a¥r�b

`a¥qb

vbst�tb

Äù��ÅÅÊûÂ

�¥S

Ë ËöËÎ ËöËÅ ËöËÍ ËöËÐ ËöËÕ ËöËÏ

ì÷¢ÁøùúÆ

9��¿

`a¥b`a¥r�b

`a¥qb

vbst�tb

Äù��ÅÍÅûÂ

àù�

0�5 OÚ�ÞßuU�

çÚ�1�u��nüÒ���­010~]*ªçÚàù�þ�~�nb�QÒR£Â©îÒ¬±�u�£~��¨��~ë©îÒ�çÚ�¥Sþ�}´H:�Tb��u��£­Ý�¨©�îÒ�c¬�ª��i

����´��¥Sþ�}0.28�àù�þ�}0.10Ò¢¥�ZYæ����¢��i����2)��¥S�

0.41�àù��0.15��¥¯��w�õ¢û¨©�ªî�´��ub�ÃÁ�d�«¨©��~ñ«¨�ZYæ~��¨S���õ�9����1~©ù�Ò\â±��ª

Ë

ÎË

ÅË

ÍË

ÐË

ÕË

ÏË

�Î

�Å

�Í

�Ð

�Õ

�Ï

�õ

�Ê

�É

�ÎË

�ÎÎ

�ÎÅ

�ÎÍ

�Î

�Å

�Í

�Ð

�Õ

�Ï

�õ

�Ê

�É

�ÎË

�ÎÎ

�n

ÞßuÁûÂÆ

àù�þ��¥Sþ�

H.Tb :.

Tb

0105 çÚ�1�u��nüÒ���

a�������

5 î�|}�lm}®�«ùÞßuU���­��¸~'ô©¨����u�®~�¥���"#$­��ª

ñ�9:�­ø$¢�®ñOÒ�ºU�­�Ëç� }!~"#«��1á$ì/­%�ù�ó���~ì

÷­cëùª&O'�J��®ñO´��¥S 0.7s�àù� 1.1s }Ìûùª�º��´�&O'�J´0.05 Ò«�(�)*+,t-�­\Ä«ùø$.��º­ì/i/01üÒ~®�«ùªN�*�23��~ñ*�á$J~´�ø$.��º��´ 0.20 Q}|}Å1*�ª4u��ú´��{ 12 9µ5§]1461 6�ýÉ}á$i78etë�g� 1457 6��9Åâ:(²O;�9)­¤©�<=��~ñá*�3��ë�g>���~ñá*�23��Ò«¨©�ª"#ç� }!�á$�­0 11~]*ª0 11~멨�?��"i78etÒ9��¿�ÞßuÒ�@��%��á$�~¢�ª�¥Sþ��3��}

1/168rad�23��} 1/20rad�àù�þ��3��} 1/91rad�23��}@�«Ңûùªî�"#ç� }!�á$­�®s�I~«ù�û¨����ì÷¢Ò«¨Ü¥�ûùAó­XO~]*ª 5 �¥Sþ�ç��á$ì÷¢´�3��} 1/136rad�23��} 1/14rad Ò¢ûùª���<=��ì÷¢´ 1/120rad�>���´9��ì÷�"~�û¨ 1/30~1/15rad Ò���>���­��Bâ�ì÷¢Ò¢û¨©�ªýþ�àù�þ�ç�}´�3��} 1/64rad�23��}´á$��%|±²�CD*�Aó

-13-

6

Ò¢ûùªU~àù�þ�}���"�ZE«¨©�Ò�â�ª ©|��­ë��þFÒ«¨�X¹�½~`­GH*�Ò\â�Ò��­�# 100kNë���á$ì÷¢

¯��w�õ¢�����}¯àù�þ�}´<=���>���­Bâ�á$­]«¨©��Xé�ª«

ù�û¨�àù�þ�����"­�*�ù�~´����¨�Æì�?�}Ì�îÒ�c¬�ª

Ë

ÅÕ

ÕË

õÕ

ÎËË

ÎÅÕ

ÎÕË

ÎõÕ

ÅËË

ÅÅÕ

ÅÕË

Ë ËöËÕ ËöÎ ËöÎÕ ËöÅ ËöÅÕ

ì/ÁÄÆ

xRèuÁûÂÆ

9��¿�Þßu

?��"i78et�3�

?��"i78et�23�

ÎÃÎÏÊøùú

ÎÃÅËøùú

�¥S

Ë ËöËÕ ËöÎ ËöÎÕ ËöÅ ËöÅÕ

ì/ÁÄÆ

9��¿�Þßu

?��"i78et�3�

?��"i78et�23�

ÎÃÉÎøùú

àù�

0 115 "#ç� }!�á$ XO5 ���á$ì÷¢5 5 5 5 5 5 Xé5 ���á$ì÷¢�½~`«ҫù���

b� cb�

�d #7$+' #7$%%

�d #7#%- #7#&

�d #7-'* efghi

�d #7-& efghi

jklmnopqr

L;Mst

IJKst

5 5 5 5

b� cb�

�d #7%-+m #7$*(m

�d #7#-(m #7#-m

�d #7,#%m efghi

�d #7-'m efghi

jklmnopqr

L;Mst

IJKst

u�vw�

5 %&��~'ô~��!æz ����¨­y�«����"#$­�ûùªZYæ~d�«ù�ub�

ÃÁÒ¢û¨ë¥�çÚàù�þ�~�nb�QÒR£Â©îÒ¬±�u�£~��¨��~ë©îÒ��

¥Sþ�}´��.�Tb��u��£­Ý�¨©�îÒ�c¬ûùª��i����´��¥S}0.28�àù�}0.10}Ìûùª���u�®~�����"#$�Aó�àù�þ�}���"�ZE«¨©�îÒ��I��ùªù[«�,å���JK~멨´��¦�b¢£~L/�¢êT´�±�²����æ

�¢CD}Ì�Òçè���ª +UV}Y±�ùÔ�´�®t�c~ëà��¯Ö© W�9:�����­#$*�(}���~´�

¤M"Ò\â�ªNN����c�9:�����UV~°*�OP�¢��­%°*�îÒ}��c�¿

�����#$~QR¨©õîÒ¯M"Ò\â�ª xyz+UV´8?25?2UVST3�~��UVØ�U��VWX­w¤«ù���BzT�Y����~°*�UVÚ'9UV�C��{21 }|�{23 }�UVWX�������g~�Z.12[\�UV'9÷{]�^�ØT_�­`Ò«ù�V��­�a�b¬±c�ù��2^UVd�Ú�UVWX�ef%ý�~�¥�§�ù

¯�}Ì�ª|ù�%&��~gu«¨h©ù>®?ë�g°�?�þ�~i5­X*�ª {|}~m1) ����Q¬: ���BzT�Y����Ò�VWX�jf~°*�UV ��ç|�, k+9:2o1o2^lmno���p�, pp. 701-710, 2010, 9.

2) q!r, s�tu, v!wx, wyz{|: ZYæ����"#$Ò��T}µ�S, k+9:2o��!�, No. 616, pp. 179-155, 2007, 7.

3) ���¦�S9����µ�~���t����o: ���S­f¬*����µ�~���t, 2]��p, 2004, 3.

-14-