morris county sheriff's office and morris county parks police partial consolidation feasibility...
TRANSCRIPT
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 1/38
MORRIS COUNTY SHERIFF’S OFFICE
AND
MORRIS COUNTY PARKS POLICE
PARTIAL CONSOLIDATION FEASIBILITY STUDY
March 2013
The Police Executive Research Forum
1120 Connecticut Avenue NW, Suite 930
Washington, DC 20036
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 2/38
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION .............................................................................................................. 3
METHODOLOGY....................................................................................................................3
CURRENT CONTEXT ...................................................................................................... 4
MORRIS COUNTY SHERIFF’S OFFICE....................................................................................4
MORRIS COUNTY PARK POLICE.........................................................................................16
CONCEPT OF OPERATIONS ....................................................................................... 23
LABOR ISSUES...................................................................................................................23
PAY AND BENEFITS............................................................................................................24
OPERATIONAL ISSUES........................................................................................................25
FACILITIES.........................................................................................................................26
ORGANIZATIONAL DESIGN..................................................................................................26
STAFFING AND COST OF A CONSOLIDATED DEPARTMENT...................................................27
COST COMPARISON WITH CURRENT CONTEXT....................................................................28
IMPLEMENTATION COSTS....................................................................................................29
COST.................................................................................................................................31REDUCTION OF DUPLICATION OF SERVICES........................................................................31
ORGANIZATIONAL EFFICIENCY............................................................................................31
FACILITIES.........................................................................................................................31
CONCLUSION ............................................................................................................... 32
FURTHER CONSIDERATIONS ..................................................................................... 32
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 3/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
Introduction
Morris County, New Jersey has retained the Police Executive Research Forum (PERF) to
study the feasibility of consolidating the Morris County Sheriff’s Office (MCSO) Special
Service Division into the Morris County Park Police (MCPP). The intent of theassessment is to provide Morris County officials with sufficient data to determine
whether such a consolidation is feasible and/or desirable.1
This report focuses on a wide range of issues that have an impact on the feasibility of
such an endeavor, including operational, organizational, cost, and human resource issues.
These issues in this report are presented as a comparison between the current context and
a concept of operation for a consolidated department. Recommendations will be based
on what is believed to be the best outcome for Morris County, considering all the factorsexamined. The consolidation of law enforcement agencies is a complex processes, and
this report seeks to reduce the complexity to clear, actionable recommendations.
Methodology
To carry out his project, PERF applied a methodology that included interviews with
elected officials and Morris County staff members of the MCSO, and MCPP staff.
Observation of operations, data analysis and a review of internal and internet documents
were also conducted. Secondary interviews and observations were conducted to clarify
and expand on information gathered in the early phases of the study.
The report consists of the following top level sections:
• Current Context
• Morris County Sheriff’s Office
• Morris County Park Police
• Concept of Operations for a Consolidated Department
•Findings
• Conclusions
1 There have been three prior studies regarding the potential consolidation, the first in 1984 and the latest in
2011. The first study recommended only changes to how the park police do business. The 2011 report
recommended merging the Sheriff’s non-mandated duties into the Park Police. This report also contained
an optional approach, where the Park Police were eliminated, and their responsibilities were assumed by
the Sheriff. Many issues described in these reports are relevant today and are discussed here.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 3
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 4/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
Current Context
Current context, sometimes termed as “as-is” or the current environment, describes how
the MCSO Special Service Division and the MCPP currently do business. Current
conditions describe the organizational structure of the agencies, budgets, operational
strategies and human resources practices. This information will be presented for each
Department, to include both overview and detail level information. A description of the
Morris County Sheriff’s Office follows.
Morris County Sheriff’s Office
The Morris County Sheriffs Office provides courthouse security, transports inmates
admitted or sentenced to other county or state institutions, serves process papers and
domestic violence temporary restraining orders, and executes foreclosures. These duties
are the constitutional responsibilities of the elected Sheriff.
In addition to the constitutional responsibilities, the Sheriffs Office operates a number of
specialized units that are part of the Special Services Division. The following diagram
depicts the 2013 table of organization for the Special Services Division.
Since Morris County is made up of 39 incorporated areas that provide for their own
police services, The MCSO has no road patrol duties, and County elected officials have
been reluctant to expand the Sheriff’s responsibilities to include patrol duties. The
Special Services Division provides support and augments municipal, county, state, and
federal law enforcement agencies. Any of these entities may call for the services of the
Special Services Division. There is no triaging or qualifying criterion for these requests,
thus, most of the Special Services Division workload is driven by requests made by
outside agencies.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 4
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 5/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
The units that make up the Special Services Division include a crime scene unit, forensic
and photo labs, K-9 unit, bomb squad, an emergency response team and evidence unit.
Each of these units is described below.
Forensic/Photo Labs
The forensic and photo labs provide evidence processing for local, county, state, and
federal law enforcement agencies operating within Morris County. Some of the many
services it provides include developing and printing photographic film, video
enhancement and duplicating, fingerprint development and comparison, ballistics, tool
mark comparison, handwriting analysis and serial number restoration. The
forensics/photo lab unit operates in an older facility; however, their equipment, tools and
techniques are state of the art. A new facility for the forensics and photo lab is being
constructed at this time.
Emergency Services - K-9Unit/Bomb Squad
This unit is a specialized team of sheriff’s officers who use highly trained dogs to
perform services such as search and rescue operations, narcotics and arson detection and
fugitive tracking. At present, there are 8 handlers working in the K9 unit, with
responsibility for 17 canines. Each handler handles more than one canine, as some of the
canines are trained for specific conditions. Members of the unit work either 8AM to 4
PM or 8PM to 3AM Monday through Friday. The unit is subject to call out when the
need arises. When there is no activity requiring their special service, members of the unit
conduct training and other activities supporting the operation. The canine unit works out
of an older, stand-alone facility that includes both office space and kennels.
This unit also responds to explosive emergencies for purposes of bomb detection and
disposal. The members of the Emergency Services unit make up the core of the
departments emergency response team.
Crime Scene Unit (CIS)
This unit provides personnel for a range of investigative procedures including crime
scene processing, evidence collection and preservation, fingerprint analysis. Personnel
assigned to CIS also operate the department’s crime lab. The unit responds to crime
scenes in Morris County when requested. The Crime Scene Unit works primarily a day
shift, Monday through Friday. The unit is subject to frequent call outs. On major cases,
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 5
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 6/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
such as homicides, the staff of the CIS unit may be augmented by warrant squad
personnel.
The CIS Unit documents autopsies that are conducted in relation to potential criminal
matters. They will also assist the medical examiner by providing photographicdocumentation in autopsies not related to criminal matters.
Central Avenue Complex
The name of this unit refers to a physical location; however it is the evidence section of
the department, responsible for the management and storage of evidence and property.
The facility was recently remodeled.
Scheduling
The following tables provide the schedules worked by the three units in the Special
Services Division.
Criminal Investigation Section
Assigned Sun Mon Tues Wed Thurs Fri Sat
5 Detectives Off 7a – 3p 7a – 3p 7a – 3p 7a – 3p 7a – 3p Off 3 Detectives
1 Sergeant
3 Clerical
2 Photo Techs.
Off 8a – 4p 8a – 4p 8a – 4p 8a – 4p 8a – 4p Off
1 Detective
1 Sergeant
Off 9a – 5p 9A-5p 9a – 5p 9a – 5p 9a – 5p Off
There is no night time on-duty coverage, creating the need to call officers out for crime
scene responses. The overtime accrued by this unit is discussed later in this report. CIS
used to work a 2nd shift but it was discontinued due to personnel shortages. There are
two newly assigned detectives in the section. Once they are fully trained, CIS will
reschedule two detectives to an afternoon shift.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 6
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 7/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
Emergency Services Unit
Assigned Sun Mon Tues Wed Thurs Fri Sat
6 Detectives Off 8a- 3p 8a- 3p 8a- 3p 8a- 3p 8a- 3p Off 2 Detectives Off 8p – 3a 8p – 3a 8p – 3a 8p – 3a 8p – 3a Off
1 Sergeant Off 8a – 4p 8a – 4p 8a-4p 8a-4p 8a – 4p Off
The Emergency Services unit includes the MCSO canine teams. To comply with FLSA
requirements, officers are given one hour per day to care for their canines at home, thus
the seven hour work day.
ESU officers are subject to callout at all times, however, the assignment of two officers to
a night shift reduces the amount of overtime required for call outs.
Evidence Section
Assigned Sun Mon Tues Wed Thurs Fri Sat
1 Sergeant
1 Officer
Off 8a – 4p 8a – 4p 8a – 4p 8a – 4p 8a – 4p Off
The officers’ current union contract states their work week will be five consecutive work
days on the same shift with two consecutive days off.
Budget Overview
The MCSO Special Services Division FY 2013 budget request has been submitted to
County officials, but has not yet been approved. Operational costs for the Special
Services Division are not broken out from the entire MCSO budget. Because the
functions of the Special Service Division are markedly different than the remainder of the
Sheriff’s Office department, estimating their share of the operational budget would not be
accurate.
Personnel Costs2 , 3
The Special Services Division of the MCSO is staffed by 23 sworn and six clerical
personnel. The ranks held by sworn personnel consist of Lieutenant, Sergeant, Detective,
Investigator, and Officer. Civilian personnel carry out supervisory, clerical, and photo
lab responsibilities. Detailed personnel costs for salaries, pension, and overtime are
provided in the following table.
2 Since overtime is included in personnel cost computations, the most current data available is for 2012.3 MCSO Special Services Division personnel have not received pay increases since 2010.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 7
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 8/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
2012 Personnel Costs – Special Services Division4
Functional Position Salary Overtime HoursOvertime
Cost Pension CostTotal Cost of
Position
Det/Lieutenant - Legal Services Div. $113,582.00 16 $1,989.39 $27,327.83 $142,899.22
Sergeant - Bomb Commander $107,040.90 130 $10,259.37 $25,754.04$143,054.31
Sergeant - Criminal Investigation Section $93,037.00 307.75 $19,348.02 $22,384.70 $134,769.72
Sergeant - Evidence Section $93,037.00 96.75 $6,197.43 $22,384.70 $121,619.13
Sergeant - Emergency Services Section $105,541.01 124.5 $9,742.85 $25,393.17 $140,677.03
Sergeant - Criminal Investigation Section $47,268.67 0 $0.00 $11,372.84 $58,641.51Criminal Investigation Section(Detective) $73,773.01 398 $15,692.26 $17,749.79 $107,215.06Criminal Investigation Section(Detective) $62,000.01 488 $17,775.14 $14,917.20 $94,692.35
Emergency Services Section (Detect ive) $67,233.02 534.5 $21,409.12 $16,176.26 $104,818.40Criminal Investigation Section(Detective) $87,225.99 55.5 $3,373.33 $20,986.57 $111,585.89Criminal Investigation Section(Detective) $62,000.01 495.5 $17,374.40 $14,917.20 $94,291.61
Emergency Services Section (Detect ive) $87,225.99 229.25 $12,752.01 $20,986.57 $120,964.57
Evidence Section (Detective) $95,076.33 11 $710.05 $22,875.36 $118,661.74
Emergency Services Section (Detective) $80,324.00 367 $16,426.49 $19,325.95 $116,076.44Criminal Investigation Section(Detective) $73,773.01 709.84 $32,068.63 $17,749.79 $123,591.43
Emergency Services Section (Detective) $62,000.01 685 $26,667.25 $14,917.20 $103,584.46
Emergency Services Section (Detective) $95,076.33 18.25 $995.83 $22,875.36 $118,947.52Criminal Investigation Section(Detective) $62,000.01 325.25 $12,649.83 $14,917.20 $89,567.04
Emergency Services Section $78,824.00 463.25 $21,909.52 $18,965.05 $119,698.57
Emergency Services Section $72,273.01 572.25 $23,827.82 $17,388.89 $113,489.72
Emergency Services Section $44,162.00 429.75 $10,631.06 $10,625.38 $65,418.44
Criminal Investigation Section $67,233.02 492 $18,137.59 $16,176.26 $101,546.87
Criminal Investigation Section $54,377.99 392.25 $11,781.07 $13,083.34 $79,242.40
Special Services - Supervising Clerical $61,467.18 43 $1,918.44 $6,847.44 $70,233.06
Photo Lab Technician $49,859.56 0 $0.00 $5,554.35 $55,413.91
Photo Lab Technician $34,515.70 3.25 $80.59 $3,845.05 $38,441.34
Criminal Investigation Section - Clerical $26,778.67 0 $0.00 $2,983.14 $29,761.81
Emergency Services - Clerical $26,232.00 78.75 $1,559.09 $2,922.24 $30,713.33
Criminal Investigation Section - Clerical $26,232.13 71.5 $1,372.54 $2,922.26 $30,526.93
TOTALS: $2,009,169.56 7538.09
$316,649.12 $ 454,325.18 $2,780,143.81
Overtime incurred by the Special Services Division is significant, totaling $316,649 in
2012. The Emergency Services Section incurred an average of $15,843 per officer in
overtime. The average per officer overtime amount in the Criminal Investigation Section
was $16,466. Although overtime can be incurred for different reasons, the primary use of
4 Includes partial costs for employees separated during the year.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 8
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 9/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
overtime was for off-duty call-outs. Since neither unit provides 24/7 coverage, overtime
must be used to provide typical services to other communities.
When considering a consolidation or merger, the most significant cost reductions occur if
the number of personnel in the consolidated department can be reduced, subsequentlyreducing personnel costs. The personnel costs for the MCSO and MCPP will be used as
a basis for determining if there will be cost savings if a consolidation were to occur.
Workload - CIS
The Criminal Investigation Section (CIS) responds to crime scenes at the request of local
Morris County police agencies to assist with collecting and analyzing evidence that the
local agencies do not usually have the expertise to process. The CIS responds to both
indictable and non-indictable offenses. The table below shows the most frequent types
of crimes responded to by CIS members in the year study period.
Top activities for the Morris County Sheriff’s Office Criminal Investigations Section
There were 1170 total field responses in 2012.
The crime scene activities carried out by CIS personnel resulted in 38 different types of
evidence related actions. The most frequent are provided in the following table.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 9
Activity Type Number
Burglary and Theft 544Death 151
Burglary and Theft – Motor Vehicle 90
Motor Vehicle Accident 53
Fire 35
Recovered Stolen Motor Vehicle 35
Aggravated Assault 33
Sexual Assault 29Theft 25
Search Warrant 25
Robbery 24
Attempted Burglary and Theft 13
Motor Vehicle Theft 10
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 10/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
MCSO Crime Scene Actions by Type
Crime Scene Action Number
AFIS 6610
Print Comparisons 2082Evidence Comparison 10
Firearms Analysis 74Handwriting Analysis 26
Photo Line-Ups 265Crime Scene Process 750
Video Tapes 422
According to information supplied by the Sheriff’s Office CIS one sergeant and eight
members are allotted to CIS response. As described above, they work week days on
eight hour shifts, with some unit members working a shift from 7 a.m. to 3 p.m. and other
coming in an hour later to work from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. The following chart shows the
distribution by hour of the day and day of the week of CIS field responses. Shaded areas
represent times when the response is normally by on-duty officers.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 10
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 11/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
MCSO CIS FIELD RESPONSES – July 1, 2011 – June 30, 2012
Hour Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday00 4 6 4 9 7 1 3
01 11 5 4 5 1 2 4
02 4 5 12 2 4 1 203 6 2 3 1 9 1 8
04 8 7 2 4 5 1 4
05 3 3 4 2 3 4 2
06 6 10 8 19 6 12 5
07 6 11 15 10 11 13 8
08 12 11 9 16 18 22 16
09 11 28 7 23 9 14 8
10 13 11 15 17 10 17 8
11 12 8 25 20 11 10 8
12 8 10 11 14 19 22 16
13 6 21 18 15 19 16 10
14 9 21 13 18 14 9 915 7 21 15 16 11 20 13
16 3 15 15 17 13 19 14
17 11 10 9 12 6 18 10
18 5 11 8 12 12 14 2
19 4 5 13 13 10 14 4
20 3 7 9 12 9 11 8
21 8 6 17 12 7 17 6
22 10 3 10 6 8 23 9
23 1 12 11 12 13 11 6
Of the total of 1,674 responses 41% occurred during CIS on-duty time. The next tableshows the number of field responses by hour of the day for the year period.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 11
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 12/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
Field responses for the
Criminal Investigations
Section are highest at 0800,0900, 1200, 1300 and 1500
hours. Lowest points are early
mornings from midnight
through 0500.
The next chart shows the average number of field response per day of the week for the
year’s data.
Fridays have the highest average field
responses (5.6) followed by Wednesday at
5.5.
CIS members averaged approximately 72
hours per week on field responses, 28 hours
while on duty and 43 while off duty. Field
responses accounted for approximately 12.5% of the on-duty time of CIS members.
In addition to field response CIS officers perform analytical and technical work in the
crime lab. They carried out actions in 38 functional areas during 2012. The highest
levels of activity on included the following.
Activity Number
Case Photography 1369Evidence Collected 1945Investigation Report 1206Latent Prints Collected 1963Latent Prints Evaluated 2136
Prints Compared 1374Suspect Prints 3288Elimination Comparison 1478Suspect Comparison 8712
Workload - Emergency Services Unit
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 12
Number of CIS Field Response by Hour -- July 1
2011 - June 30, 2012
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
0 0 0 2 0 4 0 6 0 8 1 0 1 2 1 4 1 6 1 8 2 0 2 2
CIS Field Responses -- Daily Average July 1, 2011- June 30, 2012
0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 13/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
According to the MCSO, the work of ESU has been evolving. ESU is the first
responding unit to many critical incidents in Morris County. Their work has expanded in
all three facets of ESU, the K-9 Unit, Bomb Squad; and Search and Rescue Team. Their
flexibility enables them to readily respond to critical incidents or short notice details.
ESU specializes in response to a problem where they provide a rapid stabilizing force.
In addition, members of the ESU may assist local agencies with traffic enforcement, with
aggressive driving and with DUI enforcement checkpoints.
At present, there are eight handlers working in the K9 unit, with responsibility for 17
canines. Each handler may have more than one canine, as some of the canines are trained
for specific conditions. As described earlier, members of the unit work a seven hour
shift5 either 8AM to 3 PM or 8PM to 3AM Monday through Friday. The unit is subject to
call out when the need arises. The canine handlers are classified as investigators in thedepartment’s rank structure. When there is no activity requiring their special service,
member of the unit conduct training.
ESU members recorded 1,133 activities for the year from July 1, 2011 through June 30,
2012. The following table shows the most frequent recorded activities.
Top activities for the Morris County Sheriff’s Office Emergency Services Unit
Activity Number
K9 Patrol Tracking6 570Narcotics Search 153
K9 Missing Person Track 97
Assist Other Agency 68
Motor Vehicle Check or Stop 47
These five activities account for 83% of all activities. K9 Patrol Tracking accounts for
50% of all recorded activities. The following table shows the distribution of ESU
activities for the period from July 1, 2011 through June 30, 2012. Shaded areas represent
the on-duty times for ESU officers.
5 Canine officers are allotted one hour per day to care for their animals.6 Canine patrol tracking consists of such activities as track scenting, wind scenting, and field search,
building search, bite and bark. The ESU responds to all requests for the canine unit, and also schedules
enforcement activities with other law enforcement agencies.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 13
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 14/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
ESU Field Activities – Distribution by Hour of the Day and Day of the Week
Hour Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday
00 2 6 7 6 6 4 801 2 5 2 3 2 6 7
02 6 1 5 5 2 8 8
03 3 5 2 2 6 3 204 6 7 1 2 2 9
05 6 3 8 1 5
06 1 1 7 8 4 2
07 2 8 14 7 3
08 2 5 6 5 4 17
09 4 2 8 11 8 18 1
10 1 16 17 14 9 2 3
11 5 1 3 5 9 9 2
12 1 9 15 24 5 14
13 3 20 6 11 17 8 6
14 2 11 23 10 20 9 3
15 3 12 15 17 12 15 416 5 8 10 2 10 9 8
17 3 7 6 8 4 15 7
18 6 3 4 5 4 10 4
19 2 9 6 5 10 9 6
20 5 8 7 5 8 5 6
21 14 4 14 10 8 14 4
22 3 8 8 12 12 8 16
23 5 6 11 7 16 6 5
Of the 1,133 recorded activities, 616, or 54%, took place during the on-duty hours of the
ESU. Thursday and Friday had the highest average activities per day at 3.8. Tuesdaywas next highest with an average of 2.7 recorded activities per day. The following chart
shows the frequency of ESU activities by hour.
The most frequent
time for ESU activities
was during the
afternoon. A second
high point was at 2100
and 2200. Recordedactivities averaged
approximately 40
hours per week. An
average of 17.3 hours
was consumed during
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 14
ESU Recorded Activities per Hour -- July 1, 2011 -
June 30, 2012
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 15/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
on-duty time. This represents 9% of the available on-duty time. The number of activities
for the year averaged just over three per day.
The Emergency Services Unit is engaged in a number of activities when they are not
responding to calls or engaging in other field activities. They include, but are not limitedto:
• Training with the various canines both individually and as a team.
• Conducting training related to their bomb squad responsibilities.
• Conducting weapons and tactics training to prepare for response to hostage rescue
and active shooter situations.
• Maintaining equipment.
• Carry out reporting and record keeping functions.
ESU training records for 2012 indicated that the unit participated in three types of
training. The following table provides the type of training and number of training hours
expended in 2012.
Type of Training Administrative Training K-9 Training Specialized Training
Hours of Training 526 3439 631
As stated earlier, ESU members work seven hours a day for five straight days. Not all
officers will come to work each day due to vacations, illness, court appearances and other
leave time. Units similar to the ESU typically have an absentee rate of 30%. Applyingthis rate to the scheduled time results in a weekly number of hours for the unit of 196,
these projects to 10,192 per year.
The total amount of recorded training time is 4,596, which is 45% of the ESU on-duty
time. Administrative training accounts for 5% of the time, K-9 training accounts for 34%
and specialized training accounts for 6% of the total unit time.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 15
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 16/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
Morris County Park Police
The Morris County Park Commission established the Morris County Park Police (MCPP)
in 1962. New Jersey Statutes give counties the authority to create police divisions to
provide for the security of the parks and other recreational facilities. The Park Police aregoverned by a Park Commission. The Commission is appointed by County Freeholders
The primary mission of the Park Police is to provide law enforcement services in Morris
County Parks. The Park Police are authorized to enforce laws throughout Morris County
and the State of New Jersey. The Park Police may provide assistance and specialized
services to other agencies. The Morris County Park Police organizational design is
shown below.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 16
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 17/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
The MCPP is a full service police department, but due to the unique nature of their duties,
the majority of their work is proactive and self-generated.
The MCPP carries out the following functions:
• Patrol (vehicle, mounted, motorcycle, bicycle, and ATV)
• Traffic enforcement
• Investigations
• Security services
• Crowd control
• Search and Rescue
• Community outreach activities
The department maintains a cadre of instructors to certify officers in the variousspecialties they perform.
Budget Overview
The MCPP FY 2013 budget request has been submitted, but not yet approved.
Operational costs for the MCPP are included in the Park Commission budget. 2012
personnel costs are detailed below.
Personnel Costs
Sworn members of the MCPP are unionized, but do not fall under the civil service
provisions of the State of New Jersey.
The MCPP has an authorized staff of 30 sworn and 1 civilian position. Ranks associated
with sworn personnel include Chief, Captain, Lieutenant, Sergeant, Detective/Patrol and
Patrol Officer. The Department was authorized 34 sworn officers in 2008. The
authorized strength has been incrementally reduced since 2008. No officers are assigned
full-time to specialty patrol, such as the mounted patrol. Specialty patrols only occur
when officers are available.
The majority of costs associated with the MCPP are related to personnel. Personnel cost
include salary, overtime, insurance benefits, and pension costs. 2012 salary, overtime,
and pension costs are presented in the following table.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 17
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 18/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
Detailed 2012 Personnel Costs – Morris County Park Police7
Functional PositionSalary Overtime
HoursOvertime
Cost8
PensionCost
Total Cost of Position
Chief $120,359.20 0 $0.00 $28,958.42 $149,317.62
Chief Retired $110,546.25 0 $0.00 $26,597.43 $137,143.68
Captain - Administration $117,015.37 85 $5,620.33 $28,153.90 $150,789.60
Lieutenant - Administration $114,509.60 119 $8,281.84 $27,551.01 $150,342.45
Lt. Ret.- Administration $133,687.70 90 $5,183.36 $32,165.26 $171,036.32
Sgt. - Ret.Patrol Supervisor $69,640.67 7 $478.35 $16,755.55 $86,874.57
Sgt. - Patrol Supervisor $106,075.14 20 -$586.61 $25,521.68 $131,010.21
Sgt. - Patrol Supervisor $110,165.34 74 $3,542.12 $26,505.78 $140,213.24
Sgt. - Patrol/Det Supervisor $105,323.50 246 $13,349.70 $25,340.83 $144,014.03
Sgt. - Patrol Supervisor $100,556.11 222 $8,342.36 $24,193.80 $133,092.27
Sgt. - Patrol Supervisor $86,154.64 61 $3,126.18 $20,728.81 $110,009.63
Sgt. - Patrol Supervisor $98,906.23 197 $9,035.94 $23,796.84 $131,739.01
Patrol $97,579.84 76 $2,896.88 $23,477.71 $123,954.43
Patrol $97,668.08 186 $7,538.22 $23,498.94 $128,705.24
Patrol $92,876.07 95 $1,696.07 $22,345.98 $116,918.12
Patrol/Mounted $91,650.66 74 $3,106.23 $22,051.15 $116,808.04
Patrol $93,467.70 120 $854.56 $22,488.33 $116,810.59
Patrol $94,171.90 133 $4,411.91 $22,657.76 $121,241.57
Patrol $88,078.07 81 $2,645.02 $21,191.58 $111,914.67
Detective/Patrol $78,939.25 43 $655.19 $18,992.78 $98,587.22
Detective/Patrol $66,634.53 135 $3,516.94 $16,032.27 $86,183.74
Patrol $59,611.03 34 $423.71 $14,342.41 $74,377.15
Patrol $60,914.87 65 -$861.88 $14,656.12 $74,709.11
Patrol/Mounted $62,200.12 121 $3,145.63 $14,965.35 $80,311.10
Patrol/Mounted $57,972.17 11 -$1,875.53 $ 13,948.10 $70,044.74
Patrol $58,245.76 81 $2,932.75 $14,013.93 $75,192.44
Patrol $54,006.37 60 -$504.23 $12,993.93 $66,496.07
Patrol $41,762.56 98 -$1,673.42 $ 10,048.07 $50,137.21
Patrol $40,803.92 72 $1,633.60 $9,817.42 $52,254.94
Patrol $16,686.53 0 $0.00 $4,014.78 $20,701.31
Admin. Assistant $42,283.48 0 $0.00 $10,173.41 $52,456.89
Total $2,568,492.66 2600 $86,915.22 $617,979.33 $3,273,387.21
While salary and pension costs are set for the year, overtime cost vary based on a number
of factors. They include, but are not limited to minimum staffing requirements, special
events, court time, unanticipated workload, and supervisory staffing needs.
Proportionately, the bulk of the overtime in the MCPP is accrued by supervisory andmanagement personnel.
7 Includes partial costs for employees separated during the year.8 Negative overtime costs are the result of revenues from vendor overtime or outside detail overtime
exceeding the total overtime cost on an individual officer basis.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 18
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 19/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
The average per-officer overtime cost in the MCPP is approximately $3,000 annually.
The average per officer overtime cost in the MCSO Special Services Division is $13,750.
The substantial difference in overtime can be attributed to the difference in how many
hours are expended providing services while the officers are on duty, versus the number
of hours expended providing services on overtime.
When considering a consolidation or merger, the most significant cost reductions occur if
the number of personnel in the consolidated department can be reduced, subsequently
reducing personnel costs. The combined personnel costs for the MCSO and MCPP will
be used as a basis for determining if there will be any cost savings if a consolidation were
to occur.
Scheduling
Patrol officers, detectives and sergeants work a 5 on 5 off schedule working a 10.75 hour
work day. Patrol personnel are divided into four squads, two on each shift. When one
squad on the shift is working, the other is off. The Lieutenant works an 8 hour shift,
generally Monday through Friday.
Minimum patrol staffing is two officers on duty. One officer is assigned north of Route
10, and the other is assigned south of Route 10. A supervisor (Sergeant) is on duty 95%
of the time.
Workload
PERF requested a year of records for MCPP from the county’s computer aided dispatch
(CAD) system. In order to gauge the level of work for each unit, a record for each officer
on each event was requested. Some events require multiple units; others can be handled
by a single officer. The data that was supplied to PERF was for the 12 month period
from July 1, 2011 through June 30, 2012.
The following table shows the most frequently occurring events recorded for the Morris
County Parks Police. There were a total of 26,922 unit records for 26,018 different
events. This indicates that multiple units are rarely assigned to activities performed by
MCPP officers.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 19
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 20/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
Most Frequent Activities for the Morris County Parks Police July 1, 2011 – June 30, 2012
Event Type Number
Detail Check Park/Golf Course 17239
Motor Vehicle Check or Stop 1241 Administrative Detail9 1228
Vehicle Maintenance10 973
Escort11 899
Assist Other Agency 462
Training 373
Check Area12 251
Crowd Control 227
Alarm Commercial 162
These ten activities account for 86% of all officer activities recorded for the MCPP. The
single dominant activity is “Detail Check Park/Golf Course” which accounted for 66% of all MCPP patrol activity during the year. This activity fits the core mission of the Parks
Police since they exist to ensure that Morris County residents can use their parks under
safe and secure conditions.
These checks occur year round, approximately 48% occur from October through March
and 52% from April through September. Although the parks are open only from dawn to
dusk, there is still a need to patrol them after dark to ensure that no one is there in
violation of closing times and that the parks are not being used for illegal activities.
The adjacent chartshows the number of
checks performed by
9 A generalized category that encompasses everything from delivering summonses,
complaints and paperwork to various courts to finishing reports, to completing
various administrative tasks that the officers may be assigned by a supervisor.10 Time recorded for vehicle maintenance refers to the time recorded for the officers
to complete their detailed patrol car check that takes place on a regular basis.11 A coding the department uses when officers “escort” the county park golf course
daily monies to the bank and make the deposit for the park commission. The code
may also be used if MCPP officers provide a funeral escort or transport a victim or
someone in need of assistance in a patrol car. These generally do not result in
overtime.12 Each county park area is built into the CAD system as “patrol checks”. When an
officer is on patrol in any county park area, the officer starts the patrol event in the
CAD and when the officer is done the officer closes the event in the CAD. This system
provide accurate and time stamped information regarding patrol activities in the
County Parks.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 20
MCPP Park and Golf Course Checks By Hour
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
0 2 4 6 8 1 0
1 2
1 4
1 6
1 8
2 0
2 2
Hour
N u m b e r o f C h e c k s
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 21/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
hour. The chart reflects the patrol schedule which deploys patrol officers for 20 to 21
hours a day depending on the season, hence the very low frequency of checks from 2 a.m.
to 6 a.m. One peak time for checks is at 8 a.m. as officers begin dayshift. Checks then
increase in the afternoon with high points in the early evening at 7 p.m., 8 p.m. and 9
p.m. For the year, the number of recorded activities averages 3.7 per hour.
The next chart shows the distribution of checks by day of the week.
Checks average about 80 per day
on Saturday and then drop to 71 to
73 other days. This reflects the
days of the greatest use of thecounty’s parks and golf courses.
The second most frequent activity
recorded for Parks Police patrol
officers is “Motor Vehicle Stops
and Checks.” During the period
1241 occurred. Approximately60% occurred inside the parks.
The adjacent chart shows the
distribution of these stops and
checks by hour of the day. It
should be noted that from 0200 through 0600 hours MCPP patrol officers are not
scheduled to work. Motor vehicle stops and checks increase in the evenings after the
parks close.
As described earlier, MCPP patrol officers work five days consecutive days for 10.75
hours, followed by five straight days off. There are two shifts per day. The shift start
and end times vary seasonally but there is usually some over lap during the late
afternoon. Currently 17 officers are assigned to the patrol function.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 21
MCPP Park and Golf Course Checks -- Daily
Average
64
66
68
70
72
74
76
78
80
82
SUN MON TUE WED THU FRI SAT
MCPP Motor Vehicle Stops and Checks by Hour:
Inside and Outside the Parks
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23
Hour of the Day
N u m b e r o f
S t o p s / C h e
c k s
Inside
Outside
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 22/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
On most shifts, four officers are scheduled although all four will seldom be present due to
vacation, sick leave and other leave usage. When absences are factored in a show-up rate
typical for similar agencies is 75%. This means that of those scheduled to work any
given shift, about 75% of the personnel will be at work. Therefore the average number of
officers at work will be three per shift. The department’s informal minimum staffingrequirement of two officers and one supervisor per shift allows for one officer to work in
the northern part of the county and a second in the southern part. Back-up can be
provided by the other MCPP officer, by the supervisor or by a local department.
Most of the work performed by MCPP patrol officers is self-initiated. Officers
themselves determine when to perform a park or golf course check and when to stop or
check a motor vehicle. These two activities account for 68.6% of the recorded patrol
activities. Responding to outside requests to assist another agency, to check an area or to
respond to an alarm account for 3.2% of MCPP patrol activities.
These data indicate that ensuring that the Morris County Parks are safe and secure is
performed primarily by the self-initiated patrol activities of MCPP patrol officers. Only
approximately 1% of the activities recorded deal with criminal complaints.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 22
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 23/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
Concept of Operations
The feasibility of merging the MCSO Special Services Division into the MCPP should be
determined by the examination of a number of issues. Those issues include, but are not
limited to:
• Labor issues
• Pay and benefits
• Operational Issues
• Facilities issues.
• Staffing
• Potential cost reductions
Each of these components of feasibility is discussed next.
Labor Issues
All sworn personnel in the MCSO fall under the state’s civil service system. MCPP
sworn personnel do not. In order for the MCSO Special Services Division to be merged
into the MCPP, MCSO Special Services Division employees would have to be laid-off or
terminated from the MCSO and then rehired by the MCPP.
New Jersey civil service regulations 4A:8-1.1 state that “An appointing authority mayinstitute layoff actions for economy, efficiency or other related reasons.” The Morris
County Sheriff, as the appointing authority for sheriff’s officers, would probably have to
declare any layoff.
When a layoff is declared and approved by the New Jersey Civil Service Commission,
civil service regulations require that layoffs occur on a “last in, first out” basis. The
newest employees in the Sheriff’s Office would be laid off first. Based on current
seniority conditions in the Sheriff’s Office, court employees would make up the largest
group of employees to be laid off. Because of their seniority CSI and ESU employees
would not likely be subject to the lay-offs, but would remain with the Sheriff, although
no longer providing their specialized services because, in order to meet court staffing
requirements, they would most likely be assigned to work in the courts.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 23
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 24/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
Civil service regulations encourage local jurisdictions to consider voluntary alternatives
to layoff. A previously considered option involved offering Sheriff’s officers a voluntary
transfer to the MCPP. Such a transfer would require that Sheriff’s employees give up
their civil service positions, although they could continue to operate in their area of
expertise in the MCPP. Such a transfer would have to be voluntary. It is unknown howmany CIS and ESU members would move from the MCSO to the MCPP. The consensus
among those interviewed was that few would make the change.
Unless virtually all of the current CIS and ESU members moved to the MCPP, there
would be a significant loss in expertise in these specialty areas. Considerable time and
expense for the extensive training needed would be required to develop high quality
canine handlers and crime scene and crime lab personnel. Although some positions
might be filled through lateral entry by those with suitable training, there would still be
some period of diminished operational efficiency and effectiveness.
Pay and Benefits
The issue of pay and benefits for MCSO employees joining the MCPP would be dictated
by how MCSO personnel were merged into the MCPP. The approach discussed earlier
(the lay-off or termination of MCSO personnel followed by re-hiring by the MCPP)
would likely result in a negotiated agreement where the merged employees would
eventually receive MCPP pay and benefits. Issues such as seniority and where the new
employees would start in MCPP pay scales would require resolution before exact salary
costs can be identified. For the purposes of analysis and comparison, the average pay, byrank, between the two departments is presented in the following table.
Rank MCSO13 MCPP14
Lieutenant $113,583 $115,000Sergeant 89,184 $101,196Detective/Investigator $75,600 n/a15
Officer $55,257 $72,73316
Averaging existing actual wages result in pay rates that are higher in the MCPP than
they are in the MCSO , but the MCSO and MCPP pay scales reflect very little difference13 2010 Pay rate. No salary increases have occurred since then.14 2012 Pay rate.15 There is a MCPP job classification of detective/patrol. Since the salaries for these positions were within
the range of patrol officer salaries, those positions and their respective salaries were averaged with the
officer salaries.16 The MCPP salary range for officers is from $39,000 to $88,000 as the result of an incremental pay step
program.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 24
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 25/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
when top of scale pay rates are considered. In the case of a Lieutenant, the annual
difference is $456. In the case of a Sergeant it is $541. Officer top of scale salaries are
$2274 higher in the Park Police, however, some of the difference is offset by a “detective
differential” received by some MCSO personnel. The differentail is $1500 per year. If
MCSO special services personnel were merged into the MCPP on a person for person basis, it is likely that overall salary costs for the county would be similar, and pension
costs would remain the same.
Operational Issues
Each operational unit that would be involved in the consolidation currently has distinct
operational responsibilities with little overlap. The MCPP is primarily responsible for
patrol of the parks and have county-wide jurisdiction. The CIS and Emergency Services
sections of the MCSO have county wide responsibilities for specialized services. The
consolidation would result in creating a larger department, which overall would includethe same services performed by units in their current organizational placement.
One possible scenario for enhanced service would be to have the ESU members assigned
to the MCPP patrol function. Two canine handlers and their dogs could be assigned to
each of the current patrol squads. This would increase the size of each patrol squad from
four to six. If minimum staffing of each squad included one canine at all times, response
to local county agencies could be accommodated almost around the clock. Issues with
this option include:
• Workload data suggest that the current level of MCPP patrol fits the level of work
needed. The large majority of the work being performed is self-initiated not
responding to citizen generated calls for service. The low level of calls about
crime in the parks suggests that adequate patrolling is being provided. Increasing
the size of each squad by adding two canine officers to each is not warranted in
light of the workload data.
• If canine handler positions were substituted for MCPP patrol officer positions to
achieve the current level of squad staffing, coverage gaps could well occur. If a
canine officer were sent on a call to a local agency that needed the skills of the
dog, staffing in the parks would be decreased during his absence. Some calls
require multiple hours of canine expertise.
• When only one canine officer was on duty, many calls would require a call out
since the workload data indicate 60% of all canine responses involved two or
more dogs.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 25
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 26/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
• Some canine responses might be delayed so the canine officer can get the
appropriate dog. Different dogs are trained for different tasks including search
and rescue, patrol, bomb and explosive discovery, and drug detection. If the
officer is patrolling with a patrol dog yet a drug dog is needed the officer would
have to go to the kennel to get the right dog. Currently most canine responses aredirectly from the kennel enabling the handler to bring the right dog from the
outset.
• Although the time spent in K9 training might be reduced in keeping with national
standards, there is still a substantial need for on-going dog training. This
requirement along with the hour per day needed for maintaining the animal will
create frequent absences from duty by canine officers.
FacilitiesThe MCPP facility is small and outdated. It could not accommodate any additional
personnel or equipment. The county is building a new facility to house the MCSO crime
lab. Included in the facility is space for the county communications center, data center,
and emergency operations center. The later functions are not under the supervision of the
MCSO. In addition, the Sheriff’s administrative offices and the emergency services
facilities are in different locations.
Organizational Design
The organizational design of a police agency defines function, workflow, lines of
communication, and workflow. If MCSO Special Services and MCPP were to
consolidate, the following table of organization is recommended. The table incorporates
the MCSO Special Services sections according to their current operational functions.
MCPP patrol squad size is not increased based on the discussion above.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 26
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 27/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
This approach adopts a two division organization, with operations and administration
functionally separate.
Staffing and Cost of a Consolidated Department
The previous section of this report discussed the proposed organizational design for a
consolidated department. The organizational design is important in describing the
functional responsibilities and workflow in the department. The number of personnel
assigned to each function determines how much it will cost to operate the department. A
primary consideration in determining whether a consolidation is feasible is the potential
for cost reductions as compared to the current environment.
The following table describes the proposed cost and staffing model for a consolidated
department. It provides the anticipated cost associated with merging the two entities and
retaining all existing positions. Since the proposed consolidation would be the result of
merging the MCSO Special Services Division into the MCPP, salary amounts are derived
from averaged salary costs, by rank, in the Morris County Park Police.
Consolidated Department Staffing and Personnel Costs
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 27
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 28/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
Functional PositionNumber of Positions
EstimatedSalary
TotalSalary
PensionCost
Total PersonnelCost
Department Head 1 $120,359 $120,359 $28,958 $149,317
Administration 1 $117,015 $117,015 $28,154 $145,169
Administration 1 $114,509 $114,509 $27,551 $142,060
Special Operations 1 $114,609 $114,609 $27,575 $142,184
Patrol Supervisor 6 $101,196 $607,176 $146,087 $753,263
Evidence Supervisor 1 $101,196 $101,196 $24,348 $125,544
Bomb Commander 1 $101,196 $101,196 $24,348 $125,544
Criminal Investigation 1 $101,196 $101,196 $24,348 $125,544
Emergency Services 1 $101,196 $101,196 $24,348 $125,544
Crime Lab 1 $101,196 $101,196 $24,348 $125,544
ESU 5 $75,642 $378,210 $90,997 $469,207
CIS 6 $75,642 $453,852 $109,197 $563,049
Investigations/Patrol 2 $72,733 $145,466 $34,999 $180,465
Patrol 16 $72,733 $1,163,728 $279,993 $1,443,721
ESU 3 $72,733 $218,199 $52,499 $270,698
CIS 2 $72,733 $145,466 $34,999 $180,465
Evidence 1 $72,733 $72,733 $17,500 $90,233
Admin. Assistant 1 $42,283 $42,283 $10,173 $52,456
Supervising Clerical 1 $61,467 $61,467 $14,789 $76,256
Photo Lab Technician 2 $42,283 $84,567 $20,347 $104,914
CIS Clerical 2 $27,000 $54,000 $12,992 $66,992
ESU Clerical 1 $27,000 $27,000 $6,496 $33,496
Totals 57 $1,788,650 $4,426,619 $1,065,045 $5,491,663
Overtime $403,654.00
Grand Total $5,895,317.48
It is estimated that overtime costs in the consolidated organization would not change
from the combined overtime total of the two departments. Subsequently, overtime costs
incurred by the departments in 2012 are added to the cost model for the consolidated
department.
Cost Comparison with Current Context
The following table describes the current combined personnel costs of the MCSO
Special Services Division and the MCPP compared to an estimated consolidated cost.
Current Personnel Costs Compared to Consolidated Costs
2012 Combined
Personnel Cost17
Consolidated
Personnel Cost Difference
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 28
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 29/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
Personnel Costs $6,053,531 $5,895,317 -$158,213
Personnel costs in the consolidated department would be $158,213 less than the
combined 2012 personnel costs of the two agencies.
This model was based on a position by position merger of the MCSO Special Services
Division and the MCPP, The small cost reduction can be attributed to the application of
average MCPP salaries to this model. While it was noted earlier that existing MCPP
salaries are on average higher, the salary scales for the two departments are very similar.
The variation occurs as the result of using actual salaries in the computation of current
costs, and average current salaries in the MCPP as the basis for consolidated cost.
Implementation Costs
In order to consolidate the operations of the MCSO Special Services Division into theMCPP, cost not related to personnel, salary and benefits will be incurred. Since all of the
equipment, vehicles and facilities utilized by the MCSO Special Services Division are
owned by Morris County, it is assumed that there will be no cost to transfer these items to
the MCPP. Consequently, current vehicles, weapons, and other equipment will be
adequate for the consolidated department at start-up. Maintenance and routine
replacement should be managed within the consolidated department’s budget in future
years. Non-standard types of equipment (firearms, radios) should be identified and
scheduled for replacement. During implementation planning, a replacement schedule for
equipment and vehicles should be developed to clarify future costs.
For the purposes of organizational, identity items related to department identity or
“brand” need to be changed at startup. Two cost items should be included in the
consolidation project budget as implementation costs. They include remarking police
vehicles at $1,100 apiece and providing new officer uniforms and equipment at $2,000
apiece.18 The operational budget for the MCPP will need to increase to accommodate the
need for new supplies and maintain new equipment.
Beyond the cost of equipment and operational supplies, significant hours will beexpended by police officials and other county officials in preparing for the consolidation,
17 This baseline is based on 2010 MCSO personnel costs and 2013 MCPP personnel costs. Adjusting
MCSO personnel costs to 2013 rates will result in raising the current combined costs while the consolidated
personnel costs would remain the same. Tables showing the respective rates are included in the Appendix.18 These estimates are based on a recent analysis by PERF in Berks County, PA.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 29
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 30/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
along with managing operational and administrative changes within the MCPP. Those
tasks included, but are not limited to:
• Developing plans, requesting permissions, and developing documentation to
facilitate the personnel move from MCSO to MCPP.• Clarifying pay and benefit issues
• Negotiating with the respective unions.
• Negotiating with the Civil Service Commission.
• Transferring MCSO employees to MCPP
• Develop a new chain of command in the MCPP.
• Developing new MCPP operating policies in procedures.
• Developing new MCPP work schedules.
• Training new MCPP specialists in their generalist duties.
It is difficult to quantify the cost of the efforts that are described above. As the details of
a consolidation become less uncertain, the effort required to carry out these tasks can be
better defined.
If this project were to move forward, a detailed implementation plan should be developed
by the stakeholders and carried out by a qualified project manager.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 30
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 31/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
FindingsThe purpose of this study was to determine the feasibility of merging the Special Services
Division of the MCSO into the MCPP. The research has indicated that the consolidation
is feasible, but that there is no compelling reason to merge the organizations. This
conclusion is based on a number of considerations. They are detailed below.
Cost
Limited cost savings will be realized as the result of a consolidation. At the same staffing
levels that exist in the current environment, the cost of the consolidated department is
estimated to be less than the total costs of the two departments by $158,213. This cost
difference is insignificant due to several factors discussed above.
Reduction of Duplication of Services
The law enforcement services provided by the MCPP and MCSO Special Services are
overwhelmingly mutually exclusive. Each provides services that are separate and
distinct.
Organizational Efficiency
The organizational structure recommended here would be efficient in managing the
current functions of the MCPP and the MCSO Special Service Division. It would also
provide a foundation for future growth if the county would decide to develop a county
police department. As the two organizations currently exist, both have desirable
organizational platforms from which to manage their organizations. No significant
benefits would be derived from combining them.
Facilities
No facility currently exists that could accommodate the consolidated police department.
The MCPP is small and outdated, and MCSO facilities are scattered and some are
designed for specific and limited function. Except for the existing MCPP building, none
are designed to support a patrol function.
From an organizational standpoint, it is ideal to operate a law enforcement agency in one
location. Unless a building program were undertaken as part of a consolidation, facilities
would likely same the same as they are now. The need for capital investments to
improve or construct new facilities would remain the same as they are in the current
environment.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 31
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 32/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
Conclusion
This analysis reveals no operational effectiveness or cost savings to be gained by
consolidation of the MCSO Special Services Division into the Morris County Park Police
in the near term. By all accounts, the current services provided by the MCSO crime
scene personnel, the crime lab and canine officers are of high quality. A merger would
not achieve a clear public benefit. There is little service overlap between the current
operations and there would be no redundancy in a consolidated department that would
allow a decrease in positions. On the contrary, because of labor issues – and the inability
to move the Special Services Division with all it current personnel intact – expertise
would decrease until it could be built back over multiple years.
Further Considerations
If the obstacles to the consolidation of the MCSO Special Services Division and the
Morris County Park Police could be overcome and discussions are held in the future
about a merger, there are certain potential efficiencies that might be achieved. They relate
to Criminal Investigation Section scheduling, Criminal Investigation Section
civilianization, and call out thresholds.
CIS Scheduling
CIS personnel in a merged department could be scheduled so that personnel are on dutyduring an evening shift. It was reported that such coverage is being examined by the
MCSO. These changes would result in a reduction in the number of night call-outs, and
subsequently a reduction in overtime. The chart on page 12, “MCSO CIS FIELD
RESPONSES – July 1, 2011 through June 30, 2012”, overlays the current CIS schedule
on the times when field responses occur. The current Monday through Friday schedule –
with its two shifts from 7 a.m. to 3 p.m. and from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. – covers 41% of the
field responses.
Redeploying the existing personnel so that some employees would work a shift onweekdays from 4 p.m. to midnight would cover an additional 28% of the field responses
for a total coverage of approximately 69% of the field response. Overtime for callouts
might be reduced by some 28% as a result. This altered coverage is shown in the chart
below.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 32
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 33/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
MCSO CIS FIELD RESPONSES – July 1, 2011 – June 30, 2012
With Evening Shift Added
Hour Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday00 4 6 4 9 7 1 3
01 11 5 4 5 1 2 402 4 5 12 2 4 1 2
03 6 2 3 1 9 1 8
04 8 7 2 4 5 1 4
05 3 3 4 2 3 4 2
06 6 10 8 19 6 12 5
07 6 11 15 10 11 13 8
08 12 11 9 16 18 22 16
09 11 28 7 23 9 14 8
10 13 11 15 17 10 17 8
11 12 8 25 20 11 10 8
12 8 10 11 14 19 22 16
13 6 21 18 15 19 16 1014 9 21 13 18 14 9 9
15 7 21 15 16 11 20 13
16 3 15 15 17 13 19 14
17 11 10 9 12 6 18 10
18 5 11 8 12 12 14 2
19 4 5 13 13 10 14 4
20 3 7 9 12 9 11 8
21 8 6 17 12 7 17 6
22 10 3 10 6 8 23 9
23 1 12 11 12 13 11 6
Shaded areas represent on-duty coverage.
CIS Civilianization
In a merged department, CIS personnel involved primarily in evidence collection and
analysis could be civilians. Many law enforcement agencies across the country have
successfully used non-sworn personnel for all aspects of crime scene field work and
laboratory processing.
A standard set of objections is often raised when considering the civilianization of
operational positions. Although civilian employees do not have the general policing
experience of sworn officers, they can be trained to a level where they have
commensurate or greater skills, knowledge and ability in carrying out the specific range
of operational processes involved in the evidence and crime scene functions.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 33
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 34/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
Civilians have proven to be reliable and capable in safeguarding evidence and managing
confidential/sensitive information. The measure of whether a person can be trusted to
work in sensitive positions does not lie in their sworn vs. civilian status, but in their
personal values, the rigor of their background investigation, and their work history.
Civilian employees sometimes are subjected to less scrutiny than sworn officers in their background investigations. But in cases where the civilian is handling confidential
information and/or evidence, the depth of the background investigation should be at least
as rigorous as that of a police officer.
Civilianization could be achieved through attrition and by hiring experienced technicians
from other agencies. Care would need to be taken to gradually blend personnel in order
to maintain the current level of superior expertise.
Call Out ThresholdsIn the current environment, ESU or CIS will respond to virtually every request received
from another police department in Morris County. While most of the callouts may be
justified, this approach places Special Services workload and overtime accrual in the
hands of others.
With consolidation, call-out thresholds could be developed, defining circumstances under
which ESU/CIS personnel will respond. Establishing thresholds, and subsequently call-
outs, may not result in any savings when officers are on duty, but may result in overtime
reductions when officers are not on duty.
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 34
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 35/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
APPENDIX: Salary Tables
Morris County Sheriff’s Office
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 35
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 36/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 36
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 37/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study
Morris County Parks Police
Police Executive Research Forum
Page 37
7/28/2019 Morris County Sheriff's Office and Morris County Parks Police Partial Consolidation Feasibility Study
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/morris-county-sheriffs-office-and-morris-county-parks-police-partial-consolidation 38/38
Morris County, NJPolice Consolidation Feasibility Study