late-qing and minguo periodical databases - comparision and evaluation martina siebert east asia...

Late-Qing and Minguo Periodical databases - Comparision and Evaluation

Martina SiebertEast Asia Department - China section

|

Chinese News-paper HistoryChinese News-paper History The DatabasesThe Databases Comparison and

EvaluationComparison and Evaluation

萬國公報 / 中外紀聞1895-1896

強學報1895-1896

事物報1896-1898

邸報Dibao “Imperial gazette”

Han / Tang / Song / Ming

end of Qing

Missionary press

察世俗每月統計傳“China Monthly”

1815-1821

東西洋考每月統計傳“Eastern Western

Monthly Magazine”1833-1838

萬國公報“The China Globe

Magazine”1874-1907

Chinese press

。。。

|

6266 journal titles(1886 / 1949)

4350 journal titles (BeiTu)(1892 / 1949)

629 journal titles（ 1902 / 1954）

302 (Qing) +3427 (3 batches Minguo)

journal titlesplanned: 20.000 titles

(1833-1911 / 1911-1949)



|



|

6266 journal titles(1886 / 1949)

4350 journal titles (BeiTu)(1892 / 1949)

629 journal titles（ 1902 / 1954）

302 (Qing) +3427 (3 batches Minguo)

journal titlesplanned: 20.000 titles

(1833-1911 / 1911-1949)



|



|

鎮江： Shanghai (21 issues) vs. Apabi (21 issues every page!)



|

重庆： Shanghai 1934-1936 (21 issues) vs. Dacheng 1922 (Beijing, 1 issue), 1929 (Nanjing, 12 issues), 1935-1936 (Zhenjiang, 12 issues), 1936 (Wuhan, 2 issues), 1936 (Xiamen, 1 issue), 1947-1948 (Qingdao, 10 issues).

|



-1910 71911-1920 271921-1930 991931-1940 1631941-1950 2951951-1954 1empty 37total 629

Apabi (1902 / 1954) Dacheng (1892 / 1972)

-1910 421911-1920 1461921-1930 4661931-1940 17421941-1950 17631951- 3empty 2104total 6266

|

Apabi

Shanghai

Dacheng

No of titles bibliographic reliability

user copies

629

6266

3729

(20.000?)

OK. whole journal

mediocre. whole journal

good. no cover etc.

screenshots(> bad quality)

PDF(no preview)

page by page graphic download(time consuming)



[email protected]

Staatsbibliothek zu Berlin

Ostasienabteilung

late-qing and minguo periodical databases - comparision and evaluation martina siebert east asia...

Documents

evaluation slide

databases comparison

chinese press slide

empty2104 total6266

journal titles beitu

batches minguo journal

journal mediocre

journal good