kimberlin v. walker, et al transcript (day 1)

8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 1)

1/72

"# $%& '"(')"$ '*)($ +*( ,*#$-*,&(. '*)#$./ ,0(.10#2

33333333333333333333333333334

55

6(&$$ 7",6&(1"# 55

89:;>/ 55

?@ 5 ';?;9 #A@ BCDEFF5

00(*# G017&(/ &$ 01 55

2H>H


2/72

"# $%& '"(')"$ '*)($ +*( ,*#$-*,&(. '*)#$./ ,0(.10#2

333333333333333333333333333345

56(&$$ 7",6&(1"# 5

589:;>/ 5

5?@ 5 ';?;9 #A@ BCDEFF

500(*# G017&(/ &$ 01 5

52H>H


3/72


4/72


5/72


6/72

6

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 0


7/72

7

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

,(@ *V$(*#"'5 .ANL TA


8/72

8

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

;


9/72

9

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

a;=


10/72

10

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

>;


11/72

11

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

=TH [9:;> I;I >;9H : \A=;A< A< +L;I:M =A :PK =T:= =T;P

P=:=N=H UH LN9HI N


12/72

12

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

$TH< PNLH9M : J;?;9 J:PH/ aT;JT :99 ;= I;J=:=HP/ ;=`P :99

I;J=:=HI UM P=:=N=H :M/ aT:=

J:< UH ULANOT= UH>ALH : J;?;9 J:PH/ H= JH=HL:/ ;=`P PNLH9M

JA


13/72

13

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 6N= 33

$%& '*)($5 -A :TH:I@

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 "< =T;P J:PH/ MAN K


14/72

14

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

$%& '*)($5 GH99/ a:P =TH;L \A=;A< \:IH =A [LAT;U;=

MAN =A =HP=;>M UHJ:NPH MAN`?H UHH< JA


15/72

15

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

,(@ *V$(*#"'5 %H`P =:9K;


16/72

16

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

=AA@ 0


17/72

17

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

"`\ LH>HLL;H


18/72

18

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

\H@ 'L;\HP =T:=@

$%& '*)($5 099 L;OT=@ 2H>:\:=ALM P=:=H\H:\:=ALM P=:=H\H


19/72

19

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

=A PTAa =T:=b

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 GH99/ " IAH


20/72

20

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

=THM`LH P:M;


21/72

21

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

P:M MAN aHLH :LLHP=HI >AL =T:=b

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 $THM P:M =T:= " a:P JT:LOHI a;=T =T:=@

$THM P:M =T:= " :\ :@

$%& '*)($5 "P =T:= : MHP@ $T:= =THM P:M MAN aHLH

:LLHP=HI >AL [HIA[T;9;:b 0 JT:LOH ;P :< :LLHP=@ VA ;P =T:=

aT:= =THM P:;Ib

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 $THM P:M =T:= "`\ : [HIA[T;9H@

$%& '*)($5 6N= \M ^NHP=;A< ;P/ IA =THM P:M =T:= MAN

aHLH :LLHP=HI AL JT:LOHI a;=T [HIA[T;9;:b $T:=`P


22/72

22

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

$%& '*)($5 GT:= :LH =THM :99HO;;LHI >LA\ =TH;L cAUP@

$T:= " >ALJHI =TH\ =A >9HH =TH;L TA\HP@ $THPH :LH :99 >:9PH@

$THM`?H IA


23/72

23

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

$%& '*)($5 'A " N


24/72

24

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

$%& '*)($5 "=`P


25/72

25

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

$T:=`P aT:= =TH LN9H P:MP@ 0


26/72

26

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

$%& '*)($5 *K:M@

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 0


27/72

27

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 6N= "`I 9A?H =A TH:L aT:= MAN T:?H =A

P:M@

$%& '*)($5 $TH =LN=T@

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 $TH =LN=T/ L;OT=@

$%& '*)($5 VA/ ;< A=THL aALIP/ ;> MAN`LH J:99HI :

=HLLAL;P=/ :


28/72

28

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

O;L9 =A UH H\ULA;9HI ;< =T;Pb

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 ]NIOH/ \M I:NOT=HL ;P Q_ MH:LP A9I@

VTH T:P UHH< UN99;HI AN= A> =aA PJTAA9P/ =aA T;OT PJTAA9P@

6N99;HI UM =THPH ONMP@

,(@ *V$(*#"'5 .ANL TA


29/72

29

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

[HLcNLM ;PPNH@ "`99 =:KH 33 "`99 LN9H A< =T:=@

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 -LH:=@

$%& '*)($5 .HP/ P;L@

,(@ *V$(*#"'5 .ANL TA


30/72

30

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

:99HO:=;A


31/72

31

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

aH`99/ MAN K


32/72

32

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

H?;IH


33/72

33

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

$T:=`P aT:= 9A?;AL :< H?:9N:=;A< AL MAN OH= TH9[@

,(@ *V$(*#"'5 0O:;


34/72

34

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 " KM =A ;=@

$%& '*)($5 -AAI 9NJK a;=T =T:=@

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 .H:T@ 6N= :


35/72

35

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

,(@ *V$(*#"'5 .HP/ MANL TA MAN 9AAK

U:JK/ ]NIOH ,J-:;?H A> =TH PH?H< JAN


36/72


37/72

37

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

$%& '*)($5 "


38/72

38

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

$%& '*)($5 GT:=`P =TH =T:=b *L a:P =T:= :

P[HJ;>;J ;


39/72

39

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

a:M =TH [:L=;HP JAN9I [LA?H T:L\@ $THM T:?H


40/72

40

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

A> =THPH T:?H UHH< :N=TH


41/72

41

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

=aA ;PPNHP =T:= JAN


42/72


43/72

43

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

MAN K


44/72

44

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

=TH A=THL P;IH ;P LH[LHPH


45/72

45

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

P:\H ;HLLHI =A =TAPH ;< =TH ; IAJN\H


46/72


47/72

47

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

,(@ *V$(*#"'5 (;OT=@

$%& '*)($5 89:;>P/ :H


48/72

48

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

$%& '*)($5 GH99 =T;P ;P =TH J;LJN;= JANL=@ -A :TH:I@

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 "> =TH P=:=H\H T:P IH\A JL;\HP@ $T:= =T;P T:P T:L\HI \H@ "=

T:P T:L\HI \M LH[N=:=;A


49/72

49

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

$%& '*)($5 #A@

,(@ *V$(*#"'5 #A/


50/72

50

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

P:OH :I?;JH/ " \:M


51/72

51

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

aAN9I UH@ 0


52/72

52

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

,(@ *V$(*#"'5 "`\ IA MANL A[H;9HI PA\H PNU[AHAL PA\H

a;=


53/72

53

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

a;=T =T:= ;PPNH@

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 *K:M@ 099 L;OT=@ $T:

=TH J:PH PTAN9I UHb "< A=THL aALIP/ aT:= ;P ;= =T;P J:PH ;P

:UAN=b

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 2H>:\:=;A< ::9PH 9;OT=@


54/72

54

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

$%& '*)($5 VA =TH [9:;> J9:;\P =T:= IH>H:\HI@ GT:= ;Pb $T:= =TH

IH>H


55/72

127

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

today, and youll be released. And then tomorrow well hear the

meat of the case, so to speak. So please dont leave the floor

because your break isnt going to be that long, okay? Juror

ALH\:< A> =T;P cNLM/ PA JA

its all the same 33 I dont see my defense as being 33

$%& '*)($5 (;OT= 33

,(@ *V$(*#"'5 33 \ALH =T:< : JAN[9H \;


56/72

128

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

$%& '*)($5 #Aa/ a;=T A[H


57/72

129

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

,(@ *V$(*#"'5 " N;?H3\; MAN a:


58/72

130

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

Otherwise, youre just talking to them and then you just kind of

lose whatever we had. Its not 33

$%& '*)RT: Well, heres the 33 heres the problem:

$TH 9H =T;P =L;:9 33 :;


59/72

131

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

,(@ *V$(*#"'5 .H:T@

THE COURT: Its kind of nice if they know something

:UAN= aT:= =TH J:PH ;P 33

,(@ *V$(*#"'5 (;OT=@

$%& '*)($5 33 :


60/72

132

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

)#"2$"+"&2 +&,01& B5 $TH I;P=L;J= J:PH@

$%& '*)($5 )@V@ 2;P=L;J= 'ANL=@

)#"2$"+"&2 +&,01& B5 #A/ =TH A


61/72

133

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

PNOOHP=;


62/72

134

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

know; I havent found any case that would prohibit the admission

A> H?;IH


63/72

135

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

=T:= MAN a;99 UH :U9H =A =HP=;>M/ IAHP


64/72

136

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

[9:;> =A JA\H U:JK =A MAN =A\ALLAa a;=T :


65/72

137

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

=T;P 33 :99 A> : PNIIH< M;HJ=/ MANL TA


66/72

138

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 $T: MAN

do, your testimony is subject to be stricken, and you wont be

helping the party that youre testifying for.

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 "P =T:= 33 ;P =T:= :>=HL A[H


67/72

139

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

:UN


68/72

140

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 2NL;

MAN


69/72

141

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

=HJT MAN


70/72

142

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

MAN J:< H


71/72

143

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

RQ

RR

RB

RS

R_

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 ,M I:NOT=HL 7H9P;H@

$%& '*)($5 *K:M/ :99 L;OT=@ 0


72/72

144

Q

R

B

S

_

F

Y

C

E

QD

QQ

QR

QB

QS

Q_

QF

QY

QC

QE

RD

k 2;O;=:99M P;O

kimberlin v. walker, et al transcript (day 1)

Documents