Judging Kellogg Community College Critical review T.J. Taylor

MCCPA Judging Form --- 2014

Contest Category: Critical review

Entrant’s Name: T.J. Taylor

Title of Entry: “Old Boy” review

School Name: Kellogg Community College

Honorable Mention

Judge’s Comments: While your review requires some familiarity with the genre to fully appreciate it, you

do capture it well. It is your obvious interest that shines through here and makes me want to check out

the original. One tip: Find new ways to say “original.” Three in the lede alone distracts the reader.

Judge’s Name: Sue White

Judge’s Affiliation: Contributing writer for The Saginaw News and MLive.com