introduction - csmfo

70

Upload: others

Post on 16-Oct-2021

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Introduction - CSMFO
Page 2: Introduction - CSMFO

1

Introduction

Rick Phillips City of Las Vegas Investment Officer 1989-1998 Clark County Chief Investment Officer 1998-2005 FTN Main Street President & Chief Investment Officer 2005 - Present Manage/Consult on $50+ Billion AUM GIOA Founder

Tom Juarez Dean Witter/Morgan Stanley 1985-1999 Bank of America 1999-2004 City of Los Angeles Investment Officer 2005-2010 City of Los Angeles Chief Investment Officer 2010 - Present

Page 3: Introduction - CSMFO

2

7 Habits of Highly Effective Investment Programs

1. You Have a Detailed Asset/Liability Matching Model (aka: Cash Flow Model)

2. You Have a Responsible Amount of Interest Rate Risk and Credit Risk3. You Don’t Try to Time the Market4. You Love Losses and Hate Gains (the unrealized kind)

5. You Follow GAAP (Generally Accepted Accounting Principles)

6. You Benchmark Your Investment Program and Portfolio in Multiple Ways7. You Provide Quality, Timely, Transparent Reporting

Page 4: Introduction - CSMFO

3

Habit #1

You Have a Detailed Asset/Liability Matching Model (aka: Cash Flow Model)

Page 5: Introduction - CSMFO

4

GIOA Model Investment Policy Primary Objectives

1. Safety of Principal: Safety of principal is the foremost objective of the [entity’s]investment program. Investments by the [designated official] shall be undertaken ina manner that seeks to ensure the preservation of capital in the overall portfolio. Toattain this objective, diversification of security types, sectors, issuers, and maturitiesis necessary in order that potential losses on individual securities do not exceed theincome generated from the remainder of the portfolio.

2. Liquidity: The investment portfolio shall be structured to timely meet expectedcash outflow needs and associated obligations which might be reasonablyanticipated. This objective shall be achieved by matching investment maturities withforecasted cash outflows and maintaining an additional liquidity buffer forunexpected liabilities.

3. Investment Income: The investment portfolio shall be designed to earn a marketrate of investment income in relation to prevailing budgetary and economic cycles,while taking into account investment risk constraints and liquidity needs of theportfolio.

Page 6: Introduction - CSMFO

5

Detailed Asset/Liability (Cash Flow) Model

If You Don’t Know Where You’ve Been, You Won’t Know Where You’re Going Many Municipalities Have Too Much Liquidity (But Your Risk is Asymmetrical)

Cash Flow Model: Daily for 12 Months Monthly for 5 Years Worry About the Big Rocks (80/20 Rule) Excel is Awesome!

You Have a Responsible Amount of Liquidity to Ensure You Don’t Need

to Sell a Security for Liquidity

Page 7: Introduction - CSMFO

6

Cash Flow Model…Excel is Awesome!

Page 8: Introduction - CSMFO

7

Cash Flows May Not Repeat Exactly…But Usually Rhyme

Page 9: Introduction - CSMFO

8

Knowing the Rhyme Helps Match Assets with Liabilities

Page 10: Introduction - CSMFO

9

Different Operating Portfolio Strategies/Structures

Page 11: Introduction - CSMFO

10

Habit #2

You Have a Responsible Amount of Interest Rate Risk and Credit Risk

Page 12: Introduction - CSMFO

11

Interest Rate Risk

Which Risk Has the Largest Long-Term

Impact on My Investment Income?

Credit Risk

Page 13: Introduction - CSMFO

12

Optimal Operating Fund Duration: Risk Adjusted Return

(Avg Yield – Risk Free Yield) / Avg Duration = MSR

(3.35% 2y – 2.78% 3m) / 1.90 2y = .299

3.35% 2yr / 4.52% 10yr = 74% 1.90 2Yr / 7.96 10Yr = 24% Yield Comparison Duration Comparison Source: Bloomberg

Page 14: Introduction - CSMFO

13

Year Weighted Avg Maturity vs. 2 Year Weighted Avg Maturity

Page 15: Introduction - CSMFO

14

1 Year WAM vs. 2 Year WAM: A Long View of Returns

Source: Bloomberg

Page 16: Introduction - CSMFO

15

The Worry of Skyrocketing Interest Rates??

Page 17: Introduction - CSMFO

16

Real World Shorter Duration vs. Longer Duration #1

Page 18: Introduction - CSMFO

17

Real World Shorter Duration vs. Longer Duration #1

Page 19: Introduction - CSMFO

18

Before/After: Implementing a Asset/Liability Matching Strategy

Page 20: Introduction - CSMFO

19

You Have a Responsible Amount of Interest Rate Risk

Page 21: Introduction - CSMFO

20

CREDIT

Page 22: Introduction - CSMFO

21

Is Credit Worth the Risk?

Source: Bloomberg

Page 23: Introduction - CSMFO

22

Is Credit Worth the Risk?

$1,000,000,000 x 45% Credit Exposure x 40 BPs Avg Spread = $1,800,000/Yr Investment Income

Source: Bloomberg

Page 24: Introduction - CSMFO

23

One-Year Default Rates

Page 25: Introduction - CSMFO

24

Cumulative Default Rates

Page 26: Introduction - CSMFO

25

Composite Credit Rating

Page 27: Introduction - CSMFO

26

Credit Risk Tools

Source: Bloomberg

Page 28: Introduction - CSMFO

27

Habit #3

You Don’t Try to Time the Market

Page 29: Introduction - CSMFO

28

Forecasting

“The only function of economic (and interest rate) forecasting is to make astrology look respectable." John Kenneth Galbraith, Economist

"The Federal Reserve is currently not forecasting a recession.”Ben Bernanke (former Fed Chair), January 10, 2008

“Our ability to forecast is limited”.CNBC November 2019

Source: Google

Page 30: Introduction - CSMFO

29

Fooled By Randomness

“Generate a long series of coin flips producing heads and tails with 50% odds each and fill up sheets of paper. If the series is long enough you may get eight heads or eight tails in a row, perhaps even ten of each. Yet you know that in spite of these wins the conditional odds of getting a head or a tail is still 50%.”

Page 31: Introduction - CSMFO

30

It’s Tough to Time the Stock Market

Page 32: Introduction - CSMFO

31

It’s Tough to Time the Bond Market

Page 33: Introduction - CSMFO

32

Oops!

Oct 2018

May 2019

Source: Bloomberg

Page 34: Introduction - CSMFO

33

Security Type Selection for Different Strategies

Securities to Match Cash Outflows: Bullets ABS Credit Card (soft bullets) Floating Rate Notes

Securities to Market Time: Bullets Paydowns (ABS/MBS/SBA) Floating Rate Notes Callables Step-Ups/Step-Downs Bond Mutual Funds Floating NAV Funds (Remove Preservation of Principal

from the Investment Policy?)

Page 35: Introduction - CSMFO

34

Effective Duration: Agency 1-5Yr Bullets vs. 1-5Yr Callables

Effe

ctiv

e D

ura

tio

n

1-5 Yr Agency Bullet Index

1-5 Yr Agency Callable Index

Brexit

Source: Bloomberg

Page 36: Introduction - CSMFO

35

Average Prices: 1-5Yr Callables vs. 1-5Yr Bullets

Avg

Pri

ce

100

1-5 Yr Bullets

1-5 Yr Callables

Source: Bloomberg

Page 37: Introduction - CSMFO

36

Total Return: 2000-2019 1-5Yr Callables vs. 1-5Yr Bullets

1-5 Yr Bullets

1-5 Yr Callables

Avg Effective Duration: Bullets 2.33 Callables 1.48

194.55% – 164.78% = 29.77%Or 1.65% Per Year from 2000-2019

Pe

rce

nt

Tota

l Re

turn

Source: Bloomberg

Page 38: Introduction - CSMFO

37

Total Return: 2000-2019 1-5Yr Callables vs. 1-3Yr Bullets

1-3 Yr Bullets

1-5 Yr Callables

Avg Effective Duration: Bullets 1.78 Callables 1.48

179.08% – 164.78% = 14.3%Or .79% Per Year from 2000-2019

Pe

rce

nt

Tota

l Re

turn

Source: Bloomberg

Page 39: Introduction - CSMFO

38

What If Your Timing Was Awesome!

Brexit Low .89%

Powell Hawkish High 3.10%

5Yr

Yie

ld

Source: Bloomberg

Page 40: Introduction - CSMFO

39

Awesome Timing: 1-3Yr Bullets vs. 1-5Yr Callables Total Return

Pe

rce

nt

Tota

l Re

turn

101.108% – 100.833% = .275%Or Only .12% Per Year from 2016-2018

1-5 Yr Callables

1-3 Yr Bullets

Source: Bloomberg

Page 41: Introduction - CSMFO

40

“Why Would I Buy a 5Yr When the 3Mo is the Same or Higher?”

Source: Bloomberg

Page 42: Introduction - CSMFO

41

Fed Funds…Not a Lot of Runway Left for the Next Recession

Source: Bloomberg

Page 43: Introduction - CSMFO

42

Habit #4

You Love Losses and Hate Gains(the unrealized kind)

Page 44: Introduction - CSMFO

43

Source: Google

Page 45: Introduction - CSMFO

44

The “Bad News” of “Good News”

Page 46: Introduction - CSMFO

45

Creating a Stable’r Investment Income

Page 47: Introduction - CSMFO

46

Habit #5

You Follow GAAP(Generally Accepted Accounting Principles)

Page 48: Introduction - CSMFO

47

#5: You Follow GAAP (Generally Accepted Accounting Principles)

If you are not amortizing, when will you recognize the $100,000 gain (income)?

You Amortize

Involves More Work: Monthly Journal Entries Custodians’ Amortization Methodology May Not Match Your Investment Accounting System

Participant $$$ In

Participant $$$ Out

Bond MaturesPurchase Bond

Source: Bloomberg

Page 49: Introduction - CSMFO

48

Not Amortizing Premiums: Overstating Income

Page 50: Introduction - CSMFO

49

You Distribute Inv Income on an Accrual Basis…Not a Cash Basis

Page 51: Introduction - CSMFO

50

Habit #6

You Benchmark Your Investment Program and Portfolio in Multiple Ways

Page 52: Introduction - CSMFO

51

GIOA Model Investment Policy Primary Objectives

1. Safety of Principal: Safety of principal is the foremost objective of the [entity’s]investment program. Investments by the [designated official] shall be undertaken in amanner that seeks to ensure the preservation of capital in the overall portfolio. To attainthis objective, diversification of security types, sectors, issuers, and maturities is necessaryin order that potential losses on individual securities do not exceed the income generatedfrom the remainder of the portfolio.

2. Liquidity: The investment portfolio shall be structured to timely meet expected cashoutflow needs and associated obligations which might be reasonably anticipated. Thisobjective shall be achieved by matching investment maturities with forecasted cashoutflows and maintaining an additional liquidity buffer for unexpected liabilities.

3. Investment Income: The investment portfolio shall be designed to earn a market rateof investment income in relation to prevailing budgetary and economic cycles, whiletaking into account investment risk constraints and liquidity needs of the portfolio.

Investment Portfolios are the Only Area Which Provide Revenue to Your Entity Without Charging Taxes or Fees to Your Citizens

Page 53: Introduction - CSMFO

52

Benchmarking Your Investment Plan: Suitable vs. Legal

Page 54: Introduction - CSMFO

53

CFA Institute: Characteristics of Useful Performance Benchmarks

A benchmark is a collection of securities or risk factors and associated weights that

represents the persistent and prominent investment characteristics of a manager's

investment process. A benchmark should be:

• Unambiguous: The identities and weights of securities constituting the benchmark are clearly defined.

• Investable: It is possible to forgo active management and simply hold the benchmark.

• Measurable: The benchmark's return is readily calculable on a reasonably frequent basis.

• Appropriate: The benchmark is consistent with the manager's investment style and sectors.

• Specified in Advance: The benchmark is specified prior to the start of an evaluation period and known to all interested parties.

“The failure of a benchmark to possess these properties compromises its utility as an effective investment management tool. The properties listed merely

formalize intuitive notions of what constitutes a fair and relevant performance comparison. It is interesting to observe that a number of commonly used

benchmarks fail to satisfy these properties.” CFA Institute

Page 55: Introduction - CSMFO

54

Important Benchmark Characteristics

To Be Relevant, Benchmarks Should Reflect the General Characteristics of a Portfolio’s:

Sector Allocations Duration/Maturity Turnover

Three Types of Benchmarking:

Weighted Yield Book Rate of Return Total Rate of Return

Page 56: Introduction - CSMFO

55

Performance Benchmarking

Page 57: Introduction - CSMFO

56

Book Return vs. Total Return

Source: Bloomberg

Page 58: Introduction - CSMFO

57

Book Return vs. Total Return

3.5

4.0

4.5

5.0

5.5

6.0

6.5

7.0

7.5

8.0

Pe

rce

nt

Yie

ld

2 Year T-Note Yield

4.23%

5.15%

7.70%

Source: Bloomberg

Page 59: Introduction - CSMFO

58

Long Run: Total Return and Book Return…Basically Equal

0.8%99.2%

100.0%

% of Total Return

Source: Bloomberg

Page 60: Introduction - CSMFO

59

1-5 Year Tsy/Agy Index Yield History

Yie

ld

Start1988

End2019

Source: Bloomberg

Page 61: Introduction - CSMFO

60

2016: A Volatile Total Return Year

Source: Bloomberg

Page 62: Introduction - CSMFO

61

A Real World Example

Page 63: Introduction - CSMFO

62

Habit #7

You Provide Quality, Timely, Transparent Reporting

Page 64: Introduction - CSMFO

63

Clearly Communicating Information to Your Audiences

• Know Your Audiences: • Governing Body• Management• Auditors• Rating Agencies• GFOA (CAFR)• Peers• Taxpayers

• Be Completely Transparent

• Keep it Simple – Charts/Graphs/Tables

• Provide Details to the Appropriate Audiences

• Demonstrate How the Investment Portfolio is Meeting Objectives

Page 65: Introduction - CSMFO

64

"When performance is measured, performance improves. When performance is measured and reported, the rate of improvement accelerates.“ Thomas S. Monson

Your Investment Report Should Be on Your Website

Page 66: Introduction - CSMFO

65

City of Los Angeles…Best Practice Example

Page 67: Introduction - CSMFO

66

Page 68: Introduction - CSMFO

67

You Have a Repeatable, Structured Process Based Upon:

2 Things We Know Well and 1 We Don’t:

Longer Duration Provides Higher Returns Over the Long Run

Your Cash Flows Don’t Always Repeat, But They Usually Really Rhyme

Your Can’t Time the Market

Page 69: Introduction - CSMFO

68

Page 70: Introduction - CSMFO

69

Disclosure

Although this information has been obtained from sources which we believe to be reliable, we do not guarantee its accuracy, and it may be incomplete orcondensed. This is for informational purposes only and is not intended as an offer or solicitation with respect to the purchase or sale of any security. Allherein listed securities are subject to availability and change in price. Past performance is not indicative of future results, and changes in any assumptionsmay have a material effect on projected results. Ratings on all securities are subject to change.

FHN Financial Capital Markets, FHN Financial Portfolio Advisors, and FHN Financial Municipal Advisors are divisions of First Horizon Bank. FHN FinancialSecurities Corp., FHN Financial Main Street Advisors, LLC, and FHN Financial Capital Assets Corp. are wholly owned subsidiaries of First Horizon Bank. FHNFinancial Securities Corp. is a member of FINRA and SIPC — http://www.sipc.org/.SIPC.

FHN Financial Municipal Advisors is a registered municipal advisor. FHN Financial Portfolio Advisors is a portfolio manager operating under the trust powersof First Horizon Bank. FHN Financial Main Street Advisors, LLC is a registered investment advisor. None of the other FHN entities, including FHN FinancialCapital Markets, FHN Financial Securities Corp., or FHN Financial Capital Assets Corp. are acting as your advisor, and none owe a fiduciary duty under thesecurities laws to you, any municipal entity, or any obligated person with respect to, among other things, the information and material contained in thiscommunication. Instead, these FHN entities are acting for their own interests. You should discuss any information or material contained in thiscommunication with any and all internal or external advisors and experts that you deem appropriate before acting on this information or material.

FHN Financial, through First Horizon Bank or its affiliates, offers investment products and services. Investment products are not FDIC insured, have no bankguarantee, and may lose value.