Dairy Science Park - Blueprint

Innovative Development Approaches for Livestock and Dairy Development in KP and

Balochistan

www.dairysciencepark.org.pk

1

2

ProposedCurrent

The Development Approach

3

Total value Rs.1000 bAn meat prod Rs.200 b

• Entrepreneurship contribution???• Hygienic food production ????

The Issue

4

• Animal transportation ?• Products processing ?• Formal investment ?

• Traceability of products ???• QC certification ????

Cherries Peach

Dates

Guvava

Fruits & Vegetables

•Pesticides

•QC

•Processing

•Packaging

•Exports???

•Entrepreneurship??

Vegetables 5

Institutional focus

• Livestock Extension, health coverage

• Livestock Research, vaccine and diagnosis

• Livestock Education, veterinary medicine

• Agric Extension/Research, Crops Production & Mngt

• Deputy Commissioner, price capping, no QC

• Legal courts, price capping, no QC

• SMEDA, little attempts

• KPCCI, low priority

• Public health, low priority

• ORIC Offices of Universities, underutilized

• Entrepreneurship/exports, missing

• Hygienic/Halal concepts, missing

• QC Control/Traceability, missing

6

7

The Dairy Science Park ApproachA

cad

em

ia –

Ind

ustr

y –

Go

vern

men

t

Inte

rven

tio

n

2011, IW-DSP-I, Peshawar

2013, IW-DSP-II, Peshawar

8

2015, IW-DSP-III, Peshawar

2017, IW-DSP-IV, Konya

9

2015 - Amsterdam

Sandia National Laboratory

USDS agreed on Biorisk

Management Collaboration

2016 - Dubai

Sandia National Laboratory-

Dairy Science Park BRM

Workshop

10

2016 - Bangkok

SNL-DSP Workshop on

BRM Curriculum

Development

2017 - Phuket

SNL-DSP BRM

Workshop on public

health awareness

11

2017 - Colombo

SNL-DSP Workshop on

BRM integration into DVM

Curriculum

2018 - Amman

SNL-DSP Workshop on

BRM techniques in

Research Methodologies

12

2014

Minister Agric inaugurated

Livestock Desk at KPCCI

2014

Univ Feed Mill

functionalized

13

2016

MoU on Collaborative BRM

Initiative between KMU, UAP,

DSP and HEC

2017

MoU on BRM and Women

Entrepreneurship between

WUM, DSP and HED

14

• Minister LGE&RD chaired a high level meeting and agreed on establishing

Task Force on Dairy Science Park; approved Rs.200 m for Slaughter-house

• Additional Chief Secretary appreciated DSP as “the innovative idea of the LG

regarding establishment of Dairy Science Park at Peshawar to provide hygienic

food production to the whole province

• Chief Minister KP approved Task Force for DSP on 2-8-2018; notification

pending at Agriculture Department

15

(Committed for youth entrepreneurship and hygienic food production in KP, FATA and the adjoining regions of Afghanistan and China in partnership with the United Nations)

Prof M Subhan QureshiChief Organizer DSP/

Dean FAHVS UAP

16

17

UN SDG Action 9671

DSP Community

Center Chamkani

18

19

20

21

Dairy entrepreneurship

models

• Dairy/meat Farming

• Elite animals production

• Feed production

• Silage making

• Pharmaceuticals prod

• Training and consultancy

• Diagnostic labs

• Clinics

• Dairy Processing

• Products marking

22

23

24

25

Quails Entrepreneurship

models

•Broiler farming

•Quails breeding

•Inputs supplies

•Meat processing

•Biotech Products

•Diagnostic/QC labs

•Packaging/marketing

26

Jan Meat Shop

27

28

Peshawar

Meat

29

Academia Industries

Linkages

• Applied Research

• Industrial Linkages

• Best Teachers

Award

Socioeconomic

impact

• Business

incubation

• Entrepreneurship

development

• Exportable

surpluses

30

31

Financial Rules• Public Sector Orgs bound to followPublic Procurement Regulatory Authority Ordinance,

2002 (XXII of 2002).

1. Clause 21, the Public Procurement Rules, 2004, Open competitive bidding.

2. Under Clause 30, Evaluation of bids.- (2) For the purposes of comparison of bids quoted

in different currencies, the price shall be converted into a single currency specified in the

bidding documents.

3. Clause 30, Sub-clause (2), the rules calls for comparison of the items on the

basis of cost.

Consultant’s comments

1. Suppliers offer lower prices; Lower price means lower quality of items.

2. Cheaper animal feeds, medicines or other inputs; adverse effects on animals’

health, reproduction, productivity and public health.

3. Enhanced farm expenditures.

4. The purchase committees suffer audit paras and NAB proceedings for

purchasing items with better quality with somewhat higher prices.

32

The Proposal

1. Under Clause 5. International and inter-governmental commitments of the Federal

Government. –

2. Whenever these rules are in conflict with an obligation or commitment of the Federal

Government arising out of an international treaty or an agreement …… the provisions of

such international treaty or agreement shall prevail to the extent of such conflict.

3. Under the above clause the Consultant concludes that procurement process on the

basis of PPRA Rules results in purchase of low quality animal feeds, medicines and

other input supplies in the extension organizations; low quality research materials at

the research/extension organizations and low quality delayed supplies at the

Universities.

4. It hinders the smooth delivery of services by the public service organizations , lowering

the trust and expectations of the people.

5. Hence, the National Consultant FAO-UN considers the PPRA Rules as a contradiction

with the interests of stakeholders of livestock value chain. and under Clause 5 and

suggests formulation of new rules within the following guidelines:

33

FAO Guidelines for procurement and sales rules

1. The Rules must be simple, transparent and must ensure quick delivery of goods.

2. The purchase committee for a functioning Unit of an organization shall comprise 2

senior officers and a person from the industry/civil society, with delegation of

powers to purchase the desired items.

3. The purchase committee for an Organization would comprise three senior most

officer one member of industry/civil society and one independent auditor.

4. An Endowment Fund would be available in an authorized bank account.

5. Three quotation may be obtained, if required.

6. The Rules must be followed while reviewing, ordering, obtaining, and paying for

goods/services.

7. Checkpoints/steps must be minimum to avoid the complexity of the purchase

process.

8. The Funds available to the organization shall be non-lapsable.

9. The bill shall be passed by the chairman of the committee within 3 days in case of

a Unit and within 10 days in case of an Organization.

10.Transparency of the process shall be monitored by an M&E Committee.

Accessibility of records would be ensured to the relevant accountability

organization. No member of the purchase committee would be harassed by the

audit parties, NAB or senior officials/elected peoples’ representatives.

34

Innovative approach for L&DD

Balochistan

35

Edu

cati

on

Demand based DVM, Agribusiness, Industrial Biotech dairy/meat tech, ICT, Solar Tech, Food Tech, Corporate Farming, Biorisk Management, Wool/Hides and Skins

Accredited-PVMCUnfriendly PVMC and Univ

adminAdvice PVMC and Univ admin to utilize

resource base

Business Incubation Unfriendly account systemPPRA Rules, Clause 5 conflicts with FAO

Opinion prevails, BICs est

Outreach Conflict of interests FAO approach for coordination, DSP Entrepreneurship Cycle, QC, Export

Stakeholders Protection Advocacy Forum Legal, admin, financial, marketing support

36

Res

earc

h

Diagnostic and research network

Accurate, Rapid, Cheap solutions

Sustainable, fiscally, socially

Students internship Skilled manpower available Confident and productive citizens

Collaborative postgraduate research

Academic solutions to industrial issues

Emergence of entrepreneurship models

Farming innovations and recording

Reducing farm costs, improving products quality

Elite animals stocks available, investment models available

Vaccine/biotech production

Academic ideas transformation into actions

An export oriented network of entrepreneurs

37x

Exte

nsi

on

Veterinary hospitals/AI Centers/Mobile clinics

Business support to farmers; health coverage; disease

eradicationRegistration of SMEs, indoor treatments

Livestock/poultry/fodders Farms

Breed conservation; Developing feasible models

Supply of elite animal, semen, fodder seeds, etc/demo models

Training Institutes Training of staff, farmers, butchers, others

Demonstration of entrepreneurship models

Planning, Development and Legislation

Infrastructural and capacity development

Enhanced institutional capacity to respond to commercialization challenges

Marketing support services Demo milk/meat shops

Products processing factoriesAn export oriented network of

entrepreneurs

38x

Ind

ust

ry

Farmers AssociationsFarmers issues highlighting, linkages

with public sector organizations; parliamentarians approach

Farmers supported in legislative, marketing and technical issues

Processors AssociationsProcessors issues highlighting;

linkages with producers and service providers

Supply of elite animal, semen, fodder seeds, etc/demo models

Entrepreneurship AssociationsEntrepreneurs issues highlighting;

business incubation; export linkages; Islamic financing

Production of traceable exportable surpluses

BCCI National and international linkages International Halal Food Trade

SMEDA Capacity development and linkages An export oriented network of entrepreneurs

Dairy Science Park - Blueprint

Innovative Development Approaches for Livestock and Dairy Development in KP and

Balochistan

www.dairysciencepark.org.pk

39

40

Quetta Technopark

Academia – Biz Incubation

Exte

nsio

n a

nd

Resea

rch

Indu

stry

/Civ

il Socie

ty

Halal Food Export

Thanks