improving services of anganwadi centres & increasing its...
TRANSCRIPT
Improving Services of
Anganwadi Centres &
Increasing its Reach
Jovie Katticaran
PGDM, IIM Kozhikode
Submitted on 31st March, 2012
Improving Services of Anganwadi Centres & Increasing its Reach Page | 2
Jovie Katticaran, PGDM IIM Kozhikode [email protected] Page 2
Acknowledgements
I would like to thank Dr Ruby Singh, the CDPO of the Fulvarishariff Project, for taking the time to
answer all my questions, taking me around the Anganwadi centres, showing me the required
documents and making my life a whole lot easier. I’m also in debt to the supervisors Anju and
Kanchan whom I accompanied on surprise visits and who showed me the activities happening at the
centres.
I would like to thank the Director of ICDS Bihar, Mr Praveen Kishore and Ms Abha Prasad, Monitoring
Officer who gave me this opportunity to work with ICDS Bihar.
Last but not the least, my gratitude to all the kids who patiently tolerated me while I took my snaps
and questioned them on what they had studied.
Jovie Katticaran
Improving Services of Anganwadi Centres & Increasing its Reach Page | 3
Jovie Katticaran, PGDM IIM Kozhikode [email protected] Page 3
Table of Contents Acknowledgements ........................................................................................................................... 2
Introduction ...................................................................................................................................... 4
Improving Service Delivery ................................................................................................................ 4
Problem of Monitoring .................................................................................................................. 5
Implementing a Monitoring System ........................................................................................... 7
Adequate Number of Supervisors for Inspections ...................................................................... 8
Improving the Reporting System ................................................................................................ 8
Community Participation ........................................................................................................... 9
Surprise Checks & Punitive Actions against Defaulters ............................................................... 9
Creating an Environment of Learning ............................................................................................. 9
Improving Housing Facilities & Renting Premises Away From Residences of Sevikas................. 10
Toilets & Other Facilities .......................................................................................................... 12
Selection & Training of Anganwadi workers ................................................................................. 13
Selection from examination ..................................................................................................... 14
Regular tests and continuing education ................................................................................... 16
Selection of Eligible Students ....................................................................................................... 16
Criteria to be Maintained while Selecting Students .................................................................. 17
Universalising the Program .............................................................................................................. 18
Advantages & Disadvantages of Having a Ceiling on Number of Students ................................ 18
Maintaining Teacher-Student Ratio.......................................................................................... 18
Housing needs ......................................................................................................................... 19
Phased Approach to Universalisation ........................................................................................... 19
Conclusions ..................................................................................................................................... 20
Improving Services of Anganwadi Centres & Increasing its Reach Page | 4
Jovie Katticaran, PGDM IIM Kozhikode [email protected] Page 4
Introduction The Integrated Child Development Services Scheme (ICDS) was launched on 2nd Oct, 1975. It is the
world’s largest programme for early childhood development. The ICDS has 5 objectives which are
1. To improve the nutritional health status of children in the age group of 0-6 years
2. To lay the foundation for proper psychological, physical and social development of the child
3. To reduce the incidence of morbidity, mortality, malnutrition and school dropout
4. To achieve effective coordination of policy and implementation amongst various
departments to promote child development
5. To enhance the capability of the mother to look after the normal health and nutritional
needs of the child through proper nutrition and health education.
The above objectives are achieved through the following services
1. Supplementary nutrition
2. Immunization
3. Health check-up
4. Referral services
5. Pre-school non-formal education
6. Nutrition & health education
This report deals with improving the pre-school, non-formal education currently being provided to
students in the age group of 3-6 years. The pre-school centres are called Anganwadi centres and are
run by an Anganwadi worker called the Sevika and her helper called the Sahayika.
Each district in Bihar is divided into smaller administrative units called Projects. The Anganwadi
centres in a project are looked after by a Child Development Project Officer (CDPO) assisted by a
number of supervisors. My work revolves around the 192 Anganwadi centres in the Fulvarishariff
Project under the administration of Dr Ruby Singh, the CDPO of the area.
Improving Service Delivery The Anganwadi centres are run for 4 hours from 8AM -12PM. Each centre has 40 students who are
taught to recite rhymes, count and learn the alphabets. The Sevika and Sahayika provide snacks in
the morning and a nutritious meal every day.
Apart from teaching, these centres also seek to improve the nutrition levels of children. Children
with malnutrition are given special care. Children who are in Grade 3 & Grade 4 levels of
malnutrition are sent to clinics where they are looked after for a month along with their mother.
These pre-school centres also place emphasis on hygiene and sanitation. The centres encourage
students to enrol in a primary school after their pre-school education and maintain records of
students who have later enrolled in schools and those who have sadly dropped out.
However, many centres do not function properly and are a far cry from a model pre-school. This
report looks at improving the services offered by the Anganwadi centres.
Improving Services of Anganwadi Centres & Increasing its Reach Page | 5
Jovie Katticaran, PGDM IIM Kozhikode [email protected] Page 5
Problem of Monitoring
The Anganwadis are located at varying distances from the CDPO office. At Fulvarishariff, there are
192 centres being monitored by 1 CDPO officer and 6 supervisors. Monitoring 192 centres is no easy
task as many of these are located in areas which are not easily accessible and have no tarred roads
leading to them. These centres are also devoid of IT systems and surveillance technology. It is
therefore impossible for the CDPO officer to monitor the working of the centre everyday and to
ensure its regular functioning.
The problems that ensue from lack of monitoring are rampant across the centres. A round of
surprise visits threw up a host of irregularities – absenteeism of the Anganwadi workers and their
helpers, high absenteeism of children, insufficient and in one instance no food being prepared for
the afternoon meal, fudging of attendance registers, take-home rations not being distributed etc.
Photo 1: Surprise Visit to Centre Photo 2: Children being seated in order
Photos 3 & 4: Insufficient food made for the children. Sadly too less for the 20 students present
Improving Services of Anganwadi Centres & Increasing its Reach Page | 6
Jovie Katticaran, PGDM IIM Kozhikode [email protected] Page 6
Photos 5&6: Attendance registers being fudged. The Sevika uses a ‘.’ to mark absent students which she later changes to a ‘I’ to claim that students were present. She then claims finances for feeding more students than she actually has.
Improving Services of Anganwadi Centres & Increasing its Reach Page | 7
Jovie Katticaran, PGDM IIM Kozhikode [email protected] Page 7
The following measures have been proposed to improve the monitoring system currently present.
Implementing a Monitoring System
Seva Mandir, an NGO in Rajasthan, along with J-PAL has come up with a very interesting approach to
monitor primary school teachers to ensure that they come to class. Primary school teachers have
been provided with digital cameras with which they take a photograph of themselves along with
their students twice a day with a gap of 5 hours between the 2 photos. The photographs, which have
the date and time stamp, are checked at the end of the month. The date and time functions of the
camera are sealed and are tamper proof. If at the end of the month, the teachers show 2 photos for
every working day, they earn a financial incentive. It is therefore, in the interest of the primary
school teacher to ensure that she comes to class regularly to earn this financial incentive. This
approach only encourages the teacher to come to class. It does not help monitor the quality of the
learning experience being provided by the teacher in the classroom.
The camera approach to monitoring can be applied to Anganwadi centres as well. Each worker can
be given a camera and taught how to use it. A seal should make the date and time functions of the
camera tamper proof. The workers could then be instructed to take a picture of themselves along
with the children every day. The photograph could even show the worker and helper serving the
afternoon meal to the students. Once a month, when the supervisors visit the centres to collect the
Monthly Progress Report which is currently being done, they could check the camera for a
photograph with a date corresponding to each day of the working of the Anganwadi. The payment of
a component of the workers’ salary could depend on showing the required set of photographs with
the corresponding dates.
Finances Required
The finances are calculated for a centre like Fulvarishariff which has about 200 centres under its
jurisdiction. The digital cameras can be combined with online technology that helps the district
office view the photographs as soon as they are clicked. The calculations beneath are done for a
basic monitoring model in which the supervisors check the camera once a month.
Initial investment Cost in Rs
200 Nos Basic model digital camera @ Rs 5000 each
1000000
Yearly investment Maintenance cost of 10% of camera price per camera per year
100000
The initial capital expenditure would be around 1 million INR. These cameras from reputed brands
like Sony, Kodak would normally come along with a warranty of 3 years. However, we take a
Improving Services of Anganwadi Centres & Increasing its Reach Page | 8
Jovie Katticaran, PGDM IIM Kozhikode [email protected] Page 8
conservative approach and estimate an annual maintenance cost of Rs 500 per camera every year.
Therefore, the yearly investments would be INR 0.1 million a year.
Adequate Number of Supervisors for Inspections
The number of supervisors could be increased to ensure that every centre is visited twice a month.
Calculation Quantity
No of centres 1 supervisor can visit a day 3 3 No of centre visits carried out by 1 supervisor in a month with 25 working days. We assume she has to remain in the office for 8 days out of the 25 days to complete office/paper work
=3*17 54
No of centres to be covered 200 No of visits required to cover each centre twice a month =200*2 400 No of supervisors required =400/54 =
7.4 8
Thus, a district like Fulvarishariff would require the services of 8 supervisors. It currently has 6
supervisors and does not seem to face a deficit of manpower. However, only recently was the
district assigned 6 supervisors and a few months before this report was made, the district used to
function with only 1 supervisor.
Thus, a district with around 200 centres would need 8 supervisors working in the area. A supervisor
can barely visit 3 centres a day as the centres are open only for 4 hours ( from 8-12 AM ) and has to
cover the distances between centres.
Improving the Reporting System
In the system currently being followed, the supervisors give a report of their inspections at the end
of the month. Immediate action against Anganwadis that are flagrantly flouting rules are delayed as
a result of this procedure. Another problem that seems to arise is when Anganwadi workers who
were absent during the inspection, realise that an inspection had been carried out; they cajole the
supervisors into changing the report in their favour. To prevent this from happening, one suggestion
by Dr Ruby Singh, CDPO of Fulvarishariff, was to instantly report the status of centres during the
inspection in the form of an SMS. Thus, the CDPO can quickly scan through the SMS at the end of the
day and immediately take action against the Centres that are not performing up to expectations. The
SMS would also have to correlate with the report made by the Supervisors at the end of the month
and thus the Anganwadi workers would not be able to influence the report after the inspection has
taken place.
A messaging format would have to be made for the SMS reporting so that it is easy for the
supervisors to type out a simple text message that still clearly gives an overview of the status of the
Anganwadi centre. All supervisors currently have in possession a mobile phone and therefore, no
extra investment needs to be made for this instantaneous reporting.
Improving Services of Anganwadi Centres & Increasing its Reach Page | 9
Jovie Katticaran, PGDM IIM Kozhikode [email protected] Page 9
Community Participation
A lot can be achieved if the community, the beneficiaries of the ICDS program, can be encouraged to
participate in the functioning of the Anganwadi centre. The Bachpan Devas celebrated every
Saturday where the parents of the students are invited to come to the Centre goes a long way in
getting the community involved. The social audit that has started being introduced is a prime
example of how the community can be vigilant and can ensure that the rations of rice and wheat
allotted to them aren’t being siphoned away.
As the community becomes aware of the benefits of the Anganwadis centres, they will also be
vigilant against malpractices that may be carried out by Sevikas and Sahayikas. This would ensure
that these centres follow fixed, regular routines, function for 4 hours and feed children their daily
meals.
Surprise Checks & Punitive Actions against Defaulters
Surprise checks must be carried out every month so that the Anganwadi centres realise that at any
point of time there might be an inspection. An analysis should be done on centres that are not faring
well to understand the reason for such dismal performance. When cases of siphoning of funds by
workers or Sevikas come up, punitive action should be swift so that they are made an example to the
rest of the Anganwadi personnel.
Creating an Environment of Learning
The Anganwadi centres are a precursor to primary schools and teach students in the age group of 3-
6 years rhymes, alphabets, numbers and offer them nutritious food. This is also the point of first
contact for students with formal teaching, activities in a classroom and learning along with their
peers. These centres should have an environment conducive to learning. A child that enjoys going to
these centres would also look forward to going to a primary school.
Improving Services of Anganwadi Centres & Increasing its Reach Page | 10
Jovie Katticaran, PGDM IIM Kozhikode [email protected] Page 10
Improving Housing Facilities & Renting Premises Away From Residences of Sevikas
Housing facilities for most centres are currently inadequate. The most pressing problem seems to be
finding a classroom with sufficient space for 40 students. Many centres are cramped with 40
students expected to sit in a room meant for 20. Urban centres are paid Rs 750 a month and rural
centres Rs 200 a month towards rent for premises. The current amount of Rs 200 being paid to
Anganwadi workers who are not in urban areas is grossly insufficient. Semi-urban areas where the
rents are closer to those of urban areas , but are given only Rs 200 a month seem to face the brunt
of this situation.
Due to insufficient funds, many of the workers resort to holding the classes in their houses.
However, it becomes a Herculean task to monitor workers who work from their houses. These
workers spend a large portion of their work time doing household chores. It also becomes difficult
to monitor if the rations of rice and wheat are being given to the beneficiaries or are being
consumed by the Sevika household itself. Sevikas should therefore be encouraged to rent premises
at a distance of 1-2kms from their house. The rent allocated for premises should be increased in
semi-urban areas or steps should be taken by the CDPO or DPO office to find premises suitable to
house 40 students.
Photo 7: Centre in need of repair
Improving Services of Anganwadi Centres & Increasing its Reach Page | 11
Jovie Katticaran, PGDM IIM Kozhikode [email protected] Page 11
Photos 8 & 9: Children being taught along with cattle in the cattle shed. Cattle were hastily removed when we arrived for the inspection
Improving Services of Anganwadi Centres & Increasing its Reach Page | 12
Jovie Katticaran, PGDM IIM Kozhikode [email protected] Page 12
Is it possible to sublet premises during non-class hours?
One solution to the rents being insufficient to cover the cost of renting suitable premises would be
to sublet the premises in the evenings for other community activities. For instance, the classroom
can be rented out to conduct adult literacy programmes which usually take place in the evenings. In
this manner, by subletting premises for other community activities, rent being paid could be much
lower than the actual rent needed.
Toilets & Other Facilities
None of the centres visited had toilets. Children had to defecate in the open in nearby areas and this
created an unhygienic environment. The Anganwadis can be an excellent starting point for students
to be taught cleanliness, hygiene and basic sanitation.
In many cases, children had to sit through the searing heat with temperatures soaring up to 46
degrees Celsius in rooms that had no electricity and very little ventilation. During the summer
months can class timings be shifted to early mornings or evenings when the temperatures are not as
high?
Photo 10: Child defecating outside the centre for lack of toilets
Improving Services of Anganwadi Centres & Increasing its Reach Page | 13
Jovie Katticaran, PGDM IIM Kozhikode [email protected] Page 13
Photo 11: Dark room with barely any light for the students to learn and play in this Anganwadi Centre
Selection & Training of Anganwadi workers
On my visits to Anganwadi centres, I was surprised by the marked difference in the abilities and
enthusiasm levels of Sevikas. The centres that were progressing well had very dedicated Sevikas who
were capable of handling and teaching children. The students at these centres were also more
confident, responded to questions, were eager to recite rhymes and the absenteeism levels were
remarkably low. The students at these centres were also taught about hygiene and came to classes
in uniforms that were clean and washed. Rampant absenteeism marked the centres were Sevikas
were negligent of duties. The students were also unenthusiastic and did not respond to questions.
Improving Services of Anganwadi Centres & Increasing its Reach Page | 14
Jovie Katticaran, PGDM IIM Kozhikode [email protected] Page 14
The hygiene levels at these centres were dismal with students appearing to be wearing unwashed
uniforms and at worst, no uniforms at all.
It would have been an interesting experiment to compare the primary school enrolment
percentages from a well run centre with those of an also ran to see how far a well run centre
encouraged children to go to school. However, due to lack of time, I was not able to carry out this
analysis.
It is therefore essential to have a very capable and educated Sevika who is aware of basic nutrition
and health issues to ensure that the ICDS programme achieves its objectives.
Selection from examination
Currently the Sevikas are selected on the basis of the marks obtained from their 10th grade
examinations with further points being awarded to other criteria - clearing the 12th grade exams,
completing an undergraduate or diploma course. There is also attention being paid to the social
hierarchy the Sevika comes from. The Sevika of a centre in a community is currently selected from
the majority caste dominant in the area.
The current selection procedure ignores the capabilities of Sevikas and pays no attention to their
awareness of nutrition and health based issues. Therefore, an examination could be conducted for
Sevikas where they are tested on basic knowledge levels. This would ensure that the selected
Sevikas have the required knowledge levels to take care of the children.
Improving Services of Anganwadi Centres & Increasing its Reach Page | 15
Jovie Katticaran, PGDM IIM Kozhikode [email protected] Page 15
Photos 12, 13 & 14 A Pilot Anganwadi Selection Test being conducted at Fulvarishariff
Conducting the Anganwadi Examination
The basic criteria for writing the exam would be having cleared the 10th grade exam. There would
therefore be a wide pool of applicants vying to be selected. (For instance, there were 2.6 million
applicants for the Bihar teacher Eligibility Tests through which primary and middle school teachers
are selected for government run schools. )The planning and logistics involved would be a very
expensive affair and would require the involvement of a large number of personnel. Suitable
examination centres would also have to be located and advertisements in the local papers to inform
the population of the examination would also have to be published.
One solution to minimize expenditure on such a large scale would be to conduct the examination for
Anganwadi workers along with the examination for selection of Primary & Secondary School
Improving Services of Anganwadi Centres & Increasing its Reach Page | 16
Jovie Katticaran, PGDM IIM Kozhikode [email protected] Page 16
teachers to the government schools which are currently being conducted in the State (Bihar Teacher
Eligibility Test). There would be a separate page or section within the current examination which the
applicants desirous of Anganwadi posts would have to fill in. The applicants who cleared this exam
would form a pool of meritorious candidates from which Sevikas would be selected with attention
being paid to the distance between the Sevika residence and the Anganwadi centre.
Regular tests and continuing education
To ensure that the Sevikas remain committed to the task at hand and to improve their knowledge
levels, regular tests and training should be conducted for the Sevikas. The results of these tests could
be a clear indictor of the areas in which the knowledge levels are currently lacking and further
training could be given in these areas. Such tests would also ensure that the Sevikas pay attention
during the training modules being given.
Selection of Eligible Students
In the current scheme of the programme, the selection of the 40 students at the Anganwadi centre
is left to the discretion of the Sevika. However, in certain areas, children who reside very close to the
centre and who are from an economically weak background are excluded from the program while
marginally better off students who reside at a distance are selected for the programme. Therefore,
students who are much more in need of the ICDS programme and who are more at risk from low
nutrition levels are sometimes excluded from the programme. The CDPO office should give clear
guidelines on the children to be selected so that the Anganwadi worker does not end up choosing a
skewed sample of students.
Improving Services of Anganwadi Centres & Increasing its Reach Page | 17
Jovie Katticaran, PGDM IIM Kozhikode [email protected] Page 17
Criteria to be Maintained while Selecting Students
While selecting students 2 main criteria should be kept in mind
Risk of Low Nutrition Levels in Child
Distance of residence from Anganwadi centre
Improving Services of Anganwadi Centres & Increasing its Reach Page | 18
Jovie Katticaran, PGDM IIM Kozhikode [email protected] Page 18
First priority should be given to children from families who are very weak economically and are at
very high risk of low levels of nutrition. The Anganwadi worker should select students from the
lowest socio-economic quintile in the community as these children are at higher risk to malnutrition
and deficiency related diseases.
If the ceiling of 40 cannot be completed even after selecting students from this background,
Anganwadi workers should start selecting students from the next lowest socio-economic quintile
and work their way upwards. However, as she works up the list, she should start paying heed to the
distance of student residences from the Anganwadi centre. For instance, if she has to choose
between 2 students , both of the same socio-economic background, higher preference should be
given to the student whose residence is closer to the Anganwadi centre.
Universalising the Program Currently, each centre caters to the needs of forty children in the age group of 3-6 years. This ceiling
excludes a number of eligible children in areas with a dense population. However, a number of
hurdles would have to be overcome to include more students in the ICDS programme
Advantages & Disadvantages of Having a Ceiling on Number of Students
Advantages Disadvantages
Helps ensure a minimum level of quality o A satisfactory teacher-student
ratio in classroom is maintained o 2 workers can look after a fixed
number of students rather than having, for instance 100 students, being neglected by the 2 workers
In areas with a very dense population, many students are left out of this programme
Monitoring becomes easier o The headquarters knows that
every centre has only 40 students
o Every month, it is easy to allocate the same finances for every centre
It would be difficult for the ICDS programme to show any results if it caters only to a very narrow percentage of the population
If Sevikas are allowed to choose all students who are eligible, she might end up fudging accounts and showing children on rolls that are not actually present. An officer would have to go to each centre to verify if all the students on the rolls are actually present
May antagonise community members whose children have not been selected by the ICDS programme
Maintaining Teacher-Student Ratio
The current teacher – student ratio is 1:40. Increasing the number of students in a classroom woud
see a decline in the quality of the teaching since the teacher would have less time to spend on each
Improving Services of Anganwadi Centres & Increasing its Reach Page | 19
Jovie Katticaran, PGDM IIM Kozhikode [email protected] Page 19
student. Thus, in areas where there are another 40 eligible students, a new centre would have to be
setup and staffed with a Sevika and Sahayika. Thus, more Sevikas and Sahayikas would have to be
recruited.
However, it would be inefficient if a new centre had to be opened up in a community where 10-20
eligible students are excluded from the program. The extra 10-20 students could be enrolled in the
existing Anganwadi centre. Such centres with a student- teacher ratio of more than 40:1 should be
assigned 2 Sahayika instead of 1. This would ensure that the Sahayikas can help out and look after
the kids while the Sevika concentrates on teaching.
Housing needs
The ICDS programme faces difficulty in finding premises to run the Anganwadi centres with a sum of
Rs 200 per month (for non-urban areas) spent on renting premises. It might prove to be difficult to
find centres in areas where there already exists an Anganwadi centre. The ideal centre is a
government owned building and in many areas the sole government owned building might have
been rented out for the ICDS programme already. Special attention must be taken to find suitable
premises for both centres.
Phased Approach to Universalisation
To bring more children under the umbrella of the ICDS programme, a phased approach must be
taken
Pick out areas of high density in population and grade them into 4 categories
o Area 1: communities where number of children left out of the programme is close to
20-40 students and where these excluded students do not prefer going to a
privately run nursery school
o Area 2: communities where number of children left out of the programme is close to
40 students and where these excluded students prefer going to a privately run
nursery school
o Area 3: Communities where the number of children excluded from the ICDS
programme is less than 20 and these students do not prefer going to a privately run
nursery school
o Area 4: Communities where the number of children excluded from the ICDS
programme is less than 20 and these students prefer going to a privately run nursery
school
The preference order for universalisation would be in the following order
Improving Services of Anganwadi Centres & Increasing its Reach Page | 20
Jovie Katticaran, PGDM IIM Kozhikode [email protected] Page 20
New centres would be opened up in communities which are earmarked as Area1. New
premises would have to be selected, preferably at a distance from the existing one. A Sevika
and Sahayika would also have to be recruited to run the new centre
In communities earmarked as Area 3, the 10-20 students would be added to the existing
Anganwadi centre and the ceiling would be raised to 60 students. These centres would be
provided an extra Sahayika.
In communities earmarked as Areas 2& 4, even if new centres are opened up, the excluded
students may not join it as they prefer the privately run nursery schools. So unless they show
a willingness to join the ICDS programme, new centres should not be opened up and neither
should the existing ceiling be increased.
Conclusions Anganwadi centres play an important role in the development of a child and are also a precursor to
formal education. More importantly, it fosters a learning environment and encourages children to
enrol in primary schools. The importance of primary education cannot be over-emphasized. Once a
child opts out of primary school, later reintegration into the education system is very difficult in the
country. It also becomes difficult to improve the socio-economic status of the child.
The centres also monitor the nutrition levels of the children. Their mothers are taught the
importance of feeding children nutritious food. The children and their mothers are also given
nutrition supplements like vitamins, iron and folic acid. The cases of severe malnutrition levels
(Grade III and grade IV) have decreased in communities where Anganwadi centres have been
functioning.
However, many centres are a far cry from a model pre-school education. Their services need to be
properly monitored and improved. Rampant siphoning of funds and irregular functioning of the
centres dissuade children from regularly attending the programme. Currently, the reach of the
Anganwadis is also limited and efforts are on to universalise the programme and bring more children
into its fold.
Improving Services of Anganwadi Centres & Increasing its Reach Page | 21
Jovie Katticaran, PGDM IIM Kozhikode [email protected] Page 21