head and neck cancer: a multidisciplinary approach

1
1308 Book Reviews practice. A remarkable distillation of current concepts has been packed into 359 pages. Written by leading experts from North America, Europe, and Australia, most chapters are sufficiently detailed yet remarkably readable. The clinical chapters take the reader from basic concepts to current areas of uncertainty or controversy with great clarity. Both the nonpharmacological and pharmacological management of these problems are handled deftly. Other strengths include high-quality mechanical produc- tion, useful illustrations, generally appropriate references, and sufficiently in-depth coverage for even experts in the field. Deficiencies: The chapter on clinical pharmacology is too brief, superficial, and inadequately referenced. Recommended Readership: This book is a "must" for gastroen- terologists in training because they will routinely encounter pa- tients with these types of disorders in their daily practice. Expe- rienced gastroenterologists may also gain new information by perusing the contents. Physicians in practice, including internists and family practitioners, will enjoy the practical management hints. The book should be included in all major medical libraries and be given a prominent place in gastroenterology units. Overall Grading: ***** Nicholas J. Talley, MD, PhD, University of Sydney, Penrith, New South Wales, Australia Healing Latinos: Realidad y Fantasia; The Art of Cultural Competence in Medicine, edited by David Hayes-Bautista and Roberto Chiprut, 221 pp, $26, 8700 Beverly Blvd, Los Angeles, CA 90048, Cedars-Sinai Health System (telephone: 310-794- 0663), 1998, ISBN 0-96701 00-0-4 Type of Book: A brief multiauthored collection of personal per- spectives on the care of Latino patients. Scope of Book: This small volume presents a series of reflections on the medical care of Latino patients based on the authors' experiences with the large Latino community in the Los Angeles area. Contents: The book consists of 19 short chapters, each written by a professional with experience in caring for Latino patients. The contributors include physicians, clergy, a hospital administrator, and a nutritionist. The introductory chapter presents a definition of culture and provides a brief description of Latino culture in the United States. Subsequent chapters address specific themes, such as "La Mujer (Woman)," "Magic and Medicine," "Discovering Curanderismo," and "The Meaning of Death." Each chapter illus- trates its message with vignettes drawn from the personal experi- ence of the author. One chapter has only 2 pages; the longest is 16 pages. Strengths: The chapters are written with care and feeling. Read- ers familiar with Latino culture will find the content authentic. The creative style is a departure from standard medical writing, and many will find this refreshing. Deficiencies: Readers who prefer a traditional textbook format will dislike the anecdotal style. The book would be stronger if it included more data from the expanding literature on the health status of the Hispanic population in the United States. Mayo Clio Proc, December 1999, Vol 74 Recommended Readership: All health care workers with an in- terest in Latino patients. Overall Grading: *** Juan M. Bowen, MD, Division of Community Internal Medicine, Mayo Clinic Rochester, Rochester, Minn Head and Neck Cancer: A Multidisciplinary Approach, edited by Louis B. Harrison, Roy B. Sessions, and Wuan Ki Hong, 1096 pp, with iIIus, $185, Philadelphia, Pa, Lippincott-Raven (tele- phone: 800-638-3030), 1999, ISBN 0-397-51777-7 Type of Book: A multiauthored textbook on the multidisciplinary evaluation and treatment of head and neck tumors. Scope of Book: This text presents the broad range of expertise and awareness of multiple treatment options that are necessary to manage patients with head and neck tumors successfully. Contents: The book consists of 43 chapters written by recognized experts in their fields. The section on basic science reviews epide- miology, etiology, and current concepts of the molecular biology of invasion and metastasis of head and neck cancer. The section on general principles introduces the numerous areas of expertise necessary to care for patients with head and neck tumors success- fully. The 100-page chapter on pathology of the head and neck could be a text in itself. Site-specific chapters describe multi- modality treatment options for tumors of specific regions. The last section reviews contemporary issues such as future treatment directions, gene therapy, and outcome measurements and in- cludes an important discussion of ethical issues in the manage- ment of patients with head and neck tumors. Strengths: The sections on basic science, pathology, and contem- porary issues are especially well written and will be an excellent source of important information for many years. The radiographic examples that appear at the end of each site-specific chapter are of high quality and provide an interesting addition not found in similar texts. Deficiencies: Most multiauthored texts have problems with re- dundancy, and this one is not an exception. Unfortunately, the treatment options are often presented as competing modalities, rather than the author committing to the single or multiple treat- ment plan that would be best for the patient. Surprisingly, some areas of contemporary management of head and neck tumors are scarcely mentioned, such as the expanded role of laser resection for laryngeal cancer and other head and neck tumors and the role of skull base and parapharyngeal-infratemporal fossa surgery. The importance of the management of comorbid medical condi- tions does not receive the attention it merits. Recommended Readership: This book will be of great value to residents and fellows in otorhinolaryngology-head and neck sur- gery, radiation oncology, and medical oncology. All surgeons and physicians who manage patients with head and neck cancers will find many useful chapters. Overall Grading: **** Kerry D. Olsen, MD, Division of Head and Neck Surgery, Mayo Clinic Rochester, Rochester, Minn For personal use. Mass reproduce only with permission from Mayo Clinic Proceedings.

Upload: kerry-d

Post on 04-Jan-2017

213 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Head and Neck Cancer: A Multidisciplinary Approach

1308 Book Reviews

practice. A remarkable distillation of current concepts has beenpacked into 359 pages. Written by leading experts from NorthAmerica, Europe, and Australia, most chapters are sufficientlydetailed yet remarkably readable. The clinical chapters take thereader from basic concepts to current areas of uncertainty orcontroversy with great clarity. Both the nonpharmacological andpharmacological management of these problems are handleddeftly. Other strengths include high-quality mechanical produc­tion, useful illustrations, generally appropriate references, andsufficiently in-depth coverage for even experts in the field.Deficiencies: The chapter on clinical pharmacology is too brief,superficial, and inadequately referenced.Recommended Readership: This book is a "must" for gastroen­terologists in training because they will routinely encounter pa­tients with these types of disorders in their daily practice. Expe­rienced gastroenterologists may also gain new information byperusing the contents. Physicians in practice, including internistsand family practitioners, will enjoy the practical managementhints. The book should be included in all major medical librariesand be given a prominent place in gastroenterology units.

Overall Grading: *****Nicholas J. Talley, MD, PhD, University ofSydney, Penrith, NewSouth Wales, Australia

Healing Latinos: Realidad y Fantasia; The Art of CulturalCompetence in Medicine, edited by David Hayes-Bautista andRoberto Chiprut, 221 pp, $26, 8700 Beverly Blvd, Los Angeles,CA 90048, Cedars-Sinai Health System (telephone: 310-794­0663), 1998, ISBN 0-96701 00-0-4

Type of Book: A brief multiauthored collection of personal per­spectives on the care of Latino patients.Scope ofBook: This small volume presents a series of reflectionson the medical care of Latino patients based on the authors'experiences with the large Latino community in the Los Angelesarea.Contents: The book consists of 19 short chapters, each written bya professional with experience in caring for Latino patients. Thecontributors include physicians, clergy, a hospital administrator,and a nutritionist. The introductory chapter presents a definitionof culture and provides a brief description of Latino culture in theUnited States. Subsequent chapters address specific themes, suchas "La Mujer (Woman)," "Magic and Medicine," "DiscoveringCuranderismo," and "The Meaning of Death." Each chapter illus­trates its message with vignettes drawn from the personal experi­ence of the author. One chapter has only 2 pages; the longest is 16pages.Strengths: The chapters are written with care and feeling. Read­ers familiar with Latino culture will find the content authentic.The creative style is a departure from standard medical writing,and many will find this refreshing.Deficiencies: Readers who prefer a traditional textbook formatwill dislike the anecdotal style. The book would be stronger if itincluded more data from the expanding literature on the healthstatus of the Hispanic population in the United States.

Mayo Clio Proc, December 1999, Vol 74

Recommended Readership: All health care workers with an in­terest in Latino patients.Overall Grading: ***Juan M. Bowen, MD, Division of Community Internal Medicine,Mayo Clinic Rochester, Rochester, Minn

Head and Neck Cancer: A Multidisciplinary Approach, editedby Louis B. Harrison, Roy B. Sessions, and Wuan Ki Hong, 1096pp, with iIIus, $185, Philadelphia, Pa, Lippincott-Raven (tele­phone: 800-638-3030), 1999, ISBN 0-397-51777-7

Type ofBook: A multiauthored textbook on the multidisciplinaryevaluation and treatment of head and neck tumors.Scope ofBook: This text presents the broad range of expertise andawareness of multiple treatment options that are necessary tomanage patients with head and neck tumors successfully.Contents: The book consists of 43 chapters written by recognizedexperts in their fields. The section on basic science reviews epide­miology, etiology, and current concepts of the molecular biologyof invasion and metastasis of head and neck cancer. The sectionon general principles introduces the numerous areas of expertisenecessary to care for patients with head and neck tumors success­fully. The 100-page chapter on pathology of the head and neckcould be a text in itself. Site-specific chapters describe multi­modality treatment options for tumors of specific regions. The lastsection reviews contemporary issues such as future treatmentdirections, gene therapy, and outcome measurements and in­cludes an important discussion of ethical issues in the manage­ment of patients with head and neck tumors.Strengths: The sections on basic science, pathology, and contem­porary issues are especially well written and will be an excellentsource of important information for many years. The radiographicexamples that appear at the end of each site-specific chapter are ofhigh quality and provide an interesting addition not found insimilar texts.Deficiencies: Most multiauthored texts have problems with re­dundancy, and this one is not an exception. Unfortunately, thetreatment options are often presented as competing modalities,rather than the author committing to the single or multiple treat­ment plan that would be best for the patient. Surprisingly, someareas of contemporary management of head and neck tumors arescarcely mentioned, such as the expanded role of laser resectionfor laryngeal cancer and other head and neck tumors and the roleof skull base and parapharyngeal-infratemporal fossa surgery.The importance of the management of comorbid medical condi­tions does not receive the attention it merits.Recommended Readership: This book will be of great value toresidents and fellows in otorhinolaryngology-head and neck sur­gery, radiation oncology, and medical oncology. All surgeons andphysicians who manage patients with head and neck cancers willfind many useful chapters.

Overall Grading: ****Kerry D. Olsen, MD, Division of Head and Neck Surgery, MayoClinic Rochester, Rochester, Minn

For personal use. Mass reproduce only with permission from Mayo Clinic Proceedings.