first step presentation 2a 05-22-09 - college of …...treatment integrity first step consultant and...

38

Upload: others

Post on 29-Jun-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 2: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 3: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 4: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 5: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 6: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 7: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 8: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 9: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 10: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 11: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 12: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 13: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 14: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 15: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 16: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 17: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 18: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 19: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 20: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 21: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 22: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social

TABLE 1. Dependent Variables and Measures

Dependent Variable Dependent Measure Population Frequency

1. Student Academic Engaged Time

Direct Observation Selected Targets and Selected Peers

Daily during Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up

Classwide

Five Pre and Five Post (until stability)

2. Student classroom behaviors

Direct Observation Selected Targets and Selected Peers

Daily during Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up

Behavior Rating Indices via the Early Screening Project (ESP)

Selected Targets and Selected Peers

One Pre and One Post

3. Student social interactions

Direct Observation

Targets interacting with classwide peers

Five Pre and Five Post (until stability)

Social Interaction Ratings via the Early Screening Project (ESP)

Selected Targets and Selected Peers

One Pre and One Post

4. Teacher delivered positives and negatives

Direct Observation

Teacher delivered Classwide

Daily during Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up

5. Teacher perceptions

Student, teacher and classroom ecology

One Pre and One Post

AND

Teacher Perceptions of Behavior and Classroom Ecology (Diagnostic Tool for the Classroom)

Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher

Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up

Social Validity (Social Satisfaction Survey)

Teacher Once at Post Intervention

Page 23: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social

02468

101214161820

1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35 37 39 41 43 45 47 49 51 53 55 57 59

S ession s

Freq

of P

B p

er 6

min

010203040506070809010 0

Perc

ent A

ET

per

3 m

in

P B 's A E TT arg et 1

02468

101214161820

1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35 37 39 41 43 45 47 49 51 53 55 57 59

S ession s

Fre.

Of P

B p

er 6

min

010203040506070809010 0

Perc

ent A

ET

per

3 m

in

T a rg et 2

02468

1 01 21 41 61 82 0

1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35 37 39 41 43 45 47 49 51 53 55 57 59

S ession s

Freq

of P

B p

er 6

min

01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 01 0 0

Perc

ent A

ET

per

3 m

in

T a rg et 3

02468

1 01 21 41 61 82 0

1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35 37 39 41 43 45 47 49 51 53 55 57 59

S ession s

Freq

of P

B p

er 6

min

01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 01 0 0

Perc

ent A

ET

per

3 m

in

T a rg et 4

Ix (T ea ch er S ta r ts) F ollow -u pB a selin e

FIGURE 1. Changes in Problem Behavior and Academic EngagedTime (AET) for Target Students

Page 24: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social

TABLE 14. Summary of Pre and Post Observations of Percent of Classwide Academic Engaged Time (C-AET)

Pre-Score Post-Score Mean

Pre Post Range

Pre Post 44 88 36 84 52 79 54 77

Classroom 1

39 86

45 82.8 36-54 77-88

67 89 48 93 55 91 63 86

Classroom 2

56 90

57.8 89.8 48-67 86-93

46 74 28 80 32 56 44 43

Classroom 3

40 68

38 64.2 28-46 43-80

38 84 57 73 53 89 35 77

Classroom 4

49 81

46.4 80.8 38-57 73-89

Page 25: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social

02468

1 01 21 41 61 82 0

1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35 37 39 41 43 45 47 49 51 53 55 57 59

S e s s io n s

Freq

of P

B p

er 6

min

T c h r P o s T c h r N e gT c h r + / - 1

02468

1 01 21 41 61 82 0

1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35 37 39 41 43 45 47 49 51 53 55 57 59

S e s s io n s

Freq

of P

B p

er 6

min

T c h r + / - 2

02468

1 01 21 41 61 82 0

1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35 37 39 41 43 45 47 49 51 53 55 57 59

S e s s io n s

Freq

of P

B p

er 6

min

T c h r + / - 3

02468

1 01 21 41 61 82 0

1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35 37 39 41 43 45 47 49 51 53 55 57 59

S e s s io n s

Freq

of P

B p

er 6

min

T c h r + / - 4

Ix (T e a c h e r S ta r t s ) F o l lo w -u pB a s e l in e

FIGURE 4. Changes in Teacher Classwide Posit ive and Negative Interactions

Page 26: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 27: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 28: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social

Effect SizesFirst Step Efficacy vs. Effectiveness Study

APS Efficacy Study SRI Effectiveness Study

San Jose & Chicago Social SkillsTeacher .87 1.11

Parent .54 .24

Problem Behavior

Teacher .73 .63

Parent .69 .29

Academic Engaged Time .44 .36

Page 29: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 30: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social

School Context• Factors that Influence Educator Adoption of

New Practices:– Fits seamlessly into ongoing school routines– Consistent with school and educator values– Universal versus targeted interventions– Solves a high priority problem or issue– Time and effort costs are reasonable– Teacher perceives s/he has the skills and resources

to apply practice effectively

Page 31: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social

Albuquerque Public Schools (APS) Efficacy Study of the First Step to Success Program

2004 – 2008

• Four-year large scale study funded by the Institute of Education Sciences (IES).

• 200 participants in grades 1-3 involved in the study.

Page 32: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social

(APS) Efficacy Study (Continued)

• 101 received First Step (FS) -- 99 were Usual Care Controls (UCC).

• Participants, along with teachers and classrooms, were randomly assigned to FS or UCC.

• Outcome measures were collected at pre, post, and follow-up time points.

Page 33: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 34: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 35: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social
Page 36: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social

First Step National Effectiveness Study2006-2011

Key Features• Implemented across Five Sites

– California (San Jose) Year 1– Illinois (Chicago Area) Year 1– Florida (Tampa) Year 2– West Virginia (Huntington Area) Year 2– Oregon (Eugene Area) Year 2

• 432 Participants– 244 First Step– 188 Usual Care Control

Page 37: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social

Effect SizesFirst Step Efficacy vs. Effectiveness Study

APS Efficacy Study SRI Effectiveness Study

San Jose & Chicago Social SkillsTeacher .87 1.11

Parent .54 .24

Problem Behavior

Teacher .73 .63

Parent .69 .29

Academic Engaged Time .44 .36

Page 38: First Step Presentation 2a 05-22-09 - College of …...Treatment Integrity First Step Consultant and Teacher Throughout Baseline, Intervention, and Follow-up Social Validity (Social

To access this program online:

go to the website for the Institute on Violence and Destructive Behavior:http://ivdb.uoregon.eduand click on this program, listed under:Presentations by Hill Walker