field investigation of best practices employing …...field investigation of best practices for...

27
FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard Sweigard, PI Dharmendra Kumar, RA Department of Mining Engineering University of Kentucky Bridging Reclamation, Science & The Community June 8 th ,2010 1

Upload: others

Post on 11-Aug-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION

EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH

Dr. Richard Sweigard, PIDharmendra Kumar, RA

Department of Mining EngineeringUniversity of KentuckyUniversity of Kentucky

Bridging Reclamation, Science & The CommunityJune 8th,2010

1

Page 2: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

Objectives

� Regional inventory of highwall elimination methods on steep-slope mines

throughout the Appalachian region

� Field investigation of application of FRA on steep-slope mines emphasizing� Field investigation of application of FRA on steep-slope mines emphasizing

operational, economical & stability perspectives

2

Page 3: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

Field Visits

� A total of 28 mine sites were visited throughout the Appalachian region

3

Page 4: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

Field Investigations

� Compare operational efficiency and project economics with FRA

reclamation to non-FRA reclamation

� Characterize the level of compaction� Characterize the level of compaction

� Evaluate the stability of steep-slopes that were reclaimed using FRA

4

Page 5: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

Description of Experimental Site

� Approx. 4.7 acre Peel Poplar site reclaimed by combination of truck and

lateral dozer push by ICG in Pike County, KY

� Volume of backfilled material: 760,000 yd^3

� Height of highwall reclaimed is approx.173 ft and slope angle ranges from � Height of highwall reclaimed is approx.173 ft and slope angle ranges from

27° to 33°(Average angle 29°)

�Approx. half of the site consists primarily of Gray sandstone and the other

half has a top layer of soil and Brown sandstone

5

Page 6: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

6Drawing of Site with Orientation of Monuments

Page 7: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

Top 4 ft Loose Materials

7Cross-sectional Profile of Slope

Page 8: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

Highwall before Elimination

8

Page 9: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

Highwall Elimination Activities

777D Truck Hauling Spoil9

Page 10: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

Highwall Elimination Activities

Lateral Pushing of Spoil10

Page 11: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

Highwall Elimination Activities

Grading Work 11

Page 12: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

Final Grading

� Single pass grading was done by Dozer Cat D11R from top to bottom

� Passes did not overlap & small ridges were left between passes

12

Page 13: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

Final Graded Site

13

Page 14: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

Planting Activities

Planting in Gray Area 14

Page 15: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

Trees Inventory

15

Page 16: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

Field Measurements

� Spoil measurement;

� Bulk density

� Penetration resistance

� Depth of refusal (Maximum penetration depth)� Depth of refusal (Maximum penetration depth)

� Surveying of monuments for mass movement

� 70 (31-Gray Area & 39 Brown Area) steel rebars (1/2 inch -dia & 4 feet length) are driven to monitor mass movement

16

Page 17: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

Penetrometer

Wildcat Dynamic Cone Penetrometer-Field set up 17

Page 18: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

18

Penetrometer Monitoring Points

Page 19: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

(Initial Measurements)

19

Page 20: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

Nuclear Density Gauge

Troxler 3440-Nuclear Density Gauge-Field set up 20

Page 21: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

21

Bulk Density Monitoring Points

Page 22: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

1.55

1.6

1.65

Den

sity

(g/c

m^

3)Dry Bulk Density (6") 1- Brown Spoil

2-Gray Spoil

Bulk Density Measurement(Initial Measurements)

22

1 2

2009 1.45 1.6

1.35

1.4

1.45

1.5

Den

sity

(g/c

m^

3)

Page 23: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

Movement Monitoring

Survey of Monument23

Page 24: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

Survey of Monuments

Total Station set up for Survey of Monuments24

Page 25: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

Location of Monuments

25

Page 26: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

Current Analysis

� Spoil measurement

� Bulk density & penetration resistance

� Surveying of monuments for mass movement

� Economic analysis of reclamation cost will be done

� Trees survival rate

26

Page 27: FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES EMPLOYING …...FIELD INVESTIGATION OF BEST PRACTICES FOR STEEP SLOPE MINE RECLAMATION EMPLOYING THE FORESTRY RECLAMATION APPROACH Dr. Richard

QUESTIONS??QUESTIONS??

27