dummy book response

1
Although the exact layout that I had in mind for my Dummy Book got a bit messed up because of the way Staples printed it, it was still extremely beneficial to hear feedback from both Meg and Paige. When thinking about the order in which to present my photos, I wasn’t really sure at first on how to organize them. I spent a lot of time looking at each print and trying to find similarities between different photographs, and also isolating some that would possibly stand alone in the spread, instead of being paired up with another picture. Meghan talked a bit about how the images portrayed a movement and balance between intimacy and intensity, and those are two things that really wanted to get across. She also talked about the eye contact of the subjects of the images with the viewer and how that was very powerful. One of her suggestions is to focus more on the eye contact, which will force to viewer to be more engaged with the book. She talked about how as a viewer, she felt intrusive looking at the images, but at the same time they drew her in. There is definitely a battle between feeling close to and separate from the images that she picked up on, and that I am trying to convey. Paige also commented on the arrangement of the photographs and how the variety of positions and depth of the headshots intrigues the viewer and pulls them close. She also mentioned how the book invoked a dynamic between dependence and independence. That is something else that I really wanted to portray with my book. Especially after reading about Nan Goldin’s The Ballad of Sexual Dependency, where she is constantly struggling with independence and dependence as well, I really wanted my own investigation into my relationship to describe that struggle as well. In Ballad, Goldin says “I have a strong desire to be independent, but at the same time a craving for the intensity that comes from interdependency.” That quote really spoke to me and I have realized that especially towards the end of our relationship, we were both struggling with these concepts. Paige also pointed out that throughout the pictures, JJ’s wardrobe consists of a lot of plaid. She suggested that at the end of the book, if I could end the book with him in a very different outfit, then that would make clear the turn of the relationship. She also mentioned that the last four spread really transition to show JJ alone in all of the pictures, instead of us together, and she thought that was very effective as well. I still have more images that I need to print, and then work into the sequence, so I think that it is definitely going to change a lot more before the complete, finalized product. But both of their suggestions were extremely helpful!!

Upload: mimi-roller

Post on 18-Feb-2016

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

response to the critiques of Meg and Paige

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Dummy Book Response

Although  the  exact  layout  that  I  had  in  mind  for  my  Dummy  Book  got  a  bit  messed  up  because  of  the  way  Staples  printed  it,  it  was  still  extremely  beneficial  to  hear  feedback  from  both  Meg  and  Paige.       When  thinking  about  the  order  in  which  to  present  my  photos,  I  wasn’t  really  sure  at  first  on  how  to  organize  them.    I  spent  a  lot  of  time  looking  at  each  print  and  trying  to  find  similarities  between  different  photographs,  and  also  isolating  some  that  would  possibly  stand  alone  in  the  spread,  instead  of  being  paired  up  with  another  picture.    Meghan  talked  a  bit  about  how  the  images  portrayed  a  movement  and  balance  between  intimacy  and  intensity,  and  those  are  two  things  that  really  wanted  to  get  across.       She  also  talked  about  the  eye  contact  of  the  subjects  of  the  images  with  the  viewer  and  how  that  was  very  powerful.    One  of  her  suggestions  is  to  focus  more  on  the  eye  contact,  which  will  force  to  viewer  to  be  more  engaged  with  the  book.    She  talked  about  how  as  a  viewer,  she  felt  intrusive  looking  at  the  images,  but  at  the  same  time  they  drew  her  in.    There  is  definitely  a  battle  between  feeling  close  to  and  separate  from  the  images  that  she  picked  up  on,  and  that  I  am  trying  to  convey.    Paige  also  commented  on  the  arrangement  of  the  photographs  and  how  the  variety  of  positions  and  depth  of  the  headshots  intrigues  the  viewer  and  pulls  them  close.    She  also  mentioned  how  the  book  invoked  a  dynamic  between  dependence  and  independence.    That  is  something  else  that  I  really  wanted  to  portray  with  my  book.    Especially  after  reading  about  Nan  Goldin’s  The  Ballad  of  Sexual  Dependency,  where  she  is  constantly  struggling  with  independence  and  dependence  as  well,  I  really  wanted  my  own  investigation  into  my  relationship  to  describe  that  struggle  as  well.     In  Ballad,  Goldin  says  “I  have  a  strong  desire  to  be  independent,  but  at  the  same  time  a  craving  for  the  intensity  that  comes  from  interdependency.”    That  quote  really  spoke  to  me  and  I  have  realized  that  especially  towards  the  end  of  our  relationship,  we  were  both  struggling  with  these  concepts.       Paige  also  pointed  out  that  throughout  the  pictures,  JJ’s  wardrobe  consists  of  a  lot  of  plaid.    She  suggested  that  at  the  end  of  the  book,  if  I  could  end  the  book  with  him  in  a  very  different  outfit,  then  that  would  make  clear  the  turn  of  the  relationship.    She  also  mentioned  that  the  last  four  spread  really  transition  to  show  JJ  alone  in  all  of  the  pictures,  instead  of  us  together,  and  she  thought  that  was  very  effective  as  well.    I  still  have  more  images  that  I  need  to  print,  and  then  work  into  the  sequence,  so  I  think  that  it  is  definitely  going  to  change  a  lot  more  before  the  complete,  finalized  product.  But  both  of  their  suggestions  were  extremely  helpful!!