combining analytical sensors and nessi to improve process...

36
Brian Marquardt , Charles Branham Kent Mann – University of Minnesota Dave Veltkamp – C8 Medisys Applied Physics Laboratory / Center for Process Analytical Chemistry University of Washington Seattle, WA 98105 Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process Understanding

Upload: others

Post on 22-Jul-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

Brian Marquardt , Charles BranhamKent Mann – University of MinnesotaDave Veltkamp – C8 Medisys

Applied Physics Laboratory /Center for Process Analytical ChemistryUniversity of WashingtonSeattle, WA 98105

Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process Understanding

Page 2: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

Analytical Sampling for Online Applications

Page 3: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

Why Use Microreactors?

High Throughput Experimentation For..

Discovery and screeningProcess optimizationProcess developmentProcess controlProduction?

Page 4: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

Challenges To Using Microreactors

Analytical characterizationSampling and screeningData handlingProcess modeling and feed back control (particularly if they are used for production)Reaction optimization – move toward feed forward control????

Page 5: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

CPAC/FDA/Corning MicroReactor

Collaborative project between 3 entities to improve reaction development and optimization through the use of continuous microreactors, NeSSI and analyticsFunded by the FDA to demonstrate the benefits of improved reactor design, effective sampling and online analytics to increase process understandingProject begins November 2008

Page 6: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

Corning Microreactor + NeSSI

Page 7: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

NeSSI Ballprobe - Raman/NIR/UV

Page 8: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

Spectroscopic Analysis of ReactorPossible problems with performing online spectroscopic measurements

Bubble formation in sample linesdue to pressure dropsample degassing

Phase change between reactor and analyzerdue to temperature or pressure change

Most PAT problems are due to sampling not measurement deviceNeed better systems to sample processes

Page 9: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

NeSSI Raman Sampling Block

• Parker Intraflow NeSSI substrate• Sample conditioning to induce backpressure to

reduce bubble formation and the heated substrate allows analysis at reactor conditions

Page 10: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

What is NeSSI?• Industry-driven effort to

define and promote a new standardized alternative to sample conditioning systems for analyzers and sensors

Standard fluidic interface for modular surface-mount components Standard wiring and communications interfacesStandard platform formicro analytics

Page 11: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

What does NeSSI ProvideSimple “Lego-like” assembly

Easy to re-configureNo special tools or skills required

Standardized flow components“Mix-and-match” compatibility between vendorsGrowing list of components

Standardized electrical and comm. (Gen II)“Plug-and-play” integration of multiple devicesSimplified interface for programmatic I/O and control

Advanced analytics (Gen III)Micro-analyzersIntegrated analysis or “smart” systems

Page 12: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

Benefits of Being NeSSIYour condition space is constrained□ Volumes, flow rates, pressures, and viscosities inherently

bounded by architectureYour interfaces are defined□ Electrical power, communication, and sample are all available

in a standard way□ Power budget could be main driver to miniaturizeYour sample conditioning can be defined and controlled□ Specify up-stream and down-stream NeSSI components (and

verify)All this means your analytical can be more directed and focused

Page 13: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

Where Does NeSSI Fit in the LabInstrument/Sensor Interfaces

Design standards make development simplerReduced toolset to be masteredReduced sample variability to account for

Calibration/validation built-inConsistent physical environment for measurementStream switching and/or mixing allow generation of standards to match analytical requirements

Reaction monitoringMicroreactors and continuous flow reactorsBatch reactors (with fast loop)

Sample PreparationGas handling (mixing, generation, delivery)Liquid handling (mixing, dilution, conditioning, etc.)

Page 14: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

NeSSI with an Array of Micro-Analytical Techniques will Impact Many Industries

• Process Control• Process Optimization• Product Development

Page 15: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

NeSSI Sensing TechnologiesGas Chromatography

Thermal DesorptionDielectricSpectroscopies

IR NIR UV- Vis Raman Fluorescence

Impedance Conductivity Refractive Index

Particle SizingLight scattering (?)

Turbidity pHRGAMass SpectrometryLC, SEC, ICTerahertz (?)

Page 16: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

NeSSI™: Enabler for MicroAnalytical

(the “rail” concept)

Standard Mechanical Interface “Rail”

Standard Electrical (Digital) Interface “Rail”

Anyone’s Sensor Anyone’s Actuator

SAM*

Standard“hockey-puckPC”

PV

*Sensor/Actuator Manager

Standard“connectivity

What technologies are availableSuitability for modular sampling systems

Page 18: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

At-Line GC’s with NeSSI CompatibilityABB Natural GC

Siem

ens microS

AM

Agilent 3000 M

icro GC

Page 19: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

Applied Analytics Inc. Diode Array OMA-300 A Fiber-optics-diode-array process analyzerFor on-line concentration monitoring

Page 20: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

Applied Analytics Microspec IR

FEATURESIdeal for monitoring PPM level WATER in various solventsIn stream quantitative measurementsContains no moving parts andExtremely robust allowing for installations in process stream environmentsReplaces analyzers such as process spectrometers in the process plant.

Page 21: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

Small Diameter ATR-IR-Fiber ProbesFiber Photonics Inc.

www.fibrephotonics.comDiamond ATR-IR-Fiber Probe of 2.7mm diameter in NeSSI

Page 22: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

Agilent NeSSI Dielectric SensorCable to Agilent

Network Analyzer

Swagelok 2-Port

Valve Base

Dielectric Probe

Inner Body

O-ring (inside)

Outer Body

Exploded View

Close up of Coaxial

Probe Tip

Page 23: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

NeSSI™ IR Gas Cell

Page 24: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

NeSSI Compatible Optical Cells Axiom Analytical, Inc.

Courtesy of Mike DoyleAxiom Analytical, Inc.

Currently Available

FFV Series Transmission Cells (Near-IR, UV-Visible)FNL-120 UV-Visible ATR Cell

In DevelopmentRaman Cells (Single- and Multi-pass)

Possible DevelopmentDiffuse Reflectance CellsMid-IR ATR Cells

Page 25: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

Chevron NeSSI/Analytical UnitSpecifications

ASI Microfast GCParker NeSSI gas handling/sampling systemCarrier gasMobility

Page 26: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

NeSSI based Analytical Developments at CPAC

Page 27: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

NeSSI Gas/ Vapor System

NeSSI Gas/Vapor System

Permeation Tower

Aspectrics EPIR w/ glass cell

N2 Waste

NeSSI Flow Cell

ASI microFAST GC

Page 28: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

NeSSI Calibration Gas Generation System

Features of NeSSI System :• 4 Stage dilution, able to produce and maintain gas concentrations in ppb

range• Fully automated system, set and forget capability

Automated NeSSI Gas/Vapor System

N2

O2

Mixed Gases

Mass FlowControllers

Page 29: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

Gas Mixing System LabView Control Program

Page 30: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

Design of Small Fiber Optic SensorsOxygenMoistureAmmoniaHydrogenCommon Solvents

AlcoholsEstersAmines

Chlorinated OrganicsOrganic Hydrocarbons

(BTEX)Carbon Dioxide

(in development)Hydrogen Sulfide

(in development)

• vapochromic chemistry• optical response to analyte

• simple design• reversible response• low power• inexpensive• fast response times• high quantum efficiency• long term sensor stability• sensitive to a variety of analytes• wireless communication• battery powered

Page 31: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

Modular NeSSI Oxygen Gas Sensor

Exploded View

1/16 in bifurcated fiber optic fiber

1/16 to 1/8 in Swagelok union

Agilent NeSSI Mount

Sensor Body

Close up of Outer Body Tip

Vapochromic Tip

Fiber optic ferrule with plastic housing

Page 32: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

Sensor response to O2

Pre

dict

ed O

2%

Calculated O2 %

R2 = 0.990, 3 PCRMSEC = 1.0744

20 replicates at each concentrationConcentration range: 0 -100% Oxygen

Inte

nsity

(cou

nts)

Wavelength (nm)

100 %

0%

120

100

80

60

40

20

01009080706050403020100

Page 33: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

Future Miniature Oxygen Sensor

Oxygen Sensor and probe Oxygen Sensing Tip

Page 34: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

Liquid Chromatography for NeSSI™ Scott Gilbert, CPAC Visiting Scholar

Crystal Vision Microsystems LLCAtofluidic Technologies, LLC

• Split flow approach to sampling

• μ-fluidic LC Chip for On-line Sample Pretreatment

• Pulsed electrochemical detection (on-chip)

micromixer

diluent in

column

mobile phase in

sample in

Liters per minute

microliters per minute

nanoliters per minute

Page 35: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

Development of a Micro-NMR System

M. McCarthy, UC Davis

Page 36: Combining Analytical Sensors and NeSSI to Improve Process ...depts.washington.edu/cpac/NeSSI/40_IFPAC_09/Presentations/Marq… · Your condition space is constrained Volumes, flow

AcknowledgmentsCenter for Process Analytical ChemistryStudents – Charles Branham and Wes Thompson, UWVendors who provided slidesProfessor Kent Mann’s Group, Univ. of MinnesotaScott Gilbert – UW Visiting scholarSwagelok, Parker and Circor ABB, Agilent, Aspectrics, Honeywell, ExxonMobil