7/31/2019 Clinical Effectiveness Bulletin no. 64 May 12

1/24

J@Q Mgorbrw bjf Gjedrcbvgdj Qirugai Jdrv` Qvbeedrfq`gri

2

Amgjgabm Ieeiavguijiqq Oymmivgjed J@Q \gcbw Abi gj Jdv`

Qvbeedfq`giGqqyi Jd; 56 Cbw ?

7/31/2019 Clinical Effectiveness Bulletin no. 64 May 12

2/24

J@Q Mgorbrw bjf Gjedrcbvgdj Qirugai Jdrv` Qvbeedrfq`gri

?

Qdyaiq ed Amgjgabm Ieeiavguijiqq Oymmivgj

\mibqi qyhhiqv eyv`i qgviq v`bv q`dymf oi cdjgvdif gj v`i |dfyavgdj de v`gq oymmivgj

Xioqgviq

Ada`bji Mgobw `vv|;$$xxx*v`iada`bjimgobw*adc$A_F Aijvi ed _iugixq bjf Fgqqicgjbvgdj `vv|;$$xxx*af*wdn*ba*yn$afxio$

# FB_I Fbvbobqi de Boqvbavq de _iugixq de Ieeiavq'# J@Q Iadjdcga Iubmybvgdj Fbvbobqi

@ibmv` Via`jdmdhw Bqqiqqcijv @VB' Fbvbobqi`vv|;$$xxx*`vb*ba*ynFbgmw @ibmv` Oymmivgj`vv|;$$xxx*q`ieegimf*j`q*yn$`ibmv`oymmivgj$Fi|bvcijv de @ibmv``vv|;$$xxx*f`*hdu*yn$ij$gjfip*`vc Ngjhq Eyjf`vv|;$$xxx*ngjhqeyjf*dh*yn$JiMC Jbvgdjbm Imiavdjga Mgobw ed Cifgagjiq' jixq oymmivgj`vv|;$$xxx*jimc*j`q*yn$ij$JGAI`vv|;$$xxx*jgai*dh*yn$QGHJ`vv|;$$xxx*qghj*ba*yn$jix*`vcm

http://www.thecochranelibrary.com/http://www.thecochranelibrary.com/http://www.hta.ac.uk/http://www.hta.ac.uk/http://www.hta.ac.uk/http://www.sheffield.nhs.uk/healthbulletin/http://www.sheffield.nhs.uk/healthbulletin/http://www.sheffield.nhs.uk/healthbulletin/http://www.dh.gov.uk/en/index.htmhttp://www.dh.gov.uk/en/index.htmhttp://www.dh.gov.uk/en/index.htmhttp://www.kingsfund.org.uk/http://www.kingsfund.org.uk/http://www.kingsfund.org.uk/http://www.nelm.nhs.uk/en/http://www.nelm.nhs.uk/en/http://www.nelm.nhs.uk/en/http://www.nice.org.uk/http://www.nice.org.uk/http://www.sign.ac.uk/new.htmlhttp://www.sign.ac.uk/new.htmlhttp://www.sign.ac.uk/new.htmlhttp://www.sign.ac.uk/new.htmlhttp://www.nice.org.uk/http://www.nelm.nhs.uk/en/http://www.kingsfund.org.uk/http://www.dh.gov.uk/en/index.htmhttp://www.sheffield.nhs.uk/healthbulletin/http://www.hta.ac.uk/http://www.thecochranelibrary.com/

7/31/2019 Clinical Effectiveness Bulletin no. 64 May 12

3/24

J@Q Mgorbrw bjf Gjedrcbvgdj Qirugai Jdrv` Qvbeedrfq`gri

1

Adjvijvq gj v`gq gqqyi;

Bmad`dm ************************************************************************************************************************************** 6Bqv`cb bjf AD\F ******************************************************************************************************************* 6Oibqv Gc|mbjvq ************************************************************************************************************************* 6Abjai ************************************************************************************************************************************** 6Abfgdubqaymb Fgqibqiq ********************************************************************************************************** 9A`gmfij bjf Wdyjh \id|mi ****************************************************************************************************** 9Adccgqqgdjgjh ************************************************************************************************************************* 5Ficijvgb ********************************************************************************************************************************** 5Fijvbm @ibmv` **************************************************************************************************************************** 5Fgboiviq ************************************************************************************************************************************ 8Icihijaw Abi *********************************************************************************************************************** 8Ijf de Mgei Abi ************************************************************************************************************************ 8Ebmmq |iuijvgdj ************************************************************************************************************************ 0Hijibm \bavgai *********************************************************************************************************************** 0Hygfbjai ********************************************************************************************************************************** 0@ibmv` _iedcq *********************************************************************************************************************** 2 |mbai de fibv`>abyqi de fibv`> fibv`q gj `dq|gvbm> abi `dciq> bjf ijf de mgei abi q|ijf ed iba` \AV gjIjhmbjf*

`vv|;$$xxx*ijfdemgeiabi#gjvimmghijai*dh*yn$ijfTdeTmgeiTabiT|degmiq$|gcbwTabiTvyqvT|degmiq*bq|p

X`bv fd xi njdx jdx v`bv xi fgfj(v njdx b wib bhd4 Jix gjvimmghijai dj ijf de mgeiabi gj IjhmbjfIjf de Mgei Abi Gjvimmghijai JivxdnV`gq i|dv mddnq bv v`i abi iaiguif ow |bvgijvq bv v`i ijf de mgei- gj b ubgivw de qivvgjhq* Gvbmqd hguiq gjedcbvgdj bodyv qvbee adc|ivijai bjf vbgjgjh miuimq- bjf |yomga bvvgvyfiq vdfibv`*`vv|;$$xxx*ijfdemgeiabi#gjvimmghijai*dh*yn$iqdyaiq$|yomgabvgdjq$x`bvTxiTnjdxTjdx*bq|p

^oban vd vd|gaqS

Ebmmq |iuijvgdj

Ebmmq |iuijvgdj; jix b||dba`iq vd gjvihbvif ebmmq |iuijvgdj qiugaiq*J@Q AdjeifibvgdjV`gq ogiegjh gq gjvijfif vd `im| v`i J@Q bjf mdabm hduijcijv v`gjn bodyv jix b||dba`iqvd v`i adccgqqgdjgjh bjf |dugqgdj de adc|i`ijqgui- gjvihbvif ebmmq |iuijvgdj qiugaiq* Gvq`dxq v`bv b edayq dj |iuijvgdj bjf ibmw gjviuijvgdj v`dyh` kdgjv xdngjh `bq oijiegvq edv`i x`dmi `ibmv` bjf qdagbm abi qwqvic*`vv|;$$xxx*j`qadjeif*dh$\yomgabvgdjq$ogiegjhq$\bhiq$Ebmmq\iuijvgdjJixB||dba`iq*bq|p

Hijibm \bavgai

\gcbw Abi; Vdfbw bjf Vdcddx # Gc|dugjh hijibm |bavgai ow xdngjh fgeeiijvmwFimdgvviV`gq i|dv ipbcgjiq v`i ab|bagvw bjf ab|bogmgvw de hijibm |bavgai jdx bjf gj v`i eyvyi-xgv` b edayq dj H\q bjf hijibm |bavgai jyqiq*`vv|;$$xxx*fimdgvvi*adc$ugix$ijTHO$yn$iqiba`#bjf#gjvimmghijai$fimdgvvi#iqiba`#yn$fimdgvvi#yn#aijvi#ed#`ibmv`#qdmyvgdjq$oo5i10e5

7/31/2019 Clinical Effectiveness Bulletin no. 64 May 12

9/24

J@Q Mgorbrw bjf Gjedrcbvgdj Qirugai Jdrv` Qvbeedrfq`gri

7

JGAI Via`jdmdhw B||rbgqbmqBvgbm egogmmbvgdj qvdni |iuijvgdj' # gubdpbobjVB?95`vv|;$$hygfbjai*jgai*dh*yn$VB?95

\dqvbvi abjai # abob{gvbpim

VB?99`vv|;$$hygfbjai*jgai*dh*yn$VB?99

JGAI Rybmgvw QvbjfbrfqDubgbj abjai rybmgvw qvbjfbf`vv|;$$xxx*jgai*dh*yn$hygfbjai$rybmgvwqvbjfbfq$dubgbjabjai$`dci*kq|

JGAI Adjqymvbvgdj FdaycijvqAwqvga egodqgq # cbjjgvdm; b||bgqbm adjqymvbvgdjAmdqgjh fbvi ed adccijvq; 1 Kymw ?

7/31/2019 Clinical Effectiveness Bulletin no. 64 May 12

10/24

J@Q Mgorbrw bjf Gjedrcbvgdj Qirugai Jdrv` Qvbeedrfq`gri

2