block-scale experiment on bentonite colloid – radionuclide...

1
BLOCK-SCALE EXPERIMENT ON BENTONITE COLLOID – RADIONUCLIDE INTERACTION INTRODUCTION In Finland, the repository for spent nuclear fuel (SNF) will be excavated at a depth of about 500 meters in the fractured crystalline bedrock. Bentonite clay is assumed to be a potential source of colloids which could enhance the migration of radionuclides. The collective processes of the rock matrix, bentonite colloids and radionuclides (Fig. 1) are important to investigate to assess the relevance of bentonite colloids regarding the safety disposal of SNF. The objective was to study bentonite colloid – radionuclide interaction in a block scale experiment, which provides an intermediate stage between laboratory and in-situ experiments. EXPERIMENTAL • Kuru Grey Granite Block (Fig. 2) - Main minerals: Potassium feldspar (36 %), quartz (35 %), plagioclase (21 %), amphibole and micas (8 %) - Natural water conducting fracture 0.9x0.94 m intersected by nine vertical boreholes equipped with injection or sealing packers - Tracer collection from the outer vertical boundary of the block - Main flow channel 0.75 m, channel width 0.06 m and aperture 0.65 mm - Flow velocity 50 μl/min • Synthetic Ni-labeled Montmorillonite (Fig. 3) • Grimsel Groundwater (I = 1.2 mM) Determination of fracture flow properties using conservative tracers: Fluoresceine, Amino-G, HTO and 36 Cl • Reactive tracers: 85 Sr, 152 Eu • Colloid analysis by Laser Induced Breakdown Detection (LIBD) at KIT- INE in Karlsruhe and Photon Correlation Spectroscopy (PCS) • Radioactivity analysis: - Liquiq scintilation counting (Hidex 300SL) - Tl activated NaI crystal (1480 Wizard 3’’) RESULTS The breakthrough locations of the out flowing tracer determined with fluoresceine and photography are shown in Fig. 4. Several tracer experiments conducted with conservative tracers ensured that the flow conditions were stable. Good reproducibility was obtained with the different type of the tracers (Fig. 5). Mean particle diameters of Ni-labeled Montmorillonite colloids in Allard and Grimsel water simulant are shown in Fig. 6. A clear difference can be seen in the colloid size in 4.2 mM Allard and 1.2 mM Grimsel water. The difference in the ionic strength is rather small but it still affects the colloid stability significantly. In the flow experiments no breakthrough of 152 Eu or Ni-labeled Montmorillonite colloids were detected in Allard water. Allard water in the fracture was changed to Grimsel water simulant. Although, a lot of Grimsel water simulant was pumped through the fracture prior the new colloid experiments, no colloid breakthrough was obtained due to saline water remaining in the fracture. Although separate batch experiments showed that 152 Eu was adsorbed on Ni- labeled Montmorillonite colloids in Grimsel water conditions indicating that instable colloids were the reason for 152 Eu retardation. CONCLUSIONS The ionic strength of the water simulant had a significant influence on the stability and mobility of the montmorillonite colloids and thus on their ability to carry radionuclides. The main uncertainties remain in the quantification of colloids under more realistic repository conditions. At saline conditions, like at the Finnish repository site in Olkiluoto, the colloids are unstable and therefore do not affect the radionuclide transport. However, the possible scenario of glacial melt water intrusion may still have to take into account. Repeatable breakthroughs were obtained with the conservative tracers, which provides a good base for the further experiments. REFERENCE [1] Huber F. M., Heck S., Truche L., Bouby M., Brendlé J., Hoess P. and Schäfer T. (2015) Radionuclide desorption kinetics on synthetic Zn/Ni-labeled montmorillonite nanoparticles. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 148 , 426-441. Valtteri Suorsa, Pirkko Hölttä Laboratory of Radiochemistry, Department of Chemistry University of Helsinki, Finland This study is a part of Finnish Research Programme on Nuclear Waste Management financed by The State Nuclear Waste Management Fund. Fig. 2. The granitic block used in the experiments. Water pools were previously installed on the vertical sides and top of the block in order to ensure the saturation of the block and to stabilize the hydraulic head on the vertical faces. Fig. 3. The Ni-labeled montmorillonite synthesised at KIT-INE. [1] Fig. 5. The breakthrough curves of different conservative tracers with the water flow rate of 50 μl/min. 0,000001 0,00001 0,0001 0,001 0,01 0,1 1 1 10 100 1000 10000 c/c0 Time [min] AGA. A 290216 Cl-36 070316 AGA020316 H-3 070316 H-3 230316 H-3 080416 AGA150416 AGA190416 0 200 400 600 800 0,00 50,00 100,00 150,00 200,00 250,00 300,00 Zave (nm) Time from t0 (h) GGW1 GGW2 "Allard1" Allard2 Fig. 6. Mean colloid size as a function of time. The squares represent Ni-mont. colloids in Allard and the circles in Grimsel water simulant. Fig. 4. Breakthrough of the fluoresceine can be seen in the right part of the fracture marked with red circles. Fig. 1. Colloid/radionuclide and host rock interaction. (EU/BELBaR/T. Schäfer)

Upload: dodung

Post on 04-Jun-2018

221 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: BLOCK-SCALE EXPERIMENT ON BENTONITE COLLOID – RADIONUCLIDE ...kyt2018.vtt.fi/pvseminaari2017/posterit/Suorsa_NRC9_Suorsa_poster... · BLOCK-SCALE EXPERIMENT ON BENTONITE COLLOID

BLOCK-SCALE EXPERIMENT ON BENTONITE COLLOID –

RADIONUCLIDE INTERACTION

INTRODUCTIONIn Finland, the repository for spent nuclear fuel (SNF) will be excavated at a depth of about 500 meters in the fractured crystalline bedrock. Bentonite clay is assumed to be a potential source of colloids which could enhance the migration of radionuclides. The collective processes of the rock matrix, bentonite colloids and radionuclides (Fig. 1) are important to investigate to assess the relevance of bentonite colloids regarding the safety disposal of SNF. The objective was to study bentonite colloid – radionuclide interaction in a block scale experiment, which provides an intermediate stage between laboratory and in-situ experiments.

EXPERIMENTAL• Kuru Grey Granite Block (Fig. 2)

- Main minerals: Potassium feldspar (36 %), quartz (35 %), plagioclase (21 %), amphibole and micas (8 %) - Natural water conducting fracture 0.9x0.94 m intersected by nine vertical boreholes equipped with injection or sealing packers - Tracer collection from the outer vertical boundary of the block - Mainflowchannel0.75m,channel width 0.06 m and aperture 0.65 mm - Flowvelocity50μl/min

• Synthetic Ni-labeled Montmorillonite (Fig. 3)

• Grimsel Groundwater (I = 1.2 mM)• Determinationoffractureflowproperties

using conservative tracers: Fluoresceine, Amino-G, HTO and 36Cl

• Reactive tracers: 85Sr, 152Eu• Colloid analysis by Laser Induced

Breakdown Detection (LIBD) at KIT-INE in Karlsruhe and Photon Correlation Spectroscopy (PCS)

• Radioactivity analysis: - Liquiq scintilation counting (Hidex 300SL) - Tl activated NaI crystal (1480 Wizard 3’’)

RESULTS Thebreakthroughlocationsoftheoutflowingtracerdeterminedwithfluoresceineandphotography are shown in Fig. 4. Several tracer experiments conducted with conservativetracersensuredthattheflowconditions were stable. Good reproducibility was obtained with the different type of the tracers (Fig. 5).

Mean particle diameters of Ni-labeled Montmorillonite colloids in Allard and Grimsel water simulant are shown in Fig. 6. A clear difference can be seen in the colloid size in

4.2 mM Allard and 1.2 mM Grimsel water. The difference in the ionic strength is rather small but it still affects the colloid stability significantly.

Intheflowexperimentsnobreakthroughof152Eu or Ni-labeled Montmorillonite colloids were detected in Allard water. Allard water in the fracture was changed to Grimsel water simulant. Although, a lot of Grimsel water simulant was pumped through the fracture prior the new colloid experiments, no colloid breakthrough was obtained due to saline water remaining in the fracture. Although separate batch experiments showed that 152Eu was adsorbed on Ni-labeled Montmorillonite colloids in Grimsel water conditions indicating that instable colloids were the reason for 152Eu retardation.

CONCLUSIONSThe ionic strength of the water simulant had asignificantinfluenceonthestabilityandmobility of the montmorillonite colloids and thus on their ability to carry radionuclides. The main uncertainties remain in the quantificationofcolloidsundermorerealisticrepository conditions. At saline conditions, like at the Finnish repository site in Olkiluoto, the colloids are unstable and therefore do not affect the radionuclide transport. However, the possible scenario of glacial melt water intrusion may still have to take into account. Repeatable breakthroughs were obtained with the conservative tracers, which provides a good base for the further experiments.

REFERENCE[1] Huber F. M., Heck S., Truche L., Bouby M., Brendlé J.,

Hoess P. and Schäfer T. (2015) Radionuclide desorption kineticsonsyntheticZn/Ni-labeledmontmorillonitenanoparticles. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 148, 426-441.

Valtteri Suorsa, Pirkko HölttäLaboratory of Radiochemistry, Department of Chemistry

University of Helsinki, Finland

This study is a part of Finnish Research Programme on Nuclear Waste Management financed by The State Nuclear Waste Management Fund.

Fig. 2. The granitic block used in the experiments. Water pools were previously installed on the vertical sides and top of the block in order to ensure the saturation of the block and to stabilize the hydraulic head on the vertical faces.

Fig. 3. The Ni-labeled montmorillonite synthesised at KIT-INE. [1]

Fig. 5. The breakthrough curves of different conservative tracerswiththewaterflowrateof50μl/min.

0,000001

0,00001

0,0001

0,001

0,01

0,1

1

1 10 100 1000 10000

c/c0

Time[min]

AGA.A290216

Cl-36070316

AGA020316

H-3070316

H-3230316

H-3080416

AGA150416

AGA190416

0  

200  

400  

600  

800  

0,00   50,00   100,00   150,00   200,00   250,00   300,00  

Z-­‐ave  (nm)  

Time  from  t0  (h)  

GGW1  

GGW2  

"Allard1"  

Allard2  

Fig. 6. Mean colloid size as a function of time. The squares represent Ni-mont. colloids in Allard and the circles in Grimsel water simulant.

Fig. 4.Breakthroughofthefluoresceinecanbeseenintheright part of the fracture marked with red circles.

Fig. 1.Colloid/radionuclideandhostrockinteraction. (EU/BELBaR/T.Schäfer)