automotive design avoiding plastic design pitfalls©1992-2015. paul a. tres. all rights reserved....

25
©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. A UTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield Hills, MI Excerpts from the 7 th English edition of DESIGNING PLASTIC P ARTS FOR ASSEMBLY by Paul A. Tres, © Carl Hanser Verlag, Münich 2014

Upload: others

Post on 01-Mar-2021

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls

Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc.

Bloomfield Hills, MI

Excerpts from the 7th English edition of DESIGNING PLASTIC PARTS FOR ASSEMBLY by Paul A. Tres,

© Carl Hanser Verlag, Münich 2014

Page 2: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

Fixing Honda Pitfall

Page 3: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

Lower Back Comfort Zone

FORE & AFT ADJUSTMENT Provides 2” (50 mm) of infinitely adjustable fore and aft displacement

VERTICAL ADJUSTMENT Five positions allow 2” (50 mm) of vertical adjustment in 0.5” increments

Lumbar Comfort

Page 4: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

Aftermarket Lumbar Support

Page 5: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

Page 6: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

Lumbar Gear Drive

Page 7: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

Page 8: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

• Number of gear teeth = 14 • Metric module = 1.00 • Pressure angle = 20o

• Tooth arc thickness = 1.83 mm • HOB addendum = 1.33 mm • HOB tip radius = 0.43 mm • Roll angle for loading = 42.556o

• Tooth face width = 4.5 mm • Gear input torque = 953.5 N·mm • Root diameter = 12.052 mm • Y –Lewis form factor = 0.37039 • Load tangent to base circle = 144.956 N • Load normal to tooth center line = 119.872 N • Parabola height = 1.72 • Parabola base = 1.995 • Bending moment arm = 1.422 N·mm • Load radius at center of tooth = 7.954 N

Satellite Gear Calculations

Page 9: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

Satellite-Sun Gears FEA

Page 10: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

Satellite Gear MSA

Page 11: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 Strain, %

Stre

ss, M

Pa

Stress, kpsi

16

14

12

10

8

6

4

2

0

120

100

80

60

40

20

0

-40oC

0oC

23oC

80oC

100oC 120oC

70

Tensile Stress/Strain Curves Delrin® 111P NC010 Lot VLD5M37, ISO 11403

Polymer Used: Delrin® 111P NC010

Page 12: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

0.04” (1 mm)

Solution

Page 13: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

Fixing Mercedes Pitfall

Page 14: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

Page 15: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

Page 16: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

Washer Fluid Bottle

Page 17: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

PP Grade PD-626 Units

Yield Stress 4,400 psi

Yield Strain 13 %

Flexural Modulus @ 1% secant 170,000 psi

Rockwell Hardness N/A R Scale

Heat Deflection Temperature @ 66 psi 190 oF

Notched Izod Impact @ 73oF 0.5 ft∙lb/in

Water Absorption after 24 hour N/A %

Density 0.9 g/cm3

Melt Flow Rate 12 dg/min

Polypropylene Properties

Page 18: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

Hot Plate Welding Process

Press

Press

Press

Press

Fusing area

Fixtures

Page 19: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

Weld Joint Design

1.3t = 0.105” (2.6 mm) 0.08” (2 mm)

0.27” (6.8 mm)

0.16” (4 mm)

Page 20: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

Bottle Volume Increased - 7.6l

Page 21: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

Weld Joint Desired

0.16” (4 mm)

Page 22: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

Weld Joint Achieved

Page 23: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

Deep Draw Warpage

Page 24: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

Blow Molding for Redesign

• 9” deep draw induces large warpage

• Increasing 5l initial volume to 7.6l compounded the problem

• Welding tried to compensate for warpage

• Creates pre-stress condition in the weld joint

Solution

Blow molding process

eliminates the design pitfall

Page 25: AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved. AUTOMOTIVE DESIGN Avoiding Plastic Design Pitfalls Paul A. Tres ETS, Inc. Bloomfield

©1992-2015. Paul A. Tres. All rights reserved.

Thank you! Questions??