an analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of...

26
Enhet Sign 2006-06-07 An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm barrels and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from clothing Jan Andrasko National Laboratory of Forensic Science, Sweden

Upload: vodang

Post on 04-Apr-2018

222 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm barrels

and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from clothing

Jan AndraskoNational Laboratory of Forensic

Science, Sweden

Page 2: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

Appearance of propellant grains on clothing

(shooting distance about 30 cm)

Page 3: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

Smokeless powder recovered from pistol barrel

Smokeless powder on clothing

Page 4: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

Various shapes of smokeless powder

Page 5: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

Some examples of smokeless powder

Page 6: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

Composition of smokeless powder

• Nitrocellulose 80 – 99 %• Nitroglycerine 0 – 20% (double-base powder)• Stabilizers ca. 1%

– Diphenylamine (DPA)– Ethylcentralite (EC)– Methylcentralite (MC)– Hydroquinone– Resorcinol

• Compounds reducing smoke and muzzle flash– 2,4-Dinitrotoluen (2,4-DNT)– 2,6-Dinitrotoluen (2,6-DNT)

• Plasticizers– Diethylphthalate (DEP)– Dibutylphthalate (DBP)– Dioctylphthalate– Diphenylphthalate– etc.

• Products of the reaction between nitric oxide and stabilizers– 2-Nitrodiphenylamine < 0,1%– 4-Nitrodiphenylamine < 0,1%– N-nitrosodiphenylamine ca. 0,5 –1%

• Graphite

Page 7: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

Page 8: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

Gas chromatography

GC/FID

GC/MS

Suitable mainly for qualitative analysis of propellants.Thermally unstable compounds such as nitroglycerine and N-nitrosodiphenylamine can not be determined quantitatively.The sensitivity is good – a single partially burned grain issufficient for analysis.

Micro Thermal Desorption can be performed rapidly, withoutuse of solvents for extraction.

High pressure liquid chromatography

(HPLC)

Suitable for quantitative analysis, even of thermally unstablecompounds and nitrated derivatives of stabilizers.

Extraction with methanol overnight.

Analytical methods used

Page 9: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

Compound Abbreviation Chemical structure

Diphenylamine DPA

N-nitrosodiphenylamine N-nitroso-DPA

2-nitrosodiphenylamine 2-nitroso-DPA

2-nitrodiphenylamine 2-nitro-DPA

4-nitrodiphenylamine 4-nitro-DPA

2,2´-dinitrodiphenylamine 2,2´-dinitro-DPA

2,4-dinitrodiphenylamine 2,4-dinitro-DPA

2,4´-dinitrodiphenylamine 2,4´-dinitro-DPA

NH

NO

NH

NO2

NH

NO2NO2

NH NO2

NH NO2

NO2

NH NO2

NO2

N

NO

NH

Possible derivatives from diphenylamine nitration

Page 10: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

Differences in propellant composition

Page 11: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

Nonfired smokeless powder (caliber .22)

manufacturer NG 2,4-DNT DPA centralite I centraliteII

DEP DBP DPP 2-nitroDPA

4-nitro DPA other peaks(ret.times)

Fiocchi + + + - + - + - + +Norma - - + - + + + - + + 20.66Vostok + - + + + - - - + + 12.57CCI + - + - + - - - + + 16.75Remington + - + - + - - - + +Schönebeck - - + - - - - - + +FN + + + - - - + - + +Lapua - - + - + - - - + +ELEY - - + - - - - - + + 23.50RWS + + + - + - + - + + 20.67Hinterberger - - + - - - - - + + 19.63Winchester + + + - - - + + + + 19.63ICI + - - - + - - - - -Remington + - + - - - + - + + 27.64Remington + - - - + - - - - -Selier&Bellot - - + - - - - - + +Winchester + + + - - - + + + + 14.68Federal + + + - + - + - + +Remington + - + - - - - - + +

DEP, DBP, DPP – diethyl-, dibutyl and diphenyl phthalate

Page 12: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

Nonfired smokeless powder (caliber .22)

manufacturer NG 2,4-DNT DPA centralite I centraliteII

DEP DBP DPP 2-nitroDPA

4-nitro DPA other peaks

Fiocchi 10.4 19.4 100 - 294.9 - 11.9 - 8.1 20.9Norma - - 100 - 89.1 4.8 313.8 - 3.0 5.8 20.66Vostok 19.75 - 100 52.9 1.9 - - - 11.9 34.4 12.57CCI 19.55 - 100 - 10,6 - - - 6.9 12.35 16.75Remington 12.4 - 100 - 238.3 - - - 7.6 7.8Schönebeck - - 100 - - - - - 3.35 6.2FN 45.3 3.3 100 - - - 19.2 - 19.8 49.9Lapua - - 100 - 49.85 - - - 17.1 24.7ELEY - - 100 - - - - - 3.65 4.0 23.50RWS 21.5 1.55 100 - 138.9 - 7.0 - 14.4 33.6 20.67Hinterberger - - 100 - - - - - 6.1 10.6 19.63Winchester 35.0 17.8 100 - - - 41.6 5.95 19.2 39.8 19.63ICI 11.7 - - - 100 - - - - -Remington 11.2 - 100 - - - 1.0 - 2.95 9.9 27.64Remington 24.35 - - - 100 - - - - -Selier&Bellot - - 100 - - - - - 6.0 7.3Winchester 19.4 57.15 100 - - - 26.5 377.0 11.8 18.7 14.68Federal 10.5 8.1 100 - 310.6 - 19.7 - 8.1 12.8Remington 45.8 - 100 - - - - - 50.6 91.7

DEP, DBP, DPP – diethyl-, dibutyl and diphenyl phthalate

Page 13: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

HPLC analysis

Page 14: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

GC comparison of propellant particles from clothing and firearm barrel

Page 15: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

GC comparison of propellant particles fromclothing and firearm barrel

Page 16: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

HPLC comparison of propellant particlesfrom clothing and firearm barrel

Page 17: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

HPLC comparison of fired and non-fired propellant

Page 18: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

retention time unfired cloth, largegrains

cloth, smallgrains

pistol barrel

4.0 (NG) 19.2 20.7 20.9 20.94.5 0.10 0.47 0.59 0.834.9 0.13 0.945 1.32 1.695.2 0.35 0.78 0.78 0.767.0 (N-nitrosoDPA) 27.85 28.9 30.0 32.37.2 (2,4´-dinitroDPA?) 0.11 1.22 1.58 2.527.7 (4-nitroDPA) 2.43 3.50 4.04 5.248.1 (DPA) 43.15 37.7 35.4 30.5511.5 (2-nitroDPA) 7.25 7.97 8.07 8.45

2-nitroDPA/4-nitroDPA 2.97 2.27 1.99 1.61N-nitroso/4-nitroDPA 11.45 8.24 7.42 6.16N-nitroso/2-nitroDPA 3.84 3.63 3.72 3.827.2/4-nitroDPA 0.045 0.35 0.39 0.48

Walther pistol, caliber 7.65mm

PMC smokeless powder

Quantitative analysis by HPLC

Page 19: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

Composition of different production lots may vary a lot (fired propellant)

Page 20: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

A manufacturer can sometimes change the composition of the product significantly

Page 21: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

Small qualitative or semiquantitative differences can be detected

(fired propellant)

Page 22: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

Different propellant with similar composition

Page 23: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

SPME holder with the fibre removed

Page 24: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

Ink sample for thermal desorption

Page 25: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

Inserting ink sample for thermal desorption

A

B

Page 26: An analysis of smokeless powder from inside of firearm ... · and a comparison with grains of smokeless powder from ... Sign 2006-06-07 Appearance of propellant ... CCI 7.65 mm ammunition

EnhetSign 2006-06-07

GC analysis of single particles by micro thermal desorption