title slide 1 03060. importance of process comparative cost estimates ventilation and other...

Title Slide

103060

Importance of process Comparative cost estimates Ventilation and other environmental issues

03079/2

Design process Tunnel structure Ventilation Lighting Finishes

03079/3

Determine number of lanes needed Select tunnel shape Determine depth required Analyze ground characteristics Select tunnel construction method

03079/4

03079/5

Depth

03079/6

Hard ground Soft ground Under water

03079/7

Tunnel boring machines Road headers Drill and blast

03079/8

Cut-and-cover Shields Grouting Ground freezing NATM

03079/9

03079/10

Immersed tube

Types of tunnel ventilation systems Natural Longitudinal Transverse

03079/11

03079/12

03079/13

03079/14

03079/15

03079/16

Eisenhower TunnelUSA

Mont-Blanc TunnelSwitzerland

03079/17

Symmetrical Line of sight Counter-beam

CCTV

Radio rebroadcast, cell phone

CO, NOX

Monitor

Wall tile or panel

Pavement

Ceiling Panel

Exhaust air

Supply airSupply air

Lights on ceiling or wall

Emergency walkway and egress system

03079/18

03079/19

Ted Williams TunnelBoston, Massachusetts

LaerdallNorway

03079/20

Rank Name LocationLength(miles)

YearComp

Vehicles/Day(x1,000)

Ventilation “Air Cleaning”

Technology

1 Laerdal Norway 15.3 2000 1 Electrostatic precipitators;

NOx filtration; CO-unknown

3 Zhongwanshan China 11.3 2009 Unknown

4 St. Gotthard Road Tunnel

Switzerland 10.5 1980reopened

2001

19 None

5 Arlberg Austria 8.6 1978 None

03079/21

2 TBD California,USA

11.5 TBD 110 est. TBD

03079/22

Rank Name LocationLength(miles)

YearComp

Vehicles/Day(x1,000)

Ventilation “Air Cleaning”

Technology

6 Hsuehshan China/ Taiwan

8.1 2005 None

7 Frejus France/Italy 8.0 1980 3.3 trucks/day

None

8 Mont-Blanc France/Italy 7.3 1965reopened

2002

2.5 trucks/day

None

Portage Glacier Highway

Alaska, USA

2.5 2000 None

Eisenhower Tunnel

Colorado, USA

1.7 1973/1979

31.1 None

Hanging Lake Colorado, USA

0.7 1992 19.8 None

Establish a process for reviewing tunnel alternatives

Insist on comparative cost estimates Insist on ventilation solutions as part of

all tunneling evaluations

03079/23

Do tunnels cost more than highways and bridges? If so, how much more?

Is there a way to clean the air that comes out of the ventilation building before releasing it into the atmosphere?

Does the air that comes out of the vent building smell? Will I be able to see it coming out (like a smokestack)?

How do the environmental regulators generally regard tunnel projects – positively or negatively?

What do you do with all the dirt and rock that’s excavated from a tunnel project?

. . .03079/24