a model for consciousness based on the sequential behavior of the conscious actions f. anceau

© F. Anceau , Page 1

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

A Model for Consciousness Based on the Sequential Behavior of A Model for Consciousness Based on the Sequential Behavior of the Conscious Actionsthe Conscious Actions

F. ANCEAUF. ANCEAU

CNAM - ParisCNAM - Parisanceau@cnam.franceau@cnam.fr

http://lmi17.cnam.fr/~anceauhttp://lmi17.cnam.fr/~anceau

© F. Anceau , Page 2

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

One possible story of awareness

The brain of primitive animals was a merging of independent and concurrent control functions.

A possible Darwinian evolution:Under the pressure of the evolution (efficiency of hunting and

escaping), high-level integrative functions begin to appeared.In order to obtain a consistent behavior of these functions, A

Synchronization Mechanism then appeared by the reuse of a part of the Attention Mechanism.

Using this Synchronization Mechanism very efficient high-level Functions (intelligence, memory,…) appear.

Awareness could be that Synchronization Mechanism.

© F. Anceau , Page 3

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

A possible evolution of awareness

fish ? dog ape human?

rising of awareness

innateinnateautomaticautomaticprocessesprocesses

learnedlearnedautomaticautomaticprocessesprocesses

high-levelfunctions

Evolution Stream

© F. Anceau , Page 4

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

The starting points of the discussion (1)

We are talking about "basic" (pure) consciousness Reductive approach:

Pure consciousness is consciousness minus every things which are not absolutely necessary:

- Intelligence

- Long-term memory

- Affects

- Perceptions

- …….. Pure consciousness could be awareness

© F. Anceau , Page 5

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

The starting points of the discussion (2)

Voluntary actions and thoughts are conscious ones.

They are fully sequential:

- It is not possible to do several independent conscious actions in parallel (without any training).

- training improve the efficiency of actions and allows their concurrent execution but such actions becomes automatic (i.e. less voluntary).

The sequentiality could be a basic property of the awareness(We will see that it could also provide a test for awareness)

© F. Anceau , Page 6

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

Principles for consciousness

As in the other domains of science, we have to distinguish between:

- The basic principles of a phenomenon(e.g. aerodynamics is the basic principles of flying)

- Their instantiation in human or animals(e.g. the flight of a bird)

The principles for consciousness must be extracted by scientific investigation.

Probably, the consciousness of a computer will be as different of the human consciousness than the fight of an aircraft is different of those of a bird.

© F. Anceau , Page 7

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

Specificity of this model of awareness

This model differs from the "standard" one:

- Awareness is not giving meaning to perceptions.

Intentionality is not necessary.

- Awareness is a (specific) process.

- Sequentiality is the main property of this conscious process.

- Awareness provides timing consistency to high-level mental functions (intelligence, reasoning,….).

© F. Anceau , Page 8

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

A SMALL TEST

© F. Anceau , Page 9

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

© F. Anceau , Page 10

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

© F. Anceau , Page 11

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

© F. Anceau , Page 12

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

© F. Anceau , Page 13

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

© F. Anceau , Page 14

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

© F. Anceau , Page 15

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

© F. Anceau , Page 16

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

© F. Anceau , Page 17

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

How many:

Drawings?

Blips?

© F. Anceau , Page 18

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

7 Drawings

9 Blips

© F. Anceau , Page 19

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

Sequentiality

Sequentiality of conscious actions / perceptions seems a logical necessity.

It is not a constraint coming from a resource shortage!(primitive brain was massively parallel)

We have no idea about how we can think in parallel.

This explains why writing a parallel program is so difficult!

We can do parallel actions:

- If they are automatic ones (possibly in parallel to a conscious one)

© F. Anceau , Page 20

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

Automatic actions

Automatic actions are fully parallel.

They can be triggered by conscious thought.

By learning, a sequence of conscious actions becomes automatic (and parallel).

Automatic actions are more efficient and more accurate than conscious ones.

© F. Anceau , Page 21

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

Conscious actions and sequential programming

The formalism of sequential programming can be used to describe conscious actions and thought:

- sequence of actions

- decisions branching

- sub-routine call

- interrupt

- co-routine (simulating parallel execution by stepping)

We can also execute sequences of a set of simultaneous actions (strictly synchronized actions)

© F. Anceau , Page 22

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

Awareness is a (specific) process

Awareness could be seen as a (specific) process(W. James) which could be:

- active (during wake-up state)

- non-active (during sleep or coma) This process can stay active, even when it receives no

percept. “Being-for-myself” could be a specific property of this

process(First person perspective)

Being-in-the-world => Being-for-myself

© F. Anceau , Page 23

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

A process is….

Basic view:

A basic unit of sequential behavior

It contains:

- a state (valid at each time)

- a means to change this state• next state depends on:

• current state• inputs of the process

e. g. an automaton

TUTORIAL!

© F. Anceau , Page 24

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

Awareness is the kernel of Consciousness

Awareness

High-levelmentalfunctions

Consciousness

Consciousness = Awareness + High-level Functions

© F. Anceau , Page 25

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

Awareness

It contains the "Mystery" of consciousness (Chalmers' hard problem)

Awareness could be the same for many animals and human.

We will suggest a model for awareness

© F. Anceau , Page 26

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

High-level Functions

The complexity of the high-level mental functions makes the difference between human and animals

These functions could be approached by engineering:

- Intelligence => Artificial Intelligence

- Memorization => Data Bases

- Deduction => Inference systems, Automatic provers

- Giving meaning => Semantic systems

- …….. They are automatic ones

- We do not feel how they work! Their behavior is non-conscious.

© F. Anceau , Page 27

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

Mental processes

They are:

- The Conscious Process (containing awareness)(fully sequential)

- Many Automatic Processes(working in parallel)

© F. Anceau , Page 28

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

Conscious actions

Conscious (voluntary) actions are triggered by the conscious process

"Reports" about these actions are returned to this process

© F. Anceau , Page 29

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

Voluntary versus Conscious actions

Non-Voluntary actions are automatic ones

- They are triggered by automatic processes• directly by external stimuli

(e.g. burning sensation)

• from a global order given by the conscious process(e.g. running)

- But "Reports" about these actions are returned both:• as feed-back to the automatic processes for control purpose

• as global report to the conscious process

We cannot distinguish between Voluntary and non-Voluntary actions on their feed-back from actions!

© F. Anceau , Page 30

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

(serial) control level(serial) control level

learningmechanism

newautomaticprocess

learnedautomaticprocesses

consciousprocess

automaticprocesses

basic automatic processes (drivers)physicalactions

reportcommand

Awareness

© F. Anceau , Page 31

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

Awareness and Attention

We are conscious of the stimuli on which we are paying attention.

The moving of the "focusing point" of the attention scan sequentially our environment.

- We pay attention on one thing at a time.

- We call "Attention point" the focusing point of the attention.

Then, we can unify the notions of "Attention point" and Awareness.

During the process of the evolution, Awareness could have been derived from the Attention Mechanism.

© F. Anceau , Page 32

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

Attention point movement

A metaphor: The global conditions (affects, intentions, needs,

external events, etc..) could be seen as twisting a metaphoric mental surface where the attention point moves like a ball.

The Attention Point moves on this surface. It triggers automatic processes when it reaches their

”sensitivity areas” It contains nothing else!

We can suggest a neural correlate for the Attention point

or an electrical realization using formal neurons.

© F. Anceau , Page 33

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

Metaphoric mental surface

point d'attention

zone d'activationd'une fonctionautomatique

force locale résultante

surface mentaledéformée

Attention point

Metaphoric surface

Activation areaof an automaticprocess

Local resulting force

© F. Anceau , Page 34

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

Synchronization mechanism

They need a synchronization mechanism to have a consistent behavior of the high level funcions.

- Notions of "before", "after", etc…- The massively parallel structure of the brain do not

provide directly such a synchronization mechanism. The massively parallel computers need also such

synchronization mechanism- Global semaphore, global dating system……

It is not trivial to build a synchronization mechanism on a massively parallel computer.

© F. Anceau , Page 35

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

Awareness as an environment

Awareness could be seen as an environment for high-level functions.

This environment makes possible the very existence of high-level brain functions (intelligence, long-term memory, reasoning..) by providing synchronization mechanism to them.

Being-for-Myself could be a by-product of this environment.

The evolutionary advantage of this synchronization mechanism justify its existence.

© F. Anceau , Page 36

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

Awareness as an environment

environment(sequential)

high-levelautomaticfunctions

elementaryautomatic processes(massively parallel)

consistentbehavior

lack ofconsistency

(sequentialital)

synchronisation

Being-for-myself(by-product)(parallel)

© F. Anceau , Page 37

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

A test for awareness

Look (by functional RMI) for the brain behavior for two different conscious separate stimuli (e.g. sounds and images) without training!

Locate the main brain dipoles responsible of theses responses.

Check (by magneto-encephalography) if the brain gives parallel or sequential answer for a simultaneous stimulation.

Sequential answer => existence of a sequential monitor => existence of awareness.

© F. Anceau , Page 38

Sept. 1-3 2003, Models of Consciousness Exploration Workshop

Conclusions

All of this is only a set of hypothesis!

Experimental verifications are necessary

This model of awareness is very simple- to understand- to implement (e.g. in a computer)

This point of view can give idea to AI developers:- Importance of sequentiality- The necessity to use of a sequential environment for

synchronizing high-level functions But, this simplicity leave a taste of "something is

missing"……. (the Hard Problem!)