adhesion myth or magic
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
1/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRYMYTH OR MAGIC
LCDR ROD GUNNING, DC, USN
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
2/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Background1955-Buonocore applied acid to teeth to render the
tooth more receptive to adhesion.1956- First commercially available bonding agent.1978- Second generation adhesives introduced.
1980s- Total etch concept gains acceptance.1990s-Hybrid layer concept1990s- Multistep and one step adhesive systems.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
3/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Present
Universal, all purpose, or multipurpose adhesivesystems claim to bond to enamel, dentin,amalgam, metal, and porcelain such that makingan appropriate product selection for use in daily
practice becomes difficult.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
4/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
erminologyAdhesion or bonding- The forces or energies betweenatoms or molecules at an interface that hold two phasestogether.Adherend- The surface or substrate that is adhered.Adhesive/ adherent/ bonding agent/ adhesive system- Amaterial that can join substances together, resistseparation, and transmit loads across the bond.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
5/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
erminologyAdhesive failure- The bond that fails at the interface
between the two substrates.Cohesive failure- The bond fails with in one of thesubstrates, but not at the interface.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
6/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Potential Advantages>
Microleakage reduction.> Postoperative sensitivity reduction.> Marginal staining reduction.> Reinforce weakened tooth structure.> Does not act like a wedge.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
7/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Potential Advantages>
Repair deteriorating or debonded restorations.without additional loss of tooth structure.> Expands range of esthetic possibilities.> Minimizes removal of sound tooth structure.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
8/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
I ndications
Replace carious and fractured tooth structure.Fill erosion or abrasion defects in cervical areas.Correct unaesthetic shapes, positions, dimensions,or shades.Bond silver amalgam restorations.Cement crowns.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
9/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
I ndications
Bond orthodontic brackets.Treat dentinal hypersensitivity.Repair fractured porcelain, amalgam, and resinrestorations.Pit and fissure sealants.Core build up foundations.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
10/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Principles of Adhesion
Mechanical Theories Adsorption Theories Diffusion Theories Electrostatic Theories
Etched Enamel
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
11/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Adhesion to enamel is much easier to
achieve than is adhesion to dentin. Enamelcontains primarily hydroxyapatite, whichhas a high surface-free energy, whereasdentin is composed of two distinctsubstrates, hydroxyapatite and collagenwhich has a low surface free energy.
Parameters Affecting Adhesion to Enamel and Dentin
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
12/71
Com positon of Enam el and Dentin by
W eight and Volume95
70
86
50
4
18
2
25
112 12
25
0102030405060708090
100
EnamelW t %
DentinW t %
EnamelVol %
DentinVol %
InorganicOrganicWater
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
13/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Parameters Affecting Adhesion to Enamel and Dentin
Changes in dentinSmear layer Internal and external dentinal wetnessWetting of the adhesivePolymerization contraction of restorative resins
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
14/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Parameters Affecting Adhesion to Enamel and DentinCompensation for polymerization contractionThermal expansion coefficientTransmission of stress across the restoration-toothinterface
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
15/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Parameters Affecting Adhesion to Enamel and DentinChanges in dentinSmear layer Internal and external dentinal wetnessWetting of the adhesivePolymerization contraction of restorative resins
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
16/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Parameters Affecting Adhesion to Enamel and Dentin
Physiologic dentinal sclerosisReactive sclerosisTertiary or reparative dentin
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
17/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGICParameters Affecting Adhesion to Enamel and Dentin
Changes in dentinSmear layer Internal and external dentinalwetnessWetting of the adhesive
Polymerization contraction of restorative resins
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
18/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Parameters Affecting Adhesion to Enamel and DentinThe smear layer is defined as any debris, calcific innature, produced by reduction or instrumentation of dentin, enamel, cementum, or as a contaminant that
precludes interaction with the underlying pure toothtissue.
The smear layer may reduce dentin permeability by asmuch as 86%.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
19/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Parameters Affecting Adhesion to Enamel and DentinChanges in dentinSmear layer Internal and external dentin wetnessWetting of the adhesivePolymerization contraction of restorative resins
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
20/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Parameters Affecting Adhesion to Enamel and Dentin
Internal dentinal wetness occurs withsmear layer removal.
External dentinal wetness may occur with humidity.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
21/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Parameters Affecting Adhesion to Enamel and DentinChanges in dentinSmear layer Internal and external dentinal wetnessWetting of the adhesivePolymerization contraction of restorative resins
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
22/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Parameters Affecting Adhesion to Enamel and Dentin
The adhesive system must sufficientlywet the solid surface, have a viscositythat is low enough to penetrate themicroporosities, and be able to displaceair and moisture during the bonding
process.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
23/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Wetting of a surface by a liquid is
characterized by the contact angle of adroplet placed on the surface. Sufficientwetting of the adhesive will only occur if itssurface tension is less than the surfaceenergy of the adherend.
Parameters Affecting Adhesion to Enamel and Dentin
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
24/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
S u b s t r t
C t c t A l
U > 9 0 U < 9 0
U
Parameters Affecting Adhesion to Enamel and Dentin
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
25/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Parameters Affecting Adhesion to Enamel and DentinChanges in dentin
Smear layer Internal and external dentinal wetnessWetting of the adhesivePolymerization contraction of restorative resins
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
26/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Parameters Affecting Adhesion to Enamel and DentinCurrent resin composites shrink 3-7% by volume.
Bonding interface to tooth is a weak component.Bond strength should be in the range of 17-20 MPa.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
27/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Parameters Affecting Adhesion to Enamel and DentinCompensation for polymerization contraction
Thermal expansion coefficientTransmission of stress across the restoration-toothinterface
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
28/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Parameters Affecting Adhesion to Enamel and Dentin
FlowHygroscopic expansionElasticity
Cervical sealing
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
29/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Parameters Affecting Adhesion to Enamel and DentinCompensation for polymerization contraction
Thermal expansion coefficientTransmission of stress across the restoration-toothinterface
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
30/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Parameters Affecting Adhesion to Enamel and Dentin
The coefficient of thermal expansion of resin isabout four times larger than that of tooth structurewhich may contribute to marginal gap formation.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
31/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Parameters Affecting Adhesion to Enamel and DentinCompensation for polymerization contraction
Thermal expansion coefficientTransmission of stress across the restoration-toothinterface
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
32/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Parameters Affecting Adhesion to Enamel and Dentin
A true bond will transmit stress applied to therestoration to the remaining tooth structure.High masticatory stresses are likely to reduce thelongevity of adhesive restorations.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
33/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Adhesion to EnamelEnamel etching and high surface energy.Clean etched field without moisture and saliva.Bond strengths 25-30 MPa.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
34/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Type of Acid
Acid ConcentrationEtching timeEtchant formRinse time
Etching activationEnamel instrumentation
Enamel condition
Primary vs. PermanentPrism structureFluoridatedDemineralized
Stained
Parameters That Effect Etching On Enamel
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
35/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Development Of Resin Dentinal AdhesivesFirst generationSecond generationThird generationFourth generationFifth generation
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
36/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Development Of Resin Dentinal AdhesivesBuonocore in 1956 reported thatglycerophosphoric acid dimethacrylate (GPDM)could bond to etched dentin.First commercially available dentin bonding agent
introduced with N-phenylglycine glycidylmethacrylate (NPG-GMA).Bond strengths in 2-3 MPa range.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
37/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Development Of Resin Dentinal AdhesivesFirst generationSecond generationThird generationFourth generationFifth generation
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
38/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Development Of Resin Dentinal AdhesivesBond strengths in 5-6 MPa range.Bond to smear layer.Based on phosphorous esters of methacrylatederivates.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
39/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Development Of Resin Dentinal AdhesivesFirst generationSecond generationThird generationFourth generationFifth generation
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
40/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Development Of Resin Dentinal AdhesivesPrimer and adhesive systems introduced.Removal or modification of the smear layer.Hydrophobic and hydrophilic.Bond strengths 10 MPa
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
41/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Development Of Resin Dentinal AdhesivesFirst generationSecond generationThird generationFourth generationFifth generation
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
42/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Development Of Resin Dentinal AdhesivesTotal etch concept.Hybrid zone formation in dentin.Conditioners and primers.Low viscosity unfilled/ semifilled adhesive resin.Copolymerization.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
43/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Development Of Resin Dentinal AdhesivesFirst generationSecond generationThird generationFourth generationFifth generation
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
44/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Development Of Resin Dentinal AdhesivesSingle component bonding systems.Does not represent improved bond strength or microleakage reduction.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
45/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Adhesion to DentinConditioning of dentinPrimersAdhesive resinAdhesive strategies
Cross banded collagenCross banded collagen
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
46/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Adhesion to DentinConditioning of dentinPrimersAdhesive resinAdhesive strategies
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
47/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Adhesion to DentinConditioners such as acids or a calcium chelator (EDTA) chemically alters the dentin surface withthe objective to remove or alter the smear layer,simultaneously demineralize the dentin surface,and expose the microporous scaffold of collagenfibrils.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
48/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Adhesion to DentinConditioning of dentinPrimersAdhesive resinAdhesive strategies
Primer does not plug tubules.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
49/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Adhesion to DentinHydrophilic wetting agentsCompatible with dentin and resinBifunctional moleculeMonomers include HEMA, NTG-GMA,NPG-GMA, PMDA, BPDA, and PENTA
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
50/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Adhesion to DentinConditioning of dentinPrimersAdhesive resinAdhesive strategies
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
51/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Adhesion to DentinHybrid layer stabilization
Resin tagsLow viscosityHydrophobic monomers (bis-GMA, UDMA)Hydrophilic monomers (TEGMA)Wetting agent (HEMA)Oxygen inhibited layer (15 micrometers)
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
52/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Adhesion to DentinConditioning of dentinPrimersAdhesive resinAdhesive strategies
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
53/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Adhesion to DentinHybridizationResin tag formationWet bonding
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
54/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Adhesion to Restorative MaterialsAmalgam bondingCeramic bondingGlass ionomer cements
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
55/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Adhesion to Restorative MaterialsSystems: All bond 2, amalgambond plus, panavia,scotch bond multi-purpose plus.Micromechanical mixing.Bond strength less than 10 MPa.
Potential to weaken amalgam.May increase fracture resistance.May seal better than traditional cavity varnishes.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
56/71
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
57/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Adhesion to Restorative Materials
A B C D E
Silanization with a bifunctional coupling agent.
F
Ceramic Bonding
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
58/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Adhesion to Restorative MaterialsAmalgam bondingCeramic bondingGlass ionomer cements
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
59/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
PolyalkenoicAcid
Silica
CoreCa2+,Al3+,Na+,F-
PolycarboxylateSalt MatrixH+ COO-
Acid Base Setting Reaction of Conventional GI Cements
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
60/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Adhesion to Restorative MaterialsConventional Glass Ionomer Cements
Acid base reactionLong term release of fluorideAdhesion to tooth
Coefficient of thermal expansion
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
61/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Adhesion to Restorative MaterialsResin Modified Glass Ionomer Cements
Acid base reaction.Monomers include HEMA.Photoinitiator (camphorquinone).
Examples: Fugi IILC, Vitremere.Improved properties over conventional GI.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
62/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Adhesion to Restorative MaterialsThe underlying mechanism of adhesion of glassionomer cements to tooth structure is thought to
be an ion-exchange process in which the polyalkenoic acid softens and infiltrates the toothsurface, displacing calcium and phosphate ions.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
63/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Adhesion to Restorative MaterialsAn intermediate adsorption layer of calcium andaluminum phosphates and polyacrylates is formedat the glass ionomer cement-hydroxyapatiteinterface. A reversible breaking and reforming of calcium-carboxyl complexes in the presence of water is suggested to form a dynamic bond.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
64/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Potential Problems with Dentin Adhesive SystemsCuring mechanisms: AccessResin pooling: Polymerization shrinkage 7-8%Film thickness: Solvent vs. aqueousProtocol variations: Application techniques
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
65/71
ADHESIVE DENTISTRY MYTH OR MAGIC
Clinical SignificanceDentin bonding is technique sensitive andelimination of microleakage may be unreliable.Enamel bonding is much more predictable thandentin bonding. With more enamel at the marginsof a preparation, greater confidence can be givenfor the longevity of the adhesive restoration.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
66/71
WAYS TO HANDLE STRESS
When someone says have a nice day, tell themyou have other plans.Forget the diet center and send yourself acandygram.Make a list of things to do that you you have
already done.Go shopping. Buy everything. Sweat in it. Returnit the next day.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
67/71
WAYS TO HANDLE STRESS
Relax by mentally reflecting on your favoriteepisode of The Flintstones during thatimportant seminar.Read the dictionary upside down and look for important messages.
Write a short story using alphabet soup.Stare at people through the tines of a fork and
pretend that they are in jail.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
68/71
YOU MIGHT BE A RESIDENT IF.Instructors dont really care when you turn work inanymore.You start refering to stories like Snow White et al.
You frequently wonder how long you can live on pastawithout getting curvy.You look forward to taking time off to do laundry.You have given up trying to keep your books organized
and are now just trying to keep them all in the samegeneral area.You consider McDonalds real food.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
69/71
YOU MIGHT BE A RESIDENT IF.Everything reminds you of something in your discipline.There is a copier in the library that you consider yours.You look forward to summer because you are more
productive without the distraction of classes.You consider all projects as works in progress.You find the bibliographies of books more interestingthan the actual text.
You have accepted guilt as an inherent feature of relaxation.World War III could take place and youd be clueless.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
70/71
BEFORE I CAME TO RESIDENCYI WISH I HAD KNOWN..
That Sunday is a figment of the worldsimagination.That friends are what makes this placeworthwhile!A farewell is necessary before we can meet again,
and meeting again, after moments or a lifetime, iscertain for those who are friends.
-
8/8/2019 Adhesion Myth or Magic
71/71
BEFORE I CAME TO RESIDENCYI WISH I HAD KNOWN..
That residents throw airplanes, too.That every clock shows a different time.That if I were smart in college- so what?That treatment plans require more time than allthe other classes put together.
That you can know everything and fail a test.That you can know nothing and ace a test.