aabbcc 123456 - praja

AaBbCc123456

M U N I C I PA L C O U N C I L L O R S 2 0 14

M U M B A I R E P O R T C A R D M U N I C I P A L C O U N C I L L O R S 2 0 1 4 3

Founded in 1998, the PRAJA Foundation is a non-partisan voluntary organisation which empowers the citizen to participate in governance by providing knowledge and enlisting people’s participation. PRAJA aims to provide ways in which the citizen can get politically active and involved beyond the ballot box, thus promoting transparency and accountability.

Concerned about the lack of awareness and apathy of the local government among citizens, and hence the disinterest in its functioning, PRAJA seeks change. PRAJA strives to create awareness about the elected representatives and their constituencies. It aims to encourage the citizen to raise his/her voice and influence the policy and working of the elected representative. This will eventually lead to efforts being directed by the elected representatives towards the specified causes of public interest.

The PRAJA Foundation also strives to revive the waning spirit of Mumbai City, and increase the interaction between the citizens and the government. To facilitate this, PRAJA has created www.praja.org, a website where the citizen can not only discuss the issues that their constituencies face, but can also get in touch with their elected representatives directly. The website has been equipped with information such as: the issues faced by the ward, the elected representatives, the responses received and a discussion board, thus allowing an informed interaction between the citizens of the area.

PRAJA’s goals are: empowering the citizens, elected representatives & government with facts and creating instruments of change to improve the quality of life of the citizens of India. PRAJA is committed to creating a transparent, accountable and efficient society through people’s participation.

Òepee HeÀeTb[sMeve ner He#eefvejHes#e keÀece keÀjCeejer mJe³ebmesJeer mebmLee Deens. osMee®³ee jep³ekeÀejYeejele menYeeieer nesC³eemeeþer veeieefjkeÀebveer me#ece JneJes ne J³eeHekeÀ GÎsMe meceesj þsTve 1998 ceO³es Òepee®eer meg©Jeele Peeueer. veeieefjkeÀebveer celeoeveeHegjlee®e efJe®eej ve keÀjlee jepekeÀer³e¢<ìîee DeefOekeÀ me¬eÀer³e JneJes, jep³ekeÀejYeej DeefOekeÀ HeejoMe&keÀ Je pevelesuee GÊejoe³eer DemeeJee ³ee ¢<ìerves ceeefnleer Je %eevee®ee mlej Gb®eeJeC³eemeeþer Òepee mebmLesves efJeefJeOe GHe¬eÀce neleer Iesleues Deensle.

mLeeefvekeÀ mJejep³e mebmLeeb®³ee keÀecee®eer ueeskeÀebvee ceeefnleer vemeles DeeefCe cnCetve l³eebvee ³eeefJe<e³eer keÀceeueer®eer DeveemLee Jeeìles. ns ef®e$e yeoueues Heeefnpes Demes mebmLesuee Jeeìles. ueeskeÀebleerue Goemeerve YeeJevee yeoueC³ee®³ee nsletves Òepeeves DeeHeues ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeer Je l³eeb®es celeoejmebIe ³eeefJe<e³eer peeie=leer keÀjC³eeme meg©Jeele kesÀueer Deens. ³eeletve veeieefjkeÀebveer DeeHeuee DeeJeepe GþJeeJee DeeefCe ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeRvee DeeJeM³ekeÀ les efveCe&³e I³ee³euee Je keÀeces keÀje³euee Yeeie Hee[eJes, ³eemeeþer pevepeeie=leer keÀjC³eeJej Deece®ee Yej Deens. keÀeueeblejeves ³ee Òe³elveeletve meeJe&peefvekeÀ efnlee®³ee ¢<ìerves cenÊJee®³ee cegÐeeJej meecetefnkeÀ keÀece GYes jenerue.

cegbyeF& ns SkeÀ mepeie DeeefCe me¬eÀer³e veeieefjkeÀeb®es Menj JneJes; ³ee¢<ìerves veeieefjkeÀ DeeefCe mejkeÀej ³eeb®³eele HejmHejmebJeeo Ie[JeC³ee®ee Òepee mebmLes®ee Òe³elve Deens. l³eemeeþer www.praja.org ³ee mebmLes®³ee JesyemeeF&ìJej efJeMes<e Dee@veueeF&ve megefJeOee GHeueyOe kesÀueer Deens. ³eeefþkeÀeCeer veeieefjkeÀ DeeHeu³ee celeoejmebIeeleerue ÒeMve lej ceeb[t MekeÀleele®e, efMeJee³e mebyebefOele ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeRMeer mebHeke&Àner keÀª MekeÀleele. ³ee JesyemeeF&ìJej Òel³eskeÀ celeoejmebIe, efleLeues veiejmesJekeÀ DeeefCe lesLeerue þUkeÀ mecem³eeb®eer ceeefnleer Deens. veeieefjkeÀ DeeHeu³ee mecem³ee ceeb[t MekeÀleele DeeefCe SkeÀceskeÀebMeer mebJeeoner meeOet MekeÀleele.

Òepee®es O³es³e ë veeieefjkeÀ, ueeskeÀÒeefveOeer DeeefCe mejkeÀej DeefOekeÀ me#ece JneJesle ³eemeeþer JeemleJe ceeefnleer Heg{s DeeCeCes DeeefCe veeieefjkeÀeb®es peerJeveceeve Gb®eeJeC³eemeeþer keÀe³e&#ece yeoue Ie[JeCes, ns Òepee®es O³es³e Deens. DeefOekeÀ HeejoMe&keÀ, GÊejoe³eer DeeefCe keÀe³e&#ece meceepe efvecee&Ce JneJee ³eemeeþer ueeskeÀmenYeeieeves keÀece keÀjC³eemeeþer mebmLee Je®eveye× Deens.

2


Chapter Pg. No.

The Team 7

Why was a Report Card needed and what does it contain? 9

Foreword 12

Acknowledgements 15

Assessing the performance of Municipal Councillors objectively 17

Ranking Score Sheet 18

Key Analysis 134

The Methodology

(1) Matrix – Scale of Ranking 162

(2) Parameters for Past Records as per Affidavit 165

(3) Parameters for Present Performance in the Corporation and Committee Meetings 166

(4) Parameters for People’s Perception as per Opinion Poll 169

(5) Parameters for Negative Marking 174

DeO³ee³e He=<þ ¬eÀceebkeÀ

Òepee®eer ìerce 6

ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeR®es ÒeieefleHegmlekeÀ keÀe Heeefnpes DeeefCe keÀmes Heeefnpes? 8

ÒemleeJevee 10

$eÝCeefveos&Me 14

veiejmesJekeÀeb®³ee keÀeceefiejer®es Jemlegefve<þ cetu³eceeHeve 16

¬eÀceJeejer iegCe leeefuekeÀe 18

cegK³e efJeMues<eCe 134

keÀe³e&He×leer

(1) cetu³eceeHeve ceespeHeÆer 149

(2) De@HeÀer[sJnerì Üejs peenerj kesÀuesueer ceeieerue (YetlekeÀeueerve) ceeefnleer 152

(3) ceneveiejHeeefuekeÀe DeeefCe meefceleer yewþkeÀeleerue keÀeceieerjer mebyebOeer cetu³eceeHeve IeìkeÀ 153

(4) pevecele ®ee®eCeervegmeej ueeskeÀeb®eer celes/¢<ìerkeÀesve 156

(5) vekeÀejelcekeÀ iegCeebkeÀvee®es IeìkeÀ 160

TABLE OF CONTENTShe´cegKe efJeMues<eCe


THE TEAMìerce

meuueeieej

Devegpe YeieJeleer GÐeespekeÀ

[e@. meer. Deej. ÞeerOej efJeHeCeve mebMeesOeve efJe<e³ekeÀ J³eeJemeeef³ekeÀ

[er. Sce. megKeìCekeÀj ceepeer ceneveiejHeeefuekeÀe Dee³egkeÌle, cegbyeF& Je Dee³eSSme (efveJe=Êe), ceepeer cegK³e meef®eJe ceneje<ì^ Meemeve

Oe´gJe cegvêe GÐeespekeÀ

Dee³ejerMe ce[sje efMe#eCeefJe<e³ekeÀ meuueeieej, meWìj HeÀe@j efmeJnerue meesmee³eìer®³ee meuueeieej meom³e

peceeue ceskeÀueeF& HejkeÀer³e ®eueveefJe<e³ekeÀ meuueeieej

pegpeg yeemet peeefnjele J³eeJemeeef³ekeÀ

kesÀ. Sce. Sme. (ìerìg) Denlegefue³ee veeruemeve DeesDeejpeer-ceeie&®es ceepeer DeO³e#e DeeefCe meerF&Dees

cegmleHeÀe [e@keÌìj keÀe³eos efJe®eejkeÀ (mee@efueefmeìj)

efveleeF& cesnlee keÀe³e&keÀejer efJeéemle, Òepee HeÀeTb[sMeve, GÐeespekeÀ

jepeve cesnje GÐeespekeÀ

megcebieueer iee[e mebmLeeHekeÀ efJeéemle, Òepee HeÀeTb[sMeve; GÐeespekeÀ

[e@. megcee ef®eìCeerme meceepeMeeðe%e DeeefCe SmeSve[erìer efJeÐeeHeerþe®³ee ceepeer kegÀueiegª

meesveeueer MeenHetjJeeuee yeBkeÀ J³eeJemeeef³ekeÀ

efJeve³e mebIeJeer GÐeespekeÀ

efJeJeskeÀ Demejeveer GÐeespekeÀ

ceekexÀì jerme®e& Spevmeer nbmee jerme®e&

DeMeeskeÀ oeme J³eJemLeeHekeÀer³e meb®eeuekeÀ, nbmee jerme®e&

YeeJesMe ceveefmebIeeveer mebMeesOeve meb®eeuekeÀ, nbmee jerme®e&

DeeefCe nbmee ìerce®es Flej meom³e – levegÞeer Òemeeo, le©Ce Þee@HeÀ, pee@³e ®e¬eÀyeesleea, efJeveeso efleJeejer DeeefCe ®evê efmebie

Òepee®eer ìerce

efceefuebo cnmkesÀ ÒekeÀuHe meb®eeuekeÀ, Òepee HeÀeTb[sMeve

efÒe³eebkeÀe Mecee& ÒekeÀuHe J³eJemLeeHekeÀ, Òepee HeÀeTb[sMeve

DeeefCe Òepee®es Flej keÀce&®eejer Heg{erueÒeceeCes - yeueJeble efkeÀjej, o#elee Yeesmeues, osJeebkeÀ iegjJe, efo#ee efmebn, efoueerHe leebyes, SkeÀveeLe HeJeej, n<e&oe iegb[îes, p³eeslmvee ceiej, keÀewmlegYe Iejle, efkeÀMeesj oUJeer, efveuece efcejeMeer, DeesbkeÀej Keesle, HeefjefCelee ieCesMe, Þe×e Hejye, mJeHveerue þekegÀj DeeefCe efJeHegue Iejle

Advisors

Anuj Bhagwati Trustee, Praja Foundation; Entrepreneur

Dr. C. R. Sridhar Market Research Professional

D M Sukhtankar former Municipal Commissioner, Mumbai and former Chief Secretary, Government of Maharashtra

Dhruv Mundra Entrepreneur

Iris Madeira Trustee, Praja Foundation; Education Consultant, Board of Advisor’s Centre for Civil Society

Jamal Mecklai Trustee, Praja Foundation; Foreign Exchange Consultant

Juju Basu Advertising Professional

K. M. S. (Titoo) Ahluwalia Former Chairman & CEO A.C. Nielsen ORG-MARG

Mustafa Doctor Advocate

Nitai Mehta Managing Trustee, Praja Foundation; Entrepreneur

Rajan Mehra Entrepreneur

Sumangali Gada Founder Trustee, Praja Foundation; Entrepreneur

Dr. Suma Chitnis Social Scientist & former Vice Chancellor, SNDT University

Sonali Shahpurwala Banker

Vinay Sanghi Entrepreneur

Vivek Asrani Trustee, Praja Foundation; Entrepreneur

Market Research Agency Hansa Research

Ashok Das Managing Director, Hansa Research

Bhavesh Mansinghani Sr. Research Director, Hansa Research

And the rest of the Hansa team including Tanushree Prasad, Tarun Shroff, Joy Chakraborty, Vinod Tiwari and Chandra

Singh

Praja Team

Milind Mhaske Project Director, Praja Foundation

Priyanka Sharma Project Manager, Praja Foundation

And rest of the Praja Team including Balwant Kirar, Dakshata Bhosale, Devank Gurav, Diksha Singh, Dilip Tambe, Eknath Pawar, Harshada Gundaye, Jyotsna Magar, Kaustubh Gharat, Kishor Dalvi, Nilam Mirashi, Onkar Khot, Parinita Ganesh, Shraddha Parab, Swapneel Thakur, Vipul Gharat.


WHY WAS A REPORT CARD NEEDED AND WHAT DOES IT CONTAIN?ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeR®es ÒeieleerHegmlekeÀ keÀe Heeefnpes DeeefCe keÀmes Heeefnpes?

The People of India have had Elected Representatives representing them in various bodies from the parliament to the panchayat for the last 60 years.

These representatives have deliberated, debated, questioned, proposed new laws, passed new laws and governed the nation at all levels using the mechanisms given to them by the Constitution of India. The 1950 constitution which we gave to ourselves laid out the way in which we would govern ourselves. In the last three decades we have seen a steady decline in the quality of governance due to various reasons, prime amongst them being commercialisation of politics and criminalisation of politics. This has created a huge governance deficit in our country.The Electorate has remained a silent witness for most part of this and are feeling let down and frustrated by the Government and the elected representatives.

The time when the citizen has a ‘real’ say is during elections which happen once in five years. The elections are the only time when the elected representatives are appraised for their performance in the corresponding term by the electorate.

Looking at the growing problems of Governance and the ever increasing needs of the citizens there is a need of a continuous dialogue and appraisal of the working of the elected representatives.

It is this need of continuous dialogue and appraisal that made Praja develop this Report Card.

Performance Appraisal of Elected Representatives has become the need of the hour.

This appraisal has been done keeping in mind the constitutional role and responsibility of the elected representatives and the opinion of their electorate.

This Report Card covers the working and performance of the 227 elected Municipal Councillors of Mumbai for the period of March 2012 to March 2014; data from the affidavits filed by the Councillors with the election commission; updated data on criminal records (till December 2013); and results of an opinion poll across the City of Mumbai.

We believe this Report Card which we will be publishing every year will give to the citizens, elected representatives, political parties and the government valuable feedback on the functioning of the elected representatives. We also hope that it will set standards and bench marks of the performance of the elected representatives not only in Mumbai but across the country.

DeeHeu³ee osMeeves mJeeleb$³eeHe½eele ÒeeefleefveefOekeÀ ueeskeÀMeener®eer keÀe³e&He×leer mJeerkeÀejueer. cnCetve Heb®ee³eleerHeemetve mebmeosHe³e¥le meJe& mlejebJej ueeskeÀebveer efveJe[tve efouesues ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeer l³eeb®es ÒeefleefveefOelJe keÀjleele.

Yeejleer³e mebefJeOeeveeves DeeKetve efouesu³ee ®eewkeÀìerle keÀece keÀjCes, ®e®ee& Je efJe®eejefJeefvece³e keÀjCes, veJes keÀe³eos cebpetj keÀjCes DeeefCe osMee®ee keÀejYeej ®eeueJeCes ner ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeR®eer peyeeyeoejer Deens. Hejbleg iesu³ee leerve oMekeÀebHeemetve DeeHeu³ee jep³ekeÀejYeeje®ee opee& KeeueeJele ®eeueuee Deens. ³ee®eer DeveskeÀefJeOe keÀejCes Deensle. l³eeHewkeÀer cenÊJee®eer oesve keÀejCes cnCepes jepekeÀejCee®es Jee{les J³eeHeejerkeÀjCe DeeefCe iegvnsieejerkeÀjCe.

jepekeÀejCee®es yeouele peeCeejs mJeªHe Deece pevelee cegkeÀeìHeCes Heenele Deens. DeeHeues mejkeÀej DeeefCe ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeer ³eeb®³eeJej®ee l³eeb®ee efJeéeeme G[le ®eeueuee Deens.

oj Hee®e Je<ee¥veer SkeÀoe efveJe[CegkeÀe ³esleele. ³eeJesUer celeoejebvee KeN³ee DeLee&ves celeÒeoMe&vee®eer mebOeer efceUles. iesu³ee keÀe³e&keÀeUele DeeHeu³ee ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeerves keÀMee ÒekeÀej®es keÀece kesÀues ns leHeemeC³ee®eer efveJe[CetkeÀ ner SkeÀcesJe mebOeer Demeles.

jep³ekeÀejYeejeleerue Jee{l³ee mecem³ee DeeefCe veeieefjkeÀeb®³ee Jee{l³ee iejpee ³ee oesvner®ee efJe®eej keÀjlee veeieefjkeÀebMeer ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeR®ee melele®ee mebJeeo DemeCes iejpes®es Deens. lemes®e l³eeb®³ee keÀecee®es kesÀJeU Hee®e Je<ee&letve SkeÀoe®e veJns lej meelel³eeves cetu³eceeHeve nesCes iejpes®es Deens.

meelel³eHetCe& mebJeeo DeeefCe cetu³eceeHeve MekeÌ³e JneJee ³ee nslegves Òepeeves ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeR®es Òeieefle HegmlekeÀ efJekeÀefmele kesÀues Deens.

ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeR®³ee keÀeceefiejer®es cetu³eebkeÀve ner keÀeUe®eer iejpe Deens.

ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeR®eer IeìveelcekeÀ YetefcekeÀe DeeefCe peyeeyeoejer DeeefCe peveles®eer l³eeefJe<e³eer®eer celes ³ee oesvner®ee efJe®eej keÀªve ner cetu³eceeHeve He×leer efJekeÀefmele kesÀueer Deens.

³ee Òeieleer HegmlekeÀele cegbyeF&leerue 227 veiejmesJekeÀeb®ee cee®e& 2012 les cee®e& 2014 ³ee keÀeueeJeOeerleerue keÀeceefiejer®ee; veiejmesJekeÀeves efveJe[CetkeÀ Dee³eesieeuee De@efHeÀ[sJner[ keÀªve meeoj kesÀuesueer ceeefnleer; iegvnsieejer Heeée&YetceerefJe<e³eer DeÐe³eeJele ceeefnleer (ef[meWyej 2013) He³e¥le DeeefCe cegbyeF& MenjeceO³es kesÀuesueer cele®ee®eCeer ö ³ee DeeOeejs ne uesKeepeesKee Iesleuee Deens.

Deecner Demes ÒeieleerHegmlekeÀ ojJe<eea meeoj keÀjCeej Deenesle. l³eecegUs veeieefjkeÀ, efveJe[tve Deeuesues ÒeefleefveOeer, jepekeÀer³e He#e DeeefCe jep³e mejkeÀej ³eebvee DeeHeu³ee ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeRveer keÀMee ÒekeÀej®eer keÀeceefiejer kesÀueer ns JesUesJesUer ue#eele ³esF&ue. l³eeDeeOeejs cegbyeF&le DeeefCe meJe& osMeYej ³eesi³e keÀejYeeje®es ceeHeob[ efJekeÀefmele kesÀues peeleerue, DeMeer Deecneuee DeeMee Jeeìles.

8


ÒemleeJevee

2014 ®³ee ces ceefnv³eele ueeskeÀmeYes®³ee efveJe[CegkeÀe heej he[u³ee, l³eeefveefceÊeeves osMeYejele DeveskeÀ pevecele ®ee®eC³ee IesC³eele Deeu³ee. yengleskeÀ efþkeÀeCeer ueeskeÀebveer Deeheues he´Mve ceeb[leevee, Dehes#ee J³eÊeÀ keÀjleevee ®eebieues jmles, Meg× heeCeer, ieìejeb®eer mees³e, mJe®ílee Je Meew®eeue³es, yeieer®es, KesUe®eer cewoeves ³ee Je DeMee ieesäeRJej Yej efouee. Kejs lej ner meJe& keÀeces keWÀê eEkeÀJee jep³e mejkeÀej®³ee veJns lej mLeeefvekeÀ mJejep³e mebmLeeb®³ee DeKel³eeefjle ³esleele. cnCetve®e ns®e pej cegbyeF&keÀjeb®es Deie´¬eÀcee®es he´Mve Demeleerue lej l³eeb®³ee mees[JeCegkeÀermeeþer veeieefjkeÀebveer kesÀJeU he=LJeerjepe ®eJneCe Jee vejWê ceesoer ³eeb®³eekeÀ[tve yeouee®eer Dehes#ee ve þsJelee cegbyeF&®³ee 227 veiejmesJekeÀebmeceesj Deeheues cegÎs ceeb[ues heeefnpesle. he´pee HeÀeGb[sMeve®³ee Jeleerves ojJe<eea veiejmesJekeÀeb®es cnCepes l³eeb®³ee keÀeceefiejer®es heíeleer hegmlekeÀ le³eej keÀjC³eele ³esles. ueeskeÀebveer l³eebvee Deeheues heéfleefveOeer cnCetve efveJe[tve efoues Je ceneveiejheeefuekesÀle heeþJeues. heeefuekesÀ®³ee meYesle les ueeskeÀeb®es he´Mve ceeb[leele keÀe? keÀesCekeÀesCeles he´Mve ceeb[leele? les mees[JeC³eemeeþer keÀe³e Je keÀMee he´keÀejs he´³elve keÀjleele? ueeskeÀefnlee®eer keÀesCekeÀesCeleer OeesjCes þjJeleele? - ³ee Je DeMee he´Mveeb®ee ceeieesJee IesC³ee®ee he´³elve he´peekeÀ[tve kesÀuee peelees.Deeheu³ee veiejmesJekeÀeb®³ee keÀeceefiejer®es iegCeebkeÀve keÀªve l³eeb®es heíeleer hegmlekeÀ keÀe{C³eeceeies efJeefMeä nslet Deens. cegbyeF&®ee jepekeÀer³e keÀejYeej megOeejuee heeefnpes, Deeheues ueeskeÀheéfleefveOeer peveleshe´leer GÊejoe³eer Demeues heeefnpesle ³ee nsletves ns keÀece kesÀues peeles. Deeheu³ee ueeskeÀheéfleefveOeeRJejerue IeìveelcekeÀ peyeeyeoeN³ee DeeefCe l³eeb®³ee celeoejmebIeeleerue veeieefjkeÀeb®es l³eeb®³ee keÀeceefiejeryeeyele®es cele ³ee DeeOeejs veiejmesJekeÀeb®es iegCeebkeÀve kesÀues peeles. meJe& 227 veiejmesJekeÀeb®es heíeleer hegmlekeÀ le³eej keÀjC³eele ³esles Je l³eeceO³es efJeefMeä mebK³eelcekeÀ Je iegCeelcekeÀ ³ee oesvnerner IeìkeÀeb®ee efJe®eej kesÀuee peelees. ceeefnleer DeefOekeÀej keÀe³eÐeeKeeueer Deecner DeeJeM³ekeÀ mebK³eelcekeÀ ceeefnleer mebkeÀefuele keÀjle Demelees. lemes®e nbmee efjme®e& ³ee mebmLesJej mebMeesOevee®eer peyeeyeoejer meesheJeueer Demetve l³eebveer 22,580 veeieefjkeÀeb®³ee cegueeKeleerletve l³eeb®es Deeheu³ee ueeskeÀheéfleefveOeerefJe<e³eer®es cele peeCetve Iesleues Deens. ceneheeefuekesÀleerue veiejmesJekeÀeb®eer efveJe[ HesÀye´gJeejer 2012 ceO³es Peeueer, cnCepes l³eebveer oesve Je<ee¥®ee keÀe³e&keÀeue hetCe& kesÀuee Deens. ogmeN³ee Je<eea®³ee (Sefheúe 2013 - cee®e& 2014) heíeleer hegmlekeÀeletve keÀener cenÊJee®³ee yeeyeer efveoMe&veeme Deeu³ee Deensle. l³eehewkeÀer ®eebieu³ee Je mekeÀejelcekeÀ ieesäer he´Lece peeCetve IesT³eele: Deeheeheu³ee meefceleer®³ee yewþkeÀebceO³es 100… GheeqmLeleer DemeCeeN³ee veiejmesJekeÀeb®eer mebK³ee ceeieerue Je<eea (efJeÊeer³e Je<e& 2012-13) 3 nesleer leer Jee{tve ³ee Je<eea 5 Peeueer Deens (oerhekeÀ YetlekeÀj, Deefveue eE$eyekeÀkeÀj, DevegjeOee hes[CeskeÀj, nsceebieer JejUerkeÀj, veesMeerj cesnlee). ³ee ogmeN³ee Je<ee&le ceeie®³eehes#ee 27… peemle he´Mve/cegÎs efJe®eejues/ G®eueues iesues (2012-13 efJeÊeer³e Je<ee&le 2232 he´Mve efJe®eejues lej 2013-14 efJeÊeer³e Je<ee&le 2835 he´Mve efJe®eejues iesues). ceeieerue Je<ee&le (2012-13) kesÀJeU SkeÀe veiejmesJekeÀeves 50ntve peemle he´Mve efJe®eejues nesles, lej 2013-14 ceO³es ner mebK³ee Jee{ueer Deens. mene veiejmesJekeÀebveer 50 ntve DeefOekeÀ he´Mve efJe®eejues Deensle. Deveble vej ³eebveer meJee&efOekeÀ he´Mve (91) efJe®eejues Demetve l³eeKeeueesKeeue meF&oe Keeve (85 he´Mve) DeeefCe oerhekeÀ heJeej (73 he´Mve) ³eebveer efJe®eejues Deensle. ceeieerue Je<eea®³ee leguevesle ³ee Je<eea he´Mveeb®³ee iegCeJeÊesJej 3.8… Jee{ Peeueer Deens. veeieefjkeÀeb®³ee le¬eÀejeR®³ee mebK³es®³ee leguevesle efJe®eejuesu³ee he´Mveeb®es hećeeCe 28.7… ves Jee{ues Deens. meJe&meeOeejCe iegCeebkeÀveeceO³esner Lees[erMeer Jee{ Peeuesueer Deens; ceeieerue Je<eea mejemejer iegCeebkeÀve 58.57… nesles lej les ³ee Je<eea 59.41… Peeues Deens. Demes mekeÀejelcekeÀ yeoue Peeues Demeues lejer cegbyeF&®es peerJeveceeve megOeejues Deens Demes cee$e efomele veener. ³ee®es keÀejCe keÀe³e DemeeJes? cegbyeF&leerue he´Mveeb®eer J³eehleer heenlee Peeuesuee yeoue Je megOeejCee DehegN³ee Je Lees[îee Deensle. Deelee keÀener ve yeoueuesu³ee Jee eE®eleepevekeÀ ieesäer heent³ee:

meJe&meeOeejCe GheeqmLeleer®es hećeeCe 6.7… ves keÀceer Peeues Deens. SkeÀner he´Mve ve efJe®eejuesu³ee veiejmesJekeÀeb®eer mebK³ee ceeieerue efJeÊeer³e Je<ee&le (2012-13) 13 nesleer, leer ³eboe (efJeÊeer³e Je<e& 2013-14) keÀceer Peeueer Deens. cee$e ³ee Je<eeaner 10 veiejmesJekeÀebveer SkeÀner he´Mve efJe®eejuesuee veener. ³eehewkeÀer keÀener veiejmesJekeÀ Demes Deensle (Deefvelee ³eeoJe, p³eeslmvee hejceej, ueefuelee DeCCeece}eF&) ³eebveerner iesu³ee Je ³ee DeMee oesvner Je<ee&le, cnCepes®e efveJe[tve Deeu³eeheemetve SkeÀner he´Mve efJe®eejuesuee veener. SketÀCe he´Mveeb®³ee mebK³esle Jee{ Peeuesueer Deens (28.7…), cee$e l³eeleerue veeiejer megefJeOeebefJe<e³ekeÀ he´Mveeb®eer mebK³ee keÀceeueer®eer keÀceer (26.9…) Deens. veiejmesJekeÀebyeeyele®eer ceeefnleer, ueeskeÀmebheke&À ³eeb®es hećeeCe 27.7… ves, lej ueeskeÀeb®³ee vepejsletve ®eebieu³ee keÀeceefiejer®es hećeeCe 11.8… ves Ieìues Deens, Demesner Deece®³ee meJex#eCeeletve efometve ³esle Deens. iegCeebkeÀveevegmeej `ye' ÞesCeer efceUCeeN³ee veiejmesJekeÀeb®eer mebK³ee ceeieerue efJeÊeer³e Je<ee&le 28 nesleer, leer ³eboe Jee{tve 34 Peeueer Deens. heCe SkeÀener veiejmesJekeÀeves `De' ÞesCeer mebheeefole kesÀuesueer veener. ns®e pej ueeskeÀheéfleefveOeeR®es JeemleJe ef®e$e Demesue lej Deeheu³ee Menjele `De' ÞesCeer®³ee mesJeemegefJeOee keÀMee GheueyOe nesleerue? Deeheu³ee veiejmesJekeÀebJej Menje®³ee efJekeÀemee®eer peyeeyeoejer Deens. ner l³eeb®eer IeìveelcekeÀ peyeeyeoejer Deens, ns l³eebveer mecepetve Iesleues heeefnpes Je efle®es heeueve kesÀues heeefnpes. veiejmesJekeÀebveer ceneheeefuekesÀceO³es Deeheu³ee celeoejmebIeeleerue veeieefjkeÀeb®es Je l³eeb®³ee he´Mveeb®es heéfleefveefOelJe keÀje³e®es Demeles. mesJeemegefJeOee osCes ns veiejmesJekeÀeb®es veJns lej he´MeemekeÀer³e ³eb$eCes®es keÀece Deens. ³ee mesJeemegefJeOee megjUerleheCes ®eeueleele keÀer veener ³eekeÀ[s ue#e osCes, l³ee¢äerves ³esCeeN³ee mecem³eeb®es efvejekeÀjCe keÀjC³eemeeþer keÀece keÀjCes ne veiejmesJekeÀeb®³ee peyeeyeoejer®ee Yeeie Deens. ner peyeeyeoejer heej hee[C³eemeeþer cees®ex, efveoMe&ves keÀe{C³ee®eer DeeJeM³ekeÀlee veener. lej ueeskeÀheéfleefveOeeRveer ³ee mecem³ee ceneheeefuekeÀe meYesle ceeb[u³ee heeefnpesle, mees[JeC³eemeeþer l³eeb®ee heeþhegjeJee kesÀuee heeefnpes. veeieefjkeÀ DeeefCe he´Meemeve ³eeb®³eeleerue ogJee cnCetve keÀece kesÀues heeefnpes. ³eemeeþer l³eebveer le¬eÀej efveJeejCe ³eb$eCeskeÀ[s Centralised Complaint Registration System (CCRS) Deeuesu³ee veeieefjkeÀeb®³ee le¬eÀejeR®ee DeY³eeme kesÀuee heeefnpes, veeieefjkeÀebMeer meelel³eeves mebJeeo meeOeuee heeefnpes DeeefCe ceneheeefuekesÀleerue mebyebefOele yewþkeÀe Je meefcel³eebkeÀ[s heeþhegjeJee kesÀuee heeefnpes. he´mleeJeves®³ee meceejeshe keÀjleevee ceuee keÀener ®eebieu³ee ieesäeR®ee GuuesKe keÀje³e®ee Deens DeeefCe 2014 ®³ee iegCeebkeÀveeleerue heefnu³ee leerve ¬eÀceebkeÀeJejerue veiejmesJekeÀeb®es, mvesnue DeebyeskeÀj (78.46…), nsceebieer JejUerkeÀj (78.43…) DeeefCe %eevecegleea Mecee& (77.97…), ³eeb®es DeefYevebove keÀje³e®es Deens. heefnu³ee one ¬eÀceebkeÀeJejerue ueeskeÀheéfleefveOeeRceO³es m$eer Je heg©<e veiejmesJekeÀeb®eer mebK³ee yejesyejerves, cnCepes hee®e-hee®e DeMeer Deens, nerosKeerue efJeMes<e veeWo IesC³eemeejKeer yeeye Deens. jepekeÀer³e he#eefvene³e heenlee heefnu³ee one ¬eÀceebkeÀeJejerue veiejmesJekeÀebceO³es 5 efMeJemesves®es, 3 Yeepehee®es DeeefCe 2 keÀeBie´sme®es Deensle. Yeepehee veiejmesJekeÀeb®es mejemejer iegCeebkeÀve meJee&efOekeÀ cnCepes 65.26… Demetve l³eeheeþesheeþ efMeJemesvee (60.56…) DeeefCe jeä^Jeeoer keÀeBie´sme (58.13…) ³ee he#eeb®es Deens.cegbyeF&®³ee heeuekeÀlJee®eer peyeeyeoejer hesueCeeN³ee ³ee meJe&®e ueeskeÀheéfleefveOeeR®es ceve:hetJe&keÀ DeefYevebove! heg{erue Je<eea ³ee veiejmesJekeÀeb®eer keÀeceefiejer Je l³eeb®es iegCeebkeÀve ³eehes#ee DeefOekeÀ ®eebieues nesF&ue DeMeer DeeMee Deens.

efveleeF& cesnlee, J³eJemLeeHekeÀer³e efJeéemle, he´pee HeÀeTb[sMeve


FOREWORD

During the May 2014 general elections, opinion polls across the country showed that the top issues concerning citizens are good roads, clean water, drainage, sanitation, parks, play grounds and so on. These services are ensured by the local self government institutions and not the central or the state governments. If those are the main issues then Mumbaikars need to be more vigilant and engaged with Mumbai’s 227 elected Municipal Councillors and ‘not’ just with Prithviraj Chavan or Narendra Modi. Through our Municipal Councillor Report Card Praja conducts an annual performance appraisal of how your ‘Nagar Sevaks’ have performed? Are they raising the right issues in the forums where you have sent them to represent you? Are they setting the right policies? Are they engaged with you to solve your issues?

Praja Foundation has been painstakingly creating the rankings of elected representatives for the city of Mumbai to improve its governance and add accountability to its elected representatives. The appraisal has been done keeping in mind the Constitutional role and responsibility of the elected representatives and the opinions of their electorate. The Report Card covers the working and performance of the 227 Municipal Councillors on different parameters, both quantitative and qualitative. We have collected our quantifiable data through RTI applications over the year. We also commissioned Hansa Research to do a scientific-statistical survey among over 22,580 households (people) of Mumbai to gauge the public perception of the Municipal Councillors on the above mentioned parameters.

After getting elected in February 2012, our Municipal Councillors have completed two years in office. The second year (April 2013-March 2014) report card gives interesting insights into their performance. First the good news:

As compared to only three Municipal Councillors in the earlier year (FY 2012-13), five Municipal Councillors (Deepak Bhutkar, Anil Trimbakkar, Anuradha Pednekar, Hemangi Worlikar, Noshir Mehta) have 100% attendance in their respective committee meetings. A total of 27% more questions/issues were asked/raised in the second year of their current term (2232 questions in Financial Year 2012-13 which increased to 2835 in FY 2013-14). As compared to only one Municipal Councillor in the earlier year (FY 2012-13), six Municipal Councillors have asked more than 50 questions during FY 2013-14. Anant Nar has asked the most (91) questions followed by Saeeda Khan (85 questions) and Deepak Pawar (73 questions). Compared to the earlier year there is an overall increase in the quality of questions by 3.8%. While proportion of Questions asked compared to citizen's complaints has increased by 28.7%. Even the overall score has increased slightly from 58.57% in the earlier year to 59.41% currently.

But if there has been such improvement then why aren’t we seeing the same in the quality of life in Mumbai? This is because the improvement is only slight and not enough looking at the quantum of the overall problems our city faces:

Overall attendance has dropped by 6.7%. As compared to last year (FY 2012-13) when we had 13 Municipal Councillors who had not asked a single question we still have 10 Municipal Councillors who haven’t asked a single question this year (FY 2013-14); of this there are three Municipal Councillors (Anita Yadav, Jyotsna Parmar, Lalita Annamalai) who haven’t asked a single question in both the years since they were elected. Inspite of the (28.7%) rise, proportion of Questions asked compared to civic complaint's remains a pathetic 26.9%. According to our survey, overall awareness and accessibility of the Municipal Councillors has dropped by 27.7%; overall perceived performance has dropped by 11.8%. Although Municipal Councillors who have received an overall ‘B’ grade have increased from 28 in 2012-13 to 34 in 2013-14, we still don’t have any Municipal Councillor who is getting an ‘A’ grade.

If this is the case, then how can we expect our city to get ‘A’ grade services?

The custodians of the city, our Municipal Councillors, need to understand and follow their Constitutional role in letter and spirit, which is deliberation. They primarily represent their constituencies and their issues in the corporation and do not execute the services provided by the corporation for which we have the administrative wing. They are required to ensure smooth delivery of the services by raising issues in the corporation forums and not by taking ‘morchas’ on the corporation’s officers. They are the link between citizens and the administration, for which they must study citizens’ complaints, registered in their wards from the Centralised Complaint Registration System (CCRS) and by interacting with their constituents and then raise the relevant issues in respective meetings of the corporation.

Let me conclude on a positive note by congratulating the top three rankers of our 2014 Report Card, Snehal Ambekar (78.46%), Hemangi Worlikar (78.43%) and Gyanmurti Sharma (77.97%). In the top 10, gender equality is maintained with five male Municipal Councillors and equal number of female Municipal Councillors. In the top 10, Shiv Sena has five Municipal Councillors, BJP three and INC two. Overall, with an average score of 65.26% BJP is the top party followed by Shiv Sena at 60.56% and NCP at 58.13%.

On behalf of Praja Foundation, we extend our heartiest congratulations to these custodians of the city! We can only hope for an overall improvement in rankings for next year.

Nitai Mehta, Managing Trustee, Praja Foundation


ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS$eÝCeefveoxMe

Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it’s the only thing that ever has.

– Margaret Mead

Change comes when people stand up and demand for it, and then strive to get it. Today we are at that juncture of history where time demands that we stand up and demand that change and go and get it.

Individuals involved in developing this report card strongly believe that they cannot just wait and remain mute spectators when time is demanding action from them. All of them have come together to develop this report card with an over-arching belief in the Constitution of India and the opportunity it creates for improved and efficient governance – the mean towards achieving the high ideals of the constitution – Justice, Liberty, Equality and Fraternity.

This book is a compilation of sincere, concerned efforts of the Core Praja Team. We would like to particularly appreciate the guidance of: D M Sukhtankar, Dr. C R Sridhar, KMS (Titoo) Ahluwalia and Dr. Suma Chitnis. And also to Praja’s Advisors for their active support.

It is important here to acknowledge Hansa Research for conducting the opinion poll.

It is also very important to acknowledge the support of Vakils for doing a splendid publishing work.

Praja has obtained much of the data used in compiling this report card through Right to Information Act, 2005; without which sourcing information on the Municipal Councillors would have been very difficult. Hence, it is very important to acknowledge the RTI Act and everyone involved, especially from the civil society, in bringing such a strong legislation. Also to those government officials who believe in the RTI act and strive for its effective implementation.

Very importantly, Praja Foundation appreciates the support given by:

efJe®eejer DeeefCe DeeHeu³ee O³es³eeMeer ÒeeceeefCekeÀ DemeCeeN³ee veeieefjkeÀeb®ee uenevemee mecetn peie yeouet MekesÀue keÀe, DeMeer MebkeÀener ceveele DeeCet vekeÀe; keÀejCe DeepeJej kesÀJeU ³eecegUs®e yeoue Ie[uee Deens.

– ceeiee&jsì ceer[

yeoue lesJne®e Ie[sue pesJne ueeskeÀ peeie=le nesleerue, ceeieCeer keÀjleerue DeeefCe leer HetCe& nesC³eemeeþer meJe&leesHejer Òe³elve keÀje³euee meppe nesleerue. Deepe DeeHeCe SkeÀe DeMee SsefleneefmekeÀ ìHH³eeJej GYes Deenesle, pesJne keÀeUe®eer DeeHeu³eekeÀ[tve ner®e ceeieCeer Deens ö yeoue Ie[JeC³eemeeþer Gþe, meppe Jne DeeefCe lees keÀªve oeKeJee.

Deepe®ee keÀeU DeeHeu³eekeÀ[tve keÀener þesme ke=Àleer®eer DeHes#ee keÀjCeeje keÀeU Deens. DeMee JesUer Meeble jentve nesCeeN³ee Ieìveeb®es cetkeÀ mee#eeroej nesCes yejesyej veener. ³ee efJe®eejeves SkeÀ$e ³esTve Deecner keÀener ueeskeÀebveer ³ee Òeieleer HegmlekeÀe®³ee keÀeceeuee meg©Jeele kesÀueer. Deece®ee Yeejlee®³ee jep³eIeìvesJej efJeéeeme Deens. v³ee³e, mJeeleb$³e, mecelee DeeefCe yebOeglJe ³ee Ieìvesves Ieeuetve efouesu³ee lelJeebvee meeO³e keÀjC³ee®eer meeOeves DeeHeu³ee IeìveelcekeÀ ®eewkeÀìerle®e GHeueyOe Deensle DeeefCe DeeHeu³eeuee DeeHeuee jep³ekeÀejYeej DeefOekeÀ ®eebieuee Je keÀe³e&#ece keÀjC³ee®eer mebOeerner jep³eIeìvesletve GHeueyOe Deens, ³eeJej Deece®eer DeHeej Þe×e Deens.

ns HegmlekeÀ le³eej keÀjC³eeceO³es Òepee ìerce®³ee ceveëHetJe&keÀ kesÀuesu³ee keÀe³ee&®ee ceesþe Jeeìe Deens. keÀener J³ekeÌleeR®³ee ceeie&oMe&vee®ee ³eeefþkeÀeCeer efJeMes<e GuuesKe keÀjCes DeeJeM³ekeÀ Deens ë [er. Sce. megKeìCekeÀj, [e@. meer. Deej. ÞeerOej, kesÀSceSme (ìerìg) DenuegJeeefue³ee Dee [e@. megcee ef®eìCeerme ³eeb®es DeeefCe Òepee meuueeieej meom³eebveer kesÀuesu³ee me¬eÀer³e ³eesieoeveeyeÎue Deecner l³eeb®es DeeYeejer Deenesle.

nbmee jerme®e&ves pevecele ®ee®eCeer®es keÀece kesÀues Demetve ³ee cenÊJee®³ee keÀeceeyeÎue l³eeb®es DeeYeej.

lemes®e Del³eble ®eebieu³ee He×leerves ÒekeÀeMevee®es keÀece keÀjCeeN³ee JekeÀeruemed®esner Deecner DeeYeejer Deenesle.

³ee Òeieleer HegmlekeÀemeeþer DeeJeM³ekeÀ yejer®eMeer ceeefnleer Òepeeves ceeefnleer DeefOekeÀej keÀe³eoe, 2005 JeeHeªve efceUJeueer Deens. l³eeefMeJee³e ner ceeefnleer GHeueyOe nesCes Del³eble keÀþerCe nessles. l³eecegUs ne keÀe³eoe DeeefCe lees keÀe³eoe DeeCeC³eemeeþer Je lees HeefjHetCe& JneJee PeìCeejs meJe&peCe, ÒeecegK³eeves keÀe³e&keÀlex Je veeiejer mebmLee ³eeb®esner Deecner DeeYeejer Deenesle. lemes®e ceeefnleer DeefOekeÀej keÀe³eÐeeJej efJeéeeme DemeCeejs DeeefCe l³ee®eer ÒeYeeJeer DebceueyepeeJeCeer keÀjC³eemeeþer Òe³elve keÀjCeeN³ee mejkeÀejer DeefOekeÀeN³eeb®esner Deecner DeeYeej ceevelees.

³ee GHe¬eÀceeme efouesu³ee menkeÀe³ee&yeÎue Heg{erue mebmLeeb®esner DeeYeej ë

Narotam Sekhsaria FoundationNarotam Sekhsaria Foundation FORD FOUNDATIONFORD FOUNDATIONMADHU MEHTA FOUNDATIONMADHU MEHTA FOUNDATION


The air in India is thick with criticism of politicians. The question that arises is: how can the performance of our elected representatives be assessed objectively? Surely the right way cannot be by asking them for their opinion of themselves. Nor is it adequate to get a few political pundits (who may have their own angles) to evaluate them.

The only way such an assessment can be done in a manner that is, and is seen to be, unbiased and credible, is through a systematic and transparent study undertaken independently by respected professionals. That is precisely what The Praja Report Card seeks to accomplish.

The ratings of the Municipal Councillors’s are based on:

(a) Data accessed through RTI on attendance of different Committee Meetings of the Municipal Corporation, number and type of questions raised, use of discretionary funds, etc.

(b) Personal interviews with 22,580 citizens of Mumbai conducted by a reputed survey research organisation, to investigate the views of citizens on their elected representatives.

We believe the Report Card is an important step forward in promoting accountability and transparency in the political governance of the country.

K.M.S. (TITOO) AHLUWALIA, Formerly Chairman & CEO of A.C. Nielsen ORG-MARG

Yeejleele meO³ee jepekeÀer³e Heg{eN³eeb®³ee efJejesOeer pevecele le³eej Peeues Deens. HeCe Keje ÒeMve DeeHeCe ³ee jepekeÀejCeer ueeskeÀeb®³ee keÀeceefiejer®es Jemlegefve<þ cetu³eceeHeve keÀmes keÀjCeej ne Deens. ³eemeeþer l³eebvee l³eeb®³ee keÀeceeyeÎue keÀe³e Jeeìles ns efJe®eejCes Hegjsmes veener. efkebÀJee keÀener jepekeÀer³e le%e ceb[UeRvee cetu³eceeHeve keÀje³euee meebieCesner ³eesi³e þjCeej veener (l³eeb®ee mJeleë®eener keÀener SkeÀ keÀue Demet MekeÀlees).

HeejoMe&keÀ DeeefCe He×leMeerj mJeªHee®³ee DeY³eemeeletve ueeskeÀÒeefveOeeR®es meceleesue, HetJe&ûenefJejefnle DeeefCe efJeéeemeen& cetu³eceeHeve keÀjCes MekeÌ³e Deens. DeeefCe Demes cetu³eceeHeve keÀjCes ne Òepee Òeieleer HegmlekeÀe®³ee keÀecee®ee nsleg Deens.

veiejmesJekeÀeb®es cetu³eceeHeve Heg{erue iees<ìeRJej DeeOeeefjle Deens.

(De) ceneievejHeeefuekesÀ®³ee efJeefJeOe meefceleer yewþkeÀebvee GHeefmLeleer, efJe®eejuesu³ee ÒeMveeb®eer mebK³ee Je ÒekeÀej veiejmesJekeÀ efveOeer®ee efJeefve³eesie Fl³eeoer ceeefnleer DeefOekeÀejeKeeueer efceUJeuesueer ceeefnleer.

(bye) cegbyeF&leerue 22,580 veeieefjkeÀeb®³ee Jew³eefkeÌlekeÀ cegueeKeleer ö ³ee cegueeKeleer SkeÀe ceev³eJej mebMeesOeve mebmLesves Iesleu³ee Demetve veeieefjkeÀeb®eer ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeRefJe<e³eer celes peeCetve IesCes ne l³ee®ee GÎsMe neslee.

jep³ekeÀejYeejeceO³es GÊejoeef³elJe Je HeejoMe&keÀlee ner cetu³es ªpeC³eemeeþer Òeieefle HegmlekeÀeb®ee GHe¬eÀce ceolekeÀejkeÀ þjsue Demee Deecnebuee efJeéeeme Jeeìlees.

kesÀ. Sce. Sme. (ìerìg) DenuegJeeefue³eeceepeer DeO³e#e DeeefCe meerF&Dees - S.meer. veeruemeve DeesDeejpeer-ceeie&

ASSESSING THE PERFORMANCE OF MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORs OBJECTIVELYveiejmesJekeÀeb®³ee keÀeceefiejer®es Jemlegefve<þ cetu³eceeHeve


MUMBAI’S 227 COUNCILLORs

AND THEIR RANKINGS

AB

EFC

D

Note:The ranking of Councillors for Constituency no. 48 & 135 is not available as these councillors are the Mayor (Sr. No. 1), passed away during this period (Sr. No. 2) and has been recently elected (Sr. No. 3).

MUNICIPAL COUNCILLOR

PARTY DETAILS

Sr. No. 1: Sunil Vaman Prabhu

SS

Age: 45Edu.: HSCWard: P/SouthArea: Nirlon - Krushi Vidyapeeth Jaiprakash NagarWard No.: 48Member: Ward Committee P/South,

Sr. No. 2: Hanifa Bi

INDEPENDENT

Age: 70Edu.: SeventhWard: M/EastArea: Cheeta Camp, Constitency No.: 135

Sr. No. 3: Khairunnisa Akbar Hussain

Bhartiya Shetkari Kamgar

Party

Age: 24Edu.: SeventhWard: M/EastArea: Cheeta Camp, Constitency No.: 135

While reading the ratings of the councillors in the next pages kindly note the following:

(1) The parameter indicating Quality of Questions is summation of scores for ‘Importance of questions asked by issues raised in the question’ (max. marks - 18) and ‘Issues raised compared to Citizen’s Complaints (max. marks - 10), while certain individual parameters (Discretionary Funds, Education Qualification, Income Tax, Awareness & Accessibility, Corruption Index and Broad Measures) are not shown separately.

(2) The grades are given based on actual percentage of marks earned for the particular parameter and are given as below:

(a) Grade ‘A’ – Between 100% to 80% (b) Grade ‘B’ – Less than 80% but more than or equal to 70% (c) Grade ‘C’ – Less than 70% but more than or equal to 60% (d) Grade ‘D’ – Less than 60% but more than or equal to 50% (e) Grade ‘E’ – Less than 50% but more than or equal to 35% (f) Grade ‘F’ – Less than 35%.(3) Every Municipal Councillor is a member of BMC General Body and their respective Ward

Committee.(4) Shift: denotes reason of major movement in ranks from 2013 to 2014.



PARTY GRADETOTAL SCORE

%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF

QUESTIONSQUALITY OF QUESTIONS

LEAST CRIMINAL RECORD

PERCEIVED PERFORMANCE

GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

SS

2014 B 74.10 15 B 11.13 A 14.27 B 22.27 A 5 E 14.44

2013 C 69.28 33 A 12.22 A 13.67 C 18.06 A 5 D 16.98

Abhishek V. Ghosalkar

Age: 31 yrs, Edu.: HSC, Maharashtra Board Technical Education Ward: R/North, Area: Kandarpada - I. C. Colony, Constituency No.: 1

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Ward Committee R/Central and R/North

SS

2014 B 70.70 30 A 12.81 A 13.01 C 17.03 A 5 D 15.84

2013 C 63.84 75 A 12.57 A 13.67 F 9.21 A 5 C 19.76

Sheetal M. Mhatre

Age: 40 yrs, Edu.: B.A., Public Relation and Journalism Ward: R/North, Area: Gaondevi - Dahisar (E), Constituency No.: 2

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee R/Central and R/North

Shift: Quality of questions

INC

2014 D 54.40 154 C 9.75 D 8.16 C 19.29 F -5 D 15.20

2013 D 55.63 148 C 9.72 B 11.94 D 16.79 F -5 C 19.11

Sheetal A. Mhatre (Kulkarni)

Age: 36 yrs, Edu.: Bachelor of Architecture Ward: R/North, Area: Ketkipada - Shailendra Nagar, Constituency No.: 3

Member: Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, Standing Committee

SS

2014 D 55.70 149 A 12.72 A 12.47 D 15.72 F -7 E 14.79

2013 D 57.15 136 A 13.84 C 9.89 C 17.49 F -7 C 19.94

Udesh S. Patekar

Age: 46 yrs, Edu.: S.Y.B.Com. Ward: R/North, Area: Vaishali Nagar, Constituency No.: 4

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee R/Central and R/North




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

MNS

2014 D 50.13 184 B 11.40 D 8.49 E 12.18 F -5 D 16.06

2013 D 59.37 117 A 12.40 A 13.67 C 17.07 F -5 C 18.36

Prakash Y. Darekar

Age: 42 yrs, Edu.: B. Com, Journalism Certificate Course Ward: R/North, Area: Ashokvan - Chintamani Nagar, Constituency No.: 5

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, Education Committee

Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of questions

SS

2014 D 57.50 136 A 13.56 F 1.65 D 15.18 A 5 D 15.10

2013 C 64.83 69 A 14.40 E 7.16 E 11.70 A 5 B 22.98

Hansaben G. Desai

Age: 72 yrs, Edu.: B.Sc., B.Ed. Ward: R/North, Area: Ambawadi - Ovari Pada, Constituency No.: 6

Member: Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, Education Committee

Shift: No. of questions; Perceived Performance

SS

2014 C 68.89 47 A 12.24 A 14.27 D 15.69 A 5 D 15.69

2013 B 72.60 14 A 12.11 A 13.40 C 19.32 A 5 C 20.59

Shubha U. Raul

Age: 47 yrs, Edu.: B.A.M.S., M.D. Ayurveda Ward: R/North, Area: Mandapeshwar, Constituency No.: 7

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, Standing Committee, Tree Committee

INC

2014 D 57.13 137 B 11.43 F 4.31 E 13.70 A 5 D 16.70

2013 C 68.31 39 B 11.69 C 10.41 C 16.97 A 5 B 21.83

Shivanand Shetty

Age: 41 yrs, Edu.: Upto SSC Ward: R/Central, Area: Gorai - M.H.B. Colony (Old), Constituency No.: 8

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, Education Committee

Shift: No. of questions; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

BJP

2014 B 75.64 8 A 14.20 A 14.46 B 19.83 A 5 D 15.15

2013 B 77.03 2 A 13.92 A 14.13 B 20.73 A 5 B 21.30

Manisha A. Chaudhari

Age: 52 yrs, Edu.: B.Sc. Ward: R/Central, Area: Govind Nagar, Constituency No.: 9

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, Tree Committee

NCP

2014 C 60.77 112 D 8.72 B 11.61 E 13.69 A 5 E 14.75

2013 C 62.88 86 B 10.80 E 5.64 C 18.13 A 5 C 20.62

Riddhi B. Khursange

Age: 30 yrs, Edu.: HSC Ward: R/Central, Area: Daulat Nagar, Nancy Colony, Constituency No.: 10

Member: Ward Committee R/Central and R/North

MNS

2014 C 69.00 45 B 11.99 D 8.49 B 21.96 A 5 D 15.56

2013 C 63.75 76 A 13.75 E 7.16 D 14.82 A 5 B 21.38

Shilpa S. Chogle

Age: 56 yrs, Edu.: Seventh, Ward: R/Central Area: Bansi Nagar - Tata Power House, Constituency No.: 11

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Ward Committee R/Central and R/North

Shift: No. of questions; Quality of questions

BJP

2014 C 61.61 103 A 13.96 D 8.96 E 13.64 A 5 E 14.33

2013 C 60.53 102 A 13.96 F 4.58 E 12.96 A 5 B 21.22

Asawari A. Patil

Age: 56 yrs, Edu.: HSC Ward: R/Central, Area: Datta Pada, Constituency No.: 12

Member: Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee R/Central and R/North




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

MNS

2014 D 51.63 176 E 7.41 F 4.31 C 17.39 F 0 D 16.52

2013 C 67.49 47 A 13.05 A 12.87 C 17.72 F 0 B 21.40

Chetan C. Kadam

Age: 40 yrs, Edu.: HSC, Ward: R/Central Area: Rajendra Nagar, Khatav Estate, Constituency No.: 13

Member: Ward Committee R/Central and R/NorthShift: Attendance; No. of questions; Perceived Performance

BJP

2014 C 67.35 60 A 14.03 B 10.74 D 16.53 A 5 E 14.05

2013 D 58.70 123 A 14.19 E 5.64 E 10.92 A 5 C 20.04

Bina P. Doshi

Age: 52 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: R/Central, Area: Borivali TPS 3 - Kora Kendra, Constituency No.: 14

Member: Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee R/Central and R/North


BJP

2014 D 55.71 148 D 8.30 D 7.62 C 18.35 F 0 E 14.43

2013 C 67.32 50 A 12.53 B 10.82 C 19.31 F 0 B 21.21

Mohan R. Mithbaokar

Age: 67 yrs, Edu.: B.A. (Economics), B.Com. Ward: R/Central, Area: Eksar - Yogi Nagar, Constituency No.: 15

Member: Ward Committee R/Central and R/NorthShift: Attendance; No. of questions; Perceived Performance

BJP

2014 D 53.93 157 A 13.28 F 3.45 D 15.98 F 0 E 14.22

2013 D 58.80 121 B 10.74 E 5.64 C 17.27 F 0 B 22.25

Pravin Shah

Age: 58 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: R/Central, Area: Chikuwadi - Kanti Park, Constituency No.: 16

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee R/Central and R/North




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

NCP

2014 C 66.96 64 A 13.78 A 12.00 D 15.27 A 5 E 14.90

2013 C 64.24 73 A 12.78 B 10.82 E 13.22 A 5 B 23.81

Sandhya V. Doshi

Age: 38 yrs, Edu.: B.Com. (Part 2), Ward: R/Central Area: Charkop (North), M.H.B. Colony (New), Constituency No.: 17

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Markets and Gardens Committee, Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, Improvements Committee

SS

2014 C 68.35 50 A 14.89 C 9.42 E 13.12 A 5 C 18.92

2013 C 65.41 64 A 14.51 D 8.03 D 14.00 A 5 C 20.31

Shrikant K. Kavathankar

Age: 57 yrs, Edu.: F.Y.B.Com, Ward: R/South Area: Charkop (South) - Kandivali (West), Constituency No.: 18

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee R/South

INC

2014 C 60.84 111 B 11.07 E 6.11 D 14.16 A 5 C 18.51

2013 D 58.43 129 A 12.57 F 4.58 D 14.63 A 5 C 19.72

Neha V. Patil

Age: 25 yrs, Edu.: B.M.S., M.M.S. Part 2 (Appeared) Ward: R/South, Area: Charkop-Industrial Estate, Constituency No.: 19

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Ward Committee R/South

BJP

2014 C 67.75 54 D 8.14 A 12.80 C 18.07 A 5 D 16.74

2013 C 60.30 105 C 9.79 A 13.26 F 9.11 A 5 C 19.32

Shailaja V. Girkar

Age: 58 yrs, Edu.: Eleventh Ward: R/South, Area: Mahavir Nagar - Dhanukar Wadi, Constituency No.: 20

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee R/South, Standing Committee





%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

INC

2014 B 76.98 4 A 14.46 A 13.67 C 18.55 A 5 C 18.30

2013 B 70.58 24 A 12.46 A 12.47 C 17.93 A 5 C 19.44

Ramashish G. Gupta

Age: 49 yrs, Edu.: B.Com, Ward: R/South, Area: Narwane Sanskrutik Centre - Aarya Chanakya Nagar, Constituency No.: 21


Shift: Attendance; No. of questions

BJP

2014 B 75.92 6 A 13.24 B 11.61 C 19.45 A 5 C 19.63

2013 C 63.36 82 A 14.43 E 5.64 E 10.83 A 5 B 23.80

Sunita R. Yadav

Age: 43 yrs, Edu.: HSC, Ward: R/South Area: Poisar Village (West) - Kandivali (East), Constituency No.: 22

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee R/SouthShift: No. of questions; Quality of questions

SS

2014 B 75.75 7 C 10.35 A 13.34 B 20.41 A 5 C 19.65

2013 C 68.02 41 A 13.92 E 6.36 D 15.38 A 5 B 23.95

Prajakta V. (Sawant)Vishwasrao

Age: 29 yrs, Edu.: F.Y.B.Com, Ward: R/South Area: Poisar (East), Rajaram Nagar - Ashok Nagar, Constituency No.: 23

Member: Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee R/South


INC

2014 B 72.48 24 B 11.21 A 13.80 B 21.19 F 0 C 19.27

2013 C 62.84 88 B 11.83 D 8.03 D 14.55 F 0 A 24.74

Yogesh J. Bhoir

Age: 35 yrs, Edu.: T.Y.B.Com, Ward: R/South, Area: Samata Nagar - Dattani Park - Mahindra & Mahindra Company, Constituency No.: 24

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee R/SouthShift: No. of questions; Quality of questions




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

INC

2014 B 71.59 29 A 12.48 A 14.66 C 17.81 A 5 D 15.64

2013 B 73.13 10 B 11.60 A 14.66 D 16.40 A 5 B 22.32

Ajanta R. Yadav

Age: 47 yrs, Edu.: B.H.M.S. Ward: R/South, Area: Damupada, Constituency No.: 25

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee R/South

INC

2014 D 55.96 146 D 7.96 B 10.74 E 13.56 F 0 D 16.70

2013 D 51.64 169 C 9.11 E 5.64 F 9.11 F 0 B 23.49

Sagar S. Thakur

Age: 25 yrs, Edu.: B.Com, M.B.A. (Appeared), Ward: R/South Area: Vadarpada Colony - Gautam Nagar, Constituency No.: 26

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Ward Committee R/South

BJP

2014 D 54.56 153 A 14.41 F 1.65 E 10.26 A 5 D 16.24

2013 D 51.58 170 B 11.59 F 0.86 F 9.11 A 5 C 20.73

Mukeshkumar Mistry

Age: 55 yrs, Edu.: SSC, Ward: R/South Area: Devji Bhimji Colony - Paras Nagar, Constituency No.: 27


INC

2014 C 66.93 66 B 11.93 C 10.22 C 19.23 F 0 C 18.56

2013 C 63.70 78 A 12.72 A 14.73 E 13.76 F 0 C 19.84

Geeta A. Yadav

Age: 38 yrs, Edu.: D.H.M.S. Ward: R/South, Area: Irani Wadi - Kandivali (W), Constituency No.: 28

Member: BEST Committee, Ward Committee R/South




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

SS

2014 C 69.08 44 A 13.21 A 12.35 D 15.10 A 5 D 16.43

2013 B 72.46 15 A 14.33 A 13.40 D 15.32 A 5 B 21.23

Ajit D. Bhandari

Age: 50 yrs, Edu.: HSC, Ward: P/North, Area: Manori Marve, Erangel, Akse, Daravali Village, Madh Island, Constituency No.: 29

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee P/North

INC

2014 C 67.54 58 D 8.49 B 10.74 C 18.82 A 5 D 17.50

2013 C 66.02 60 B 10.88 A 12.47 D 16.41 A 5 C 18.75

Siraj I. Shaikh

Age: 36 yrs, Edu.: SSC, Ward: P/North Area: Valnai Village - Kharodi Village Malavani Colony, Constituency No.: 30

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Ward Committee P/North

INC

2014 C 69.58 39 B 11.17 A 13.01 D 16.01 A 5 D 17.39

2013 D 56.17 142 B 10.88 F 1.98 D 15.06 A 5 C 19.21

Parminder R. Bhamra

Age: 48 yrs, Edu.: HSC, Ward: P/North Area: Adarsh Dugdhalaya - Evershine Nagar, Constituency No.: 31

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee P/North Shift: No. of questions

SS

2014 D 50.60 182 A 12.92 F 1.65 F 6.00 A 5 C 18.03

2013 D 59.53 114 A 13.22 F 4.58 D 14.13 A 5 C 19.73

Anagha P. Mhatre

Age: 63 yrs, Edu.: SSC, Ward: P/North Area: Bhadaran Nagar - Mamaledar Wadi, Constituency No.: 32

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Ward Committee P/North, Standing Committee





%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

BJP

2014 C 63.23 91 A 12.46 D 8.96 E 11.86 A 5 C 18.96

2013 C 68.44 38 B 12.00 B 10.82 D 16.07 A 5 B 22.15

Ramnarayan A. Barot

Age: 68 yrs, Edu.: L.C.E.H. (Mumbai) Ward: P/North, Area: Pushpa Park, Constituency No.: 33

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee P/North, Improvements Committee

Shift: No.of questions; Quality of questions

SS

2014 C 64.10 80 A 13.97 F 3.45 C 17.62 A 5 D 17.06

2013 C 67.46 48 A 14.13 C 9.89 D 16.58 A 5 C 18.42

Sunil D. Gujar

Age: 51 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: P/North, Area: Tanaji Nagar, Constituency No.: 34

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee P/North

INC

2014 F 33.36 220 E 5.98 F 0.00 F 0.00 C 3 D 17.38

2013 C 62.12 95 D 7.92 E 7.16 C 18.68 C 3 B 21.63

Bhomsingh H. Rathod

Age: 57 yrs, Edu.: Matriculation Ward: P/North, Area: Appa Pada, Constituency No.: 35

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee P/North, Education Committee

Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance

SS

2014 E 49.42 190 B 11.93 F 5.04 F 6.57 C 3 D 16.88

2013 C 60.17 107 A 13.55 F 4.58 D 14.94 C 3 B 21.26

Prashant D. Kadam

Age: 38 yrs, Edu.: Upto Twelfth Ward: P/North, Area: Malad Hill Reservoir, Constituency No.: 36

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee P/North Shift: Attendance; Quality of questions




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

SS

2014 E 43.27 209 C 10.15 F 0.72 F 6.04 A 5 D 16.37

2013 D 58.74 122 A 12.74 E 5.64 E 10.54 A 5 B 22.91

Manisha S. Patil

Age: 41 yrs, Edu.: Fifth Ward: P/North, Area: Municipal colony Malad (East), Constituency No.: 37

Member: Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee P/North


NCP

2014 C 61.23 109 C 9.62 C 9.42 E 12.75 A 5 D 17.45

2013 D 59.84 112 D 7.65 E 6.36 E 12.99 A 5 B 23.98

Rupali A. Raorane

Age: 33 yrs, Edu.: HSC, Ward: P/North Area: Dhanjiwadi - Narsobawadi - Kokanipada, Constituency No.: 38

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee P/North

SS

2014 D 52.85 165 A 14.78 F 0.72 F 6.57 A 5 C 18.78

2013 E 49.03 189 A 14.56 F 0.86 F 3.00 A 5 B 21.20

Sayali S. Warise

Age: 35 yrs, Edu.: B.Com Ward: P/North, Area: Pimpri Pada - Pathanwadi, Constituency No.: 39

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee P/North

BJP

2014 B 77.97 3 A 13.60 A 14.46 C 18.31 A 5 C 19.59

2013 B 70.15 27 A 13.58 A 14.46 D 15.57 A 5 C 18.22

Gyanmurti R. Sharma

Age: 42 yrs, Edu.: B.Sc., L.L.B. Ward: P/North, Area: Raheja Complex - Dindoshi, Constituency No.: 40

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee P/North, Improvements Committee

Shift: Quality of questions; Perceived Performance




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

BJP

2014 C 69.89 35 B 10.61 A 13.47 D 15.39 A 5 C 18.43

2013 C 64.65 71 B 11.11 B 11.94 D 14.53 A 5 C 18.47

Vinod B. Shelar

Age: 43 yrs, Edu.: D.M.E. Ward: P/North, Area: Makrani Pada, Constituency No.: 41

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee P/North, Education Committee

Shift: No. of questions

MNS

2014 C 66.74 67 D 8.57 A 14.87 C 19.53 F 0 D 17.77

2013 D 55.66 147 D 8.40 B 11.61 D 14.02 F 0 C 18.55

Deepak P. Pawar

Age: 45 yrs, Edu.: Eighth, Ward: P/North Area: Liberty Garden - Nadiyadwalla Colony, Constituency No.: 42

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee P/North, Improvements Committee


INC

2014 D 55.51 150 B 11.31 F 5.04 E 12.73 A 5 D 15.43

2013 E 46.42 198 D 8.31 F 1.98 F 8.74 A 5 C 18.84

Qumarjahan Mohd. Moin Siddiqi

Age: 48 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: P/North, Area: New Collectors Colony, Constituency No.: 43

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee P/North


INDEPENDENT 2014 D 56.10 144 D 7.98 F 5.04 D 15.81 A 5 D 16.27

2013 D 50.42 179 D 8.43 E 6.36 F 9.12 A 5 C 19.17

Cyril P. D’souza

Age: 41 yrs, Edu.: Fourth, Ward: P/North Area: New Collectors Compound, M.H.B. Colony, Constituency No.: 44

Member: Ward Committee P/North, Tree Committee Shift: Quality of questions




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

INC

2014 B 72.27 25 A 12.53 D 8.49 A 22.42 A 5 D 17.83

2013 C 62.86 87 A 14.16 F 4.58 D 15.13 A 5 B 21.30

Sneha V. Zagade

Age: 24 yrs, Edu.: S.Y.B.Com (Appeared) Ward: P/South, Area: Sunder Nagar - Piramal Nagar, Constituency No.: 45

Member: Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee P/South


SS

2014 B 70.41 31 A 14.06 C 9.42 C 17.86 A 5 C 18.07

2013 B 74.08 6 A 14.59 D 8.03 B 21.28 A 5 B 23.08

Varsha S. Tembvalkar

Age: 39 yrs, Edu.: T.Y.B.Com Ward: P/South, Area: Dindoshi - Pandurangwadi, Constituency No.: 46

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Ward Committee P/South

SS

2014 D 55.32 151 A 12.39 F 3.45 E 10.79 A 5 D 17.70

2013 D 54.38 156 A 13.87 F 4.58 E 10.50 A 5 C 18.29

Jitendra H. Valvi

Age: 35 yrs, Edu.: HSC Ward: P/South, Area: Aarey Colony (East), Constituency No.: 47

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee P/South

SS

2014 D 55.99 145 C 9.52 D 7.62 B 19.64 F -5 C 18.21

2013 D 55.76 146 A 13.70 E 7.16 D 15.79 F -5 B 21.05

Lochana C. Chavan

Age: 47 yrs, Edu.: Upto SSC, Ward: P/South Area: Unnat Nagar - Motilal Nagar No. 2 & 3, Constituency No.: 49

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee P/South




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

SS

2014 D 52.27 172 A 12.77 E 6.11 D 15.19 F -5 D 16.21

2013 D 58.50 126 A 14.18 B 11.21 C 18.02 F -5 D 16.17

Rajan V. Padhye

Age: 50 yrs, Edu.: HSC Ward: P/South, Area: Shastri Nagar- Bangur Nagar, Constituency No.: 50

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Ward Committee P/South, Improvements Committee

Shift: Attendance; No. of questions, Quality of questions

SS

2014 D 59.27 124 A 13.92 D 7.62 F 8.07 A 5 D 17.66

2013 C 66.33 59 A 13.39 C 9.35 D 15.52 A 5 C 19.57

Pramila D. Shinde

Age: 44 yrs, Edu.: SSC, Ward: P/South Area: Motilal Nagar No.1 - B.E.S.T. Bus Depot, Constituency No.: 51

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee P/SouthShift: No. of questions; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance

INC

2014 C 66.40 72 A 12.78 F 5.04 C 18.09 A 5 C 18.49

2013 E 48.82 191 A 13.06 F 0.86 F 6.16 A 5 C 19.31

Kiran V. Patel

Age: 46 yrs, Edu.: B.A. Ward: P/South, Area: Siddharth Nagar - Jawahar Nagar, Constituency No.: 52

Member: Women and Child Welfare Committee,Ward Committee P/South


INDEPENDENT 2014 E 36.56 217 D 8.60 F 0.00 F 0.00 A 5 D 15.96

2013 D 56.03 143 B 11.24 F 2.91 E 12.00 A 5 B 21.82

Changez J. Multani

Age: 46 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: K/West, Area: Oshiwara - Bandivli (East), Constituency No.: 53

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee K/West

Shift: Attendance; No. of questions, Quality of questions; Perceived Performance




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

SS

2014 D 58.22 129 C 10.28 A 12.47 C 17.33 F -5 D 16.14

2013 C 62.96 85 A 12.59 A 14.13 C 16.98 F -5 B 21.57

Raju S. Pednekar

Age: 48 yrs, Edu.: HSC Ward: K/West, Area: Tarapore Garden - Adarsh Nagar, Constituency No.: 54

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee K/West, Improvements Committee

INC

2014 C 64.06 82 A 12.78 E 7.16 D 16.45 A 5 D 16.67

2013 C 64.63 72 A 12.28 D 8.96 E 13.71 A 5 B 22.09

Jyotsna A. Dighe

Age: 60 yrs, Edu.: Post Graduate Ward: K/West, Area: Swami Samarth Nagar, Constituency No.: 55

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee K/West, Standing Committee, Improvements Committee

SS

2014 B 75.41 10 A 14.70 A 14.79 C 18.03 A 5 D 16.90

2013 B 75.48 3 A 13.76 A 15.00 C 17.01 A 5 B 22.69

Yashodhar P. Phanse

Age: 51 yrs, Edu.: B.A. Ward: K/West, Area: Versova (North), Constituency No.: 56

Member: Ward Committee K/West,Standing Committee, Tree Committee

INC

2014 D 54.96 152 B 10.97 F 4.31 E 10.90 A 5 D 17.78

2013 E 49.38 185 A 12.22 F 1.98 F 9.66 A 5 D 17.12

Devendra S. Amberkar

Age: 50 yrs, Edu.: B.A. Ward: K/West, Area: Amboli Hill, Constituency No.: 57

Member: Ward Committee K/West, Standing Committee,Improvements Committee, Tree Committee





%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

SS

2014 C 63.28 90 A 14.41 E 6.11 D 14.26 A 5 D 16.50

2013 C 67.60 46 A 14.38 C 9.35 D 15.54 A 5 C 20.89

Jyoti J. Sutar

Age: 52 yrs, Edu.: HSC, Ward: K/West Area: Sahaji Raje Sports Complex - Malcolm Baug, Constituency No.: 58

Member: Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee K/West

INC

2014 D 59.85 120 A 13.54 D 8.96 F 8.81 A 5 D 17.54

2013 C 65.50 63 A 12.96 C 9.35 E 12.98 A 5 B 21.67

Vanita K. Marucha

Age: 52 yrs, Edu.: HSC, Ward: K/West Area: Seven Bunglow - Versova (South), Constituency No.: 59

Member: Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee K/West, Education Committee


SS

2014 B 76.38 5 A 14.73 A 13.01 C 18.55 A 5 C 18.09

2013 B 71.58 19 A 13.68 C 10.41 C 17.79 A 5 B 21.48

Sanjay K. Pawar

Age: 47 yrs, Edu.: HSC Ward: K/West, Area: Manish Nagar - Bhavan’s College, Constituency No.: 60

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Ward Committee K/West

INC

2014 C 63.65 87 A 12.99 A 14.07 C 18.72 F -5 D 15.88

2013 D 58.54 125 A 12.40 B 11.94 D 14.99 F -5 C 20.29

Mohsin H. Haider

Age: 45 yrs, Edu.: B.Com Ward: K/West, Area: Gilbert Hill - Andheri Market, Constituency No.: 61

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Ward Committee K/West, Improvements Committee





%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

BJP

2014 C 67.23 61 A 13.50 D 8.96 D 15.95 A 5 D 16.82

2013 B 70.51 25 A 13.97 A 12.87 D 16.58 A 5 C 18.79

Ameet B. Satam

Age: 37 yrs, Edu.: M.M.S., Ward: K/West Area: Lallubhai Park - Shri Ram Zarokha, Constituency No.: 62

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee K/West, Tree Committee


BJP

2014 C 69.77 36 A 13.53 A 14.19 D 15.29 A 5 D 15.76

2013 B 71.75 18 A 12.13 A 14.27 C 16.82 A 5 C 20.31

Dilip G. Patel

Age: 62 yrs, Edu.: HSC, Ward: K/West Area: Bhakti Vedanta Marg - Cooper Hospital, Constituency No.: 63

Member: Ward Committee K/West, Standing Committee

INDEPENDENT 2014 D 54.06 156 A 13.45 F 3.45 F 9.41 A 5 D 17.75

2013 D 55.90 145 A 14.29 F 2.91 D 14.92 A 5 D 17.72

Bhavna A. Mangela

Age: 36 yrs, Edu.: HSC, Ward: K/West Area: S.N.D.T. University Campus - Juhu Airport, Constituency No.: 64

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee K/West

INC

2014 C 66.41 71 B 10.58 E 7.16 C 19.49 A 5 D 17.19

2013 D 54.80 151 B 10.82 F 2.91 E 11.65 A 5 B 21.30

Binita M. Vora

Age: 33 yrs, Edu.: B.Com, Diploma in Apparel Manufacture and Design Ward: K/West, Area: Vile Parle (W) - Mithibai College, Constituency No.: 65

Member: Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee K/West





%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

BJP

2014 E 46.98 199 F 3.73 F 0.72 E 12.03 A 5 C 19.50

2013 E 42.43 209 F 4.91 F 0.86 F 8.00 A 5 C 20.89

Ujjwala S. Modak

Age: 47 yrs, Edu.: B.A., Ward: K/East, Area: Bandrekar Wadi - Ismail College - Natwar Nagar, Constituency No.: 66

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee K/East

SS

2014 C 62.84 96 A 12.61 F 3.45 C 18.76 A 5 C 18.03

2013 D 53.05 163 A 12.13 F 2.91 F 9.09 A 5 C 20.71

Manjiri G. Parab

Age: 57 yrs, Edu.: Ninth Ward: K/East, Area: Jogeshwari Caves - Majaswadi, Constituency No.: 67

Member: Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee K/East


SS

2014 C 67.16 62 A 14.83 A 15.00 C 18.64 F -5 D 17.69

2013 C 65.03 67 A 15.00 A 14.93 C 17.60 F -5 C 20.92

Anant B. Nar

Age: 48 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: K/East, Area: Shivneri Vasahat - Meghwadi, Constituency No.: 68

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Ward Committee K/East

SS

2014 C 62.06 101 B 10.71 F 5.04 D 16.40 A 5 C 18.92

2013 E 49.97 182 A 13.33 F 0.86 F 8.00 A 5 C 19.42

Shivani S. Parab

Age: 36 yrs, Edu.: SSC, Ward: K/East Area: Shankarwadi - Sher-E-Punjab Colony Constituency No.: 69

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee K/East





%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

MNS

2014 C 62.20 99 B 11.59 C 10.22 C 18.84 F -2 C 18.56

2013 D 52.41 165 A 13.17 F 2.91 D 15.10 F -2 C 20.00

Bhalchandra G. Ambure

Age: 43 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: K/East, Area: Squatter’s Colony - Tolani College, Constituency No.: 70

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Ward Committee K/East, Standing Committee


SS

2014 E 47.08 198 B 11.47 F 1.65 F 6.00 A 5 D 17.96

2013 D 53.63 160 B 11.67 F 2.91 E 12.97 A 5 C 18.91

Sandhya S. Yadav

Age: 38 yrs, Edu.: F.Y.J.C. Ward: K/East, Area: Gundavali Gaonthan (West), Constituency No.: 71

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee K/EastShift: No. of questions; Quality of questions

SS

2014 C 62.87 94 A 12.14 A 13.01 C 16.94 F -5 C 19.78

2013 E 44.40 201 A 12.58 F 4.58 F 9.59 F -5 C 20.00

Sunita J. Elawadekar

Age: 50 yrs, Edu.: Upto SSC Ward: K/East, Area: Gundavali (East) - E.S.I.S. Hospital, Constituency No.: 72



INC

2014 E 40.74 212 B 11.75 F 0.00 F 0.00 A 5 C 18.99

2013 E 49.08 188 A 12.03 F 1.98 F 8.87 A 5 C 19.78

Kesarben M. Patel

Age: 39 yrs, Edu.: Seventh Ward: K/East, Area: Veravali - M.I.D.C., Constituency No.: 73






%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

SS

2014 C 64.85 78 A 14.21 C 9.42 B 19.89 F -2 D 17.33

2013 C 62.20 94 A 14.11 A 12.87 C 17.16 F -2 C 18.34

Pramod P. Sawant

Age: 41 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: K/East, Area: Vijay Nagar - Bhavani Nagar, Constituency No.: 74


INC

2014 D 58.10 130 D 7.83 F 2.52 C 17.57 A 5 C 18.18

2013 D 58.67 124 C 9.69 C 9.89 E 13.33 A 5 D 17.86

Sushma K. Rai

Age: 37 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: K/East, Area: Sahar Airport - Maroshi Village, Constituency No.: 75

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee K/East

SS

2014 C 60.13 119 A 12.76 E 7.16 E 10.82 A 5 C 18.40

2013 D 58.48 127 A 12.62 F 2.91 E 12.72 A 5 B 21.31

Smita S. Sawant

Age: 53 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: K/East, Area: Chakala - Sahar Airport, Constituency No.: 76

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Ward Committee K/East

INC

2014 E 38.37 215 B 10.66 F 0.00 F 0.00 A 5 D 15.71

2013 D 50.66 178 A 12.21 F 0.86 F 8.87 A 5 C 19.38

Winnifred B. D’souza

Age: 54 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: K/East, Area: Sahar Village - Baman Wada, Constituency No.: 77

Member: Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee K/East, Improvements Committee

Shift: Attendance; Quality questions




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

SS

2014 C 62.54 97 B 11.23 F 5.04 D 16.73 A 5 C 19.54

2013 C 61.85 96 B 11.69 D 8.03 D 15.14 A 5 C 20.25

Manisha M. Panchal

Age: 48 yrs, Edu.: Ninth, Ward: K/East Area: M. V. College - Vijay Nagar - Koldongri, Constituency No.: 78


SS

2014 D 53.73 161 A 12.42 F 2.52 F 9.06 A 5 C 19.72

2013 D 56.57 139 A 12.97 E 6.36 E 10.87 A 5 B 22.34

Shubhada S. Patkar

Age: 58 yrs, Edu.: B.A., D.Ed., Ward: K/East, Area: Tejpal Scheme - Paranjape Scheme - Vile Parle (East), Constituency No.: 79

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Ward Committee K/East, Education Committee

INDEPENDENT 2014 D 51.36 180 C 9.46 F 2.52 D 15.60 F 0 D 17.79

2013 C 60.15 108 A 12.47 F 4.58 D 14.52 A 5 C 20.75

Jyoti P. Alavani

Age: 40 yrs, Edu.: B.Com Ward: K/East, Area: Vile Parle (E), Telephone Exchange, Constituency No.: 80

Member: Ward Committee K/EastShift: Attendance; No. of questions; New FIR

MNS

2014 E 49.89 186 A 12.09 F 2.52 F 6.00 A 5 C 19.28

2013 E 41.38 211 A 13.03 F 1.98 F 0.08 A 5 C 19.47

Snehal S. Shinde

Age: 40 yrs, Edu.: Upto SSC Ward: H/East, Area: Prabhat Colony, Anand Nagar, Constituency No.: 81

Member: Public Health Committee, Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee H/East and H/West





%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

MNS

2014 D 56.92 138 D 7.52 F 3.45 C 18.54 A 5 D 15.41

2013 E 41.37 212 B 10.55 F 0.00 F 0.00 A 5 C 20.99

Sukhada R. Pawar

Age: 35 yrs, Edu.: Upto HSC Ward: H/East, Area: Vivekanand Nagar, Constituency No.: 82

Member: Ward Committee H/East and H/WestShift: No. of questions; Quality of questions

SS

2014 D 56.11 143 C 10.44 F 5.04 E 10.97 A 5 D 17.66

2013 D 59.01 119 C 9.77 E 6.36 D 14.78 A 5 C 19.21

Sunaina S. Potnis

Age: 51 yrs, Edu.: B.Com, Ward: H/East Area: University Campus - Dharamashi Colony, Constituency No.: 83

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee H/East and H/West, Education Committee

INC

2014 C 64.04 84 A 14.02 A 12.87 C 17.41 F -5 D 17.74

2013 E 47.72 194 A 12.21 F 2.91 D 16.46 F -5 D 17.65

Brian F. Miranda

Age: 46 yrs, Edu.: HSC, Ward: H/East Area: Kalina Village - Santacruz Cantonment, Constituency No.: 84

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Ward Committee H/East and H/West


INDEPENDENT 2014 D 52.06 173 B 11.63 F 2.52 D 14.13 C 3 E 14.78

2013 E 42.63 207 C 9.82 F 0.86 F 8.14 C 3 D 17.05

Ilyas B. Shaikh

Age: 52 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: H/East, Area: Bharat Nagar (E), Constituency No.: 85

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee H/East and H/West





%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

SS

2014 C 64.07 81 A 14.32 E 6.11 D 14.83 A 5 D 16.81

2013 D 56.44 140 A 13.67 E 5.64 E 10.22 A 5 C 18.88

Pooja V. Mahadeshwar

Age: 47 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: H/East, Area: T.P.S. III Santacruz - Ashok Nagar, Constituency No.: 86

Member: Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee H/East and H/West


BJP

2014 C 69.25 41 A 13.67 A 13.94 E 11.65 A 5 C 18.00

2013 C 60.64 99 A 12.14 C 9.89 E 10.79 A 5 C 20.02

Krishna D. Parkar

Age: 34 yrs, Edu.: F.Y.B.Com, Ward: H/East Area: Dawari Colony - Khar Rifle Range, Constituency No.: 87

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee H/East and H/West, Standing Committee


SS

2014 B 72.73 23 A 15.00 B 11.61 D 16.62 A 5 D 17.50

2013 C 67.72 45 A 14.86 E 7.16 C 18.34 A 5 C 18.93

Deepak R. Bhutkar

Age: 49 yrs, Edu.: SSC, D.M.E. Ward: H/East, Area: Teacher’s Colony - Jawahar Nagar, Constituency No.: 88



SS

2014 C 67.92 52 A 15.00 B 10.74 E 11.76 A 5 C 18.42

2013 D 58.20 130 A 14.46 E 7.16 F 6.00 A 5 B 23.64

Anil P. Trimbakkar

Age: 59 yrs, Edu.: B.Com, Ward: H/East Area: Government Colony - Bharat Nagar (W), Constituency No.: 89

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee H/East and H/West, Education Committee





%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

INC

2014 C 61.31 107 B 11.09 C 10.22 E 12.73 A 5 D 15.28

2013 C 66.37 58 A 13.64 B 11.21 E 13.58 A 5 C 19.44

Priyatama S. Sawant

Age: 41 yrs, Edu.: B.A.M.S Ward: H/East, Area: Bandra Terminus - Nirmal Nagar, Constituency No.: 90

Member: Ward Committee H/East and H/West, Education Committee

Shift: Attendance; Perceived Performance

INC

2014 B 70.00 34 C 10.40 B 10.74 B 19.70 A 5 D 17.16

2013 E 43.28 206 C 10.49 F 0.86 F 6.08 A 5 C 18.13

Gulistan Ahrar A. Shaikh

Age: 30 yrs, Edu.: B.U.M.S. Ward: H/East, Area: Kherwadi, Constituency No.: 91

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee H/East and H/West

Shift: No. of questions; Quality question

MNS

2014 D 57.60 131 C 9.53 D 7.62 E 10.10 A 5 C 19.35

2013 E 48.64 192 B 11.30 F 0.86 F 9.26 A 5 C 18.78

Geeta S. Chavan

Age: 51 yrs, Edu.: Sixth Ward: H/West, Area: Khira Nagar - Muktanand Park, Constituency No.: 92

Member: Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee H/East and H/West


BJP

2014 C 62.23 98 B 10.80 C 10.22 E 11.79 A 5 D 17.43

2013 C 67.20 52 B 11.27 D 8.03 C 18.81 A 5 C 20.63

Alka S. Kerkar

Age: 61 yrs, Edu.: B.Sc., Ward: H/West, Area: Vitthaldas Nagar - Madhu Park (Khar West) Saraswat Colony, Constituency No.: 93





%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

INC

2014 E 47.79 195 D 8.45 F 1.65 F 8.48 A 5 D 17.22

2013 E 42.50 208 C 10.34 F 0.00 F 0.00 A 5 B 22.40

Sunita S. Wavekar

Age: 36 yrs, Edu.: T.Y.B.Com Ward: H/West, Area: Khar Danda, Chuim Village, Constituency No.: 94

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee H/East and H/West


INC

2014 C 66.52 70 A 14.02 D 7.62 D 14.57 A 5 C 18.31

2013 B 72.43 16 A 13.85 B 11.61 C 16.80 A 5 B 21.97

Asif A. Zakaria

Age: 43 yrs, Edu.: B.Com Ward: H/West, Area: Union Park - National College, Constituency No.: 95

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee H/East and H/West, Standing Committee


INC

2014 E 46.34 201 C 9.99 F 1.65 F 6.00 A 5 D 16.70

2013 E 49.58 184 B 11.13 F 0.86 F 8.10 A 5 C 20.10

Karen Cecilia A. D’mello

Age: 48 yrs, Edu.: B.A., L.L.B., Ward: H/West Area: Bandra Fort - Pali Market - National Library, Constituency No.: 96

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee H/East and H/West

INC

2014 D 52.71 168 D 8.42 F 1.65 D 14.48 A 5 D 16.16

2013 C 60.30 106 C 10.09 F 2.91 C 17.89 A 5 C 20.59

Mohd. Tanveer Mohd. Ali Patel

Age: 35 yrs, Edu.: HSC, Ward: H/West Area: Lilavati Hospital - Bandra Bus Terminus, Constituency No.: 97






%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

BJP

2014 C 61.59 104 B 11.92 F 4.31 D 16.11 A 5 D 17.26

2013 C 60.53 101 A 13.19 F 2.91 D 15.42 A 5 B 21.20

Samita V. Kamble

Age: 46 yrs, Edu.: B.Com Ward: T, Area: Mulund Colony - Tulsi Lake, Constituency No.: 98

Member: Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee S and T

BJP

2014 B 71.85 28 B 11.94 E 7.16 B 20.64 A 5 B 21.11

2013 D 52.53 164 C 10.45 F 2.91 F 8.02 A 5 B 22.91

Bhavna B. Jobanputra

Age: 27 yrs, Edu.: B.A. Ward: T, Area: Mulund Check Naka - ESIS Hospital, Constituency No.: 99

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee S and T


NCP

2014 D 55.81 147 B 10.69 D 8.49 D 15.98 F -5 C 18.65

2013 B 70.46 26 B 10.72 B 11.61 C 19.56 A 5 B 21.28

Nandkumar A. Vaity

Age: 52 yrs, Edu.: HSC, Ward: T Area: Topiwala College - Gavan Pada - Mhada Colony, Constituency No.: 100

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Public Health Committee, Ward Committee S and T

Shift: No. of questions; Quality of questions; New FIR & Chargesheet; Perceived Performance

MNS

2014 D 50.02 185 A 12.88 F 4.31 E 10.12 F 0 D 17.72

2013 D 51.43 172 A 13.14 F 4.58 E 13.90 F 0 C 18.52

Sujata R. Pathak

Age: 32 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: T, Area: Nane Pada - Palm Acers, Constituency No.: 101

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee S and T




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

BJP

2014 D 59.38 123 A 13.02 A 12.00 D 15.81 F -5 D 17.54

2013 B 70.91 22 A 13.97 C 10.41 C 18.89 A 5 C 20.37

Prakash K. Gangadhare

Age: 59 yrs, Edu.: Eleventh Ward: T, Area: Mulund Central, Constituency No.: 102

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee S and T, Improvements Committee

Shift: Quality of questions; New FIR & Chargesheet; Perceived Performance

BJP

2014 C 63.46 88 B 11.90 B 11.28 C 17.71 F -2 D 17.57

2013 C 64.89 68 B 11.23 A 12.47 C 19.20 F -2 C 20.41

Manoj K. Kotak

Age: 41 yrs, Edu.: SSC, Ward: T, Area: Johnson & Johnson - Sarvodaya Nagar - Nahur Village, Constituency No.: 103

Member: Education Committee, Ward Committee S and T, Standing Committee

INC

2014 D 53.87 158 B 11.73 C 9.42 D 14.09 F -5 D 17.63

2013 D 56.29 141 B 11.33 A 13.40 D 15.64 F -5 D 17.88

Suresh H. Koparkar

Age: 62 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: S, Area: Milind Nagar, Constituency No.: 104

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee S and T, Improvements Committee

INDEPENDENT 2014 C 63.13 93 A 12.54 D 8.16 D 14.06 A 5 D 17.37

2013 E 49.36 186 A 12.23 F 2.91 F 6.01 A 5 C 19.80

Mangesh N. Pawar

Age: 46 yrs, Edu.: HSC Ward: S, Area: Bhandup Village, Constituency No.: 105

Member: Ward Committee S and T, Standing Committee, Markets and Gardens Committee





%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

SS

2014 D 57.50 135 B 11.55 C 9.42 D 16.72 F -5 C 19.81

2013 D 57.24 135 A 13.52 B 11.94 D 14.70 F -5 C 20.09

Ramesh G. Korgaonkar

Age: 53 yrs, Edu.: Upto SSC Ward: S, Area: Gaondevi (Bhandup) Tembipada, Constituency No.: 106

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Ward Committee S and T, Standing Committee, Tree Committee

MNS

2014 C 65.28 77 A 13.84 A 12.93 C 18.14 F -5 C 18.38

2013 D 54.46 155 A 14.03 C 9.89 E 12.05 F -5 C 19.36

Anisha A. Majgaonkar

Age: 37 yrs, Edu.: Graduate, Ward: S, Area: Nardas Nagar, Constituency No.: 107

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee S and T


MNS

2014 E 39.04 213 D 8.44 F 0.00 F 0.00 A 5 C 18.61

2013 C 62.74 90 A 12.09 E 6.36 D 14.46 A 5 B 21.14

Rupesh U. Waingankar

Age: 27 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: S, Area: Kokan Nagar - Bhattipada, Constituency No.: 108

Member: Public Health Committee, Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee S and T


MNS

2014 B 70.07 33 A 13.89 C 10.22 D 16.76 A 5 C 18.21

2013 C 69.19 35 A 14.05 D 8.03 C 17.57 A 5 B 23.19

Vaishnavi V. Sarfare

Age: 38 yrs, Edu.: HSC Ward: S, Area: Hanuman Nagar - Farid Nagar, Constituency No.: 109

Member: Ward Committee S and T, Improvements Committee




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

NCP

2014 C 65.73 74 A 12.41 E 6.11 D 14.09 A 5 B 21.14

2013 C 69.36 31 A 13.50 B 11.61 D 15.90 A 5 B 21.01

Dhananjay S. Pisal

Age: 59 yrs, Edu.: B.Com Ward: S, Area: Datar Colony - C.G.S. Quarters, Constituency No.: 110

Member: Ward Committee S and T, Standing Committee, Tree Committee


SS

2014 E 47.09 197 D 8.10 E 6.11 F 4.03 A 5 D 16.86

2013 C 60.55 100 A 12.00 E 5.64 D 15.74 A 5 C 19.36

Ashok D. Patil

Age: 55 yrs, Edu.: B.A., L.L.B. Ward: S, Area: Kanjur Village, Constituency No.: 111

Member: BEST Committee, Ward Committee S and T Shift: Attendance; Quality of questions

MNS

2014 C 64.12 79 D 8.92 E 7.16 C 17.56 A 5 C 19.48

2013 C 64.66 70 A 12.37 C 9.35 D 15.46 A 5 C 19.89

Priyanka S. Shrungare

Age: 45 yrs, Edu.: M.A., B.Ed. Ward: S, Area: Kannamwar Nagar, Constituency No.: 112

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee S and T

SS

2014 E 49.71 188 D 7.71 E 6.11 F 8.75 A 5 C 18.15

2013 D 55.47 149 C 9.64 E 7.16 E 12.30 A 5 C 20.29

Tavji S. Gorule

Age: 60 yrs, Edu.: Seventh Ward: S, Area: Tagore Nagar, Constituency No.: 113

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee S and T, Improvements Committee





%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

SS

2014 D 58.85 126 C 9.41 F 3.45 E 13.50 A 5 C 20.49

2013 E 41.41 210 A 12.83 F 0.86 F 0.05 A 5 C 18.86

Vishwas T. Shinde

Age: 50 yrs, Edu.: HSC Ward: S, Area: Hariyali Village - Godrej Colony, Constituency No.: 114

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee S and T


NCP

2014 D 56.68 141 D 7.53 F 3.45 D 14.46 A 5 C 19.24

2013 D 56.89 137 F 4.64 D 8.03 D 16.74 A 5 C 19.48

Chandan C. Sharma

Age: 49 yrs, Edu.: HSC, Ward: S Area: Eden Bungalows - Tirandaz Village, Constituency No.: 115

Member: Ward Committee S and T, Improvements Committee

MNS

2014 F 28.54 225 F 4.29 F 0.72 F 3.03 F -5 C 19.51

2013 D 56.01 144 B 10.56 C 9.35 D 15.49 F -2 C 19.56

Avinash B. Sawant

Age: 42 yrs, Edu.: Ninth, Ward: S Area: Vihar Lake - Powai Lake - Paspoli village, Constituency No.: 116

Member: Public Health Committee, Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee S and T, Improvements Committee

Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of questions; New FIR

SS

2014 D 57.60 132 C 9.13 F 5.04 E 13.47 A 5 D 17.95

2013 C 60.43 104 B 10.52 D 8.96 C 17.58 F 0 C 19.56

Bharti S. Bawdane

Age: 41 yrs, Edu.: M.B.B.S Ward: N, Area: Rahul Nagar, Constituency No.: 117

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee N




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

NCP

2014 F 29.45 224 E 7.39 F 0.72 F 1.00 F -5 C 18.34

2013 E 39.23 216 B 10.85 F 4.58 F 8.78 F -10 C 20.08

Harun Y. Khan

Age: 54 yrs, Edu.: SSC, Ward: N Area: Parksite Colony - Vikroli Village, Constituency No.: 118

Member: Ward Committee N, Education CommitteeShift: Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of questions

MNS

2014 C 60.52 117 D 8.41 F 4.31 D 16.73 A 5 C 19.08

2013 D 59.99 111 D 8.30 F 4.58 D 16.44 A 5 B 21.84

Sanjay D. Bhalerao

Age: 36 yrs, Edu.: B.Com, Ward: N Area: Damodar Park - Sanghani Estate, Constituency No.: 119

Member: Ward Committee N, Education Committee

NCP

2014 E 48.66 192 E 7.45 F 4.31 F 6.02 A 5 C 18.89

2013 D 57.63 133 B 11.39 D 8.03 F 7.87 A 5 B 21.38

Pratiksha R. Ghuge

Age: 35 yrs, Edu.: HSC, Ward: N, Area: Sarvodaya Hospital - Central Government Colony - Jagdusha Nagar, Constituency No.: 120

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee N


BJP

2014 B 73.86 16 C 10.37 A 12.47 B 22.28 A 5 D 16.75

2013 B 72.00 17 A 12.21 B 11.94 B 20.13 A 5 C 20.51

Ritu R. Tawade

Age: 41 yrs, Edu.: S.Y.B.Com Ward: N, Area: Bhim Nagar - Ram Nagar, Constituency No.: 121

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Ward Committee N




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

INDEPENDENT 2014 B 73.66 17 A 12.54 A 13.86 C 18.70 A 5 D 16.57

2013 C 68.52 37 A 14.02 A 12.47 E 12.20 A 5 B 21.44

Deepak W. Hande

Age: 45 yrs, Edu.: HSC Ward: N, Area: Bhatwadi - Barve Nagar, Constituency No.: 122

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee NShift: No. of questions; Quality of questions

SS

2014 C 67.43 59 A 12.76 E 6.11 C 17.11 A 5 C 20.46

2013 B 70.11 28 A 13.27 A 12.47 C 16.88 A 5 B 21.19

Ashwini B. Mate

Age: 45 yrs, Edu.: HSC Ward: N, Area: Chirag Nagar - Narayan Nagar, Constituency No.: 123

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Ward Committee N, Improvements Committee

INC

2014 C 65.53 75 B 11.75 A 12.00 B 21.85 F -5 C 18.93

2013 D 59.43 116 A 12.27 A 13.67 E 13.61 F -5 B 22.01

Pravin V. Chheda

Age: 49 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: N, Area: Kirol Village - Ramji Ashar School, Constituency No.: 124

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee N, Standing Committee


NCP

2014 D 51.69 175 D 8.81 F 0.72 E 11.84 A 5 C 18.32

2013 D 59.50 115 C 9.49 E 7.16 E 12.49 A 5 B 21.49

Rakhee H. Jadhav

Age: 39 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: N, Area: Pant Nagar, Constituency No.: 125

Member: Ward Committee N, Standing CommitteeShift: No. of questions; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

MNS

2014 D 54.33 155 D 7.89 F 2.52 D 14.74 A 5 C 18.18

2013 D 55.38 150 B 10.94 E 5.64 E 13.92 A 5 D 16.79

Suresh D. Awale

Age: 41 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: N, Area: Ramabai Nagar, Constituency No.: 126

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee N

BJP

2014 C 66.53 69 C 9.82 A 12.35 D 14.15 A 5 C 18.21

2013 C 67.44 49 A 13.45 B 11.61 D 15.99 A 5 C 18.94

Falguni M. Dave

Age: 52 yrs, Edu.: Diploma in Medical Technology Ward: N, Area: Garodia Nagar - Somaiya College, Constituency No.: 127

Member: Public Health Committee, Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee N

MNS

2014 F 32.42 223 F 3.45 F 0.00 F 0.00 A 5 D 17.98

2013 E 44.79 200 E 5.62 F 0.86 F 9.37 A 5 C 20.30

Mangal P. Kadam

Age: 33 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: N, Area: Kamraj Nagar, Constituency No.: 128

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee N


SP

2014 B 73.21 19 A 13.21 A 14.40 C 16.81 A 5 D 17.78

2013 C 66.96 54 A 12.86 A 12.47 C 17.40 A 5 D 17.76

Reshma R. Nevrekar

Age: 44 yrs, Edu.: Upto SSC Ward: M/East, Area: Lotus Colony, Rafique Nagar, Constituency No.: 129

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Public Health Committee, Ward Committee M/East, Women and Child Welfare Committee





%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

INDEPENDENT 2014 E 38.58 214 D 8.08 F 1.65 F 6.00 F 0 D 17.85

2013 D 53.63 159 D 8.95 F 2.91 D 16.38 A 5 C 18.21

Mohd. Siraj Mohd. I. Shaikh

Age: 32 yrs, Edu.: Ninth Ward: M/East, Area: Shivaji Nagar No.1, Constituency No.: 130

Member: Ward Committee M/East, Standing CommitteeShift: No. of questions; Quality of questions; New FIR

SP

2014 E 47.52 196 D 8.53 E 6.11 D 14.09 F -5 D 17.78

2013 E 38.44 218 D 7.58 F 2.91 E 12.17 F -5 D 16.81

Noorjahan R. Shaikh

Age: 38 yrs, Edu.: Seventh, Ward: M/East Area: Shivaji Nagar No.2 - Sanjay Nagar, Constituency No.: 131

Member: Ward Committee M/East, Education CommitteeShift: No. of questions; Quality of questions

SP

2014 B 71.94 27 A 12.81 A 13.94 D 14.81 A 5 C 18.38

2013 D 54.79 152 B 11.72 E 7.16 F 9.58 A 5 D 17.23

Rais K. Shaikh

Age: 39 yrs, Edu.: B.Com, Ward: M/East Area: Shastri Nagar - Kamla Raman Nagar, Constituency No.: 132

Member: Ward Committee M/East, Standing CommitteeShift: Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance

SP

2014 C 63.19 92 A 12.25 F 5.04 D 15.38 A 5 C 18.53

2013 C 60.15 109 B 11.85 E 6.36 D 15.16 A 5 D 17.94

Shantaram M. Patil

Age: 69 yrs, Edu.: Inter Arts Ward: M/East, Area: Baiganwadi, P.M.G. Colony, Constituency No.: 133

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee M/East




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

SS

2014 D 53.83 160 C 9.71 B 11.61 E 13.31 F -5 D 17.20

2013 C 61.55 97 C 9.54 A 13.40 B 20.54 F -5 C 19.32

Rahul R. Shevale

Age: 41 yrs, Edu.: Civil Engineering, Ward: M/East Area: Mankhurd Village - Mandala Village, Constituency No.: 134

Member: BEST Committee, Standing Committee, Ward Committee M/East

Shift: No. of Questions; Quality of questions

SS

2014 D 52.03 174 B 11.34 F 2.52 F 9.32 A 5 D 16.85

2013 E 40.80 214 A 13.24 F 0.00 F 0.00 A 5 D 17.71

Manju B. Kumare

Age: 37 yrs, Edu.: M.A., Ward: M/East Area: Anushakti Nagar - (B.A.R.C.) - Trombay, Constituency No.: 136

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee M/East

Shift: No. of Questions; Quality of questions

INC

2014 D 56.74 140 A 13.24 F 4.31 E 12.86 A 5 D 15.34

2013 D 52.30 166 A 12.66 F 2.91 D 14.37 A 5 E 14.11

Sunanda V. Lokare

Age: 40 yrs, Edu.: Eighth, Ward: M/East Area: New Gautam Nagar, Constituency No.: 137

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee M/East

BRPB

2014 D 51.40 179 C 9.92 D 8.16 D 14.65 F -5 D 16.66

2013 D 51.09 174 A 14.36 E 7.16 E 13.52 F -5 D 17.74

Arun V. Kamble

Age: 41 yrs, Edu.: B.A. Ward: M/East, Area: Deonar - Abattoir, Constituency No.: 138

Member: Ward Committee M/East




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

SS

2014 E 45.66 204 B 10.96 F 5.04 D 16.15 F -10 D 17.51

2013 E 44.28 202 C 9.84 F 1.98 C 17.83 F -10 B 21.96

Dinesh H. Panchal

Age: 38 yrs, Edu.: Fifth, Ward: M/East Area: Deonar Village - Mankhurd Childrens’ Home, Constituency No.: 139

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee M/East

INC

2014 C 60.74 113 A 13.02 E 6.11 E 13.66 A 5 D 15.95

2013 D 56.86 138 A 13.52 F 4.58 E 13.25 A 5 D 16.51

Usha A. Kamble

Age: 51 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: M/East, Area: R.C.F. Township, Constituency No.: 140

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Ward Committee M/East

BJP

2014 B 73.13 20 A 13.77 B 11.61 C 18.14 A 5 D 17.61

2013 C 62.26 92 B 11.31 C 9.35 D 16.57 A 5 D 17.31

Vithal A. Kharatmol

Age: 57 yrs, Edu.: Matriculation, Ward: M/East, Area: Adarsh Nagar - Hindustan Petroleum - Anik Village, Constituency No.: 141

Member: Ward Committee M/East, Standing Committee, Education Committee


INC

2014 E 48.76 191 C 9.25 F 1.65 F 9.31 A 5 C 18.55

2013 E 46.91 195 C 9.67 F 2.91 E 11.15 A 5 D 17.64

Seema R. Mahulkar

Age: 38 yrs, Edu.: Ninth, Ward: M/West Area: Anik, Mahul Villages - R.C. F. Company, Constituency No.: 142

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee M/West




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

BJP

2014 C 60.72 114 A 13.39 E 6.11 E 12.55 A 5 D 16.68

2013 D 54.66 153 A 13.45 E 7.16 F 8.90 A 5 D 17.03

Mahadev S. Shivgan

Age: 52 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: M/West, Area: Suman Nagar - Sindhi Society, Constituency No.: 143

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee M/West


BJP

2014 B 74.68 12 A 12.92 A 12.00 B 21.89 A 5 D 15.87

2013 D 53.53 161 A 13.16 E 7.16 F 8.57 A 5 D 16.46

Rajshree S. Palande

Age: 39 yrs, Edu.: B.A., Ward: M/West Area: Siddharth Colony - Basant Park, Golf Club, Constituency No.: 144

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Improvements Committee, Ward Committee M/West


INC

2014 C 67.73 55 B 11.70 C 10.22 B 19.85 A 5 E 14.98

2013 C 66.94 55 A 12.30 A 12.87 C 17.75 A 5 C 18.54

Vandana G. Sable

Age: 45 yrs, Edu.: Ninth Ward: M/West, Area: Sahakar Nagar, Constituency No.: 145

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Ward Committee M/West

SS

2014 D 50.56 183 B 10.51 F 4.31 F 6.00 A 5 D 17.74

2013 C 60.52 103 B 11.76 C 10.41 E 13.92 A 5 D 17.61

Suprada P. Phaterpekar

Age: 30 yrs, Edu.: HSC, Interior Designer, Fashion Designer, Ward: M/West Area: Subhash Nagar - Beggar’s Home, Constituency No.: 146

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee M/West, Education Committee





%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

INC

2014 B 70.23 32 A 14.29 B 11.28 E 13.80 A 5 C 18.86

2013 D 58.46 128 A 14.82 E 6.36 E 12.02 A 5 C 18.33

Anil R. Patankar

Age: 49 yrs, Edu.: HSC Ward: M/West, Area: Borla (Central) - Ghatla Gaon, Constituency No.: 147

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee M/West, Improvements Committee


INC

2014 D 52.73 167 D 9.00 F 2.52 E 13.58 A 5 D 16.63

2013 E 40.07 215 A 12.95 F 0.00 F 0.00 A 5 C 18.23

Sangita C. Handore

Age: 50 yrs, Edu.: Seventh Ward: M/West, Area: Rahul Nagar-Jyoti Nagar, Constituency No.: 148

Member: Ward Committee M/WestShift: No. of questions; Quality of questions

SS

2014 D 57.53 133 A 14.32 E 7.16 F 8.35 A 5 D 17.70

2013 E 48.90 190 A 13.47 F 0.86 F 8.02 A 5 C 20.13

Deepa N. Parab

Age: 62 yrs, Edu.: Upto SSC Ward: M/West, Area: Tilak Nagar - Chedda Nagar, Constituency No.: 149

Member: Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee M/West


NCP

2014 D 59.45 122 D 8.09 D 8.16 E 12.73 A 5 C 19.47

2013 D 59.29 118 D 8.81 C 9.35 D 15.03 A 5 C 19.23

Savita S. Pawar

Age: 43 yrs, Edu.: Seventh, Ward: L Area: Tungwa Village - Chandivali Village (West), Constituency No.: 150

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Markets and Gardens Committee, Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee L




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

MNS

2014 E 46.11 202 D 8.69 F 4.31 E 10.60 F -2 D 17.51

2013 D 52.30 167 C 10.38 E 6.36 D 14.63 F -2 C 18.68

Ishwar D. Tayade

Age: 43 yrs, Edu.: B.A. Ward: L, Area: Chandivali Village (East), Constituency No.: 151

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee L, Education Committee


SS

2014 D 53.87 159 B 11.91 F 2.52 F 9.45 A 5 C 18.99

2013 D 58.18 131 C 10.26 E 5.64 D 16.63 A 5 D 17.71

Komal K. Jamsandekar

Age: 45 yrs, Edu.: Upto SSC Ward: L, Area: Mohili Village, Constituency No.: 152

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee L, Education Committee

INDEPENDENT 2014 C 62.11 100 E 5.62 C 9.42 C 18.07 A 5 D 17.00

2013 C 62.75 89 D 8.23 C 9.35 D 14.88 A 5 B 21.59

Leena H. Shukla

Age: 35 yrs, Edu.: B.Com Ward: L, Area: Kajupada Hill - Asalpha Village, Constituency No.: 153

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Ward Committee L, Education Committee

MNS

2014 B 72.16 26 C 9.59 A 14.46 C 18.41 A 5 D 17.70

2013 C 68.21 40 A 13.65 A 14.73 E 9.96 A 5 B 21.46

Dilip B. Lande

Age: 52 yrs, Edu.: B.Com., Ward: L, Area: Kamani Industries - Sakinaka, Constituency No.: 154

Member: Ward Committee L, Standing Committee, Tree Committee




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

INDEPENDENT 2014 F 33.55 219 F 4.03 F 0.00 F 0.00 A 5 C 18.52

2013 E 36.89 221 E 6.13 F 0.00 F 0.00 A 5 B 21.71

Lalita Annamalai

Age: 54 yrs, Edu.: Ninth Ward: L, Area: Jarimari, Constituency No.: 155

Member: Ward Committee L

SP

2014 C 64.03 85 C 9.95 C 10.22 C 17.23 A 5 D 16.63

2013 E 43.37 205 D 8.50 F 0.86 F 8.00 A 5 C 18.30

Mohd. Ishak Kasim Ali Shaikh

Age: 36 yrs, Edu.: Eighth Ward: L, Area: Home Guard Training Center, Constituency No.: 156

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee L


SS

2014 C 69.19 42 B 11.87 E 6.11 B 20.83 A 5 C 18.38

2013 C 68.87 36 A 13.00 B 10.82 B 20.06 A 5 D 16.62

Manali M. Tulaskar

Age: 35 yrs, Edu.: SSC, Ward: L, Area: Wadia Estate - Hall Village - Premier Automobiles, Constituency No.: 157

Member: Works Committee (Suburbs), Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee L

SP

2014 E 49.76 187 E 7.50 F 2.52 E 11.69 A 5 D 17.05

2013 F 33.51 224 E 6.33 F 0.00 F 0.00 A 5 C 18.94

Dilshad A. Azmi

Age: 53 yrs, Edu.: Fourth Ward: L, Area: Kurla Village, Dayanand Vidyalaya, Constituency No.: 158

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee LShift: Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of questions




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

SP

2014 C 67.83 53 A 12.97 A 13.67 C 17.91 F -2 C 18.30

2013 C 65.23 66 A 12.28 B 11.94 B 21.15 F -2 C 18.29

Ashraf Azmi A. Ansari

Age: 48 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: L, Area: Vinoba Bhave Nagar, Constituency No.: 159

Member: Ward Committee L, Improvements Committee

SS

2014 B 72.80 22 A 13.49 A 14.13 D 16.06 A 5 D 17.12

2013 B 72.88 13 A 13.53 A 14.27 C 18.71 A 5 C 19.21

Sanjana K. Mungekar

Age: 39 yrs, Edu.: Eleventh Ward: L, Area: Kurla Terminus - Kamgar Nagar, Constituency No.: 160

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee L

NCP

2014 C 64.06 83 B 11.30 A 14.93 F 9.65 A 5 D 16.18

2013 C 65.40 65 A 14.48 A 14.87 E 9.99 A 5 D 17.51

Saeeda A. Khan

Age: 45 yrs, Edu.: M.D., DNB, D.A., MBBS Ward: L, Area: Shikshak Nagar, Constituency No.: 161

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee L

SS

2014 B 74.24 14 A 15.00 A 14.66 E 12.75 A 5 C 19.83

2013 B 73.46 8 A 15.00 A 14.54 B 19.69 A 5 D 17.10

Anuradha M. Pednekar

Age: 44 yrs, Edu.: B.A.M.S, Ward: L, Area: Nehru Nagar - Bhabha Hospital - Takiya Ward, Constituency No.: 162

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee L, Standing Committee




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

SS

2014 D 52.28 171 A 14.02 F 1.65 E 10.05 A 5 D 15.56

2013 D 51.01 175 A 14.18 F 2.91 F 9.73 A 5 D 16.88

Darshana D. Shinde

Age: 43 yrs, Edu.: Ninth Ward: L, Area: Kasai Wada - Everard Nagar, Constituency No.: 163

Member: Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee L

INDEPENDENT 2014 C 68.51 48 C 9.82 A 12.00 D 16.22 A 5 C 18.47

2013 C 67.89 43 A 12.39 B 11.94 C 19.36 A 5 D 16.78

Vijay P. Tandel

Age: 40 yrs, Edu.: F.Y.B.Com (Appeared) Ward: L, Swadeshi Mill - Eye Hospital, Constituency No.: 164

Member: Ward Committee L

SS

2014 C 63.31 89 A 14.61 F 4.31 D 14.82 A 5 C 18.58

2013 D 54.63 154 A 13.73 F 1.98 E 10.66 A 5 C 20.13

Pranita P. Waghdhare

Age: 50 yrs, Edu.: Upto SSC Ward: F/North, Area: Pratiksha Nagar - Sion, Constituency No.: 165

Member: Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee F/South and F/North


INC

2014 C 69.56 40 A 12.78 B 10.74 C 17.03 A 5 C 18.01

2013 C 63.22 83 A 12.82 D 8.03 D 15.36 A 5 C 19.34

Lalita K. Yadav

Age: 37 yrs, Edu.: Seventh Ward: F/North, Area: Salt Pans, Sion Transit Camp, Constituency No.: 166

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee F/South and F/North





%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

BJP

2014 B 72.83 21 A 13.86 A 12.47 D 16.61 A 5 D 17.89

2013 D 59.66 113 A 12.61 F 2.91 D 16.45 A 5 C 18.83

Rajeshree R. Shirwadkar

Age: 36 yrs, Edu.: B.A.F.A, Ward: F/North, Area: Lokmanya Tilak Hospital - Shanmukhanand Hall, Constituency No.: 167

Member: Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee F/South and F/North


BJP

2014 C 69.12 43 B 10.60 C 9.42 C 19.18 A 5 D 17.92

2013 C 65.62 61 B 11.58 C 10.41 D 16.56 A 5 C 19.53

Selvan R. Tamil

Age: 55 yrs, Edu.: HSC Ward: F/North, Area: Raoli Hill, Constituency No.: 168

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee F/South and F/North

SS

2014 C 60.63 116 B 11.37 C 9.42 E 12.68 A 5 D 15.15

2013 B 71.22 20 A 13.11 B 11.21 C 19.01 A 5 C 19.63

Shradha S. Jadhav

Age: 49 yrs, Edu.: HSC, Ward: F/North, Area: C.G.S. Colony - Sector - 7, Constituency No.: 169

Member: Ward Committee F/South and F/North, Improvements Committee


SS

2014 C 68.39 49 A 14.32 B 11.61 D 14.12 A 5 D 17.35

2013 B 74.85 4 A 14.15 A 14.00 B 21.07 A 5 C 18.57

Trushna C. Vishwasrao

Age: 54 yrs, Edu.: Upto SSC, Ward: F/North, Area: Antop Hill - C.G.S. Colony, Constituency No.: 170

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee F/South and F/North, Standing Committee





%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

BJP

2014 E 45.47 205 C 9.44 F 0.72 F 8.14 A 5 D 16.17

2013 D 50.09 181 B 11.30 F 2.91 E 10.13 A 5 D 17.39

Mahant R. Chaube

Age: 53 yrs, Edu.: Ninth, Ward: F/North, Area: Sangam Nagar, Constituency No.: 171


INDEPENDENT 2014 F 33.59 218 E 5.42 F 0.72 F 8.67 F -5 D 16.78

2013 E 48.29 193 C 9.19 F 4.58 D 15.67 F -5 C 19.41

Manojkumar M. Sansare

Age: 46 yrs, Edu.: B.Sc (Electronics) Ward: F/North, Area: Korba Mithagar - Wadala Salt Pans, Constituency No.: 172

Member: Ward Committee F/South and F/NorthShift: Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of questions

SS

2014 D 51.60 178 B 11.88 F 1.65 F 8.81 A 5 D 17.26

2013 E 38.13 219 A 14.12 F 0.00 F 0.00 A 5 E 14.02

Alka H. Doke

Age: 55 yrs, Edu.: SSC, Ward: F/North, Area: Lepars Home-BPT Hospital Colony, Constituency No.: 173


Shift: No.of questions; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance

INC

2014 D 59.06 125 B 11.21 D 8.96 E 11.32 A 5 D 15.58

2013 C 63.73 77 A 13.81 E 7.16 D 15.87 A 5 C 18.25

Nayna M. Sheth

Age: 61 yrs, Edu.: SSC Ward: F/North, Area: Hindu Colony - Parsi Colony, Constituency No.: 174

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee F/South and F/North, Tree Committee





%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

RPI (A)

2014 E 43.54 208 C 9.78 F 0.72 F 6.00 A 5 D 16.04

2013 D 51.49 171 B 11.30 F 2.91 E 12.00 A 5 D 16.98

Sabreddy M. Borra

Age: 46 yrs, Edu.: Upto Ninth Ward: G/North, Area: Mahim Kala Killa, Constituency No.: 175

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee G/North, Tree Committee

Shift: Attendance, No. of questions; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance

SS

2014 E 45.93 203 D 7.59 F 0.72 F 9.06 A 5 D 17.56

2013 E 36.36 222 D 8.29 F 0.00 F 0.00 A 5 C 18.98

Anusha R. Kodam (Valpadasi)

Age: 23 yrs, Edu.: T.Y. Bio - Technology (Appeared) Ward: G/North, Area: Dharavi Transit Camp, Constituency No.: 176

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee G/North


SS

2014 D 51.62 177 A 12.41 D 7.62 E 11.11 F -5 C 18.49

2013 D 50.87 177 A 12.07 F 2.91 D 16.77 F -5 C 19.80

Rajendra N. Suryavanshi

Age: 49 yrs, Edu.: SSC, Ward: G/North, Area: Kakkaiyadevi Temple (Dharavi) - Khambadevi Nagar - Mukund Nagar, Constituency No.: 177

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee G/North

INC

2014 D 52.82 166 A 12.18 F 2.52 F 9.15 A 5 D 17.97

2013 E 37.62 220 A 12.49 F 1.98 F 0.11 A 5 D 15.02

Vakil S. Ahmed Shaikh

Age: 35 yrs, Edu.: Eighth Ward: G/North, Area: Western India Tanneries, Constituency No.: 178

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee G/NorthShift: Quality of questions; Perceived Performance




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

SP

2014 F 33.19 221 D 7.80 F 0.00 F 0.00 A 5 D 15.39

2013 E 35.51 223 D 8.42 F 0.00 F 0.00 A 5 C 18.96

Jyotsna H. Parmar

Age: 33 yrs, Edu.: Fifth, Ward: G/North, Area: Mahim Sonapur - Dharavi Kumbharwada, Constituency No.: 179

Member: Works Committee (City), Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee G/North

INDEPENDENT 2014 D 56.91 139 B 11.94 F 5.04 E 11.71 A 5 D 16.22

2013 E 43.48 204 B 11.67 F 1.98 F 0.11 A 5 C 20.01

Vishnu R. Gaikwad

Age: 59 yrs, Edu.: Eleventh, Ward: G/North, Area: Estrella Battery Company - Rajarshi Shahu Nagar, Constituency No.: 180

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee G/NorthShift: No. of questions; Quality of questions

MNS

2014 C 67.05 63 A 13.60 F 5.04 C 18.51 A 5 C 18.90

2013 C 61.37 98 A 13.55 E 5.64 D 15.47 A 5 C 18.94

Shraddha R. Patil

Age: 37 yrs, Edu.: HSC, Ward: G/North Area: Mahim Creek, Mahim Police Quarters, Mahim Killa, Constituency No.: 181

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee G/North

Shift: Quality of questions;

MNS

2014 E 48.14 194 A 14.23 F 0.72 F 3.11 A 5 C 18.08

2013 C 69.33 32 A 14.58 D 8.03 C 17.71 A 5 C 20.67

Virendra V. Tandel

Age: 49 yrs, Edu.: SSC, Ward: G/North Area: Shitaladevi Temple - Hinduja Hospital, Constituency No.: 182

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee G/North, Tree Committee

Shift: No. of questions; Quality of questions; P.P




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

MNS

2014 D 52.70 169 A 13.23 F 5.04 E 13.02 F -5 C 20.41

2013 E 46.88 196 A 13.60 F 2.91 D 15.06 F -5 D 17.78

Manish D. Chavan

Age: 43 yrs, Edu.: Fourteenth, Ward: G/North Area: Ruparel College - Matunga Workshop, Constituency No.: 183

Member: Works Committee (City), Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee G/North, Standing Committee


MNS

2014 B 74.51 13 C 9.03 A 13.26 A 22.61 A 5 D 17.62

2013 C 69.64 29 A 13.31 A 12.87 D 16.32 A 5 C 19.81

Sudhir K. Jadhav

Age: 49 yrs, Edu.: SSC, Ward: G/North, Area: Kamgar Krida Kenra, Dadar Railway Station, Constituency No.: 184

Member: Ward Committee G/North Shift: Attendance; Quality of questions

MNS

2014 D 58.33 128 B 10.84 D 8.96 B 20.69 F -5 D 16.84

2013 D 58.90 120 A 13.36 C 9.89 C 19.46 F -5 C 19.29

Sandeep (Yashwant) S. Deshpande

Age: 40 yrs, Edu.: M.A., Ward: G/North Area: Ravindra Natya Mandir - Shivaji Park, Constituency No.: 185

Member: BEST Committee, Ward Committee G/North, Standing Committee

MNS

2014 C 60.33 118 C 9.61 F 3.45 C 18.45 A 5 D 16.83

2013 C 67.91 42 A 13.89 D 8.96 D 16.63 A 5 C 20.01

Seema M. Shivalkar

Age: 29 yrs, Edu.: B.Sc., Ward: G/South, Area: S.T. Depot, Weatern Railway Workshop, Constituency No.: 186

Member: Ward Committee G/South Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; P.P




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

MNS

2014 B 73.39 18 A 12.00 B 10.74 C 18.87 A 5 C 19.77

2013 C 69.27 34 A 12.92 B 11.94 C 17.14 A 5 C 19.93

Santosh B. Dhuri

Age: 44 yrs, Edu.: HSC, Ward: G/South Area: T.V.Centre - Prabhadevi, Constituency No.: 187

Member: Works Committee (City), Public Health Committee, Ward Committee G/South

SS

2014 B 78.43 2 A 15.00 A 13.47 C 18.12 A 5 C 19.84

2013 B 78.22 1 A 14.26 A 14.60 B 20.35 A 5 B 21.13

Hemangi H. Worlikar

Age: 41 yrs, Edu.: B.A., Ward: G/South, Area: Worli Village, Constituency No.: 188

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee G/South

SS

2014 D 58.47 127 C 9.69 F 3.45 D 14.72 A 5 C 18.61

2013 D 51.91 168 C 10.38 F 2.91 E 12.56 A 5 D 16.79

Mansi M. Dalvi

Age: 41 yrs, Edu.: Thirteenth, Ward: G/South Area: Worli dairy - Sasmira, Constituency No.: 189

Member: Public Health Committee, Improvements Committee, Ward Committee G/South


MNS

2014 E 36.89 216 D 7.85 F 0.00 F 0.00 A 5 C 19.04

2013 E 43.53 203 C 9.38 F 0.86 F 6.00 A 5 B 21.58

Hemlata V. Wange

Age: 44 yrs, Edu.: Ninth, Ward: G/South, Area: Worli B.D.D. Chawls, Constituency No.: 190

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee G/South Shift: Attendance; Quality of questions




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

SS

2014 D 53.22 163 B 11.98 B 11.28 D 16.02 F -10 D 16.93

2013 D 57.75 132 A 12.73 A 12.87 D 16.34 F -10 B 21.85

Kishori K. Pednekar

Age: 51 yrs, Edu.: SSC.: HSC, Ward: G/South Area: Gandhi Nagar - Dawn Mills, Constituency No.: 191

Member: Works Committee (City), Standing Committee, Ward Committee G/South

NCP

2014 C 65.52 76 B 11.81 D 8.96 D 15.58 A 5 C 18.18

2013 C 63.54 81 A 13.06 B 11.21 E 10.63 A 5 C 20.99

Ratna R. Mahale

Age: 44 yrs, Edu.: B.A., L.L.B (Appeared), Ward: G/South, Area: Mahalaxmi Race Course - Nehru Tarangan, Constituency No.: 192

Member: Works Committee (City), Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Education Committee, Ward Committee G/South

NCP

2014 C 69.72 37 A 14.31 C 9.42 C 18.06 A 5 D 16.93

2013 B 71.04 21 A 14.13 B 10.82 C 17.67 A 5 B 21.16

Sunil M. Ahir

Age: 38 yrs, Edu.: Eighth, Ward: G/South Area: Shanti Nagar - Arthur Road Jail, Constituency No.: 193

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee G/South

SS

2014 B 78.46 1 A 13.83 B 10.74 B 21.04 A 5 C 20.85

2013 C 67.88 44 A 14.51 E 6.36 D 16.65 A 5 B 21.93

Snehal S. Ambekar

Age: 41 yrs, Edu.: B.Com, Ward: G/South, Area: Parel - B.D.D. Chawls, Constituency No.: 194

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee G/SouthShift: No. of questions; Quality of questions




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

INC

2014 D 52.57 170 B 10.93 F 2.52 F 6.00 A 5 B 21.12

2013 D 60.00 110 A 12.63 F 4.58 E 11.79 A 5 B 23.16

Sunil V. More

Age: 52 yrs, Edu.: B.Com, L.L.B. (General), Ward: F/South, Area: Ranjeet Studio - Naigaon B.D.D. Chawls, Constituency No.: 195

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee F/South and F/North, Standing Committee


INC

2014 E 48.59 193 A 12.11 F 0.72 F 6.00 A 5 C 19.76

2013 E 46.81 197 B 11.35 F 0.86 E 10.90 A 5 D 16.17

Pallavi M. Mungekar

Age: 41 yrs, Edu.: Ninth, Ward: F/South, Area: Naigaum Police Parade Ground, B.P.T. Hospital, Constituency No.: 196

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee F/South and F/North,

SS

2014 C 66.93 65 A 13.69 D 8.49 C 17.01 A 5 D 15.74

2013 C 65.56 62 A 13.94 D 8.96 C 16.87 A 5 C 18.24

Nandkishor S. Vichare

Age: 53 yrs, Edu.: B.Com, Ward: F/South Area: Mahatma Gandhi Vasahat - Bhoiwada, Constituency No.: 197

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee F/South and F/North, Tree Committee

SS

2014 F 32.68 222 E 7.42 F 2.52 F 6.00 F -10 C 19.75

2013 D 50.29 180 B 11.88 D 8.03 E 11.23 F -5 C 19.81

Sanjay (Nana) G. Ambole

Age: 51 yrs, Edu.: SSC, Ward: F/South, Area: India United Mills - Nare Park, Constituency No.: 198

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee F/South and F/North, BEST Committee

Shift: Attendance; No. of Questions; Quality of questions, New FIR




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

SS

2014 C 68.27 51 A 12.80 D 8.16 C 17.94 A 5 C 18.36

2013 B 73.02 11 A 13.96 C 9.89 B 19.72 A 5 B 21.30

Hemangi H. Chemburkar

Age: 53 yrs, Edu.: SSC, Ward: F/South, Area: K.E.M. Hospital - Raj Kamal Studio - Mahatma Gandhi Hospital, Constituency No.: 199

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee F/South and F/North


SS

2014 C 61.24 108 B 11.88 F 5.04 E 13.53 A 5 C 19.79

2013 C 62.53 91 A 14.18 F 4.58 E 10.12 A 5 A 24.95

Vaibhavi V. Chavan

Age: 30 yrs, Edu.: SSC, Ward: F/South, Area: Veternary Hospital - Abhyuday Nagar, Constituency No.: 200


SS

2014 D 51.19 181 C 10.43 F 0.72 F 8.67 A 5 C 20.37

2013 E 45.01 199 B 11.11 F 0.00 F 0.00 A 5 A 24.27

Shweta S. Rane

Age: 43 yrs, Edu.: B.A., Ward: F/South Area: Cotton Green-Sewri Fort, Constituency No.: 201

Member: Works Committee (City), Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee F/South and F/North


MNS

2014 C 63.95 86 A 14.28 E 6.11 E 10.51 A 5 B 21.05

2013 B 70.83 23 A 13.94 D 8.96 D 15.55 A 5 A 24.11

Samita S. Naik

Age: 47 yrs, Edu.: SSC, Ward: E, Area: Veer Jijamata Udyan - Ghodapdeo - Mazgaon Dock (North), Constituency No.: 202

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee A, B and EShift: No. of questions; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

SS

2014 C 60.67 115 A 13.63 A 13.47 E 11.86 F -5 C 19.70

2013 C 62.25 93 A 14.61 A 14.07 C 18.74 F -10 B 21.11

Ramakant S. Rahate

Age: 55 yrs, Edu.: SSC, Ward: E, Area: Kasturba Hospital - India United Mill, Constituency No.: 203

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee A, B and E, Improvements Committee

ABS

2014 D 53.28 162 B 10.88 F 0.72 E 12.95 A 5 D 17.72

2013 E 49.31 187 B 10.91 F 0.86 F 6.07 A 5 B 23.07

Vandana P. Gawli

Age: 42 yrs, Edu.: Upto SSC, Ward: E, Area: Byculla Railway Station - Municipal Colony, Constituency No.: 204

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee A, B and E, Improvements Committee

ABS

2014 E 49.44 189 F 4.68 E 6.11 F 7.23 A 5 C 19.43

2013 D 53.97 157 E 6.44 E 6.36 E 10.92 A 5 B 21.08

Geeta A. Gawli

Age: 30 yrs, Edu.: SSC, Ward: E Area: Nair Hospital - Byculla Fire Brigade, Constituency No.: 205

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee A, B and E, Standing Committee

INC

2014 E 41.57 211 E 6.64 F 1.65 F 6.00 A 5 D 16.27

2013 E 38.86 217 E 7.33 F 1.98 F 0.00 A 5 C 20.59

Faiyaz A. Khan

Age: 52 yrs, Edu.: S.Y.B.A., Ward: E, Area: Mazgaon Court - Madanpura, Constituency No.: 206

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee A, B and E, Education Committee




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

SS

2014 C 65.95 73 B 11.38 B 11.28 D 14.24 A 5 D 17.05

2013 B 74.58 5 B 11.66 A 14.27 C 17.88 A 5 B 22.70

Yamini Y. Jadhav

Age: 46 yrs, Edu.: B.Com, Ward: E, Area: Anjirwadi, Dockyard - Mazgaon Dock (South), Constituency No.: 207

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee A, B and E, Education Committee


INC

2014 C 61.42 106 A 12.99 D 8.49 E 13.24 A 5 E 14.70

2013 C 67.32 51 A 13.59 D 8.03 C 16.85 A 5 C 20.40

Manoj P. Jamsutkar

Age: 45 yrs, Edu.: HSC, I.T.I. Electrician Trade, Library Science, Ward: E, Area: Mastan Talao - J.J. Hospital - Vikrikar Bhavan, Constituency No.: 208

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee A, B and E


INC

2014 E 44.69 206 C 9.04 F 2.52 F 6.00 A 5 D 17.13

2013 D 53.66 158 D 8.90 F 1.98 D 14.81 A 5 C 19.79

Shahana R. Khan

Age: 50 yrs, Edu.: Seventh, Ward: E Area: Kamathipura, Constituency No.: 209

Member: Women and Child Welfare Committee, Ward Committee A, B and E


INC

2014 B 75.46 9 A 15.00 B 11.28 B 20.35 A 5 D 16.83

2013 B 73.54 7 A 15.00 A 13.26 C 19.38 A 5 C 18.77

Noshir R. Mehta

Age: 67 yrs, Edu.: B.Sc., Ward: D, Area: Bellasis chawls - Navjeevan Society, Constituency No.: 210

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee C and D, Improvements Committee




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

SS

2014 C 61.49 105 A 14.67 A 12.47 E 13.89 F -2 D 16.47

2013 F 33.19 225 A 12.55 F 0.00 F 0.00 F -2 C 19.38

Arvind D. Dudhwadkar

Age: 54 yrs, Edu.: Upto SSC, Ward: D, Area: Wellington Sport Club - Bhatia Hospital, Constituency No.: 211

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee C and D, BEST Committee


BJP

2014 C 67.62 57 A 12.44 E 6.11 C 18.42 A 5 C 18.65

2013 C 63.61 79 A 13.40 F 4.58 D 14.72 A 5 B 22.27

Sarita A. Patil

Age: 37 yrs, Edu.: B.Com, Ward: D, Area: Mahalaxmi - Air Condition Market - Umar Park, Constituency No.: 212

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee C and D

SS

2014 B 74.93 11 A 12.35 A 13.34 B 19.76 A 5 D 17.49

2013 C 69.53 30 A 12.02 B 10.82 C 17.75 A 5 C 20.61

Anil S. Singh

Age: 39 yrs, Edu.: SSC, Ward: D Area: Priyadarshani Park - August Kranti Maidan, Constituency No.: 213

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee C and DShift: No. of questions; Quality of questions

BJP

2014 C 62.86 95 A 12.75 D 7.62 E 13.85 A 5 D 16.64

2013 D 51.18 173 A 14.46 F 1.98 F 8.68 A 5 D 16.75

Jyotshna D. Mehta

Age: 53 yrs, Edu.: HSC, Ward: D, Area: Kamala Nehru Udyan - Rajbhavan, Constituency No.: 214

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee C and DShift: No. of questions; Quality of questions




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

SS

2014 E 44.17 207 A 13.04 F 3.45 F 9.00 F -5 D 16.68

2013 D 53.26 162 A 13.68 C 10.41 F 9.29 F -5 B 21.69

Surendra R. Bagalkar

Age: 56 yrs, Edu.: HSC, Ward: D, Area: Prarthana Samaj - Opera House, Constituency No.: 215



INC

2014 D 53.20 164 A 12.08 F 3.45 E 11.82 A 5 D 16.85

2013 E 49.97 183 A 12.05 F 1.98 F 8.90 A 5 C 19.67

Shantilal C. Doshi

Age: 53 yrs, Edu.: Eighth, Ward: D, Area: Harkisandas N. Hospital - Khetwadi, Constituency No.: 216

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee C and D

SS

2014 D 56.51 142 A 13.67 F 3.45 E 10.57 A 5 D 16.83

2013 C 63.19 84 A 14.48 D 8.03 E 11.10 A 5 C 20.91

Yugandara Y. Salekar

Age: 44 yrs, Edu.: B.A., Ward: C Area: Durgadevi Udyan - Madhav Baug - Bhuleshwar, Constituency No.: 217

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee C and DShift: No. of questions; Perceived Performance

SS

2014 C 69.64 38 A 13.66 D 8.49 C 18.88 A 5 D 16.62

2013 C 63.59 80 A 14.92 D 8.96 E 11.79 A 5 C 19.28

Sampat S. Thakur

Age: 46 yrs, Edu.: B.A., Ward: C, Area: Chandanwadi, Chirabazar, Gymkhana, Constituency No.: 218


Shift: Attendance; Quality of questions




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

BJP

2014 C 60.95 110 B 10.74 E 7.16 D 14.44 A 5 C 18.61

2013 C 66.72 56 A 13.84 E 6.36 C 19.03 A 5 B 21.01

Veena M. Jain

Age: 51 yrs, Edu.: Ninth, Ward: C, Area: Mumbadevi - Mulji Jetha Market - Dhobi Talao, Constituency No.: 219

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee C and DShift: Attendance; Quality of questions; P.P

SP

2014 C 68.92 46 C 10.18 C 9.42 B 20.22 A 5 D 17.11

2013 B 73.30 9 A 13.38 A 13.94 C 17.30 A 5 C 20.55

Yaqoob J. Memon

Age: 62 yrs, Edu.: F.Y.B.A., Ward: C, Area: Khara Talao - Null Bazar - Ghoghari Mohalla, Constituency No.: 220

Member: Works Committee (City), Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee C and D, BEST Committee


INC

2014 D 57.51 134 F 3.77 F 5.04 C 19.00 A 5 D 17.70

2013 C 67.06 53 C 10.02 B 11.21 C 17.67 A 5 C 20.69

Dnyanraj Y. Nikam

Age: 52 yrs, Edu.: SSC, Ward: B Area: Imamwada - Dongri, Constituency No.: 221

Member: Ward Committee A, B and E, Standing Committee, Tree Committee


INC

2014 C 61.70 102 A 12.62 E 6.11 D 14.93 A 5 D 16.05

2013 C 63.95 74 B 11.94 C 9.89 E 12.33 A 5 B 21.16

Waqarunnisa Ansari

Age: 63 yrs, Edu.: SSC, H.T.C., Ward: B, Area: Bengalipura - Princess Dock, Constituency No.: 222

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee A, B and EShift: No. of questions; Perceived Performance




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

INC

2014 C 67.64 56 A 12.86 C 10.22 D 14.73 A 5 D 17.84

2013 B 72.98 12 A 13.71 B 11.21 C 17.97 A 5 B 21.93

Javed I. Juneja

Age: 37 yrs, Edu.: HSC, Ward: B, Area: Musafir Khana - Victoria Docks, Constituency No.: 223

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee A, B and EShift: Quality of questions; Perceived Performance

SS

2014 C 66.62 68 A 12.60 C 9.42 B 21.51 F -2 C 19.09

2013 D 50.87 176 A 12.45 F 2.91 D 15.07 F -2 C 19.13

Ganesh Y. Sanap

Age: 34 yrs, Edu.: Ninth, Ward: A, Area: Mahatma Phule Market - Churchgate - Museum - Indira Dock, Constituency No.: 224

Member: Markets and Gardens Committee, Ward Committee A, B and E


INC

2014 E 46.79 200 A 12.34 F 1.65 F 6.57 A 5 D 16.23

2013 D 57.62 134 A 13.12 F 1.98 D 15.61 A 5 C 20.94

Sushama A. Salunkhe

Age: 32 yrs, Edu.: Upto SSC, Ward: A, Area: Brabourne Stadium, Colaba Market - Gateway of India, Constituency No.: 225

Member: Public Health Committee, Ward Committee A, B and E


INC

2014 E 42.63 210 B 11.33 F 0.00 F 0.00 A 5 C 19.29

2013 E 40.88 213 A 12.59 F 0.00 F 0.00 A 5 C 18.44

Anita R. Yadav

Age: 45 yrs, Edu.: HSC, Ward: A, Area: Sassoon Dock, World Trade Centre, Geeta Nagar, Constituency No.: 226

Member: Works Committee (City), Ward Committee A, B and E




%RANK

ATTENDANCENO. OF




GradeActual

out of 15Grade

Actual out of 15

GradeActual

out of 28Grade

Actual out of 5

GradeActual

out of 30

INDEPENDENT 2014 D 59.46 121 C 10.38 D 7.62 E 11.71 A 5 C 18.74

2013 C 66.41 57 A 12.65 D 8.03 C 18.18 A 5 C 20.05

Makarand S. Narvekar

Age: 35 yrs, Edu.: B.com, L.L.B. Ward: A, Area: R.C. Church - Colaba Dandi - Navy Nagar, Constituency No.: 227

Member: Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Ward Committee A, B and E, Education Committee

Shift: Attendance; Quality of questions


cegK³e efJeMues<eCe / KEY ANALYSIS

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

110

120

130

140

150

A B C D E F

143(63%)

40(18%)

21(9%) 14(6%)

5(2%) 3(1%)

102(45%)

50(22%)

30(13%) 28(12%)

9(4%) 6(3%)

Num

ber

of C

ounc

illor

s

Grade

Attendance

A - 100% to 80% attendanceB - Less than 80% to 70% attendance

C - Less than 70% to 60% attendance D - Less than 60% to 50% attendance

E - Less than 50% to 35% attendance F - Less than 35% attendance

2013

2013

2013 2013 2013 2013

2014

2014

2014

2014

2014 2014

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

0 1 2 to 10 11 to 30 31 to 50 Above 50

13(6%) 17(8%)

118(52%)

69(31%)

8(4%) 1(0.44%)

10(4%)14(6%)

102(45%)

80(36%)

13(6%) 6(3%)

Questions Asked

2013

2014

Number of Question

Num

ber

of C

ounc

illor

s

NOTE: NUMBER OF COUNCILLORS IN 2013 ARE 226 & IN 2014 ARE 225

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

A B C D E F

0(0%) 1(0.44%) 1(0.44%)

9(4%)

36(16%)

179(79%)

0(0%) 3(1%) 8(4%)

23(10%)

52(23%)

139(62%)

Num

ber

of C

ounc

illor

s

Grade

A - 100% to 80% marks B - Less than 80% to 70% marks C - Less than 70% to 60% marks D - Less than 60% to 50% marks

E - Less than 50% to 35% marks

F - Less than 35% marks

2013 2013 2013

2013

2013

2013

2014 2014 2014

2014

2014

2014

AverageScore is20.9% in

2013 & 26.9%in 2014

Proportion of Questions Asked by Councillors Compared toCitizen's Complaints

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

A B C D E F

179(79%)

0(0%) 3(1%) 0(0%) 0(0%)

44(19%)

175(78%)

0(0%) 3(1%) 0(0%) 0(0%)

47(21%)

Num

ber

of C

ounc

illor

s

Grade

Least Criminal Record

A - 100% to 80% marks B - Less than 80% to 70% marks C - Less than 70% to 60% marks

D - Less than 60% to 50% marks

E - Less than 50% to 35% marks

F - Less than 35% marks

2013

2013 2013 2013 2013

2013

2014

2014 2014 2014 2014

2014

Note: Of the 34 Councillors having FIRs as per their February 2012 Affidavits, cases on two have been withdrawn.

Number of Municipal Councillors with:

FIRs as per Affidavit February 2012 34

New FIRs Registered as on 31st December 2013 21

Charge sheeted as on 31st December 2013 41


0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

50

A B C D E F

0(0%)

18(15%)

47(39%)

33(28%)

19(16%)

3(3%)

0(0%)

16(15%)

38(36%)

33(31%)

13(12%)

5(5%)

Num

ber o

f Cou

ncill

ors

(225

)

Grade

Gender-wise Analysis (2014)

Female (120)Male (105)

AverageMarks ofMale is59.40%

AverageMarks ofFemale

is 59.41%

A - 100% to 80% marksB - Less than 80% to 70% marksC - Less than 70% to 60% marks D - Less than 60% to 50% marks E - Less than 50% to 35% marks F - Less than 35% marks

Score 2013 A B C D E FAverage Marks

Female (121) 0 14 41 36 28 257.62%

In (%) 0 12 34 30 23 2Male (105) 0 14 40 36 14 1

59.66%In (%) 0 13 38 34 13 1

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

A B C D E F

4(2%)

67(30%)

119(53%)

34(15%)

2(1%) 0(0%)0(0%)4(2%)

84(37%)

126(56%)

11(5%)

0(0%)

Num

ber

of C

ounc

illor

s

Grade

Perceived Performance

A - 100% to 80% marks B - Less than 80% to 70% marks C - Less than 70% to 60% marks D - Less than 60% to 50% marksE - Less than 50% to 35% marksF - Less than 35% marks

2013

2013

2013

2013

2013 20132014

2014

2014

2014

20142014

Average Scoreis 66.5% in

2013 & 58.6%in 2014

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

A B C D E F

3(1%)

26(12%)

38(17%)

32(14%)

71(31%)

56(25%)

0(0%) 1(0.44%) 2(1%)

21(9%)

81(36%)

120(53%) Awareness & Accessibility

Num

ber

of C

ounc

illor

s

Grade

A - 100% to 80% marksB - Less than 80% to 70% marksC - Less than 70% to 60% marks D - Less than 60% to 50% marksE - Less than 50% to 35% marks F - Less than 35% marks

2013

2013

20132013

2013

2013

2014 2014 2014

2014

2014

2014AverageScore is

48.8% in 2013& 35.3% in

2014


Party

Akhil Bharatiya

Sena (2)

Bharatiya Janata Party (31)

Bhartiya Republican

Party Bahujan Mahasangha

(1)Independent

(15)

Indian National Congress

(52)

Maharashtra Navnirman

Sena (28)

Nationalist Congress

Party (13)

Republican Party Of

India RPI(A) (1)

Samajwadi Party (9)

Shiv Sena (74)

Average Score (226)

2013 51.64 62.23 51.09 52.86 57.20 58.10 61.48 51.49 52.36 59.95 58.57%

0.00

10.00

20.00

30.00

40.00

50.00

60.00

70.00

AkhilBharatiyaSena (2)

BharatiyaJanata Party

(31)

BhartiyaRepublican

PartyBahujan

Mahasangha(1)

Independent(14)

IndianNational

Congress (52)

MaharashtraNavnirmanSena (28)

NationalistCongressParty (13)

RepublicanParty Of

India RPI(A)(1)

SamajwadiParty (9)

Shiv Sena(74)

51.36

65.26

51.40 52.83

58.6056.50 58.13

43.54

59.95 60.56

Sco

re

Political Party

Party-wise Average Score (2014)

AverageScore of 225Councillors is

59.41%

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

50

55

60

65

70

75

80

85



(31)

BhartiyaRepublican

PartyBahujan

Mahasangha(1)

Independent(14)

IndianNational

Congress(52)



RepublicanParty Of

India RPI(A)(1)

SamajwadiParty (9)

Shiv Sena(74)

225Councillors

8

1

74 2

12

34

17

3

18

97

4

27

85

14

1

6

16

84

26

66

1 2 2

10

51 1 2

8

32

2 1 2 1 1 1

8

Num

ber

of C

ounc

illor

s (2

25)

Political Party

Party-Wise Grade (2014)

A - 100% to 80% marks B - Less than 80% to 70% marks

C - Less than 70% to 60% marks D - Less than 60% to 50% marks E - Less than 50% to 35% marks F - Less than 35% marks

Score 2013

Akhil Bharatiya

Sena (2)

Bharatiya Janata Party (31)

Bhartiya Republican

Party Bahujan Mahasangha

(1)Independent

(15)


(52)


Sena (28)


Party (13)

Republican Party Of

India RPI(A) (1)

Samajwadi Party

(9)

Shiv Sena (74)

226 Councillors

A 0

B 6 5 1 2 1 13 28

C 15 5 16 11 5 3 26 81

D 1 9 1 4 16 10 5 1 1 24 72

E 1 1 5 15 6 1 3 10 42

F 1 1 1 3

M U N I C I P A L C O U N C I L L O R S 2 0 1 4 141M U M B A I R E P O R T C A R D140

BOTTOM 10 COUNCILLORS

TOP 10 COUNCILLORS

Overall Rank

WardConstituency No.

Political Party Councillors

Score (out of 100) 2013 2014

G/S 194 SS Snehal Suryakant Ambekar 78.46 44 1

G/S 188 SS Hemangi Hareshwar Worlikar 78.43 1 2

P/N 40 BJP Gyanmurti Ramchandra Sharma 77.97 27 3

R/S 21 INC Ramashish Gopal Gupta 76.98 24 4

K/W 60 SS Sanjay Kashinath Pawar 76.38 19 5

R/S 22 BJP Sunita Ramnagina Yadav 75.92 82 6

R/S 23 SS Prajakta Vikas (Sawant)Vishwasrao 75.75 41 7

R/C 9 BJP Manisha Ashok Chaudhari 75.64 2 8

D 210 INC Noshir Rusi Mehta 75.46 7 9

K/W 56 SS Yashodhar Padmakar Phanse 75.41 3 10

Overall Rank



Score (out of 100) 2013 2014

S 116 MNS Avinash Bhaskar Sawant 28.54 144 225

N 118 NCP Harun Yusuf Khan 29.45 216 224

N 128 MNS Mangal Prameshwar Kadam 32.42 200 223

F/S 198 SS Sanjay (Nana) Gajanan Ambole 32.68 180 222

G/N 179 SP Jyotsna Harjivan Parmar 33.19 223 221

P/N 35 INC Bhomsingh Hirsingh Rathod 33.36 95 220

L 155 IND Lalita Annamalai 33.55 221 219

F/N 172 IND Manojkumar Martandrao Sansare 33.59 193 218

K/W 53 IND Changez Jamal Multani 36.56 143 217

G/S 190 MNS Hemlata Vinod Wange 36.89 203 216

0

50

100

150

200

250



(31)

BhartiyaRepublican

PartyBahujan

Mahasangha(1)

Independent(14)

IndianNational

Congress(52)



RepublicanParty Of

India RPI(A)(1)

SamajwadiParty (9)

Shiv Sena(74)

176

76

179

146

119127

120

208

103 109

Ran

k

Political Party

Party-wise Average Rank (2014)

Party

Akhil Bharatiya

Sena (2)

Bharatiya Janata Party

(31)

Bhartiya Republican

Party Bahujan

Mahasangha (1)

Independent (15)


(52)


Sena (28)


Party (13)

Republican Party Of

India RPI(A) (1)

Samajwadi Party

(9)Shiv Sena

(74)

2013 172 90 174 147 124 117 93 171 140 105

M U N I C I P A L C O U N C I L L O R S 2 0 1 4 141


BOTTOM 10 COUNCILLORS IN QUESTIONS ASKED

TOP 10 COUNCILLORS IN QUESTIONS ASKED

Overall Rank



No. of question

asked 2013 2014

K/E 68 SS Anant Bhiku Nar 91 67 62

L 161 NCP Saeeda Arif Khan 85 65 83

P/N 42 MNS Deepak Pandurang Pawar 73 147 67

K/W 56 SS Yashodhar Padmakar Phanse 59 3 10

L 162 SS Anuradha Mahesh Pednekar 51 8 14

R/S 25 INC Ajanta Rajpati Yadav 51 10 29

P/N 40 BJP Gyanmurti Ramchandra Sharma 47 27 3

R/C 9 BJP Manisha Ashok Chaudhari 47 2 8

L 154 MNS Dilip Bhausaheb Lande 47 40 26

M/E 129 SP Reshma Ramesh Nevrekar 46 54 19

Overall Rank



No. of question

asked 2013 2014

P/N 35 INC Bhomsingh Hirsingh Rathod 0 95 220

K/W 53 IND Changez Jamal Multani 0 143 217

K/E 73 INC Kesarben Murji Patel 0 188 212

K/E 77 INC Winnifred Baptist D'souza 0 178 215

S 108 MNS Rupesh Uttam Waingankar 0 90 213

N 128 MNS Mangal Prameshwar Kadam 0 200 223

L 155 IND Lalita Annamalai 0 221 219

G/N 179 SP Jyotsna Harjivan Parmar 0 223 221

G/S 190 MNS Hemlata Vinod Wange 0 203 216

A 226 INC Anita Ramesh Yadav 0 213 210

BOTTOM 10 COUNCILLORS IN ATTENDANCE

TOP 10 COUNCILLORS IN ATTENDANCE

Overall Rank



Score (out of 15) 2013 2014


D 210 INC Noshir Rusi Mehta 15.00 7 9

L 162 SS Anuradha Mahesh Pednekar 15.00 8 14

H/E 88 SS Deepak Ramchandra Bhutkar 15.00 45 23

H/E 89 SS Anil Pandurang Trimbakkar 15.00 130 52

R/S 18 SS Shrikant Krishna Kavathankar 14.89 64 50

K/E 68 SS Anant Bhiku Nar 14.83 67 62

P/N 39 SS Sayali Sunil Warise 14.78 189 165

K/W 60 SS Sanjay Kashinath Pawar 14.73 19 5


Overall Rank



Score (out of 15) 2013 2014

N 128 MNS Mangal Prameshwar Kadam 3.45 200 223

K/E 66 BJP Ujjwala Shrikrushna Modak 3.73 209 199

B 221 INC Dnyanraj Yashvant Nikam 3.77 53 134

L 155 IND Lalita Annamalai 4.03 221 219

S 116 MNS Avinash Bhaskar Sawant 4.29 144 225

E 205 ABS Geeta Ajay Gawli 4.68 157 189


L 153 IND Leena Harish Shukla 5.62 89 100

P/N 35 INC Bhomsingh Hirsingh Rathod 5.98 95 220

E 206 INC Faiyaz Ahmed Khan 6.64 217 211


BOTTOM 10 COUNCILLORS IN PERCEIVED PERFORMANCE

TOP 10 COUNCILLORS IN PERCEIVED PERFORMANCE

Overall Rank



Score (out of 30) 2013 2014

S 110 NCP Dhananjay Sadashiv Pisal 21.14 31 74

F/S 195 INC Sunil Vishnu More 21.12 110 170

T 99 BJP Bhavna Bhavin Jobanputra 21.11 164 28

E 202 MNS Samita Sanjay Naik 21.05 23 86


S 114 SS Vishwas Tukaram Shinde 20.49 210 126

N 123 SS Ashwini Bharat Mate 20.46 28 59

G/N 183 MNS Manish Dattaram Chavan 20.41 196 169

F/S 201 SS Shweta Shyamsunder Rane 20.37 199 181


Overall Rank



Score (out of 30) 2013 2014

R/C 14 BJP Bina Paresh Doshi 14.05 123 60

R/C 16 BJP Pravin Shah 14.22 121 157

R/C 12 BJP Asawari Anil Patil 14.33 102 103

R/C 15 BJP Mohan Ramchandra Mithbaokar 14.43 50 148

R/N 1 SS Abhishek Vinod Ghosalkar 14.44 33 15

E 208 INC Manoj Pandurang Jamsutkar 14.70 51 106

R/C 10 NCP Riddhi Bhaskar Khursange 14.75 86 112

H/E 85 IND Ilyas Bashir Shaikh 14.78 207 173

R/N 4 SS Udesh Shantaram Patekar 14.79 136 149

R/C 17 NCP Sandhya Vipul Doshi 14.90 73 64

BOTTOM 10 COUNCILLORS IN QUALITY OF QUESTIONS ASKED

TOP 10 COUNCILLORS IN QUALITY OF QUESTIONS ASKED

Overall Rank



Score (out of 28) 2013 2014

G/N 184 MNS Sudhir Krushna Jadhav 22.61 29 13

P/S 45 INC Sneha Vinayak Zagade 22.42 87 25

N 121 BJP Ritu Rajesh Tawade 22.28 17 16


R/C 11 MNS Shilpa Shirish Chogle 21.96 76 45

M/W 144 BJP Rajshree Shripat Palande 21.89 161 12

N 124 INC Pravin Velji Chheda 21.85 116 75

A 224 SS Ganesh Yashwant Sanap 21.51 176 68

R/S 24 INC Yogesh Janardan Bhoir 21.19 88 24


Overall Rank



Score (out of 28) 2013 2014

P/N 35 INC Bhomsingh Hirsingh Rathod 0 95 220

K/W 53 IND Changez Jamal Multani 0 143 217


K/E 77 INC Winnifred Baptist D'souza 0 178 215

S 108 MNS Rupesh Uttam Waingankar 0 90 213

N 128 MNS Mangal Prameshwar Kadam 0 200 223

L 155 IND Lalita Annamalai 0 221 219

G/N 179 SP Jyotsna Harjivan Parmar 0 223 221


A 226 INC Anita Ramesh Yadav 0 213 210


TOP 12 COUNCILLORS IN DISCRETIONARY FUND UTILISED (` IN CRORES)

Overall Rank


Political Party Councillors Funds 2013 2014

R/S 21 INC Ramashish Gopal Gupta 1.2 24 4

R/S 23 SS Prajakta Vikas (Sawant)Vishwasrao 1.2 41 7

R/S 26 INC Sagar Singh Thakur 1.2 169 146

R/S 27 BJP Mukeshkumar Mistry 1.2 170 153

K/E 77 INC Winnifred Baptist D'souza 1.2 178 215

H/E 90 INC Priyatama Sharadkumar Sawant 1.2 58 107

N 119 MNS Sanjay Dattatray Bhalerao 1.2 111 117

F/N 165 SS Pranita Prakash Waghdhare 1.2 154 89

F/N 169 SS Shradha Shridhar Jadhav 1.2 20 116

F/N 170 SS Trushna Chandrakant Vishwasrao 1.2 4 49


G/N 182 MNS Virendra Vishnu Tandel 1.2 32 194

BOTTOM 10 COUNCILLORS IN DISCRETIONARY FUND UTILISED (` IN LAKHS)

Overall Rank


Political Party Councillors Funds 2013 2014

D 216 INC Shantilal Chogalal Doshi 84 183 164

K/E 79 SS Shubhada Shashikant Patkar 85 139 161

K/W 64 IND Bhavna Ameet Mangela 87 145 156

K/E 70 MNS Bhalchandra Gangaram Ambure 90 165 99

P/N 36 SS Prashant Dashrath Kadam 92 107 190


K/E 78 SS Manisha Manohar Panchal 92 96 97

M/W 142 INC Seema Rajendra Mahulkar 95 195 191


K/E 67 SS Manjiri Gurunath Parab 96 163 96

BOTTOM 10 COUNCILLORS IN AWARENESS & ACCESSIBILITY

TOP 10 COUNCILLORS IN AWARENESS & ACCESSIBILITY

Overall Rank



Score (out of 5) 2013 2014

N 123 SS Ashwini Bharat Mate 3.63 28 59

N 121 BJP Ritu Rajesh Tawade 3.07 17 16

L 157 SS Manali Mangesh Tulaskar 3.04 36 42

L 162 SS Anuradha Mahesh Pednekar 2.97 8 14

E 202 MNS Samita Sanjay Naik 2.89 23 86

L 150 NCP Savita Sharad Pawar 2.81 118 122

H/E 81 MNS Snehal Suhas Shinde 2.81 211 186

S 106 SS Ramesh Gajanan Korgaonkar 2.79 135 135

T 99 BJP Bhavna Bhavin Jobanputra 2.77 164 28

P/S 49 SS Lochana Chandrakant Chavan 2.71 146 145

Overall Rank



Score (out of 5) 2013 2014

M/E 138 BRPBM Arun Vishvanath Kamble 0.85 174 179

R/S 25 INC Ajanta Rajpati Yadav 0.85 10 29

G/N 179 SP Jyotsna Harjivan Parmar 0.86 223 221

M/E 140 INC Usha Anil Kamble 0.89 138 113



R/S 20 BJP Shailaja Vijay Girkar 0.93 105 54

H/E 85 IND Ilyas Bashir Shaikh 0.93 207 173

F/N 169 SS Shradha Shridhar Jadhav 0.94 20 116

F/N 174 INC Nayna Manhar Sheth 0.98 77 125


keÀe³e&He×leer

1. cetu³eceeHeve ceespeHeÆer

Òepeeves efJeefJeOe #es$eeleerue le%e J³ekeÌleerbMeer efJe®eejefJeefvece³e keÀªve cetu³eceeHeve He×leer efJekeÀefmele kesÀueer Deens. jepekeÀjCe, meceepeefJe%eeve, ceekexÀì jerme®e&, ceeO³eces DeMee efJeefJeOe #es$eeleerue le%e J³ekeÌleeRveer ³ee keÀeceer DeeHeues ³eesieoeve efoues Deens. DeHesef#ele GÎsMe meeO³e nesC³ee®³ee ¢<ìerves mebMeesOevee®eer DeeKeCeer keÀjleevee Heg{erue ÒeMveeb®ee ÒeeOeev³eeves efJe®eej kesÀuee iesuee.

De. keÀesCel³ee efvekeÀ<eebJej veiejmesJekeÀeb®³ee keÀeceefiejer®es cetu³eceeHeve kesÀues Heeefnpes?

ye. Òel³eskeÀ veiejmesJekeÀe®³ee celeoejmebIee®ee Deboepe ³esCes cenÊJee®es; l³ee¢<ìerves mebMeesOevee®eer DeeKeCeer keÀMeer keÀjeJeer DeeefCe vescekeÌ³ee keÀesCel³ee J³ekeÌleerb®³ee cegueeKeleer I³eeJ³eele?

³eeleerue Heefnu³ee ÒeMveemeeþer Demee efJe®eej kesÀuee keÀer; 26 veesJnWyej 1949 ceO³es Yeejleeves DeeHeueer jep³eIeìvee Heeefjle kesÀueer, mJeerkeÀejueer. ³ee mebefJeOeeveele ueeskeÀMeener jep³ekeÀejYeeje®eer efve³eceeJeueer meceeefJe<ì Deens. keWÀê, jep³e DeeefCe mLeeefvekeÀ mJejep³e mebmLee ³ee leervner mlejeJejerue keÀejYeej me#ece Je ueeskeÀeefYecegKe JneJee ³ee¢<ìerves Ieìvesle DeeJeM³ekeÀ les yeoue JesUesJesUer kesÀues iesues Deensle, veJes keÀe³eos mebcele keÀjC³eele Deeues Deensle. IeìveelcekeÀ lejlegoer DeeefCe efJeefJeOe keÀe³eos ³eeÜejs ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeRvee l³eeb®³ee keÀecee®es DeefOekeÀej yeneue keÀjC³eele Deesues Deensle; lemes®e DeefOekeÀejeb®ee iewjJeeHej nesT ve³es ³eemeeþer efveye¥Oe Ieeleuesues Deensle. meJe&®e yeeyeleerle ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeRves keÀmes Demeues Heeefnpes ³ee®eer efJeefMe<ì ®eewkeÀì mebefJeOeeveeves DeeKetve efoueer Deens. l³eecegUs veiejmesJekeÀeb®³ee keÀeceefiejer®es cetu³eceeHeve efvekeÀ<e ns HetCe&leë l³eeb®eer IeìveelcekeÀ YetefcekeÀe, peyeeyeoeN³ee Je l³eemeboYee&le Ieìvesves DeeKetve efouesueer keÀe³e&®eewkeÀì ³ee meboYee&ves le³eej kesÀues Deensle, efJeMes<eleë 73 Je 74 J³ee Ieìveeog©mleerves meceeefJe<ì Peeuesues 12Jes Mes[îetue DeeefCe cegbyeF& ceneveiejHeeefuekeÀe keÀe³eoe, 1888 ³eeb®ee efJe®eej Peeuee.

Hejbleg, Ieìvesvesner peveceleeuee meJeex®®e mLeeve efoues Deens. l³eecegUs ueeskeÀÒeefveOeeRefJe<e³eer veeieefjkeÀeb®es keÀe³e cele Deens ne efvekeÀ<e Del³eble cenÊJee®ee Je DeeJeM³ekeÀ Deens. l³eecegUs ogmeN³ee ÒeMvee®es GÊej efceUefJeC³eemeeþer ueeskeÀeb®es DeeHeu³ee celeoejmebIeeleerue ueeskeÀÒeefveOeer®³ee (veiejmesJekeÀe®³ee) keÀeceeefJe<e³eer®es cele peeCetve IesCes DeeJeM³ekeÀ Deens.

³eeHeg{erue Yeeieele ³ee DeY³eemee®eer j®ee keÀMeer kesÀueer DeeefCe Dev³e cenÊJeHetCe& leHeMeerue efoues Deensle. HeCe les peeCetve IesC³eeDeeOeer ³ee DeY³eemee®es þUkeÀ ceeefnleer ñeesle keÀesCeles nesles DeeefCe l³eeb®ee cetu³eceeHeve keÀmee JeeHej kesÀuee iesuee ns mecepetve IesCes DeeJeM³ekeÀ Deens.

Menjeleerue Òel³eskeÀ veiejmesJekeÀe®eer keÀeceefiejer leHeemeC³eemeeþer Heg{erue ceeefnleer DemeCes DeeJeM³ekeÀ Deens ë

1. keÀener efvekeÀ<e ceespelee ³esC³eemeejKes Deensle, GoenjCeeLe&, veiejmesJekeÀeb®eer ceneveiejHeeefuekesÀleerue Je meefceleer yewþkeÀeb®eer GHeefmLeleer, ³ee oesvner efþkeÀeCeer l³eebveer efJe®eejuesu³ee ÒeMveeb®eer mebK³ee, ³ee ÒeMveeb®es cenÊJe DeeefCe ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeerves kesÀuesu³ee efveOeer®ee efJeefve³eesie.

RANKS OF PARTY HEAD/COMMITTEE CHAIRPERSON

Score (out of 100) Overall Rank

WardConstituency No. Party Councillors

Party Head/Committee Chairperson 2013 2014 2013 2014

R/C 9 BJP Manisha Ashok Chaudhari R/N and R/C Ward Committee 77.03 75.64 2 8

K/W 56 SS Yashodhar Padmakar Phanse SS Party Head 75.48 75.41 3 10

F/N 167 BJP Rajeshree Rajesh Shirwadkar Women and Child Welfare Committee

59.66 72.83 113 21

M/E 132 SP Rais Kasam Shaikh SP Party Head 54.79 71.94 152 27

R/S 25 INC Ajanta Rajpati Yadav R/S Ward Committee 73.13 71.59 10 29

P/S 46 SS Varsha Swapnil Tembvalkar P/S Ward Committee 74.08 70.41 6 31

M/W 147 INC Anil Ramchandra Patankar M/W Ward Committee 58.46 70.23 128 32

K/W 63 BJP Dilip Ghanshyam Patel BJP Party Head 71.75 69.77 18 36

G/S 193 NCP Sunil Mohan Ahir G/S Ward Committee 71.04 69.72 21 37

H/E 87 BJP Krishna (Mahesh) Dhondu Parkar Works Committee (Suburbs) 60.64 69.25 99 41

L 164 IND Vijay Pandharinath Tandel L Ward Committee 67.89 68.51 43 48

F/N 170 SS Trushna Chandrakant Vishwasrao

F/S and F/N Ward Committee 74.85 68.39 4 49

K/W 62 BJP Ameet Bhaskar Satam K/W Ward Committee 70.51 67.23 25 61

S 110 NCP Dhananjay Sadashiv Pisal NCP Party Head 69.36 65.73 31 74

K/E 74 SS Pramod Pandurang Sawant K/E Ward Committee 62.20 64.85 94 78

T 103 BJP Manoj Kishorbhai Kotak Education Committee 64.89 63.46 68 88

P/N 33 BJP Ramnarayan Amtharam Barot Improvements Committee 68.44 63.23 38 91

B 222 INC Waqarunnisa Ansari A, B and E Ward Committee 63.95 61.70 74 102

D 211 SS Arvind (Arun) Devji Dudhwadkar C and D Ward Committee 33.19 61.49 225 105

N 119 MNS Sanjay Dattatray Bhalerao N Ward Committee 59.99 60.52 111 117

A 227 IND Makarand Suresh Narvekar Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee

66.41 59.46 57 121

G/N 185 MNS Sandeep (Yashwant) Sudhakar Deshpande

MNS Party Head 58.90 58.33 120 128

T 100 NCP Nandkumar Atmaram Vaity S and T Ward Committee 70.46 55.81 26 147

K/W 57 INC Devendra Shridhar Amberkar INC Party Head 49.38 54.96 185 152

M/E 134 SS Rahul Ramesh Shevale Standing Committee 61.55 53.83 97 160

G/S 191 SS Kishori Kishor Pednekar Works Committee (City) 57.75 53.22 132 163

M/E 138 BRPBM Arun Vishvanath Kamble M/E Ward Committee 51.09 51.40 174 179

P/N 32 SS Anagha Prakash Mhatre P/N Ward Committee 59.53 50.60 114 182

H/E 81 MNS Snehal Suhas Shinde H/E and H/W Ward Committee 41.38 49.89 211 186

E 205 ABS Geeta Ajay Gawli Public Health Committee 53.97 49.44 157 189

G/N 182 MNS Virendra Vishnu Tandel G/N Ward Committee 69.33 48.14 32 194

G/N 175 RPI (A) Sabreddy Mallesh Bora Markets and Gardens Committee

51.49 43.54 171 208

F/S 198 SS Sanjay Gajanan Ambole BEST Committee 50.29 32.68 180 222


2. ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeer®eer Jew³eefkeÌlekeÀ Heeée&Yetefce; ³eeceO³es Mew#eefCekeÀ Hee$elee, Dee³ekeÀj efJeJejCe He$es, iegvnsieejer Heeée&Yetefce Demeu³eeme l³eeefJe<e³eer®eer DeÐe³eeJele ceeefnleer.

3. ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeerb®³ee celeoejmebIeeleerue veeieefjkeÀeb®eer celes, l³eeb®³eeefJe<e³eer®eer ceeefnleer, keÀeceeefJe<e³eer®es meceeOeeve DeeefCe veiejmesJekeÀecegUs veeieefjkeÀeb®es peerJeveceeve Gb®eeJeues Deens keÀe ³ee efJe<e³ee®eer celes.

keÀesCekeÀesCel³ee iees<ìeR®eer ceeefnleer I³ee³e®eer ns efveef½ele Peeu³eeJej leer keÀMee ÒekeÀejs efceUJee³e®eer ³ee®ee cnCepes®e keÀe³e&He×leer®ee efJe®eej keÀjC³eele Deeuee. Jejerue cegÐeebHewkeÀer 1 Je 2 ¬eÀceebkeÀe®³ee ceeefnleermeeþer ceeefnleer DeefOekeÀej keÀe³eoe JeeHejC³eele Deeuee Je GHeueyOe ceeefnleer®ee DeY³eeme kesÀuee iesuee. veiejmesJekeÀeb®es iegCeebkeÀve keÀjleevee keÀceeue iegCe 100 Deensle. ceespelee ³esC³eepeesi³ee efvekeÀ<eebJej 70… Yej efouee Deens. 3 ¬eÀceebkeÀeleerue ceeefnleermeeþer Òel³eskeÀ celeoejmebIeeleerue veeieefjkeÀeb®ee meJnx Iesleuee DeeefCe l³eeb®eer l³eeb®³ee ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeerefJe<e³eer®eer celes peeCetve Iesleueer. veiejmesJekeÀe®³ee keÀeceefiejerefJe<e³eer ueeskeÀeb®eer celes, ¢<ìerkeÀesve ³eeJej 30… Yej efouee iesuee.

¬eÀceebkeÀ 1 Je 2 meeþer Heg{erue mejkeÀejer ñeesleeletve ceeefnleer efceUJeueer.

De. efveJe[CetkeÀ Dee³eesie keÀe³ee&ue³e, ye=.cegb.ce.Hee.

ye. ceeefnleer DeefOekeÀejemeeueer, ceneHeeefuekeÀe meef®eJe, ye=.cegb.ce.Hee. (ye=.cegb.ce.Hee. cegK³e keÀe³ee&ue³e DeeefCe yesmì).

keÀ. ceeefnleer DeefOekeÀejeKeeueer, meene³³ekeÀ DeefYe³eblee (Heefjj#eCe), ye=.cegb.ce.Hee. (ye=.cegb.ce.Hee. ®³ee meJe& 24 Jee[&ceOetve).

* ceeefnleer DeefOekeÀejeKeeueer, cegbyeF& Heesefueme keÀe³ee&ue³ekeÀ[tve ceeefnleer.

¬eÀceebkeÀ 3 ®³ee ceeefnleermeeþer cegbyeF& Menje®³ee efJeefJeOe Yeeieeleerue 22,580 ueeskeÀeb®eer meJnxÜejs cele®ee®eCeer kesÀueer. nbmee ceekexÀì efjme®e&ves ÒeMveeJeueerÜeje ne meJnx Iesleuee.

cetu³eceeHevee®eer He×leer Jemlegefve<þ Deens ns ue#eele IesCes iejpes®es Deens. ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeerb®ee jepekeÀer³e He#e efkebÀJee l³eeb®eer Jew³eefkeÌlekeÀ / jepekeÀer³e efJe®eejmejCeer ³eebvee cenÊJe efoues iesues veener.

jepekeÀejCee®es PeHeeìîeeves iegvnerieejerkeÀjCe nesle Deens. les JesUer®e jesKeues veener lej DeeHeu³ee osMeeleerue ueeskeÀMeener J³eJemLes®ee Hee³ee®e efKeUefKeUe nesC³ee®eer MekeÌ³elee Deens. l³eecegUs ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeerb®eer iegvnsieejer efJe<e³ekeÀ Heeée&Yetceer peeCetve IesC³ee®ee DeeJepet&ve Òe³elve kesÀuee Deens DeeefCe l³eeceO³es Heg{erue iees<ìeR®ee meceeJesMe Deens ö efveJe[CetkeÀ MeHeLeHe$eele efouesu³ee l³eeb®³eeJejerue SHeÀDee³eDeej Peeuesu³ee kesÀmesme; efveJe[tve Deeu³eeveblej oeKeue Peeuesu³ee iegvnsieejer kesÀmesme DeeefCe cenÊJee®es Òeuebefyele leHeemeeOeerve iegvns.

lekeÌlee 1ë veiejmesJekeÀeb®³ee keÀeceefiejer®eer ceespeHeÆer

¬eÀ. efvekeÀ<e keÀceeue …

efìHeCCeer

1 Jele&ceeve

De ceneHeeefuekeÀe DeeefCe meefceleer yewþkeÀebvee GHeefmLeleer

15 DeefOekeÀ leceMeerueebmeeþer Heeve ¬eÀ. 153 Jejerue 3De Hene.

ye efJe®eejuesu³ee ÒeMveeb®eer mebK³ee 15 15 ner keÀceeue Je 1 ner efkeÀceeve ìkeÌkesÀJeejer.

keÀ ÒeMveebletve Gþuesueer mecem³ee, efJe<e³e ³eeDevegMebieeves l³ee®es cenÊJe

18 DeefOekeÀ leHeMeerueemeeþer Heeve ¬eÀ. 155 Jejerue 3keÀ Hene.

[ veeieefjkeÀeb®³ee le¬eÀejeR®³ee leguevesle ceeb[uesu³ee mecem³eeb®es ÒeceeCe

10 DeefOekeÀ leHeMeerueebmeeþer Heeve ¬eÀ. 155 Jejerue 3[ Hene.

F SefÒeue 2012 les cee®e& 2014 ojc³eeve yeeHejuesuee SketÀCe veiejmesJekeÀ efveOeer

5 DeefOekeÀ leHeMeerueebmeeþer Heeve ¬eÀ. 156 Jejerue 3F Hene.

SketÀCe 63

2 YetlekeÀeU

De Mew#eefCekeÀ Hee$elee 1 ‰fkeÀceeve oneJeer Heeme - 1; Dev³eLee - 0

ye Dee³ekeÀj 1 He@vekeÀe[& Deens - 1; Dev³eLee - 0

keÀ iegvnsieejer Heeée&Yetceer 5 pej GcesoJeejeJej Metv³e kesÀmesme Demeleerue lej Dev³eLee Heg{erueÒeceeCes ë

1. Ketve, yeueelkeÀej, ís[íe[, obieue, Keb[Ceer ³eeKesjerpe iegvnsieejer kesÀmesme - 3

2. Dev³eLee - 0

SketÀCe 7

3 celes/¢ef<ìkeÀesve cegbyeF& Menje®³ee efJeefJeOe celeoejmebIeeleerue 22,580 ueeskeÀeb®³ee pevecele ®ee®eCeerJej DeeOeeefjle ceeefnleer

De ueeskeÀeb®³ee vepejsletve keÀeceefiejer 11 meeJe&peefvekeÀ mesJeebefJe<e³eer®es iegCe

ye ceeefnleer Je Heesnes®e 5 DeeHeu³ee ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeer Je l³ee®³ee/efle®³ee jepekeÀer³e He#eeefJe<e³eer ueeskeÀebceOeerue peeieªkeÀlee Je l³ee®eer Heesnes®e ³eeefJe<e³eer®es iegCe

keÀ Ye´<ìe®eejefJe<e³ekeÀ 7 ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeer®³ee Ye´<ìe®eejefJe<e³eer®es cele/mecepe ³eeJej DeeOeeefjle iegCe

[ meJe&meeOeejCe GHee³e³eespevee 7 SkebÀoj peerJeveceeve Gb®eeJeC³eele ³eesieoeve Je meceeOeevekeÀejkeÀ keÀeceefiejer ³eeDevegMebieeves iegCe

SketÀCe 30

4 Je<e&Yejele oeKeue Peeuesu³ee veJ³ee iegvnsieejer kesÀmesmemeeþer vekeÀejelcekeÀ iegCeebkeÀve

-5 Je<e&Yejele oeKeue Peeuesu³ee Òel³eskeÀ SHeÀDee³eDeejmeeþer

5 iegvnsieejer DeejesHe$eebmeeþervekeÀejelcekeÀ iegCeebkeÀve

-5 oeKeue Peeuesu³ee Òel³eskeÀ iegvnsieejer DeejesHeHe$eemeeþer


lekeÌlee 1ë veiejmesJekeÀeb®³ee keÀeceefiejer®eer ceespeHeÆer

¬eÀ. efvekeÀ<e keÀceeue …

efìHeCCeer

6 ceeueceÊee efJeJejCe DeeefCe iegvnsieejerefJe<e³ekeÀ ojJe<eea mJeleëntve ceeefnleerpeenerj ve kesÀu³eeme vekeÀejelcekeÀ iegCeebkeÀve (*)

-5 DeeHeueer JesyemeeF&ì, Jele&ceeveHe$es, Òepee JesyemeeF&ì ³eeJeªve Jee Dev³e ceeO³eceeletve ner ceeefnleer peenerj keÀjlee ³esF&ue. lemes®e ³ee ceeO³eceeletve ®egkeÀer®eer ceeefnleer Ieesef<ele kesÀu³ee iegCe keÀeHeues peeleerue.

SketÀCe 100

(*) mJeleëntve peenerj kesÀuesu³ee ceeefnleermebyebOeer vekeÀejelcekeÀ iegCeebkeÀvee®ee DeJeuebye ³ee Je<eea keÀjC³eele Deeuesuee veener. leLeeefHe ns Òeieleer HegmlekeÀ ueeskeÀÒeefleOeeR®³ee HeejoMe&keÀles®ee HegjmkeÀej keÀjCeejs Demeu³eeves l³eebveer ojJe<eea DeeHeues ceeueceÊes®es leHeMeerue mJeleëntve peenerj keÀjCes DeHesef#ele Deens. lemes®e ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeR®eer Òeeflecee mJe®í Demeueer Heeefnpes Je l³eekeÀefjlee l³eebveer iegvnsieejer kesÀmesmemebyebOeer®es DeÐe³eeJele leHeMeerue ojJe<eea

mJeleëntve meeoj kesÀues Heeefnpesle.

2. De@HeÀer[sJnerì Üejs peenerj kesÀuesueer ceeieerue (YetlekeÀeueerve) ceeefnleer

efveJe[CegkeÀer®³ee JesUer De@efHeÀ[sJnerìÜejs peer ceeefnleer efoueer peeles leer cnCepes veiejmesJekeÀe®es efMe#eCe, iegvnsieejer Heeée&Yetceer Je efJeÊeer³e ceeefnleer ³eeb®ee ³eeceO³es meceeJesMe Deens. SketÀCe 100 HewkeÀer 7 ceeke&À ³ee IeìkeÀebmeeþer efouesues Deensle.

De. efMe#eCe

pej ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeerves oneJeer Heeme efkebÀJee l³eeHeg{erue Mew#eefCekeÀ Hee$elee veceto kesÀueer Demesue lej 1 iegCe Dev³eLee 0 iegCe efoues Deensle. SkeÀefJemeeJ³ee MelekeÀeleerue SkeÀ efJekeÀmeveMeerue osMe ³ee veel³eeves DeeHeu³ee veeieefjkeÀeb®es efMe#eCe ne ceeveJeer efJekeÀemee®ee SkeÀ ÒecegKe efvekeÀ<e Deens. mejkeÀejer mesJesleerue efvecve peeiesJej Yejleer nesC³eemeeþerner efkeÀceeve Mew#eefCekeÀ Hee$elee DemeeJeer ueeieles. l³eeÒeceeCes®e Deelee DeeHeu³ee ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeRmeeþerner efkeÀceeve Mew#eefCekeÀ Hee$eles®ee Deeûen OejCes DeeJeM³ekeÀ Deens. Hejbleg veiejmesJekeÀeb®eer keÀeceefiejer ceespeC³eemeeþer®³ee SketÀCe IeìkeÀeb®³ee leguevesle ³ee IeìkeÀeuee keÀceerle keÀceer Jepeve efoues peeJes Demesner Deecneuee Jeeìles.

ye. Dee³ekeÀj

Yeejleele efveJe[tve ³esCeeN³ee ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeR®es GlHeVe l³eeb®³ee keÀe³e&keÀeueele DeveskeÀ HeìeRveer Jee{les DeMeer ueeskeÀeb®eer OeejCee Deens DeeefCe ³eeuee Heg<ìer osCeejer ceeefnleer DeveskeÀoe peenerj Peeuesueer Deens. De@HeÀer[sJnerìvegmeej He@ve keÀe[& Demeu³eeme 1 iegCe Je vemeu³eeme 0 iegCe efoues Deensle.

keÀ. iegvnsieejer Heeée&Yetceer

jepekeÀejCee®es iegvnsieejerkeÀjCe ns SkeÀ ogëKeo JeemleJe Deens. yeN³ee®e ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeR®eer iegvnsieejer Heeée&Yetceer Demeu³ee®es efveoMe&veeme ³esle Deens. cnCepes®e; 1) l³eeb®³eeJej SHeÀDee³eDeej veeWoJeues Deens; 2) DeejesHeHe$e oeKeue Peeues Deens; DeeefCe 3) keÀesìe&ves efMe#ee peenerj kesÀueer Deens.

meeJe&peefvekeÀ Dee³eg<³eele DemeCeeN³ee J³ekeÌleeR®es ®eeefj$³e mJe®í Demeues Heeefnpes. l³eecegUs DeeHeues ÒeefleefveefOelJe keÀjCeeN³ee J³ekeÌleer iegvnsieejer Heeée&Yetceer®³ee Demelee keÀecee ve³esle ns þjJeC³ee®ee, ceeb[C³ee®ee DeefOekeÀej veeieefjkeÀebvee Deens. l³eecegUs veiejmesJekeÀeb®es iegCe þjJeleevee ner ceeefnleer peeCetve Iesleueer Deens.

1. GcesoJeejeJej Metv³e kesÀmesme Demeleerue lej 5 iegCe

2. Ketve, yeueelkeÀej, ís[íe[, obieue, Keb[Ceer DeMee iegv¿eebKeeueer SHeÀDee³eDeej oeKeue Peeues Demeu³eeme - 0 iegCe

3. Jejerue ¬eÀceebkeÀ 2 Kesjerpe Flej keÀejCeebmeeþer SHeÀDee³eDeej oeKeue Peeues Demeu³eeme - 3 iegCe

Heg{s cegÐee ¬eÀceebkeÀ 5 ceO³es efJe<eo kesÀu³eeÒeceeCes iegvnsieejer Heeée&YetceermeboYee&le vekeÀejelcekeÀ iegCeebkeÀvener efoues iesues Deens.

SkeÀ ue#eele Iesleues Heeefnpes keÀer, Òel³eskeÀ J³ekeÌleermeeþer ns iegCeebkeÀve keÀjCes iegbleeiegbleer®es þjues Demeles, l³eecegUs ÒeLece kesÀmesme®es JeieeakeÀjCe keÀªve l³ee®es iegCeebkeÀve keÀjCes DeefOekeÀ meb³egefkeÌlekeÀ Deens.

3. ceneveiejHeeefuekeÀe DeeefCe meefceleer yewþkeÀeleerue keÀeceefiejer mebyebOeer cetu³eeceeHeve IeìkeÀ

Yeejle ne ÒeeefleefveOeerkeÀ ueeskeÀMeener®ee osMe Deens. ³eeceO³es veeieefjkeÀ DeeHeues ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeer efveJe[leele DeeefCe ns ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeer ueeskeÀeb®³ee Jeleerves meYeeie=nele keÀece keÀjleele, veeieefjkeÀeb®³ee ÒeMveebJej efJe®eejefJeefvece³e keÀjleele, l³eemeeþer IeìveelcekeÀ ceeie&oMe&ve Je ³eb$eCee ³eeb®³ee DeeOeejs DeeJeM³ekeÀ keÀe³eos keÀjleele. cnCepes efJe®eejefJeefvece³e ns ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeR®³ee keÀeceefiejer®ee SkeÀ cenÊJee®ee IeìkeÀ Demetve l³eeJej ceeHeveele DeefOekeÀ Yej osC³ee®eer iejpe Deens.

De. GHeefmLeleer

ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeRveer mebyebefOele meYeeie=nebceO³es GHeefmLele jeneJes Je keÀecekeÀepe keÀjeJes ³eemeeþer veeieefjkeÀ l³eebvee efveJe[tve osleele. l³eecegUs ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeRveer 100… efkebÀJee l³ee®³ee peJeUHeeme keÀeueeJeOeer meYeeie=nele GHeefmLele DemeCes Del³eeJeM³ekeÀ Deens. l³eecegUs GHeefmLeleer®³ee ìkeÌkesÀJeejerJej iegCeebkeÀve Deens ë 100… GHeefmLeleer cnCepes 15 iegCe DeeefCe 0… cnCepes 0 ]iegCe.

ye=.cegb.ce.Hee. ceO³es Òel³eskeÀ veiejmesJekeÀ ne ceneveiejHeeefuekesÀ®ee meom³e Demelees lemes®e Jee[& meefcel³eeb®ee meom³e Demelees. ³eeefMeJee³e keÀener veiejmesJekeÀ ns Heg{erÒeceeCes efJeefMe<ì keÀe³e& meefcel³eeb®es meom³e Demeleele.

1. mLee³eer meefceleer

2. yesmì meefceleer

3. mLeeHel³e (Menj) meefceleer

4. mLeeHel³e (GHeveiejs) meefceleer

5. megOeej meefceleer

6. efMe#eCe meefceleer


7. meeJe&peefvekeÀ Deejesi³e meefceleer

8. ceefnuee yeeue keÀu³eeCe meefceleer

9. efJeefOe meefceleer

10. Je=#e ÒeeefOekeÀjCe meefceleer

11. yeepeej Je GÐeeve meefceleer

DeMee ÒekeÀejs, veiejmesJekeÀebceO³es ¿ee oesve ke@Àìsiejer Demetve l³eebvee 15 iegCee®es efJelejCe keÀjleevee JesieJesieÈ³ee He×leerves efJe®eej kesÀuee iesuee Heeefnpes.

GHeefmLeleer

veiejmesJekeÀ ceneveiejHeeefuekeÀe meJe&meeOeejCe meYee

yewþkeÀe

Jee@[& meefceleer yewþkeÀe

efJeefJeOe meefcel³eeb®³ee (JejerueÒeceeCes)

SketÀCe

ke@Àìsiejer De 9 6 ueeiet veener. 15

ke@Àìsiejer ye 7 4 4 15

ye. ÒeMveeb®eer mebK³ee

SKeeÐee veiejmesJekeÀeves vescekesÀ efkeÀleer ÒeMve efJe®eejues Heeefnpesle efkebÀJee efJe<e³eeJej ÒeMve efJe®eejues Heeefnpesle ³ee®es keÀener efveef½ele ceeHeob[ veenerle. DeeHeu³ee osMeeleerue SketÀCe HeefjefmLeleer DeeefCe ÒeMveeb®eer iegbleeiegble ue#eele Ieslee veiejmesJekeÀeves veeieefjkeÀeb®³ee iejpeebvee DevegMebietve MekeÌ³e eflelekesÀ peemle ÒeMve GþJeCes DeeJeM³ekeÀ Deens. ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeRvee DeefOekeÀeefOekeÀ ÒeMve efJe®eejC³eeme ÒeJe=Êe keÀjC³ee®³ee nsletves iegCeebkeÀveeceO³es ìkeÌkesÀJeejer®ee JeeHej kesÀuee Deens.

ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeRvee meYeeie=nele efJe®eejuesu³ee ÒeMveebceO³es Heg{erue ÒekeÀej®es ÒeMve efJe®eejele Iesleues Deensle ë

• keÀe³e&¬eÀce Heef$ekeÀe

• njkeÀleer®es cegÐes

• DeuHeeJeOeer met®evee

• 66(De) DevJe³es oerIe& mJeªHee®es ÒeMve (Interpellation)

• 66(ye) Je 66(keÀ) Debleie&le efJe®eejCee kesÀuesues ÒeMve

• þjeJeeb®³ee met®evee

• meYesle ceeb[uesues ÒemleeJe

• leele[er®es keÀecekeÀepe

• mLeieerefle®ee þjeJe

• ®e®ee& DeLeJee meYee mLeieerefle®ee ÒemleeJe Je ÒemleeefJele megOeej

• GHemet®evee

³ee efJeYeeieele meJee&efOekeÀ ÒeMve efJe®eejCeeN³ee ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeruee keÀceeue 15 iegCe efceUt MekeÀleele. ûegHe HejmeWìspe jBkeÀ ÒeceeCes ns iegCeebkeÀve kesÀues Deens.

ìkeÌkesÀJeejerle 15 ns keÀceeue iegCe Deensle DeeefCe 0 ns efkeÀceeve iegCe Deensle.

keÀ. ÒeMveebletve Gþuesueer mecem³ee, efJe<e³e ³eeDeveg<ebieeves l³ee®es cenÊJe

ceneHeeefuekesÀ®eer keÀle&J³es þeceHeCes cegbyeF& ceneveiejHeeefuekeÀe DeefOeefve³ece,1888 ceO³es vecetve kesÀueer iesueer Deensle. Heg{s ner keÀle&J³es oesve Jeiee&le DeLee&led DeeJeM³ekeÀ keÀle&J³es (keÀuece 61, 62) Je mJes®íeOeerve keÀle&J³es (keÀuece 63) efJeYeeieueer iesueer Deensle. DeeJeM³ekeÀ keÀle&J³eeb®³ee Debleie&le jmles, HeeCeer HegjJeþe, ceueefveëmeejCe, Fceejleer, DeeHeelkeÀeueerve J³eJemLeeHeve, ceneHeeefuekeÀe ceeueceÊee, ÒeeLeefcekeÀ efMe#eCe, Deejesi³e, jml³ee®eb Hegvevee&veecekeÀjCe F. yeeyeer cees[leele. lemes®e mJes®íeOeerve keÀle&J³eebceO³es PeesHe[HeÆer efJekeÀeme, Kegu³ee peeiee, GÐeeveW, ceeie& HeefjJenve, Tpee&, Jeerpe, peueeMe³es (OejCe, efmeb®eve) meceepe YeJeve/cebefoj F. yeeyeer cees[leele.

Jele&ceeve ceeHeob[eÒeceeCes DeecneR keÀener DeeJeM³ekeÀ mesJee ng[ketÀve keÀe{u³ee Deensle p³ee cetueleë veeieefjkeÀ mJeªHee®³ee Deensle Je p³eeb®³eeJej ye=nvcegbyeF& ceneveiejHeeefuekesÀ®ee, ¿ee mesJee cegbyeF&®³ee veeieefjkeÀebHe³e¥le Heesnes®eefJeC³eemeeþer, SkeÀeefOekeÀej Deens. ¿ee mesJeebJej G®eueu³ee peeCeeN³eeyeeyeer ceueefveëmeejCe jmles, HeeCeer HegjJeþe, IevekeÀ®eje J³eJemLeeHeve F. efJe<e³eebMeer efveie[erle Deensle. ¿ee cegÐeebJ³eefleefjkeÌle, veiejmesJekeÀ les efJe<e³ener ceeb[t MekeÀleele pes ceneHeeefuekeÀ®³ee Òel³e#e #es$eele veenerle HeCe jep³e Je keWÀê Meemevee®³ee DeKel³eeefjle Deensle. pemes, iegvns, Hejje<ì^ J³eJenej, ke=Àef<e, HeMeg mebJeOe&ve, cegbyeF& ceneveiej #es$e efJekeÀeme ÒeeefOekeÀjCe F.

GHejeskeÌleuuesefKele JeieeakeÀjCeebJej DeeOeeªve ÒeMveeb®³ee iegCeJeÊee/cenÊJeeuee Keeueerue ÒeceeCes Yeej Je Òel³eskeÀer SkegÀCe 100 HewkeÀer iegCe efoues iesues Deens ëö

cegÐes/keÀle&J³es DeeJeM³ekeÀ mJes®íeOeerve veeieefjkeÀDeeJeM³ekeÀ

jep³e/keWÀê SkegÀCe

iegCe 8 6 3 1 18

* veeieefjkeÀeb®³ee le¬eÀejeR®³ee leguevesle ceeb[uesu³ee mecem³eeb®es ÒeceeCe

ye=nvedcegbyeF& ceneveiejHeeefuekesÀves veeieefjkeÀeb®³ee le¬eÀejer ng[ketÀve keÀe{C³eemeeþer Je veeWoJeC³eemeeþer SkeÀ He×efle efJekeÀefmele kesÀueer Deens. ¿ee le¬eÀejeR®ee jKejKeeJe keWÀêerke=Àle le¬eÀej veeWoCeer ³eb$eCes®³ee (meermeerDeejSme) Debleie&le kesÀuee peelees. l³eeb®eer veeWoCeer SkeÀ mee@HeÌìJes³ej J³eemeHeerþele kesÀueer peeles efpeLes l³eeb®eb JeieeakeÀjCe efJeefYeVe ÒeJeiee&le le¬eÀejer®³ee efJeYeeie Je mJeªHee®³ee DeeOeejeJej, [eme, ceueefveëmeejCe, jmles, HeeCeer HegjJeþe Jemeenle DeefOekeÀejer, Fceejle Fl³eeefo, kesÀuee peelees. ueeskeÀ ÒeefleefveefOe Demeu³eeves DeMeer DeeMee kesÀueer peeles keÀer veiejmesJekeÀ veeieefjkeÀeb®³ee le¬eÀejeR®³ee efveJeejCeemeeþer ÒeMve efJe®eejleerue efkebÀJee cegÎs ceeb[leerue. cnCetve meoj ceeHeob[ veiejmesJekeÀebveer ceeb[uesu³ee cegÐeebMeer veeieefjkeÀeb®³ee le¬eÀejeR®eer Je keWÀêerke=Àle le¬eÀej veeWoCeer ³eb$eCeeÜejs DeefYeuesefKele DeekeÀ[îeeb®eer kesÀuesu³ee letueveebJej DeeOeeefjle Deens. ¿ee ceeHeob[eKeeueer cees[Ceejs ye=nvedcegbyeF& ceneveiejHeeefuekesÀ®es efJeYeeie Keeueerue ÒeceeCes Deensle. Fceejleer Jemeenle DeefOekeÀejer, ceueefveëmeejCe, ceeueceÊee, GÐeeve, HejJeevee, ye=nvedcegbyeF& ceneveiejHeeefuekeÀe efJe<e³ekeÀ, keÀer[ efve³eb$eCe, jmles, ogkeÀeves Je DeemLeeHevee (Sme Je F&), IevekeÀ®eje J³eJemLeeHeve (Sme[yu³etSce), Hepe&v³e peueJeeefnveer, Meew®eeue³e Je HeeCeer HegjJeþe. ceeefnleer®³ee DeefOekeÀeje®³ee Debleie&le efceUefJeuesu³ee.


F. SefÒeue 2012 les cee®e& 2014 keÀeueeJeOeerle veiejmesJekeÀ efveOeer®ee JeeHej

veiejmesJekeÀebvee Òel³eskeÀ DeeefLe&keÀ Je<ee&le 60 ueeKe ªHe³es efveOeer efceUlees. DeeHeu³ee celeoejmebIeeleerue keÀesCel³ee efJeefMe<ì keÀeceemeeþer ne efveOeer JeeHeje³e®ee ³ee®ee les efveCe&³e IesT MekeÀleele. efve³eesefpele ìHHeele efveOeer Ke®e& keÀªve l³ee®ee DeefOekeÀeefOekeÀ ueeYe keÀªve IesCes DeHesef#ele Deens. l³eecegUs keÀceeue 1 keÀesìer 20 ueeKe ªHe³es Je<e& 2012 les 2014 ³ee DeeefLe&keÀ Je<ee&le ÒeeHle efveOeerHewkeÀer efkeÀleer ìkeÌkesÀ®ee JeeHej kesÀuee l³eeJej ns iegCeebkeÀve DeeOeeefjle Deens ë 1) 100… (Jee DeefOekeÀ) les 91… - 5; 2) 90… les 76… - 4; 3) 75… les 61… - 3; 4) 60… les 51… - 2 DeeefCe 2) 50… Hes#ee keÀceer - 0

4. pevecele ®ee®eCeervegmeej ueeskeÀeb®eer celes/¢<ìerkeÀesve

ueeskeÀeb®³ee vepejsletve ueeskeÀÒeefveOeeR®eer keÀeceefiejer ³eemeeþer SketÀCe 40 iegCe osC³eele Deeues. keÀeceefiejer®es leHeMeerueJeej cetu³eebkeÀve keÀjlee ³eeJes ³eemeeþer JesieJesieÈ³ee ÒekeÀejs ³ee iegCeeb®eer 4 Yeeieele efJeYeeieCeer kesÀueer, leer Heg{erueÒeceeCes ë

DeeHeu³ee Yeeieeleerue meeJe&peefvekeÀ mesJeemegefJeOeebefJe<e³eer ueeskeÀeb®eer celes ³eeJej meJee&efOekeÀ Yej efouee, ³eeuee 11 iegCe efoues.

veiejmesJekeÀeefJe<e³eer ceeefnleer, peeieªkeÀlee Je Heesnes®e ³eeuee SketÀCe 5 iegCe efoues.

Ye´<ìeefJe<e³ekeÀ celeebvee 7 iegCe efoues.

meJe&meeOeejCe GHee³e³eespevee ³ee IeìkeÀeuee 7 iegCe efoues.

³eeÒekeÀejs iegCeeb®eer efJeYeeieCeer keÀjleevee meeJe&peefvekeÀ mesJeemegefJeOee DeeefCe Ye´<ìe®eejcegkeÌle keÀe³e&He×leer ³ee cegÐeebvee Flej oesve cegÐeeb®³ee leguevesle DeefOekeÀ cenÊJe osC³ee®ee nslet Deens. ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeer l³eeb®³ee efJeefJeOe ÒekeÀej®³ee keÀeceecegUs ueeskeÀefÒe³e Demet MekeÀleele Jee l³eeb®³eeefJe<e³eer ®eebieues cele Demet MekeÀles. meJe&meeOeejCe cele ®eebieues Demeues lejer keÀeceefiejer mecepetve IesC³eemeeþer DeefOekeÀ yeejkeÀeF&ves efJe®eej nesC³ee®eer iejpe Deens. cnCetve ³ee ®eej ÒekeÀejele ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeerefJe<e³eer®es pevecele mecepetve IesC³eele Deeuee.

meeJe&peefvekeÀ mesJeemegefJeOeebefJe<e³eer ueeskeÀeb®es cele DeefOekeÀ Keesueele Je vescekesÀHeCeeves mecepetve ³esC³eemeeþer ³ee efJeYeeieelener leerve mlej keÀjC³eele Deeues. ³eeHewkeÀer Heefnu³ee mlejele ÒeecegK³eeves jep³e mejkeÀejMeer mebyebefOele mesJeemegefJeOee meceeefJe<ì Deensle, lej ®eewL³ee mlejele mLeeefvekeÀ mJejep³e mebmLeebMeer mebyebefOele mesJeemegefJeOee meceeefJe<ì Deensle. Heefnuee mlej ö ³eeceO³es jml³eeb®eer DeJemLee, jnoejer Je ì^@HeÀerkeÀ pe@ce, meeJe&peefvekeÀ yeieer®eeb®eer GHeueyOelee,

meeJe&peefvekeÀ JeenlegkeÀer®eer GHeueyOelee, HeeCeer HegjJeþe, HeeCeer efvemmeejCe, mJe®ílee Je Meew®eeue³es ³eeb®ee meceeJesMe Demetve ³eeuee 6 iegCe efoues.

ogmeje mlej ö ³eeceO³es ªiCeeue³es Je JewÐekeÀer³e megefJeOee Je MeeUe Je ceneefJeÐeeue³es ³eeb®ee meceeJesMe Demetve ³eeuee 4 iegCe efoues.

eflemeje mlej ö ³eeceO³es Jeerpe HegjJeþe, keÀe³eoe Je megJ³eJemLee DeeefCe iegvnsieejer ³eeb®ee meceeJesMe Demetve ³eeuee 1 iegCe efoues.

mebMeesOeve DeejeKe[e

efJeOeevemeYee DeLeJee ceneveiejHeeefuekeÀe meom³e cnCepes efJeefMe<ì celeoejmebIeeletve mJeleb$e efveJe[CegkeÀer®³ee Üejs celeoejebveer efveJe[tve efouesues ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeer.

cegbyeF&ceO³es Òel³eskeÀ efJeOeevemeYee celeoejmebIe ÒeMeemekeÀer³e Jee@[&ceO³es efJeYeeieuee Demetve Jee@[& mlejeJej mJeleb$eHeCes efveJe[ues peeCeejs ueeskeÀÒeefveOeer cnCepes veiejmesJekeÀ. ³ee ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeruee DeeHeu³ee celeoejmebIeele keÀece keÀjC³ee®es DeefOekeÀej Demeleele.

Òemlegle DeY³eeme ne ÒeecegK³eeves veiejmesJekeÀeb®³ee keÀeceefiejerMeer mebyebefOele Demeu³eeves ns veiejmesJekeÀ p³ee efJeOeevemeYee celeoejmebIeeleerue Jee@[e¥®es ÒeefleefveefOelJe keÀjleele les celeoejmebIeeleerue ceeefnleer IesCes iejpes®es nesles.

l³eecegUs Deecner Òel³eskeÀ celeoejmebIeeleerue SkeÀ ÒeefleefveOeerkeÀ vecegvee meceeefJe<ì keÀjC³ee®es þjJeues. Hejbleg, Òel³eskeÀ celeoejmebIee®ee DeekeÀej, cnCepes®e ueeskeÀmebK³ee Je J³eeHleer, JesieJesieUe Demelees DeeefCe l³eecegUs l³eeceO³es meceeefJe<ì celeoejmebIee®eer mebK³eener JesieJesieUer jenles.

cegbyeF&ceO³es 36 efJeOeevemeYee celeoejmebIe Demetve l³eeceO³es ceneveiejHeeefuekesÀ®es 227 Jee@[& Deensle. Deecner meJe& 227 Jee@[e&le SkeÀmeejKee vecegvee IesC³ee®es þjJeues DeeefCe l³eevegmeej Òel³eskeÀ Jee[e&le 100 ³eeÒeceeCes vecegvee efveJe[ kesÀueer. ³eeÒeceeCes pes celeoejmebIe DeekeÀejeves ceesþs Deensle lesLeerue vecegv³ee®ee DeekeÀej ceesþe jeefnuee.

³ee DeY³eemeele meg©Jeeleeruee meceeefJe<ì SketÀCe vecegvee ë 227 ceveHee Jee[& ƒ 100 J³ekeÌleer † 22,700 J³ekeÌleer.

³eeveblej vescekeÌ³ee keÀesCel³ee J³ekeÌleeR®eer efveJe[ keÀje³e®eer ns þjJeues, les Heg{erueÒeceeCes ë

ñeer Je Hegª<e ³ee oesneW®ee meceeJesMe.

18 Je<ex Je l³eeHes#ee peemle Je³ee®³ee (celeoejeuee Hee$e) J³ekeÌleer.

³eeÒeceeCes ìeiexì ûegHe efveef½ele Peeu³eeJej l³ee®eer efuebie DeeefCe Je³eesieìe®es ³eesi³e ÒeefleefveefOelJe ³esC³ee®³ee ¢<ìerves efJeYeeieCeer efveef½ele kesÀueer.

Je³e DeeefCe efuebie ³eeJej DeeOeeefjle efJeYeeieCeermeeþer Fbef[³eve jer[jMeer[ mì[er®ee DeeOeej Iesleuee. (ne meJee&le ceesþe yesmeueeF&ve meJnx; je<ì^er³e mlejeJej ³ee®es keÀece efce[er³ee jerme®e& ³egPeme& keÀewefvmeueves kesÀues lej cegbyeF& efJeYeeieele nbmee jerme®e& ûegHeves kesÀues).

ÒeMveeJeueer®³ee DeeOeejs mebyebefOele J³ekeÌleeR®³ee Lesì cegueeKeleer IesTve DeeJeM³ekeÀ ceeefnleer pecee kesÀueer.

vecegvee efveef½eleer®eer Heg{erue Òeef¬eÀ³ee DeJeuebyeueer ë

Òel³eskeÀ Jee@[&ceO³es 100 cegueeKeleer Iesleu³ee.

Jee@[&ceOeerue 2 les 3 ceesþer efþkeÀeCes efveJe[tve l³eeceO³es vecegvee efJeYeeieCeer kesÀueer. yeepeejHesþ, jsuJes mìsMeve, cee@ue Fl³eeoer ieoea®eer efþkeÀeCes ³eemeeþer efveJe[ueer.


³eeefþkeÀeCeer ueeskeÀebMeer Lesì mebHeke&À meeOetve l³eeb®³eeMeer yeele®eerle keÀªve DeeJeM³ekeÀ ceeefnleer efceUJeueer.

cetu³eceeHevee®es IeìkeÀ

veiejmesJekeÀeb®³ee cetu³eceeHeveekeÀefjlee Deecner ÒeecegK³eeves ®eej efJeYeeieeleerue ceeefnleer IesC³ee®es þjJeues, les Heg{erueÒeceeCes ë

DeeHeu³ee Yeeieeleerue efJeefJeOe megefJeOeebyeeyeleerle ueeskeÀeb®eer celes ë

jml³eeb®eer efmLeleer

JeenletkeÀer®eer keÀeW[er

meeJe&peveefkeÀ yeieeryes / KesUe®eer cewoeves ³eeb®eer GHeueyOelee

Dee@ìes, ì@keÌmeer Je yeme ³eemeejK³ee meeJe&peefvekeÀ JeenlegkeÀer®³ee meeOeveeb®eer GHeueyOelee

jsMeve ogkeÀeveele Oeev³ee®eer GHeueyOelee

ªiCeeue³es DeeefCe Flej JewÐekeÀer³e megefJeOee

³eesi³e ÒekeÀej®³ee MeeUe Je ceneefJeÐeeue³es

Jeerpe HegjJeþe

HeeCeer HegjJeþe

HeeJemeeÈîeele HeeCeer legbyetve jenC³ee®eer mecem³ee

Òeot<eCee®eer mecem³ee

iegvnsieejer Ieìvee

keÀe³eoe Je megJ³eJemLee ³eeb®eer efmLeleer

mJe®ílee Je Meew®eeue³e megefJeOee

veiejmesJekeÀeyeeyele ceeefnleer, peeieªkeÀlee Deens Je l³ee®³eeHe³e¥le menpe Heesnes®elee ³esles keÀe.

veiejmesJekeÀ Je Ye´<ìe®eej ³eeefJe<e³eer®es pevecele.

veiejmesJekeÀe®³ee keÀeceefiejerefJe<e³eer meJe&meeOeejCe meceeOeeve DeeefCe l³eecegUs peerJeveceeve Gb®eeJeues Demes Jeeìles ³eeefJe<e³eer pevecele.

Dee³eDeejSme ®³ee DeeOeej js<ee DeekeÀ[îeeb®ee GHe³eesie keÀjerle efJeMJe ªHejsKeeMeer pegUJeCeer keÀjC³eemeeþer Je³e Je efuebiee®³ee vecegvee j®evesle og©mleer kesÀueer iesueer Deens.

veiejmesJekeÀe®³ee iegCeHe$ekeÀe®es SkeÀ GoenjCe ë

Heg{s veiejmesJekeÀe®³ee iegCeHe$ekeÀe®es SkeÀ GoenjCe efoues Deens. l³eeJeªve iegCe osC³ee®eer He×leer mHe<ì nesF&ue ë

¬eÀ. IeìkeÀ meJe&meeOeejCe ieì (ûegHeeRie) iegCe keÀceeue iegCe

1 veiejmesJekeÀe®³ee jepekeÀer³e He#ee®es veebJe mcejCeele DemeCes

peeieªkeÀlee DeeefCe Heesnes®e 77 100

2 veiejmesJekeÀe®es veebJe mcejCeele DemeCes peeieªkeÀlee DeeefCe Heesnes®e 77 100

3 veiejmesJekeÀeMeer menpe Yesìlee ³esles,l³ee®³eeHe³e¥le Heesnes®elee ³esles

peeieªkeÀlee DeeefCe Heesnes®e 69 100

4 veiejmesJekeÀeyeeyele®es meceeOeeve meJe&meeOeejCe GHee³e³eespevee 59 100

5 peerJeveceeveele megOeejCee meJe&meeOeejCe GHee³e³eespevee 69 100

6 Ye´<ìe®eej Ye´<ìe®eej ceeHeve 72 100

7 JeerpeHegjJeþe ueeskeÀeb®es cele - 3 mlej 67 100

8 iegvnsieejer Ieìvee ueeskeÀeb®es cele - 3 mlej 57 100

9 keÀe³eoe Je megJ³eJemLee efmLeleer ueeskeÀeb®es cele - 3 mlej 61 100

10 jsMeve ogkeÀeve Oeev³ee®eer GHeueyOelee ueeskeÀeb®es cele - 1 mlej 61 100

11 Òeot<eCe mecem³ee ueeskeÀeb®es cele - 1 mlej 56 100

12 ªiCeeue³es Je Flej JewÐekeÀer³e megefJeOee ueeskeÀeb®es cele - 2 mlej 67 100

13 ³eesi³e MeeUe Je ceneefJeÐeeue³es ueeskeÀeb®es cele - 2 mlej 68 100

14 jml³eeb®eer efmLeleer ueeskeÀeb®es cele - 1 mlej 58 100

15 JeenletkeÀer®eer keÀeW[er ueeskeÀeb®es cele - 1 mlej 57 100

16 meeJe&peefvekeÀ yeefie®es / cewoeves GHeueyOelee ueeskeÀeb®es cele - 1 mlej 62 100

17 meeJe&peefvekeÀ JeenlegkeÀer®eer GHeueyOelee ueeskeÀeb®es cele - 1 mlej 59 100

18 HeeCeer HegjJeþe ueeskeÀeb®es cele - 1 mlej 62 100

19 HeeJemeeÈ³eele HeeCeer legbyeC³ee®eer mecem³ee ueeskeÀeb®es cele - 1 mlej 56 100

20 mJe®ílee Je Meew®eeue³e megefJeOee ueeskeÀeb®es cele - 1 mlej 59 100


IeìkeÀe®es iegCeebkeÀve

¬eÀ. IeìkeÀ Yeej iegCe keÀceeue iegCe

1 ceeefnleer, peeieªkeÀlee Je Heesnes®e 5 74 100

2 meJe&meeOeejCe GHee³e³eespevee 7 64 100

3 Ye´<ìe®eejefJe<e³ekeÀ 7 72 100

4 ueeskeÀeb®es cele - Heefnuee mlej 6 59 100

5 ueeskeÀeb®es cele - ogmeje mlej 4 68 100

6 ueeskeÀeb®es cele - eflemeje mlej 1 62 100

Yeej ue#eele IesTve Debeflece iegCeebkeÀve

veiejmesJekeÀe®³ee keÀeceefiejerefJe<e³eer®es cele †

((574)+(764)+(772)+(659)+(468)+(162))/100 † 20.1 SketÀCe 30 HewkeÀer

veiejmesJekeÀe®³ee ³eeDeeOeer Heeefnuesu³ee Flej efvekeÀ<eeb®es iegCeebkeÀve DeeefCe ns iegCeebkeÀve ³eebvee SkeÀ$e keÀªve Òel³eskeÀ veiejmesJekeÀe®es iegCe efveef½ele kesÀues iesues.

ceeefnleer®eer legueveelcekeÀ He[leeUCeer

SKeeoe meJnx keÀjleevee, DeeHeu³ee vecegv³eeletve peer DeekeÀ[sJeejer Heg{s ³esles efle®eer leguevee J³eeHekeÀ DeJekeÀeMe Jee ueeskeÀmebK³esleerue meebefK³ekeÀerMeer meebefK³ekeÀerMeer kesÀueer peeles. ner meebefK³ekeÀer JesieJesieÈ³ee JesUsuee kesÀuesu³ee l³ee®e meJex#eCeeletve Iesleueer peeles efkebÀJee Flej ñeesleeletve Iesleueer peeles.

³eeJesUer Deecner ³ee meJex#eCeele efuebie DeeefCe Je³e ³eemeboYee&ves peer j®evee efometve Deeueer efle®eer leguevee Fbef[³eve jer[jMeerHe meJnxMeer kesÀueer. DeMeer legueveelcekeÀ He[leeUCeer kesÀu³eeves ueeskeÀmebK³es®es ÒeefleefveefveOelJe DeefOekeÀ De®etkeÀ nesC³eele ceole Peeueer.

5. vekeÀejelcekeÀ iegCeebkeÀvee®es IeìkeÀ

veJ³eeves oeKeue Peeuesu³ee SHeÀDee³eDeej meeþer vekeÀejelcekeÀ iegCeebkeÀve

pej efveJe[tve Deeu³eeveblej ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeerJej veJ³eeves SHeÀDee³eDeej oeKeue Peeuee Demesue lej leer iebYeerj yeeye Deens, l³eecegUs ³ee ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeerves efceUJeuesu³ee iegCeeletve 5 iegCe Jepee kesÀues iesues.

³ee Òeef¬eÀ³esle efkeÀleer veJes SHeÀDee³eDeej oeKeue Peeues ³ee®eer mebK³ee ue#eele Iesleuesueer veener. SkeÀpejer oeKeue Peeuee lejer DeeefCe iegv¿ee®es ieebYeer³e& ue#eele IesTve vekeÀejelcekeÀ iegCeebkeÀve kesÀues Deens.

DeejesHeHe$e oeKeue Peeu³eeves vekeÀejelcekeÀ iegCeebkeÀve

iegv¿ee®ee HegjeJee neleer Deeu³eeJej DeejesHeHe$e oeKeue nesles. l³eecegUs ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeer®³ee ®eeefj$³ee®³ee ¢<ìerves ner iebYeerj yeeye Deens. l³eecegUs ³ee keÀejCeemeeþer ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeerves efceUJeuesu³ee iegCeeletve 5 iegCe Jepee kesÀues iesues.

³ee Òeef¬eÀ³esle efkeÀleer veJeer DeejesHeHe$es oeKeue Peeueer ³ee®eer mebK³ee ue#eele Iesleuesueer veener. SkeÀpejer oeKeue Peeues lejer DeeefCe iegv¿ee®es ieebYeer³e& ue#eele IesTve vekeÀejelcekeÀ iegCeebkeÀve kesÀues Deens.

ceeueceÊee efJeJejCe DeeefCe iegvnsieejer efJe<e³ekeÀ veeWoer ojJe<eea mJeleëntve ceeefnleer peenerj ve kesÀu³eeme vekeÀejelcekeÀ iegCeebkeÀve

efveJe[CetkeÀ Dee³eesiee®³ee efve³eceevegmeej efveJe[CegkeÀerme GcesoJeejer oeKeue keÀjCeeN³ee J³ekeÌleerves Flej keÀeieoHe$eebyejesyej®e De@HeÀer[sJnerìÜejs mJeleë®eer ceeueceÊee Je iegvnsieejer Heeée&Yetceer®eer ceeefnleer meeoj keÀjCes DeeJeM³ekeÀ Deens. efveJe[tve Deeu³eeJej ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeer Hegvne ner ceeefnleer efveJe[CetkeÀ Dee³eesie Jee DeeHeues celeoej ³eebvee meeoj keÀjle veenerle, lej Hejle Heg{®³ee efveJe[CegkeÀer®³ee JesUsuee efkebÀJee Dev³e efveJe[CegkeÀeruee GYes jene³e®es Demeu³eeme®e leer ceeefnleer efoueer peeles. Hejbleg ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeerves ner ceeefnleer Òel³eskeÀ DeeefLe&keÀ Je<ee&®³ee DeKesjerme DeeHeu³ee celeoejmebIeele mJeleëntve Ieesef<ele keÀjCes peªjer®es Deens Demes Deecneuee Jeeìles. ner ceeefnleer DeeHeueer JesyemeeF&ì, Jele&ceeveHe$es, Òepee JesyemeeF&ì ³eeJeªve Jee Dev³e ceeO³eceeletve ner ceeefnleer peenerj keÀjlee ³esF&ue. ³eeletve HeejoMe&keÀlee ³esF&ue.


1. Matrix – Scale of Ranking

The Matrix for measuring the functioning of the Municipal Councillors has been designed by Praja with inputs from reputed people with sectoral knowledge in governance, social science, market research, media.

In order to design the research and get the desired output, it was important to answer the following two questions:

a. On what parameters should the performance of Municipal Councillors be evaluated?

b. How should the research be designed in order to represent areas of each Municipal Councillors and meet the right people?

For the first question; The Indian Democracy functions on rules and strictures laid down in The Constitution of India adopted on the 26th November, 1949. The constitution has been amended on numerous occasions and various acts have been passed and adopted by subsequent assemblies to strengthen the functioning of centre, state and local self government institutions. All these acts/legislations with their base in the constitution give our elected representative needed powers for functioning; have built the needed checks and balances; and serve as the source of the terms of reference for the elected representatives on all aspects of their conduct as the people’s representatives. Hence, the first parameter for evaluating the performance of Municipal Councillors is based solely in the mechanisms and instruments and duties and responsibilities as led in the Constitution of India, in particular, the 12th Schedule of the Constitution that was introduced through the 73rd and 74th Amendments of the Constitution, and the Mumbai Municipal Corporation Act, 1888.

However; The Constitution itself derives its power from the free will of its citizens as also the document itself states that it has been adopted, enacted and given to themselves by the people. Hence the perceptions of the people who are represented by the elected representatives are the other important, necessary parameter for evaluating the performance of the elected representatives (the Municipal Councillors). Thus, to answer the second question it is necessary to study people’s perceptions of the Municipal Councillors performance, by who represent them from their respective constituencies.

The next few pages will elaborate the study design and details of the study conducted to judge the performance of Municipal Councillors in Mumbai; but before we get into details, it is important to understand the sources of data and its broad usage in the ranking matrix.

THE METHODOLOGYThe following information was required to judge the performance of each Municipal Councillor in the city:

1. Some of the tangible parameters like an elected Municipal Councillors attendance in the Corporation and the Committee Meetings, the number of questions (issues) she/he has raised in the above forums (Corporation and Committee Meetings), importance of those questions, and utilization of funds allotted to her/him.

2. Some parameters on her/his background such as educational qualification, income tax records & criminal record (if any).

3. Some soft parameters like the perception/impression of the people in his/ her constituency, awareness about them, satisfaction with their work and improvement in the quality of life because of the Municipal Councillor.

Once the areas of evaluation were finalised, it was important to decide upon the methodology which would best provide the required information. Information mentioned in points 1 & 2 above was gathered from RTI & by means of secondary research. Municipal Councillor Scores have been derived out of maximum 100 marks with 70% weightage given to tangible facts about the Municipal Councillor. For the Information on the 3rd point a primary survey was conducted amongst the citizens in each constituency to evaluate the perceived performance of the Municipal Councillor. 30% weightage was given to perceived performance of Municipal Councillors in the minds of common man.

The data used for points 1 and 2 has been collected from government sources:

a. Election Department MCGM.

b. Under Right to Information Act from Municipal Secretary, MCGM (MCGM Head Office and BEST).

c. Under Right to Information Act from Assistant Engineer (Maintenance), MCGM (from all the 24 Administrative Wards of MCGM).

d. Under Right to Information Act from Mumbai Police.

People’s perception as per point 3 has been mapped through an opinion poll of 22,580 people across the city of Mumbai by Hansa Market Research conducted through a structured questionnaire.

It is very important to understand here that the matrix is objectively designed and provides no importance to the political party of the representative or to any personal/political ideology.

Criminalisation of politics in the country has been growing since independence and is a phenomenon which if not checked now can destroy the democratic foundations of our nation. Hence personal criminal record related parameters pertaining to the elected representative are taken into consideration such as:


their FIR cases registered against them as stated in the election affidavit; new FIR cases registered against them after being elected in the current term; and important pending charge sheets.

Table 1: Scale for Ranking Performance for Councillor

Scale of Ranking

Sr. No.

Indicator Max %

Comments

1 Present

A Attendance in the Corporation and Committee Meetings

15 Refer Point 3a on page 166 for details.

B Number of Questions Asked

15 Against Group Percentage Rank. 15 being the top most percentiles and so on to the lowest for 1.

C Importance of questions asked by issues raised in the question

18 Refer Point 3c on page 168 for details.

D Issues raised compared to Citizen’s Complaints

10 Refer Point 3d on page 168 for details

E Total Discretionary Funds Utilised during April, 2012 to March, 2014

5 Refer Point 3e on page 169 for details

Total 63

2 Past

A Education Qualification 1 A minimum of 10th Pass - 1; if not - 0

B Income Tax 1 Possesing PAN Card - 1; if not - 0

C Criminal Record 5 If the candidate has zero cases registered against her/him, then 5; else as below:

(1) Criminal Cases Registered excluding the following charges: Murder, Rape, Molestation, Riot, Extortion - 3

(2) Rest - 0

Total 7

3 Perception Based on a opinion poll of 22,580 people spread across different constituencies in the city of Mumbai

A Perceived Performance 11 Score on Public Services

B Awareness & Accessibility 5 Score on Awareness amongst people about their representative, their political party and ease of access to the representative

Scale of Ranking

Sr. No.

Indicator Max %

Comments

C Corruption Index 7 Score on perceived personal corruption of the representative

D Broad Measures 7 Score on overall satisfaction and improvement in quality of life

Total 30

4 Negative marking for new criminal cases registered during the year

-5 For any new FIR registered during the year.

5 Negative marking for Charge sheet

-5 For any Charge sheet in a criminal case.

6 Negative marking for no annual pro-active disclosures by the elected representatives of Assets and Liabilities and Criminal record (*)

-5 This can be done on own website, newspaper, Praja Website or any other source which should be announced publicly.

Also marks would be cut for wrong disclosures in the above mentioned forums.

Total 100

(*) This negative parameter on proactive disclosures has not been applied for the current year. But as one the primary purpose of the Yearbook is to promote transparency amongst elected representatives, it is imperative that they proactively provide personal information on their personal annual economic status and to emphasise their probity in public life, they should share every year their updated criminal record.

2. Parameters for Past Records as per Affidavit

Parameters for Past Records are based on information in election affidavit that includes educational, criminal and financial records of Municipal Councillors. Total seven Marks out of Maximum 100 marks are allocated for this parameter.

a. EducationIf the elected representative has declared in his affidavit, education qualification as 10th pass or more then on the scale one mark is allocated, else zero marks are given.

As a developing 21st century country, basic modern education is an important criterion for human development. Even at lowest clerical jobs in the government, the government insists on a minimum educational level. Going by the same logic and the times, it is prudent that a similar yardstick be applied to our elected representatives. However, we also believe that the educational parameter should be given a minimal weightage in the overall scheme vis-a-vis other parameters, that are more crucial for judging performance of the elected representatives.


b. Income TaxIt is widely published and believed in India that annual income levels and wealth of those who are elected sees a manifold increase in the few years when they represent. Marks are allocated for possessing a PAN card (one mark), as per the affidavit; else if not possessing a PAN card than zero marks are allocated.

c. Criminal Record

Criminalisation of politics is a sad reality. A significant number of elected representatives have a criminal record i.e. 1) they have FIRs registered against them; 2) charge sheets filled; and 3) even convictions given by the courts of law.

There is no excuse for not having moral probity in public life. It is the right of the citizens to have people representing them with no criminal records. Hence the scheme of ranking has into account marks for people with clean records:

i. Those with absolutely no criminal FIRs registered are given five marks.

ii. Those with FIRs registered against, with cases containing the following charges: murder, rape, molestation and extortion are given zero marks.

iii. Those with other FIRs registered against, other than those mentioned in No. ii above, are given three marks.

We have negative markings as explained in No. 5 below for other parameters related to crime records like charge sheet.

Kindly note that allocating scoring for each individual case would have been complex, instead scoring for cases after them being categorised as above seemed more logical and hence number of individual cases are not of that important but the category of case needed for the scoring.

3. Parameters for Present Performance in the Corporation and Committee MeetingsIn an indirect, representative democracy like India’s, citizens elect their representatives so that these representatives can represent them in the houses of legislation and deliberate on issues related to the citizens and form needed legislations under the guidelines of and using the mechanisms of the constitution. Thus it is very clear that the weightages in the performance scale have to be more biased to these functions of the elected representatives i.e. of Deliberation.

a. AttendanceThe mandate given by citizens to the representatives is to attend the business of the respective legislative houses. It is hence prudent that the representatives attend 100% or near to 100% sessions of their respective houses. Hence the marking is based on percentage of attendance: 100% getting 15 while 0% getting zero.

However, in the MCGM a councillor is always a member of the Corporation and a particular Ward Committee, and apart from that some of the councillors are members of various committees viz:

i. Standing Committee

ii. BEST Committee

iii. Works (City) Committee

iv. Works (Suburb) Committee

v. Improvements Committee

vi. Education Committee

vii. Public Health Committee

viii. Women and Child Welfare Committee

ix. Law and Revenue Committee

x. Tree Authority Committee

xi. Market and Garden Committee

Thus, it is understood that there can be two categories of councillors and they need to be allocated the 15 marks in different ways:

ATTENDANCECouncillor Corporation General

Body Meetings (GBM)Ward Committee

MeetingsDifferent Committee

Meetings (mentioned above)Total

Category A 9 6 N.A. 15

Category B 7 4 4 15

b. Number of QuestionsThere cannot be really a set benchmark for the right number of questions or issues that have to be asked by a representative. However given the range and complexity of issues that our country is facing, it is necessary for the representative to raise as many issues as they can, which are necessary for the citizens. Hence to stimulate the representatives to ask maximum number of questions the scale uses the percentile system for scoring.

Devices used for asking ‘Questions’ that have been considered in the marking:

• Agenda Raised

• Point of Order

• Short Notice Question

• Interpellation: Right to ask question under section 66 (A) of MMC Act

• Discussion on urgent public matters under section 66 (B) of MMC Act

• Asking statement from Municipal Commissioner under section 66 (C)

• Notice of Motions

• Proposal Raised


• Urgent Business

• Adjournment of meeting and business to be transacted at adjourned meeting

• General discussion on budget estimation

• Proposal for adjournment of debate or meeting and Amendments proposed

• Amendment Proposal

The marking for this section is out of a maximum 15 marks that the representative can get for being the person with the maximum number of questions asked. The marking here is done against Group Percentage Rank:

15 being the top most percentile and so on to the lowest for 0.

c. Importance of questions asked by issues raised in the questionThe duties of the Municipal Corporation are laid down precisely under the Mumbai Municipal Corporation Act, 1888. They are further divided into Obligatory duties (Section 61, 62) and Discretionary duties (Section 63). The Obligatory duties include issues related to roads, water supply, sewerage, buildings, disaster management, municipal properties, primary education, health, renaming of roads, etc. are covered. The Discretionary duties include issues related to slum development, open spaces, gardens, road transport, energy, electricity, water bodies (dams, irrigation), community halls/temples, etc.

In the present scale, we have culled out certain services from the Obligatory duties that are essentially civic in nature and where the MCGM has monopoly for delivery of these services to the citizens of Mumbai. The issues that can be raised on these services are related to subjects such as drainage, roads, water supply, solid waste management, etc.

Apart from these issues, an councillor can raise subjects that are not under the direct purview of the corporation but are covered by the state and central governments. Such as, crime, foreign affairs, agriculture, animal husbandry, MMRDA (Mumbai Metropolitan Regional Development Authority), etc.

Based on the above classifications the weightages for the quality/importance of the questions has been designated as below from the total marks out of 100 in the overall scale:

Issues/Duties Obligatory Discretionary Civic(Obligatory)

State/Central Total

Marks 8 6 3 1 18

d. Issues raised compared to Citizen ComplaintsMCGM has developed a system for tracking, recording citizen complaints. These complaints are maintained under the Centralised Complaint Registering System (CCRS). They are registered into a software platform where they

are classified into different categories by departments and the nature of the complaint such as drainage, road, water supply, colony officer, building, etc. As citizens’ representatives, it is expected that Municipal Councillors also ask questions or raise issues to resolve citizens issues (complaints). Hence the current parameter is based on comparing issues raised by councillors related to the citizen complaints based on the RTI information procured related to the data maintained by CCRS. The departments of MCGM that are covered under this criteria are as follows: Buildings, Colony officer, Drainage, Estate, Garden, License, MCGM related, Pest control, Pollution, Roads, Shop and Establishment (S & E), Solid Waste Management (SWM), Storm Water Drainage, Toilet and Water Supply.

A maximum of 10 marks have been allocated for this parameter.

e. Utilisation of Discretionary Funds Utilised April 2012 to March 2014Municipal Councillors get a total of Rs. 60 lakhs in every financial year. This fund they can spend as per their discretion on certain specified development work in their constituencies. It is necessary that the funds are utilised in a planned phased manner to achieve optimal results. Hence, the marks given are based on percentage of the funds utilised out of the maximum Rs. 1.2 crore for the financial years 2012-2014:

(1) 100% (or more) to 91% - five marks; (2) 90% to 76% - four marks; (3) 75% to 61% - three marks; (4) 60% to 51% - two marks; and (5) 50% and below - zero marks.

4. Parameters for People’s Perception as per Opinion Poll

Since perceived performance was given a weightage of 30 points, we divided it further in to four broad areas in order to evaluate the performance in detail. All these four areas were given differential weightage based to the importance in defining the Municipal Councillors performance. The weightages were divided in the following scheme:

n Perception of Public Services (impression of the people about the facilities in the area) was given a weightage of 11 points,

n Awareness & Accesibility of the Municipal Councillor was given a weightage of 5 points,

n Corruption index was given a weightage of 7 points and

n Broad overall measures were given a weightage of 7 points

The rationale for giving the above scoring points was to give more importance to the key issues like facilities in the area & corruption as compared to Municipal Councillor being aware and accessible or overall feel of the people


being positive. This is because we believe that scoring positively overall or being popular is actually a function of your work in different areas. Hence, these areas should be given more importance than the overall satisfaction. Moreover a blanket overall performance for an individual may be good but when interrogated deeply about different traits the positives and negatives can be clearly pointed.

The next step after assigning weightages to government’s four broad areas was to make sure that facilities which come under local jurisdiction to get more importance than the ones which come under the state or central government’s jurisdiction. Hence the weightage for Perception of Public Services was further divided into a hierarchy of 3 levels to meet the desired objective.

Level 1 included facilities which are more critical to local government whereas Level 3 included facilities that are more critical to state government.

n Level 1 – This level included areas like Condition of Roads, Traffic Jams & Congestion, Availability of public gardens, Availability of public transport facilities, Water Supply, Water logging problems & Cleanliness & Sanitation facilities. It was given a weightage of 6 points.

n Level 2 – This level included areas like Hospitals & other Medical facilities & Appropriate Schools & Colleges. It was given a weightage of 4 points.

n Level 3 – This level included areas like Power Supply, Instances of Crime, Law & Order situation. It was given a weightage of 1 point.

Research Design:

n A Municipal Councillor is a representative elected by the voters to over see the functioning of the ward.

n Winner of elections in each ward is termed as a Municipal Councillor and has the power to manage the functioning of the ward.

n This division helps to provide clear delegation of responsibilities at the ground level.

n Since, our study focused on evaluating the performance of Municipal Councillors it was necessary to cover and represent all the wards to which each of these Municipal Councillors belonged.

n Hence, we decided to cover a sample from each ward. We decided to cover all the 227 municipal wards equally, with a sample of 100 in each ward.

n The initial total sample for the study covered: 227 municipal wards x 100 respondents = 22700 respondents.

n Next step was to define the target group for the study. We finalised on covering within each ward:

p Both Males & Females

p 18 years and above (eligible to vote)

n Once the target group was defined, quotas for representing gender and age groups were set.

n The quotas were set on the basis of age and gender split available through Indian Readership Study (Large scale baseline study conducted nationally by Media Research Users Council (MRUC) & Hansa Research group for Mumbai Region.

n The required information was collected through face to face interviews with the help of structured questionnaire.

n In order to meet the respondent, following sampling process was followed:

p 100 interviews were conducted in each municipal ward.

p 2 – 3 prominent areas in the ward were identified and the sample was divided amongst them. These areas were mainly crowded areas such as market place, railway stations, malls etc.

p Respondents were intercepted in these areas and the required information was obtained from them.

n Sample composition of age & gender was corrected to match the universe profile using the baseline data from IRS. (Refer to weighting paragraph on next page).

Parameters of Evaluation:

While deciding the parameters of evaluation for a Municipal Councillor, we decided to capture the information on four important aspects. These were as follows:

n Impression of the people about different facilities in his/her area

p Condition of Roads

p Traffic jams & Congestion of roads

p Availability of public gardens/open playgrounds

p Availability of public transport facilities like Auto, Taxis & Buses

p Availability of food through ration shops

p Hospitals and other medical facilities


p Appropriate schools and colleges

p Power Supply

p Water Supply

p Water Logging during rainy season

p Pollution problems

p Instances of Crime

p Law & Order situation

p Cleanliness & Sanitation facilities

n Awareness & Accessibility of the Municipal Councillor

n Perception of corruption for Municipal Councillor

n Broad overall measures like overall satisfaction with Municipal Councillor & improvement in quality of life because of Municipal Councillor.

Illustration of Scorecard for an Municipal Councillor:

Below is an illustration of scorecard for a Municipal Councillor which will help us to understand the scoring pattern:

Parameter Scores

Sr.No.

Parameters Broad groupings Scores MaximumScore

1 Recall for party name to which the Municipal Councillor belongs

Awareness & Accessibility 77 100

2 Recall for Name of the Municipal Councillor


3 Accessibility of the Municipal Councillor


4 Satisfaction with the Municipal Councillor

Broad overall measures 59 100

5 Improvement in Lifestyle Broad overall measures 69 100

6 Corruption Corruption Index 72 100

7 Power Supply Impression of people - Level 3 67 100

8 Instances of Crime Impression of people - Level 3 57 100

9 Law & Order situation Impression of people - Level 3 61 100

10 Availability of food through ration shops

Impression of people - Level 1 61 100

11 Pollution problems Impression of people - Level 1 56 100

Sr.No.

Parameters Broad groupings Scores MaximumScore

12 Hospitals and other medical facilities


13 Appropriate schools and colleges


14 Condition of Roads Impression of people - Level 1 58 100

15 Traffic jams & Congestion of roads


16 Availability of public gardens/open playgrounds


17 Availability of public transport facilities like Auto, Taxis & Buses


18 Water Supply Impression of people - Level 1 62 100

19 Water Logging during rainy season


20 Cleanliness & Sanitation facilities


Scores of Netted Variables

Sr.No.

Netted Variables Weightage Assigned Scores Maximum Score

1 Awareness & Accessibility 5 74 100

2 Broad overall measures 7 64 100

3 Corruption Index 7 72 100

4 Impression of people - Level 1 6 59 100



Weighted Final Scores

Perceived performance score of the Municipal Councillor =

((5*74)+(7*64)+(7*72)+(6*59)+(4*68)+(1*62))/100 = 20.1 out of 30

This score was further added with the performance on hard parameters and a composite score for each Municipal Councillor was derived.

Weighting the data:

When conducting a survey, it is common to compare the figures obtained in a sample with universe or population values. These values may come from the same survey from a different time period or from other sources.


In this case, we compared the age & gender compositions achieved in our survey with the similar compositions in IRS study (Indian Readership Survey). In the process, minor deviations for demographics were corrected.

Hence, weighting not only helped us to remove the demographic skews from our sample data but also ensured that the representation of demography was correct.

5. Parameters for Negative Marking

Negative marking for new FIR cases registered

If there has been a new FIR registered against the elected representative after his election then this happens to be a matter of concern; and hence out of the marks earned by the representative, five marks would be deducted.

Do note that in the process of allocating marks does not take into account number of new criminal FIR cases, but simply takes into account even a single occurrence for allocating marks based on the severity of the crime.

Negative marking for Charge Sheet registered

A charge sheet signifies prima facie evidence in the case. This is again a serious concern for moral probity of the representative. Hence out of the marks earned by the representative, five marks would be deducted.

Do note that in the process of allocating marks does not take into account number of criminal charge sheets, but simply takes into account even a single occurrence for allocating marks based on the severity of the crime.

Negative marking for no annual pro-active disclosures by the elected representatives of Assets and Liabilities and Criminal record

As per the election commission norms the candidate standing for elections have to file an affidavit detailing amongst other things, their own asset and liabilities and criminal records. The candidate who gets elected later, does not share this information with his constituency or the election commission until and unless he/she stands for re-election or for a new election on different seat or post. However given the need of the time, we feel that it is necessary that the elected representatives proactively make their assets and liabilities (income status) and criminal records available to their constituencies at the end of every financial year when they are representing. This can be done through Newspapers or other Public Medias or through their own Websites or through Praja Website. This will bring larger transparency.

The four lions of the Ashoka Pillar, symbolising power, courage, pride and confidence are the ethos behind the Indian Republic as embedded in our Constitution. We salute the top 3 ranking Municipal Councillors of Mumbai as torch bearers of this idea. They have topped the list by on an objective ranking system as explained earlier in this report card, performing more efficiently relative to their peers. Jai Hind.

DeMeeskeÀ mlebYeeJejerue ®eej efmebn ns meÊee, Oew³e&, DeefYeceeve DeeefCe DeelceefJeéeeme ³eeb®es ÒeleerkeÀ Deensle. DeeHeu³ee jep³eIeìvesle DeO³eeËle meeJe&Yeewce Yeejlee®³ee mebkeÀuHee®es les ÒeleerkeÀ Deens. cegbyeF&leerue meJee&efOekeÀ iegCe efceUJeCeeN³ee 3 veiejmesJekeÀebvee Deece®ee ÒeCeece DeeefCe les ³ee Yeejleer³e HejbHejs®es Kejs HeeuevekeÀlex Deensle Demes Deecneuee Jeeìles. Keeueerue veceto kesÀuesu³ee Jemlegefve<þ cetu³eebkeÀve Òeef¬eÀ³esletve DeeefCe DeeHeu³ee yejesyejer®³ee veiejmesJekeÀeb®³ee leguevesle ÒeYeeJeer keÀeceefiejer keÀªve l³eebveer ns DeJJeue mLeeve efceUJeues Deens. pe³eefnbo.

#1: GOLD

#2: SILVER#3: BRONZE

THE FOUR LION TORCH

M U M B A I R E P O R T C A R D176

THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA

WE, THE PEOPLE OF INDIA, HAVING SOLEMNLY RESOLVED TO CONSTITUTE INDIA INTO A SOVEREIGN SOCIALIST SECULAR DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC AND TO SECURE TO ALL ITS CITIZENS: JUSTICE, SOCIAL, ECONOMIC AND POLITICAL;

LIBERTY OF THOUGHT, EXPRESSION, BELIEF, FAITH AND WORSHIP;

EQUALITY OF STATUS AND OF OPPORTUNITY; AND TO PROMOTE AMONG THEM ALL

FRATERNITY ASSURING THE DIGNITY OF THE INDIVIDUAL AND THE UNITY AND INTEGRITY OF THE NATION.

Room No. 5, 2nd floor, Botawala Building, 11/13, Horniman Circle, Fort, Mumbai - 400 023.Ph. 6525 2729 • WWW.praja.org

aabbcc 123456 - praja

Documents