7/21/2019 1701-6862-1-PB

1/23

Cultural Studies Review

volume 16 number 2 September 2010

http://epress.lib.uts.edu.au/journals/index.php/csrj/index

pp. 24870

!Sally Macarthur 2010

ISSN 1837-8692

Women, New Music and the Composition of Becomings

SALLY MACARTHUR

UNIVERSITY OF WESTERN SYDNEY

!"#$%&'& )*##'+,- %. #/%"0/#1 #% 2,3%4' 5'6'"7'1 )6*0"' #/' )+*8#28'- *,&

&2-8%"+-'- %. 9,':; 86*--28*6 $"-28"8/ * 86*2$ $*? -''$ *@-"+& 023', 9,':;

$"-28 /*- '*+,'& * +')"#*#2%, .%+ @'2,0 ",%+#/%&%A1 'A)'+2$',#*6 *,& -"@3'+-23'1

*,& 8/*+*8#'+2-'& @? * $2,&-'# )+'%88")2'& :2#/ $"-28*6 )+%0+'--1 8%$)6'A2#? *,&

/2-#%+28*6 ,'8'--2#?

7/21/2019 1701-6862-1-PB

2/23

Sally MacarthurWomen and New Music 249

2, #/' '*+6? =JJK- :/', C :%+4'& *- #/' $"-28 %..28'+ .%+ #/' L"-#+*62*, 8/*$@'+

$"-28 %+0*,2-*#2%, M"-28* N23*< E% $2,2$2-' #/' )%--2@262#? %. *"&2',8'- 6'*32,0 2,

&+%3'- *# #/' 2,#'+3*6 @+'*41 M"-28* N23* *&%)#'& #/' )+*8#28' %. )+%0+*$$2,0 #/'

,':1 #/"- ",.*$262*+1 :%+4 @'.%+' #/' 2,#'+3*6 @+'*4< C# *--"$'& #/*# 2. *"&2',8'-

:'+' .%+8'& #% 62-#', #% #/' $"-281 #/'? :%"6& 0+*&"*66? &'3'6%) * )*6*#' .%+ 2#< O"#

$*2,-#+'*$ *"&2',8'- /*3' 6%,0 +'-2-#'& 9,':; $"-281 ,% $*##'+ /%: /*+& #/'

86*--28*6 $"-28 %+0*,2-*#2%,- /*3' #+2'& #% 2,#+%&"8' 2#< P2,&* 5"-$*, $*4'- #/'

)%2,# #/*# *"&2',8'- :/% +'0"6*+6? *##',& 986*--28*6; 8%,8'+#- %. /2-#%+28 $"-28 *+'

6'-- 624'6? #% *##',& 9,':; $"-28 8%,8'+#-

7/21/2019 1701-6862-1-PB

3/23

VOLUME16NUMBER2SEPT2010

250

&'')6? ',#+',8/'& *,& -'6.G)'+)'#"*#2,0< \*)2& #'8/,%6%028*6 8/*,0'- /*3'

2$)*8#'& %, $"-28 *- $"8/ *- '6-':/'+' 2, #/' ,': 8%,3'+0',# $'&2* *0'< C, #/'

9,':; $"-28 -8','1 #/' ',#+')+','"+2*6 &2-8%"+-' #/*# -'6.G8%,-82%"-6? *,&

",8+2#28*66? 8'6'@+*#'- 9,':; $"-28;- 9'&02,'--; 2- 8%,#+*&28#'& @? * -'# %.

*,*8/+%,2-#28 )+*8#28'- #/*# @'6%,0 2, #/' ,2,'#'',#/ 8',#"+?< C :266 *+0"' #/*#

:%$',;- $"-28 6*84- * )'+.%+$*,8' 3',"' @'8*"-' 2# .*26- #% 8%,.%+$ #% #/'-' )+'G

'-#*@62-/'& -#+"8#"+'-< C :266 *6-% 2,3'-#20*#' #/' )%62#28*6 *,& 2&'%6%028*6 )*##'+,- *#

:%+4 #/*# -'+3' #/' 2,#'+'-#- %. )*+#28"6*+ 0+%")- *,& 2,/2@2# %#/'+-'' L,#%, U'@'+,1 >7, A"+7 +% +7, H,9 B8$#3I #+*,-< P'% O6*84 2, U2662 \'28/

X'&'' L+,%6& >8/%',@'+01 9c%: !,' O'8%$'- P%,'6?;

2, P'%,*+& >#'2, X'&?&,'? Z'-#23*6Y1 %+ 2,86"&'& * +*,0' %. %#/'+ $'&2*1 %+

&+*:, )%)"6*+ $"-28 2,#% 2#- &%$*2,< C,&''&1 \%@'+# Z2,4 /*- +'8',#6? *+0"'& #/*# 2, *&&2#2%, #% #/'-'+2*6 /'0'$%,? #/'+' /*- @'', *, 2,#',-2.28*#2%, %. *, '$'+0',# #%,*6 $*2,-#+'*$ #/*# /*- 2#- +%%#- 2,

$2,2$*62-# $"-28< >'' \%@'+# Z2,41 9Xk%-#GY$2,2$*62-$- =JTKoBKKKa E/' >'*+8/ .%+ * S': M*2,-#+'*$;

2, S28/%6*- V%%4 *,& L,#/%,? k%)6' X'&-Y1 >7, @".:!#(0, K#$+%!; %5 >9,&+#,+7 @,&+8!; B8$#31

V*$@+2&0' ],23'+-2#? k+'--1 V*$@+2&0'1 BKKI1 QDJoQR< 5'-)2#' #/'-' &'3'6%)$',#-1 $? *+0"$',# 2-

#/*# 62##6' /*- 8/*,0'& 2, 9,':; $"-28< E/' $"-28 &')',&- %, #/' 8',#+*62#? %. #/' $*6'1 ',#+')+','"+2*6

8%$)%-'+< >"8/ * 8%$)%-'+ :266 %.#', -'6.G8%,-82%"-6? -''4 %"# #/' 9,':; :/26' 9+'2,3',#2,0 #/' :/''6;1

7/21/2019 1701-6862-1-PB

18/23

Sally MacarthurWomen and New Music 265

2, %,' +'8',# 'A*$)6' +'2,#+%&"82,0 *0'62*,G624' $"-28 #/'*#+' *- 2. 2# :*- @'2,0 )+'-',#'& .%+ #/'

.2+-# #2$'"-*, M8V6*+? &+*:- *##',#2%, #% #/2- 2&'* 2, /'+ 8+2#2H"' %. 9,':; X&2..28"6#Y $"-28< >'' >"-*,

M8V6*+?1 9E'+$2,*6 k+'-#20'a E/' V*-' %. L3*,#Gb*+&' M"-28 V%$)%-2#2%,;1 @86+8!"6 @!#+#=8,1 >)+2,0

=JWJ1 ))< QWoRB'' P2,&* 5"-$*,1

9],/'*+&G%.a M"-28 *- k'+.%+$*,8' *,& #/' \'8')#2%, %. #/' S':;1 A,!$1,3+#4,$ %5 H,9 B8$#31 3%6< DB1

,%< B1 >"$$'+ =JJI1 ))< =DKoIT'' >"-*, M8V6*+?1 9\'-)%,-' #% P2,&* 5"-$*,;1 A,!$1,3+#4,$ %5 H,9 B8$#31

3%6< DB1 ,% D1 >"$$'+ =JJI1 )< =QD?&,'?1 =JJT1 ))< I=oWQ"7*,,' V"-2841 9k'+.%+$2,0mV%$)%-2,0mU%$*,a Z+*,8'-8* V*882,2 $''#- e"&2#/ O"#6'+; 2, >*66?

M*8*+#/"+ *,& V*#' k%?,#%, X'&-Y1 B8$#3$ "&( -,.#$.$d *,& >*66? M*8*+#/"+1 9L E/%"-*,&

7/21/2019 1701-6862-1-PB

21/23

VOLUME16NUMBER2SEPT2010

268

52--%,*,8'-a M"-28 \'-'*+8/ *,& #/' S%$*&28 Z'$*6' V%$)%-'+;1C8$+!"6#"& -,.#$+ J+8(#,$1 3%6< BI1

,%< QJ1 M*+8/ BKKJ1 ))< QDoRJ"7*,,' V"-2841 9b',&'+1 M"-28%6%0? *,& Z'$2,2-$; 2, S28/%6*- V%%4 *,& M*+4 n3'+2-# X'&-'' >*66? M*8*+#/"+1 9L O'8%$2,0GC,.2,2#' V?86' 2, #/' M"-28 %. L,,' O%?&;1 V"(#3"6 B8$#3%6%0;1 3%6< D1

BKKW1 q/##)amm:::*A%, @*840+%",&1 #/"- 8%,-)28"%"- .%+ 2#- 6*84 %.

&23'+-2#? #% @' .%",& 2, L"-#+*62*'' b'+*6&2,' k*-8*661 9M%?* b'#- #/' b%G*/'*& #% &% N%--

!)'+*;1C8$+!"6#"&1 BJ S%3'$@'+ =JTD1 )< D7, -8+8!, %5 B8$#3E B",$+% 5%! +7, N#0#+"6 B8$#3 V,4%68+#%&1

O'+46'' k+'--1 O%-#%,1 BKKQ%62'1 9>%)/2' 5+2,4'+;- c2-#%+?; 2, *#/'+2,' O'+0'+%, *,& k/262) N< O%/6$*, X'&-Y1

N#$3#16#&0 B8$#3E B8$#3%6%0; "&( D+$ @"&%&$1 ],23'+-2#? %. V/28*0% k+'--1 V/28*0% *,& P%,&%,1 =JJB1 )?&,'?1 BKKT1 )< D!"&$1%$#+#%&$W

TKn627*@'#/ b%"6&1 9Z'$2,2-# E/'%+? 2, M"-28 n&"8*#2%, \'-'*+8/a b++6G266* b*$'- *- S%$*&28 k+*8#28'

X%+ c%: M"-28 n&"8*#2%, Z'66 .+%$ b+*8'Y;1 B8$#3 /(83"+#%& V,$,"!371 3%6< R1 ,%< =1 M*+8/ BKKI1 )< RW%)/2' 5+2,4'+;- c2-#%+?;d *,& V"-2841 9b',&'+1 M"-28%6%0? *,&

Z'$2,2-$;!"&$1%$#+#%&$1 )< =K