wp 2.3 status review preliminary architecture and technical feasibility 5/11/2009 dublin, ireland...
TRANSCRIPT
WP 2.3 Status Review
Preliminary architecture and technical feasibility
5/11/2009
Dublin, Ireland
GNSS for INnovative Road Applications
21/04/23 Page 2WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
PARTIES INVOLVED
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo21/04/23 Page 3WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
1. D2.3 Focused on several objectives:
1. The assessment of the technical feasibility of the proposed applications (RUC, VAS, PAYD, traffic information generation, modeling and provision)
2. The definition of the architecture to provide said services3. The assessment of the required changes on the currently available
platforms4. The definition of the interfaces among the selected elements
2. The analysis was carried out at two different levels:
1. Ideal system 2. Gina demonstrator
1. End to end2. Exhaustive trials
WP 2.3 Work Overview
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo21/04/23 Page 4WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
1. Sumer break implied a late start of the WP 2.3 activities1. This was partially taken into account when preparing the
schedule
2. Requirements analysis was successfully performed
3. Requirements have been compared with the different modules capabilities
4. Overall architecture definition complete with a slight delay1. Depended on the definition of some interfaces2. Depended on which VAS were going to be implemented
5. Analysis of adaptations required complete
6. Discusion of the interfaces among the different elements complete
7. Final report compilation with a slight delay that left little time for internal review
8. Final draft version provided for the MTR
WP 2.3 Work Status Overview
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo21/04/23 Page 5WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
1. Current position in schedule (+3 days):
REVIEW OF CURRENT STATUS
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo21/04/23 Page 6WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
1. Task Plan (Delivered: 20/07/09)
2. Final Report Structure (Delivered: 20/07/09)
3. Preliminary analysis of VAS requirements (Delivered: 27/08/09)
4. Preliminary VAS platform architecture (Delivered: 07/09/09)
5. Final VAS requirements and architecture (Delivered: 23/10/09)
6. Final Data Analysis HUB (Delivered: 26/10/09)
7. Final Draft Deliverable version (Delivered: 05/11/09)
DELIVERED ITEMS
RESULTS OF ACTIVITIES FOR DEFINITION OF ARCHITECTURE
WP 2.3: Preliminary architecture and technical feasibility
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo21/04/23 Page 8WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
1. Generic RUC platform:
RESULTS OF ACTIVITIES FOR DEFINITION OF ARCHITECTURE
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo21/04/23 Page 9WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
1. Overall GINA Architecture:
RESULTS OF ACTIVITIES FOR DEFINITION OF ARCHITECTURE
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo21/04/23 Page 10WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
Low Cost On-Board Equipment– “Smart-Obu”– Advanced GPS-GPRS functionalities– Carries out Positioning calculations– Provides current GeoObject, time and Integrity
information Supports multiple services
– Will anonymize PVT information where required for VAS
– Will only send non PVT data linked to the identity– eCALL, Fleet Management, PAYD, Accident
reconstruction, remote diagnosis, Real-time traffic info, stolen vehicle location & recovery, ETC, ‘green-journey’ determination…
Can be configured in several ways– With or without SISNeT– With or without CAN bus connection
Several configurations will be tested in post-process during the exhaustive trials
CAN Bus connection has liability issues which may void the vehicle guarantee
– Some vehicles may be fitted with the CAN bus connection under full responsibility of the end user
OBUs
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo
OBU Architecture
21/04/23 Page 11WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
Navigation manager:
Manages the GPS module and the EDAS/SISNeT connection
Extracts the info related to Lat, Long, speed and forwards it to other modules
Communications manager:
Establishes & monitors the GPRS link
Local Storage Manager:
Generates Log and/or raw data files while the system is working
Watchdog Manager:
Monitors OBU power source and system correct performance
Triggers alarm messages for OBU different failures
External Interfaces Manager:
Collects data from the different OBU external interfaces
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo
OBU Architecture (II)
21/04/23 Page 12WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
Geo-Objects Manager:
Keeps the tariff structure information
Calculates the distance, speed and time within each geo-object
Updates geo-object information
Reports the data periodically
Enforcement Manager
Verifies compliance requests against the vehicle identity
Verifies the position of the OBU against the compliance request
Handles responses to the enforcement system
System Core Manager:
Start/Stop OBU different modules
Gathers information from the different modules
Performs Data Fusion of the different info
Parse Outgoing messages (e.g. into XML)
GINA defined code for specific operations and tasks
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo
Changes Required in the OBU
21/04/23 Page 13WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
Currently configured to send PVT data periodically to the CI
– Not compliant with the ABvM privacy requirements
Can only send aggregated data to the CI
– Shall perform the geo-object usage calculations
– New data types to accomodate for the tariff structure
– New Geo-object types– Interface adaptations to update/change the
tariff structure
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo
Toll Service Provider Platform
21/04/23 Page 14WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
Logical Structure of the platform– Middleware handles
access to OBUs– Technical layer performs
data fusion of the information coming from the OBUs
– Technical layer provides access to the data to the core services
• Aggregated Geo data• OBU information reports
– Information provided by the core services is available through a Web Services interface
• Can be processed and formatted to provide added value services
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo21/04/23 Page 15WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
Palview GINA Platform:– Middleware + Back-end +
RUC Module– Information provision to other
modules– Information Storage– OBE Remote configuration– Communication with the
OBUs– OBU software update– Secure access management– Standard Interfaces to VSPs
through web services– Tariff information and
payment generation– Graphical User Interface– Report and data analysis
generation– OBE Remote configuration
Toll Service Provider Platform
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo21/04/23 Page 16WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
Palview® is composed by a Core Infrastructure which gives flexibility for supporting different services
– Interface between equipments and Services Providers
– Responsible of collecting, processing and centralising location-based information
– Guarantees Data Privacy to users
Palview® Main Modules Communications Mngt Database Mngt Cartography/Maps Mngt Administration/Control module Equipment Diagnosis module (incl. Automatic FW
updating)
Acting as a “LBS-Middleware”: no functionality is directly offered to the final users
No PVT information will be retrieved by the system, only reporting for RUC and additional services
PALVIEW ARCHITECTURE
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo21/04/23 Page 17WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
Application Manager– Administration of equipment configurations. – Control of equipment software updates. – Administration of automatic system tasks, for
example, automatic dumps, anti-theft, etc Equipment (OBU) communications module
– Translates between the OBU and the CI data formats
Data Storage module– stores all the logs received from the mobile
equipment in the database including:• Usage of geo-objects by type and hour • Km travelled by geo-object type and hour• Bytes transferred during communications with the
mobile equipment by the mobile equipment. Reports module
– Generates reports from the logs on the database
GEO (Geographic Object) module– Manages the tariff structure, pricing and timing – Updates the information in the OBUs
Web Service API– platform access interface
CORE INFRASTRUCTURE (Palview)
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo21/04/23 Page 18WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
CI interface– Web service based interface with the CI
Billing module– Get the charge-object usage information from the core platform– Classify the information about the geo-objects usage per OBU– Associate the OBU information with the vehicle where the vehicle is
installed– Apply the tariffs in effect in the moment that the usage was incurred:
• Per km travelled• By area/specific road/road class• By time of the day/day of the week• By vehicle class• Add additional fixed charges for crossing cordons/boundaries/gantries
– Store the information back in the CI Web interface (CRM)
– Manage the security of the online access– Access to the end-user information– Update personal information– Update accounting information– Manage the vehicles of an account– Modify the association between vehicles
and OBUs on their account
RUC Module (Palview)
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo
Changes Required in the CI
Interfaces adaptation to new modules– New Web Services Development
Inclusion of Pricing and Tariff Structure Management of geographical
information– Aggregated or anonymised to comply
with ABvM privacy requirements– Modification of tariff structure uploaded
to the OBUs New Reports to be implemented
– To suit Data Analysis requirements– To fulfill VSPs requirements
Development of the RUC module– Customized user interface for the GINA
project– Front-end pricing information calculation
21/04/23 Page 19PRESENTATION TITLE VERDANA (9)
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo
SERVICE CENTRE (RITA)
– Collect and store traffic data• Data used for shadow tolling • Several traffic indicators:
– Traffic Volume– Average speed– Occupation– Intensity– Density
– Support for traffic management• Fault detection (road equipment faults)• Alarm detection
– Automatic incident detection– Meteorology– Tunnel events (smoke, fire, CO2 levels, …)
• Road management• Audit management• Incident management
21/04/23 Page 20WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo
SERVICE CENTRE (RITA)
21/04/23 Page 21WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
Equipment Services
CAV PTZPMV PGV
DVR MV OSD
Drivers
CAV PTZPMV PGV
DVR MV OSD
Meteo
Meteo
RITA BrokerOperator Terminal
Devices Array
Audit Manager
Traffic Manager
Equipment Manager
Fault Manager
Schedule Manager
Warnings Manager
Data Access Layer (DAL)
Operator TerminalTunnel UIRoad Map
Video Viewer
ESRI PluginCustom Controls
Device Consoles
Windows Forms
Custom Controls
GIS DB
Reports Logic ProviderReports Presentation Layer
IISMS SQL Reporting
ServicesMS SQL Reporting
Services
Port Comm
Tunnel DAI
Tunnel DAI
Import Manager
RITA DB
RITA Reports DB
RITA Reports DW DBIIS
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo
RITA ARCHITECTURE
Data Access Layer– RITA– RITA Reports– RITA Reports DW
– The GIS DB is quite different, as it is stored in .MXD files used directly by the ArcGIS engine and represent the entire concession roads and equipments.
RITA Reports– Data Import Service– Reports Provider (Microsoft Reporting Services)
– HTTP access– Export reports in several formats
(excel, pdf, …)– RITA server independent– Easily replacable by another
reports tool without changingthe system arquitecture
21/04/23 Page 22WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo
RITA ARCHITECTURE
User Interface – Multilanguage support– Access based on user profile
Divided into 5 components:– Equipment consoles
• maintenance, general equipament control
– Operator Terminal• Gives controlled access to all RITA funcionalities
– Roap Map• GIS map implementation
– Video Viewer• Up to 4 simultaneous camera views
– Tunnel UI
21/04/23 Page 23WP 2.3 STATUS REVIEW
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo
Value Added Services
Pay as You Drive Charging Scheme
Tracking of Fleet Vehicles– Display Vehicles Position– Incident Response Time– Validation of Contractual Obligations
21/04/23 Page 24WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
Central System
EnforcementReports
Reporting Services
GINA UI
ADO Net
VAS Components
MOVILOC
Enforcement Logic
TCP/IP
VAS
PAYDLogic
Tracking LogicVAS
ADO Net
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo
Value Added Services
Overall Architecture– Equipments Layer
• Moviloc• ANPR
– Server Layer• Drivers• Services• Broker
– UI Layer• Operator UI• Reports
21/04/23 Page 25WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
GIS DAL
System DAL
GINA DAL
Relational
Storage
Enforcement
Reports
OperatorTerminal
GINA UI
.Net Remoting
ANPR Solution
Equipment Layer
UI Layer
Server Layer
Server Layer TCP/IPTCP/IP
ANPR Service
ArcGIS
AD
O N
et
IService
GIS
MOVILOC Connector
OBU Service
Broker
Traffic ManagerFault Manager
ANPR Faults
PVT Faults
Reporting Services
Admin ConsoleGINA
ConfigurationSystem
Configuration
Traffic Management
GISRITA GIS
GINA GIS
ANPR Console
OBU Console
Relational
Reports
Enforcement Reports
Enforcement Handler
IDriver
ANPR Driver OBU Driver
PortCommunication
VAS Manager
PAYD Handler
Tracking Handler
Segment Passages
Incident Arrival Time
PAYD
Tracking
PAYDReports
TrackingReports
VAS Management
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo
Value Added Services
OBU Handler Architecture– Information enters the
system by a driver and service
– Information is handled bythe VAS Manager in RITA
21/04/23 Page 26WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
System DAL
Service Interface
Broker
Ser
vice
In
terf
ace
OBU Service
Driver Interface
Service Interface
Bro
ker
Inte
rfa
ce
OBU Console
OBU Driver
Alarm Publisher
Fault Publisher
Service Poll Handler
Equipment Poll Handler
OBU Data Handler
GIN
A V
h.
Usa
ge
Su
bscr
iber
Usage Validator
Poll Handler
Fault Handler
Alarm Handler
GIN
A V
h.
Usa
ge
Pu
blis
her
Service Registering
Handler
FaultManager
EquipmentManager
Service Registering
HandlerEquipment Poll
Service Poll
Contains the Broker and all Managers
Interfaces
PVT Parser
Publish/Subscriber
Publish/Subscriber
WarningsManager
Fault Subscriber
Alarm Subscriber
.Net Remoting
Publish/Subscriber
.Net Remoting
Publish/Subscriber
.Net Remoting
.Net Remoting
Direct Call
The service contains a list of running drivers.
Each driver is an instance in the service memory
TrafficManager
MOVILOC Connector
MOVILOC
Request-Reply Web Service
PVT Error Handling
Vehicle Usage Publisher
Publish/SubscriberOBU Request
Handler
Enforcement Handler
Enforcement
ADO Net
TCP/IP
.Net Remoting
Vehicle Usage Subscriber
GIN
A V
h.
Usa
ge
Pu
blis
her
GIN
A V
h.
Usa
ge
Su
bscr
iber
VAS Manager
.Net Remoting
VAS
ADO Net
GINA Vh. Usage
Subscriber
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo
Value Added Services
VAS Handler Architecture– Data has 2 paths
• PAYD Data• Tracking Data
– PAYD data can be processed in batch (end of day)
– Tracking Data has a real-time meaning
21/04/23 Page 27WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
Broker Interface
Sys
tem
DA
L
VAS Handler
OBU Handler
VAS
PAYDResult
Handler
Reports
Reporting Services
GINA UI
TrackingDisplay
ADO Net
Tra
ckin
g P
ublis
her
Tra
ckin
g S
ubsc
riber
OBU Service
PAYD Handler
VASManagement
Tracking Handler
TrackingResult
Handler
ADO Net
GINA Vh. Usage
Subscriber
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo
Enforcement
Detects anomalies on the Vehicles OBUs– ANPR Solution for enforcement– A Vehicle is Detected by ANPR solution -> Central System Validates
detection with OBU on the vehicle
21/04/23 Page 28WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
Compliance UnitCentral System
Enforcement
Reports (Enforcement)
Reporting Services
GINA UI
AD
O N
et
Enforcement Results Publish
Enforcement Results Subscriber
Only publishes notifications related to anomalies detected
MOVILOC
Compliance Unit UI
Enforcement Results Subscriber
ANPR Solution
ANPR DataEnforcement Logic
Queries OBUs foir position by
given time
TCP/IP
TCP/IP
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo
Enforcement Architecture
Overall Architecture– Equipments Layer
• Moviloc• ANPR
– Server Layer• Drivers• Services• Broker
– UI Layer• Operator UI• Reports
21/04/23 Page 29WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
System DAL
Enforcement
Reports
Operator Terminal
GINA UI
.Net Remoting
ANPR Solution
TCP/IPTCP/IP
ANPR Service
ADO Net
IService
MOVILOCConnector
OBU Service
.Net Remoting
Broker
Traffic ManagerFault Manager
ANPR Faults
PVT Faults
Reporting Services
Admin ConsoleGINA
ConfigurationSystem
Configuration
ANPR Console
OBU Console
Relational
Reports
Enforcement Reports
Enforcement Handler
IDriver
ANPR Driver OBU Driver
PortCommunication
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo
Enforcement Architecture
ANPR Handler Architecture– Information enters the system
by a driver and service– Information is handled by
the enforcement handler in RITA
21/04/23 Page 30WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
System DAL
Broker
Service Interface
Ser
vice
Inte
rfac
e
Driver Interface
Service Interface
Bro
ker
Inte
rfac
e
ANPR Service
ANPR Driver
Alarm Publisher
Fault Publisher
Service Poll Handler
Equipment Poll Handler
GIN
A A
NP
R
Pub
lishe
rG
INA
AN
PR
S
ubsc
riber
Poll Handler
Fault Handler
Alarm Handler
GIN
A A
NP
R
Pub
lishe
r
Service Registering
Handler
FaultManager
EquipmentManager
Service Registering
HandlerEquipment Poll
Service Poll
Contains the Broker and all Managers
Interfaces
ANPR Parser
Publish/Subscriber
WarningsManager
Fault Subscriber
Alarm Subscriber
Publish/Subscriber
.Net Remoting
Publish/Subscriber
.Net Remoting
.Net Remoting
Direct CallThe service contains a list of running drivers.
Each driver is an instance in the service
memory
TrafficManager
GINA ANPR Subscriber
Enforcement Handler
ANPR Receiver
ANPR Solution
ADO Net
PortCommunication
PVT Console
GIN
A P
VT
S
ubsc
riber
Publish/Subscriber .Net Remoting
TCP/IP
Allows for individual and batch reception
Enforcement
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo
Enforcement Architecture
OBU Handler Architecture– Information enters the system
by a driver and service– Information is handled by
the enforcement handler in RITA
21/04/23 Page 31WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
System DAL
Service Interface
Broker
Se
rvic
e I
nte
rfa
ce
OBU Service
Driver Interface
Service Interface
Bro
ker
Inte
rfa
ce
OBU Console
OBU Driver
Alarm Publisher
Fault Publisher
Service Poll Handler
Equipment Poll Handler
GIN
A P
VT
P
ublis
her
GIN
A P
VT
S
ubsc
riber
OBU Data Handler
GIN
A P
VT
S
ubsc
riber
PVT Validator
Poll Handler
Fault Handler
Alarm Handler
GIN
A P
VT
P
ublis
her
Service Registering
Handler
FaultManager
EquipmentManager
Service Registering
HandlerEquipment Poll
Service Poll
Contains the Broker and all Managers
Interfaces
PVT ParserPVT
Subscriber
Publish/Subscriber
Publish/Subscriber
WarningsManager
Fault Subscriber
Alarm Subscriber
.Net Remoting
Publish/Subscriber
.Net Remoting
Publish/Subscriber
.Net Remoting
.Net Remoting
Direct Call
The service contains a list of running drivers.
Each driver is an instance in the service memory
TrafficManager
MOVILOC Connector
MOVILOC
Request-Reply Web Service
PVT Error Handling
PVT Publisher
Publish/Subscriber
OBU Request Handler
Enforcement Handler
Enforcement
ADO Net
TCP/IP
.Net Remoting
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo
Enforcement Architecture
Enforcement Handler Architecture– Receives data from ANPR and
OBU– Checks enforcement rules– Publishes results
21/04/23 Page 32WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
Sys
tem
DA
L
Enforcement Handler
GINA ANPR Subscriber
ANPR Handler
OBU Handler
Enforcer
EnforcementResult
Handler
Reports (Enforcement)
Reporting Services
GINA UI
Enforcement Results Display
ADO Net
En
forc
emen
t Res
ults
P
ubl
ishe
r
En
forc
emen
t R
esul
ts S
ubsc
riber
Only shows notifications related to anomalies detected
OBU Service
Compliance Unit UI
Enforcement Results Display
En
forc
emen
t R
esul
ts S
ubsc
riber
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo21/04/23 Page 33WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
1. The comunication channel among the obus and the main infrastructure will be done by GPRS/UMTS
2. Reports will be send daily for each vehicle with only the RUC data (smart OBU)
1. This optimizes bandwidth and server usage
3. For Tracking Data the position is sent, at smaller intervals (30seconds)
1. Needs Special users authorization
4. Communication among other elements will be through a secure internet access
COMMUNICATIONS
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo21/04/23 Page 34WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
1. Two reference systems will be used for the exhaustive trials
1. A trajectography + DGPS positioning system provided by GMV
2. A precise receiver providing matching against geo-objects provided by NavTeq
2. The summary of the information collected by the reference equipment was sent to TRL on 08/09/09
1. Position2. Protection levels3. Current GeoObject4. Etc.
REFERENCE SYSTEM
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo21/04/23 Page 35WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
DATA ANALYSIS HUB
Two Types of Analysis– Exhaustive: Comparing system behavior against
known truth– Usage (end-to-end) : Recording usage over time and
geography to determine driver behavior Both objectives can be met using the following
sample statistics produced by the HUB on a per journey basis
Data Analysis platform:– Road Network, Charge Object and Route Data stored
in the HUB database. – Information about vehicle, driver and journeys
travelled retrieved and stored– The OBU uploads data at an agreed interval to the
file system– The HUB services framework monitors for new files
and processes them– The HUB services saves the results into the database. – Reporting and statistical analysis tools (e.g. R and
BIRT) are used to aggregate the data– The HUB web GUI allows for the dissemination of the
analysis
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo
DATA ANALYSIS HUB Key Elements:
– OBUs• Provide usage data
– Reference system• Provides truth data
– File System• Accepts and stores data files from the devices
– Workflow• Decides based on the file type the type of data in use (vehicle
position, road usage, charge object usage) and forwards it to the relevant processor
– Vehicle Position Processor• Processes the cross-track and absolute error calculations
against the reference device for statistical analysis.
– Road Usage Processor• Processes the road/segment usage data against underlying
truth data as represented by an ordered list of road segments.
– Charge Object Usage Processor• Uploads the charge object usage data into the database.
– HUB Database• Stores the results from the processors and the relational
representation of the underlying vector mapping.
– HUB Web GUI• Presents the results of the HUB analysis component.
– HUB Analysis• Uses open source technologies, e.g. BIRT, R, in order to output
stats on the performance of the system in relation to the data processed against truth data.
21/04/23 Page 36WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo21/04/23 Page 37WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
1. HUB Sample Web Implementation
DATA ANALYSIS HUB
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo21/04/23 Page 38WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
1. Analysis of requirements complete
2. Overall architecture definition complete
3. Interface definition complete
4. Final Draft Delivered
1. Feedback and comments will be incorporated to the draft
5. First feedback by consortium members being integrated in the document
1. Core Infrastructure architecture revision2. GNSS signal Spoofing discussion to be included in the deliverable
DELIVERABLE STATUS
GNSS for Innovative road Applications
Company’s
logo21/04/23 Page 39WP2.3 STATUS REVIEW
1. Strict Dutch ABvM privacy requirements
1. Hinders most VAS implementation2. Hinders enforcement implementation
1.Searching for alternative implementations
2. Interdependance with trial definition
1. Not relevant for final platform2. Necessary for the demonstrator platform definition
3. Late release of contributions
1. Delayed integration and review process
MAIN OBSTACLES
Thank you