wheat processing and product development: a training
TRANSCRIPT
Presented by Tamirat Kore
Agricultural Quality Research Laboratory, Addis Ababa
December 31, 2015
Introduction of wheat
Nutritional composition and health benefits of wheat
Types of wheat
Quality of wheat
Wheat milling process
Types of flour
Wheat products
Bread
Biscuits and cookies
Pasta, macaroni and cookies
Yeast raised doughnut
Wheat is the most important staple food crop for more than
one third of the world population
Globally, wheat is the leading source of vegetable protein in
human food, having higher protein content and more calories
than maize or rice, the other major cereals.
It is nutritious and easy to store and can be processed into
various types of food.
It is an excellent health building food
Wheat is considered as a good source of protein,
minerals, B-group vitamins and dietary fiber
Although the environmental conditions can affect
nutritional composition of wheat grain with its essential
coating of bran, vitamins and minerals.
Wheat grain is stable food used to make flour for
leavened, flat, and steamed breads, biscuits, cookies,
cakes, breakfast cereals, pasta, and noodle and for
fermentation to make beer, other alcoholic beverage.
Wheat Composition
•Carbohydrate 70%
•Protein 9-15%
•Fat 2-2.2%
•Fiber 2-2.5%
•Ash 1.8 %
•Moisture 9-13%
Wheat is one of the most important foods in a balanced
diet
The nutrition community recommends that 55-60
percent of our daily calories come from carbohydrates.
Also, no more than 30 percent of our calories should
come from fat, and approximately 12-15 percent of
calories should be derived from protein.
Clearly, calories acquired from carbohydrates such as
wheat products are the healthiest and most important to
incorporate in our diets.
Complex carbohydrates provide essential nutrients, are
less likely to be stored as fat and more likely to be
stored as muscle fuel
So, what’s in wheat that makes it so healthy?
One major component in wheat which is only found in
plant foods is dietary fiber.
Dietary fiber is the carbohydrate in food which humans
cannot digest.
sweep out the digestive tract as well as satisfying a Fiber
acts as a broom to appetite longer
One slice of whole wheat bread contains 2 grams of
dietary fiber; one slice of white bread contains 0.5 grams;
and one ounce of wheat bran cereal contains between 8
and 9 grams of dietary fiber.
The American Dietetic Association recommends eating
20-35 grams of fiber each day, but on average
Insoluble fiber
Found in wheat bran and whole grains,
Insoluble fiber passes through the digestive system quickly,
promoting regularity and reducing the risk of colon
irregularities or diverticulosus, a type of colon disease.
Research suggests foods containing insoluble fiber may also
help reduce the risk of colon and breast cancer when part of
a low-fat diet.
Soluble fiber–
Found in oats, beans, some fruits and vegetables and refined
white flour products.
Studies indicate foods containing soluble fiber may help
decrease blood pressure and cholesterol levels, helping to
reduce the risk of heart disease.
They may also help control blood sugar levels in people
with diabetes.
Thiamin (B1)-
Needed daily for good appetite, digestion, and healthy nerves.
It also helps the body make better use of fat and carbohydrates.
Riboflavin (B2)-
This vitamin is essential for the use of protein by the body.
Niacin (B3)-
This is the “anti-pellagra” vitamin.
Pellagra is a nutrient deficient disease that has been virtually eliminated since the enrichment of white flour products.
Iron
Iron is essential for providing our bodies with energy.
Iron acts in this way by carrying oxygen from the lungs to
muscles and other parts of the body.
A deficiency of iron causes a disease known as anemia which
results in a lack of energy.
Protein
Wheat foods provide 2-4 grams of protein per one ounce serving.
Six to seven ounces of protein per day are required for the average teenager and adult.
Protein is an important component of every cell in the body.
Hair and nails are mostly made of protein. Our body uses protein to build and repair tissues and use protein to make enzymes, hormones, and other body chemicals.
Protein is an important building block of bones, muscles, cartilage, skin, and blood
Wheat cultivars are further classified in terms of wheat
hardness, protein content, and protein quality.
1. Hard wheat
They have high gluten content(higher protein quantity and
quality)
When hard wheat is milled the endosperm cells separate along
the cell wall margin into easily sifted particles
It has high extraction of white flour
Hard types tend to have possessing a vitreous
endosperm with starch granules tightly packed in a
protein.
During milling, some starch grains are damaged,
resulting in an increased surface area that leads to
higher water absorption
The bran is easily separated from the endosperm
It capable of high water absorption during dough
production
2. Soft wheat The gluten content is low
Soft wheat has much lower extraction rate
The flour consists of a mass of fine cell debris with poor
flow characteristics
The softer wheat have a less compact starch-protein
complex which results in less starch damage and lower
water absorption.
The protein level of soft wheat is usually lower, producing
less resistant, more extensible dough
It is required for biscuit making
3. Durum wheat It is the hardest wheat grown
Durum wheat is suitable for pasta and macaroni
It is most often ground into a granular flour with a light
yellow color known as semolina, which has the ideal
properties for making the best pasta
Durum is high in protein and gluten, which are necessary
for making good pasta
It is occasionally used for baked goods (especially risen
breads), but it is not used for this purpose as often as other
wheat varieties.
1. Physical
2. Chemical
3. Botanical
Physical
◦ Test weight (HLW)
◦ 1000 kernel weight
◦ Hardness
◦ Color
◦ Impurities
◦ milling quality
◦ virtuousness
2. Chemical
Moisture
protein content
alph-amylase
ash or color grade value
fat acidity
3. Botanical- commercially important wheat’s falls under three
species (Triticum aestitivum, Triticum compactum and
Triticum Durum)
Test weight/Hectoliter weight
Test weight, measured as weight of grain per unit
volume, is the simplest and most widely predictor for a
grain’s milling quality.
Test weight per bushel is a grading factor
Test weight is defined kg/hl
Wheat 74kg/hl =poor, 78kg/hl=good and 82kg/hl=very
good
Wet gluten
Gluten is prepared by washing out most of the starch and soluble from a piece of dough developed from flour and water.
The wet gluten can be examined visually for its color and elasticity. The required sample:-10g of flour, 20g salt, 1000ml of waterProcedure
Take 10g of flour and added to dish Add 5-6ml of 2% NaCl solution Then mix well for 8-10 minutes, and then put for 10 minute in
distilled water After 10 minutes, then wash carefully with 300-400ml of NaCl
solution. Press it to remove the water by using small presser Weight in the balance Calculate the percentage of the gluten content by multiplying with
10.
Wheat flour is the most important ingredient in home
baking
It is the framework for almost every commercially
baked product and pasta.
Of the grains available for the production of flour,
wheat is unique
It is the only cereal grain with sufficient gluten content
to make a typical loaf of bread without being mixed
with other grains
There are three part of wheat kernel (wheat berry)
Wheat Flour cont….
The wheat kernel consists of the bran, endosperm and germ.
Bran is the hard outer covering of the wheat kernel
◦ Botanically known as coat of many layers, precarp, seed coat,
hyaline, aleurone layer.
◦ It is high in fiber and nutrients
Endosperm constitutes more than 80% by weight the inside of
the kernel-mostly starch
Germ is the nutrient rich embryo that will sprout and grow into a
new wheat plant.
◦ major distinctive part of the germ are embryonic axis and
scutellum
Wheat berry Part %
Bran Preicarp and testa 6.4
Aleurone layer 6.7
Endosperm Starchy endosperm 84.1
Germ embryonic axis 1.3
scutellum 1.5
Total 100
Bran All purpose flour
1. All-purpose flour
is a product of the ground endosperm of hard wheat or a
combination of hard and soft wheat kernels.
It can be used for
any recipe requiring flour such as breads, cakes, and pastries;
as a coating for meat, vegetables, and other food items
intended for frying or sautéing;
and as a thickening agent for gravies, sauces, and stews.
All-purpose flour is available in bleached, unbleached
and enriched
1.1. Enriched all-purpose flour has iron and B-
vitamins (thiamine, niacin, and riboflavin) added in
amounts equal to or exceeding that in whole wheat
flour.
1.2. Unbleached all-purpose flour
Unbleached all-purpose flour is bleached by oxygen
in the air during an aging process and is off-white in
color.
Nutritionally, bleached and unbleached flour are
equivalent.
1.3. Bleached all-purpose flour
It is exposed to chlorine gas or benzoyl peroxide to
whiten and brighten flour color.
Chlorine also affects baking quality by “maturing” or
oxidizing the flour, which is beneficial for cake and
cookie baking.
The bleaching agents react and do not leave harmful
residues or destroy nutrients.
2. Bread flour
It is ground form the endosperm of the hard red spring wheat kernel.
Bread flour is similar to all purpose flour, but it has greater gluten strength and is generally used for yeast breads.
The high gluten content is necessary in order for bread to rise effectively.
The use of bread flour results in larger bread loaves with a lighter and less crumbly texture.
Bread flour is unbleached, high-gluten flour that typically contains 99.9 % hard wheat flour with malted barley added to increase the yeast activity, making it ideal for bread making.
Bread flour is also referred to as unbleached flour.
3. Cake flour
Cake flour is produced from the endosperm portion of
the wheat kernel of soft wheat varieties.
It is high in starch and has a low protein content, which
means that it contains very little gluten, making it
suitable for cake recipes.
It is especially suitable for cakes, cookies, crackers, and
pastries.
If cake flour is not available, cornstarch makes a good
substitute.
4. Pastry flour
Pastry flour is produced from soft-wheat and it has a fine-texture and a high starch content, but less starch than cake flour.
It is milled from a soft, low gluten wheat and is used for pastries.
Pastry flour is finely ground, but it is not as fine as cake flour.
It is available in bleached and unbleached varieties and is most often used for making flaky pie crusts, cookies, biscuits, and assorted pastries.
5. Semolina Flour
Semolina flour is available coarsely ground or ground
twice for a fine texture with a light yellow color
It is the coarsely ground endosperm of durum wheat
which is used almost exclusively for making pasta.
Durum wheat has the ideal properties for making the
best pasta.
It is high in protein and gluten, which are used to create
high quality pasta products such as macaroni and
spaghetti
6.Whole-Wheat Flour
Whole-wheat flour is produced from grinding the full wheat berry (kernel).
All parts of the wheat berry are used in the flour including the bran, germ, and the endosperm, which when milled, creates the speckled brown color that is characteristic of the flour
Three granulations (particle size) of whole-wheat are produced: fine, medium, and coarse.
The particle size influences the rate liquid is absorbed into the flour.
Finer grained flour absorbs liquid at a faster rate than medium or coarse grains, thus affecting the preparation of the dough.
Fine grain whole-wheat flour is used for all types of baked goods, such as breads, rolls, and pastries.
Medium grained can be used for the same types of foods, but will provide a coarser crumb.
Coarse whole-wheat flour has a much larger bran particle and consequently is most often used to provide breads with natural, nutty flavors and rough textures.
WHITE FLOUR is made from endosperm only= not whole grain
WHOLE WHEAT FLOUR combines all 3 parts of the wheat kernel=whole grain
Quality parameters of the flour such as color, protein, granulation distribution, gluten quantity and quality, and starch damage play a role in the suitability of flour for the baker.
Physical test:- Color, milling quality and Virtuousness.
Chemical test:-Moisture, protein, fiber, starch, mineral content and color grade
Amounts and types of final products vary among mills are a result of differences in flow-sheet, adjustments, and
kinds of wheat milled
Flours from the different stages in the mill are not identical in physical appearance, chemical analysis, or baking
properties.
Another important factor besides the determination of quality is the concept of flour uniformity
Optimum flour granulation distribution is an important parameter for the baking process.
Drastic change in granulation effects on water absorption, water retention during
fermentation, proofing, and
quality of finished breads.
Flour color depends on wheat cleanliness,
tempering level,
fineness of flour, and
the amount of bran particles it contains.
Too much fine bran effects flour shade, producing a darker shade.
Change in mill ambient conditions could also affect flour color.
Mixing of different quality wheat varieties so as to meet desired product quality.
Blending is mostly done on protein basis.
Hard wheat varieties are blended with soft wheat varieties in order to obtain the desired level of protein content in the resulting flour.
Traditional wheat product used in Ethiopia
Wheat Nifro and Qolo Wheat Injera Difo Dabo Chechebsa Dabo qolo Kitta
Wheat products In world Bread Biscuits Cookies Pastry Cakes Macaroni Pasta Noodle Beer and alcoholic
beverage
1. BREAD It is yeast leavened wheat product Bread is made by many different procedures. The particular procedures used depend on
tradition, the amount (cost) and type of energy
available the type and consistency of the flour
available, the type of bread desired, and the time between baking and eatingWhat are the major recipes?
The major ingredients for bread making are wheat flour, yeast, water and salt
The other ingredients are fat, sugar, milk or milk solids, oxidants, enzymes, surfactants, and additives to protect against molds.
Flour is responsible for the structure of the bread and it allows the formation of visco-elastic that retains gas.
Yeast is the major role to convert fermentable carbohydrates into Co2 and ethanol.
The gases provide the lift that produces a light or leavened loaf of bread.
The Salt functions in bread making are taste and affect rheological properties.
It makes dough stronger by shielding charges on the dough protein.
The last fundamental ingredient is water which is a
plasticizer and solvent. Shortening/oil-bread stays soft and more palatable for a
long period of time.
giving increased volume to bread
acts as a plasticizer in dough
Sugar- It is source of fermentable carbohydrates for the yeast
It provides a sweet taste to the bread
Oxidants- ascorbic acid, potassium bromate, and calcium peroxide at level PPM
improve dough strength and results in bread with better loaf volume and texture.
The processing of bread can be divided into three basic operations:
mixing or dough formation,
fermentation, and
baking
Two procedures1. Straight-dough system
2. Sponge-and dough process
Type of breada. Pan bread
b. Baguettes and Hearth breads
c. Flat breads
d. Buns
e. Croissants
Bread ingredients
The basic dough formula for 500 g flour consisted of salt (7.5 g), yeast (5 g), baking powder (4 g) and water, which needed to have a consistency
Procedures for bread making
Mix 500g of the flour with small amount of water little by little
Then add and mix 5gm of yeast, 7.5gm of sugar, 5gm of salt (Common salt) and 0.5gm improvers to the flour.
If the dough creates a smooth surface then it’s enough for water observation and extruding.
After mixing, the dough will be placed in the fermentation cabinet at a temperature of 30°C and 85% RH for 45 min.
Then again set for 2nd development for 20 minutes
After fermenting the dough divided and molded using a dough-forming device and put into pans for the final proofing.
The dough samples will ferment until they reach 2 cm above the rim and then baked.
The baking oven temperature reaches to 230-260°c for 20-22 minutes
Cool the bread loaves at room temperature for 5min
Test the color of the bread(crumb, sponge)
Test the weight
Test volume(texture)
Test water absorption
Flow sheet for the straight dough procedure of bread processingAll formula ingredients
Mix to optimum development
Ferment for 100 min
Punch (Mixing 2or more)
Ferment for 55 min
DivideIntermediate proofing for 25 min
Mold and pan
Proofing for 55 min
Baking
The main ingredients for biscuits and cookies production are
wheat flour, fat (shortening), sweeteners (sugar), Leavening agents (baking powder), eggs, milk, salt and flavors.
Wheat flour Wheat gluten generally determines the suitability of
flour for biscuit making.
The softer wheat have a less compact starch-protein complex which results in less starch damage and lower water absorption.
The protein level of soft wheat is usually lower, producing less resistant, more extensible dough.
Soft wheat is a unique blend of white, soft grained wheat varieties.
Less starch damage from soft wheat flour thus occurs which favors an increase in biscuit diameter.
Flour protein levels needed for biscuit making typically range from 7 to10% and are often selected by functionality for end use , price, and availability
The flour protein has a major influence on biscuit quality and in particular, on its diameter.
The quantity and quality of the protein present in flour have a major role in influencing the rheological behavior, particularly when flour is the major constituent of the formula.
Sweeteners (sugar) All biscuit formula contains sweeteners, which contain
the bulk of dissolved material in most dough. It contributes to texture, flavor, sweetness and color in
biscuit The quantity, granulation and type of sugar used
influence the quality of biscuits Sucrose, a non-reducing disaccharide, is the common
sugar used in biscuit preparation The continuing change in texture and development of
the final crispness has been attributed to slow crystallization of sucrose from concentrated sugar syrup formed during the earlier stage of processing
Up on cooling, much of it crystallizes and strongly affects the texture of baked biscuits.
Sugars functionality in biscuits systems includes more than only imparting sweetness
Shortening (Fat)
Fat are used as surface sprays in cream filling and coating and as
release agents
Fat functionality is very versatile in baked products that include
providing of flavor and mouth feel and contributes to the
appearance, palatability and texture of the biscuits
Fat is the principal recipe responsible for tenderness, keeping
quality, grain and texture and it adding a rich quality to biscuit.
Mechanical properties of biscuit are largely dependent on the fat
components of the formulation
Water
Water is often a processing aid or catalyst, rather than as an
ingredients.
Water functions in several ways, including
hydrating flour protein and starch,
dissolving sugars, salt and various leavening chemicals
aiding in ingredient distribution and
helping control dough temperature
A dough consistency is directly related to its water content or
absorption.
Water activity is an important way to measure and monitor water
mobility in baked products.
Baking powder (Leavening Agent)
Leavening agent aerates the dough to make light and porous
It is responsible for good volume, improved eating quality and
uniform cell structure.
Mostly used leaving agents are sodium bicarbonate and sodium
Meta bisulfate
Other Ingredients
Other ingredients include milk, egg, salt, honey and aerating
agents.
Milk and eggs are a good source of protein and lactose, which aid
in shape retention and browning reaction.
Salt perform two principal functions in biscuit dough. The first is
flavor and controls fermentation and aids in suppressing
undesirable bacteria as a second function of salt
Biscuit dough generally falls into two broad categories- hard and soft
dough.
The visco-elastic properties of hard dough represent the presence of a
protein (gluten) matrix which is developed during mixing and
sheeting.
During baking, the biscuit may continue to shrink in outline, but
become thicker.
Soft dough does not have formed gluten structure, because of their
high levels of shortening and sugar, and are generally mealy or sandy
in texture.
Dough pieces formed from soft dough tend to retain their shape until
baking, but then they spread or flow, becoming thinner.
Dough undergoes several changes during baking:
Changes in dimension and texture,
loss of moisture, and
color and flavor development are the most important.
Baking is divided into three phases.
The first involves dough expansion and the start of moisture loss.
Dough expansion and water loss reach maximum rates and color
development start during second phase.
The third phase concludes baking with a lower rate moisture loss,
thinning of the biscuit, and increasing surface area
Biscuit ingredients Biscuit dough will be prepared using a mixture of
wheat flour 100g, sugar powder 30 g, shortening 20 g; skimmed milk powder 2 g; sodium chloride 1 g; ammonium bicarbonate 1 g and sodium bicarbonate 0.5 g.
Biscuit preparation 1. Sugar, fat and skimmed milk powder will be
creamed in the mixer for 2 min at 121 rpm and 5 min at 173 rpm, respectively.
2. Add water containing sodium chloride, ammonium bicarbonate and sodium bicarbonate to the above cream and mix for 5–6 min at 121 rpm to obtain a homogenous cream.
3. Finally wheat flour will be added and mixed for 3 min at 60 rpm.
4. Dough will be sheeted/molded using a rolling pin to a thickness of 3.5mm with the help of an aluminum platform and frame
5. Biscuits will be shaped with a cutter of 55mm diameter and baked on an aluminum tray at 200 °C for 9–10 min when a very light brown color form before removal of the biscuit
6. It allows cooling and storing at atmospheric temperature.
Cookies makingCookies ingredients
Cookies with straight grade wheat flour (500 g), sugar (250 g), hydrogenated vegetable ghee (250 g), eggs (60 g each) and baking powder (10 g).
Preparation of cookies1. Weigh the ingredients accurately
2. Mix vegetable ghee (oil) and sugar, then add eggs one by one.
3. The straight grade flour are homogenously mixed and blended with baking powder and sifted.
4. Add the flour to sugar ghee- egg mass and mix to get a homogeneous mass.
5. Roll the batter with uniform thickness with the help of the rolling pin
6. Cookies will be cut out with the help of cookie cutter and placed in trays.
7. Baking will be done at 170–180 °C for 15–20 min.
8. Cookies will be allowed to cool at room temperature for 8–10 min and stored in airtight glass jars
Flow chart for the preparation of Biscuit and cookies
Wheat flour, Water and baking ingredient
Weighing
Mixing
Kneading
Shaping
Baking (175 0C for 20 min)
Cooling
Storage
Pasta
Pasta products are produced/made are semolina (wheat flour), water and other optional ingredients.
The wheat flour (semolina) which consists of fine particles of uniform size and produces the highest quality of pasta products.
Macaroni
The raw material of macaroni products produced from wheat flour, water and other optional ingredients.
The wheat flour used for macaroni is both hard and durum wheat which consists of fine particles of uniform size and produces the highest quality
The process flow chart of pasta products
Mixing of the ingredients (wheat flour and water)
Pre mixer, Mixer and Vacuum mixer
Dough preparation
Screw conveyer
Extrusion
Cutting
Dryingpre dryer, 1st ,2nd &3rd dryer
Cooling
Packaging
The process flow chart of Macaroni
Mixing of the ingredients (wheat flour, water …)PremixerMixer
Dough preparation
Molding
CuttingDrying (pre dryer, dryer)
Stabilizer
Packaging
Raw material quality of pasta and macaroni The flour granulation level should be checked. If the sieve size is 129µ, the granulation of the flour
must between 35-45% as well as If the sieve size 180µ, the granulation of the flour
must between 60-70%
Final quality determination of pasta and macaroni The quality evaluation of pasta and macaroni
products involves color, appearance, texture and cooking quality
a. Appearance, texture and cooking quality color are evaluated by organoleptic test/sensory
b. Color (brightness, purity) can be assessed by sensory
c. Determination of cooking test
Evaluation of cooking test parameter Cooking tester apparatus are stove, balance, dish and beaker Procedures If possible to check the moisture content of the sampled products Pour 1L of water in the dish and wait till if boil and then add the
sample(100g) .If the sample is long cut pasta to minimized into small pieces Stir using wooden rod and test the cooking sense If the cooking is ok, then distilled water (residue) and rinse with
water Check the aromatic sense check the water observation Check any other defectCalculationWater Observation =Final weight-Install weight/
Install weight Final weight= Weight of the cooked product Install weight= Weight of the product before cooked
Quality defects
The common quality defects of pasta and macaroni
white spot
Crack
Bend for pasta
The color of final product pasta and macaroni are yellow color
There are two classes of deep fried pastries,
1. yeast raised doughnut and
2. cake doughnut.
Both products have rather specific flour requirement that vary somewhat according to end product and process requirements.
In both cases flour blend high protein hard wheat flour and low protein soft wheat flour are required.
Yeast raised doughnut:-
are made from dough containing yeast as leavening agent
This dough is similar to bread dough The ingredients it contain
require a blend (60-100%) hard wheat flour and (0-40%) soft wheat flour usually with 11-12.5% protein and 8.5-9.5% protein respectively.
5-10% sugar5-10% shortening2-3 times yeast level higher than those of
bread The basic mixing or dough development
requirements are similar to bread.
Most Yeast raised doughnut are made with straight dough procedure
all ingredients are added at once
fermentation takes place with all the ingredients in the dough
Higher yeast level, less fermentation requirement than bread.
Regardless of the fermentation process, the dough is subsequently shaped as required and
It allowed to proof or rise for 25-40 minuteThe proofing condition are much drier than those required for
bread;
Proof moisture is 40-70% for doughnut as against 85-95% for bread.
then the dough pieces are fried in a deep fat fryer at about 185-195°c depending on product variety and process limitations:
they are either surface fried with turning point or
fried submerged
4. Cake doughnut (bonbolino)
are similar to cakes in that they are rich, sweet batters
produced with chemical leavening.
However, their formulas are rather different from baked
cakes due to deep fat frying of the batter.
This batter is extruded directly into the frying fat.
It is expanded during frying by the interaction of sodium
bicarbonate and leavening acids (so-called baking powder)
the raw material usedBlend of 70/30 or 50/50 soft wheat flour and hard wheat flour
Generally, a soft wheat flour of 8.5-9.5% protein and a
hard wheat flour of 10.5-12% protein appropriate for
cake doughnuts.
Flour is the predominant ingredient of the formula;
◦ flour quality is important for controlling viscosity and batter
flow
◦ and thus for the quality of the end product
The final properties of the doughnut are influenced by several factors
1. Frying fat is absorbed from the fryer during cooking. 20-24% of the final doughnut is fat, which is absorbed during
frying.
2. Control of the time at which the batter surfaces is also important
3. Control of batter flow during frying is critical4. The batter must have adequate strength just before the
doughnut is turned to prevent excess bubbling or gassiness at the batter surface. this prevents excess fat absorption and small holes in the
surface of the doughnut flour quality helps to support the batter strength