what will 5g be? seminar report
DESCRIPTION
Seminar ReportTRANSCRIPT
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
5G is the next step in the evolution of mobile communication. It will be a key
component of the Networked Society and will help realize the vision of essentially
unlimited access to information and sharing of data anywhere and anytime for anyone
and anything. 5G will therefore not only be about mobile connectivity for people.
Rather, the aim of 5G is to provide ubiquitous connectivity for any kind of device and
any kind of application that may benefit from being connected.
Mobile broadband will continue to be important and will drive the need for
higher system capacity and higher data rates. But 5G will also provide wireless
connectivity for a wide range of new applications and use cases, including wearables,
smart homes, traffic safety/control, and critical infrastructure and industry
applications, as well as for very-high-speed media delivery. In contrast to earlier
generations, 5G wireless access should not be seen as a specific radio access
technology. Rather, it is an overall wireless-access solution addressing the demands
and requirements of mobile communication beyond 2020.
LTE will continue to develop in a backwards-compatible way and will be an
important part of the 5G wireless-access solution for frequency bands below 6GHz.
Around 2020, there will be massive deployments of LTE providing services to an
enormous number of devices in these bands. For operators with limited spectrum
resources, the possibility to introduce 5G capabilities in a backwards-compatible way,
thereby allowing legacy devices to continue to be served on the same carrier, is highly
beneficial and, in some cases, even vital.
In parallel, new radio-access technology (RAT) without backwards-
compatibility requirements will emerge, at least initially targeting new spectrum for
which backwards compatibility is not relevant. In the longer-term perspective, the
new non-backwards-compatible technology may also migrate into existing spectrum.
Although the overall 5G wireless-access solution will consist of different components,
including the evolution of LTE as well as new technology, the different components
should be highly integrated with the possibility for tight interworking between them.
This includes dual-connectivity between LTE operating on lower frequencies and new
technology on higher frequencies. It should also include the possibility for user-plane
aggregation, that is, joint delivery of data via both LTE and a new RAT.
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 1
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
CHAPTER 2
LITERATURE SURVEY
1. 5G technology of mobile communication: A survey: Gohil, A, Modi, H, Patel
S.K, Charotar Univ. of Sci. & Technol., Changa, India S,2013.
5G, researches are related to the development of World Wide Wireless Web
(WWWW), Dynamic Adhoc Wireless Networks (DAWN) and Real Wireless
Communication. The most important technologies for 5G technologies are 802.11
Wireless Local Area Networks (WLAN) and 802.16 Wireless Metropolitan Area
Networks (WMAN), Ad-hoc Wireless Personal Area Network (WPAN) and Wireless
networks for digital communication. 4G technology will include several standards
under a common umbrella, similar to 3G, but with IEEE 802.xx wireless mobile
networks integrated from the commencement. The major contribution of this paper is
the key provisions of 5G (Fifth Generation) technology of mobile communication,
which is seen as consumer oriented. In 5G technology, the mobile consumer has given
utmost priority compared to others. 5G Technology stands for 5th Generation Mobile
Technology. 5G technology is to make use of mobile phones within very high
bandwidth. The consumer never experienced the utmost valued technology as 5G.
The 5G technologies include all types of advanced features which make 5G
technology most dominant technology in near future.
2. Massive MIMO for Next Generation Wireless Systems,Erik G. Larsson, Ove
Edfors, Fredrik Tufvesson, Thomas L. Marzetta, IEEE Vol. 52, No. 2, pp.
186-195, Feb. 2014
Multi-user Multiple-Input Multiple-Output (MIMO) offers big advantages over
conventional point-to-point MIMO: it works with cheap single-antenna terminals, a
rich scattering environment is not required, and resource allocation is simplified
because every active terminal utilizes all of the time-frequency bins. However, multi-
user MIMO, as originally envisioned with roughly equal numbers of service-antennas
and terminals and frequency division duplex operation, Massive MIMO (also known
as "Large-Scale Antenna Systems", "Very Large MIMO") makes a clean break with
current practice through the use of a large excess of service-antennas over active
terminals and time division duplex operation. Extra antennas help by focusing energy
into ever-smaller regions of space to bring huge improvements in throughput and
radiated energy efficiency.
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 2
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
3. Millimeter Wave Mobile Communications for 5G Cellular, Rappaport T.S.,
Shu Sun ,Mayzus R., Hang Zhao, Azar Y., Wang K., Wong, G.N., Schulz
J.K., Samimi M., Gutierrez, F.IEEE, Page(s):335-349,2013.
The global bandwidth shortage facing wireless carriers has motivated the exploration
of the underutilized millimeter wave (mm-wave) frequency spectrum for future
broadband cellular communication networks. There is, however, little knowledge
about cellular mm-wave propagation in densely populated indoor and outdoor
environments. Obtaining this information is vital for the design and operation of
future fifth generation cellular networks that use the mm-wave spectrum. In this
paper, we present the motivation for new mm-wave cellular systems, methodology,
and hardware for measurements and offer a variety of measurement results that show
28 and 38 GHz frequencies can be used when employing steerable directional
antennas at base stations and mobile devices.
4. N. Lee, R. W. Heath Jr., D. Morales-Jimenez, and A. Lozano, “Base station
cooperation with dynamic clustering in super-dense cloudRAN,” in IEEE
GLOBECOM’13 Workshop on Cloud-Processing in Heterogeneous Mobile
Communication Networks, Dec. 2013.
The mobile Internet has seen tremendous progress due to the standardization efforts
around WiMAX, LTE and beyond. There are also early trends towards adoption of
software radio and a growing presence of general purpose platforms in wireless
networking. Such platforms are programmer-friendly and with recent advances on
multi-core and hybrid architectures, allow signal processing, network processor class
packet processing, wire-speed computation and server-class virtualization capabilities
for software radio realizations of 3G and 4G wireless stacks. Software radio over IT
platforms will enable the virtualization of base stations and consolidation of virtual
base stations into central pools (a local “cloud site”) with fiber connectivity to towers,
which we call a Wireless Network Cloud (WNC). A Virtual base station (BS) pool
supporting multiple BS software instances over a general OS and IT platform is an
important step towards the realization of the larger WNC concept. This paper
introduces the first TDD WiMAX SDR BS implemented on a commodity server, in
conjunction with a novel design of a remote radio head (RRH). We also present the
first working prototype of a virtual BS (VBS) pool, exploring the systems challenges
in supporting a VBS pool on multi-core IT platforms. The results from our VBS pool
prototype for WiMAX verify that these solutions can meet system requirements
including synchronization, latency and jitter.
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 3
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
CHAPTER 3
5G Requirements and Capabilities
In order to enable connectivity for a very wide range of applications with
vastly different characteristics and requirements, the capabilities of 5G wireless
access must extend far beyond those of previous generations of mobile
communication.
3.1 MASSIVE SYSTEM CAPACITY
Traffic demands for mobile-communication systems are predicted to increase
dramatically. To support such traffic in an affordable way, 5G networks must be able
to deliver data with much lower cost per bit compared with the networks of today.
Furthermore, in order to be able to operate with the same or preferably even lower
overall energy consumption compared with today, 5G must enable radically lower
energy consumption per delivered bit.
Another aspect of 5G system capacity is the capability to support a much
larger number of devices compared with today. The new use cases envisioned for 5G
include, for example, the deployment of billions of wirelessly connected sensors,
actuators and similar devices. Each device will typically be associated with very little
traffic, implying that, even jointly, they will have a limited impact on the overall
traffic volume. However, the sheer number of devices to be connected provides a
challenge, for example, in terms of efficient signaling protocols.
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 4
Fig. 1 5G Requirements and Capabilities
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
3.2 VERY HIGH DATA RATES EVERYWHERE
Every generation of mobile communication has been associated with higher data
rates compared with the previous generation. In the past, much focus has been on the
peak data rate that can be supported by a wireless-access technology under ideal
conditions. However, a much more important capability is the data rate that can
actually be provided under real-life conditions in different scenarios.
5G should be able to provide data rates exceeding 10Gbps in specific
scenarios such as indoor and dense outdoor environments.
Data rates of several 100Mbps should be generally achievable in urban and
suburban environments.
Data rates of at least 10Mbps should be achievable essentially everywhere,
including sparsely populated rural areas in both developed and developing
countries.
3.3 VERY LOW LATENCY
Lower latency has been a key target for both 4G and the evolution of 3G,
driven mainly by the continuous quest for higher achievable data rates. Due to
properties of the internet protocols, lower latency over the wireless interface is critical
to realize the higher data rates. 5G targets even higher data rates, and this in itself will
drive a need for even lower latency. However, lower latency will also be driven by the
support for new applications. Some of the envisioned 5G applications, such as traffic
safety and control of critical infrastructure and industry processes, may require much
lower latency compared with what is possible with the mobile communication
systems of today. To support such latency-critical applications, 5G should allow for
an application end-to-end latency of 1ms or less.
3.4 ULTRA-HIGH RELIABILITY AND AVAILABILITY
In addition to very low latency, 5G should also enable connectivity with ultra-
high reliability and ultra-high availability. For critical services, such as control of
critical infrastructure and traffic safety, connectivity with certain characteristics, such
as a specific maximum latency, should not only be ‘typically available.’ Rather,
connectivity with the required characteristics has to be always available with
essentially no deviation.
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 5
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
3.5 VERY LOW DEVICE COST AND ENERGY CONSUMPTION
The possibility for low cost and low energy consumption for mobile devices
has been a key requirement since the early days of mobile communication. However,
in order to enable the vision of billions of wirelessly connected sensors, actuators and
similar devices, a further step has to be taken in terms of device cost and energy
consumption. It should be possible for such 5G devices to be available at very low
cost and with a battery life of several years without recharging.
3.6 HIGH NETWORK ENERGY PERFORMANCE
While device energy consumption has always been prioritized, high energy
performance on the network side.
High network energy performance is an important component in reducing
operational cost, as well as a driver for better dimensioned nodes, leading to
lower total cost of ownership.
High network energy performance allows for off-grid network deployments
relying on decently sized solar panels as power supply, thereby enabling
wireless connectivity to even the most remote areas.
High network energy performance is part of a general operator aim of
providing wireless access in a sustainable and more resource-efficient way.
The importance of these factors will increase further in the 5G era, and the possibility
of very high network energy performance will therefore be an important requirement
in the design of 5G wireless access.
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 6
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
CHAPTER 4
KEY TECHNOLOGIES
4.1 Extreme Densification and Offloading
Ultra-dense networks will arise not only from an expanded user base and
shorter links, but also from an enriched topology, including different technologies and
operating in different spectral bands. Their purpose is to provide more capacity
through offloading where needed, such as in large sporting events (on an as-needed
basis, since there are of relatively short duration), in public places with a lot of users
such as airports, university campuses, or malls, or indoors, where the absorption loss
due to walls can considerably reduce link margin and, therefore, throughput. With the
advent of ultra-dense networks combined with the diminished role of the legacy
macrocell, handsets in close vicinity of each other can communicate directly through
device-to-device links. The many advantages extend from reduced power emission
and interference, to group broadcast and mesh networking, to enhanced security
provided from the absence of intermediate network routing. However, ultra-dense
networks pose their own set of challenges that must be addressed in order for them to
help achieve the 1000x increase in capacity required for 5G networks.
Fig. 2 Ultra dense Small Cells.
New propagation models are needed for ultra-dense networks. Driven by legacy
cellular systems, most models currently available are tower-to-ground with base
stations typically at 30 m and above. Device-to-device links, however, will be ground
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 7
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
to-ground: picocells on lightpoles and indoor femtocells placed on table tops or
mounted on walls or ceilings will be < 10 m above ground. The problem is that few
ground-to-ground channel models to date exist in the literature. In addition, most
channel models assume independent fading between links. In ultra-dense networks in
particular, it does not hold good because there will be significant correlation between
links, necessitating the study of joint links. NIST also has expertise in this area, but
much more work needs to be done for sufficient characterization. In addition, the
introduction of carrier aggregation to provide additional bandwidth will require
developing ground-to-ground and indoor channel models for new frequency bands. In
addition to channel propagation models, detailed system models are needed to
accurately characterize and develop signal processing algorithms at the physical
(PHY) layer, as well as Medium Access Control (MAC) layer and routing protocols.
A big issue that needs to be dealt with is interference mitigation:
Coordination algorithms for synchronizing cells, managing power, and
selecting carriers needs to be examined in terms of their inaccuracy (timing
offsets, etc.), and how these impact performance.
Determining the limits of densification (i.e. how much capacity reuse is
possible before interference or channel effects or overhead causes saturation)
is an important issue that needs to be addressed. This will require development
of additional models and simulation tools to answer.
Also, small cells in ultra-dense deployments that are not serving UEs (user
equipment) may go into sleep mode to conserve power, resulting in a network
populated by base stations that turn on and off in response to UE migration.
Additionally, future networks may include small cells that are deployed by
customers without direct setup by the service provider. This means that base
stations in ultra-dense deployments must be able to autonomously perform self-
organizing functions such as discovery, synchronization, authentication, and
power control, and selection of appropriate common carriers in networks that use
carrier aggregation.
5G and all networks beyond it will be extremely dense and heterogeneous,
which introduces many new challenges for network modeling, analysis, design
and optimization. It allows users in close proximity to establish direct
communication, replacing two long hops via the BS with a single shorter hop.
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 8
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
Provided there is sufficient spatial locality in the wireless traffic, reduced power
consumption and/or higher data rates, and a diminished latency.
4.2 Millimetre Wave
mmWave is a promising technology for future cellular systems. Since
limited spectrum is available for commercial cellular systems, most research has
focused on increasing spectral efficiency by using OFDM, MIMO, efficient
channel coding, and interference coordination. Network densification has also
been studied to increase area spectral efficiency, including the use of
heterogeneous infrastructure (macro, Pico, femto cells, relays, distributed
antennas) but increased spectral efficiency is not enough to guarantee high user
data rates. The alternative is more spectrum.
Millimeter wave (mmWave) cellular systems, operating in the 30-300GHz
band, above which electromagnetic radiation is considered to be low (or far)
infrared light, also referred to as terahertz radiation.
Fig. 3 Millimeter wave frequency spectrum.
The main reason that mmWave spectrum lies idle, because of atmospheric and
rain absorption, strong path loss, low diffraction around obstacles and penetration
through objects.
Despite industrial research efforts to deploy the most efficient wireless
technologies possible, the wireless industry always eventually faces overwhelming
capacity demands for its currently deployed wireless technologies, brought on by the
continued advances and discoveries in computing and communications, and the
emergence of new customer handsets and use cases (such as the need to access the
internet).
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 9
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
mmWave trend will occur in the coming years for 4G LTE, implying that at
some point around 2020; wireless networks will face congestion, as well as the need
to implement new technologies and architectures to properly serve the continuing
demands of carriers and customers.
The life cycle of every new generation of cellular technology is generally a
decade or less (as shown earlier), due to the natural evolution of computer and
communications technology. Wireless future where mobile data rates expand to the
multi gigabit-per-second range, made possible by the use of steerable antennas and
mm-wave spectrum that could simultaneously support mobile communications and
backhaul, with the possible convergence of cellular and Wi-Fi services.
Recent studies suggest that mm-wave frequencies could be used to augment
the currently saturated 700 MHz to 2.6 GHz radio spectrum bands for wireless
communications. The combination of cost-effective CMOS technology that can now
operate well into the mm-wave frequency bands, and high-gain, steerable antennas at
the mobile and base station, strengthens the viability of mm-wave wireless
communications. Further mm-wave carrier frequencies allow for larger bandwidth
allocations, which translate directly to higher data transfer rates.
Mm-wave spectrum would allow service providers to significantly expand the
channel bandwidths far beyond the present 20 MHz channels used by 4G customers.
By increasing the RF channel bandwidth for mobile radio channels, the data capacity
is greatly increased, while the latency for digital traffic is greatly decreased, thus
supporting much better internet based access and applications that require minimal
latency. Mm-wave frequencies, due to the much smaller wavelength, may exploit
polarization and new spatial processing techniques, such as massive MIMO and
adaptive beam forming.
Given this significant jump in bandwidth and new capabilities offered by mm-
waves, the base station-to-device links, as well as backhaul links between base
stations, will be able to handle much greater capacity than today's 4G networks in
highly populated areas. Also, as operators continue to reduce cell coverage areas to
exploit spatial reuse, and implement new cooperative architectures such as
cooperative MIMO, relays, and interference mitigation between base stations, the cost
per base station will drop as they become more plentiful and more densely distributed
in urban areas, making wireless backhaul essential for flexibility, quick deployment,
and reduced ongoing operating costs. Finally, as opposed to the disjointed spectrum
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 10
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
employed by many cellular operators today, where the coverage distances of cell sites
vary widely over three octaves of frequency between 700 MHz and 2.6 GHz, the mm-
wave spectrum will have spectral allocations that are relatively much closer together,
making the propagation characteristics of different mm-wave bands much more
comparable and ``homogenous''. The 28 GHz and 38 GHz bands are currently
available with spectrum allocations of over 1 GHz of band-width. Originally intended
for Local Multipoint Distribution Service (LMDS) use in the late 1990's, these
licensees could be used for mobile cellular as well as backhaul.
A common myth in the wireless engineering community is that rain and
atmosphere make mm-wave spectrum useless for mobile communications. However,
when one considers the fact that today's cell sizes in urban environments are on the
order of 200 m, it becomes clear that mm-wave cellular can overcome these issues.
Fig. 3.1 and Fig. 3.2 show the rain attenuation and atmospheric absorption
characteristics of mm-wave propagation. It can be seen that for cell sizes on the order
of 200 m, atmospheric absorption does not create significant additional path loss for
mm-waves, particularly at 28 GHz and 38 GHz. Only 7 dB/km of attenuation is
expected due to heavy rainfall rates of 1 inch/hr for cellular propagation at 28 GHz,
which translates to only 1.4 dB of attenuation over 200 m distance. Work by many
researchers has confirmed that for small distances (less than 1 km), rain attenuation
will present a minimal effect on the propagation of mm-waves at 28 GHz to 38 GHz
for small cells.
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 11
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
Fig. 3.1 Rain attenuation in dB/km across frequency at various rainfall rates
Fig. 3.2 Atmospheric absorption across mm-wave frequencies in dB/km
Millimeter Wave Challenges:
1) Propagation Behavior
Millimeter wave transmission and reception is based on the principle of line of
sight (LOS) paths. Received signal strength is relatively stronger than other directions
in line of sight (LOS) path. Line of sight path correspond to the situations where the
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 12
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
main lobes of the transmitter and receiver pair are positioned in a way to capture the
line of sight.
Since the beam width is narrow and the distance covered by millimeter wave is small
(approx. 200 m). Even if there are obstacles usually large objects such as buildings
blocks these LOS paths we can still use mm-wave by the principle of Non-line of
sight propagation.
Non-line of sight path propagation takes place through paths that contains a single-
reflected signal and multiple reflected signal which will yield the best signal strength
for the receiver.
Except for connections between fixed devices, such as a PC and its peripherals, where
non-LOS may be encountered permanently, but most cases involves portable devices
that should be able to have LOS connections because these devices can be moved to
adjust aiming.
These reflections can establish non-LOS links, but these will be still tens of dB
weaker than LOS signal, hence the data rates provided by these non-LOS links are
quite less compared to rates provided by LOS signal.
So, how to improve the performance is
Incorporate directional beam forming.
Receiver and transmitter antenna should communicate via. Main beam to
achieve higher array gain.
Self-steerable smart antenna is required such that it adjust automatically to
achieve higher gain; hence the data rate is increased.
Smart antenna is required to distinguish between LOS and non LOS paths
2) Large Arrays, Narrow Beams
Fig. 3.3 millimeter wave beam width
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 13
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
Building a cellular system out of narrow and focused beams is highly
nontrivial and changes many traditional aspects of cellular system design. MmWave
beams are highly directional, almost like flashlights, which completely changes the
interference behavior as well as the sensitivity to misaligned beams. The interference
adopts an on/off behavior where most beams do not interfere, but strong interference
does occur intermittently. Overall, interference is de-emphasized and mmWave
cellular links may often be noise limited, which is a major reversal from 4G. Indeed,
even the notion of a “cell” is likely to be very different in a mmWave system since,
rather than distance, blocking is often the first order effect on the received signal
power.
Link acquisition. A key challenge for narrow beams is the difficulty in
establishing associations between users and BSs, both for initial access and for
handoff. To find each other, a user and a BS may need to scan lots of angular
positions where a narrow beam could possibly be found, or deploy extremely
large coding/spreading gains over a wider beam that is successively narrowed
in a multistage acquisition procedure. Developing solutions, particularly in the
context of high mobility, is an important research challenge.
Leveraging the legacy 4G network. A concurrent utilization of microwave
and mmWave frequencies could go a long way towards overcoming some of
the above hurdles. An interesting proposal in that respect is the notion of
“phantom cells” (relabeled “soft cells” within 3GPP), where mmWave
frequencies would be employed for payload data transmission Signalling Data
from small-cell BSs while the control plane would operate at microwave
frequencies from macro BSs (Fig. 3.4). So it ensure stable and reliable control
connections, based on which blazing fast data transmissions could be arranged
over short range mmWave links. Sporadic interruptions of these mmWave
links would then be far less consequential, as control links would remain in
place and lost data could be recovered through retransmissions.
Fig. 3.4 mmWave-enabled network with phantom cells.
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 14
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
Novel transceiver architectures needed. Despite the progress made in WiFi
mmWave systems, nontrivial hardware issues remain and in some cases will
directly affect how the communication aspects are designed. Chief among
these is the still-exorbitant power consumption of particularly the analogto-
digital (A/D) but also the digital-to-analog (D/A) converters needed for large
bandwidths. A main consequence is that, although large antenna arrays and
high receiver sensitivities are needed to deal with the pathloss, having
customary fully digital beam formers for each antenna appears to be
unfeasible. More likely are structures based on old-fashioned analog phase
shifters or, perhaps, hybrid structures where groups of antennas share a single
A/D and D/A. On the flip side, offering some relief from these difficulties, the
channels are sparser and thus the acquisition of channel-state information is
facilitated; in particular, channel estimation and beamforming techniques
exploiting sparsity in the framework of compressed sensing are being
explored.
4.3 Massive MIMO
Multiple-antenna (MIMO) technology is becoming mature for wireless
communications and has been incorporated into wireless broadband standards like
LTE and Wi-Fi. Basically, the more antennas the transmitter/receiver is equipped
with, the more the possible signal paths and the better the performance in terms of
data rate and link reliability. The price to pay is increased complexity of the hardware
(number of RF amplifier frontends) and the complexity and energy consumption of
the signal processing at both ends.
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 15
Hundreds of Base Stations
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
Fig. 4: Massive MIMO
In single-user MIMO (SU-MIMO), the dimensions are limited by the number
of antennas that can be accommodated on a portable device. However, by having each
BS communicate with several users concurrently, the multiuser version of MIMO
(MU-MIMO) can effectively pull together the antennas at those users and overcome
this bottleneck. Then, the signaling dimensions are given by the smallest between the
aggregate number of antennas at those users and the number of antennas at the BS.
Furthermore, coordinated multipoint (CoMP) transmission/reception, multiple BSs
can cooperate and act as a single effective MIMO transceiver thereby turning some of
the interference in the system into useful signals.
Well-established by the time LTE was developed, MIMO was a native
ingredient thereof with two-to-four antennas per mobile unit and as many as eight per
base station sector, and it appeared that, because of form factors and other apparent
limitations, such was the extent to which MIMO could be leveraged. a number of
antennas much larger than the number of active users per time-frequency signaling
resource and given that under reasonable time-frequency selectivity accurate channel
estimation can be conducted for at most some tens of users per resource, puts the
number of antennas per base station into the hundreds. Initially it is termed as “large-
scale antenna systems” also known as “massive MIMO”.
Offers enticing benefits:
An enormous enhancement in spectral efficiency without the need for
increased BS densification, with the possibility as is always the case of trading
some of those enhancements off for power efficiency improvements.
Smoothed out channel responses because of the vast spatial diversity, which
brings about the favorable action of the law of large numbers. In essence, all
small-scale randomness abates as the number of channel observations grows.
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 16
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
Simple transmit/receive structures because of the quasiorthogonal nature of
the channels between each BS and the set of active users sharing the same
signaling resource. For a given number of active users, such orthogonality
sharpens as the number of BS antennas grows and simple linear transceivers,
even plain single user beamforming, perform close-to-optimally.
Massive MIMO Challenges:
1) Pilot Contamination and Overhead Reduction: Pilot transmissions can be made
orthogonal among same-cell users, to facilitate cleaner channel estimates but must be
reused across cell for otherwise all available resources would end up consumed by
pilots. It causes interference among pilots in different cells and hence puts a floor on
the quality of the channel estimates. So it’s called “pilot contamination,” does not
vanish as the number of BS antennas grows large, and so is the one impairment that
remains asymptotically. However, pilot contamination is a relatively secondary factor
for all but colossal numbers of antennas. Furthermore, various methods to reduce and
even eliminate pilot contamination via low-intensity coordination have already been
formulated. Still, a careful design of the pilot structures is required to avoid an
explosion in overhead. The ideas being considered to reign in pilot overheads include
exploiting spatial correlations, so as to share pilot symbols among antennas, and also
segregating the pilots into classes (e.g., channel strength gauging for link adaptation v.
data detection) such that each class can be transmitted at the necessary rate, and no
faster.
2) Architectural Challenges: A more serious challenge to the realization of the
massive MIMO vision has to do with its architecture. The vision requires radically
different BS structures where, instead of a few high-power amplifiers feeding a
handful of sector antennas, number of tiny antennas fed by correspondingly low-
power amplifiers; most likely each antenna would have to be integrated with its own
amplifier. Scalability, antenna correlations and mutual couplings, and cost, are some
of the issues that must be sorted out. At the same time, opportunities arise for
innovative topologies such as conformal arrays along rooftops or on building facades,
and we next dwell on a specific topological aspect in which innovation is taking
place.
3) Full-Dimension MIMO and Elevation Beamforming: Existing BSs mostly
feature linear horizontal arrays, which in tower structures can only accommodate a
limited number of antennas, due to form factors, and which only exploit the azimuth
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 17
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
angle dimension. By adopting planar 2D arrays and further exploiting the elevation
angle, so-called full-dimension MIMO (FD-MIMO) can house many more antennas
with the same form factor. As a side benefit, tailored vertical beams increase the
signal power and reduce interference to users in neighboring cells. Some preliminary
cell average and edge data rates obtained from Samsung’s network simulator are
listed in Table I where, with numbers of antennas still modest for what massive
MIMO is envisioned to be, multiple-fold improvements are observed.
TABLE I: FD-MIMO system-level downlink simulation results at 2.5 GHz. Half-
wavelength antenna spacing in both the horizontal and vertical dimensions at the BSs,
2 antennas per user, 30% overhead. The baseline is SU-MIMO with 4 antennas per
BS and the FD-MIMO results (average and edge data rates) are for MU-MIMO with
16 and 64 antennas, respectively corresponding to 4 × 4 and 8 × 8 planar arrays per
BS sector.
SU-MIMO FD-MIMO 16 FD-MIMO 64
Aggregate Data Rate (b/s/Hz/cell) 2.32 3.28 6.37
Edge Data Rate (b/s/Hz) 0.063 0.1 0.4
4) Channel Models: Parallel to the architectural issues run those related to channel
models, which to be sound require extensive field measurements. Antenna
correlations and couplings for massive arrays with relevant topologies must be
determined, and a proper modeling of their impact must be established; in particular,
the degree of actual channel orthogonalization in the face of such nonidealities must
be verified. And for FD-MIMO, besides azimuth, the modeling needs to incorporate
elevation, which is a dimension on which far less data exists concerning power
spectra and angle spreads. A 3D channel modeling study currently under way within
3GPP is expected to shed light on these various issues.
5) Coexistence with Small Cells: massive MIMO BSs would most likely have to
coexist with tiers of small cells, which would not be equipped with massive MIMO
due to their smaller form factor. Although the simplest alternative is to segregate the
corresponding transmissions in frequency, the large number of excess antennas at
massive MIMO BSs may offer the opportunity of spatial nulling and interference
avoidance with relative simplicity and little penalty. As networks become dense and
more traffic is offloaded to small cells, the number of active users per cell will
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 18
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
diminish and the need for massive MIMO may decrease. Aspects such as cost and
backhaul will ultimately determine the balance between these complementary ideas.
6) Coexistence with mmWave: mmWave communication requires many antennas
for beamsteering. The antennas are much smaller at these frequencies and thus very
large numbers thereof can conceivably fit into portable devices, and these antennas
can indeed provide beamforming power gain. Any application of massive MIMO at
mmWave frequencies would have to find the correct balance between power
gain/interference reduction and parallelization.
CHAPTER 5
DESIGN ISSUES FOR 5G
5.1 The Waveform: Signaling and Multiple Access
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 19
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
The signaling and multiple access formats, i.e., the waveform design, have
changed significantly at each cellular generation and to a large extent they have been
each generation’s defining technical feature. They have also often been the subject of
fierce intellectual and industrial disputes, which have played out in the wider media.
The 1G approach, based on analog frequency modulation with FDMA, transformed
into a digital format for 2G and, although it employed both FDMA and TDMA for
multiple access, was generally known as “TDMA” due to the novelty of time-
multiplexing. Meanwhile, a niche spread spectrum/CDMA standard that was
developed by Qualcomm to compete for 2G became the dominant approach to all
global 3G standards. Once the limitations of CDMA for high-speed data became
inescapable, there was a discreet but unmistakable retreat back towards TDMA, with
minimal spectrum spreading retained and with the important addition of channel-
aware scheduling. Due to the increasing signal bandwidths needed to support data
applications, orthogonal frequency-division multiplexing (OFDM) was unanimously
adopted for 4G in conjunction with scheduled FDMA/TDMA as the virtues of
orthogonality were viewed with renewed appreciation.5G could involve yet another
major change in the signaling and multiple access formats.
1) OFDM and OFDMA: OFDM has become the dominant signaling format for high-
speed wireless communication, forming the basis of all current WiFi standards and of
LTE, and further of wire line technologies such as digital subscriber lines, digital TV,
and commercial radio. Its qualities include:
A natural way to cope with frequency selectivity.
Computationally efficient implementation via FFT/IFFT blocks and simple
frequency-domain equalizers.
An excellent pairing for MIMO, since OFDM allows for the spatial
interference from multiantenna transmission to be dealt with at a subcarrier
level, without the added complication of intersymbol interference.
From a multiple access vantage point, OFDM invites dynamic fine-grained resource
allocation schemes in the digital domain, and the term OFDMA is employed to denote
orthogonal multiple access at a subcarrier level. In combination with TDMA, the
time-frequency grid into small units known as resource blocks that can be easily
discriminated through digital filtering. Being able to do frequency and time slot
allocation digitally also enables more adaptive and sophisticated interference
management techniques such as fractional frequency reuse or spectrum partitions
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 20
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
between small cells and macrocells. Finally, given its near-universal adoption,
industry has by now a great deal of experience with its implementation, and tricky
aspects of OFDM such as frequency offset correction and synchronization have been
essentially conquered.
2) Drawbacks of OFDM: OFDM is the unquestionable frontrunner for 5G. However,
some weak points do exist that could possibly become more pronounced in 5G
networks.
First, the peak-to-average-power ratio (PAPR) is higher in OFDM than in
other formats since the envelope samples are nearly Gaussian due to the summation of
uncorrelated inputs in the IFFT. Although a Gaussian signal distribution is capacity
achieving under an average power constraint, in the face of an actual power amplifier
a high PAPR sets up an unattractive tradeoff between the linearity of the transmitted
signal and the cost of the amplifier. This problem can be largely overcome by
precoding the OFDM signals at the cost of a more involved equalization process at the
receiver and a slight power penalty; indeed, this is already being done in the LTE
uplink.
Second, OFDM’s spectral efficiency is satisfactory, but could perhaps be
further improved upon if the requirements of strict orthogonality were relaxed and if
the cyclic prefixes (CPs) that prevent interblock interference were smaller or
discarded. The use of a novel OFDMA-based modulation scheme named frequency
and quadrature amplitude modulation (FQAM), which is shown to improve the
downlink throughput for cell-edge users. Perhaps the main source of concerns is the
applicability of OFDM to mmWave spectrum given the enormous bandwidths therein
and the difficulty of developing efficient power amplifiers at those frequencies. For
example, a single-carrier signaling with null cyclic prefix as an alternative to OFDM
at mmWave frequencies.
3) Potential Alternatives to OFDM: Some alternative approaches to incremental
departures from OFDM rather than the step-function changes that took place in
previous cellular generations.
Time-frequency packing: Time-frequency packing and faster-than-Nyquist
signaling have been recently proposed to circumvent the limitations of strict
orthogonality and CP. In contrast to OFDM, where the product of the symbol
interval and the subcarrier spacing equals 1, in faster-than-Nyquist signaling
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 21
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
products smaller than 1 can be accommodated and spectral efficiency
improvements on the order of 25% have been claimed.
Nonorthogonal signals: There is a growing interest in multicarrier formats,
such as filter bank multicarrier, that are natively nonorthogonal and thus do
not require prior synchronization of distributed transmitters. A new format
termed universal filtered multicarrier (UFMC) has been proposed whereby,
starting with an OFDM signal, filtering is performed on groups of adjacent
subcarriers with the aim of reducing side lobe levels and intercarrier
interference resulting from poor time/frequency synchronization.
Filter bank multicarrier: To address the drawbacks of rectangular time
windowing in OFDM, namely the need for large guard bands, the use of filter
bank multicarrier permits a robust estimation of very large propagation delays
and of arbitrarily high carrier frequency offsets, whereas OFDM would have
required a very long CP to attain the same performance levels.
Generalized frequency division multiplexing: GFDM is a multicarrier
technique that adopts a shortened CP through the tail biting technique and is
particularly well suited for noncontiguous frequency bands, which makes it
attractive for spectrum sharing where frequency-domain holes may have to be
adaptively filled.
Single carrier: Single-carrier transmission has also been attracting renewed
interest, chiefly due to the development of low-complexity nonlinear
equalizers implemented in the frequency domain.
Tunable OFDM: OFDM could be well adapted to different 5G requirements
by allowing some of its parameters to be tunable, rather than designed for
essentially the worst-case multipath delay spread. In particular, given the
increasingly software-defined nature of radios, the FFT block size, the
subcarrier spacing and the CP length could change with the channel
conditions: in scenarios with small delay spreads—notably dense urban/small
cells and mmWave channels—the subcarrier spacing could grow and the FFT
size and the CP could be significantly shortened to lower the latency, the
PAPR, the CP’s power and bandwidth penalty, and the computational
complexity; in channels with longer delay spreads, that could revert to
narrower subcarriers, longer FFT blocks, and a longer CP.
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 22
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
5.2 Cloud-Based Networking
Cloud networking is to provide network services in a manner similar to the
elastic compute and storage services provided in cloud computing so that it can be
accessed from anywhere and via a variety of platforms. And to use cloud computing
technologies within the network infrastructure as a more flexible, cost effective
approach to support both traditional network services and those delivered to
application tenants in a cloud computing environment. Network function
virtualization (NFV) and software defined networking (SDN) are the two technologies
to advance mobile communication networking. Although the move towards
virtualization is thus far taking place only within the core network, this trend might
eventually expand towards the edges. In fact, the term cloud-RAN is already being
utilized, but for now largely to refer to schemes whereby multiple BSs are allowed to
cooperate. If and when the BSs themselves become virtualized down to the MAC and
PHY.
1) Network Function Virtualization: NFV enables network functions that were
traditionally tied to hardware appliances to run on cloud computing infrastructure in a
data center. It should be noted that this does not imply that the NFV infrastructure will
be equivalent to commercial cloud or enterprise cloud. What is expected is that there
will be a high degree of reuse of what commercial cloud offers. It is natural to expect
that some requirements of mobile networks such as the separation of the data plane,
control plane and management plane, will not be feasible within the commercial
cloud. Nevertheless, the separation of the network functions from the hardware
infrastructure will be the cornerstone of future architectures.
Virtualizing Network Functions can potentially offer many benefits including, but not
limited to:
Reduced equipment diversity and reduced power consumption through
consolidating equipment and exploiting the economies of scale of the IT
industry.
Architecturally decoupling the network function, based in software, from the
support infrastructure, based in hardware. This can provide independent
scaling and innovation among both.
Increased speed of Time to Market by minimizing the typical network
operator cycle of innovation. Economies of scale required to cover
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 23
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
investments in hardware-based functionalities are strongly mitigated through
software-based deployment, making other modes of feature evolution feasible.
Availability of network appliance multi-version and multi-tenancy, which
allows use of a single platform for different applications, users and tenants.
This allows network operators to share resources across services and across
different customer bases.
Targeted service introduction based on geography or customer sets is possible.
Services can be rapidly scaled up/down as required.
Ability to deploy systems that elastically support various network functional
demands and which allow directing the capacity of a common resource pool
against a current mix of demands in a flexible manner.
Enable a wide variety of eco-systems and encourage openness. NFV opens the
virtual appliance market to pure software entrants, small players and
academia, thus encouraging more innovation to bringing more new services
and new revenue streams quickly at much lower risk.
Enable new types of network services. NFV can readily be applied to the
control and management plane in addition to the data plane. This allows
virtual networks to be created and managed by end users and third parties
using the tools and capabilities heretofore reserved only for native network
operators.
To leverage these benefits, there are a number of technical challenges which need to
be addressed:
Achieving high performance virtualized network appliances which are
portable between different hardware vendors, and with different hypervisors.
Achieving co-existence with custom hardware based network platforms while
enabling an efficient migration path to fully virtualized network platforms.
Similarly transitioning from existing BSS and OSS to more nimble DevOps
and Orchestration approaches.
Managing and orchestrating many virtual network appliances while ensuring
security from attack and misconfiguration.
Ensuring the appropriate level of resilience to hardware and software failures.
Integrating multiple virtual appliances from different vendors. AT&T would
like to “mix & match” hardware from different vendors, hypervisors from
different vendors and virtual appliances from different vendors without
incurring significant integration costs and avoiding lock-in.
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 24
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
SDN can act as an enabler for NFV, since the separation of control and data planes
enables the virtualization of the separated control plane software. NFV can also act as
an enabler for Software Defined Networks (SDN), since the separation between data
plane and control plane implementations is simplified when one or both of them are
implemented in software running on top of standard hardware.
2) Software Defined Networking: SDN is an architectural framework for creating
intelligent networks that are programmable, application aware, and more open. SDN
allows the network to transform into a more effective business enabler. SDN enables
applications to request and manipulate services provided by the network and allows
the network to expose network state back to the applications. A key aspect to the
architectural framework is the separation of forwarding from control plane, and
establishment of standard protocols and abstractions between the two. However, the
term SDN is also applied to a number of other approaches that espouse more open,
software-centric methods of developing new abstractions for both the control plane as
well as forwarding plane of networks.
Benefits of SDN include:
Creating multiple, virtual network control planes on common hardware. SDN
can help extend service virtualization and software control into many existing
network elements.
Enabling applications to request and manipulate services provided by the
network and allow the network to expose network state back to the
applications.
Exposing network capabilities through APIs
Making the control of network equipment remotely accessible and modifiable
via third-party software clients, using open protocols such as OpenFlow,
PCEP or even BGP-FlowSpec5.
Logically decoupling network intelligence into differentiated software-based
controllers, as opposed to integrated routers and switches. Often this flexibility
allows a more centralized layer of control with a more global network view,
and that has some benefits in terms of improving control plane algorithms.
5.3 Energy Efficiency
Classical designs for wireless communications, which tend to maximize rate,
capacity and coverage, potentially lead to solutions where energy efficiency drops.
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 25
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
Energy efficiency is understood from two viewpoints. On the one hand, the energy
spent by the infrastructure may increase, implying high operational costs for the
operator that will indirectly affect also the invoice of the finals users. On the other
hand, some communication strategies require high computational burden at the
terminal side having negative impact on battery lifetime. Hence, the intelligent use of
energy becomes a major new target in addition to the classical design criteria.
Currently two approaches to reduce energy consumption on the radio link exist. First,
small cells reduce the distance to the terminal. The main challenges of this approach
are related to providing an economic backhaul solution and to minimize the additional
deployment cost. The second approach is massive MIMO, where energy is more
focused towards the user by means of more directive beams. In this way, less energy
is wasted yielding interference for other users at the end. The challenges of massive
MIMO include the diffusion of energy due to scattering in NLOS scenarios, limiting
the achievable directivity, and the complexity of spatial multiplexing of users. Both in
the terminal and at the base station, the goal of minimizing the energy consumption
per bit will require a paradigm shift in wireless system design to dramatically improve
efficiency in terms of power and spectrum usage. Further research on implementation
technologies is necessary, focused on low power hardware architectures and energy
efficient signal processing. Some approaches have been proposed on multihop
cooperative networking, and wireless network coding. There are further potential
savings by operating the network with energy efficiency in mind. Nowadays base
stations consume a constant power, regardless of the traffic load. During off-peak
traffic hours, small cells are switched off while coverage is maintained by macrocells.
For active base stations serving a single user, following Shannon’s theorem, the most
energy efficient situation would be to use the full bandwidth and to reduce power so
that the throughput target is met. However, an interference limited multiuser scenario
is more typical in mobile networks. Serving multiple users having different signal to
interference ratios in a TDMA fashion such as round robin, changing the power
dynamically would result in unpredictable interference in adjacent cells. The same
holds for OFDMA, implying inhomogeneous interference on different frequency sub
bands. Hence, current PHY and MAC layers design needs technology advances,
including dynamic power control that is optimally coordinated among the users and
with surrounding cells so that there is proportionality between the traffic and the
energy consumption. Due to the rapidly increasing network density and the access
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 26
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
network consumes the largest share of the energy. Research has focused on the
following areas.
1) Resource allocation: The design of resource allocation strategies aimed at the
optimization of the system energy efficiency and by accepting a moderate
reduction in the data rates that could otherwise be achieved, large energy savings
can be attained.
2) Network Planning: Energy-efficient network planning strategies include
techniques for minimizing the number of BSs for a coverage target and the design
of adaptive BS sleep/wake algorithms for energy savings, since networks have
been designed to meet peak-hour traffic, energy can be saved by (partially)
switching off BSs when they have no active users or simply very low traffic. Of
course, there are different degrees of hibernation available for a BS2 and attention
must be paid in order to avoid unpleasant coverage holes.
3) Renewable energy: Another intriguing possibility is that of BSs powered by
renewable energy sources such as solar power. In developing countries lacking a
reliable and ubiquitous power grid, but it is also intriguing more broadly as it
allows “drop and play” small cell deployment (if wireless backhaul is available)
rather than “plug and play”. In a dense HetNet, plausible per-BS traffic loads can
actually be served solely by energy harvesting BSs, where the resource allocation
makes efficient use of both renewable and traditional energy sources.
4) Hardware solutions: Finally, much of the power consumption issues will be dealt
with by hardware engineers, low-loss antennas, antenna muting, and adaptive
sectorization according to traffic requirements.
Energy efficiency will be a major research theme for 5G, spanning many of the other
topics.
• True cloud-RAN could provide an additional opportunity for energy efficiency
since the centralization of the baseband processing might save energy,
especially if advances on green data centers are leveraged
• The tradeoff between having many small cells or fewer macrocells given their
very different power consumptions
• A complete characterization of the energy consumed by the circuitry needed
for massive MIMO is currently lacking.
• MmWave energy efficiency will be particularly crucial given the
unprecedented bandwidths.
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 27
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
CHAPTER 6
5G SPECTRUMS, REGULATION AND
STANDARDIZATION FOR 5G
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 28
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
5G technologies will encounter with public policy, industry standardization,
and economic considerations.
6.1 Spectrum Policy and Allocation
The beachfront microwave spectrum is already saturated in peak markets at
peak times while large amounts of idle spectrum do exist in the mmWave. Due to the
different propagation characteristics and phantom cells, future systems will need to
integrate a broad range of frequencies. Low frequencies for wide coverage, mobility
support and control, and high frequencies for small cells. This will require new
approaches to spectrum policy and allocation methods. Massive MIMO and small
cells, which address the efficient use of spectrum, must also be considered important
issues in spectrum policy. Spectrum allocation and policy is an essential topic for 5G.
1) Exclusive Licenses: The traditional approach to spectrum policy is for the
regulator to award an exclusive license to a particular band for a particular
purpose, subject to limitations (e.g., power levels or geographic coverage).
Exclusive access gives full interference management control to the licensee and
provides an incentive for investments in infrastructure, allowing for quality-of
service guarantees. Downsides include high entry barriers because of elevated
sunk costs, both in the spectrum itself and in infrastructure, and that such
allocations are inherently inefficient since they occur over very long time scales
typically decades and thus the spectrum is rarely allocated to the party able to
make the best economic use of it. To address these inefficiencies, market-based
approaches have been propounded. Attempting to implement this idea, spectrum
auctions have been conducted recently to reform spectrum, a process whereby
long-held commercial radio and TV allocations are moved to different (smaller)
bands releasing precious spectrum for wireless communications. A prime example
of this is the so-called “digital dividend” auctions arising from the digitization of
radio and TV. However, there are claims that spectrum markets have thus far not
been successful in providing efficient allocations because such markets are not
sufficiently fluid due to the high cost of the infrastructure. According to these
claims, spectrum and infrastructure cannot be easily decoupled.
2) Unlicensed Spectrum: At the other extreme, regulators can designate a band to
be “open access”, meaning that there is no spectrum license and thus users can
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 29
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
share the band provided their devices are certified (by class licenses). Examples
are the industrial, scientific and medical (ISM) bands, which are utilized by many
devices including microwave ovens, medical devices, sensor networks, cordless
phones and especially by WiFi. With open access, barriers to entry are much
lower and there is enhanced competition and innovation, as the incredible success
of WiFi and other ISM-band applications makes plain.
a. The downside of open access is potentially unmanageable interference, no
quality-of-service guarantees and possibly, the “tragedy of the commons,”
where no one achieves a desired outcome. Still, it is useful to consider the
possibility of open access for bands utilized in small cells as future
networks may involve multiple players and lower entry barriers may be
needed to secure the emergence of small-cell infrastructures.
b. Although interference is indeed a significant problem in current open
access networks, it is interesting to note that cellular operators nevertheless
rely heavily on WiFi offloading: currently about half of all cellular data
traffic is proactively offloaded through unlicensed spectrum. WiFi
hotspots are nothing but small cells that spatially reuse ISM frequencies.
At mmWave frequencies, the main issue is signal strength rather than
interference, and it is therefore plausible that mmWave bands be
unlicensed, or at a minimum several licensees will share a given band
under certain new regulations.
3) Spectrum Sharing: Options do exist halfway between exclusive licenses and
open access, such as the opportunistic use of TV white space. While the potential
of reusing is enticing, it is not crystal clear that reliable communication services
can be delivered that way. Alternatively, Authorized Shared Access and Licensed
Shared Access are regulatory frameworks that allow spectrum sharing by a limited
number of parties each having a license under carefully specified conditions.
Users agree on how the spectrum is to be shared, seeking interference protection
from each other, thereby increasing the predictability and reliability of their
services.
4) Market-Based Approaches to Spectrum Allocation: the advantages of
exclusive licenses for ensuring quality of service, it is likely that most beachfront
spectrum will continue to be allocated that way. Nevertheless, better utilization
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 30
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
could likely be obtained if spectrum markets could become more fluid. To that
end, liberal licenses do not, in principle, preclude trading and reallocation on a fast
time scale, rendering spectrum allocations much more dynamic. Close attention
must be paid to the definition of spectrum assets, which have a space as well as a
time scale, and the smaller the scales, the more fluid the market . In small cells,
traffic is much more volatile than in macrocells and operators may find it
beneficial to enter into sharing arrangements for both spectrum and infrastructure.
Dynamic spectrum markets may emerge, managed by brokers, allowing licenses
to spectrum assets to be bought and sold or leased on time scales of hours, minutes
or even ms. Along these lines, an interesting possibility is for a decoupling of
infrastructure, spectrum and services. In particular, there may be a separation
between spectrum owners and operators. Various entities may own and/or share a
network of BSs, and buy and sell spectrum assets from spectrum owners, via
brokers. These network owners may offer capacity to operators, which in turn
would serve the end customers with performance guarantees. However, would
require very adaptable and frequency agile radios. Offloading onto unlicensed
spectrum such as TV whitespace or mmWave bands could have unexpected
results. In particular, adding an unlicensed shared band to an environment where a
set of operators have exclusive bands can lead to an overall decrease in the total
welfare. because operators might have an incentive to offload traffic even when
this runs counter to the overall social welfare, defined as the total profit of the
operators and the utilities of the users, minus the costs. An operator might have an
incentive to increase prices so that some traffic is diverted to the unlicensed band,
where the cost of interference is shared with other operators, and this price
increase more than offsets the operator’s benefits. Further, while unlicensed
spectrum generally lowers barriers to entry and increases competition, the
opposite could occur and in some circumstances a single monopoly operator could
emerge within the unlicensed bands.
6.2 Regulation and Standardization
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 31
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
Fig. 5 5G Timeline
1) 5G Standardization Status: Several regional forums and projects have been
established to shape the 5G vision and to study its key enabling technologies. For
example, the aforementioned EU project METIS has already released documents
on scenarios and requirements. Meanwhile, 5G has been increasingly referred to
as “IMT-2020” in many industry forums and international telecommunications
union (ITU) working groups [174] with the goal, as the name suggests, of
beginning commercial deployments around 2020. To explore 5G user
requirements and to elaborate a standards agenda to be driven by them, the ETSI
held a future mobile summit in Nov. 2013. The summit concluded, in line with the
thesis of this paper, that an evolution of LTE may not be sufficient to meet the
anticipated 5G requirements.
That conclusion notwithstanding, 5G standardization has not yet formally
started within 3GPP, which is currently finalizing LTE Rel-12 (the third release
for the LTE-Advanced family of 4G standards). The timing of 5G standardization
has not even been agreed upon, although it is not expected to start until later Rel-
14 or Rel-15, likely around 2016–2017. However, many on-going and proposed
study items for Rel-12 are already closely related to 5G candidate technologies
(e.g., massive MIMO) and thus, in that sense, the seeds of 5G are being planted in
3GPP. Whether an entirely new standards body will emerge for 5G which is
unclear; the ongoing success of 3GPP relative to its erstwhile competitors (3GPP2
and the WiMAX Forum) certainly gives it an advantage, although a name change
to 5GPP would seem to be a minimal step.
2) 5G Spectrum Standardization: Spectrum standardization and harmonization
efforts for 5G have begun within the ITU. Studies are under way on the feasibility
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 32
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
of bands above 6 GHz, including technical aspects such as channel modelling,
semiconductor readiness, coverage, mobility support, potential deployment
scenarios and coexistence with existing networks. To be available for 5G,
mmWave spectrum has to be repurposed by national regulators for mobile
applications and agreement must be reached in ITU world radio communication
conferences (WRC) on the global bands for mmWave communications. These
processes tend to be tedious and lengthy, and there are many hurdles to clear
before the spectrum can indeed be available. On the ITU side, WRC-18 is shaping
up as the time and venue to agree on mmWave spectrum allocations for 5G. In
addition to the ITU, many national regulators have also started their own studies
on mmWave spectrum for mobile communications. In the USA, the technological
advisory council of the federal communications committee (FCC) has carried out
extensive investigations on mmWave technology in the last few years and it is
possible that FCC will issue a notice of inquiry in 2014, which is always the first
step in FCC’s rulemaking process for allocation of any new frequency bands. As
discussed above, it is also unclear how such bands will be allocated or even how
they should be allocated, and the technical community should actively engage the
FCC to make sure they are allocated in a manner conducive to meeting 5G
requirements. Historically, other national regulators have tended to follow the
FCC’s lead on spectrum policy.
6.3 Economic Considerations
The economic costs involved in moving to 5G are substantial. Even if
spectrum costs can be greatly reduced through the approaches discussed above, it is
still a major challenge for carriers to densify their networks to the extent needed to
meet 5G requirements. Two major challenges are that BS sites are currently expensive
to rent, and so is the backhaul needed to connect them to the core network.
1) Infrastructure Sharing: One possible new business model could be based on
infrastructure sharing, where the owners of infrastructure and the operators are
different. There are several ways in which infrastructure could be shared.
Passive Sharing. The passive elements of a network include the sites
(physical space, rooftops, towers, masts and pylons), the backhaul connection,
power supplies, and air-conditioning. Operators could cover larger
geographical areas at a lower cost and with less power consumption if they
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 33
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
shared sites, and its might be of particular importance in dense 5G networks.
Regulation could be required to force major operators to share their sites and
improve competition.
Active Sharing. Active infrastructure sharing would involve antennas, BSs,
radio access networks and even core networks. BS and/or radio access
network sharing may be particularly attractive when rolling out small-cell
networks. This type of sharing could lead to collusion, with anticompetitive
agreements on prices and services. Regulations are required to prevent such
collusion, but on the positive side are the economies of scale.
Mobile virtual network operators. A small cell may be operated by a mobile
virtual network operator that does not own any spectrum but has entered into
an agreement with another operator to gain access to its spectrum within the
small cell. The small cell may provide coverage to an enterprise or business
such that, when a user leaves the enterprise, it roams onto the other operator’s
network.
Offloading. Roaming is traditionally used to increase coverage in scenarios
when service providers’ geographical reaches are limited. However, in 5G,
and as discussed above, traffic may be offloaded for a different reason: spatial
and temporal demand fluctuations. Such fluctuations will be greater in
smallcell networks. Recent papers consider the incentive for investment under
various revenue-sharing contracts that sharing increases investment, and the
incentive is greater if the owner of the infrastructure gets the larger fraction of
the revenue when overflow traffic is carried. A bargaining approach for data
offloading from a cellular network onto a collection of WiFi or femtocell
networks.
2) Backhaul: A major consideration that has been considered in several places
throughout the backhaul, which will be more challenging to provide for hyper-
dense ultra-fast networks. However, we find optimism in three directions.
Fiber deployments worldwide continue to mature and reach farther and farther
into urban corridors.
Wireless backhaul solutions are improving by leaps and bounds, with
considerable start-up activity driving innovation and competition. Further,
mmWave frequencies could be utilized for much of the small-cell backhauling
due to their ambivalence to interference. in fact be the first serious deployment
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 34
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
of non-LoS mmWave with massive beamforming gains given that the
backhaul connection is quite static and outdoors-to-outdoors, and thus more
amenable to precise beam alignment.
Backhaul optimization is becoming a pressing concern, given its new status as
a performance-limiting factor. The problem of jointly optimizing resources in
the radio network and across the backhaul. Compression techniques for uplink
cloud-RAN. Another approach is the proactive caching of high bandwidth
content like popular video.
CHAPTER 7
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 35
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
CONCLUSION
5G is the next step in the evolution of mobile communication and will be a
key component of the Networked Society. To enable connectivity for a wide range of
applications and use cases, the capabilities of 5G wireless access must extend far
beyond those of previous generations. These capabilities include very high achievable
data rates, very low latency and ultra-high reliability. Furthermore, 5G wireless access
needs to support a massive increase in traffic in an affordable and sustainable way,
implying a need for a dramatic reduction in the cost and energy consumption per
delivered bit.
5G wireless access will be realized by the evolution of LTE for existing
spectrum in combination with new RAT primarily targeting new spectrum. Key
technology components of 5G wireless access include extension to higher frequency
bands, advanced multi-antenna transmission, lean design, user/control separation,
flexible spectrum usage, device-to-device communication, and backhaul/access
integration.
CHAPTER 7
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 36
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
REFERENCES
1. Cisco, “Visual networking index,” white paper at Cisco.com, Feb. 2014.
2. D. Gesbert, S. Hanly, H. Huang, S. Shamai, O. Simeone, and W. Yu, “Multi
cell MIMO cooperative networks: A new look at interference,” IEEE Journal
on Sel. Areas in Communications, vol. 28, no. 9, pp. 1380 –1408, Dec. 2010.
3. S. Singh, M. Kulkarni, and J. G. Andrews, “A tractable model for rate in noise
limited mmwave cellular networks,” in Proc., IEEE Asilomar, Nov. 2014.
4. J. G. Andrews, “Seven ways that HetNets are a cellular paradigm shift,” IEEE
Communications Magazine, vol. 51, no. 3, pp. 136–144, Mar. 2013.
5. D. Bethanabhotla, O. Bursalioglu, H. C. Papadopoulos, and G. Caire, “User
association and load balancing for cellular massive MIMO,” in Proc.,
Information Theory and its Applications (ITA), Feb. 2014.
6. D. Ng, E. Lo, and R. Schober, “Energy-efficient resource allocation in
OFDMA systems with hybrid energy harvesting base station,” IEEE Trans. On
Wireless Communications, vol. 12, no. 7, pp. 3412–3427, Jul. 2013.
7. D. Ng, E. Lo, and R. Schober, “Energy-efficient resource allocation in
OFDMA systems with hybrid energy harvesting base station,” IEEE Trans. on
Wireless Communications, vol. 12, no. 7, pp. 3412–3427, Jul. 2013.
8. “Network function virtualization - network operator perspectives on industry
progress,” white paper, Oct. 2013.
[Online].Available: http://portal.etsi.org/NFV/NFV White Paper2.pdf
9. “Software-defined networking, the new norm for networks,” Apr. 2012.
[Online]. Available: http://www.opennetworking.org
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 37
What Will 5G Be? 2014-2015
10. Y. Benkler, “Open wireless vs. licensed spectrum: Evidence from market
adoption,” Harvard Journal of Law and Technology, vol. 26, no. 1, pp. 71 -
163, Oct. 2012.
11. R. Berry, M. Honig, and R. Vohra, “Spectrum markets: Motivation,
challenges, and implications,” IEEE Communications Magazine, vol. 48, no.
11, pp. 146–155, Nov. 2010.
12. J. Khun-Jush, P. Bender, B. Deschamps, and M. Gundlach, “Licensed shared
access as complementary approach to meet spectrum demands: Benefits for
next generation cellular systems,” ETSI Workshop on Reconfigurable Radio
Systems, Cannes, France, pp. 1–7, Dec. 2013.
13. ITU-R WP5D, “Work plan, timeline, process and deliverables for “IMT-2020”
development,” Feb. 2014.
14. Z. Zhu, P. Gupta, Q. Wang, S. Kalyanaraman, Y. Lin, H. Franke, and S.
Sarangi, “Virtual base station pool: towards a wireless network cloud for radio
access networks,” in Proc., ACM International Conference on Computing
Frontiers, 2011, p. 34.
Dept. of CS&E, Vemana Institute of Technology Page 38