what is the key to an amazing tiramisu__ - home cooking - chowhound

CHOWcups123 Oct 27, 2010 05:20 PM

What is the key to an amazing tiramisu??Seriously, I've had so many average or not so great tiramisus but I know when we were in italy, they were heavenly! I'mwondering what the trick to this is. In some ways, the recipes seem very simple and I wonder if in italy or even here,the people that make it well, maybe there is something more to it. The last time I made it, it didn't turn out righttexturally (too soggy).

I'm going to try and make my own ladyfingers though. I'm thinking that would probably make a big difference. Anyoneideas? Has anyone tried alternating the vanilla mascarpone layer with a mascarpone chocolate layer?

Any recipes or help would be appreciated!

75 Replies . Latest Feb 18, 2012 by lilgi

lilgi Feb 17, 2012 05:07 PM

I adore the recipe I use, and for those that have asked me for it, I advise against dunking the ladyfingerseven though mine is worded that way. The brush provides much more control, too much espresso trulyruins this dessert imo.

2 Replies

re: lilgi

prima Feb 18, 2012 10:47 PM

Thanks for mentioning that. I had dunked mine, and the tiramisu's ladyfinger layers were alittle soggier than I'd like. Will use a brush next time!

re: prima

lilgi Feb 18, 2012 11:17 PM

yeah, it's real easy to dunk one millionth of a second more than necessary :)

sunshine842 Feb 17, 2012 12:54 PM

Here's another back-of-the-package winner -- it's cooked, and rich as Rockefeller -- and an absolutelyfavorite every time I've made it.

http://www.sbiladyfingers.com/Recipes...

These are the ladyfingers sold in the bakery department of thousands of grocery stores across thecountry...soft, not crunchy - but the recipe rocks.

(I can't buy that brand any more - so I make it with the crunchy ones, but the recipe is still great)

2 Replies

re: sunshine842

prima Feb 17, 2012 04:20 PM

Will try this recipe next time...

What is the key to an amazing tiramisu?? - Home Cooking - Chowhound http://chowhound.chow.com/topics/743338#6018931

1 of 14 24/06/2013 09:09 p.m.

re: prima

sunshine842 Feb 17, 2012 10:34 PM

this past summer, I made strawberry tiramisu (which is funny, as it's just fancyshortcake!) for a "good china" dinner for company - I layered the lady fingers,brushed with orange juice and Cointreau, with this same lovely cream and slicedfresh strawberries into wine glasses, garnished with a small berry and some mintleaves and refrigerated.

Was very simple, but looked awesome and was OH so good.

westernmeadowlark Feb 17, 2012 12:40 PM

I make an amazing tiramisu, not even bragging. There used to be a wonderful italian-inspired-winecountry restaurant in Livermore, CA (my hometown), called Stoney Ridge Winery. They made the besttiramisu I've ever had in a restaurant. After they closed, I had to figure out how to replicate it at home.Most recipes call for eggs, but mine does not and I think it tastes all the better for it.

I started out with this recipe: http://www.cookingforengineers.com/recipe/26/Simple-Tiramisu

I change it up in several ways. No espresso, just a cup of brewed coffee to soak the ladyfingers, butthat's mostly because I don't have an espresso machine and don't want to run to the coffee shop to buyan espresso. I replace the brandy with kaluah liquor.

To make the mascarpone filling, I whip the cream well, then separately mix up the mascarpone, vanilla,kaluah and sugar so that it is soft, then (Most Important Step) shave about half a bar of chocolate intothe mascarpone mix using a microplane grater. Gently fold the mascarpone into the whipped cream.

Layer the soaked ladyfingers into the pan, then a layer of the mascarpone, then shave another quarterof the chocolate bar onto the mascarpone. put in the next layer of soaked ladyfingers, top with theremaining mascarpone, and shave the remainder of the chocolate bar over the top.

It's best if you let it come together in the fridge overnight - gives the ladyfingers time to equalize out andnot be soggy, and for the coffee to seep into the mascarpone.

In my opinion the chocolate shavings replacing the cocoa powder and scattered throughout the creammixture really elevate it

I'm considering trying to make my own mascarpone this weekend to try out in this recipe :)http://biology.clc.uc.edu/fankhauser/...

mMel.D Feb 17, 2012 12:25 PM

I think often times restaurant/store bought tiramisu isnt good because whatever cheese is used hasgotten stale or dried out. You need to buy very fresh mascarpone cheese. I wouldnt make the ladyfingers b/c the store bought ones are pretty good - I always use this brand http://www.capri-flavors.com/images/b... and the package comes with the BEST recipe!Make the espresso in advance and let it cool off.For me, for the best results, whip the egg whites with an electric or stand mixer until they form softpeaks and then fold the yolks (with any sugar already blended into the yolks) and mascarpone in verygently. Then you can start layering process. Dip the fingers into the espresso (use a shallow bowl anddont over fill so you dont drench the fingers just keep refilling it as the liquid is used up), cover a rowwith the mascarpone sprinkle the cocoa, repeat.

1 Reply

re: Mel.D

prima Feb 17, 2012 04:07 PM

I used some mascarpone that had been opened for another recipe a few weeks ago, but hadanother 6 weeks until its best before date, and the tiramisu still turned out much better than


2 of 14 24/06/2013 09:09 p.m.

most restaurant/store versions I've bought. I was a little concerned that it might not turn outthat great, but the marscarpone/egg layer (from this recipe http://www.epicurious.com/recipes/foo... ) was the best I've had in a long time.

Charles Yu Dec 15, 2011 08:02 PM

Best Tiramisu I had was not in Italy but a homemade one in Toronto!! The secret?! My friend usedExpresso from Blue Mountain coffee beans and added Hennessy XO Cognac with the Marsala wine!!Out of this world!!!

3 Replies

re: Charles Yu

prima Dec 16, 2011 11:39 AM

Interesting. I'm going to be using Illy, and haven't figured out the booze element yet. ProbablyFrangelico or Amaretto, maybe with a splash of cognac or brandy.

re: primammystikdrey Dec 16, 2011 01:06 PM

I always use amaretto... it is divine!

re: mystikdrey

prima Feb 16, 2012 12:27 PM

;-) Good to know!

prima Dec 15, 2011 07:57 AM

Does anyone have a cooked egg-version they'd like to share?Lidia's Limoncello version has cooked yolks, but the whites are still raw.http://www.epicurious.com/recipes/foo...

9 Replies

re: primaaantimony Dec 15, 2011 08:04 AM

What about using pasteurized raw eggs? If it's a safety, rather than a flavor issue you'reworried about.

re: antimony

prima Dec 15, 2011 08:28 AM

I don't know that pasteurized raw eggs are available in Canada, where I live, apartfrom in the form of Egg Beaters, which I don't think I'd want to use in a tiramisu. ;-) Igrocery-shop often, and I've never seen any pasteurized eggs for sale.

I guess I could just use the cooked yolks, and sub a little whipped cream for thewhites.

re: primaaantimony Dec 15, 2011 12:18 PM


3 of 14 24/06/2013 09:09 p.m.

They aren't hard to find around me (Boston, USA), and pasteurizedwhites are even more common, but I believe you.

There are also eggnog recipes I've seen that basically scald the mixture-- I bet you might be able to do something similar. But I've never tried it --I'm comfortable going with raw, myself.

But certainly I'd substitute before using Egg Beaters. Ew.

re: antimony

prima Dec 15, 2011 01:37 PM

I checked one of our better grocery stores today- there wereabout 10 varieties of eggs, including quails' eggs andhardboiled eggs in the shell, but no pasteurized eggs.

Don't worry, I'm not an Egg Beaters kind of cook. Can't bringmyself to buy them or try them. ;-)

re: prima

chowser Dec 15, 2011 02:30 PM

I just saw your question about cooked egg yolks. I'veused this recipe(I think it's an old one from BonAppetit) with cooked egg yolks. It's really creamyand I'm fine serving it to children, even with thealcohol...

http://www.brolenrecipes.com/view/sis...

re: chowser

prima Dec 15, 2011 02:34 PM

Thanks so much, chowser.

re: prima

splatgirl Dec 15, 2011 08:35 AM

My recipe calls for beating together egg yolks and sugar but not cooking. In the past, when Iwas adapting the recipe be to a firmer dessert that can be made in a springform pan and thensliced like a cake, I have cooked the eggs/sugar at this point--whisk over simmering wateruntil thick, just like you would any other egg sauce or custard. You could do this with anyrecipe.If you want "cooked" whites, use powdered. Or pasturized eggs on both counts.

Incidentally, this is NOT the route to the best tiramisu IMO. While I achieved the textural andfancier presentation goal I was going for, tiramisu really is not tiramisu unless it's kind ofpillowy and loose.

1. It's all about the best ingredients and finding your favorite booze element(s). Mine areKaluha and Frangelico--not traditional. A good marsala version ranks a very high second.2. Not too sweet! I repeat: NOT TOO SWEET. Also not too much chocolate. It's all aboutbalance. If you want a chocolate dessert make something else.3. As above, loose and pillowy but not oozing liquid. Made no more than one day ahead.4. Alessi brand dry ladyfingers, dunked in expresso to the count of three. Don't bother withfresh or homemade--they detract.

re: splatgirl

prima Dec 15, 2011 08:38 AM


4 of 14 24/06/2013 09:09 p.m.

thanks for all your comments & tips, splatgirl ;-)

re: prima

prima Feb 16, 2012 12:34 PM

found another version with cooked eggs: http://www.epicurious.com/recipes/foo...

rrjlebed Mar 22, 2011 08:55 AM

One thing that I add to mine between layers is finely chopped really good dark chocolate! Not traditionalbut adds texture and flavor. And, instead of just cocoa on the top layer I add some more of thechocolate only this time shaved.......... Yumm! I actually make mine layered in a bowl instead of in a panand spoon it out. Enjoy!!

jjenhen2 Mar 21, 2011 07:05 AM

I made the Cooks Illustrated version the other day for a dinner party, and let me say that I am lukewarmat best on Tiramisu, but I needed an Italian dessert, so that's what I made. It was honestly, the bestthing I've ever eaten! Creamy, light, and totally delicious! It uses whipped cream instead of egg whites,and I used light rum instead of dark, which gave it a subtle booziness without the strong alcohol flavor. Iwould highly, highly recommend the cooks illustrated recipe! (And for the record, I actually don't trustGiada's recipes one bit and would never turn to her for help with an Italian anything. She's ridiculous. Ofcourse, that's a discussion for another thread.)

3 Replies

re: jenhen2mMsBees Mar 21, 2011 08:33 AM

I wish I had tried this recipe. Right now I'm in the process of making Anne Burrells and itsmells very eggy. But there is no going back now I already added the mascarpone

re: jenhen2

iL Divo Dec 15, 2011 07:53 PM

I'm with you on this Jen, she is very generic about how she concocts things always referring toher Italian roots.

you really gave a huge shout out to CI regarding their tiramisu being the best thing you've evereaten. that's a great compliment.Is this the one?http://www.spokesmanreview.com/blogs/...

I'd love to try that.

egg yolkzabaglionemarscaponethe lady fingers from the Italian deli's in Providence RI

re: iL Divojjenhen2 Dec 27, 2011 06:18 PM

Sorry for the delay - just getting back to this thread now. Yes, that's the recipe. Myonly comment is that I had lots of coffee mixture left over, so next time I would do 2


5 of 14 24/06/2013 09:09 p.m.

cups of coffee and a little less espresso powder (but the same amount of rum!!).

mMsBees Mar 21, 2011 06:37 AM

HELP!!!!! All I could find was american style lady fingers. So I bought by weight, I'm going to double upthe lady fingers to simulate the thicker italian version lady finger. Here is my question.

Should I dry these american style lady fingers in the oven before using????

7 Replies

re: MsBees

HillJ Mar 21, 2011 06:46 AM

Hi MsBees, when you refer to american style do you mean the soft dough version sold in mostgrocery store bakery depts? If so, I wouldn't try to dry them but I would use a soft brushrather than the dipping method to soak in the liquor or espresso flavor. If I remember theseright, the soft lady fingers are split lengthwise and sort of a sandwich type of cookie. If I havethis right, I've seen them doubled and I've seen bakers spread filling between the split of thecookie as well as between the prepared layers. So you have a few options. Keeping thedessert cold is super important with soft lady fingers.

re: HillJmMsBees Mar 21, 2011 08:35 AM

Thanks hillj. Yikes I drid them out. They seem fine. We shall see what happens. I'mserving it to college students. Hopefully they won't know the difference.

re: MsBees

HillJ Mar 21, 2011 08:38 AM

Ha! Well how did drying them out work? I would still brush on not dip theliquid so they remain as dry as possible.

re: HillJmMsBees Mar 21, 2011 12:08 PM

:) the drying worked perfectly but the egg mascarpone mixturewas a disaster. It was so bad I threw it out. :(

I guess I'll be making tiramisu later this week.

re: MsBees

HillJ Mar 21, 2011 12:31 PM

http://chowhound.chow.com/topics/701577MsBees, on this link is a tiramisu recipe by CH Kater.It's fast, straight forward and delicious. I would highlyrecommend trying it when you're ready to beginagain. If it makes you feel any better, we've all hadour recipe disasters and practice does make(delicious) perfect! Good luck!

re: HillJm


6 of 14 24/06/2013 09:09 p.m.

MsBees Mar 22, 2011 03:50 AM

Thanks HillJ. I have it bookmarked. :)

re: MsBees

HillJ Mar 22, 2011 05:29AM

My pleasure.

hHarters Oct 29, 2010 02:16 PM

I've never made it myself but, based on restaurant eatings, the success for me hangs on the flavour ofgood strong coffee and an appropriate shot of Marsala.

rRick Oct 29, 2010 10:32 AM

One word, Amaretto.

iIsolda Oct 28, 2010 05:33 PM

I hate tiramisu, but my son adores it and is always asking for it. I would love to find a recipe that mightchange my mind, if that is possible.

2 Replies

re: Isolda

bushwickgirl Oct 28, 2010 11:25 PM

Maybe you just need to change the flavor profile? Here's a limoncello tiramisu recipe I'vemade, admittedly in the summer months, rather than now, and it's just delicious, especially ifyou make your own limoncello:

http://www.epicurious.com/recipes/foo...

re: bushwickgirlccups123 Oct 29, 2010 04:12 AM

okay so, do they really use ladyfingers in italy or the high end bakeries in the US?Does the ladyfinger soak up the surrounding liquid such that it sort of melds into onelayer because I swear the tiramisu I have had the "ladyfinger layer" is a soft cakeyone layer type texture. I'm assuming that they don't typically put a cake layer forreasons stated above.

Also, how do people feel about the use of raw eggs? apparently that is moreauthentic.

The type of tiramisu I like is sweet but also has a certain bitterness to it, i'massuming that is the espresso.

If you make your own ladyfingers (i don't have a trader joes around), do the recipesonline provide a hard, crispy texture?

chowser Oct 28, 2010 12:58 PM


7 of 14 24/06/2013 09:09 p.m.

I like making my own ladyfingers best, using a savoiardi recipe. But a good store bought one works well,too. I have spent a fortune on some at an Italian deli/bakery and bought some that cost much less fromTrader Joe's (not sure if it's seasonal) and they've worked about the same. I like tiramisu that uses a lotof egg yolks for an extra creamy texture. This is one of my favorite recipes (it's called tiramisu eggnogtrifle but is a tiramisu--don't know why they called it something different). I like marsala better than rumin it. Realy, you can't go wrong w/ 12 egg yolks and 4 8 oz packages of mascarpone.

http://www.epicurious.com/recipes/foo...

5 Replies

re: chowser

ipsedixit Oct 28, 2010 03:31 PM

I've never found the real upside of making ladyfingers. The effort to reward ratio just isn'tworth the time in my opinion.

Now, that being said, if I am going to make my own tiramisu base, you know what's actually apretty good alternative and actually worth the time and effort? Biscotti.

re: ipsedixit


It never seemed like much work to me but I love playing with a pastry bag. I'venever tried it with biscotti but that sounds great, even just a plain trifle would begood.

re: chowser


Or day old, stale pound cake.

In fact, when I have extra pound cake that's just sort of lying around, I'llleave it in the fridge, uncovered, overnight and voila (!) perfect tiramisubase.

re: chowserpPandora Oct 28, 2010 08:49 PM

I'm interested in hearing more about the Trader Joe's ladyfingers. I picked them up once andtheye seemed hard, so I didn't buy them and got some from the supermarket instead. But itsounds like ladyfingers are supposed to be crispy so maybe the Trader Joes version isactually better? I always thought ladyfingers were supposed to be soft like sponge cake.

re: Pandora

chowser Oct 29, 2010 03:21 AM

You want the hard ones because they'll soften up in the mix. The sponge cake oneswill almost dissolve if you try to dip them in coffee and end up very mushy.

ttoomuchfat Oct 28, 2010 11:17 AM

I think tiramisu is over rated but that's another issue. However, what makes a tiramisu particularly crappyis a wet one. Do not overdip the ladyfingers.

For those of you who love, love, love tiramisu, why?


8 of 14 24/06/2013 09:09 p.m.

I think it's very one-note...YAWN.

8 Replies

re: toomuchfat

ipsedixit Oct 28, 2010 11:30 AM

For those of you who love, love, love tiramisu, why?

I think it's very one-note...YAWN.

___________________________________

It maybe because you've never had a real good one made with quality ingredients.

So many times the commercial tiramisu you can buy at bakeries or restaurants are eitheressentially wet breadsticks soaked with coffee and topped with cream cheese, or soadulterated and gussied up as to be closer to ice cream cake than traditional tiramisu.

As to "one-note". Lots of things are "one-note" ... chocolate cake, vanilla ice cream, sugarcookies, etc., and all those things -- when done right -- are fantastic. In fact, vanilla ice creamis my favorite ice cream flavor in addition to be the most popular (or 2nd most popular) icecream flavor.

Just my 0.02, of course ... and feel free to leave your piece of tiramisu for me.

re: ipsedixitttoomuchfat Oct 28, 2010 01:45 PM

I have had tiramisu at high-end restaurants, presumably made with high qualityingredients and that made by my wife that had good quality ingredients since Ibought them.

I agree with you in concept about some of the one-note delicious foods. However,for me, I prefer to have a counterpoint...something different in taste, texture, ortemperature.

I prefer vanilla ice cream with some chocolate sauce and toasted almonds over abowl of great but monotonous vanilla ice cream with nothing. Or, maybe with a nicecookie.

You get the point.

re: ipsedixitiIsolda Oct 28, 2010 05:35 PM

You think vanilla ice cream is one note? A really delicious, homemade,custard-based vanilla ice cream is a symphony!

re: Isolda

invinotheresverde Mar 21, 2011 07:21 AM

Seriously. It's the best stuff on earth!

re: Isolda

sunshine842 Mar 21, 2011 12:53 PM

the most memorable gelato in Italy I had over a two week vacation (hint:that's a LOT of gelato!) was in a little shop in Siena. Don't know why, but


9 of 14 24/06/2013 09:09 p.m.

the vanilla just looked really good, so that's what I got.

I like vanilla, and a really good vanilla ice cream has plenty of depth offlavor....

But this? This was roll your eyes back in your head, sigh a little, thenskulk off into a corner where you can guard it with your life, growling at allwho dare approach until it's gone good.

Tiramisu's a lot like that...it can be really plain and not very special, or itcan be mindblowing and memorable when it's really good.

Worst tiramisu ever was in Salt Lake City...no liquor, which I expected,but no coffee (which I didn't realize was off-limits when I ordered it),either, which means you got a bowl of dry-as-dust cookies with somewhipped cream and some shaved chocolate.

Yuck.

re: Isolda

iL Divo Dec 15, 2011 07:39 PM

"A really delicious, homemade, custard-based vanilla ice cream is asymphony"I love how you said that :)

re: toomuchfat


I think tiramisu is too often made poorly and that's generally the case. There are layers ofcreamy flavor to a good tiramisu.

re: toomuchfat

boyzoma Oct 28, 2010 02:43 PM

Well, as one who loves tiramisu, it is not one note. Yes, it has to be of good qualityingredients, but it also has layers of flavors and textures. Otherwise you could be eatingsomething like a mousse (don't get me wrong - I love a good mousse) or pudding. Just myown opinion.

aarp29 Oct 28, 2010 08:02 AM

I've had much success with this recipe:http://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/gi...

This will give you the chocolately mascarpone that you were asking about. Like others have noted, Iagree that it is important to use the firm lady fingers and not to over dip them.


You speak of a topic near and dear to my heart ... as a fanatic of ice cream (and all things icy andcreamy), I simply adore tiramisu.

So, lets discuss.

Tiramisu has many many variations, with the only constant probably being the mascarpone cheese.

At it's core, tiramisu is essentially a semifreddo, an Italian ice cream cake of sorts. So if you think of it inthose terms and begin the process with that as your fulcrum, things are a bit easier.


10 of 14 24/06/2013 09:09 p.m.

So lets start with the basic ingredients and figure out where we want to start and end.

Eggs.In Italy, the tiramisu you had probably used raw eggs. Many recipes in the U.S. will either use cookedeggs (at least eggs heated in a double broiler, or bain-marie) for fear of Salmonella poisoning, orcompletely sub out the eggs with whipped cream. (Some people get even more fancy and bain-mariethe egg yolks, only, and use whipped cream in place of the egg whites.) Stay traditional ... use raweggs. Remember, you're trying to make a Zabaglione, not a custard.

Espresso.Use good quality real Italian espresso, not American espresso. This might be another area where yourexperience here and in Italy differed. Many commercial (incl. restaurants) will use weak or Americanespresso which is generally more bitter than its Italian counterpart, or (gasp!) coffee. But understandsomething, using real espresso will be expensive if you do not have an espresso machine and wholebeans at home. For example most recipes call for something like 1.5 or 2 cups of espresso. If you pricethat out (either in shots or fluid ounces), you can easily end up paying something like $20 or more just forthe espresso from a coffee shop. That said, the cost is worth it and your tummy will thank you for it.

Cocoa powderUse the Natural Cocoa Powder. Not (and I repeat, not) the Dutch Cocoa powder you might find at themarket.

Lady Fingers, or the base.Use Italian lady fingers, Savoiardi. They are thicker than typical American style ladyfingers and arespongy enough to be highly absorbent but still retain a good crispness to them.

Wine or liquorUse sweet Marsala wine. Some will call for things like Kahlua, Rum or even Bourbon or whiskey. Staytrue to the original, use sweet Marsala.

LayersGo two layers (e.g. ladyfinger, filling, ladyfinger, filing, cocoa powder). Don't do one, and don't gobeyond two.

Those are the key basics as I see them for making a classic tiramisu. Once you've got those down, youcan experiment and adjust your ingredients and/or make additions as you see fit to suit your tastes.

Good luck and enjoy.

4 Replies

re: ipsedixitllidia Oct 30, 2010 04:05 AM

$20 or more just for the espresso from a coffee shop !!!

Just get an inexpensive 6-cup aluminum Moka coffeemaker and a can/packet of Lavazza. Imake it double-strength (1/2 the water) for tiramisu; takes 3-4 rounds to get 2 cups.

I agree with all your other tips!!

I use a "Balducci's" recipe found on the web and have never had any complaints from Italians.I use the packaged (dry) ladyfingers available here and there is no real problem withsogginess; you just have to keep an eye on drizzling the espresso evenly and slowly, until theladyfingers have absorbed it to their maximum, but not beyond. That's where the double-strength espresso makes a big difference.

re: lidia


lidia,

Re: making espresso in coffeemaker. I generally find it lacking because espresso issupposed to made with hot water that is heated to just the right temperature (about


11 of 14 24/06/2013 09:09 p.m.

15 degrees below boiling) and with the water forced through the ground beans withjust the right pressure. A coffeemaker *can* make espresso with espresso beans,but it's just not the same for me ... not rich and lacks depth of flavor.

But lucky for me, I found a used espresso machine at a yard sale ... :-)

re: ipsedixit

invinotheresverde Mar 21, 2011 07:20 AM

"Stay true to the original, use sweet Marsala".

I don't know. It's pretty damned good with Sambuca...

re: ipsedixit

njmarshall55 Feb 16, 2012 02:43 PM

What he or she said! The only problem I find with ALL my trials at this, is leftover. Regardlessof my choices for ingredients, if it's not eaten all at once, it WILL go mushy on you. Guess it'sthe nature of the beast. I suppose it's like those cannoli's you see in the rotating cake case ina diner...they LOOK mushy..and sad...

JungMann Oct 27, 2010 07:31 PM

Definiely use the firm lady fingers as HillJ sugggests, and do not oversoak them. The dry portions of thecookie will continue to wick the liquid in the wet portion. I find, also, that using Irish creme for the liquoryields fantastic results.

HillJ Oct 27, 2010 06:04 PM

There are diff approaches to tiramisu. Some focus on the espresso coffee flavor others the chocolateshavings. Those components are definately key but getting the lady finger dipped right is everything.Soggy tiramisu is usually a soggy lady finger issue. I wouldn't make lady fingers from scratch for thisparticular recipe (but homemade is lovely for many other purposes so don't let me discourage you) butusing firm not soft baked lady fingers would be my recommendation straight off. Next is your marcaponecheese; buy the best quality you can find. My fav recipe is from Giada which can be found on the FNwebsite easily. She also does a raspberry tiramisu that is fantastic. Good luck!

10 Replies

re: HillJ

mamachef Oct 27, 2010 07:42 PM

+1 on HillJ: the quality of the products you put into it will have a direct bearing on the finishedproduct - and that means the liquers also. I can't even tell you how many mediocre TiramisusI've had because the maker used cheap alcohol. It really makes a difference. I haven't done achocolate layer, but I've done an espresso layer and it was marvelous.

re: mamachef

HillJ Oct 27, 2010 08:05 PM

I don't use alcohol of any kind in my tiramisu. I just never cared for the taste and mykids enjoy tiramisu so I wouldn't add it on their account. But I have used extractsand one really unique version uses Anise; very diff. I also don't care for cocoapowder of any kind in this recipe, much prefer dark chocolate shavings mid layerand on top.

But the important thing is to make a tiramisu that appeals to your preference and ifyou begin with really good quality, firm baked lady fingers, a great quality


12 of 14 24/06/2013 09:09 p.m.

marcapone cheese you're well on your way.

Recently I had a pumpkin tiramisu at a party and it was very tasty. I couldn'timagine the combo of pumpkin & espresso...but it really worked.

re: HillJ

iL Divo Oct 28, 2010 03:56 PM

I was just going to post here HillJ that I am fond of it too but not with theinclusion of alcohol. The biggest problem I find when ordering it (notalways but it is common) is the soggy factor. When i've made it I get thelady fingers from a Little Italy deli. They're packaged and very crisp,almost could seem delicate but maybe have to be to stand up to typicalingredients. I prefer those coffee syrups if I need to add a certainsomething extra or simply rely on the coffee or expresso to bepredominant.

I prefer creamy and rich to soggy and mooshy.

re: iL Divo

HillJ Oct 28, 2010 03:58 PM

Couldn't agree more, iLD. Some of the syrups sold atStarbucks work incredibly well in tiramisu.

re: HillJ

iL Divo Dec 15, 2011 07:34 PM

HillJ, I should list the flavors I've bought that arebrilliant.

re: HillJ

HillJ Oct 27, 2010 08:21 PM

http://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/gi...This is Giada's basic recipe; as I mentioned I omit the rum and go with dark chocolate for myfamily.

re: HillJ

mcel215 Oct 29, 2010 01:49 AM

I made a delcious Tiramisu last weekend for a family gathering. It was Giada'srecipe with a few changes.

I used a shot of brandy in the egg yoke/mascarpone mixture and a tablespoon of itin with the coffee. Also, on top of the first layer, I heavily sprinkled dutch cocoapowder. On top of the second layer, I sprinkled it again heavily with the cocoa andalso did chocolate shavings.

I was surprised how much I liked the brandy in it. And yes, I could taste thealchohol, but to me it was very authentic tasting.

And I have made it with both soft and hard ladyfingers, the hard ones I dip in thecoffee mixture, the soft ones I let sit on the counter for a few hours to air dry. And Ipaint them with the coffee mixture, so they don't get soaggy at all.

I love Tiramisu.


13 of 14 24/06/2013 09:09 p.m.

re: mcel215

chef chicklet Mar 22, 2011 10:11 AM

I like the sound of yours too. I vote for the alchohol as well. I will justmake two, one for the adults and one for the non/drinkers and children.

re: chef chicklet

mcel215 Dec 15, 2011 11:26 AM

Thanks, I'm making it again for Christmas myself. :)

re: HillJaattran99 Oct 29, 2010 09:40 AM

I love Giada's recipe, too. I like mine on the sweeter side, so I increase the sugar to 1/4 cup.If at your disposal, try to find fresh mascapone cheese and fresh egg...it does make adifference. I use Italian ladyfingers that you can pick up from any Italian market.

boyzoma Oct 27, 2010 05:24 PM

I don't have a recipe for you, but I'm glad you started this thread. I too am a tiramisu lover and will beavidly following this post.


14 of 14 24/06/2013 09:09 p.m.

what is the key to an amazing tiramisu__ - home cooking - chowhound

Documents

lilgi prima

prima lilgi

lilgi lilgi

sunshine842 prima

prima sunshine842

time ive

amazing tiramisu

recipe rocks