western theories of international...
TRANSCRIPT
Western Theories of International Relations
Spring 2018
PAN Zhongqi 潘忠岐 Professor, SIRPA, Fudan R625, Wenke Building Tel: 13917273597; Email: [email protected]
Gustaaf Geeraerts Professor, SIRPA, Fudan R718, Wenke Building Tel: 13761743128 Email: [email protected]
Syllabus and Course Overview
Ø 网络课堂登陆方法 p http://202.120.227.42/ p http://educenter.fudan.edu.cn/ p 用户名:zqpan 密码:(不需要)
Ø 精品课程建设 p http://jpkcmake.fudan.edu.cn/d201429/
main.psp Ø 助教:于凡超
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 2
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 3
Approaches to
International Relations (IR)
Chapter 1
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 4
International Relations in Daily Life
Ø International events in everyday lives p The civil war in Syria p Terrorist attacks by IS p The North Korean nuclear crisis p The G-20 summits p The economic crisis of 2008 and the
Great Recession p The growth of China’s economy
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 5
International Relations in Daily Life
Ø Immediate relevance of remote events p The civil war in Syria p Terrorist attacks by IS p The North Korean nuclear crisis p The G-20 summits p The economic crisis of 2008 and the
Great Recession p The growth of China’s economy
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 6
International Relations in Daily Life
Ø Personal participation in IR p Living p Traveling p Shopping p Learning p Working
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 7
International Relations in Daily Life
Ø Implications for IR p Actors in IR are various. p Nation-states are major but not the only
actors. p “Non-state actors” – IOs, NGOs,
MNCs, and individuals are all actors. p International relations is not just
relations among nations.
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 8
International Relations in Daily Life
Ø Implications for IR p IR is the study of the interactions
among the various actors that participate in international politics, including states, IOs, NGOs, sub-national entities like bureaucracies and local governments, and individuals.
p Other appellations for IR are: international politics, world politics, global politics.
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 9
International Relations in Daily Life
Ø Foundational Questions of IR p How can human nature be characterized? p What roles does the individual play in IR? p What are the characteristics of the state? p What drives states’ international
behavior? p What are the characteristics of the
international system? p How might international system be
structured to achieve order?
Why bother about theories?
Ø Theories are instruments to analyse the world around us.
Ø We see ourselves confronted with a host of questions about international relations.
Ø How to answer them? Ø That is where IR theories come in.
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 10
What do theories do?
Ø They organize the world in a certain way. Ø They indicate what is more or ress
important. Ø They allow us to ponder important
questions. Ø They help us to order our knowledge
about important problems and do that in a way that stimulates us to find answers to those very problems.
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 11
A wonder medecin?
Ø Theories are helpful, but certainly do not solve all our problems.
Ø They do not tell us which theory to choose. Ø We can try to develop criteria for the selection of
theories (epistemology) but these are always controversial up to some point.
Ø Whenever we use a theory we need to be aware of its assumptions (and thus its limitations).
Ø The course aims to help you in developing this ability.
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 12
What is this thing called “theory”?
Ø Speculation Ø Abstraction, generalization and making
connections Ø System of empirically tested hypotheses
(empirical theory) Ø A system of generalizations (laws)
obtained through empirical observation (positivism)
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 13
What is this thing called “theory”?
Ø Theories explain general tendencies, that is recurring conjunctions between variables generated by underlying mechanisms (scientific realism)
Ø An image of how the world should be (normative theory)
Ø A critique of the present order, while at the same time, offering a perspective of change and emancipation (radical and critical theory, Marx, Wallerstein, Cox)
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 14
Evaluating theories
Ø Understanding of a given process or problem
Ø Explanatory power Ø Anticipation of future developments
(prediction?) Ø Consistency and coherence Ø Scope and depth Ø The level of critical self-reflection and
intellectual engagement with competing theories
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 15
Some rules of thumb for judging theories
Ø A sound theory is/has p Consistent p Lucid p Explicit p Scope p Depth
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 16
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 17
Thinking Theoretically
Ø You need to be clear as to whether what kind of theory you are dealing with (causal, constitutive, normative).
Ø You need to understand what an underlying mechanism is. Scientific analysis is in essence about processes and phenomena that are not directly observable.
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 18
Thinking Theoretically
Ø When you study a given phenomenon or process you need to always ask yourself of what it is an instance, the larger pattern or process it belongs to.
Ø You must be ready to appreciate and accept the need to sacrifice detailed descriptions for broad observations. Theory is about more than mere description.
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 19
Thinking Theoretically
Ø You must be tolerant of ambiguity, concerned about probabilities, and distrustful of absolutes.
Ø You must be playful about international phenomena.
Ø You must be genuinely puzzled by international phenomena.
Ø You must be constantly ready to be proven wrong.
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 20
Thinking Theoretically
Ø Competing explanations of IR p Realism p Liberalism p Radicalism (Marxism) p Critical theory (constructivism)
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 21
Thinking Theoretically
Ø Realism: a billiard table
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 22
Thinking Theoretically
Ø Liberalism: a cobweb
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 23
Thinking Theoretically
Ø Radicalism: layers of cake? (material)
24
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 25
Thinking Theoretically
Ø Critical theory (constructivism): layers of cake? (discourse )
26
Structure (culture)
Agents
Shapes/ Maintains/ Transforms
Influences
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 27
Thinking Theoretically
Ø Stephen Walt p No single approach can capture all the
complexity of contemporary world politics.
p Therefore we are better off with a diverse array of competing ideas rather then a single theoretical orthodoxy.
p Competition between theories helps reveal their strengths and weaknesses and spurs subsequent refinements, while revealing flaws in conventional wisdom.
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 28
Developing the Answers
Ø History p Answers have been discovered in history. p History provides us a crucial background
for the study of IR. p History not only provides detailed
knowledge of specific events, but also serves as a yardstick to test generalizations.
p Thucydides (460-400 BC) and his History of the Peloponnesian War
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 29
Developing the Answers
Ø Philosophy p Plato (427-347 B.C.) p Greek political philosopher. The Republic, is a Socratic dialogue, written by Plato around 380 BC, concerning justice, the order and character of the just, city-state, and the just man.
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 30
Developing the Answers
Ø Philosophy p Plato (427-347 B.C.) p Greek political philosopher. In the book's dialogue, Socrates discusses the meaning of justice and whether or not the just man is happier than the unjust man. They consider the natures of existing regimes and then propose a series of different, hypothetical cities in comparison. This culminates in the discussion of Kallipolis, a hypothetical city-state ruled by a philosopher king.
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 31
Developing the Answers
Ø Philosophy p Aristotle (384-322 B.C.) p Greek political philosopher who addressed the problem of order in the individual Greek city-state. The first to use the comparative method of research, observing multiple points in time and suggesting explanations for the patterns found.
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 32
Developing the Answers
Ø Philosophy p Hobbes (1588-1679) p English political philosopher who in Leviathan described life in a state of nature as solitary, selfish, and brutish. Individuals and society can escape from the state of nature through the establishment of a strong authority embodied in the state, a Leviathan.
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 33
Developing the Answers
Ø Philosophy p Rousseau (1712-1778) p French political philosopher whose Social
Contract helped inspire political reforms or revolutions in Europe, especially in France. The Social Contract argued against the idea that monarchs were divinely empowered to legislate. Rousseau asserts that only the people, who are sovereign, have that all-powerful right.
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 34
Developing the Answers
Ø Philosophy p Rousseau (1712-1778) p Rousseau posits that the political aspects
of a society should be divided into two parts. First, there must be a sovereign consisting of the whole population, women included, that represents the general will and is the legislative power within the state.
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 35
Developing the Answers
Ø Philosophy p Rousseau (1712-1778) p The second division is that of
the government, being distinct from the sovereign. This division is necessary because the sovereign cannot deal with particular matters like applications of the law. Doing so would undermine its generality, and therefore damage its legitimacy.
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 36
Developing the Answers
Ø Philosophy p Rousseau (1712-1778) p Thus, government must remain a separate
institution from the sovereign body. When the government exceeds the boundaries set in place by the people, it is the mission of the people to abolish such government, and begin anew.
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 37
Developing the Answers
Ø Philosophy p Kant (1724-1804) p German political philosopher who is a
central figure in modern philosophy. Kant argues that the human mind creates the structure of human experience and that reason is the source of morality, In Perpetual Peace, he advocated a world federation of constitutional republics bound by the rule of law.
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 38
Developing the Answers
Ø Alternative Approaches p Behavioralism (positivism) • Finding patterned ways of behavior
(inductivism) EG: Singer and Small on the causes of war
• Explaining recurring patterns of behavior (deductivism)
EG: Waltz’s balance of power theory
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 39
Developing the Answers
Ø Alternative Approaches p Critical theory • Postmodernism: concept deconstruction EG: Cynthia Weber on sovereignty
• Constructivism: discourse analysis EG: Peter Katzenstein and The Culture of National Security
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 40
Integrating the Answers
Ø The Correlates of War project p Turning to statistical data to discover
general patterns of wars • Collect data. • Generate specific testable hypotheses that
explain the outbreak of war. • Connect the relationships that are found
into a coherent theory of why wars occur.
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 41
Integrating the Answers
Ø The Democratic Peace Debate p Whether democracies are more peaceful
than non-democracies? • Yes: since 1789 no wars have been fought
between independent states with democratically elective governments.
• No: democratic governments were not noticeably more peace-prone.
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 42
In Sum: Making Sense of IR
Ø To ask and answer core foundational questions of IR, the realist, liberal, radical, and critical theories provide frameworks.
Ø To find explanations of international events, IR scholars also use insights from many other disciplines, including history, philosophy, economics, behavioral psychology, and critical studies.
Approaches to Studying IR History Offers a rich source for examining individual or
multiple cases.
Philosophy Offers reasoned expositions about the world around us as they can be found in the work of famous philosophers
Behaviouralism (positivism)
Finds patterns in human behavior and state behavior using empirical methods (induction) Explains these recurring patterns on the basis of general assumptions (deduction)
Critical Alternative Deconstructs major concepts and uses discourse analysis to build thick description.
Zhongqi Pan/Gustaaf Geeraerts 44
In Sum: Making Sense of IR
Ø IR is a pluralistic and eclectic discipline. Ø To understand IR, we need the help of IR
theory. Ø And to understand IR theory, we need to
examine general “stuff” of diplomatic history.