welcome to dell emc networking · 18-09-2017  · • macvlan: each container gets an individual...

40
- Gartner Welcome to Dell EMC Networking “The world’s most innovative, disruptive & visionary networking vendor…” Internal Use - Confidential

Upload: others

Post on 20-May-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

- Gartner

Welcome to Dell

EMC Networking

“The world’s most innovative, disruptive &

visionary networking vendor…”

Internal Use - Confidential

Page 2: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

2

Internal Use - Confidential

Recognition and Vision from Gartner

2014 2015 2016

“All organizations globally should consider Dell EMC, provided there is appropriate channel and sales coverage with networking skills in the region” – Extract from Gartner Magic Quadrant for Data Center Networking, July 2017

2017

Page 3: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Trends in

Networking

Bernd Kornmaier

Page 4: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Agenda

• Data Center Transformations

• Ethernet Evolution

• In-Rack Networking Trends

• Data Center Fabrics & Interconnect Trends

• Open Networking Software Trends

Page 5: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Data Centers enablers of Digital Transformation

Mobile Apps

Web 2.0

Cloud Services

Big Data

Web

Wireless

Device Explosion

CONTENT ACCESSDATA CENTER

EXPLOSION

Multi-Cloud

Open Source

Virtualization

Containers/Microservices

SDN

NFV

Datacenter Network Must Enable Digital Transformation, Adapt to 3rd Platform

Source: IDC 2017

Page 6: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Traditional and Cloud-Native IT

ITIL-based

IT processes

Client-server

scale-up apps

Infrastructure

resiliency

Coexisting IT paradigms

DevOps based

IT processes

Distributed

scale-out apps

Application

resiliency

Page 7: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Dell EMC is challenging the networking status quo

Proprietary

ASICs

Proprietary

architectures

Proprietary

software

Shifting the paradigm

Business

agility

Investment

protection

Innovation

velocity

Traditional Networking Open Networking

Page 8: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Ethernet Evolution

Page 9: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

100GbE & Beyond: Ethernet Trajectory

Total DC Ethernet ports

shipped * Dell Oro Group

Demand Growth * LightCounting

100G Adoption will ramp

faster than 40G * Dell Oro Group

Cloud Early Adoption* LightCounting

Page 10: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

In-Rack Networking Trends

Page 11: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

100GbE takes off

…Result is 100GbE has

become the new 40GbE

• High Density Single chip solutions – Lower System Costs

• Economies of scale benefitting Optics –Lower Optics Cost

• Switch ASIC process technology evolution –lower Power

• Switch ASIC lookup engine efficiencies –lower Latency

• Backwards Compatible Form Factors

• Higher switch radix - 100GbE ready for Aggregation / Spine

Page 12: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Transition Use Case - 10GbE Down / 100GbE Up

S4

10

0 L

eaf

100GbE Spine

10G

bE

10G

bE

• With onset of affordable 100G in the

Aggregation layers, existing rack

components need to connect to 100GbE

Fabric

• Optimize infrastructure with 10GbE down to

the rack and 100GbE up to the fabric

• Dell has responded with 2 new families:

– S4100 Series

– S4200 Series

Page 13: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

25GbE in the Rack

Take advantage of embedded 25GbE

I/O’s shipping in the latest generation

of servers, storage & networking

• Expand use of virtualization

technologies in both servers and

storage

• Grow use of cloud-based and web-scale

technology

• Increase use of flash technology in

storage systems requiring high-speed

I/O

• Increase I/O performance for multi-

processor servers

25GbE

NIC

25GbE

NIC

14G Server

iSCSI Storage Systems

10/25GbE 10/25GbE

3

25GbE

25GbE

10

0G

bE

100GbE

Page 14: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Move to 25GE on Servers is Happening

10/40G

25/100G

Page 15: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Emerging Use Case - 25GbE Down / 100GbE Up

S5

10

0 L

eaf

100GbE Spine

25G

bE

25G

bE

• As soon as 25GbE hits economies of scale (near parity with 10G) -- 25G will become the de-facto standard.

• 25G down and 100G is the coming default build demand. Better utilization of existing components

• Dell Responds with multiple 25G TOR options

– Z9100-ON – 25G Breakout Support

– S6100-ON – 25G Breakout Support

– S5048-ON – Native 25G Support

– S5148-ON – Native 25G Support

Page 16: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Data Center Fabric Trends

Page 17: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Fabric Trends

ARCHITECTURES

Scale Out

Leaf-and-Spine

MANAGEMENT

DevOps

Fabric-wide Mgmt.

SOFTWARE DEFINED

Operational Agility

Software Defined Fabric

CONVERGENCE

RDMA over Converged Ethernet

NVMe over Fabric

AUTOMATION

Fabric Controllers

Workflow Automation

VIRTUALIZATION

Multitenancy

Overlay Networking

Page 18: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Scale out Multitenant Data Center Fabrics (EVPN)• Scale-out Network Virtualization with BGP EVPN VXLAN

• BGP EVPN - Controller-less switch based Ethernet VPN

technology for scale out data center fabrics

• Leverage traditional layer 3 underlay

• BGP control plane for VXLAN overlays

• Inter-tenant Routing (VRFs) and Multi-homing (VLT)

• Benefits

• Open and standards based fabric technology

• Scalable multitenancy

• VM Mobility in the overlay

• Use Cases

• Intra Data Center Network Overlays

• Data Center Interconnects (DCI)

BGP Control Plane

VXLAN Data Plane

IP Underlay

EVPN

Page 19: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

EVPN Technology Overview

VTEP-1 VTEP-3 VTEP-4VTEP-1 VTEP-5

iBGP EVPN iBGP EVPN

VLTVLT

IP

BGP EVPN RR BGP EVPN RR

VRRP VRRP

VRF VRF

VTEP-2 VTEP-5

BGP EVPNAS 65001

Configure BGP EVPN address family and IP underlay; VLT for dual homing

Configure VxLAN VNI-to-VLAN map

Configure VRFs and associate VNIs for tenant segmentation

1 2 3

Page 20: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Data Center Interconnects (DCI)

• Interconnecting Data Centers over a Private

Wide Area Network

• Market disruption via merchant silicon based

platforms and disaggregated model

• Traditional technologies: IP Routing, MPLS

• Emerging technologies: BGP EVPN VXLAN

• Public Clouds and Service Providers: Segment

Routing

• Advances in long reach Optical technologies

(100G and Beyond) enablers of traditional

switching for DCI use cases

Page 21: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Fabric Automation Trends

Cloud Based Fabric Design & Deployment• Simplifies and automates new fabric deployments and scale

out of existing fabrics in the data center.

Intent based configuration

• Design driven by specifying business intent

Dell EMC SmartFabric

Dell EMC Fabric Design Center

Faster time to deployment• Plug-and-play fabric deployment

Predictable always-on performance• Automatic topology validation

Fabric-level management• One cli, API, & console to design, build and monitor fabrics

Self-healing fabric

• Automatically detects fabric misconfigurations or link

level failure conditions

Page 22: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Open Networking Software Trends

Page 23: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Broad Open Networking OpportunitiesGreen & Brownfield – In & Around DC – Software the Differentiator

Traditional

Virtualized

DC

SDDCPrivate

Cloud

Network

Packet

Broker

DCIDMZ

Boundary

Application

AnalyticsWAN DevOps

Open

Source

OS9 &

OS10 Enterl l

OS10 Open l* l l

BSN – BCF l l l

BSN – BMF l l

Pluribus l l* l l l l

Cumulus l l* l* l l

IPI l l

Silver Peak l

NSX l l l

Midokura l l

DC

* = when paired with a NVO

Specialized Tools, Software, Licenses Linux & Open Source

Common Hardware

NV

O

Page 24: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Networking OS Macro Trends

SAI Compliant, CPS Programmable OS10

DevOps solutions ready

Single Management pane for heterogeneous compute and Networking Infrastructure

Analytics and Telemetry

Collect and analyze practically everything about Network Fabric

Large Scale out Network Designs using standardized features

Linux Automation Ready

Page 25: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Disaggregation of Networking Stack

Open networking

Optional SDN/NVO controller

Standard orchestration & automation tools

Any networking OS

Open standard hardware

Merchant silicon

Closed Networking

Proprietary ASICs

Proprietary networking OS

Hundreds of protocols

Proprietary architectures & management tools

OS10

Page 26: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Containers and Microservices

• Single-host networking: Private network

within host (NAT for outside)

• Multi-host networking evolution:

• Bridged: Containers connected to

Linux Bridges (L2 virtual switches)

• VXLAN encapsulation between

hosts for L2 network

• MacVlan: Each container gets an

individual MAC and IP in the same

subnet as host

• IPVlan: Each container shares

same MAC as host and individual

IP in any subnet

Linux Containers Networking with Docker

• Software architecture pattern possible with

today’s technologies (containers, network

virtualization, cloud computing)

• Improves process isolation, security,

restartability, and upgradability

• Increased East-West traffic from servers

Microservices

Page 27: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Analytics with In-band Network Telemetry (INT)

• Improve monitoring of P+V network

traffic and fault isolation

• Real time

• Low CPU overhead (Data plane)

• End point (P or V) monitoring

• Latency

• Link utilization

• True paths

• Packet-level granularity

• Push model

• Under the scope of the P4 consortium.

Model sponsored by Dell EMC, VMware,

Intel, Arista and others

In-band Network Telemetry (INT)

How it works

• INT-aware devices insert INT messages

in packets, real-time and transparently

• INT-aware devices can consult the

information and expose data to clients

• INT-aware devices could also react upon

INT data

• INT messages are removed at destination

Page 28: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

What is Intent Based Networking

1. Translation and Validation– The system takes a higher-level business policy

(what) as input from end users and converts it to the necessary network

configuration (how). The system then generates and validates the resulting

design and configuration for correctness.

2. Automated Implementation – The system can configure the appropriate

network changes (how) across existing network infrastructure. This is typically

done via network automation and/or network orchestration.

3. Awareness of Network State – The system ingests real-time network status

for systems under its administrative control, and is protocol- and transport-

agnostic.

4. Assurance and Dynamic Optimization/Remediation– The system

continuously validates (in real time) that the original business intent of the

system is being met, and can take corrective actions (such as blocking traffic,

modifying network capacity or notifying) when desired intent is not met.

Why IBN:

“Networks are holding

businesses back as most

enterprise networks are

complex, rigid, hard to

change and slow to

provision, hard-coded

and downright slow to

change any kind of

security defenses *

Forbes.com

“Don’t tell me What to do, Tell me What you want!”

* IBN as defined by Gartner

Page 29: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Open Networking Solutions with Pluribus:

Page 30: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

New Feature: Native Visibility with Open DCI

DC-3

DC-1 DC-2

s6010 s6010

s6010

s6048T

s6048Ts6048T VTEPs

VTEPs

VTEPs

L3Underlay

VXLANHATunnel

VXLA

NHA

Tunn

el

VXLANHA

Tunnel

Pluribus Open DCI bridges multiple sites

The same visibility is now everywhere

Data is displayed in the same dashboard

Flow Connection Analytics

‒ Real-time

‒ No Sampling

‒ Correlation between server-client

‒ Correlation between overlay/underlay

Performance Analysis

‒ Intra-DC & Inter-DC

Security/Forensic Analysis

Integration with vCenter, Nutanix

REST API

Page 31: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

31 of Y

Internal Use - Confidential

5-Site DCI on

Dell

Hybrid-Fabric w/

E28

Multi-tenancy

Virtual Link

Extension HA

Per Tenant

Connection Flow

Analytics

VTEP HA

Multi-site DC

fabric

Loopfree

overlay

3-Site DCI on

Dell

31

DCI Use Cases With Dell

VTEP HA

Multi-DC Fabric

Nutanix

analytics

2-Site DCI on

DellOpen

DCI

Page 32: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Cloud Service Provider - Itconic

Why Pluribus / Dell:We gained a future-ready network for our cloud

services by working w Dell

Customer Comments - López García explains: “We wanted

to implement a more open solution, specifically on

networking, giving us greater freedom to make changes as

we needed.”

Cisco solutions were “too predefined” and lacked

adaptability. Opinion among key stakeholders was that

Cisco didn’t focus enough on its relationships with partners,

particularly organisations such as VMware, which would

play a central role in Itconic’s cloud services platform

Page 33: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Pluribus Benefits

Virtualization

Controller less SDN

High Scalability

Brownfield implementation

Visibility on what is going

on in the network

Multi-tenancy

Service insertion

Page 34: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Open Networking Solutions with BigSwitch:

Page 35: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

Internal Use - Confidential

IDENTIFYING A BIG SWITCH OPPORTUNITY

• Network Refresh

• New Datacenter PODs

• OpenStack

• Cisco ACI Pilot

35© 2014, BIG SWITCH NETWORKS, INC. PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL

• Network Security

• Network Monitoring

• Broader Visibility

• Security Service Chaining

BIG CLOUD FABRIC

BIG MONITORING FABRIC

Page 36: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

36

Internal Use - Confidential

Shared “ONE BIG SWITCH” ArchitectureDisaggregation of the “MainFrame”

FABRIC CARD

SUPERVISOR(S)

LINE CARD(S)

LINE CARD

LINE CARD

LINE CARD

LINE CARD

LINE CARD

SUPERVISOR

2

FA

BR

IC

CA

RD

FA

BR

IC

CA

RD

LINE CARD

LINE CARD

LINE CARD

LINE CARD

LINE CARD

SUPERVISOR

1

FA

BR

IC

CA

RD

FA

BR

IC

CA

RD

LINE CARD

LINE CARD

LINE CARD

LINE CARD

LINE CARD

SUPERVISOR

2

FA

BR

IC

CA

RD

FA

BR

IC

CA

RD

LINE CARD

LINE CARD

LINE CARD

LINE CARD

LINE CARD

SUPERVISOR

1

FA

BR

IC

CA

RD

FA

BR

IC

CA

RD

BIG CLOUD

FABRIC

CONTROLLER

HierarchicalControl Plane

1 3

SPINE SWITCHES

2

10G/40G

Backplane

41 32 4

COMPUTE

WORKLOAD

SERVICES &

CONNECTIVITY RACKSCOMPUTE WORKLOAD

LEAF SWITCHES

Physical&

VirtualWorkloads

1G/ 10G/40G

Workloads

• Disaggregated frame – One “Big Switch”

• Open, Simple, Economical, Vendor Choice, Scale-out

• Traditional frame design

• Single point of management

• Proprietary, Expensive, Lock-in, Fixed Slots

NET

NET

NET

SDN & Clos Fabric Necessary for NetFrame Disaggregation

Page 37: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

37

Internal Use - Confidential

! tenant

tenant BLUE

logical-router

route 0.0.0.0/24 tenant system

interface segment web

ip address 10.1.1.254/24

segment web

member-port-group pg-bm0 vlan 20

Why Customers Buy: 1) Simplicity

External Core

Router

WEB WEB APP APP DB DB

Segment-Web Segment-DB

MULTIPLE L2 SEGMENTS

Segment-App

Logical Router

(w/ policy)

LB

FWTENANT BLUE

Application Agility(Logical Networking,

Provisioning Templates)

Hitless FabricUpgrade

~15Minutes

Hitless Upgrade(Controller coordinated)

Zero-Touch Fabric(REST APIs, GUI, CLI)

BoxbyBox

Feature Big Cloud

Fabric

Switch OS Install Automatic

Link Aggregation Automatic

Fabric Formation Automatic

Trouble-shooting Fabric-wide

L4-7 Service

Chaining

Declarative (per

tenant)

Add/Remove/

Update Fabric

Automatic

Fabric Visibility Controller or API

BoxbyBox

BoxbyBox

16 racks, 40 devices

Page 38: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

38

Internal Use - Confidential

Why Customers Buy: 2) RESILIENCY @ SCALEChaos Monkey Resilience proves BCF is Best in class HA at Scale

Chaos Monkey Testing: 42k simulated

End-points/VMs of background load

and 640+ forced component failures

during the “under stress” test runs

32 leaf / 6 spine / 16 rack pod

Controller fail-over every 30 seconds

Switch fail-over every 8 seconds

Link fail-over every 4 seconds

Conclusion: 640 component failures in 30 minutes with no

impact on application performance

Page 39: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

39

Internal Use - Confidential

Why Customers buy: 3) simple, simple, simple

Verify Logical Path

Segment, Logical Router, L3 Policy, L4-7 device (next hop)

View Simulated Topology

Source ingress Leaf Spine egress Leaf Dest

Fabric Trace Fabric Analytics

Easy fine-grain time-series search

of log events based on:

• Event state (e.g. failures)

• Configuration change (REST,

CLI or GUI)

• Tenant / Segment / Devices

• End-point (MAC or IP)

attachment & detachment

Fabric Programmability

– Native REST APIs: GUI & CLI are REST clients (consistent & hardened)

– Controller is single point of API integration (versus tens of boxes)

Benefits

• No DevOps cost for network automation

• Print REST from CLI/GUI (accelerate DevOps through NetOps)

• Scalable M2M API interaction

dt-controller1# debug rest

***** Enabled display rest mode *****

dt-controller1# show tenant blue

REST-POST: POST http://127.0.0.1:8080/api/v1/data/controller/core/aaa/audit-event {"attribute": [{"value": ”show tenant blue", "key": "cmd_args"}], "event-type": "cli.command", "session-cookie": "yx6pjq6cwo5YXZwHsDyw6Z_3Zm5PITwE”}

REST-POST: http://127.0.0.1:8080/api/v1/data/controller/core/aaa/audit-event done 0:00:00.003089

Page 40: Welcome to Dell EMC Networking · 18-09-2017  · • MacVlan: Each container gets an individual MAC and IP in the same subnet as host • IPVlan: Each container shares same MAC as

40

Internal Use - Confidential

Big Cloud Fabric is open, simple and economical alternative to ACIA Better Alternative to Cisco ACI

Challenges:

• Proprietary: HW-heavy, Vendor lock-in

• Complex: Box-by-box control plane, Pro-service necessary,

Confusing Taxonomy

• Cost: Still Expensive

• Company: Reorgs, Talent depletion, Low Morale

Confusing & Unnecessary Taxonomy:

• Promise theory, Contracts, EPG

Advantages:

• Open: HW/SW disaggregation, Vendor choice

• Simple: No complex protocols, zero-touch

• Economical: Commodity Bare-metal HW

APIC: Application Policy Infrastructure Controller

Very large System Integrator Feedback

• “Four people worked on different tests but every one of us

was impressed with the ease of use and quality”

• “Done demos internally and to several customers…

consistently received very positive feedback, even from SDN

skeptics”

• “ACI is complicated, customers are confused even when

Cisco presents it, has only partial CLI”

APIC is a policy controller, not SDN controller

Gartner: Cisco ACI is NOT SDN